one thing i cant understand is why Hwayoung didnt even speak or explain that she wasnt buillied when the whole Comunity is on fire .. seriosly hwayoung big reason on Tara going down
Lee Boku yeah I would give it to u if I can find it ,but I read it from people's (queens) comments in other videos saying that . Even if you can find her Tweet what are going to say ?
she did talk but she never said she wasnt bullied. but there missunderstanding there. its realy fuel that T-ara management forced her to denied the scandal, even some believe that mbk at that time taking her sis as hostage.
Toua Lodbrok will you listen if she talk about bullying? No one would care to listen, because people hate her anyway. So, Why blame her? Do you believe a girl could ruin T-ara? one of the biggest girl group in that era?
+Rawda Ali well, just don't blame anyone.... because we never know the truth... we were not with them.... I don't trust any of them... not hwayoung not tAra not their company not netizen....
Why am I even here? Hahaha just recently found out this issue and I'm curious. Not a fan of t ara, but I know alot of their song. Never knew that Hwayoung was once part of them. Only knew her as an actress. Now, this answer my question why she's a great actress. Lol
omg same! i saw Hwayoung a lot in dramas and I think she's a great actress. Then come to find out she was a part of t-ara lol. It's crazy because I remember when the bullying scandal came out and everything too. Wild.
She was one good rapper but everything turned into mess. I didn't like the addition of members. Obviously, MBK didn't handle their artist well and just let it pass untill T-ARA sank.
That was the “proof” that was used for T-ara in order to bring them down because they were a threat to groups like 2NE1 and snsd. Coming from a small company they had no one to fight for them.
I know right! A few days ago I still see a lot of comments talked shit about T-ara. Seriously people?! It has been 5 years and they still not get the fact that T-ara wasn't bully that girl.
Jenny Le but now it's proven. I like T-Ara...but what Hwayoung did wasn't ok. some chats were shown, a staff member talked and even Hwayoung admitted that she bullied Ahreum. sorry...but those facts can't be proven wrong. I love T-Aras music...but I really dislike them for bullying the girl. Watch Abizz-Ehtertainments video.
Jenny Le Dao, Hannah Xxxx and Xu Tong Jenny Le Dao - You're right; T-ara didn't bully Hwayoung. Hannah Xxxx - You seem a bit confused, but you wrote your comment nine months ago, so you may have a better understanding now. The scandal was about T-ara bullying Hwayoung, but that didn't happen, and Hwayoung never claimed that it did. Did you think it was about T-ara bullying Areum? Hwayoung did not admit that she bullied Areum. It was her twin sister, Hyoyoung, who sent the threatening texts. Hwayoung and the other T-ara members had big argument in Japan. Hyomin posted a vague tweet about determination, and four of the other members retweeted it. Qri and Areum were not involved in that, and Hwayoung responded to the tweets, which were clearly aimed at her. Two days later Hyoyoung, Hwayoung's twin sister, sent the threatening messages. They were bad, but the way they were written (rather inconsistent and incoherent) makes me think she was drunk when she wrote them, and she was angry about something that she didn't fully understand. Hwayoung, who was very fond of Areum, a fellow late recruit, was upset about not having her support and moaned about it to her sister. Hyoyoung got drunk and did something she shouldn't have done. Three days after that, Hwayoung was dismissed by the management and the scandal really took off. If you dislike T-ara for bullying “the girl,” forget it. They didn't bully Hwayoung or Areum. Xu Tong - The tweets were a bad mistake which made T-ara look like bullies, but Hwayoung has never sought revenge. Instead, she publicly supported T-ara and wished them success, but too many people ignored her and continued persecuting them or accusing Hwayoung of claiming she was bullied, which she has never done.
@@jasmin7463 The only way you can think that is if you already believe that she was bullied or that she pretended she was. She said it was disappointing; things can happen between girls and they were young and immature, including her. That is it, that's all she said about her time in T-ara. She implies that she was part of the problem and there is no suggestion of bullying or any sort of mistreatment. We know there was an argument but that can happen in any group. Her critics complain about her saying the members were immature, but Eunjung had said exactly that on The Beatle2 Code ruclips.net/video/18GJ-3xcIZI/видео.html and the whole group had admitted on their own website in 2012 that they could have avoided the scandal by acting in a more mature way. seoulbeats.com/2012/08/why-it-makes-me-sorry-that-hwayoung-is-sorry/ Another common complaint is about Hwayoung "crying her eyes out on Taxi." She said she cried in her room many times, but that was after she left T-ara and is what I would expect from anyone in her position. She only shed a few tears in the interview when Hyoyoung was talking about how she felt watching her sister going through such a hard time. Click this link for the full story of how the scandal happened. t-ara-and-hwayoung.blogspot.com
She could simply not like that type of game, she could've been thinking of school work or family problems and it's possilbe she was having a hard time understanding Japanese and was busy internally translating.
this makes me happy bc as a queen of 4 years ( going 5 years in july) i get frustrated when ppl badh T-ara and honestly, i saw this video before and i used to think it was who was chosen as the prettiest and it didnt bother me and i didnt understand why ppl thought it was bullying of hwayoung was chosen. nonetheless, I'll stick with T-ara no matter what. thanks for this video.
