I am a Brazilian living in Canada, currently attending university and my professor will make Paulo's work a vital part of the course. I am so proud of my country!
@@revelation3679 That's correct, I forget which Marxist from the Frankfurt School wrote about the "praxis" of Critical Theory. I believe it was Herbert Marcuse.
@@Sk8erBhai It's not an act of love to indoctrinate children with false and toxic ideas, even if you give it that label. People like to give nice sounding labels to the things they do. You need to instead look at what they are actually doing.
Very helpful - thank you for making this! The background audio was incredibly distracting though and I found myself wanting to turn it down so I could focus on what you were saying a bit better.
A helpful note on Brazilian pronuciation. Recife is pronounced Heh-SEE-fee. Initial Rs in BRAZILIAN Portuguese are pronounced like our H when followed by a vowel.
@@Eu-Abreu From a Brazilian ... You don’t know what you are talking about Brasil! Educate yourself before you speak. Ask a Brazilian, go to Brasil. Listen to Brazilian music, watch some Brazilian videos. Brasil is not Portugal.
@@Eu-Abreu Brazilians in Recife talking about Recife: ruclips.net/video/H-WdVvl401E/видео.html You don’t have to take my word for it. Go to the source.
Now that you added the BRAZILIAN next to Portuguese I can tell you that you are right to certain accents of Brazilian Portuguese. You have Portuguese speak population in Europe Africa and Asia that don't pronounce things like you said.
It would be excellent if it were more revealing of what Freire actually did. He was a Marxist and a promoter of violent revolution. Critical Pedagogy is a tool to that end. It doesn’t actually help people on the lower end of power and wealth spectrum to gain more skills and progress to higher levels of existence, whatever they choose that to be.
Marx and Hegel were his influences? I mean anyone who says Karl Marx (an avowed atheist and deconstructionist) is an influence in how they develop their world view, I wouldn't put much stock in their philosophy.
Yup, it ran Brazil to dust, instead of studying cognitive load and behaviour psychology, they still shove his polarizating bs down everyone's throat until the entire country became possesed by ideology and always on the edge for any kind of fight or "revolution". Well, Brazil is a continental country full of amazing brilliant people that spearheaded a lot of tecnology that are remarkeable, but they are the exception as the whole majority is a corrupted mass drowned into marxism and corruption that the expectation of becoming one of the 3 biggest and most influential economies of the world by 2010 couldn't be more delusional. There's a lot of issues that ruined Brazil's future, but Education is problably what made everything possible... What a clown world, the whole politcal scenario is like a circus. The doutrination hit so hard that everyone can be easily manipulated, they care more about what they belive than what must be truth or right to do. What to expect when the philosophy of your educational system is based on conflict and learning how you are opressed and how to spress everyone else so you stay in the crab bucket?
@boomp: yes. Marx was a lazy individual that never worked and sponged off of other people. Just like the people that aspire to raising “social consciousness”
It's easy to understand, the goal is to produce marxist critical theorists who will go on to the perpetual revolution, there is nothing about education.
A educado brasileira está entre as piores do mundo . Ainda bem que o mundo não aplicam seu método nas escolas . Brazil has the worst education in the world. Thank god Paulo Freire methods was not accepted in USA
I was in Poland visiting a University to discuss about Bauman, the main subject changed when they discover that I am a Brazilian researcher, same happened in Norway, and other countries, so don't be the "vira-lata" ;) The best Freire's researchers are from Brazil.
Got it... "Communist" makes people think of starvation and Gulags, but "Critical" sounds like "Critical Thinking". So, now we revere Karl Marx, founder of Criticism.
@@Meatchop The latest example in a pattern? There was once an idea called "Critical Thinking" that everyone agreed was a necessary skill. Now, there seem to be a bunch of ideas called "Critical X" that all seem to boil down to "Down with the oppressive Bourgeoisie", but conceptualize the Bourgeoisie as a different cross section of the populace. Tell me how conscientizaçao is not just a superset of Marxism.
