The live performance in Japan is even more beautiful, imo. It’s just Baekhyun, Chen, and D.O. on stage, and without the story playing in the background, the focus is entirely on the music and their vocals. Even if you don’t react you should watch it on your own! 😊
Chanyeol and Tao were the only ones who managed to cry on the set, all of them tried to do it in front of the camera, but only the two of them succeed it 🥹 Not a surprise though, Tao is such a good actor ,very much appreciated by the chinese audience (my favourite is "The Game Changer"), and Chanyeol has himself a few acting achievements as well
I need to check out some of Tao's solo stuff. The one thing that always pops into my head when I think of him is when he got mad at some trainees when one of them fell and no one helped her and also when someone asked about what if a guy cheats on you, what to do. Plus the haunted house episode where he was terrified of going in. Any good suggestions on where to start?
Me too....every video I commented to watch this live 😅 Christmas Day + The First Snow + Miracles in December at The EXO'luXion in Seoul ruclips.net/video/zLcsQmUVfBI/видео.htmlsi=sx9zfzAvvC5DxvTf
Miracles in December will always be my favorite song from EXO Story plot of the music video (the lyrics would explain more) : the members prepared presents for their loved ones (their partners) on Christmas, but they got broken up with instead (could see from Tao's superpower which is time: after he turned back time, a pair of feet was walking towards Sehun, so that actually meant the girl left Sehun) and they're pretty devastated and expressed their emotions and apologies and how much they missed their loved ones in this song
Even you dont' understand korean you can understand the feelings that they are transmiting during the video, their expression, the intention of the song. Because of that I ended with teary eyes everytime I saw the mv. But the way lyrics are so so so sad, full of regrets and asking about turn back time. Yes, ChenBaekSoo are the Holy Trinity of Vocals; beautiful, amazing, outstanding voices. Merry Christmas! Thanks for your support EXO discography.
Pleeeease the live of Christmas Day + First Snow + miracles in december in pink outfits and suspenders! The suspender choreo is ridiculously sassy and good and the miracles in december in the end is a huge tear jerker
"Miracles In December" actually features the 4 main vocalists in EXO. If you haven't yet, you should check out the Mandarin version as well. If you have never heard the Mandarin version, then you are missing out on hearing Luhan's beautiful voice also. :D In the EXO-M version of "Miracles in December" you will see that Luhan sings instead of D.O. Luhan was one of the main vocalists in EXO-M. Chen and Luhan are both EXO-M members so they sang the Mandarin songs, and to round out the vocals Baekhyun subbed in as an EXO-M member. :D Now to explain what is happening in the story in the MV. As you noticed, Xiumin was the one that made it snow. Xiumin has the power to control ice/frost/snow, so anytime something has to do with these weather elements they will focus on him. In the MV you see Xiumin with the lapel pin that is shaped like EXO's album logo. He steps outside and looks up at the sky and at that moment his pin shimmers and it begins to snow. It is thought that the members' powers are tied to their emotions, so when Xiumin is sad or melancholy, he almost can't help it, and he will make it snow. Next, as you also noticed, we see Tao stop time. Tao has the power of time control, so he is the one that turned back time and then instantly brought time back to the present again. The snow was falling in reverse at one point because Tao was rewinding time. Then you see everything pause for a second and the snow starts falling down again when he brings everything back to the present. There also was an eclipse. Eclipses affect the members' powers and it is also where they gather strength, etc. So, you will see them focus on an eclipse or something to do with the moon and sun, or other planetary phenomenon, in a lot of EXO's storyline. This even happens in live performances. You will see instances of them using their powers to control things that happen on stage during live concert performances. Suho makes it rain on stage, Xiumin will make it snow, Chanyeol will control fire, Chen will control the thunder and lightning, Baekhyun often makes the lights go on and off, etc. If you keep this all in mind when you watch any of their MVs or live performances, it's kind of fun to search for the instances where they are using their powers. In some MVs and songs