Bfdia 1 fails at even being a season premiere, because it fails to even introduce us to the newcomers, like Nickel and Yellow Face don't even have lines Edit: I realized YF had 1 line, but it didn't really give us any insight for his character
I feel like Donut was just put into situations that made him angry, like Pencil telling him to deal with the unfair teams caused him to get violent and in BFDIA 2 he was angry because he probably knew he was going to be eliminated, being up against two veterans paired with his knowledge of voting
Plus, he may have just still been bitter about the whole event, on top of everything you said, and Coiny just, being Coiny probably wasn't helping matters.
32:17 ha! Take that Giatsnowball! Also I think one of the writers said that announcer didn’t interact with bfdia after ep 6 so he just considered it as cancelled to him
as someone who is arguably good at platformer games, (i beat all of hollow knight and celeste, but with 2 dashes on farewell), i played through all of 5b and the levels could really be better made. a lot of them rely on weird tricks like this one level where you need to jumo as book holding match then making her throw match while she falls and switch really fast for match to hold book to not fall in a hole in the span of a second, with a lot of the levels having weirdly placed spikes and stuff like that, and a lot of the levels took really long to figure out, but the game is stull fun, especially with the gimmicks it has of different characters having different aspects like weight, height, speed and especially the recovery center, in a lot of levels it's really fun to figure out where to put each side of the hprc to know when to do what. but the ending with the "i'm sorry" level was really frustrating considering i, and most people at the game's release, not knowing it was unfinished, especially with the menu displaying the levels as if they were all complete, so there should be at least a text box in the starting screen saying like "yo the game isnt complete btw sorry lmao" or something like that
I disagree with you on BFDIA 6 not feeling creepy or unsettling I think the location of a entire gigantic abandoned city is a bit uncanny and eerie, while the ENTIRE evil hotel scene was creepy on why it was even built and how they were trapped in such a closed place with a murderer. And finally the ending of Woah Bunch being trapped in a loop and not being able to asleep all night even if they wanted too just feels unsettling to me. Most of the challenge creepy factor also takes place at night. Anywho i just think BFDIA 6 still has the creepy early bfdi vibes But yeah 7, 8 and 9 definitely lost that creepy factor 6 still had.
As soon as you talked about how WOAH Bunch couldn’t sleep for months because of how Evil Leafy is constantly after them on the same platform actually makes it feel horrifying
Honestly, this video was extremely entertaining. I enjoyed it a lot, as it went into a lot of depth into BFDIA, plus I loved how you went into detail about why certain episodes are worse than others. And while yes, I do think bringing back BFDIA was a mistake (other than BFDIA 6), it's okay. Great video, can't wait to see your thoughts on BFB!
Does “Degrasssifan” even still watch BFDI? I would love to see their reaction seeing gelatin get so far in BFB, and the rest of the season he joined in
I don’t mind Evil Leafy being incapacitated all the time, as while I do think she’s a good villain, I feel having her appear all the time could make episodes feel repetitive and would degrade Evil Leafy to a joke much like other horror icons.
I think we forget that Evil Leafy was also planned to be a contestant. It’s not like she’s some demi-god or a powerful spirit. She has powers and abilities that she utilizes to be threatening. Much like how other contestants later on have abilities like Lightning or Black Hole. And also Puffball. So I don’t think her dying in BFDIA 5c was bad for the episode since we know she can be killed by being clever or by sheer luck. I think Evil Leafy should just be left alone. Only include her when it’s exploring the lore of Yoyle City.
When you got to the mirror part in BFDIA 6, I thought the mirror was Evil Leafy's personal recovery center, or summoning place because the "mirror staring" TB said seems to have token inspiration from Bloody Mary.
Okay, a lot of your points are valid on a lot of the episodes, my only gripes are with BFDIA 8 and 9. Before my defending of these two episodes, could you believe it, there are more flaws to BFDIA 8 that you didn’t mention, like how the other teams got to the Eiffel tower as well or how both Ruby AND Pencil jumped right in front of the car, killing themselves. BFDIA 8 is still the worst out of the new episodes, but in my eyes, it’s not a 3/10. 1. In BFDIA 9, PB Speaker Box said she *ordered it last episode,* so the French recovery center was completely new, so no plotholes here, still doesn’t explain why FreeSmart went all the way back to Goiky just for the Club of Awesomeness. 2. You mentioned the challenge being fun, the elimination, and how FreeSmart won being good, but there are other positives. The chaotic nature of the challenge in general was actually one of the best challenges imo, though the execution of the losing team was just awful as mentioned. The ending was funny, Fries just randomly being in the Yoyle Forest again just makes it better lol. 3. The Eiffel Tower being destroyed will probably make the cast go back to Yoyle City for sure since it was the only relevant thing in Goiky, so it wouldn’t make sense to stay in Goiky, especially with no recovery center again. Boom! Both main problems solved. (Hopefully, anyway…) The deteriorating of the show’s uniqueness just doesn’t feel right. Lastly, yeah, FreeSmart not caring that much about the Club of Awesomeness was definitely a con. 4. The positives outweigh the negatives, you could be overthinking about the show turning into a season 1 copy. The elimination was satisfying to watch, the challenge was very good all around, the references were amazing, and the ending was alright. Almost the whole episode was good honestly, but that’s just my take on it. If I were to rate them, I’d go: BFDIA 8: 5/10, yeah, there are so many flaws, but the challenge and the elimination themselves are what save it. BFDIA 9: 8/10, the challenge was amazing, loved the references, and only a couple minor flaws.
