@@cymoonrbacpro9426 He did when he wrote his field equations for general relativity - gravitational waves are a natural result of the form the equations take, the same way that Maxwell's equations of electromagnetism naturally produce wave solutions (electromagnetic waves, or light)
もみじまんじゅう Did you know that LIGO system is receiving signals that number in the hundreds and they classify them as “glitches” ! And Scientist have no idea the sources of these so-called glitches. Could it be that this GW chirp is actually just a glitch which are misinterpreted to be a gravitational waves. Please note the excerpts of the article which follows; *LIGO glitches are detector events of unknown origin whose frequency spectrum does not look like the expected gravitational wave signals. I don’t know exactly how many of those the detector suffers from, but the way they are numbered, by a date and two digits, indicates between 10 and 100 a day. LIGO uses a citizen science project, called “Gravity Spy” to identify glitches. There isn’t one type of glitch, there are many different types of them, with names like “Koi fish,” “whistle,” or “blip.” In the figures below you see a few examples.* And here’s another example of an article relating to the blips; *Blip glitches are short noise transients present in data from ground-based gravitational-wave observatories. These glitches resemble the gravitational-wave signature of massive binary black hole mergers. Hence, the sensitivity of transient gravitational-wave searches to such high-mass systems and other potential short duration sources is degraded by the presence of blip glitches. The origin and rate of occurrence of this type of glitch have been largely unknown.* This is going to be the biggest debacle in scientific history, and I must say, a well deserve one!
Elizabeth Hillman Nothing more than quantum fluctuation and not gravitational waves, some might say it is part of quantum noise, this conclusion would be correct.
Richard Feynman didn't have a college degree for most of his career in physics. Nikola Tesla never had a college degree. Stop worshipping academia. Many of humannity's top physicists and inventors didn't go to college. Isaac Newton himself never received a college degree. He lived on the top of a stone tower for most his life.
soviet onion - Your closed mind shows total ignorance. All science starts at "life science" which is mysticism and theory and trying to prove that inventions are not crazy. It's all a experiment is the best and worst ways.
The ISS experiments came from life science and the movie 2001 space odyssey was showing you what the crystal protein lattice is designed to do. YOU have been taken out of the equation. No more video games for you.
@@smh9902 Feynman got his bachelors degree in 1939 when he was 21. "Richard Feynman didn't have a college degree for most of his career in physics" LMAO you could have easily fact checked this in 30 seconds, instead of repeating some dumb myth that agreed with your own viewpoint
@@sisu9663 Okay, well, you're missing the point. Isaac Newton and Nikola Tesla didn't have a college degree. There is literally nothing you can learn inside college that can't be learned outside college. And That's a fact.
Kip Thorne at 35:09 plus..at the time of the Black Hole collision, that 'storm' that lasted for 20 milliseconds, the energy output of that collision was 50 times greater than the energy output of ALL of the stars in the Universe combined. Think about that.. Oh man!!
I'm not sure anyone knows how many stars there are in the universe. Kip didn't bother to make it clear whether he meant fifty time greater than all the stars in the universe for those few milliseconds or fifty times greater than all the stars in the universe since the beginning of time. But when nobody on the panel objected when Reize told us _twice_ that Alpha Centauri is three and a quarter light years away I get the feeling LIGO's much-touted precision is not particularly high on their agenda. Nevertheless it all sounds pretty impressive, eh what? .
If we now look for LIGO signals from the regions of space occupied by the distant galaxies that Hubble showed are accelerating away, would we expect to see the strength of the gravitational waves of equivalent size black hole collisions being dramatically or completely reduced to nothing due to the possible expansion of space time?
This is like solving A 100-year old physics homework. God damn it! Why do I know about this only now, RUclips should priories their recommended system.
Whats happened, when photodiode with pinhole turn to distant star.... small distant shifts to left, right cause light variations.. and possible detect waves...
I have a question, being that the LIGO system is picking up many glitches and some of them look like gravitational waves, how certain are you that your interpretation is the right one, considering these anomalies? In other words, is it a Possible that you are inadvertently cherry picking the data? See this; *”Blip glitches are short noise transients present in data from ground-based gravitational-wave observatories. These glitches resemble the gravitational-wave signature of massive binary black hole mergers. Hence, the sensitivity of transient gravitational-wave searches to such high-mass systems and other potential short duration sources is degraded by the presence of blip glitches. The origin and rate of occurrence of this type of glitch have been largely unknown. In this paper we explore the population of blip glitches in Advanced LIGO during its first and second observing runs. On average, we find that Advanced LIGO data contains approximately two blip glitches per hour of data. We identify four subsets of blip glitches correlated with detector auxiliary or environmental sensor channels, however the physical causes of the majority of blips remain unclear.”* Is the LIGO consortium a exercise in confirmation bias?