Just because Hwayoung looks more like quiet person doesn't mean she's bullied. Well, i don't know about Ahreum. She new & her career on T-Ara was quick, even i don't realize if she was around. Because the last T-Ara MV i follow was Lovey Dovey.
Thanks for uploading this! Really, there is nothing wrong in informing and defending the truth! If the Antis and the real bully K-netz won't stop, we Queen's shouldn't stop either to show our love and support for our T-ARAs! And Big Thanks for doing this +TheQueenJiyeon !
I strongly believed that every body has their own stress level, sadness, anger, eagerness to survive, happiness. I sincerely hope that beautiful and kindhearted Tara,( tiara) are able to not mind what other people may assume and really understand just how amazing and beautiful their voices are and how incredible that they r still there for each other thru out all these year whether they present themselves publicaly or work with other male groups. Please believe me.
Anyone besides me gets the irony of the song "Lies" as T-ara's debut song? T-ara announced they will do a comeback later in 2021. Pass the word to all Queen's. (T-ara fandom meaning "Belonging to the Queens of Kpop, the Queen's own.)(Although proper English would be Queens', meaning Belonging to multiple Queens, but this is Korean, not English nor American.)
The haters should stop now! Stop blaming our precious T-ara.. They should be shame of themselves! Queen's, let's continue our support for our lovely T-ara.. T-ara unnies, saranghaeyo👑👑👑💝💝💝
I appreciate your effort but I think it's useless now to explain all the stuff about it to the haters. SK don't deserve a legendary elite, talented group like T-ARA. Just let them be, let them hate while us QUEENS will keep supporting them. It is indeed a shame that they can't be popular anymore but T-ARA don't need that amymore since have loyal and dedicated fans already. Those idiots can keep believing in false accusations and keep hating on them calling them flops or bullies but we all know T-ARA is made their mark in the Kpop industry and proved many dipshits that they are indeed untouchable legends.
Nora Enkhtaivan their amazingly successful in China they don't need the kpop industry period their the only kpop group granted permission by the government to promote over there that's pretty impressive since their popularity is huge
and the fact that i was in the Fandom a month before the incident makes me feel really happy yet with the incident , people start hating them and makes me really upset.
My personal opinion It's just people react too fast,they doesn't even try to know the whole story and start blaming and criticizing. Bullying is a matter that can be misunderstood easily. just like in jimin's (AoA) case. Even now we don't know the whole story still there r thousands of video about ppl bashing her. I'm not AoA or jimin's fans nor I'm defending her.but a matter can b seen differently by different point of view so I simply think K-pop fans shouldn't criticized idols so early that they don't even bother to know the whole story (ALSO IT'S MY PERSONAL OPINION IF YOU R OFFENDED BY IT I'M SORRY PLZ IGNORE IT)
Xiaojie Ziyun soo from what I know this girl tried to avoid preforming at the concert faked a leg injury. Causing trouble rest of t ara to REHEARSE and change the concert songs. She did all that to avoid preforming at a concert.
i know this comment is irrelevant but omg just look at qri's visual.... she's so pretty even when she's giving the "restless bitch face". qri is a queen for sure hahaha
i honestly thing that this whole situstion was stupid! T-ara was so polular and one of the biggest girl group at that time, they were contributing with the "k-wave" and people rave about them, they had international fandom and they were so big in asia especially japan, but antis and k-nets ruined it by made or belive with false rumor and hwayoung who make the situation worse and playing as victim to gain public sympathy, when T-ara should be apriciated for thrir hard work and spread k-wave "heat" at thst time!
We cannot judge on who's fault it is, we may never know what really happened. But to my opinion the people (management) are the blame for not letting the band (group) choose who they want in their group instead its the management who are the ones that dump individuals in/out of a group without a say or a vote, obviously by doing that you would get few individuals who would not get along. So tell me who's fault it is?
Please Search to Facebook, Twitter, INS,... and more. I don't need T-ARA to be as famous as 5 years ago. HOWEVER, I don't accept that IN SOME Newspaper, HWA still called " a member of T-ARA" although She left this group. I can't that she slapped in the face and No staffs can criticize her because her house is rich. #Need_Justice_For_T-ARA
Below is a translation of the leaked chat messages: Hyoyoung: Ahreum it’s Hyoyoung unnie. Ahreum: Yes unnie hi^^!! Hyoyoung: Ahrem you have to be thankful and say thank you when you’re being taken care of. If you don’t want to get beaten up act right. Word spreads fast in this field. Don’t mouth around and don’t act cheap ^^. I’m extremely angry right now so let’s not run into each other. Hyoyoung: If I’ve misunderstood anything do you want to meet and talk? Or do you want to apologize now. Ahreum: I don’t know what you’re talking about but I want to meet and talk. I’ve never done anything bad enough to deserve to hear such words. Hyoyoung: Little ones can get lost. Hyoyoung: I’m going to beat the dust off you at Music Bank. Hyoyoung: I’m going to scratch your face so you can’t go on TV** Hyoyoung: ㅎㅎㅎ Just you wait~^^ Hyoyoung: I’m not going to be a singer ㅎ so just wait ^^. Dogs only listen when they take a beating. Hyoyoung: You bitch. Just wait until I catch you. Hyoyoung: Yes just keep~~~snitching.
