Thanks for watching everyone, hope yous enjoyed the video! Be sure to check out my other videos on Native Americans if you found it interesting and give me a thumbs up or considering subscribbling if you're new!
Hey man, I'm commenting here since you will probably see it. I recently saw your videos regarding the 80 years war and the Dutch revolution warfare. I must say that while they are very accurate in some parts, you tend to underestimate the Spanish. I believe that this is due to the black legend, a legend created by England to undermine Spanish power. Spanish Tercios where the best combative units in the world until early 17th century. They where not only organized but also very disciplined. In Spanish Tercios, pillaging was forbidden, and only once the punishment (death) was not applied, this is Rome's sack in 1527, and even then, most troops where from Germany. So please, investigate a little if you're gonna made a video including Spain. And specially don't believe the first thing you read about either their cruelty or their behaviour in the Americas. I can forward you a text in which Spaniards compassion and good behaviour left a mark in populations they were occupying. Or a video. Please, contact me through this comment if you wanna discuss.
The word anasazi translates into the connotations of “ancestors of our enemies” and not necessarily into “ancestral enemies”. Also, having a video with the Cambridge archaeologists talking about the Ancestral Puebloans would be very interesting
As a fellow Diné, it's mostly true among our people as our elders tell us that when they first encountered these people, most structures from the anasazi were abandoned as if they disappeared without no trace. So many Diné that encountered other neighbouring tribes like acoma, hopi, and zuni's, refer their homes to that of the anasazi. So the term, literally translate, "Ancestors of our enemies". Which is why we believe many of these pueblo tribes have some similarities among the anasazi's and maybe descents of them. Btw, most Diné don't say the "Ana" we just say, "Nasazi".
As I was told, Navajo and Apache languages were similar enough that people could just talk to each other. Not just in the 1800s, but also during World War 2 when you had Navajo and Apache soldiers just communicating with each other whenever they came across one another.
Here in New Mexico, Acoma is pronounced in line with Spanish, more like Acka-ma or Acko-ma, with very little emphasis on the O sound. While each pueblo is its own federally recognized tribe, they can be grouped together linguistically-- tiwa speakers, tewa speakers, etc. The New Mexico and Arizona pueblos still going strong today are the oldest continuously inhabited sites in North America.
I may be 3 years late but I’m a local, Acoma is not the only one that speaks keres language. There’s Seven Pueblos in the keres group such as Cochiti, Santo Domingo, San Felipe, Santa Ana, Zia, Laguna and Acoma. All of the villages speak the same language but in different dialects and accents.
@@tritosac I’m a Native I know what bands are since my tribe has 11 bands in my Nation the St’At’imc . Bands don’t separated a people from their tribal identity.
@@armann04 I think people have a hard time with READING COMPREHENSION. I never said that bands separate people from tribal identity. I merely stated that there are many bands within each of those branches of Apache tribes. Do you remember READING COMPREHENSION? It is something we all practiced when we were in the first grade. You read a paragraph and determine the MAIN POINT of the paragraph. It's very simple. It surprises me how many ADULTS have problems with READING COMPREHENSION when it is something generally mastered by the time kids enter elementary school.
As someone from the PNW, I'm saddened to find that their is a distinct lack of information and academic interest in tribes from the the Northwestern United States and Canada, so would you be willing to do a video on them?
Ya we're kinda the mysterious, forgotten little corner of the US. Everyone knows about the Southeast, New England, and the Southwest, but there's less understanding of who we are up in Cascadia. I kinda like it that way tbh, but I agree that there could be more research done on the incredibly interesting tribes up here. Captain Jack of the Modoc War was a pretty interesting character. They went into the lava beds of NorCal and held off a large number of US troops before finally succumbing. Anyways, I second your comment Alex.
It’s funny how inclusive you want to sound but you’re always being snobby at the Native Indigenous Americans from Mexico. You or any other gatekeeper of Native “Indigenism” will not block me from calling myself a Native American because my Brown skin tone and my 82% Native DNA are my proof.
I'm Apache Indian and just so-happened to work as an Aviation Flight Operations Specialist, at Fort Rucker, Alabama's Apache Helicopter Airfield (Hanchey Airfield). I ran that place more times than not (2002-2004). We had the OH-58D, AH-64A and the AH64-D aka Longbow on our Airfield. I still remember the phone numbers and protocol for emergency. I was made for that. I eventually changed my M.O.S. to be a Power Generation Equipment Repairer and did that from 2007-2012, after coming back to the Army with a waver for misconduct. I was always in trouble...😂😂😂
Since the Apache & Navajo had quite a bit of interaction with Spanish explorers and Mexicans after Mexico won it's independence from Spain (when New Mexico & Arizona were still part of Mexico), many of them had learned how to speak Spanish.
History With Hilbert when that video gets made, you should include the history of Indian removal in relation to these tribes, and the experiences of Freedmen and slaves in them. There's a researcher names Ray Von Robertson that you should look into as he's done a great deal of research on the topic.
I would love to see something like a language tree. There are so many layers. It's almost as if each settlement could be a "tribe" rather than a tribe equating to a group of people sharing the same language, ancestry, government, etc. as we think about it in a modern sense. Please make more videos exploring Native Americans.