Apoy in bfdia 9 puffball speaker box said she ordered the RECOVERY center once she was back alive, so I don't think pencil would have known that the recovery center was there
Considering the recovery center Puffball Speaker Box ordered was dissolved, and there are no other recovery centers, I assume they'll all go back to Yoyleland in BFDIA 10. And to keep the continuity of the series, maybe Gelatin will go back to working at his steakhouse before Puffball Speaker Box finishes reading the votes so that he's technically never eliminated.
I really wish the BFDIA cast stayed in Yoyle City for the whole season, it’s a more interesting location and it’s just more pleasing to look at than the neon green grasslands.
I think the timestamp was 30:53 the one you were looking for? But in any case, yeah there was that challenge as well, and turns out that the team was very enjoyable in that episode too! So it truly is a winning formula to have a team not know what the challenge is!!
In BFDIA 10 they will go back to yoyle city because: 1- Freesmart's reason to return to goiky, the cubhouse of awesomeness, is gone and the'll probably want to search a substitute 2- The temporary french recovery center is also gone and the original is still glued to yoyle city and we know it's not going anywhere 3- Yoyleland was never completely abandonned because it still appeared in episodes 8 and 9 in a way that feels like it's still important
Coming back to this to say that I'm really disapointed about BFDIA10 and they literally escaped Yoyleland again but for absolutely no reason. At this point, maybe they don't actually use Yoyleland until IDFB, hell they may not even use Yoyleland after IDFB 2 if this trend continues. Cary's writing got very bad
I think leaving Yoyleland (and, by extension, Yoyle City) exclusively to IDFB isn’t a bad idea, I mean if IDFB doesn’t continue then ot’s up to speculation but it’s better than having Yoyleland spoiled to us in a season that doesn’t even need to spoil it
34:40 I don't really think this is a plot hole since Pin didn't even let Spongy talk about it in BFDIA 5, she just told him to zip it 38:48 I'm guessing they'll go back to Yoyle city in either BFDIA 10 or 11 since there are no recovery centers left in Goiky
There’s a plot hole in BFDIA 9 that no one has seemed to mention yet, the way the words are arranged on the metal box that purple face is trapped in are different than in BFB, in BFB it was arranged (left to right) don’t purple open inside, but in BFDIA it’s arranged (left to right) don’t open purple inside, it dosen’t really matter that much but I still felt like bringing it up
And the worst thing about going back to Goiky in bfdia 8: YOU COULD HAVE DONE THIS EXACT CHALLENGE ON THE YOYLE NEEDY WTH?? Also, instead of bringing back Gelatins steakhouse for the 10,000th time to fill some random role in the plot, how about we explore another buisness or an actual shadehouse? I wonder where it would be fitting and perfect to bring in a new building or store... YOYLELAND?!!?!?!?!?!??!!?!?1 BFDIA 8 was entertaining but the things that happen in it are just so random and felt like a first draft
THANK YOU APOY FOR THE DONUT EXPLANATION Btw it has been said that Donut said "COINY! This isnt funny" is because he thought Coiny said " We'll Lose a Whole Bunch!"
I feel like modern bfdia misunderstands what BFDIA really was. Sure, it was nonsensical and goofy at times, but it also had dark and suspenseful moments. Nowadays it lacks more dark storytelling and is rather just more unoriginal and silly, brushing aside Evil Leafy, Yoyle City..everything cool it had going for it. And I agree with you, I would’ve been fine with BFDIA ending at 5e. With IDFB existing and basically confirming the vote results, there was no real point to continue it. I feel like IDFB would’ve made more sense to bring back.
44:50 if you pay attention to nickels face, when he said the ty in non-existy his eyes shrink in a way where he looks like I.i. nickel. I don't know if it was intentional though.
@@Navitheguy one of nickels face expressions looks like it's in the I.I.I. style, probably because of the smaller eyes and different mouth. Also idk why but the time stamp I left is now 1 minute ahead, it might of been a mistake by me but idk.
I have a theory about bfdia, specifically that they are going to yoyleland in like a couple episodes, but puffball speaker box wants to stay because she shares a material possession quirk similar to puffball and her prizes. As well as this, flower is somehow in Idfb meaning that she is freed from the freeze juice and therefore would follow them alongside leafy in bfdia
I do not know why, but despite it being unfair, I just can’t help but also love how W.O.A.H Bunch lost. It’s definitely stupid how they go UFE, but it was also honestly hilarious.
I miss the old dialogue and the pacing of the show. The problem with the modern episodes is the breakneck pacing, despite being way longer than the first 5 episodes, the new episodes somehow find a way to go faster, and they are mostly filler. BFDIA episodes should stay around 15 minutes long. My other issue is that the characters have been changed to be more like their modern selves, the worst example of this being Ruby. Not to mention the dialog and humor isn't the same as it used to be. I was excited for BFDIA to come back, and I still like what we got, but I'm disappointed because even though it's the same characters and location, it just doesn't feel like bfdia.
