I’m reading now Fr. Charles’ book about Mother Pascalina and it’s like Murder in 33rd Degree times 10! He’s pulling no punches in that one, talks about the same situations in even more detail. And there’s many beautiful account from Padre Pio, Pius X, Pius XI, Pius XII, Leo XIII. Highly recommend
I sincerely hope that you both have another discussion together about Pope Francis and the confusion resulting regarding many statements. The two of you complement each other and provide a very balanced discussion. I love reading the "Moynihan Letters", and find that Urbi et Orbi Commnications provides a very important dimension that helps understanding.
I just finished your book Fr. Muir. It was very interesting. And I loved the follow-up on all the characters at the end. I thank you Fr. Muir. I love the Letters Mr. Moynihan and I love the periodical.
I've only seen a few of these episodes, but I am very impressed with what I have seen and heard so far. I will do my best to keep current and try to catch up with past episodes. I am particularly impressed with the patience and charitableness of Mr. Moynihan as well as his incredible knowledge and experiences. Tom P from Massachusetts
Pope Francis is gathering quite a motley crew around him-atheists, proabortion protestant theologians; priests such as excommunicated Fr. Rupnik who sexually abused religious sisters
❤I totally agree! How can we be depressed! God has sent His Mother as the General of the Army. If only people would listen to her messages. It’s vital. The job we have to do is pray for the salvation of souls. 💯 %!!
As a Catholic who attends a diocesan TLM (for as long as that will last), I am so sick and tired of being labeled as “angry” by people who don’t know me. I know many, many traditional Catholics and I would never describe them as “angry.” I hope Father Murr misspoke here. We *are* deeply *hurt* by our Holy Father’s antipathy toward us, and are hurt that we are the *only* segment of Holy Mother Church that Pope Francis will not engage in “dialogue” with while he promotes homosexual friendly prelates and speaks of gravely sinful matters with such warmth and acceptance. Traditional Catholics are among the most joyful, devoted people I’ve ever known who simply want to worship God in the Mass our fathers and grandfathers did-the Mass that made millions of saints and for at least a thousand years was considered good and holy. We also pray daily for Pope Francis and ask God to soften his heart toward us. This is heart breaking.
The only solution is pray pray pray the Rosary as our Mother Mary had pleaded for us to do in all her apparitions. I truly love your show, you are God's voice in this confusing time. I love our Catholic church, I truly believe and never doubted that it is the Church our Lord Jesus established on earth no matter who becomes our pope and only our Lord Jesus Christ will make the change we needed at this time.
Felling simultaneously sorry for and perturbed by Pope Paul VI is about the best description of Pope Paul VI I’ve ever heard. He was truly a sort of Shakespearean tragic figure
If I may, but why do you keep it to just 1h? Look at Joe Rogan and his 3-4h long podcast. Who knows how long we’re going to have Charles Murr with us (we can’t be presuming he’ll be here long - that’d be a sin of presumption). Why not invite Charles Murr and just let him speak? Make a series, each as long as it needs to be, let it out to the world and you’ll see that people will watch the entire thing / you’ll be surprised!
What do you think of the thesis of Andrea Cionchi in 'The Ratzinger Code'? I think it is brilliant and helps to endure the current situation much better!
Thankyou for the information, Im still waiting to hear about what happened after Pope Paul VI died, was the next Pope approached in his short term of 33 days with the information Pope Paul the VI was too weak to deal with?
We are confused but Mother Mary at Fatima gave us the weapon the Rosary and the fasting and penance .. am sure we will get the grace And we have to be in sanctifying grace always Used the sacraments and adoration whilst it’s available God is in charge We don’t leave the church because of Judas … no we hang on
Francis said he wants the Church to be honest, transparent and open!?? That’s a joke! That’s the opposite of hispanic characteristics. His actions for the last ten years are the opposite of his statement, another example of hispanic characteristics. They say one thing, but do the opposite. Anyone who has lived in hispanic countries knows this. However, everyone who keeps asking why the pope did what he did does not know hispanic culture. His role model was Juan Perón. The American version is Bill Clinton.
