"Ah, Saber's Excalibur is longer than Caliburn, but Caliburn is thicker and harder than Excalibur." "You're so knowledgeable about swords, Emiya-kun." "...Swords?"
I always liked the head cannon that Shirou or Archer were the ones to wield Excalibur against Shafar, as a way of bringing it full circle - highly illogical and unlikely, but a fun thought for me
I mean it could happen, consider the whole point of counter guardian is to protect the world and humanity from the threat that try to destroy it, Alaya might send EMIYA back to the ancient time to fight against the threat, so I see the idea of EMIYA being the first wielder of Excalibur is possible, Alaya might remove his limitations and let him be powerful enough to wield it.
Something that must be said, is that we haven't seen Excalibur full power yet, much like the Excaliburn of her male counterpart, Excaliburn is limited by various oaths, in her interlude we get to lift one of them, just that one managed to improve Excaliburn rank from A to A++, and Artoria stated that Excaliburn released at full power would be once in a lifetime event.
Technically we did see it, but only in Extella’s backstory. When we see the White Titan’s invasion flashback they describe the blinding light that stops the Titan and how it came from a mere human. That game was the one who first told us that Excalibur could only exhibit its real power against Threats from the Stars. Although it is Prototype that tells us about the twelve seals of Excalibur (which FGO clarifies that it applies to all King Arthurs, not just the Prototype version).
i think the idea of Excalibur being the sword from stone comes from fan-fic like Disney when I read the book, the story clearly said King Arthur's sword from stone broke and he had to find a replacement. that's why lady of the lake came into play and gave him Excalibur along with the scabbard. Merline asked him whether he prefer the sword or the scabbard, and King Arthur joyfully said he preferred the sword - which Merlin laughed at the idea and pointed out that the scabbard was far more valuable because it grants the wielder invulnerability to harms.
there are many versions of the arthurian legends, iirc including one where caliburn and excalibur are the same sword or where excalibur was the sword in the stone. that's probably why some people confuse the two
@@tsuna_mayoYep, Arthur pulled out the Caliburn or the Excalibur depending on what version of the story you read, Fate uses the Caliburn -> Excalibur version as we know, though I was confused the first time, Shirou projects the Caliburn and Saber says "hey that's my sword" then she uses Excalibur when attacking Gilgamesh
This actually made me think of something and that is emiya’s projection ability and how he can’t trace divine constructs and i thought that’s why he couldn’t even comprehend ea but if Excalibur is also a divine construct and it’s implied that he is able to replicate it, even if it’s to a lesser extent and extremely costly, I was wondering what’s the difference between the two and other divine constructs for that matter?
Familiarity with the object mainly- Shirou can (SPOILERS FOR FATE ROUTE IF YOU HAVEN'T READ IT) actually project avalon without any downside, despite it being a divine construct, due to it being inside his body for many years and thus easier to comprehend. The reason emiya can't normally trace divine constructs is because their makeup is beyond human comprehension.
Emiya cannot project divine construct but it can create weapons that have the same abilitys and much same fire power but those projeccions aren't comsidered divine constructs also they cost a lot of magic energy to use, about EA it is simply irreplicable like it has copyright
In Extraverse, EMIYA or Nameless is capable of projecting a lesser copy of Excalibur; Excalibur Image. The reason why he can do this is because of Moon Cell's environment that managed to expand his range of projection. And is also the reason why he can project Aestus Estus (Nero's sword) and Gae Bolg.
he cannot comprehend the data he reads when traces AE. its like a programmer seeing a string of code in a completely foreign coding language, but worse since that coding language is something that predates humanity.
@@culturedboii5327 How could you get that last half wrong lol. The reason Mumei projects the Extella weapons is because he could always do it. The only supplementary is that Mumei, when allied with other servants, has an easier time/boost in projecting things they own, but that doesn't really matter since he pulls them out when in UBW
Seeing that Excalibur was formed from Gaia’s will really makes his powerful it is make a lot of sense. I remember in MBTL Arcueid says that her and the sword are basically family, that being said who would win in a fight Heroic Spirit Saber or Princess of the True Ancestors Arcueid?
arcueid would win. excalibur is only at full power when its fighting against threats to humanity and the planet. and arcueid is the literal embodiment of the earth so excalibur would be very weak against her
@@ShadowAraun im pretty sure arthur's excalibur works the same way. it can only get unsealed fully against threats to humanity and beasts etc., he cant just unseal it whenever he wants
I wonder if Surtr was around when Sefar arrived because his sword was also made by the Planet, although his was for the purpose of ending the Norse Age of Gods we do see in Lostbelt 2 that it isn't limited to that.
