Pleasantly surprised by the response to this video! Please let me know if you'd like to see a part two and any suggestions for the content of that video!
Andrew Forde would love a part 2....how about something the focuses on certain aspects of foul play....tripping for example - one of the most cowardly pieces of foul play in our game. Really love your channel Andrew 👍
Yes please, seeing Nathan Hines pulling off his crap is always amusing. That he's a coach now is kinda mental. I don't watch Top 14 rugby but i'm always imagining Montpellier as a team of very naughty boys 🤣
“Ruckgate” was probably the funniest thing I have seen in test level rugby. The clip of a very confused Dylan Hartley trying to get an explanation from the ref are even better 😂
@@atticuscorbett2111 thats what I thought, sure someone with a better knowledge of rules can explain why it isnt. If it isnt then why dont u c more teams doing it?
There seems to be a lot of confusion regarding shithousery, so to clarify... Sometimes it's cheating, other times it's perfectly legal. Usually it's clever, often it winds up the opposition. Occasionally it's downright disrespectful, but it's always funny! P.S. great work Andrew, love these original concept videos.
Leith scrum half : I know it's naive but it's gamesmanship not sportsmanship. Once money crept into rugby it was as plain as the nose on your face that it would go the same way as football.
@@stevetaylor9846 As soon as money enters the arena, kiss honor in the game good bye. I was just thinking about how Rugby has been unaffected by the lure but I was wrong.
Well said Sir, notably by a scrum half. It shows rugby chaps have a well honed sense of humour. I used to play with a prop who carried lipstick in his pocket and would do his lips before the first scrum and then kissed his oppo. Some coped with it and some did not. The rest of us pissed ourselves laughing.
Naas Botha's five drop goals were better I think. ruclips.net/video/xlrFHd-EHNE/видео.html Yes, it wasn't a RWC, but it was the most important tournament in SA in those days and both sides were packed with Springboks. The big difference for me, is that (a) they were taken more in open play i.e less organised (not waiting on a call in the pocket) (b) the old leather ball.
Jacques Hughes Never knew Naas Botha had already done that. Never got to see Botha play as his career was just coming to an end as I got into the game. Would have liked to have seen some of those Boks-Danie Gerber sounded an awesome player.
@@jacqueshughes3085 Naas's five were fantastic, true, but not in an international, so JDB takes the win on this one. In any event, I don't think anyone else has ever done that. Of course, drop goals are not important. They can't win you important matches like, say, the RWC final or anything...
To me thats tactics and playing to your strengths. The whole point of the game is to score points and keeping the scoreboard ticking over puts pressure on the other team.
Janie de Beer's five drop goals were not shithousery at all. Perfectly within the laws and he was just touched by the rugby gods that day. Totally brilliant!
In 2003 Johnny Wilkinson was on fine form for England and there was a lot of squealing that drop-goals ought to be downgraded. They weren't saying that when England were being kicked out of the WC in 1999.
Those 5 drop goals remind me that when rugby was invented, the whole point was to get into a position to score goals. A try was only worth one point, and the main point of scoring one was to be in a position to take the conversion. That is why it was called a "try" - you could try to take the kick. 5 drop goals you would be the hero.
@@sionfitzgerald6333 Yeh, could not even remember what I had said! In my defence though, it was 8 months ago, that would be a concern if you had replied to a comment I made yesterday. Also, I would make the point that if I comment on something that happened a thousand years ago, all it means is that I can read history, does not make me Methusalah. But yeah, i do have first hand recollection of actual rucking, and the five eigths kicking out in full anywhere for field position, and tries being worth 4 points (or was it 3?), so I am quite old. Nobody wants to get old, but if you don't die before then, that is what happens.
Things is, I don't think you can particularly blame Phillips or Rees, and the refereee didn't see it, but I can't for the life of me understand how the assistant ref said it was definitely the same ball! That was mad.
One I can remember was Auckland vs Canterbury 2002. Canterbury kick the ball too far, Carlos Spencer watches as the ball rolls into their in goal area as Andrew Merhtens approaches. Carlos steps on the ball with his foot, acting as though that counts as forcing the ball. Then he casually picks the ball up and walks towards the 22, like he’s going to take a drop out. Merhtens falls for it and turns his back on Carlos, walking back to the 22. As soon as Andrew turns around Carlos runs and continues play, because you can’t force the ball with your foot 😅 Another one was with Adrian Cashmore for Auckland, in 99 I think. Auckland had a penalty 10m out or something like that. For some reason everyone assumed he was taking a shot at goal. The opposition team turned their backs expecting a shot at goal. Cashmore taps the ball and walks over for a try. Can’t remember who it was against.