YES! SOMEONE WHO SHARES SIMILAR OPINION ON THE NEW BFDIA EPISODES AS ME! IT FELT NICE THEY TRIED TO REVIVE THE SEASON BUT THE NEW EPISODES JUST DON’T HAVE THAT CHARM LIKE THE OLDER ONES!
@@wix-1-3dgcjt6 True, I think it’s BFDIA 2 Get Digging that has the most filler with Puffball flying and Fries making other contestants dig. But I like the writing in BFDIA 4 and 5 more than the current episodes. Honestly, those two episodes carry old BFDIA.
why did you hold "teams doing stuff instead of being absent/doing nothing for the rest of the episode" for two separate episodes???? like it's fine to want characters to be more "logical" but imagine if the episodes just ended there. it would be a complete anticlimax and would be boring. its like holding preventing death against BH as a character because if he didn't, then DPA would literally never lose. it's suspending a bit of belief so that things don't become insanely predictable. plus if they did that, you would have to answer why they just don't keep on killing the other teams before doing the challenge every single time because nothing's stopping them
10:00 honestly the way they brought back Bubble in BFDIA 9 was a lot better handled than how they did it in BFDIA 3 if they brought her back that way in a surprising matter it would’ve honestly been extremely heartwarming too see. (I mean a person who we thought was going to be long dead comes back in an unexpected way would be so cool!)
We Rocky fans won’t put up with this unnecessary hate! 😤 Jokes aside. I agree with most of your takes on all the episodes especially BFDIA 5 being the best episode of the season. Somethings I would correct would be the chase scene in BFDIA 1 does line up with the end of BFDI. Although maybe not smoothly, it is presumed and easy to tell that everyone is chasing Leafy for stealing Dream Island. Now that I’ve put more thought into it, BFDIA 1 is pretty weak for being an intro to a new season. But I feel as if BFDIA 1 is more of a transition episode than an introduction because of how season 2 started. Anyways, I am biased towards Rocky switching teams in BFDIA 6. It seemed like another way to try to get a contestant out of the show. Rocky’s personality just doesn’t match that type of decision. Not to mention the fact that Golf Ball and Tennis Ball are his friends. Fries should’ve been the one to switch teams as he had many quarrels with GB and TB. And now that Puffball was eliminated, I feel he has no reason to stay. NEWAYS! I’m not very fond of the newer episodes. Stuff like the voice changes are just minor differences and although it’s a slight bother, it’s too petty to make it a real critique. This is where I HEAVILY agree with you! I love how BFDIA 5 explores the lore of these places as well as these character! And this is something I wish the newer episodes would’ve done. To me, they feel too goofy, and they should all be like BFDIA 5a and 5e. Time for character development, funny moments, contestants doing the challenge, characters interacting with each other , and lore droppings. Nice video!
Well to answer the plotline question: Annoucer secretly hosted during BFDIA 1 - 5, which is why in BFDIA 6 we see him talking to FSB. He needed him to host since he was gonna go away for a while, Announcer thought BFDIA was cancelled due to the budget being low.
I think the reason why they made the WTF, and not the TLC, LOL, or any other chamber, because if they didn't, it would technically ruin the continuity of IDFB, with Firey, Rocky and Yellow face not being in the TLC/LOL, also TV taking the key, also keeps the continuity of the contestants having to use the wall teleporter through the TLC/LOL in IDFB to save a failed debuter or eliminated contestant.
33:03 Rocky is shown to be durable enough to survive stuff like this. The flower posters, though… Also the whole “removing Eiffel Tower” thing was because it isn’t in BFB.
10:19 Something noteworthy is the splitting into different sides part since from what ive seen there is three sides between them Side 1:Pencil and Match Side 2:Bubble and Ruby Side 3:Book and Ice cube
I like to imagine that at the finale of the season theyre gonna somehow revert everything after bfdia 5, it would be disappointing but would make the most sense story wise since no one would remember it
The fact that this is the last season where Evil Leafy shows up sucks, considering that actually having a non contestant acting as a villain is a pretty interesting concept 😭
Matpat mode on:I feel like donut got that character development because they try to escape the tlc/lol And has them motivate the others so they all escape but then it makes another bfdia challenge to put them back in the tlc/lol and some of them get into golfall’s underground factory and tinker around with machines which is how the recommended characters got the bfb designs
39:33 didnt pbsb literally say she recovered WOAH Bunch with the HPRC BIF BOTET a few scenes later and explained that Fries and TB got there with the car?
33:07 Announcer canonically has zero idea that BFDIA 6+ exists Spongy probably forgot when he said "I've been eliminated FOUR times!" (or he ends up winning lol)
stuff like the Eiffel tower being removed and the new eliminated contestant place HAD to happen to match up with idfb so it’s certain they’ll move back to yoyle land
I don't usually comment on videos but it's odd how Ice Cube is in the Goiky Canal when in TPOT 5 she literally died in the water. This was the timestamp by the way: 36:46
I think its cool the evil leafy keeps Getting frozen and Somehow coming back It gives thr idea that no Matter many times rid Of her She will Always rise again
i dont understand why gelatin didnt kill gb and then recovered him with the laser in bfdia 9, i mean he was kinda stupid in the episode so that could be the reason why but still it would be nice to see golf ball actually do something for the first time since bfdia 7
Spoilers for BFB I haven’t seen the voting results yet(don’t spoil them), but I think that the people are most likely to eliminate gelatine, for doing very very stupid stuff & sabotaging WOAH bunch in BFDIA 8. This would normally be fine, but then there’s the infamous scene from BFB 29, where the announcer labels gelatine as “the 1 contestant that was never eliminated.” But if he’s gone, that tears a massive hole in the canon, it’s doomed.
