Is population jihad fact or fiction? Watch this 3-minute fact-check by Sreenivasan Jain
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 апр 2024
- #loksabhaelection2024 #lovejihad
PM Narendra Modi’s claims that the Congress wants to redistribute private wealth among those with “more children” and “infiltrators” have triggered a political war of words between the Opposition and the BJP.
Such references to Muslims have often found space in the Hindutva conspiracy theory of “population jihad” - one of many about how the country’s largest religious minority is unrelenting in its “planned campaign” to turn India into an Islamic state and seize its resources. And there has been little journalistic scrutiny to such claims, which aren’t just amplified by right-wing politicians but have increasingly found their way to mainstream news in recent years.
In their recent book, Love Jihad and Other Fictions, co-authors Sreenivasan Jain, Mariyam Alavi and Supriya Sharma had questioned several such theories.
What about “population jihad”? Is it fact or fiction? Watch senior journalist Sreenivasan Jain offer a complete answer in around three minutes.
Buy the book: amazon.in/Love-Jihad-Other-Fi...
Subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscript...
Power NL and TNM's coverage of the 2024 general elections: www.newslaundry.com/2024-elec...
Download the all-new Newslaundry app: www.newslaundry.com/download-app
Join us on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va61...
Follow and engage with us on social media:
Facebook: / newslaundry
Twitter: / newslaundry
Instagram: / newslaundry
Buy the book: amazon.in/Love-Jihad-Other-Fictions-Falsehoods/dp/8119635590
Subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscription?ref=social
Power NL and TNM's coverage of the 2024 general elections: www.newslaundry.com/2024-electionfund?ref=nl-social
Download the all-new Newslaundry app: www.newslaundry.com/download-app
Join us on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va61PEo0QeacOqU9vr2k
Check the avg no. Of children in both hindu and Muslim families. Fact is there in front of you, but you choose to ignore it.
So much misinformation in this video. Hope channel Journalists are educated.
Comparing Absolute growth rather than relative growth shows how much illiterate u guys are
the guys above me: 🤡
@@e4yNHzsPqMG Bro gave u some argument If u would have been educated either u have accepted or Countered them.
But u r actual clown here ok
@@e4yNHzsPqMG counter their arguments or ask them question
Excited to see Sreenivasan Jain…my most favourite Journalist from India
@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji If one of your ancestors supported Raja Jaichand against Prithviraj Chauhan, can I say that shows where your loyalty lies?
@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji First of all what a person's father did has nothing to do with what his son does. I used that Jaichand example just to illustrate this basic point. By dragging in Sreenivasan Jain's father into this debate you are just trying to confuse the issues and venting your venom. The topic of this video is "Population Jihad". What relevance has Jain's father to this topic? And where do you draw the inference that if somebody's father had a certain viewpoint his son will necessarily share the same?
@@Bharatmatters-yi7jishows where his father's loyalties lie. By that margin he didn't matter and abandon his wife. Abandon godhra, abandon Manipur, do Fuck all in ten years and think 2ab is a miracle. Bol ab Teri jali na. 😂
Savarkar was a British stooge...we all know where your loyalties lie@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji
Muslims produce 25 percent more babies than Hindus.
I am delighted to see Mr Jain after long time. Wish him gud luck and good work for NL
Dude get a real job . Stop being a IT cell coolie
@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji Visa aur tickets bhej de mujhe gobarbhakt
War rukwa di Papa
😂😂
wawrr rukwaw di paw paw
😂😂😂
मैं. हिन्दू हु पर किसी से नफरत नहीं करती क्युकी मुझे ना किसी से खतरा हैं ना मेरे संस्कार मुझे इसकी इज़ाज़त देते हैं हैं जय हिन्द 😊❤😊❤😊😊❤😊❤
Abdul come from real id
@@mjwarror3372No Abdul does not have to come out with his real name...cause she is not Abdul... it's just your mom pooped you put rather than giving a proper birth to you😂😂😂
I'm a muslim and love hindus
Jai Hind!