Sometimes I wonder if a lot of why this ideas get so much pushback is bc they were developed in times/places that were just different than where they’d typically be applied now. I just don’t think they’re universally applicable and should probably be used to inform a curriculum, but not to construct one
@@CartoonsEComicsStudio apesar da sua ironia e da afirmação generalizada, o nosso país têm muitos teóricos incríveis da educação. Entretanto, o nosso péssimo índice não se justifica a partir dessas pessoas, mas sim pela ausência delas. Lembrei até de uma frase do educador José Pacheco, idealizador da Escola da Ponte em Portugal, quando ele diz que no Brasil se tem a melhor educação do mundo, assim como a pior destacando o ensino que vai na contramão de Paulo Freire, Rubem Alves, Darcy Ribeiro...
@@Ewerthonlucas Formado em pedagogia que ja levou uma facada nas costas de um aluno Teoria não eh! pratica na prática tá uma merda . P.S Nunca mais piso numa escola vYGOSTIK/FREIRE na vida .
@@CartoonsEComicsStudio O Método Paulo Freire não é implementado no Brasil. A culpa não é dele que a educação tá uma merda. Sabe que países implementam o método crítico do Paulo Freire em sua educação? Finlândia, Alemanha e Coreia do Sul. Ele é venerado e aclamado no mundo inteiro, facilmente o intelectual brasileiro mais reconhecido no exterior. Só o próprio país de origem dele que transformou ele em um bode expiatório para todos os problemas com a educação brasileira, mesmo ele possuindo influência minúscula no sistema pedagógico nacional. Mentiram pra você, meu amigo. É muito fácil culparem um morto pelos problemas do país do que culpar os vivos.
To restrict or subdue. So to prevent someone from doing something. It literally comes from the meaning "to press against/press down". Think like a rasta; "downpress".
@@DarkAngel2512 isn't that what mother nature does all the time? You surviving is a miracle all it's own. So is mother nature a form of oppression? Is someone not agreeing with your views a form of oppression? Is just being alive mean you will feel oppressed? Is that feeling just a choice that can be detached from reality, er, mother nature? Is being afraid to die a choice trying to escape oppression?
@@AstroSquid I personally wouldnt apply oppression to nature. Oppression comes from intent. Disagreeing with someone doesnt prevent them from doing stuff. Not sure if you're coming at me with the "disagreeing is oppression" because you've mistook me for a far leftie. I'm a moderate. I was trying to clarify what oppression is vs what they might claim it to be. Them trying to silence others speech is oppression. Someone having an opinion isnt.
@@DarkAngel2512 Yeah, agreed, for the far left oppression has different meanings. Intent is perfect normal way of trying to identify oppression, but the other way is to look at outcome, which is what the far left do. The funny thing is they hide their definitions. I pretty much a liberal, but I guess I'm a moderate now.
@@AstroSquid I didnt label myself ten years ago as I had no idea about the labels. I wasnt heavy into politics and had no idea what a democrat, Republican was. I'm from UK. And I didnt really know the diff between Tory and Labour either. I think these labels dont even match the reality that much as most people have a mix of values. My friend was against abortion but was perfectly fine smoking weed whilst pregnant whilst my values on that were the other way around. I had friends who were like me, working class (I say working class but many werent working atall) but they were Jamaican and homophobic whilst I wasnt. Back then we didnt have all this labels madness.
The fault I find in Freire is exactly because whe equated the superiority of teachers in the banking system of education with the oppressor. It is a marxist (or "marxidized") way of seeing things which is, in itself, a shortsighted way of doing so. The superiority of the teacher needs to be affirmed for the very reason we need authority in class (and I think socialists normally confuse authority with authoritarianism). And it shows, in Brazil, how much students don't respect teachers anymore, since they consider their teachers as their equals and nothing more...
The reason behind the misbehaving of students has nothing to do with seeing teachers as "their equals". It's a coping mechanism of marginalized communities that see aggressiveness and competition as a way to survive the world they live in, apart from other cultural values.
@@majorserg Yo, Sergio, I noticed a contradiction in your statement, those who treat each other as equals, as a rule, respect each other. According to Freire, if the student does not see the teacher as an equal, it is a sign that he is not capable of exposing or sharing his own reality. This is the objective of what Freire calls "Word", used as a purpose in "generative theme". Sir, theres a problem, but not with Freire statement, but with us, the teachers... If you need to show your autority, even with your own kids, means u lack something to touch them, something like being in their place, even metaphysically.