Are gravitational waves originating from the binary black hole merger still happening? How long will it last? And how we just happened to run into the time frame in which it hit the earth while our civilization was advanced to detect them?
Great questions. I like this type of questions because this are fundamentally the most basic questions when it comes to common sense and people tend to not think of.
After the merger, the gravitational wave is attenuated to well below noise threshold. It is not still emitting gravitational waves because it is now a single rotating black hole. The fact that we have detected this signal is a mix of luck and frequency. It suggests that black holes are a lot more numerous than previously estimated. Hope this helps
Since gravitational waves are limited to the speed of light, how is it theoretically possible to move faster than the speed of light using a Alcubierre Warp Drive?
Because the warp drive theory does not exceed light speed. Theoretically a warp drive compresses the empty space between you and your destination. Think of a 10 foot carpeted room. At one foot per second it would take you 10 seconds to cross the carpet. A warp drive would effectively roll up the carpet in front of you so the other side is only a foot away. You travel the same speed, but cross the carpet in one second, not ten. That's warp drive theory!
You mean toys like cell phones, GPS systems, solar powered cells, insulation, vaccines, etc. Keep making fun, I doubt you could live without the science "toys" you mock like a moron.
You are either a troll or an uneducated, opinionated keyboard warrior. Either way, I have no time to play with you. Bye bye and enjoy your own little world.
+Michael This is confirmation of a new way of observing the universe... this is comparable to the invention of the telescope. Not only can we observe known objects in the universe in a new way, we may also be able to detect previously unknown objects.
By asking a question as dumb as that! There is no point in telling you what is important about this discovery! A more immediate concern you should have is having someone competent enough to remove the cork that are in your head and emptying the ship out of it, that would be a start in your road to reasonability! Although the Republican Party might want you to keep that cork stop. Good because Trump is going to need those votes
Still don't understand, why people on this tiny planet fight for small things, when giant massive eaters like black holes in space are trying to merge n stay as one😜
I can hear these waves when they come. And hit the planet... it’s like a really deep feeling or vibration comming from everywhere... Is that odd? It’s almost as if some one has a subwoofer pulsing rumbling like or vibrating bbrrrrrrooooww.. brrrrroooowwwww
Diameter 150 km?? What about the point-like diameter most astronomers think is the diameter of a black hole, especially the big bangers?? Or, perhaps, one scientific stupidity more killed off?
The greatest probability is that you don't understand the science not that the science is wrong. Claiming science is "stupid" is the zenith of stupidity.
+rickylarch To believe in the 'four wonders' (first creatio ex nihilio, second inflation with no physical laws, third dark matter, and fourth dark energy) is stupid, really very, very stupid, when the simple alternative that space-time has no limits solves the problem. That Big Bangers chose to name their naive religious beliefs as 'science', well, it is not my fault nor my wish.
Clearly, you are much smarter than the top minds of science since you don't know the definition of religion and you have solved the origin of the universe. Please share your calculations with us. The world awaits your proofs with great anticipation.
Even today, i cannot believe Einstein predicted this 100 years ago! Brilliant
SPillay He did not predict this, that a myth!
@@cymoonrbacpro9426 He did when he wrote his field equations for general relativity - gravitational waves are a natural result of the form the equations take, the same way that Maxwell's equations of electromagnetism naturally produce wave solutions (electromagnetic waves, or light)
LIGO India, happy and super excited that it has been planned!
Jay Shah ban chot
Rahul Singh Yadav INDIGO! I can’t wait until it goes online!?
Rahul Singh Yadav Planned indeed, In order to guarantee more funding! Keep the enterprise going, junk science!
ヨビノリから来た日本人がいるはず。
we did it !
もみじまんじゅう Did you know that LIGO system is receiving signals that number in the hundreds and they classify them as “glitches” ! And Scientist have no idea the sources of these so-called glitches. Could it be that this GW chirp is actually just a glitch which are misinterpreted to be a gravitational waves. Please note the excerpts of the article which follows;
*LIGO glitches are detector events of unknown origin whose frequency spectrum does not look like the expected gravitational wave signals. I don’t know exactly how many of those the detector suffers from, but the way they are numbered, by a date and two digits, indicates between 10 and 100 a day. LIGO uses a citizen science project, called “Gravity Spy” to identify glitches. There isn’t one type of glitch, there are many different types of them, with names like “Koi fish,” “whistle,” or “blip.” In the figures below you see a few examples.*
And here’s another example of an article relating to the blips; *Blip glitches are short noise transients present in data from ground-based gravitational-wave observatories. These glitches resemble the gravitational-wave signature of massive binary black hole mergers. Hence, the sensitivity of transient gravitational-wave searches to such high-mass systems and other potential short duration sources is degraded by the presence of blip glitches. The origin and rate of occurrence of this type of glitch have been largely unknown.* This is going to be the biggest debacle in scientific history, and I must say, a well deserve one!
