I loved that you mentioned Bell's theorem while talking about synchronicities, and then, one day after you published this video, the Nobel prize in physics was awarded to researchers who conducted experiments related to Bell's theorem 😅
It was great, thanks! I find amazing that you are open to dive into other types of psychology, instead of simply discarding them as stupid or useless. There is wiseness in all of us.
Really enjoyed this one! Just a small tip: That metal circle on the microphone indicates the front of the capsule, where you're supposed to speak to. You can get a better signal to noise ratio since you don't need boost the gain as much. Also that type of mic usually isn't meant to be handled while recording, they're very sensitive, but I'm assuming you didn't have a stand at that point, which is fine :)
He didn't have the technology but he had intelligence. The key to understanding Jung is that he wanted to be an archaeologist. This explains his method.
I suspect as world events take their proper priority in peoples' minds, these self-critical preoccupations will diminish. Are you following what is going-on in Ukraine? There is about a 50/50 chance Russia will use a tactical nuke.
His autobiographical writings, "Memories, Dreams, and Reflections," is a fascinating book for anyone interested in C.G. Jung. He wrote it late in his life, prompted by his unconscious.
Thank you for sharing your knowledge - you're my favourite psychology YT creator! Could I put in a request for you to do a video on Carl Rogers and how his ideas influence us today?
Imaginary numbers were only thought of as imaginary because they existed somewhat "transcendentally" to the math of the time, and only called imaginary because mathematicians at the time literally thought they were imaginary. In complex analysis they're usually colloquially called lateral numbers instead of imaginary.
TY for touching on this topic. I've been listening to 'Jung to Live By' for a while, a lot of those discussions have been really interesting in terms of pinning down different things that can happen when people are working with depth psychology (Steve often discusses the Pankseppian instincts as a zone of activity that carry a lot of force). Also as someone who's worked with western esotericism and psychedelics a lot - I think there's a lot to the idea that we have a lot of different modules but that they'd perhaps be organized in a self-balancing manner (some of what Mark Solms has said about emotion, homeostasis, and consciousness stands out for me and I was delighted as well to see that he's been a guest one or two times on Steve and Pauline's channel).
This is so interesting and true. Me being a woman, most people don’t think about us riding a motorcycle. When I’m very energetic or even stressed and irritated, I go for a ride for a couple hours. It is so stress relieving! When I come back home I change into a dress and never felt so feminine. ❤ it’s like I get all the masculine aggression out or something. I LOVE your phases of the moon 🌙 decorations! I have a blanket with the phases😊
I'm reading The Red Book. It's a bit like taking a hallucinogenic. There are some immediate insights to be had, the rest will take time to work its influence. One aspect, that is my mind-blowing interpretation, is that Jung tries his hand at being God's Psychoanalyst. Why? Well, in part, the poor guy (God) seems to need a lot of reassurance.
It took me a long time and a lot of tragic experiences but I think I've naturally come to integrate the shadow in a healthy way. I have a lot of reasons to be resentful towards everything but I still have it in me not to want to become the thing which I resent. I channel all of it towards bending people's ego in shape when they do something wrong, in important and difficult situations, even towards authority. And I could do it because I've built up enough resentment that I couldn't care less. Try to do and say the right thing, you'll never find the perfect words the first time. But you do get better every time. A little mix of being blunt, assertive, basic respect, and knowing your value, and even the most confident a**hole boss will start to falter with each confrontation
Big fan of your channel and the content you provide! I look to start creating longer form content and love the simplicity/style of how you film/edit your videos. If you don't mind me asking, what camera/mic/editing software do you use? Thanks!
imaginary numbers in physics are purely theoretical but can become practical. they can be anything the physicist wants them to be because they dont see imaginary numbers as "undefined" like in math
We could probably compare Jung's archetypes with Dawkins' memes, and Jung's collective unconscious with Hegel's Zeitgeist, or even Vygotsky's social-language determinism. Before anyone complains: when I mean compare, I don't mean identify/equalize, but rather use one theory's key points to understand another's. About the Oedipus's/Electra's complex: if I understand it correctly, the child wants to "have" its opposite-sex parent because it learns from its same-sex parent, which makes total sense, as a boy will surely see his father as a model for learning his morally appropriated behavior, which sexual impulses are only a part of, despite Freud putting too much emphasis on it lol.