I think hwayoung is a new member in T-ARA. So she is not good with these game , events. Like u a new member in a group, They talk and laugh together, but u just sit there, dont know anything to say , to do. I saw a lot of T ara Games, events, hwayoung cant follow up the team, she cant fake acting( fake smile, v.v. ) either. about she was buillied, thats not her fault. The other groups, fans, companies hate T-Ara , so they make thing in those clip that T-Ara buillied hwayoung to ruin t-ara. they are the one that we should blame to
The staff exposing Hwayoung: The staff member goes on to discuss Hwayoung’s leg injury from July 2012. The staff member confirms that while Hwayoung did fall, she was released from the hospital with her manager, after doctors said there were no serious issues. However, after she returned home she went to another hospital and got herself a semi-cast. She would take the cast off when she was inside transport but would ask the manager to help her walk when reporters were around.
I don’t think they bullied her and o don’t think she was in the wrong either. I bet you she just didn’t fit in with them, which sometimes happens. It’s normal because you won’t always fit in everywhere. And because she didn’t fit in, she just misunderstood their words and actions. When you are insecure, your mind does that to you. If they laugh, you think they are making fun of you. And then they sense her insecurity. It was just an uncomfortable situation that for really twisted.
@@kimberlyumiten1358 it is possible and that what makes it easy to fool the blind fans. I had seen some idol doing that but i won't mention the name. for an example when this 1 idol "acting nicely" while other just being themselves not "acting nicely" subconsciously making blind fans thinking "why can't the rest of the member being nice?" then you discovered actually that 1 "nice" idol have history of back mouthing/backstabbing their member/friends in social media that's when you realise that idol not really that "nice". that idol just pretended to be nice in front of the camera to make her member look like the bad 1. it sad but it happen.. hopefully all the bad fake idol that trying to sabotage their own member get exposed
Kpop ruined my life her two sister bullied one of the members but she acted like a victim instead and even faked getting her leg hurt and other stuff. You can search this up and there will be more details on it.
WAIT SHES FROM HELLO MY TWENTIES!!!! (This is late but I I was looking rewatching Hello my 20s and I searched more about the cast and realized she was in a a girl group and now I’m here)
Everyone's mad at hwayoung so I thought she was the one who bullied them but if I'm correct netizens made speculations that the members bullied her. And the only bad thing hwa young did was not speak on it?? If that's what happened I feel bad for all of them cause it's normal to have fights with friends but it ruined them cause it was public
It was said that the members of T-ara were bullying one of their members Hwayoung, Hwayoung was then removed from the group which fueled the fire even more. It soon came out that both Hwayoung and her sister were in fact the bullies. Hwayoung even faked an injury during their tour but was seen getting her nails done
@@andredrw289 That is wrong. There were no bullies and Hwayoung didn't fake an injury. It was basically a misunderstanding that got out of hand. t-ara-and-hwayoung.blogspot.com/
t ara was one of the first kpop group I know, the more I look into the case the sadder I get. it seems like it was just small discord because they was so busy and stressed out. added with poor management that caused big reaction and bad interpretation/overreaction by knetz that made it went out of control. MBK and knetz was shit at that time and that's it. MBK is still shit tho, poor DIA😔
KAI-RIL -A- It already happened to the legendary group SNSD who people were all speculating she was ignored ALL the time and was kicked out but what to do they're legend ain't they? So ofcourse no one would talk.
Im mad with hwayoung but im also upset with the members and the staff why just exposed her after years of tormenting them she ruined the group they lives and career they should have fought .
Well they did try to expose her but no one believed and T-ara got hated more because it was seen like T-ara was making up lies to frame the innocent rat
Because their management believed that time , that if they just stayed quiet people will just forget that issue. The management also wants to protect Hwayoung and her sister as well.
I really like T-ara area especially Hyomin since I watch Invincible Youth because of SNSD but I start to love other groups..If only this incident didn't happen then I think T-ara would be popular until now..😔 This bullying case really destroy T-ara's career..
To be honest, the people who wrote the article and the reason a lot of people started to blame T-Ara for bullying Hwayoung is in fact even more terrible person. People who still hates them because of bullying Hwayoung needs to get back on their life and MOVE ON. It's year 2016 and soon 2017. No human will still stand still because one day, each human will have to fall as well to learn from it. If T-Ara quit because of the scandal, they would be seen as weaklings, but they didnt quit. Because they still remember the fans and people who will truly support them till the end!
Back to the days when this blew up, the media made the T-ARA members seems like they're bullying Hwayoung. When in reality, Hwayoung, along with her twin sister are the actual bullies.
Martha Borrott Because Hwayoung said a lie and so many people didn't try to understand the events.They blame to T-ara, they insulted.(I saw so many bad comments about T-ara.Poor T-ara didn't to deserve that).Last year,Hwayoung sister's messages was leaked.She threatened to former member Areum.