@@pedrohenriquecalsavara7094 In teaching, equality is not good. If the student does not recognize the authority of the teacher, he will not obey the instructions, such as be quiet, open the book, listen, say things, not to turn around, etc. In Brazil, where I live, students not only see their teacher without any respect, but when they are rebuked, they call their parents who come to school and PUNISH the teacher for calling their attention. No contradiction in what I said. Equality in dignity is not the same as equality of rank.
The instructor I had who was teaching critical consciousness said students had deformed psyches. The man is a sociopath and the school is forcing students to agree to marxist politics. It was horrible. I despise Paulo Freire and the school.
@@sprucewayne10 Yeah, but how well? It is very hard to learn how to read as an adult. Furthermore, comparing adult-adult learning relationships to adult-child is disingenuous.
This ideology teaches WHAT to think, not HOW to think, playing with the fire of marxism... “If you give a man a fish, you feed him for a day. If you teach a man to fish, you feed him for a lifetime.”
The very concept of education presumes hierarchy. You assume that one party has information that the other doesn't have. Without this assumption, no one is educating anyone; someone is manipulating their equals to agree with them even though their ideas have no more validity. I mean... you can believe that, but if you also believe this process is "Love", I think you're a "monster".
This is pure brainwashing. Of course, the student isn’t “forced” to believe, as the teacher is only the “facilitator”. Remember, solidarity (group think) is essential! Sick!
A better way to frame your question would be as a statement; Because of Paulo Freire, African Americans still struggle with the colonial past.” It’s interesting you used the word “struggle”.
It's incredible how easy it is to fool people into supporting bad ideas by simply using words like "love." I would prefer teachers not needing to "love" kids in order to educate them, much less cripple them with delusions of oppression.
I agree, there is a lot of information! The upper limit of this video assignment was 5 minutes; I wanted to do justice to the subject. If you turn the speed down to .75, it might be easier to follow. Thanks for watching! ❤️
@@doraeliaruiz1636 I did before I watched this video. Neuroscience shows that many people learn via different modalities. Does someone pay you to run around bullying people online?
It's tragic how Paulo Freire is a champion of education and pedagogy all over the world except for the country where he came from. But considering the culture and values of that country. It's not surprising. Disappointing, but not surprising.
@@nanav9200 it's because his horrible marxification of education was a blight on Brazil, and you're an evil oppressor marginalizing their lived experiences of being utterly abused by the system. How. Fucking. Dare. You.
Oh don't worry, the rest of the world is hardly aware of him yet, in many ways thanks to videos such as this one. Though they are aware of the subversive nature of the doctrine and the failing education that follows, not to mention the polarisation of society. Slowly but surely the rest of the world is waking up to it though, the connections will be made and i expect he will be seen with contempt pretty much everywhere given time.
@@dbelow_1556 I lived in Brazil for ,26 years of my life I've yet to see a school that uses his method. You might find it in Public and Private Universities. But if you'd care to enlighten me about any schools that use the Freire method, I'd oblige
It was a shocker to hear in this video that in the USA the state of Arizona "banned" Paulo Freire's book. Banning works of expression is clearly unconstitutional. Nobody could make such a claim about the geographical areas of the USA. So this video is terribly wrong for stating this as a fact !!! Now on the other hand, if you are referring to books restricted from prisoners in the State of Arizona by their department of corrections, well that's a different story. Prisoner's don't get to choose 'to do' or 'not to do' many options of life. I think the world accepts that concept. The reason for the prisoner's ban on "Predagoy of The Oppressed" was based on pre-existing rules which aim to omit materials from the prison system which may influence aggression against the prison staff. Weather or not this specific ban on Freire's book was correct or not is left up to debate. Nonetheless, the USA does not ban books. They can't !
