20 People, but Only 10 Spots In The Bunker

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 сен 2024

Комментарии • 1,4 тыс.

  • @FredericoASousa
    @FredericoASousa 2 года назад +5675

    It looked like the professor was punishing the poet more than anyone else

    • @mattyryon
      @mattyryon 2 года назад +357

      He just really hates poets, that's how he lost his first girl probably lol

    • @Rizzhi16
      @Rizzhi16 2 года назад +14

      Like marvel to iron man in what if?!

    • @JustMe-qp7if
      @JustMe-qp7if 2 года назад

      😂

    • @galleo9462
      @galleo9462 2 года назад +107

      If u are trapped in a bunker with only 10 ppl and have zero entertainment you gonna start wishing u had an author or a poet to write you tall tales or storys or rhyms to keep u ocupied... like my dudes the worst teacher ever lol

    • @darklight6921
      @darklight6921 2 года назад +8

      @@galleo9462 not only that but after you get out you will be living in the stone age.

  • @victorf1736
    @victorf1736 2 года назад +2041

    I love how Hollywood consistently assumes people who excels in STEM has no inherent artistic merits.

    • @C4TC4T
      @C4TC4T 2 года назад +115

      Seriously; I’m going to school to be a zoologist but on the side I’m doing interior decorating and designing; many people are talented on both sides of the coin

    • @MadieteMakua
      @MadieteMakua 2 года назад +51

      I'm doing a Bachelor's degree in mechanical engineering, I'm a sneaker customizer on the side

    • @jdally9872
      @jdally9872 2 года назад +56

      I have 2 bachelors degrees in engineering, and I can confirm I have absolutely 0 artism

    • @GandalfOfRivia
      @GandalfOfRivia 2 года назад +30

      In other hand, people who excels in STEM assumes they are better than everyone and art is easy.

    • @organicspectroscopy7242
      @organicspectroscopy7242 2 года назад +33

      @@GandalfOfRivia Not really..

  • @mierbeuker8148
    @mierbeuker8148 2 года назад +5515

    This movie makes about as much sense as the difference between a canary.

    • @Aykes_
      @Aykes_ 2 года назад +174

      iam so confused on what this movie is

    • @Squirleypoo
      @Squirleypoo 2 года назад +45

      What is the difference between a duck?

    • @hihi-ud8sz
      @hihi-ud8sz 2 года назад +26

      What’s the difference between a lime

    • @canadapapers
      @canadapapers 2 года назад +9

      Ya. If you can make anything then what is the point.

    • @eddygci8
      @eddygci8 2 года назад +5

      Concurred

  • @KimKarniol
    @KimKarniol 2 года назад +4198

    The script was like watching the writer desperately try to justify their academic career path to themselves and failing.

    • @slevinchannel7589
      @slevinchannel7589 2 года назад +24

      9:28: Haha, its like D&D!
      Or Yugioh Season 1!!
      People just make stuff up that sounds like it makes sense,
      right? Did i get this right?

    • @bittertruth4847
      @bittertruth4847 2 года назад +14

      Yep, this statement is factually correct

    • @shikko6489
      @shikko6489 2 года назад

      Yes

    • @quinnbaygo2112
      @quinnbaygo2112 2 года назад +1

      OMG YES

    • @parapiobuin9037
      @parapiobuin9037 2 года назад +6

      Well…no matter where you go on earth, no matter how destitute or desperate, there are people there who sing, dance, tell stories, and fall in love. People don’t have time or energy for luxuries during war and famine. People fall in love and write songs in time of war and famine. Art, creation, and love are intrinsic human qualities. We don’t live without them. We just exist. Also, when everyone is given the opportunity to learn and create, you optimize all of human potential. Because there is no saying where the greatest scientist live. They might be at a slum somewhere and they might have died never learned how to read and write. And people discover and create by accident and by playing and by indulging their curiosity. There is no logic to human ingenuity. You can give people tools and you can give people access to all the knowledgeable equally and optimize human potential that way and then wait for the right accidents. Like human beings, we are also a product of accidents and chaos. Random mutations and random discoveries. It’s kind of beautiful.

  • @darthbiscuit
    @darthbiscuit 2 года назад +3705

    Humanity: "Please survive you're all that's left"
    Theater kids: "no thanks we're good"

    • @yarvewhraewlrhaewoirjaeowi5959
      @yarvewhraewlrhaewoirjaeowi5959 2 года назад +27

      philosophy

    • @yucol5661
      @yucol5661 2 года назад +33

      Reality. People only do stuff needed to live when they feel like it. How many people would go through the trouble of self sufficient, hunter gatherer life? After an apocalypse

    • @danberhe6949
      @danberhe6949 2 года назад +15

      @@yucol5661 someone with kids, thats why being infertile was important (even though the movie does an awful job at it).

    • @justawarlord
      @justawarlord 2 года назад +5

      @@yucol5661 well they are called conspiracy theorist or nut jobs but they are always prepared

    • @NoCluYT
      @NoCluYT 2 года назад +24

      @@yucol5661 most people would. when pushed to the limits people will do anything to survive. its our natural instinct

  • @catdogfan732
    @catdogfan732 2 года назад +2994

    So Petra was cheating on her boyfriend with her professor and got away with it?

    • @youAREkolokoy
      @youAREkolokoy 2 года назад +345

      Yup american/western things you know. Its normal to them,

    • @joaop4585
      @joaop4585 2 года назад +472

      She belongs to the streets

    • @b2kzangelalwayz
      @b2kzangelalwayz 2 года назад +15

      What do you mean by got away with it?

