“Forgetting is part of the learning process”. I needed to hear that. Thank you. I let it frustrate me too much when I forget stuff I worked hard to remember.
I learned english in the same way, just starting reading harry potter book series and watching the big bang theory, always searching for every word written/listened and in the end I was able to understand english spoken and written. I am hoping to use the same method for japanese. The most import thing for me was not have fear of forget words but fear of not use the idiom in a certain day.
Something I enjoy a lot is watching/listening to Japanese songs with the Japanese lyrics. Even if I don’t know the reading of the kanji, I can often pick up what the artist is singing after a few good listens. I feel like it helps me a lot to remember things to song.
Same. I find simply looking at the kanji, even if I don't memorize it, even if I don't know what it means, just looking at it and subconsciously storing it in my mind greatly helps remembering it when I eventually actually try to learn it.
@ Most songs you can find the lyrics online which helps a lot. From there it’s looking up the meanings (I usually do that after a few good listens.) Will see that lyrics and hear them singing it and discover how to say the kanji. I can then look it up on a dictionary app. (Or if I can’t figure it out draw it in the app). Just keep in mind that lyrics follow song grammar and so some things sung might not word as an actual sentence so it’s best used for vocabulary building and minor grammar. But the huge benefit is listening (and if you sing) speaking practice. I also write out the lyrics to get extra writing practice too. I usually spend a month or two picking apart one song. There is nothing more fun than breaking out into Japanese song IMO. ☺️
You are absolutely correct. Reading is the magic trick. When I realized that I was making no progress with Japanese, I took a step back and ask myself "You've learned English before, how did you do it?" And the answer was that I've read fanfiction a lot. But the thing is, it is easy to read English, but in Japanese, whenever I came across an unfamiliar kanji I'd just mumble and move on. So I started playing voiced visual novel games in Japanese. I am still not at the level where I can read a book and I am a very impatient person so I just stop studying when I feel bored. But in visual novels, voice actors usually read most of the sentences, and from the context and their acting I can kind of make out a meaning, and if I can't, I look it up. After I encounter the same kanji a few times, it becomes a familiar kanji. Reading takes a lot of time, and at least for people who learn Japanese simply for entertainment like me, finding reading materials that you enjoy is very important.
@@linhtrieu4933 I had written a very long reply before but it got deleted I guess, so now I will write a shorter one. You can watch ToKini Andy's video "How I Learned Japanese with Visual Novels" video. So, I turned to visual novels because watching Japanese movies with Japanese subtitles or reading books with audiobook version playing in the back doesn't work for me. They always move on so quickly and I need some time to process the information, but if I stop too frequently I get bored. Visual Novels are good because they move on my pace. I usually play them on PC, but there are also mobile games that you can download, but I use QooApp to download them because they are usually restricted to Japanese Google Play. I played HypMic like that, and it's free to read the story parts of it. The only downfall to visual novels that I can think of is this; if you are not interested in anime, you might not like visual novels either, because they are both part of the same entertainment culture. Visual novels have a very "anime" feel to them and I like it.
I learned English by reading (and reading and reading..), I never used dictionaries, and it worked for me. Japanese has some obstacles there... and I seem to be a bit similar to you (based on that other comment), I get bored if I can't actually ingest what I'm watching (I need the story to be a story, not text or pictures on a page - it needs to be inside my mind or I don't learn anything). Will have to look up what those "visual novels" are, I haven't run across that before. EditUpdate: Seems like those VNs are only available via various gaming platforms which I don't have access to, unfortunately.
Hello! I’m Japanese😊 I just happen to find your video. Your Japanese pronunciation is very good!! Also, It’s not easy for us to learn kanji. You know about Kani better than Japanese. “悪女について“ Is my favorite novel!
You've learned kanji just by reading. So have I. Of course, in the very beginning, I copied a couple of hundred of them, enough to learn about basic strokes (all 9 of them!) and radicals, etc. But then I kind of realized that trying to memorize kanji was the same as trying to memorize vocabulary, and this is just not the way I think you can learn a language. So I started doing what I had always been doing for other (alphabet-based) languages, i.e. just reading everything I could get my hands on. In the case of Japanese, that meant finding stories (either actual books or on the Internet) with "okurigana" or romaji and comparing each original Japanese sentence with its translation, sometimes writing both languages side by side so as to make it easier to read again later. And wouldn't you know it? I started to realize that without making any special effort at memorizing, I was remembering quite a lot of kanji in a general way, in the same way that people remember faces. When you think about it, anyone is able to recognize (without necessarily being able to put a name on each one) hundreds, if not thousands of faces, without ever having had to analyze their different characteristics (shape of eyes, nose, mouth, ears, forehead, etc.), and I've come to believe that "recognizing" kanji works just the same. The mind is one extraordinary tool we humans have.
@@StrategicGamesEtcStrange but true. I had actually never checked the definition of "okurigana" and just assumed it was basically synonymous with "furigana", perhaps just an older term. Thanks for setting me straight.
Humans have specific neural circuitry to recognize (human) faces, people with brain damage in certain areas aren't able to recognize them. It's not the same with kanji although once you learn all the radicals, etc it becomes pretty easy to recognize them by their sub-structures.
I use the same method to learn English - reading. And, as you said, spaced repetition occurs randomly within the reading of different materials, including the healthy cycle of forgetting. It's interesting and encouraging to know the similarity in language learning, whatever language you are interested in.
These are really great advices. I have been learning Chinese for long time (I only know a few words and sentences in Japanese), but I can relate. I did use Anki but it has its downsides. All the techniques you mentioned are based on your experience, but I confirm they are also backed by science. Great video 👍🏻
I liked your method for learning kanji and in the first stage of grouping I categorize them in verbs, adjectives, nouns and finally adverbs, conjunctions, etc. This way many of the kanji that you memorized in the verbs are the same in adjectives and nouns, and this way you memorize the readings of the kanjis in context.
I would love it if you made a video with book recommendations grouped by their difficulty! I am sure a lot of other people would appreciate it as well.
Amazing tips! I found that when I tried to use Anki I quickly lost motivation to keep reading. Seeing how much people swear by it I thought maybe I was doing it wrong. I think my brain just needs to be more fast paced with study and learning through genuine repetition of context and content.
Thanks so much Brin, I'm glad you enjoyed this. As you can tell from some of the other comments, you're not alone! You're not doing anything wrong, just try different things and see what fits you. Context based learning has certainly worked for me, so if you haven't tried it, why not give it a shot. And if it's not for you, move on or mix and match until you've found your style.
Nice video! As a Singaporean Chinese, I have no problems understanding the meaning of the kanji. HOWEVER what I can't stand the most is every character has at least 2-3 different sounds depending on how it is matched with different kanji! Even a simple 月 has like at least 3 ways of speaking depending on if it's a moon, a month or a full moon! Knowing English, Chinese & Japanese, I am 100% sure Japanese is the toughest language to learn! Good luck to everyone learning Japanese!!! Gambatte!
Thank you for the explanation, I've been struggling for some years wanting to learn kanji since I want to read Japanese literature and miscellaneous books, but every time I get frustrated with how fast I forget what I just studied. I'll try again and make an effort of trusting the process, it helps knowing that forgetting is "normal" and part of it.
Hi, I cross this video accidentally. I am a native Taiwanese and Mandarin speaker. However, my child and I are living in the US. This is how I teach him kanji (hanji) in Taiwanese and Mandarin. He starts with very basic simple words. For example, “日”，“月”，“金”，“木”，“水“，”火“，“土”， “一”， “二”... and some basic verb. "來“，”去“，”走“... Let him get familiar with these basic components (I guess less than 50 words). Once he knows these words well, learning new words will be easy since almost all kanji words are composed of these basic components. The next step is writing meaningful short sentences. For example, “上學“ (go to school). These meaningful sentences help children to learn quickly. As time flies, we increase the length of sentences. We pick a new sentence every week. And repeat the same sentence by writing it down once every day. Of course, he forgets words quickly. But, the commonly used words in books, videos, and signs will refresh his memory from time to time. So, he learns really useful words.
Thanks for the tips and recommendations! The "deconstructing" part was really interesting, specially because I noticed that I have been using the method without even noticing. Now with more aware of it, I will try to implement it more consistently.
Ah this was refreshing, thank you for just sharing your learning journey and methods. Very useful and interesting! And unconventional, which always helps. Different perspectives are always good to know!
I've been half-heartedly trying to learn Japanese for eight years now. It's only been in the last couple of years that I fully realised that learning by rote just isn't very good. It is guaranteed to work, but it is incredibly inefficient and a very long slog. Part of sticking to it has been familiarity from my school days, but also laziness. I tried Anki several times and hated it. Learning things in context really is the best way once you have a solid foundation. It can be tough and frustrating at first, as you understand almost nothing. But you end up learning vocabulary, grammar, and phrases that are actually used and you will actually use. And you get entertainment and/or knowledge from it, even at the most basic level. I've been doing the Memrise courses for a while now, and I think they are good in-between way. Sure, it is rote learning, but they introduce words and then sentences or phrases that use those words. There's some basic explanation of the grammar at first, but they really just throw you in there for the most part. It's therefore something I recommend, especially if someone is struggling to find and choose material to study/practise with.
I was wondering where I knew your name from and then it hit me ahah glad to see you are still pushing your newsletter and now this channel! I know you are more focused on the reading side of things, but I would love to see your methods regarding what you did to improve your listening. Would also be cool to see your opinion and approaches regarding reading physical books vs. reading books in a digital format using tools like yomichan. Anyways, glad to see you pushing content like this and sharing your insights!
Great to see you back here :) Wanted to hold off on plugging this channel on the newsletter until I had some more content to share, but the video has taken off in an unexpected way. I'll start posting on the newsletter again too, but after I finish my dissertation. Personally I always go for paper. I've never used yomichan, so can't really give an opinion, but I'd say pick whatever suits your style of learning or combine until you've found a routine that works for you.