Vice Versa, the Navajos called the Spanish "Nakai Dine" or the "Wandering People". Nakai is a verbal descriptive and can be used to describe someone just walking or a roaming pack of animals. Thinking from the point of view of a Navajo in the 1600s who first saw Spaniards they would have been explorers. Men who were going around mapping the territory. To Navajos though it looked like these new comers were just wandering in circles, hence Nakai Dine the Wandering People. Nakai was used pretty generally for the Spanish, the Mestizos, and their African slaves they brought with them. Nakai now is used as the label for people from Mexico.
If you get a chance look up Walnut Canyon, AZ. Its a cliff dwelling community that was established in 1066. I don’t remember who established it but it really made an impression on me because it’s both an active dig site and a state park. So you can go walking around the buildings and it’s just a really cool experience.
I worked with quite a few Navajo tribal members when I worked in the Southwestern United States. Hello, Mike and Joe Begay! Long time, no see! I also worked with a guy whose tribe wasn't recognized by the United States government. Which is a a major problem for Native American people who are trying to have a voice with the federal government. Those tribes who aren't recognized have major issues that are even worse than treaty tribes.
@@historywithhilbert146 The two tribes that I know of personally are the Chinook of Washington and Oregon and the Alamo Mogollon of New Mexico. I worked with members of each of these tribes. The Chinooks have been trying for years to get recognized by the federal government. The information I was told by my coworker was particularly sad, considering how that tribe was the one who helped the Lewis and Clark Expedition when they camped at the mouth of the Columbia River during the winter of 1805. I would have to research to get the names and numbers of other tribes in order to give you more information. I will say that not getting federal recognition is a huge issue for these Native American people. They deal with the same problems other Native American Nations have, and yet they don't have the same voices at the tables when it comes to dealing with any government agencies, federal, state or local. Additionally, there are other tribes who don't support these claims and work against recognition. Politics between tribes can be just as harsh as any other loose association of humans. A prime example would be the fighting between various unions here in the United States. There's a huge difference between the viewpoints of the Policemen Unions and say, the Longshoremen's Union. Sorry I meandered a bit, I just wanted to describe how complex the situation is. As one unrecognized Native told me, "I get all the crap from whites because I'm an Indian, and I get none of the benefits that you guys think all Indians get. This sucks!" I honestly agree with him. Hope this long response helped a bit. Sorry for the length.
With all due respect, "federal recognition" does *not* give us a voice with the federal government. Matter of fact, "federal recognition" is a euphemism for *documentary genocide.* *The Creator* made us who we are, *not* the dictates or government.
'Pueblo' has the same etymology as 'people' in English which comes from Norman French. Both Words come from Latin 'populus'. Also the word 'population' (Spanish 'poblacion')
It depends. If you're referring to a large group of people, then, yes, "pueblo" means "people" or "nation", but if you're referring to a place, "pueblo" means "town". Now, considering the name of places like "Pueblo Bonito", probably the name "Pueblo" refers to the places (towns), because "Pueblo Bonito" literally means "Cute Town".
Great video, good job 👍🏽 HOWEVER.... Their are some facts you may like to hear from a Navajo perspective. Im Diné from northern Arizona and the Name you called the Anasazi, the; "Ancient enemies" is not the translations. We have no word to describe enemy to another group of people. Although we Navajos did made war but in a self defense. The name, in my language is 'Anaa'í meaning "the people who are around us," "the people who are not Navajos who are around us." That is the only word we describe to another tribe, not in a negative way. So if we look at Anasazi....'Anaa'sazí, which really means "the ancient one who were around us." It didn't say they were here before the Navajos...no! Our people were saying they lived side-by-side with us all around during the ancient times. The name Navajo probably did came from the Pueblos yes, its all written in Spanish documents. BUT... Their are some elders here say that the name didn't came from pueblos it came from our own language which is; Naabaahí which means " warrior" a name that was given to us by the Sun God himself during the summer/ warm, hot season.
I've been to Mesa Verde. Very impressive place. Apparently it's pretty much the only place in the world to have the perfectly preserved remains of a stone-age culture.
Thank you for this video Hilbert! I'm from Utah and have visited many Fremont and Anasazi sites in southern Utah. It would be very cool if you did a video on some of the rock art of the area as it is very beautiful and very cool!
For a second thought you pulled up a surprise vid on the origin of the Names of South American Natives, would be pretty interesting to see it become a reality tho!
Great video. I’m from that area and have several vision quests and much camping in the 4 corners area. The Navajo are also known as sheep herders. While farming is possible near the few rivers in the desert, grazable land is more common. Also you might be interested in the Fremont culture. They were the northern neighbors of the now termed “Ancestral Puebloans.” They had one of the most important rock art sites in the whole area, a whole genre of style named Barrier Canyon style. Location also known as Horseshoe Canyon en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_Canyon_(Emery_and_Wayne_counties,_Utah)
Actually, I've heard this term being used from the Ute tribes as they also have a similar word like "navaju" that refer to us as "Headbasher" or "Headcrusher". Most likely we used club axes or blunt objects during raids or being raided.
Tasavuh or "head basher" is a Hopi phrase used for Navajos. Navajo/Navaju is the Pueblo/Tewa word that ended up becoming the name for Navajos. Given how isolated Hopis were at the time it makes sense that Spain would use another tribe's name instead.
