If u have ever listened to kiko solo albums ud know he's on an other lv to Marty and Chris. Chris brodrick is technically unbelievable but sloppy too and has awful tone Marty is an exotic player with accute picking KIKO is all the above minus the flaws
he definately has a talent for this. plus too there are really alot of obscure unknown guitarists out there right now that are really good b/c of RUclips etc.
Chris just got high score on guitar hero, he hit all the right buttons at exactly the right time. Kiko's playing it like he's one of the characters on guitar hero. Marty IS the guitar hero
Marty’s is dripping with feel but of course he’s the creator of it. That being said, I’m sure if you had a vid of Marty playing a Chris Poland solo you’d also have to give it to the originator.
I love how Chris played it absolutely perfectly note for note and yet still didn't sound like Marty. Marty Friedman just actually has such a unique tone that just cannot be replicated
Yes, but Chris was as close as humanly possible. Loureiro completely fucked up this solo. I'm a musician I was taught one thing: when you play your shit, do whatever the hell you want. HOWEVER, when you play someone's piece, play it CORRECTLY.
@@dehypnotizerz Who taught you this probably never created an original song in their life, only copied and played covers or most probably you didn't understand what they meant lol. First "i'm a musician" trying to give any credit to your comment is stupid, most people here are probably musicians as well and KIKO is a better musician than us all, so you're trying to use an idiotic credibility. Second, there are two types of current band members playing former members pieces: the ones that try to copy and the ones that try to make it their own, as seen above with Chris and Kiko respectively. Nothing wrong with trying to play it perfectly, although that's an impossible task not even Marty plays his solos perfectly and of course, absolutely nothing wrong on changing it a bit. In fact, guitarists that don't copy but infuse their style into other's solo usually are the BEST and MOST CREATIVE players. That's why Kiko gave us the best albums since Friedman's era in my and most of the fans and critics opinion. So if you want to listen to the album solos GO LISTEN TO THE ALBUM! Live shows are supposed to be different, music is passion, is art, the best players put their feelings into their music and if you were a good musician you would know that. Bad musicians copy, good ones BREATHE the music out. So once again, who taught you that "when you play someone's pieces play it correctly" was probably meaning for you to not make MISTAKES, not butcher the music, to not play off key and etc. Tips i'd give to my beginner students, not to a world-class musician. Now i can't comprehend the level of arrogance a person has to have to say that one of the best guitar player in the world is fucking up something because they didn't play it like it was recorded 30 years ago. The internet, a really strange place.
@@dehypnotizerzWho ever taught u that must be like orchestra musician or classical or something like that, i understand there are some music which need to be play like it compose 100% but rock, pop and rap is not one of them... I like Chris version more than Marty's live version, every other guitarist i heard played this solo always tried to match Marty play note for note, which is impossible to outplay Marty... But chris played like he own it and change lil bit here and there, like listen closely to the build up before Marty bend the string in 0:31 and Chris in 1:44 its not the same, this solo will always be one of his most memorable moment in his time in Megadeth...
its Marty' use of vibrato to convey expression and emotion. Chris' playing is text book note for note but lacks the soul style of feel that Marty poured into his solo's.
One thing I think that gets overlooked is how serious Dave takes his rhythm playing. He doesn't look bored. He doesn't look around aimlessly. He locks in that right hand and effings rages. What a guy.
Marty's solo is amazing and the difference between video 1 and 2 in the drums is remarkable too. The power that flows in stage with Marty and Menza together is in another level.
@@deskducker Just listen, jesus. Broderick plays it cleaner than Marty because he has better technique. That being said, Marty's version will imo always be more enjoyable to listen to. I feel Broderick sort of over engineered the solo to the point that every note is exactly on the grid. While technically incredible, this loses a lot of the "swing" in the original solo and makes it sound like someone grid aligned everything in a daw.
Luc Christiany exactly.. all three are great players.. but we "feel" the solo when marty plays it. broderick plays the notes super clear but he sounds a little robotic to me..
Marty: because he wrote the most epic solo of all time from his emotions and feelings with the guitar and music Chris: Because he played the solo just like Marty when I went to see Megadeth live. It was fucking great. I was 15. I never saw Friedman live. Kiko: Because that dude throws his feeling in to the whole solo. You can feel HIS emotion he adds to the solo. That's beautiful.
Marty friedman - plays it the most authentic way because he wrote it Chris broderick - does a really good cover of it Kiro loreiro - plays it in his style like he re-wrote it
You have to look at this from a certain perspective. Marty wrote it! Tornado of souls has to be one of the all-time greatest solos ever. The video shows Kiko with some awesome stage presence.
Only Marty plays the solo with the little nuances that most people seem to ignore and make the solo a joy to listen.....Broderick plays the right notes at the right time, basically, and that's it... Kiko, is clearly playing the solo with feeling, with joy, with mastery in his own way, aknowledging that he will never play the solo like marty and that is RESPECT!!! . Saying that Kiko is the best replacement for Marty is not fair, he is an exceptional guitar player on his own.
Broderick's was just...boring. You'd think it would be hard to make that solo boring, but maybe it's kinda like with drums on grid - if it's too "correct" it loses all its feeling.
@@zaphod888 Drums and lead guitar from that era was super boring. I was happy when they left the band. Dirk is the best thing to happen to the band in years.
I imagine Kiko must have grown listening to that solo (among many others of Rest in Peace), and so when he had the opportunity to actually play it with the OGs it's just a jolly good time for him. You can see in his face how fucking much he's enjoying it. Love it.
@@brunovilela4219 you talk as if you know him, lol wtf you're talking about. kiko saw megadeth live a couple of times when he was a teenager, HIS WORDS. besides that, he's always talking about his influences. just cut the bullshit.
Ese solo tiene vida propia..es melancólico..triste...pero a la vez tiene fuerza , tiene orden y desorden.. Es un verdadero Tornado ... Es simplemente maravilloso
Marty has the smoothness, and Keiko has some ridiculous scale runs, but my favorite part of the solo, the two-string arpeggios, are only NAILED by Chris the way Marty did in the studio
This is a perfect solo created by Marty. To this day my favorite Megadeth song because of it. He's a total beast. Chris does a fine job, but you get the feeling he's exactly doing that, a job. No heart in it. Kiko does what a perfect solo deserves, don't mess too much with it, but put in it what's in your soul. That makes him an accomplished artist. I'd say Marty first only cause you can't beat perfection, Kiko a very close second, and Chris at third.