    • @joaop4585
      @joaop4585 2 года назад +324

      ​ @b2kzangelalwayz She clearly get away with cheating. Nothing bad happened to her. Her boyfriend didnt find out and her lover was so much a simp that he killed himself

    • @dnxx503
      @dnxx503 2 года назад +11

      @@youAREkolokoy not to every one

  • @harryhotfist
    @harryhotfist 2 года назад +4120

    This movie was like listening to a potato chip but from inside the bag

    • @nikmrn
      @nikmrn 2 года назад +52

      i don't get the metapher lol

    • @dubyalast3734
      @dubyalast3734 2 года назад +137

      @@nikmrn exactly

    • @harryhotfist
      @harryhotfist 2 года назад +66

      @@nikmrn you are the potato chip

    • @KingstonTiger
      @KingstonTiger 2 года назад +7

      @@harryhotfist lol-

    • @r4y09
      @r4y09 2 года назад +29

      Isn't the boy in 0:33 from spy kids lol am I the only one who noticed

  • @kunaii_cs
    @kunaii_cs 2 года назад +5984

    "James who is no longer a homosexual in this exercise." 😂

    • @Buggod21
      @Buggod21 2 года назад +8

      What you talking about you are not making sense

    • @plutotism03
      @plutotism03 2 года назад +60

      @@Buggod21 its in the story did you not hear-

    • @Buggod21
      @Buggod21 2 года назад +5

      @@plutotism03 hold on im confused I thought he wasn’t

    • @plutotism03
      @plutotism03 2 года назад +9

      @@Buggod21 oh i meant the narrator said it

    • @akarsonsingh5a838
      @akarsonsingh5a838 2 года назад +3

      I can't understand story when door open they died then how they are still talking in room what is exercise?

  • @chaoticneutralgiraffe2269
    @chaoticneutralgiraffe2269 2 года назад +1644

    When the D&D group of unfilfilled dreams get together to create a narrative that mechanics, engineer and science is useless, but poems, painting and theater is the shit that rocks..

    • @joaop4585
      @joaop4585 2 года назад +160

      Add the useless winer, homossexual with perfect genes and add a hedge fund manager with gold while the market wont exist in a apocalitic scenario

    • @saisrinivasv.d136
      @saisrinivasv.d136 2 года назад +145

      that is the thing that is bothering me, making food, painting , writing poems and singing can be learnt by anyone based on practice but being an engineer, chemist, biologist,sugeon etc cannot be masterd by simple practice but rather requires formal training and lot of effort. it seems like the director shoehorning idea of arts are better than science and emotions are more important than logic, and most mindboggling thing is that if they are willing to commit sucide and die, they could have given the bunker to the other people who are willing to live, rather than throwing them away and commiting sucide, only thing i understood from the movie is that never give leadership to idiots who are not willing to see the logical problem ahead of them and will kill everyone including themselves

    • @Moviecaps
      @Moviecaps  2 года назад +80

      Director showcased that you are not more valuable than others depending on your profession/skills, everyone is equal.

    • @joaop4585
      @joaop4585 2 года назад +50

      No disrespect, ADM. But htf a infertile carpinter gonna be equal a engineer (fertile)?

    • @joaop4585
      @joaop4585 2 года назад +22

      We are human beings and all of that. But in the end some ppl are better in some areas than others.
      You can be good in leadership and conclusive decisions and i can be on investiment areas and see if they worth the risk and the r.o.p (im working on it a few months so isnt a lie, im just not a senior lol)

  • @kylereynhart
    @kylereynhart 2 года назад +432

    This is such a dumb movie, it makes no sense, if it's a thought exercise then u have to share everything with the class outloud, so how do they secretly do things? And how can 1 persons narration suddenly decide the fate of others? Like the last kid????

    • @Agautam1
      @Agautam1 2 года назад +39

      yeah, in last exercise Petra is like, I choose the fashion designer as it boost mood etc. etc., then the guy with chemistry degree because of his perfect genes, then chooses james in the end and its like , well every life is equal so that's why I choose james, TF 😂😂😂😂

  • @deborahblackvideoediting8697
    @deborahblackvideoediting8697 2 года назад +467

    When I was in Junior High, we had an English project very similar to this. If I remember correctly, there were 16 characters in the scenario, but there was only room for 10 of them in the bunker. We were given descriptions of each of the characters (profession, personality, skills, age, health, etc.) and had to choose which 10 would get to survive in the bunker. We spent several days on the project and had to defend each of our choices - the reasons why we chose each person who lived and each person who died. I can't remember all the details, but I do remember that one of the characters was a despicable, middle-aged woman who was not only a terrible person, but who had no skills to help the group survive. However, she did have one thing going for her...she owned the bunker!

    • @boxingelfis1499
      @boxingelfis1499 2 года назад +19

      Was she the first one to be taken out?

    • @thatname7298
      @thatname7298 2 года назад +11

      I know everyone wants to ask this question... Did the group get the information about the bunker from her and kick her out?

    • @deborahblackvideoediting8697
      @deborahblackvideoediting8697 2 года назад +13

      @@boxingelfis1499 - I remember we each had to do the assignment ourselves at home, and then decide later as a group in class. I let her stay because she owned the bunker, but the group kicked her out right away!

    • @deborahblackvideoediting8697
      @deborahblackvideoediting8697 2 года назад

      @@boxingelfis1499 - Lol, yes! When I did the assignment myself at home, I let her stay because she owned the bunker. But later when we decided as a group in class, she was the first one to go!

    • @eli6797
      @eli6797 2 года назад +4

      Depends on the description of the other characters but I probably would’ve kicked her out. Peoples personalities and who they are affect all aspects of life (the reason why people love or hate their jobs is because of the way their coworkers or customers/patrons interact with them) and if I had to live in a bunker for presumably a year/years with someone who made it miserable (set aside all the bunkers amenities), I’d go out of my way to get rid of said person

  • @joshuathomas5626
    @joshuathomas5626 2 года назад +507

    This movie script sounds like someone who failed "Naked and Afraid".

  • @idc_cope
    @idc_cope 2 года назад +1411

    The carpenter had every flavor all to himself 🤣 smart man 🙌🏾

    • @yessum15
      @yessum15 2 года назад +254

      Turns out "The Carpenter" was only his nickname cause he always finds a way to lay the wood.

    • @miguelanthony5775
      @miguelanthony5775 2 года назад +24

      @@yessum15 💀💀💀💀😭😭

    • @boxingelfis1499
      @boxingelfis1499 2 года назад +19

      @@yessum15 If I was a king and you were my Court Jester.....I would not execute you.

