RED SUMMER OF 1919 - 10th Cav Buffalo Soldiers vs Police
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 авг 2024
- In this video we discuss what were the drivers to the horrific "Red Summer of 1919" by focusing on one specific event - the Battle for Brewery Gulch in Bisbee, Arizona on July 3rd, 1919.
If you'd like to read the full text of the memo sent by Colonel J.L.A. Linard (underneath General Pershing's command) to the French command, you can do so via this link:
www.dropbox.com/s/jid41qe1cr8...
InRange is entirely viewer supported:
/ inrangetv
"If they're this aggressive toward you when your armed, just imagine what they'll be like if your defenseless"
*you're
@@96SN95 really?
@@Dreadought Yup
You're = you are. Your = something that belongs to you.
armed minorities are hard to Oppress
Yet another example of why you shouldn’t surrender your arms, and why you should embrace your fellow Americans as brothers/sisters.
100 rounds fired and nobody hit except the unfortunate Hispanic woman. I’m thinking the soldiers had been drinking and the posse were just shitty marksmen.
@@Chiller01 Or were trying to NOT murder each other, but too stubborn to stand down.
@Frank Tank stop that.
@Adam Williams he can say it and we can also tell him hes a piece of shit for saying it. So fuck off.
i mean he's not wrong. you can't support globalization and marxism and still claim to be a patriot of the United States.
Thats incredible, Americans literally wrote letters saying 'do not treat these troops like normal people because they're African American' and the French troops were like 'wow' and burned them up🔥
Sadly, Black Jack Perishing was the writer. A young officer served under Gen Perishing after Columbus New Mexico. He was a very young Gen George Patton.
To be fair, the military is subordinate to the civilian government in the US so he had to follow the policies of Woodrow Wilson and the southern Democrats. And writing 'do not treat these troops like normal people _in front of white Americans'_ kind of makes the white Americans sound bad if seeing a black man treated normally will set them off...
Here in SW England, when GIs arrived in the '40s the locals accepted them, and didn't give a stuff about colour. There were documented occassions when white GI's tried to stop black GIs dancing with local girls, and the white GIs were shown the door. The view here was that these men are coming to our Country to fight; who cares what colour they are?
Yeah that's very noble and i'm proud that my country did that, but to be fair the french officers did that more because the military desperately needed more men, and knowing that if you give soldiers the respect they deserve they'll usually fight way better, rather than because they were shocked by the rascim and segregation (i'm pretty confident most of them were hardliner colonialists). The French Army had tons of colonial troops fighting on the western front that are still not given the credit they deserve (eventhough the idea they were seen as more expendable is wrong, their casualty rates are similar or lower than the white soldiers')
@@alanlawson4180 I was going to say something along the same lines.
A lot of people in Cornwall (and elsewhere I'm sure) won't have sugar in tea because they didn't want to support the plantations abroad.
gun channel sharing anti-racist messages and talking about Wobblies in a positive light, love to see it
God help us
@Brian Zhang facts real leftists all about the constitution and 2a rights
the history speaks for itself. it just needs to be told
@@enathanielg If they haven't I'm hoping they cover Blair Mountain. The Free Speech Fights would also be awesome to see covered, but I'm probably hoping for a bit too much there.
Pretty sure this confirms my suspicions about inranges political leanings, and that makes me over the moon
I might like the directly firearm related content on this channel, but I support this channel for pieces like this. Great work, keep it up!
Karl, your empathy is refreshing. The loudest voices never seem to have any. Yours is worth listening to.
I really enjoy these Vignette videos! I'm of the belief that all history, no matter how "uncomfortable" or "shocking", must be preserved and understood. We cannot allow ourselves to forget. Many of your Vignette videos have taught me about historical events which I wouldn't otherwise have been aware of. Thank you for sharing your love of history! :)
If we don't learn from past mistakes, we are forced to repeat them.
Also personally, and as a German, I 100% agree with you.
@Matt Thanks for the tip. I'll check it out! :)
@Matt Will check this out.