On the Little/shoe thing, I can well remember a Swansea v. Ponty game @ St Helen's when a mislaid Ponty boot was bunged into the Bank crowd by a certain Swansea & Wales player. After a short(ish) game of pass the parcel in the crowd it eventually made its way back to the pitch, but not until after that phase of play was over!
I'm unable to use Super Rugby footage or Rugby Championship footage, so I don't think I'll be able to make a de Allende tribute to a standard that he deserves I'm afraid as a lot of footage will be missing.
After the ref had instructed John Smit to speak with the team. I'm pretty sure that was the refs last international match - or very close to it, pretty much ended his test career as it should have. Ronan O'Gara was involved from memory - always give me great pleasure to watch him get run over on the way to a try, make stupid decisions then take the man out in the air to snatch defeat from the draw at the end of the 2nd lions test in 09. I don't believe in Karma, but damn he definitely deserved that.
@@AndrewDavidForde Yeah, O'Shea was the head coach, but Venter was the defense coach and he was the one who came up with the idea. It's typical mischievous Venter. Google it - there's a Guardian article from early 2018 where they interviewed O'Shea, Venter and Parisse about it.
Italy was tactical because the ruck was not formed so it was open play the lenster try counts because it was a penalty he has 4 choices to pick a scrum kick for touch tap and go of kick for goal
I love Nathan Hines for managing to hold 3 players in the ruck. Being honest though, I hated being held back and always saw it as twatty play. A one off in an important position I could forgive, but a player doing it on a regular basis is just wrong as far as I'm concerned and deserves a punch that doesn't get noticed by the officials.
I would also like to suggest people jumping when receiving a pass to avoid a tackle. They should be sin bined but no that's always punish that committed tackler.
I never understood Italy's offside defence but I really respected their pinash as a newcomer to the 6 nations. They weren't just there to make up the numbers and every year after England they're my favourites.
It was a "loophole" in the laws that they had obviously discussed with the ref beforehand. Before anyone complains about the use of loophole there, yes I know it wasn't a loophole really, but the IRB obviously thought it was against the spirit of the game as changed the rules the following year to stop it happening again. As much as it was entertaining (unless you were an England fan), it's not the sort of thing you want being replicated.
Obviously it’s being good at rugby, most of these are just being good at rugby, but that’s another level, the disrespect that they just kept slotting the point every time they entered the 22. England had zero response.
I think before or early part of the professional game I remember hearing drop goals just wearnt done or respected. Only trys mattered. I remember people complaining about the English 03 wc victory and we only got it due to wilko boot and didn't play proper rugby. Now people just say fucking impressive but the game is evolved a lot
@@BooshisLoose1 100%agree. To refer this as shit is totally disgusting and disrespectful to a world record. Jannie's 5th drop goal must be one of the best ever. Let's not forget how the WC was won in 1995 & 2003.
Re. Pienaar taking the full 90 seconds - in football they have a rule of 'Ungentlemanly conduct' - don't know if there's something similar in rugby but he should have stopped the conversion and ordered the re-start.
Although Hayden dived and it was definitely skullduggery that’s not what the penalty was given for so had no effect on the game, unlike those in this vid. However, he did succeed in making himself look like a goose.
About the Italy ruck episode. I understand at that time the rules said no ruck is formed if one team is not putting players into it but what I can't understand is why they don't just tackle the English number 9 , if no ruck is formed then it's open play isnt it ? Why wait for the 9 to pass the ball
to play you have to go through the gate . This being the tackled player . If you go through the gate you would make contact with the English and thereby create a ruck , which they did not want.
Why? They were attempting to charge him and disrupt his place kick, so he just pointed it out. EXACTLY the same way as a scrumhalf steps back from a ruck or a scrum and throws his arms up: "hey ref, do you believe what they are doing here?!"
