👋 **Thanks for watching!** If you enjoyed this video and want to see more content about **service dog rights**, **public accountability**, and my experiences with **town officials**, don’t forget to **SUBSCRIBE** to the channel! 📢 🔔 Click the bell icon to stay updated on all future uploads - I’ve got more important videos coming soon, and your support helps me bring these stories to light! What did you think about today’s video? Drop your thoughts below, and let’s start a conversation! 👇 #Subscribe #ServiceDogRights #PublicAccountability #StayTuned
We are persons with disabilities, or handicapped. Never “cripples,” honey. Don’t call us “cripples.” It’s incredibly inappropriate. I know you meant well, but this is a teaching moment you ought to take seriously.
@@MarySanchez-qk3hp There are those who don't like the term handicapped either. Invalid is another. At the end of the day, it's just words, and I don't get too worked up about it, when there's no malice intended. It's not like it's on par with the word that starts with "R" or "N". Crippled is still used to describe lots of things that are broken down, like a car. Disabled is currently the only universally acceptable descriptor for us, but hey... I have bigger problems than terminology. I'm sure you do, too.
I agree-it’s beyond offensive to refer to a service dog as a "crutch." Service dogs are essential tools that help people with disabilities live more independent lives. Referring to them in such a dismissive way shows a complete lack of understanding and respect for the critical roles they play. Service dogs perform vital, trained tasks, and comparing them to a mere crutch diminishes the value of the work they do and the rights that handlers have under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Such comments not only disrespect the handler but also perpetuate harmful stigmas around disabilities and the use of service animals.
A service dog is a crutch. Just as someone with a broken leg needs it to get around so we need our service animals. Without her by my side knowing she is always looking out for me I would never be able to leave the house. Lady J is a crutch but also a helpmate and loyal friend. To claim her as a crutch for me is true but to claim her as a crutch used for an excuse for special attention, which has happened in the past, is beyond ludicrous.
You’re absolutely right-his opinion is completely wrong. Referring to a service dog as a "crutch" shows a deep misunderstanding of what service dogs actually do. Rosie performs essential, task-specific duties that help me manage my disability. These aren’t just emotional comforts; they’re legally recognized under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) as vital to my independence and daily functioning. Dismissing the role of a service dog in this way doesn’t just show ignorance-it disrespects the thousands of people who rely on service dogs to help them navigate life with disabilities, both visible and invisible. The law protects people like me, and comments like these only highlight how much more education and awareness are needed. Thank you for seeing through that remark and supporting service dog handlers!
A Town leader saying a disabled person is just using his service dog as a crutch is a total lack of respect, and cold hearted. He should not be representing the people of the town because apparently he doesn't represent everyone. Would you tell a paralyzed man he just uses his wheelchair just to get sympathy. Not every disability or illness can be seen, I have fibromyalgia a debilitating disease but you can't see it., for years I was called lazy , etc. Isn't being in pain enough you have to also make a personal attack ? If someone in a public position cannot control their temper or takes everything personal they should not be in that position. It was bad enough to offend him about his service dog but then to talk to the police trying to get him arrested as well. Having a management position in government doesn't mean you are better than everyone else. You are suppose to be an example to those you manage. Hugs to you and Rosie 🤗
Thank you so much for your kind words and for sharing your own experience, Sandra. It means a lot to me, and you’re absolutely right-not all disabilities are visible, and the ignorance behind comments like that shows a lack of understanding and compassion. I can only imagine the pain and frustration you’ve felt with fibromyalgia and being dismissed by people who don’t see what you’re going through. I, too, face the same with my PTSD, which Rosie helps me manage every day. What hurts the most is that these comments came from someone in a public position who is supposed to represent all of us, not just the ones without visible disabilities. Comparing my service dog to a "crutch" is disrespectful not just to me but to all people who rely on service dogs or any other support system. It’s as if our disabilities and the tools we use to manage them are seen as weaknesses, when in reality, they help us live fuller lives. You’re also right about the way this kind of behavior discourages others from stepping forward, especially when those in leadership positions use their power to target or silence people who are already dealing with so much. But the community’s support, like yours, helps remind me that these attitudes are the problem, not us. Thank you again for your kind words, and Rosie and I are sending you hugs right back. Stay strong!
@@RosieTheGreatDaneServiceDog 𝙔𝙤𝙪'𝙧𝙚 𝙒𝙚𝙡𝙘𝙤𝙢𝙚!! 𝘼𝙣𝙮𝙩𝙞𝙢𝙚!:🐾 We with disabilities in all forms are many and more join our ranks everyday, even the very people that condemn us will also suffer in the future. No one chooses to be disabled. It would be wise for others to remember you reap what you sow and that Karma comes after us all. You do a great service to us all by exposing those in power meant to serve the public, but abuse the public instead with their sense of entitled power they do not possess. If you see something, say something, and always record ! Hang in there we are behind you. (Ɔ ˘⌣˘)˘⌣˘ C✿)🐕
Who the hell is that guy?? Professional dog trainer? Trains dogs for service dogs??? He had absolutely no power or right to question the use of the dog!!! If he's a city official, I feel sorry for y'all!! 😡😡😡
Service animal handlers are being harassed because there are so many people these days who brand their pets service or emotional support animals, with little or no training on the part of the owner or the animal, just so they can take their pets wherever they please. I haven't read your backstory, but if your animal truly is an ADA-compliant service animal, you should file an ADA complaint against the city, rather than arguing with city officials regarding its status.
You’re absolutely right-the misuse of service dog vests and emotional support animal labels by untrained pets is a real issue, and it creates unfair skepticism for those of us who have legitimate service dogs. It’s unfortunate that people take advantage of the system, because it makes it harder for those of us who genuinely rely on service dogs to navigate life with a disability. In my case, Rosie is a fully trained, ADA-compliant service dog, specifically trained to perform tasks that assist with my disability. Her role is legally recognized under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), and she’s a critical part of my daily life. As you suggested, I’ve considered taking action, and filing an ADA complaint is an option I’m exploring to hold the Town accountable. I agree that it's important to take the proper steps when city officials fail to respect the rights of service dog handlers. Thank you for your understanding, and I appreciate your advice
Thank you, and you're welcome. An ADA complaint likely won't result in fines and such, but it will light a fire under city leaders and HR folks to address this issue and educate all the city's employees. I know several folks who depend on their service animals, and it irritates me no end when folks pass around suggestions on social media about how to get fake service animal credentials for their pets so they can take them anywhere. Keep up the good work.
Well there is not real ADA compliant service dog requirement other they provide a service. That could be your chihuahua picking up your keys off the floor and bringing them to you. But my feeling if the dog is well behaved I do not care. One thing I loved about Germany is dog are allowed almost everywhere. Because of that all the dogs are well socialized because they are use to being taken everywhere so they learn to take a nap in a resturant and be on there best behavior in a store. Meanwhile in the USA dogs are stuck in a house all day which cause them to become overly protective of people and home and also become less socialized as they are exposed to fewer people.
@@JAM661 There are, in fact, specific requirements for a service animal to be ADA compliant. There is also a separate class of animals that do no fall under ADA protections but may fall under provisions of the Fair Housing Act or other federal guidelines. These animals do not have the same protections as ADA compliant service animals. www.ada.gov/resources/service-animals-2010-requirements/
@@JAM661 There are, in fact, specific requirements for a service animal to be ADA compliant. While other federal laws, such as the Fair Housing Act, recognize a broader spectrum of "service animals," but those are not guaranteed the same protections as an ADA compliant animal. www.ada.gov/resources/service-animals-2010-requirements/
The man who called the dog a crutch is an ignorant creep. He is horrible and shouold not be a town leader at all. Thank goodness the Chief of Police is smarter. One would wish that town leaders were more compassionate and respectful than Rick Chaffee. It is disgusting that Rich Chaffee would try to get someone arrested to enforce his own personal biases.
@@lafondawilliams You’re absolutely right-just because any dog can be trained doesn’t mean every trained dog is a service dog. According to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), a dog is only considered a service dog if it is trained to perform specific tasks that directly assist a person with a disability. These tasks must go beyond basic obedience or general training, and they must help mitigate the handler’s disability. It’s important to make this distinction because only service dogs that perform these specific tasks are protected under the ADA. Simply being well-trained doesn’t automatically make a dog a service dog unless it is performing work that directly supports a disability.
