@@gwynt909 You should do research before you post. Airplane doors are not bolted shut and are opened from the inside. Submarine hatches are also opened and closed from the inside.
Well stockton rush will be remembered for not listening to everybody who told him it was not safe. Basically, we're going to remember him as "we told you so"
I have ZERO interest to go in a submarine, space shuttle, or anything that explores something I can just see on RUclips in my living room. There is a tour of the Titanic on RUclips that's about an hour and a half long. I couldn't watch it for more than a few minutes because it was too scary to me. I guess in my old age I've become a whimp because I don't even like driving that much anymore, and I used to love it.
Im younger than ypu and i never find going to the moon or soace or oceon because quite frankly earth has everything i want to see Elon musk wants to build a city in space or something like that i wouldnt pay togo there if i could
Stockton is the epitome of a spoiled brat. He couldn't afford to maintain his OceanGate business in a safe, regulated manner, so he smashed it. Literally. He decided to play Russian Roulette with a fully loaded revolver. "Logic and Engineering" my backside!
I would like to add that Stockton wanted to purchase a submarine but was told only a limited quantity were available for purchase. He wanted to preserve history for all of us, including his wife; a descendant of some of those lost on Titanic. Waiting years wasn’t an option as Titanic will not be recognizable too many more years. He was no more crazy than the Wright Brothers, Elon Musk, Richard Branson etc… Many inventors or innovators have died doing what they love. The parachute is one of the greatest inventions of all time even though its inventor died while demonstrating it. Some people have just been lucky. NASA knew what they were doing, yet they lost two different orbiter’s catastrophically. And we all know what happened to Titanic. It’s easy to look like a genius you die.
A really stupid and fool hearty idea for anyone to agree to. An engineer I am not but neither am I an extreme risk taker with experimental new ideas that others in the industry say is not proven to be safe for whatever purpose it ŵas intended for. The world's navy branches have been building steel pulled submarines for years with but a few mishaps, that alone should have told the builder something, "if it works dont' mess with it".
That kids life was ahead of him,college,job,marriage,kids. But, his father kept pestering him to go with him , even though he didn't want to go,but he relented to make him happy,sad mistake.😢
Sorry Stockton, you will be remembered by being irresponsible. Putting your own life in danger is okay. But it's not okay to endanger lives of others. Wealthy insane tourists who paid $250.000/pp. Stockton took pride in - cutting corners. Well... this is the result. He created another graveyard to go watching the Titanic graveyard. .
That is what infamy means...fame, for negative reasons, or in a negative manner. Rush will, indeed, always be infamous, especially in the submersible world.
Here is another fact which came in to my knowledge and i forget to mention in the video that this is not the first dive which Titan submersible made for titanic wreck that was the 3rd attempt before that 2 divides aborted because of poor weather conditions in the depth some also said that this happend acure because Titan submersible need to go for rebuild. Correct me if I am wrong. I really appreciate your love and support.
For a man who wanted to be remembered as an innovator, Rush was, in his own way, every bit as hidebound as any of the "enemies to INNOVATION" he scorned so completely.
@@uncoveredbyafzalsiddiqui 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 I remember a video of him saying it was such a safe transport, there hadn’t been an accident in over 35 years…yes, because they’re tested 🙄😤
This would have been a very good video if it weren't for the distracting music and the annoying noise when the scene switched. I ended up clicking out of it without finishing it.
Something I find frustrating is how this will bring about new regulations that could potentially stem innovation. The fact that Titan managed 13 dives to the Titanic is proof of concept. If someone was to develop the construction and test it properly, establish limits and ensure suitable safety and communication equipment is installed, there are certainly scenarios where a similar 'type' of vessel could be advantageous. Had Rush approached it in the correct way, shelved his ego and not let greed make his decisions, Titan could have been the genesis. Instead, he has probably single handedly ended any advances that could have been made in composite pressure hulls for deeper depths.
@RichardMcLaren the carbon filter was an accident waiting to happen. It was lighter and cheaper than what was needed. If you want to innovate....start with what is known.
@ElizzzaB Yes, you're possibly right, except it didn't fail. There were many corners cut in the development of Titan, which is what I meant by saying "if someone was to........and ensure suitable safety....." The point is, it did work. That is proof of concept. From there on, it should have been properly tested and developed to fully understand it. It also shouldn't have such an egotistical CEO.
Stockton Rush said safety wasn't an issue. Well , then he might as well built that submersible out of plastic. He was asking for trouble and he certainly found it.
@@lisadunn2208 not only would he of been sued, but more than likely he would be facing criminal charges too. They would probably go after him for negligent manslaughter. Multiple counts too, depending on how many people died.
Stockton rush did achieve something for science. He demonstrated the limitations of carbon fibre and even more importantantly, bonding two dissimilar materials.