While you are probably philosophically correct about the constitutionality of such an action, you are unfortunately very incorrect about the banning of books in the United States! From Wikipedia: "In 2006, Pedagogy of the Oppressed came under criticism over its use by the Mexican American Studies Department Program at Tucson High School. ... The book was among seven titles officially confiscated from Mexican American studies classrooms, sometimes in front of students, by the Tucson Unified School District after the passing of HB 2281." Further information on Arizona's efforts to ban books, including Pedagogy of the Oppressed, can be found here: www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/cifamerica/2012/jan/18/arizona-banned-mexican-american-books
@@theliterarycritic Playing fast and loose with the facts. To say the state of Arizona has banned his book without any further clarification is imo deceitful. This lack of clarification would imply to most viewers that the ban is somehow universal in scope within the state of AZ. That is not the case. This book is not banned in that way at all. It is banned as classroom content in public elementary and secondary schools and that is it. All Critical Theory (including Critical Pedagogy) is crappy neo-marxian religion based on a conspiracy theory.
99.99% of books are "banned" (not included) from schools because they're somehow inappropriate for classroom needs. It's not some great insult to the book not to include it in classrooms
@@theliterarycritic There is a big difference between the state prohibiting you from buying a book and reading it on your own time, and the state refusing to pay for a book to be provided and taught to you in a state school. To ignore this difference is either remarkably stupid or remarkably dishonest.
I am from Brasil
I am proud about Freire❤
you love your dog, I get it.....
I am a Brazilian living in Canada, currently attending university and my professor will make Paulo's work a vital part of the course. I am so proud of my country!
As a Brazilian living and studying in America I feel extremely proud to watch this video about the work and life of Paulo Freire ❤
But! Critical Theory is not being taught in American schools...
It is being taught in schools, but we're working on getting it banned.
Subtle correction: it is not being taught, per se, but practised, enacted.
Critical Theory demands its application not simply it’s teaching
@@revelation3679 That's correct, I forget which Marxist from the Frankfurt School wrote about the "praxis" of Critical Theory. I believe it was Herbert Marcuse.
@@revelation3679 critical praxis, per se
@Koen Dietrich touché! Praxis
Thank you.... Short but very detailed
There is absolutely no mention of his communist politics or his admeration for Marxism. Its kind of wierd how they LEFT that out, pun intended.
Education is an act of love... thats an amazing thought
And that book gets banned.
Love is too dangerous. Lets just promote hate instead
@@Sk8erBhai It's not an act of love to indoctrinate children with false and toxic ideas, even if you give it that label. People like to give nice sounding labels to the things they do. You need to instead look at what they are actually doing.
@@ian_b I agree and I do not support teaching any kind of religion to children.
Let's ruin genetations in the name of love, everything sounds good in the name of love yay!
Excellent video, thank you for sharing that!
Arizona banned Pedagogy of the Oppressed? Yikes!
Inspiring!
Communism
Beautiful explanation. Contents are chosen very concisely & brilliantly. Thanks 👍.
There is no mention to his communist politics or his Ties to Marxism. Weird how they left that out. Pun intended
Cheer~~~the branch of science concerned with the formation, nature, ecology, and classification of soil---soil science.😊
Sources (listed at the end) wikipedia, wikipedia, wikipedia, wikipedia, and some other sources including youtube. Great...
Thats how you know its pro commie lol!
Very helpful - thank you for making this! The background audio was incredibly distracting though and I found myself wanting to turn it down so I could focus on what you were saying a bit better.
A helpful note on Brazilian pronuciation. Recife is pronounced Heh-SEE-fee. Initial Rs in BRAZILIAN Portuguese are pronounced like our H when followed by a vowel.
From a Portuguese... You don't know what you are talking about!
@@Eu-Abreu From a Brazilian ... You don’t know what you are talking about Brasil! Educate yourself before you speak. Ask a Brazilian, go to Brasil. Listen to Brazilian music, watch some Brazilian videos. Brasil is not Portugal.
@@Eu-Abreu Brazilians in Recife talking about Recife: ruclips.net/video/H-WdVvl401E/видео.html You don’t have to take my word for it. Go to the source.
Listen to Brazilian pronunciation of Recife: ruclips.net/video/_TVNmcdU5Jc/видео.html
Now that you added the BRAZILIAN next to Portuguese I can tell you that you are right to certain accents of Brazilian Portuguese.
You have Portuguese speak population in Europe Africa and Asia that don't pronounce things like you said.
Also, shout out to Antonia Darder and Peter McClaren!
Love the concise breakdown!
Lo
excellent video!! very educational and entertaining.
