*me over decade ago when Final Fantasy introduced the gunblade* “What a fuckin terrible and stupid weapons design, that would literally be useless” *Ian discovers a real life gunblade* “Fuck I want one”
Wait wait, isn't that FFviii gunblade not really a gun? I mean it doesn't shoot projectile at range, rather it has like blanks loaded in chamber and firing it would "vibrate the blade" to deal damage
@@at0micl0bster I think this example might even be the one they based Gaius’s gunblade on, especially given the clip point and general saber-esque design.
Arguably, it becomes a dramatically *better* weapon once the blade breaks off, since then you're just left with a revolver without a massive unwieldy bayonet attachment. This is the perfect "I am not left handed!" gun.
I think that this type of weapon makes most sense when you enter close sword combat - shot the first guy and sword fight the next one. Or when the blade is stuck in the armor of the enemy finish him with a shot so he cant use his weapon. But the best use is likely to throw the sword at the enemy to confuse him and then shot him with a normal revolver.
Sensible person: "Why not use a more effective saber in one hand and a more efecctive revolver in the other instead?" Rule of cool guy: "WELL, because you can dual-wield saber-revolvers this way!"
You could also have a pistol in the other hand, the difference from a normal sabre-pistol combo being that you can fire a dozen shots without reloading
Yea, the lacking of flames really does take away from this one. Hiccup’s sword on How to Train your Dragon was a good try but not gun. Neither had the saw part though ;)
FF was always known for having outlandish widely impractical weapons... The gunblade being one of the most agregious offenders, Their logic was creating a bore obstruction for somehow more damage.
I suspect that this was for the swordsman who was in all likelihood not a swordsman at all and shat himself at the thought of actually closing with the enemy
Tacticool in The Stone Age: "My club has a rock attached to BOTH ends!" ..... "No, I don't know how to use it, but it still means I'm better than you!"
ok, at this point I am fully convinced that there's a lone FFVIII fanboy running around in a Tardis throughout timelines planting these gun-blades just to get back at the bullies that used to tease him about his obsession with strange weapons.
Why can I picture the Doctor extremely annoyed and sitting at a Cafe. Just waiting for his Phone Box to return. Looking at a smartphone and scrolling through the history section seeing what changes were made. To only see a new weapon as developed but failed to catch on. ie the Gunblade. So it isn't going to be catastrophic world ending event. Though he will still scold the person who stole his Phone Box.
Additional -Lore- Info: "Weapon wielded by the Knights of Cainhurst. Combines an elegant knight's sword with the peculiar firearm wielded by the Cainhurst order. The old nobles, long-time imbibers of blood, are no strangers to the sanguine plague, and the disposal of beasts was a discrete task left to their servants, or knights, as they were called for the sake of appearances."
Patreon members get to see the extended footage where Ian spends hours mastering the junction system and drawing Firaga until his Guardian Force is full.
I have to be "that guy" and point out that FFVIII gunblade functioned differently than this. It's simply a blade with gun-like mechanism that firing blanks to power up the blade; magic may or may not involved. There are other gun + sword combo weapon that can function as both in other FF but Squall's and Seifer's gunblade are strictly swords, they don't even have any barrel. The look is spot-on though.
I can actually see the pistol being used as a sneaky "first strike" sort of weapon. Someone is coming towards you with a sword, you pull your swordgun out and wield it like a normal saber. Assailant stops just outside sword range to initiate a duel. You point the barrel of the revolver at him and gut shot him.
Then break off your sword blade at the weak mounting point in front of the revolver cylinder, while trying to finish off your startled opponent. I do wonder if a better designed version would be viable in that regard - might be better to have it fire a tiny shotgun round, for maximum noise and pain but little actual harm. Even if someone is expecting it, having a loud noise go off and even weak projectiles hit you would require a bunch of training to suppress reaction to.
@@LJCyrus1 Shotgun would be a terrible idea, because if it's any kind of shot, the likelihood of the shot bouncing off or blowing off the blade is very much a risk you wouldn't want to take. You'd still use a pistol of some kind, or if you're just looking for noise, blanks.
I love how Ian just enjoys himself while doing this. The little smiles or expression in his eyes between words. It's just wholesome. Additionally to the interesting content itself, obviously, that's why I always come back to these.
It reminds me of how friend described a motor sailor " 40% motorboat, 40% sailboat = 20% efficient " The sum ended up less than the parts alone. Great stuff Thanks.
I've heard motor-sailors described as having all the convenience and ease of operation of a sailing vessel combined with the peace and serenity of a throbbing diesel engine. Same thing i guess.
@@ukoutdoors3022 We often forget recreational vehicles or vessels are often chosen for comfort or ruggedness, not efficiency. Motor Sailors have their place as do other recreational vessels.
@@jeffreyplum5259 Indeed. My own boat, a 1976 Moody 33, is massively overbuilt by today's standards, and is equipped with an unusually powerful engine. That's the main reason I bought her, since Lord knows she ain't the prettiest.
@@ukoutdoors3022 I live near the coast of New England. Small craft warning are common here. I boat which can take you out and bring you back when things get nasty has a beauty of its own. Pretty oftem means fragile, not something to bet your life on. Thank you Sir.
One of the Rules: any time somebody presents you with an item that is a combination of thing A and thing B, you can probably buy both a better A and better B for the price of the combination thing. See sword/pistol, car/boat, and car/airplane as prime examples.
The memories of timing the R1 trigger every time Squall or Seifer hit an enemy and that satisfying rumble of the Dual Shock... Aaaannnd the f*ckn frustration of that bloody card game!!! 😂 Great video as usual Ian!