@@bunsuke.nihongo I always preferred reading paper over digital, but Japanese puts you in a weird spot where, reading paper kinda sucks since looking up word takes so much time, and digital makes lookups easy but reading on digital also sucks ahah. So I've been mostly listening and do some light reading here and there. Hope we get more videos from you soon 👍
@@jporfirio_ Whtas wrong with reading digitally? The time you safe for looking up words is tremendous, so unless you're really fluent already I would highly suggest using Yomichan because it's so convenient. If Eyestrain is bothersome to you, I would recommend a Kindle (Or any other E-Reader) with E-Ink technology, this is the best of both worlds in my opinion since you can load your own dictonaries into it and read comfortably. (I have the 大辞林 and 広辞苑 on my Kindle and really enjoy reading there).
I am glad I ran into your channel. Looking forward for more videos about kanji. New to learning Japanese, everybody seems to think that my primary goal it is be able to talk but actually I am more interested on be able to read it. I been trying to learn in different ways kanji, but I been struggling. Repetition methods with flash cards kill me. I am going to give it a try to reading. Maybe some day I will be able to learn all that you know, I am only 17 years BEHIND! 😅.
If doing flashcards for a long time is painful, just set a time limit of, for example, 20 minutes a day or whatever. If you stick with it you'll probably have most of the Joyo kanji memorized in a year or so, I would think.
Finally, I found my answer why it's difficult for me to learn kanji. Thanks! I understand your explanation about kanji nicely! Good luck on your study!
I actually understood and could digest Most of what he was trying to convey. I surprised myself when I knew several Kanji. This would have been confusing to me not too long ago. Thank You. Whenever I watch a video like this it boosts my interest to learn the language, as sometimes I get a little complaisant and start to wain away
My mind is blown, I had no idea I could learn Kanji this way, it's fantastic! You just motivated me to study again, thank you! I think this video can help a lot of people. Have you ever thought about adding Spanish subtitles to it? I would love to do Spanish subtitles for this video and share it with my friends, so they can also get motivated too. If that's something you'd be interested in, please let me know! Love from Argentina :)
Bunsuke is an example of a very good "Teacher". I know a total of 10 Kanji. But he inspires me to learn more. Anecdotally, I believe "Good Teachers" should rank among the highest paid professionals in society. However, our society will not allow this. Good Teachers do their job because they Love it. How many people actually Love their job? Amen.. ha haa . Keep studying and improving. I am 67 years old and started learning Japanese 6 months ago. I think its time to toy with Kanji.
Hi, I just got out of the N5 exam, so your advanced advice comes a bit early for me, but I know I'll get back to this video in the future. Thanks for your thoughts.
I think one of the better ways to use Anji is as a supplement to your way of reading and writing down new stuff. People call this 'sentence mining', where they create an anki flashcard of a sentence from their input material that has a new word. This is a sort of way to try to get more repetitions out of one encounter for a word, to try to recognize it easier the next time you see it. I think both ways are good, and the anki isn't necessary, just an attempt to remember stuff quicker for some people.
I've been reading and using a lot of these tactics you mentioned with my own Japanese journey for some time now. You've broken it down it excellently. I let go of the habit of writing down words for Japanese, and instead just read a ton. It's like you said "if it's important it will come up again," but I think I will steal your habit of writing down words for reading in Korean, which I am a beginner at. I think in the early stages of reading, you don't have as many "categories" and ways to mentally associate words and so you're more likely to struggle to remember words. I think writing down sentences I've read will help me pick up the foundational Korean vocab. Honestly so glad I found someone else who uses reading instead of spaced repetition software. It's like, the more time I'm building flashcards, the less time I have to read.
Thank you for the tips, i think i will use this method 🤠I wish there was a complete and helpful video like this one for Arabic too 😂 finding good methods for learning languages on RUclips is so hard,, I’m glad I found your channel!
although particular methods and mnemonic techniques may differ, one of the possible principles to guide one's kanji studies in terms of what kanji they study and in what sequence may be the scope of each particular level of the Kanji Kentei test (at least this is what Japanese people themselves do)
This was quite useful. I've been mindmapping kanji, but it ends up all over the place because of a lack of logical structure. I'll take a look at the groupings and see if that works better. Thanks!
Very usefull tips! Already using them now! Thank you for taking the time to share! Like and subscribe buttons smashed! Anyway, if you're a regular language student with few minutes a day for the language, I'd say that a SRS like Anki is a must, specially for kanji begginers. But If your doing a PhD... on japanese literature... already immersed in japanese the entire work time..., well... that really seems to be a whole different situation that demands much higer level than just a plain "root" memorization, right? Very good to know that.
Can you please, list names of these resources in the description, as a text, or as a message? These resources look interesting, and I understand that these dictionaries are for more advanced learners, but I would like to look up for these, but it looks really hard, or rather time consuming to search for names, only by visuals and pronounced names in the video.
I have been learning English like this as well and also felt that reading is just another way of space repetition (but making it fun). Anki just don't work for me and for what I have noticed, even heard there were some studies, it actually doesn't work for most people and don't think it's because all of these people aren't able to figure out how the method works. Flashcards aren't the only way to learn and I wish more people were aware of this, maybe then less students would end up frustrated and giving up only because they try something that didn't work for them.
Do you have a recommendation specifically for learning the phonetic pieces? I have already finished Heisig's RTK part 1, so I can recognize kanji pretty well. The phonetic components seem like a great way to memorize, but this is the first place I've ever seen it even mentioned.
I am not a fan of Anki, so this video was very insightful. Do you still tutor or do you have online classes? Also is there a link for all the resources you covered in the video?
Since you’re literature student please assuage my deepest concern about kanji: How do you read classical haiku (or any verse poetry) when they use kanji & there’s multiple readings? Can it obscure the author’s intent with respect to meter, or can it be guessed precisely enough that nobody would debate it?
If multiple readings fit in the meter one would hope the editor or publisher provides a reading based on the latest research. I sometimes compare different editions of a text, usually the 新潮日本古典集成 and the 小学館新編日本古典文学全集
Hi , Book you mentioned. I want to get it. ( I am in Tokyo) (覚えやすいテーマ別段階別漢字実践練習) Could you please share author name and publication. As you mentioned could not find it online, want to try my luck in store.
You have to learn the radicals and etymology. I’m learning from a RUclips videos a Korean author of kanji book made and I’m learning 40 characters a day. She teaches the etymology and how the characters are made from radicals. She spends about 30 seconds on Each character so I finish 40 characters in 20 minutes. Then I look at the list and the one I don’t remember, I watch the video again. I repeat until I know all 40 characters. Then when I finish a grade level, I use online kanji test by grade level
Hello again Bunsuke-san, wishing you a good year-end occasion and a good beginning in the next one. How are you doing? 😃 It's gone two weeks since I discovered your substack, and I'm now already on entry #250. I also read Tamura Toshiko's 生血 or Lifeblood you presented in the immersion reading project. Here's how it went: I get what you described about reading stories. Reading the first pages felt like I lost my bearings and orientation, my eyes spin, I got sleepy, distracted, among other stuffs, just from trying to read everything in one sitting without trying to comprehend what I just read. What I know for sure is, I have to get used to it little by little, like progressing from a shallow pond to a deep pool. It's not that I don't understand most of the meaning of the individual words, but I have to get used to handling every single one that repeatedly came and see them all in a certain context in order to picture the scene of the story in my mind's eye. Doing it tires, of course, and so the moment I lost focus, I took some minutes off before I came back to reread it. In the process I actually came to understand the story on an unconscious level, so, after coming back to it repeatedly, I discovered that I wasn't drowning compared to the first few times, I just need to move along with the flow so as not to drown. Reading is something that got easier as you do it often and let the flow carry you around, surfaces, depths, anywhere it went, just let go of the fear and trust on the eventual arrival of understanding. All in all, I finished these two chapters of Lifeblood in two days. Actually, three days, as I postpone reading the last two, three pages on the second day, because I have some errands that day. So, consuming native material is the best way to understand a new language, be it written or spoken. Unfortunately, just start reading from day one is not so easy in Japanese, at least in the beginning. Kanji came with a lot of information to unpack, despite only occupying single character blocks, and you just have to stick to being accompanied by dictionaries for a while. I know I still do, even after all this time. I still rely on 10ten reader to help me with the way some Kanji readings should be read if I want to be quick so as not to lose the plot. Other dictionaries that could help is Google search. Just type in とは or 意味 after the vocabulary you're looking up is a godsend if you already at some point along your progress, as are some other J-J dictionaries. Overall, the progress of my learning is not that bad though, I still got to identify how I could've done this the more efficient, time-and-cost-saving way. The way things works for me is to look up each and every word and consider their sum in totality. I guess I am just obsessive with the meaning of words. The unknown drives me crazy. 😆 I remember now why I want to learn Japanese. Initially, I wish to understand everything on manga, anime, visual novels, etc without waiting for translations, all the subtleties, nuances, choice of words in these works. I think I'd like return to those old materials soon. It's going to be like meeting your first love again after a while, bittersweetly familiar, keeping a bit of the tragic consciousness in the background as you know that as all the things had came full circle and the object you desire and yearned for is finally within your reach, all you are left with even more yearning and desire of the ideal. 🥀 The Germans call it Sehnsucht, I guess? Not all is sad and tragic, I have even more higher hopes for the future of my language learning. This time I'm picking languages other than Japanese, like German, French and Spanish, and maybe some Dutch, Italian, and Portuguese. Of course I'll be returning to Japanese materials when I found some works that interests me. I hope in the coming decade I already know all of them to a certain level where I could just read materials and understand 80-90% of what was written, the way I currently know the words I read in Japanese right now.
How to start reading books if i don't know kanji at all. Even basic ones. So, the reading of simple books is becoming an unresolvable task: I can't recognize characters how they look like and can't know how they sound. Seems like a dead end to me ((
do you know any useful resourses for learning the origin of kanjis and how the combination of it's radicals make sense. because i am very interested in learning the origin of them but i can't find any useful websites on the internet even wikipedia and chinese etymology doesn't make any help🥲
Outlier Linguistics. RUclips channel and website. They’ve got a video introduction paleography (文字學). They’re also creating a dictionary for that purpose.
It's not a very effective one. Some words are harder to remember than others, and seeing words twice a year isn't enough to keep it in your memory. And before you say "oh, well those words aren't that important", the vast majority of words are like that, and are needed to engage in anything adult-related.
