Talking Aliens with NASA UAP Chair, David Spergel

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 фев 2025

Комментарии • 4,8 тыс.

  • @StarTalk
    @StarTalk  Месяц назад +139

    Go to ground.news/startalk to stay fully informed on the latest Space and Science news. Subscribe through our link for 50% off unlimited access to the Vantage plan this month.

    • @CaptainBuggyTheClown
      @CaptainBuggyTheClown Месяц назад +18

      ground news invokes "AI" as a catch for investors and ultimately contributes to the AI slop we're seeing ruin the internet.

    • @My-Pal-Hal
      @My-Pal-Hal Месяц назад +1

      WAIT JUST A DOG GONE MINUTE ! ! !
      I thought for the sake of being Concise. It was "Anomalous" not Aerial. Because of the trans medium nature of Unidentified Anomalous Phenomenon like UFO's and USO's.
      .... maybe check that device in your pockets, mines an android, and NASA says my data is Correct , amateurs 😂

    • @My-Pal-Hal
      @My-Pal-Hal Месяц назад +6

      For a show you say is all about being Correct.
      Then Diss those Android devices in your pocket.
      MY ANDROID DEVICE SAYS YOU'RE ALL INCORRECT !!!
      Because my understanding is it's Anomalous, not Aerial. Because of the trans medium nature of the Unidentified Anomalous Phenomenon.
      And NASA AGREES WITH ME 😂
      .... amateurs

    • @carencyclopediachannel
      @carencyclopediachannel Месяц назад +1

      10 minutes into it and you guys missed two important points. 1. no money for the app is a lame or lack of imagination excuse. Crowdfund it, I bet millions and millions of people would contribute to it, especially if it will be public. 2, No one asked the question, about him at NASA checking the data! What data, the one leaked and public, or all the data that Pentagon stated in the congress hearing that it has and it is classified?

    • @StayFractalesque
      @StayFractalesque Месяц назад +1

      stop conflating UFOs with ALIENs you BOTs

  • @GuitarsimpleOfficial
    @GuitarsimpleOfficial Месяц назад +310

    So… Let me get this straight … As renowned scientists, since you can not explain what are the vehicles that outmaneuver Top Gun pilots with their ultra high tech planes, you suggest they are Chinese drones ? … what happened to physics ? … No wings, no exhaust, no noise, no speed limit, from air to underwater. I though this was a physics channel. Why don’t you use physics and try to match that to Chinese drones ?? … or is that too much to ask ?? … Maybe it’s not aliens but whatever it is … it’s not subject to the laws of physics.

    • @jameskelly8506
      @jameskelly8506 Месяц назад +17

      If aliens were smart enough to get here from another planet, light years away, why bother with us?

    • @DouglasRose-v5h
      @DouglasRose-v5h Месяц назад +35

      Bottom line if you can't explain it he is on one side. Truth is he doesn't know and he's afraid to investigate rather than admit that he doesn't know🎉

    • @Steven-lb4bl
      @Steven-lb4bl Месяц назад

      @@jameskelly8506ask them👽

    • @Kadji-q7m
      @Kadji-q7m Месяц назад +13

      You still don't know what the phenomenon is. You can't simply just conclude about what they are when you have no idea what they are.

    • @khaledelmosrati9251
      @khaledelmosrati9251 Месяц назад

      ​​He did admit that there is something going on but we do not fully understand it.
      The problem is that he is jumping to saying conclusive statements and at the same time he is asking for more data. ​@@DouglasRose-v5h

  • @WillieBilliie
    @WillieBilliie Месяц назад +162

    THE GAS LIGHTING HERE IS CRAZY BRO

    • @tashles
      @tashles Месяц назад +20

      Blatantly manipulative

    • @nickboi9740
      @nickboi9740 Месяц назад

      right. ain't no way he a jew

    • @sbabymoney3204
      @sbabymoney3204 Месяц назад +6

      Can you name another time this channel has gaslit you?

    • @Camera1production
      @Camera1production Месяц назад

      ​@sbabymoney3204 any time aliens are brought up, they cannot fathom that it's happening. So, these guys say contradictions all of the time. Space is pretty much infinite but life is rare because we haven't seen it yet, yet another alien race, maybe the only other in the entire universe, wouldn't be interested in us, and their tech couldn't possibly be more advanced to detect us before we detect them.

    • @WillieBilliie
      @WillieBilliie Месяц назад +6

      @sbabymoney3204 nah just this one

  • @bigmacpattywakk
    @bigmacpattywakk Месяц назад +9

    28:07 love how Neil and Chuck completely pivoted after this guy said “the military’s job is to protect the country.” Neil said “uh huh” 😂

    • @zackscoooy
      @zackscoooy 29 дней назад +2

      27:50 you're welcome 😅

    • @davidcombs97
      @davidcombs97 28 дней назад +2

      @@zackscoooy "we would like more data about the tic tac"(tic tac was captured from military technology) "lets set up an app where everyone takes a picture and uploads it" 5:00 "if you look at these more carefully, theyre camera defects" but lets use everyones phone to collect data that we don't trust!

    • @zackscoooy
      @zackscoooy 28 дней назад

      @@davidcombs97 thanks

  • @bagelssmellgreat
    @bagelssmellgreat Месяц назад +47

    Throughout years of listening and watching, I am so proud of Lord Nice. He has continued to impress with his comedic presence and intellectual excitement. Thank you for showing us what continuous curiosity looks like.

  • @Silvia6
    @Silvia6 Месяц назад +229

    Merry christmas and happy holidays Neil ❤ and Chuck 🎉

    • @Amsterdam-s4s
      @Amsterdam-s4s Месяц назад +2

      It's a pegan day!

    • @alfadog67
      @alfadog67 Месяц назад +1

      @@Amsterdam-s4s 2 weeks in my neighborhood!

    • @David-fr9ve
      @David-fr9ve Месяц назад +1

      Sycophant 🙄

    • @penny6484
      @penny6484 Месяц назад +6

      Merry Christmas 🎄

    • @EJ-74
      @EJ-74 Месяц назад +6

      @@Amsterdam-s4sIt’s actually what ever you want it to be 🤷🏼‍♂️

  • @joshual7671
    @joshual7671 Месяц назад +65

    I thought that mustache was illegal 😅

    • @Hombrew778
      @Hombrew778 Месяц назад

      😂😂

    • @ceo-te6ro
      @ceo-te6ro Месяц назад +2

      was looking for this comment

    • @idh9395
      @idh9395 Месяц назад +4

      It should be.

