@@Shri100percent The smartphone you're using now to type and read these comments, is a product of massive child labour and slavery. We are also a part of the problem, knowingly and unknowingly.
@@Demonsidedog yes exactly , showing this video will do nothing for kids , maybe making global warming a subject will but will u increase school time , or take away time from another subject for that
River? More like the atmospheric ocean with us dwelling at the bottom with the sun powering it's restless currents that bring the rain that keeps us alive.
Squint your eyes during the magic hour when the sun is going down the water droplets above you are backlit by the sun at that point, sunlight moving from the sunset would light up the water in the sky.
This quote hits hard "The Earth does not expect you to save her,she expects you to respect her" Forever etched in my heart, mind, and soul Thanks a lot, Ted-Ed Keep up the amazing work👌👌👌
The Earth balances out everything, regardless of whether humans respect it or not. Since humans have been ruining the balance of our enclosed ecosystem, the nature is restoring it. The balancing process might look cruel to humans, but we just have to go through it
@@containedhurricane What's happening now feels more like "I guess this are the consequences of my own actions" than "the earth is just balancing itself". But I guess it's just a feeling, definitely not something that's been researched and proven to be true.
And that expectation isn't for Earth's sake. It's for our sake. She was here before humans. If humans are insane enough to make her uninhabitable to themselves and therefore go extinct, guess who will still be here: Earth. We grossly mistake our cleverness for intelligence. It's the antithesis of intelligence when it disregards the whole of what Life, the Universe and Earth herself are teaching and have taught us. The most truly intelligent people are like those natives, whatever continent they may be on. Modern culture has sold its intelligence and indeed its soul for cleverness and social, political, and societal games its collective mind cooks up.
It is interesting how indigenous people have done a better job of conservation. Some people say that they have no accomplishments but I would count this in itself as an accomplishment. They have shown more far-sightedness when it comes to the future and our liveability in the environment than most others who prioritized short term financial greed.
Which indigenous people? They're not a monolith, every civilization in Mesoamerica had different practices. Quite a few in the Amazon practiced slash and burn because charcoal was really the only way to make jungle soil suitable for agriculture, called "terra preta". Which is basically the same thing as they're doing now, it was just on a smaller scale. If the Aztecs had the technology and hundreds of millions of mouths to feed they probably would be doing something similar. They were willing to sacrifice thousands of people a year for good harvests I doubt they would balk at cutting down trees en masse instead. Plus, they already did cut down lots of trees for agricultural purposes. It just wasn't at a scale big enough to constitute an ecological disaster. All of the most powerful Mesoamerican civilizations engaged in a lot of geoengineering of their surroundings. Clearing out fields, cutting irrigation ditches and water reservoirs, building farm terraces, building chinampas, etc. All of which involved cutting down trees. Again it just wasn't at a scale that caused much damage because their populations were much smaller than today.
@@barahngVocê tem razão. A população humana cresceu demais. Talvez estejamos maiores que os dinossauros, portanto com risco de extinção. Não parece que estejamos perto de alguma solução para que isso não ocorra.
It’s truly very eye opening. Modern industrialization paints itself as the epitome of intelligence and evolution, yet it destroys the ecosystem which will ultimately destroy us. They make indigenous people out to be simple-minded people, yet they know deeply the importance of sustainability and reverence for other life forms. They have ancient earth knowledge.
Absolutely love how this video seamlessly weaves together stunning art, well-researched content, captivating narration, and a truly enchanting soundtrack.❤️
Seeing the title, I immediately thought of Skypiea. It follows then, that I am surprised to find out that the nation who fought for the protection of these flying rivers and the rainforests, is also called Wampis.
Yes! Eiichiro Oda is making a masterpiece for this and future generations. He is channelizing lessons of how to be human beings connected with the all.
I saw a quote recently, I'm paraphrasing. "why would you assume giving land back to Indigenous people means displacing others?" Many have become so poisoned by the idea of land ownership Vis a Vis colonisation as opposed to land stewardship by Indigenous people
to free indigenous people you would have to dismantle the united states government and that really scares people who cant imagine not living in a genocidal capitalist empire, and also people who make being american their only personality trait
Nobody has to be displaced, give back the land to the original natives to preside over, and everyone else just lives there, too. Like nothing happened, problem solved. There should be no reservations or "our land and their land" things going on. Basically, the reverse version of assimilation. Instead of the native nations assimilating into the major nation, it's the other way around or at least full autonomy given to the tribes and reservations.
loved this combination of an ecology and culture lesson! the description of the sky rivers themselves did make me think though, what differentiates this process from that of clouds?