@@Rebecca-bz6ph I spend most of my time immersing, either actively watching and reading content, or listening to recordings of said content on repeat. I turn new words I find into Anki cards and then study them for about 30 min - 1 hr everyday. I also occasionally watch grammar videos on RUclips.
I would argue that doing space repetition by reading can be more effective than flashcards. If you pay attention to the context the word is used and make some of the connections the guy in the video mentioned (like comparing or grouping them with antonym and synonym) instead of having to see the same flashcards hundreds of times you can learn it by just seeing the word a couple if times, maybe even learning it and sticking it to your head forever having only seeing it once. In the end you just have to go and see what methodology works best for you, just keep in mind that flashcards aren't the only way to learn and they may not be the best way to learn for you.
it's true but it's not the entire story. It depends what words you wanna learn. For instance, in an intro textbook I learned the word 給料 (salary). and put that into Anki. Then I read books in Japanese, that is monolingual Japanese books shipped from Japan. I read 9 books before one of them mentioned the word 給料, which I was able to read because of Anki. Is that an important word? IDK. But I bet every Japanese person and nearly every learner knows it. Textbooks, anki, and reading books, all are forms of studying and all will refresh your memory differently and at different rates.
Essentially, the key is making connections by using, contextualizing, and grouping kanji to make progressively more connections. This tracks with what we know about learning. Trying to memorize disembodied lists doesn't work as well as just reading or writing with the words you're wanting to learn. The more connections your brain can make with something the easier it becomes to recall. Stellar vid! Some great ideas to try.
You don't memorize them as arbitrary lists, but rather by their structure and etymology. And anyway, using SRS to memorize Kanji (along with mnemonics, etc) absolutely does work and works really fast. The reason so many people say it works great is b/c all those people used it and learned Kanji that way.
When you start out learning japanese, trying to solely learn through reading is going to be very time consuming and inefficient. The purpose of anki is to build a good foundation of vocabulary by remembering the basic meaning of a word, so that when you encounter it while reading, you are able to at least understand what it means, which makes it easier to draw connections to how the word is used and in which context it appears in.
I like your tip about reading books and learning kanji and vocab through encounters. I personally love to read and don’t enjoy using flashcards and stuff, but most people online tend to focus really heavily on learning through study tools so I felt like ‘I was doing it wrong’. I will never forget the words 商品 or 防犯カメラ after reading kombini ningen though😅. I’ll pursue reading more and dedicate time to it in my studying schedule to treat it as a formal studying tool.
Hi Tony, trust me you are not alone, as you can see in the comments from others, many people feel frustrated with flashcards and other related systems/apps/methods. Keep at it, and do it in a way that suits your needs and goals. This stuff is supposed to be fun!
This is great. A lot to process here. My own personal story is, after majoring in Japanese at a university, I started working as a freelance Japanese to English translator around 2000 or 2001. Before that, I had not been able to pass JPLT level one (and barely passed level two, after two tries). After a couple years of sweating it out on translation projects daily, I decided to try JPLT level one again. I was SHOCKED at how much kanji I knew. When I went through my kanji texts for test prep, I was actually laughing at how much kanji I had not known before becoming a translator. Most of the areas I had marked as problem areas for me felt so basic now. And then when I actually took the test, I sailed through the kanji and reading sections so fast, I could not believe it (this after sweating bullets on level two a few years before). So, my takeaway was, translating 8 to 10 hours a day every day pushed my kanji recognition level up so much higher than my college or post college studies ever did. Don't get me wrong, it was tough. What I think happened is, when I was studying, before starting work as a translator, I spent a lot of time diving into each kanji. It was hard to move on to the next kanji or the next vocab word. You want to make sure you have fully memorized it. And then, I would get super frustrated and demoralized if I later discovered I had forgotten it. It was actually pretty emotionally difficult, especially after college when I felt like I had no clear goals. It felt like swimming in a giant ocean, with no land in sight. I never knew if I was making progress. It always felt like I was losing ground faster than gaining it. Then, when I started translating, I had no more time for any of that. Clients wanted projects done quickly, so I never worried about if I was memorizing words or kanji or not. I just kept looking up words I did not know and translating text as fast and as accurately as I could. If I made mistakes, I corrected them and moved on to the next job. It turns out that this was a great way to study, at least for me. After I was freed from the pressure of trying to completely memorize each vocab word or kanji before moving on, I wound up actually memorizing a lot more words and kanji through simple repetition. I should mention, my skills at writing kanji by hand are so horrible now as to be embarrassing, but that is because I spend my free time doing things other than practicing writing kanji. If I made that a core hobby outside of work, I'd probably be pretty good at it. (I mention this to show one downside of my method of learning) Also, I should mention, I do not study Japanese at all outside of work now. Oh, I watch the occasional Japanese show or movie, and sometimes I do read Japanese for pleasure, but outside of work, I mostly read English novels and make art. I barely ever do anything that looks remotely like studying kanji. So if your passion for kanji does let you keep studying after a full day of translating or reading, all the more power to you! You will be much better than I. So... for everyone out there studying... I do not know if it is right for me to say this method works for everyone, but I wanted to mention it here in case it helps you. I basically translated anywhere from three thousand to five thousand characters daily, five days a week, for about two years (after developing a firm kanji base in college), and that put me up to a level where JLPT level one kind of actually felt like a joke to me. (Well, except for the grammar. That was kind of difficult, because a lot of it was not commonly used grammar, so I was not used to seeing it in my translation projects) It does sort of echo the main approach here in this video, which is to basically read a lot. The main message I take from all of this is to keep moving forward. Whether it is reading, translating, or even just studying note cards, always be moving forward, and do not worry too much about forgetting. Important words will keep popping back up in your life, and you can relearn them as many times as you need.
thank you for this, I am currently majoring in japanese studies and doing my year abroad in Tokyo for my masters degree. I have no specific interest in learning japanese like anime or idols (like most people around me) so I often loose motivation to continue studying. I've been trying to find ways to learn the language that I enjoy doing and not because I am forced to learn it. I think I'll try a bit of translation daily to help me and Im trying to be okay with forgetting kanjis and remembering them later.
@@cap1368 Cool! Good luck to you! If that does not work out, don't forget about just reading a bit daily, too, like the video talks about. I'm also not into anime etc. (although I love comics and will read a Japanese comic if it is good, as I will read a comic from any country if it is good), but I do like Japanese novels. My first Japanese novel was by Yoshimoto Banana, and I cannot recommend her enough (apologies if you already know about her). Also, the Onmyoji novel series is pretty good. These days I sometimes download a Japanese novel on my kindle every now and then. Although, like I said, in my off time I mostly read English novels and comics these days, ha ha. Anyways, good luck!!!! And enjoy the Tokyo study oportunity! I never got a chance to go abroad when I was still in school, so even though I live in Japan now, I am super envious!
Hi! I'm super curious to know how you got into translating. Its my dream job but it seems so hard to break into and I've been worried about not being up to jlptn1 level despite having finished my degree in Japanese studies
@@lucachristina5520 I got into translating by applying online as a freelance translator at Japanese translation companies. Translation company websites will usually have a 求人情報 link of some sort. You click it, and then fill out their online form. Sometimes you might have to submit a resume, so go online to find some good examples and templates for freelance translator resumes in Japanese (have multiple Japanese people check your resume if possible). If they think you seem good, they will send you a "trial" (トライアル). One trial should never be more than about half a page, and it should never be a real job. It is a test. You translate the trial and return it to them, usually by e-mail. Then, if they like your trial work, they will start sending you real job. Just a very small amount at first, until you build up a trust relationship with them. This whole process takes a looooooong time, so do not get discouraged. Most companies will not send you a trial, and most companies will never contact you after you return the trial. Then, even if you perform well on the trial, most companies will not give you actual work, at least not right away. You have to keep registering at new companies. I did an average of three to five new companies per day when I was starting out. If you register at too many companies, you might get too many trials, but if you register at too few, you will not get any, so do what fits your schedule. Expect to make TONS of mistakes at all stages of the process, even the trials, and expect to not get any actual work for a long time. Just keep trying. Eventually someone will give you a chance, and you might even mess that up too. Just keep going. That is how I did it. My first year was horrible, but I kept going. Then, even after my first five years, I felt like I was making mistakes daily, and it was hard to keep clients coming back. But now I have been doing it for twenty years and it is a stable job. You will eventually get good at it. Just keep trying. Also, side note: no one at Japanese companies knows about the JLPT. It's great to take it, and it is great to have on your resume, but it is not even near a requirement. I passed level 1 of the JLPT after I had already been translating professionally for over a year, and no one ever really asked for it on my resume. Anyhow, good luck!!! Just remember: it is pretty normal for the process to go slow and be a bit demoralizing. Just stick to it and you will eventually succeed. Meet your trial and job deadlines, be open to criticism, and always work on improving. Make sure to look up official English names for companies, organizations, and places. Look up everything and check your work twice or three times, especially in the beginning! Double checking is your most powerful tool. And never forget: sitting and concentrating for hours and hours is the hardest part. You will get better at that. And my most important piece of advice: stretch. You will have such a better career if your body is stretched out and feeling good while you work. It will improve your concentration and your speed. Good luck!
@@flexorlamonticus thank you so much for the incredibly detailed response!!! I'll take a look into some Japanese translation companies and see where I can go from there!!!
I also learn by reading and find it a little annoying that Anki is pushed so hard because it just isn’t for me (although I could be determined enough if that was truly the only way). I recognize of course that it could be very good for someone else. Anyway I like what this channel is about. I think it will be useful for people, and I wish success. I also found it funny you said that you were nervous
@@abcdefg3315 I actually don’t care when they pile up, I just reduce the pile. But everything else about it is so annoying for me. I don’t want to trash too much another person’s method that might work for them, but I see people talking about sentence mining or reviewing the most common words with the flash cards. I think the opposite, that uncommon cards should be reviewed to the point that it would matter enough to use them and just read everything else. In other words, I think the same as you that it should be use for revision. But that is just me
as a linguistics student i really enjoy your way of grouping kanji by phonetic component, semantic component and meanings. the kun-yomi method was new to me and seems very interesting! i will try to pay more attention to it, sometimes i notice kun-yomi relations but i never looked at it intensively. the 2 kanji compound relations categories are also something I've been doing sort of subconsciously, I've tried to look more into it but was never able to build a concrete study method around it, it was just something i would be aware of while studying new kanji and nothing more. I'll try to think of a more structural way to combine all these notions into a bigger concrete study plan, it really seems to be up my alley as I too dislike learning random vocab lists or drill anki flashcards.