As I briefly mentioned in the chat, the Parisian meaning of 'Apache' came to Poland, especially Warsaw where 'apasz' began meaning the same. There is a whole little weird genre of songs romanticizing the shady underbelly of the pre-WW2 Warsaw, that often features this term, for example: ruclips.net/video/n8a5zK6CQ28/видео.html It is no longer in the regular use, but the word 'apaszka', meaning a neck scarf, still is. Meanwhile, an actual Apache in Polish is 'Apacz' (plural 'Apacze').
Yes indeed you correct i am from michoacan and i do speak one or or language that is call purhepecha phore and i have native friends from new mexico and peru that they speak there language and is similar in different words
The Five Civilised Tribes and the reason behind the name is on my list of videos to make as is a video on the ettmologors behind the tribes living on the Eastern seaboard
Hi there, would you do a video about Kvenland in depth? also about the creation of the Kingdom of the Dunmonii by that tribe AND Vortigern Rule with a also a brief focus to the Brittonic diaspora in Galicia??
I'm interviewing quite a few guests this next week so stay posted! Do you have a preferred site for listening to podcasts? I need to choose where to start uploading them.
When I read "Southern Native American Tribes," I thought it was the Five Civilized Tribes, located from the Southern U.S. (and most of whom forced to go to Oklahoma); but quickly realize you meant Southwest U.S. instead.
The Five Civilised Tribes and the reason behind the name is on my list of videos to make as is a video on the ettmologors behind the tribes living on the Eastern seaboard
This is really nerdy, but the inverted caps omega you use for 'u' is IPA for the short 'u' sound in 'hook'. I found this really confusing in a story about pronunciation...
Good Evening, Question... have you ever seen the you tube channel Smooth Gefixt , They are building a stone celtic round house in Ireland, AND they are Dutch.. ck them out... ALSO, how is your Split Screen video format coming along??.. Saved a few of your videos to re-watch. 👍😎👍
2:10 actually Mapache is a native word, it comes from the Nahuatl (language of Nahua in Mexico and Central America) word Mapachin. Many Mexican Spanish words have native origins because the assimilation of native Mexicans wasn’t 100% completed so many of our ancestors retained vocabulary specific to the Americas (usually in a Nahuatl as it was used as a lingua franca in MesoAmerica because of the influence of the Mexicah/Aztecs)
it still pings my ears when i hear british english pronunciation of the letter "h" with the h sound, as an american i am surrounded with people who say it "ey-ch" not "hey-ch"
There are about 3.7 million people who live in Mongolia, and 10 million people speak Mongolian. It's not gonna die out. But preserving Mongolian culture is also important.
The Apache held the largest territory with the fewest warriors which says something. They used horses similarly to the white or Dakots Sioux simply riding them to the battle them dismounting to fight
Navajo and Apache share a similar language. Both tribes came from upper present day Canada. Migrated to the southwest region. Navajo share a similar dialect with tribes near Bechoko Canada.
History With Hilbert you’ve never heard of Hopi ear candles? I was sure that’s what the pause was about. They are kinda wild: tubular candles you stick in your ear alight to somehow clear ear wax. If you’ve ever had a slightly hippy romantic partner they are what you think of when you hear “Hopi”. My review: Kinda relaxing; Ear wax situation unchanged.
History With Hilbert mate, my weird ex picked them up from Holland and Barrett in Guildford. If you are into Surrey space cadets, maybe pick up a couple of packs. It won’t enhance the romance, but it’d save you a trip into town if you’ve already got them.
The transcription of the word ‘Navajo’ into Spanish is indeed in line with the Mexican Spanish pronunciation. There Navajo is actually pronounced Na-va-ho. You seem to have a very good Iberian Spanish accent, but that ‘J’ sound is completely different. I don’t believe the spelling’s got anything to do with American English involvement. Americans pronunciation of Spanish just tends to be based on the Mexican variant. Neither Spanish nor English is native to me, so I’m not sure if I’m missing some information, like development of Spanish in the Americas over time, but that’s just some brief recap over that misconception.
title is confusing How did Southern Native American Tribes get their names? Southern america thats Brazil Argentina Chile Peru Bolivia Columbia. But this video is about Tribes in what is now the United Statse of America? very confusing ( the united states is located in North America )
@@historywithhilbert146 southern US and Mexico. Or the southern part of north America. Both would be more correct. Hence less confusing. a lot of US Americans make the same mistake when saying they are Americans when refaring to their contry. Everyone living in north or south America are Americans. thanks for replaying. you making a simular video for tribes in south america ? including the 3 African tribs in French Guyana.
Isn't apach a French dance like a tango? Throwing women on the floor and such, bashing their heads? How about doing a video about the Havasupai Indians that live in the Grand Canyon.
Based on the histories I have learned from actual Native Americans this poster has no clue what he is talking about or he merely makes it up in the middle of the night.
The first Spanish conquistador contact what the navajos was at Acoma Mesa we were trading with the Acoma pueblos The Conquistadors they knew we were kind of War like they called us querochero we constantly raided other tribes and pueblos Zuñi is called us apachu it was that the Tewa pueblos called us Nabajaú the Mexicans found out they were different types of Apaches so they called us Apache de Navajo later on they shortened it to Navajo
The Navajo, and Apache speak a Na Dene Language formerly called Athabaskan that is related to most of the First Nations languages of Northern Canada and Alaska. These People almost all call themselves Dene meaning again People.
