How The AXIS Could Have Won... (AlternateHistoryHub Reaction)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 345

  • @emanueldervishi9761
    @emanueldervishi9761 Месяц назад +177

    Dont forget,Germany said to the Italians WW2 would start around 1942,which is probably the reason italy was so garbage during WW2.If they were prepared they could have done a major difference

    • @Very_spicyseaweed
      @Very_spicyseaweed Месяц назад +24

      The leadership of Italy was just not gonna cut it, whether or not they had time to build up. Their best general (subjectively) Giovanni Messe was even kept in a political position in Albania because of his *royalist background.* Even after he was kept in charge of the Italian Expeditionary Force in Russia, which is even further from Italy than Albania. Keep in mind that one of their largest problems was the constant bombing of Northern Italy's cities (Milan, Venice, Turin, Florence, their largest) was culling their capabilities overall.

    • @frequan6261
      @frequan6261 Месяц назад +9

      Allies on their own would’ve steamrolled germany if they waited until 1942

    • @Hank-y8j
      @Hank-y8j Месяц назад +1

      @@Very_spicyseaweed

    • @hollister2320
      @hollister2320 Месяц назад +1

      You’re right, from 💩 their pants in ‘45 rather than ‘43😂

    • @FTN_Ale
      @FTN_Ale Месяц назад

      @@Very_spicyseaweed he also went to the african front

  • @francoislacombe9071
    @francoislacombe9071 Месяц назад +93

    The Manhattan Project completed 3 bombs before the war ended. One was tested at the Trinity site, the other two were used on Japan. A fourth was being readied, but Japan surrendered and it was never completed. Its plutonium core was recovered and used for research, becoming the infamous Demon Core after it caused two criticality incidents and killed two scientists. It was then melted down and recycled into other weapons.

  • @Kaisermormof9646
    @Kaisermormof9646 Месяц назад +145

    09:45-10:08 Drew, you seem to forget Russia's defeat in WWI. The Germans thought that Russia was in the same Situation as they were in WWI, thus making it super easy to beat Russia. Wich of course was not true.

    • @nabakunlaismime5526
      @nabakunlaismime5526 Месяц назад

      Wich

    • @minestar2247
      @minestar2247 Месяц назад +13

      on top of the loss against finland in addition to the anti judeo bolchevic(that era's cultural marxism) conspiracy
      yeah, the germans really underestimated russia

    • @Ijst19
      @Ijst19 Месяц назад +9

      yea it goes under the radar the fact that Germany won the war on the eastern front, unlike the western front. So when they blitzed France and the rest of Europe in ww2 you could forgive them in thinking they could do it again in defeating the Russians..

    • @IkeaOrca569
      @IkeaOrca569 Месяц назад

      ​@@Ijst19 I mean with that amount of troops they can in this alternative timeline where they did not have to worry of africa and britain. But Holding onto that soviet territories would be a nightmare . That amount of resistance will shatter any hope for a full conquest of siberia, central asia and the british isles

    • @A-Rd
      @A-Rd Месяц назад

      Doesn't germans was industrializing and training army with them?

  • @shades_of_reality
    @shades_of_reality Месяц назад +56

    The idea Alternate History Hub had, that was the same thing I had been thinking for a long time. I once read somewhere that Guderian's Panzer division had come close to taking Dunkirk before the Sichelschnitt was completed so I guess that could also have happened. And the British and France also held Germans near Senne river so if that had not happened, it would have been even easier

  • @JustaBunchofGoofs
    @JustaBunchofGoofs 2 часа назад +1

    13:25 YES! Mosley I was so upset he didn’t mention him in the video

  • @13Joshuahun
    @13Joshuahun Месяц назад +26

    Have you ever watched WW2: In colour on Netflix/RUclips it goes through the key battles and moments using old footage on with both the German/Russian/UK side and US/Japan side and it does really give you a sense of how close some battles where to changing how the next few months at least would have played out. Highly recommend

  • @BasicallyBaconSandvichIV
    @BasicallyBaconSandvichIV Месяц назад +88

    The memes would be very interesting in this timeline. Instead of mainly France surrender, it'll be bri'ish incompetence.

