Fishing North Atlantic REVIEW IS IT ANY GOOD? with Sim UK

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 123

  • @SimUKReviews
    @SimUKReviews  4 года назад +12

    Some Ideas for game Improvements:
    1) Stored boats can only be accessed at the port they are in + docking fees apply
    2) You can use the Sea Cat ferry to speed travel between ports (at a cost).
    3) AI boats need to have AI on them + we should be able to employ AI to run our old boats (and be able to buy multiple of the same).
    4) MULTIPLAYER - Total game transformation.
    5) Deeper levels of realism: Mechanical failure, maintenance + repairs.
    6) Better more realistic physics and damage modelling (to include sinking).
    7) Bigger waves, dangerous weather and tides.
    8) Better AI crew controls.
    9) Better control binding options.
    10) Audio improvements ACROSS THE BOARD.
    What are your idea?

    • @ItsShane79
      @ItsShane79 4 года назад +1

      You forgot VR support. ^^

    • @NilsHedstrom
      @NilsHedstrom 4 года назад +1

      I think it should have two modes, one simulator mode like you mention with engine failure and other problems and stuff like requiring actual boating skill and knowledge to dock with moorings etc. but one mode should just be casual game like with fishing Barents sea.

    • @NilsHedstrom
      @NilsHedstrom 4 года назад

      Also the way the boats move with the waves seems very un-realistic especially rocking that much in a seemingly calm port in calm weather but I guess it's cause its just a beta

    • @weibrot8324
      @weibrot8324 2 года назад

      Well i had similar ideas xD

  • @jimmydali
    @jimmydali 4 года назад +10

    1. Multiplayer
    2. interacting with ai crew on the vessel
    3. real-time mechanical failures and vessel degradation
    4. getting weather alerts thru radio coms
    5. Search & Rescue missions
    6. Deployable Spotter Plane to scout for schools of Swordfish
    7. Character tiredness
    8. Vessel sinkable but also rescue-able
    9. Rival Companies
    10. Wheel support

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад +1

      Fantastic list I would buy that instantly

    • @joe18425
      @joe18425 4 года назад

      Multiplayer ?
      Question:
      If released
      In multiplayer would you like to have the ability to pull in other players lines/nets ?

    • @palmolive2517
      @palmolive2517 6 месяцев назад

      Well they only did the wheel support😂

  • @samanthapatrick4345
    @samanthapatrick4345 3 года назад +3

    I think adding an actual story to the game and adding crew loyalty missions would be pretty cool as well and being able to talk to your crew members at the bar would be cool, I almost forgot there's a bug that leaves a notification that the cargo has been delivered after I'd completed the mission the really need to take care of that because it's irritating

  • @farinafranqui
    @farinafranqui 2 года назад +2

    This game really needs the crew to react to events like a big haul or a small haul, etc. like in Deadliest Catch: Alaskan Storm. It also needs crew members to get injured or fall of the boat based off of how windy, wavy, and tired they are.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  2 года назад

      Yes, that would be good....Really good actually.

  • @richardperry3293
    @richardperry3293 4 года назад +3

    As someone who grew up in the stern of a boat off the coast of Maine I like it. I have done every type of fishing they offer as well. I am still lobstering and purse seining still. A few things I would change....lobstering...they havent use wooden traps in forever even in Canada. I know theyre the stereotypical lobster trap look and it probably doesnt matter but I would probably make them wire mesh with differing colors. Harpooning. They use spotter planes these days when they are harpooning. Most use rod and reel but back in the old days it was harpooning and planes were and still are used. I have read a few complaints about the inability to find schools of fish, that would solve a few issues. make it more realistic and help find a plane. Generally the plane got 25-30% as a reference. Longlining/trawling also a bit different but still decent. Other stuff I havent gotten to yet. So cant comment on anything beyond what I have seen in videos. The whole netting I have watched doesnt make any sense though but until I see how they do it myself I cant really say. Boat physics. They dont just stop they have quite a bit of drift. I would also look at tides. And the CAT is a real boat we see it daily now that it goes out of Portland.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад

      Spotter Planes and fishing lines, I would love that!