Alternatively, Medieval polearms are the origin of the can opener. Seriously, just look at some old can openers and you'll eventually see a tiny fauchard.
I can easily picture Matt Easton from scholagladiatoria doing the exact opposite. (Not saying he would, but I can picture it.) :P Hey, I like swords *and* guns. Just maybe not in the same weapon.
When he says 'no tang' he's referring to how much of the blade extends into the handle, without which a sword will surely break the moment it hits anything..so yeah the useless blade is dismissed
It seems to me the ideal weapon of this sort would be a straight blade with a short shotgun barrel on each side.... One man facing several charging opponents, shotgun blast and a more even sword fight.... Point, shoot, thrust.... Praying all the while....
That opening line is my second favourite thing that I've heard on this channel. Only thing that beats it is "I am the way and the light, but sometimes the light is a muzzle flash.
Nah he’s a villain in FF14 who says “Such devastation” it’s an actual thing and has become a meme. The line anyways, but they use a very similar weapon though longer and straighter.
This has some big "drive me closer, I wish to hit them with my sword" energy. I've not seen a gun-blade with a multishot gun component before, the ones I've seen have been more 'age of sail' powder and ball type.
It's entirely fantasy, as it doesnt really shoot any projectile out like a gun. It's more a like a jackhammer logic. As said by the two gentlemen above If anything, a glue gun, grease gun and caulking gun are more of gun than Squall's gunblade will ever be.
It's basically a combination of two very short range weapons. The sword is likely to be just as effective as the revolver if the enemy is close enough for the revolver to be useful. And the sword won't run out of ammunition.
@@AdamantLightLPwould like to see a modern recreation where the sword takes focus and the revolver is an afterthought and not the other way around in the video
Now I want this shit in Hunt: Showdown. Just imagine, as you are charging someone you can use the pistol to aimpunch them so they can't headshot you and then you finish them with the blade.
Blunderbuss-Sword, where the grip is the barrel and the pommel keeps it sealed, until you're ready to end one guy rightly and more mercifully shoot a second guy.
There is a lot of these at the Doge Palace Museum in Venice, plenty of swords, axes and blunt weapons mixed up with more or less reliable firearms. Quite a collection
Someone send Ian there pls thx Edit: found some info, don't think they're genuine. Still cool "Among the most amazing exhibits that could well be accorded a separate article, are samples of the hybrid weapons, and theirhere more than 180 copies! This shooting club and hybrids of the gun and ax, hybrids and arquebus crossbow, gun-Mace gun, a Mace, a pistol-axe, a pistol and even axe... a gun-stick!"
this is the first one of these i've seen that actually almost looks useful, if the grip was redesigned to give tang to the blade it would be an honest to god functional combat gunblade
This actually a great idea. All "Gentleman" were required to wear a sword on occasion and for self defense. You pull your sword and shoot them in the face then back to the dance.
@@ObsoleteVodka Skal is a nice chap I think, but he does not have anything like the knowledge and experience Matt does, though the baldness fits from Matt.
It reminds me of upgrading your starting pistol in a game. Eventually, ya get a suppressor, flashlight, laser, extended mag, red dot, BIPOD, and SWORD BAYONET.
I saw something like this in an American Revolution exhibit in some museum. It had two small flintlocks attached to the handle with the blade in the middle
This is for when you try to run someone through but your sword gets stuck in them and you are having a hard time pulling it out. A quick pull or two on the trigger and now you have lots of room to withdraw your sword with no binding. And it pretty much takes care of any possible counter attack.
Harder but slower. Everything in weapon design is balancing compromises, at least until a novel "new" thing comes onto the scene like "bronze," "iron," "gunpowder," or "fission"
@@mattfleming86 Fission?!?... Don't you effing DARE give anybody any good ideas now!!! :P "50 cal Desert Eagle? PFFFT! Look at this 200MJ phase aligned Xenon ion emitter!"
No no, hold on we do have something here. _Gunblade bayonet_ Think about it. You have a sharp & pointy stick on a long stick, the sharp and pointy stick has a smol stick that throw rock good, and the long stick also throw rock very good! Das a...t..wo...three! Three sticks in one, with rock too! Iz gutta be gud!
Less for "Last ditch". More for during the charge, when the sword would have been presented in a more or less "firing" position. You could get several volleys before the impact and melee.
Curved blade suggests cavalry , The position you demonstrated is about the same as a cavalry trooper would be in a charge . A volley at close range at the end of a charge would be devastating , IMO, could be ! .
So from an actual sword guy... - The blade is behind the grip. That's a no-no, as it's awkward and you'd not be able to hit properly. I don't know any historical examples of weapons which had that feature. It completely messes your wrist work- and weapons from that era have a lot of that. - It would not cut well, as you have a lot of mass in the hilt. Still, it's quite curved and the grip is bent forward- if not for the damn gun, it would have made a pretty cool sabre with a lot of oomph in the cut! - It has no @#$%% tang. Swords do get bashed around- don't want to parry only to find out, that your blade fell off. Furthermore, the hammer is not protected in any way- in a fight blades interact in weird ways- it can totally bend, chip, or otherwise incapacitate the mechanism. - It would have made a lot more sense if stuck to a straight bladed weapon. So yeah, from our perspective it's also pretty bad.
@@colemanmoore9871 if you look at the place were the base of the blade meets the hilt you'll notice it's not in line with the grip but behind it (or abobe it if you hold it horizontally)
Best case scenario, the blade snaps off cleanly. Worst case, but no less likely scenario, the blade snaps off, but holds on well enough to first bend or twist the revolver frame so that the cylinder and barrel no longer line up to each other.