Urbi et orbi Com... ; I'm sorry , but this is the second " Hour Long talk " in which you were to speak about the strange , and " MORE THAN TRAGIC [ DEATH ] , Pope John Paul I , in 1978 , after only 33 days , as Pope . But as it was , the first hour was taken up with , it seems to me just loose " Banter " , reminiscing , about this , and that , and never getting to the point of the " STORY " . Do I have to listen to another , 2 hours before I'll hear the point of the STORY ? John
John, I couldn't agree more. I am flabbergasted by having to of the last witnesses of this era, faithful to the Church, blather on when there are so many other questions at to ask/discuss. Thanks for saying what I was thinking.
Padre Murr’s information and experiences are very interesting. Mr. Moynihan also delivers interesting information, but sometimes speaks so slowly it appears he has finished. Also, he includes too many unnecessary details. It’s enough to know something happened in a particular month and year. Wasting time trying to remember the date is unnecessary.
In Fr. Gobbi’s book our Lady specifically names LeFevre and begs him to stay with John Paul 2, and not to divide the Church because it would snowball out of control. How can Father Muir defend him?
The next Pope should leave Rome and rule the church from the Grand Chartreuse.... locked away in the mountains.... away from the TV cameras... if he has something to say.... make it short and in easily understandable language..... like.... like.... I know..... like Jesus.
Yeah, I'm one of those kids you lost, for 20 years. You people murdered my soul, my entire family, and everyone I grew up with in Catholic School - you people killed me and everyone I knew with your false new Conciliar religion & worship, which is not the same Catholic faith and worship of the ages, and not the birthright that you people stole from us. I'm lucky that I've lived to tell the tale so far, after having been brought back and shown true faith and worship, by a literal miracle in a Latin Mass chapel that showed me the truth and converted me from atheist to devout Traditional Catholic instantaneously, on the spot. I do not care that you are 90-years-old. In fact, it is all the more important for me to tell you the truth, so that you can repent of what you've done and take some kind of responsibility for your role in destroying the Church and losing countless souls, by supporting the evil Dark Church of Apostasy that grew up from the Council. If you have ever attended and supported the diabolic Novus Ordo sect without repenting of that evil, then you need to, or else I will be testifying against you at the Final Judgment, as the negligent homicidal murderer that you are. Everyone associated with that evil sect is a naive idiot at best, who is gravely negligent and guilty of the manslaughter of souls, or else is a liar, a thief, and a willful murderer of souls at worst. There's really no excuse for you people, nothing that gets you off the hook entirely. And any of you who subjected a child to that filth 100% deserves to burn in Purgatory until at least the end of time, because you're filthy child abusers. I grew up in your diabolic Novus Ordo, went to Catholic School my whole life, straight through college, saw the contradiction between the traditional faith and what was being taught after the Council, couldn't stand the tedious, banal, repulsive new Mass, and became an atheist, like 40% of people who graduate from Catholic school these days (the rest become Protestant, or something else). Your new Conciliar religion and worship literally turned me into an atheist. The Catholic faith was supposed to be the Truth, and truth never changes - so when all the sudden it clearly is changing after 1900 years, that discredits the entire religion, and eventually religion and God in general. When something that claims to be the Truth turns out to be a lie, a person get soured on all of it. And part of what turned me into an atheist as well, btw, is your diabolic practice of Communion in the hand. I distinctly remember between the ages of approximately 10 and 17 looking around at Mass and observing how people were receiving Communion, and deciding that nobody was actually taking the Church's teachings seriously and that there was something seriously wrong, because in all that time I had only ever observed one person who treated the Eucharist as if God was present in front of him and as if He was truly receiving God. That person was a young man in his late twenties or early thirties, who knelt on the ground and received on the tongue, despite the fact that there was no kneeler for him. I saw that when I was 10 years old. In comparison, everyone I ever saw before and after that received Communion as if it was no big deal in comparison, like they were just going up for Communion out of habit and formality to get their cracker, which was deeply awkward for them at best. And as a kid I was smart enough to realize that nobody ever refrained from going to Communion, and few people ever went to Confession, and certainly, no priest ever reinforced official Catholic teaching about receiving in the state of Grace from the pulpit, or what a Catholic's obligations were. So clearly, nobody took Catholic teaching seriously, since nobody put it into effect and insisted upon it. So, Deacon, I'm sorry, but I'm not sorry to lay this on you as a 90-year-old. If you have ever had anything to do with that disgusting sect of the Vatican II Novus Ordo, which murdered me for decades and my whole family and everyone I ever knew, then I tell you that you need to repent of your participation in that filth. Go to the true Latin Mass, or to some other ancient rite in communion with Rome, such as the Greek Byzantine Rite, or the Melchite Rite - somewhere where they do not commit the atrocity of Communion in the hand. There is no circumstance under which the Novus Ordo is ever acceptable, other than extreme sacramental emergency. But if you do continue at a Novus Ordo church, then may God hold you accountable for the evil example you set to every child at every Mass you ever participated in there. May you burn for your obstinate evil.