Good to see you Sir. I really miss Reality Check. Thanks to come back, India needs a journalist like you. Wish you all the best.
Love you Sreenivasan Ji....very nicely presented👍
A cast census is absolutely necessary.
My favourite journalist
Mine is Mr Sanket Upadhyay.
Currently he has also left NDTV and not the Red-Mike.
PS- Fav among English Journalists
For Hindi, no one can come near Mr.Ravish Kumar.
@@skmuzammilzeeshan6173did you mean rubbish kumar. Can you link me his Sandeshkhali video.
@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji if you don't like, please don't blame like Modi. No criticism please.
There is no solution to the crisis of existing establishment
today to any of the people in power along with the ruling parties, rather there has always been a deliberate attempt to engage people in communal politics.
This series is something that was so required 🙌 thank you for taking this step 🙏
Thank you sooo sooo much for making this video.
Only 👉 24.79% 👈 of Hindus voted for Modi/BJP🌷
---- 100 % voters = 24.79% (BJP) + 42.21% (Other) + 33% (Did not vote)
--- If voter who did not vote at all vote against BJP- Then game over
Illiterate . U don't need vote share U need majority in respective Parliament seat & assemblies to win.
show ur data resource....ur bot
@@AbhiCh-ht9qr 100 percentage = 67 percentage voted + 33 percentage did not vote
-- BJP (37 percent of 67 percent = 24.79)
-- Other (63 percent of 67 percent = 42.21)
Did not vote: 33
One time i went to vote, stood in line, in heat, listening to instructions from illiterate and rude staff and when my turn came they said apki vote to dal chuki pehle he....tabse nahin gaya aur na jaunga ab ! gunday baithe hote hain voting booths pe. Just giving you a reason why people don't go. Apna demag kharaab karne se accha ghar baitho ! 110007 ki kahani bata raha hun kahin aap socho kisi remote village ki baat ho rahi hai !
@@ShivanshuSJC
Last 15 years exactly what happening in Bangladesh too.
Even the dead one who died years ago came to vote 😂 for present day government.
So,last time election less than 10% people voted.
There is joke in BD that Election Day an old man was sitting out side the booth for a long time then a man asked did you vote, he no some one did it for me, he asked than why are you waiting for ? He replied that last your aunt came to vote but didn’t meet her , this time I want to
see her , after she died I never seen but she came for vote in last election.
Poor English I hope you understand.
Thank you, very well presented
Excited to see Sreenivasan Jain here , thanks
thanks for the series… keep this 3 min. video and give the links to the articles in reference for ppl to deep dive … this is good to share it with ppl having peanut size brain
@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji he won't reply now
@@catfish9391 I Know these Sickulars are just fools
🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@Bharatmatters-yi7jicopy paste ke alave kuch aata nahi hai kya 💀
I read your book. Great read and research! Quite the page turner and really morbid, but unfortunately true.Thank you! Hope some bhakti in the political sphere gets removed because of this book.
I come to news laundry to have a laugh , this was actually good content nice job
Woah , so great to see you here Sir 😊💕
I can't wait to see Sreenivasan with a red mike in hand again ❤ LET'S GOOOOOO
Love to see Vasu back with all might. One of the best journalist India has produced. A real old NDTVist
100 percentage = 67 percentage voted + 33 percentage did not vote
-- BJP (37 percent of 67 percent = 24.79)
-- Other (63 percent of 67 percent = 42.21)
Did not vote: 33
Liked your comment. No matter how much data is provided the BJP just debunk it as Fake. Think Owaisi gave a very pertinent comment on Muslim families by saying Modi has 6 siblings and Amit Shah too has six. Total 7 children per family and another name quoted had 7 = 8 children.
So nice to see Srinivasan on Newslaundry . All the best for new inning.
Welcome Sreenivasan Jain
Good to see you with News laundry.