    • @SarahPettigrew
      @SarahPettigrew 3 года назад

      Lobster fisher from Nova Scotia here 🙋‍♀️ Wooden traps have always been used here and are still being used to this day. Wire traps used in the fall and wooden in the spring for our district.

  • @mitchturton8527
    @mitchturton8527 4 года назад +2

    1. Multiplayer would change this game
    2. I hope it comes to console
    3. More realistic damage
    4. Natural disasters
    5. Better contracts
    6. Being able to work on other peoples boats

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад

      MP would transform this game I agree. Good ideas, thanks.

  • @weibrot8324
    @weibrot8324 2 года назад +1

    I will simply copy paste my questions from Steam forum into here since it also can be seen as suggestions/wishlist.
    I would like to see much deeper boat/ship and sea/weather and sinking (physics) simulation in FNA or the next fishing simulation they maybe already working on, the concept is great and fills obviusly a gap but it should definitely focus more on the simulation aspect and provide a larger vareity of gameplay like sending distress calls/signals and answering/reacting to distress calls/signals, evacuating the ship/boat when sinking (activating alarm, commanding your sailors to get into the survival suits, preparing lifeboat and finally abandoning ship/boat) due to a heavy storm as example (yes plz heavier than in FNA and FBS).
    Ouh and btw good review :D
    How realistic/simulated is the sinking?
    ~ Are you able to activate alarms, send distress calls, make distress signals, evacuate your crew?
    ~ Can you answer/react on distress calls/signals and rescue sailors/fishermen/people?
    ~ How realistic is the flooding simulated?
    How realistic is the ship steering/simulation?
    ~ Is it possible to set the maneuver thrusters (port & starboard) to turn 360° on spot?
    ~ Do you have on factory ships ballast tanks you can controll?
    How realistic is the sea current, wind and waves simulated?
    ~ Will your boat/ship float away if you dont anchor?
    ~ Will your boat/ship be affected by wind?
    ~ Are waves realistic simulated?
    ~ Can you encounter monster waves?
    Do dynamic failures exist?
    ~ Can parts of your boat/ship like your engine and ropes dynamically break/fail?
    ~ Can fires on board of your and AI controlled boats/ships happen?
    Can you recruite AI captains?
    ~ Is it possible to recruite AI captains and let them man other boats/ships you own and give them tasks?

  • @jborynec
    @jborynec 4 года назад +1

    I was on the fence, but your review gave me enough information that I felt comfortable buying the game. Thanks kindly.

  • @Pokèmon-Ben
    @Pokèmon-Ben 4 года назад +1

    Would love to see, a company system, owning ai boats and buys storage/shop?

  • @kubabooba548
    @kubabooba548 3 года назад +2

    I've seen the roadmap, and it looks like the developers are taking this game very seriously. Hopefully, with all the improvements, when this game releases on console, it's going to be epic!

  • @outcastgaming7147
    @outcastgaming7147 4 года назад +1

    I think that the ai crew can pick up gear and when your boat sinks you can bail the water out and working life boats when your ships going down and there should be sandbanks and channels and the ai follow the channels and when you call for help a coast guard boat comes and tows you in and you can see the coast guard boat when you get towed in

  • @davidmccarthy7058
    @davidmccarthy7058 3 года назад +1

    I've always liked your reviews and this was no exception. You definitely sold this game, it looks awesome

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  3 года назад

      I hope they have finally delivered on their promises?