the members use their powers more than others, but at least one member will use their powers in almost everything they do, it just might be more subtle sometimes than others. So, this is just another element of EXO's performances that make watching them unique. I think of "Miracles in December" as a kind of breakup song that is about how the holidays makes you nostalgic for that loved one that you are no longer with. It makes you remember all the good times and makes you wish you were together even though you know, deep down, you are better off now that you have broken up. As I see it, all the gifts are supposed to be what they would have given to their girlfriends if they hadn't broken up before the holidays. I interpret the story as, "she" was a different girl for each of the members, and "she" was not meeting any of them, she was a memory of a past relationship that was no more. That's why Tao turns back time for a moment to relive being in the relationship, but then quickly returns to the present because he knows, deep down, he is better off and that you really can't go back in time and expect to fix everything in the relationship. That's why they are all sad and crying because they are heartbroken. I like to think, for example, that the puppy was probably going to be a present for Kai's girlfriend, but now that they have broken up, it just reminds him of her. It's kind of a bittersweet memory. :D The "miracle" is that the girl had such a profound impact on their life that, even though they aren't together anymore, she will always play a big role in his life history, etc. The "miracle" is that the holidays give you a reason to look back and reflect on those special moments in life, and even though the memories might make them sad because they are no longer able to make new memories together, the old memories are still there. And the "miracle" is that he has now realized she has taught him so much about love and life, but unfortunately, he has realized it too late and he can't go back, so he is sad. He's now upset because he is unable to show her the appreciation she deserves, etc., etc. And, if you like the studio version of "Miracles in December," just wait until you see them perform this song live in concert. I think you will fall in love with it even more. :D
2:49 this was Kerry subtly trying to tell you to resume the song😂 5:28 its funny you'd call him that. Bunny is his associated animal. Fans call him Bunnymyeon = Bunny + Junmyeon 7:33 thats Tao😂😂
Watching those old clips of the Killing voice songs I realize the huge improvement in Chen's vocals and even his Korean diction as he sings it blows my mind tbh The way they deliver their lines play a huge role in how good the song sounds overall I never really paid attention to it until recently... the Killing voice video is a treasure for real
in spite of turning back time Tao was still not able to change the outcome that the girl will still go break up with him /turn him down😢 Depending on my mood, I either cry or feel a twinge in my heart for this song. Thanks for the react
I love that Kerry noticed that Xiumin made it snow in the mv and then she said that Suho got innocent looks like Bunny when in fact Suho's animal avatar is actually Bunny 😂 by the way the one who did time manipulation and even cried at the end is Tao. He's an underrated actor tbh. He showed his acting skills from early on like KyungSoo. 7:21 nope they didn't went back in time but just revived that moment until time resumed at its usual pace, bringing them back to where reality as they realize how their mistakes individually cost them to lose someone they love. Non of them got any happy ending by the end of this mv. You'll realize once you read the lyrics and alos please guys watch Exo-M verison too.❤
I discovered exo much later but I didn't realise how handsome Luhan is, wow that guy is gorgeous. That's why they say exo's visuals are no joke. Thank you for reacting to Exo and making me rediscover them through you guys.
Beautiful and heartfelt reaction, thank you. It's been years since this song and mv was released, and here we are, bawling are eyes altogether at how amazing this song still is. What great Miracle/s in December it is indeed that EXO songs are touching lives even up to this day!! K-Pop vocal trinity: Chen, Baekhyun, and D.O., collectively Emperors of K-Pop as EXO 💖
As much as Chen's vocals make tears well up in my eyes but its Chanyeol and Tao's tears towards the end of video that got me 😢 Miracles in December to this day is still my favorite Christmas song. I hope you guys would react to Exo-M version or else you'll miss out on Luhan's vocals.