Absolutely agreed! What do you reckon about Super Rugby Aotearoa? Golden Point introduced and all of a sudden more drop goal attempts by NZ teams in one weekend than in the last few years of Super Rugby 🙄 I like the idea of a clear winner, but all these drop goals can be a bit ridiculous!
@@rukaks Mate I'm all on board with the Golden Point. Nothing worse than getting to full-time and having a draw. Adds a bit of tension and excitement to the end. But I reckon it's good to see it come back into the arsenal. Had a bit too much pressure on the boys over the last few years to always go for a try when just punting one over and resetting would have been a better option. That said, I don't want it to become the default option. It's not in our DNA though so should be OK.
Against "how we play in NZ"? Really? I submit for your consideration one of the most famous drop goals ever, by one of the most famous All Blacks: Zinzan Brooke v England in the RWC 1995. But of course, a Kiwi would never even contemplate such a thing.
Loved a lot of them. That lift for the conversion 🤣 Only 2 I would say I was not a fan of was the England Italy game was a joke. Clever but it ruined the game. The other being Wales try against Ireland. I wish that could have been reversed.
I'll never understand why people moan about Italy changing their tackle technique to find a new way of defending and avoiding an offside line forming at a ruck. It was genius, and it was up to England to find a way around it. They ought to have realised that they should just pick-and-go, the advantage Italy exploited wasn't the laws, it's that England's players were dense. It's the only match ever between the teams that's worth watching.
Gordon Struth - to be fair, it wasn’t England being dense it was the law being applied inconsistently during the game. Haskell even asked the ref for clarification and the ref brushed him off with that pathetic ‘im not your coach’ line. Funnily enough, Italy still lost.
I'm amazed Hines didn't get cracked for that. If they'd at least hit his arms the ref would've been fine with it- like getting raked for holding. You cheat and the ref can allow certain actions to go ahead.
What’s wrong with the lions using lifters, the five drop goals, the Nathan Hines holding 3 grown men, madigans quick try, the racing quick try and the last one, all perfectly legal and a great use of initiative to win the game.
Some great shenanigans! I think you have to be innovative, but it’s clear by actually knowing the laws you can turn them to your advantage... every caught ball while keeping your foot out of touch for example. Think K Read knocking the ball out of Johnny Gray’s hands in 2017 was pretty shitty, but what I would love to see again was a penalty right on the try line and the tallest player on the team *headed* it over the defence for someone to run round & touchdown!! Is this still allowed in either code do you know?
the 5 DGs just highlight the fuckwittery that is rugby union's 3pt for a DG rule. it'd be a far better sport reducing it to one point and penalty kicks to two points as per league.
The thing that most Munster fans overlook is the fact that Peter Stringer dummied the put-in to try to draw the penalty from the Tigers pack. Which is cheating! This is why the ref missed it. Stringer made the motion of putting the ball in and the ball went in! albeit in the direction of the tigers tight five. If Stringer hadn't cheated Backy wouldn't have had the opportunity. Oh and to be fair any decent No. 7 would do the same thing. If you think you're favourite no.7 wouldn't you're kidding yourself. P.s. That was my best trip to Cardiff ever.
There have been some very bad refereeing mistakes, but nobody got injured. It’s the thuggery that some refs. choose not to see and adjudicate on that upsets me.
I'd be interested to know how many of these weren't pinged by the refs eventually. Many are a bit of quick thinking. Some are gamemanship. Others are outright cheating and poor sportsmanship outside of the spirit of the game.
Pleasantly surprised by the response to this video! Please let me know if you'd like to see a part two and any suggestions for the content of that video!
Part two ASAP
Andrew Forde would love a part 2....how about something the focuses on certain aspects of foul play....tripping for example - one of the most cowardly pieces of foul play in our game. Really love your channel Andrew 👍
You misspelled 'fuckery'...
One name, Finlay Calder a hundred incidents to choose from.
Yes please, seeing Nathan Hines pulling off his crap is always amusing. That he's a coach now is kinda mental. I don't watch Top 14 rugby but i'm always imagining Montpellier as a team of very naughty boys 🤣
'You can't win a game with just drop-goals'.
'Hold my DeBeer'.
😂😂😂😂
Dont tell Naas
“Ruckgate” was probably the funniest thing I have seen in test level rugby. The clip of a very confused Dylan Hartley trying to get an explanation from the ref are even better 😂
Let's be honest Dylan Hartley still needs which shoe goes on which foot explaining.