Because she lead public to believe she was bullied and forced out of T Ara. It was later revealed that she and her twin were instigating a lot of issues that lead to her being forced out
It’s old news from 2012 but it’s okay I can explain it to you. It’s the saddest scandal I know :( So basically t-ara is innocent and that snake hwayoung (the one with fake expressions and the one not laughing while everybody else is laughing) faked a leg injury just because she didn’t want to perform. A rumor spread that t-ara was bullying hwayoung (which wasn’t true) and it made lots of problems on the internet, yet hwayoung didn’t even bother to release a statement that t-ara didn’t do anything. So yeah she ruined their career. If she had released a statement nothing would’ve happened :( what a snake, tara had so much potential and were basically the second top girl group at that time after girl’s generation and Koreans thought tara were the only ones that could beat girls generation literally fuck you hwayoung For more info read this article www.allkpop.com/forum/threads/t-aras-entire-story-whole-t-ara-scandal-possessed-member-t-ara-before-with-pics.272196/
@@saba9803 oh my this is so sad. I saw their group recently on knowing bros. and didn't know them honestly but started to like their songs. I especially like Jiyeong. Hope they have a comeback.
![[VIDEO PROOF] TRUE or NOT T-ARA bully HWAYOUNG?](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TEtshB9xtl8/mqdefault.jpg)
one thing i cant understand is why Hwayoung didnt even speak or explain that she wasnt buillied when the whole Comunity is on fire .. seriosly hwayoung big reason on Tara going down
Mouna Hermouche Where!!! I need the receipts. This has gone on too long.
Lee Boku yeah I would give it to u if I can find it ,but I read it from people's (queens) comments in other videos saying that . Even if you can find her Tweet what are going to say ?
she did talk but she never said she wasnt bullied. but there missunderstanding there. its realy fuel that T-ara management forced her to denied the scandal, even some believe that mbk at that time taking her sis as hostage.
Toua Lodbrok will you listen if she talk about bullying? No one would care to listen, because people hate her anyway. So, Why blame her? Do you believe a girl could ruin T-ara? one of the biggest girl group in that era?
+Rawda Ali well, just don't blame anyone.... because we never know the truth... we were not with them.... I don't trust any of them... not hwayoung not tAra not their company not netizen....
Why am I even here? Hahaha just recently found out this issue and I'm curious. Not a fan of t ara, but I know alot of their song. Never knew that Hwayoung was once part of them. Only knew her as an actress. Now, this answer my question why she's a great actress. Lol
same 😂
omg same! i saw Hwayoung a lot in dramas and I think she's a great actress. Then come to find out she was a part of t-ara lol. It's crazy because I remember when the bullying scandal came out and everything too. Wild.
I miss t ara.
ruclips.net/video/3Xolk2cFzlo/видео.html
^This. WATCH THAT. IT'S GOOD.
She was one good rapper but everything turned into mess. I didn't like the addition of members. Obviously, MBK didn't handle their artist well and just let it pass untill T-ARA sank.
I am here just to learn about the situation because of AOA bullying scandal that's currently popped off...
Same
Me too
I think in a lot of groups (definitely back then) there was a lot of bullying going on. Seems like everyone was fighting for attention too
Sameeee
@@lelainerduh some groups probably still are
Just because one of the members didn’t smile doesn’t mean that they are bullies 😐
They are haters , what do we expect. 🤷
@Sirk Corner not just Hwayoung, i meant.
That was the “proof” that was used for T-ara in order to bring them down because they were a threat to groups like 2NE1 and snsd. Coming from a small company they had no one to fight for them.
@Nina Park ok, i guess.
@@ninapark4342 if not because of the scandal..they probably will continue conquer the charts for a whole damn year
I know right! A few days ago I still see a lot of comments talked shit about T-ara. Seriously people?! It has been 5 years and they still not get the fact that T-ara wasn't bully that girl.
Jenny Le but now it's proven. I like T-Ara...but what Hwayoung did wasn't ok. some chats were shown, a staff member talked and even Hwayoung admitted that she bullied Ahreum.
sorry...but those facts can't be proven wrong.
I love T-Aras music...but I really dislike them for bullying the girl.
Watch Abizz-Ehtertainments video.
Jenny Le Dao, Hannah Xxxx and Xu Tong
Jenny Le Dao - You're right; T-ara didn't bully Hwayoung.
Hannah Xxxx - You seem a bit confused, but you wrote your comment nine months ago, so you may have a better understanding now.
The scandal was about T-ara bullying Hwayoung, but that didn't happen, and Hwayoung never claimed that it did.
Did you think it was about T-ara bullying Areum? Hwayoung did not admit that she bullied Areum. It was her twin sister, Hyoyoung, who sent the threatening texts.
Hwayoung and the other T-ara members had big argument in Japan. Hyomin posted a vague tweet about determination, and four of the other members retweeted it. Qri and Areum were not involved in that, and Hwayoung responded to the tweets, which were clearly aimed at her.
Two days later Hyoyoung, Hwayoung's twin sister, sent the threatening messages. They were bad, but the way they were written (rather inconsistent and incoherent) makes me think she was drunk when she wrote them, and she was angry about something that she didn't fully understand. Hwayoung, who was very fond of Areum, a fellow late recruit, was upset about not having her support and moaned about it to her sister. Hyoyoung got drunk and did something she shouldn't have done.
Three days after that, Hwayoung was dismissed by the management and the scandal really took off.
If you dislike T-ara for bullying “the girl,” forget it. They didn't bully Hwayoung or Areum.