Urbi et Orbi Com ; I'm sorry " AGAIN " , but stimulating ? REALLY ? If you do this again please , please have a " Thought " for your listeners . I don't wish to be unkind , because I'm truly wish to know the end of this story . John
I’m reading now Fr. Charles’ book about Mother Pascalina and it’s like Murder in 33rd Degree times 10! He’s pulling no punches in that one, talks about the same situations in even more detail. And there’s many beautiful account from Padre Pio, Pius X, Pius XI, Pius XII, Leo XIII. Highly recommend
I sincerely hope that you both have another discussion together about Pope Francis and the confusion resulting regarding many statements. The two of you complement each other and provide a very balanced discussion. I love reading the "Moynihan Letters", and find that Urbi et Orbi Commnications provides a very important dimension that helps understanding.
Me too...been looking forward to this talk. Thank you, Fr Muir, Dr Moynihan, and Deb
Another excellent program! I need to know about confession. From start to finish! Thank you and bless you all abundantly!!!!
I just finished your book Fr. Muir. It was very interesting. And I loved the follow-up on all the characters at the end. I thank you Fr. Muir. I love the Letters Mr. Moynihan and I love the periodical.
You all are so awesome and gives me so much hope listening to you thank you very much and God bless
I've only seen a few of these episodes, but I am very impressed with what I have seen and heard so far. I will do my best to keep current and try to catch up with past episodes. I am particularly impressed with the patience and charitableness of Mr. Moynihan as well as his incredible knowledge and experiences. Tom P from Massachusetts
I can't wait for your next program to address the questions of faithful Catholics about our current pontificate!
This is wonderful.✨🙏🏼✨Hail Full of Grace!✨
Thank you!
So sorry I missed the live stream.... Thank you!
You know a man by the people he surrounds himself with, or by the company he keeps!
Pope Francis is gathering quite a motley crew around him-atheists, proabortion protestant theologians; priests such as excommunicated Fr. Rupnik who sexually abused religious sisters
100% sure. I completely agree with your comment and since childhood I realized that statement describes a truth undeniable. 💫💫💫💫💫💫💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
❤I totally agree! How can we be depressed! God has sent His Mother as the General of the Army. If only people would listen to her messages. It’s vital. The job we have to do is pray for the salvation of souls. 💯 %!!
As a Catholic who attends a diocesan TLM (for as long as that will last), I am so sick and tired of being labeled as “angry” by people who don’t know me. I know many, many traditional Catholics and I would never describe them as “angry.” I hope Father Murr misspoke here.
We *are* deeply *hurt* by our Holy Father’s antipathy toward us, and are hurt that we are the *only* segment of Holy Mother Church that Pope Francis will not engage in “dialogue” with while he promotes homosexual friendly prelates and speaks of gravely sinful matters with such warmth and acceptance.
Traditional Catholics are among the most joyful, devoted people I’ve ever known who simply want to worship God in the Mass our fathers and grandfathers did-the Mass that made millions of saints and for at least a thousand years was considered good and holy.
We also pray daily for Pope Francis and ask God to soften his heart toward us. This is heart breaking.
💜💜💜💜💜💜
💯
Amazing stuff, as always.