"What do we do?" Lol
Is it not offside?
@@atticuscorbett2111 thats what I thought, sure someone with a better knowledge of rules can explain why it isnt. If it isnt then why dont u c more teams doing it?
@@garyhammond7683 If there is no ruck formed then there is no off side line to be in front of
Jannie de beer was just a class act that day
Ok, but, it doesn't look that hard. Why don't they do that more often?
Michael Branson Because it is
Michael Branson it reallybis
English butthurt again :D
But he was a twat every day
You forgot when that french player threw away Maro Itojes scrum cap in this year's 6 nations 😂😂😂😂
So true 😂👏🏻🤣 I saw it live
That wales try from the illegal quick line-out still hurts to this day
There seems to be a lot of confusion regarding shithousery, so to clarify...
Sometimes it's cheating, other times it's perfectly legal.
Usually it's clever, often it winds up the opposition.
Occasionally it's downright disrespectful, but it's always funny!
P.S. great work Andrew, love these original concept videos.
Leith scrum half : I know it's naive but it's gamesmanship not sportsmanship. Once money crept into rugby it was as plain as the nose on your face that it would go the same way as football.
It's perfectly legal if you don't get caught 😉😆
@@stevetaylor9846 As soon as money enters the arena, kiss honor in the game good bye. I was just thinking about how Rugby has been unaffected by the lure but I was wrong.
i believe we in the USA call it "gaming the system"
Well said Sir, notably by a scrum half. It shows rugby chaps have a well honed sense of humour.
I used to play with a prop who carried lipstick in his pocket and would do his lips before the first scrum and then kissed his oppo. Some coped with it and some did not. The rest of us pissed ourselves laughing.
Italy’s offside defence was brilliant. I don’t think you can blame them for it!
You can't say its in the spirit of the game
Tim Loves Bacon Yeah England definitely had the better team and were well capable of winning, but the match was incredibly entertaining.
Tim Loves Bacon Italians surrendering? Well, they have form...
Haskell: 'Sir on the ruck thing, what do we have to do, to make it a ruck?'
Poite: 'I am the referee not a coach, your coach will have the solution'
What was the deal with that? Referee seemed to allow it.
As an England fan, i can't class Janie Dr Beer's drop goals as shithousery. It had just not realy been done before (or since?) Fair play
Naas Botha's five drop goals were better I think. ruclips.net/video/xlrFHd-EHNE/видео.html Yes, it wasn't a RWC, but it was the most important tournament in SA in those days and both sides were packed with Springboks. The big difference for me, is that (a) they were taken more in open play i.e less organised (not waiting on a call in the pocket) (b) the old leather ball.
Jacques Hughes Never knew Naas Botha had already done that. Never got to see Botha play as his career was just coming to an end as I got into the game. Would have liked to have seen some of those Boks-Danie Gerber sounded an awesome player.
@@jacqueshughes3085 Naas's five were fantastic, true, but not in an international, so JDB takes the win on this one.
In any event, I don't think anyone else has ever done that.
Of course, drop goals are not important. They can't win you important matches like, say, the RWC final or anything...
I mean it kind of is shithousery, but more in a "nananie booboo you can't stop me" way
To me thats tactics and playing to your strengths. The whole point of the game is to score points and keeping the scoreboard ticking over puts pressure on the other team.
Janie de Beer's five drop goals were not shithousery at all. Perfectly within the laws and he was just touched by the rugby gods that day. Totally brilliant!
In 2003 Johnny Wilkinson was on fine form for England and there was a lot of squealing that drop-goals ought to be downgraded. They weren't saying that when England were being kicked out of the WC in 1999.
@@douglasporter3865 ok
The day an All Black kicks 5 droppies is his last day in the black jersey
@@rbjohmson77 and probably wins the game.
Those 5 drop goals remind me that when rugby was invented, the whole point was to get into a position to score goals. A try was only worth one point, and the main point of scoring one was to be in a position to take the conversion. That is why it was called a "try" - you could try to take the kick. 5 drop goals you would be the hero.