Glad to see you again sreenivasan jain. Looking forward for more classy journalism from you.
Need this video in Hindi too. Want to show it to my grandparents!
Good to see you back Sreenivasan Jain, keep up the good work~
Nice to see u sreenivas jain❤
A very good initiative ❤
Thank you
Nice To Hear After A Long Time.
Great to see Srinivasan Jain!
Great one, Seeenivasan..
Excellent👍
Agar Modi ne bola hai toh zaroor Fiction hi hoga...
@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji pehle tu fake profile se toh bahar aa...
@@FarhanMoosa how many siblings are you?
@@FarhanMoosa how many siblings are you
@@catfish9391 tere siblings se toh kam hi hai... fake profile!!
@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji lo bhai.. jinko apne hi ancestors ka pata nahi... woh dusron k ancestors k baare mein argue karte rehte hai!!
I respect Srinivasan Jain
Try to make this vedio in Hindi. It would be better because those who believe in this mostly don't know English.
Very important point. Islamaphobic hate messages are the most in Hindia
Glad to see you after a long time ❤
@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji why do we have to involve Pakistan everywhere. It's not funny to say things about women... Lets focus on our country only....
How Pakistan is doing is a headache of the people of Pakistan.
@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji Lol 😂
@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji No absolutely wrong the people that voted believed in that and went there. The people who didn't agreed stayed here. Chill and get a life.
@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji Thank you for the history lessons do you accept gpay ?
Shreenivas in NL.. Wow.. 👌
Please upload a Hindi version as well. I have a lot of chest-thumping hindutva relatives to share this with.
Yeah please make sure you're relative's also read Congress manifesto?
excited and happy to see you back but on different platform wehave stoppedwatching NDTV after eminent journalist likeyou Ravish and so many others left the channel now my bestwishes always with uall passing through a very critical phase but struggles and challenges always make people more strong keep it up my best wishes always with u all 💐👍
Subscribed :)
Awesome work Mr. Sreenivasan. As Ravish Kumar said, "Not all battles are fought for victory. Some are fought simply to tell the world that someone was there on the battlefield."
I do hope we win this war against Hindutva propaganda machine.
I am impressed that news laundry is finally using logic
Good to see you here
I am glad he is on news laundry.
Thanks
👍
Please translate this 3 minute... so that i can share to my family group
Shared with your family group and explain to them what is happening what is truth .
#WeNeedEducatedPM
#WeDontNeedMarketingPM
#WeDontNeedInsensitivePM
We don't know means no one knows on the count of the illegal immigrants. When ID cards including passports are issued meticulously where on earth will the numbers be known?
I've read your book. It's mind changing. However, I have a suggestion to improve the book's presentation. You could highlight the important points of the cases and data through bullets. It's kind of a summary or a quick catch of it.
Srinivasan sir is the best journalist
Is this a repost? Have seen this before, right?
Nice report
Superb data
Very nice
Maha Ram Bhakth Maha
Jhoota Modiji in his own words:
"Jhooth Bolo,
Baar baar jhooth bolo,
jo bhi bol sakte hai sab jhooth bolo,
jaha bhi bol sakte hai jhooth bolo,
jitni baar bol sakte hai jhooth bolo,
kisi bhi vishay par bolo to sirf aur sirf jhooth bolo."
Also the replacement rate. We must talk about the death rate among communities.
This is very much alarming situation for Muslims. Muslim women had to produce more children otherwise in coming decade, other communities particularly Hindus will overpower them because of narrow down rates of growths
Love shreenivasn
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Definitely I can say not in South
Once poison is injected,will it not spread to every part of the body?
@senguptasayn Yes, the poison of Hatred from Hindutva. Anti-dote is on the way. 2024 elections. 🤣🤡
@@Bharatmatters-yi7ji You're so obsessed with Pakistan. You belong there. 🤣💩🤡
Bhai ji, pls make a video about the Decreasing/vanishing minority (hindu,Sikh) population in Afghanistan, Pakistan and Bangladesh...