4:02 Ladies and gentlemen...BOOM :D
Michele Levi thank you!
And that’s when I cried.
We got him.
I am so happy to study this! What a time to be alive.
Elizabeth Hillman Nothing more than quantum fluctuation and not gravitational waves, some might say it is part of quantum noise, this conclusion would be correct.
All these conspiracy nutjobs in the comment section. Show me a PHD and maybe I'll take your word with even the tiniest grain of salt.
Richard Feynman didn't have a college degree for most of his career in physics. Nikola Tesla never had a college degree. Stop worshipping academia. Many of humannity's top physicists and inventors didn't go to college. Isaac Newton himself never received a college degree. He lived on the top of a stone tower for most his life.
soviet onion - Your closed mind shows total ignorance. All science starts at "life science" which is mysticism and theory and trying to prove that inventions are not crazy. It's all a experiment is the best and worst ways.
The ISS experiments came from life science and the movie 2001 space odyssey was showing you what the crystal protein lattice is designed to do. YOU have been taken out of the equation. No more video games for you.
@@smh9902 Feynman got his bachelors degree in 1939 when he was 21. "Richard Feynman didn't have a college degree for most of his career in physics" LMAO you could have easily fact checked this in 30 seconds, instead of repeating some dumb myth that agreed with your own viewpoint
@@sisu9663 Okay, well, you're missing the point. Isaac Newton and Nikola Tesla didn't have a college degree. There is literally nothing you can learn inside college that can't be learned outside college. And That's a fact.
Einstein's work still speaking to us today. Genius.
Kip Thorne at 35:09 plus..at the time of the Black Hole collision, that 'storm' that lasted for 20 milliseconds, the energy output of that collision was 50 times greater than the energy output of ALL of the stars in the Universe combined. Think about that.. Oh man!!
eastwestcoastkid ruclips.net/video/Ivt0TgZbHvE/видео.html check this out
I'm not sure anyone knows how many stars there are in the universe. Kip didn't bother to make it clear whether he meant fifty time greater than all the stars in the universe for those few milliseconds or fifty times greater than all the stars in the universe since the beginning of time.
But when nobody on the panel objected when Reize told us _twice_ that Alpha Centauri is three and a quarter light years away I get the feeling LIGO's much-touted precision is not particularly high on their agenda. Nevertheless it all sounds pretty impressive, eh what?
.
Gaby...Proud argentinian scientist....!!!
More people on Earth should be watching this.
Kuangheng Hwang Why?
From the Anpanman👋
If we now look for LIGO signals from the regions of space occupied by the distant galaxies that Hubble showed are accelerating away, would we expect to see the strength of the gravitational waves of equivalent size black hole collisions being dramatically or completely reduced to nothing due to the possible expansion of space time?
BLACK HOLE IS FLAT TOO
1/1000 of the size of the proton.....
@Fox Mulder English, please?
This is like solving A 100-year old physics homework.
God damn it! Why do I know about this only now, RUclips should priories their recommended system.
Absolutely amazing. Absolutely amazing.
congrats to Prof Kip Thorne and Prof Rainer Weiss for winning Nobel prize in Physics - the most prestigious even in Nobel prize categories
does this prove that gravity and time and space have each got a vector direction
Whats happened, when photodiode with pinhole turn to distant star.... small distant shifts to left, right cause light variations.. and possible detect waves...
Amazing Discovery ! God Bless U & help U always in your Journey!....
4:02
Fascinating.
They totally skated over the Russia's question.
I have a question, being that the LIGO system is picking up many glitches and some of them look like gravitational waves, how certain are you that your interpretation is the right one, considering these anomalies? In other words, is it a Possible that you are inadvertently cherry picking the data?
See this; *”Blip glitches are short noise transients present in data from ground-based gravitational-wave observatories. These glitches resemble the gravitational-wave signature of massive binary black hole mergers. Hence, the sensitivity of transient gravitational-wave searches to such high-mass systems and other potential short duration sources is degraded by the presence of blip glitches. The origin and rate of occurrence of this type of glitch have been largely unknown. In this paper we explore the population of blip glitches in Advanced LIGO during its first and second observing runs. On average, we find that Advanced LIGO data contains approximately two blip glitches per hour of data. We identify four subsets of blip glitches correlated with detector auxiliary or environmental sensor channels, however the physical causes of the majority of blips remain unclear.”* Is the LIGO consortium a exercise in confirmation bias?
amazing
Are gravitational waves originating from the binary black hole merger still happening? How long will it last? And how we just happened to run into the time frame in which it hit the earth while our civilization was advanced to detect them?