Good video. Another idea to kinda go alongside this one are weapons that possibly match or even surpass excalibur, but I'll watch whatever you put out regardless
Something I don't see anyone talking about is how mikiya from Kara no kyoukai shows up in El melloi case files which kinda makes me think knk is in the fate timeline could just be a throwback but I think it's a cool thought
most people dont read the light novels thats why no one is talking about it. and yeah, kara no kyoukai is in the same timeline as stay night and case files. the author works very closely with nasu and he confirmed it on twitter
What if a Marble phantasm user is inside a reality marble? Would they still be able to use their Marble Phantasm or not because they are cut out from the world
This talk of Excalibur has got me thinking since it's supposed to be the strongest weapon connected to the planet how does Tanaka's arm compare to it? since THAT is also technically a weapon of the planet
Still baffles me Excalibur is at most A++ it’s literally the planets power in the form of a blade. Plus considering its nature and the fact it defeated something that weakened and nearly eliminated nearly al the gods. Makes wonder if it could reach EX in the hands of Arcueid her being an Archetype two manifestations of the planet in tandem. But I will admit design wise I live Caliburn over Excalibur.
basically A++ rank is the highest level that can be measured while EX has some trick to it the easiest comparison is Excalibur and AE Excalibur is raw power in the purest form, a beam of pure intense heat that incinerates those before it AE.... in simple terms shreds space itself. it is a sword that cuts and collapses space. to quote the wiki "it creates a rip in space that extends from not only the earth but also to the sky and atmosphere. It is a crack that distorts space to pierce the very nature of the World itself to show the "Truth." All that uses the cut space as a foundation is swallowed and crushed by the void, and the dazzling light only continues to grow as it continues to complete the destruction. Its use in a fight is not something that can be called a battle, but rather the wrath of nature itself."
To be fair at it’s full power Excalibur is ex rank since it is literally victory on the conceptual level the problem is a lot like Ea it’s nearly impossible to actually unleash its full power
Short answer: You pull the sword of selection, you're king. That's caliburn. (Also, get ready for years of conflict, blood, sweat, tears, and relationship issues). Excalibur? Hmm, idk yet. But when the lady of the lake coughed it up, Saber saw this saber and said, "Oh hey, this saber looks like me! I'm gonna use it."
I've always find it weird the supposed ceremonial sword that wasn't designed for battle is the more useable one aesthetic-wise. Caliburn has the proportion of a proper sword, bar the lack of the proper pommel. Excalibur sucks ass.
Now that I think about it. Gram while seen as a holy sword of selection like Caliburn . It's also considered a demonic sword similar to Balmung. But what does make a weapon demonic or holy in the first place? Is it the purpose of their creation? Their abilities? Or something else?
Excalibur depending on what universe. Was the equivalent of the greatest demonic blade to its divine nature, they are equivalent. Also depending on wat universe Excalibur was also made from in some form from gram.
I was wondering if you could make a video about what can UBW can copy and not. Rho Aias for example. It looks more like a magic/enegy shield rather than physical one.
From what I understand, it isn't replicating the actual shield itself, but it's concept, in turn making the Blade Works Rho Aias a Conceptual Weapon. I don't have the greatest understanding of how it all works, but from what I understand and saw said by someone is that the original shield had 7 layers of some material, don't remember what, that acted as defenses. The Rho Aias of the Blade Works took the concept of the shield and it's 7 material layers, and turned them into a 7 petalled defense that is meant to stop all projectiles, if I remember correctly. I could be completely misunderstanding this, but that's what I understand based on what I've heard and seen from others.
@@multiversal_guardian7079 What EMIYA is projecting is still Rho Aias, he's just projecting it as a Conceptual Weapon because it's better that way(also the conceptual part is mostly in regards to it's abilities not it's form). Remember that NPs can have Alteration used on them, but also Greek Weapons are shown to be weird as shit as Odysseus shows. It's also implied that it's form changed as a result of becoming an NP
I have a question if weapons like Excalibur and EA are that powerful due to their origins what with Excalibur being forged by the Fae from Avalon itself and EA being created before the concept of swords even existed if we took legendary weapons from like DnD who derive their power from their legends would they also stack up to weapons like Excalibur if we used the Natsu rules?
The fact that only 3 seals realised Excalibur is alredy an a++rank np imagine if artoria unsealed 6 of the seals like Arthur since both of their Excaliburs work exactly the same
9:40 And then, over the horizon... The man destined to always have the bigger dick, Ado Edem, emerges with his sword that fucking kills Types: Slash Emperor. That one's the real deal when we talk about feats... And heights too!
Tsiah!!!! I love your videos! Would you consider doing a video on the True Ending tonight for Fate Stay Night/VN (Realta Nua)? Such how talking about how Shirou reaches Avalon, what he did before that and how Saber waited for him all this time. Maybe even speculate on how he broke free from Alaiya?
Hey man can you do a video of differentiating the swords that the lady of the lake made Excalibur, Galatine, and arondight, aside from their destructive power is there any unique abilities/attributes that it gives them such as like if someone holds excalibur the user will no longer age but live long. -thank you.