    • @MaBtrrip
      @MaBtrrip 27 дней назад +11

      maybe he likes charlie chaplin

    • @tmi_7
      @tmi_7 27 дней назад +1

      He's got the little goatee. He knows if he's gonna have that moustache, he has to have the rest. Can't have that moustache and clean everywhere else 🤣🤣🤣

  • @rhesreeves5339
    @rhesreeves5339 Месяц назад +22

    I love that Chuck's voice goes up 3 octaves when hearing about the deepest bass note ever. The wavelength as long as the universe.🤯

  • @suki9
    @suki9 Месяц назад +125

    Why not talk about the credible 1% UAP's?

    • @Nostromo2144
      @Nostromo2144 Месяц назад

      Can't talk much about stuff that you don't have enough data about, which needs to be scientifically gathered and analysed. Did IQs just drop sharply while I was away...? I would actually argue that crowd-sourcing it is a bad idea - the signal to noise ratio will probably drop from 1% to 0.0001% lol!

    • @randallbesch2424
      @randallbesch2424 Месяц назад +20

      Yes tell us why they are credible and remain unknown.

    • @RECTALBURRITO
      @RECTALBURRITO 29 дней назад +12

      Explain what you mean when you said "credible".

    • @Nostromo2144
      @Nostromo2144 29 дней назад

      @@suki9 seems the tin foil brigade is out in full force, now demanding dictionary definitions lol! I'm sure dictionaries are another way for Big Brother to control the population - evil gubments!
      For the hard of hearing/viewing/listening, with basic reading comprehension disorder: 'credible' means the phenomena haven't been definitively explained or debunked. They could still be anything, even little green men, but no proof either way has been found or provided. Here endeth the lesson.

    • @ghost9x308
      @ghost9x308 29 дней назад +18

      He said that in that one percent they didn’t see anything conclusive because they data they had was too poor

  • @wowzee898
    @wowzee898 Месяц назад +20

    Happy Holidays to the StarTalk team and all the people who enjoy these episodes.

  • @universootn
    @universootn Месяц назад +7

    Le tengo mucha admiración a usted Neil deGrasse Tyson por lo excelente de sus análisis y conocimientos. Saludos desde Puerto Rico / I have great admiration for you Neil deGrasse Tyson for the excellence of your analysis and knowledge. Greetings from Puerto Rico

  • @TinaJesse859
    @TinaJesse859 День назад +1

    Whenever you have guys like this discussing UFO’s they very rarely ever attend to recent videos and higher quality footage. They always discuss it from a 1980’s perspective .

    • @fabianmckenna8197
      @fabianmckenna8197 11 часов назад

      Bring up the evidence in high quality footage if it's around but all I ever see is blurry out of focus work.
      Considering we all carry smartphones easily capable of snapping decent video and photos, it's surprising that nothing has shown up on WhatsApp, Facebook, Instagram, TicToc etc.
      Watched a very interesting video about the Navy tic tac UAP's etc and they explained all the fast movement, sharp turns etc by "focusing" on the camera systems and lenses used.
      Remember there are several cameras, thermal detectors etc all switching between close up and zooms.
      Made a lot of sense instead of believing the aliens travel for at least five years just to buzz our fighters, abduct a few farmers, subject them to various tests then return them "unharmed "

  • @MrWizardGG
    @MrWizardGG Месяц назад +18

    Merry Christmas Neil & Chuck

  • @MStreppelhoff
    @MStreppelhoff Месяц назад +16

    "Three people can keep a secret... if two of them are dead..."... Thats so funny :D

    • @dandan9603
      @dandan9603 Месяц назад +2

      and very true

    • @razdillinger3852
      @razdillinger3852 Месяц назад +2

      Manhattan project refutes this to a large extent (compartmentalized info) , at least while it was happening.

    • @sweetpuppies1065
      @sweetpuppies1065 Месяц назад +2

      @@razdillinger3852The USSR was getting information about the atomic bomb before it was finished.

    • @patrickford396
      @patrickford396 Месяц назад +2

      @@sweetpuppies1065but the US population wasn’t getting that info. No one is saying that the UAP reality isn’t known by Russia.

    • @randallbesch2424
      @randallbesch2424 Месяц назад

      Then the psychic and necromancer got the information from the deceased.

  • @PrognosisGnosis
    @PrognosisGnosis Месяц назад +7

    Neil’s updated take on being open to discussing UAP and NHI is refreshing. I think many of his fans are relieved that he’s considering this as part of the scientific conversation.

    • @tragoamorepaixao
      @tragoamorepaixao 19 дней назад +2

      relieved? this guy is a genius when it comes to physics and chemistry… and he didn’t use ANY of that knowledge to discuss the plausibility of those cases… I’m actually truly ashamed of him. Just a bunch of elderly speaking about their own opinions of the cases…

    • @BradleyChetty
      @BradleyChetty 17 дней назад

      ​@@tragoamorepaixaobecause he knows that our laws of physics and chemistry don't apply to them and their tech

    • @tragoamorepaixao
      @tragoamorepaixao 17 дней назад

      @@BradleyChetty that doesn’t matter at all, he knows all he needs to know to SAY why those cases defy physics, give us better examples, use his best advantage (knowledge) to make a truly interesting video with a technical vision about thoses cases, look at what he did instead…

    • @Groux504
      @Groux504 14 дней назад

      ​@tragoamorepaixao his take on the subject is very condescending if you ask me👎🏿

    • @RidingDirtyAdventures
      @RidingDirtyAdventures 11 дней назад

      sadly the reality is he is simply jumping on the bandwagon and doesn't actually believe in extraterrestrial or inner-terrestrial nor dimensional beings...

  • @SemiPerfectDark
    @SemiPerfectDark 29 дней назад +1

    At 53:00, I love Chuck's reaction during this sequence. He looks like he's going to cry in awe of science.

  • @francescomarano1977
    @francescomarano1977 Месяц назад +13

    startalk on christmas eve....thank you!

  • @theresamcpherson7352
    @theresamcpherson7352 Месяц назад +14

    Thank you Dr.Neil, Lord Nice and Dr.David Spergel. Happy Holidays to All!