@@Misericorde9 it's tempered and the barrel is short, so probably that's not going to happen- look at how thick it is. But yeah, I guess one cannot completely rule out that the blade will bend the barrel away. Incidentally, the trigger could serve as a pretty good finger loop, those were a thing at that time and are pretty neat.
Imagine being overrun while running all out of ammo and now imagine your exitement as you pull out that crazy gadget you brought that you now finally get to use legitimatley, all while thinking about all the people who made fun of it and mumbling:"ha! Told you so!".
I would love to see more combination firearms like this one. There are some excellent examples of gun-axes, gun-maces, gun-shields and even gun-keys. Seeing how they work would be amazing.
7:16 it looks like the tip of the blade and the tip of the cross-bar might actually form a line parallel to the revolver barrel that could be used for aiming!
Very interesting weapon, also very unpractical. It would seem the main problem isn’t with the grip angle or difficulty aiming, but the fact that the blade would most likely break on first contact without a tang. As for difficulty aiming, it was most likely not intended to be aimed but rather fired at a large body of attackers at close range or in a scrum where it would hit something no matter where it was pointed. Thanks for sharing it with us, we appreciate your efforts in bringing us these videos.
Those 7mm pinfire cartridges were about on par with the .32 S&W in terms of bullet weight, velocity and power. I know they will go through at least 3/4 inch plywood at close range. And while the pinfire system was surpassed by both rimfire and centerfire cartridges, they hung on well into the first two decades of 20th century. They did so for several reasons. The first was because many of the pinfire revolvers coming out of Belgium were very, very low cost. Which made them popular. Second, because the single and double barrel versions of the pistols were hugely popular in South America. And third, because many low-cost, utilitarian shotguns had been turned out in the decades leading up to the 20th century, and many of the people using them saw no reason to move to a centerfire firearm when they had a perfectly adequate shotgun already.
For anyone who wants to know of mostly practical combos, the gun axe. Single shot but the ranges most sub 16 inch barrels of the era used it didnt matter much as similar to axe range.
My introduction to the notion of sword guns was the animated movie Space Pirate Captain Harlock (may be slightly off on the name, its been a while). Name character has a sort of rapier looking weapon with a full length rifle barrel going down the center of the blade for dealing with unwanted passengers who were too far away to slash. Very pretty
Okay, so to apply a (overly?) generous interpretation, one tactical purpose it MIGHT serve is intimidation. If a bunch of people (a mutinous ship's crew, or escaped prisoners, say) are squaring up to rush the guy with a sword, in the belief that they'll overwhelm him before he gets much more than one swing in, then him firing a _shot_ into or over them MIGHT cause them to think twice, or at least come on more cautiously. People tend to believe, rightly or wrongly, that they've got a decent chance of dodging a sword and grappling the swordsman, but they don't tend to think the same about repeating firearms. Of course, there's a strong argument for saying that the swordsman would be better off with a real sword AND a real pistol, but then he'd have to choose which to brandish, or use one or the other in his weak hand. Mind you, I instinctively pick up a sword with my (dominant) left hand but a gun with my right, so I'd be fine... 😉
Bayonets really are the best of both. Holding the firearm is mostly the same for intended ranged use while the bayonet is only noticeable when it is required. A bayoneted rifle might not have the same prowess as a sword but it has all the bite a heavy duty spear or glaive has which works well in battles between infantry companies.
There are lots of "gunblades" out there, from flintlock to pinfire like these. However, Im hard pressed to even think Squall's weapon id a gunblade as it doesn't actually shoot a projectile at range
"You have insulted my honour, and I demand satisfaction! Do you duel?"
"Yes"
"Saber? Pistol?"
"Yes."
"Fancy pants told Krod to choose weapon, Krod choose surprise!"
Ha
Just say saber ... then shoot em with the pistol part when they don't know.
I think you just solve the true purpose of this weapon... Unless the guy brings a referee to inspect the weapons.
Underrated xD
*me over decade ago when Final Fantasy introduced the gunblade*
“What a fuckin terrible and stupid weapons design, that would literally be useless”
*Ian discovers a real life gunblade*
“Fuck I want one”
They have ones that look similar to the one here in FF14 (the mmo)
Wait wait, isn't that FFviii gunblade not really a gun? I mean it doesn't shoot projectile at range, rather it has like blanks loaded in chamber and firing it would "vibrate the blade" to deal damage
@@at0micl0bster I think this example might even be the one they based Gaius’s gunblade on, especially given the clip point and general saber-esque design.
It's still practically useless
@@WingMaster562 nah it had a second button press at the end of the attack to deal projectile damage at the end of the cut
"Then Oog think to Oog's self, Why doesn't Oog put ACOG on Oog's club? Oog call it 'tactical club'."
But Oof forget, club isn't colored black. So sales were slow, and Oog's business went extinct.
Bog no like ACOG for club. Forgrip is more good.
Rog say ,want shusssh stick.
Club too loud.
@@heathbarnhart1092 The mental image of a cartoony wooden club with a black foregrip stuck on the middle is hilarious
Colonel 100 just unlock bipods for his knife.
The gun is a great backup for when the blade inevitably snaps off at the first strike since it has no tang whatsoever.
Arguably, it becomes a dramatically *better* weapon once the blade breaks off, since then you're just left with a revolver without a massive unwieldy bayonet attachment. This is the perfect "I am not left handed!" gun.
I think that this type of weapon makes most sense when you enter close sword combat - shot the first guy and sword fight the next one. Or when the blade is stuck in the armor of the enemy finish him with a shot so he cant use his weapon. But the best use is likely to throw the sword at the enemy to confuse him and then shot him with a normal revolver.