Thank you for your every reaction to our dear EXO 😊. I wished for more reactions about them especially their live performances (in concerts) also their variety shows. You'll definitely enjoy every bit of it. ❤
If you think this song was beautiful in the MV, wait until you see a live performance of this....OMG.....shivers and tears and feels galore!!!. *kerry glares* I mean.....the tones, the high notes, what a beautiful Christmas Song!!!.... You really should read the lyrics. Basically everyone there was thinking up the perfect gift for their love....and in the end, she wasn't there, Sehun just happened to be the one that showcased the visual of girl meets boy....but all of them were waiting and all disappointed and upset. ruclips.net/video/Qcjz0NIwg5A/видео.html here is the live version
Most of SMTOWN MVs don't have English subtitles back then they only started putting subtitles in 2018 and the first MV to have it is EXO’s TEMPO. Yes, the ONLY Main vocal are singing.
So, while Baekhyun plays the piano for the mv (which he *does* know how to play), Lay would often accompany them on stage and play the piano during the promotions for the song. Some special stages actually included: Lay on the piano + Baekhyun + D.O + Chen + Luhan (who sang the EXO-M version of the song with Chen & Beakhyun)~~~
It's funny that you said you think Suho has a bunny look bc he actually is represented in the fandom by a bunny. The other ones are Xiumin - cat, Kai - bear, D.O. - penguin, Chen - dinosaur, Baekhyun - dog, Chanyeol - tiger, Lay - sheep, and Sehun sometimes wolf sometimes baby chick.
No, they were all at that courtyard to meet their girl, each of them...when the girl disappeared from Sehun, it was to mean the same for each of them there...collectively, as each one prepared gifts and obviously chose that courtyard to meet their own girl. (independent of each other) Going back in time brings them to a moment in the past when they are meeting up with their girl, but the moment she vanishes, they are in the present, with the stark reminder of their actual reality...they realize their own truths as to their relationships, then each cry to themselves.... As the lyrics suggest, they had a history with this person, had some good times too...but because the boys were not as attentive to their girls in their lives, being self-absorbed to a fault and relying on the girl to just wait for them.. it proved too much for the girl, as she chose to move on. Taking someone's love for granted can be so easy for some...but it can come at a cost.... The lyrics speak of their book of memories, and their past times together. 💙🌺
Thank you for the reaction guys, you have become my favorite reactors in such a short time:) I wanna recommend Exo Vlive for Love Shot. Vlive is no longer there but the video is on RUclips. It's fun and Christmas-themed so it would be nice.
So this is the EXO-K version actually! Pre-merge EXO-K meant the Korean version of the songs, while EXO-M meant the Mandarin (chinese) version of the song. This song is special because Chen and Baekhyun BOTH sang the K and M version, while D.O. sang only in K and Lu Han (who already left) in M. Other members who didnt sing participate in the music video as npc (idk how to describe it) so you could see Lu Han acting here, while you would see D.O. instead over in the Mandarin version! But there's not much a big difference beside from that and the language it's sung in
It's beautiful sad song, if you can say that. You should read the lyrics. They mention something about their powers. Our lovely bunny Suho. Thank you for keeping your journey with EXO.
Tips for the future: if it says Korean Ver. It literally means Korean Ver, the Korean Verison of the song. Same with Chinese Ver. Any members can be singing the song, its just in that specifically listed language. 'The War' album was released entirely in chinese and there were no chinese members in it. Lay wasn't promoting with EXO, so it was just the korean members but they sung in chinese. In the early days ofcourse they were seperated by group. If it's listed as EXO-K/EXO-M its specifically only those group members performing. But you will hardly see that anymore. That period only lasted about 2 years honestly.
there's another song with just the 3 of them. it's called December 2014 from their 1st live album. not a lot of people are familiar w/ this & even EXO forgot they had this. 😂
Please watch with lyrics then you ll understand emotional delivery in all 3 guys lines are so different This is a masterpiece song. Chen really impress me a lot.
I don't think it is. I think that's a misconception that has spread because it looks like Monggu. Kai had already had all three of his dogs before this MV was filmed. You see all three far more grown in the EXO Showtime episode they appear in which was filmed around the time this mv was.