I love your channel, since I started watching your videos I felt more interested in seriously studying the human psyche, soon I will start my career as a graduate in psychology. This video in particular means a lot to me because I believe that within the fields of this subject, Jungian psychology is the one that interests me the most since it combines spirituality and mysticism with science. And what better mystery than the human mind? Since I was a teenager, I have always been interested in the study of personalities, whether through astrology, numerology, personality tests, etc. I think it is the current that identifies me the most, although perhaps the race will surprise me with another aspect, who knows. I send you a warm hug from Argentina, I am a great fan of your channel, it shows that you are a very candid and empathetic person. 🌹
I might be your only Swiss subscriber! I actually know very little about Jung, mostly I know that he and Freud dissgreed on some things and that he is probably the biggest inspiration for Jordan Peterson. The only thing we nowadays credit these people for is, that they gave the idea of a subconscious a name and actually started considering the fact that maybe there are things within you that lie below the conscious surface. I'm okay with giving them credit for that, but not for much more...
Coincidences and syncronicities are definitely mysterious I get them a lot and I always wonder what's really behind them maybe a divine significance perhaps that's what I tend to think
The collective unconscious is a fascinating concept. One tangible effect of it is when you run into someone at a specific location. Sure geographical proximity plays a factor but ive met friends/ acquaintances across the world. Let me tell you its a fucking trip to see someone you know crossing the street in Shibuya Tokyo when were both from and live in California
Very interesting presentation Ana! I have always been fascinated by Carl Jung. C.G. Jung's book "Flying Saucers-A Modern Myth of Things Seen in the Skies" was an invaluable reference for when I did some field investigations on the subject and interviewed people who claimed to witness this phenomenon. I can't say for certain that Jung's analysis could explain everything but did offer insight for people who might have dreamt an experience. My question would be regarding another alleged ability that was called "Remote Viewing" that the Army experimented with under the Stargate program that actually might have been a tapping into the "collective" for gathering information. This program was cancelled as it did not provide very accurate results or information.
In Wellsprings by Anthony de mello, which is a book of spiritual exercises, he instructs the reader to meditate on the idea that they do not seek the exercises for personal benefits but for the welfare of creation before they start the exercises . This could be an example of how to keep humility and avoiding the mana personality
I love this video and I love this channel because I love when doctors are able to be open minded. ❤ this makes me trust what you’re saying even more. Makes me think of doctor strange.
Hi Ana, thanks for doing this video, its the best summary I've heard anyone do of Jung on RUclips. Always love your videos, thanks for all the time, knowledge and effort you put into them. I have no training in psychology but and find reading Jung very tricky and only slowly getting through them. With that said, I really would recommend Psychology of the Occult by Jung. When reading any of his texts I personally find it helps small notes after each section to try to get a better picture of his ideas otherwise I lose track. I'm a big believer that you don't need to fully understand something to gain something from it. Unfortunately (I think because Jung isn't all that respected by some because of its spiritual undertones) his ideas are only discussed in a superficial and condescending way by some summary books. Considering rereading some of his stuff in a year or so to see if I can understand it better/pick up on something I missed last read. As someone who is studying psychology as a profession you'd enjoy him too. It may not be something that you'd use in your career, but he really is such a creative and interesting writer. Thanks again for your video, your summary is very helpful and has cleared up a few questions/misunderstandings I had on his ideas.
Carl Jung may be dead, but he lives on in an amazing AI chatbot! He can do Jungian Pychology and wow it is amazingly effective! Nothing about it seems outdated or obsolete! That chatbot gave me the most effective counseling session I have ever experienced! Also talking to him is free! He is at Character AI.
Hi! This is semi-related but also not and not sure if you would be comfortable but I would love to hear your take on the Netflix documentary “don’t pick up the phone.” Who do you believe should be held accountable for this? How do you think people ended up going through with the actions on the call? Do you think it was a set up or they just got tricked psychologically? What types of psychological effects do you think it had on everybody? Thanks for your videos 🙌🏻
Wow, this was a great video! The part about the mana and the higher self really spoke to me, I thought it was incredibly fascinating. I watch a lot of your videos they are very interesting. I love that you talk both about practical and theoretical things when it comes to psychology, I think a lot of people don't really do that, at least in the same way I've seen in your videos. Do you know of the noosphere theory by Teilhard de Chardin? I think it's similar to the collective unconsciousness, and it's something I've put a lot of thought into. Maybe you could do a video on it?