@@N-B-MMA Who cares - it's still great. I've played guitar since the early 80's and don't go to watch guitar players mimic others. If Kiko wants to add his own way of playing it whilst adding his own special sauce, for me, that's better than just rolling off a copy and sounding like some talented kid in the local guitar store on a Saturday. Take the essence of what the solo is and make it your own. IF it's something like the slow parts off Hotel California or Freebird, you gotta replicate it, but if it's a full on exhibition of vibrato and passion like this solo then you just gotta give it what you got - full guns blazing, in your own style. When you have one of the great metal lead players - like Marty, Schenker, Van Halen, Yngwie, etc (you get the idea) you're not going to out play them or sound better than then at their own game. Add YOUR own spice to it and play it how you need to. If you're in Megadeth, you're probably not hired to sound like someone else.
Los dos son unos monstruos, difícil decisión, Kiko es un virtuoso técnicamente, tiene feeling y una ejecución formidable, Friedman también es técnico y siempre tuvo la habilidad creadora para construir solos propia de pocos guitarristas dentro del Metal y del Rock, no hay solo de guitarra de él en el que no se desborde habilidad, feeling y originalidad. Por tanto, al margen de la capacidad técnica de ambos, voto en favor del autor del solo (Friedman), aunque también reconozco la virtuosidad del aquí intérprete (Kiko)
Well, it’s Megadeth man. Any metal musician would love to play in that band. When so many talented man are lined up, picking one of them doesn’t require so much.
This one is in my top 3 guitar solos of all time. Been lucky enough to see all 3 play it live on multiple occasions. I've never liked Chris' version (saw him 4-5 times). Sometime it would feel like he's playing Guitar Hero missing some notes, but the main problem was it was lacking the energy and momentum this solo has. Saw Kiko play it in one of him early Megadeth concerts. Played it beautifully, very close to Marty's (not like here, which is extra awesome).
@@Vic666DK stop bitching kiddos, for me and most people he is not boring... dont make your childish opinion a statement, Mustaine looked at him for some reason, he is just great on his own
Music is more about feel than precision, but it's even better to have both. Brodericks was more about making every note precise and was very stiff. Marty had both because he made the solo and Kiko added his own twist to it
I've been playing guitar for 43 years.. Marty is the writer, he's got the internal code for the feel of this solo so he's not exactly as recorded.. Chris was the closest to the recorded version and i found this to be a sign of reverence and respect ... Kiko made no mistakes and injected his own energy and it also made a huge difference for me.. I liked all 3 .. more than one way to skin a cat!
Marty should be taken out of this comparison, he is the creator of the solo for God's sake. I'd like to see a comparison between Al, Glenn, Chris and Kiko.
@@jjj-qj8lu tbh, I'm sure Dave can play the solo, he's able to play some of the most challenging riffs in metal while also singing at the same time, Dave's a fantastic guitar player and plays several lead solos in alot of their songs. He might have trouble now considering he's almost 60 (although, he can still shred). I can even play the song/solo but clearly not as accurate or clean as these guys can.
@@Zamblinger dude i dont think that youre understanding me.Im not saying that dave is not an amazing guitar player,he surely is and he plays a lot of challenging rhythm stuff. However this solo does not fit with daves lead playing style at all. Daves lead is still impressive but its filled with repetitive pentatonic-chromatic licks,im not saying he plays easy stuff im just saying hes not used to play with martys style hes not that versatile in lead.
@@jjj-qj8lu I'm not sure if he can do it in first try or sound exactly like marty but he definitely can. If people out here on youtube can, he most certainly can too.If he decides to practice, that is lmao.
This is the exact order. Kiko does a really good job of playing it like Marty I think. Broderick is an amazing guitarist but I can't help but feel like he's more of a machine and less of a human.
I've been humbled to meet Marty a few times over the years and he's just a beautiful human being who just loves the guitar. Had a great chat with him and it turns our he's a big Viz fan too LOL. Amazing guy. Had a great chat about Elvis and what inspires him musically. Full of advice and happy to share his love for music with you and tips about his style. I met Chris once outside a show and he wouldn't entertain the fans. Wouldn't sign anything and jumped in the cab while Dave Ellefson chatted to us and had a cheeky selfie with us all. Such a shame about Chris. Amazing talent but just a but self absorbed.
Kiko really made it his own at this point! Great solo! And Marty's version is full of emotion. Both are amazing guitarists and I like both interpretations of the solo.
Dirty Harry - Maybe thats the reason. Our brains are hardwired to "like" or "expect" certain note combos (chords, scales, tridas..blah blah music theory blah blah) so when he misses those notes it gives it that famous Mar-tay "flow" / "feeling" / "humanization". And like is said here already, it's his solo and a bit faster. Broderick has some dope stuff on Endgame but he's too much like xerox machine. (thats a machine that makes photocopies, for anyone born before 2000). If you take a shit on one and press copy, it doesn't come out smelling good or bad, but neither does a rose. Chris's Tornado solo ruined the Rust anniversary concert for me. Which then ruined his Deth Cred with me. Let that be a warning to all..Fuck up 99 Ways to Die, Liar, or Tornado. Instant loss of Deth Cred. And this vid was from when he just got in Deth. Looked a bit dickish with the winks. He's playing for In Flames now it looks like. hmmm Kiko was pretty rad on Dystopia.(Damn that album is 3 years old already...wait that means Endgame is 10 later this year.) Can't leave fair feedback on his Tornado skills here, due to the sound quality of video. No offense Flavio! Always a top Deth debate question!! ESPECIALLY for a song almost 30 years old. Lets add this to the debate, yes it was professionally recorded. Yes, he looks like he's thinking about what Simpson's episode is on that night, but he puts it down. ruclips.net/video/tXpbfFmH3Zs/видео.html and dont forget Marty's words on the subject www.martyfriedman.com/info_archive_detail.php?id=13&det=83
Chris plays the solo great, when he runs down the neck before the famous main part he kinda makes it more technical,.. Marty is truely an incredible artist and plays with so much feeling he rarely ever played that solo the same way, when he runs down the neck is different in every video, that's the way an artist plays as opposed to a technician... Chris's technical ability is second to none.... Truly the best 2 guitarists in Megadeth. My opinion. Sorry I had to edit my original opinion. Marty will always be my favorite,. He's been playing a part in my life for 35 years now. I'm being biased.