Look we all know now they went on a death trip Rush would have known he was going to die doing this trip. Its obvious after all the evidence and comments from other people that worked with Rush advising him not to do this. l feel sorry for the people aboard that didn’t know and the family’s left behind.
I’ve flown FPV drones made of carbon fiber and how they explode and break… there’s no way in hell CF is a good choice for those depths. After the first trip down there it’s most likely experienced a loss in integrity.
I realy don't understand that man - he's sitting there in his disastrous creation pragging about his stupidity. I am so sorry for those who got mislead by his lies.
Again, I am hit with how terribly tragic this was, an incident so extreme that its just so difficult to put in words. People dying during such morbid conditions, it all is so very hard to grasp. We dont belong down there and what was there to see really, it was just a thrill and an ability to do something " out of this world" experience. I dont get how PH, as he has been presented, a well renowned explorer, felt safe to go with the Titan, he must have been well aware of the skepticism and the critics from all over regarding this submersible. And Stockton...what to say about him. He was way out of his head from the start it seems. Having dreams and ambitions and wanting to stand out and make a mark as its been said, being innovative. The ecocomy spinning out of control and with that, all safety matters as well. Stuck with something that has cost a fortune and the urge to prove yourself and the "nesessity" to make profit from all of it .He was pretty much chasing passengers it seems, like he was desperate. That thing, needed to pay off and he needed to prove himself. It just all makes you speechless really 💔
Said it before, and i'll say it again. The ONLY person i feel bad for out of the five, is the 19 year old, who was reluctant at first to go. But he didnt want to disappoint his father who wanted him to go. May he rest in peace. The others however, rot!
Except that he wasn't reluctant to go. He was hugely enthusiastic and wanted to set a recorded for solving the Rubiks Cube at the deepest location on Earth. His Mother said so and thats why she letchim go in her place! The investigation has been showing all kinds of bullshit that was in the media.
Here's a guideline for any aspirant dive vessel builders: do not name any of your craft after ships that have sunk, particularly within 4 days of launch.
Did you see the water on the side of the view window? 15:56 I can understand moisture from our body heat but didn't they have air scrubbers to help with that?
The use of Carbon fiber hulls in deepsea vehicles is not an innovative action, it's a direct idiocracy - hence both the industry, IMO and every body else with knowledge about that matter - said no no no - ignorance and faulty pride mixed whit misunderstood physics - must be the explanation of that disaster...
"Nobody had built a craft made of carbon fibre to go to those depths before." Yeah, there's a reason for that. (Although I believe the US navy has, and it made 2 trips of depth and was retired).
It wasn't the marerials it was the ignorance, and impatience coupled with a sheer lack of respect for the engineers/seasoned experts of the greedy CEO that caused this accident...
For a truly innovative submersible check out the triest which was built in 1954 in Switzerland and safely reached several times the depth of the titan. The triest is wild but still true to the physics of deep depths and is still here. It was retired in the mid 1960s and is on display in the us navy museum.
@@DebbieStidham-fb8we I know It was used for ballast because it’s lighter than water but not compressible. Wild. They use that syntactic foam these days. Far less flammable
@uncoveredbyafzalsiddiqui When u look at the wreckage, none of the adhesive remains on the rings, just the carbon hull, which is a sign of adhesive failure, or poor bonding techniqus. Especially with the adhesive they used, which is not like a normal "glue", but has the consistency of something like Peanut Butter, or a Paste. We use it quite abit, and always acid etch any smooth surfaces to be bonded to anything.
These experts are not warning out of opinion....They know for sure that neglecting these safety concerns would end in tragedy!! Please listen to these experts!! They are not experts for nothing. Rip to these 5 men. This is extremely sad 😒
Being clostrophobic, the thought of being bolted in, no hatch, would have been a deal breaker. Right up there with going over Niagara falls in a barrel and going hunting with Dick Cheney.
One of the titan titanium panels was not intact. see underwater pics. failure seems to be between the 2 titanium panels that are bolted together You can see the titanium plug removed from titanium housing ring in non window(rear) end
Seems unlikely because the debris were squished into the rear dome. Which means it is far more likely the initial failure was at the front and all the debris as it continued to fail were pushed into the rear dome with the rush of water. That amount of force hitting it could potentially destroy the bolts holding the two parts of the rear dome together.
@@uncoveredbyafzalsiddiqui that is my assumption. The force was large enough to snap the bolts holding the titanium ring and domes together (which is absolutely believable in my opinion) but not large enough to damage the titanium domes.