Clouds are part of this process. The river metaphor is basically just describing the consistent flow of large amounts of water, it's doesn't actually happen in discrete channels like a river. Rather, it's the air over a jungle (or other high-transpiration area) in general being higher in moisture (though still only a small fraction of the air is water vapor, about 4% at the very most) and getting blown in certain directions by prevailing winds. It's basically using the metaphor of a river to explain the aerial part of the water cycle. I feel like the video does well at expressing that the vegetation is very important to maintaining precipitation patterns and its clearance is immensely disruptive, but it did really poorly at actually explaining why that is and how it works, creating new misconceptions.
You know what is better finding out that the warmer the planet gets the more rain we will have around the globe and with a +10°C of climate change in the next centuries the Sahara deserts might start to have new forest growing
Wow, this video is mind-blowing! I had no idea about the concept of flying rivers in the Amazon rainforest. It's fascinating to learn about these invisible waterways and how essential they are to sustaining life on Earth.
It's so fascinating to learn about flying rivers. As an Indian, it reminds me of a native cultural term, "Aakasa Ganga', which literally means 'sky river'.
I hope this video helped a lot to open the eyes of everyone about various indigenous peoples around the world who are victims of modernizations and industrializations of companies and their own government.
This proves that keeping our trees around is essential to getting water around and to life on this planet. Destroy the trees we truly destroy ourselves.
As a Brazilian I am honored to live in a country that posses an environment so beautiful as the Amazon rainforest. If you are a foreigner reading this, come to Brazil and enjoy the hikes here.
This is why I absolutely adore Ted-Ed for bringing out gem pieces like this one, so people with little knowledge would learn more and understand better about this place we call home 🌍💖🙏
Me too. In my opinion, the health of the earth is money. In reality.... The health of the earth is wealth. If stocks equaled conserved land every one would be a millionaire.
Who cares about the natives lol? Why should I treat the Inuits with privilege in my house just because the land had Inuit descent? When they clearly killed other tribesmen for it and then got killed for it?
It isn't just the government, they're doing it because the corporations that demand more resource usage for their customers are basically paying off people to clear the way. Vote with your wallet and don't buy from companies that destroy the rain forest
The indigenous communities in South America are constantly facing threats! It is the same here in Brazil! We must protect the indigenous people and ensure they continue preserving the forests in South America
What people tend to not understand is that we aren't trying to save the earth. The earth will still be here with or without us. The slogan should be "save HUMANITY, plant a tree."
I knew forest transpired water vapor, but I didn't know it was on such a vast scale and has such a huge impact on weather. 'Flying River', what a concept!. It was encouraging to see that in the last election, Brasil turned away from right wing authoritarianism and back toward a more pro-environmental government. Good for Brasil and good for the planet.
In fact, both governments don't care about the Amazon, so much so that 2023 had one of the worst deforestation rates in history. They use "green propaganda" to get elected and win votes of the poor population.
A philosophical recognized conclusion says: that, those who take the best care of it are the rightful owners. The land thrives when it is actually owned as part of ones self. With love. Not possessed like a simple possession
I remember Bahirathan, the king, meditated for years, asking Siva the God to bring the sky river Ganga to earth. I thought sky river is just for mythology, but here I am, hearing Sky River is always there.
Animation is so Beautiful.. I feel that Environment..😍very proud moment when I saw Upamanyu Bhattacharya's name in the description..this animated & Directed by Indian studio.
Thats an incredible approach and I hope its adopted wherever possible as soon as possible. So many of the critical processes we're destroying are so intangible.
and ironically it is many of those who claim to love Him who are doing the most damage, and in His name, too. brazilian farmers and ranchers often profess to enact genocide on the Native peoples in the Name of God. bitter, bitter irony.