You clearly have never met my dogs. Services provided would include comforter and sheet destruction, bra destruction, carpet destruction, getting in the way of a walking human and stopping on a dime, barking in their sleep at 2:00 a.m., giving us grief for being two minutes late with their dinner, and would most likely give the combination code to the safe to any and all bad guys breaking in the house. Too dumb to provide any useful benefit to mankind, but smart enough to use being dumb to ensure a life of leisure for themselves. And now, one of them is trying to make me feel bad for dissing them, so I have to go pat her little tummy. Too freakin' cute, I swear....
There is a very short conversation that can be had. Two questions can be asked. 1. Is that a service animal? 2.What service does the animal provide? End of conversation. No demonstration of the service required. No special jacket with markings, no papers need to be shown, animal can be anywhere the person can be. This is Federal law.
This guy would have hit the roof with my Chihuahua Service Dog. When this guy gets older and needs a cane, I hope someone tells him it’s just a ‘crutch’ and then he’ll understand what it’s like to be disabled and not allowed to access the same spaces that everyone else has access to.
A million years ago (seems like!) I used to wonder at all the money spent on ramps, automatic doors, designated parking, etc., all to benefit disabled people, and kind of resented the amount of money that businesses had to spend to become ADA-compliant. For a long time, I worked security at a huge distribution center, where we were required to provide a certain number of handicap parking spaces due to the number of employees we had--the parking spaces were rarely used since everybody working there did manual labor--except for admin jobs everybody was able-bodied. Then my left leg began to go out on me, and I tripped frequently. Today, I am forced to walk with forearm crutches, can't walk even a half-block without my wheelchair. Now I understand. Without the ADA compliance there would be a lot of buildings I couldn't get into, or be able to park close enough. A lot of it is simply people have no concept of how difficult mobility can be until they experience it themselves. Oh, and I have a Chihuahua too--she's very calm and well-behaved, an excellent companion.
People with service dogs don’t have to answer any questions. Once they confirm the dog is a service dog, the facility must accept it. The legal stance is: ‘further inquiry is both unjustified and illegal. The staff or management of the centre may not ask, "What is your disability?" This is private, protected information and considered harassment of the disabled. They may not ask for the dog to demonstrate the task it provides. It is also illegal to ask for "proof" of any kind, including documentation or a vest, as neither the federal or state government requires it. The only entity allowed to decide if an animal is truly a service dog is a judge’.
*FALSE ACCORDING TO THE ADA* _When it is not obvious what service an animal provides, only limited inquiries are allowed. Staff may ask two questions: (1) is the dog a service animal required because of a disability, and (2) what work or task has the dog been trained to perform._
This so called town leader should be fired. He is a disgrace to the community. It doesn’t matter how big or small the dog is, most dogs can be trained to be a service dog. I had a back injury 30 years ago and still suffer. Been walking with cane for 29 years. And some people make the comment, “but you look so good.” Walk a day in my body, then you will change your mind. With other words, don’t say anything dumb.
I'm diabetic and need a service animal because of my neuropathy and passing out but to look at me you'd never know. DISABILITIES ARE NOT ALWAYS VISIBLE ACTUALLY MOST ARE NOT! Where these idiots get their ignorant and uneducated thoughts is beyond comprehension. He should be charged for HARASSMENT AND BULLYING THE DISABLED!
3:20+ Listening to the ‘boss’ talking to police: he comes across as self-opinionated and completely ignorant about disability; specifically in this case ignorant about PTSD. Would he call a long cane a ‘crutch’ for a blind person? Does he need a crutch coffee in the morning? 😡
My thoughts exactly. My ex-husband was an expert at passive-aggressive gaslighting, to the point that I would finally explode, and then it was "Why are you so sensitive?...... it was just a joke", which would piss me off even more! He was the king of pressing buttons.
Thank you for pointing that out. It’s true-if someone close to him needed a service dog, this whole situation would likely be viewed very differently. Unfortunately, it often takes personal experience for some people to understand the importance and value of service dogs. For those of us living with disabilities, our service dogs aren’t just companions-they’re a lifeline. Rosie helps me in ways that I can’t do on my own, and for someone in a leadership position to dismiss that shows a real lack of empathy. It shouldn’t take knowing someone personally to respect the needs of people with disabilities, but sadly, that’s sometimes the case. Hopefully, raising awareness and speaking out can help change these attitudes for everyone who relies on service dogs or other forms of support.
Service dogs are not a crutch ! That makes me mad. I would sue him. I would call a Ada lawyer . Especially if he said it in front of other people. They should fire him. Those in public office need to learn how to handle people. He needs to at least all to the man,then be fired.
People need to realize that those with service/support dogs do NOT need or have to explain their disability or need. As an example, if a woman was brutally raped, and eventually found that a service dog helped her deal with PTSD, ALSO helping her feel safe, in case she was ever attacked again.....if someone asked her, "What is your need for a service dog?", is she supposed to explain every time that it's because she was raped? An emotional support dog can be a REAL need, and you cannot SEE the person's need or disability. Some needs are physical (fainting or seizure episodes, diabetes/low blood sugar, etc.) and some are extreme emotional .
*FALSE ACCORDING TO THE ADA* _When it is not obvious what service an animal provides, only limited inquiries are allowed. Staff may ask two questions: (1) is the dog a service animal required because of a disability, and (2) what work or task has the dog been trained to perform._
@@grizzlycountry1030 That requires no explanation beyond "Yes" and "the dog puts it's paws on my chest." They don't have to explain why or for what symptom.
Well I wonder if he would have told a man in a wheelchair that his wheelchair was just a crutch ( implying it was not really needed and just used as a excuse. As a town leader he should know more about disabilties and since he is not s doctor he has no right to determine someone needs for a service dog. This is very disrespectful to disabled people and show he should not be representing the community.
Rich Chaffee really doesn't get it. His statement tells us all that he is oblivious. Absolutely the dog is a crutch. We all love our animal "crutches". Man's best friend!
Wow. This is a very uneducated "town leader". I would highly "suggest" he and his entire staff take a class on the laws of service dogs. How to handle a person with PTSD. This "town leader" (who in my opinion should be removed from office) antagonized this person intentionally. What a tool. And that's MY OPINION.
I have chronic back pain. People can’t see it but I definitely feel it. I can’t walk very far without pain nor can I sit or stand any length of time. The town leader was so arrogant. I sure hope he never has to deal with any disability, unless stupidity is a disability
I’m really sorry to hear about your chronic back pain, and I completely understand what you’re going through. It’s so frustrating when people don’t recognize or understand invisible disabilities, yet those challenges are very real and impact every part of daily life. Like you said, just because others can’t see the pain doesn’t mean it isn’t there or that it doesn’t matter. As for the town leader’s remark, I agree-it was beyond arrogant and shows a serious lack of compassion. It’s sad to think that some people don’t realize how hurtful and dismissive these comments can be until they experience something similar themselves. Let’s hope he never has to deal with any form of disability, because as you know, it’s tough enough without also having to deal with disrespect. Thank you for your support-it means a lot to me and to Rosie as we keep pushing forward!
I say the dog is not a crutch but an aid to help you! Speaking as someone on the spectrum, I find that society is not tolerant of my different behavior .. Forcing others to behave as they wish them to, is very intolerant and wrong!
While the guy who made the "dog is a crutch" comment is entitled to his opinion, it doesn't make him any less of an a$$hole. He should be fired from his position.
In Australia a service dog is called an assistance dog....I have an assistance dog and I know that when I have a person try to refuse entry because of my dog it starts my panic attacks....this man should not be in a position as a town official very unprofessional.....really no understanding
What?!? And here I though the most stupid opinion on this page was with the so-called "town leader's" opinion that a service dog is a crutch, and then I read yours. You seem to have a lack of understanding of our basic rights. Every single American is guaranteed to have both the right to an opinion AND the right to speak it. That absolutely includes public servants. (If anything, it's more important for a public servant to use his or her right to speak their opinions, because it's often the easiest way of deciding who is worthy of the public's trust, and particularly if that person lacks a track record.) It could be a stupid, thoughtless, and tone-deaf opinion, but it is still his right to have it and speak it. Considering the sacrifice so many gave to protect YOUR right to have and speak an opinion AND the "town leader" who spoke his opinion, enshrined in our First Amendment, is a remarkably anti-American opinion, in my opinion. What is also his right is to deal with the repercussions of his lackluster assessment of his service dog and his handler, and if this is a position that is gained through election, he should be voted out of office. He clearly has little to no empathy for his fellow man. Empathy is perhaps one of the more important things public servants should be endowed with having.