    • @spongmongler6760
      @spongmongler6760 2 года назад +2

      'smart' as much as a turd with wings

    • @idc_cope
      @idc_cope 2 года назад +2

      @@yessum15 🤣🤣🤣🤣yess

  • @jiankaifeng9164
    @jiankaifeng9164 2 года назад +627

    Man, the script to this movie just sounds like something straight out of a Dhar Mann video

    • @Misericorde451
      @Misericorde451 2 года назад +34

      Except the ones with regret by the end of it is not the characters, but the audience for wasting time watching.

    • @sophiaredwood5825
      @sophiaredwood5825 2 года назад +1

      PLEASE

  • @wesleyvant7787
    @wesleyvant7787 2 года назад +591

    So she was cheating on her boyfriend with their teacher but is somehow the savior of them all??

    • @joaop4585
      @joaop4585 2 года назад +122

      Dumb script dumb movie

    • @dnxx503
      @dnxx503 2 года назад

      Yeh

    • @DrakeOola
      @DrakeOola 2 года назад +38

      What the hell were with the 'rigged cards' tho, Didn't the teacher come up with this exercise and write them each a role to play in it. Why did they need hidden cards for the boyfriend...

    • @biteme8822
      @biteme8822 2 года назад +1

      That's the merit of the whole movie which is a norm nowadays.

    • @yucol5661
      @yucol5661 2 года назад

      What do you mean savior? It was a CLASS

  • @arroe8386
    @arroe8386 2 года назад +433

    So the girl didn't have the best grades because she was actually smart, but because she was sleeping with the teacher

    • @darklight6921
      @darklight6921 2 года назад +25

      she knows how to get ahead in life.

    • @walterbrunswick
      @walterbrunswick 2 года назад

      @@darklight6921 good one

    • @tias2705
      @tias2705 2 года назад +9

      She's actually smart, just also sleeping with the professor. If she wasn't smart, the class wouldn't respect her enough to let her pick survivors and would question how she does well enough to beat them all if her participation in class is only mediocre. She also outsmarts the professor. I think their attraction was probably intellectual and physical.

    • @sugarkane1571
      @sugarkane1571 2 года назад +4

      If she wasn’t smart she wouldn’t be sleeping with the teacher.

    • @Chronically_ChiII
      @Chronically_ChiII 2 года назад +10

      @@tias2705More like she wasn't smart, and on top of that the whole class is filled with idiots, or else they would have criticized the glaring flaws with how the thought experiment was set up.

  • @estrellassoliloquies
    @estrellassoliloquies 2 года назад +93

    Petra, who has been pretending to be a saint all along, turned out to be a cheater, and doesn't even seem guilty of it... I would be mad if this film was sensible.

  • @Untenableify
    @Untenableify 2 года назад +283

    "My man poet did not have enough" ahahaha

    • @akshub
      @akshub 2 года назад +2

      Nothing is enough for the poet

  • @MinhNguyen-cs1ll
    @MinhNguyen-cs1ll 2 года назад +95

    Philosphy proffesor abuses his teaching position, and invokes petty thought experiments to get with his student.

    • @Chronically_ChiII
      @Chronically_ChiII 2 года назад +4

      While students cheats with her boyfriend with no remorse.

    • @elliottstokes3917
      @elliottstokes3917 2 года назад

      Yea the second he threatened to lower another pupils grade for the blind walking out everyone should of been like “welp he’s gonna be fired in the morning and this won’t matter, you guys wanna go to Burger King?”

  • @OldSchoolingg
    @OldSchoolingg 2 года назад +576

    Unique I guess? Would’ve been better if these exercises were virtual reality, and felt real. And if they didn’t continue they would fail the class and die? Raise the stakes? Seemed so tense for no reason and knowing they’re just in a classroom perfectly safe with no reason to care about what happened about the bunker reality

    • @araw_buwan
      @araw_buwan 2 года назад +80

      I thought about why this movie fell short and you said it perfectly. There were no stakes, no danger and no consequence if they busted the thought experiments. The closest potential consequence they had was a failing grade, which is vague and has no bearing on what the characters will do after the movie's events end. And what the hell was the purpose of having the movie take place in Jakarta? This movie could've happened literally anywhere

    • @beerenmusli8220
      @beerenmusli8220 2 года назад +3

      Did you ever play a role playing game your self?

    • @DrakeOola
      @DrakeOola 2 года назад +50

      @@araw_buwan Seems more like the actors wanted to take a free vacation so they went to a nice tropical location, tried to use their fame to have the trip covered for free then when they were denied a free pass they decided to film a movie at the last second to recoup the costs. Then they just used the footage from their vacation, added a couple cgi explosives and tried to make a story out of whatever they filmed. One of their friends had access to a classroom so they decided to make it 'a thought experiment'. All just an unplanned, last minute effort. Only way this even remotely makes sense as a movie... 💀

    • @FalconCleancut
      @FalconCleancut 2 года назад +1

      so basically squid games?😅

    • @OldSchoolingg
      @OldSchoolingg 2 года назад +1

      @@FalconCleancut I’ve never seen it. But from what I’ve heard it’s what everyone’s talking about. And what I said is like the squid game, the show doesn’t sound original at all.

  • @PhaserFelix
    @PhaserFelix 2 года назад +250

    This movie lost my interest on when the teacher said, I will lower your boyfriend grade.
    Only students in movies would stay silent during that.
    I myself would instantly go to the prinicipal, and I know my friends in the class if not the whole class that I had would follow. Because my class was like a family, tho I can't even imagine any teacher act like that irl anyway.

    • @biteme8822
      @biteme8822 2 года назад +18

      you forgot she cheated with the professor herself so such threat meant differently as you suggested.