Did not know the phenomenon (synchronicities) had a name, but definitely has thought about it many times, also from a chemical / molecular perspective (!?) due to my scary accurate spidey senses/intuition. Interesting that it has gotten some new attention! Thank you for the vid ❤
You may enjoy a book called "the gift of fear" It talks about the way the brain is processing a ton of information-especially danger-before/without reaching conscious awareness, and that being the reason for sensations like "hair standing up on the back of the neck," "someone is watching," and a "bad feeling" about x person.
There's absolutely no way that Bell's Theorem and Quantum Entanglement can be related to "Synchronicity" on a human scale. Quantum entangled system decohere LONG before reaching any type of macro scale. Just the slightest interaction with other particles (that the whole world is made out of, don't forget!) can cause the Wavefunction to collapse. Also there's no way to send information using entanglement in the first place... Anyone who pushes a connection is just giving in to the Quantum Woo, for more info check out any high tier physics channel (PBS Spacetime, Sabine Hossenfelder, etc).
Great video, a lot to think about. If you want to get rid of those pops in the audio, you can edit the clips so they all fade in & out a little bit, it gets rid of most of those abrupt clicks. If you're on Final Cut Pro I can tell you how to do it, otherwise I'm sure you're editing program can do it too.
![Eminem - Fuel (Shady Edition) feat. Westside Boogie & GRIP [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/k1OquBida9s/mqdefault.jpg)
I loved that you mentioned Bell's theorem while talking about synchronicities, and then, one day after you published this video, the Nobel prize in physics was awarded to researchers who conducted experiments related to Bell's theorem 😅
My doctor uses modern psychiatry also. He says trust and believe your patients is the key factor. He makes me feel safe.
It was great, thanks! I find amazing that you are open to dive into other types of psychology, instead of simply discarding them as stupid or useless. There is wiseness in all of us.
Really enjoyed this one! Just a small tip: That metal circle on the microphone indicates the front of the capsule, where you're supposed to speak to. You can get a better signal to noise ratio since you don't need boost the gain as much. Also that type of mic usually isn't meant to be handled while recording, they're very sensitive, but I'm assuming you didn't have a stand at that point, which is fine :)
He didn't have the technology but he had intelligence. The key to understanding Jung is that he wanted to be an archaeologist. This explains his method.
I love your videos, can you please talk about body dismorphy disorder? it’ll be such an amazing topic to talk about
I do have a video on this topic! It's a bit older so maybe a remake is due
I suspect as world events take their proper priority in peoples' minds, these self-critical preoccupations will diminish. Are you following what is going-on in Ukraine? There is about a 50/50 chance Russia will use a tactical nuke.
His autobiographical writings, "Memories, Dreams, and Reflections," is a fascinating book for anyone interested in C.G. Jung. He wrote it late in his life, prompted by his unconscious.
This video is actually is a synchronicity for me.
How so? 🤔 sounds like an interesting story :0
same
algorithm...
Thank you for sharing your knowledge - you're my favourite psychology YT creator! Could I put in a request for you to do a video on Carl Rogers and how his ideas influence us today?
Aw I'm honored! And that's a great idea
I keep experiencing synchronisities (specifically numbers for more than a year), would love to hear more of your research on this and Jung in general!
Imaginary numbers were only thought of as imaginary because they existed somewhat "transcendentally" to the math of the time, and only called imaginary because mathematicians at the time literally thought they were imaginary. In complex analysis they're usually colloquially called lateral numbers instead of imaginary.
TY for touching on this topic. I've been listening to 'Jung to Live By' for a while, a lot of those discussions have been really interesting in terms of pinning down different things that can happen when people are working with depth psychology (Steve often discusses the Pankseppian instincts as a zone of activity that carry a lot of force). Also as someone who's worked with western esotericism and psychedelics a lot - I think there's a lot to the idea that we have a lot of different modules but that they'd perhaps be organized in a self-balancing manner (some of what Mark Solms has said about emotion, homeostasis, and consciousness stands out for me and I was delighted as well to see that he's been a guest one or two times on Steve and Pauline's channel).