@@Pro3110 You need to worry about your own intelligence. I clearly talked about the role of a public servant. Your need to throw a temper tantrum doesn't change that.
My suggestion would be to use the power off the press release against them! First, the involved should make a complaint to the DOJ. Regardless of the result, as soon as the complaint is transmitted; make a press release, including all the TV, radio stations, and newspapers PLUS all the area citizen journalists, auditors, and pod casters in and around the area. Finally, hold the press conference at the courthouse (public forum) and say that a state and federal investigation has been DEMANDED. This should get the case traction for a civil movement, if not a criminal one. Plus, with any luck, it will attract the attention of a hotshot lawyer who might want the case.
Thank you for the suggestion! I’ve definitely thought about taking this issue further and using media attention to shed light on what’s been happening. Filing a complaint with the DOJ is an option I’ve been considering, especially with the way things have been handled. It’s important to hold public officials accountable when they cross a line, and making sure the community is aware of what’s going on is key to that. That said, my goal isn’t to escalate things to the point of legal battles unless it’s absolutely necessary. As I’ve mentioned before, I don’t want to sue my own town because, in the end, it’s the taxpayers who would pay the price. Still, I do believe that the more people know about these kinds of actions, the more pressure it puts on officials to do the right thing. I appreciate your thoughts on bringing in the press and other media outlets. It’s something I’ll keep in mind as I weigh my options for moving forward.
Elevated voices and or curse words are not disturbing the peace. It is 1st Amendment guaranteed speech. Only fighting words quality as disturbing the peace. Also under the 1st Amendment, you have the right to petition the government for a redress of grievances.
the town leader/employee needs to have his actions and opinions dragged before the local citizens and after showing that as a town employee his personal feelings do not exist when in the course of his offical duties. ......All town employees need to understand there can be legal consequencies/repercusions for their actions when dealing with the public..
Depends. Service dogs are dogs trained to perform specific work tasks to assist with a disability, generally physical/mobility tasks. Psychiatric service dogs are much more clinically and legally murky. The ADA does say psychiatric service dogs can be a real thing but emphasize that they have to be specifically trained for specific work task(s). There aren’t any psychiatric disabilities that involve true physical/mobility impairments, and there isn’t yet any peer reviewed evidence regarding specific work tasks for psychiatric disorders. Service dogs aren’t a part of any best practices/treatment guidelines for any psychiatric disorders. A lot of people slap on service dog vests to their untrained pets. Many people have taken their dog through a psychiatric service dog training program, yet aren’t actually trained to perform a SPECIFIC work tasks required for specific disability. Licensed mental health providers often sign off on letters of support for psychiatric service dogs, but these invariably do not include any specific work task recommendations. So if a discrimination lawsuit actually gets litigated, you are going to have to prove the training was focused on a specific ADA-consistent work task, and be able to demonstrate the specific work task that the dog performs (as opposed to just proving emotional support for symptoms.)
@@AA-ch7yw There are service dogs specifically trained for PTSD, cardiac alert, diabetic alert, epilepsy alert and many other invisible disabilities. And legally only 2 questions can be asked. If it's a service dog and what do they perform. That's it. What this man did to the service dog owner is a violation and he could be charged.
@@AA-ch7yw It seems there are several misunderstandings in your comment about psychiatric service dogs. First, under the ADA, psychiatric service dogs are legally recognized and afforded the same protections as service dogs for physical disabilities. There is no legal murkiness - psychiatric service dogs are covered by the ADA and cannot be banned from public places, work, school, or restaurants, as long as they are trained to perform tasks directly related to their handler's disability. Additionally, while it’s true that psychiatric service dogs may perform different tasks depending on the individual’s needs, there is ample evidence that these dogs can and do perform specific tasks, such as interrupting panic attacks, grounding during flashbacks, and waking handlers from night terrors. These tasks are critical for many people with PTSD and other psychiatric disorders, and to claim there’s no peer-reviewed evidence is simply not true. Lastly, psychiatric service dogs are part of treatment plans for many people, particularly veterans with PTSD. The VA recognizes the value of these dogs and has integrated them into treatment guidelines for those who qualify. Dismissing their role does a disservice to the many people who benefit from these dogs every day. I hope this helps clarify things! References 1. Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Guidelines - The ADA clearly defines service animals, including psychiatric service dogs, and outlines the legal protections they are granted. This can be found on the official ADA website: - ADA Service Animal Guidance www.ada.gov/topics/service-animals/ 2. Veterans Affairs (VA) and Service Dogs for PTSD - The VA supports the use of psychiatric service dogs for veterans with PTSD, recognizing the benefits these animals provide. Here’s a resource from the VA on service dogs for veterans: Veterans Affairs on Service Dogs (www.prosthetics.va.gov/ServiceAndGuideDogs.asp) 3. Peer-Reviewed Study on PTSD and Service Dogs - This study, published in the *Journal of Psychiatric Research*, found that psychiatric service dogs can reduce PTSD symptoms and improve the quality of life for veterans: - Yount, R.A., Olmert, M.D., & Lee, M.R. (2012). Service dog training program for treatment of post-traumatic stress in service members. Journal of Psychiatric Research 46(4), 630-638. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22388683/
@@heartland96a Yes , a trained service dog is covered by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Under the ADA, service dogs cannot be banned from public places like workplaces, schools, or restaurants , as long as they are trained to perform specific tasks that assist with a person’s disability. The ADA ensures that individuals with disabilities, accompanied by their service dogs, are allowed access to public spaces. The only exceptions are if the dog is out of control or poses a direct threat to the health or safety of others. For more information, you can refer to the official ADA guidelines on service animals: ADA Service Animal Guidance www.ada.gov/resources/service-animals/
Does this man understand exactly what a service dog is? Their are many categories of service dogs with the most being emotional support,do I think it’s legit,not always but it is the world we live in
Thank you for your comment! I’d like to clarify a common misconception about service dogs. Emotional support animals (ESAs) and service dogs are actually quite different. While ESAs provide comfort to their owners, they don’t have the same legal status or training as service dogs. Service dogs, by definition under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), are individually trained to perform specific tasks that directly assist a person with a disability. This can include guiding someone with vision impairment, alerting someone with hearing loss, or, in my case, helping mitigate the symptoms of PTSD by performing tasks like providing tactile stimulation or interrupting night terrors. ESAs, while valuable to many, don’t undergo the same rigorous training as service dogs and aren’t granted the same public access rights. It’s important to recognize the difference to ensure the rights of people with disabilities and their service dogs are respected. Thanks for engaging in this discussion!
@@RosieTheGreatDaneServiceDog I have been very active in the dog community and had a friend who trained dogs for guide dogs for the blind out east,but I also have a sister who has a very unruly GS and in order to move into her apartment applied for service dog status by simply going online. The dog has no special training and is almost out of control,it’s people like her that spoil it for true service dogs
If they are a service animal they are suppose to have the service harness stating service dog or animal on it, now with that said if they do not have that harness its not a service animal and need to leave. With a harness indicating service animal you cannot ask if its a service animal or what service do they provide. DO NOT TOUCH SERVICE ANIMALS
Hey LEO, you can absolutely question the legitimacy of a service dog... 1) Is this animal a service animal? 2) What tasks is the animal trained to do to assist you with your disability? -Service dog handler
According to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), a business or public entity may only ask two specific questions regarding a service dog when it is not obvious what service the dog provides 1. Is the dog a service animal required because of a disability? 2. What work or task has the dog been trained to perform? However, if it is clear that the dog is a service animal (for instance, if the dog is wearing a service dog vest or performing an obvious task like guiding a person who is visually impaired), it is inappropriate to ask these questions. The ADA prohibits unnecessary inquiries when the service animal's role is evident. For further reference, see 28 C.F.R. § 35.136(f) of the ADA, which outlines the limitations on permissible questions about service animals.
There are times when people DO play up their disability as an excuse for bad behaviour. They don’t have the exclusive right to insult others and then cry boo-hoo if they’re insulted in return.