So, this is such a professional video. I swear I couldn't believe it was done by a channel with less than 20k subscribers.. am I missing something? I will have to watch more videos. But this one alone earned my like and to be a subscriber.. I felt like this was something I'd of watched on national geographic or something. Great job. Hope this kind of video continues and get the recognition and attention from subscribers and viewers it deserves 👏 😊 And no one could pay me then or now to EVER get into that thing. Or anything that goes that deep under water!! That's opening things up to having WAY TO MAMY "problems" occur that have absolutely zero ability at getting help
@@uncoveredbyafzalsiddiqui you missed what I said. The military doesn't use controllers as their only means of control. They have other means of control when something falls
@buildingracingvideos4714 The U.S. Navy has adopted Xbox-style controllers to operate periscopes and other systems on a few of its submarines, particularly on the Virginia-class submarines. This innovation started around 2017 to replace more complex, bulky, and expensive control panels. The use of these commercially available game controllers is practical because they are familiar to many young sailors, reducing training time, and they are also much cheaper than custom-built military equipment. So far, this controller approach has been seen in a limited number of submarines, particularly those equipped with advanced photonics masts (periscopes). While not all U.S. Navy submarines use this type of controller, it has been part of the modernization efforts to simplify operations and reduce costs.
"If you're not breaking things you're not innovating." -Stockton Rush Perhaps he was too innovative on that last run. And shoulda dialed it back a bit. Shoulda coulda woulda tho, hindsight is 20/20 and all that.
Imagine how the previous passengers of Titan must feel know that could have happened to them. Rush was playing Russian Roullette with peoples lives. It probably good that he isn't around to face the music!
The Titan Sub made it to the Titanic werk 13 times successfully. The sub should have had its hull redone every 6 or 7 trips, but they just kept using the original hull Everytime. Rush did make a successful sub, he just didn't do the property preventive maintenance.
Stockton Rush's hubris and arrogance not only cost him his own life but that of 4 other people and jeopardised the submersible community. I'm sure if the 4 occupants knew how this thing was built would not have gone!
Stockton Rush would have fit right in at the dawn of early aviation, but, the unforgiving deep sea world does not forgive ignoring physical reality in search of a dream.
The thermal and expansion propeties of titanium, carbon fiber, and glue are all different. It's astonishing the accident took this long to happen. Plus, i bet that glue they used would show it was full of air bubbles if they examined it closely. Think about that the next time you fly somewhere in a glued together airplane.
There's a heck of a coincidence that the titanic sank not only because of the iceburg but also because those money men wanted her to beat the time for crossing and cut corners in the lack of lifeboats. Well now er get the titan built by a man who cut corners all for money and killed 5 people and they both lie next to each other on the ocean floor. Rip to all those innocents who lost their lives because of a few gready men ❤
You are exactly right. I already made a video on Titanic Mystry and mentioned 6 mistakes, which cause Titanic to sank. You can see that in my comment section.
I don't know why people keep focusing on the game controller. So your logic is if the buttons are not on a game controller then it works better, without any experience or evidence.
Sounds like that Rush guy was a penny pincher. Wanted to cut all these safety corners yet still charged a quarter of a million dollars to go down into that thing. Common sense would also tell you that every dive he took would wear down and weaken the sub a bit more each time.
The hull did withstand the pressure. They just didn't pay attention to damage done over time. Rush should have replaced and reinforced the hull at frequent intervals. Rush should have headed what the data was showing. Instead, if dismissing it, he was reckless, and it cost the life of 4 others who may have changed their minds if presented with the correct data.
A safe and effective submarine constructed of novel untested materials, materials known to fatigue under loading cycles and to be strong in tension, but unpredictable in compression. The fact that the safety factor for testing was only 1.09 should tell you all you need to know.
Stockton was trying to sell the dream that anyone could see the wreckage and explore it safely. His arrogance blinded him into think that he could break the rules. He couldn’t and took with him 3 other people that believed him and a kid who had to be convinced by his father to go with him.
If this has been a regular citizen doing this insane trip the rescue operation would have not been this huge! How much money did this cost and taxpayers pay for ? The us navy should have never been involved unless the navy is going to do this for everyone!
I recon that there was a reason, why SR didn't continued he's career as an air line pilot... but sadly he had the opportunity to continue he's rampage in the deep sea dive universe, whitout others succeeding in stopping he's madness.
Reality Behind Justin Trudeau Resignation! ruclips.net/video/n4RIx8o9Rjw/видео.htmlsi=Dg2d2caJJcZSDDx7
You’d have to be out of your mind to crawl inside that thing, get bolted in from the outside with no way out from the inside.. Nope, no way.
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
While it might be nice to have a way out at the surface, I doubt you would want to get out 12,500 down.
He was talking about how experimental the sub was with investors. I was no, no way,
But you will get into an aeroplane, submarine, etc. And be bolted in from the outside?