@@derPetunientopf The weapon is from the 1800's.
Armor fell out of use in the early 1700's.
@@walternelson2687 Okay good poin, but it could still get stuck in the enemys body.
@@derPetunientopf then he’s already dead I suppose.
Everyone: Don't bring a knife to a gunfight...
Milan: *"Anyways, So I drew my sword and started blasting."*
@Cyo 22 Bud's gun emporium: "HOO BOy! It sure do! Y'all yant that frangible ammunition for about treefiddy mo?"
@Cyo 22 A laser sight would really help with that aiming issue.
Did you mean "In ogni caso, ho sfoderato la mia spada e cominciato a sparare" ?
I'm getting pretty tired of the
Someone:
Someone else:
Meme
@@kino_61 crazy gibberish!
Sensible person: "Why not use a more effective saber in one hand and a more efecctive revolver in the other instead?"
Rule of cool guy: "WELL, because you can dual-wield saber-revolvers this way!"
Gotta make room for the Gun-Shield
@@FatJack210 Which was a real thing by the way.
"it's also a gun!"
You could also have a pistol in the other hand, the difference from a normal sabre-pistol combo being that you can fire a dozen shots without reloading
Think of how handy it would be during a sword fight. Shoot or stab, or shoot and stab.
When I was a kid, we called these "super death swords". They usually had flames and a saw part too.
Yea, the lacking of flames really does take away from this one. Hiccup’s sword on How to Train your Dragon was a good try but not gun. Neither had the saw part though ;)
You’re missing the “Transforms into a scythe”
Wait is this Bloodborne related?
Oh you're gonna love chainswords, then.
This guy grew up in the 41st millenium
Final Fantasy gave these contraptions the perfect name: Gun Blade.
I was looking for this comment xD
Lol no they took that name from historical weapons
lol
I honestly thought this was a joke cuz of FF lol
FF was always known for having outlandish widely impractical weapons... The gunblade being one of the most agregious offenders, Their logic was creating a bore obstruction for somehow more damage.
Here I was appreciating the blade and then Ian ruins it by saying, "no tang."
Ian didnt ruin it... the person who created it did... could have given it a looong rat tail tang
It does have some Sunny Delight, though.
Lack of tang kind of makes this a wall-hanger, rather than a usable sword.
I would've expected that they could have used the tang as the cylinder axis so there's a missed opportunity.
I suspect that this was for the swordsman who was in all likelihood not a swordsman at all and shat himself at the thought of actually closing with the enemy
Tacticool in The Stone Age: "My club has a rock attached to BOTH ends!" ..... "No, I don't know how to use it, but it still means I'm better than you!"
ok, at this point I am fully convinced that there's a lone FFVIII fanboy running around in a Tardis throughout timelines planting these gun-blades just to get back at the bullies that used to tease him about his obsession with strange weapons.
you got me :D
Why can I picture the Doctor extremely annoyed and sitting at a Cafe. Just waiting for his Phone Box to return. Looking at a smartphone and scrolling through the history section seeing what changes were made. To only see a new weapon as developed but failed to catch on. ie the Gunblade. So it isn't going to be catastrophic world ending event.
Though he will still scold the person who stole his Phone Box.
I was certain that I will find FFVIII reference in comments.
@@ukaszgrzesik7231 I may or may not be culpable of this.
Something about this concept terrifies the living shit out of me...
Additional -Lore- Info:
"Weapon wielded by the Knights of Cainhurst.
Combines an elegant knight's sword with the peculiar firearm wielded by the Cainhurst order.
The old nobles, long-time imbibers of blood, are no strangers to the sanguine plague, and the disposal of beasts was a discrete task left to their servants, or knights, as they were called for the sake of appearances."
a yes a fellow bloodbourne fan
Came here to say this
A Hunter is a Hunter.....
may the good blood guide your way
@@mathhenrique9395 even in a dream
Would love to also see an ammo-oriented episode that explores the history and function of pinfire cartridges....
He already has a video on the pinfire system, it's linked in the end of the video.
Semen lol
@@samholdsworth3957 🧐
I would really like a series on the development of 7.62, 5.56 and other famous ammunitions of the world and nations.
"So you're telling me you was shot... by his sword? Huh, now ain't that something."- Columbo
One more thing... *draws the gunblade*
Patreon members get to see the extended footage where Ian spends hours mastering the junction system and drawing Firaga until his Guardian Force is full.
Yup, there it is.
Thank you sir!
Mostly drawing firaga.
I have to be "that guy" and point out that FFVIII gunblade functioned differently than this. It's simply a blade with gun-like mechanism that firing blanks to power up the blade; magic may or may not involved. There are other gun + sword combo weapon that can function as both in other FF but Squall's and Seifer's gunblade are strictly swords, they don't even have any barrel. The look is spot-on though.
@@cnhnx >firing blanks to power up the blade
???
I think magic might be involved.
"Let's have a sword fight like gentlemen"
"Alright, pulls out sword"
"Why your holding your sword like that?"
Ian: it's a useless tacticool relic
Yharnam Hunter: *THE HUNT INTENSIFIES*
Ian: "What's that smell?.....It's French Infantry Rifles!!!"
When the Good Hunter become the Best Hunter.
Pair this with a bone ash’d cannon and you’re good to go in PVP
@@FutBoy281 “How it sings to me... enough to drive a man mad...” #RIPBigDaddyG
Ghog: Why is your spear so short, Bhirc?
Bhirc: Its the snub-nose model.
I love RUclips's auto-subtitles:
"Like any other double action revolver when you pull the trigger it's going to [___] the hammer."
Hunter: How much bloodtinge do I need to use this weapon?