I encourage people from these groups to teach their own history but the idea you can only talk about history if you're genetically related to those you're talking about is ridiculous.
Thanks for watching everyone, hope yous enjoyed the video! Be sure to check out my other videos on Native Americans if you found it interesting and give me a thumbs up or considering subscribbling if you're new!
Hey man, I'm commenting here since you will probably see it.
I recently saw your videos regarding the 80 years war and the Dutch revolution warfare. I must say that while they are very accurate in some parts, you tend to underestimate the Spanish. I believe that this is due to the black legend, a legend created by England to undermine Spanish power. Spanish Tercios where the best combative units in the world until early 17th century. They where not only organized but also very disciplined. In Spanish Tercios, pillaging was forbidden, and only once the punishment (death) was not applied, this is Rome's sack in 1527, and even then, most troops where from Germany. So please, investigate a little if you're gonna made a video including Spain. And specially don't believe the first thing you read about either their cruelty or their behaviour in the Americas.
I can forward you a text in which Spaniards compassion and good behaviour left a mark in populations they were occupying. Or a video.
Please, contact me through this comment if you wanna discuss.
I loved the video, would consider doing one on the eastern tribes?
Well done! Had never heard or read such a comprehensive etymology of tribe names.
The word anasazi translates into the connotations of “ancestors of our enemies” and not necessarily into “ancestral enemies”.
Also, having a video with the Cambridge archaeologists talking about the Ancestral Puebloans would be very interesting
Thank you for the feedback, I'll see if she's up for it!
Puebloans sounds funny
As a fellow Diné, it's mostly true among our people as our elders tell us that when they first encountered these people, most structures from the anasazi were abandoned as if they disappeared without no trace. So many Diné that encountered other neighbouring tribes like acoma, hopi, and zuni's, refer their homes to that of the anasazi. So the term, literally translate, "Ancestors of our enemies". Which is why we believe many of these pueblo tribes have some similarities among the anasazi's and maybe descents of them. Btw, most Diné don't say the "Ana" we just say, "Nasazi".
This really should be titled Southwestern Tribes, not Southern Native tribes....
Exactly specially more explaining of the six Apache tribes that are not one nation as many don’t know they’re not one people.
Looking at the list of peoples in the video that would actually be a better title come to think of it!
History With Hilbert
When are you cover some of my ancestors: Pamunkey, Shawnee and Cherokee?
@@historywithhilbert146 Yes it would ....there are more than 100 Southern tribal nations
Deshone Robinson
Originally red but there was intermarriage.
As I was told, Navajo and Apache languages were similar enough that people could just talk to each other. Not just in the 1800s, but also during World War 2 when you had Navajo and Apache soldiers just communicating with each other whenever they came across one another.
Here in New Mexico, Acoma is pronounced in line with Spanish, more like Acka-ma or Acko-ma, with very little emphasis on the O sound. While each pueblo is its own federally recognized tribe, they can be grouped together linguistically-- tiwa speakers, tewa speakers, etc. The New Mexico and Arizona pueblos still going strong today are the oldest continuously inhabited sites in North America.
Thanks for the information!
I may be 3 years late but I’m a local, Acoma is not the only one that speaks keres language. There’s Seven Pueblos in the keres group such as Cochiti, Santo Domingo, San Felipe, Santa Ana, Zia, Laguna and Acoma. All of the villages speak the same language but in different dialects and accents.
there 6 tribes of the Apache Western Apache(White Mountain): Chiricahua: Mescalero: Jicarilla: Lipan: Plains Apache(Kiowa Apache)
It gets even more complicated than that. There are dozens of different bands with distinct names within each of those tribes.
@@tritosac I’m a Native I know what bands are since my tribe has 11 bands in my Nation the St’At’imc . Bands don’t separated a people from their tribal identity.
@@armann04 I think people have a hard time with READING COMPREHENSION. I never said that bands separate people from tribal identity. I merely stated that there are many bands within each of those branches of Apache tribes. Do you remember READING COMPREHENSION? It is something we all practiced when we were in the first grade. You read a paragraph and determine the MAIN POINT of the paragraph. It's very simple. It surprises me how many ADULTS have problems with READING COMPREHENSION when it is something generally mastered by the time kids enter elementary school.
@@tritosac It's not his fault it's americans in general. Trust me.
Especially in Texas.
@@armann04 tell em unc
There's the Pueblo. I've always wondered how to build a town on a cliff
Well they are the experts ;)
As someone from the PNW, I'm saddened to find that their is a distinct lack of information and academic interest in tribes from the the Northwestern United States and Canada, so would you be willing to do a video on them?
That's a great idea - I've added it to my list of videos to make!
Ya we're kinda the mysterious, forgotten little corner of the US. Everyone knows about the Southeast, New England, and the Southwest, but there's less understanding of who we are up in Cascadia. I kinda like it that way tbh, but I agree that there could be more research done on the incredibly interesting tribes up here. Captain Jack of the Modoc War was a pretty interesting character. They went into the lava beds of NorCal and held off a large number of US troops before finally succumbing. Anyways, I second your comment Alex.