    • @Suisfonia
      @Suisfonia 2 года назад +7

      Umm, if you think teachers haven't acted this way or similar, then you don't pay much attention to news related to schools do ya? A teacher here in Nevada was recently fired for threatening to lower a students grade if he didn't show her his you know what (teacher was dumb enough to think that the zoom sessions weren't recorded), and sadly that wasn't an isolated incident. There were reports of this going on in Chicago, Detroit, also in Austin, LA, mainly cities or states where the teachers union is *strong* Hell the teacher here was on PAID LEAVE from October of 2020 up until July 2021, when the parents finally got the teacher fired (though we suspect she wasn't)

    • @sophiaredwood5825
      @sophiaredwood5825 2 года назад

      Thought the exact same thing

    • @ko-Daegu
      @ko-Daegu 2 года назад +2

      @@Suisfonia ok they act he never said they don’t
      It he said students reaction is unreal

    • @byrddii3516
      @byrddii3516 2 года назад

      It's because she was sleeping with him that she didn't go straight to the principal

  • @cela9852
    @cela9852 2 года назад +800

    I don't why I laughed so hard after the shock of the published poet being shot wore off. Like damn, talk about undervaluing someone's work😂😂😂

    • @jdally9872
      @jdally9872 2 года назад +27

      lmao same, I still don't know why it was so funny when he got shot the 2nd time. He never had a chance

    • @boxingelfis1499
      @boxingelfis1499 2 года назад +11

      Jokes on them, he could have told the greatest tales of their adventures and they'd become legendary.

    • @slevinchannel7589
      @slevinchannel7589 2 года назад

      WEIRD CLASS

    • @miloradowicz
      @miloradowicz 2 года назад +5

      It's kinda ironic that the one shooting the poet teaches philosophy for a living himself.

    • @KabbalahSherry
      @KabbalahSherry 2 года назад +2

      @@boxingelfis1499 - Facts though 🤷🏻‍♀️😏💯

  • @rekkou1880
    @rekkou1880 2 года назад +270

    The moral of the story is that, group choice won't matter if the one in power is selfish. So you might as well pick the choice that gives the biggest middle finger.

    • @DrakeOola
      @DrakeOola 2 года назад +40

      There was no moral of the story. The story was stupid. The end.

    • @Khajitxi
      @Khajitxi 2 года назад +21

      @@DrakeOola yeah. You’d think they could have tried to just guess the password or let the engineer/electrician reverse engineer how to open the door. If your bunker is good enough to survive the end of civilization then it should hopefully be well designed enough to have an emergency exit method or documentation.

    • @slevinchannel7589
      @slevinchannel7589 2 года назад +2

      9:28: Haha, its like D&D!
      Or Yugioh Season 1!!
      People just make stuff up that sounds like it makes sense,
      right? Did i get this right?

    • @regil93
      @regil93 2 года назад +4

      The moral of the story is that if you want good grades you better sleep with your professors.

    • @norfcarolinadude8179
      @norfcarolinadude8179 2 года назад

      If the stakes were higher for the characters it would've been better. Nothing happens if they die so they just choose the people that won't help survive to have fun. If there were stakes other than a bad grade then the people that could help survive would be chosen instead of the people that have no real value other than entertainment.

  • @ToxicSunrise132
    @ToxicSunrise132 2 года назад +412

    Honestly, if it wasn't tainted by the professor letting his personal feelings run rampant (Seriously, what does he have against poets?!) I think that would have been a fascinating thought exercise.

    • @slevinchannel7589
      @slevinchannel7589 2 года назад +5

      9:28: Haha, its like D&D!
      Or Yugioh Season 1!!
      People just make stuff up that sounds like it makes sense,
      right? Did i get this right?

    • @ShaggyRogers1
      @ShaggyRogers1 2 года назад +12

      It doesn't really make sense as a thought exercise either though. Something like this would inevitably have people discussing things outside of the "group" and everyone having imperfect information. You literally can't do something secretively and plan etc when you literally have to say it out loud so everyone hears. People never make decisions alone, and a classroom "thought exercise" would never be able to replicate the actual starting scenario correctly. This plot is also filled with "my narration says this happens because it fits what I want to have happened" instead of actual logical cause and effect. Professor locked out? Suddenly he has the only exit code to hold the group hostage even though that was never mentioned until literally that moment. Next sim attempt they literally try to metagame and claim that they know the code due to the previous failure(?????) and then all of a sudden this time there wasn't any bombs and the professor has been living nearby ready to shoot them on exit. This movie's writing is straight out of a smoke filled liberal arts college dorm that somehow just had to find a way to shoehorn a creepy sexual jealous overtone for some reason.

    • @sugarkane1571
      @sugarkane1571 2 года назад +2

      A poet killed my parents once… Now I will purge all poets from the future…

    • @miloradowicz
      @miloradowicz 2 года назад +5

      @@ShaggyRogers1 the idea of this exercise is to figure out your own values and priorities. As you go through the list of participants you are going to surround yourself with, you have to weigh each of them against another, and decide which traits are importance to you and why. The experiment doesn't have any other purpose or value, and it's not supposed to be a simulation of group dynamics or survival in a post-apocalyptic scenario.
      That's why I think the movie fell flat, its conclusion was dictated by nothing but the students being tired and pissed off at the professor. It' was not mentioned in the recap, but in the movie that star-girl made a show of changing their sitting arrangements, so that all the students ended up on one side, and the professor on the other. It wasn't we, the survivors, against them, the rejects, anymore. It was a big "f you" to the old dude. The whole movie was nothing but a long and boring break up scene between the girl and the old dude, with jealousy fits thrown in here and there.

  • @dodo2829
    @dodo2829 2 года назад +276

    This movie makes sense as much as my theories.

  • @informationyes
    @informationyes 2 года назад +44

    Imagine creating a thought experiment where you give your self cheat codes

  • @rudyavila1825
    @rudyavila1825 2 года назад +5

    Funny how they mentioned Plato's allegory of the cave but didn't mention the fact that Plato was no fan of artists. In his Republic he had all artists kicked out.

  • @david4rancibia34
    @david4rancibia34 2 года назад +255

    so acording to this movie, all homosexuals can get along and fall in love with each other, that's hilarious
    also, give one of the spots to a guy only because he's gay too? come on

    • @amagostartdatbigfirekickba9865
      @amagostartdatbigfirekickba9865 2 года назад +79

      "Sorry you can't come along, you are useless."
      "But I like men's butts."
      "Well, why didn't you say so? Come on in lmao!"
      pepega movie

    • @roblo8188
      @roblo8188 2 года назад +8

      FR it doesn't work that way

    • @Dance_Party
      @Dance_Party 2 года назад +17

      Imagine the movie went, yo im straight and i wont have a partner, so they get a random woman into the group just so the guy can be satisfied. It’s so bad lol.