Cainhurst: YES
Thank you, I was waiting for the mandatory reiterpallasch reference
I can actually see the pistol being used as a sneaky "first strike" sort of weapon. Someone is coming towards you with a sword, you pull your swordgun out and wield it like a normal saber. Assailant stops just outside sword range to initiate a duel. You point the barrel of the revolver at him and gut shot him.
Proto Indiana Jones moment
Then break off your sword blade at the weak mounting point in front of the revolver cylinder, while trying to finish off your startled opponent.
I do wonder if a better designed version would be viable in that regard - might be better to have it fire a tiny shotgun round, for maximum noise and pain but little actual harm.
Even if someone is expecting it, having a loud noise go off and even weak projectiles hit you would require a bunch of training to suppress reaction to.
@@LJCyrus1 Shotgun would be a terrible idea, because if it's any kind of shot, the likelihood of the shot bouncing off or blowing off the blade is very much a risk you wouldn't want to take. You'd still use a pistol of some kind, or if you're just looking for noise, blanks.
extremely unsportsmanlike, of course. no true gentleman would use such a weapon.
"Hey, this guy is a better sword fighter than me"..... *shoots opponent in the face*
Almost looks like something Edward Kenway would use in his shenanigans against the Spanish and British in the Caribbean :D
@@gehstur7150 Squall
A Gunblade!!!!!
@@Dark0neone Even more like the one used by Gaius van Baelsar in ff14
Fr
Yes, every time I see sword guns my mind instantly goes back the the sword-guns from ACIV and the finisher animations.
I love how Ian just enjoys himself while doing this. The little smiles or expression in his eyes between words. It's just wholesome. Additionally to the interesting content itself, obviously, that's why I always come back to these.
Ian: _Tacticool is not a new thing_
*Caveman who figured out tying a rock to a stick makes it hit harder* : _Happy Ooga Booga noises_
I'm confused, that's actually more useful.
The first M-Rok mount was invented.
Congratulations for copying a joke Ian just made.
@@larsdejong7396 Ian's tying 2 sticks together was less cool than the RockStick.
It's the Ooga Booga-loo
It reminds me of how friend described a motor sailor " 40% motorboat, 40% sailboat = 20% efficient " The sum ended up less than the parts alone. Great stuff Thanks.
I've heard motor-sailors described as having all the convenience and ease of operation of a sailing vessel combined with the peace and serenity of a throbbing diesel engine. Same thing i guess.
@@ukoutdoors3022 We often forget recreational vehicles or vessels are often chosen for comfort or ruggedness, not efficiency. Motor Sailors have their place as do other recreational vessels.
@@jeffreyplum5259 Indeed. My own boat, a 1976 Moody 33, is massively overbuilt by today's standards, and is equipped with an unusually powerful engine. That's the main reason I bought her, since Lord knows she ain't the prettiest.
The sum ended up less than the parts alone.....like an Alpha Romeo.
@@ukoutdoors3022 I live near the coast of New England. Small craft warning are common here. I boat which can take you out and bring you back when things get nasty has a beauty of its own. Pretty oftem means fragile, not something to bet your life on. Thank you Sir.
One of the Rules: any time somebody presents you with an item that is a combination of thing A and thing B, you can probably buy both a better A and better B for the price of the combination thing. See sword/pistol, car/boat, and car/airplane as prime examples.
Gave you like, but I see the smartphones frowning at you ;)
Sometimes it works really well though, like long gun + knife > bayonet
You're right, combining tools usually compromises the functions of those tools. The multi-purpose Swiss Army knife springs to mind.
Or a spork, which is just as good as a spoon or a fork
Boat/plane came out pretty useful
The memories of timing the R1 trigger every time Squall or Seifer hit an enemy and that satisfying rumble of the Dual Shock... Aaaannnd the f*ckn frustration of that bloody card game!!! 😂 Great video as usual Ian!
Frustration of Triple Triad? What?
When you look at it, medieval polearms are oldschool tacticool, combining axes and spears and hammers :)
Alternatively, Medieval polearms are the origin of the can opener. Seriously, just look at some old can openers and you'll eventually see a tiny fauchard.
But at least they are useful and working tacticool with real reasons why they have everything and the kitchen sink on them. :)
there were practical uses for every bit in those polearms. They were very well designed
There were polearms with handgonnes built in.
And integrated sleep support to sleep on duty.
I love combo weapons. Sure they're not practical anymore, but they are so cool, and some are works of art/madness.
"But then, the important part here..."
I love how Ian dismisses the sword part and is immediately attracted to the gun part.
I can easily picture Matt Easton from scholagladiatoria doing the exact opposite. (Not saying he would, but I can picture it.) :P
Hey, I like swords *and* guns. Just maybe not in the same weapon.
Well the sword couldn't be too usable without anything attaching the blade and hilt
When he says 'no tang' he's referring to how much of the blade extends into the handle, without which a sword will surely break the moment it hits anything..so yeah the useless blade is dismissed
Guns are cooler than swords
It seems to me the ideal weapon of this sort would be a straight blade with a short shotgun barrel on each side....
One man facing several charging opponents, shotgun blast and a more even sword fight.... Point, shoot, thrust.... Praying all the while....
*has sword*
Gunsmith Columbo: “just one more thing”
*adds revolver*
Oooh haven't seen Columbo reference like...ever over the internetz. Have a like! :)
Oh hey, a gunblade.
Time to get my Final Fantasy on.
Ian is a gunbreaker main confirmed
SUCH DEVASTATION
"Squall, I'm dying.. "
*whatever*
As a Gunbreaker main, i need this as a glamour for my character in FFXIV.