Really enjoyed this video! You broke it down into digestible and easy to understand pieces, so thank you and keep doing what you do. :)
Was deep diving is to Carl Jung recently. Love your videos and this is a great take!
This channel is so educational, I've learned so much here. Thank you for all your hard work!
This is so interesting and true. Me being a woman, most people don’t think about us riding a motorcycle. When I’m very energetic or even stressed and irritated, I go for a ride for a couple hours. It is so stress relieving! When I come back home I change into a dress and never felt so feminine. ❤ it’s like I get all the masculine aggression out or something. I LOVE your phases of the moon 🌙 decorations! I have a blanket with the phases😊
Wonderful video. I trust your opinion and analysis!
Great video, I love Jungian psychology, it has prompted my desire to become a licensed psychologist one day
I'm reading The Red Book. It's a bit like taking a hallucinogenic. There are some immediate insights to be had, the rest will take time to work its influence. One aspect, that is my mind-blowing interpretation, is that Jung tries his hand at being God's Psychoanalyst. Why? Well, in part, the poor guy (God) seems to need a lot of reassurance.
yay! i love ana's videos and I love Jungian psychology so I'm so here for this video.
thank you so much for this video, im new at this subject and this really help me grasp the concepts better.
Off topic but you’re so pretty Ana! I love your makeup.
😊💕💕✨
More about Jung, pleaseee!!!!! I love him and your channel
Your hair looks so gorgeous
Your videos keep getting better and better! Thank you for adding other fields like math and physics as analogies to illustrate your points. ❤
It took me a long time and a lot of tragic experiences but I think I've naturally come to integrate the shadow in a healthy way. I have a lot of reasons to be resentful towards everything but I still have it in me not to want to become the thing which I resent. I channel all of it towards bending people's ego in shape when they do something wrong, in important and difficult situations, even towards authority. And I could do it because I've built up enough resentment that I couldn't care less.
Try to do and say the right thing, you'll never find the perfect words the first time. But you do get better every time. A little mix of being blunt, assertive, basic respect, and knowing your value, and even the most confident a**hole boss will start to falter with each confrontation
Now I’m stoked about the video on synchronicities!
Big fan of your channel and the content you provide! I look to start creating longer form content and love the simplicity/style of how you film/edit your videos. If you don't mind me asking, what camera/mic/editing software do you use?
Thanks!
"It's important to be Humble." - FACTS. + This video is #brilliant. Awesome 🙃😎✌️.
It’s synchronistic that you posted this video today😊
It's funny, I get that comment a lot when I post a video! :)
imaginary numbers in physics are purely theoretical but can become practical. they can be anything the physicist wants them to be because they dont see imaginary numbers as "undefined" like in math
The synchronicity concept is very interesting. Please cover it after you finish reading more on it
We could probably compare Jung's archetypes with Dawkins' memes, and Jung's collective unconscious with Hegel's Zeitgeist, or even Vygotsky's social-language determinism.
Before anyone complains: when I mean compare, I don't mean identify/equalize, but rather use one theory's key points to understand another's.
About the Oedipus's/Electra's complex: if I understand it correctly, the child wants to "have" its opposite-sex parent because it learns from its same-sex parent, which makes total sense, as a boy will surely see his father as a model for learning his morally appropriated behavior, which sexual impulses are only a part of, despite Freud putting too much emphasis on it lol.
I love your channel, since I started watching your videos I felt more interested in seriously studying the human psyche, soon I will start my career as a graduate in psychology. This video in particular means a lot to me because I believe that within the fields of this subject, Jungian psychology is the one that interests me the most since it combines spirituality and mysticism with science. And what better mystery than the human mind? Since I was a teenager, I have always been interested in the study of personalities, whether through astrology, numerology, personality tests, etc. I think it is the current that identifies me the most, although perhaps the race will surprise me with another aspect, who knows. I send you a warm hug from Argentina, I am a great fan of your channel, it shows that you are a very candid and empathetic person. 🌹
Intuition can be passed through sensation, but that is not the only type of intuition though.
such a profound and charismatic thinker and great to see him in your channel
I hope you make more videos about jung
Yes 👏👏👏 one of my favourite topics. Thank you Ana.