  • @themapleleafforever1526
    @themapleleafforever1526 4 года назад +1

    Aurora BORIALIS*. This is a good review, I wonder why the like bar is turned off.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад

      It's a pointless, easily exploitable interface which makes it an irrelevance. If you're easily swayed by it you shouldn't be. A video is either good, bad or indifferent & other peoples `opinions` should not sway that opinion...just saying/answering your question :-)

  • @LengthyEmperor
    @LengthyEmperor 2 года назад +1

    I have seen this game pop up on sale on my Xbox Dashboard. Didn’t know it existed until then. I do love my simulator games as a nice calm chill out time. After watching your review I think I will purchase this game

  • @ah13stu7
    @ah13stu7 4 года назад +1

    Thanks for your splendid thorough review. I, like you, would prefer a more simulation based game but I suppose it depends on what type of player the game makers are looking towards. I know it's not Britain but something along the lines of a shipping forecast where there are areas of sea that have differing weather and sea state giving added thinking of where to fish.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад

      Thank you, yes that would be excellent.

  • @paprika8795
    @paprika8795 2 года назад +1

    it's been pretty good after patches now. they work so hard and good communication with players.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  2 года назад

      Have they implemented wheel and controllers support yet?

  • @markgee2087
    @markgee2087 4 года назад +1

    I would’ve liked to have seen more mechanics like you said engines/gear breakdowns the ability’s to then fix it using different tools, the game it’s self is good but I think the developers could learn a thing or two watching a few seasons of deadliest catch or trawler wars this type of simulator has HUGE potential.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад +1

      It does, as did FBS, but this time they have built it to scale.

    • @markgee2087
      @markgee2087 4 года назад +1

      @@SimUKReviews I look forward to updates in the future, I’m hoping one day they release a fishing North Sea with scallop dredgers beam trawlers etc

  • @fishingforaliving1625
    @fishingforaliving1625 4 года назад

    Great video ! ,I currently fish from cornwall on an under 10M steel trawler, I have played the barent sea on Xbox and had completed all the achievements, unlocked all the boats etc. I think i will wait untill a few more bugs have been ironed out. i really think this game would benefit from a workshop system so people could help the devs improve the game. Fishing is HARD , i agree with what your saying. I wish series was as far along in progress as Farming Sim(also workshop improved). Thanks for the video, my first sub , keep it up. cheers

  • @Philminator
    @Philminator 3 года назад +1

    Great review as always. I was looking this up, because the enhanced edition just released on next gen consoles.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  3 года назад +1

      I fell out of love with this dev team, hope they have improved.

    • @Philminator
      @Philminator 3 года назад +1

      @@SimUKReviews I do too. I'm nervous yet excited to maybe try the PS5 version. If it wasn't $50 Canadian I would get it. It's only $30 on Steam.

  • @TheArkyCrew
    @TheArkyCrew 4 года назад +1

    It sounds like a hell of an improvement from the other game. I mean I love barrents sea. Anyway it's good to be back and dropping comments on your vids. I love your no bs way of breaking stuff down. So keep it up!

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад

      Cheers, yes if youre a fan of FBS this is an easy buy, just be patient with any bugs and save often! Lol

  • @RyTrapp0
    @RyTrapp0 4 года назад +1

    I find these games very frustrating - for as much as they get right(and it's a LOT), they just seem to have a low ceiling. Once you've experienced the boats that you've wanted to(some are just completely interesting to me) and upgraded them, then what's the point of continuing? Although I like the fishing, it gets a little repetitive and some way of making it feel more realistically 'unpredictable' would be a welcome improvement.
    The obvious solution is to expand the game to include even just a basic "business ownership" experience - think ETS2/ATS, just the ability to buy multiples of boats and hire captain & crew to run them. You could even have a system where long time crew can work their way up to captain as they gain experience. Have "home ports" for different boats with the ability to relocate them on the fly(maybe one port will have a really favorable short term sale rate, and you want to get a couple of boats hitting that port hard for the duration). Set schedules for your various boats, choose what each boat is fishing, make things like bait mix/type either a user choice or can be left up to the captain(maybe even allow them to over-bait, which you may find in the financials vs other boats in your fleet and you may need to correct that). Of course, a key part of this would have to include the occasional "issue"/mistake; crew(occasionally your most experienced crew too of course) get injured and need to be temporarily replaced, boats occasionally get damaged due to mistakes/heavy seas(re: more weather!), maybe even have the occasional problem with crewing not showing up on time, suggesting someone may need replacing.
    Obviously the basic ups and downs of economics would need to be implemented - it would be refreshing to have an economic downturn year of abnormally low prices that slash your income and require the player to make tough decisions to make it to the next season. While these ideas could get pretty complex pretty easily, I'm not suggesting that they have to be complex, simple & basic is fine as long as it's well implemented.
    These are pretty basic concepts that can be handled through a menu system, and I believe that the value added would easily surpass the work required to implement it - especially in long term replayability, having the desire expand a fleet and maximize your margins year over year is a nice open ended goal.
    As much as I enjoy both of the 'Fishing...' titles, I can't help but feel like it's just that last piece of depth that's missing. Money doesn't have value if there's nothing to spend it on, give us reasons to keep making money!