17 years? You're so good at Japanese that it seems like such a short amount of time for someone your level. I can't even imagine having a time in your life not knowing Japanese. The language just feels so inside you when I hear you speak. Hard to believe you didn't know anything before 2007 (which felt like yesterday to me)
Thank you so much for this incredible video, Bunsuke. I really like the unique methods you use to remember the kanji. It's very different from other videos I've seen on RUclips which always seem to promote Anki or rote memorisation writing drills. Please keep making more content, I'm very excited to hear more from this channel. :)
I guess learning Japanese is harder than Chinese because to learn Japanese u need to understand the kanji as a root but in my experience learnong Chinese is easier cause its not a root but a word with meaning itself
I also don't enjoy Anki at all (only use it when I have to cram for exams) and love reading. The only downside is that I am not great at branching out outside what I usually enjoy reading, so my vocabulary consists basically of 専門用語, some useful vocabulary from popular Japanese novels and then extra random words from horror/sci-fi stuff. Since coming to Japan I also find that I learn best through super embarassing encounters where I mess some words up or I am stressed and need to communicate about something new. 😅
I completely get this. You start reading in a certain area and then get stuck after a while. But start picking up slightly outside your comfort zone and you'll pick up different vocab and writing styles in no time. If your like sci fi you might enjoy Abe Kobo. If you like mystery, you might also enjoy Matsumoto Seicho. Just a few ideas off the top of my head ;)
I did that with English. I wouldn't worry. I knew vocabulary for medieval warfare way before I could talk about a lot of every day stuff just because of video games (I should add maybe that my native language is German and German is one of the big languages that get media translated. So this was a conscious choice for me and not something I was forced into due to the lack of availability in my native language) but your command over the language improves regardless of what you consume. At some point I just started to read the news in English and watched RUclipsrs to get more into natural slang and stuff like this. I made incredibly embarassing mistakes when I started communicating with people. Forgetting basic words or not even knowing basic words. Like, I've read the word "glove" A LOT playing world of warcraft but it wasn't until I started playing with people on English servers that I had to say it and the way I said it just didn't make sense at all to a native speaker. 2 years later I wrote my bachelor thesis in English. It all just came together. The more I read and watched stuff I enjoyed the better my English got and the easier it was for me to get into the news and politics and all that stuff an adult should be able to talk about.
@@robinkuster1127 your "glove" story remind me that just this year I learn the pronunciation of "knot" while learn the pronunciation of hiragana lol And I have been studying English for years! So yeah, the only problem with reading a lot in the language that you want to learn is if you only read. Practicing your hearing ability and eventually pronunciation will solve this issue tho
You are way over my head about Kanji. Soon as you started talking about Kanji, you lost me. I will probably never understand Japanese language but a few words here and there. Probably too old (73 yo) to start grasping the language to even have basic conversations or understand Japan videos. But I am looking at the basics.
I watched this when it first came out, but I think I will re-watch it every once in awhile. Such good tips! You described some things that I didn't realize I already do in my head! And thank you for the references, I meant to look for the 音符 dictionary and forgot, so I need to go back to Amazon and see if I can get it. Please post more videos when you can!
yes I agree about reading, it is so important to learning Japanese, learning Kanji is only part of it. I also find practicing listening and talking to be equally important
Imo anki is part of the most efficient method for learning Japanese. You won't be able to recognize 2000 words in 2 months with your method. Getting through this early vocab to be able to immerse sooner is incredibly valuable.
yeah, I was able to memorize 2040 or so kanji in literally 2 months exactly - meaning going from 2,040 unmemorized to zero unmemorized in my deck. Of course I still had to spend hours maintaining it for a while, but over time it dropped to about 20 minutes a day. Of course, I enjoyed doing the flashcards. Other people might not. Sucks to be them.
I've used Anki a *lot* over the years, and it does not work for me. Anything I learn with Anki, or lists for that matter, may stick for a while but it sticks in the wrong part of the brain, kind of, and it just.. dissipates after a while. All of it. The *only* way for me to learn anything is through what I call association, which is hard to peg down but it's about "getting" it, from context. I learned all my English vocabulary (which is very large if I say so myself) solely through association - I've never used a dictionary, and never learned anything by any memory tricks. If I look at my (still poor) Japanese vocabulary I've had lots of problems remembering stuff I've tried to learn through Anki and other methods, but vocabulary I've picked up simply because I understood what my wife was saying (she's Japanese) I remember forever after. The trick is to understand the meaning of something not through translation, but from context. Then it sticks. Some people can learn from lists and the like. I can't. Never could.
I started learning 2 years ago, I still use anki but the way I use it and the reason for using has changed over time. When I first started learning, I had this idea that anki was a magic ticket to learning Japanese effortlessly. That ended up not being true, but I ended up using it to remember words I encountered easier. The problem was that I was spending too long doing it, and not long enough reading or watching stuff. Nowadays I never need to do it more than 5 mins a day, because I don't make too many cards, and I don't force myself to perfectly remember. As you said, forgetting is part of the learning process.
Im good at memorizing each characters.. But listening, grammar, vocab is whats hard for me haha.. For now 90+ kanji characters and each meaning is i memorized.. But some meaning is i only know through English.. Some i know through japanese words.. If only i had japanese friends but none. Im from Philippines and wanted to learn nihonggo for applying on japan and i also love Japanese language.. Why didnt i learn Japanese language before tho even if im anime fan haha..
I thought I had enough of "how to learn Japanese" videos, as I've been inundated with them for the many years I've tried to learn this language, but what makes this video different is the list of incredibly interesting books. Origins of the kanji and radicals are very interesting to me, so those are up my alley. Hope they're not too expensive. Thanks for the video!
Hello! Very interesting video! You have so beautiful books! Could you recommend a book about the history of the japaense language *and theories about the origin). I am looking for it for a long time and don'y find any book. It could be bilingual english-japanese. Thank you in advance.
![[Limbus Company - Teaser] Season5 - Oblivion](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8anKuEeZLeI/mqdefault.jpg)
“Forgetting is part of the learning process”. I needed to hear that. Thank you. I let it frustrate me too much when I forget stuff I worked hard to remember.
This stuff can get frustrating at times, but it just takes patience, focus, and consistency. Otherwise just enjoy the ride, bumps and all.
I learned english in the same way, just starting reading harry potter book series and watching the big bang theory, always searching for every word written/listened and in the end I was able to understand english spoken and written. I am hoping to use the same method for japanese. The most import thing for me was not have fear of forget words but fear of not use the idiom in a certain day.
That's one of the best quotes I've ever heard for learning.
Me too!!
Don't fool yourself. Failing is part of the process, yes. But it still means you failed.
Something I enjoy a lot is watching/listening to Japanese songs with the Japanese lyrics. Even if I don’t know the reading of the kanji, I can often pick up what the artist is singing after a few good listens. I feel like it helps me a lot to remember things to song.
That makes a lot of sense, I've heard of other people doing this a lot!
Same. I find simply looking at the kanji, even if I don't memorize it, even if I don't know what it means, just looking at it and subconsciously storing it in my mind greatly helps remembering it when I eventually actually try to learn it.
@brinJPN do you have tips for such songs?
@ Most songs you can find the lyrics online which helps a lot. From there it’s looking up the meanings (I usually do that after a few good listens.) Will see that lyrics and hear them singing it and discover how to say the kanji. I can then look it up on a dictionary app. (Or if I can’t figure it out draw it in the app). Just keep in mind that lyrics follow song grammar and so some things sung might not word as an actual sentence so it’s best used for vocabulary building and minor grammar. But the huge benefit is listening (and if you sing) speaking practice. I also write out the lyrics to get extra writing practice too. I usually spend a month or two picking apart one song. There is nothing more fun than breaking out into Japanese song IMO. ☺️
You are absolutely correct. Reading is the magic trick.
When I realized that I was making no progress with Japanese, I took a step back and ask myself "You've learned English before, how did you do it?" And the answer was that I've read fanfiction a lot. But the thing is, it is easy to read English, but in Japanese, whenever I came across an unfamiliar kanji I'd just mumble and move on. So I started playing voiced visual novel games in Japanese. I am still not at the level where I can read a book and I am a very impatient person so I just stop studying when I feel bored. But in visual novels, voice actors usually read most of the sentences, and from the context and their acting I can kind of make out a meaning, and if I can't, I look it up. After I encounter the same kanji a few times, it becomes a familiar kanji.
Reading takes a lot of time, and at least for people who learn Japanese simply for entertainment like me, finding reading materials that you enjoy is very important.
@ellikereelif Im very interested in resourses that included both text and sound, can you tell more about the visual novels that you used? Thanks 🤩
@@linhtrieu4933 I had written a very long reply before but it got deleted I guess, so now I will write a shorter one. You can watch ToKini Andy's video "How I Learned Japanese with Visual Novels" video.
So, I turned to visual novels because watching Japanese movies with Japanese subtitles or reading books with audiobook version playing in the back doesn't work for me. They always move on so quickly and I need some time to process the information, but if I stop too frequently I get bored. Visual Novels are good because they move on my pace.
I usually play them on PC, but there are also mobile games that you can download, but I use QooApp to download them because they are usually restricted to Japanese Google Play. I played HypMic like that, and it's free to read the story parts of it.
The only downfall to visual novels that I can think of is this; if you are not interested in anime, you might not like visual novels either, because they are both part of the same entertainment culture. Visual novels have a very "anime" feel to them and I like it.
@@ellikereelif thank you for your "actually detailed" reply. I'll try it out on PC through stream, I guess.