Is there anything stopping a master from summoning a servant version of themselves like rin summoning ishtar. Shouldn't their bodies count as catalysts for that servant?
Hey Tsiah, I have a question. Can you make a video to discuss Alteration magecraft? So, based on what I have read so far both from the Wiki and other sources. Alterarion is a magecraft that give the caster an ability to give and change the properties and abilities to inanimate objects like what has been shown by Karmaglyph in El-Melloi Adventure. And do you think Shirou is capable of using this magecraft to give abilities and Properties to his projected items? And could he use Alteration to give conceptual powers to any of his projected weapons?
@@TrueBladeSoul I'm afraid that's not how Shirou and EMIYA turn swords into arrows. It's been stated in the Wiki and other sources that they use their personal version of Reinforcement to manipulate the physical shape of their projected weapons. While Alteration, as far as I know, is to give an object a property or effect that it originally didn’t have. Alteration also mentioned to enable the caster to make drastic changes to substances such as turning metal into rubber, fire into ice, or concrete into mud. And since Alteration can be considered as magecraft related to creating Swords, in my opinion, I though that maybe it's possible for Shirou to learn how to use it. And considering how versatile the Unlimited Blade Works, I wonder if Shirou could use Alteration magecraft to a more Advance level like how he uses Projection and Reinforcement.
I have to wonder if Zouken didn't do what he did in Fate/Zero would Lancelot have still been summoned as a berserker or would another berserker have been summoned in his place?
Depends. From what I heard you can summon any servant even without a catalyst. Sakura summoned Medusa without a catalyst. However, a catalyst just improves your chances of summoning a specific servant
Hmm, Gilgamesh became a Caster as a response to Grand Caster "Solomon." So is it possible for Gilgamesh to pull off the same feats, or greater than, GOETIA? Something that surpasses what Archer Gilgamesh begun but failed to complete in Fate Stay Night?
For fate zero i would just stay away from fuyuki since your chance of being killed are much higher compared to fsn. For fsn i would just warned bazzet about kirei betrayals/maybe reveals archer's identity to shirou early just to troll with him.
Why doesnt anyone talk about the sword that killed author, excaliburn morgan crafted it in dragons fire speacially to kill the great king in one legend anyway and I believe that legend was the basis for a Tv show about merlin for some reason. Hell maybe the fact all 3 sword have similar names is why people get so confused. That and thw fact some legends say that they are all one sword weilded at different times for diffent reasons by different people
Can take a balmung lvl arrow to the face+(b+) rank detonation, though Siegfried was heavily wounded afterwards. Karna was also said to be able to behead Siegfried if the latter got careless even for a moment. It's pretty good against....99% percent of servants?
@imranabdirafikov3847 One, I don't see how this relates to the previous topic of dragon cores vs. Galvanism. Second I'm pretty sure that the light novel said that either one could have lost their heads if they got careless, but I will have to check that.
Hey, do you think you could make a video to clear up what happened in the whole event where I believe Gilgamesh defeat all the gods and as to what happened after and why?
Since Excalibur is A++ rank and lets say borderline S what weapons do reside in the S rank and what makes the weapon so beyond if being forged by gods or other mythological being.
there is no S rank in fate. there is EX rank but EX doesnt necessarily mean its the strongest, it just means that it cant be measured by conventional means
I always thought Artoria had a much deeper story and lore than most people think. Which is why shes my only 5 star at NP5 and well my name lmao Also please give me her suit from zero as a costume in FGO XD
If a Sword like Excalibur is always needed to kill the White Titan... Then where was Ea? Or does this mean He's Wielder is not interested in steppimg up should Excalibur not be created a timeline like LB6? Or is this suggesting that Excalibur is only stronger than Ea thanks to it drawing power from the very Breath of the Planet EXACTLY like Enkidu? But then doesn't this mean Enkidu is just as strong, if not stronger, since both Enkidu and Excalibur can both unlock the Threat to Humanity special attack when in the presence on such a Threat?
Have you tried researching the other Weapons, Tools, and Armor of Artoria, like, how much would her Fighting Style would Change if she have her Prydwen with her, or how would her tactics would've change if she used Carnwennan, due to our own History stating that she had it with her, which it's stated that it gave her the ability to turn invisible and merge with the shadows, then there's her 3 specifically named Pieces of Armor, like Goswhit, Gwen, and Wygar. Which, Mysterious Heroin X has hers as a Hat, Scarf, and her Jacket Respectively. Also, why not do a Research on the other Wielders and Weapons that are also named Excalibur as well, aka you could explain if there's an Excalibur that Shirou would have a much easier time Replicating. Speaking of Shirou, there's a pert where Shirou is stated to have Golden Magic Circuits. Speaking of Magic Circuits, is there a Math or Formula on them. I mean, it stated that the Average Amount of Magic Circuits is 20 and the Average Power Output of an Adult is 25 Units. Usually, with this, Rin, for having 40 Main and 30 Sub, her Power Output would be 82.5 Units, yet, it stated that her max is 1,000 Units, which I don't quite understand for how that's possible, or what the hell is Blue Blood: Magic Circuits and such. Same goes to Magic Cores and how Artoria has a Dragon Magic Core or how powerful is a Magic Core is, compare to Magic Circuits, as well as if it's Possible to have both Magic Core and Magic Circuits. This also includes what's the known Maximum Amount of Magic Circuits could a Person have and what's the known Maximum Output could a Single Circuit could have if it was Developed like if they're a part of a Clan / Family of Mages. Oh, as well as your own thoughts on the other Magic Systems in other Anime compare to the Fate Series Magic System. Like Fairy Tail having a Magic Container that was described as if like an Extra Invisible Organ within the body.