  • @skelapus
    @skelapus Месяц назад +17

    We would love to see you and Steven Greer talk to each other. That would be great interview he is the Aficionado on these drones and well-known to be. What do you think about an interview with him we would all like to see that I think I don't know if I really can't speak for everybody but the people paying attention all this he's coming forward on the as the aficionado very publicly

    • @WookiRahh
      @WookiRahh Месяц назад

      hahahahha good luck with that this tyrant (NDT) wouldnt do a legit interview without motives you got to be kidding me right hahaha

    • @dolce1248
      @dolce1248 Месяц назад

      Steven Greer is a ufologist who believes a wide range of conspiracy theories including that our government is controlled by aliens. I admit it would be interesting, but I wouldn’t consider him an aficionado UAPs, nobody knows what it is so calling someone an expert, especially Steve Greer….is hard for me to fathom.

    • @LeighRobinsonBushcraft
      @LeighRobinsonBushcraft Месяц назад +1

      That you Steven?

    • @John-i5c3m
      @John-i5c3m Месяц назад

      Preparing for a new false flag operation by introducing a confusing array of drones, UAPs, UFOS that morf into planes and drones, ext. To confuse the masses then announce that we are being attached by aliens to create a war.

    • @SteveBradshaw-pm2im
      @SteveBradshaw-pm2im Месяц назад

      Dr Greer will get his “litmus” test sometime in the next 8 weeks or so (Jan/Feb 2025) He has publicly said that insider whistleblowers are coming forward to blow the lid off the UAP story. Why now? Because of recent legislation protecting them from reporting info about UAPs. If it doesn’t happen then so much for Dr Greer.

  • @VFR800MOVIE
    @VFR800MOVIE Месяц назад

    😂 I laugh my pants off at 4:48 when Neil made his comment on classification.

  • @petersinclair3997
    @petersinclair3997 Месяц назад +11

    Australia’s JORN radar can surveil thousands of square kilometres at one time. No sightings reported there.

    • @Nostromo2144
      @Nostromo2144 Месяц назад

      I wonder why that is...? Perhaps us Ossies aren't paranoid enough to believe the truth is out there? ;)

    • @randallbesch2424
      @randallbesch2424 Месяц назад +3

      these things can be RADAR invisible.

    • @kanaric
      @kanaric 29 дней назад

      @@randallbesch2424 Sure they can. ITS A CONSPIRACY. IT DIDNT FIND WHAT I WANTED SO CONSPIRACY

    • @GioYoLOL
      @GioYoLOL 28 дней назад +1

      ​@@Nostromo2144I would love to see alien proof but I have enough things to worry about on the ground to worry about unseen things. I love looking at the sky though!

  • @michaelfleming4015
    @michaelfleming4015 Месяц назад +20

    I once saw a lightning ball on the back porch of my parents house in Miami. It flew onto the porch, hovered for several seconds and then flew out again. So cool!

    • @TOPHITTA463
      @TOPHITTA463 22 дня назад +1

      That was me😅

    • @grandpawshepdog2942
      @grandpawshepdog2942 19 дней назад

      Its called a firefly. A good bug zapper will take care of it.

    • @jesse7644
      @jesse7644 18 дней назад

      Super heated spasma from a lightning strike. DONT touch it

  • @JoaoRenatoBezerra
    @JoaoRenatoBezerra Месяц назад +20

    UAP was originally designed to be Unidentified "Aerial" Phenomena. However, per Luis Elizondo's book IMMINENT, they renamed UAP to Unidentified "Anomalous" Phenomena (keeping the same acronym), after discovering that big part of the cases also covered under-water and air-water incidents. This simple change captures a broader picture of the Phenomena.

  • @Ludeo
    @Ludeo Месяц назад +1

    And you must be the monopoly guy! Psst! Thanks for the free parking!

  • @PG_Boeske87
    @PG_Boeske87 Месяц назад +13

    loved the dark matter and energy casual chat 😊The beauty of sience is not knowing how stuff works, but making educated (philosophical) guesses about it and keep the wondering alive

    • @NameForgotten1
      @NameForgotten1 Месяц назад

      There is less evidence for the existence of Dark Matter than there is for visitation. Let that sink in friend. Dark Matter is still pure math and we have not been able to experimentally confirm it's existence. Dark Matter should be treated with the same skepticism as visitation until we know more.

    • @randallbesch2424
      @randallbesch2424 Месяц назад

      Dark matter holds the galaxy together, dark energy separates it.

    • @NameForgotten1
      @NameForgotten1 Месяц назад

      @ and we have zero scientific experimentation that proves either. They are bo better than religion as an explanation. They could be real, or we may abandon them as we discover new information.

  • @ShopWorker-gi7uv
    @ShopWorker-gi7uv Месяц назад +6

    I’m not a scientist but even if there isn’t proof of extraterrestrials it seems to me that app would still be useful in keeping track of whoever is flying whatever in our air spaces.

  • @bibihunden
    @bibihunden Месяц назад +12

    A little tip. If we are going to use the camera in our smartphones to document what is happening up in the sky, it assumes that we turn autofocus OFF. Blurred images are of no use, and DO NOT use digital zoom, and try to hold the phone steady.

    • @JROD082384
      @JROD082384 Месяц назад +2

      How about you go first and show all of the simpletons you condescended to how it's done since you are such an amazing god-tier expert at smartphone photography???

    • @Nostromo2144
      @Nostromo2144 Месяц назад +4

      @@JROD082384 he just told you...does he need to teach you reading comprehension as well...? ;-p

    • @CardboardProphet
      @CardboardProphet 15 дней назад

      There is nothing

  • @LaSpookyEXE
    @LaSpookyEXE 13 дней назад

    Can’t believe he has a podcast I’m definitely running in everyday

  • @Iblametryss222
    @Iblametryss222 Месяц назад +16

    I’ve been waiting for a episode W neillll for so long lets goooo and u got chuck nice in here too 🔥🔥

  • @Starfals
    @Starfals 22 дня назад +8

    The ball of lightning thing is really scary. It happened to me and my family when i was 18. We were just watching TV (the whole family) and then this big lightning ball came in thru the window and just sat there. Sitting in the middle of the room, as we slowly tried to escape from it. Later on (when the thing was gone) the whole room was burned and had scratch marks.
    Insanely scary phenomenon.