characters with the BIGGEST personality changes from BFDIA 5e to BFDIA 6 (no particular order): Needle, Bomby, Ice Cube, Nickel, Gelatin (in my opinion)
if you like object shows with permanent deaths youd probably like obs, since one of the hosts had the ability to recover contestants and lost it, with the characters being more worried about dying, and especially getting hurt, with one of my favorite things about the show being the permanent redesigns they get once they're injured or need to do so for a challenge (like oreo, house, cup and coal)
@@Princesspeachfan456 obsolete battle show it was made by sacri she has a bunch of cool shows like burner the 5 secondly object show and battle for grandma
I played it too. Honestly, it felt like it was getting easier. I was having so much trouble in the early stages. I got all win tokens except level 50 and 53.
I actually think they were trying to save GB, since this is VTE, not giving GB much screentime would prob make her receive less votes and... SPOILERS! Look at Gelatin, he got LOTS of screentime this episode, but since he was annoying, he got the boot, this could've easily been GB if she gotten lots of screentime this ep.
![Basketball: From Follower To Leader [BFB Character Analysis]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/epFzlEwQa8s/mqdefault.jpg)
![Basketball: From Follower To Leader [BFB Character Analysis]](/img/tr.png)
What's your favorite BFDIA episode, and why?
Discuss it here in the comments!
BFDIA 9 honestly the whole concept of guessing what another character is doing is a great challenge and should’ve been done earlier ngl
BFDIA 6, no doubt. Pretty much perfect from start to finish.
BFDIA 6, the hype was unreal
BFDIA 9 because they did Tennis Ball Perfectly.
Bfdia 3 I don’t why It’s something about inspector nightmare trilogy that I like
Bfdia 1 fails at even being a season premiere, because it fails to even introduce us to the newcomers, like Nickel and Yellow Face don't even have lines
Edit: I realized YF had 1 line, but it didn't really give us any insight for his character
i don’t think EVERY new character needed a line in the season premiere, as sometimes it’d just feel like an obligation
They do though, if you have new characters and old ones they all need lines, every character needs at least a line per episode!@@yololthepikminenjoyer
Yellow face had a line
Kinda felt like a short episode with not much going on other than the chase scene
even lollipop had lines
the og bfdia (ep 1-5) is so iconic and charming, for some reason i feel more nostalgia towards it than bfdi
Same here, I stayed up all night watching bfdia 1-5 and my god it felt so good
I agree with both of you. Need we say more?
same
I feel like Donut was just put into situations that made him angry, like Pencil telling him to deal with the unfair teams caused him to get violent and in BFDIA 2 he was angry because he probably knew he was going to be eliminated, being up against two veterans paired with his knowledge of voting
Plus, he may have just still been bitter about the whole event, on top of everything you said, and Coiny just, being Coiny probably wasn't helping matters.
FINALLY SOMEONE KNOWS
32:17 ha! Take that Giatsnowball! Also I think one of the writers said that announcer didn’t interact with bfdia after ep 6 so he just considered it as cancelled to him
as someone who is arguably good at platformer games, (i beat all of hollow knight and celeste, but with 2 dashes on farewell), i played through all of 5b and the levels could really be better made. a lot of them rely on weird tricks like this one level where you need to jumo as book holding match then making her throw match while she falls and switch really fast for match to hold book to not fall in a hole in the span of a second, with a lot of the levels having weirdly placed spikes and stuff like that, and a lot of the levels took really long to figure out, but the game is stull fun, especially with the gimmicks it has of different characters having different aspects like weight, height, speed and especially the recovery center, in a lot of levels it's really fun to figure out where to put each side of the hprc to know when to do what. but the ending with the "i'm sorry" level was really frustrating considering i, and most people at the game's release, not knowing it was unfinished, especially with the menu displaying the levels as if they were all complete, so there should be at least a text box in the starting screen saying like "yo the game isnt complete btw sorry lmao" or something like that
I disagree with you on BFDIA 6 not feeling creepy or unsettling
I think the location of a entire gigantic abandoned city is a bit uncanny and eerie, while the ENTIRE evil hotel scene was creepy on why it was even built and how they were trapped in such a closed place with a murderer.
And finally the ending of Woah Bunch being trapped in a loop and not being able to asleep all night even if they wanted too just feels unsettling to me.
Most of the challenge creepy factor also takes place at night.
Anywho i just think BFDIA 6 still has the creepy early bfdi vibes
But yeah 7, 8 and 9 definitely lost that creepy factor 6 still had.
As soon as you talked about how WOAH Bunch couldn’t sleep for months because of how Evil Leafy is constantly after them on the same platform actually makes it feel horrifying
bfdia6 felt like they were actually trying to make bfdia, but after that they went with the 'we must make it casual season!!!' and made it another bfb
Well Evil Leafy will 101% return IDFB is a reason
Looking amazing. One of the best videos by far. Great job, APOY.
Honestly, this video was extremely entertaining. I enjoyed it a lot, as it went into a lot of depth into BFDIA, plus I loved how you went into detail about why certain episodes are worse than others.