Friedman made it so that's his.,.. But Chris nailed it and looked good doing it. Keep shredding Charlie, you're one of my favorite guitarists.🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸✌️
@@tricky92x Im talking about the RIP line up. Gar dying really affected Mustaine, every member after him seemed like a hired gun and only a matter of time till they were replaced.
Yep 👍 the drumming made Marty sound way fucking better but still he did have more soul to it and feel although kiko is fucking great this I give to Marty.
Lo unico que se puede decir que el maldito Mustein tiene un ojo para Elegir las segundas guitarras en su Grupo. Pero me quedo con Marty Friedman por su ejecución mas rápida y punzante.
I loved all of them, Chris plays it so perfect and sweeps sound more fluid like than anybody else’s. Marty plays it w out sweeping, he picks all of the notes and plays the scale which sounds unique to him. Kiko simplifies it and makes it his own w more hammer ons. He is the bravest cuz he really makes it his. Like I said though I loved all of them!!
Brodrick and Kiko are amazing. All these guys are. But to my ear its trying to capture the energy and fluidity of Martys playing. In my book he will always be the best of the best. A real beast !
Totally right, Marty respects so much this beautiful solo, the others don't care much about the sync but still it is the expected behavior. Kiko is more concentrated on Conquer or die
Mano, Marty criou o solo. Tocar é a coisa mais fácil do mundo quando você tem as oportunidades. Criar vem da alma. Comparação nada haver a desse vídeo na real. E que bom BR participando aqui
That's impossible because there was 3 songs the band had never played live before the rust in peace anniversary on that album - where they played the full album. Marty and Nick were long gone from Megadeth when they finally did.
Marty's the best for _creating_ it. Not sure who's best at _playing_ it, that's probably more a matter of taste... they're all good. David Escobar's version is nice too btw, check it out.
Escobar plays it far better than all these live recordings, but of course, Marty recorded the original and it sounds pretty amazing there. There is even a 16yo French girl (Tina S) that plays it better than the performances in this video.
Well, I'd say that Marty Friedman's solo Is the best here, not only because he wrote it, but also because of the feel he's given it. Both the slow parts (at the bends) and the shreds have been infused with the appropriate feel. The other two are mainly technical people, and especially Chris Broderick, who sounds quite mechanical. Great musicians all of them! B-)
Okay 👌🏻They'reall amazing but Marty has the best energy, Chris kinda has a cocky arrogance whenHe solos. but Kiko! Love his vib and the last five seconds of that solo is awesome as he kinda customized it to make it his own.
Kiko is definitely a badass in my book, but the reason why Chris has that air of confidence (or, in your words, cocky arrogance, either terms could be used) is he's a straight monster on the fretboard. Mechanical like playing? Yeah. But that's because he has such high skill. Just the intro to Act of Defiance's "Throwback" makes me feel like nothing could compare to him. It's crazy how much ability he has.
They were all good not one of them was bad they were all great I love all of them. I think they’re excellent guitar players you know Megadeth should be proud to have them in their van. They’re bad God bless.
I wonder if the guitarists pass down their Megadeth sweatband as some kind of heirloom. "Kiko, I bequeath this wrist band full of sweat onto thee" "Ew, that's gross" "TAKE IT OR I'LL TELL DAVE"
Brodrick and Kiko miss the interpretation in the beginning. Pay attention. Probably a wrong score and... Who cares!!! Friedman created the solo. He is the one. Regarding their own creatings, I prefer Megadeth with Kiko than Broderick.
I love all three. The point is that Broderick and Loureiro are not trying to play it like Friedman instead they're playing their own versions with some little changes as remarks and without losing its spirit. This is beauty of music played by very talented musicians. What a history written by Megadeth!
That’s his problem. Marty and Kiko look like they could pick up any guitar and blast out that solo, but for me Chris Broderick would want to practice it to perfection first. Love his version of Caprice No.7 though👍
Legend has it that Dave still can't say what's on his mind to this day
Lol
this is quite funny
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
MasterOfPuppets Hello big brother
Hahahahahahaha
Marty: I wrote it i play it.
Chris: Why the hell am i playing the solo i didn't write?
Kiko: Nice, let's play and have fun.
hahaha... brother kiko plays with these solos... the guy plays fusion... what is Megadeth for fusion? you wrote well.
you sir are 100% correct
Correct
I think this is 1 of Kiko' s favorites. That's Mega. Got to play a history of the band. Poland thru Kiko!
correct
Kiko - passionate & brave
Chris - perfect & cold
Marty - man & guitar
If u have ever listened to kiko solo albums ud know he's on an other lv to Marty and Chris.
Chris brodrick is technically unbelievable but sloppy too and has awful tone
Marty is an exotic player with accute picking
KIKO is all the above minus the flaws
The best comment
Kiko and Marty i believe they are in perfect time... Chris a bit slow
despite the technical qualities in his solo album, Kiko made better solos harmoniously in the band Angra.
@@colossuscreedgaming8233 man what are you talking about that tone was so nice .
Don’t care who’s the best. Someone give Dave a statue for finding these incredible guitarist to play in Megadeth!!
Takes one to know one, because Dave himself is a damn good guitarist
All those guitarists deserve a statue for surviving Mustaine company.
he definately has a talent for this. plus too there are really alot of obscure unknown guitarists out there right now that are really good b/c of RUclips etc.
If you don't care about who's best then why are you here
Dude right! Meanwhile kirk hammet is considered royalty and he can't play anything live even close to how the record sounds. SMH.
Chris just got high score on guitar hero, he hit all the right buttons at exactly the right time. Kiko's playing it like he's one of the characters on guitar hero. Marty IS the guitar hero
best one yet
This is the best comment...i dont understand why everyone is bashing at Chris...he wasn't that disappointing at all for megadeth
Chris is the best
Can't be serious, Chris hit 15 dud notes and added 27extra and his tone is easy the worst.