Xu Tong - The tweets were a bad mistake which made T-ara look like bullies, but Hwayoung has never sought revenge. Instead, she publicly supported T-ara and wished them success, but too many people ignored her and continued persecuting them or accusing Hwayoung of claiming she was bullied, which she has never done.
@@nightjaronthegate she literally talked on taxi about it (with her sister) and made herself look like a victim.
@@jasmin7463 The only way you can think that is if you already believe that she was bullied or that she pretended she was. She said it was disappointing; things can happen between girls and they were young and immature, including her. That is it, that's all she said about her time in T-ara. She implies that she was part of the problem and there is no suggestion of bullying or any sort of mistreatment. We know there was an argument but that can happen in any group. Her critics complain about her saying the members were immature, but Eunjung had said exactly that on The Beatle2 Code ruclips.net/video/18GJ-3xcIZI/видео.html and the whole group had admitted on their own website in 2012 that they could have avoided the scandal by acting in a more mature way. seoulbeats.com/2012/08/why-it-makes-me-sorry-that-hwayoung-is-sorry/
Another common complaint is about Hwayoung "crying her eyes out on Taxi." She said she cried in her room many times, but that was after she left T-ara and is what I would expect from anyone in her position. She only shed a few tears in the interview when Hyoyoung was talking about how she felt watching her sister going through such a hard time.
Click this link for the full story of how the scandal happened. t-ara-and-hwayoung.blogspot.com
hwayoung snake, go to hell
they laughed at everyone tho
I know right it been 5 years already people are still. I still have a hope that people are gonna forget about it. It's not even true. 😞
i hope so
me too
+TheQueenJiyeon morevpls!!
Its clear they're really enjoyed the questionaire except hwayoung. Hwa expression seems…so fake.
She could simply not like that type of game, she could've been thinking of school work or family problems and it's possilbe she was having a hard time understanding Japanese and was busy internally translating.
I think something is really bothering her.
Who would not be bothered living with 6 snakes..
I think haters like *being a bitch for life k* and some crappy haters are at fault here , end of story
6ARA Forever butthurt fans here😂😂😂😂
this makes me happy bc as a queen of 4 years ( going 5 years in july) i get frustrated when ppl badh T-ara and honestly, i saw this video before and i used to think it was who was chosen as the prettiest and it didnt bother me and i didnt understand why ppl thought it was bullying of hwayoung was chosen. nonetheless, I'll stick with T-ara no matter what. thanks for this video.
Just because Hwayoung looks more like quiet person doesn't mean she's bullied. Well, i don't know about Ahreum. She new & her career on T-Ara was quick, even i don't realize if she was around. Because the last T-Ara MV i follow was Lovey Dovey.
She actually leave T-ara because of stress. Cause haters keeps on attacking her.
Thanks for uploading this! Really, there is nothing wrong in informing and defending the truth! If the Antis and the real bully K-netz won't stop, we Queen's shouldn't stop either to show our love and support for our T-ARAs! And Big Thanks for doing this +TheQueenJiyeon !
It's okay, T ara has their Chinese fans and other international fans (ME!)who will keep supporting them.
I strongly believed that every body has their own stress level, sadness, anger, eagerness to survive, happiness. I sincerely hope that beautiful and kindhearted Tara,( tiara) are able to not mind what other people may assume and really understand just how amazing and beautiful their voices are and how incredible that they r still there for each other thru out all these year whether they present themselves publicaly or work with other male groups. Please believe me.
when the whole group doesn't like someone it means smt. they don't act like that cause of nothing.
Behind her smile, its fake. She jusst wants others to be picked so ahe can have something to laugh at and not about her.. :/
But
Anyone besides me gets the irony of the song "Lies" as T-ara's debut song? T-ara announced they will do a comeback later in 2021.
Pass the word to all Queen's.
(T-ara fandom meaning "Belonging to the Queens of Kpop, the Queen's own.)(Although proper English would be Queens', meaning Belonging to multiple Queens, but this is Korean, not English nor American.)
THIS VIDEO NEEDS TOFUCKING SPREAD LIKE WILDFIRE ON THE INTERNET PEOPLE QUICK SHARE THIS ON TWITTER
The haters should stop now! Stop blaming our precious T-ara.. They should be shame of themselves!
Queen's, let's continue our support for our lovely T-ara.. T-ara unnies, saranghaeyo👑👑👑💝💝💝
I appreciate your effort but I think it's useless now to explain all the stuff about it to the haters. SK don't deserve a legendary elite, talented group like T-ARA.
Just let them be, let them hate while us QUEENS will keep supporting them.
It is indeed a shame that they can't be popular anymore but T-ARA don't need that amymore since have loyal and dedicated fans already.
Those idiots can keep believing in false accusations and keep hating on them calling them flops or bullies but we all know T-ARA is made their mark in the Kpop industry and proved many dipshits that they are indeed untouchable legends.
Nora Enkhtaivan their amazingly successful in China they don't need the kpop industry period their the only kpop group granted permission by the government to promote over there that's pretty impressive since their popularity is huge
and the fact that i was in the Fandom a month before the incident makes me feel really happy yet with the incident , people start hating them and makes me really upset.