Didn't know Squall was Italian.
That opening line is my second favourite thing that I've heard on this channel.
Only thing that beats it is "I am the way and the light, but sometimes the light is a muzzle flash.
Ammo(n)
*A certain lonesome edgy RPG protagonist with a giant face scar is interested.*
Nah he’s a villain in FF14 who says “Such devastation” it’s an actual thing and has become a meme. The line anyways, but they use a very similar weapon though longer and straighter.
"Whatever..."
@@selay333 stay your tongue, Youngblood 😂
Now I wanna see a Browning .50 cal on a Scottish Claymore - 2 handed sword!
With a common battle cry:
*FREEDOM!*
This has some big "drive me closer, I wish to hit them with my sword" energy.
I've not seen a gun-blade with a multishot gun component before, the ones I've seen have been more 'age of sail' powder and ball type.
That, this comes nearly close to practical lol.
"Look boy! Da humie slapped a choppa on a shoota!" "You idiot! Da humie slapped a shoota on a choppa!"
"...gun-blade...multishot..."
*Warframe PTSD intensifies*
now i have the urge to duct tape a glock to a claymore
@@Well-Rounded_Wildcard More dakka! More dakka!!
So, Squall’s sword isn’t entirely fantasy? We need a Smith and Wesson 500 magnum sword now because that’s what I think of when I seen his sword.
Though depending on the source, either the barrel was the spine of the blade or the bullet smacked the blade to vibrate it.
@@cooper10182 there’s a explosive cartridge with no bullet that when fires creates a vibration. I dug deeper than a Diglet to get that information.
It's entirely fantasy, as it doesnt really shoot any projectile out like a gun. It's more a like a jackhammer logic. As said by the two gentlemen above
If anything, a glue gun, grease gun and caulking gun are more of gun than Squall's gunblade will ever be.
gun blade is just a smaller version of bayonet musket.
they should put a claymore on a claymore
"I will kill you with my sword at long range!"
His sword at long range:
"Twas a gentleman's sw'rd duel,
Until the sw'rd starteth shooting"
~William Shakespeare~
Meanwhile the other gentlemen in the area laugh as they unscrew their pommels
The first thing I wondered about this was where the tang was, glad you elaborated on that.
Modern day 2-bore stopping rifle claymore : for when you absolutely positively need to go overkill everything
Took me a second to disconnect "modern" and "claymore". But you my friend are doing as Scotland intends.
"We need to bring the claymores....no not that one"
It's basically a combination of two very short range weapons. The sword is likely to be just as effective as the revolver if the enemy is close enough for the revolver to be useful. And the sword won't run out of ammunition.
The sword will just snap off though.
@@AdamantLightLPwould like to see a modern recreation where the sword takes focus and the revolver is an afterthought and not the other way around in the video
Whoever designed this would definitely love a zip-22 on the forward rail of their decked out AR.
Lol
I mean that would be a better grip at the very least
I got a zip 22 zip tied to the barrel of my AR
@@aborted4196 and you want a swordpistol for Christmas don't you lil one, better put it on the list for santa!
Now I want this shit in Hunt: Showdown. Just imagine, as you are charging someone you can use the pistol to aimpunch them so they can't headshot you and then you finish them with the blade.
This takes ending him rightly to a whole new level
Yes, ending him wrongly
ending him from farawayly
Didn't know they made pinfire pommels!
Blunderbuss-Sword, where the grip is the barrel and the pommel keeps it sealed, until you're ready to end one guy rightly and more mercifully shoot a second guy.
Oh, I can already feel the memes of Ian threatening the camera this his gun sword. It feels good.
There is a lot of these at the Doge Palace Museum in Venice, plenty of swords, axes and blunt weapons mixed up with more or less reliable firearms. Quite a collection
Someone send Ian there pls thx
Edit: found some info, don't think they're genuine. Still cool
"Among the most amazing exhibits that could well be accorded a separate article, are samples of the hybrid weapons, and theirhere more than 180 copies! This shooting club and hybrids of the gun and ax, hybrids and arquebus crossbow, gun-Mace gun, a Mace, a pistol-axe, a pistol and even axe... a gun-stick!"
Much sword many gun wow
@@Jh5kRadio I know someone’s gonna say this lol
this is the first one of these i've seen that actually almost looks useful, if the grip was redesigned to give tang to the blade it would be an honest to god functional combat gunblade
Epitaph on a tombstone “ he died because his sword ran out of bullets!”
I've wanted a gun sword since final fantasy 8, seeing these old combination weapons is so cool.
Just imagine my disappointment when I realized that Squall's gunblade doesnt actually shoot projectiles, it's just a jackhammer powered with blanks
This actually a great idea. All "Gentleman" were required to wear a sword on occasion and for self defense. You pull your sword and shoot them in the face then back to the dance.
Professionals have standards: be polite, be efficient...
I challenge you to a duel, swords or pistols?"
"Yes"
The gentleman had spoken roughly to a lady. He had to answer for his poor manners.
Not when this was made :)
Don't forget about tea bagging their corpse before you make your way back.
If you thought your LT was incompetent then just imagine him rolling up with an actual gunblade.
From the people who brought you Reese's peanut butter cups..... "There's a sword in my gun. There's a gun in my my sword!" 😳🍫🗡️
Blazefire Sabre
The first thing I noticed was that there might not be a tang, glad you pointed it out that there is indeed no tang!
Invite Matt Easton for this sort of thing Ian. He is the "Bald Sword Jesus" and an antique dealer as well as archeologist.
Skallagrim is sword Jesus. Matt is sword Buddha.