@@gwynt909 You should do research before you post. Airplane doors are not bolted shut and are opened from the inside. Submarine hatches are also opened and closed from the inside.
Well stockton rush will be remembered for not listening to everybody who told him it was not safe. Basically, we're going to remember him as "we told you so"
Exactly.
He will be remembered as a fool
@lynnetucholke-shorter5653 thank you for sharing your opinion.
Sometimes gotta put your ego to the side or things like this happen
I have ZERO interest to go in a submarine, space shuttle, or anything that explores something I can just see on RUclips in my living room. There is a tour of the Titanic on RUclips that's about an hour and a half long. I couldn't watch it for more than a few minutes because it was too scary to me. I guess in my old age I've become a whimp because I don't even like driving that much anymore, and I used to love it.
God Bless You.
Im younger than ypu and i never find going to the moon or soace or oceon because quite frankly earth has everything i want to see Elon musk wants to build a city in space or something like that i wouldnt pay togo there if i could
@@graceguerrero7045 🥰 cheers
Same here !!!
Same here, I agree with you!!!
Profit over safety ? Greed pure and simple.
👍
I think his ego was a factor too, an obnoxious man it seems
@@lilacscentedfushias1852 👍
Business as usual.
Stockton is the epitome of a spoiled brat. He couldn't afford to maintain his OceanGate business in a safe, regulated manner, so he smashed it. Literally.
He decided to play Russian Roulette with a fully loaded revolver.
"Logic and Engineering" my backside!
I feel the same way.
I would like to add that Stockton wanted to purchase a submarine but was told only a limited quantity were available for purchase. He wanted to preserve history for all of us, including his wife; a descendant of some of those lost on Titanic. Waiting years wasn’t an option as Titanic will not be recognizable too many more years. He was no more crazy than the Wright Brothers, Elon Musk, Richard Branson etc… Many inventors or innovators have died doing what they love. The parachute is one of the greatest inventions of all time even though its inventor died while demonstrating it. Some people have just been lucky. NASA knew what they were doing, yet they lost two different orbiter’s catastrophically. And we all know what happened to Titanic. It’s easy to look like a genius you die.
@@jasonandvictoriahenderlite526 interesting. Thank you for sharing your opinion
A really stupid and fool hearty idea for anyone to agree to. An engineer I am not but neither am I an extreme risk taker with experimental new ideas that others in the industry say is not proven to be safe for whatever purpose it ŵas intended for. The world's navy branches have been building steel pulled submarines for years with but a few mishaps, that alone should have told the builder something, "if it works dont' mess with it".
So true. And Rush will certainly be remembered for the rules he broke.
proof you dont need a brain to become a millionaire
Well, making money and brain, I think, two different categories. 🤔
Especially to be born one ☝️
Yea, look at Mark Cuban, just a blooming idiot
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
You got that right
Only one I feel sry for is the boy, bro didn't even wanna go but was tryna impress his dad 😢 rip to them tho 🙏🏾
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
Me too. Not only that, he was the son of a billionaire. What a life he had ahead of him. Life's a bitch sometimes.
@winstonsmith8240 thank you for sharing your opinion.
@@winstonsmith8240 even if he was the son of a janitor, he was 19, I don't think being a billionaire was on his mind while he was dying
That kids life was ahead of him,college,job,marriage,kids. But, his father kept pestering him to go with him , even though he didn't want to go,but he relented to make him happy,sad mistake.😢
Stockton Mush's Epitaph: "You'll be remembered for the rules you break."
RIP to the 4 people he murdered.
RIP
💯
Yeap Rule #1, Don't do shit that gets you killed.
Sorry Stockton, you will be remembered by being irresponsible.
Putting your own life in danger is okay.
But it's not okay to endanger lives of others. Wealthy insane tourists who paid $250.000/pp.
Stockton took pride in
- cutting corners.
Well... this is the result.
He created another graveyard to go watching the Titanic graveyard.
.
Absolutely something I think that might be this is his plan to remain in history.
He dies not famous but infamous
@margaretcorns2350 he is famous don't Metter good way or bad way.
That is what infamy means...fame, for negative reasons, or in a negative manner. Rush will, indeed, always be infamous, especially in the submersible world.
@@uncoveredbyafzalsiddiqui what do you think infamous means?!
Unfortunately, once you’ve seen one ocean gate video, you’ve seen them all
That's the beauty of informational videos.
@ulrich...To be fair, this is one of the better ones! 😁
@@englanduk6131 💗
Here is another fact which came in to my knowledge and i forget to mention in the video that this is not the first dive which Titan submersible made for titanic wreck that was the 3rd attempt before that 2 divides aborted because of poor weather conditions in the depth some also said that this happend acure because Titan submersible need to go for rebuild. Correct me if I am wrong. I really appreciate your love and support.