Pro 2A, Pro Wobbly, Pro history, Anti racist. This is why I love Karl and Inrange. Keep up the good work. Just gained a patreon sub
Being European and not following Amarican politics and sentiments, can someone explain to me what 'Pro Wobbly' means? I figured 'pro 2a' out, thats your second amandment thing about carrying arms, right? I don't mean this as a political question, maybe someone can just explain the issue if at all possible, thanks 😀
"woobly" refers to Industrial Workers of the World union. Unions are political issue in the US. @@hetschipVeronica
This is the reason I am a patron. The subject matter is why I'm a 2nd Amendment rights advocate.This is the history that I convey during "the 2nd is For Everyone: Diversity Shoot" since 2015 and on the 2A4E podcast. Saying American citizens don't need the 2nd Amendment because tyranny would never happen in America ignore that it's already happened in America. #knowyourhistory
One thing I don't understand is how a group of citizens, even heavily armed as some American are, could cope against the Federal Government war apparatus, they simply have bigger guns.
It's a real question, not trying to be polemic or anything....
@@redkawa636 Insurgencies generally don't succeed via conventional military victory, they succeed via holding out long enough for the government to show its hand by being so bloody and draconian that the people decide they prefer the rebels to the government.
@@theseukonnen1200 True....100 years ago, but nowadays, with people living to post their butts on Instagram and freaking out if the new Iphone is sold out I doubt it.
You also forget "they" control the media, all the media, they can tell people what they want and people would believe it.
Sorry but I am super skeptical about that as reasoning for the 2nd.
As guns' enthusiasts we love it, but that's about it in 2020.
@@redkawa636 i’m skeptical about the reasoning for the 2A, but just because one supports the 2A doesn’t mean they necessarily support the reasoning behind it.
rather it might have to do more with the practical benifit it affords people.
like i also doubt the citizens of the US would be able to organize a legitimate defense against our armed forces, especially since our military’s experience for the past 15+ years has been specifically in fighting insurgent/guerilla forces.
but it does allow for practical defense in emergency situations, such as racist attacks or home invasions by police or citizens. or for people who live in rural environments where they often have to fend for themselves or hunt for sustenance, it’s an everyday part of life.
I don’t care why the 2A was drafted, but i do care about the legitimate benefits it affords people.
@@lilchinesekidchen Eh, but the defense against the government is the reason I hear the most...and it does not make sense to me.
But also in a home defense scenario I have my doubts, I'd rather up the defenses of my home (I would never live in one of those American paper boxes) then face a professional criminal who would not hesitate my split second to shoot.
What would go into my mind in that split second? lawyers, Police, Hospital, news coverage, threats from the deceased person's family and generally about 100K in expenses...then I'm dead!:-))
Don't get me wrong, I love guns, I am ex military and own a few myself, I just feel safer in a continent where most of people is unarmed, considering the kind of people we need to deal with today.
I really wish one day somebody could explain me real practical reasons for the 2nd, rather then "stick it to the man" or "a bear might attack my family"..I am just interested in the subject, that's all:-)
The US army segregation lasted until at least WW2, and caused a lot "wtf" moments in the UK when GI's were garrisoned here (eg "park street riots" on Wikipedia")
Some thing in Australia with the Battle of Brisbane
Yes my father, an Army veteran, was subjected to this during his service in Great Britain during WWII.
I think the segregation in the United States military in fact lasted until about the time of the Korean War so the early 1950’s.
Desegregation happened to America the same year that the United States Air Force was formed. 1947.
That's interesting because the British had segregated Indian regiments which were comprised of Indian troops but had British officers until 1947.
I know I’m piling on, but RUclips definitely needs more content like this. Though my financial support of you is paltry, please use it to continue providing historical content like this.
2:18 - Not that it actually matters, but I think the correct term is "disinter." Just FYI.
as a french, i'm in shock that US command asked that to french officer in ww1.. i can understand why some of them joined the french troops and stayed here.
thank you for sharing this part of the story of your country
French officers: "Liberté, Egalité, Fraternité!"
Pershing: "Oh! We too, enjoy Liberty, eagles and frat parties!"
French officers: "..."
I didn't expect dark corners of American history when I subbed to this channel. It makes my American friends enthusiasm for the 2nd amendment much clearer.
Karl is an example of the kind of vehement anti-reactionary we need far more of among supporters of gun rights.
This is fantastic content, and something I hope to see more of on InRange. Proud to support you guys and the creation of fantastic and educational content such as this.
