Netenyahu, however, funded Hamas for years before Oct 7th, ignored warnings of the attack and also stymied every peace effort from the 90's to now. The effect: people have died for his mess.
@@TheGhurabah You're aware that hostages are more of a bargaining chip and politically relevant... Militarily they're not really important... They don't shoot missiles out their bum, or explode on command... So yeah, militarily Israel is achieving its goals, independent of the hostages dying or not.
Why always focus on oct 7 see the bigger picture palestinian want to get their independent freedom. Just like indonesia fought the dutch for 300 years and finally got independent i. 1945
Why always focus on oct 7 see the bigger picture palestinian want to get their independent freedom. Just like indonesia fought the dutch for 300 years and finally got independent i. 1945
I think they have romantic soul, kind of innocent soul. Like American students back in the day, believed that become soldier fighting in South America is a great thing like heroes until they learnt that their enemy also had guns and fired back.
Yeah, when Netenyahu funds Hamas, everyone regrets it. When he ignored warnings of the attack, everyone regrets it. Children die, it can be ignored for now but charges will come.
@@dstaff7373when trump is for sure , Trump 2024 . Now you have a guy in power that cannot have a war after 9:30 pm as his pills to keep him up all day wore off.
Why would they leave after Hamas proved that they're willing to murder thousands of civilians? I don't care about the moral argument, but simply from a perspective of ensuring safety for your country, it would be braindead to leave the region that's been used multiple times to stage attacks on your country.
"Hezbollah serves the Iranian interest"...all the arab countries know that. That is why they are keeping quiet, hoping that isreal will neutralise Hezbollah for them. Other than for the Hezbollah supporters in lebanon, the rest of the lebanese (including the Lebanese army) want Hezbollah to be neutralised.
I still can't understand how a group of people could set up camp in a country an attack another without the security forces not investigating that group that causing them to be under attack, but i think Lebanon is financially benefiting from this
GEneva Convention IV, Article 51, section 7: 7. The presence or movements of the civilian population or individual civilians shall not be used to render certain points or areas immune from military operations, in particular in attempts to shield military objectives from attacks or to shield, favour or impede military operations.
GREAT OPINIO Sir Gantz why is the WORLD akways blame Israel when Israel did not start this war...hamas did and Hezbollah joined the war .. now,who is the culprit ?
Im speaking from the ground, from Northern Israel. The situation here is very bad, much worse than official Israel politicians willing to admit. 10 km area from the border is paralyzed for almost one year.
Depending on the other guy to take the de-escalation offramp is the same idea that gave us World War 1. Neither side is actually giving the other side a politically realistic option to de-escalate. Israel is actually pretty spot on when they say that Hezbollah is bad for the Lebanese people and is simply a front for Iran. But that being right doesn’t really mean much in the modern world, especially in the Middle East
If a person gets in a fight with a police officer and pulls out a knife, and the police officer draws his gun, which resolves the confrontation by compelling the person with the knife to surrender, I would say pulling out a gun is an escalation, which in effect is a de-escalation.
Killing civilians has nothing to do with response to Hamas or Hezbollah but to force Palestinians to leave their homes so the territory can be colonized by Israel.
Everyone knows what the war is. During bombing Dresden in the Second war 100 000 people were killed. IN JUST ONE CITY! Israel is the most gentle and careful in the history. They give the warnings in time so that people can leave.
Yes, Arabs attacked Israel 5 times in last 76 years. Lost all the time, learned NOTHING and attacked again. Palestinians ARE REFUSING 2 states solution and insist on their FromRtoS cleaning.
Why always focus on oct 7 see the bigger picture palestinian want to get their independent freedom. Just like indonesia fought the dutch for 300 years and finally got independent i. 1945
Fight in the cause of Allah, and know that Allah is All-Hearing, All-Knowing. Who will lend to Allah a good loan which Allah will multiply many times over? It is Allah ˹alone˺ who decreases and increases ˹wealth˺. And to Him you will ˹all˺ be returned.
I hate that these journalists do not press Israeli supporters when they say Hamas started this and all the blame is on Hamas. Why does only Israel have the right to defend itself and kill thousands of civilians doing it? And after displacing these civilians from their homes. Israel has been stealing land since before it's founding.
U lack sense of reasoning. What do u expect when u start a war against people that never fought you? Ain't u aware that in war a lot happened imaginable and unimaginable.
Get yourself educated. Land name Judea, Samaria, Israel, Galilea - is Israeli land for 3 500 years. Phillistin means intruder, invader. They do not have the letter P in their alphabet and cannot even bronounce it.