Great questions. I like this type of questions because this are fundamentally the most basic questions when it comes to common sense and people tend to not think of.
After the merger, the gravitational wave is attenuated to well below noise threshold. It is not still emitting gravitational waves because it is now a single rotating black hole. The fact that we have detected this signal is a mix of luck and frequency. It suggests that black holes are a lot more numerous than previously estimated. Hope this helps
Since gravitational waves are limited to the speed of light, how is it theoretically possible to move faster than the speed of light using a Alcubierre Warp Drive?
Because the warp drive theory does not exceed light speed. Theoretically a warp drive compresses the empty space between you and your destination. Think of a 10 foot carpeted room. At one foot per second it would take you 10 seconds to cross the carpet. A warp drive would effectively roll up the carpet in front of you so the other side is only a foot away. You travel the same speed, but cross the carpet in one second, not ten. That's warp drive theory!
You mean toys like cell phones, GPS systems, solar powered cells, insulation, vaccines, etc. Keep making fun, I doubt you could live without the science "toys" you mock like a moron.
You are either a troll or an uneducated, opinionated keyboard warrior. Either way, I have no time to play with you. Bye bye and enjoy your own little world.
HighlandMan
Lmao :DDDDDD
I dont have an hour to watch this can somone just tell me why this is important
Same here! Trying to skip through to get the good parts (no luck so far ^^)
+Michael This is confirmation of a new way of observing the universe... this is comparable to the invention of the telescope. Not only can we observe known objects in the universe in a new way, we may also be able to detect previously unknown objects.
+mendali thx buddy
Awesome :)
+Eric Gustafsson well is a long way from detection to building a telescope. Nevertheless a small step has been made.
By asking a question as dumb as that! There is no point in telling you what is important about this discovery! A more immediate concern you should have is having someone competent enough to remove the cork that are in your head and emptying the ship out of it, that would be a start in your road to reasonability! Although the Republican Party might want you to keep that cork stop. Good because Trump is going to need those votes
hahahahahahaha
"Billions of years ago" eh? LOl......
May the force be with you. Does Falcon run on gold ?
last I heard life's detection has turned out to be dust in the machine
You're thinking of BICEP2 not accounting for cosmic dust, it's a different experiment
Still don't understand, why people on this tiny planet fight for small things, when giant massive eaters like black holes in space are trying to merge n stay as one😜
I can hear these waves when they come. And hit the planet... it’s like a really deep feeling or vibration comming from everywhere... Is that odd? It’s almost as if some one has a subwoofer pulsing rumbling like or vibrating bbrrrrrrooooww.. brrrrroooowwwww
All I want to know is when we are going to invent women robots. Just like Blade Runner. Then I'll talk gravity waves. LOL
Electric Universe, look it up. Walt Thornhill.
didnt Tesla work all this out in the 30s ..
Ahh yes, you're right we just forgot about it. Ok guys nothing more to see here, this whole meeting is pointless now
Lol there where more ppl here in italy at a conference of a kid inventing a new word than this... Fuck this life
南鄉子•重力波
億萬載前波，穿越時空宛若梭。莫測神秘誰捕獲? LIGO, 學界三人諾獎托。
蘋果掉出魔, 重力方程誕心窩。創立愛翁相對論, 奇招, 牛頓相形也見拙。
Stop lieing 2 our children & the world, We live on a flat MOTIONLESS PLANE!!!
Liers! Liers! Liers! There's no gravity!!!
Are you joking or is this serious?
Yeah EaRtH Is FlAt. ScIeNce iS FaKe.
Diameter 150 km?? What about the point-like diameter most astronomers think is the diameter of a black hole, especially the big bangers?? Or, perhaps, one scientific stupidity more killed off?
The greatest probability is that you don't understand the science not that the science is wrong. Claiming science is "stupid" is the zenith of stupidity.
+rickylarch To believe in the 'four wonders' (first creatio ex nihilio, second inflation with no physical laws, third dark matter, and fourth dark energy) is stupid, really very, very stupid, when the simple alternative that space-time has no limits solves the problem. That Big Bangers chose to name their naive religious beliefs as 'science', well, it is not my fault nor my wish.
+N.G.H. Calmarena But I admit I should have put 'scientific' like I have put it here.
Clearly, you are much smarter than the top minds of science since you don't know the definition of religion and you have solved the origin of the universe. Please share your calculations with us. The world awaits your proofs with great anticipation.
+rickylarch Certainly, I will do that, if you just tell me what I'm supposed to calculate?
so fake !!!!!!!!! hahahaahaahaha