Poor T-ara, they lived with snake🐍🐍🐍
Margo Stewart poor hwayoung..she live with snakes
redvelvet for life k Have you ever read the news about T-ara?
Margo Stewart yeahh..ive read about tara,and ive read about hwayoungs side too..so both are wrong and only one must not be sided
redvelvet for life k Why did Hwayoung's sister threaten to former member Areum?
Who knows what is happening behind the scene...noone knows what ahreum or tara members are doimg off cam to make ryu sisters angry
I love every T-ara members (Even Hwayoung)
Hwuayoung is a🐍
stay strong t-ara. we always support you 💪💪👭👭👭
My personal opinion
It's just people react too fast,they doesn't even try to know the whole story and start blaming and criticizing. Bullying is a matter that can be misunderstood easily. just like in jimin's (AoA) case. Even now we don't know the whole story still there r thousands of video about ppl bashing her. I'm not AoA or jimin's fans nor I'm defending her.but a matter can b seen differently by different point of view so I simply think K-pop fans shouldn't criticized idols so early that they don't even bother to know the whole story
(ALSO IT'S MY PERSONAL OPINION IF YOU R OFFENDED BY IT I'M SORRY PLZ IGNORE IT)
I agree .. peoples just jump into conclusions so fast like they know everything and they were with them personally to know every detail ..
who will survive in the end hmmm
True
T-ARA deserve to rise !!!
I hate that girl named hwayoung Tried to play victim huh
What kind of questionnaire is that!?
There only LAUGHING! Its just for fun!
People misunderstood everything 😳😡
#FightingT-ara
can you explain Hwayoung's tweet please?? Lots of Tara antis seem to use that as their main defence
Please upload more soon. this was really good.
Something rubs me the wrong way about her. There was definitely some fakeness and conflicts in the group
only that girl is fake. she single handly ruin t ara. t ara would have became soo popualr and more successful but she ruined t ara
Yeah hwarat was fake and she got exposed like a rat.
Can someone explain to me what happened? Of course I’ll do my own research later on.
Xiaojie Ziyun soo from what I know this girl tried to avoid preforming at the concert faked a leg injury. Causing trouble rest of t ara to REHEARSE and change the concert songs. She did all that to avoid preforming at a concert.
Offcourse there are , they actually admit that they have misunderstanding sometimes. But it's really far from bullying.
i know this comment is irrelevant but omg just look at qri's visual.... she's so pretty even when she's giving the "restless bitch face". qri is a queen for sure hahaha
the fact hwayoung is snake make t-ara disbanned, other member not bully her...that scandal is hoax
i honestly thing that this whole situstion was stupid! T-ara was so polular and one of the biggest girl group at that time, they were contributing with the "k-wave" and people rave about them, they had international fandom and they were so big in asia especially japan, but antis and k-nets ruined it by made or belive with false rumor and hwayoung who make the situation worse and playing as victim to gain public sympathy, when T-ara should be apriciated for thrir hard work and spread k-wave "heat" at thst time!
congrats, now the truth revealed
We cannot judge on who's fault it is, we may never know what really happened. But to my opinion the people (management) are the blame for not letting the band (group) choose who they want in their group instead its the management who are the ones that dump individuals in/out of a group without a say or a vote, obviously by doing that you would get few individuals who would not get along. So tell me who's fault it is?
I still say the twins
Please Search to Facebook, Twitter, INS,... and more. I don't need T-ARA to be as famous as 5 years ago. HOWEVER, I don't accept that IN SOME Newspaper, HWA still called " a member of T-ARA" although She left this group. I can't that she slapped in the face and No staffs can criticize her because her house is rich.
#Need_Justice_For_T-ARA
Their not
Below is a translation of the leaked chat messages:
Hyoyoung: Ahreum it’s Hyoyoung unnie.
Ahreum: Yes unnie hi^^!!
Hyoyoung: Ahrem you have to be thankful and say thank you when you’re being taken care of. If you don’t want to get beaten up act right. Word spreads fast in this field. Don’t mouth around and don’t act cheap ^^. I’m extremely angry right now so let’s not run into each other.
Hyoyoung: If I’ve misunderstood anything do you want to meet and talk? Or do you want to apologize now.
Ahreum: I don’t know what you’re talking about but I want to meet and talk. I’ve never done anything bad enough to deserve to hear such words.
Hyoyoung: Little ones can get lost.
Hyoyoung: I’m going to beat the dust off you at Music Bank.
Hyoyoung: I’m going to scratch your face so you can’t go on TV**
Hyoyoung: ㅎㅎㅎ Just you wait~^^
Hyoyoung: I’m not going to be a singer ㅎ so just wait ^^. Dogs only listen when they take a beating.
Hyoyoung: You bitch. Just wait until I catch you.
Hyoyoung: Yes just keep~~~snitching.