Sadly though this watermelon is better than. 95% of the comments on the war that are usually just knee jerk answers by ppl who have a superficial and ignorant view of a conflict that has gone on for decades. “Free Palestine.” For example… okay how based on all the complexities are diplomatic efforts that have failed by far more informed ppl!
Shameless escalation by illegal state of Israel 🇮🇱. They've no regards to humanity at all. Advanced weapons killing Innocent human beings in Palestine 🇵🇸, Lebanon 🇱🇧 & other poor states
These “poor states” all 5 of them started the first war against Israel 1948, when Israel had 806 000 people. Cowards. They lost all their wars and NEVER LEARNED.
Sir the root of the tree is your treatment of the Palestinians. You want the missiles to stop, fess up to the origins of Israel and share the holy land. So far all I see is Israel doing 'from the Euphrates to the Nile!' as lead settler Weiss cries!
You know the combatant to civilians ratio of the gaza war? You know it's 2 : 1? Means 2 civilians killed for each combantant, You know that when the USA and NATO forces had wars their ratio was 5 : 1 means 5 civilians killed for each combantant and it was in less dense area? Did you criticize them too? have you ever heard of the term collateral damage? Do you know that hamas has teenagers 16yr 17yr and even younger as members? Can you answer any of that?
Before shedding tears for the people of Lebanon... remember that they created Hezbollah, elected it, supported it, worked with it, hid it, sheltered it, filled its ranks and celebrated all of its atrocities. Aren't they dancing in the streets anymore?
She’s “evil” because that person who called her that is obviously tribal and can’t understand nuances. The kind of people who shouldn’t be listened to.
Finally DW invited someone who talks sense
You love disinformation I believe
Finally, a decent and honest guest on DW. Dana, you are a brilliant and an amazing lady. Great analysis. Keep it up.
Really he saying truth. There is no option for Israel.
He is deluded just like the Romans he doesn't believe in God. He only believe in worldly power. But that kind of power is temporary and impermanent.
"Israel has faced a barrage of criticism for its campaign against Hezbolhah"...only from a particular sect and their acolytes.
Israel never starts war, but have always finished it.
Netenyahu, however, funded Hamas for years before Oct 7th, ignored warnings of the attack and also stymied every peace effort from the 90's to now. The effect: people have died for his mess.
@@TheGhurabahwhere is Gaza now are flat
@@TheGhurabah You're aware that hostages are more of a bargaining chip and politically relevant...
Militarily they're not really important...
They don't shoot missiles out their bum, or explode on command... So yeah, militarily Israel is achieving its goals, independent of the hostages dying or not.
@@hopedozzer7214 what this guy means to say is Israel will finish its colonialism.
Finally an interview with a sensible person.
Dana Stroul - what a breath of fresh air. Finally someone who is well informed and understands the conflict!
But those critising Israel for defending themselves, have a really serious problem. What is wrong with this world?🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
The staggering levels of collateral.
@@ethancoster1324 the region of the conflicts are densely populated- unfortunate but factual
@@ethancoster1324The collateral to fighter ratio from Israeli attacks is vastly lower than any comparable rate from other modern wars.
People who are critiquing don't have their country getting bombed
@@adamredwine774 Correct- but most people have ZERO sense of History!
Who is this brilliant young lady?? Wow!! Thank u for being honest. I have saved this video clip
A barrage of international criticism. Seriously. Israel was attacked and has responded like every other nation state has the right to do.
Ignorance is not an excuse. This crises started well before Oct 7th!
@@muhammadnimji4626yeah they started around 700 AD
Lol you mean in Hebron massacre in 1929?@@muhammadnimji4626
DW is a leftists, they are pro Palestinian 😑😑😑
Hamas was also attacked prior to October 7th , so they had the right to respond in the only way a rebel army can
Those counties criticising Israel 🇮🇱 , will they sit back and do nothing when their country is attacked? Shame on you
maybe hasbara should invest elsewhere cuz this aint cutting it
Why always focus on oct 7 see the bigger picture palestinian want to get their independent freedom. Just like indonesia fought the dutch for 300 years and finally got independent i. 1945
Egypt should open its borders for Palestinians
The palestinian land is actually jordan.
WHY? WHY NOT EU AND UK OR USA? THEY ARE BEHIND ALL THESE CRIMES.
They wont accept them coz anywhere they go there will be chaos
@@crisalis they should accept them because they are all same people (Arabs)
@@kishwerchaundarysure blame everyone around and never look at what you have done wrong, you people act like a 5yr kids, grow up.