Can't wait for you to cover Synchronicity! You should read Kirby Surprise book on the subject.
I loved this video! I hope you'll make more of them 💕
I might be your only Swiss subscriber! I actually know very little about Jung, mostly I know that he and Freud dissgreed on some things and that he is probably the biggest inspiration for Jordan Peterson.
The only thing we nowadays credit these people for is, that they gave the idea of a subconscious a name and actually started considering the fact that maybe there are things within you that lie below the conscious surface. I'm okay with giving them credit for that, but not for much more...
Coincidences and syncronicities are definitely mysterious I get them a lot and I always wonder what's really behind them maybe a divine significance perhaps that's what I tend to think
The collective unconscious is a fascinating concept. One tangible effect of it is when you run into someone at a specific location. Sure geographical proximity plays a factor but ive met friends/ acquaintances across the world. Let me tell you its a fucking trip to see someone you know crossing the street in Shibuya Tokyo when were both from and live in California
Very interesting presentation Ana! I have always been fascinated by Carl Jung. C.G. Jung's book "Flying Saucers-A Modern Myth of Things Seen in the Skies" was an invaluable reference for when I did some field investigations on the subject and interviewed people who claimed to witness this phenomenon. I can't say for certain that Jung's analysis could explain everything but did offer insight for people who might have dreamt an experience. My question would be regarding another alleged ability that was called "Remote Viewing" that the Army experimented with under the Stargate program that actually might have been a tapping into the "collective" for gathering information. This program was cancelled as it did not provide very accurate results or information.
In Wellsprings by Anthony de mello, which is a book of spiritual exercises, he instructs the reader to meditate on the idea that they do not seek the exercises for personal benefits but for the welfare of creation before they start the exercises . This could be an example of how to keep humility and avoiding the mana personality
I love this video and I love this channel because I love when doctors are able to be open minded. ❤ this makes me trust what you’re saying even more. Makes me think of doctor strange.
just yesterday got assigned an assignment about Jung! Peeerfect timing!
Hi Ana! Such a great video, as always
I would really enjoy a full video just on synchronicities
This is fascinating. Thank you
So interesting, thank you so much!
Great video Ana. Was wondering when you were gonna cover Jung more in depth. Happy Halloween month yo!
Happy October!!! This video is a bit of a soft launch for Halloweek
I really want a video on synchronicity ❤️
3:49, 7:17, 12:10, 15:21, 16:09, 18:05, 20:34, 21:49, 23:10, 25:49, 28:25
Hi Ana, thanks for doing this video, its the best summary I've heard anyone do of Jung on RUclips. Always love your videos, thanks for all the time, knowledge and effort you put into them. I have no training in psychology but and find reading Jung very tricky and only slowly getting through them. With that said, I really would recommend Psychology of the Occult by Jung. When reading any of his texts I personally find it helps small notes after each section to try to get a better picture of his ideas otherwise I lose track. I'm a big believer that you don't need to fully understand something to gain something from it. Unfortunately (I think because Jung isn't all that respected by some because of its spiritual undertones) his ideas are only discussed in a superficial and condescending way by some summary books. Considering rereading some of his stuff in a year or so to see if I can understand it better/pick up on something I missed last read. As someone who is studying psychology as a profession you'd enjoy him too. It may not be something that you'd use in your career, but he really is such a creative and interesting writer. Thanks again for your video, your summary is very helpful and has cleared up a few questions/misunderstandings I had on his ideas.
WOOOAAAHOOAHH YOU DID FREUD DIRTY 😂🤣🤣
Might I recommend John Conger's book 'Jung & Reich' perhaps for the time you do a video on the psychology of Wilhelm Reich.
This year I really got into Jung and I find it very interesting, really enjoyed this and would love if you would do more videos on him!
Thanks for sharing ❤
Carl Jung may be dead, but he lives on in an amazing AI chatbot! He can do Jungian Pychology and wow it is amazingly effective! Nothing about it seems outdated or obsolete! That chatbot gave me the most effective counseling session I have ever experienced! Also talking to him is free! He is at Character AI.