@@ObsoleteVodka Skal is a nice chap I think, but he does not have anything like the knowledge and experience Matt does, though the baldness fits from Matt.
@@PalleRasmussen and capt context works with auctions himself so would be really good
@@ObsoleteVodka Gun Jesus and Sword Buddha are the religions the world really needs.
A collab of these two gentlemen would be epic.
It reminds me of upgrading your starting pistol in a game. Eventually, ya get a suppressor, flashlight, laser, extended mag, red dot, BIPOD, and SWORD BAYONET.
Omg it’s a gunsword. Childhood me has wanted to see this since FFVIII.
It's a period piece from a time of hacking and slashing to ranged combat. Thanks Ian.
Looks like something straight came out from Final Fantasy
I saw something like this in an American Revolution exhibit in some museum. It had two small flintlocks attached to the handle with the blade in the middle
I would love to see someone make a modern version of a gun sword just for fun. Immagine a sabre with a built in .44 magnum.
Look up Michaelcthulu. Aside from the lack of viable ammunition (for good reason), you will not be disappointed.
@@geoffreyentwistle8176 I just looked him up, and you are correct. I want that gun blade.
@@mercedes_nuts Nothing about it would be an atf field day. People make their own firearms all the time.
.44 Mag Gladius
2-bore claymore : for when you absolutely positively need to go overkill
This is for when you try to run someone through but your sword gets stuck in them and you are having a hard time pulling it out. A quick pull or two on the trigger and now you have lots of room to withdraw your sword with no binding. And it pretty much takes care of any possible counter attack.
A real-life Gunblade?!
Except it's not stupid in the lore of how it's supposed to work.
Not only is it cool, the sword looks of high quality as well. Appreciate the video
Original tacticool proponent:
"I had a rock and I had a stick, so I tied rock to stick. Now I can hit harder."
"Back in my day, all we had was two sticks and a rock, for the whole platoon! And we had to share the rock!"
Harder but slower. Everything in weapon design is balancing compromises, at least until a novel "new" thing comes onto the scene like "bronze," "iron," "gunpowder," or "fission"
@@mattfleming86 Fission?!?... Don't you effing DARE give anybody any good ideas now!!! :P
"50 cal Desert Eagle? PFFFT! Look at this 200MJ phase aligned Xenon ion emitter!"
@@andersjjensen Haha "That ship done sailed" though. Portable nukes are a little trickier though...
Now I can hit further. In theory. But not as far as by throwing the rock and not as precise as using stick only. Oh well.
Only Ian could make an entire gunblade video without ever mentioning video games.
Karl "Check out this sweet rifle bayonet!"
Ian "Hold my beer..."
You're right this would make a perfect bayonet for a smg. You need the length of the sabre to get enough reach.
No no, hold on we do have something here.
_Gunblade bayonet_
Think about it. You have a sharp & pointy stick on a long stick, the sharp and pointy stick has a smol stick that throw rock good, and the long stick also throw rock very good! Das a...t..wo...three! Three sticks in one, with rock too! Iz gutta be gud!
Saw something similar to this in a movie. Forgot which one, but it was cool to see. Need to see more of these in movies.
Less for "Last ditch". More for during the charge, when the sword would have been presented in a more or less "firing" position. You could get several volleys before the impact and melee.
And have your sword blade promptly fall off at the first real contact because you don't have much of a tang lol
This has never shown up in a movie???!!! This is the most pirate/gangster fire arm ever!!! I love it!!! Only for its off the wall thinking.
What would you rather have, a sidearm of a blade for close quarters?
Answer: Yes.
Same as Naked Snake.
Now we need to see Ian run a course with this, using both the pistol and the saber.
You should get in touch with Matt Eaton from schola gladiatoria to discuss such blades together.
Context!
definitely, also for the couple sword-bayonets they both covered!
Thank you , Ian .
Curved blade suggests cavalry , The position you demonstrated is about the same as a cavalry trooper would be in a charge . A volley at close range at the end of a charge would be devastating ,
IMO, could be ! .
So from an actual sword guy...
- The blade is behind the grip. That's a no-no, as it's awkward and you'd not be able to hit properly. I don't know any historical examples of weapons which had that feature. It completely messes your wrist work- and weapons from that era have a lot of that.
- It would not cut well, as you have a lot of mass in the hilt. Still, it's quite curved and the grip is bent forward- if not for the damn gun, it would have made a pretty cool sabre with a lot of oomph in the cut!
- It has no @#$%% tang. Swords do get bashed around- don't want to parry only to find out, that your blade fell off. Furthermore, the hammer is not protected in any way- in a fight blades interact in weird ways- it can totally bend, chip, or otherwise incapacitate the mechanism.
- It would have made a lot more sense if stuck to a straight bladed weapon.
So yeah, from our perspective it's also pretty bad.
OK, I can understand most of what you are saying, but what does "The blade is behind the grip" mean?
@@colemanmoore9871 if you drew a straight line along the back of the blade, it would not align with the grip, it would be slightly behind
@@colemanmoore9871 if you look at the place were the base of the blade meets the hilt you'll notice it's not in line with the grip but behind it (or abobe it if you hold it horizontally)
Best case scenario, the blade snaps off cleanly. Worst case, but no less likely scenario, the blade snaps off, but holds on well enough to first bend or twist the revolver frame so that the cylinder and barrel no longer line up to each other.
@@Misericorde9 it's tempered and the barrel is short, so probably that's not going to happen- look at how thick it is. But yeah, I guess one cannot completely rule out that the blade will bend the barrel away. Incidentally, the trigger could serve as a pretty good finger loop, those were a thing at that time and are pretty neat.