It would be excellent if it were more revealing of what Freire actually did. He was a Marxist and a promoter of violent revolution. Critical Pedagogy is a tool to that end. It doesn’t actually help people on the lower end of power and wealth spectrum to gain more skills and progress to higher levels of existence, whatever they choose that to be.
Marx and Hegel were his influences? I mean anyone who says Karl Marx (an avowed atheist and deconstructionist) is an influence in how they develop their world view, I wouldn't put much stock in their philosophy.
He was also inspired by Mao. Enough said. To think this guys work is some of the most popular books in education scares me.
It's neomarxist trash. Read some Marcuse and you will understand how crazy these people are.
Yup, it ran Brazil to dust, instead of studying cognitive load and behaviour psychology, they still shove his polarizating bs down everyone's throat until the entire country became possesed by ideology and always on the edge for any kind of fight or "revolution". Well, Brazil is a continental country full of amazing brilliant people that spearheaded a lot of tecnology that are remarkeable, but they are the exception as the whole majority is a corrupted mass drowned into marxism and corruption that the expectation of becoming one of the 3 biggest and most influential economies of the world by 2010 couldn't be more delusional.
There's a lot of issues that ruined Brazil's future, but Education is problably what made everything possible... What a clown world, the whole politcal scenario is like a circus. The doutrination hit so hard that everyone can be easily manipulated, they care more about what they belive than what must be truth or right to do. What to expect when the philosophy of your educational system is based on conflict and learning how you are opressed and how to spress everyone else so you stay in the crab bucket?
Have you studied Karl Marx's works?
@boomp: yes. Marx was a lazy individual that never worked and sponged off of other people. Just like the people that aspire to raising “social consciousness”
Awesome!
Very inspiring
Even brazilians don't understand it yet. It's a shame!
Sad but it’s true.. I’m leaning about it now in the college
@@ambardebora3135 learn it quickly, before Jair closes your university too
It's easy to understand, the goal is to produce marxist critical theorists who will go on to the perpetual revolution, there is nothing about education.
A educado brasileira está entre as piores do mundo . Ainda bem que o mundo não aplicam seu método nas escolas .
Brazil has the worst education in the world. Thank god Paulo Freire methods was not accepted in USA
I was in Poland visiting a University to discuss about Bauman, the main subject changed when they discover that I am a Brazilian researcher, same happened in Norway, and other countries, so don't be the "vira-lata" ;) The best Freire's researchers are from Brazil.
Got it... "Communist" makes people think of starvation and Gulags, but "Critical" sounds like "Critical Thinking". So, now we revere Karl Marx, founder of Criticism.
What were you watching
@@Meatchop The latest example in a pattern? There was once an idea called "Critical Thinking" that everyone agreed was a necessary skill. Now, there seem to be a bunch of ideas called "Critical X" that all seem to boil down to "Down with the oppressive Bourgeoisie", but conceptualize the Bourgeoisie as a different cross section of the populace.
Tell me how conscientizaçao is not just a superset of Marxism.
@@colindupee I think you should do some of your own reading.
@@Meatchop you should read anything other than marxist theory
@@Meatchop Open your mind. ruclips.net/video/HAQdYE8rQPI/видео.html
Great content, but why are Freire and his family depicted as white in the cartoons?
Sometimes I wonder if a lot of why this ideas get so much pushback is bc they were developed in times/places that were just different than where they’d typically be applied now. I just don’t think they’re universally applicable and should probably be used to inform a curriculum, but not to construct one
Orgulho do Brasil!
E é sim olha que beleza ta a nossa educação , aumentamos 16 vezes nossos investimentos desde 88 e só piora
@@CartoonsEComicsStudio apesar da sua ironia e da afirmação generalizada, o nosso país têm muitos teóricos incríveis da educação. Entretanto, o nosso péssimo índice não se justifica a partir dessas pessoas, mas sim pela ausência delas.
Lembrei até de uma frase do educador José Pacheco, idealizador da Escola da Ponte em Portugal, quando ele diz que no Brasil se tem a melhor educação do mundo, assim como a pior destacando o ensino que vai na contramão de Paulo Freire, Rubem Alves, Darcy Ribeiro...