    • @bradwhite5884
      @bradwhite5884 2 года назад +4

      @@Dance_Party Also, when it comes to repopulating the world, we need someone to satisfy with for that to happen

    • @pieru
      @pieru 2 года назад

      @@bradwhite5884 speak ingles, what the fuck is "satisfying with"?

  • @ellie_sarabellum
    @ellie_sarabellum 2 года назад +41

    This movie can be seen as a philosophical debate to the question "what is necessary for survival?", or as a rant by a Professor jealous that the student he slept with refuses to break up with her boyfriend and is trying to engrain the idea that he has more value than him.

    • @_ethan_locke_
      @_ethan_locke_ Год назад

      I think the movie is a combination of both of those concepts. The teacher believes because he has a job and financial stability (i.e. the exit code) he should have more value then a kid who lacks intelligence and financial stability (i.e. a florist). However, during the third thought experiment, she proves that the kids who lacked value would live happily together, and at the end of the day, that is all that really matters. The teacher cant accept this, because he believes value is more important then happiness (in order to preserve the human race). During the final scene, the teacher kills himself, because he cant accept that "value" is ultimately meaningless in comparison to "happiness".

  • @potato_demon
    @potato_demon 2 года назад +88

    the zoologist: blogs for peta
    welp she not going in the bunker

  • @menace8880
    @menace8880 2 года назад +45

    Well glad I saved myself some time by watching this instead of the movie

  • @ducknorris233
    @ducknorris233 2 года назад +35

    I had a teacher in middle school that did an exercise where everyone in the class was stranded on a life raft and then people were slowly voted off. As a kid it was very fun but it caused a problem with parents not wanting the schools to teach morality.

  • @gburyhockey9
    @gburyhockey9 2 года назад +28

    this is not a thought experiment, but a hypothetical situation. a thought experiment is something like schrödinger’s cat or the ship of theseus. a thought experiment has two distinctly different solutions to the same situation. the answer to this hypothetical is clear, you select those with the skills and profession that give the most benefit of survival, as the goal of this hypothetical situation is purely survival. the professor said it himself that they don’t have enough experience to find food, build shelter, irrigate water. instead these kids are happy dying of starvation while listening to music and looking at art.

  • @jcdenton1635
    @jcdenton1635 2 года назад +16

    1:03 Fun fact. Those towers are not cgi fantasy, but a real temple complex called Sewu built by Javanese Buddhists in the 8th century. Beautiful landmark.

    • @itoxotaxatix
      @itoxotaxatix 2 года назад +2

      Actually the towering temple is candi Prambanan not Sewu. But some of the scene did on the candi sewu, and some other in candi Plaosan. So it's some kind of mashup of 3 temple complex

  • @DavidAnderson-ub4nq
    @DavidAnderson-ub4nq 2 года назад +40

    "soldier with perfect memory remembers the code from last ineration" thought experiment about reincarnation then. and if it was humans last chance for survival would it be so bad for the homosexual to reproduce?

    • @amagostartdatbigfirekickba9865
      @amagostartdatbigfirekickba9865 2 года назад +23

      Right? The line: "Soldier with perfect memory remembers the code from last iteration." is immediately followed by "James who is no longer a homosexual in this exercise." like wtf

  • @kronoso_o8042
    @kronoso_o8042 2 года назад +70

    If the previous simulations had unique conditions, even the bunker location changes then why does the exit code not change? And why do the characters retain memory and experience from previous Sims?

    • @Chronically_ChiII
      @Chronically_ChiII 2 года назад +22

      Why did they accept a person just because they're gay?
      Why did anyone fund this movie?
      So many questions.

    • @ko-Daegu
      @ko-Daegu 2 года назад +6

      @@Chronically_ChiII this whole thing is so shity

    • @HmfcAK
      @HmfcAK 2 года назад +5

      @@Chronically_ChiII Right?! Like if they were voting out infertile women, then why not vote out the gays, since he wouldn't have sex with a woman

    • @miloradowicz
      @miloradowicz 2 года назад +8

      @@HmfcAK a gay man still can impregnate a woman, just as a gay woman can conceive with a man. What makes no sense however was that they alowed gay people to not participate in the repopulation effort. Personal preferences and freedoms give way to necessity when you are the last humans alive.

    • @SoldMySoul45
      @SoldMySoul45 2 года назад +1

      @@miloradowicz Not in my world it doesn’t. I’m gay, I don’t give a damn if it’s me and a man alone in the world as the last humans. Not having sex with him.

  • @oceso
    @oceso 2 года назад +15

    basically they are saying that people of art are worth more and are the only ones who can feels joy because they can afford to waste all of their time on useless dogshit activities and pretend like it has value.

    • @begreater226
      @begreater226 2 года назад +3

      Yeah. Typical modern one dimensional view. One can be a electrician and play music. But that's the superiority complex of many people in academia that study stuff like literature, politics and philosophy etc.

    • @biteme8822
      @biteme8822 2 года назад +1

      specifically they chose to die after surviving the apocalypse. Thought?

  • @zachf748
    @zachf748 2 года назад +26

    The characters actions in the thought exercises are just so ludicrous… Makes no sense.

    • @slevinchannel7589
      @slevinchannel7589 2 года назад +1

      9:28: Haha, its like D&D!
      Or Yugioh Season 1!!
      People just make stuff up that sounds like it makes sense,
      right? Did i get this right?

  • @Peter.H___
    @Peter.H___ 2 года назад +7

    It’s sad that people like Petra actually exist. I hope they’re able to change and become better people

    • @nikosoa
      @nikosoa 2 года назад +1

      Love how all blame immediately goes to her and not the teacher fucking his student and fudging the grades. Is it that hard to hold men accountable ?

  • @chris_louis
    @chris_louis 2 года назад +15

    Petra's affair with zimit made it from bad to worse...at the beginning it was good...felt like a mind game, then it became boring and the affair made it worse.

  • @Blackwater_House
    @Blackwater_House 2 года назад +78

    I was one of 40 Survivalists who participated in a University “Survival Exercise” based on Statistical Probabilities and Historical Incidents. At the end of the Activity, based on Historical Lessons and Statistical Probabilities I was the Only Survivor.