YES Rich Chaffee is an ignorant nasty bully. Chaffee has probably been a BULLY for a long long time. That Chaffee later proceeded to malign the guy with the service dog (when the guy with the service done was NOT present) - and trying to JUSTIFY his words maligning Chris to others is clear evidence that Rich Chaffee is trying to shore up his persona as the "nice guy" when Rich Chaffee is NOT a nice guy. Those who "agree" with Chaffee are just currying favour with Chaffee - this is what weak scarred people do to curry favour with the BULLY so they can demonstrate that they are NO THREAT to the nasty bully. This is how BULLIES CEMENT their POWER moves. And YES training and consultation about HOW a service dog operates and WHY service dogs are of great value to the people who need a service dog IS urgently needed in this TOXIC workplace.
A veteran in a small town in North Carolina had a service dog provided by the VA. Two local buffoon cops approached him one day demanding his ID. He suffers from PTSD and the cops actions set his PTSD off. His service dog emitted a low growl, and one officer took out his tasser and shot the dog. It ran off, and a friend found the but it had died. The VA provided a new service dog, but in small town way, nothing was done to the buffoons. I am guessing if the city council provided funds to the police department for training on how to interact with persons with disabilities this leader would have another fit
Ah, the mysteries of the RUclips algorithm! It has a mind of its own, kind of like a cat-showing you things you didn’t ask for but secretly might enjoy. 😉 Stick around, though-this "silliness" might grow on you! 🐕🦺
Too many people think of their little doggie as a child and totally ignore signs in many stores not place them in a cart. Those who really need one are getting a bad rap.
Most people with "service dogs" are just scammers that want to take their pet everywhere they go. If you're going to freak out because you can't have your pet with you at Target, go get some real help.
What a nervous LEO. Hand rubbing and finger cracking. Maybe he should see someone about that. If he was conversing with me and doing that I would ask him to stop. Is he a rooky cop?
Wouldn't it be interesting if Rich were to acquire some condition that requires him to need a service dog - see what it's like to not be believed and constantly questioned. The smug look and "I didn't do anything" attitude would soon disappear! Karma is a bi*** my friend.
What right do you have to saysomeone shouldn't have a service dog. This jerk should lose his job. I had a Great Dane as a service dog. She was with me 14 yrs. Miss her every day..
In some states like mine service dogs have to be certified. A lot of people carry little dogs around claiming they are “anxiety dogs” and they aren’t. Some people do use dogs as a excuse.
@@jamescarpenter7161 Actually, under federal law, service dogs are not required to be certified in any state, including yours. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) does not require certification for service dogs. They only need to be trained to perform specific tasks that assist a person with a disability. Any requirement for certification or registration is often a misunderstanding or misinformation at the state or local level. Regarding 'anxiety dogs,' it's important to differentiate between emotional support animals (ESAs) and service dogs. Emotional support animals provide comfort by their presence but are not trained to perform specific tasks, so they don’t have the same legal protections as service dogs. Service dogs, however, are trained to do specific tasks that directly mitigate a disability. For example, a service dog trained to help someone with PTSD might perform tasks like waking them from night terrors, providing grounding during flashbacks, or guiding them to a safe space during an anxiety attack. While there may be misuse by some people, it's essential to understand that for individuals with disabilities, service dogs are a lifeline, not a 'crutch.' These dogs enable people to live more independently by performing tasks they cannot do on their own. For more information, you can refer to the official ADA guidelines on service animals ADA Service Animal Guidance www.ada.gov/resources/service-animals/
Actually, no states in the U.S. require service dogs to be certified. Under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), service dogs are not required to be certified or registered. The ADA defines a service dog as a dog that has been individually trained to perform specific tasks for a person with a disability. These tasks must be directly related to the handler’s disability. While it’s true that some people may falsely claim their pets as service animals, it’s important to remember that legitimate service dogs provide critical assistance to their handlers, and asking for certification or proof of training is not allowed under the ADA. Emotional support animals (often incorrectly referred to as 'anxiety dogs') are not considered service animals under the ADA, as they do not perform specific tasks related to a disability. However, emotional support animals have protections under other laws in certain contexts, like housing. Misunderstanding these differences can lead to confusion about the legal rights of service dog handlers.
Everyone has a right to an opinion.wrong,right,shitty. Ignorant. Crude rude or obscene. Doesn't matter. First amendment right. Now,to threaten someone,over insult. That is a crime. I have to answer to this problem. Watch what you say. Try not to air your opinion unsolicited. Don't react to words. We all learned,at a young age," sticks,and stones can break your bones,but words can never hurt you. Unless you let them. Holy cow,is this where we have come. Pathetic.
The towns leader should obviously keep his opinions to himself, as he’s a representative of the town and we all know opinions are like a-holes, everyone has one! The police are correct that he was provoked by being told having a “service dog” as a crutch! Rich is a problem for the town and likely will not be getting reelected.
Chaffee is the elected Assessor. He is in that position till 2025. This should go to ADA.gov, the local news stations and paper. This citizens need to know what kind of person he is before the next election. Vote Chaffe out!
*ACCORDING TO THE ADA* _When it is not obvious what service an animal provides, only limited inquiries are allowed. Staff may ask two questions: (1) is the dog a service animal required because of a disability, and (2) what work or task has the dog been trained to perform._ *ADA.gov* *U.S. Department of Justice* *Civil Rights Division*
👋 **Thanks for watching!** If you enjoyed this video and want to see more content about **service dog rights**, **public accountability**, and my experiences with **town officials**, don’t forget to **SUBSCRIBE** to the channel! 📢
🔔 Click the bell icon to stay updated on all future uploads - I’ve got more important videos coming soon, and your support helps me bring these stories to light!
What did you think about today’s video? Drop your thoughts below, and let’s start a conversation! 👇
#Subscribe #ServiceDogRights #PublicAccountability #StayTuned
He's a town leader. He should respect the law, which he didn't do.
Just another example of abusing our veterans. If they don’t fire this horrible person sue the town maybe then they will listen.
Dog is a crutch? He would deprive a cripple of his crutch?
Sounds like an evil dude.
We are persons with disabilities, or handicapped. Never “cripples,” honey. Don’t call us “cripples.” It’s incredibly inappropriate. I know you meant well, but this is a teaching moment you ought to take seriously.
@@MarySanchez-qk3hp There are those who don't like the term handicapped either. Invalid is another. At the end of the day, it's just words, and I don't get too worked up about it, when there's no malice intended. It's not like it's on par with the word that starts with "R" or "N". Crippled is still used to describe lots of things that are broken down, like a car. Disabled is currently the only universally acceptable descriptor for us, but hey... I have bigger problems than terminology. I'm sure you do, too.
Rich Chaffee is a bully. Bullies are cowards.
That dog as a crutch remark is disgusting.
I agree-it’s beyond offensive to refer to a service dog as a "crutch." Service dogs are essential tools that help people with disabilities live more independent lives. Referring to them in such a dismissive way shows a complete lack of understanding and respect for the critical roles they play. Service dogs perform vital, trained tasks, and comparing them to a mere crutch diminishes the value of the work they do and the rights that handlers have under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).
Such comments not only disrespect the handler but also perpetuate harmful stigmas around disabilities and the use of service animals.
It's a form of discrimination to a person with disabilities.
Obvious and blatant ableism
A service dog is a crutch. Just as someone with a broken leg needs it to get around so we need our service animals. Without her by my side knowing she is always looking out for me I would never be able to leave the house. Lady J is a crutch but also a helpmate and loyal friend. To claim her as a crutch for me is true but to claim her as a crutch used for an excuse for special attention, which has happened in the past, is beyond ludicrous.
Bullies should never be allowed to get the upper hand. Bullies are just Bullies
This man is so wrong on his opinion.
You’re absolutely right-his opinion is completely wrong. Referring to a service dog as a "crutch" shows a deep misunderstanding of what service dogs actually do. Rosie performs essential, task-specific duties that help me manage my disability. These aren’t just emotional comforts; they’re legally recognized under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) as vital to my independence and daily functioning.
Dismissing the role of a service dog in this way doesn’t just show ignorance-it disrespects the thousands of people who rely on service dogs to help them navigate life with disabilities, both visible and invisible. The law protects people like me, and comments like these only highlight how much more education and awareness are needed.
