Thank you for such an interesting video, & the different hypotheses about this custom. There is a kindness for refugees unable to walk further. It would have taken perhaps a couple of days to build the tomb. At least they had shelter from weather, & attack from wild animals for another 2 days with their bowl of rice. Also, in the past during times of famine in my country, the frail, sick & elderly were given very watered down soup/porridge & so they died from starvation first. It was the only way for the bread winners & some children to have enough food to survive until the next harvest. There's not that much difference..... if you happen to be old! As always, you've given me much to think about.
Yes, especially when the ancient society encountered wars or famines, people's survival was a big problem, and people often made sacrifices. These tombs of the living dead are likely to be the product of that specific time. Now think about how the society is developing better and better, and people's living standards have been improving. What a blessing this is.
@@xingjilvtu Thank you for your insight. I want to say that one of the things I admire the most about modern China is the poverty alleviation schemes. Rural life will always entail hard physical work, long hours, & concerns for suitable weather. My impression is that everyone's very basic needs are now met. There is now no need for that ultimate sacrifice / act of love a parent has for their children & grandchildren in times of famine. To me, this is one of the greatest achievements in history, especially considering all the different types of natural disasters which can strike in China.
你好，继续加油✊
多謝分享
Another interesting history thanks for sharing ❤️👍💯💯
感谢您分享👍 😃谢谢👍
秋平好:你拍的村庄田野上多是什么素菜啊一片绿色的风景不错:贵州各地区市县我多去过:
辛苦了，解說精闢
谢谢喜欢
这些墓里有遗骸吗？还是被处理空了？
洞葬是許多西南民族的特色，一般是使用天然的洞穴，有能力的用棺木抬進洞裡安置，沒能力的直接置於洞內深處。這裡可能沒有天然大溶洞，才產生了模仿溶洞的人造石墓，老人活著的時候先為自己建石洞備用，甚至先購買棺木置入。有的老人還會先躺棺木中試用，是為活死人！到了臨終時就直接的在棺木中死去，並非是被子女拋棄洞中，除非是荒年戰亂才會。現在沒有棺木應該是葬俗改變為土葬，這些洞葬舊墓被清理過了，舊俗也成為了恐怖傳說
明治维新之前的日本，绝大多数平民也是极为穷困，尤其在一些偏远的山区，对老年人也会采用这样的处理方法。现在看来极为不人道，在那个年代应该是真没有办法，老人干不了活又要吃粮食，不处理的话很可能会把小孩和年轻人一起拖累饿死。
84 年与朋友的去陜西耒一个深度华山游 在华山地区一个非常偏僻悬岩山上（几乎9O度垂直）看到一些新开凿的洞口 大概有拾多个 每个洞只都有一条铁链垂下及简单步级浅坑 洞口离地面约10-15 公尺左右 可能方便上下洞口之用 毎洞口地下有新石碎 感到非常好奇 问及远边正在放牧的乡民 说是一些来自许多不同地方信佛年长居士 及云游四方佛家高僧 膗人开凿 他们都不吃只喝水渡日慢慢坐化 当時非常惊奇 暗暗下决心将来非要搞个明白 可是世界事情往往变幻莫测 至今已无法再安排再重返追究真蹄 当年用菲林拍摄的照片 由于時间久远 无法找到 如博主有兴趣 同友结伴可密访（不必虚声张势 以免无法进入非开放区域）谢谢你和大家
有机会去看看
Thank you for such an interesting video, & the different hypotheses about this custom.
There is a kindness for refugees unable to walk further. It would have taken perhaps a couple of days to build the tomb. At least they had shelter from weather, & attack from wild animals for another 2 days with their bowl of rice.
Also, in the past during times of famine in my country, the frail, sick & elderly were given very watered down soup/porridge & so they died from starvation first. It was the only way for the bread winners & some children to have enough food to survive until the next harvest.
There's not that much difference..... if you happen to be old!
As always, you've given me much to think about.
Yes, especially when the ancient society encountered wars or famines, people's survival was a big problem, and people often made sacrifices. These tombs of the living dead are likely to be the product of that specific time. Now think about how the society is developing better and better, and people's living standards have been improving. What a blessing this is.
@@xingjilvtu Thank you for your insight.
I want to say that one of the things I admire the most about modern China is the poverty alleviation schemes. Rural life will always entail hard physical work, long hours, & concerns for suitable weather. My impression is that everyone's very basic needs are now met. There is now no need for that ultimate sacrifice / act of love a parent has for their children & grandchildren in times of famine. To me, this is one of the greatest achievements in history, especially considering all the different types of natural disasters which can strike in China.
@@judithafholland Indeed, people's lives are getting better and better now, this is obvious, as long as you work hard and work hard
要搬运和处理如此大量的石头才能建成这样一个墓，我觉得后代付出的努力并不小。汉地的很多墓只不过是在土地上挖坑，然后把棺木放进去再填土。汉人墓地的工程规模和复杂度还比不上贵州深山这些少数民族的石头墓。古代医疗条件太差，到了年老失去生命活力的时候在一个安静的地方自然饿死，其实很人道。有点像现代的安乐死。
因為石頭大多不能種到糧食，人們就用此方式進行解決問題了？
大概都屬于頁片岩，才能組裝房牆
那些墓為什麼都是被挖開的狀態
👍👍👍👍👍👍
你好，可以留个TG之类的联系方吗~？我这边想谈谈广告推广合作
这个墓就是给老人送进去，等着活活饿死的，这是传统习俗，什么夜郎，什么孟获，就有点鬼扯了。
@Nothing Nothing 如果在現代，你會這麽做嗎？還傳統美德咧！？當然，在疫情氾濫下，死亡率的增加，只是這種活死人墓不夠完美，最好把重症快死的人送進去，再添加柴火焚葬
@@nothingnothing3023反正我那边地区没听过这种＂习俗＂。
@@nothingnothing3023 说不定是少数民族的？
@@nothingnothing3023 咋的 后悔当中华民族了？
👍👍
你推開小房子拍照給大家看看呢？
被拘的是你吗
👏
神雕侠侣里面那个活死人墓吗？🙏
不是 那是在终南山 是在陕西
活死人墓找到小龍女
可以去终南山看看
還有「陽過」😂
誰敢住
窮鄉僻壤的陋習，
麻煩大叔帶路給大叔一點領路費。
👦🍎👍🤝
按照中國這個趨勢發展下去也差不多了
2逼真多呀😄😄😄😄😄😄
停滯不前噢！
@@玉如黃-x3t 那台湾应该属于衰退了