    • @SciRuler
      @SciRuler Месяц назад +8

      Why not both? French and British surrender, despite both winning WW1

    • @oliversherman2414
      @oliversherman2414 27 дней назад +1

      ​@@SciRulerand despite France having the most military victories in history

  • @PolishGuy54
    @PolishGuy54 Месяц назад +41

    9:57 Polish Bolshevik war wasnt defensive war for poland it was offensive war. It was started because polish Hicom knew that Soviets would strike so they decided to strike first

  • @ugrasergun
    @ugrasergun Месяц назад +15

    16:00 you forget about the mud season if you do that your military will be bugged down by mud instead of snow. Actually a winter invasion is much better when the ground is frozen and you can use your mechanized units more easily.

    • @SciRuler
      @SciRuler Месяц назад

      Your opinion on why German launched offensives in Summer (the mud hardened by then iirc) while Soviet launched offensives in Winter?

    • @AntoninHamstra
      @AntoninHamstra Месяц назад +1

      Only if your vehicles are cold resistant. The german mistake was thinking ",we'll have Russia completely on its knees long before winter" and only gave their soldiers summer uniforms and not making enough winter uniforms. The Germans were quite capable of fighting in cold environments, as shown by their divisions that were stationed in Finland and fought the Finns and the Soviets after the Finns changed sides

    • @ugrasergun
      @ugrasergun Месяц назад +1

      @@AntoninHamstra I meant it would be better than late winter offensive a summer offensive is of course would be more advantageous for Germany.

    • @AntoninHamstra
      @AntoninHamstra Месяц назад +1

      @@ugrasergun I see

  • @GyörgyMátyás47
    @GyörgyMátyás47 Месяц назад +56

    Petition for drew to make a hungarian countryball plushie day 28 or something i forgot again

  • @bc10Comrade
    @bc10Comrade Месяц назад +19

    Petition for drew to play Guts and Blackpowder while talking about the 18th century (day 278)

  • @mescalero_3309
    @mescalero_3309 Месяц назад +55

    Brother what? Invade late winter??
    If you did that, then once everything starts to thaw you would not be able to move ahead a single centimetre, since literally all of Russia turns into mud that season

    • @minestar2247
      @minestar2247 Месяц назад

      the mongols managed to do that, what's the excuse?

    • @-landon931
      @-landon931 Месяц назад +4

      Yes!

    • @Darth_B
      @Darth_B Месяц назад +3

      I mean It’d be genius
      Without the mud

    • @mescalero_3309
      @mescalero_3309 Месяц назад +2

      @@Darth_B yeah, but the mud is there and that is the one reason, why germany didnt attack earlier in our timeline

    • @leviop3407
      @leviop3407 Месяц назад +1

      spring would have been best

  • @frostysharkboi
    @frostysharkboi Месяц назад +10

    12:12 a war with the Soviet Union was not something one could stop, the main reason the Germans went after th was for ideological reasons, Hitlers goal from the start had always been to destroy the USSR, not Britain. In fact the reason they wanted peace with Britain as so they could focus all of their energy on an attack of to the USSR. Germany not attacking the USSR means Nazism at its core is completely different and probably never rises to power in the first place, instead being replaced by a different lucky facist group

  • @Zimbabweballenthusiast
    @Zimbabweballenthusiast Месяц назад +182

    Petition for a 🇿🇼 plushy day, 212

  • @KostaKilibarda
    @KostaKilibarda Месяц назад +6

    basically thank god dunkirk was sucessful

  • @187Streak
    @187Streak Месяц назад +10

    Petition to have Drew enlisted in Albanian Navy

  • @marechal_joukov2375
    @marechal_joukov2375 Месяц назад +1

    19:52 many of the soviet plan were rly good Drew ! For real

  • @lawden210
    @lawden210 Месяц назад +21

    28:25 Does Drew realise he's reading a bot comment?