@Elif Thank you. I will try ...anime, reading, learning Kanji...sounds fantastic. Maybe I will finally succeed
I learned English by reading (and reading and reading..), I never used dictionaries, and it worked for me. Japanese has some obstacles there... and I seem to be a bit similar to you (based on that other comment), I get bored if I can't actually ingest what I'm watching (I need the story to be a story, not text or pictures on a page - it needs to be inside my mind or I don't learn anything). Will have to look up what those "visual novels" are, I haven't run across that before.
EditUpdate: Seems like those VNs are only available via various gaming platforms which I don't have access to, unfortunately.
Hello!
I’m Japanese😊
I just happen to find your video.
Your Japanese pronunciation is very good!!
Also, It’s not easy for us to learn kanji.
You know about Kani better than Japanese.
“悪女について“ Is my favorite novel!
Thanks! Glad you liked the video:)
有吉佐和子さんいいですよね！吉行淳之介の『悪女という種族』も、全然作風は違うけど、面白いですよー！
吉行淳之介の世界も好きです。
映画なのですが、「吉原炎上」という映画やばいです！遊女の物語で、女性の激しいさがが描かれています。
「吉原炎上」は初めて聞きました！今度調べてみますね、おすすめありがとうございます😄
@@bunsuke.nihongo 是非是非😀もしご覧になったら感想お聞かせください🙌
You've learned kanji just by reading. So have I.
Of course, in the very beginning, I copied a couple of hundred of them, enough to learn about basic strokes (all 9 of them!) and radicals, etc. But then I kind of realized that trying to memorize kanji was the same as trying to memorize vocabulary, and this is just not the way I think you can learn a language. So I started doing what I had always been doing for other (alphabet-based) languages, i.e. just reading everything I could get my hands on.
In the case of Japanese, that meant finding stories (either actual books or on the Internet) with "okurigana" or romaji and comparing each original Japanese sentence with its translation, sometimes writing both languages side by side so as to make it easier to read again later. And wouldn't you know it? I started to realize that without making any special effort at memorizing, I was remembering quite a lot of kanji in a general way, in the same way that people remember faces. When you think about it, anyone is able to recognize (without necessarily being able to put a name on each one) hundreds, if not thousands of faces, without ever having had to analyze their different characteristics (shape of eyes, nose, mouth, ears, forehead, etc.), and I've come to believe that "recognizing" kanji works just the same. The mind is one extraordinary tool we humans have.
Furigana, but yes.
@@StrategicGamesEtcStrange but true. I had actually never checked the definition of "okurigana" and just assumed it was basically synonymous with "furigana", perhaps just an older term. Thanks for setting me straight.
Humans have specific neural circuitry to recognize (human) faces, people with brain damage in certain areas aren't able to recognize them. It's not the same with kanji although once you learn all the radicals, etc it becomes pretty easy to recognize them by their sub-structures.
@@takanara7 I must have brain damage b/c I forget people's faces and I def can't remember Kanji like you guys can, smh.
llol@@sethaldrich6902
I use the same method to learn English - reading. And, as you said, spaced repetition occurs randomly within the reading of different materials, including the healthy cycle of forgetting. It's interesting and encouraging to know the similarity in language learning, whatever language you are interested in.
the mystery of how people learn english pronuciation still completely blows my mind. i suppose reading along with audio books must help alot.
These are really great advices. I have been learning Chinese for long time (I only know a few words and sentences in Japanese), but I can relate. I did use Anki but it has its downsides. All the techniques you mentioned are based on your experience, but I confirm they are also backed by science. Great video 👍🏻
are you still using anki
Does he have an ig account
I liked your method for learning kanji and in the first stage of grouping I categorize them in verbs, adjectives, nouns and finally adverbs, conjunctions, etc. This way many of the kanji that you memorized in the verbs are the same in adjectives and nouns, and this way you memorize the readings of the kanjis in context.
Thank you, I'm glad you liked it.
I would love it if you made a video with book recommendations grouped by their difficulty! I am sure a lot of other people would appreciate it as well.
Amazing tips! I found that when I tried to use Anki I quickly lost motivation to keep reading. Seeing how much people swear by it I thought maybe I was doing it wrong. I think my brain just needs to be more fast paced with study and learning through genuine repetition of context and content.
Thanks so much Brin, I'm glad you enjoyed this. As you can tell from some of the other comments, you're not alone! You're not doing anything wrong, just try different things and see what fits you. Context based learning has certainly worked for me, so if you haven't tried it, why not give it a shot. And if it's not for you, move on or mix and match until you've found your style.
Nice video! As a Singaporean Chinese, I have no problems understanding the meaning of the kanji. HOWEVER what I can't stand the most is every character has at least 2-3 different sounds depending on how it is matched with different kanji! Even a simple 月 has like at least 3 ways of speaking depending on if it's a moon, a month or a full moon! Knowing English, Chinese & Japanese, I am 100% sure Japanese is the toughest language to learn! Good luck to everyone learning Japanese!!! Gambatte!
@youknowkbbaby which at one time, did not exist at all. ;)
Thank you for the explanation, I've been struggling for some years wanting to learn kanji since I want to read Japanese literature and miscellaneous books, but every time I get frustrated with how fast I forget what I just studied. I'll try again and make an effort of trusting the process, it helps knowing that forgetting is "normal" and part of it.
Thank you so much - these tips are really helpful and I’ll definitely start incorporating them into my own studies. Looking forward to future videos!
Thank you! I'm glad you found these helpful! Stay tuned for more ;)
Hi, I cross this video accidentally. I am a native Taiwanese and Mandarin speaker. However, my child and I are living in the US. This is how I teach him kanji (hanji) in Taiwanese and Mandarin. He starts with very basic simple words. For example, “日”，“月”，“金”，“木”，“水“，”火“，“土”， “一”， “二”... and some basic verb. "來“，”去“，”走“... Let him get familiar with these basic components (I guess less than 50 words). Once he knows these words well, learning new words will be easy since almost all kanji words are composed of these basic components.
The next step is writing meaningful short sentences. For example, “上學“ (go to school). These meaningful sentences help children to learn quickly. As time flies, we increase the length of sentences. We pick a new sentence every week. And repeat the same sentence by writing it down once every day.
Of course, he forgets words quickly. But, the commonly used words in books, videos, and signs will refresh his memory from time to time. So, he learns really useful words.
very instructive.
Thanks for the tips and recommendations!
The "deconstructing" part was really interesting, specially because I noticed that I have been using the method without even noticing. Now with more aware of it, I will try to implement it more consistently.
Ah this was refreshing, thank you for just sharing your learning journey and methods. Very useful and interesting! And unconventional, which always helps. Different perspectives are always good to know!
I've been half-heartedly trying to learn Japanese for eight years now.
It's only been in the last couple of years that I fully realised that learning by rote just isn't very good. It is guaranteed to work, but it is incredibly inefficient and a very long slog. Part of sticking to it has been familiarity from my school days, but also laziness. I tried Anki several times and hated it.
Learning things in context really is the best way once you have a solid foundation. It can be tough and frustrating at first, as you understand almost nothing. But you end up learning vocabulary, grammar, and phrases that are actually used and you will actually use. And you get entertainment and/or knowledge from it, even at the most basic level.
I've been doing the Memrise courses for a while now, and I think they are good in-between way. Sure, it is rote learning, but they introduce words and then sentences or phrases that use those words. There's some basic explanation of the grammar at first, but they really just throw you in there for the most part. It's therefore something I recommend, especially if someone is struggling to find and choose material to study/practise with.
I was wondering where I knew your name from and then it hit me ahah glad to see you are still pushing your newsletter and now this channel! I know you are more focused on the reading side of things, but I would love to see your methods regarding what you did to improve your listening. Would also be cool to see your opinion and approaches regarding reading physical books vs. reading books in a digital format using tools like yomichan.
Anyways, glad to see you pushing content like this and sharing your insights!
Great to see you back here :) Wanted to hold off on plugging this channel on the newsletter until I had some more content to share, but the video has taken off in an unexpected way. I'll start posting on the newsletter again too, but after I finish my dissertation.
Personally I always go for paper. I've never used yomichan, so can't really give an opinion, but I'd say pick whatever suits your style of learning or combine until you've found a routine that works for you.
@@bunsuke.nihongo I always preferred reading paper over digital, but Japanese puts you in a weird spot where, reading paper kinda sucks since looking up word takes so much time, and digital makes lookups easy but reading on digital also sucks ahah. So I've been mostly listening and do some light reading here and there.
Hope we get more videos from you soon 👍
@@jporfirio_ Whtas wrong with reading digitally? The time you safe for looking up words is tremendous, so unless you're really fluent already I would highly suggest using Yomichan because it's so convenient. If Eyestrain is bothersome to you, I would recommend a Kindle (Or any other E-Reader) with E-Ink technology, this is the best of both worlds in my opinion since you can load your own dictonaries into it and read comfortably. (I have the 大辞林 and 広辞苑 on my Kindle and really enjoy reading there).
I am glad I ran into your channel. Looking forward for more videos about kanji. New to learning Japanese, everybody seems to think that my primary goal it is be able to talk but actually I am more interested on be able to read it. I been trying to learn in different ways kanji, but I been struggling. Repetition methods with flash cards kill me. I am going to give it a try to reading. Maybe some day I will be able to learn all that you know, I am only 17 years BEHIND! 😅.
Glad you found me, too! No rush, it's all about the journey, not the goal :)
If doing flashcards for a long time is painful, just set a time limit of, for example, 20 minutes a day or whatever. If you stick with it you'll probably have most of the Joyo kanji memorized in a year or so, I would think.
Finally, I found my answer why it's difficult for me to learn kanji. Thanks!
I understand your explanation about kanji nicely! Good luck on your study!