And while yes, I do think bringing back BFDIA was a mistake (other than BFDIA 6), it's okay.
Great video, can't wait to see your thoughts on BFB!
Does “Degrasssifan” even still watch BFDI? I would love to see their reaction seeing gelatin get so far in BFB, and the rest of the season he joined in
Sadly he doesn’t. I don’t think he even reacted to Gelatin being in the final 2 of BFB 😭
I'm assuming they're Canadian or something because Degrassi is a Canadian sitcom
The fact that the voting from BFDIA 1 is more intresting than the episode XD
I don’t mind Evil Leafy being incapacitated all the time, as while I do think she’s a good villain, I feel having her appear all the time could make episodes feel repetitive and would degrade Evil Leafy to a joke much like other horror icons.
I think we forget that Evil Leafy was also planned to be a contestant. It’s not like she’s some demi-god or a powerful spirit. She has powers and abilities that she utilizes to be threatening. Much like how other contestants later on have abilities like Lightning or Black Hole. And also Puffball. So I don’t think her dying in BFDIA 5c was bad for the episode since we know she can be killed by being clever or by sheer luck. I think Evil Leafy should just be left alone. Only include her when it’s exploring the lore of Yoyle City.
When you got to the mirror part in BFDIA 6, I thought the mirror was Evil Leafy's personal recovery center, or summoning place because the "mirror staring" TB said seems to have token inspiration from Bloody Mary.
30:55 just not in tpot 9, also didn’t know about the challenge.
bfdia seven released before TPOT nine, so his comment is still valid as it hasn’t happened yet at that point.
@@puppies3330 he also stated he would like to see the idea again in tpot, which already happened…
11:18 Can always count on my man Zee. Thanks, Zee!
apoy looks like he's one apoy x eggy joke from going postal in the thumbnail
lol
Evil Leafy carrying the entirety of Bfdia on her back:
The only thing she carries on her back is first
hell parts:
@@Sloppster8763lol
nah
im only just realizing that Tennis Ball running in the comp is a reference to my favorite OSC trend as a kid - it burns.
holy moly my pose made into this video!! holy sh this was so epic, good job apoy!!!
Very nice, I loved listening to this and watching sometimes during studying.
Okay, a lot of your points are valid on a lot of the episodes, my only gripes are with BFDIA 8 and 9.
Before my defending of these two episodes, could you believe it, there are more flaws to BFDIA 8 that you didn’t mention, like how the other teams got to the Eiffel tower as well or how both Ruby AND Pencil jumped right in front of the car, killing themselves. BFDIA 8 is still the worst out of the new episodes, but in my eyes, it’s not a 3/10.
1. In BFDIA 9, PB Speaker Box said she *ordered it last episode,* so the French recovery center was completely new, so no plotholes here, still doesn’t explain why FreeSmart went all the way back to Goiky just for the Club of Awesomeness.
2. You mentioned the challenge being fun, the elimination, and how FreeSmart won being good, but there are other positives. The chaotic nature of the challenge in general was actually one of the best challenges imo, though the execution of the losing team was just awful as mentioned. The ending was funny, Fries just randomly being in the Yoyle Forest again just makes it better lol.
3. The Eiffel Tower being destroyed will probably make the cast go back to Yoyle City for sure since it was the only relevant thing in Goiky, so it wouldn’t make sense to stay in Goiky, especially with no recovery center again. Boom! Both main problems solved. (Hopefully, anyway…) The deteriorating of the show’s uniqueness just doesn’t feel right. Lastly, yeah, FreeSmart not caring that much about the Club of Awesomeness was definitely a con.
4. The positives outweigh the negatives, you could be overthinking about the show turning into a season 1 copy. The elimination was satisfying to watch, the challenge was very good all around, the references were amazing, and the ending was alright. Almost the whole episode was good honestly, but that’s just my take on it.
If I were to rate them, I’d go:
BFDIA 8: 5/10, yeah, there are so many flaws, but the challenge and the elimination themselves are what save it.
BFDIA 9: 8/10, the challenge was amazing, loved the references, and only a couple minor flaws.
Apoy in bfdia 9 puffball speaker box said she ordered the RECOVERY center once she was back alive, so I don't think pencil would have known that the recovery center was there
Finally, at least someone addressed it.
Considering the recovery center Puffball Speaker Box ordered was dissolved, and there are no other recovery centers, I assume they'll all go back to Yoyleland in BFDIA 10. And to keep the continuity of the series, maybe Gelatin will go back to working at his steakhouse before Puffball Speaker Box finishes reading the votes so that he's technically never eliminated.
I really wish the BFDIA cast stayed in Yoyle City for the whole season, it’s a more interesting location and it’s just more pleasing to look at than the neon green grasslands.
the eiffel tower recover center seems to be gone so i think they'll go back
37:05 to try and explain this, they died lots of times in the Goiky Canal, so they probably adapted to surviving underwater longer or something.
It has never worked like that EVER. Bubble defeats this whole concept.
30:53 they did do this concept, in TPOT 9 where Just Not didn’t know what the challenge was and ended up for elimination because of Pillow
I think the timestamp was 30:53 the one you were looking for?
But in any case, yeah there was that challenge as well, and turns out that the team was very enjoyable in that episode too!
So it truly is a winning formula to have a team not know what the challenge is!!