The only solution is pray pray pray the Rosary as our Mother Mary had pleaded for us to do in all her apparitions. I truly love your show, you are God's voice in this confusing time. I love our Catholic church, I truly believe and never doubted that it is the Church our Lord Jesus established on earth no matter who becomes our pope and only our Lord Jesus Christ will make the change we needed at this time.
Great show! Thanks and keep up the great work!
Thanks for watching!
Looking forward to next interviews......Bravo....xx
Felling simultaneously sorry for and perturbed by Pope Paul VI is about the best description of Pope Paul VI I’ve ever heard. He was truly a sort of Shakespearean tragic figure
Sorry I missed the live stream too...but thank you very much!
If I may, but why do you keep it to just 1h? Look at Joe Rogan and his 3-4h long podcast. Who knows how long we’re going to have Charles Murr with us (we can’t be presuming he’ll be here long - that’d be a sin of presumption). Why not invite Charles Murr and just let him speak? Make a series, each as long as it needs to be, let it out to the world and you’ll see that people will watch the entire thing / you’ll be surprised!
I know I'd watch!!!
There are more questions than answers about those issues broached.
George wrote articles for the American Spectator.
I’d like you to speak about Archbishop LeFebre. Why specifically did he break away?
What do you think of the thesis of Andrea Cionchi in 'The Ratzinger Code'? I think it is brilliant and helps to endure the current situation much better!
Thankyou for the information, Im still waiting to hear about what happened after Pope Paul VI died, was the next Pope approached in his short term of 33 days with the information Pope Paul the VI was too weak to deal with?
Richard Hamilton, Who Voted for Hitler (Princeton UP, 1984) stressed the difference between the Catholic and non-Catholic areas of Germany.
We are confused but Mother Mary at Fatima gave us the weapon the Rosary and the fasting and penance .. am sure we will get the grace
And we have to be in sanctifying grace always
Used the sacraments and adoration whilst it’s available
God is in charge
We don’t leave the church because of Judas … no we hang on
Francis said he wants the Church to be honest, transparent and open!?? That’s a joke! That’s the opposite of hispanic characteristics. His actions for the last ten years are the opposite of his statement, another example of hispanic characteristics. They say one thing, but do the opposite. Anyone who has lived in hispanic countries knows this. However, everyone who keeps asking why the pope did what he did does not know hispanic culture. His role model was Juan Perón. The American version is Bill Clinton.
Urbi et orbi Com... ; I'm sorry , but this is the second " Hour Long talk " in which you were to speak about the strange , and " MORE THAN TRAGIC [ DEATH ] , Pope John Paul I , in 1978 , after only 33 days , as Pope . But as it was , the first hour was taken up with , it seems to me just loose " Banter " , reminiscing , about this , and that , and never getting to the point of the " STORY " .
Do I have to listen to another , 2 hours before I'll hear the point of the STORY ?
John
John, I couldn't agree more. I am flabbergasted by having to of the last witnesses of this era, faithful to the Church, blather on when there are so many other questions at to ask/discuss.
Thanks for saying what I was thinking.
@@timfronimos459 Your welcome ! Jack
Wow. 20 minutes in and fr murr has not been able to speak and I have no ideas what is going on. 😂😂😂😂
Padre Murr’s information and experiences are very interesting. Mr. Moynihan also delivers interesting information, but sometimes speaks so slowly it appears he has finished. Also, he includes too many unnecessary details. It’s enough to know something happened in a particular month and year. Wasting time trying to remember the date is unnecessary.
In Fr. Gobbi’s book our Lady specifically names LeFevre and begs him to stay with John Paul 2, and not to divide the Church because it would snowball out of control. How can Father Muir defend him?
Hogwash. False.
The next Pope should leave Rome and rule the church from the Grand Chartreuse.... locked away in the mountains.... away from the TV cameras... if he has something to say.... make it short and in easily understandable language..... like.... like.... I know..... like Jesus.
You think Jesus’ parables short and simple??
Did you forget the vatican helped nazis escape after the war
Catholic's main purpose of saving souls is not being fulfilled. We are losing our children. Please reply. 90 year old Deacon John.