Fantastic educational video without hitting the viewer over the head Never heard of this tribes predicament before nor the sky river drying up due to forest clearing! 👏👏👏👏
Read 'Braiding Sweetgrass'. Humans have been here for hundreds of thousands of years. Indigenous folk have honored the human tradition of living in a fully mutually beneficial collaboration with nature for the bulk of that history. Money is VERY new to our species, and wildly corrosive. If we do not let go of money, then humans truly WILL find their end...but we don't _have_ to end, for things to be well for both us and nature. Not by a long shot.
The claim at 4:27 sounds outlandish. A quarter of the world's land? Should give some sources in the description. (Not found in the linked Dig Deeper section either)
"Oh, what a whimsical and fascinating beauty"
"Ofcoarse we're killing it"
Who's we? Blame the right people instead of the ordinary person
@@Shri100percent You think they'd be in power if majority of us had a spine?
@@Shri100percent
The smartphone you're using now to type and read these comments, is a product of massive child labour and slavery.
We are also a part of the problem, knowingly and unknowingly.
That is what Average Europe and American see the original world
Of course!
This needs to be taught at schools and shown on the media, in general. People need to understand the importance of the forests for our very survival.
Or just go on RUclips. You show this video in school u forget about it the next day lol just like I’m sure u did 4 month layer … 🎭 tic
AND the importance of recognizing and supporting the indigenous peoples who protect those forests!
Wont happen, industrial lobbying prevents it to avoid having more complains
@@mmakotal4388🥲 one day, you will forget being young 😭
@@Demonsidedog yes exactly , showing this video will do nothing for kids , maybe making global warming a subject will but will u increase school time , or take away time from another subject for that
A flying river?! That sounds like a fantastical and magical environmental feature in a fantasy world. Very inspiring.
(me a dnd dm) hmmmmm *takes notes*
River? More like the atmospheric ocean with us dwelling at the bottom with the sun powering it's restless currents that bring the rain that keeps us alive.
Squint your eyes during the magic hour when the sun is going down the water droplets above you are backlit by the sun at that point, sunlight moving from the sunset would light up the water in the sky.
same thoughts!! id love to incorporate flying rivers into future worldbuilding
The visual animation is amazing
This quote hits hard "The Earth does not expect you to save her,she expects you to respect her"
Forever etched in my heart, mind, and soul
Thanks a lot, Ted-Ed
Keep up the amazing work👌👌👌
It amazes me how so many people see basic respect as a chore instead of the bare minimum UnU
The Earth balances out everything, regardless of whether humans respect it or not. Since humans have been ruining the balance of our enclosed ecosystem, the nature is restoring it. The balancing process might look cruel to humans, but we just have to go through it
@@containedhurricane What's happening now feels more like "I guess this are the consequences of my own actions" than "the earth is just balancing itself".
But I guess it's just a feeling, definitely not something that's been researched and proven to be true.
And that expectation isn't for Earth's sake. It's for our sake. She was here before humans. If humans are insane enough to make her uninhabitable to themselves and therefore go extinct, guess who will still be here: Earth. We grossly mistake our cleverness for intelligence. It's the antithesis of intelligence when it disregards the whole of what Life, the Universe and Earth herself are teaching and have taught us. The most truly intelligent people are like those natives, whatever continent they may be on. Modern culture has sold its intelligence and indeed its soul for cleverness and social, political, and societal games its collective mind cooks up.
@@leirumf5476😮p
The animation is phenomenal... felt like I was reading/watching a graphic novel
It was made with a lot of drawings to make many scenes, which required a huge effort from a creative team
@containedhurricane Yeah, being an anime fan, I'm aware of the animation process... Even the smallest of clips need so much work and effort 🫣🫣
You will be proud to know that it's done by an Indian only
@@ForteExpresso yeah I know, I saw the details in the description ✨️✨️
@@containedhurricanejnm?1vda❤ qq 0 , hamen 4v hu
whoever animated this is a legend
Animators:
Rishav Mohanty
Upamanyu Bhattacharyya
@@hiarunkumar oh wow i see :0
its great to see fellow brown ppl creating art for everyone to see :D
Ikr its beautiful
It is interesting how indigenous people have done a better job of conservation. Some people say that they have no accomplishments but I would count this in itself as an accomplishment. They have shown more far-sightedness when it comes to the future and our liveability in the environment than most others who prioritized short term financial greed.