@@fredericoferreira2707 yeah he didnt need to kill her, it was just faster that way. the reason kirei didnt kill her in fate route is probably just to mess with shirou
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
OMG A RUclipsR WHO READS THEIR COMMENTS FOR LONGER THAN AN HOUR!!! THANK YOU I LOVE YOU SO MUCH!!!😭😭😭
THE REAL ARJUNA!?!?!!!!?!!??
WHAT THE HELL IS HAPPENING??? WHY ARE WE ALL SCREAMING???
Congratulations 😊
@@Mikael_OreI'M NOT SURE!!!
It doesn't take an hour to read 200 comments
"Ah, Saber's Excalibur is longer than Caliburn, but Caliburn is thicker and harder than Excalibur."
"You're so knowledgeable about swords, Emiya-kun."
"...Swords?"
I always liked the head cannon that Shirou or Archer were the ones to wield Excalibur against Shafar, as a way of bringing it full circle - highly illogical and unlikely, but a fun thought for me
If Alya also helped in creation then maybe
I mean it could happen, consider the whole point of counter guardian is to protect the world and humanity from the threat that try to destroy it, Alaya might send EMIYA back to the ancient time to fight against the threat, so I see the idea of EMIYA being the first wielder of Excalibur is possible, Alaya might remove his limitations and let him be powerful enough to wield it.
I mean they can. They just die after using it. Emiya also can use it without drawback (not dying) in Fate Extra.
@@misteris2385which is the timeline when the origin of Excalibur was revealed
@@misteris2385Archer uses Excalibur in Extra? I don't remember any of that
Something that must be said, is that we haven't seen Excalibur full power yet, much like the Excaliburn of her male counterpart, Excaliburn is limited by various oaths, in her interlude we get to lift one of them, just that one managed to improve Excaliburn rank from A to A++, and Artoria stated that Excaliburn released at full power would be once in a lifetime event.
Technically we did see it, but only in Extella’s backstory. When we see the White Titan’s invasion flashback they describe the blinding light that stops the Titan and how it came from a mere human. That game was the one who first told us that Excalibur could only exhibit its real power against Threats from the Stars. Although it is Prototype that tells us about the twelve seals of Excalibur (which FGO clarifies that it applies to all King Arthurs, not just the Prototype version).
Exxxxxxxxxxxx.....caliburrrrrrrrrr
If soulcalibur 7 ever happens it would be sick if she was a guest character in the game
REAL
i think the idea of Excalibur being the sword from stone comes from fan-fic like Disney
when I read the book, the story clearly said King Arthur's sword from stone broke and he had to find a replacement. that's why lady of the lake came into play and gave him Excalibur along with the scabbard. Merline asked him whether he prefer the sword or the scabbard, and King Arthur joyfully said he preferred the sword - which Merlin laughed at the idea and pointed out that the scabbard was far more valuable because it grants the wielder invulnerability to harms.
No, that also was still Claiburn in Disney's "The Sword In The Stone".
Isnt Clament the name of the sword in the stone or something?
@@InternetAddict069 i don't remember what it was called. that's why i left it out lol.
there are many versions of the arthurian legends, iirc including one where caliburn and excalibur are the same sword or where excalibur was the sword in the stone. that's probably why some people confuse the two
@@tsuna_mayoYep, Arthur pulled out the Caliburn or the Excalibur depending on what version of the story you read, Fate uses the Caliburn -> Excalibur version as we know, though I was confused the first time, Shirou projects the Caliburn and Saber says "hey that's my sword" then she uses Excalibur when attacking Gilgamesh
This actually made me think of something and that is emiya’s projection ability and how he can’t trace divine constructs and i thought that’s why he couldn’t even comprehend ea but if Excalibur is also a divine construct and it’s implied that he is able to replicate it, even if it’s to a lesser extent and extremely costly, I was wondering what’s the difference between the two and other divine constructs for that matter?
Familiarity with the object mainly- Shirou can (SPOILERS FOR FATE ROUTE IF YOU HAVEN'T READ IT) actually project avalon without any downside, despite it being a divine construct, due to it being inside his body for many years and thus easier to comprehend. The reason emiya can't normally trace divine constructs is because their makeup is beyond human comprehension.