@@Ewerthonlucas Formado em pedagogia que ja levou uma facada nas costas de um aluno Teoria não eh! pratica na prática tá uma merda .
P.S Nunca mais piso numa escola vYGOSTIK/FREIRE na vida .
@@CartoonsEComicsStudio não entendi.
@@CartoonsEComicsStudio O Método Paulo Freire não é implementado no Brasil. A culpa não é dele que a educação tá uma merda. Sabe que países implementam o método crítico do Paulo Freire em sua educação? Finlândia, Alemanha e Coreia do Sul.
Ele é venerado e aclamado no mundo inteiro, facilmente o intelectual brasileiro mais reconhecido no exterior. Só o próprio país de origem dele que transformou ele em um bode expiatório para todos os problemas com a educação brasileira, mesmo ele possuindo influência minúscula no sistema pedagógico nacional.
Mentiram pra você, meu amigo. É muito fácil culparem um morto pelos problemas do país do que culpar os vivos.
Um monstro sagrado
Hahahah tão sagrado que nem um país aprova seu método . Só ficou no Brasíl péssimo
@@MarleneNotsoB In USA Henri Giroux got Paulo Friere into all the schools of education. Giroux also got Friere into churches
I would respect this video more if it went into the details of why this is banned in Arizona
Because it's Marxism and Critical Race Theory. We're working on getting banned in all of the country.
ruclips.net/video/uHdJJthdGUk/видео.html
it was banned because it is seen as a radical marxist ideology under the guise of being “critical” and crt is being fought back against.
What identifies oppression?
To restrict or subdue. So to prevent someone from doing something. It literally comes from the meaning "to press against/press down". Think like a rasta; "downpress".
@@DarkAngel2512 isn't that what mother nature does all the time? You surviving is a miracle all it's own. So is mother nature a form of oppression? Is someone not agreeing with your views a form of oppression? Is just being alive mean you will feel oppressed? Is that feeling just a choice that can be detached from reality, er, mother nature? Is being afraid to die a choice trying to escape oppression?
@@AstroSquid I personally wouldnt apply oppression to nature. Oppression comes from intent. Disagreeing with someone doesnt prevent them from doing stuff. Not sure if you're coming at me with the "disagreeing is oppression" because you've mistook me for a far leftie. I'm a moderate. I was trying to clarify what oppression is vs what they might claim it to be. Them trying to silence others speech is oppression. Someone having an opinion isnt.
@@DarkAngel2512 Yeah, agreed, for the far left oppression has different meanings. Intent is perfect normal way of trying to identify oppression, but the other way is to look at outcome, which is what the far left do. The funny thing is they hide their definitions.
I pretty much a liberal, but I guess I'm a moderate now.
@@AstroSquid I didnt label myself ten years ago as I had no idea about the labels. I wasnt heavy into politics and had no idea what a democrat, Republican was. I'm from UK. And I didnt really know the diff between Tory and Labour either. I think these labels dont even match the reality that much as most people have a mix of values. My friend was against abortion but was perfectly fine smoking weed whilst pregnant whilst my values on that were the other way around. I had friends who were like me, working class (I say working class but many werent working atall) but they were Jamaican and homophobic whilst I wasnt. Back then we didnt have all this labels madness.
just a dumb question is this considered a theory?
The fault I find in Freire is exactly because whe equated the superiority of teachers in the banking system of education with the oppressor. It is a marxist (or "marxidized") way of seeing things which is, in itself, a shortsighted way of doing so.
The superiority of the teacher needs to be affirmed for the very reason we need authority in class (and I think socialists normally confuse authority with authoritarianism). And it shows, in Brazil, how much students don't respect teachers anymore, since they consider their teachers as their equals and nothing more...
The reason behind the misbehaving of students has nothing to do with seeing teachers as "their equals". It's a coping mechanism of marginalized communities that see aggressiveness and competition as a way to survive the world they live in, apart from other cultural values.
@@LucianoAguiarS But...if they saw their teachers as worthy of respect and superiors, they would not misbehave. So it does have to do with it.