@@colossuscreedgaming8233 True, Chris made a new solo lol. The only thing he hits right and on time is the part before the final shred
Dave Mustaine for the talent of having found 3 great guitarists :D
Wins the award for "comment most likely to have been written by Dave Mustaine"
😂😂😂😂 fair point 😂
4, actually.
Poland
Friedman
Broderick
Lureiro
@@adamsakran8708 he said great
@@Jerry-rp6sx yeah, and? Which one isn't great?
Marty’s is dripping with feel but of course he’s the creator of it. That being said, I’m sure if you had a vid of Marty playing a Chris Poland solo you’d also have to give it to the originator.
ыыы
Hello sir
Marty is the creator . Kiko loureiro was the closest
@@abrahamrodrigues1049 who is Kino sir?
@@sebastiangerardo5804 I mean kiko. Thanks for the heads up
I love the random shoe that flies up in the air during Kiko's solo. That was metal.
3:04
lmao had to watch it again!
Tornado of soles
LMAO
Okay that was a shoe. That's all I need to know. Props to whoever did that.
@@nicopillay4059 lol
Marty Friedman plays it as if his soul was inside the tornado too. 🤘🏻♥️
True
Best comment ever
Nah mate he was the tornado to the souls
I love how Chris played it absolutely perfectly note for note and yet still didn't sound like Marty. Marty Friedman just actually has such a unique tone that just cannot be replicated
Yes, but Chris was as close as humanly possible. Loureiro completely fucked up this solo. I'm a musician I was taught one thing: when you play your shit, do whatever the hell you want. HOWEVER, when you play someone's piece, play it CORRECTLY.
@@dehypnotizerz Who taught you this probably never created an original song in their life, only copied and played covers or most probably you didn't understand what they meant lol.
First "i'm a musician" trying to give any credit to your comment is stupid, most people here are probably musicians as well and KIKO is a better musician than us all, so you're trying to use an idiotic credibility.
Second, there are two types of current band members playing former members pieces: the ones that try to copy and the ones that try to make it their own, as seen above with Chris and Kiko respectively. Nothing wrong with trying to play it perfectly, although that's an impossible task not even Marty plays his solos perfectly and of course, absolutely nothing wrong on changing it a bit. In fact, guitarists that don't copy but infuse their style into other's solo usually are the BEST and MOST CREATIVE players.
That's why Kiko gave us the best albums since Friedman's era in my and most of the fans and critics opinion.
So if you want to listen to the album solos GO LISTEN TO THE ALBUM! Live shows are supposed to be different, music is passion, is art, the best players put their feelings into their music and if you were a good musician you would know that. Bad musicians copy, good ones BREATHE the music out.
So once again, who taught you that "when you play someone's pieces play it correctly" was probably meaning for you to not make MISTAKES, not butcher the music, to not play off key and etc. Tips i'd give to my beginner students, not to a world-class musician.
Now i can't comprehend the level of arrogance a person has to have to say that one of the best guitar player in the world is fucking up something because they didn't play it like it was recorded 30 years ago. The internet, a really strange place.
@@dehypnotizerzWho ever taught u that must be like orchestra musician or classical or something like that, i understand there are some music which need to be play like it compose 100% but rock, pop and rap is not one of them... I like Chris version more than Marty's live version, every other guitarist i heard played this solo always tried to match Marty play note for note, which is impossible to outplay Marty... But chris played like he own it and change lil bit here and there, like listen closely to the build up before Marty bend the string in 0:31 and Chris in 1:44 its not the same, this solo will always be one of his most memorable moment in his time in Megadeth...
its Marty' use of vibrato to convey expression and emotion. Chris' playing is text book note for note but lacks the soul style of feel that Marty poured into his solo's.
One thing I think that gets overlooked is how serious Dave takes his rhythm playing.
He doesn't look bored. He doesn't look around aimlessly.
He locks in that right hand and effings rages.
What a guy.
For that reason Dave is my favourite metal player. The N° 1.
He's outstanding... Think how good Metallica would still be eh.!!! Megadeath are brilliant..!
@@jbearmcdougall1646 Haha I dunno.
I haven't liked anything Megadeth has put out since The System Has Failed.
But they're still my favorite. :)
That’s why he appeals to me so much because he is so in tune with his instrument and playing
Of Kirk ever breaks an arm Dave should fill in for a while.... .!!
Marty's solo is amazing and the difference between video 1 and 2 in the drums is remarkable too. The power that flows in stage with Marty and Menza together is in another level.
They were much younger too.
Spot on.
Una lástima que uno de los pocos bateristas que transmite sentimiento con la batería ya no esté 😥😥
3:19 That fucking BEND!!! OMGG!!!!!
Friedman: the more "sensitive" way
Broderick: the most "precise" way
Loureiro: the most "personal" way
All three are just perfect, in their own way.
Martin Penwald marty is supposed to be personal and kiko sensitive how come kiko be personal when its not his solo that doesn’t make sense to me
Yeah I meant that Kiko played it making it his own. He didn't play it exactly like Marty, he personalised it.
Martin Penwald Broderick more precise? Marty wrote the damn thing. How are you more precise than the original itself?
@@deskducker Just listen, jesus. Broderick plays it cleaner than Marty because he has better technique. That being said, Marty's version will imo always be more enjoyable to listen to.
I feel Broderick sort of over engineered the solo to the point that every note is exactly on the grid. While technically incredible, this loses a lot of the "swing" in the original solo and makes it sound like someone grid aligned everything in a daw.
NO lol, Marty did all three lol,what the hell is wrong with you people lol
Marty _Friedman
that was his solo man
ajay gurung You're right. All 3 are great players, but Marty create it, that's his sound ;)
Luc Christiany exactly.. all three are great players.. but we "feel" the solo when marty plays it. broderick plays the notes super clear but he sounds a little robotic to me..
Exactily..
You all are right and He'll yeah Megadeath
all of his solos sounds like a perpetual training exercises to me!
I like Marty’s touch and time. His solo is the most aggressive and emotional.
The emotion and Joy in Kikos face says it all 🤷🏻♀️ God I love my job
i thought you were takin a leak in your pfp💀
@@aydenalvarez6633 same💀💀💀💀💀
Marty: because he wrote the most epic solo of all time from his emotions and feelings with the guitar and music
Chris: Because he played the solo just like Marty when I went to see Megadeth live. It was fucking great. I was 15. I never saw Friedman live.