It’s funny how inclusive you want to sound but you’re always being snobby at the Native Indigenous Americans from Mexico. You or any other gatekeeper of Native “Indigenism” will not block me from calling myself a Native American because my Brown skin tone and my 82% Native DNA are my proof.
@@7919AEM ??
I'm Apache Indian and just so-happened to work as an Aviation Flight Operations Specialist, at Fort Rucker, Alabama's Apache Helicopter Airfield (Hanchey Airfield). I ran that place more times than not (2002-2004). We had the OH-58D, AH-64A and the AH64-D aka Longbow on our Airfield. I still remember the phone numbers and protocol for emergency. I was made for that. I eventually changed my M.O.S. to be a Power Generation Equipment Repairer and did that from 2007-2012, after coming back to the Army with a waver for misconduct. I was always in trouble...😂😂😂
Since the Apache & Navajo had quite a bit of interaction with Spanish explorers and Mexicans after Mexico won it's independence from Spain (when New Mexico & Arizona were still part of Mexico), many of them had learned how to speak Spanish.
It would be great with a video about the eastern tribes
It's on the list!
History With Hilbert when that video gets made, you should include the history of Indian removal in relation to these tribes, and the experiences of Freedmen and slaves in them. There's a researcher names Ray Von Robertson that you should look into as he's done a great deal of research on the topic.
I'm from a small tribe in North Carolina I doubt we'll get mentioned lol
Deshone Robinson But your lack of knowledge is on display to all unfortunately.
@Deshone Robinson My Cherokee and Creek acquaintances will be rather surprised to lean that.
Love anything about the Native American tribes , thanks hillbert and as a fellow geordie from the “hoy ya hammer ower here hini “ tribe 😉
Haha that's smashing! I'll have to remember that one 😂😂
I would love to see something like a language tree. There are so many layers. It's almost as if each settlement could be a "tribe" rather than a tribe equating to a group of people sharing the same language, ancestry, government, etc. as we think about it in a modern sense. Please make more videos exploring Native Americans.
Vice Versa, the Navajos called the Spanish "Nakai Dine" or the "Wandering People". Nakai is a verbal descriptive and can be used to describe someone just walking or a roaming pack of animals. Thinking from the point of view of a Navajo in the 1600s who first saw Spaniards they would have been explorers. Men who were going around mapping the territory. To Navajos though it looked like these new comers were just wandering in circles, hence Nakai Dine the Wandering People. Nakai was used pretty generally for the Spanish, the Mestizos, and their African slaves they brought with them. Nakai now is used as the label for people from Mexico.
These not the wandering people.. it was a much better tribe.
8:35 I refuse to watch Ancient Aliens. Based on principle. That is a big, hard, NO.
I watched it when I was a young teen - just for the laughs you know 😉
I don’t spend much time on the tinfoil hat brigade either.
Generated some great memes though
History With Hilbert oh, totally!
If you get a chance look up Walnut Canyon, AZ. Its a cliff dwelling community that was established in 1066. I don’t remember who established it but it really made an impression on me because it’s both an active dig site and a state park. So you can go walking around the buildings and it’s just a really cool experience.
Very cool I'll take a look!
I worked with quite a few Navajo tribal members when I worked in the Southwestern United States. Hello, Mike and Joe Begay! Long time, no see! I also worked with a guy whose tribe wasn't recognized by the United States government. Which is a a major problem for Native American people who are trying to have a voice with the federal government. Those tribes who aren't recognized have major issues that are even worse than treaty tribes.
Do you know if there are many unrecognised tribes?
@@historywithhilbert146 The two tribes that I know of personally are the Chinook of Washington and Oregon and the Alamo Mogollon of New Mexico. I worked with members of each of these tribes. The Chinooks have been trying for years to get recognized by the federal government. The information I was told by my coworker was particularly sad, considering how that tribe was the one who helped the Lewis and Clark Expedition when they camped at the mouth of the Columbia River during the winter of 1805. I would have to research to get the names and numbers of other tribes in order to give you more information. I will say that not getting federal recognition is a huge issue for these Native American people. They deal with the same problems other Native American Nations have, and yet they don't have the same voices at the tables when it comes to dealing with any government agencies, federal, state or local. Additionally, there are other tribes who don't support these claims and work against recognition. Politics between tribes can be just as harsh as any other loose association of humans. A prime example would be the fighting between various unions here in the United States. There's a huge difference between the viewpoints of the Policemen Unions and say, the Longshoremen's Union. Sorry I meandered a bit, I just wanted to describe how complex the situation is. As one unrecognized Native told me, "I get all the crap from whites because I'm an Indian, and I get none of the benefits that you guys think all Indians get. This sucks!"
I honestly agree with him. Hope this long response helped a bit. Sorry for the length.
With all due respect, "federal recognition" does *not* give us a voice with the federal government. Matter of fact, "federal recognition" is a euphemism for *documentary genocide.*
*The Creator* made us who we are, *not* the dictates or government.
As someone from the Southwest I really appreciate you doing this video! Gracias!
'Pueblo' has the same etymology as 'people' in English which comes from Norman French. Both Words come from Latin 'populus'. Also the word 'population' (Spanish 'poblacion')
Hadn't thought about that actually but that makes sense!