I suggested this live stage with chrismas songs with link..but my comment was REMOVED. Should i be a subscriber to suggest anything for EXO..am not a new EXOL.🙄
Hi there. We did see your comment but I'm afraid we just didn't get a chance to record another video in time for Christmas. We don't remove any comments, so I don't know why it would be gone. Please do keep suggesting ideas for reactions. Almost everything we do is based on comments from viewers. No need to subscribe, you're welcome either way! ❤️
@@alongfortheridereactsi appreciate ur replay...i just wanted u to enjoy every exo's contents we exols r a bit greedy😋..if u dont mind i can send more links for live stages. Ps : new subscriber❤️
The live performance in Japan is even more beautiful, imo. It’s just Baekhyun, Chen, and D.O. on stage, and without the story playing in the background, the focus is entirely on the music and their vocals. Even if you don’t react you should watch it on your own! 😊
Chanyeol and Tao were the only ones who managed to cry on the set, all of them tried to do it in front of the camera, but only the two of them succeed it 🥹
Not a surprise though, Tao is such a good actor ,very much appreciated by the chinese audience (my favourite is "The Game Changer"), and Chanyeol has himself a few acting achievements as well
My favorite is '' legally romance'' I love it
I need to check out some of Tao's solo stuff. The one thing that always pops into my head when I think of him is when he got mad at some trainees when one of them fell and no one helped her and also when someone asked about what if a guy cheats on you, what to do. Plus the haunted house episode where he was terrified of going in.
Any good suggestions on where to start?
@@Ming3484 Start by his dramas and variety shows. Personally my first introduction to Tao was "brighest star in the sky".
@@Tooba-K123 I'll check it out. Thanks. I know it's most likely not on Kokowa+, so where would I find it? RUclips?
Please!!! I am waiting for Christmas day + First Snow + Miracles in December live
Me too....every video I commented to watch this live 😅
Christmas Day + The First Snow + Miracles in December at The EXO'luXion in Seoul
ruclips.net/video/zLcsQmUVfBI/видео.htmlsi=sx9zfzAvvC5DxvTf
That's the one I've been recommending too. High five.
Miracles in December will always be my favorite song from EXO
Story plot of the music video (the lyrics would explain more) : the members prepared presents for their loved ones (their partners) on Christmas, but they got broken up with instead (could see from Tao's superpower which is time: after he turned back time, a pair of feet was walking towards Sehun, so that actually meant the girl left Sehun) and they're pretty devastated and expressed their emotions and apologies and how much they missed their loved ones in this song
Even you dont' understand korean you can understand the feelings that they are transmiting during the video, their expression, the intention of the song. Because of that I ended with teary eyes everytime I saw the mv. But the way lyrics are so so so sad, full of regrets and asking about turn back time. Yes, ChenBaekSoo are the Holy Trinity of Vocals; beautiful, amazing, outstanding voices. Merry Christmas! Thanks for your support EXO discography.
Pleeeease the live of Christmas Day + First Snow + miracles in december in pink outfits and suspenders! The suspender choreo is ridiculously sassy and good and the miracles in december in the end is a huge tear jerker
"Miracles In December" actually features the 4 main vocalists in EXO. If you haven't yet, you should check out the Mandarin version as well. If you have never heard the Mandarin version, then you are missing out on hearing Luhan's beautiful voice also. :D In the EXO-M version of "Miracles in December" you will see that Luhan sings instead of D.O. Luhan was one of the main vocalists in EXO-M. Chen and Luhan are both EXO-M members so they sang the Mandarin songs, and to round out the vocals Baekhyun subbed in as an EXO-M member. :D
Now to explain what is happening in the story in the MV. As you noticed, Xiumin was the one that made it snow. Xiumin has the power to control ice/frost/snow, so anytime something has to do with these weather elements they will focus on him. In the MV you see Xiumin with the lapel pin that is shaped like EXO's album logo. He steps outside and looks up at the sky and at that moment his pin shimmers and it begins to snow. It is thought that the members' powers are tied to their emotions, so when Xiumin is sad or melancholy, he almost can't help it, and he will make it snow.