You must be very old 😂
@@sionfitzgerald6333 Yeh, could not even remember what I had said! In my defence though, it was 8 months ago, that would be a concern if you had replied to a comment I made yesterday. Also, I would make the point that if I comment on something that happened a thousand years ago, all it means is that I can read history, does not make me Methusalah. But yeah, i do have first hand recollection of actual rucking, and the five eigths kicking out in full anywhere for field position, and tries being worth 4 points (or was it 3?), so I am quite old. Nobody wants to get old, but if you don't die before then, that is what happens.
originally an unconverted try was worth nothing
Yes it was a try at goal
And a drop goal until the 50s i think was worth 4 points, when a try was worth 3.
4 out of 5 drop goals from 35m+ though.. can't argue with that
I always smile when England forgot ruck rules against Italy 😂
Especially when the English players asked the ref what to do about Italys abstract tactic.
Richard Platt And the ref answered “I’m the referee, not your manager!”
@@adopancia7445 Yes, it made all stand up and take notice.
I've played twenty years and never ever seen it done
I always smile at the 36-15 scoreline...
We got shafted with the hand of back and that phillips try. Annoying, but nothing we can do about t is now
There's a guy on the previous thread who's been banging on about it for nine years!
Things is, I don't think you can particularly blame Phillips or Rees, and the refereee didn't see it, but I can't for the life of me understand how the assistant ref said it was definitely the same ball! That was mad.
I would hate to win knowing I was a cheat.
Rory Watkins if you ain’t cheating you’re last
Rory Watkins I don’t think they care, that’s the thing with shithouses
Ah that Italian game. I've never seen professional rugby players so confused.
1:04 Damn I've never seen a pen blocked by players in that way before. Amazing.
Those were the days, back when Daleks commentated on rugby.
Making 5 dropkick conversions on someone is just sheer disrespect lmao.
Sheer rugby genius, is what it was. You give me the opportunity for points, I am going to take it.
Not disrespectful. But it did show up the limitations of the Boks from that era.
It's no more disrespectful than johnny Wilkinson kicking penalty after penalty.
You snooze you loose. That's Rugby.
One I can remember was Auckland vs Canterbury 2002. Canterbury kick the ball too far, Carlos Spencer watches as the ball rolls into their in goal area as Andrew Merhtens approaches. Carlos steps on the ball with his foot, acting as though that counts as forcing the ball. Then he casually picks the ball up and walks towards the 22, like he’s going to take a drop out. Merhtens falls for it and turns his back on Carlos, walking back to the 22. As soon as Andrew turns around Carlos runs and continues play, because you can’t force the ball with your foot 😅
Another one was with Adrian Cashmore for Auckland, in 99 I think. Auckland had a penalty 10m out or something like that. For some reason everyone assumed he was taking a shot at goal. The opposition team turned their backs expecting a shot at goal. Cashmore taps the ball and walks over for a try. Can’t remember who it was against.
On the Little/shoe thing, I can well remember a Swansea v. Ponty game @ St Helen's when a mislaid Ponty boot was bunged into the Bank crowd by a certain Swansea & Wales player. After a short(ish) game of pass the parcel in the crowd it eventually made its way back to the pitch, but not until after that phase of play was over!
Can't remember that. At a guess, I'd say Moriarty (the younger)?
Damien de Allende tribute please can't wait for his munster debut
Great vid btw 👍👊
I'm unable to use Super Rugby footage or Rugby Championship footage, so I don't think I'll be able to make a de Allende tribute to a standard that he deserves I'm afraid as a lot of footage will be missing.
@@AndrewDavidForde aw pity mate, keep the good videos coming anyways,only thing getting me through quarantine
Fw I’ll see what I can do and try and post it on a second channel, he’s a top player so I wish I could !
They show the South Africans drop goals against England. But they didn't show England winning the World Cup off the boot of Johnny Wilkinson.
Ye cus no one likes England
But that wasn’t gamesmanship, it was the last minute of extra time.
@@keithorbell8946 Johnny Wilkinson kicked the ball over the posts, on at least six occasions.
Number 1 still hurts me, and I wasn’t even born yet
I'm still sore about those Jannie de Beer kicks. Seems like yesterday.
Ireland's quick tap against South Africa in Dublin think in 2005 when South Africa were still in the a huddle??
After the ref had instructed John Smit to speak with the team. I'm pretty sure that was the refs last international match - or very close to it, pretty much ended his test career as it should have.