As a native Arizonan who's family has been here since before statehood (and who homesteaded near Portal) this is fantastic content. It is important even if I had no connection to Arizona, but I truly love what you're doing and appreciate it.
I was somewhat stunned to see Connecticut listed twice in the places race riots took place. It was never mentioned in school or anywhere. This amnesia is why, or at least one of the many reasons, we keep reenacting this stupidity even into the 21st century.
And today I found out - Black Jack Pershing was something of a dick.
To be fair to Pershing, the wording of the letter(s) seems to be more focused on preventing racial violence, rather than a desire to keep black soldiers "in their place". Pershing was one of the more outspoken proponents of black American troops, and I think his issuing of those orders was, to him, a necessary evil to prevent white vigilantism in the Army, and thus a breakdown of order in the AEF. Just from what was shown here, the focus seems to be less on how equality and fraternity would be harmful to social order, and more on how it would incense white American troops and cause problems for black troops. Still really shitty, but I don't think it was simply a case of Pershing being spiteful. Dude was still a product of his time, of course, so it would be dishonest to say he had zero racist views, just that he was still better than the majority.
At the beginning of the Civil War President Lincoln sent troops into Connecticut to prevent Connecticut from seceding.
@@Gallipoli620 I think you may well be onto something there. As a Brit I used to almost resent FDR for not getting into WW2 earlier. I came to realise that he did want to but couldn't unless he was president so had an election to win first.
To decide, and one's own _need_ to decide, whether he was acting deceptively, politically, or heroically depends on personal beliefs and preconceptions. An open and balanced view can take time.
@@buggs9950 FDR was President from 1933 to 1945....He and Hitler came to power simultaneously. Prior to Pearl Harbor, the USA was extremely isolationist....Led by, among others, Charles Lindbergh, buried up the road from me on Maui...
Karl, episodes like this are one of the major reasons I am a Patreon of your channel. Honestly, it's a challenge right now for me to quell my anger after seeing and reading the "secret" and very racist correspondence that General "Black Jack" Pershing promulgated as well as the racist correspondence by President Wilson, who was probably the most racist President ever, right up there with Andrew Johnson.
Part of my anger stems from my father's experience in World War II, where he patriotically served his country, but as many Black Soldiers during that war, was relegated primarily to a service role. Unfortunately, he had undiagnosed PTSD from his participation in D-Day, which didn't manifest itself to us until years later (another story). It wasn't from what most people would think, but it was from collecting dead bodies of the White Patriots, who were allowed to fight, but died on the beaches of Normandy. Who knows, if he had been allowed to fight, my 5 brothers and sisters may not have been born.
My father, because he loved the Army so much, went on to have a distinguished career in the Illinois National Guard, where he retired as a Sergeant First Class. His service there included riot duty during the Martin Luther King riots, with shoot to kill orders on the Chicago West Side along with later guarding the infamous Cuban refugees, who had been criminals or criminalized in Cuba, under Castro, that were sent here as a political stunt by that regime.
As I, along with many other Americans, and the world wait for the outcome of this election, your words of "induced amnesia" really resonate. Thank you as always for your content. I have an even higher appreciation for valiantry of the Buffalo Soldiers. If you're ever in the Houston area, I encourage you and others to visit the Buffalo Soldier's Museum here. I'm due for another visit after watching this enlightening content. Again, thank you sir!
Thank you for your comment. "induced amnesia" seems to be fairly common in a wide range of human history. It is something that Graham Hancock says often about the more distant past.
That letter is shocking. It's amazing how much is glossed over in history classes. It seems most high school classes go something like "slavery ended in 1865, things weren't great at water fountains or lunch counters but that was solved in 1964. Racism is over." Thank you for sharing this vital story.
4:06 I saw this List and thought. "Thats a damn long list."
And that is an incomplete list of major events from just 1919.
It's unnerving when I realize I've been through some of those places.
And then it kept going.
19th century has lists just as long.
Fantastic vignette! Respect the effort you put into these.
I always love this type of videos.
The case of early 1900s syndicalists, in particular, has a lot to teach. Basically, they were just a large number of factory workers arguing for their right to not have their kids die of malnutrition and tuberculosis but the same people that owned the factories and mines also owned the newspapers and they made the public think of them as dangerous terrorists thirsty for blood. An interesting tale about fear and deception that always makes me think who's profiting whenever I hate my fellow man.