    • @Evoque2020
      @Evoque2020 18 дней назад +1

      😱😱 scary,unforgettable and extraordinary experiences
      it came in through the window glass? 😱😱

    • @deluxetransport3208
      @deluxetransport3208 День назад

      What?

  • @MistaWu
    @MistaWu Месяц назад +4

    Your talks are always enligtening, especially those little clarifications/explainers you do on the little stuff...
    I agree with Chuck, with all these beautiful and super intelligent ways and tools designed and built to understand our universe, how can one not love science...

  • @cl4udioiturra
    @cl4udioiturra Месяц назад +18

    Dr.Neil, thanks so much for this awesome Christmas gift............

  • @mike814031
    @mike814031 13 дней назад

    6:34 I love how Neil asks all the really interesting questions like the details I love to know about but didn't know were there and I wouldn't even think to ask, but then again I'm no professional lol so there's that. But I love his videos, infact I wish he explained more into those technically interesting details that are fun to know about like I didn't know our phones had to correct for that (the magnetic anomaly). it's fun to know why things work the way they do.

  • @marhnat8526
    @marhnat8526 Месяц назад +10

    I'm really glad I had the chance to see a large UFO with my own eyes, along with six other people. If I hadn’t experienced it myself, I might have doubted their existence. While I don’t automatically believe everything, I try to keep an open mind and don’t dismiss others' experiences.

    • @Jrizzle7
      @Jrizzle7 14 дней назад +1

      100% agree. I saw my first last july, 2024. Christchurch newzealand. People need to see to believe, I did. Changed the way I look at the world

  • @santos010
    @santos010 Месяц назад +3

    Guys!! Thank you for this great interview.

  • @Winsane
    @Winsane Месяц назад +10

    Those eyebrows are out of this world and I love them

    • @fathersoftorque73
      @fathersoftorque73 Месяц назад +5

      It's the choice of mustache style that has me wondering why

    • @gerryst-aubin5877
      @gerryst-aubin5877 Месяц назад +1

      They are attached to his glasses!

  • @yurihuertavasquez9544
    @yurihuertavasquez9544 Месяц назад +1

    Great interview, like Socrates “ I only know that I know nothing “ . But I always say that the advance of science is unstoppable. I like very much this interview. Greetings from Panamá 🇵🇦

  • @luna-kiva
    @luna-kiva Месяц назад +8

    “Measure what is measurable, and figure out how to measure what is unmeasurable” - Galileo 🧔🏼‍♂️.
    I look forward to the day scientists learn how to measure consciousness, feelings, memories, emotions, dreams, out of body experiences, hallucinations, love, visions, spiritual experiences, NDEs, astral travel, and all other subjective experience that no amount of objective study can measure.
    “You should not ignore things you don’t understand.” - David Spergel 🥸.
    I love this show.

    • @TheSkyHive
      @TheSkyHive 21 день назад

      If we lived in a world free of greed I would be excited by your comment,however I am more fearful because you know they will use it to further exploit and control us.

  • @MBighk
    @MBighk Месяц назад +35

    Seems you've avoided the really interesting and unexplainable cases. For example, USS Nimitz incident, 2004. Broad daylight with perfect seeing conditions over the Pacific off the coast near San Diego. Objects tracked on radar and infrared and seen visually by five expert witnesses (highly trained pilots). Object moved from 80,000 ft. to sea level in one second with no shock wave. Pilots witnessed object zip away at hypersonic speeds while ship-board radar tracked it.
    Also, assigning human motivations to non-human entities is a violation of behavioral science methods.

    • @toby9999
      @toby9999 22 дня назад +1

      The fact that they're unexplainable makes them uninteresting. What would you want to say about an unexplainable thing? Perhaps "i can't explain it". I don't get it.

    • @MBighk
      @MBighk 20 дней назад +3

      @@toby9999 Avi Loeb mentioned a colleague who said he "wished Ommuamua didn't exist." Too many scientists would rather stay in their comfort zones than have to admit the world doesn't work the way they think it does.

    • @SkaliasPablo
      @SkaliasPablo 18 дней назад +2

      My man really said "why would I want to be curious?" on a science podcast lmao

    • @johnbyrnes7912
      @johnbyrnes7912 2 дня назад +1

      Unfortunately the standard response from those concerned with status is to misdirect and obfuscate rather than engage and open resistance and abuse ! 🤡

    • @kevinaustin0369
      @kevinaustin0369 День назад

      Exactly what I was thinking about. The speed they traveled can’t be ignored. Although they did here. It’s undeniable, recorded and witnessed. And we certainly do not have capability to do so.

  • @MarkB8903
    @MarkB8903 Месяц назад +5

    Wow, very interesting. I have been watching Neil deGrasse and the cast content for many years even the tv series. I have seen every episode. Neil and Chuck Nice are a good mix.

  • @lordman
    @lordman 14 часов назад

    This has been an amazing episode!! What an ending!!!

  • @estarlinmartori9607
    @estarlinmartori9607 Месяц назад +6

    We need a 2nd interview just need to invite Dr. Steven Greer looking forward to this one

    • @SteveBradshaw-pm2im
      @SteveBradshaw-pm2im Месяц назад

      Dr Greer will get his “litmus” test sometime in the next 8 weeks or so (Jan/Feb 25). Emboldened by recent congressional legislation protecting UAP whistle blowers, he has been saying that around a dozen “insiders” with access to real data about alien technology and biology are coming forward to blow the lid off the UFO/UAP story. If that does not occur, then Dr Greer is full of, well, you know. Time will tell.

  • @kneekoo
    @kneekoo Месяц назад +34

    27:52 _"The military's job is to protect the country, their job is not to study unidentified scientific phenomena."_
    Quite interesting how "scientific" was plugged in there, to make it easy for people to agree that the military is supposed to do military stuff, not science stuff. And most people wouldn't bat an eye at that, except that the military actually does a lot of research/science. If he said unidentified *aerial* phenomena, then that would immediately catch more people's attention because the US pilots are supposed to investigate potential aerial threats in the US airspace.