It depends. If you're referring to a large group of people, then, yes, "pueblo" means "people" or "nation", but if you're referring to a place, "pueblo" means "town". Now, considering the name of places like "Pueblo Bonito", probably the name "Pueblo" refers to the places (towns), because "Pueblo Bonito" literally means "Cute Town".
Man, as a Navajo, I'm down for a Southern Boogaloo.
Right back atcha 🔥🔥
Thank you for the video. Been a while since you last posted, glad to the video today :)
Thanks Emily, I hope you're well!
History With Hilbert I am, thank you
I'm Apache and my Great Great Great Grandfather fought with Geronimo. (San Carlos, Apache). Navajo and Apache are from the Anasazi...
Great video, good job 👍🏽
HOWEVER.... Their are some facts you may like to hear from a Navajo perspective.
Im Diné from northern Arizona and the Name you called the Anasazi, the; "Ancient enemies" is not the translations. We have no word to describe enemy to another group of people. Although we Navajos did made war but in a self defense. The name, in my language is 'Anaa'í meaning "the people who are around us," "the people who are not Navajos who are around us." That is the only word we describe to another tribe, not in a negative way. So if we look at Anasazi....'Anaa'sazí, which really means "the ancient one who were around us." It didn't say they were here before the Navajos...no! Our people were saying they lived side-by-side with us all around during the ancient times.
The name Navajo probably did came from the Pueblos yes, its all written in Spanish documents. BUT... Their are some elders here say that the name didn't came from pueblos it came from our own language which is; Naabaahí which means " warrior" a name that was given to us by the Sun God himself during the summer/ warm, hot season.
Aóó' 🙌
My tribe's name is Coharie which is derived from the Iroquoian Tuscarora word ("Schohari") which means Driftwood
Ugh, don’t get me started on exonymy....Why can’t we just call folks what they call themselves?
In a nutshell 😂😂
MrZapparin
In what sense do you mean?
www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=covfefe
We should call their land what they called it, too. I'm from Cuyahoga County in Ohio, and it doesn't hurt to say it with my white European mouth.
Taxi Rob Is Cuyahoga truly what they’d called it or is it a settler bastardization of the name like many state and county names?
A lot of them didn't really have a name for themselves.
I've been to Mesa Verde. Very impressive place. Apparently it's pretty much the only place in the world to have the perfectly preserved remains of a stone-age culture.
I'd love to go some time and see it for myself!
Thank you for this video Hilbert! I'm from Utah and have visited many Fremont and Anasazi sites in southern Utah. It would be very cool if you did a video on some of the rock art of the area as it is very beautiful and very cool!
Glad you enjoyed the video! I'm sure I'll have to dive into this topic again in future 🔥🔥
Me being Native American I didn’t even know why my tribe got their name but watching this video gave me plenty of information thank you friend
For a second thought you pulled up a surprise vid on the origin of the Names of South American Natives, would be pretty interesting to see it become a reality tho!
That would be a huge video but also interesting!
Thank you. Very interesting.
Please do some vlogs on the Eastern Tribes
Such as Pequot ,.Mohawk , and Wampanoag .
It's on my list!
I think Southern Boogaloo means something very different in America
Oh no 😮😮
Great video. I’m from that area and have several vision quests and much camping in the 4 corners area. The Navajo are also known as sheep herders. While farming is possible near the few rivers in the desert, grazable land is more common. Also you might be interested in the Fremont culture. They were the northern neighbors of the now termed “Ancestral Puebloans.” They had one of the most important rock art sites in the whole area, a whole genre of style named Barrier Canyon style. Location also known as Horseshoe Canyon en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_Canyon_(Emery_and_Wayne_counties,_Utah)
Thank you for all the info! I'll have a look into the Fremont!
I thought Navajo meant "headbasher" in the Pueblo language. The Anazazi meaning "ancient enemy" in Navajo was spot on though.
Actually, I've heard this term being used from the Ute tribes as they also have a similar word like "navaju" that refer to us as "Headbasher" or "Headcrusher". Most likely we used club axes or blunt objects during raids or being raided.
Tasavuh or "head basher" is a Hopi phrase used for Navajos. Navajo/Navaju is the Pueblo/Tewa word that ended up becoming the name for Navajos. Given how isolated Hopis were at the time it makes sense that Spain would use another tribe's name instead.
The Zuni word for Navajo is Bachu. It comes from a much older word meaning "horse thief". Navajo do not like being called this usually.
@@navajoguy8102 i think tasavu means thief cuz us hopis have a saying I don't remember what it was but the translation was "look at thief"
the word navajo comes from the Spanish term Ladron con navaja which meant "thief with the knife"
Awesome video as usual, what do you use for animation/drawings? Really improves video quality
Thank you! I just use Powerpoint ;) Bit of creativity here and there haha.
Bring in the Pueblo specialist, please!
Thanks for the feedback I'll get in touch with her!
As I briefly mentioned in the chat, the Parisian meaning of 'Apache' came to Poland, especially Warsaw where 'apasz' began meaning the same. There is a whole little weird genre of songs romanticizing the shady underbelly of the pre-WW2 Warsaw, that often features this term, for example:
ruclips.net/video/n8a5zK6CQ28/видео.html
It is no longer in the regular use, but the word 'apaszka', meaning a neck scarf, still is.
Meanwhile, an actual Apache in Polish is 'Apacz' (plural 'Apacze').