Next, as you also noticed, we see Tao stop time. Tao has the power of time control, so he is the one that turned back time and then instantly brought time back to the present again. The snow was falling in reverse at one point because Tao was rewinding time. Then you see everything pause for a second and the snow starts falling down again when he brings everything back to the present.
There also was an eclipse. Eclipses affect the members' powers and it is also where they gather strength, etc. So, you will see them focus on an eclipse or something to do with the moon and sun, or other planetary phenomenon, in a lot of EXO's storyline.
This even happens in live performances. You will see instances of them using their powers to control things that happen on stage during live concert performances. Suho makes it rain on stage, Xiumin will make it snow, Chanyeol will control fire, Chen will control the thunder and lightning, Baekhyun often makes the lights go on and off, etc. If you keep this all in mind when you watch any of their MVs or live performances, it's kind of fun to search for the instances where they are using their powers. In some MVs and songs the members use their powers more than others, but at least one member will use their powers in almost everything they do, it just might be more subtle sometimes than others. So, this is just another element of EXO's performances that make watching them unique.
I think of "Miracles in December" as a kind of breakup song that is about how the holidays makes you nostalgic for that loved one that you are no longer with. It makes you remember all the good times and makes you wish you were together even though you know, deep down, you are better off now that you have broken up.
As I see it, all the gifts are supposed to be what they would have given to their girlfriends if they hadn't broken up before the holidays.
I interpret the story as, "she" was a different girl for each of the members, and "she" was not meeting any of them, she was a memory of a past relationship that was no more. That's why Tao turns back time for a moment to relive being in the relationship, but then quickly returns to the present because he knows, deep down, he is better off and that you really can't go back in time and expect to fix everything in the relationship. That's why they are all sad and crying because they are heartbroken. I like to think, for example, that the puppy was probably going to be a present for Kai's girlfriend, but now that they have broken up, it just reminds him of her. It's kind of a bittersweet memory. :D
The "miracle" is that the girl had such a profound impact on their life that, even though they aren't together anymore, she will always play a big role in his life history, etc. The "miracle" is that the holidays give you a reason to look back and reflect on those special moments in life, and even though the memories might make them sad because they are no longer able to make new memories together, the old memories are still there. And the "miracle" is that he has now realized she has taught him so much about love and life, but unfortunately, he has realized it too late and he can't go back, so he is sad. He's now upset because he is unable to show her the appreciation she deserves, etc., etc.
And, if you like the studio version of "Miracles in December," just wait until you see them perform this song live in concert. I think you will fall in love with it even more. :D
D.O - Lee Mujin Service
EXO Heaven + Girl×friend + 3.6.5 live and
EXO peter pan + xoxo + lucky + 3.6.5 live stage
2:49 this was Kerry subtly trying to tell you to resume the song😂
5:28 its funny you'd call him that. Bunny is his associated animal. Fans call him Bunnymyeon = Bunny + Junmyeon
7:33 thats Tao😂😂
Watching those old clips of the Killing voice songs I realize the huge improvement in Chen's vocals and even his Korean diction as he sings it blows my mind tbh
The way they deliver their lines play a huge role in how good the song sounds overall I never really paid attention to it until recently... the Killing voice video is a treasure for real
in spite of turning back time Tao was still not able to change the outcome that the girl will still go break up with him /turn him down😢
Depending on my mood, I either cry or feel a twinge in my heart for this song. Thanks for the react
I recommend EXO-unfair live in their Christmas costumes…
Thanks for the reaction ~
+ Chanyeol & Kai are the cry babies in exo 😂❤
Sehun too... All the 3 giants are cry babies 😅
I love that Kerry noticed that Xiumin made it snow in the mv and then she said that Suho got innocent looks like Bunny when in fact Suho's animal avatar is actually Bunny 😂 by the way the one who did time manipulation and even cried at the end is Tao. He's an underrated actor tbh. He showed his acting skills from early on like KyungSoo.