Honestly, your research has been so sloppy.
Titanic 2 anxiety
For a man who wanted to be remembered as an innovator, Rush was, in his
own way, every bit as hidebound as any of the "enemies to INNOVATION" he scorned so completely.
I would say they were cautious with good reasons.
IMO… Stockton broke the Rules with…No logic or engineering, behind it! 🤷🏽♀️
He thought he was the best, and to achieve something, you needed to break the rules.
@@uncoveredbyafzalsiddiqui 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 I remember a video of him saying it was such a safe transport, there hadn’t been an accident in over 35 years…yes, because they’re tested 🙄😤
@@lilacscentedfushias1852 exactly
This would have been a very good video if it weren't for the distracting music and the annoying noise when the scene switched. I ended up clicking out of it without finishing it.
Thanks. I’m just gonna move on already. I hate when videos are ruined by dumb music.
Same, especially the noise i really dont understand that decision
I tried to give it a chance, but instead of listening to the narration I ended up watching out for those transition sounds 😭
I see what you mean about the music and the switching noise.
You ruined it for me! 😂
For me, the worst design decision of all was not having a tether cable attached to the support ship. That's such a dumb idea.
They didn't even have a GPS to find it when they lost it. Or pretended to lose it for 4 days. They knew it was gone.
It wouldn’t have made a difference. They would have pulled the cable up with nothing on it. Like a fish taking your bait.
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
Because in that depth of sea no GPS works.
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
There is a MASSIVE difference between regulation (frequently bureaucrats with no real world knowledge) and proper safety protocols.
100% true.
Something I find frustrating is how this will bring about new regulations that could potentially stem innovation. The fact that Titan managed 13 dives to the Titanic is proof of concept. If someone was to develop the construction and test it properly, establish limits and ensure suitable safety and communication equipment is installed, there are certainly scenarios where a similar 'type' of vessel could be advantageous.
Had Rush approached it in the correct way, shelved his ego and not let greed make his decisions, Titan could have been the genesis. Instead, he has probably single handedly ended any advances that could have been made in composite pressure hulls for deeper depths.
@@RichardMcLaren I agreed.
@RichardMcLaren the carbon filter was an accident waiting to happen. It was lighter and cheaper than what was needed. If you want to innovate....start with what is known.
@ElizzzaB Yes, you're possibly right, except it didn't fail. There were many corners cut in the development of Titan, which is what I meant by saying "if someone was to........and ensure suitable safety....."
The point is, it did work. That is proof of concept. From there on, it should have been properly tested and developed to fully understand it. It also shouldn't have such an egotistical CEO.
Stockton Rush said safety wasn't an issue. Well , then he might as well built that submersible out of plastic. He was asking for trouble and he certainly found it.
Thank you for sharing your valuable thoughts.
He did make it out of plastic, that's what carbon fibre is, plastic...
Titanic radioactive ☢️☣️☢️☣️
Titanic 2
Tragic disaster because of EGO and Arrogance of one man.
100% right.
Rush should be thankful that he went down with the ship! He would have been sued into oblivion!
They are being sued
@@lisadunn2208 not only would he of been sued, but more than likely he would be facing criminal charges too. They would probably go after him for negligent manslaughter. Multiple counts too, depending on how many people died.
stocton rush wasn't outside of the box , he was out of his damn mind
Imagine paying $250,000 for the priviledge to be blown to bits
That was their destine.
More like crushed
@@JonSheppards2InchWilly 😃
*imploded into a tiny sphere..
He will be remembered as a dangerous buffoon !
Yes, no doubt.
Ballard and Cameron knew what they were talking about all along. Rush wasn’t pursuing innovation. He was all about greed.
I heard in another video that Rush wouldn't even allow his children in the submersibles he was creating. I think he knew how dangerous they were.
😮
Stockton rush did achieve something for science. He demonstrated the limitations of carbon fibre and even more importantantly, bonding two dissimilar materials.
I'm wondering if a movie 🎥🍿🍿 would ever be made about it
Look we all know now they went on a death trip Rush would have known he was going to die doing this trip. Its obvious after all the evidence and comments from other people that worked with Rush advising him not to do this. l feel sorry for the people aboard that didn’t know and the family’s left behind.
Exactly feel that same way. I also mentioned in my comments that I feel that's his way to remain in history doesn't matter in a good way or bad way.
Maybe he could not take failure?
Stockton was clearly an arrogant toxic person…IMO
Thanks for sharing your opinion! It's always interesting to hear different viewpoints on players and their impact on the game.
I’ve flown FPV drones made of carbon fiber and how they explode and break… there’s no way in hell CF is a good choice for those depths. After the first trip down there it’s most likely experienced a loss in integrity.