They’re 🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍
Poor Ahreum 😭😭😭😭, she is a great person
I think hwayoung is a new member in T-ARA. So she is not good with these game , events. Like u a new member in a group, They talk and laugh together, but u just sit there, dont know anything to say , to do. I saw a lot of T ara Games, events, hwayoung cant follow up the team, she cant fake acting( fake smile, v.v. ) either. about she was buillied, thats not her fault. The other groups, fans, companies hate T-Ara , so they make thing in those clip that T-Ara buillied hwayoung to ruin t-ara. they are the one that we should blame to
I never like her from the start, even I tried too
In my opinion they can get angry anytime but their all pretty. No one is ugly for me. 🥰
Do you have a full video where Jiyeon didn't high five hwayoung I want to watch it. Because I believe in Jiyeon hehehe
The staff exposing Hwayoung:
The staff member goes on to discuss Hwayoung’s leg injury from July 2012. The staff member confirms that while Hwayoung did fall, she was released from the hospital with her manager, after doctors said there were no serious issues.
However, after she returned home she went to another hospital and got herself a semi-cast. She would take the cast off when she was inside transport but would ask the manager to help her walk when reporters were around.
PPL NEED TO KNOW THIS I DON'T CARE IF IT'S TOO FUCKING LATE IWILLCUTYOUALL T-ARA DIDN'T DESERVE WHAT HAPPENED GODDAMNIT!
this is really sad😭😭😭
and now im 9 years late
So how about other proof that t ara bullying hwayoung? Can u explain that too?
it was forged, can't believe y'all believe shit 💀
You're crying over nothing sticks and Bones but words will never hurt me
yeah please upload more and more
No, they won't learn, people without wisdom won't ever commit that he/she is a fool, that's how stuborn they are.
I don’t think they bullied her and o don’t think she was in the wrong either. I bet you she just didn’t fit in with them, which sometimes happens. It’s normal because you won’t always fit in everywhere. And because she didn’t fit in, she just misunderstood their words and actions. When you are insecure, your mind does that to you. If they laugh, you think they are making fun of you. And then they sense her insecurity. It was just an uncomfortable situation that for really twisted.
agreed
Hwayoung didn't say anything.... she just stay quiet.... remember.... everyone laugh..... together....
hwayoung is the one that bullying the group
How can she bully the whole group? That was so impossible
@@kimberlyumiten1358 it is possible and that what makes it easy to fool the blind fans. I had seen some idol doing that but i won't mention the name.
for an example when this 1 idol "acting nicely" while other just being themselves not "acting nicely" subconsciously making blind fans thinking "why can't the rest of the member being nice?"
then you discovered actually that 1 "nice" idol have history of back mouthing/backstabbing their member/friends in social media that's when you realise that idol not really that "nice".
that idol just pretended to be nice in front of the camera to make her member look like the bad 1.
it sad but it happen.. hopefully all the bad fake idol that trying to sabotage their own member get exposed
@@yawntownsmultistan579 so this girl bullied everyone or is everyone just bitter so their making this up
Kpop ruined my life her two sister bullied one of the members but she acted like a victim instead and even faked getting her leg hurt and other stuff. You can search this up and there will be more details on it.
WAIT SHES FROM HELLO MY TWENTIES!!!! (This is late but I I was looking rewatching Hello my 20s and I searched more about the cast and realized she was in a a girl group and now I’m here)
Everyone's mad at hwayoung so I thought she was the one who bullied them but if I'm correct netizens made speculations that the members bullied her. And the only bad thing hwa young did was not speak on it?? If that's what happened I feel bad for all of them cause it's normal to have fights with friends but it ruined them cause it was public
can someone pls explain the situation and all cuz i dont even know how i ended up here but i wanna know?
It was said that the members of T-ara were bullying one of their members Hwayoung, Hwayoung was then removed from the group which fueled the fire even more. It soon came out that both Hwayoung and her sister were in fact the bullies. Hwayoung even faked an injury during their tour but was seen getting her nails done
@@andredrw289 That is wrong. There were no bullies and Hwayoung didn't fake an injury. It was basically a misunderstanding that got out of hand.
t-ara-and-hwayoung.blogspot.com/
I miss my queens 😢🖤
thank you so much, I'll share it everywhere 😄
hwa never denied she was bullied, we dont know what happened to her at home
Well she got exposed and her explanation was : "I never said I was bullied it was knets who did it dont blame me for something you did"
She actually denies it ones and choose to be silent after.
t ara was one of the first kpop group I know, the more I look into the case the sadder I get. it seems like it was just small discord because they was so busy and stressed out. added with poor management that caused big reaction and bad interpretation/overreaction by knetz that made it went out of control. MBK and knetz was shit at that time and that's it. MBK is still shit tho, poor DIA😔
MBK and knetz : Shit
i want to see how about if other group especially from famous agency do a same thing(bully) too and what their reaction.. same as T-ARA get or not..
it happens always, snsd freaking kicked jessica out and nothing happened
KAI-RIL -A- It already happened to the legendary group SNSD who people were all speculating she was ignored ALL the time and was kicked out but what to do they're legend ain't they? So ofcourse no one would talk.
TheQueenJiyeon ok but snsd doesnt kicked jessica, sm did..
all the member agreed on kicking her out
Anyone who knows the opening song, it may seem off but I really want to know, please.
T-ara hurt until today (prism)
"...hwayoung as the ugliest member"
i dunno if her twin agrees
She knows it well... Lol HAAHAHAH. JK ✌️
Im mad with hwayoung but im also upset with the members and the staff why just exposed her after years of tormenting them she ruined the group they lives and career they should have fought .