Yeah, I'm one of those kids you lost, for 20 years. You people murdered my soul, my entire family, and everyone I grew up with in Catholic School - you people killed me and everyone I knew with your false new Conciliar religion & worship, which is not the same Catholic faith and worship of the ages, and not the birthright that you people stole from us. I'm lucky that I've lived to tell the tale so far, after having been brought back and shown true faith and worship, by a literal miracle in a Latin Mass chapel that showed me the truth and converted me from atheist to devout Traditional Catholic instantaneously, on the spot. I do not care that you are 90-years-old. In fact, it is all the more important for me to tell you the truth, so that you can repent of what you've done and take some kind of responsibility for your role in destroying the Church and losing countless souls, by supporting the evil Dark Church of Apostasy that grew up from the Council. If you have ever attended and supported the diabolic Novus Ordo sect without repenting of that evil, then you need to, or else I will be testifying against you at the Final Judgment, as the negligent homicidal murderer that you are. Everyone associated with that evil sect is a naive idiot at best, who is gravely negligent and guilty of the manslaughter of souls, or else is a liar, a thief, and a willful murderer of souls at worst. There's really no excuse for you people, nothing that gets you off the hook entirely. And any of you who subjected a child to that filth 100% deserves to burn in Purgatory until at least the end of time, because you're filthy child abusers.
I grew up in your diabolic Novus Ordo, went to Catholic School my whole life, straight through college, saw the contradiction between the traditional faith and what was being taught after the Council, couldn't stand the tedious, banal, repulsive new Mass, and became an atheist, like 40% of people who graduate from Catholic school these days (the rest become Protestant, or something else). Your new Conciliar religion and worship literally turned me into an atheist. The Catholic faith was supposed to be the Truth, and truth never changes - so when all the sudden it clearly is changing after 1900 years, that discredits the entire religion, and eventually religion and God in general. When something that claims to be the Truth turns out to be a lie, a person get soured on all of it.
And part of what turned me into an atheist as well, btw, is your diabolic practice of Communion in the hand. I distinctly remember between the ages of approximately 10 and 17 looking around at Mass and observing how people were receiving Communion, and deciding that nobody was actually taking the Church's teachings seriously and that there was something seriously wrong, because in all that time I had only ever observed one person who treated the Eucharist as if God was present in front of him and as if He was truly receiving God. That person was a young man in his late twenties or early thirties, who knelt on the ground and received on the tongue, despite the fact that there was no kneeler for him. I saw that when I was 10 years old. In comparison, everyone I ever saw before and after that received Communion as if it was no big deal in comparison, like they were just going up for Communion out of habit and formality to get their cracker, which was deeply awkward for them at best.
And as a kid I was smart enough to realize that nobody ever refrained from going to Communion, and few people ever went to Confession, and certainly, no priest ever reinforced official Catholic teaching about receiving in the state of Grace from the pulpit, or what a Catholic's obligations were. So clearly, nobody took Catholic teaching seriously, since nobody put it into effect and insisted upon it.
So, Deacon, I'm sorry, but I'm not sorry to lay this on you as a 90-year-old. If you have ever had anything to do with that disgusting sect of the Vatican II Novus Ordo, which murdered me for decades and my whole family and everyone I ever knew, then I tell you that you need to repent of your participation in that filth. Go to the true Latin Mass, or to some other ancient rite in communion with Rome, such as the Greek Byzantine Rite, or the Melchite Rite - somewhere where they do not commit the atrocity of Communion in the hand. There is no circumstance under which the Novus Ordo is ever acceptable, other than extreme sacramental emergency.
But if you do continue at a Novus Ordo church, then may God hold you accountable for the evil example you set to every child at every Mass you ever participated in there. May you burn for your obstinate evil.
Urbi et Orbi Com ; I'm sorry " AGAIN " , but stimulating ? REALLY ? If you do this again please , please have a " Thought " for your listeners . I don't wish to be unkind , because I'm truly wish to know the end of this story . John
Complimenting Padre Murr or vice versa is unnecessary.
Originally I admired Archbishop Vigano, but now view him as a half-bizarre figure. Why does he continue to live in hiding?!
Um, he has good reason to fear for his life, for speaking out!
People associated with globalist, naturalist power want him dead.
Are you really that naive?
His life was threatened.