    • @firezgamer6965
      @firezgamer6965 Месяц назад +9

      Considering him, I don't think he realizes

    • @chaosgamer016_5
      @chaosgamer016_5 Месяц назад +6

      Well you see how that bot works is it steals real peoples coment and other bots mass like it so that some idiot wuld think it's an real person and click it's shady link

    • @StinkyCheeseYT
      @StinkyCheeseYT Месяц назад +1

      ​@@chaosgamer016_5 Literally only kids 8 and below fall for that💀

    • @peace_2520
      @peace_2520 Месяц назад

      @@StinkyCheeseYT Yes and there are a lot of 8 year olds on the internet

    • @StinkyCheeseYT
      @StinkyCheeseYT Месяц назад

      @@peace_2520 Yeah sadly

  • @Tami42069
    @Tami42069 Месяц назад +3

    Drew should react to all of Projekt Kaisertum

  • @minestar2247
    @minestar2247 Месяц назад +1

    13:32 well yeah, who says that in a case of the british losing, oswalt mosley wouldn't get more power, especially since he was active at the time

  • @Trinibagox
    @Trinibagox Месяц назад +5

    Petition for drew to make a trinidad and Tobago country ball plushie day 24 or something idk

  • @generaledelogu1892
    @generaledelogu1892 Месяц назад +1

    Now I get to rewatch the video only with Drew commentating over it 😎

  • @Potato_salad_plays
    @Potato_salad_plays Месяц назад

    i love it how at 24:58 they use battle ships from the movie howls moving caslte

  • @Henricoras863
    @Henricoras863 День назад +1

    Nice video

  • @jenshjsteen2595
    @jenshjsteen2595 Месяц назад +1

    16:20
    Winter will not be the best time to invade bechause of the mud in spring/ late winter

  • @chrisbeer5685
    @chrisbeer5685 Месяц назад +2

    16:14
    *Laughs in Spring Rasputitsa

  • @sleepycat-f7w
    @sleepycat-f7w Месяц назад +3

    Are you sure about that? Attack Russia in spring? cold and muddy? all vehicles stuck in the road and most maneuver thing become horse?

  • @AntoninHamstra
    @AntoninHamstra Месяц назад

    16:11 You forget that after the winter, all the snow melts and rain comes and the ground gets very muddy which would slow you down. The next year after the Germans invaded the USSR, 1942, they continued to advance, but their equipment and soldiers were bogged down by all the mud and it really slowed down their advance into the Steppe and the Caucasus.

  • @Dsksaito_
    @Dsksaito_ Месяц назад +2

    you should react to zvallid video of What If USA had joined Germany in 1917 during WW1? he made other video of WW2 - What if USA joined Axis instead of the Allies,WW2 - What if Soviets join Axis in 1940.

  • @largestudent198
    @largestudent198 Месяц назад

    The moment an individual is erased from perspective is the moment humanity has lost.

  • @N3bula_Finn
    @N3bula_Finn Месяц назад +1

    Petition for a winter war style Finland ball: day 16

  • @Nooob3775
    @Nooob3775 Месяц назад +1

    I don’t think the American planes would even be able to get to Germany with the Luftwaffa being a threat

    • @solarissv777
      @solarissv777 Месяц назад +1

      Yeah, during, basically, battle of Britain. Against much more experienced German pilots in (due to the lack of allied bombings) more advanced planes.

  • @shrehanshukla6617
    @shrehanshukla6617 Месяц назад +1

    Y’all need to watch zvalid for alternative history

  • @michaelsickenger7692
    @michaelsickenger7692 Месяц назад

    Lets get this man a Mozambique plush.

  • @apxnear9768
    @apxnear9768 Месяц назад

    Petition for drew to make a nono Germany, kingdom of Italy and imperial Japan countryball

  • @a7medkws135
    @a7medkws135 Месяц назад

    Even late winter its to muddy to move trucks and tanks because all the snow melts

  • @craftingattacker-e5686
    @craftingattacker-e5686 Месяц назад +2

    My question for this video would be, from where would the US nuke Germany, the UK is gone, would they build a aircraft carier so big it could let a B-29 take air? Or would they do something completly else? And btw, Germany had there own atomic program, well it was more directed towords a reactor, but you never know...

    • @lillj-2020
      @lillj-2020 Месяц назад +1

      Yeah and i dont see how the US would of finished the Nuke at that time because we captured german scientists during the war and they helped make the nuke with the knowledge they already had so if we never captured those scientists how would we of been able to finish the madhatten project at that time??