@@APOYOSChi at 3:11 what was the song used?
@@BlueKoraidonoh that’s a remix of never be alone
@@APOYOSC which remix(who created it)
yeah that’s the timestamp I was trying to give for some reason it bugged out, anyway yeah that episode was really good
In BFDIA 10 they will go back to yoyle city because:
1- Freesmart's reason to return to goiky, the cubhouse of awesomeness, is gone and the'll probably want to search a substitute
2- The temporary french recovery center is also gone and the original is still glued to yoyle city and we know it's not going anywhere
3- Yoyleland was never completely abandonned because it still appeared in episodes 8 and 9 in a way that feels like it's still important
4- IDFB starting in Yoyleland, so that means BFDIA finale will be 100% already in yoyle land
You're assuming that with no evidence
Assume deez nuts
Coming back to this to say that I'm really disapointed about BFDIA10 and they literally escaped Yoyleland again but for absolutely no reason. At this point, maybe they don't actually use Yoyleland until IDFB, hell they may not even use Yoyleland after IDFB 2 if this trend continues. Cary's writing got very bad
I think leaving Yoyleland (and, by extension, Yoyle City) exclusively to IDFB isn’t a bad idea, I mean if IDFB doesn’t continue then ot’s up to speculation but it’s better than having Yoyleland spoiled to us in a season that doesn’t even need to spoil it
34:40 I don't really think this is a plot hole since Pin didn't even let Spongy talk about it in BFDIA 5, she just told him to zip it
38:48 I'm guessing they'll go back to Yoyle city in either BFDIA 10 or 11 since there are no recovery centers left in Goiky
spoilers! no. they gonna go to goiky completely, and whenever someone dies, they go to yoyle land to recover that person.
@@perkelefan290then why not just stay in Yoyle, saves the inconvenience of having to drive
There’s a plot hole in BFDIA 9 that no one has seemed to mention yet, the way the words are arranged on the metal box that purple face is trapped in are different than in BFB, in BFB it was arranged (left to right) don’t purple open inside, but in BFDIA it’s arranged (left to right) don’t open purple inside, it dosen’t really matter that much but I still felt like bringing it up
In bfb 23, it said "don't open purple inside"
@@Payt0nR that’s up to down
@@WoodpekazYT I mean, it was already a plot hole with the box in bfb, so bfdia 9 wasn't the first to make the plot hole
I noticed that too when I first watched it
24:37 Why does it look like Puffball got offended when you talked about how she might get a character analysis video?💀
Imagine evil leafy joined Bfdia and won it.
The ending of 5a is one of my favourite moments from the entirety of BFDI.
Let's go APOY! We basically share the same opinions on 5e! Completely agree that Yoyle city is amazing, and it really should be used more often.
And the worst thing about going back to Goiky in bfdia 8:
YOU COULD HAVE DONE THIS EXACT CHALLENGE ON THE YOYLE NEEDY WTH??
Also, instead of bringing back Gelatins steakhouse for the 10,000th time to fill some random role in the plot, how about we explore another buisness or an actual shadehouse? I wonder where it would be fitting and perfect to bring in a new building or store... YOYLELAND?!!?!?!?!?!??!!?!?1
BFDIA 8 was entertaining but the things that happen in it are just so random and felt like a first draft
I feel like bfdia was meant to be more dark. With evil leafy and the random deaths.
Not horrifying, but slightly more dark
THANK YOU APOY FOR THE DONUT EXPLANATION
Btw it has been said that Donut said "COINY! This isnt funny" is because he thought Coiny said " We'll Lose a Whole Bunch!"
I feel like modern bfdia misunderstands what BFDIA really was. Sure, it was nonsensical and goofy at times, but it also had dark and suspenseful moments. Nowadays it lacks more dark storytelling and is rather just more unoriginal and silly, brushing aside Evil Leafy, Yoyle City..everything cool it had going for it.
And I agree with you, I would’ve been fine with BFDIA ending at 5e. With IDFB existing and basically confirming the vote results, there was no real point to continue it. I feel like IDFB would’ve made more sense to bring back.
44:50 if you pay attention to nickels face, when he said the ty in non-existy his eyes shrink in a way where he looks like I.i. nickel. I don't know if it was intentional though.
I thought the same
That's what I thought
Wdym
@@Navitheguy one of nickels face expressions looks like it's in the I.I.I. style, probably because of the smaller eyes and different mouth.
Also idk why but the time stamp I left is now 1 minute ahead, it might of been a mistake by me but idk.
I love these types of videos, please do this with BFB
I have a theory about bfdia, specifically that they are going to yoyleland in like a couple episodes, but puffball speaker box wants to stay because she shares a material possession quirk similar to puffball and her prizes. As well as this, flower is somehow in Idfb meaning that she is freed from the freeze juice and therefore would follow them alongside leafy in bfdia
And just because she wasn't in the TLC.
She already got freed from the freeze juice in bfdia 5a
I do not know why, but despite it being unfair, I just can’t help but also love how W.O.A.H Bunch lost. It’s definitely stupid how they go UFE, but it was also honestly hilarious.
I miss the old dialogue and the pacing of the show. The problem with the modern episodes is the breakneck pacing, despite being way longer than the first 5 episodes, the new episodes somehow find a way to go faster, and they are mostly filler. BFDIA episodes should stay around 15 minutes long.