I actually understood and could digest Most of what he was trying to convey. I surprised myself when I knew several Kanji. This would have been confusing to me not too long ago. Thank You. Whenever I watch a video like this it boosts my interest to learn the language, as sometimes I get a little complaisant and start to wain away
私は日本人🇯🇵ですが、オランダ🇳🇱に貴方のような方がいるのにとても感動しました‼️
My mind is blown, I had no idea I could learn Kanji this way, it's fantastic! You just motivated me to study again, thank you! I think this video can help a lot of people. Have you ever thought about adding Spanish subtitles to it? I would love to do Spanish subtitles for this video and share it with my friends, so they can also get motivated too. If that's something you'd be interested in, please let me know! Love from Argentina :)
This was amazing! Thank you so much for making this video Bunsuke. 👏
You're very welcome! I hope some of this was useful :)
Bunsuke is an example of a very good "Teacher". I know a total of 10 Kanji. But he inspires me to learn more. Anecdotally, I believe "Good Teachers" should rank among the highest paid professionals in society. However, our society will not allow this. Good Teachers do their job because they Love it. How many people actually Love their job? Amen.. ha haa . Keep studying and improving. I am 67 years old and started learning Japanese 6 months ago. I think its time to toy with Kanji.
Hi, I just got out of the N5 exam, so your advanced advice comes a bit early for me, but I know I'll get back to this video in the future. Thanks for your thoughts.
We did the n5 on the same day! That's so cool
imma be honest-- seems like your dedication is just way higher than mine. anki is easy. this seems hard, and like way more work.
I think one of the better ways to use Anji is as a supplement to your way of reading and writing down new stuff. People call this 'sentence mining', where they create an anki flashcard of a sentence from their input material that has a new word. This is a sort of way to try to get more repetitions out of one encounter for a word, to try to recognize it easier the next time you see it. I think both ways are good, and the anki isn't necessary, just an attempt to remember stuff quicker for some people.
I've been reading and using a lot of these tactics you mentioned with my own Japanese journey for some time now. You've broken it down it excellently.
I let go of the habit of writing down words for Japanese, and instead just read a ton. It's like you said "if it's important it will come up again," but I think I will steal your habit of writing down words for reading in Korean, which I am a beginner at. I think in the early stages of reading, you don't have as many "categories" and ways to mentally associate words and so you're more likely to struggle to remember words. I think writing down sentences I've read will help me pick up the foundational Korean vocab. Honestly so glad I found someone else who uses reading instead of spaced repetition software. It's like, the more time I'm building flashcards, the less time I have to read.
A reference or link for the books you recommended would be nice in the description or show notes!
Thank you for the tips, i think i will use this method 🤠I wish there was a complete and helpful video like this one for Arabic too 😂 finding good methods for learning languages on RUclips is so hard,, I’m glad I found your channel!
although particular methods and mnemonic techniques may differ, one of the possible principles to guide one's kanji studies in terms of what kanji they study and in what sequence may be the scope of each particular level of the Kanji Kentei test (at least this is what Japanese people themselves do)
This was quite useful. I've been mindmapping kanji, but it ends up all over the place because of a lack of logical structure. I'll take a look at the groupings and see if that works better. Thanks!
My main reason for learning Japanese was to read the literature. So this is a godsend. I have a long way to go, but I really appreciate it.
Excellent video! Thank you!
Very useful method! happy that I found you when struggling with Japanese.
日本人が見てもとても楽しいし、勉強になります。将来は、まさに来る、か。日本人なら平将門知ってるんで、将はまさ、と読むことは知ってるけど、将来という熟語と結びつけて考えたことなかったですねー。あと、俺も青空文庫相当読むんで、その紹介も嬉しかった。しまいに漢詩まで出てきたのでもう平伏します笑
Very usefull tips! Already using them now! Thank you for taking the time to share! Like and subscribe buttons smashed!
Anyway, if you're a regular language student with few minutes a day for the language, I'd say that a SRS like Anki is a must, specially for kanji begginers.
But If your doing a PhD... on japanese literature... already immersed in japanese the entire work time..., well... that really seems to be a whole different situation that demands much higer level than just a plain "root" memorization, right? Very good to know that.
Thanks, glad you liked the video :)
Can you please, list names of these resources in the description, as a text, or as a message? These resources look interesting, and I understand that these dictionaries are for more advanced learners, but I would like to look up for these, but it looks really hard, or rather time consuming to search for names, only by visuals and pronounced names in the video.
Amazing video!!! Please keep doing this
Nice to know a great efforts to learn Kanji.
3:32 The book seems to be out of print on Amazon Japan 🥺 This is what I was looking for 😭
あああーーー すごい教材のおすすめ❤️ 先生は、vocabulary notebook を使いますか。言葉を習う方法を説明しましたが、どうやってこの言葉を記録したり、整ったりしますか？
「あ、この言葉を見たけど、どこに書いたのかなー？」という気持ちがどう扱いますか？
I like this method, it is the same as mine but more advanced
You should try Anki. You will love it.
I have been learning English like this as well and also felt that reading is just another way of space repetition (but making it fun). Anki just don't work for me and for what I have noticed, even heard there were some studies, it actually doesn't work for most people and don't think it's because all of these people aren't able to figure out how the method works. Flashcards aren't the only way to learn and I wish more people were aware of this, maybe then less students would end up frustrated and giving up only because they try something that didn't work for them.
What are your thoughts on Heisig's book 'Remembering the Kanji' ?
Thank the algorithms for bringing me to your channel. Five ⭐️ s.
Do you have a list somewhere of the books you refer to? I thought it would be in the description but I don't see it. This is a very good video!
I find Anki sleep inducing
Do you have a recommendation specifically for learning the phonetic pieces? I have already finished Heisig's RTK part 1, so I can recognize kanji pretty well. The phonetic components seem like a great way to memorize, but this is the first place I've ever seen it even mentioned.
I do really enjoy the info. Thank you. Is there a way to remove the background music? It is an issue for me for hearing and focus. Thank you again.
I am not a fan of Anki, so this video was very insightful. Do you still tutor or do you have online classes? Also is there a link for all the resources you covered in the video?
Since you’re literature student please assuage my deepest concern about kanji:
How do you read classical haiku (or any verse poetry) when they use kanji & there’s multiple readings? Can it obscure the author’s intent with respect to meter, or can it be guessed precisely enough that nobody would debate it?
If multiple readings fit in the meter one would hope the editor or publisher provides a reading based on the latest research. I sometimes compare different editions of a text, usually the 新潮日本古典集成 and the 小学館新編日本古典文学全集
This man is incredible. I can't wait to be on that level.
Bonjour. Merci pour cette vidéo même si je ne suis qu'une débutante. Je viens d'abandonner (provisoirement ) Anki pour faire un peu comme vous. Bye !
Could you please comment down the name of the first book you recommended, the one that is hard to get? Thanks.
Hi ,
Book you mentioned. I want to get it. ( I am in Tokyo) (覚えやすいテーマ別段階別漢字実践練習) Could you please share author name and publication. As you mentioned could not find it online, want to try my luck in store.
This guys English is flawless also I am assuming he is European born
Alright but like..all of those books are in Japanese and have Kanji. So how do you read those books to start with?
Depends on where you are in your learning journey. Perhaps you need a good tutor to help you on your way...
@@bunsuke.nihongo Thank You
You have to learn the radicals and etymology. I’m learning from a RUclips videos a Korean author of kanji book made and I’m learning 40 characters a day. She teaches the etymology and how the characters are made from radicals. She spends about 30 seconds on Each character so I finish 40 characters in 20 minutes. Then I look at the list and the one I don’t remember, I watch the video again. I repeat until I know all 40 characters. Then when I finish a grade level, I use online kanji test by grade level
What's the name of her channel?
@@elentilion 일본어 상용한자 1026. It’s in Korean. Search learn kanji by radicals. There are English books that teach kanji using radicals also,
@@sunglee3935 Thank you.
@@elentilion I found this book. THE KEY TO ALL JOYO KANJI: A Study Guide Using Common Shapes and Character Histories
@@sunglee3935, I actually to this exact book this week. It's pretty good!
Hello again Bunsuke-san, wishing you a good year-end occasion and a good beginning in the next one. How are you doing? 😃 It's gone two weeks since I discovered your substack, and I'm now already on entry #250. I also read Tamura Toshiko's 生血 or Lifeblood you presented in the immersion reading project. Here's how it went:
I get what you described about reading stories. Reading the first pages felt like I lost my bearings and orientation, my eyes spin, I got sleepy, distracted, among other stuffs, just from trying to read everything in one sitting without trying to comprehend what I just read. What I know for sure is, I have to get used to it little by little, like progressing from a shallow pond to a deep pool. It's not that I don't understand most of the meaning of the individual words, but I have to get used to handling every single one that repeatedly came and see them all in a certain context in order to picture the scene of the story in my mind's eye. Doing it tires, of course, and so the moment I lost focus, I took some minutes off before I came back to reread it. In the process I actually came to understand the story on an unconscious level, so, after coming back to it repeatedly, I discovered that I wasn't drowning compared to the first few times, I just need to move along with the flow so as not to drown. Reading is something that got easier as you do it often and let the flow carry you around, surfaces, depths, anywhere it went, just let go of the fear and trust on the eventual arrival of understanding. All in all, I finished these two chapters of Lifeblood in two days. Actually, three days, as I postpone reading the last two, three pages on the second day, because I have some errands that day.
So, consuming native material is the best way to understand a new language, be it written or spoken. Unfortunately, just start reading from day one is not so easy in Japanese, at least in the beginning. Kanji came with a lot of information to unpack, despite only occupying single character blocks, and you just have to stick to being accompanied by dictionaries for a while. I know I still do, even after all this time. I still rely on 10ten reader to help me with the way some Kanji readings should be read if I want to be quick so as not to lose the plot. Other dictionaries that could help is Google search. Just type in とは or 意味 after the vocabulary you're looking up is a godsend if you already at some point along your progress, as are some other J-J dictionaries. Overall, the progress of my learning is not that bad though, I still got to identify how I could've done this the more efficient, time-and-cost-saving way. The way things works for me is to look up each and every word and consider their sum in totality. I guess I am just obsessive with the meaning of words. The unknown drives me crazy. 😆
I remember now why I want to learn Japanese. Initially, I wish to understand everything on manga, anime, visual novels, etc without waiting for translations, all the subtleties, nuances, choice of words in these works. I think I'd like return to those old materials soon. It's going to be like meeting your first love again after a while, bittersweetly familiar, keeping a bit of the tragic consciousness in the background as you know that as all the things had came full circle and the object you desire and yearned for is finally within your reach, all you are left with even more yearning and desire of the ideal. 🥀 The Germans call it Sehnsucht, I guess? Not all is sad and tragic, I have even more higher hopes for the future of my language learning. This time I'm picking languages other than Japanese, like German, French and Spanish, and maybe some Dutch, Italian, and Portuguese. Of course I'll be returning to Japanese materials when I found some works that interests me. I hope in the coming decade I already know all of them to a certain level where I could just read materials and understand 80-90% of what was written, the way I currently know the words I read in Japanese right now.