And that dynamic hasn't changed. Anarchists are still maligned as agents of chaos by the corporate press.
@ high five to my fellow anarchists and syndicalists!
It’s more the case that blame and animosity placed on Anarchist Syndicalist was disproportionate rather than completely unfounded. The campaign by the federal government and commercial interests to brand organized (and particularly foreign born) labor as “seditious” during this period has a lasting legacy. BUT violent terrorism in the form of bombings DID occur such as those carried out by the Gallieanists in 1919 and the earlier Preparedness Day bombing in San Francisco. Additionally, materials from the time encouraged supporters and cells to carry out “Propaganda by the deed” in just such a fashion.
You probably got some pushback on this episode. However, it's real American history.
Thanks for having the courage to tell us about our past, including the nation's sins and faults.
We are much better now than then, but we are a work in progress, as always.
Yes, we can't avoid remaking the mistakes of the past if we don't acknowledge them.
@@turbografx16 Absolutely true. History is an excellent teacher.
Faster than a Nevada vote count.
I feel bad about that
They set a low bar
Interesting video & timing. In a similarly contested election in 1876 Rutherford B Hayes was declared president but the price was the “great comprimise” which withdrew federal troops from the south ending reconstruction and signalling the beginning of Jim Crow.
@@Chiller01 I won't be reconstructed and I do not give a damn.
So?
Big oof. That's tough to read, but so important to remember. Most people with an interest in history tend to forget that most of what our great-grandparents took for granted would horrify us today. Thank you for the very candid information that reminds us just how far we've come.
And that's why we're reliving that history today: lessons learned are easily forgotten.
You are in very special place Mr Karl. You've already changed my view on gun culture in USA. Now you get me better educated person. I'm thankful.
As always, a terrific walk through an otherwise forgotten (or we should perhaps say suppressed) part of our history. 👍
Love your retro AR replica videos
@@MichaelMacGyver thanks!
I think it's important not to let it be labelled as "forgotten" actually, it neatly absolves people & broader society of blame. The words we use can be so important in ways we cannot anticipate. Love your content both here and on your channel Deev! One of my favourite RUclipsrs, I know you have a lot of admiration for Karl & Ian, but know that some of us out here look at you in the same way.
Proto red and black scare? That's the All American Special
1919 was a crazy year.
Thank you for doing this Karl! We need more people willing to cover chapters of history intentionally left out of the traditional narrative. You’re doing a great job, keep up the great work!
As a biracial son of a black veteran of the Korean War I truly appreciate the true history you display in your video . I lost my dad 6 years ago and he did not talk much of his experiences, but i always got the sense that he never felt black soldiers were ever given the respect they deserved for their service.
Thank you again for your historical content. I cannot get enough of it and frequently re-watch episodes. Please never stop.
great info
Everytime I see you comment its always "great info". Is this some code for a richard party?
Fascinating video... history that often time won't be remembered if not for channels like this 👍🕊️
Thank you so much for showing American history that has been buried and forgotten.
You’re appreciated.
Keep the content coming.
Content of quality like this is so rare, many thanks to Inrange for bringing this. It is so hard to find "new" history and not the same old rehashed ww2 stories over and over again. Inrange and Ian where the first i suported via patreon and i have never regretted it, as a matter a fact since the quality is getting better and better i usualy up my contribution every now and then.
Some channels that "rehash" WWII also cover topics like this. The Great War and History Guy - ... channels have covered some of this history. 'Between Two Wars' by TimeGhost History channel, talked about the beginning of the red scare recently:
m.ruclips.net/video/ITxVRfBVo4s/видео.html
Videos like this are the reason InRange is one the best channels on RUclips. You're awesome!
That letter Pershing sent was absolutely disgusting, no wonder why they were burned
Who is ready for /k/ to have a complete shit fit again?
more like ARFCOM lmao never seen a bigger bunch of neocon fudds, at least /k/ traditionally had some nuance though ever since the website's switch to become the new hub for white supremacist/nationalist boomers and Qtards I'm sure /k/ has fallen as well
Now *THIS* is the content I sub for. Sure, all the shooting stuff is great but *THIS*, this is the history that must be remembered and it is an absolute shame so many don't know about it. Hell, most people don't even know about Blair Mountain or Bacon's Rebellion.