    • @roblo8188
      @roblo8188 2 года назад +15

      cool story bro. you should make a script and own the rights to it

    • @ampoo1451
      @ampoo1451 2 года назад

      ....

    • @soda989
      @soda989 2 года назад +6

      I’ll take *things that never happened* for $500, Alex 😂

    • @pvthudson5069
      @pvthudson5069 2 года назад

      I'll give you 12 cents for 85% of the project

    • @OnPointFirearms
      @OnPointFirearms 2 года назад

      *DeVry University.

  • @richcymru3976
    @richcymru3976 2 года назад +4

    This movie was way ahead of its time, the most 2021 movie ever! A fashion designer getting a spot in the bunker because can make you feel more confident over an electrician.

    • @Chronically_ChiII
      @Chronically_ChiII 2 года назад +4

      How your clothes look will be irrelevant when the light malfunction...
      then you die.

  • @walidank2979
    @walidank2979 2 года назад +33

    It's amazing how they only seem to choose pleasure for short-term and ignore all the long-term decision repopulating the planet granted that's are the only people alive at that point but leave it to some girl to pick all of the socially defective people that would not contribute in a meaningful way of sustaining life so far as entertaining life for a short while

    • @parjai97
      @parjai97 2 года назад +3

      And ending it all.

    • @phastinemoon
      @phastinemoon 2 года назад +2

      No offense, but only ten people probably means long-term survival isn’t really on the table (especially not when, in this scenario, the cause of destruction is a nuclear apocalypse - even if you outlast the initial strike for a year, radiation affects EVERYTHING, and you probably won’t have much resources to rebuild ALL of society after that. At most, you’ll have a generation, maybe two if the kids reproduce REALLY young, and even then…)

    • @walidank2979
      @walidank2979 2 года назад +1

      @@phastinemoon most likely that would be the case but it still shows you the headspace the people were in was contradictive for better circumstances

  • @shottgum7899
    @shottgum7899 2 года назад +22

    Zimit is kinda the worst fake philosophy professor

  • @oetaurqo1133
    @oetaurqo1133 2 года назад +3

    "what a wet fucking fart" this movie is. holy fuck

  • @nopenope6151
    @nopenope6151 2 года назад +42

    professor: "he is too good for you" to the girl that cheats on her boyfriend with him just cause she has excellent grades in HIS class,
    yea i kinda doubt that, i think he is too good for her

  • @yessum15
    @yessum15 2 года назад +16

    This movie had a powerful message everyone here is overlooking. The moral is:
    *IF YOU'RE GOING TO STUDY ABROAD, MAKE SURE THE SCHOOL YOU APPLY TO IS ACTUALLY ACCREDITED*
    Accreditation status can be verified though the US Dept of Education or the Council for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA). This will ensure that you are taught legitimate coursework by a valid licensed university professor and earn credits that will be accepted by other respected academic institutions and can be applied towards earning a degree that future employers will recognize.
    Failing to do so might land you in the dire straights depicted in this film: earning worthless fake diploma mill credits by forcing yourself to humor the incoherent ramblings of a (presumably) recovering alcoholic expatriate at the Jakarta campus of Trump University while enduring nightly sessions of getting you booty blown out by this same deadbeat dad who fled his job as an Uber driver in the United States in order to avoid paying child support.
    Trust me kids, there's a better way.

  • @miranda13c
    @miranda13c 2 года назад +6

    Puck’s brother from Glee, Spy Kid, Ginny Weasley, what a wide variety of cast.

  • @holysauce4982
    @holysauce4982 2 года назад +7

    The logic forgot about gravity and flew away

  • @olgamadura5570
    @olgamadura5570 2 года назад +7

    We had our English teacher run this experiment for us. Though we wrote our own cards I think and then picked one randomly. He also was he bunker builder but in the second one was also a psychopath.
    It was a cool lesson for sure and he played us the movie on the next lesson. I think that made the movie much more enjoyable - we already went through that.
    And no, our teacher wasn't having an affair with anyone (as far as I'm aware, I hope not, we were like 14).

  • @xcxlol1963
    @xcxlol1963 2 года назад +4

    Clearly a total waste of 12:04 minutes. Didn't understand a thing and got even more confused🥲

  • @Kim_Imyoung
    @Kim_Imyoung 2 года назад +3

    This was more confusing than the math test that we just had yesterday.

  • @KabbalahSherry
    @KabbalahSherry 2 года назад +2

    "Petra refuses to participate, but Simmons (teacher) threatens to lower her boyfriend's grade if she does not."
    WTF?!?! 🤷🏻‍♀️🤣 LMAOO

  • @LorenzoC36
    @LorenzoC36 2 года назад +4

    Imagine if intelligence mattered more than it does we wouldn't have tiktok. What a wonderful world.

  • @willia451
    @willia451 2 года назад +2

    So Petra pumped and dumped the teacher? James. Run. Run now!!

  • @safuwanfauzi5014
    @safuwanfauzi5014 2 года назад +8

    Cool, student get traditional Javanese building class with craving and Javanese roof style, Some Indonesian schools are very beautiful with local architecture I saw in Bali, the school gate used "candI Bentar". 2 ancient temple in Java Indonesia Candi Mendut and Prambanan, other top 10 like Candi Sewu, Candi Plaosan, Candi Pawon, Candi Penataran, Candi Jawi, Candi Ratu Boko, Candi Kalasan, Candi Sambisari, Candi Arjuna, Candi Sari, Candi Lumbung and thousand more in Java, Bali, Sumatra and Borneo(not included in peninsular Malaysia and Southernmost Thailand Candi Lembah bujang, Candi Yaring Pattani and Srivijayan temple of "Wat Kaeo in Chaiya, Surat Thani", part of empire In past)

  • @MustafaKhan-jz4rp
    @MustafaKhan-jz4rp 2 года назад +2

    My man zimmit tried to Stop them from doing suicide by threatening to shoot them😭 yeah that's some real philosophical Shit right there

  • @kyleellis9177
    @kyleellis9177 2 года назад +4

    Threatens to lower boyfriends grade... Go to Dean of School and he's fired.
    He immedialy goes and gets a gun and shoots someone for his spot. Someone in his class would have realized this is a creepy power move and gone for another teacher/Dean. This TTeacher has no job going forward.