I can not believe they glued the port ring on ! Port ring was on the ocean floor and the hull was crushed like a pancake !!
I realy don't understand that man - he's sitting there in his disastrous creation pragging about his stupidity. I am so sorry for those who got mislead by his lies.
May Their Soul rest in peace.
Again, I am hit with how terribly tragic this was, an incident so extreme that its just so difficult to put in words. People dying during such morbid conditions, it all is so very hard to grasp. We dont belong down there and what was there to see really, it was just a thrill and an ability to do something " out of this world" experience. I dont get how PH, as he has been presented, a well renowned explorer, felt safe to go with the Titan, he must have been well aware of the skepticism and the critics from all over regarding this submersible. And Stockton...what to say about him. He was way out of his head from the start it seems. Having dreams and ambitions and wanting to stand out and make a mark as its been said, being innovative. The ecocomy spinning out of control and with that, all safety matters as well. Stuck with something that has cost a fortune and the urge to prove yourself and the "nesessity" to make profit from all of it .He was pretty much chasing passengers it seems, like he was desperate. That thing, needed to pay off and he needed to prove himself. It just all makes you speechless really 💔
Sad reality.
Said it before, and i'll say it again. The ONLY person i feel bad for out of the five, is the 19 year old, who was reluctant at first to go. But he didnt want to disappoint his father who wanted him to go. May he rest in peace. The others however, rot!
❤️
You wouldn’t be so insensitive if you weren’t so. Stupid!
Except that he wasn't reluctant to go. He was hugely enthusiastic and wanted to set a recorded for solving the Rubiks Cube at the deepest location on Earth. His Mother said so and thats why she letchim go in her place! The investigation has been showing all kinds of bullshit that was in the media.
Exactly this. That poor young man. He had more sense in his little toe than all the others put together.
I think the others were innocent victims also. Information was withheld?
Now people are visiting the wreck of the wreck. Wreckception
😄
Stockton will be remembered for cutting corners , not listening to industry experts oh and murder
Thank you for sharing your valuable thoughts.
08:00 "Any Submersible at these depths must be designed with Extreme Care precision and Safety in mind."
Stockton Rush: "Nah."
Would you rather take a deep water tour with Stockton Rush, or a wild life tour with Timothy Treadwell?
i prefer to stay at home with my wife at least 10% chance of survive. lolz
I'd rather go to a secluded snowbound cabin with Jack Nicholson.
Hmm. Decisions decisions...
Can I take the 3rd option of going hunting with Dick Cheney?
Here's a guideline for any aspirant dive vessel builders: do not name any of your craft after ships that have sunk, particularly within 4 days of launch.
Thank you for sharing your valuable thoughts 😊
Not being tethered is insane. We can go further in space than the ocean depths. 🤯
Thank you for sharing your valuable thoughts.
Did you see the water on the side of the view window? 15:56 I can understand moisture from our body heat but didn't they have air scrubbers to help with that?
i really have no idea about this but i am shore someone will definitely answer about this.
Air scrubbers don't filter heat.
Ok ty 😊@@TheGrumpyEnglishman
@@TheGrumpyEnglishman 👍
@@TheGrumpyEnglishman scrubbers produce heat. It is an exothermic reaction when soda-lime reacts with CO2
The use of Carbon fiber hulls in deepsea vehicles is not an innovative action, it's a direct idiocracy - hence both the industry, IMO and every body else with knowledge about that matter - said no no no - ignorance and faulty pride mixed whit misunderstood physics - must be the explanation of that disaster...
Mind blowing information. I am a big fan of your videos you covers everything well.
Thank you. I'm tried my best to satisfy my followers.
Never put your life in the hands of a narcissist.
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
Instead of an innovator he will be remembered as a nit-wit.
Thank you for sharing your valuable thoughts.
Just a little bit in and I must say…. This is one of the best videos I’ve seen explaining the situation. Thank you 🙏
Thank you for your love and support ❤️
Robert Ballard should never have given up the coordinates of the Titanic wreck site.
"Nobody had built a craft made of carbon fibre to go to those depths before." Yeah, there's a reason for that. (Although I believe the US navy has, and it made 2 trips of depth and was retired).
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
It wasn't the marerials it was the ignorance, and impatience coupled with a sheer lack of respect for the engineers/seasoned experts of the greedy CEO that caused this accident...
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
Lol WHAT "BODY RECOVERED"....
Exactly. Just clickbait.
thanks for saving me from wasting my time i was only here to see the recovered body which is impossible to exist at that depth after the implossion.
The body of the sub. Its no rocket science i guess....
excatly
exactly
Beautiful ❤️❤️
Thank you for your love and support ❤️
For a truly innovative submersible check out the triest which was built in 1954 in Switzerland and safely reached several times the depth of the titan. The triest is wild but still true to the physics of deep depths and is still here. It was retired in the mid 1960s and is on display in the us navy museum.