Thank you for seeing through that remark and supporting service dog handlers!
A Town leader saying a disabled person is just using his service dog as a crutch is a total lack of respect, and cold hearted. He should not be representing the people of the town because apparently he doesn't represent everyone. Would you tell a paralyzed man he just uses his wheelchair just to get sympathy. Not every disability or illness can be seen, I have fibromyalgia a debilitating disease but you can't see it., for years I was called lazy , etc. Isn't being in pain enough you have to also make a personal attack ? If someone in a public position cannot control their temper or takes everything personal they should not be in that position. It was bad enough to offend him about his service dog but then to talk to the police trying to get him arrested as well. Having a management position in government doesn't mean you are better than everyone else. You are suppose to be an example to those you manage. Hugs to you and Rosie 🤗
Thank you so much for your kind words and for sharing your own experience, Sandra. It means a lot to me, and you’re absolutely right-not all disabilities are visible, and the ignorance behind comments like that shows a lack of understanding and compassion. I can only imagine the pain and frustration you’ve felt with fibromyalgia and being dismissed by people who don’t see what you’re going through. I, too, face the same with my PTSD, which Rosie helps me manage every day.
What hurts the most is that these comments came from someone in a public position who is supposed to represent all of us, not just the ones without visible disabilities. Comparing my service dog to a "crutch" is disrespectful not just to me but to all people who rely on service dogs or any other support system. It’s as if our disabilities and the tools we use to manage them are seen as weaknesses, when in reality, they help us live fuller lives.
You’re also right about the way this kind of behavior discourages others from stepping forward, especially when those in leadership positions use their power to target or silence people who are already dealing with so much. But the community’s support, like yours, helps remind me that these attitudes are the problem, not us.
Thank you again for your kind words, and Rosie and I are sending you hugs right back. Stay strong!
@@RosieTheGreatDaneServiceDog 𝙔𝙤𝙪'𝙧𝙚 𝙒𝙚𝙡𝙘𝙤𝙢𝙚!! 𝘼𝙣𝙮𝙩𝙞𝙢𝙚!:🐾 We with disabilities in all forms are many and more join our ranks everyday, even the very people that condemn us will also suffer in the future. No one chooses to be disabled. It would be wise for others to remember you reap what you sow and that Karma comes after us all. You do a great service to us all by exposing those in power meant to serve the public, but abuse the public instead with their sense of entitled power they do not possess. If you see something, say something, and always record ! Hang in there we are behind you. (Ɔ ˘⌣˘)˘⌣˘ C✿)🐕
Who the hell is that guy?? Professional dog trainer? Trains dogs for service dogs??? He had absolutely no power or right to question the use of the dog!!! If he's a city official, I feel sorry for y'all!! 😡😡😡
Service animal handlers are being harassed because there are so many people these days who brand their pets service or emotional support animals, with little or no training on the part of the owner or the animal, just so they can take their pets wherever they please. I haven't read your backstory, but if your animal truly is an ADA-compliant service animal, you should file an ADA complaint against the city, rather than arguing with city officials regarding its status.
You’re absolutely right-the misuse of service dog vests and emotional support animal labels by untrained pets is a real issue, and it creates unfair skepticism for those of us who have legitimate service dogs. It’s unfortunate that people take advantage of the system, because it makes it harder for those of us who genuinely rely on service dogs to navigate life with a disability.
In my case, Rosie is a fully trained, ADA-compliant service dog, specifically trained to perform tasks that assist with my disability. Her role is legally recognized under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), and she’s a critical part of my daily life. As you suggested, I’ve considered taking action, and filing an ADA complaint is an option I’m exploring to hold the Town accountable. I agree that it's important to take the proper steps when city officials fail to respect the rights of service dog handlers.
Thank you for your understanding, and I appreciate your advice
Thank you, and you're welcome. An ADA complaint likely won't result in fines and such, but it will light a fire under city leaders and HR folks to address this issue and educate all the city's employees. I know several folks who depend on their service animals, and it irritates me no end when folks pass around suggestions on social media about how to get fake service animal credentials for their pets so they can take them anywhere. Keep up the good work.
Well there is not real ADA compliant service dog requirement other they provide a service. That could be your chihuahua picking up your keys off the floor and bringing them to you. But my feeling if the dog is well behaved I do not care. One thing I loved about Germany is dog are allowed almost everywhere. Because of that all the dogs are well socialized because they are use to being taken everywhere so they learn to take a nap in a resturant and be on there best behavior in a store. Meanwhile in the USA dogs are stuck in a house all day which cause them to become overly protective of people and home and also become less socialized as they are exposed to fewer people.
@@JAM661 There are, in fact, specific requirements for a service animal to be ADA compliant. There is also a separate class of animals that do no fall under ADA protections but may fall under provisions of the Fair Housing Act or other federal guidelines. These animals do not have the same protections as ADA compliant service animals.
www.ada.gov/resources/service-animals-2010-requirements/
@@JAM661 There are, in fact, specific requirements for a service animal to be ADA compliant. While other federal laws, such as the Fair Housing Act, recognize a broader spectrum of "service animals," but those are not guaranteed the same protections as an ADA compliant animal.
www.ada.gov/resources/service-animals-2010-requirements/
The man who called the dog a crutch is an ignorant creep. He is horrible and shouold not be a town leader at all. Thank goodness the Chief of Police is smarter. One would wish that town leaders were more compassionate and respectful than Rick Chaffee. It is disgusting that Rich Chaffee would try to get someone arrested to enforce his own personal biases.
This is appalling. If the situation was reversed and the town official was told his service dog was "fake" and a "crutch", how would he react?
That's bloody disgusting, any dog can be trained to be a service dog . That guy had no right to say that. Disgusting
Just because any dog can be trained doesn't mean any dog is a service dog
@@lafondawilliams You’re absolutely right-just because any dog can be trained doesn’t mean every trained dog is a service dog. According to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), a dog is only considered a service dog if it is trained to perform specific tasks that directly assist a person with a disability. These tasks must go beyond basic obedience or general training, and they must help mitigate the handler’s disability.
It’s important to make this distinction because only service dogs that perform these specific tasks are protected under the ADA. Simply being well-trained doesn’t automatically make a dog a service dog unless it is performing work that directly supports a disability.
You clearly have never met my dogs. Services provided would include comforter and sheet destruction, bra destruction, carpet destruction, getting in the way of a walking human and stopping on a dime, barking in their sleep at 2:00 a.m., giving us grief for being two minutes late with their dinner, and would most likely give the combination code to the safe to any and all bad guys breaking in the house. Too dumb to provide any useful benefit to mankind, but smart enough to use being dumb to ensure a life of leisure for themselves.
And now, one of them is trying to make me feel bad for dissing them, so I have to go pat her little tummy. Too freakin' cute, I swear....
@@Pro3110 Ah, yeah, it's calling training your dog.
There is a very short conversation that can be had. Two questions can be asked.
1. Is that a service animal?
2.What service does the animal provide?
End of conversation. No demonstration of the service required.
No special jacket with markings, no papers need to be shown, animal can be anywhere the person can be. This is Federal law.
This guy would have hit the roof with my Chihuahua Service Dog. When this guy gets older and needs a cane, I hope someone tells him it’s just a ‘crutch’ and then he’ll understand what it’s like to be disabled and not allowed to access the same spaces that everyone else has access to.
A million years ago (seems like!) I used to wonder at all the money spent on ramps, automatic doors, designated parking, etc., all to benefit disabled people, and kind of resented the amount of money that businesses had to spend to become ADA-compliant. For a long time, I worked security at a huge distribution center, where we were required to provide a certain number of handicap parking spaces due to the number of employees we had--the parking spaces were rarely used since everybody working there did manual labor--except for admin jobs everybody was able-bodied. Then my left leg began to go out on me, and I tripped frequently. Today, I am forced to walk with forearm crutches, can't walk even a half-block without my wheelchair. Now I understand. Without the ADA compliance there would be a lot of buildings I couldn't get into, or be able to park close enough. A lot of it is simply people have no concept of how difficult mobility can be until they experience it themselves. Oh, and I have a Chihuahua too--she's very calm and well-behaved, an excellent companion.