    • @andysierra1618
      @andysierra1618 Месяц назад

      ​@@lillj-2020Actually I don't even see the germans launching Sea Lion, which would be the point? They would have already gotten everything they wanted from them. Mustache man even wanted to allie Britain at the beginning

  • @MexicanDOOM
    @MexicanDOOM 12 дней назад

    I say Japan only surrendered because of Hirohito's say so. The military was ready to resist an American Invasion.

  • @PolskaPrussia
    @PolskaPrussia Месяц назад +1

    Petition for drew to make a malta countryball (day 209h
    In honor of Malta Ball for keeping this up. I haven't seen his post yet so blow this out of the water guys.

  • @Titan-cameraman676
    @Titan-cameraman676 Месяц назад +1

    2:14 N@z! Bikers never heard of it

  • @nathanbent7610
    @nathanbent7610 Месяц назад +2

    the problem with invading Russia Late winter is that the second the ground thaws it becomes all mud even the roads

  • @TheRealKiRBEY
    @TheRealKiRBEY Месяц назад

    So by this alt version of history dunkirk would be the most important event in the world

  • @Football_Belgium
    @Football_Belgium Месяц назад

    4:51 watched it drew u should too i watched it many times and also yesterday

  • @jaydenriemer3970
    @jaydenriemer3970 Месяц назад +1

    Petition for a Prussia and Venice countryball plush day 86.

  • @yiannchrst
    @yiannchrst Месяц назад

    Nice vid! May the algorithm gods bless you

  • @welshpotato9
    @welshpotato9 Месяц назад +1

    petition for cymru plushy day 703

  • @liviapavel316
    @liviapavel316 Месяц назад

    I could recommend a very good alternative Chanel its called: possible history

  • @MrsjulieMackay
    @MrsjulieMackay Месяц назад +1

    Petition For Drew To Visit Norway (Day 109)

  • @TheThirdR3
    @TheThirdR3 Месяц назад

    .....
    0:15 he's gonna regret saying that in WW3

  • @regentmad1037
    @regentmad1037 Месяц назад

    who knows if germany would have still declared if they didn't feel quite as desperate and concerned.

  • @ProfTricky3168
    @ProfTricky3168 Месяц назад +2

    Drew should follow with CallMeEzekeal WW2 videos

  • @ilovesaintlucia
    @ilovesaintlucia Месяц назад

    I just realized that “POW” means prisoner of war

  • @Gogeta-oo2ed
    @Gogeta-oo2ed Месяц назад +1

    Can you make usa British ball and kingdom of France now

  • @miguelpaulo3125
    @miguelpaulo3125 Месяц назад

    i really doubt that the soviets would colapse in mounths. One of the biggest problems with barbarosa was the dificulties to supply the frontlines, and even if the germans had captured moscow, they would still had to deal with the soviets in the urals and maybe siberia.

  • @varnasblade
    @varnasblade Месяц назад

    Actually Drew the Germans probably went at the most optimal time in Russia. After Winter you get something called Rasputitsa which is when all the ground ice melts and the spring rains turn the world to mud. And tanks aren't making it very far in that.

  • @regentmad1037
    @regentmad1037 Месяц назад

    when that happens all of russia turns to mud XD. it's virtually impassible after the thaw.

  • @shrekler8538
    @shrekler8538 Месяц назад

    Petition for drew to revive his old age of history 2 videos day 470

  • @Beloved1cor13
    @Beloved1cor13 Месяц назад +1

    Hor4 of iron IIII 0:23

  • @galaxyexplorer8075
    @galaxyexplorer8075 Месяц назад +1

    Day 255 of getting Drew to make a New Zealand ball with a laser kiwi accessory

  • @tapani1857
    @tapani1857 Месяц назад

    The most unrealistic part of this scenario is Operation Sealion.

    • @Dylan-yy3rw
      @Dylan-yy3rw 21 день назад

      Of the germans spent a few years with the steel and oil of all of europe,, they could probably make a bigger navy than the British. So it may have happened eventually. I don't think 1945, I think closer to 1948 or 49.

