Agreed. The original Claire Torry version has a lot more visceral emotion. The live version is okay as well, but it's obvious they are trying to replicate the original. I always recommend the original to a first time listener.
This is from the album Dark Side Of The Moon, there is a reason it has spent 988 weeks on the charts, that is 988 over 14 years. Think you should do the album version but that's just me.
As an older gentleman Pink Floyd is right in my wheelhouse where popular music is concerned. I've heard this song (indeed the entire album) hundreds of times and this song never fails to give me goosebumps - even when listening on my car radio with plain run of the mill ordinary speakers. I appreciate where you said it made you think of a child crying. This song always made me think about a baby - a brand new baby being born - from that babies perspective it is being suddenly torn from its perfectly safe and comfortable existences in the mothers womb - being literally pushed out and into a cold harsh brightly lit place - wailing in fear and confusion and then being lain sweetly warmly into his mothers arms and finding comfort once again. - by the way I just subscribed to your channel. Oh and another thing - if the vocal gymnastics in this some moved you (and I know it did) I highly recommend you play and react to "Child In Time" by Deep Purple.
But they didn't. They brought in a "known outsider" (somebody knew of her) who they were told; could wail like a bastid. But that person didn't play live with them.
@@user-nd6bl1hm8i Yes they brought in Clare Torrey to sing on the original album track. But how does that negate the fact that Floyd had their backup singers sing this track in the concert performance?
Hi Emma! 細心の曲だけでなく、過去の名曲もリアクションするあなたの選曲が大好きです。 Dark Side of the Moonからの選曲ですね。このアルバムは本当に素晴らしくて、何度聞き返したかわからないぐらいです。 最初から最後までよい曲ばかりなので、ぜひアルバムを通して聴いていただきたいです。
If Sam, Claudia and Durga came up with the original version, then people would say Claire’s version wasn’t as good. Honestly I think both are just as spectacular.
All the girls were told was to sing the emotions they would feel if they were going through the five steps of death starting with an denial down to acceptance. It's very emotional. It's goosebump time. Lol
🥰🤩🤩😍😍😍😍😍😛😋😇wow fantastic Emma you are falling down the rabbit hole with pink Floyd every song makes you want to see more tons of songs all hits great reaction Emma
@@JaquelineGoodspeed All three singers were the backup singers for the tour - Sam Brown (the blonde), Durga McBroom and Claudia Fontaine. They sang the whole concert. Clare Torry sang (and improvised) on the original album track.
Nice reaction. I always thought this version did a good job of representing the confusion of standing in front of the Pearly Gates. Do I go in, do I stay out, back and forth until you finally relax and step on through.
The back up or should I say lead singers for this performance at Pulse and some of their other performances are Sam Brown, Claudia Fontaine, Durga McBroom . Thanks
As I'm sure has been suggested before I got here, go into the background of this song. Part of a concept album, "DARK SIDE OF THE MOON" if I'm remembering correctly from the day. The wordless vocals of Clare Tory on the original album express the 5 stages of dying, defined as: Denial, Anger, Bargaining, Depression, & Acceptance -- Look up interviews & specials on the recording, as Roger Waters described it in the wake of their essentially giving Clare Tory NO clear instruction on what they wanted from her in the studio, a "HAPPY ACCIDENT" -- or maybe GENIUS on Clare Tory's part. By the way, I'm pretty SURE that his HER on the opening vocal segment, and all the singers do SUCH GREAT interpretations of those segments they are entrusted with. -- PS - at 4:20-ish your comment: "reminds me of a child's cry" -- When we die, we're ALL wailing children, aren't we.............?
Memories... But you should listen to the album - to understand Pink Floyd each album must be treated as a unit and listened to in one sitting and with the songs in the correct/original order.
Would love to see you do a reaction from the same concert of the song. High Hopes. David plays a solo on the same instrument you seen in this video called a steel guitar or a lap guitar it is an amazing performance hoping to see you do it I have high hopes of you doing a reaction to it
both versions are just amazing...RIP claudia fontaine...
RIP.
You definitly should listen to the Album version with Clare Torry. Never surpassed by any singer.
Clare Torry is the OG when it comes to this track, she came up with this almost on the spot!
Agreed. The original Claire Torry version has a lot more visceral emotion. The live version is okay as well, but it's obvious they are trying to replicate the original. I always recommend the original to a first time listener.
tout a fait daccord
Only took around 3 takes if I remember,
Great reaction, I subbed you because there are certain songs that shouldn't be paused every ten seconds!
The ability to say everything while saying nothing. That’s this song.
The goal was to express the 5 stages of grief without saying a word! This is a fantastic song and fantastic concept!