  • @cardiac71
    @cardiac71 3 года назад +1

    Very good review! Thanks.

  • @lonster-tc7es
    @lonster-tc7es 3 года назад +1

    I like the review and agree this game has serious potential. But the bugs are unnerving. I have the ps4 version. Yet the bugs are still there, I set 5 longlines 5000 hooks. Did my waiting 2 lines went blue so I waited another 4 hrs. During those 4hrs all me lines went blank. No fish, what have shaks eatten all my fish in 25hr? Not likely its bugs

  • @tommo2777
    @tommo2777 3 года назад +1

    I'm just finding it hard to use altogether it's takes so long for the guy to get from the steering wheel to the fishing deck

  • @bigq2014
    @bigq2014 4 года назад +2

    I hope in the future they add rogue waves if there isn’t any already

    • @bigq2014
      @bigq2014 4 года назад +1

      Also sim your not wrong I hope they add almost all of the things that you said they should keep up the good work ima subscribe to u

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад

      Thanks Big Q welcome!

  • @KiwiMace
    @KiwiMace 4 года назад +1

    Good thorough review again Sim. First half had me buying it immediately but not as convinced after reviewing the bugs/simplicity. However, overall it looks like fun and I'm likely to pick this up

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад

      I hope they will add hardcore mode, Multiplayer would be incredible.

  • @brucejohnson863
    @brucejohnson863 3 года назад +1

    I commercial fish I want storms we are the only boat out after 15 km winds

  • @lucasparker7964
    @lucasparker7964 3 года назад +1

    Can the Devs create a drowning update and if the boats do sink could you also do that thing when boats go underwater there is a suction hole when they go down so it sucks you under if you are y and X close.

  • @vforvitti
    @vforvitti 3 года назад +1

    Hiya Sim UK!!
    I got the game + DLC on xbox one and boy this one is really good!! Love it! Are you reviewing the new DLC?
    Cheers, mate and all good things!

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  3 года назад

      Glad you're enjoying the game!
      No I won't be reviewing the dlc.

  • @monkeyjackmonkeyjack3779
    @monkeyjackmonkeyjack3779 4 года назад +1

    good review and great work on the steering wheel and throttle suggestion to the devs. im also of the view of wanting a more simlike experience, especially bad weather! the arcade factor left a bad taste in my mouth from FBS. going to buy just for the fact that devs promised to include the steering wheel and throttle support. also as an ex fisherman that worked trawlers in the pacific and antartica out of NZ, this will bring some fond memories and maybe a couple of bad ones haha. cheers mate!

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад +1

      LOL Awesome.
      Be interested in your suggestions for the game?