Our entire labor history is lost to the general population as well.
I always appreciate when you produce this kind of content. It also always saddens me when you provide information and stories that I should have been taught in high school and college.
This right here, this kind of content is why this is the best gun channel on RUclips. Not just history, but woke history.
Man i love history videos like this and it's cool that a channel such as yours cover these topics, it part of what makes this channel different from most. Thanks for more good content. Keep up the good work.
These vids are my favourites. I truly enjoy everything you guys are doing. Thanks!!
Hey Karl, do you think the 1921 Tulsa Race Riots were part of this same post-war series of violent events? Think you might come to the Tulsa area to put your unique spin on that event?
The History Guy and The Great War channel have both covered the 1919 communist and racist paranoia. This gives a good particular to their overviews.
Great work as always, Karl. These are some of my favorite.
I subscribed to InRange because of the firearms content, but it was the vignettes that pushed me to become a patron.
These videos are my favorite part of this channel. Great work, keep them coming!
After this lesson, any minority known that never should surrender their weapons. Can you do anything about Blair Mountain battle?
Jesus Christ this is one of those videos you watch and are just astounded you've never heard of it. And really I shouldn't be surprised but I still am. Great work, thanks for sharing.
This is an amazing video! Thank you so much for sharing this fascinating bit of history!
Thank you for touching on this! I really look forward to seeing more videos on this subject, and I'm going to do some reading, because I had never heard of this Red Summer.
Another great vid Karl, I love watching you introduce these historic vignettes and getting involved with important topics others shy away from 👍
This is history documentary at its best.
I look forward to future videos and most definitely will educate myself in this subject.
Thanks for bringing this and similar events to the general public.
Thanks Carl once again you've brought us historical information from a non bias point of view I greatly appreciate it. Stories like this deserve to be brought to light to honor these men. Great job man keep up the good work!
very thankful for the work you've done in this series. would love to see a video on the battle of blair mountain. thanks for reppin the wobs
I was unaware of this. This is why i keep coming back to these old west vignettes, it's fascinating to me how much of this stuff happened and if just never discussed. Thank you.
Thank you so much. Doing very important work, keep em coming!!
Thanks Karl, if only every person was as sensible and conscious like you! Thank you for this documentary.
Thank you so much for this, as you say we intentionally forget these things and we should not. Great video and I would love to see more of this content in the future. I love your dedication to truth and transparency and the risk you take by running this completely with donations.
Thank you so much for the video and insight, Karl. Proud to be a patreon of yours!
I love this channel...I appreciate how versed you guys are about firearms, but also discussing history that is ignored.
Thank you Karl! As, many have said before, this is the quality content I donate on Patreon for!
These ignored and/or forgotten history vignettes are not merely enlightening and entertaining, they're IMPORTANT. Please continue to present content like this, Karl!
Videos like this are EXACTLY what got me off the fence to support you on Patreon.
thank you for doing these kind of videos, i know they are not as watched as your firearms stuff, but i really enjoy them.
I wanted to commend you on providing this community a historical viewpoint that is desperately needed in this current political climate. I think we can all agree that having our historiographical predispositions challenged is immensely beneficial to our society. Again, thank you
I don't know why I was surprised to see my fellow IWW workers playing a role in some of this, as this sort of wobbly history is exactly why I joined the union, but it sure was a pleasant surprise. Thank you so much for doing this sort of content as I think it's extremely important, even just digging through some of the IWW's standoffs with authorities and the coal wars was a big wake up call. These stories about America's classism and racism really need to be heard.
Thank you for these! I love the history that's presented, and how nothing but the truth is told.
Thank you SO MUCH for making these contextual historic videos
Thank you for producing this. This is the real American history, that of the never ending battle for labor rights and civil rights against dominating institutions and the law enforcement that make it possible.
This made me a Patreon. I've been a fan of InRange and Forgotten Weapons from their starts but this video seals the deal about the hunches I've long held about Karl and Ian.
Y'all are good eggs. Thanks and keep it up. You make shooting a respectable interest.