My other issue is that the characters have been changed to be more like their modern selves, the worst example of this being Ruby. Not to mention the dialog and humor isn't the same as it used to be.
I was excited for BFDIA to come back, and I still like what we got, but I'm disappointed because even though it's the same characters and location, it just doesn't feel like bfdia.
YES! SOMEONE WHO SHARES SIMILAR OPINION ON THE NEW BFDIA EPISODES AS ME! IT FELT NICE THEY TRIED TO REVIVE THE SEASON BUT THE NEW EPISODES JUST DON’T HAVE THAT CHARM LIKE THE OLDER ONES!
SAME!!!! THIS IS EXACTLY MY OPINION BRO!!!!
old bfidia has sheet ton of filler bruh
@@wix-1-3dgcjt6 True, I think it’s BFDIA 2 Get Digging that has the most filler with Puffball flying and Fries making other contestants dig. But I like the writing in BFDIA 4 and 5 more than the current episodes.
Honestly, those two episodes carry old BFDIA.
@@wix-1-3dgcjt6 30 minutes worth? No. Plus, that filler is iconic
why did you hold "teams doing stuff instead of being absent/doing nothing for the rest of the episode" for two separate episodes???? like it's fine to want characters to be more "logical" but imagine if the episodes just ended there. it would be a complete anticlimax and would be boring. its like holding preventing death against BH as a character because if he didn't, then DPA would literally never lose. it's suspending a bit of belief so that things don't become insanely predictable. plus if they did that, you would have to answer why they just don't keep on killing the other teams before doing the challenge every single time because nothing's stopping them
By the time this series is over he will have 200k and still be celebrating the 100k special
10:00 honestly the way they brought back Bubble in BFDIA 9 was a lot better handled than how they did it in BFDIA 3 if they brought her back that way in a surprising matter it would’ve honestly been extremely heartwarming too see. (I mean a person who we thought was going to be long dead comes back in an unexpected way would be so cool!)
We Rocky fans won’t put up with this unnecessary hate! 😤
Jokes aside. I agree with most of your takes on all the episodes especially BFDIA 5 being the best episode of the season. Somethings I would correct would be the chase scene in BFDIA 1 does line up with the end of BFDI. Although maybe not smoothly, it is presumed and easy to tell that everyone is chasing Leafy for stealing Dream Island. Now that I’ve put more thought into it, BFDIA 1 is pretty weak for being an intro to a new season. But I feel as if BFDIA 1 is more of a transition episode than an introduction because of how season 2 started. Anyways, I am biased towards Rocky switching teams in BFDIA 6. It seemed like another way to try to get a contestant out of the show. Rocky’s personality just doesn’t match that type of decision. Not to mention the fact that Golf Ball and Tennis Ball are his friends. Fries should’ve been the one to switch teams as he had many quarrels with GB and TB. And now that Puffball was eliminated, I feel he has no reason to stay. NEWAYS! I’m not very fond of the newer episodes. Stuff like the voice changes are just minor differences and although it’s a slight bother, it’s too petty to make it a real critique. This is where I HEAVILY agree with you! I love how BFDIA 5 explores the lore of these places as well as these character! And this is something I wish the newer episodes would’ve done. To me, they feel too goofy, and they should all be like BFDIA 5a and 5e. Time for character development, funny moments, contestants doing the challenge, characters interacting with each other , and lore droppings.
Nice video!
11:39 I immediately started laughing at that, It's hilarious!!!!
Hearing the music in the background brings back memorys
I need that Never Be Alone remix you used for the cast voting section 😭
52:21 The music here is "Hell's Greatest Dad" from Hazben Hotel
Well to answer the plotline question: Annoucer secretly hosted during BFDIA 1 - 5, which is why in BFDIA 6 we see him talking to FSB. He needed him to host since he was gonna go away for a while, Announcer thought BFDIA was cancelled due to the budget being low.
Wait what? Show me proof. Announcer should’ve left because of the other announcers and also because he is losing his attraction to Earth.
@@Potato-so6zr there’s an screenshot but I lost it.
I think the reason why they made the WTF, and not the TLC, LOL, or any other chamber, because if they didn't, it would technically ruin the continuity of IDFB, with Firey, Rocky and Yellow face not being in the TLC/LOL, also TV taking the key, also keeps the continuity of the contestants having to use the wall teleporter through the TLC/LOL in IDFB to save a failed debuter or eliminated contestant.
imagine someone's tryna sleep to this video, but then 43:21 appears
At this rate he's gonna finish the 100k special by 200k
Lol
Yup😊
Thank you apoy very based
(Idk what to say i havent watched yet i just wanted to add a comment to help lmao)
Im worried About BFDIA 10 since gelatin made their team lose and will cause a small plot hole in BFDIA
33:03 Rocky is shown to be durable enough to survive stuff like this. The flower posters, though…
Also the whole “removing Eiffel Tower” thing was because it isn’t in BFB.
the lore in bfdia 6 is so insane
10:04 fun fact: instead of TPOT, they were originally going to kill off all the contestants that were not in the final 14
It makes Me Question Why They Didn't Go Back To BFDIA When They Were Back on RUclips
If there ever is a bfdi qna if gelatin ever gets asked who his parents is and he responds "degrassssi fan" Im gonna choke on water
there was, but that question was not featured, sad
10:19 Something noteworthy is the splitting into different sides part since from what ive seen there is three sides between them
Side 1:Pencil and Match
Side 2:Bubble and Ruby
Side 3:Book and Ice cube
43:13, …
Aight…
Cool…
Didn't wanna sleep early tonight anyway
52:22 what's the song name that start here?