Emiya cannot project divine construct but it can create weapons that have the same abilitys and much same fire power but those projeccions aren't comsidered divine constructs also they cost a lot of magic energy to use, about EA it is simply irreplicable like it has copyright
In Extraverse, EMIYA or Nameless is capable of projecting a lesser copy of Excalibur; Excalibur Image. The reason why he can do this is because of Moon Cell's environment that managed to expand his range of projection. And is also the reason why he can project Aestus Estus (Nero's sword) and Gae Bolg.
he cannot comprehend the data he reads when traces AE. its like a programmer seeing a string of code in a completely foreign coding language, but worse since that coding language is something that predates humanity.
@@culturedboii5327 How could you get that last half wrong lol. The reason Mumei projects the Extella weapons is because he could always do it. The only supplementary is that Mumei, when allied with other servants, has an easier time/boost in projecting things they own, but that doesn't really matter since he pulls them out when in UBW
Caliburn: Sword of the Stone - Magic Construct - Weak
Excalibur: Sword of the Lake - Divine Construct - Strong
Caliburn is far from weak, it's anything but
@@multiversal_guardian7079Proceed to get cut in half by a passer by king
Seeing that Excalibur was formed from Gaia’s will really makes his powerful it is make a lot of sense. I remember in MBTL Arcueid says that her and the sword are basically family, that being said who would win in a fight Heroic Spirit Saber or Princess of the True Ancestors Arcueid?
Very likely Arcueid, Heroic Spirit are much weaker compared to when they were alive
arcueid would win. excalibur is only at full power when its fighting against threats to humanity and the planet. and arcueid is the literal embodiment of the earth so excalibur would be very weak against her
@@JaeyXVI meanwhile Arthur's Excalibur
*at full power following a very long de-sealing process performed by Merlin and the KotRT *
@@ShadowAraun Artoria’s Excalibur also has the seals
@@ShadowAraun im pretty sure arthur's excalibur works the same way. it can only get unsealed fully against threats to humanity and beasts etc., he cant just unseal it whenever he wants
I think it would be a good video to discuss where Ea came from and how Gilgamesh got possession of it.
We know very little other than it is older than the planet itself. For all the info Nasu freely gives of Hil, he is very mum on Ea.
I wonder if Surtr was around when Sefar arrived because his sword was also made by the Planet, although his was for the purpose of ending the Norse Age of Gods we do see in Lostbelt 2 that it isn't limited to that.
Good video. Another idea to kinda go alongside this one are weapons that possibly match or even surpass excalibur, but I'll watch whatever you put out regardless
0:36
Saber looks so adorable with the pigtail :3
Something I don't see anyone talking about is how mikiya from Kara no kyoukai shows up in El melloi case files which kinda makes me think knk is in the fate timeline could just be a throwback but I think it's a cool thought
most people dont read the light novels thats why no one is talking about it. and yeah, kara no kyoukai is in the same timeline as stay night and case files. the author works very closely with nasu and he confirmed it on twitter
Damn I legit was just thinking about this a few hours ago. Insane timing.
love coming home from an 8 hour shift, sitting down, watching a Tsiah video with some Chinese food. love your vids man, keep up the great work.
Sounds fire! It's nice to know that I help bring it all together
What if a Marble phantasm user is inside a reality marble? Would they still be able to use their Marble Phantasm or not because they are cut out from the world
This talk of Excalibur has got me thinking since it's supposed to be the strongest weapon connected to the planet how does Tanaka's arm compare to it? since THAT is also technically a weapon of the planet
Loving the consistent uploads
Still baffles me Excalibur is at most A++ it’s literally the planets power in the form of a blade. Plus considering its nature and the fact it defeated something that weakened and nearly eliminated nearly al the gods. Makes wonder if it could reach EX in the hands of Arcueid her being an Archetype two manifestations of the planet in tandem.
But I will admit design wise I live Caliburn over Excalibur.
EX doesnt mean strongest, it just means that it cant be measured by conventional means. A++ rank can be stronger than EX
Excalibur has 13 seals placed on it to limit its power the only time it’s full power was used was against Sefar
basically A++ rank is the highest level that can be measured while EX has some trick to it
the easiest comparison is Excalibur and AE
Excalibur is raw power in the purest form, a beam of pure intense heat that incinerates those before it
AE.... in simple terms shreds space itself. it is a sword that cuts and collapses space. to quote the wiki
"it creates a rip in space that extends from not only the earth but also to the sky and atmosphere. It is a crack that distorts space to pierce the very nature of the World itself to show the "Truth." All that uses the cut space as a foundation is swallowed and crushed by the void, and the dazzling light only continues to grow as it continues to complete the destruction. Its use in a fight is not something that can be called a battle, but rather the wrath of nature itself."