Very interesting! Thanks for letting me know about it!
@@historywithhilbert146 My pleasure. ;D
Im Ojibwe from MN i believe our ancestors migrated around the great lakes area.
i have read that the zuni people speaks a language similar to purepecha (méxico), quechua and aymara (south america), you can make a video about it.
Yes indeed you correct i am from michoacan and i do speak one or or language that is call purhepecha phore and i have native friends from new mexico and peru that they speak there language and is similar in different words
@@moyrivera638 The zuny nation got many things to tell.
Will you later make a video about the five civilized tribes?
The Five Civilised Tribes and the reason behind the name is on my list of videos to make as is a video on the ettmologors behind the tribes living on the Eastern seaboard
History With Hilbert “etymologies”
the name navajo came from the Spanish who call them "ladron con navaja" which meant "thief with the knife"
I used to chat with a Navaho hottie. He said he had never seen the Navajo spelling.
Lucky you! So Navaho is a lot more common in the US as opposed to Navajo?
@@historywithhilbert146 No, Navajo is pretty much the universally recognized spelling within the Nation and within Arizona
Hello Hilbert. Do you like "Historical" games? like Fields of Glory, Steel Division, and most Games made by Paradox and Creative Assembly.
I've played a fair few of the Total War games and before that Age of Empires and Age of Mythology as well as other titles.
Spanish explorer after discovering the Pueblo according to History with Hilbert: 'Hey, golly - the town people'.
Or whatever the 16th century Spanish equivalent of "oh golly" is
@@historywithhilbert146
Dios mio?
It works!
Or "¡Ay caramba!"?
Correction…we pronounce it as Batchu
Hi there, would you do a video about Kvenland in depth? also about the creation of the Kingdom of the Dunmonii by that tribe AND Vortigern Rule with a also a brief focus to the Brittonic diaspora in Galicia??
Oof that's quite a lot - but I will get back to looking at Britain in the Early Middle Ages again soon ;)
seconding kvenland
Yes! More on Pueblo people and more on Oklahoma. Both are amazingly interesting
Thumbs up!
Cheers Kevin!
please, more podcast episodes!!!
I'm interviewing quite a few guests this next week so stay posted! Do you have a preferred site for listening to podcasts? I need to choose where to start uploading them.
@@historywithhilbert146 Personally I use Spotify but I know this may not be the most popular amongst everyone.
When I read "Southern Native American Tribes," I thought it was the Five Civilized Tribes, located from the Southern U.S. (and most of whom forced to go to Oklahoma); but quickly realize you meant Southwest U.S. instead.
The Five Civilised Tribes and the reason behind the name is on my list of videos to make as is a video on the ettmologors behind the tribes living on the Eastern seaboard
If I'm not mistaken my tribe is one of the civilized? Muskogee Creek?
@@amandapenniesuggs2409 The Muscogee are definitely one of the Five Civilized Tribes.
The Hopi are The People of the Short Blue Maize (corn).
Thanks for making it a lot more confusing
Thanks for watching!
2:21 I wonder if the Spanish word "napache" for raccoon is named after the Apache?
@@nousername4676 Thank you!
This is really nerdy, but the inverted caps omega you use for 'u' is IPA for the short 'u' sound in 'hook'. I found this really confusing in a story about pronunciation...
Thank you for letting me know I'll keep it in mind for the next one!
These are the Southwestern tribes, the Southern tribes would usually be the classically called 5 civilized tribes of the Confederacy.
Good Evening, Question... have you ever seen the you tube channel
Smooth Gefixt
, They are building a stone celtic round house in Ireland, AND they are Dutch.. ck them out... ALSO, how is your Split Screen video format coming along??.. Saved a few of your videos to re-watch. 👍😎👍
That's really cool I haven't actually- will check it out!
@@historywithhilbert146 thanks,
Please bring on your friend from Cambridge!
I'll get in touch with her!
Cool sh*t man!!!
Thank you!
2:10 actually Mapache is a native word, it comes from the Nahuatl (language of Nahua in Mexico and Central America) word Mapachin. Many Mexican Spanish words have native origins because the assimilation of native Mexicans wasn’t 100% completed so many of our ancestors retained vocabulary specific to the Americas (usually in a Nahuatl as it was used as a lingua franca in MesoAmerica because of the influence of the Mexicah/Aztecs)
it still pings my ears when i hear british english pronunciation of the letter "h" with the h sound, as an american i am surrounded with people who say it "ey-ch" not "hey-ch"
#SaveTheMongolianLanguage
Big yes
There are about 3.7 million people who live in Mongolia, and 10 million people speak Mongolian. It's not gonna die out. But preserving Mongolian culture is also important.
What about the Cherokee?
The Apache held the largest territory with the fewest warriors which says something. They used horses similarly to the white or Dakots Sioux simply riding them to the battle them dismounting to fight
Yes please bring your friend to talk about the Anasazi/Puebloans
I'll get in touch with her!
Navajo and Apache share a similar language. Both tribes came from upper present day Canada. Migrated to the southwest region. Navajo share a similar dialect with tribes near Bechoko Canada.
A video on the ancient celtic kingdom of elmet and their conflicts with the northumbrians would be interesting.
Pueblo is Spanish word as far as I know
Means town!