We got ourselves a freesmart/mystery 2.0!!!
you'd never see a video with this much depth and analysis from THAT guy 💀
I like to imagine that at the finale of the season theyre gonna somehow revert everything after bfdia 5, it would be disappointing but would make the most sense story wise since no one would remember it
30:56 was used in tpot 9 so they haven’t stopped that idea
The WTF had to be that way, so the contestants can escape and be on idfb.
"second weird episode"? what does that mean? does this confirmed that there will be a yoyle museum appearance in a really late BFDIA episode
The fact that this is the last season where Evil Leafy shows up sucks, considering that actually having a non contestant acting as a villain is a pretty interesting concept 😭
IDFB…
27:16 i mean, she *is* in a city she had never been to before
Matpat mode on:I feel like donut got that character development because they try to escape the tlc/lol And has them motivate the others so they all escape but then it makes another bfdia challenge to put them back in the tlc/lol and some of them get into golfall’s underground factory and tinker around with machines which is how the recommended characters got the bfb designs
APOY comparing Yellow Face to Purple Guy, the color he hates the most, is quite possibly the most ironic thing ever.
39:33 didnt pbsb literally say she recovered WOAH Bunch with the HPRC BIF BOTET a few scenes later and explained that Fries and TB got there with the car?
i like bfdia 8 as it was my introduction to bfdi but i love bfdia 11
33:07 Announcer canonically has zero idea that BFDIA 6+ exists
Spongy probably forgot when he said "I've been eliminated FOUR times!" (or he ends up winning lol)
it would be cool if he got hurt on the head or died so he didin't know about getting eliminated
holy shittt its finally here LETS GO
stuff like the Eiffel tower being removed and the new eliminated contestant place HAD to happen to match up with idfb so it’s certain they’ll move back to yoyle land
I agree, evil leafy was terrifying. I hope that if idfb comes back. Evil leafy would take a more antagonistic role as she did in early bfdia.
"pencil definitely had it worst in terms of voice change"
gelatin:
Love these totally new APOY reactions!!
I don't usually comment on videos but it's odd how Ice Cube is in the Goiky Canal when in TPOT 5 she literally died in the water.
This was the timestamp by the way: 36:46
hear me out, global warming
10:32 honestly, I believe this episode could’ve have been a 3 or 4/10 if you talked about the elimination, it was cool and funny
Tpot 9 just not didn’t know the challenge at beginning
I think its cool the evil leafy keeps
Getting frozen and
Somehow coming back
It gives thr idea that no
Matter many times rid
Of her
She will
Always rise again
What text to speech does apoy use? pls tell me
matthew is the one i use
Thanks!@@APOYOSC
If you want to see the BFDIA 5 rating overall, it is a 34/50, which averages out to a 7/10.
Can you make a video on needle saying “dont call me needy” on coiny’s voice
BFDIA 5c was my first BFDI episode maybe that’s why I love BFDIA 5 so much
i dont understand why gelatin didnt kill gb and then recovered him with the laser in bfdia 9, i mean he was kinda stupid in the episode so that could be the reason why but still it would be nice to see golf ball actually do something for the first time since bfdia 7
Spoilers for BFB
I haven’t seen the voting results yet(don’t spoil them), but I think that the people are most likely to eliminate gelatine, for doing very very stupid stuff & sabotaging WOAH bunch in BFDIA 8. This would normally be fine, but then there’s the infamous scene from BFB 29, where the announcer labels gelatine as “the 1 contestant that was never eliminated.” But if he’s gone, that tears a massive hole in the canon, it’s doomed.
How did i knew the video was almost gonna be an hour long?
18:22 No Shit he has a fear of dying
characters with the BIGGEST personality changes from BFDIA 5e to BFDIA 6 (no particular order):
Needle, Bomby, Ice Cube, Nickel, Gelatin (in my opinion)
I love Bfdia 4, it was the first ever episode of bfdi I had ever seen!
When you realize yellow face was not in the vote selection 💀
if you like object shows with permanent deaths youd probably like obs, since one of the hosts had the ability to recover contestants and lost it, with the characters being more worried about dying, and especially getting hurt, with one of my favorite things about the show being the permanent redesigns they get once they're injured or need to do so for a challenge (like oreo, house, cup and coal)
What does obs stand for? I wanna watch it,
@@Princesspeachfan456 obsolete battle show it was made by sacri she has a bunch of cool shows like burner the 5 secondly object show and battle for grandma
@@sunny__41 thanks
As someone who have played and finished BFDIA 5b in these last couple of days I can confirm Lego Brick is a mf
I played it too. Honestly, it felt like it was getting easier. I was having so much trouble in the early stages. I got all win tokens except level 50 and 53.
Next Ranking BFB Episode's
Letsgo i got something to watch
I actually think they were trying to save GB, since this is VTE, not giving GB much screentime would prob make her receive less votes and... SPOILERS!
Look at Gelatin, he got LOTS of screentime this episode, but since he was annoying, he got the boot, this could've easily been GB if she gotten lots of screentime this ep.