So here’s the comp I would have done… Player A: A Hall of Famer who played with one team during the same era as Mattingly: 1783 games 2304 hits 414 doubles 207 HRs 1085 RBI 965 strikeouts Walked 450 times Batted .318 with an OBP of .360 Slugged .477 w/OPS of .837 7 Gold Gloves Player B: Donnie Baseball: 1785 games 2153 hits 442 doubles 222 HRs 1099 RBI Only 444 strikeouts Walked 588 times Batted .307 with an OBP of .358 Slugged .471 w/OPS of .830 9 Gold Gloves So yeah, Donnie Baseball belongs in the Hall of Fame.
Great comparison. Kirby is a great one too. What seems blaringly obvious is that both Puckett and Koufax had World Series play. I have changed my stance over the years. Mattingly should be in the Hall. And not just saying that because he is my favorite player.
Hands down, he should be a shoe in , he's career may have been short look what he accomplished in that 12 years I mean hell Yankees retired his number they just don't retire any1 #
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
So here’s the comp I would have done…
Player A: A Hall of Famer who played with one team during the same era as Mattingly:
1783 games
2304 hits
414 doubles
207 HRs
1085 RBI
965 strikeouts
Walked 450 times
Batted .318
with an OBP of .360
Slugged .477 w/OPS of .837
7 Gold Gloves
Player B: Donnie Baseball:
1785 games
2153 hits
442 doubles
222 HRs
1099 RBI
Only 444 strikeouts
Walked 588 times
Batted .307
with an OBP of .358
Slugged .471 w/OPS of .830
9 Gold Gloves
So yeah, Donnie Baseball belongs in the Hall of Fame.
Who is player A?
@@CrackpotSports Some guy named Kirby Puckett. ;)
@@esotericcandy8732 Good comparison
Great comparison. Kirby is a great one too. What seems blaringly obvious is that both Puckett and Koufax had World Series play. I have changed my stance over the years. Mattingly should be in the Hall. And not just saying that because he is my favorite player.
I agree, Puckett is another perfect comparisons
Yes he does he was awesome before the injury.
He was one of the best before he hurt his back
Hands down, he should be a shoe in , he's career may have been short look what he accomplished in that 12 years I mean hell Yankees retired his number they just don't retire any1 #
I agree, it shouldn't even be a question about him being in the HOF
Kirby Pucket