    • @masonthunkwell9786
      @masonthunkwell9786 2 года назад

      The movie feels like it could have been an episode of It's Always Sunny in Philedalphia.

    • @kyleellis9177
      @kyleellis9177 2 года назад

      @@masonthunkwell9786 Teacher should have gone the role of being the bases AI for the exercise. So he has a reason to keep forcing things to go ccording to program.

  • @Shiirow
    @Shiirow 2 года назад +2

    20 people, 10 bunker spots. How do we solve this.
    1 gun, 10 bullets, 2d6. lowest roll "loses".

  • @Jaspieces
    @Jaspieces 2 года назад +8

    Why am i expecting ginny saying she's a wizard. 😂😂😂

  • @technetium9653
    @technetium9653 2 года назад +10

    Here's the problem right, every time they're in a scenario I think to myself that they could metagame, they know teacher's an absolute piece of shit, and since it's a thought experiment nothing is actually happening

    • @Chronically_ChiII
      @Chronically_ChiII 2 года назад +4

      Yeah, you should not take this movie seriously.
      They accept the person with a bag of gold and the gay for being gay.
      Petra is right about one thing, their worth is all the same meaning that they are all equally worthless, including the writer and the person who funded this crap.

  • @followertheleader
    @followertheleader 2 года назад +18

    The professor would have been the first to go for simply taking the poet's life. I don't trust murderers. Also having a bs code to make sure you are chosen is dumb.

    • @edithagbaji1567
      @edithagbaji1567 2 года назад

      True. I thought so similarly. It would make sense that the group collectively decide to get rid of the proffessor as he's a murder and killed the poet wthout consulting with the group first. As he can't be trusted and acts selfishlessly, I doubt he'd be able to survive in a group for a year.

    • @kronoso_o8042
      @kronoso_o8042 2 года назад +3

      An electrical engineer or an electronic engineer can break the door controls eventually. But if the situation is happening again for the first time, why do they think the exit code will be the same?

    • @chuckchuk5157
      @chuckchuk5157 2 года назад

      @@kronoso_o8042 that's the biggest plot hole.

  • @MrMrkman98
    @MrMrkman98 2 года назад +1

    The script writer is just some student who failed their philosophy 101 class trying to justify their idiocy.

  • @RyanCooper101
    @RyanCooper101 2 года назад +16

    Bullshit they could've forced the code.
    4 characters, 12 possible choices, repeated characters would be 20736 attempts
    5hours 45mins at 1 attempt a second, double if each attempt takes 2 seconds.
    Soldier with perfect memory can do the button input
    Bam, shitty made up scenario solved 1st try , movie ends at 1st scenario, professor eats shit xd

    • @florencefiancee
      @florencefiancee 2 года назад

      What do you mean by 12 choices? Aren't there 10 choices from 0-9? There are 5,040 combinations of four numbers when numbers are used only once. And repeated numbers are 10.000. Or did you calculate in the * and #?

    • @RyanCooper101
      @RyanCooper101 2 года назад

      @@florencefiancee I did consider * and #, assuming you can use them in the code

  • @crabbygeuino1310
    @crabbygeuino1310 2 года назад +1

    Wow, the soldier has such a great memory that they can remember codes from OTHER thought exercises AFTER dying

  • @garethHK808
    @garethHK808 2 года назад +6

    The last part is James leaves her! He has an affair with the military girl! THE END

  • @Destinyirus278
    @Destinyirus278 3 месяца назад +1

    When u got a degree in philosophy & you gotta make it seem like you learned something so u write this script 😂

  • @kezziahvalentino2450
    @kezziahvalentino2450 2 года назад +4

    People who took this movie seriously are gonna be the downfall of humanity

  • @kashv.k2797
    @kashv.k2797 Год назад +2

    Moral of the story: don't be a Published Poet.

  • @thekeester9632
    @thekeester9632 2 года назад +5

    Thank you for the summary. This movie was stupid on so many levels.

  • @CherrySplit
    @CherrySplit 2 года назад +1

    When the poet died for the second time I died laughing

  • @justcat6042
    @justcat6042 2 года назад +1

    This movie based on real story guys
    Jessica and Mr. Wilson. But it was the Chemistry Professor. And Jessica is the Opera singer in real life
    "Apple Bottom Jeans, Boots with the furrr"

  • @antondelacruz9362
    @antondelacruz9362 2 года назад +3

    Expectation: *escape mundane life to watch fantastic things in a movie*
    Actual movie: *mundane people talk about fantastic things in their imagination*

  • @Petaurista13
    @Petaurista13 2 года назад +1

    Fun fact about the beginning: on Polish universities there's 2--way 15 minutes rule. You can join class late if it's less than 15 minutes (some exams are exceptions) no matter if you've informed about it b4. Also students are obligated to wait for professor for 15 minutes after beginning (unless they were informed lesson is canceled). After 15 minutes and no sign from professor everybody can just make list of present students (usually left in Dean's office or simply lying near class) and go home.
    It's practiced to allow longer period if somebody inform he's late but generally you can't make it shorter unless you have valid reason for student not being able to join in middle

    • @Ronkyort0dox
      @Ronkyort0dox 2 года назад +1

      The Academic 15' is an international practice

  • @akshatghoshal6098
    @akshatghoshal6098 2 года назад +7

    how tf does someone die of coconuts in a thought experiment. Like wtf?

  • @Petaurista13
    @Petaurista13 2 года назад +1

    This exercise shows nothing but why many experts oppose experiment author participating in experiment. Teacher continuously rigs experiment in way he think it would go to the point that he breaks RP when he feels his bs being threatened.