There is law about the treatment of the disabled.....assistance dogs are a medical aid
That "Ant" of a town leader must resign. How dare he call a veteran service dog fake.
People with service dogs don’t have to answer any questions. Once they confirm the dog is a service dog, the facility must accept it. The legal stance is: ‘further inquiry is both unjustified and illegal. The staff or management of the centre may not ask, "What is your disability?" This is private, protected information and considered harassment of the disabled. They may not ask for the dog to demonstrate the task it provides. It is also illegal to ask for "proof" of any kind, including documentation or a vest, as neither the federal or state government requires it. The only entity allowed to decide if an animal is truly a service dog is a judge’.
Bless you for knowing and stating the facts. Such a shame so many "town leaders" are so ignorant along with their staffs.
*FALSE ACCORDING TO THE ADA*
_When it is not obvious what service an animal provides, only limited inquiries are allowed. Staff may ask two questions: (1) is the dog a service animal required because of a disability, and (2) what work or task has the dog been trained to perform._
I think it is time to contact the ADA and file lawsuit. Sounds to me like their numerous violations.
This so called town leader should be fired. He is a disgrace to the community.
It doesn’t matter how big or small the dog is, most dogs can be trained to be a service dog.
I had a back injury 30 years ago and still suffer.
Been walking with cane for 29 years. And some people make the comment, “but you look so good.” Walk a day in my body, then you will change your mind. With other words, don’t say anything dumb.
I'm diabetic and need a service animal because of my neuropathy and passing out but to look at me you'd never know. DISABILITIES ARE NOT ALWAYS VISIBLE ACTUALLY MOST ARE NOT! Where these idiots get their ignorant and uneducated thoughts is beyond comprehension.
He should be charged for HARASSMENT AND BULLYING THE DISABLED!
3:20+ Listening to the ‘boss’ talking to police: he comes across as self-opinionated and completely ignorant about disability; specifically in this case ignorant about PTSD. Would he call a long cane a ‘crutch’ for a blind person? Does he need a crutch coffee in the morning? 😡
Maybe that guy didn't raise his voice but he has that passive/aggreesive attitude finely tuned when it comes to presing buttons. Good luck.
My thoughts exactly. My ex-husband was an expert at passive-aggressive gaslighting, to the point that I would finally explode, and then it was "Why are you so sensitive?...... it was just a joke", which would piss me off even more! He was the king of pressing buttons.
If one of his family members or friends would need a service dog, this issue would be moot .
Thank you for pointing that out. It’s true-if someone close to him needed a service dog, this whole situation would likely be viewed very differently. Unfortunately, it often takes personal experience for some people to understand the importance and value of service dogs. For those of us living with disabilities, our service dogs aren’t just companions-they’re a lifeline.
Rosie helps me in ways that I can’t do on my own, and for someone in a leadership position to dismiss that shows a real lack of empathy. It shouldn’t take knowing someone personally to respect the needs of people with disabilities, but sadly, that’s sometimes the case. Hopefully, raising awareness and speaking out can help change these attitudes for everyone who relies on service dogs or other forms of support.
Where is this?
*It's Brookfield, Mass and It's public now. They had better hope AFA doesn't hear about this video!
Massachusetts is having a lot of problems right now. This is civil rights violation. Need to file a lawsuit for their compliance.
@@MadisonD941actually it is an AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT violation. It is a FEDERAL OFFENSE.
Then someone should report it to them
Service dogs are not a crutch ! That makes me mad. I would sue him. I would call a Ada lawyer . Especially if he said it in front of other people. They should fire him. Those in public office need to learn how to handle people. He needs to at least all to the man,then be fired.
People need to realize that those with service/support dogs do NOT need or have to explain their disability or need. As an example, if a woman was brutally raped, and eventually found that a service dog helped her deal with PTSD, ALSO helping her feel safe, in case she was ever attacked again.....if someone asked her, "What is your need for a service dog?", is she supposed to explain every time that it's because she was raped? An emotional support dog can be a REAL need, and you cannot SEE the person's need or disability. Some needs are physical (fainting or seizure episodes, diabetes/low blood sugar, etc.) and some are extreme emotional .
Well said!
*FALSE ACCORDING TO THE ADA*
_When it is not obvious what service an animal provides, only limited inquiries are allowed. Staff may ask two questions: (1) is the dog a service animal required because of a disability, and (2) what work or task has the dog been trained to perform._
@@grizzlycountry1030 That requires no explanation beyond "Yes" and "the dog puts it's paws on my chest." They don't have to explain why or for what symptom.
🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧 cannot believe someone like this still exists.
Just found your channel and subscribed. So sorry to hear about this situation. No place for this.
Well I wonder if he would have told a man in a wheelchair that his wheelchair was just a crutch ( implying it was not really needed and just used as a excuse. As a town leader he should know more about disabilties and since he is not s doctor he has no right to determine someone needs for a service dog. This is very disrespectful to disabled people and show he should not be representing the community.
Rich Chaffee really doesn't get it. His statement tells us all that he is oblivious. Absolutely the dog is a crutch. We all love our animal "crutches". Man's best friend!
Yes, the "lame and the halt" NEED crutches. But the way the term is used is derogatory towards the "lame and the halt."
If the dog is a certified service animal Chaffee is in for a world of hurt!
There is NO such thing as a "certified service animal." Read ADA.
@@bessarion1771you are correct!
@@myrtle471 I know. I had a service dog for 8 years.
I had a Great Dane. She wasmy Service dog. I had h.er for 14years.😊 Miss her dearly❤
I know some narcissists who don't have to 'raise their voice' when they gas light others. Total D...Move.
Wow. This is a very uneducated "town leader". I would highly "suggest" he and his entire staff take a class on the laws of service dogs. How to handle a person with PTSD. This "town leader" (who in my opinion should be removed from office) antagonized this person intentionally. What a tool. And that's MY OPINION.
I wonder what the compelling public reason is to question anyone about a service animal?
The ‘town leader’ should keep his opinion to himself.
I have chronic back pain. People can’t see it but I definitely feel it. I can’t walk very far without pain nor can I sit or stand any length of time.
The town leader was so arrogant. I sure hope he never has to deal with any disability, unless stupidity is a disability
I’m really sorry to hear about your chronic back pain, and I completely understand what you’re going through. It’s so frustrating when people don’t recognize or understand invisible disabilities, yet those challenges are very real and impact every part of daily life. Like you said, just because others can’t see the pain doesn’t mean it isn’t there or that it doesn’t matter.
As for the town leader’s remark, I agree-it was beyond arrogant and shows a serious lack of compassion. It’s sad to think that some people don’t realize how hurtful and dismissive these comments can be until they experience something similar themselves. Let’s hope he never has to deal with any form of disability, because as you know, it’s tough enough without also having to deal with disrespect.
Thank you for your support-it means a lot to me and to Rosie as we keep pushing forward!
I am just like you. You can see chronic pain, but it effects our lives, every minute.
To judge a service dog, you need to be a professional dog handler. What a callous man. It may come back and bite him.
A professional handler cannot judge what is or is not a service dog. They are basing this service dog on the man's behavior not on the dog itself
A professional handler cannot judge what is or is not a service dog. They are basing this service dog on the man's behavior not on the dog itself
I say the dog is not a crutch but an aid to help you! Speaking as someone on the spectrum, I find that society is not tolerant of my different behavior .. Forcing others to behave as they wish them to, is very intolerant and wrong!
Town leader is in violation of Federal Law
He was demeaning the man with the service dog. I hope he sues him
While the guy who made the "dog is a crutch" comment is entitled to his opinion, it doesn't make him any less of an a$$hole. He should be fired from his position.
In Australia a service dog is called an assistance dog....I have an assistance dog and I know that when I have a person try to refuse entry because of my dog it starts my panic attacks....this man should not be in a position as a town official very unprofessional.....really no understanding
It doesn't matter if it is legal. As a public servant, he does not have the right to opinion.
What?!? And here I though the most stupid opinion on this page was with the so-called "town leader's" opinion that a service dog is a crutch, and then I read yours. You seem to have a lack of understanding of our basic rights. Every single American is guaranteed to have both the right to an opinion AND the right to speak it. That absolutely includes public servants. (If anything, it's more important for a public servant to use his or her right to speak their opinions, because it's often the easiest way of deciding who is worthy of the public's trust, and particularly if that person lacks a track record.)