Kiko: Because that dude throws his feeling in to the whole solo. You can feel HIS emotion he adds to the solo. That's beautiful.
Marty->The master of tornado
Kiko->A veteran guitarist having fun
Chris->Guitar Pro midi playback with keytar sound
Cool man, so fun!! :-D
Pritelli is good..
Chris Broderick is better then kiko at playing the old megadeth stuff
All equally impressive
Really? Your comment about Chris shows how ignorant you are:)
I'm a big fan of Marty, but watching Kiko play is also incredible! He makes everything look easy.
he fucking ruined it...he's great though
@@vivarantx Ruined it? You’d play it better?
kiko seemed like he was tuned WAY down
@@doomdoom6010 megadeth has been playing in D standard for a decade now how do people still not know this?
Marty has soul.... Magic. Kiko is great, but nowhere near.
Marty friedman - plays it the most authentic way because he wrote it
Chris broderick - does a really good cover of it
Kiro loreiro - plays it in his style like he re-wrote it
What you told about Kiko here is correct
You nailed it .
spot on with that summary, was thinking exactly the same thing myself!
Yeah. They're all good, just different from each other. I personally enjoy the Kiko version the best.
It’s almost like it’s too easy for Chris if you get what I mean. He plays it too casually.
Kiko was running at the hardest part of the solo like nothing what
I thought the same
he wanted to help dave say whats on his mind
Just hoping this answer
Yes, and he ruined it, a wuah effect due to the variance of pressure in his right hand... Terrible
@@hectortorres8188 kkkkk do It better or Just shut up boy
Mustaine, Ellefson, Friedman, Menza
Rust In Peace = one of the best thrash albums of all time
Kitara Virtuoosi same here!
You sayed man
Yes
Anyday anytime
You have to look at this from a certain perspective. Marty wrote it! Tornado of souls has to be one of the all-time greatest solos ever. The video shows Kiko with some awesome stage presence.
Only Marty plays the solo with the little nuances that most people seem to ignore and make the solo a joy to listen.....Broderick plays the right notes at the right time, basically, and that's it... Kiko, is clearly playing the solo with feeling, with joy, with mastery in his own way, aknowledging that he will never play the solo like marty and that is RESPECT!!! . Saying that Kiko is the best replacement for Marty is not fair, he is an exceptional guitar player on his own.
Broderick's was just...boring. You'd think it would be hard to make that solo boring, but maybe it's kinda like with drums on grid - if it's too "correct" it loses all its feeling.
@@zaphod888 Drums and lead guitar from that era was super boring. I was happy when they left the band. Dirk is the best thing to happen to the band in years.
I imagine Kiko must have grown listening to that solo (among many others of Rest in Peace), and so when he had the opportunity to actually play it with the OGs it's just a jolly good time for him. You can see in his face how fucking much he's enjoying it. Love it.
Not sure if he listened to Megadeth that much (it's boring). He were more into power metal and Brazilian native genres.
@@brunovilela4219 You are boring Bruno...
@@brunovilela4219 you talk as if you know him, lol wtf you're talking about. kiko saw megadeth live a couple of times when he was a teenager, HIS WORDS. besides that, he's always talking about his influences. just cut the bullshit.
@@mau9175 I don't doubt it has influenced Kiko, but definetely not on top 15 list of his influences.
@@brunovilela4219 imagine being a power metal fan and calling Megadeth boring lmao
Ese solo tiene vida propia..es melancólico..triste...pero a la vez tiene fuerza , tiene orden y desorden..
Es un verdadero Tornado ...
Es simplemente maravilloso
well, chris and kiko's play were impressive, but marty's always gives me goosebumps!
Same
Best way to gauge these things.
I imagine Marty's old friend Jason Becker playing that solo...
Jason gonna play all notes but sweeping
@@Mr20Centimetros Could be. Very possible! It is so sad that the most advanced player of the 80s can't play anymore.
I miss Jason
Beckers play much harder and intelligent
So sad.. got to admire him continuing with music even with his condition.
Marty WROTE it! Many can play other people's music. The true talent is to compose it.
Yeah, In that specific case... maybe, but I think that music transcend that...
so true, the genius is the one that creates, not the one that learns
metalrotten I am glad you agree Abbath 😊🤘🏻
Very true, I always say this when someone has me watch someone play someone else's work...but that guy hasn't wrote anything memorable
Well said
Marty has the smoothness, and Keiko has some ridiculous scale runs, but my favorite part of the solo, the two-string arpeggios, are only NAILED by Chris the way Marty did in the studio
U need lo'g fi'gers for those
Totally agree. Chris nailed the solo as Marty created it, only a bit slower. Hats off to Marty for this great piece of music.
@@shred9475 not actually, its a matter of practice
@@wearenotundone i am 6'4 with long fingers so it came easy to me
Damn. Had never seen Kiko play before. Legend.
You must see him playing with Angra, his original band from Brazil...
@@cadimenta Temple of Shadows. No more needs to be said.
@@NextGenesis88 carry on is a legendary music too
Angels cry, the masterpiece of Angra
kiko is the only who can play solo and run at the same time
Do you have any proof of that ?
Kiko was the most entertaining using both sides of stage great facial expressions.
Marty used to run across the stage when he played solos.
Yah, cuz hes been playing the solo since he was 5 🤣
This is a perfect solo created by Marty. To this day my favorite Megadeth song because of it. He's a total beast.
Chris does a fine job, but you get the feeling he's exactly doing that, a job. No heart in it.
Kiko does what a perfect solo deserves, don't mess too much with it, but put in it what's in your soul. That makes him an accomplished artist.
I'd say Marty first only cause you can't beat perfection, Kiko a very close second, and Chris at third.
Best thing is that no-one is arguing who is best, everyone just found the light of every version 😅
Damn Megadeth got real fanbase 🔥
Many played it, but Marty created it.
That's the difference...
Correct.
Amen
Thats true but personally i think kiko really brought teh feeling into his solo. I dont wanna talk about Chris
Воистину правда! brother!
The difference is the vibrato. Marty's vibrato is in another level.
Kiko not only played it perfectly but put his own feeling to it. And that's more than just maestry. That's ...art man.
so wrong ur coment kikos bad solo performance
he didnt even bend the correct notes
@@kfc6495 Why not telling him then and applying for Megadeth guitarist?