7:21 nope they didn't went back in time but just revived that moment until time resumed at its usual pace, bringing them back to where reality as they realize how their mistakes individually cost them to lose someone they love. Non of them got any happy ending by the end of this mv. You'll realize once you read the lyrics and alos please guys watch Exo-M verison too.❤
I discovered exo much later but I didn't realise how handsome Luhan is, wow that guy is gorgeous. That's why they say exo's visuals are no joke. Thank you for reacting to Exo and making me rediscover them through you guys.
Beautiful and heartfelt reaction, thank you. It's been years since this song and mv was released, and here we are, bawling are eyes altogether at how amazing this song still is. What great Miracle/s in December it is indeed that EXO songs are touching lives even up to this day!!
K-Pop vocal trinity: Chen, Baekhyun, and D.O., collectively Emperors of K-Pop as EXO 💖
EXO has three very strong main vocalists. There is probably no idol group better than them.
Kerry saying that Suho has this bunny eyes!!! She got it! Suho's animal is a bunny!!!! Hes our bunny prince ❤ Merry christmas!!!!
As much as Chen's vocals make tears well up in my eyes but its Chanyeol and Tao's tears towards the end of video that got me 😢 Miracles in December to this day is still my favorite Christmas song. I hope you guys would react to Exo-M version or else you'll miss out on Luhan's vocals.
So beautiful. You are not alone being reduced to tears with this one.
Thank you for your every reaction to our dear EXO 😊. I wished for more reactions about them especially their live performances (in concerts) also their variety shows. You'll definitely enjoy every bit of it. ❤
Auto like for anything EXO. EXO-L' 4 life!!🥰🫶👏👏
If you think this song was beautiful in the MV, wait until you see a live performance of this....OMG.....shivers and tears and feels galore!!!. *kerry glares* I mean.....the tones, the high notes, what a beautiful Christmas Song!!!.... You really should read the lyrics. Basically everyone there was thinking up the perfect gift for their love....and in the end, she wasn't there, Sehun just happened to be the one that showcased the visual of girl meets boy....but all of them were waiting and all disappointed and upset.
ruclips.net/video/Qcjz0NIwg5A/видео.html here is the live version
🤣 😂 🤣 😂 @ Kerry glares 🤣 😂 🤣 😂
Vocal Kings 🎉🎉🎉
Most of SMTOWN MVs don't have English subtitles back then they only started putting subtitles in 2018 and the first MV to have it is EXO’s TEMPO.
Yes, the ONLY Main vocal are singing.
So, while Baekhyun plays the piano for the mv (which he *does* know how to play), Lay would often accompany them on stage and play the piano during the promotions for the song. Some special stages actually included: Lay on the piano + Baekhyun + D.O + Chen + Luhan (who sang the EXO-M version of the song with Chen & Beakhyun)~~~
Christmas Day + The First Snow + Miracles in December Live please!! and happy holidays to you both. You're so adorable!
Yey! Thank you 🙏 That's the vocal trinity of EXO for you. For me, they're top notch! Now, it's time for the live version preferably the Japan one.
Y'know I'm really enjoying your reactions
Please stay genuine, and go about in your way
🎉🎉
Already wake up and see ur reaction, oh my God i'm crying in the Chrismast morning😢
It's funny that you said you think Suho has a bunny look bc he actually is represented in the fandom by a bunny. The other ones are Xiumin - cat, Kai - bear, D.O. - penguin, Chen - dinosaur, Baekhyun - dog, Chanyeol - tiger, Lay - sheep, and Sehun sometimes wolf sometimes baby chick.
During the concerts Chanyeol is the one who cries the most, there are many videos where he gets emotional and cries a lot...
No, they were all at that courtyard to meet their girl, each of them...when the girl disappeared from Sehun, it was to mean the same for each of them there...collectively, as each one prepared gifts and obviously chose that courtyard to meet their own girl. (independent of each other)
Going back in time brings them to a moment in the past when they are meeting up with their girl, but the moment she vanishes, they are in the present, with the stark reminder of their actual reality...they realize their own truths as to their relationships, then each cry to themselves....
As the lyrics suggest, they had a history with this person, had some good times too...but because the boys were not as attentive to their girls in their lives, being self-absorbed to a fault and relying on the girl to just wait for them.. it proved too much for the girl, as she chose to move on.