😂😂😂😂😂 Hindus are vanishing means ? Sorg Mai chola Gea kea ?
Nehi , they are vanishing in their 🐄 mother country for sure . I’m the witness of this happening in many places in Bangladesh.
In my village Dhupi, Mali has been gone for India , from my father in law’s village 3 brother from dev family went to India, from my moms village 5/7 family were gone to India who were good friends of my moms family only 2 family from them are remaining in Bangladesh. They sold their property to the Muslims and left ,the whole village were full of Bhrammons but they chose to lived in India.
So, it’s an established matter that many Hindus are vanishing in INDIA .
Welcome to the newslundry sir.i used to follow you from NDTV days.
This was an old data, that's why the govt didn't do census. If Hindutva is so important for the govt then why are they not talking about religious conversion, they should make laws so that they don't expand. The loudspeaker laws which exist from very long back has not been followed even now. Neither by churches, temples nor by mosques. Only these 3 keep making huge noise and ofcourse it depends upon the local management but police should take action against those.
Hi Mr Jain. Please make the same episode in Hindi. When you speak Hindi, it reaches more people.
❗️In the History of our BeautifulAllEmbracingVibrant#🇮🇳 , these 10years will be recorded as the most horrendous anomaly that could hv hit My Country;
JaiHind❗️
Please make this information in Hindi so everyone understands it easily.
good to see some familar face. Dear Newslaundry, please hire them all and become a real News Channel.
If religion-based prejudice (i.e., prejudice that is based on SO-CALLED dharma) is taken out of the picture, most of Modi-Shah-Bisht & Co's talking-points would be gone.
🤮 MODI 🥶???❓️
Isto é a que
tenho
.......ouvindo 🦻❌️
desde ó ano passado.........😱
Yeh video hindi mei nahi hai kya? Family whatsapp group mei andhe logo ki aankhein kholni hai.
#WeNeedLovingPM
#WeDontNeed56InchPM
Fact is kryptonite for Bhakts ....
Fiction.not fact
I mean, by pure population growth metrics it seems that way
It’ll be good to do these in Hindi as well…
Data is way too Old
Sir,Did I heard it right,Mr.Modi also has 5 siblings in total,what does that would imply wrt his speech.
Its not population jihad. as per the recent survey conducted by national population control board, its come to understand that condoms are the second most effective contraceptive in India the first is SCHOOL FEES
hey news laundry i have really genuine suggestion for you all guys, not all indian are educated in english, please make videos in hindi also, not for but for the people in villages, small towns, for people who cannot afford english school. when they saw your videos in hindi they can closely relate to themselves.
0:32 if this claim was COMPLETELY incorrect then Pakistan, Bangladesh would not go against India
Dont know about pakistan..but being a bangladeshi i can say u ....we dont hate india or indians...but we hate the policys of indian govt to us....nearly 4000 people are killedmin border by bsf...india is stealing our river waters .......do u want us to love u ?....pakistan bangladesh maldives china already hates u...next will be bhutan nepal srilanka these countries
Sachar commission report says that Muslim population is growing at the fastest rate 😂
It is due to convert mostly from Christians to muslims hope it helps
@@comedyalbums7202 any source
@@comedyalbums7202
Yes, every single day there is someone or some people who accepting Islam . In Ramadan the converted rate much higher than before.
This information should be in Hindi also
Translate the book in Hindi too.
Such fact-check vids should be made in hindi. It is the hindi belt that are the most misinformed.
Census karwao pata lag jayega
అల్లాహ్ తప్ప దేవుడు లేడు. (లా ఇలాహ ఇల్లల్లాహ్)
Hindus must have more kids
They can't. It depends on fertility rate and limit on spouse. However, polyandry among Hindus is prevalent in India in certain states just like polygamy is among Muslims. There are Hindu laws and Muslims laws for this very reason: practice of religion.