Ronan O'Gara was involved from memory - always give me great pleasure to watch him get run over on the way to a try, make stupid decisions then take the man out in the air to snatch defeat from the draw at the end of the 2nd lions test in 09. I don't believe in Karma, but damn he definitely deserved that.
Jannie de Beer!! What a legend
I loved "ruckgate". Brendan Venter at his finest!
It was Conor O’Shea
@@AndrewDavidForde Yeah, O'Shea was the head coach, but Venter was the defense coach and he was the one who came up with the idea. It's typical mischievous Venter. Google it - there's a Guardian article from early 2018 where they interviewed O'Shea, Venter and Parisse about it.
I felt it was sheer genius what the Italians did, pity they didn't win the match.
Neil Back is my favourite rugby player of all time.
A bit of Sean Fitzpatrick ripping off opposing teams head bandages is worth a few lols
Italy was tactical because the ruck was not formed so it was open play the lenster try counts because it was a penalty he has 4 choices to pick a scrum kick for touch tap and go of kick for goal
Great video.. thanks Andrew, from Johannesburg, South Africa.
cybermen @ 5:40?
yes
2:17 if you play a tough team and need some point utilize drop goals. We did a few times in high school but only if you have accurate kickers.
I love Nathan Hines for managing to hold 3 players in the ruck. Being honest though, I hated being held back and always saw it as twatty play. A one off in an important position I could forgive, but a player doing it on a regular basis is just wrong as far as I'm concerned and deserves a punch that doesn't get noticed by the officials.
Pretty much gives you the all clear to deck them in though and no one can complain. I don't know why they didn't.
De beer... 'hold my beer'
1:20 - Please tell me they scored a try off the following scrum. LOL
I was at that match in Béziers, there was a cracking 30 man fight in the second half.
Jimmy Cowen pulling Bakkies Botha's jersey could be added for part 2.
What the hell is De Beer's 5 drop goals doing on here? Genius, not sh*thousery.
Saw the Glasgow try at sarries it was quite funny seeing what maro did it appeared that faz was a fan of it as well as he kept laughing
This is probably my favourite video of yours
"Shithousery" is my new favorite word. Is it commonplace where you hail from? It isn't here in the States.
Pretty much said all the time
NEIL BACK
EPIC
SHIT-HOUSE
Fully deserves to be Number one😀😀😀
Andy Hayden jumping out of the line to get an easy penalty against Wales. I know its a long time ago but it still rankles. 😢
Haha no.12 was my university team - UPRFC from Plymouth University playing Varsity against Marjon team ;)
I thought I recognised Dent! Not sure this is from Varsity is it though?
Jack I would think so - kit looks like it’s form that - you can see Cracker and I think Rups in the beginning as well
14 was absolute genius.
de beer - a typical Sth African excitement machine ...
I would also like to suggest people jumping when receiving a pass to avoid a tackle. They should be sin bined but no that's always punish that committed tackler.
May need to explain what you mean by jumping to avoid the tackle if they end up getting tackled regardless.
I think I've experienced this video in one match today. ENG vs WAL. Many bad decisions by the referee.
Not entirely sure how the lions lifting to block the kick is bad ,I thought it was just smart
I agree. Same with de Beer's 5 drop goals.
It is specifically outlawed in the Laws Of The Game
decko20009 not at the time
I never understood Italy's offside defence but I really respected their pinash as a newcomer to the 6 nations. They weren't just there to make up the numbers and every year after England they're my favourites.
It was a "loophole" in the laws that they had obviously discussed with the ref beforehand. Before anyone complains about the use of loophole there, yes I know it wasn't a loophole really, but the IRB obviously thought it was against the spirit of the game as changed the rules the following year to stop it happening again. As much as it was entertaining (unless you were an England fan), it's not the sort of thing you want being replicated.
how were those 5 drop goals 'shithousery'? isn't that just being good at rugby?
Its pure disrespect on the other team to be sloting over 5 drop goals
Obviously it’s being good at rugby, most of these are just being good at rugby, but that’s another level, the disrespect that they just kept slotting the point every time they entered the 22. England had zero response.
@@AndrewDavidForde Name of the game is to score points however they come.