It could be a stupid, thoughtless, and tone-deaf opinion, but it is still his right to have it and speak it. Considering the sacrifice so many gave to protect YOUR right to have and speak an opinion AND the "town leader" who spoke his opinion, enshrined in our First Amendment, is a remarkably anti-American opinion, in my opinion. What is also his right is to deal with the repercussions of his lackluster assessment of his service dog and his handler, and if this is a position that is gained through election, he should be voted out of office. He clearly has little to no empathy for his fellow man. Empathy is perhaps one of the more important things public servants should be endowed with having.
@@Pro3110 You need to worry about your own intelligence. I clearly talked about the role of a public servant. Your need to throw a temper tantrum doesn't change that.
That guy needs education, karma will strike him one day.
For someone who works for the city this guy needs to be schooled on service dogs and their ability to go everywhere.
Maybe the guy was worried the dog would scuff up the floors there??
Sounds like a lawsuit to me. Demeaning someone with a handicap just because its not a visible handicap has lawsuit written all over it.
My suggestion would be to use the power off the press release against them!
First, the involved should make a complaint to the DOJ. Regardless of the result, as soon as the complaint is transmitted;
make a press release, including all the TV, radio stations, and newspapers PLUS all the area citizen journalists, auditors, and pod casters in and around the area.
Finally, hold the press conference at the courthouse (public forum) and say that a state and federal investigation has been DEMANDED.
This should get the case traction for a civil movement, if not a criminal one. Plus, with any luck, it will attract the attention of a hotshot lawyer who might want the case.
Thank you for the suggestion! I’ve definitely thought about taking this issue further and using media attention to shed light on what’s been happening. Filing a complaint with the DOJ is an option I’ve been considering, especially with the way things have been handled. It’s important to hold public officials accountable when they cross a line, and making sure the community is aware of what’s going on is key to that.
That said, my goal isn’t to escalate things to the point of legal battles unless it’s absolutely necessary. As I’ve mentioned before, I don’t want to sue my own town because, in the end, it’s the taxpayers who would pay the price. Still, I do believe that the more people know about these kinds of actions, the more pressure it puts on officials to do the right thing.
I appreciate your thoughts on bringing in the press and other media outlets. It’s something I’ll keep in mind as I weigh my options for moving forward.
Elevated voices and or curse words are not disturbing the peace. It is 1st Amendment guaranteed speech. Only fighting words quality as disturbing the peace. Also under the 1st Amendment, you have the right to petition the government for a redress of grievances.
I legit thought the police got called because someone insulted a dog. I am disappointed this isn't the case, that'd be hilarious. :D
the town leader/employee needs to have his actions and opinions dragged before the local citizens and after showing that as a town employee his personal feelings do not exist when in the course of his offical duties. ......All town employees need to understand there can be legal consequencies/repercusions for their actions when dealing with the public..
Would a trained service be something covered under ADA . That they can’t be banned from any location , Store , Work, Hospital , Restaurant
Depends. Service dogs are dogs trained to perform specific work tasks to assist with a disability, generally physical/mobility tasks. Psychiatric service dogs are much more clinically and legally murky. The ADA does say psychiatric service dogs can be a real thing but emphasize that they have to be specifically trained for specific work task(s). There aren’t any psychiatric disabilities that involve true physical/mobility impairments, and there isn’t yet any peer reviewed evidence regarding specific work tasks for psychiatric disorders. Service dogs aren’t a part of any best practices/treatment guidelines for any psychiatric disorders. A lot of people slap on service dog vests to their untrained pets. Many people have taken their dog through a psychiatric service dog training program, yet aren’t actually trained to perform a SPECIFIC work tasks required for specific disability. Licensed mental health providers often sign off on letters of support for psychiatric service dogs, but these invariably do not include any specific work task recommendations. So if a discrimination lawsuit actually gets litigated, you are going to have to prove the training was focused on a specific ADA-consistent work task, and be able to demonstrate the specific work task that the dog performs (as opposed to just proving emotional support for symptoms.)
Only 2 questions can be asked. Is it a service dog? And what service do they provide? That's it.
@@AA-ch7yw There are service dogs specifically trained for PTSD, cardiac alert, diabetic alert, epilepsy alert and many other invisible disabilities. And legally only 2 questions can be asked. If it's a service dog and what do they perform. That's it. What this man did to the service dog owner is a violation and he could be charged.
@@AA-ch7yw It seems there are several misunderstandings in your comment about psychiatric service dogs. First, under the ADA, psychiatric service dogs are legally recognized and afforded the same protections as service dogs for physical disabilities. There is no legal murkiness - psychiatric service dogs are covered by the ADA and cannot be banned from public places, work, school, or restaurants, as long as they are trained to perform tasks directly related to their handler's disability.
Additionally, while it’s true that psychiatric service dogs may perform different tasks depending on the individual’s needs, there is ample evidence that these dogs can and do perform specific tasks, such as interrupting panic attacks, grounding during flashbacks, and waking handlers from night terrors. These tasks are critical for many people with PTSD and other psychiatric disorders, and to claim there’s no peer-reviewed evidence is simply not true.
Lastly, psychiatric service dogs are part of treatment plans for many people, particularly veterans with PTSD. The VA recognizes the value of these dogs and has integrated them into treatment guidelines for those who qualify. Dismissing their role does a disservice to the many people who benefit from these dogs every day.
I hope this helps clarify things!
References
1. Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Guidelines
- The ADA clearly defines service animals, including psychiatric service dogs, and outlines the legal protections they are granted. This can be found on the official ADA website:
- ADA Service Animal Guidance
www.ada.gov/topics/service-animals/
2. Veterans Affairs (VA) and Service Dogs for PTSD
- The VA supports the use of psychiatric service dogs for veterans with PTSD, recognizing the benefits these animals provide. Here’s a resource from the VA on service dogs for veterans:
Veterans Affairs on Service Dogs (www.prosthetics.va.gov/ServiceAndGuideDogs.asp)
3. Peer-Reviewed Study on PTSD and Service Dogs
- This study, published in the *Journal of Psychiatric Research*, found that psychiatric service dogs can reduce PTSD symptoms and improve the quality of life for veterans:
- Yount, R.A., Olmert, M.D., & Lee, M.R. (2012). Service dog training program for treatment of post-traumatic stress in service members. Journal of Psychiatric Research 46(4), 630-638.
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22388683/
@@heartland96a Yes , a trained service dog is covered by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Under the ADA, service dogs cannot be banned from public places like workplaces, schools, or restaurants , as long as they are trained to perform specific tasks that assist with a person’s disability.
The ADA ensures that individuals with disabilities, accompanied by their service dogs, are allowed access to public spaces. The only exceptions are if the dog is out of control or poses a direct threat to the health or safety of others.
For more information, you can refer to the official ADA guidelines on service animals:
ADA Service Animal Guidance
www.ada.gov/resources/service-animals/
Contact the EEOC and the Department of Justice it's time to make this city accountable for this
Does this man understand exactly what a service dog is? Their are many categories of service dogs with the most being emotional support,do I think it’s legit,not always but it is the world we live in
Thank you for your comment! I’d like to clarify a common misconception about service dogs. Emotional support animals (ESAs) and service dogs are actually quite different. While ESAs provide comfort to their owners, they don’t have the same legal status or training as service dogs.
Service dogs, by definition under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), are individually trained to perform specific tasks that directly assist a person with a disability. This can include guiding someone with vision impairment, alerting someone with hearing loss, or, in my case, helping mitigate the symptoms of PTSD by performing tasks like providing tactile stimulation or interrupting night terrors.
ESAs, while valuable to many, don’t undergo the same rigorous training as service dogs and aren’t granted the same public access rights.
It’s important to recognize the difference to ensure the rights of people with disabilities and their service dogs are respected. Thanks for engaging in this discussion!
@@RosieTheGreatDaneServiceDog I have been very active in the dog community and had a friend who trained dogs for guide dogs for the blind out east,but I also have a sister who has a very unruly GS and in order to move into her apartment applied for service dog status by simply going online. The dog has no special training and is almost out of control,it’s people like her that spoil it for true service dogs
Emotional support isn't considered an service animal except ones for ptsd. Those traumatic incidents are service animals.