Well they did try to expose her but no one believed and T-ara got hated more because it was seen like T-ara was making up lies to frame the innocent rat
Because their management believed that time , that if they just stayed quiet people will just forget that issue. The management also wants to protect Hwayoung and her sister as well.
I really like T-ara area especially Hyomin since I watch Invincible Youth because of SNSD but I start to love other groups..If only this incident didn't happen then I think T-ara would be popular until now..😔 This bullying case really destroy T-ara's career..
I think haters are at fault here
I'm glad that I wasn't blind at first.
intro song ? i still love T-ara QUEENS FOREVER
T-ara prism
hwayoung looks constipated lmao
To be honest, the people who wrote the article and the reason a lot of people started to blame T-Ara for bullying Hwayoung is in fact even more terrible person. People who still hates them because of bullying Hwayoung needs to get back on their life and MOVE ON. It's year 2016 and soon 2017. No human will still stand still because one day, each human will have to fall as well to learn from it. If T-Ara quit because of the scandal, they would be seen as weaklings, but they didnt quit. Because they still remember the fans and people who will truly support them till the end!
T-ARA❤️6-ARA
that's so cruel there all lovely ladies its a shame people are so cruel to put them down even in a game
From the first , i am never know if Hwayoung part of T Ara. I am never hear her nama.
Maybe she ia ghost
I think Hwayoung isn't a liar but Kwon Mina is a liar.
AREUM the best..miss you areum😥😥
i can't believe jiyeon get 0 vote
Good because i hate kpop
#WeAreSorryForTara
please support t-ara. make in trending topic of twitter, althought it's difficult
Jessica Panjaitan they need disband..
Who you ? why tho?
can i know the opening title song?
T-ara prism
can anyone tell me who was the bully and who was being bullied?
Back to the days when this blew up, the media made the T-ARA members seems like they're bullying Hwayoung. When in reality, Hwayoung, along with her twin sister are the actual bullies.
There is no bullying happened. Lol
why does everyone hate Hwayoung and call her a snake? please explain?
Martha Borrott cause they are dumbass fans of tara,blindfolded by the outer beauty of tara
Martha Borrott Because Hwayoung said a lie and so many people didn't try to understand the events.They blame to T-ara, they insulted.(I saw so many bad comments about T-ara.Poor T-ara didn't to deserve that).Last year,Hwayoung sister's messages was leaked.She threatened to former member Areum.
Because she lead public to believe she was bullied and forced out of T Ara. It was later revealed that she and her twin were instigating a lot of issues that lead to her being forced out
@@jellofish9934 calm down
Dude idk like a few hours ago many articles revealed that she bullied the girls and covered it up.
Hwayong : confirm
Jimin : we will know the truth soon
I just wanna know what happened to t-ara??? Could anyone tell me please!!
They sometimes voted Hyo and Q
So Hyomin it is...
Her face is scary 😱 😭
El poder de una "aparecida" 🤣
Whats the song playing in the beginning?
T-ara - Hurt until today
I think she doesn't know japanese
What song is playing?
T-ara prism
The truth is out already the twins is not innocent
#STAN #TARA #SorryFor5Year #RYUSNAKE
Jahat banget sih fitnah mereka padahal wktu itu mereka lagi naik daun, lagu mereka ok2
En verdad existo en realidad el Bullyin, lo que es un hecho es que Hyomin no pertenece a T-ara. "Es una lastima"
Bully is not funny,
Who do that Will destroy..
It was fake.
What is the background Music in the beginning Soo Good 👀
Oh damn what is happening, bullying? Sister hostage? Snakes?? Someone please explain even if it is super late I still wanna know
It’s old news from 2012 but it’s okay I can explain it to you. It’s the saddest scandal I know :(
So basically t-ara is innocent and that snake hwayoung (the one with fake expressions and the one not laughing while everybody else is laughing) faked a leg injury just because she didn’t want to perform. A rumor spread that t-ara was bullying hwayoung (which wasn’t true) and it made lots of problems on the internet, yet hwayoung didn’t even bother to release a statement that t-ara didn’t do anything. So yeah she ruined their career. If she had released a statement nothing would’ve happened :( what a snake, tara had so much potential and were basically the second top girl group at that time after girl’s generation and Koreans thought tara were the only ones that could beat girls generation literally fuck you hwayoung
For more info read this article www.allkpop.com/forum/threads/t-aras-entire-story-whole-t-ara-scandal-possessed-member-t-ara-before-with-pics.272196/
@@saba9803 oh damn, I will read those articles thank you
Oh and additional info hwayoung is a woman now and an actress I think she is a wife and pregnant :)
@@saba9803 oh my this is so sad. I saw their group recently on knowing bros. and didn't know them honestly but started to like their songs. I especially like Jiyeong. Hope they have a comeback.
@@saba9803 she's not married or pregnant.
What song name? First song
I haven't understand a fucking thing xD anything at all xD jajajajajaa. But was great that it was in japanese ^^
what is the rumer about them?
what is the name of tara's song which is on first minutes,
prism
what's the opening song?
Melati Kamah t-ara hurt until today
So, who's bullying who?
See, you can't tell , cause there's no bullying at all hahahaha.
What song naem? I'm okay?
کیمیا بلند هم tara- hurt until today