That was the result, but Clare knew nothing about that when she laid down the vocals.
pink floyd is music for the soul
You need to hear the entire album to get a complete feel for this song.
Or at least the song immediately preceding this one: Time
Wonderful performance, isn't it?
These singers, they poured their souls into this.
Oh yeah 👍
The first singer was Sam Brown. She is more than only a background singer!
It follows the track "Time" on the album so if you want some context..... 😉
You can never go wrong with Pink Floyd
Definitivamente la version de estudio es insuperable....👍
The Great Rick Wright In The Sky
The second singer always does it for me in this performance ❤️ three great performances.
That's Durga McBroom and I agree (personal opinion). The first singer was Sam Brown and the last was Claudia Fontaine.
This is from the album Dark Side Of The Moon, there is a reason it has spent 988 weeks on the charts, that is 988 over 14 years. Think you should do the album version but that's just me.
I think it's interesting that each singer starts her segment at the note (pitch?) that the previous singer ended on.
Here come the hoards telling you need to hear Clare Torry's album version...
👍
controversial but I prefer this version. Sam Brown amazing.
@@dillonfloyd
Me too.
Should here the original as well for it's own merit...
Most Floyd fans love both versions.
Check out Time, Comfortably Numb and Wish You Were Here from the Pulse Concert to get more context on Pink Floyd and their amazing soundscapes.
Shine on you crazy Diamond by Pink Floyd ❤
Pink Floyd makes the greatest concept albums. Listening to a Pink Floyd album is an experience. Please do full album reviews. 🤞✌️
Fantastic!
Only Pinl Floyd could make a song without words a success.
All I am going to say is, Pink Floyd - Echoes- live concert in Gdansk, or Live At Pompeii. Either version is a masterpiece of its own.
As an older gentleman Pink Floyd is right in my wheelhouse where popular music is concerned. I've heard this song (indeed the entire album) hundreds of times and this song never fails to give me goosebumps - even when listening on my car radio with plain run of the mill ordinary speakers. I appreciate where you said it made you think of a child crying. This song always made me think about a baby - a brand new baby being born - from that babies perspective it is being suddenly torn from its perfectly safe and comfortable existences in the mothers womb - being literally pushed out and into a cold harsh brightly lit place - wailing in fear and confusion and then being lain sweetly warmly into his mothers arms and finding comfort once again. - by the way I just subscribed to your channel.
Oh and another thing - if the vocal gymnastics in this some moved you (and I know it did) I highly recommend you play and react to "Child In Time" by Deep Purple.
This is the time the background singers get the LEAD
Pink Floyd is the only band I know that would give the backup singers a song of their own to sing.
But they didn't. They brought in a "known outsider" (somebody knew of her) who they were told; could wail like a bastid. But that person didn't play live with them.
@@user-nd6bl1hm8i Yes they brought in Clare Torrey to sing on the original album track. But how does that negate the fact that Floyd had their backup singers sing this track in the concert performance?
A child's cry...That's perfect, I can hear that as well.
dying and birth, the eternal circle
Claudia.🙏🖤⭐
Love how the other singers were added.
It takes more than one singer to get close to Torry's version.
Great reaction! Thanks for this moment
No problem 😊
The Powerfull!!!!!! Pink Floyd!!!!!!!! Im 70!! Still Rock n Roll!!!!!!!!!!! Till ☠️💀☠️!!!!!!
Hi Emma! 細心の曲だけでなく、過去の名曲もリアクションするあなたの選曲が大好きです。
Dark Side of the Moonからの選曲ですね。このアルバムは本当に素晴らしくて、何度聞き返したかわからないぐらいです。
最初から最後までよい曲ばかりなので、ぜひアルバムを通して聴いていただきたいです。
If Sam, Claudia and Durga came up with the original version, then people would say Claire’s version wasn’t as good. Honestly I think both are just as spectacular.
Coming Back to Life.
the blonde vocalist is Sam(antha) Brown..........she is spectacular !
I would suggest lots more Pink Floyd from this Pulse concert. Excellent live performances.
I saw the female singer in Brit Floyd do the original part perfectly. Amazing.
Goose bumps..Gorgeous Emma
Aquele que teve a sorte de assistir a esse show, nunca mais saiu de casa para assistir a mais NADA !!!!Se recolheu e se emociona a décadas.
Sam Brown is simply tremendous
All the girls were told was to sing the emotions they would feel if they were going through the five steps of death starting with an denial down to acceptance. It's very emotional. It's goosebump time. Lol
My favourite from the album (Dark Side of the Moon) is Us and Them.
Just saying.
🥰🤩🤩😍😍😍😍😍😛😋😇wow fantastic Emma you are falling down the rabbit hole with pink Floyd every song makes you want to see more tons of songs all hits great reaction Emma
Oh!!! Thank you for your comment 😘😘😘
Saw it live WOW
Sam Brown is smokin this song!!!!!!