    • @mauricebutlerfootballnewsa7566
      @mauricebutlerfootballnewsa7566 Месяц назад +4

      If the unidentified scientific phenomenon is a potential national security threat than it becomes the military job

    • @jetjazz05
      @jetjazz05 29 дней назад

      JANAP 146E makes it mandatory to report ALL unidentified flying objects as it's a matter of national security, and because of this it's subject to the espionage act if you ever speak about it, even after retirement.
      They literally put it on the books to make it their job to do exactly what he's saying they don't, and then they made it an act of espionage to mention it to anyone after filing your report.

    • @Alexander_Kale
      @Alexander_Kale 22 дня назад

      The idea that the military would just be fine with letting UFOs operate freely within the airspace of the states is bonkers. Of course they would investigate.

  • @Borgone107
    @Borgone107 Месяц назад +4

    Merry Christmas 🎁 Neil and Chuck you guys are awesome. Keep teaching and always keep looking up!

  • @jfreshh330
    @jfreshh330 29 дней назад +1

    Why does my man Neil just casually have a sword in his office 😂

  • @adityaagrawal1562
    @adityaagrawal1562 Месяц назад +7

    Merry christmas to all 🎉🎉🎄🎄🎁🎁

  • @tompfeiffer2755
    @tompfeiffer2755 Месяц назад +3

    Probably the greatest, mind blowing episode ever!

  • @robertbaico8484
    @robertbaico8484 Месяц назад +5

    Thank you for the bright updates , I wish you a blessed new year!

  • @shayshay5928
    @shayshay5928 Месяц назад

    I love how Neil interrupts to ask the questions a brain like mine needs to keep up with the conversation lol

  • @lukeyellowtail1145
    @lukeyellowtail1145 Месяц назад +5

    Id like to see people like Garry Nolan or avi loeb on star talk.

    • @darcosan
      @darcosan 19 дней назад +1

      You'll never see Gary Nolan on Start Talk. He very much hates Neil de Grasse

  • @NVD-el3of
    @NVD-el3of Месяц назад +22

    Sooo NASA’s UAP chair watched “some of but not all” of the congress’s UAP hearings….right

    • @sweetpuppies1065
      @sweetpuppies1065 Месяц назад +2

      Did you listen to all that boring nonsense? I zoned out after the “credible witness” said he couldn’t tell because it was classified.

    • @JROD082384
      @JROD082384 Месяц назад +7

      ​@sweetpuppies1065
      You are aware that if you break SCI confidentiality, even as a whistleblower, you go to federal prison, right?
      You have to be given special amnesty, which the DoD and the White House must approve, to properly whistleblow all the secrets...

    • @sweetpuppies1065
      @sweetpuppies1065 Месяц назад +1

      @ That dude got invited to speak in front of Congress. He was granted immunity yet he didn’t say anything, provided no evidence, he just told some stories. I’m calling BS.

    • @likeasoldier777
      @likeasoldier777 Месяц назад +1

      Just another bro who doesn’t believe anything but what they want to be true?

    • @msn769
      @msn769 27 дней назад

      As it should be, most scientists know Congress is a dog and pony show, with barely a brain fart among them, so why bother?

  • @matthewsfamily900
    @matthewsfamily900 Месяц назад +21

    And why do we assume visible light for aliens is in the same range of electromagnetic radiation as it is for us anyway?

    • @Zaviex
      @Zaviex Месяц назад +3

      Well it wouldn’t be light. They might have extra range on either side but the longer wavelengths are absorbed as heat and you wouldn’t see anything if they were there. The shorter ones, would be visible initially but then they’d simply pass through matter which in the same way wouldn’t reflect anything for any creature to see. So they could be different but they’d be in the same general area

    • @utubefordan
      @utubefordan Месяц назад +1

      Where did someone suggest that aliens see what we do....

    • @rexsheldon
      @rexsheldon Месяц назад

      To that affect, aliens may not even realize they’re emitting light that we can see. But it’s suspicious that it’s red and green lights lol

    • @JROD082384
      @JROD082384 Месяц назад +1

      They assume a lot more things than they realize, and that's why Neil and his guests almost always arrive at the most incorrect conclusions regarding the UAP topic...

    • @randallbesch2424
      @randallbesch2424 Месяц назад

      @@rexsheldon emitting light? Humans do that too.

  • @thilaakj7274
    @thilaakj7274 Месяц назад +1

    54:08 is me every episode

  • @DirtBoyTrucker
    @DirtBoyTrucker Месяц назад +4

    Niel is already the most interesting guy to listen to, but to have an equal come on and blow minds even more is amazing. Chuck is perfect at reacting the way all of us should. Just FUUUUUUU... JEEEEEEZZZ... AND THATS THE SHOW! LOL. I could listen to this stuff wether I get it or not, for literally hours and not be bored. Thanks guys!!!

  • @Jellofreeze
    @Jellofreeze Месяц назад +8

    We had drones back in the 80s. It's very weird that they have been re-branded as this modern achievement.

  • @jshauns
    @jshauns Месяц назад +7

    I'm skeptical by nature, especially about ET's and all that business. But this video is clearly meant to 'hush-down' any chatter on the internet about UAP's.
    That's all. "Checking Data" quality? Like what?
    "Trust me, Bro. I'm with the government" -David Spergel.

  • @viniciusdelimaalvim2670
    @viniciusdelimaalvim2670 3 дня назад

    Can't overstate how much I love this show! Keep looking up! ^^

  • @Nathan333K
    @Nathan333K Месяц назад +7

    I love the language they speak, in order for a person to appreciate this type of videos and information, they have to be thirsty for knowledge 😅

    • @randallbesch2424
      @randallbesch2424 Месяц назад +1

      And ready to do research on their own too.

  • @teresagalvin1687
    @teresagalvin1687 Месяц назад +3

    Love this show!

  • @richkroberts
    @richkroberts Месяц назад +8

    Very enjoyable. Great show Neil and Chuck.

  • @Vectrex-pi5ib
    @Vectrex-pi5ib 29 дней назад

    9:19 "Dr Spock" - 9:29 "On this show we have to be very accurate about that" - Hey hey! Doctor???!

  • @robGwaldo
    @robGwaldo Месяц назад +14

    Chuck holding it together during a gas joke opportunity is crazy

  • @tunertransformationreturns9497
    @tunertransformationreturns9497 Месяц назад +3

    Brilliant session gentlemen. Thank you.

  • @PaulMollon
    @PaulMollon Месяц назад +4

    Guys, thanks again for such a wonderful podcast👍👏😃

  • @Alrhodes322
    @Alrhodes322 27 дней назад

    Neil and chuck asking Dr robotnik about his newest invention to catch sonic!?!? Now this is the star talk I've been waiting on!