The woman guest Dana will probably never be invited back to DW... she was making too much sense that never gets talked about here.
I thought the same thing! God bless and protect this honest young lady
DW is definitely antisemetic.
DANA? AND WHO KILLED LADY DIANA?
@@desert_rose7171not everything is antsemitic pls stop using it for everything
Islamists' strategy after starting a war:
1. Apply the victim card
2. Call & request for a ceasefire
3. Hide behind civilian
4. Cry Genocide
5.
They must have learned it from perpetual victims
5. Blame Israel for everything
Why always focus on oct 7 see the bigger picture palestinian want to get their independent freedom. Just like indonesia fought the dutch for 300 years and finally got independent i. 1945
💯 💯💯💯💯💯
@@oskie1997😂😂😂
Fires 800+ rockets and dont expect a response? Youuuu so innocent child. 😂 look your pager is beeping.
8000
I think they have romantic soul, kind of innocent soul. Like American students back in the day, believed that become soldier fighting in South America is a great thing like heroes until they learnt that their enemy also had guns and fired back.
Its 8000+
1. Benny Gantz summarized the whole situation perfectly.
2. Thanks to DW for inviting a good guest, Dana Stroul.
don't mess with Israell or else you will regret it !!!
Yeah, when Netenyahu funds Hamas, everyone regrets it. When he ignored warnings of the attack, everyone regrets it. Children die, it can be ignored for now but charges will come.
Israel always gets criticized for trying to protect its citizens
What about the hostages, they are not citizens of Israel too?
protect its "settlers"
You just can't fathom it
This what "Apartheid" look's like.
Because Israel does not protect Palestine
This lady is a subject matter expert. She provides clear and concise explanations to each and every question from a notoriously biased host.
They have woken the sleeping GIANT.
That's America 🇺🇸, Don't take our Moniker given to us by a RESPECTED General Of the opposing Force...
@@dstaff7373when trump is for sure , Trump 2024 . Now you have a guy in power that cannot have a war after 9:30 pm as his pills to keep him up all day wore off.
U MEAN USA,? HE WOKEN ALSO UKRANIAN GIANT TO SELL WEAPONS ANF MAKE MONEY, IF I AM NOT WRONG?
Talking about the real GIANT....the GOD of Israel.
@@timwaqa6897 👉"This guy"...
This will go on as long as Ayatollas in power!
*Israel🇮🇱 must respect soveregnity territorial integrity of lebanon, Palestine (East Jerusalem, West Bank, Gaza Strip) & Syria (Golan)!*
End the occupation !!
Why would they leave after Hamas proved that they're willing to murder thousands of civilians?
I don't care about the moral argument, but simply from a perspective of ensuring safety for your country, it would be braindead to leave the region that's been used multiple times to stage attacks on your country.
Lebanon is a beautiful country but they made a big mistake allowing Hezbollah into its country.
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱❤️
if israel was not able to defend these missiles just imagine the situation of israel
"Hezbollah serves the Iranian interest"...all the arab countries know that. That is why they are keeping quiet, hoping that isreal will neutralise Hezbollah for them. Other than for the Hezbollah supporters in lebanon, the rest of the lebanese (including the Lebanese army) want Hezbollah to be neutralised.
At least israel defends its people. In usa. Govt leaves both borders open and multmillion bad people cross into usa. B.b a true leader.
Not really. Cool story though.
"Two-State Solution" is not viable any longer.
It is over. They missed all their chances already.
While insisting on FromRtoS first.
Never was...
I still can't understand how a group of people could set up camp in a country an attack another without the security forces not investigating that group that causing them to be under attack, but i think Lebanon is financially benefiting from this
May the Lord continue to protect and bless Israel.
What happened to your lord on Oct.7? No lord, just the US and UK.
@@DEonaraR
Go and read bible and you will understand.
@@MostViewedScreen. I don't read fairy tale books!!! I read science books!!!
@@DEonaraRThat is why you have this problem.
good video. should be reported on al jazeera
A well spoken articulate guest. You should have her back more often 👍
GEneva Convention IV, Article 51, section 7:
7. The presence or movements of the civilian population or individual civilians shall not be used to render certain points or areas immune from military operations, in particular in attempts to shield military objectives from attacks or to shield, favour or impede military operations.
Your cause is right? Stealing other people's land is right? 😂😂😂😂
Great guess speaker!!
The rest of the world is not under threat from enemies that surround their nation. They should jump into help Israel or stay out of it.