@@majorserg Yo, Sergio, I noticed a contradiction in your statement, those who treat each other as equals, as a rule, respect each other. According to Freire, if the student does not see the teacher as an equal, it is a sign that he is not capable of exposing or sharing his own reality. This is the objective of what Freire calls "Word", used as a purpose in "generative theme". Sir, theres a problem, but not with Freire statement, but with us, the teachers... If you need to show your autority, even with your own kids, means u lack something to touch them, something like being in their place, even metaphysically.
@@pedrohenriquecalsavara7094 In teaching, equality is not good. If the student does not recognize the authority of the teacher, he will not obey the instructions, such as be quiet, open the book, listen, say things, not to turn around, etc.
In Brazil, where I live, students not only see their teacher without any respect, but when they are rebuked, they call their parents who come to school and PUNISH the teacher for calling their attention.
No contradiction in what I said. Equality in dignity is not the same as equality of rank.
@@pedrohenriquecalsavara7094 No, it's quite possible to see someone as an equal and yet have little to no respect for them.
Make a video of PF and people who look like the people where he is from. Smh
Excellent synopsis!!
The instructor I had who was teaching critical consciousness said students had deformed psyches. The man is a sociopath and the school is forcing students to agree to marxist politics. It was horrible. I despise Paulo Freire and the school.
In all places this theory has been tried, how well did it work for education of the people? I'll wait...
He taught 300 adult slaves how to read and write in 45 days, dawg lol
@@sprucewayne10 they weren’t exactly slaves, but the fact they learn how to read is true 😂
@@sprucewayne10 Yeah, but how well? It is very hard to learn how to read as an adult.
Furthermore, comparing adult-adult learning relationships to adult-child is disingenuous.
It has been very successful. Look how woke marxism has infiltrated and subverted western culture
Probably about as well as Marxist theory has worked in all the places it was attempted!
This ideology teaches WHAT to think, not HOW to think, playing with the fire of marxism...
“If you give a man a fish, you feed him for a day. If you teach a man to fish, you feed him for a lifetime.”
Critical pedagogy doesn't mean teaching critcal thinking it means teaching marxist ideology
The very concept of education presumes hierarchy. You assume that one party has information that the other doesn't have. Without this assumption, no one is educating anyone; someone is manipulating their equals to agree with them even though their ideas have no more validity.
I mean... you can believe that, but if you also believe this process is "Love", I think you're a "monster".
well said
No one educates anyone else nor do we educate ourselves, we educate one another in communion in the context of living in this world.
Freire
@@midletonartsfestival Is there anything this man has ever said that isn't patently absurd?
@@midletonartsfestival "no one educates anyone else, but we educate each other" were you programmed to invent riddles?
@@midletonartsfestival Educate yourself. watch?v=HAQdYE8rQPI&list=TLPQMDMxMTIwMjJdC2szKtTPPA&index=1
This is pure brainwashing. Of course, the student isn’t “forced” to believe, as the teacher is only the “facilitator”. Remember, solidarity (group think) is essential! Sick!
According to paulo freire, do you think african education still struggles with the colonial past?
Yes... Definitely still employ banking method of teaching
A better way to frame your question would be as a statement;
Because of Paulo Freire, African Americans still struggle with the colonial past.”
It’s interesting you used the word “struggle”.
Arizona banned his book!? How Very unAmerican.
It was a beautiful thing
Good.
ruclips.net/video/uHdJJthdGUk/видео.html
I guarantee the book is here and being taught at ASU to teachers
the most evil pedagogist of all.
There is absolutely no mention of his ties to marxism and his communist politics.
Lmao how?
It's incredible how easy it is to fool people into supporting bad ideas by simply using words like "love." I would prefer teachers not needing to "love" kids in order to educate them, much less cripple them with delusions of oppression.
THIS IS SO MUCH INFORMATION ENTIRELY TOO QUICKLY.
I agree, there is a lot of information! The upper limit of this video assignment was 5 minutes; I wanted to do justice to the subject. If you turn the speed down to .75, it might be easier to follow. Thanks for watching! ❤️
Then quit being lazy, get off RUclips and read his work
@@doraeliaruiz1636 I did before I watched this video. Neuroscience shows that many people learn via different modalities. Does someone pay you to run around bullying people online?
@@doraeliaruiz1636 This was a very unnecessary, kinda hostile, and unproductive comment.