Who does that fool think he is. Does that mean think the heavens owned up and told he was boss
So what about a person who uses a crutch?🐳
@@do3150 they better not do so in our town hall !!!!
@@RosieTheGreatDaneServiceDog what is your service dog trained to do? respectfully asking.
This shows the Town council are stupid. 😡🇺🇸😉
Can't understand a thing he's saying.
If they are a service animal they are suppose to have the service harness stating service dog or animal on it, now with that said if they do not have that harness its not a service animal and need to leave. With a harness indicating service animal you cannot ask if its a service animal or what service do they provide. DO NOT TOUCH SERVICE ANIMALS
Not necessarily. Not required
Service dogs do not require any harness or identification, according to the ADA.
Hey LEO, you can absolutely question the legitimacy of a service dog...
1) Is this animal a service animal?
2) What tasks is the animal trained to do to assist you with your disability?
-Service dog handler
According to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), a business or public entity may only ask two specific questions regarding a service dog when it is not obvious what service the dog provides
1. Is the dog a service animal required because of a disability?
2. What work or task has the dog been trained to perform?
However, if it is clear that the dog is a service animal (for instance, if the dog is wearing a service dog vest or performing an obvious task like guiding a person who is visually impaired), it is inappropriate to ask these questions. The ADA prohibits unnecessary inquiries when the service animal's role is evident.
For further reference, see 28 C.F.R. § 35.136(f) of the ADA, which outlines the limitations on permissible questions about service animals.
Hey wacko. That's not what he was doing. He was belittling and demeaning the service dog handler. He didn't ask those questions.
Condescending Pigs. Listen to them. They wanted to arrest him. That government worker should be charged
This man needs to go. Emotional support. You are so ignorant. How are you such an expert.
There are times when people DO play up their disability as an excuse for bad behaviour. They don’t have the exclusive right to insult others and then cry boo-hoo if they’re insulted in return.
YES Rich Chaffee is an ignorant nasty bully. Chaffee has probably been a BULLY for a long long time. That Chaffee later proceeded to malign the guy with the service dog (when the guy with the service done was NOT present) - and trying to JUSTIFY his words maligning Chris to others is clear evidence that Rich Chaffee is trying to shore up his persona as the "nice guy" when Rich Chaffee is NOT a nice guy.
Those who "agree" with Chaffee are just currying favour with Chaffee - this is what weak scarred people do to curry favour with the BULLY so they can demonstrate that they are NO THREAT to the nasty bully.
This is how BULLIES CEMENT their POWER moves.
And YES training and consultation about HOW a service dog operates and WHY service dogs are of great value to the people who need a service dog IS urgently needed in this TOXIC workplace.
A veteran in a small town in North Carolina had a service dog provided by the VA. Two local buffoon cops approached him one day demanding his ID. He suffers from PTSD and the cops actions set his PTSD off. His service dog emitted a low growl, and one officer took out his tasser and shot the dog. It ran off, and a friend found the but it had died. The VA provided a new service dog, but in small town way, nothing was done to the buffoons. I am guessing if the city council provided funds to the police department for training on how to interact with persons with disabilities this leader would have another fit
Rosie is a sweetheart. So well behaved.💕
How did this silliness get in my YT feed?
Ah, the mysteries of the RUclips algorithm! It has a mind of its own, kind of like a cat-showing you things you didn’t ask for but secretly might enjoy. 😉 Stick around, though-this "silliness" might grow on you! 🐕🦺
Too many people think of their little doggie as a child and totally ignore signs in many stores not place them in a cart. Those who really need one are getting a bad rap.
A woman brought in a "service dog" into the grocery store, it was wearing a vest. Then it started barking at other customers. Yeah, a service dog.
He doesn’t need to explain, it’s none of his business
Quit fighting, girls.
I'd like to commend you on your restraint. Sincerely, I know how hard it can be to not answer a comment like that physically.
3:21 Did he really say that? Karma is a bitch when it hits hard.
Most people with "service dogs" are just scammers that want to take their pet everywhere they go. If you're going to freak out because you can't have your pet with you at Target, go get some real help.
The toen leader is an #####. Put him in jail!!!
What a nervous LEO. Hand rubbing and finger cracking. Maybe he should see someone about that. If he was conversing with me and doing that I would ask him to stop. Is he a rooky cop?
Wouldn't it be interesting if Rich were to acquire some condition that requires him to need a service dog - see what it's like to not be believed and constantly questioned. The smug look and "I didn't do anything" attitude would soon disappear! Karma is a bi*** my friend.
What right do you have to saysomeone shouldn't have a service dog. This jerk should lose his job. I had a Great Dane as a service dog. She was with me 14 yrs. Miss her every day..
What a dick! Does he make everyone else leave their wheelchairs, eyeglasses, hearing aids, etc at the door?!
In some states like mine service dogs have to be certified. A lot of people carry little dogs around claiming they are “anxiety dogs” and they aren’t. Some people do use dogs as a excuse.
@@jamescarpenter7161 Actually, under federal law, service dogs are not required to be certified in any state, including yours. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) does not require certification for service dogs. They only need to be trained to perform specific tasks that assist a person with a disability. Any requirement for certification or registration is often a misunderstanding or misinformation at the state or local level.
Regarding 'anxiety dogs,' it's important to differentiate between emotional support animals (ESAs) and service dogs. Emotional support animals provide comfort by their presence but are not trained to perform specific tasks, so they don’t have the same legal protections as service dogs. Service dogs, however, are trained to do specific tasks that directly mitigate a disability. For example, a service dog trained to help someone with PTSD might perform tasks like waking them from night terrors, providing grounding during flashbacks, or guiding them to a safe space during an anxiety attack.
While there may be misuse by some people, it's essential to understand that for individuals with disabilities, service dogs are a lifeline, not a 'crutch.' These dogs enable people to live more independently by performing tasks they cannot do on their own.
For more information, you can refer to the official ADA guidelines on service animals
ADA Service Animal Guidance
www.ada.gov/resources/service-animals/
You can get a pet certified as an emotional support dog. And it can go with you anywhere.
@@kathy2929 this is untrue ESA do not have access rights. Only service dogs do
Actually, no states in the U.S. require service dogs to be certified. Under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), service dogs are not required to be certified or registered. The ADA defines a service dog as a dog that has been individually trained to perform specific tasks for a person with a disability. These tasks must be directly related to the handler’s disability. While it’s true that some people may falsely claim their pets as service animals, it’s important to remember that legitimate service dogs provide critical assistance to their handlers, and asking for certification or proof of training is not allowed under the ADA.
Emotional support animals (often incorrectly referred to as 'anxiety dogs') are not considered service animals under the ADA, as they do not perform specific tasks related to a disability. However, emotional support animals have protections under other laws in certain contexts, like housing. Misunderstanding these differences can lead to confusion about the legal rights of service dog handlers.
You're a liar no where in the the United States is it required for a service dog to be registered. There is no such thing as a registry!
Are service Dogs not registered? It would be a lot easier to clear all this up if they could just check the register.
What language are they trying to use?
The comments from Rich were uncalled for from an entitled politician A-hole, what's new
Everyone has a right to an opinion.wrong,right,shitty. Ignorant. Crude rude or obscene. Doesn't matter. First amendment right. Now,to threaten someone,over insult. That is a crime. I have to answer to this problem. Watch what you say. Try not to air your opinion unsolicited. Don't react to words. We all learned,at a young age," sticks,and stones can break your bones,but words can never hurt you. Unless you let them. Holy cow,is this where we have come. Pathetic.
The towns leader should obviously keep his opinions to himself, as he’s a representative of the town and we all know opinions are like a-holes, everyone has one! The police are correct that he was provoked by being told having a “service dog” as a crutch! Rich is a problem for the town and likely will not be getting reelected.
Chaffee is the elected Assessor. He is in that position till 2025. This should go to ADA.gov, the local news stations and paper. This citizens need to know what kind of person he is before the next election. Vote Chaffe out!
File a complaint ADA.gov and send this video. They will investigate and take care of this despicable human being.
*ACCORDING TO THE ADA*
_When it is not obvious what service an animal provides, only limited inquiries are allowed. Staff may ask two questions: (1) is the dog a service animal required because of a disability, and (2) what work or task has the dog been trained to perform._
*ADA.gov*
*U.S. Department of Justice*
*Civil Rights Division*