To be fair at it’s full power Excalibur is ex rank since it is literally victory on the conceptual level the problem is a lot like Ea it’s nearly impossible to actually unleash its full power
Caliburn has the proportion of a proper sword, Excalibur is a generic fantasy SLO
Bro dropping lore content left and right and I love it!!! 😍
Short answer: You pull the sword of selection, you're king. That's caliburn. (Also, get ready for years of conflict, blood, sweat, tears, and relationship issues). Excalibur? Hmm, idk yet. But when the lady of the lake coughed it up, Saber saw this saber and said, "Oh hey, this saber looks like me! I'm gonna use it."
I've always find it weird the supposed ceremonial sword that wasn't designed for battle is the more useable one aesthetic-wise.
Caliburn has the proportion of a proper sword, bar the lack of the proper pommel. Excalibur sucks ass.
requesting for a don't sleep on ozymandias day 77
requesting for a don't sleep on ozymandias day 78
Now that I think about it. Gram while seen as a holy sword of selection like Caliburn . It's also considered a demonic sword similar to Balmung. But what does make a weapon demonic or holy in the first place? Is it the purpose of their creation? Their abilities? Or something else?
I'd say the effect it has on the wielder? But everything you said makes a lot of sense too
4:17 yep definitely sounds like Saber alright.
Love the ads on these vids! Get ya bread man
1:01 Damn arthur is thicc 😂😂
2:04 what part of fate is this pls?
I came here from a short about Mordred despite not knowing shit about Fate 💀🙏
Excalibur depending on what universe. Was the equivalent of the greatest demonic blade to its divine nature, they are equivalent.
Also depending on wat universe Excalibur was also made from in some form from gram.
I was wondering if you could make a video about what can UBW can copy and not. Rho Aias for example. It looks more like a magic/enegy shield rather than physical one.
From what I understand, it isn't replicating the actual shield itself, but it's concept, in turn making the Blade Works Rho Aias a Conceptual Weapon. I don't have the greatest understanding of how it all works, but from what I understand and saw said by someone is that the original shield had 7 layers of some material, don't remember what, that acted as defenses. The Rho Aias of the Blade Works took the concept of the shield and it's 7 material layers, and turned them into a 7 petalled defense that is meant to stop all projectiles, if I remember correctly. I could be completely misunderstanding this, but that's what I understand based on what I've heard and seen from others.
@@multiversal_guardian7079 What EMIYA is projecting is still Rho Aias, he's just projecting it as a Conceptual Weapon because it's better that way(also the conceptual part is mostly in regards to it's abilities not it's form). Remember that NPs can have Alteration used on them, but also Greek Weapons are shown to be weird as shit as Odysseus shows. It's also implied that it's form changed as a result of becoming an NP
@@darknessknows1235 that's what I was saying, it took the concept not the actual form
Lets go another goated video
I have a question if weapons like Excalibur and EA are that powerful due to their origins what with Excalibur being forged by the Fae from Avalon itself and EA being created before the concept of swords even existed if we took legendary weapons from like DnD who derive their power from their legends would they also stack up to weapons like Excalibur if we used the Natsu rules?
Could you perhaps do an entire video on all named phantasms and abilities? Maybe something like your don’t sleep on series
talk about the possibility of having two Gilgameshes alive at Strange Fake timeline
I was still wondering who were the first wielder of Excalibur before Artoria
The answer is quite simple, Caliburn will call you a naive, while Excalibur will give you golden amour and defeat dark queens.
The fact that only 3 seals realised Excalibur is alredy an a++rank np imagine if artoria unsealed 6 of the seals like Arthur since both of their Excaliburs work exactly the same
As soon as the video ended I remembered the very first weapon Gaea ever made. Kronos' scythe. It controls time.
Tsiah iv can you make a vídeo about the best combination or synergy with 2 servants or noble phantasm?
Learning Excalibur is an extension of the planet now makes sense the power gal between it and Caliburn way more bigger
you should make a video about kirei vs shirou in the heavens feel route (visual novel).
Can you explain todays menu for the emiya family?
its just a light hearted spin off, there is nothing to explain lol
@@JaeyXVI it is deep and deserves it own lore video
9:40 And then, over the horizon... The man destined to always have the bigger dick, Ado Edem, emerges with his sword that fucking kills Types: Slash Emperor. That one's the real deal when we talk about feats... And heights too!
Can always trust tsiah to post on things that aren't talked about (please make more shirou videos 😭)
Tsiah!!!! I love your videos! Would you consider doing a video on the True Ending tonight for Fate Stay Night/VN (Realta Nua)? Such how talking about how Shirou reaches Avalon, what he did before that and how Saber waited for him all this time. Maybe even speculate on how he broke free from Alaiya?
what do u mean break free from alaya? fate route shirou never made a contract with alaya
And also, how is Saber alive when Shirou enters Avalon? Didn't she die at the end of her route?