I think before or early part of the professional game I remember hearing drop goals just wearnt done or respected. Only trys mattered. I remember people complaining about the English 03 wc victory and we only got it due to wilko boot and didn't play proper rugby. Now people just say fucking impressive but the game is evolved a lot
@@BooshisLoose1 100%agree. To refer this as shit is totally disgusting and disrespectful to a world record. Jannie's 5th drop goal must be one of the best ever. Let's not forget how the WC was won in 1995 & 2003.
Re. Pienaar taking the full 90 seconds - in football they have a rule of 'Ungentlemanly conduct' - don't know if there's something similar in rugby but he should have stopped the conversion and ordered the re-start.
The lions penalty block attempt was a brilliant idea and i'm lost as to why some teams don't try it in desperate situations now. Is it illegal?
Yes, rule change shortly after.
Not a Rugby fan.
RUclips: Wanna watch this?
Sure ...
The hines one is hilarious
You've missed out Haden's dive against Wales in 1978. Massive omission.
Although Hayden dived and it was definitely skullduggery that’s not what the penalty was given for so had no effect on the game, unlike those in this vid. However, he did succeed in making himself look like a goose.
Pienaar 90 seconds to kick that is shithousery.
2:53 Number 5 he must have young kids at home ha ha
Ian madigans quick penalty was funny cause he now plays for ulster
Wouldn't really call de Beer's drop goals shithousery, more like opportunism.
Great content. Thanks.
00:04 the hand of god
About the Italy ruck episode. I understand at that time the rules said no ruck is formed if one team is not putting players into it but what I can't understand is why they don't just tackle the English number 9 , if no ruck is formed then it's open play isnt it ? Why wait for the 9 to pass the ball
to play you have to go through the gate . This being the tackled player . If you go through the gate you would make contact with the English and thereby create a ruck , which they did not want.
De Beer was quite rude actually...😂🙈
Carbonel deserves a slap 😂
Nope, that was funny and cheeky. They were trying to charge him.
Wonder what happened to him when he next got the ball in contact, though...
How about Maro Itoje pulling a players jersey inside out over their head whilst trying to clamber over a ruck.
He inspired me to do it myself 😂
It should really just be 20 examples from the All Blacks only!
Clearly the Boks pack didn't fancy it, that day.
Lots of great tricky stuff here, why were the south Africa drop goals included?
Sound have been a penalty against the French kicker at 1:00 for ungentlemanly conduct.
Why? They were attempting to charge him and disrupt his place kick, so he just pointed it out.
EXACTLY the same way as a scrumhalf steps back from a ruck or a scrum and throws his arms up: "hey ref, do you believe what they are doing here?!"
De Beer’s drop goals against the English haha. People in glass houses…
What was shit about England loosing by 5 drop goals when thats exactly how they won the world cup
2:44 is my favorite. Hahahahaha
some of them are just tongue in cheek, some of them are quick and clever thinking, but some are pure cheating that should not exist in the game
There's nothing in the rules that says a dog can't play...
The Neil Back incident was hilarious. I was there, and the Irish supporters were doing their nuts. It was so funny.
No, the Munster fans where.
Does Ronan O Gara scoring a try against the Springboks, after the ref told John Smit to talk to his players count? ... Or is that more in the ref?
Also, Carlos Spenser walking to the corner flag to score when he could've scored under the posts... And still getting the conversion
Seeing all those drop kicks just crushes my soul. Can't fault him for it, but it's so antithetical to how we play in NZ
Absolutely agreed!
What do you reckon about Super Rugby Aotearoa? Golden Point introduced and all of a sudden more drop goal attempts by NZ teams in one weekend than in the last few years of Super Rugby 🙄 I like the idea of a clear winner, but all these drop goals can be a bit ridiculous!
@@rukaks Mate I'm all on board with the Golden Point. Nothing worse than getting to full-time and having a draw. Adds a bit of tension and excitement to the end.
But I reckon it's good to see it come back into the arsenal. Had a bit too much pressure on the boys over the last few years to always go for a try when just punting one over and resetting would have been a better option.
That said, I don't want it to become the default option. It's not in our DNA though so should be OK.
Against "how we play in NZ"? Really?
I submit for your consideration one of the most famous drop goals ever, by one of the most famous All Blacks: Zinzan Brooke v England in the RWC 1995.
But of course, a Kiwi would never even contemplate such a thing.