Paulo Freire, PRESENTE ✊🏻
You are Marx’s Useful Idiot. Just hope you are aware of that.
The information is good but how fast you speak is distracting
So much praxis..
I am a huge Cornel West fan! I did not know he was influenced by Friere's teachings! Super interesting
I'm a fan of Cornel too, and I'm disappointed as well he's influenced by Marxist Critical Education.
Pretty informative thank you!
thanks commie!
👎👎🏽👎🏿
Commie bs
so communism.
🙌🏻 🙌🏻
P
What a monster.
Sooooooooo fast
It's tragic how Paulo Freire is a champion of education and pedagogy all over the world except for the country where he came from.
But considering the culture and values of that country. It's not surprising. Disappointing, but not surprising.
its because familiarity breeds contempt
@@nanav9200 it's because his horrible marxification of education was a blight on Brazil, and you're an evil oppressor marginalizing their lived experiences of being utterly abused by the system. How. Fucking. Dare. You.
Oh don't worry, the rest of the world is hardly aware of him yet, in many ways thanks to videos such as this one. Though they are aware of the subversive nature of the doctrine and the failing education that follows, not to mention the polarisation of society. Slowly but surely the rest of the world is waking up to it though, the connections will be made and i expect he will be seen with contempt pretty much everywhere given time.
@@dbelow_1556 I lived in Brazil for ,26 years of my life
I've yet to see a school that uses his method. You might find it in Public and Private Universities. But if you'd care to enlighten me about any schools that use the Freire method, I'd oblige
@@peixeserra9116 your anecdote isn't evidence
It was a shocker to hear in this video that in the USA the state of Arizona "banned" Paulo Freire's book. Banning works of expression is clearly unconstitutional. Nobody could make such a claim about the geographical areas of the USA. So this video is terribly wrong for stating this as a fact !!! Now on the other hand, if you are referring to books restricted from prisoners in the State of Arizona by their department of corrections, well that's a different story. Prisoner's don't get to choose 'to do' or 'not to do' many options of life. I think the world accepts that concept. The reason for the prisoner's ban on "Predagoy of The Oppressed" was based on pre-existing rules which aim to omit materials from the prison system which may influence aggression against the prison staff. Weather or not this specific ban on Freire's book was correct or not is left up to debate. Nonetheless, the USA does not ban books. They can't !
While you are probably philosophically correct about the constitutionality of such an action, you are unfortunately very incorrect about the banning of books in the United States!
From Wikipedia: "In 2006, Pedagogy of the Oppressed came under criticism over its use by the Mexican American Studies Department Program at Tucson High School. ... The book was among seven titles officially confiscated from Mexican American studies classrooms, sometimes in front of students, by the Tucson Unified School District after the passing of HB 2281."
Further information on Arizona's efforts to ban books, including Pedagogy of the Oppressed, can be found here: www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/cifamerica/2012/jan/18/arizona-banned-mexican-american-books
@@theliterarycritic
Playing fast and loose with the facts.
To say the state of Arizona has banned his book without any further clarification is imo deceitful.
This lack of clarification would imply to most viewers that the ban is somehow universal in scope within the state of AZ.
That is not the case. This book is not banned in that way at all.
It is banned as classroom content in public elementary and secondary schools and that is it.
All Critical Theory (including Critical Pedagogy) is crappy neo-marxian religion based on a conspiracy theory.
The state has no right to free speech. The video grossly mis-represented the “banning”.
99.99% of books are "banned" (not included) from schools because they're somehow inappropriate for classroom needs. It's not some great insult to the book not to include it in classrooms
@@theliterarycritic There is a big difference between the state prohibiting you from buying a book and reading it on your own time, and the state refusing to pay for a book to be provided and taught to you in a state school. To ignore this difference is either remarkably stupid or remarkably dishonest.
Note to self: Never go to Arizona
That is why Brazilian education is #1 in the world!!!
Well...
lol
well brazil’s dictorship kick him out before he could much
Go to these reality gore sites and you'll see it's a 💩hole country and brutes
@@carolm6523 Thank GOD
🤮 hard pass!
WTF Arizona?
ruclips.net/video/uHdJJthdGUk/видео.html
Great teacher
Can I get to know your Instagram account 🙂