Which indigenous people? They're not a monolith, every civilization in Mesoamerica had different practices. Quite a few in the Amazon practiced slash and burn because charcoal was really the only way to make jungle soil suitable for agriculture, called "terra preta". Which is basically the same thing as they're doing now, it was just on a smaller scale. If the Aztecs had the technology and hundreds of millions of mouths to feed they probably would be doing something similar. They were willing to sacrifice thousands of people a year for good harvests I doubt they would balk at cutting down trees en masse instead. Plus, they already did cut down lots of trees for agricultural purposes. It just wasn't at a scale big enough to constitute an ecological disaster.
All of the most powerful Mesoamerican civilizations engaged in a lot of geoengineering of their surroundings. Clearing out fields, cutting irrigation ditches and water reservoirs, building farm terraces, building chinampas, etc. All of which involved cutting down trees. Again it just wasn't at a scale that caused much damage because their populations were much smaller than today.
@@barahngVocê tem razão. A população humana cresceu demais.
Talvez estejamos maiores que os dinossauros, portanto com risco de extinção. Não parece que estejamos perto de alguma solução para que isso não ocorra.
It’s truly very eye opening. Modern industrialization paints itself as the epitome of intelligence and evolution, yet it destroys the ecosystem which will ultimately destroy us.
They make indigenous people out to be simple-minded people, yet they know deeply the importance of sustainability and reverence for other life forms. They have ancient earth knowledge.
@@barahngnoooo stop you're destroying their "noble savage" paradigm! lol
Absolutely love how this video seamlessly weaves together stunning art, well-researched content, captivating narration, and a truly enchanting soundtrack.❤️
Seeing the title, I immediately thought of Skypiea. It follows then, that I am surprised to find out that the nation who fought for the protection of these flying rivers and the rainforests, is also called Wampis.
Exactlyyy
Most likely not a coincidence. Oda did years upon years of research. Everything is connected. Everything is for a reason
Yes! Eiichiro Oda is making a masterpiece for this and future generations. He is channelizing lessons of how to be human beings connected with the all.
The Wampiiiiis!!!! The Wampiis is reaaaaallllll!!!!!!!
I love your name 😊
I saw a quote recently, I'm paraphrasing. "why would you assume giving land back to Indigenous people means displacing others?" Many have become so poisoned by the idea of land ownership Vis a Vis colonisation as opposed to land stewardship by Indigenous people
Because when they took the land from Indigenous people, they displaced them also
@@therogue1542 But if they just give it back, it displaces more people.
to free indigenous people you would have to dismantle the united states government and that really scares people who cant imagine not living in a genocidal capitalist empire, and also people who make being american their only personality trait
Nobody has to be displaced, give back the land to the original natives to preside over, and everyone else just lives there, too. Like nothing happened, problem solved. There should be no reservations or "our land and their land" things going on. Basically, the reverse version of assimilation. Instead of the native nations assimilating into the major nation, it's the other way around or at least full autonomy given to the tribes and reservations.
@@evanneal4936 What if the land has been processed into a large city, and has the maximum number of inhabitants?
I got goosebumps! I’m so glad there are indigenous ppl fighting to save their homeland’s nature❤❤❤.
It's not only to save their homelands but they're also saving the balance of our mother nature.
loved this combination of an ecology and culture lesson! the description of the sky rivers themselves did make me think though, what differentiates this process from that of clouds?
Seems basically the same afaik, the only extra things required for clouds are a sufficient amount of H2O and a colder atmosphere
They’re lower, narrower, and less visible. Like narrow fog
Clouds are part of this process. The river metaphor is basically just describing the consistent flow of large amounts of water, it's doesn't actually happen in discrete channels like a river. Rather, it's the air over a jungle (or other high-transpiration area) in general being higher in moisture (though still only a small fraction of the air is water vapor, about 4% at the very most) and getting blown in certain directions by prevailing winds. It's basically using the metaphor of a river to explain the aerial part of the water cycle.
I feel like the video does well at expressing that the vegetation is very important to maintaining precipitation patterns and its clearance is immensely disruptive, but it did really poorly at actually explaining why that is and how it works, creating new misconceptions.
It is clouds, clouds drifts where ever the wind blows does it not?
This simply highlights where these clouds come from; it's not just puddles ;)
You know what is better finding out that the warmer the planet gets the more rain we will have around the globe and with a +10°C of climate change in the next centuries the Sahara deserts might start to have new forest growing
Wow, this video is mind-blowing! I had no idea about the concept of flying rivers in the Amazon rainforest. It's fascinating to learn about these invisible waterways and how essential they are to sustaining life on Earth.