W now we need A vid about sabers armour
Can you do Don’t Sleep on Arthur Pendragon (Prototype?)
Hey man can you do a video of differentiating the swords that the lady of the lake made Excalibur, Galatine, and arondight, aside from their destructive power is there any unique abilities/attributes that it gives them such as like if someone holds excalibur the user will no longer age but live long.
-thank you.
Is there anything stopping a master from summoning a servant version of themselves like rin summoning ishtar. Shouldn't their bodies count as catalysts for that servant?
I think you can't normally summon a pseudo-servant in hgw
Could you do a video on the crypters or the argonauts
Hey Tsiah, I have a question. Can you make a video to discuss Alteration magecraft? So, based on what I have read so far both from the Wiki and other sources. Alterarion is a magecraft that give the caster an ability to give and change the properties and abilities to inanimate objects like what has been shown by Karmaglyph in El-Melloi Adventure. And do you think Shirou is capable of using this magecraft to give abilities and Properties to his projected items? And could he use Alteration to give conceptual powers to any of his projected weapons?
Dude Alteration is how he turns other wepons into arrows
@@TrueBladeSoul I'm afraid that's not how Shirou and EMIYA turn swords into arrows. It's been stated in the Wiki and other sources that they use their personal version of Reinforcement to manipulate the physical shape of their projected weapons. While Alteration, as far as I know, is to give an object a property or effect that it originally didn’t have. Alteration also mentioned to enable the caster to make drastic changes to substances such as turning metal into rubber, fire into ice, or concrete into mud. And since Alteration can be considered as magecraft related to creating Swords, in my opinion, I though that maybe it's possible for Shirou to learn how to use it. And considering how versatile the Unlimited Blade Works, I wonder if Shirou could use Alteration magecraft to a more Advance level like how he uses Projection and Reinforcement.
I’m pretty sure Caliburn and Excalibur is a Mandela Effect.
I have to wonder if Zouken didn't do what he did in Fate/Zero would Lancelot have still been summoned as a berserker or would another berserker have been summoned in his place?
Depends. From what I heard you can summon any servant even without a catalyst. Sakura summoned Medusa without a catalyst. However, a catalyst just improves your chances of summoning a specific servant
I thought this was about the actual swords and not Anime when I clicked on the video.😅
I just wanna know more about void shiki an shiki tona n their powers
How about a video about Siegfried and sigurd?
Hmm, Gilgamesh became a Caster as a response to Grand Caster "Solomon." So is it possible for Gilgamesh to pull off the same feats, or greater than, GOETIA? Something that surpasses what Archer Gilgamesh begun but failed to complete in Fate Stay Night?
So if excabilibur was used against arcuied, then would it just not charge up? Or would arc just tank the blast?
Could you make a video on Charlemagne? I think it would be interesting especialy his lore :D
Would Ea be stronger then excalibur if they were poured the same amount of mana into the attack itself
What about Arthur Prototype vs The Servants stay night or Apocrapha?
Can u do a video on rhongomiand vs ea?
Can make video on arjun vs karna with full power fight
What would you do if you got Isekaid or Reincarnated in Stay Night or Zero?
For fate zero i would just stay away from fuyuki since your chance of being killed are much higher compared to fsn. For fsn i would just warned bazzet about kirei betrayals/maybe reveals archer's identity to shirou early just to troll with him.
@@lordtouchme77 A very good idea.
But what would you do if you were choosen as the master of Caster?
Which Caster would you want?
@@extremeotakugamerwhen we speak from a normal grail war ,I go merlin, when a special grail war, I go with castoria.
@@flamebreaker4340 But Merlin can't be sunmoned in normal Grail Wars right?
@@extremeotakugamer I don't remember the thing about merlin can true.
Why doesnt anyone talk about the sword that killed author, excaliburn morgan crafted it in dragons fire speacially to kill the great king in one legend anyway and I believe that legend was the basis for a Tv show about merlin for some reason. Hell maybe the fact all 3 sword have similar names is why people get so confused. That and thw fact some legends say that they are all one sword weilded at different times for diffent reasons by different people
How good doyou think the armor of fafnir will be in most situations
Can take a balmung lvl arrow to the face+(b+) rank detonation, though Siegfried was heavily wounded afterwards. Karna was also said to be able to behead Siegfried if the latter got careless even for a moment. It's pretty good against....99% percent of servants?
@imranabdirafikov3847 One, I don't see how this relates to the previous topic of dragon cores vs. Galvanism. Second I'm pretty sure that the light novel said that either one could have lost their heads if they got careless, but I will have to check that.
@imranabdirafikov3847 sorry thought I was replying to someone else 😂 hence the dragon core topic
Was it revealed in the game who the six great fae are? I think its a given Oberon, Titania and Elphane are among them but who are the other 3?
Soo good😊❤
Nice topic
Hey, do you think you could make a video to clear up what happened in the whole event where I believe Gilgamesh defeat all the gods and as to what happened after and why?