@@kfc6495 🤓
I like Kiko’s last section of the solo better … there’s more feel there than anarchy
I feel like Kiko combines the soul of Marty’s playing with the precision of Chris’s.
I like his version. It was very good =D
i feel like Marty wrote it and performed it like Marty intended with that precision :D
petrucciator Petrucciator Marty could’ve done better. He messed
up quite a bit.
Damn I love this album, these guys were savage and top of the world through these years. RIP Nick Menza!!!
“Up next: Kiko Practicing Tornado of Souls”
He actually done it
His practice is ok but a ways off
@@N-B-MMA Who cares - it's still great.
I've played guitar since the early 80's and don't go to watch guitar players mimic others. If Kiko wants to add his own way of playing it whilst adding his own special sauce, for me, that's better than just rolling off a copy and sounding like some talented kid in the local guitar store on a Saturday. Take the essence of what the solo is and make it your own. IF it's something like the slow parts off Hotel California or Freebird, you gotta replicate it, but if it's a full on exhibition of vibrato and passion like this solo then you just gotta give it what you got - full guns blazing, in your own style. When you have one of the great metal lead players - like Marty, Schenker, Van Halen, Yngwie, etc (you get the idea) you're not going to out play them or sound better than then at their own game. Add YOUR own spice to it and play it how you need to. If you're in Megadeth, you're probably not hired to sound like someone else.
Nailed it🤣🤘
You crazy son of a bitch, you did it
Los dos son unos monstruos, difícil decisión, Kiko es un virtuoso técnicamente, tiene feeling y una ejecución formidable, Friedman también es técnico y siempre tuvo la habilidad creadora para construir solos propia de pocos guitarristas dentro del Metal y del Rock, no hay solo de guitarra de él en el que no se desborde habilidad, feeling y originalidad.
Por tanto, al margen de la capacidad técnica de ambos, voto en favor del autor del solo (Friedman), aunque también reconozco la virtuosidad del aquí intérprete (Kiko)
Opino igual bro...
+Pato Araos Como testiculos no va a ser Liko Lureiro en el min. 2:48 pelotudo
A ausencia de Broderick no comentario mostra a opinião de todos a respeito dele kkkkkkkk
Juan Pérez la plena man!
@@winstonzeddemore3265 exacto, los otros son unos imitadores, cojonudos, pero sólo es una copia.
Can we just acknowledge how through so many lineup changes Dave has always been able to find fantastic talent? That’s impressive as hell.
Well, it’s Megadeth man. Any metal musician would love to play in that band. When so many talented man are lined up, picking one of them doesn’t require so much.
No metal guitarist is going to say no to that gig
Same thing with Ozzy - just tons of legends around him all the time)
Auditioning for Megadeth lead guitar role is like selection for any elite special forces😂😂😂😂
Well.. Ellefson found Kiko
This one is in my top 3 guitar solos of all time. Been lucky enough to see all 3 play it live on multiple occasions. I've never liked Chris' version (saw him 4-5 times). Sometime it would feel like he's playing Guitar Hero missing some notes, but the main problem was it was lacking the energy and momentum this solo has.
Saw Kiko play it in one of him early Megadeth concerts. Played it beautifully, very close to Marty's (not like here, which is extra awesome).
Yeah Kiko and Marty's feel are incredible but Broderick's precision is just impecable
But also boring....
ok no. he missed twice. but i still think he's robot and missed just to fool somebody that he isn't.
@@Vic666DK stop bitching kiddos, for me and most people he is not boring... dont make your childish opinion a statement, Mustaine looked at him for some reason, he is just great on his own
Music is more about feel than precision, but it's even better to have both. Brodericks was more about making every note precise and was very stiff. Marty had both because he made the solo and Kiko added his own twist to it
I've been playing guitar for 43 years.. Marty is the writer, he's got the internal code for the feel of this solo so he's not exactly as recorded.. Chris was the closest to the recorded version and i found this to be a sign of reverence and respect ... Kiko made no mistakes and injected his own energy and it also made a huge difference for me.. I liked all 3 .. more than one way to skin a cat!
Marty should be taken out of this comparison, he is the creator of the solo for God's sake.
I'd like to see a comparison between Al, Glenn, Chris and Kiko.
Correct his the original he composed it he should be out for comparison
Nice profile pic
Glenn drover for sure!
@fpsqt here you go
ruclips.net/video/oNQpBjeCNA8/видео.html
Lol. Valid
Marty’s solo sounds like cooked with its right time in the oven, the others are microwaved.
Weird that we were recommended this at about the same time. Lmfao what an algorithm
I wonder if Dave has ever played Marty's Tornado solo? That would be fricken epic to see. That would damn near rip a blackhole in our universe.
i have tried this suggestion ..its on my channel!! XD
As a fan of dave im saying this: lets be honest,dave wouldnt be able to play that solo.
@@jjj-qj8lu tbh, I'm sure Dave can play the solo, he's able to play some of the most challenging riffs in metal while also singing at the same time, Dave's a fantastic guitar player and plays several lead solos in alot of their songs. He might have trouble now considering he's almost 60 (although, he can still shred). I can even play the song/solo but clearly not as accurate or clean as these guys can.
@@Zamblinger dude i dont think that youre understanding me.Im not saying that dave is not an amazing guitar player,he surely is and he plays a lot of challenging rhythm stuff. However this solo does not fit with daves lead playing style at all. Daves lead is still impressive but its filled with repetitive pentatonic-chromatic licks,im not saying he plays easy stuff im just saying hes not used to play with martys style hes not that versatile in lead.
@@jjj-qj8lu I'm not sure if he can do it in first try or sound exactly like marty but he definitely can. If people out here on youtube can, he most certainly can too.If he decides to practice, that is lmao.
1 - Marty
2 - Kiko
3 - Chris
chris is a extremely precise guitarrist but doesnt know how to make a good sounding solo variabl, kiko can, and marty was a fenomanal writer
feeNiq CS:GO agree 100% and reflected the same in my comments.
This is the exact order. Kiko does a really good job of playing it like Marty I think. Broderick is an amazing guitarist but I can't help but feel like he's more of a machine and less of a human.
iCrazyy - João marty, chris,kiko
iCrazyy - João kiko didn't even play the solo correct he fucked up in the solo
Marty is the creator but I love how Kiko feels the melody of the solo.