This needs to be talked about more.
It's so fascinating to learn about flying rivers. As an Indian, it reminds me of a native cultural term, "Aakasa Ganga', which literally means 'sky river'.
What is it in Indian culture?
Love and respect to all indigenous people of the world.
I hope this video helped a lot to open the eyes of everyone about various indigenous peoples around the world who are victims of modernizations and industrializations of companies and their own government.
This proves that keeping our trees around is essential to getting water around and to life on this planet. Destroy the trees we truly destroy ourselves.
As a Brazilian I am honored to live in a country that posses an environment so beautiful as the Amazon rainforest. If you are a foreigner reading this, come to Brazil and enjoy the hikes here.
This is why I absolutely adore Ted-Ed for bringing out gem pieces like this one, so people with little knowledge would learn more and understand better about this place we call home 🌍💖🙏
“If I jumped in the river, I would probably drown. No matter how struggle and strive, I’ll never get out of this world alive.” Hank Williams Sr
I yearn for the day when humans will put conservation over money.
True I feel like there is no conversation now a days
I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks this way.
As soon as money stops being something you need to survive, that is when almost everyone will focus on conservation
@@captain_improbability5690it will be too late by then.
Me too. In my opinion, the health of the earth is money. In reality.... The health of the earth is wealth. If stocks equaled conserved land every one would be a millionaire.
I’m so sick of the government taking over native land
Who cares about the natives lol? Why should I treat the Inuits with privilege in my house just because the land had Inuit descent? When they clearly killed other tribesmen for it and then got killed for it?
It isn't just the government, they're doing it because the corporations that demand more resource usage for their customers are basically paying off people to clear the way. Vote with your wallet and don't buy from companies that destroy the rain forest
@@KitchenAd-1131 lol put urself in their place and then say that again
@@Arithmetal_info Sorry, let me rephrase that, land only belongs to someone who fought for it
If I was in their place I wouldn't even think of such a low deed in the first place @@Arithmetal_info
Beautiful playful animation! The illustration is gorgeous and I love the shot perspectives. Real artistry at work here :)
I love how they included the capybara :)
ok i pull up
TEDEd making my nights viewing more educational ❤
Genuinely wish that they get more recognition sooner 😢
The indigenous communities in South America are constantly facing threats! It is the same here in Brazil! We must protect the indigenous people and ensure they continue preserving the forests in South America
Thank you for making these kinds of videos our communities appreciate it more than you know
im so fascinated by this... God, they need more support!!!
the arts style is absolutely gorgeous
the animation of this video...stunning
What people tend to not understand is that we aren't trying to save the earth. The earth will still be here with or without us. The slogan should be "save HUMANITY, plant a tree."
omg this was SUCH an AMAZING VIDEO!! GREAT animation, crisp and touching script and etching message!
woooowwwwwww, Upamanyu Bhattacharyya rocksssss❤❤
I knew forest transpired water vapor, but I didn't know it was on such a vast scale and has such a huge impact on weather. 'Flying River', what a concept!. It was encouraging to see that in the last election, Brasil turned away from right wing authoritarianism and back toward a more pro-environmental government. Good for Brasil and good for the planet.
In fact, both governments don't care about the Amazon, so much so that 2023 had one of the worst deforestation rates in history. They use "green propaganda" to get elected and win votes of the poor population.
"Exploring the celestial wonders, where rivers of clouds flow across the expansive canvas of the sky - nature's masterpiece above and below."
A philosophical recognized conclusion says: that, those who take the best care of it are the rightful owners.
The land thrives when it is actually owned as part of ones self. With love. Not possessed like a simple possession
And the tallest waterfall is under the ocean.
which one?
yes, which one?
so beautiful i cried. in this greedy world, they are the opposite.
I remember Bahirathan, the king, meditated for years, asking Siva the God to bring the sky river Ganga to earth.
I thought sky river is just for mythology, but here I am, hearing Sky River is always there.
Do you mean Bhageerath/Bhageerathan?
@@NoonMemeWowI guess he's Tamil. They pronounce ह, क,ख,ग,घ the same and use one letter for all.
when im bored, i watch ted ed, its just so interesting!