How to start reading books if i don't know kanji at all. Even basic ones. So, the reading of simple books is becoming an unresolvable task: I can't recognize characters how they look like and can't know how they sound. Seems like a dead end to me ((
Perhaps you're just in need of a good tutor to guide you through the early stages...ever tried hiring one?
When you write down the kanji do you review them later?
I don't, I just throw them out. For me the act of writing down helps me remember the kanji, but I never go back to those notes for review.
Tldr study for kanji kentei
hey bunsuke, love your work - we should really collab some time
what an amazing idea!! let's make it happen ;)
Are you a fan of Justin Sung by any chance?
anki the best
New subscriber here
日本語が見れるのかと思って見たら"英語！?"
当たり前ですよね、日本語を学ぼうとしている人達の為の動画ですから••••。
皆さん一生懸命頑張って下さい。外国語学習は一生のものでリミットがありません。
Take it easy!!
do you know any useful resourses for learning the origin of kanjis and how the combination of it's radicals make sense.
because i am very interested in learning the origin of them but i can't find any useful websites on the internet
even wikipedia and chinese etymology doesn't make any help🥲
Outlier Linguistics.
RUclips channel and website.
They’ve got a video introduction paleography (文字學).
They’re also creating a dictionary for that purpose.
@@HakuYuki001 ❤❤
"If it's important it will come up again" I can't stress how true this is.
”Reading is its own form of spaced repetition".. What a fantastic quote!
It's not a very effective one. Some words are harder to remember than others, and seeing words twice a year isn't enough to keep it in your memory. And before you say "oh, well those words aren't that important", the vast majority of words are like that, and are needed to engage in anything adult-related.
@@jpnpod8277 what is your language learning method?
@@Rebecca-bz6ph I spend most of my time immersing, either actively watching and reading content, or listening to recordings of said content on repeat. I turn new words I find into Anki cards and then study them for about 30 min - 1 hr everyday. I also occasionally watch grammar videos on RUclips.
I would argue that doing space repetition by reading can be more effective than flashcards. If you pay attention to the context the word is used and make some of the connections the guy in the video mentioned (like comparing or grouping them with antonym and synonym) instead of having to see the same flashcards hundreds of times you can learn it by just seeing the word a couple if times, maybe even learning it and sticking it to your head forever having only seeing it once. In the end you just have to go and see what methodology works best for you, just keep in mind that flashcards aren't the only way to learn and they may not be the best way to learn for you.
it's true but it's not the entire story. It depends what words you wanna learn. For instance, in an intro textbook I learned the word 給料 (salary). and put that into Anki. Then I read books in Japanese, that is monolingual Japanese books shipped from Japan. I read 9 books before one of them mentioned the word 給料, which I was able to read because of Anki. Is that an important word? IDK. But I bet every Japanese person and nearly every learner knows it. Textbooks, anki, and reading books, all are forms of studying and all will refresh your memory differently and at different rates.
Essentially, the key is making connections by using, contextualizing, and grouping kanji to make progressively more connections. This tracks with what we know about learning. Trying to memorize disembodied lists doesn't work as well as just reading or writing with the words you're wanting to learn. The more connections your brain can make with something the easier it becomes to recall.
Stellar vid! Some great ideas to try.
You don't memorize them as arbitrary lists, but rather by their structure and etymology. And anyway, using SRS to memorize Kanji (along with mnemonics, etc) absolutely does work and works really fast. The reason so many people say it works great is b/c all those people used it and learned Kanji that way.
When you start out learning japanese, trying to solely learn through reading is going to be very time consuming and inefficient. The purpose of anki is to build a good foundation of vocabulary by remembering the basic meaning of a word, so that when you encounter it while reading, you are able to at least understand what it means, which makes it easier to draw connections to how the word is used and in which context it appears in.
I like your tip about reading books and learning kanji and vocab through encounters. I personally love to read and don’t enjoy using flashcards and stuff, but most people online tend to focus really heavily on learning through study tools so I felt like ‘I was doing it wrong’. I will never forget the words 商品 or 防犯カメラ after reading kombini ningen though😅. I’ll pursue reading more and dedicate time to it in my studying schedule to treat it as a formal studying tool.
Hi Tony, trust me you are not alone, as you can see in the comments from others, many people feel frustrated with flashcards and other related systems/apps/methods. Keep at it, and do it in a way that suits your needs and goals. This stuff is supposed to be fun!
This is great. A lot to process here. My own personal story is, after majoring in Japanese at a university, I started working as a freelance Japanese to English translator around 2000 or 2001. Before that, I had not been able to pass JPLT level one (and barely passed level two, after two tries). After a couple years of sweating it out on translation projects daily, I decided to try JPLT level one again. I was SHOCKED at how much kanji I knew. When I went through my kanji texts for test prep, I was actually laughing at how much kanji I had not known before becoming a translator. Most of the areas I had marked as problem areas for me felt so basic now. And then when I actually took the test, I sailed through the kanji and reading sections so fast, I could not believe it (this after sweating bullets on level two a few years before).
So, my takeaway was, translating 8 to 10 hours a day every day pushed my kanji recognition level up so much higher than my college or post college studies ever did.
Don't get me wrong, it was tough.
What I think happened is, when I was studying, before starting work as a translator, I spent a lot of time diving into each kanji. It was hard to move on to the next kanji or the next vocab word. You want to make sure you have fully memorized it. And then, I would get super frustrated and demoralized if I later discovered I had forgotten it. It was actually pretty emotionally difficult, especially after college when I felt like I had no clear goals. It felt like swimming in a giant ocean, with no land in sight. I never knew if I was making progress. It always felt like I was losing ground faster than gaining it.
Then, when I started translating, I had no more time for any of that. Clients wanted projects done quickly, so I never worried about if I was memorizing words or kanji or not. I just kept looking up words I did not know and translating text as fast and as accurately as I could. If I made mistakes, I corrected them and moved on to the next job.
It turns out that this was a great way to study, at least for me. After I was freed from the pressure of trying to completely memorize each vocab word or kanji before moving on, I wound up actually memorizing a lot more words and kanji through simple repetition.
I should mention, my skills at writing kanji by hand are so horrible now as to be embarrassing, but that is because I spend my free time doing things other than practicing writing kanji. If I made that a core hobby outside of work, I'd probably be pretty good at it. (I mention this to show one downside of my method of learning)
Also, I should mention, I do not study Japanese at all outside of work now. Oh, I watch the occasional Japanese show or movie, and sometimes I do read Japanese for pleasure, but outside of work, I mostly read English novels and make art. I barely ever do anything that looks remotely like studying kanji. So if your passion for kanji does let you keep studying after a full day of translating or reading, all the more power to you! You will be much better than I.
So... for everyone out there studying... I do not know if it is right for me to say this method works for everyone, but I wanted to mention it here in case it helps you. I basically translated anywhere from three thousand to five thousand characters daily, five days a week, for about two years (after developing a firm kanji base in college), and that put me up to a level where JLPT level one kind of actually felt like a joke to me. (Well, except for the grammar. That was kind of difficult, because a lot of it was not commonly used grammar, so I was not used to seeing it in my translation projects)
It does sort of echo the main approach here in this video, which is to basically read a lot.
The main message I take from all of this is to keep moving forward. Whether it is reading, translating, or even just studying note cards, always be moving forward, and do not worry too much about forgetting. Important words will keep popping back up in your life, and you can relearn them as many times as you need.
thank you for this, I am currently majoring in japanese studies and doing my year abroad in Tokyo for my masters degree. I have no specific interest in learning japanese like anime or idols (like most people around me) so I often loose motivation to continue studying. I've been trying to find ways to learn the language that I enjoy doing and not because I am forced to learn it. I think I'll try a bit of translation daily to help me and Im trying to be okay with forgetting kanjis and remembering them later.
@@cap1368 Cool! Good luck to you! If that does not work out, don't forget about just reading a bit daily, too, like the video talks about. I'm also not into anime etc. (although I love comics and will read a Japanese comic if it is good, as I will read a comic from any country if it is good), but I do like Japanese novels. My first Japanese novel was by Yoshimoto Banana, and I cannot recommend her enough (apologies if you already know about her). Also, the Onmyoji novel series is pretty good. These days I sometimes download a Japanese novel on my kindle every now and then. Although, like I said, in my off time I mostly read English novels and comics these days, ha ha. Anyways, good luck!!!! And enjoy the Tokyo study oportunity! I never got a chance to go abroad when I was still in school, so even though I live in Japan now, I am super envious!
Hi! I'm super curious to know how you got into translating. Its my dream job but it seems so hard to break into and I've been worried about not being up to jlptn1 level despite having finished my degree in Japanese studies
@@lucachristina5520 I got into translating by applying online as a freelance translator at Japanese translation companies. Translation company websites will usually have a 求人情報 link of some sort. You click it, and then fill out their online form. Sometimes you might have to submit a resume, so go online to find some good examples and templates for freelance translator resumes in Japanese (have multiple Japanese people check your resume if possible). If they think you seem good, they will send you a "trial" (トライアル). One trial should never be more than about half a page, and it should never be a real job. It is a test. You translate the trial and return it to them, usually by e-mail. Then, if they like your trial work, they will start sending you real job. Just a very small amount at first, until you build up a trust relationship with them. This whole process takes a looooooong time, so do not get discouraged. Most companies will not send you a trial, and most companies will never contact you after you return the trial. Then, even if you perform well on the trial, most companies will not give you actual work, at least not right away. You have to keep registering at new companies. I did an average of three to five new companies per day when I was starting out. If you register at too many companies, you might get too many trials, but if you register at too few, you will not get any, so do what fits your schedule. Expect to make TONS of mistakes at all stages of the process, even the trials, and expect to not get any actual work for a long time. Just keep trying. Eventually someone will give you a chance, and you might even mess that up too. Just keep going. That is how I did it. My first year was horrible, but I kept going. Then, even after my first five years, I felt like I was making mistakes daily, and it was hard to keep clients coming back. But now I have been doing it for twenty years and it is a stable job. You will eventually get good at it. Just keep trying. Also, side note: no one at Japanese companies knows about the JLPT. It's great to take it, and it is great to have on your resume, but it is not even near a requirement. I passed level 1 of the JLPT after I had already been translating professionally for over a year, and no one ever really asked for it on my resume.