  • @daviddonley-kh8iv
    @daviddonley-kh8iv Месяц назад +1

    lol it abbreviates to AHH

  • @TanioGamer
    @TanioGamer Месяц назад

    I really like that flag behind u 🇧🇷

  • @justanotherv1ncesupporter207
    @justanotherv1ncesupporter207 Месяц назад

    Appreciate the Sicilian flag my friend, for that I'm starting a petition for a Sicilian plushie, day 1.

  • @Glazay-5603
    @Glazay-5603 Месяц назад

    27:30 They probably would not care if they got nuked, after all they fought till the very, very end.

  • @janegovednik1982
    @janegovednik1982 Месяц назад +1

    Oh what is Germany didn’t invade the Soviet Union and the Soviet union ended up joining the axis so that might have made the Axes win

    • @HypnoticChronic1
      @HypnoticChronic1 Месяц назад

      The USSR joining the Axis would be extremely unlikely, it viewed both the Germans and the Japanese as military and specifically ideological threats. Keeping the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact in place may have prolonged the war for Germany potentially pushing the war into the late 40's, but assuming all other events played out the way they did historically minus the USSR involvement then, that means the US still gets involved and eventually overwhelms Germany. The only difference in this case would be the US, UK etc. would take far higher casualties, since all German forces would be allocated to fighting them instead.

  • @samuelyninoskareis6482
    @samuelyninoskareis6482 Месяц назад

    Petition to Drew to make a Venezuela plush (day 121)

  • @davidbanszky1945
    @davidbanszky1945 Месяц назад +1

    Petition for Drew to make Hungary countryball plushie (day 246)

  • @AliKhan-oc4rk
    @AliKhan-oc4rk 24 дня назад

    The south American flaga💀💀💀💀💀💀

  • @ashchisalleh1454
    @ashchisalleh1454 Месяц назад +1

    Summon the Zombie H!!! That the answer.

  • @regentmad1037
    @regentmad1037 Месяц назад +1

    yeah because of hitler's concepts of lebensraum. germany had to be 100% self sufficient, as well as his hatred of communists makes me think he would have attacked no matter what. it might have been postponed a bit though because fuel shortages wouldn't have been as dyer. a little more prep time to get it right with less desperation and shortages.

  • @thanku7
    @thanku7 Месяц назад

    Petition for a south korean plushie

  • @regentmad1037
    @regentmad1037 Месяц назад

    who said that? my god they were integral. couldn't win without them.

  • @Turtleman-b6b
    @Turtleman-b6b Месяц назад

    funny cuz i just did this in risk universalis

  • @HypnoticChronic1
    @HypnoticChronic1 Месяц назад

    Point of note here where Drew is wrong, Poland didn't win its independence from Russia/USSR during the Polish-Soviet War, it was already independent via the Treaty of Versailles, it would be factually correct to say Poland retained its independence, by pushing the Russians back out of Polish territory and sparing most of the rest of Europe from communism for a extra 20ish years.

  • @lillj-2020
    @lillj-2020 Месяц назад +1

    How would the US Finish the madhatten project if we never Took the German Scientists?? Thats one big problem no one is talking about people forget the US captured Many German Scientists and had help making the atomic bomb and people also forget Germany was trying to figure out how to make a nuclear bomb them selfs during the war???

  • @Kehfyhjajfhfb
    @Kehfyhjajfhfb Месяц назад

    Petition for a ball balls ball plushie balls plushie ball day, 2

  • @HappyManOfficial
    @HappyManOfficial Месяц назад

    Petition for a 🏴‍☠️ plushy day 567

  • @ThymeHere
    @ThymeHere Месяц назад +2

    57MI
    493 L
    108 C
    1,45M S
    3 863 V
    SEP 5 2024

  • @monkeypie8701
    @monkeypie8701 Месяц назад +1

    Or just, don't take on both the USSR and the US at the same time! One or the other, not both!