Do you know the trieste was filled with gasoline ? Not the crew section of course.
@@DebbieStidham-fb8we I know It was used for ballast because it’s lighter than water but not compressible. Wild. They use that syntactic foam these days. Far less flammable
Good ol' Swiss Navy 🫡
Thought all the bodies turned into mush.. and imploded.😂😂
debates continue
This guy went skydiving without a parachute and mocked the people who said he’d die without one...
One mistake, keeping the Titanium Ring surfaces smooth, when the adhesive was applied. No etching or blasting for some reason?
Thank you for sharing your valuable thoughts 😊
@uncoveredbyafzalsiddiqui When u look at the wreckage, none of the adhesive remains on the rings, just the carbon hull, which is a sign of adhesive failure, or poor bonding techniqus. Especially with the adhesive they used, which is not like a normal "glue", but has the consistency of something like Peanut Butter, or a Paste. We use it quite abit, and always acid etch any smooth surfaces to be bonded to anything.
Excellent coverage 👏
Thank you for your love and support ❤️
People need to let the titanic rest in peace. Don’t you anything better to do.
Thank you for sharing your valuable opinion.
These experts are not warning out of opinion....They know for sure that neglecting these safety concerns would end in tragedy!! Please listen to these experts!! They are not experts for nothing. Rip to these 5 men. This is extremely sad 😒
We hope that future engineers will learn from this.
Being clostrophobic, the thought of being bolted in, no hatch, would have been a deal breaker. Right up there with going over Niagara falls in a barrel and going hunting with Dick Cheney.
The conclusion is FAILURE
Yes.
@@uncoveredbyafzalsiddiqui This video is a failure, too.
@iwondery1725 Thank you for your love and support ❤️
It's all fair and well to break rules when it's only your life at risk...
Invention does not mean someone put his life at risk like that.
One of the titan titanium panels was not intact. see underwater pics. failure seems to be between the 2 titanium panels that are bolted together You can see the titanium plug removed from titanium housing ring in non window(rear) end
Here, we need to understand the depth of the design. I hope soon we receive more accurate details on this.
Seems unlikely because the debris were squished into the rear dome.
Which means it is far more likely the initial failure was at the front and all the debris as it continued to fail were pushed into the rear dome with the rush of water.
That amount of force hitting it could potentially destroy the bolts holding the two parts of the rear dome together.
@retsaMinnavoiG that's right, but that force only destroyed the carbon hull, not the titanium rings! Because they can handle the pressure?
@@uncoveredbyafzalsiddiqui the 2 titanium rings where separated not destroyed. that shows a secondary failure
@@uncoveredbyafzalsiddiqui that is my assumption.
The force was large enough to snap the bolts holding the titanium ring and domes together (which is absolutely believable in my opinion) but not large enough to damage the titanium domes.
so where is the body that you was saying they found. ?
Incredible force that ripped it apart!. Human remains were recovered. I wonder their condition.
Nobody found.
@@uncoveredbyafzalsiddiqui ...So you're calling them liars?
Biological material containing DNA was recovered. This could be bone or teeth fragments or a paste like substance.
@@upyourglass Thank you for sharing.
Dead
It was that guys greed that killed him and the others
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
Appreciate your video, Thank you! Put together well! No pun intended!
Thank you for your love and support ❤️
So, this is such a professional video. I swear I couldn't believe it was done by a channel with less than 20k subscribers.. am I missing something? I will have to watch more videos. But this one alone earned my like and to be a subscriber.. I felt like this was something I'd of watched on national geographic or something. Great job. Hope this kind of video continues and get the recognition and attention from subscribers and viewers it deserves 👏 😊
And no one could pay me then or now to EVER get into that thing. Or anything that goes that deep under water!! That's opening things up to having WAY TO MAMY "problems" occur that have absolutely zero ability at getting help
Thank you for your love and support.
Ultimately what you got was bragging rights. Or obliteration, in this case.
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
He knew he was going down so he joined the crew and went out with a bang.
The military does not use game controllers as their only means of control
those are game controllers but they modified them according to their need.
@@uncoveredbyafzalsiddiqui you missed what I said. The military doesn't use controllers as their only means of control. They have other means of control when something falls
@buildingracingvideos4714 The U.S. Navy has adopted Xbox-style controllers to operate periscopes and other systems on a few of its submarines, particularly on the Virginia-class submarines. This innovation started around 2017 to replace more complex, bulky, and expensive control panels.
The use of these commercially available game controllers is practical because they are familiar to many young sailors, reducing training time, and they are also much cheaper than custom-built military equipment. So far, this controller approach has been seen in a limited number of submarines, particularly those equipped with advanced photonics masts (periscopes).