Props for covering this. It can be an uncomfortable thing, analysing aspects of one's own country's history that are rather less than glorious (trust me - as a Brit, it's a discomfort I'm all too familiar with), but to ignore such things is to contribute to the possibility of them happening again. Learning from the mistakes and unpleasantness that our ancestors were responsible for is incredibly important.
There isn't a country on Earth that can lay claim to a history of perfect, humane behaviour, and having the honesty and balls to face that fact is something that should probably be happening a great deal more.
I always enjoy these historical videos. Cheers.
Always Love your history!
Thanks for continuing to educate me!
Thank you so much for this Karl! 🌟
I love watching your historical videos like this. I live in Morenci and love seeing stories so close to home.
Fantastic post. Three weeks later the Robert Charles riots in New Orleans began. Another story worth telling. Thank you.
Its hard to find firearm related channels with such a nuanced approach to politics, history, and civil rights. Keep up the good work!
Great you shine a light on these sort of historical events. We have had similar incidents like this in the not so distant past in Australia too.
I enjoy your history pieces and appreciate your efforts to shed light on history many find inconvenient and would rather we forget.
Thank you for posting this story.
Excellent video. These are some of my favorite videos that you put out, really excellent.
Wow! I had no knowledge of these events! Thanks for expanding my mindset. Keep up the good work!
Thanks for these historical videos, Karl.
remember to join the IWW
Great video on an Important subject. I'll definitely be using this in an EO presentation in the future.
Thank you for these videos!
Awesome work! Thank you for your time! Excellent
Love these videos, thanks for making em
Great video as always. Very important topic that I love seeing covered.
Excellent piece of content. I dip in to your videos from time to time but after watching your thoughts on the recent Parler issue and then finding this, I certainly must subscribe.
This was an excellent video!! Looking very much forward to more of these
This is brilliant. Thanks for doing this.
There is definitely a lot of chosen amnesia in most communities throughout this country & im thankful for seeing light brought to it.
Its not "chosen amnesia"... its the fact that the players are all long dead and the world is a very different place today than it was 100 yrs ago. Ask a local about the Bisbee Race Riot and they will scratch their head and ponder for a moment..and either say "uh'? or remember hearing about it. Few people who live there now..had family that lived there then and it would be their great great grand parents. folks the people you are chatting with never met or knew much about. This holds true all across America. I live in a small California town that at one time, had a sign on the edge of town saying "nigger dont let the sun go down on you in this town". Yet I marched in the 1963 Detroit freedom march with Dr King. its racial history doesnt apply to me..or anyone I know. I have GREAT appreciation for Karl holding these mini history lessons and continue to look for them every day. (along with Ians videos)
@@GunnerAsch1 nah it's definitely chosen. many massive tragedies are swept under the rug in k-12 american history classes.
@@DrNo-xt9fn K-12 history isn’t meant to provide this detailed an overview of American history - it’s generally intended to provide the student with a broad sample of the historical landscape. Unless you’re a university student interested in the history of racial segregation or a WW1 buff, you’ll probably have little opportunity to ever hear about this.
Humans have a long tenancy to recency bias and selectively forgetting difficult or unresolved issues in our collective or national history. It is not new, just more... pronounced that we have so much more access to a wide variety of source materials.
Writer Graham Hancock has observed that; " 'Humans are a species with amnesia...' ( speaking about intentionally forgetting parts of our more distant past ) ".
This kind of content is why I like your channel. Due to the current circumstances, I'm not able to support you via Patreon anymore, but I'll be back. Thanks for doing these videos.
Nice one Karl👍! Keep em' coming! I'll be watching and learning, along with so many others.
Thank you for making important content such as this!
I fear many people have taken the wrong message from this of "don't be disarmed" rather than "don't give in to white supremacy".
Brilliant Karl! how weird that history repeats itself 100 years later! Keep up the good work my friend.
@High Horse black men being systemically murdered by the people in charge. Groups being labelled as Bolsheviks or communists. Government using people's differences to segregate and sow hatred. People of colour being forced to give up their weaapons against the 2nd amendment you all hold so dear and yet no-one stands up for them.
Thanks again Karl! Awesome content as always.
fascinating history, thanks a lot for this as I had no knowledge of some of these events before. Look forward to more on the Red Summer!
I'm just loving these. Keep em coming.👍🏾