Who tf is this Gal! She can stay. Theyll never have her back again.
GREAT OPINIO Sir Gantz
why is the WORLD akways blame Israel when Israel did not start this war...hamas did and Hezbollah joined the war .. now,who is the culprit ?
I’ve learned to always end the video when the so-called anchor says, and now let’s bring in so-and-so expert in this and that … buhbye
Israel couldn't fight in 2 wars
She has no clue of 6 days war
Which Israel was much wej
Ker back then
Im speaking from the ground, from Northern Israel. The situation here is very bad, much worse than official Israel politicians willing to admit. 10 km area from the border is paralyzed for almost one year.
DW please listen to the general.
Depending on the other guy to take the de-escalation offramp is the same idea that gave us World War 1. Neither side is actually giving the other side a politically realistic option to de-escalate.
Israel is actually pretty spot on when they say that Hezbollah is bad for the Lebanese people and is simply a front for Iran. But that being right doesn’t really mean much in the modern world, especially in the Middle East
The US: Now stop it.
Israel: Lol Yeah ok.
The US is so weak.
No. US wants Israel to keep going and win in private , but say stop in public.
The US “Jill where’s my ice cream”
Isreal did startet Apartheid 😂
I wonder what the "internationally recognized" borders will look like in the end?🤔
Yeah. And peace is war. Orwellian 😢
came here for the comments
They got yahyah
If a person gets in a fight with a police officer and pulls out a knife, and the police officer draws his gun, which resolves the confrontation by compelling the person with the knife to surrender, I would say pulling out a gun is an escalation, which in effect is a de-escalation.
Move means move.
Killing civilians has nothing to do with response to Hamas or Hezbollah but to force Palestinians to leave their homes so the territory can be colonized by Israel.
There is no War between hamas and israel
Operation FAFO
Where is Nasrallah with today’s warning?
The problem is that you are also brutally killing innocents along the way. Which simply means you are not right minded.
It’s really you.
@@desert_rose7171 War is like that... hizbollah are cowards hiding in innocent people...and firing missiles. What to do?
It's your mind that you need to examine.
Naive and logically flawed.
Never has been a war in the history of mankind that has not been brutal.
Everyone knows what the war is.
During bombing Dresden in the Second war 100 000 people were killed. IN JUST ONE CITY!
Israel is the most gentle and careful in the history.
They give the warnings in time so that people can leave.
It doesn’t start on October 7 it starts on decades ago
The Arabs are the intruders
Now they have to fight and stop crying for help
It started almost 2000 years ago with Romans.
Yes, Arabs attacked Israel 5 times in last 76 years. Lost all the time, learned NOTHING and attacked again.
Palestinians ARE REFUSING 2 states solution and insist on their FromRtoS cleaning.
It started 1244 when Abduls came
Escalate to de-escalate. Israel must have been using the same Russia text book. Obviously, Germany media starred to see it too
Free Galilee is forming. Very little help from central authorities.
Why always focus on oct 7 see the bigger picture palestinian want to get their independent freedom. Just like indonesia fought the dutch for 300 years and finally got independent i. 1945
Let them go and be free.
And stop causing trouble and starting multiple wars at land name Judea, Samaria, Israel, Galilea … for 3 500 years already.
Stop the genocide
Tell Hamas and his proxys
I would advise not to use words you don't know the definition of.
I wish guys like you just say as normal people, stop the war, that would help to de-escalate this situation.
Check definition and come back
What kind of analysis is this...
The right one. Educate yourself, please.
Reality check hurts
The cause and foundation of the problem is italy and France Paris,Rome,Napolitano,Napoli,America, Rome,Taranto,Torino,Sardegna)(,,
And you.
Short term : Gain for B1B1(skip jai1)
Long term : Lost for the people
So who exploded the pagers? Hexbollah?
Fight in the cause of Allah, and know that Allah is All-Hearing, All-Knowing. Who will lend to Allah a good loan which Allah will multiply many times over? It is Allah ˹alone˺ who decreases and increases ˹wealth˺. And to Him you will ˹all˺ be returned.
When DW watches A Bug’s Life… they root for the grasshoppers. 🐜🐜🐜
This isn't news this is biased
The framing of their “news” and story is hilarious
Berlin delenda est
Oh they tried, but we can actually defend ourselves and don't need to use our civilian population as meat shields, like Hamas is doing.
הרמגדון ברוך הבא 😅
Ashber bregen zait nacttwessen
βεrlin delenda est
Absolute garbage analysis.
How, please explain instead of just offering an easy opinion.
Really? She was perfect.