    • @monkeyjackmonkeyjack3779
      @monkeyjackmonkeyjack3779 4 года назад +1

      @@SimUKReviews it would be nice to be able to reload a save without losing my crew.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад +1

      @@monkeyjackmonkeyjack3779 I think that might be asking a bit too much...lol

    • @monkeyjackmonkeyjack3779
      @monkeyjackmonkeyjack3779 4 года назад

      @@SimUKReviews its a bit of a shame really mate haha. was really hoping the weather would be a bit more umm weathery. the sea seems so flat like we are about to go on a pleasure cruise around the harbour. i want to ride those swells! i want to have to fight to get into harbour in bad weather while my ships overloaded and my crews grumpy because they want to get to the pub! check out greymouth grey river bar crossings in new zealand, thats want i want to have to fight to get into port. cheers mate

  • @otherreality
    @otherreality 3 года назад +1

    Not much into fishing, but this game looks to handle nice looking boats and sea travel. Is there any game with this level of graphics focused into sailing?

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  3 года назад

      Sailaway 2 is the closest atm.

    • @otherreality
      @otherreality 3 года назад +1

      @@SimUKReviews thx! Ill check it out!

  • @JFulls94
    @JFulls94 4 года назад +1

    They need to add the ability to moor with lines, even in the last game showed the mooring lines

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад +1

      Agreed

    • @JFulls94
      @JFulls94 4 года назад +1

      Do the Devs seem open to ideas Sim UK? As you say this could become something better than it already is.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад +2

      Yes absolutely, although they are no longer replying to my emails, either they are busy (which I understand) or they have taken offence to my comments....not sure which at this time.

  • @jaycep5521
    @jaycep5521 4 года назад +2

    i would like to see a shrimping dlc

  • @MrCaptainDietrich
    @MrCaptainDietrich 4 года назад +3

    i will love to see multiplayers that i can play with friends and i will love to see that i can create my oun actor and i will love to see diveing fishing and i. will love to see boats from movies like andre gail from movie perfect storm and will love to see killer storm and that you can lirn to make chooses keep on fishing true hurrican storm or runing home for savty and if boat sink that you can use life boats and life jackets and best of all if you hear mayday that u can leve fishing and go to help the boat in dangers

  • @jpht1964
    @jpht1964 4 года назад +3

    Multiplayer? I”ll be a Tuna...

  • @MrCaptainDietrich
    @MrCaptainDietrich 4 года назад +1

    o yes captan and crew must get ingert to help them ore take them to hospitel

  • @MrCaptainDietrich
    @MrCaptainDietrich 4 года назад

    all u plane i am with u on thats

  • @aszthrotep4632
    @aszthrotep4632 4 года назад +4

    First. Hoping for big storms, you get warnings about it on the radio(or you have to keep an eye on the sky). Im wondering how tedious it will be..

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад +2

      Yes + Radio Comms! Forgot to mention that one too.

    • @aszthrotep4632
      @aszthrotep4632 4 года назад +2

      @@SimUKReviews oh another thing that would be nice, at time hearing an SOS call and you will need to rescue people, using searchlight seeking people that fell overboard or ships sinking.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад +2

      Ah yes great idea. I was thinking about crew injuries and man overboard too.

    • @aszthrotep4632
      @aszthrotep4632 4 года назад +1

      @@SimUKReviews is there a guide somewhere? im going nut over how to prepare deepline fishing. I have the equipment but dont know how to prepare.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад +1

      @@aszthrotep4632 ill make some tuts tomorrow....for now.
      Long click on the bucket.
      Walk over to metal slide hanging off the back of the boat and long click...puts it on the floor.
      Then long click on it again to set.
      15-20 hours (fast travel takes longer) then when they pop or go blue haul them in.
      So you bought it then? 😀

  • @MrCaptainDietrich
    @MrCaptainDietrich 4 года назад +1

    and that we can paint your oun boat and re name as well

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад

      Renaming already works, but painting is needed

  • @53Aeromaster
    @53Aeromaster 4 года назад +1

    How is this game controlled if a wheel is not supported?

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад

      XB controller or K+M

    • @53Aeromaster
      @53Aeromaster 4 года назад +1

      @@SimUKReviews Would a Fanatec wheel work that is Xbox compatible?

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад

      @@53Aeromaster no, at the moment it requires an xbox emulator.