  • @theunluckycharm9637
    @theunluckycharm9637 Месяц назад +13

    Chuck has improved

  • @enigma70x
    @enigma70x Месяц назад +10

    Scientists do not believe in blind faith. They need proof, not falsehoods.💡

    • @EducateCuriosity
      @EducateCuriosity Месяц назад +1

      It’s impossible to not have blind faith.

    • @randallbesch2424
      @randallbesch2424 Месяц назад

      @@EducateCuriosity says you?

    • @randallbesch2424
      @randallbesch2424 Месяц назад

      Correct since blind faith is ignorance.

    • @EducateCuriosity
      @EducateCuriosity Месяц назад

      @@randallbesch2424 just an observation of reality, you wake up every morning presuming your day is going to be the way you planned. Do you think a single person has died fully aware of their destiny prior to the situation? Of course not 99% of our lives is blind faith.

    • @jetjazz05
      @jetjazz05 29 дней назад

      What's a hypothesis? A hypothesis is a testable statement or educated guess that proposes a potential explanation for a phenomenon or a relationship between variables.
      If you test a hypothesis and fail, does this mean the hypothesis is incorrect? No, a failure to produce results from testing does not necessarily mean the hypothesis is false; it may indicate that the testing method, conditions, or sample size were inadequate.
      Pseudoskepticism is the dismissal of ideas or claims without proper investigation, often driven by bias or a refusal to consider evidence that challenges one's beliefs.

  • @MrRandomPlays_1987
    @MrRandomPlays_1987 Месяц назад +12

    29:50 - I once saw such ball of light crashing onto my balcony's floor, it was so crazy, saw it like a meter away from me from within my house, it was a stormy weather type of day and it was raining I think, thank god I did not go outside else I don't wanna think what could happen, it even left a black burn marks on the floor outside, it was gigantic in size, about almost one meter long diameter and it was all full of lightnings inside that made it white/blue in color or something, it was like 15 - 20 years ago maybe so I don't recall exactly but yeah most of it I can recall and it was so crazy.

    • @THome92
      @THome92 Месяц назад +2

      That makes no sense. At all.
      Balcony
      Crash
      Gigantic
      1 meter
      Black mark
      Sounds like it should have nuked your balcony.

    • @vonNeumannProbed
      @vonNeumannProbed Месяц назад +2

      Sounds like ball lightning, which has been enter/occur in homes and leave similar markings. Completely natural phenomenon, albeit rare.

    • @MrRandomPlays_1987
      @MrRandomPlays_1987 Месяц назад +1

      @@vonNeumannProbed Yeah, it was most likely what he described but its extremely rare once in a lifetime kind of thing that can happen to see such thing for a small percentage of people, I am both super lucky to see it that close but also super lucky to not get hit by it thankfully thank god.

    • @MrRandomPlays_1987
      @MrRandomPlays_1987 Месяц назад

      @@THome92 Why not? why would I lie? one meter is gigantic for such ball of lightning at least in my eyes it felt pretty big to witness infront of me, well as for the black marks it left, it was actually logical for it not to cause too much damage and only to leave the burning marks on the floor the same size of it which was an almost one meter long burning marks from it.

    • @vonNeumannProbed
      @vonNeumannProbed Месяц назад

      @@MrRandomPlays_1987 It may be once in a lifetime for you, however 1 in 20 people approximately have seen ball lightning in their life. I would hardly call that rare.

  • @sewerbat4634
    @sewerbat4634 15 дней назад

    using the general public as a free source of information, pure genius and a businessman like thinking 👌

  • @Perplexer1
    @Perplexer1 Месяц назад +4

    Neil is wrong. "A" no longer stands for "aerial" phenomena, since they're not necessarily aerial (some are underwater or transmedium). So "A" now stands for "anomalous" phenomena to cover those as well.

    • @theindubitable
      @theindubitable Месяц назад

      Yes, correct. Bottom line is, these people are a part of the cover up.

    • @subject8332
      @subject8332 Месяц назад

      That was actually the most correct thing he said in the whole episode.

    • @subject8332
      @subject8332 Месяц назад +2

      @Yes-gp1bt The names are an absolutely crucial distinction. Neil is basically instructing people to look for a submarine in the sky. Do you have a particular vested interest in spreading misinformation, or are you simply a narcissist who felt called out?

  • @skelapus
    @skelapus Месяц назад +10

    When are you going to talk to Steven Greer? Thanks. You rock

    • @RickySupriyadi
      @RickySupriyadi Месяц назад +3

      he won't and never will

    • @Souljourney22
      @Souljourney22 Месяц назад +2

      His career is in jeopardy if he does.

    • @NameForgotten1
      @NameForgotten1 Месяц назад +3

      @@Souljourney22 Why would it be in jeopardy? Are certain topics off limits? Do you mean to say, that you have, with scientific precision, ruled out the possibility for intelligent life across the entire universe, except for Earth?
      Think about how crazy what you are saying actually is.

    • @vonNeumannProbed
      @vonNeumannProbed Месяц назад

      @@NameForgotten1 Greer is one of the biggest grifters in "ufology," provides zero evidence to back up his claims, and his photos of ethereal beings have been debunked as nothing more than photos of insects. Why would NDT waste his time interviewing one of the most transparent grifters on the scene?

    • @Souljourney22
      @Souljourney22 Месяц назад +7

      @@NameForgotten1 because if neil were to bring dr greer on and discuss this topic he would quickly be put in his place on how we have a long history of interactions with other beings. Neil's whole stance of nothing to see here would be exposed and therefore his whole career of telling lies to the public.

  • @TonyB-l1b
    @TonyB-l1b Месяц назад +8

    Me and my freind saw a flying saucer for about 15 seconds on november 23 2022 around 2 pm, broad daylight. It did not move an inch it was scary idle and it was above a lowes on Chapman hyw Knoxville TN... it never moved but it definitely left reality instantly. It blinked out of existence. Now being in Tennessee wouldn't you assume that some Chinese aircraft or some aliens were observing a lowes instead of oak ridge or any of the many military bases in Tennessee? Nobody beleives me and if my freind didnt see it too i would not believe it either.