Yes I'm early
“And the Hopi are famous for ... Er... (don’t say ear candles don’t say ear candles) ... dances?”
Is it bad this joke went over my head 😂? Could you explain it for me?
History With Hilbert you’ve never heard of Hopi ear candles? I was sure that’s what the pause was about. They are kinda wild: tubular candles you stick in your ear alight to somehow clear ear wax. If you’ve ever had a slightly hippy romantic partner they are what you think of when you hear “Hopi”.
My review: Kinda relaxing; Ear wax situation unchanged.
Is it more of a thing in the US? I've never heard of them! Should I invest in some Hopi candles for my next romantic encounter 😉?
History With Hilbert mate, my weird ex picked them up from Holland and Barrett in Guildford. If you are into Surrey space cadets, maybe pick up a couple of packs. It won’t enhance the romance, but it’d save you a trip into town if you’ve already got them.
do you know the IPA?
Pueblo means 'village' not 'town'.
Potato popueblo
@@historywithhilbert146 patata 🤣
The transcription of the word ‘Navajo’ into Spanish is indeed in line with the Mexican Spanish pronunciation. There Navajo is actually pronounced Na-va-ho. You seem to have a very good Iberian Spanish accent, but that ‘J’ sound is completely different. I don’t believe the spelling’s got anything to do with American English involvement. Americans pronunciation of Spanish just tends to be based on the Mexican variant.
Neither Spanish nor English is native to me, so I’m not sure if I’m missing some information, like development of Spanish in the Americas over time, but that’s just some brief recap over that misconception.
Seminoles when?
Soon!
@@historywithhilbert146 HYPE
I was born in the Northwest. The chinook tribe is pronounced with “sh” sound like chataeau or charlemagne. So it’s like “shin-ook”.
Thomas Kilogram Are you?
Thanks for the feedback!
@Deshone Robinson Oh god it's one of you
@Deshone Robinson There is no saving people like you so I'm not even gonna try.
Just know you're ignoring very basic anthropology.
What's the evidence for the first inhabitants of the Americas being black?
Lol Southern Booogaloo.
title is confusing How did Southern Native American Tribes get their names?
Southern america thats Brazil Argentina Chile Peru Bolivia Columbia. But this video is about Tribes in what is now the United Statse of America? very confusing ( the united states is located in North America )
Wouldn't that be South American rather than Southern American?
@@historywithhilbert146 southern US and Mexico. Or the southern part of north America. Both would be more correct. Hence less confusing. a lot of US Americans make the same mistake when saying they are Americans when refaring to their contry. Everyone living in north or south America are Americans. thanks for replaying. you making a simular video for tribes in south america ? including the 3 African tribs in French Guyana.
Ummmm no. Just change the title to SOUTHWESTERN NATIVE AMERICAN tribes. I'm Muskogee Creek and Seminole. That my friend is Southern American
@@torbenjohansen6955
You'd think this thoughtless U.S. nomenclature couldn't be more backwards than it already is and yet... 🙄
I doubt you will find too many real Puebloans offended by Anasazi. Especially since the current Navajo word for the Hopi is Cliffshitters.
Mapache is not a Spanish word in origin. Sounds more like nahualt in origin.
Research Bacon's Rebellion and the Gullah wars. The Guale and Gullah are likely the same people.
I'll take a look!
Again , history according to the white man ....come to our homelands and ask!
Hi Hilbert! Thank you for all your great videos, I sent you an email and message on Instagram - I think it can be interesting for you :)
Isn't apach a French dance like a tango? Throwing women on the floor and such, bashing their heads? How about doing a video about the Havasupai Indians that live in the Grand Canyon.
I haven't heard of it being a dance but will look into it!
Based on the histories I have learned from actual Native Americans this poster has no clue what he is talking about or he merely makes it up in the middle of the night.
The first Spanish conquistador contact what the navajos was at Acoma Mesa we were trading with the Acoma pueblos The Conquistadors they knew we were kind of War like they called us querochero we constantly raided other tribes and pueblos Zuñi is called us apachu it was that the Tewa pueblos called us Nabajaú the Mexicans found out they were different types of Apaches so they called us Apache de Navajo later on they shortened it to Navajo
Mapache is actually a Nahuatl word. Not spanish! Even though it's used in Mexican spanish. Alot of native words in Mexican spanish.
Love seeing these types of videos why not do one on the indigenous peoples of canada?
North west south east go north Sacramento California apostolic god devil the Jesus Christ name amen
*Pueblo peoples* sounds really funny to me, I don't know why XD
The Apache are in Oklahoma, but the Navajo are not.
Good shout
Thousaneth like
The Navajo, and Apache speak a Na Dene Language formerly called Athabaskan that is related to most of the First Nations languages of Northern Canada and Alaska. These People almost all call themselves Dene meaning again People.
TBH Apache Chief wasn't one of Marvel's best characters
No mention of the Ute tribes 😔
They were great Basin tribes
This seems pretty centered on New Mexican tribes
*southwestern native American tribes 🙄
Probably would be a good edit
Non Natives teaching native history
Historian teaching history
Who better to teach their own history then the Apache, Navajo, Pueblo, Zuni
I encourage people from these groups to teach their own history but the idea you can only talk about history if you're genetically related to those you're talking about is ridiculous.