They can’t , because of alcohol . Not only in India but also all alcoholic countries fertility rates going down more than slowly.
its sad to see even educated Indians studied at good schools are supporting modiji despite everything clear in black and white.
sorry...We don't believe rama...we don't believe facts...we don't believe constitution....we believe only in modi words...
No Hate or whatever BUT a population with 33% Muslim after 20-30 years- The basic picture of India will change. Not only it will reflect on votes but in streets. No need of Muslim overtaking Hindus. I don't want in India what's happening in London, where they hold the State on ransom.
I don't think imposing something on them will work, specially when extremism is quite acceptable. I wish some Raja Rammohan, Vidyasagar of Muslim avatar, some from their own communiy were there in India.
Personal experience with Muslims-
1. In a protest site againts NRC(2019)- Kolkata- I have myself heard on public gathering on loudspeaker by a muslim speaker- "All good things like Taj mahal, in India were built by Muslim, Hindus only know gobar". I couldn't shout and counter(i was alone) about Ajanta, Ellora, Vijaynagar, south Indian stuff etc all that before Muslim rule and even Taj Mahal was not built from personal income but from taxes of majorly Hindu populace. ( if islamophoba is there, so is Hinduphobia)
2. A Known person who repairs AC in homes, directly faced a question- WHy was he alloted to a muslim houshold, he being a Hindu. (This thing happens for a Muslim too, I know. So, no one has angles by their sides)
3. Heard Muslim men in group adda reminised about their good old days of ancestors, who were the rulers of this land. Where their position has come to now (This happened Not in Urban tier 1 city, but in tier 3 town). ( why should I not think of
4. Enter a Muslim dominated area in Rural India, Not in urban cities( i have seen in Bengal) - You will feel you are in different world all together. (Do Muslim feel the same in Hindu areas? Maybe.)
5. Muslim Kolkata Mayor- Kolkata will speak in urdu someday. ( Forgetting a country was created to sake of language(bengali)). I love urdu words, but what is this?
BJP is using bad words, their ways are incorrect, others ways could have been used. But they have certains points. And it matters. Its not Muslim fault that till now Hindus were not that vocal or proud of their own identity or culture. Hindus played down themselves to accomodate others to the limit they themsleves had lost their roots. I m no supporter of likes of J sai Deepak. I wish there was a third front in election.
Aaj kal electoral bond chor bolta ha ki congress jyada bache walo ko dhan baantegi , kya ye baat ek pm ko karni chahiye , ye bate ATI asobhniye ha, ise godi media bhi khub parchar Rahi ha, Kam se Kam pm pad ki garima ka to Mann samann rakhna chahiye , chunav jitne ke liye itne nichle star ki baate karte ha pm , isi liye ek padhe likhe pm ki jarurat ha,
Left lobby trying their level best. This is another classic example. This guy joined a right wing news channel and is now on Newslaundry which proves where the alignment of left lobby of india. NewsLaundry try to be Neutral and don't allow your platform for every random guy.
THIS JOKER SREENIVASAN JAIN WAS THE INE WHO RECENTLY WROTE A BOOK SAYING LOVE JIHAD AS FICTION
SAYS MUCH ABOUT HIS CREDIBILITY
Ok it's decreasing right but still way above Hindus ....😅😅 Kuch to logical baat karo
What else logic do you want? It's a plain simple fact lol
But there are 120cr Hindus & 20cr Muslims in India!
Alcohol makes your fertility worse, western countries have that problem and it’s growing in number.
Check this out.
election commissioner modi ji ke sath hai kyun modi ji upar action nahi lera hai election commissioner muradabad
Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world regardless what we do.. cuz people also accept Islam YK..
First place yourself in the shoes of Neha Hiremath's parents and then talk about love jihad
Dna of Indian muslim should be taken....birth rate related is a fight between sefishness and sacrifice of individual happiness..