    • @Petaurista13
      @Petaurista13 2 года назад

      skipping fact that Teacher is excluded from every lesson about ethics and morality due to violation of ethics code of own profession. At least 3 times

  • @stringdoll50
    @stringdoll50 2 года назад +5

    yea but unrealistic
    The foundation of human is collaboration , so if A is lacking Hunting skills but know about Water filtration technique + B is lacking water but have great Hunting skills
    Both of them can't make out alive if not collaborate with each others that is the fundamental of why Human is on top of the world right now
    Emotion and "creative" are useful and needed but not without a basic foundation like above, you can't be happy if you don't have food to eat
    The movie assume the theory where the bunker has everything ,and it makes us to think they live "happily" and "fullest" but in reality they didn't
    live to fullest doesn't mean just live to enjoy, live is not enjoyable if you don't try your hardest

    • @phastinemoon
      @phastinemoon 2 года назад

      But that last year was all they had. In this setup, you’re just straight up not going to make it any longer than you have the bunker.

  • @_ethan_locke_
    @_ethan_locke_ Год назад +2

    My man poet didn't have enough💀

  • @VaibhavShewale
    @VaibhavShewale 2 года назад +5

    well they all have good imagination skills to imagine each others skills and what exactly the environment is without even seeing a photo or something

  • @jasonabbott4210
    @jasonabbott4210 2 года назад

    In my opinion this movie is better than most of the recycled garbage Hollywood is churning out today. Even if the movie is not perfect, it's original and takes risks. That takes courage and guts, something that corporate Hollywood sorely lacks. Finally a more cerebral film for thinking people. Thanks for the creativity.

  • @wilfredwayne7139
    @wilfredwayne7139 2 года назад +4

    That's just like a question we had for our psychology test where of course all the gays, old people and people with no skills were left outside to die by me. The twist was you needed to let in a murderer because he had the key whereas my response was to murder him and take it. I take survival very seriously.

  • @shivkumarsarkar4014
    @shivkumarsarkar4014 2 года назад

    The zoologist blogs for PETA! SPILLED MY DRINK instantly

  • @tolgatanriverdi4143
    @tolgatanriverdi4143 2 года назад +9

    Man i watched the movie with my class. But still i dont understand the ending

  • @nunyanunya4147
    @nunyanunya4147 2 года назад +2

    whats with the failed logic ov the perfect memory soldier who remembers things from alternet realities

  • @rockmyworldmusic
    @rockmyworldmusic 2 года назад +60

    This was a cool movie. Great recap as always. Do you do tutorials or have a course in video editing? Seriously, I would pay to learn these skills.

    • @Teapro324
      @Teapro324 2 года назад +2

      Skill share..

    • @User61918
      @User61918 2 года назад +16

      nigga all he does is say the plot over clips of the movie

    • @User61918
      @User61918 2 года назад +3

      jus create your summary, record you saying it, then add clips of the movie that go with each scene in your summary

    • @Chronically_ChiII
      @Chronically_ChiII 2 года назад +9

      Cool movie? This movie is a brain tumor that thinks it understands philosophy

    • @aybaws
      @aybaws 2 года назад +1

      Plenty of free RUclips tutorials to learn this style of editing

  • @SangAyie
    @SangAyie 2 года назад +1

    We know that u need
    -a farmer
    -a soldier
    -a merchant
    -an artist
    To run the world.

  • @marshalapex9792
    @marshalapex9792 2 года назад +4

    I have a solution , 5 girls 5 boys will be chosen, girls and boys get separated and fight to the death to those who don't want to fight can choose to not but they cannot change their mind ,most knowledge and academic qualifications are useless without proper tools and other services.

    • @User61918
      @User61918 2 года назад +2

      nigga if everyone fights to the death the survivors prolly gon be too fucked up mentally from it or physically too or will die from untreated wounds cus they have no doctor m

  • @asillypinecone2181
    @asillypinecone2181 2 года назад +1

    My teacher: cheaters never prosper
    This movie: 👁👄👁

  • @TheNin-Jedi
    @TheNin-Jedi 2 года назад +4

    This movie would have been so much better if after the first thought experiment the teacher reveals that its real. Skip to the island which they're already on. and bam. Other than that. Kind of weird and it feels like the movie maker wanted to make a movie about surviving in a bunker but couldn't decide on a scenario for the movie so he just made it a thought experiment.
    I don't know if I should be disappointed or praising the writers.

  • @azur3809
    @azur3809 2 года назад +1

    This sentence makes as much sense as my movie

  • @VoiceOfAnimals4.0554
    @VoiceOfAnimals4.0554 2 года назад +1

    stop thinking. that's all. finish. you're welcome

  • @david4rancibia34
    @david4rancibia34 2 года назад +6

    i don't know who's worst, the sociopath teacher or the cheating hypocritic girlfriend

    • @yessum15
      @yessum15 2 года назад +2

      Lemme help you out: it's the teacher.
      Cheating at this stage in life isn't really that big a deal. Sleeping with your students is pretty serious.
      Plus the boyfriend seemed like a bit of a doofus.

  • @teacuptoe2143
    @teacuptoe2143 2 года назад

    JENNA MARBLES AND JULIEN SOLOMITA PLAYED THIS ON THEIR PODCAST!! They called it a game and called it Nuclear Winter

  • @m.isiyam8619
    @m.isiyam8619 2 года назад +3

    So in short the girl is a cheater and the teacher commited suicide🤷😂

  • @L3THALXFOX
    @L3THALXFOX 2 года назад +1

    just shows how immature these seniors are and proves there obviously not ready for the world

  • @louisp.3332
    @louisp.3332 2 года назад +4

    Yeah, ok, even after the recap I still don’t have the foggiest idea what he is talking about or what this movie is about!

    • @NoName-xx9zd
      @NoName-xx9zd 2 года назад +2

      Don't worry, the movie makes no sense at all. Thought experiments do not work like this. You cannot hide information and then say wrong decision you all die.

    • @louisp.3332
      @louisp.3332 2 года назад

      @@NoName-xx9zd In addition, MOVIES do not work like that either lol

  • @RealKevinOnYouTube
    @RealKevinOnYouTube 3 месяца назад

    they just played 3 DnD one-shot sessions back to back during class

  • @Titan-qc1og
    @Titan-qc1og 2 года назад +4

    He just kept killing the poet man wtf

  • @si44ll26
    @si44ll26 2 года назад +1

    Petra chose based on emotions not logic at all. She will kill humanity if this was real.

  • @InvasionAnimation
    @InvasionAnimation 2 года назад +3

    I remember this movie being crap, but I need to know the knows from this for sure.