Imagine being overrun while running all out of ammo and now imagine your exitement as you pull out that crazy gadget you brought that you now finally get to use legitimatley, all while thinking about all the people who made fun of it and mumbling:"ha! Told you so!".
We've seen a lot of creative and crazy designs over the years but you could argue this gun is by far the most
Cutting edge
🤣
That guy should have packed one of these in Raiders of the Lost Ark. You know what scene I'm talking about.
I would love to see more combination firearms like this one. There are some excellent examples of gun-axes, gun-maces, gun-shields and even gun-keys. Seeing how they work would be amazing.
I heard Pistol Katars were a thing in India for a little bit during the 18th Century. Would love to see a deep dive into one of those.
Gun spears is most amazing, in that it's actually usable. Aka bayonet on a rifle.
@@WingMaster562 fire lances like wtf why were these some of the first guns.
@@josephdedrick9337 "Maybe that's a question you should ask China."
7:16 it looks like the tip of the blade and the tip of the cross-bar might actually form a line parallel to the revolver barrel that could be used for aiming!
Incoming Final Fantasy references!
Very interesting weapon, also very unpractical. It would seem the main problem isn’t with the grip angle or difficulty aiming, but the fact that the blade would most likely break on first contact without a tang. As for difficulty aiming, it was most likely not intended to be aimed but rather fired at a large body of attackers at close range or in a scrum where it would hit something no matter where it was pointed.
Thanks for sharing it with us, we appreciate your efforts in bringing us these videos.
As a Final Fantasy fan I see a Gunblade.
Though this can shoot projectile like a gun than Squall's gunblade which is just a jackhammer blade powered with blanks
Those 7mm pinfire cartridges were about on par with the .32 S&W in terms of bullet weight, velocity and power. I know they will go through at least 3/4 inch plywood at close range. And while the pinfire system was surpassed by both rimfire and centerfire cartridges, they hung on well into the first two decades of 20th century. They did so for several reasons. The first was because many of the pinfire revolvers coming out of Belgium were very, very low cost. Which made them popular. Second, because the single and double barrel versions of the pistols were hugely popular in South America. And third, because many low-cost, utilitarian shotguns had been turned out in the decades leading up to the 20th century, and many of the people using them saw no reason to move to a centerfire firearm when they had a perfectly adequate shotgun already.
Looks like a Bloodborne weapon.
No, it's more of a final fantasy 8 weapon
Splendid! A sword-gun is a sword-gun, even in Milan!
Looks like RWBY Qrows prototype sword
It's the secret third form of the Kirkhammer. It goes Hammer/Sword/Sword-gun
@@johntitor1256 Grant us bullets. Grant. Us. Bullets.
For anyone who wants to know of mostly practical combos, the gun axe. Single shot but the ranges most sub 16 inch barrels of the era used it didnt matter much as similar to axe range.
I like the gun spear more
Aka, bayonet on a rifle
@@WingMaster562 i mean yeah, but i was meaning outside military issue weird stuff
Ah... The gun blade.. "trick ur enemy to a sword fight and shot em instead" thing
So... press R1 to trigger shot? 🌝😂🤣
'Something is broken, so it wont revolve'
*quietly extends pushrod*
~not a word...~
« it's just like my japanese animes. » - Ian.
ruclips.net/video/qvvQIJ7y_ss/видео.html&ab_channel=OPFFIX
Larping is much older than I ever imagined.
😠"I challenge you to a duel!"
🤨 "Sword or pistols?"
😠 "Yes"
An elegant forgotten weapon for a more civilized age
You generally wouldn't want to shoot any gunsword still in the scabbard, because at this point it is most likely still hanging on you hip
Gunsmith : "Sir, sorry to ask, but just to be clear... Do you want a saber or a gun?"
Sir : "Yes."
Anyone remember an episode of Farscape in which Ka D'Argo is like, "I'll give you covering fire. With my sword."?
That.
My introduction to the notion of sword guns was the animated movie Space Pirate Captain Harlock (may be slightly off on the name, its been a while). Name character has a sort of rapier looking weapon with a full length rifle barrel going down the center of the blade for dealing with unwanted passengers who were too far away to slash. Very pretty
Okay, so to apply a (overly?) generous interpretation, one tactical purpose it MIGHT serve is intimidation. If a bunch of people (a mutinous ship's crew, or escaped prisoners, say) are squaring up to rush the guy with a sword, in the belief that they'll overwhelm him before he gets much more than one swing in, then him firing a _shot_ into or over them MIGHT cause them to think twice, or at least come on more cautiously. People tend to believe, rightly or wrongly, that they've got a decent chance of dodging a sword and grappling the swordsman, but they don't tend to think the same about repeating firearms.
Of course, there's a strong argument for saying that the swordsman would be better off with a real sword AND a real pistol, but then he'd have to choose which to brandish, or use one or the other in his weak hand. Mind you, I instinctively pick up a sword with my (dominant) left hand but a gun with my right, so I'd be fine... 😉
Yet, intimidation would be the only thing that that sword is useful for. The blade would snap off very quickly when you have to actually use it.
Bayonets really are the best of both. Holding the firearm is mostly the same for intended ranged use while the bayonet is only noticeable when it is required. A bayoneted rifle might not have the same prowess as a sword but it has all the bite a heavy duty spear or glaive has which works well in battles between infantry companies.
Now I see from where they got the inspiration for the Final Fantasy VIII protagonist and antagonist weapons, this is AMAZING! Thanks Ian so much!!!
There are lots of "gunblades" out there, from flintlock to pinfire like these. However, Im hard pressed to even think Squall's weapon id a gunblade as it doesn't actually shoot a projectile at range
This is genuinely like something out of a JRPG