    • @Hlbkomer
      @Hlbkomer Месяц назад +3

      I believe you!

    • @scottbreseke716
      @scottbreseke716 Месяц назад +4

      There was a famous incident where a UFO hovered above the Chicago airport (in 2006) for a few minutes and was seen by many airport personel and other people. And pics were taken.

    • @RickySupriyadi
      @RickySupriyadi Месяц назад +3

      but smart people such these 3 podcastster are too smart and too high with their position to believe, so... this why we all divided by politics around and around rather than solving it.

    • @bhabbott
      @bhabbott Месяц назад +2

      @@RickySupriyadi Sad but true - smart and dumb people tend to be divided by politics. The fatal flaw in democracy.

    • @TonyB-l1b
      @TonyB-l1b Месяц назад

      Yeah it was weird man these ones you see videos of aren't anything like what we saw.

  • @mikematt67
    @mikematt67 Месяц назад +2

    Chuck Norris studies aliens on their planet in his spare time and they have yet been able to capture a picture of him.

  • @billadams8932
    @billadams8932 Месяц назад +13

    Dr. Spock was a pediatrician who wrote a best selling book on baby and child care in 1946. the guy you’re talking about is simply Spock.

    • @ShawnStradamus520
      @ShawnStradamus520 Месяц назад +8

      Or Mr. Spock to you, sir!🖖

    • @joshharraway3173
      @joshharraway3173 Месяц назад +6

      OMG. This is one of ny biggest pet peeves. I hate when people call him Dr. Spock instead of Mr. Spock.

  • @creightonfreeman8059
    @creightonfreeman8059 Месяц назад +6

    Excuse me but a fighter plane/pilots job is exactly to find, identify, and potentially target other flying objects called enemy aircraft (and not target friendly aircraft) and the sensors in the plane and on their weapons are designed to do that. The fact that they were able to find, target and shoot down a Chinese balloon is evidence that the sensors/weapons work against objects other than just airplanes.

  • @HighHolyOne
    @HighHolyOne Месяц назад +9

    Yes, the US has Schrodinger's Alien, in a locked box.

    • @NameForgotten1
      @NameForgotten1 Месяц назад

      @@HighHolyOne what if it actually did? We have government employees saying that we do. If anything, it suggests we need to investigate this topic. After looking at the available data, suggesting otherwise is a massive leap away from reality. There is something to this topic, lets investigate.

    • @HighHolyOne
      @HighHolyOne Месяц назад +2

      @NameForgotten1 Agreed. But in the meantime, it is entirely Schrodinger's Alien, just like Schrodinger's Cat. It may be there or it may be not there, at the same time.

    • @randallbesch2424
      @randallbesch2424 Месяц назад

      @@NameForgotten1 what better way to continue to promote the failed ET hypothesis than that. Make us look like we are on the ball.

    • @NameForgotten1
      @NameForgotten1 Месяц назад

      @@randallbesch2424 i dont see how you can suggest its failed at this point? Lets just acknowledge that visitation is a possibility, and lets keep investigating.

  • @robertmancini5518
    @robertmancini5518 Месяц назад

    I can't help but to think of "pinky and the brain" every time I watch these two 😁

  • @Richard-pd7rp
    @Richard-pd7rp Месяц назад +3

    We cant assume that "aliens" (if they were visiting earth) always and exclusively wish to go undetected.
    Or can we assume that?

    • @katherinesol4267
      @katherinesol4267 Месяц назад

      What if they already live here? In the depths of the ocean or core of the earth. No atmosphere detection or observation from above to enter earth.

    • @Richard-pd7rp
      @Richard-pd7rp Месяц назад

      @katherinesol4267 Could be, Katherine!
      Same question for the panel though: can we assume that they wish to always go undetected?
      I say we can't assume that, which means that lights would be optional. Hypothetically. If they're here. If these are craft.

    • @Realmoney511
      @Realmoney511 Месяц назад +1

      U are way off they are already here long time before u where😂😂😂😂.

    • @Richard-pd7rp
      @Richard-pd7rp Месяц назад +1

      @@Realmoney511 🤷 You sound so certain! Are you able to provide some insight into how you reached this conclusion?

    • @randallbesch2424
      @randallbesch2424 Месяц назад

      @@Richard-pd7rp no since they do want us to see them at times.

  • @ThegamingsquadLOve-kg1yq
    @ThegamingsquadLOve-kg1yq Месяц назад +11

    Am I the only one who thinks it's better to use extraterrestrial being than aliens? Because aliens feels too much like a pop culture reference.

    • @subject8332
      @subject8332 Месяц назад +1

      Both will age like milk when pretty soon people realize they were here way way way before us.

    • @QuickSticks8771
      @QuickSticks8771 Месяц назад +1

      Both alien and extra terrestrial suggest something foreign and non local
      Extra perceptual seems more accurate

    • @ThegamingsquadLOve-kg1yq
      @ThegamingsquadLOve-kg1yq Месяц назад +1

      I do agree, and since you seem to know a lot about the subject(just a curious gal), do you think the sort of obsession humans, and the pop culture, have on extra perceptual beings is too much? Because personally, I feel it's been overused and overdone and maybe it's time to start focusing more on fixing the human impacts on the planet.

    • @QuickSticks8771
      @QuickSticks8771 Месяц назад

      @@ThegamingsquadLOve-kg1yq all these recent sightings and mainstream conversations about the true nature of reality help to expand the Veiw of ourselves and capabilities which will go a long way to healing our current treatment of the planet

    • @jamiecurnock2910
      @jamiecurnock2910 Месяц назад

      ​@@ThegamingsquadLOve-kg1yq both can exist at the same time, it doesnt have to be one or the other.

  • @MabDarogan2
    @MabDarogan2 Месяц назад +12

    9:20 Dr Spock was a human, Mr Spock was a half-alien

    • @BwanaBob
      @BwanaBob 23 дня назад

      These guys are TV scientists. I hope real scientists aren't lazy and sloppy.

  • @CarbuncleSlaanesh
    @CarbuncleSlaanesh Месяц назад +1

    Look at all these angry man children, this channel is just nice to listen to when I'm in my workshop; I'm not a facebook scientist and don't want to be. Sometimes it's just nice to listen to people smarter than me that actually went to school to learn about their field and probably know more than these armchair experts that are angry they're denying the conspiracy theories everyone is smoking.