What are Oberon's abilities?
Since Excalibur is A++ rank and lets say borderline S what weapons do reside in the S rank and what makes the weapon so beyond if being forged by gods or other mythological being.
As far as I know there is no S-rank the closest thing would be EX and even then that just means it can’t be measured not that it’s powerful
there is no S rank in fate. there is EX rank but EX doesnt necessarily mean its the strongest, it just means that it cant be measured by conventional means
So... To Viviam to have that many swords... Does she have UBW or GoB?
Which weapon is more powerful Excalibur or EA Swords of rupture.
Based on feats Excalibur clears it killed sefar who casually destroyed all gods and gods even stronger than Gilgamesh at that
How is Excalibur not an EX rank noble phantasm when it can kill Safar miss white giant that can solo all of the gods.
It's sealed that's why it isn't EX. Arthur Excalibur is EX in proto
In UBW, did Emiya shoot Heracles with Caliburn.
That's Caladbolg II, a modified Broken Phantasm version of Fergus's sword.
Which is more powerful rhongomyniad or Excalibur?
Excalibur
Lore aside, Excalibur still is one of most badass swords in not just anime history but the world as well.
Ea: really?
I always thought Artoria had a much deeper story and lore than most people think. Which is why shes my only 5 star at NP5 and well my name lmao Also please give me her suit from zero as a costume in FGO XD
how powerful is Lancelot's Erendite, and Mordred's blood Aruther.
If a Sword like Excalibur is always needed to kill the White Titan... Then where was Ea? Or does this mean He's Wielder is not interested in steppimg up should Excalibur not be created a timeline like LB6? Or is this suggesting that Excalibur is only stronger than Ea thanks to it drawing power from the very Breath of the Planet EXACTLY like Enkidu? But then doesn't this mean Enkidu is just as strong, if not stronger, since both Enkidu and Excalibur can both unlock the Threat to Humanity special attack when in the presence on such a Threat?
But is excalibur stronger than rhongomyniad if you can can you make a video on this explaining which one is better,their backstories,and abilities
Let’s get it
Sir nunos is the GOAT
So can I get some clarity to the lore of Gil's Ea & how does it compare to Excalibur? Could Ea even beat it?
Have you tried researching the other Weapons, Tools, and Armor of Artoria, like, how much would her Fighting Style would Change if she have her Prydwen with her, or how would her tactics would've change if she used Carnwennan, due to our own History stating that she had it with her, which it's stated that it gave her the ability to turn invisible and merge with the shadows, then there's her 3 specifically named Pieces of Armor, like Goswhit, Gwen, and Wygar. Which, Mysterious Heroin X has hers as a Hat, Scarf, and her Jacket Respectively.
Also, why not do a Research on the other Wielders and Weapons that are also named Excalibur as well, aka you could explain if there's an Excalibur that Shirou would have a much easier time Replicating.
Speaking of Shirou, there's a pert where Shirou is stated to have Golden Magic Circuits.
Speaking of Magic Circuits, is there a Math or Formula on them. I mean, it stated that the Average Amount of Magic Circuits is 20 and the Average Power Output of an Adult is 25 Units. Usually, with this, Rin, for having 40 Main and 30 Sub, her Power Output would be 82.5 Units, yet, it stated that her max is 1,000 Units, which I don't quite understand for how that's possible, or what the hell is Blue Blood: Magic Circuits and such. Same goes to Magic Cores and how Artoria has a Dragon Magic Core or how powerful is a Magic Core is, compare to Magic Circuits, as well as if it's Possible to have both Magic Core and Magic Circuits.
This also includes what's the known Maximum Amount of Magic Circuits could a Person have and what's the known Maximum Output could a Single Circuit could have if it was Developed like if they're a part of a Clan / Family of Mages.
Oh, as well as your own thoughts on the other Magic Systems in other Anime compare to the Fate Series Magic System. Like Fairy Tail having a Magic Container that was described as if like an Extra Invisible Organ within the body.
Excalibur. Strongest sword
Whats with Marduk
Doesn’t ea pull off an even better feat in fate strange fake?
Attempt 36 of asking you to do a video on white wolf's world of darkness
Thanks for this.
I was a bit confused as to if Excalibur was Caliburn reforged.
Can someone pls help me understand why gil needed to kill Ilya in ubw
because illya (or more specifically her heart) is the vessel for the grail and gilgamesh needed it to summon the grail
@@JaeyXVI yeah but he didn't had to kill her in fate route
@@fredericoferreira2707 yeah he didnt need to kill her, it was just faster that way. the reason kirei didnt kill her in fate route is probably just to mess with shirou
@@JaeyXVI makes sense man thx
BAEBAR❤
I like rhongomyniad more than excalibur.
Oh boy lb6 fairies, god I hate 95% of them
the diference is 3 letter's
Fair point
Caliburn design looks better ngl