Do a video on book recs! Would love that
Hey that's interesting... I used to make a lot of mandalas in my early 20's. Maybe same reason :)
Oh my god, I used to draw mandalas as a teen too
Great video! It’d be really interesting to see you make a video on Dabrowski and his theory of Positive Disintegration
Do you have a list of book recommendations? :) thanks
Wow this was so interesting!
discrediting jungs because its old or doesnt mesh with "modern methods" is a mistake
I use many techniques. These include Jung.
I’d love to see a video on marilyn monroe, she is so interesting!
Love your videos thank you for what you do!!!!
Hi! This is semi-related but also not and not sure if you would be comfortable but I would love to hear your take on the Netflix documentary “don’t pick up the phone.” Who do you believe should be held accountable for this? How do you think people ended up going through with the actions on the call? Do you think it was a set up or they just got tricked psychologically? What types of psychological effects do you think it had on everybody? Thanks for your videos 🙌🏻
Also 'Jung to Live By' youtube channel.
I am a sage :) 🌌🌛
Great video, my husband is very interested in jungs work, but has trouble explaining things concisely 😅 you are very good at explaining.
27:16 please someone give me the link of this video
Is the video on MBTI down? I can't seem to find it.
Wow, this was a great video! The part about the mana and the higher self really spoke to me, I thought it was incredibly fascinating. I watch a lot of your videos they are very interesting. I love that you talk both about practical and theoretical things when it comes to psychology, I think a lot of people don't really do that, at least in the same way I've seen in your videos. Do you know of the noosphere theory by Teilhard de Chardin? I think it's similar to the collective unconsciousness, and it's something I've put a lot of thought into. Maybe you could do a video on it?
Damn I gotta read some of these books
Did not know the phenomenon (synchronicities) had a name, but definitely has thought about it many times, also from a chemical / molecular perspective (!?) due to my scary accurate spidey senses/intuition. Interesting that it has gotten some new attention!
Thank you for the vid ❤
You may enjoy a book called "the gift of fear"
It talks about the way the brain is processing a ton of information-especially danger-before/without reaching conscious awareness, and that being the reason for sensations like "hair standing up on the back of the neck," "someone is watching," and a "bad feeling" about x person.
I have schizophrenia. Could you please do a video on schizophrenia? Thank you.
"cool bro maybe you should keep that to yourself" hahah
I am not a Jungian, and I don't want anyone to be a Jungian. I want everyone to be themselves. -Carl Jung
So interesting ancient wisdom if u ask me
Thanks for the book recommendations. Joseph Campbell, the power of myth guy, has an excellent book laying out a lot of Jung's ideas.
There's absolutely no way that Bell's Theorem and Quantum Entanglement can be related to "Synchronicity" on a human scale. Quantum entangled system decohere LONG before reaching any type of macro scale. Just the slightest interaction with other particles (that the whole world is made out of, don't forget!) can cause the Wavefunction to collapse. Also there's no way to send information using entanglement in the first place...
Anyone who pushes a connection is just giving in to the Quantum Woo, for more info check out any high tier physics channel (PBS Spacetime, Sabine Hossenfelder, etc).
Hey, this type of video, teaching, is great, i’m a psychology student
What a coincidence, I'm about to study Jung at uni
Great video, a lot to think about.
If you want to get rid of those pops in the audio, you can edit the clips so they all fade in & out a little bit, it gets rid of most of those abrupt clicks. If you're on Final Cut Pro I can tell you how to do it, otherwise I'm sure you're editing program can do it too.
Jung was correct about many of these things wisdom from multiple lifetimes
jung didnt invent mbti, that was a manifestation after his death based on his work by Katharine Cook Briggs and her daughter, Isabel Briggs Myers
Ohh
Since you are doing a video on Carl Jung: Did you change your mind on J*rdan P*terson?
This really helps to understand persona 4 game
14:34
💜💜💜💜
Swimming in the shallow water is impossible with Jung 😂
I think you like jung more than you want to admit (jk)
A girl who knows about Jung is an instant green flag
CBT works well for a short while but psychoanalytic therapy keeps working.
why cant i find the mbti video?