In love with this animation
I would listen to this voice anytime anyday .. Sweet and calming hope it ain't ai
Animation is so Beautiful.. I feel that Environment..😍very proud moment when I saw Upamanyu Bhattacharya's name in the description..this animated & Directed by Indian studio.
People: "There exists no magic in the real world!"
The real world: **flying rivers**
The animation is just ✨ gorjis ✨
The title & thumbnail made me think that they were talking about a mythical flying river, when in fact it was a real one. Great video as always 👍
Thats an incredible approach and I hope its adopted wherever possible as soon as possible. So many of the critical processes we're destroying are so intangible.
Their actions are so touching
The beauty and order God created is awesome. Shows His ingenuity through nature
and ironically it is many of those who claim to love Him who are doing the most damage, and in His name, too. brazilian farmers and ranchers often profess to enact genocide on the Native peoples in the Name of God. bitter, bitter irony.
Man these big companies are trying to gain more profits even knowing the cause and effect of it
That is what companies are there to do. They make profits.
Fantastic educational video without hitting the viewer over the head
Never heard of this tribes predicament before nor the sky river drying up due to forest clearing!
👏👏👏👏
Thanks for unforming about Nia tero. Thrir work is truly humbling and awesome
29 minutes, I LOVE YOU TED ED
Humidity is just water in the air, technically we're all under water even on land.
Very informative.
Thank you 💐
I'll die to wTch hour long lectures of super hard subjects with this kind of animation!!
Ted-Ed, You inspire me a lot and thanks to your organisation.
There's a lot I've learned today and I want to help defend the forest❤
Protect these people at all cost.
Woah, the animation in this video is breathtaking.
That animation 😳😳 .. Oh god , it's just beautiful
Now *that's* what I call an atmospheric river! 🏞️
Probably one of the best animated Ted Ed video 🙌🙌
Great message to share! More of these stories please
They are a very vulnerable people, I sure hope they can not only protect their homelands but also defend them.
Nature is the real wealth, humans and our money will come and go. Nature was before we came and will be after we are gone.
Read 'Braiding Sweetgrass'. Humans have been here for hundreds of thousands of years. Indigenous folk have honored the human tradition of living in a fully mutually beneficial collaboration with nature for the bulk of that history.
Money is VERY new to our species, and wildly corrosive. If we do not let go of money, then humans truly WILL find their end...but we don't _have_ to end, for things to be well for both us and nature. Not by a long shot.
When money stops making people powerful, People will care more about nature.
Honorable people. Honorable work!!!
Such a beautiful animation
Thank you for this. Interesting and important.
The claim at 4:27 sounds outlandish. A quarter of the world's land? Should give some sources in the description. (Not found in the linked Dig Deeper section either)
well consider how much land is Forrested and secluded, you get collosal numbers from India, Indonesia, Brazil and even russia
Nature is so fascinating ❤
This was a well-woven story and call-to-action.
Good work!!
Thanks for the video, i have heard about indigenous people protecting the forests but not at this extent... definitely visiting the website
This video is so beautiful
I loved the animation. So clean and beautiful.
The animation is very good
Thank you so much 👍👍👍❣❣❣❣🌹🌹🌹🎁🎁🎁🎁🎁☕🥮☕🥮
I'm intrigued with these flying rivers... I know about those jetstreams and underwater sea rivers.... But this one is new to me!
This is proof of an ultimate designer.
.... "Blessed are the meek.......
Love, peace.
Magic of nature
Why is it so hard to protect our nature. This is a beautiful thing
This is great, so great to hear success stories
🎶Come aboard and bring along🎵
🎵All your hopes and dreams🎶
🎶Together we will find everything🎵
🎵That we're looking for🎶
*Wampis!!!*
😢, save the rain forrest ❤
Love your stuff kick on love it ❤️❤️🧡💛💚💙💜🤍
Love the narrator and animation
Nature can be so cool.
Starting quote, wah
No matter the society, they'll always take pride in their arts and their ecosystem.
I support the Wampis!
this animation is just.. 👌
This feels like a movie❤❤
Theres another documentary about this! I like this one thoigh because its animated! ❤❤❤
Interesting video. Nice graphics.
The animation is so good!
I have always held this notion since my childhood that there is some sort of fresh oceans in the sky.