@@interestedbystander196 I stand corrected. How could I forget the number one skill required of all loose forwards; droppies.
@@mikedangerdoes Doesn't matter what position the man was playing in, it was a brilliant drop goal in a WC semi final.
Maybe Cudmore’s from Quebec
What did de Beer do wrong?
Another class vid by AF
Why is Dan Biggar doing the entire macarena before every kick not on here?
Loved a lot of them. That lift for the conversion 🤣
Only 2 I would say I was not a fan of was the England Italy game was a joke. Clever but it ruined the game. The other being Wales try against Ireland. I wish that could have been reversed.
I'll never understand why people moan about Italy changing their tackle technique to find a new way of defending and avoiding an offside line forming at a ruck. It was genius, and it was up to England to find a way around it. They ought to have realised that they should just pick-and-go, the advantage Italy exploited wasn't the laws, it's that England's players were dense. It's the only match ever between the teams that's worth watching.
Gordon Struth - to be fair, it wasn’t England being dense it was the law being applied inconsistently during the game. Haskell even asked the ref for clarification and the ref brushed him off with that pathetic ‘im not your coach’ line. Funnily enough, Italy still lost.
Who’s better, me or Wilkinson?
Cheeky one by Neil Back
I'm amazed Hines didn't get cracked for that. If they'd at least hit his arms the ref would've been fine with it- like getting raked for holding. You cheat and the ref can allow certain actions to go ahead.
Nothing like a bit of raking and stamping if guy is offside in the ruck too!! As long as it’s not his head that is😀
Janie Dr Beer drop kicked england out of the 1999 RWC
nice vid
one question: were do u get ur vids cause i was thinking of making a channel too
And now you can add the French ref giving Wales a try yesterday against England
What’s wrong with the lions using lifters, the five drop goals, the Nathan Hines holding 3 grown men, madigans quick try, the racing quick try and the last one, all perfectly legal and a great use of initiative to win the game.
Nathan Hines was clearly not legal they’re ur not allowed to hold a player in the ruck after the balls lefy
I don't think you understand what shithousery means.
So holding people illegally in the ruck is now know as using initiative? I don’t think so
you can't say that the lions cheated by stopping the penalty because it is perfectly legal
At the time, I believe they’ve changed the Law now, which is a shame.
Some great shenanigans! I think you have to be innovative, but it’s clear by actually knowing the laws you can turn them to your advantage... every caught ball while keeping your foot out of touch for example.
Think K Read knocking the ball out of Johnny Gray’s hands in 2017 was pretty shitty, but what I would love to see again was a penalty right on the try line and the tallest player on the team *headed* it over the defence for someone to run round & touchdown!! Is this still allowed in either code do you know?
It’s still considered no knock on off the head in both I’m pretty sure, not entirely sure tho. Definitely qualifies as shithousery
the 5 DGs just highlight the fuckwittery that is rugby union's 3pt for a DG rule. it'd be a far better sport reducing it to one point and penalty kicks to two points as per league.
I LOVE RUGBY!!!!!!!!
I wouldn't call the De Beer DGs shithousery. Its hard to do. Of course it was a tactic which conceded that SA couldn't beat England in any other way.
Neil Back, just cheating.
I sense a butthurt Munster fan - sincerly, a tigers fan😂
A Dirty, Low down trick and to be honest that is what I remember when I see or hear Neil Back's name.
@@marathonman51 Funny, the first thing I think when I hear his name is world cup winner.
The thing that most Munster fans overlook is the fact that Peter Stringer dummied the put-in to try to draw the penalty from the Tigers pack. Which is cheating! This is why the ref missed it. Stringer made the motion of putting the ball in and the ball went in! albeit in the direction of the tigers tight five. If Stringer hadn't cheated Backy wouldn't have had the opportunity.
Oh and to be fair any decent No. 7 would do the same thing. If you think you're favourite no.7 wouldn't you're kidding yourself.
P.s. That was my best trip to Cardiff ever.
There have been some very bad refereeing mistakes, but nobody got injured. It’s the thuggery that some refs. choose not to see and adjudicate on that upsets me.
I'd be interested to know how many of these weren't pinged by the refs eventually. Many are a bit of quick thinking. Some are gamemanship. Others are outright cheating and poor sportsmanship outside of the spirit of the game.