Clare Torry studio is the quintessential version! Beautiful!
She also did live versions as well.
It's about struggling with and then finally accepting death.
The original on the album was done by one woman, Claire Torry.
... and improvised on the spot in just a couple of takes.
I love them adding the black singers too
OH! THANK YOU FOR SHARING!!!
@@JaquelineGoodspeed All three singers were the backup singers for the tour - Sam Brown (the blonde), Durga McBroom and Claudia Fontaine. They sang the whole concert. Clare Torry sang (and improvised) on the original album track.
really RIck??????? Wow, nobody knew that. Thanks for coming!!!!
Music is the art of speaking through sound. Here you go.
This is art...period
The whole Dark side of the moon album is a trip within.
# 홧팅 🍒🙆♂️))
Fear, denial, resistance, acceptance, death.
This is where i found my true fremdom
Oldie but a goldie 😂😂😂
The Original Album version is a MUST listen, and also, on top of that, furthermore, you are beautiful!
goosebumps, goosebumps...:):)
Wish You Were Here.
Everyone should listen to the original studio version of this. That was pure magic. Any vocalist since has only been an homage.
Check out Godley and Creme “Cry” you won’t be disappointed.
You would absolutely love the studio version of this song on the Dark Side of the Moon album. There is only one vocalist and she did it in 2 takes.
I always think the audio of the man sounds like Antony Hopkins
Nice reaction. I always thought this version did a good job of representing the confusion of standing in front of the Pearly Gates. Do I go in, do I stay out, back and forth until you finally relax and step on through.
❤
Welcome to the floyd
The back up or should I say lead singers for this performance at Pulse and some of their other performances are Sam Brown, Claudia Fontaine, Durga McBroom . Thanks
As I'm sure has been suggested before I got here, go into the background of this song. Part of a concept album, "DARK SIDE OF THE MOON" if I'm remembering correctly from the day. The wordless vocals of Clare Tory on the original album express the 5 stages of dying, defined as: Denial, Anger, Bargaining, Depression, & Acceptance -- Look up interviews & specials on the recording, as Roger Waters described it in the wake of their essentially giving Clare Tory NO clear instruction on what they wanted from her in the studio, a "HAPPY ACCIDENT" -- or maybe GENIUS on Clare Tory's part. By the way, I'm pretty SURE that his HER on the opening vocal segment, and all the singers do SUCH GREAT interpretations of those segments they are entrusted with. -- PS - at 4:20-ish your comment: "reminds me of a child's cry" -- When we die, we're ALL wailing children, aren't we.............?
Memories... But you should listen to the album - to understand Pink Floyd each album must be treated as a unit and listened to in one sitting and with the songs in the correct/original order.
Floyd is way ahead of their time.
For all time
When you want to escape
Oh yea
Excellent reaction, thank you. Please react to "High Hopes" from their Pulse concert
They're singing The death.
I’ll never need therapy
I have Pink Floyd
check out comfortably numb from pulse
Two Suns in the Sunset.
This was on heavy play after losing both my parents. I think about their last moments here on earth before going to the Lord.
Album version is uniquely powerful cuz it was created on the spot
its a song about fighting and acceptance of death
Next please reaction Ariel Noah cover Adelle someone like you live konser, band legend from Indonesia 😊
Sometimes, words can be so overrated.
This live version is on another level compared to the studio version. Far better.
The 3 verses are meant to represent the 3 stages of life. Birth, living, and Dying.
Emma, u r beautiful!
Although this is a great version of the song, the studio version with Clare Torry is worth checking out also!
Hooohooohoooohooohooohooohoohoo
Would love to see you do a reaction from the same concert of the song. High Hopes. David plays a solo on the same instrument you seen in this video called a steel guitar or a lap guitar it is an amazing performance hoping to see you do it I have high hopes of you doing a reaction to it
best chorus, rachel fury , dunga and macha
Studio version
Roger Waters. Molly's Song with Doreen Chanter.
Yes please need to listen to Album version with Clare Torry.
Octavarium - Dream Theater 🎧👂
diana ankudinova - dune soundtrack reaction..
Check Us and them from the same concert.
Clare Torry is a must…. It’s her song ❤️
Have you reviewed Shine on You Crazy Diamond? To me it’s a modern day Requiem.
Wow! I’m interested!
I was going to watch it until I saw the live version, I'm out.
Wot's Uh the Deal.
Mourning of death
This song is about coming to terms with a terminal diagnosis.
Check out. Without Me by Evol Walk❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😂❤
Please react AINA ABDUL cover I SURRENDER Celine Dion❤❤❤