  • @Trickaz94
    @Trickaz94 Месяц назад

    Classic mistake, thinking attacking in the winter is a good idea because of the thaw in spring
    But it's the spring warmth that causes the most problems, the thaw causes the frozen ground to melt and become a giant mud field that becomes impossible to cross with an army and their supply lines
    So no, attacking in late winter would be even more disastrous

  • @shabnamqureshi5630
    @shabnamqureshi5630 Месяц назад

    But germany was thinking about making a book before Americans

  • @HansPeter-e2o
    @HansPeter-e2o Месяц назад

    The thing with the ending is that germany developed nukes the usa could only create there nukes cause they had captured german engeniers

  • @CliffCardi
    @CliffCardi Месяц назад

    Petition for Drew to display the flag of Equestria on his wall (Day 517)

  • @eduardpeeterlemming
    @eduardpeeterlemming Месяц назад

    I have watched Dunkirk and enjoyed it alot

  • @MarkEndernatorbro
    @MarkEndernatorbro Месяц назад +1

    SICILY

  • @Blaar_federal_fighter_corps
    @Blaar_federal_fighter_corps Месяц назад +1

    Me:ITS WAS 8 HOURS AHHHHHHHHHH (i am danish)

  • @Redbeardian
    @Redbeardian Месяц назад

    I think this alternate timeline fails right at the beginning. Rescinding the order to halt squeezing into the Dunkirk pocket wouldn't magically make logistics teleport all the ammo, fuel, food, water, etc to the troops to refit and make an advance feasible within a day. It's quite possible that a poorly equipped attack could be stopped and even countered causing a disaster for the Germans.

  • @TheRavenLord1
    @TheRavenLord1 Месяц назад +2

    Petition for Drew to get a SPQR Roman Empire flag Day 289

    • @Capitala-București
      @Capitala-București Месяц назад +1

      Signed

    • @DoubleTroubleMapping
      @DoubleTroubleMapping Месяц назад +1

      Signed

    • @Kaisermormof9646
      @Kaisermormof9646 Месяц назад

      @@TheRavenLord1 I love Rome, because I AM ROME! -most European countries like at least once.
      But not me, I hate Rome and the ridiculous amounts of focus it gets!
      Don't mean to be rude BTW, just saying.

    • @roghider319
      @roghider319 Месяц назад

      ​@@Kaisermormof9646 Romaboo here. Meet me at Teutenburg, 1v1.

  • @JosephHudson-nv8vt
    @JosephHudson-nv8vt Месяц назад

    Petition for a small drop (San Marino Monaco Andorra Luxemburg Liechtenstein)

  • @sincere9412
    @sincere9412 Месяц назад +1

    Honestly the only way the fascist regime would survive, no I don’t think it will, but in the New order, Speer is liberal, so he may save Germany as he is for the people.

  • @SpazzMaticu3
    @SpazzMaticu3 Месяц назад

    The best world.

  • @soezyoucantevencomprehend
    @soezyoucantevencomprehend Месяц назад +2

    Day 232 of supporting Capital-Bucharest's petition for Drew to visit Romania

  • @youryoutubeyoda
    @youryoutubeyoda Месяц назад

    That's not how nukes in the 40s work though. Without Britain, they wouldn't have any close airbase to launch the aircraft with the nukes. Even if they did, it seems like the German air defenses would be impossible to pass through without a grinding air war. Realistically, Germans have a years to consolidate their gains and even develop their own super bombs and missiles until Americans make intercontinental missiles.

  • @SamButler22
    @SamButler22 Месяц назад

    Imagine German anime

  • @Bird0b0b
    @Bird0b0b Месяц назад

    WHERE DO YOU GET YOURE FLAGS!?!?!?

  • @szymon_sowa
    @szymon_sowa Месяц назад

    Fun fact: everyone here born pre 2011 is older than a country

    • @SquidMonke4
      @SquidMonke4 Месяц назад +1

      Chinland is an unrecognized country made in 2024

  • @andycarter6620
    @andycarter6620 Месяц назад

    Day 2 asking for Kenya contryball

  • @Cazh023
    @Cazh023 Месяц назад

    If Churchill wanted us there, we would be there. Peace deal or not. If the US decides we’re going to do something, that’s also where things end. Germany could take Europe, could’ve taken the UK. Could’ve gone into Russia, the US is defeating them. If you want to question that, question why Germany and Japan are now our allies.

  • @Wildiscool
    @Wildiscool Месяц назад

    Petition for drew to reqd his comments day 3

  • @lukecarlson-ek9ic
    @lukecarlson-ek9ic Месяц назад +1

    Sweden never declared war Russia Russia declared war on Sweden, Sweden, Russia