I fell in love with Megadeth because of the songs from the "Marty era" so he is always "THEE" Megadeth guitarist to me.
Marty friedman will ALWAYS be the best. hands down.
Well, he created that beast of a solo. It makes sense.
Q: Who's best?!
A: Yes
This
They’re all good but I got goosebumps on that last one.
Chris and Kiko are amazing. Marty just has a sound that nobody can mimic.
FRIEDMAN HEAD AND SHOULDERS ABOVE THE REST.
Kiko L'Oréal Paris lulz
No need to compare. They all are great musicians.
:)
Marty is the best by far. I can hear every note, clean and tight. ❤️🤘🏻 Best lineup as well❤
I've been humbled to meet Marty a few times over the years and he's just a beautiful human being who just loves the guitar. Had a great chat with him and it turns our he's a big Viz fan too LOL. Amazing guy. Had a great chat about Elvis and what inspires him musically. Full of advice and happy to share his love for music with you and tips about his style. I met Chris once outside a show and he wouldn't entertain the fans. Wouldn't sign anything and jumped in the cab while Dave Ellefson chatted to us and had a cheeky selfie with us all. Such a shame about Chris. Amazing talent but just a but self absorbed.
Kiko really made it his own at this point! Great solo! And Marty's version is full of emotion. Both are amazing guitarists and I like both interpretations of the solo.
Marty ripped it, but thing is, Megadeth is way too easy for Kiko.
@BL Yeah, but he wrote the solo tho
Except he didn’t
@@stevemarto Sorry, I mistook Marty with Chris.
@BL chris is out of tempo. But perfect note
Exodus Gaming Not perfect notes by any means. He switched a lot of parts to
his own style, which is understandable as he isn’t the original artist.
I think Chris Broderick is way too underrated, he's literally nuts and he even adds a little bit of flair to the solo that no one talks about
There's something in Marty's phrasing that's very difficult to immitate even though he misses notes.
Dirty Harry - Maybe thats the reason. Our brains are hardwired to "like" or "expect" certain note combos (chords, scales, tridas..blah blah music theory blah blah) so when he misses those notes it gives it that famous Mar-tay "flow" / "feeling" / "humanization". And like is said here already, it's his solo and a bit faster.
Broderick has some dope stuff on Endgame but he's too much like xerox machine. (thats a machine that makes photocopies, for anyone born before 2000). If you take a shit on one and press copy, it doesn't come out smelling good or bad, but neither does a rose. Chris's Tornado solo ruined the Rust anniversary concert for me. Which then ruined his Deth Cred with me. Let that be a warning to all..Fuck up 99 Ways to Die, Liar, or Tornado. Instant loss of Deth Cred. And this vid was from when he just got in Deth. Looked a bit dickish with the winks. He's playing for In Flames now it looks like. hmmm
Kiko was pretty rad on Dystopia.(Damn that album is 3 years old already...wait that means Endgame is 10 later this year.) Can't leave fair feedback on his Tornado skills here, due to the sound quality of video. No offense Flavio! Always a top Deth debate question!! ESPECIALLY for a song almost 30 years old.
Lets add this to the debate, yes it was professionally recorded. Yes, he looks like he's thinking about what Simpson's episode is on that night, but he puts it down. ruclips.net/video/tXpbfFmH3Zs/видео.html
and dont forget Marty's words on the subject www.martyfriedman.com/info_archive_detail.php?id=13&det=83
Chris plays the solo great, when he runs down the neck before the famous main part he kinda makes it more technical,.. Marty is truely an incredible artist and plays with so much feeling he rarely ever played that solo the same way, when he runs down the neck is different in every video, that's the way an artist plays as opposed to a technician...
Chris's technical ability is second to none.... Truly the best 2 guitarists in Megadeth. My opinion.
Sorry I had to edit my original opinion. Marty will always be my favorite,. He's been playing a part in my life for 35 years now. I'm being biased.
I agree completely. It's his nuance and ability to convey emotion all over the neck at high speed in any kind of style that truly sets him apart
Natural born groove, I call it
Friedman made it so that's his.,.. But Chris nailed it and looked good doing it.
Keep shredding Charlie, you're one of my favorite guitarists.🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸✌️
3:04 somebody just threw a bottle upwards lol
Chris and Kiko sound amazing but the energy of the original line up cant be replaced, its nuclear! Shame we'll never see it again, RIP Nick!
The original line-up didn't contain Nick or Marty. Megadeth was never the same after Chris and Gar left.
@@tricky92x Im talking about the RIP line up. Gar dying really affected Mustaine, every member after him seemed like a hired gun and only a matter of time till they were replaced.
marty sounded better because of menza's loud and fast drumming
painkiller619 undertaker Además, Marty compuso el solo.
RIP Menza
And his more natural vibrato and feel. And the fact that he wrote the damned solo.
Yep 👍 the drumming made Marty sound way fucking better but still he did have more soul to it and feel although kiko is fucking great this I give to Marty.
Hell yeah!
Undoubtedly, Marty Friedman was the one who invented that guitar solo, but Chris Broderick is definately awesome.
While the internet argues over who played it best (ahem, Marty), I realize I need to practice.
Lo unico que se puede decir que el maldito Mustein tiene un ojo para Elegir las segundas guitarras en su Grupo. Pero me quedo con Marty Friedman por su ejecución mas rápida y punzante.
Kiko knows what he is doing ...👨🏻🔧
I loved all of them, Chris plays it so perfect and sweeps sound more fluid like than anybody else’s. Marty plays it w out sweeping, he picks all of the notes and plays the scale which sounds unique to him. Kiko simplifies it and makes it his own w more hammer ons. He is the bravest cuz he really makes it his. Like I said though I loved all of them!!
Brodrick and Kiko are amazing. All these guys are. But to my ear its trying to capture the energy and fluidity of Martys playing. In my book he will always be the best of the best. A real beast !
Marty’s tone is inimitabile, end of the story.
Totally right, Marty respects so much this beautiful solo, the others don't care much about the sync but still it is the expected behavior. Kiko is more concentrated on Conquer or die
BRB going to look up inimitable
Yes I agree his tone is inimitable, Dave’s voice is also inimitable
Marty has the strangest right hand posture that I've ever seen. But his hand tone is just deadly.