    • @53Aeromaster
      @53Aeromaster 4 года назад +1

      @@SimUKReviews I really appreciate your quick responses! I enjoy games with as much real simulation as possible. I just can't seem to figure out controlling a boat with a keyboard would be any fun or why a developer would think a keyboard is reasonable to use. Do I just do a search for an emulator? Is that a program needed to run in the background? Sorry to sound so ignorant, but all the simulation games I play my wheel works great...plug and play...very simple. Why is this game so difficult to get setup with a wheel? I really would like to purchase this game, but without wheel support I do not see it being very fun...just my opinion.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  4 года назад

      @@53Aeromaster x360ce. That's what I use but STEAM have their own built in version (bit clunky)

  • @cammi9948
    @cammi9948 2 года назад

    Would slap in VR

  • @adengsfx3218
    @adengsfx3218 4 года назад +1

    Amazing bro
    Like 🤝🙏😂

  • @kliefhamer
    @kliefhamer 4 года назад

    th egame is great and a lot of fun , but it runs very bad on my system, i have an i7 2700k @4.6ghz with 20gb ram and rtx 2060 and even on lowest settings its hard to keep up 60fps, is it my system or does the requirements list is just wrong on steam? fishing barrents sea had the same issues and i see they have not been ironed out yet. its a love hate relationship i have with the games.

  • @MrCaptainDietrich
    @MrCaptainDietrich 4 года назад +1

    one. more thing tornados and roge waves it all from dietrich

  • @taco-gc1ut
    @taco-gc1ut 4 года назад +1

    Hello

  • @samuelmacleod2553
    @samuelmacleod2553 4 года назад

    any idea on console release date?

  • @nflisrigged1395
    @nflisrigged1395 4 года назад

    Incredible

  • @demonsaint1296
    @demonsaint1296 8 месяцев назад

    Be nice to fish out of Newfoundland.

  • @limitededition3295
    @limitededition3295 2 года назад

    Does on ps4 have the same big wawes and feature as pc?

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  2 года назад

      Fishing North Atlantic does not have Big waves.

    • @limitededition3295
      @limitededition3295 2 года назад +1

      @@SimUKReviews but i have seen videos witj preety big im not saying like 50m

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  2 года назад

      Maybe they listened and increased them?

    • @limitededition3295
      @limitededition3295 2 года назад

      @@SimUKReviews well i don't know im thinking buying it

    • @limitededition3295
      @limitededition3295 2 года назад +1

      @@SimUKReviews also have question how many boats there are

  • @PapaSeoul
    @PapaSeoul 2 года назад +1

    The lobster tutorial is wrought with errors, it quickly diminishes enthusiasm for the game. What a horrible 1st impression, be aware/beware until patched.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  2 года назад

      Still?
      You shoukd watch my last review on this game..........

  • @breakingbaz7709
    @breakingbaz7709 3 года назад +1

    I prefer Barent Sea I’ve played 4 hrs of this and it terrible.

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  3 года назад +1

      Agreed : ruclips.net/video/fx91XlLkOA0/видео.html

  • @kenrubengjerde9971
    @kenrubengjerde9971 4 года назад

    Been playing 3 hours now and havent seen a single fish..... so i think the game is a joke!!!!!! Big dissepointment

  • @nelsonbolduc7751
    @nelsonbolduc7751 3 года назад +1

    IM NOT SURE its better than bering sea

    • @SimUKReviews
      @SimUKReviews  3 года назад

      In some ways it is...but not all ways :-)

  • @AdhdGamerDadPro
    @AdhdGamerDadPro 4 года назад +1

    Multiplayer

  • @MrCaptainDietrich
    @MrCaptainDietrich 4 года назад

    i wont simulator live on game it can lirn u how to be a save and good captain and you are rite more harder must be poet on game

  • @yorkshirepud6676
    @yorkshirepud6676 4 года назад +1

    Come on nothing said about the hover boat DLC if your going to do a review do it right MrSim !!!