While not all U.S. Navy submarines use this type of controller, it has been part of the modernization efforts to simplify operations and reduce costs.
"If you're not breaking things you're not innovating." -Stockton Rush
Perhaps he was too innovative on that last run. And shoulda dialed it back a bit. Shoulda coulda woulda tho, hindsight is 20/20 and all that.
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
Imagine how the previous passengers of Titan must feel know that could have happened to them. Rush was playing Russian Roullette with peoples lives. It probably good that he isn't around to face the music!
The Titan Sub made it to the Titanic werk 13 times successfully. The sub should have had its hull redone every 6 or 7 trips, but they just kept using the original hull Everytime. Rush did make a successful sub, he just didn't do the property preventive maintenance.
Stockton Rush's hubris and arrogance not only cost him his own life but that of 4 other people and jeopardised the submersible community.
I'm sure if the 4 occupants knew how this thing was built would not have gone!
Everyone on the Titan knew the risks of diving that deep, especially the kid. RIP.
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
Rush was so very lucky to be on that mission
I particularly liked the part of the video where they showed the body that was recovered
Thank you for your love and support ❤️
😂that was sarcasm.
@@Sergeant26 watch video from 14:15
No Scam Dear
Titanic has been down there for 112 years now.
Yes exactly.
Stockton Rush never knew his sub killed him.
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
Carbon fiber works great under tension, not so good under compression.
Warned by 36 plus experts and still proceeded ..very careless
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
A failure of innovation with a heaping amount of arrogance.
👍
Stockton Rush would have fit right in at the dawn of early aviation, but, the unforgiving deep sea world does not forgive ignoring physical reality in search of a dream.
Titanic way of saying, stop bring people down to this depth, i want to be alone and to rust and be forgotten. Maybe now they will leave her alone.
😊
Very informative
Thank you for your love and support ❤️
"Who will discover your dive team"
Thank you for sharing your opinion.
the only two that I feel bad for is the father and son who lost their lives going down to see the graveyard of the titanic
If you went on the dive, rest assured, if anything went wrong, it came with a money back guarantee if not completely satisfied. Zero complaints.
Stockton Crush is gonna be remembered as a fool.
The thermal and expansion propeties of titanium, carbon fiber, and glue are all different. It's astonishing the accident took this long to happen. Plus, i bet that glue they used would show it was full of air bubbles if they examined it closely. Think about that the next time you fly somewhere in a glued together airplane.
😃 Thank you for sharing your valuable thoughts.
There's a heck of a coincidence that the titanic sank not only because of the iceburg but also because those money men wanted her to beat the time for crossing and cut corners in the lack of lifeboats. Well now er get the titan built by a man who cut corners all for money and killed 5 people and they both lie next to each other on the ocean floor. Rip to all those innocents who lost their lives because of a few gready men ❤
You are exactly right. I already made a video on Titanic Mystry and mentioned 6 mistakes, which cause Titanic to sank. You can see that in my comment section.
I don't know why people keep focusing on the game controller. So your logic is if the buttons are not on a game controller then it works better, without any experience or evidence.
Sounds like that Rush guy was a penny pincher. Wanted to cut all these safety corners yet still charged a quarter of a million dollars to go down into that thing. Common sense would also tell you that every dive he took would wear down and weaken the sub a bit more each time.
exactly and debates continue
The hull did withstand the pressure. They just didn't pay attention to damage done over time. Rush should have replaced and reinforced the hull at frequent intervals. Rush should have headed what the data was showing. Instead, if dismissing it, he was reckless, and it cost the life of 4 others who may have changed their minds if presented with the correct data.
It's true that if he keeps maintain submersible, that might not happen.
A safe and effective submarine constructed of novel untested materials, materials known to fatigue under loading cycles and to be strong in tension, but unpredictable in compression.
The fact that the safety factor for testing was only 1.09 should tell you all you need to know.
Stockton was trying to sell the dream that anyone could see the wreckage and explore it safely. His arrogance blinded him into think that he could break the rules. He couldn’t and took with him 3 other people that believed him and a kid who had to be convinced by his father to go with him.
0:59 could be condensation but if it’s not that’s a big red flag the submersible is sweating
👍
If this has been a regular citizen doing this insane trip the rescue operation would have not been this huge!
How much money did this cost and taxpayers pay for ?
The us navy should have never been involved unless the navy is going to do this for everyone!
Rush was a damn fool. And them people that got in that can with him was crazy no way I would have gotten in that little can
I recon that there was a reason, why SR didn't continued he's career as an air line pilot... but sadly he had the opportunity to continue he's rampage in the deep sea dive universe, whitout others succeeding in stopping he's madness.
Sometimes, people's have crazy goals in their life. They want to become number one.