  • @Khashenzo
    @Khashenzo Месяц назад +4

    wow im here way too early 😂

  • @BrianMiller-mm4mz
    @BrianMiller-mm4mz Месяц назад +4

    Hyper dimensional vehicles do not “ enter from space”

  • @BetoTheButcher
    @BetoTheButcher Месяц назад +14

    Not the Android bashing 😮

    • @ClassicRoc87
      @ClassicRoc87 Месяц назад +1

      Even though some Android devices can even measure atmospheric data. older models at least can do that lol
      they probably stopped including that feature because it wasn't cost effective

  • @lj1708
    @lj1708 18 дней назад +1

    Please stop interrupting the guest and allow them to finish talking after being asked a question

    • @terimorris6394
      @terimorris6394 13 дней назад +1

      Yes ! And stop with the obnoxious’jokes that the guest doesn’t react or find funny

  • @Whosoever446
    @Whosoever446 Месяц назад +4

    Startalk needs a good table..

  • @walterabernathy5663
    @walterabernathy5663 Месяц назад +8

    Why would the government hide this stuff? In the intelligent community knowledge is power. So people hang on to stuff they know because they know stuff you don't.

    • @Flashkoch
      @Flashkoch Месяц назад +2

      Exactly. This discussion was worthless, as NDT is for science and "Dr." Spergel is for NASA. He is head of the UAP taskforce, but hasn't watched the hearings...I mean, come on. His job is not researching or finding things out, he is there to tell the public whatever the gatekeeper want him to tell. This episode had shill factor 100.

    • @randallbesch2424
      @randallbesch2424 Месяц назад

      @@Flashkoch Maybe Spergel didn't need to be there.

  • @christygaiser
    @christygaiser Месяц назад +3

    Getting real tired of being told I have this magical device in my pocket that can take hi-res videos of objects hundreds of feet in the sky moving. Do these phones exist? Probably. Do most humans have the finances to buy one of these magical hi end phones? No. My iPhone X can barely take a photo of a still target ten feet away without being grainy.
    Also regarding ball lightening and the plane - planes are not made of all metal. There are these things called windows that are made of glass. It’s not like a faraday cage ffs.

    • @schenier
      @schenier Месяц назад +2

      get a Samsung galaxy S phone then. I can take pictures of craters on the moon with mine

    • @randallbesch2424
      @randallbesch2424 Месяц назад

      The tech is common place but I don't own a smart phone. Not magickal.

  • @KamiSenpai420
    @KamiSenpai420 16 дней назад

    I wish more scientists would explain things for us simple folk like Niel does. You start to understand a little more and I think it helps open people's mind and progress the race as a whole.

  • @fanjasylvie4842
    @fanjasylvie4842 25 дней назад +3

    I have a friend in Madagascar that grew up in the same city I grew up. She is 44 yo and she told me that Aliens abducted her multiple times during 20 years. She explained to me that nobody believed her when she told people what happened to her during the abductions. She does not know what happened when they had her but she remembers pretty well how they did when they took her and when she got on the UFO. Then later she would be awoken pretty bad by their methods/ suffering a lot during the moments to get her back to Earth. Sometimes they left her outside her home or on the bed. Sometimes she was all wet, or no clothes or buttons mismatched. It s very mysterious but she can explain how was inside the UFO, how they looked like and how they made her out of consciousness.

  • @sizzla10
    @sizzla10 Месяц назад +7

    Here we are, the professional debunkers again, hope the governments paying you well guys 👍

  • @NateHarrisMusic
    @NateHarrisMusic Месяц назад +6

    If they are detecting grav. waves that moved electrons, what are they measuring against? How do they know where the electrons moved FROM?

  • @jacobydvi6251
    @jacobydvi6251 Месяц назад

    I’ve think I heard the 2 on the left on the radio as a kid kinda warm my heart folk 😂

  • @Ricolaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
    @Ricolaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Месяц назад +10

    So uh, about them orbs though?

    • @gemigtunnan
      @gemigtunnan Месяц назад +3

      Go out tonight with your phone and zoom in on any type of light far away, maybe a star, myabe a streetlight very very far away and tell me what do you see? Better yet record it and post it

  • @Morechocolatenow
    @Morechocolatenow Месяц назад +3

    “Dark energy dominates the universe and determines its fate and we don’t know what it is”!!!
    I find this extremely interesting and can’t stop linking this to the scripture:
    “Who is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of every creature: for by him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him, and for him: and he is before all things, and by him all things consist.”
    ‭‭Colossians‬ ‭1‬:‭15‬-‭17‬

  • @jasonweyland8694
    @jasonweyland8694 20 дней назад +1

    This was one of the most underwhelming and uninformed videos on the topic of UAP. Watch any interview by Luis Elizondo, Ryan Graves, David Grusch, Chris Mellon, or David Fravor. Those are people giving the real eyewitness accounts that they're too scared to really talk about in this video.

  • @JimmyGentry
    @JimmyGentry 21 день назад

    "The monochromatic tic tac" is almost certainly a bug trapped in the camera housing. I served six years in the NAVY as an aircraft electrician and have found all manner of bugs and birds and even rodents in otherwise inaccessible areas. Bend over to get a tool from the tool box when a bug flies into an electrical compartment and you'll never see it. Next time you watch the video pay close attention to the relative motion between the object being tracked and the edges of the frame. You'll find none because there is none. That's pretty stable proof that whatever is being tracked is attached to the aircraft. Take a screen shot and zoom in and you'll actually see antennae and legs. It's amazing how the fundamental laws of motion are completely ignored when someone thinks they've seen a ufo.

  • @TrueWodzu
    @TrueWodzu Месяц назад

    Imagine flying source landing on David's backyard - and he says, "we need more data" 😂

  • @NicoleymiHere1111
    @NicoleymiHere1111 17 дней назад +1

    Yeah, I’m tapping out upon hearing that “NASA is one of the most transparent agencies” & the government knows what 99% of UAP’s are 😂😂

  • @AlemMemić
    @AlemMemić Месяц назад

    As a mathematician and Data Scientist, this definitely reminds me on those hypothesis in Mathematics, where they are trying to prove something, but hope that nobody will prove it because they need to publish some research in that direction. Here we can see that entire research team is present just to find solution about those pictures regarding UFOs, but they are doing their own research which they hope will not end during their lifetime :D