Marty attacks that solo the other two guys played it.
This was one of the first concerts of Kiko and even this fact, he's the most feelingable and technical.
Exactamente. Al fin alguien que entiende las cosas como son.
Friedman, for sure ... but i would like to play it myself like Broderick does: so clean.
dude dint even look at the guitar... what a FLEX (look, i can play what marty wrote while looking away)
Clean is the last thing I’d look for in this solo
Haha clean hes the sloppist guitarist dave ever found! Just all sweep and speed and played like a broken robot
I’d rather play it like kiko, very well w passion, and not afraid to put your own twist into it
Todos tienen cosas buenas. Kiko es muy técnico, chris le mete una pasión y suena bárbar. Marty es epico porque él compuso esta obra de arte
Marty's solo, all played well but Chris was cleanest. 1st time I've watched him play it.
“Clean” isn’t really a quality here.
One of the main reasons i like Dave’s guitar playing is because it’s NOT clean.
@@kaiserstiglitz6735 that's what i love abot the guitars on rip, so natutal and raw, with all the little noises that make it unique
dos guitarristas do mega, n teve nenhum abaixo da média, só monstro meu amigo
Isso que nesse show do kiko foi tudo improviso, o primeiro show com o Megadeth e só tinha repassado algumas músicas e configurações do som
Kiko é FODA !
Mano, Marty criou o solo.
Tocar é a coisa mais fácil do mundo quando você tem as oportunidades. Criar vem da alma.
Comparação nada haver a desse vídeo na real.
E que bom BR participando aqui
Kiko mudou o solo mano, o cara tem culhões...
I saw Megadeth live with Slayer. They played the Rust in Peace album in it's entirety. Amazing. Dave, Dave, Nick and Marty. Best Megadeth line up.
Saw that tour too
That's impossible because there was 3 songs the band had never played live before the rust in peace anniversary on that album - where they played the full album. Marty and Nick were long gone from Megadeth when they finally did.
@@hundredpercentmetal true. Saw the Rust tour. They were opening for Priest. Saw the anniversary tour. They did the whole record.
They only played Rust in Peace in its entirely in 2010
Nah that was Chris B or whoever. And the drummer they had at the time. Nick & Marty were gone by then
Marty's the best for _creating_ it.
Not sure who's best at _playing_ it, that's probably more a matter of taste... they're all good.
David Escobar's version is nice too btw, check it out.
ziiofswe so true
Escobar plays it far better than all these live recordings, but of course, Marty recorded the original and it sounds pretty amazing there. There is even a 16yo French girl (Tina S) that plays it better than the performances in this video.
It's a bit confusing sometimes, having two excellent french girls playing guitar... Tina and Juliette. (Don't think J. has tried this one though.)
Well, I'd say that Marty Friedman's solo Is the best here, not only because he wrote it, but also because of the feel he's given it. Both the slow parts (at the bends) and the shreds have been infused with the appropriate feel. The other two are mainly technical people, and especially Chris Broderick, who sounds quite mechanical. Great musicians all of them! B-)
nice sum up. I felt Broderick to be the most technical. But It's the whole package that counts.
I get the feeling that Chris was bored. Just a job for him. Kiko was different. Gave it his own spin.
Okay 👌🏻They'reall amazing but Marty has the best energy, Chris kinda has a cocky arrogance whenHe solos. but Kiko! Love his vib and the last five seconds of that solo is awesome as he kinda customized it to make it his own.
Kiko is definitely a badass in my book, but the reason why Chris has that air of confidence (or, in your words, cocky arrogance, either terms could be used) is he's a straight monster on the fretboard. Mechanical like playing? Yeah. But that's because he has such high skill. Just the intro to Act of Defiance's "Throwback" makes me feel like nothing could compare to him. It's crazy how much ability he has.
Chris looks cocky because he's that good
They were all good not one of them was bad they were all great I love all of them. I think they’re excellent guitar players you know Megadeth should be proud to have them in their van. They’re bad God bless.
Chris is play very clean...good temp, chord running by flet,then can hear the blues rythm very clear..for me Chris Broderick is the best..
Chris touch all flet (button)..i can hear also the tempo with blues rythm..so clean..
1.marty
2.kiko (cause ive heard a better live audio)
3.chris
I wonder if the guitarists pass down their Megadeth sweatband as some kind of heirloom.
"Kiko, I bequeath this wrist band full of sweat onto thee"
"Ew, that's gross"
"TAKE IT OR I'LL TELL DAVE"
LOL I JUST THOUGHT THE SAME THING
@@lucasfischer6358 is it weird I read that in his portugese accent?
@@AreEnTee hahaha i loved it. Of course it isnt.
Underrated comment
Brodrick and Kiko miss the interpretation in the beginning. Pay attention. Probably a wrong score and... Who cares!!! Friedman created the solo. He is the one. Regarding their own creatings, I prefer Megadeth with Kiko than Broderick.
I love all three. The point is that Broderick and Loureiro are not trying to play it like Friedman instead they're playing their own versions with some little changes as remarks and without losing its spirit. This is beauty of music played by very talented musicians. What a history written by Megadeth!
By far Marty! + He wrote the actual solo. The two others are amazing players as well, but Marty is Marty. Respect to all 3!
Sem dúvidas , Marty foi o melhor guitarrista solo , rust in peace fornecer!!😎🤘🤘🤘
Kiko is unbelievable Dystopia was one of their best
All great...different styles...heart... and technique...that's what makes us all a tornado of souls! Often imitated..never duplicated!
Increibles, son unos máquinas. Pero me quedo con Friedman. Aunque admiro muchísimo a kiko loureiro.
Love they all, but in this solo...Broderick is just perfect!!!
That’s his problem. Marty and Kiko look like they could pick up any guitar and blast out that solo, but for me Chris Broderick would want to practice it to perfection first. Love his version of Caprice No.7 though👍
Crazy
Not Kirk Hammett.
That's my answer and I'm sticking with it.
So right !!!
smile
It’s the notes in between that are getting me
Same man it's the pre-chorus for me
Kirk couldn’t carry the water to cool any of them off
Marty created this legendary solo so it’s obvious that he can play it better than anyone else