Maybe it would help to get some real education?
Why does DW allow obvious IDF bots to flood the comment section? 🤔
Where?
@@MiladaKaiser
99% of the comments
@@WoJackHorseman24I have never Seen a bot acussing Others of being bots wow crazy how fast Technology advances
@@WoJackHorseman24 visit Al Jazeera then
@@WoJackHorseman24. They usually show up first on this channel, because DW is a US mouthpiece, but as time pases they let others comment.
Biased didn't talk about labanese civilians shame
Lebanon is shooting those rocket.
Did they expect NO ANSWER?
War kills people!!!!!
So they should not start it !
I hate that these journalists do not press Israeli supporters when they say Hamas started this and all the blame is on Hamas. Why does only Israel have the right to defend itself and kill thousands of civilians doing it? And after displacing these civilians from their homes. Israel has been stealing land since before it's founding.
U lack sense of reasoning. What do u expect when u start a war against people that never fought you? Ain't u aware that in war a lot happened imaginable and unimaginable.
😅, never fought anyone, we are victim here😅@@peterdegreat8059
Get yourself educated.
Land name Judea, Samaria, Israel, Galilea - is Israeli land for 3 500 years.
Phillistin means intruder, invader. They do not have the letter P in their alphabet and cannot even bronounce it.
@MiladaKaiser the people that occupies Isreal are converts. That's not there land.
Fsawe mulkate gegomene.
And up is down.
Left is right.
2 + 2 = 5
And this is all BS.
🍉
🇮🇱
Sadly though this watermelon is better than. 95% of the comments on the war that are usually just knee jerk answers by ppl who have a superficial and ignorant view of a conflict that has gone on for decades.
“Free Palestine.” For example… okay how based on all the complexities are diplomatic efforts that have failed by far more informed ppl!
🫏💥❌
Shameless escalation by illegal state of Israel 🇮🇱. They've no regards to humanity at all. Advanced weapons killing Innocent human beings in Palestine 🇵🇸, Lebanon 🇱🇧 & other poor states
These “poor states” all 5 of them started the first war against Israel 1948, when Israel had 806 000 people. Cowards.
They lost all their wars and NEVER LEARNED.
free Palestinians
Sir the root of the tree is your treatment of the Palestinians. You want the missiles to stop, fess up to the origins of Israel and share the holy land. So far all I see is Israel doing 'from the Euphrates to the Nile!' as lead settler Weiss cries!
You and your Weiss cries need knowledge and understanding 😂😂
Disproportionate
No such thing.
You don’t get to escalate a situation and then whine about the response. Just don’t attack people in the first place
@jdmo741 just say it how it is..
Israel invaded Gaza and Lebanon was next.. next is now.. quit the blabla noone buys it.
@@jdmo741 you are on point !
FAFO
JAIL SATANYAHU
You wanted to Yahya Sin-war? 😂
Who take the people them land why he don't talk about that
Speak English!😂
Not understandable.
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸✌️✌️💯
Benny Gantz's face is so inocent as if that was I who killed 13,000 children.
You know the combatant to civilians ratio of the gaza war? You know it's 2 : 1? Means 2 civilians killed for each combantant, You know that when the USA and NATO forces had wars their ratio was 5 : 1 means 5 civilians killed for each combantant and it was in less dense area? Did you criticize them too? have you ever heard of the term collateral damage? Do you know that hamas has teenagers 16yr 17yr and even younger as members? Can you answer any of that?
Berlin insha'Allah
Your Allah is obviously on Israeli side. He is done with terrorists.
2:46 “in solidarity with”!! Really!? or ‘as an accomplice’?
Before shedding tears for the people of Lebanon... remember that they created Hezbollah, elected it, supported it, worked with it, hid it, sheltered it, filled its ranks and celebrated all of its atrocities. Aren't they dancing in the streets anymore?
Is it just me or does that guy look like him and netenyahoo have the same mother or something ? They could be twins, maybe netinyahoo in drag ?
"A barrage of international criticism", nothing the Iron Dome can't handle. 🫡
Evil woman
What makes her "evil"? The fact she speakes the truth?
She’s “evil” because that person who called her that is obviously tribal and can’t understand nuances. The kind of people who shouldn’t be listened to.
Yup, Dalal Mughrabi was an evil woman, but Israel learned from that experience too, and Mughrabi is no more!!!!! Wonder why?
Before October 7 why you made shutdown on gaza
I’ve learned to always end the video when the so-called anchor says, and now let’s bring in so-and-so expert in this and that … buhbye