Anyhow, good luck!!! Just remember: it is pretty normal for the process to go slow and be a bit demoralizing. Just stick to it and you will eventually succeed. Meet your trial and job deadlines, be open to criticism, and always work on improving. Make sure to look up official English names for companies, organizations, and places. Look up everything and check your work twice or three times, especially in the beginning! Double checking is your most powerful tool. And never forget: sitting and concentrating for hours and hours is the hardest part. You will get better at that.
And my most important piece of advice: stretch. You will have such a better career if your body is stretched out and feeling good while you work. It will improve your concentration and your speed.
Good luck!
@@flexorlamonticus thank you so much for the incredibly detailed response!!! I'll take a look into some Japanese translation companies and see where I can go from there!!!
I also learn by reading and find it a little annoying that Anki is pushed so hard because it just isn’t for me (although I could be determined enough if that was truly the only way). I recognize of course that it could be very good for someone else.
Anyway I like what this channel is about. I think it will be useful for people, and I wish success.
I also found it funny you said that you were nervous
Thanks so much, I'll do my best to create more useful content!
@@abcdefg3315 I actually don’t care when they pile up, I just reduce the pile. But everything else about it is so annoying for me.
I don’t want to trash too much another person’s method that might work for them, but I see people talking about sentence mining or reviewing the most common words with the flash cards. I think the opposite, that uncommon cards should be reviewed to the point that it would matter enough to use them and just read everything else. In other words, I think the same as you that it should be use for revision. But that is just me
as a linguistics student i really enjoy your way of grouping kanji by phonetic component, semantic component and meanings. the kun-yomi method was new to me and seems very interesting! i will try to pay more attention to it, sometimes i notice kun-yomi relations but i never looked at it intensively.
the 2 kanji compound relations categories are also something I've been doing sort of subconsciously, I've tried to look more into it but was never able to build a concrete study method around it, it was just something i would be aware of while studying new kanji and nothing more.
I'll try to think of a more structural way to combine all these notions into a bigger concrete study plan, it really seems to be up my alley as I too dislike learning random vocab lists or drill anki flashcards.
Thank you for the generous comment, really glad you liked the video
yo another ling major???
17 years? You're so good at Japanese that it seems like such a short amount of time for someone your level. I can't even imagine having a time in your life not knowing Japanese. The language just feels so inside you when I hear you speak. Hard to believe you didn't know anything before 2007 (which felt like yesterday to me)
It would be amazing if you could list or write down the books you recommended
*he agrees while holding money wondering where to throw it
Lol😂
@@kylefenrick9168 I think they were added into the description box now!!!
Thank you so much for this incredible video, Bunsuke. I really like the unique methods you use to remember the kanji. It's very different from other videos I've seen on RUclips which always seem to promote Anki or rote memorisation writing drills. Please keep making more content, I'm very excited to hear more from this channel. :)
thanks so much for your lovely comment, I really appreciate it!
I guess learning Japanese is harder than Chinese because to learn Japanese u need to understand the kanji as a root but in my experience learnong Chinese is easier cause its not a root but a word with meaning itself
ジョシュアのチャンネルから飛んで来ました。
ブンスケさんの高い日本語能力にビックリ!
動画の内容も興味深い感じがします。でも、、、私は英語が分からない、、、、
外国人から見た日本文学がどの様に見えるのか知りたいので是非日本語の字幕も付けてもらえると嬉しいです。
I also don't enjoy Anki at all (only use it when I have to cram for exams) and love reading. The only downside is that I am not great at branching out outside what I usually enjoy reading, so my vocabulary consists basically of 専門用語, some useful vocabulary from popular Japanese novels and then extra random words from horror/sci-fi stuff. Since coming to Japan I also find that I learn best through super embarassing encounters where I mess some words up or I am stressed and need to communicate about something new. 😅
I completely get this. You start reading in a certain area and then get stuck after a while. But start picking up slightly outside your comfort zone and you'll pick up different vocab and writing styles in no time. If your like sci fi you might enjoy Abe Kobo. If you like mystery, you might also enjoy Matsumoto Seicho. Just a few ideas off the top of my head ;)
I did that with English. I wouldn't worry. I knew vocabulary for medieval warfare way before I could talk about a lot of every day stuff just because of video games (I should add maybe that my native language is German and German is one of the big languages that get media translated. So this was a conscious choice for me and not something I was forced into due to the lack of availability in my native language) but your command over the language improves regardless of what you consume. At some point I just started to read the news in English and watched RUclipsrs to get more into natural slang and stuff like this. I made incredibly embarassing mistakes when I started communicating with people. Forgetting basic words or not even knowing basic words. Like, I've read the word "glove" A LOT playing world of warcraft but it wasn't until I started playing with people on English servers that I had to say it and the way I said it just didn't make sense at all to a native speaker. 2 years later I wrote my bachelor thesis in English. It all just came together. The more I read and watched stuff I enjoyed the better my English got and the easier it was for me to get into the news and politics and all that stuff an adult should be able to talk about.
@@robinkuster1127 your "glove" story remind me that just this year I learn the pronunciation of "knot" while learn the pronunciation of hiragana lol And I have been studying English for years! So yeah, the only problem with reading a lot in the language that you want to learn is if you only read. Practicing your hearing ability and eventually pronunciation will solve this issue tho
ジョシュアさんの動画からきました！
私は逆にブンスケさんの動画で英語のリスニング力を鍛えたいと思います💪
You are way over my head about Kanji. Soon as you started talking about Kanji, you lost me. I will probably never understand Japanese language but a few words here and there. Probably too old (73 yo) to start grasping the language to even have basic conversations or understand Japan videos. But I am looking at the basics.
I’m really looking forward to the new kanji kentei game coming to Switch in a few days ❤
日本人より日本語に詳しい件
I watched this when it first came out, but I think I will re-watch it every once in awhile. Such good tips! You described some things that I didn't realize I already do in my head! And thank you for the references, I meant to look for the 音符 dictionary and forgot, so I need to go back to Amazon and see if I can get it. Please post more videos when you can!
Awesome video mate, please make a video on how you dealt with listening comprehension as well. Would love to hear your take on this regard!
Thanks a bunch! Listening is a great idea, I'll look if I can do one on that.
yes I agree about reading, it is so important to learning Japanese, learning Kanji is only part of it. I also find practicing listening and talking to be equally important
Imo anki is part of the most efficient method for learning Japanese. You won't be able to recognize 2000 words in 2 months with your method. Getting through this early vocab to be able to immerse sooner is incredibly valuable.
yeah, I was able to memorize 2040 or so kanji in literally 2 months exactly - meaning going from 2,040 unmemorized to zero unmemorized in my deck. Of course I still had to spend hours maintaining it for a while, but over time it dropped to about 20 minutes a day. Of course, I enjoyed doing the flashcards. Other people might not. Sucks to be them.
I've used Anki a *lot* over the years, and it does not work for me. Anything I learn with Anki, or lists for that matter, may stick for a while but it sticks in the wrong part of the brain, kind of, and it just.. dissipates after a while. All of it. The *only* way for me to learn anything is through what I call association, which is hard to peg down but it's about "getting" it, from context. I learned all my English vocabulary (which is very large if I say so myself) solely through association - I've never used a dictionary, and never learned anything by any memory tricks. If I look at my (still poor) Japanese vocabulary I've had lots of problems remembering stuff I've tried to learn through Anki and other methods, but vocabulary I've picked up simply because I understood what my wife was saying (she's Japanese) I remember forever after. The trick is to understand the meaning of something not through translation, but from context. Then it sticks.
Some people can learn from lists and the like. I can't. Never could.
I wish you had shown the barcode or ISBN for the book that's out of print, it seems like such a great resource but I can't find it anywhere
ジョシュアさんからきましたー！
様々な言語を操れて羨ましいです！
ジョシュアさんのチャンネルから来ました。ブンスケさんのチャンネルは英語を勉強中の日本人にも、とても興味深いです。いつか、可能でしたら日本語の字幕を付けて頂けたら有り難いです。これからのブンスケさんの動画を楽しみにしていますね！
あっ、字幕いいですね！付け方調べてみます！これからちょこちょこ日本語でもやると思います！
I started learning 2 years ago, I still use anki but the way I use it and the reason for using has changed over time. When I first started learning, I had this idea that anki was a magic ticket to learning Japanese effortlessly. That ended up not being true, but I ended up using it to remember words I encountered easier. The problem was that I was spending too long doing it, and not long enough reading or watching stuff. Nowadays I never need to do it more than 5 mins a day, because I don't make too many cards, and I don't force myself to perfectly remember. As you said, forgetting is part of the learning process.
Im good at memorizing each characters.. But listening, grammar, vocab is whats hard for me haha.. For now 90+ kanji characters and each meaning is i memorized.. But some meaning is i only know through English.. Some i know through japanese words..
If only i had japanese friends but none. Im from Philippines and wanted to learn nihonggo for applying on japan and i also love Japanese language.. Why didnt i learn Japanese language before tho even if im anime fan haha..
I thought I had enough of "how to learn Japanese" videos, as I've been inundated with them for the many years I've tried to learn this language, but what makes this video different is the list of incredibly interesting books. Origins of the kanji and radicals are very interesting to me, so those are up my alley. Hope they're not too expensive. Thanks for the video!
Sizin yerinizde olmayı çok isterdim. Kanji yazmayı çok seviyorum
Hello! Very interesting video! You have so beautiful books! Could you recommend a book about the history of the japaense language *and theories about the origin). I am looking for it for a long time and don'y find any book. It could be bilingual english-japanese. Thank you in advance.