Taking someone's love for granted can be so easy for some...but it can come at a cost....
The lyrics speak of their book of memories, and their past times together.
💙🌺
Thank you for the reaction guys, you have become my favorite reactors in such a short time:) I wanna recommend Exo Vlive for Love Shot. Vlive is no longer there but the video is on RUclips. It's fun and Christmas-themed so it would be nice.
So this is the EXO-K version actually! Pre-merge EXO-K meant the Korean version of the songs, while EXO-M meant the Mandarin (chinese) version of the song. This song is special because Chen and Baekhyun BOTH sang the K and M version, while D.O. sang only in K and Lu Han (who already left) in M. Other members who didnt sing participate in the music video as npc (idk how to describe it) so you could see Lu Han acting here, while you would see D.O. instead over in the Mandarin version! But there's not much a big difference beside from that and the language it's sung in
This song just breaks my heart just hearing them. It's so good🥺❤️ This is what I love EXO, they can just sit down and sing.❤️
Beautiful reaction 😭❤
It's beautiful sad song, if you can say that. You should read the lyrics. They mention something about their powers. Our lovely bunny Suho. Thank you for keeping your journey with EXO.
I'm crying 😭😭 I love Simon reacting and posing 😂
🤣 😂 🤣 😂 🤣 😂
Merry Christmas~
thank you for the Exo reaction~♡︎
Tips for the future: if it says Korean Ver. It literally means Korean Ver, the Korean Verison of the song. Same with Chinese Ver. Any members can be singing the song, its just in that specifically listed language.
'The War' album was released entirely in chinese and there were no chinese members in it. Lay wasn't promoting with EXO, so it was just the korean members but they sung in chinese.
In the early days ofcourse they were seperated by group. If it's listed as EXO-K/EXO-M its specifically only those group members performing. But you will hardly see that anymore. That period only lasted about 2 years honestly.
Really enjoyed your reaction, thank you 😊
there's another song with just the 3 of them. it's called December 2014 from their 1st live album. not a lot of people are familiar w/ this & even EXO forgot they had this. 😂
I’m so curious of your reaction to Chen beautiful goodbye with subs!
Hope you will also react to Lay's song, Goodbye Christmas too.
Please watch with lyrics then you ll understand emotional delivery in all 3 guys lines are so different
This is a masterpiece song. Chen really impress me a lot.
I love you Exo ❤ love you baekhyuni, Chen ❤, D.O❤
That little baby dog is Kai's dog 🥹🥹🥺
I don't think it is. I think that's a misconception that has spread because it looks like Monggu. Kai had already had all three of his dogs before this MV was filmed. You see all three far more grown in the EXO Showtime episode they appear in which was filmed around the time this mv was.
@@toriecarter2711 aww
Merry Christmas 🎄
You must react to live performances of this.
The live performance is better. And if you want to check the Exo M version, Luhan(former member) sang along side with chen and baekhyun.
Just main vocals singing
Oh actually we call Suho "bunny" lmao
❤
Please please react to the live performance of this vid. Lay playing the piano and luhan is also there.
if it doesn’t say exo-k or m in the title then it’s just the whole group.
Puppy is Kai's
Baekhyun’s bridge part get me goosebumps eveytime
I suggested this live stage with chrismas songs with link..but my comment was REMOVED. Should i be a subscriber to suggest anything for EXO..am not a new EXOL.🙄
Hi there. We did see your comment but I'm afraid we just didn't get a chance to record another video in time for Christmas. We don't remove any comments, so I don't know why it would be gone. Please do keep suggesting ideas for reactions. Almost everything we do is based on comments from viewers. No need to subscribe, you're welcome either way! ❤️
@@alongfortheridereactsi appreciate ur replay...i just wanted u to enjoy every exo's contents we exols r a bit greedy😋..if u dont mind i can send more links for live stages. Ps : new subscriber❤️
We love EXO live stages! Feel free 😊 and welcome to the channel