Hey everyone! It's been over a week since I have seen this movie, and it has really stuck with me... I have never something like this that was so thought provoking. I keep thinking about how important it is to be grateful & how valuable our time is, especially when spending it with loved ones. I just want to thank you for taking the time to enjoy this masterpiece with me! ❤
You are so right. In addition, it reminds me to support people around me, so they get the support and some experiences, their family or situation does not provide. (small scale, not rich and certainly no saint)
Watch Tenet that's Nolans greatest movie, it's an R rated written and directed by Nolan masterpiece, once again about the concept of time, and it has a terrifying villain played by Kenneth Brenagh, and it's a mind bender beyond anything ever put on screen before.
the oscars has and always will be just bunch of industry goons patting each other on the back.if you're not part of the wide scale circle jerk in hollywierd , then chances are you won't get an oscar or even a nomination.
Everyone misses the point of the ending. Brandt takes off her helmet showing that the atmosphere is breathable and that all along her love for the guy was guiding them to the right place.
Hans Zimmer never disappoints, and this movie has my favorite compositions of his. When they land on the water planet there's a faint sound of a clock ticking in the background. It happens once every 1.25 seconds, which was intentional and is mathematically accurate. Each time the clock ticks an entire day passes back on earth.
That would be equivalent to 7.89 years per hour. It could be a rounding error, but then you'd think they would've said 8 years per hour. The correct rate for seven years per hour is one day every 1.41 seconds: (1 hr.P / 7 yr.E) * 60 min/hr * 60 sec/min * 1 yr/365 days = 1.41 sec.P/day.E
This is perhaps the movie that has moved me the most in so many years as a cinema enthusiast, and it's been 47 now. Of all the reactions I’ve seen about this movie, yours is the one most similar to mine the first time I watched it in the theater. A whirlwind of emotions, questions about time, space, and the meaning of life. Most people reacting to it ask silly and embarrassing questions about marginal issues, supposed plot holes, or inconsistencies that make no sense. You immediately empathized and embraced the film for what it is: a great love story with a solid scientific foundation. Thank you, Miranda, you never disappoint.
he actually made the real black hole. Not so long time ago we got first actual pictures of black hole and it is very similiar to what shown in the movie
I love how this movie plays with emotions. When you realize he’s the “ghost”, you get a sudden sense of hope, but then you realize that he was sending messages to tell himself not to leave… and you’re crushed.
"Because my dad promised me" What father wouldn't go through hell and back for his kids. Good reminder of what good parents are like. Weather solo or couple.
Fun fact: Christopher Nolan bought a field and planted all the corn the truck drives through. After the movie was made, they harvested the corn and actually managed to turn a small profit....
I want this film to leave everyone feeling uplifted, not feeling small. It's a love letter to humanity, celebrating our brilliance, courage, and unwavering will to push beyond the limits of what we think is possible-despite the vastness of the universe and our seemingly insignificant place within it.
Christopher Nolan brought in real-life physicist Kip Thorne as a consultant on this film in order to get as much of the physics of gravity, relativity, and black holes as correct as he could. As no one had ever seen a real black hole before production began, Gargantua's appearance was based on renderings of actual scientific calculations to approximate what a black hole would really look like. It turned out to be remarkably accurate when the first-ever composite photo of a real black hole was taken in 2019, as it appeared very similar to Interstellar's Gargantua.
@@TimeFadesMemoryLasts Yeah while I love this movie everything about Millers planet and the time dilation of being on the surface is incredibly unrealistic. If the gravitational forces of Gargantua are so strong to cause such a time dilation, how could the crew operate like it was normal earth gravity while on the surface? Not to mention the dilation effect should be similar whether you were in orbit or on the surface since it wasn’t from the planet itself. The only plausible explanation was they the landed on the side of the planet nearest Gargantua where the planetary gravity and the gravity from Gargantua somehow equaled out to around 9.8m/s squared. But that doesn’t explain why someone in orbit would experience time at earth speeds. But whatever, it makes for a great scene
The most heartbreaking thing about him watching the tapes is that he went through all those emotions and had to process decades of events in just one sitting, he felt joy for a second only to be broken a minute later...that's just too tragic
They’re pretty neck and neck I think for the majority of the population or the majority of Nolan and zimmer fans so I’ve never been upset with someone thinking one is better than the other, I often think I know which one I like more, but then it changes just like that. I attended my dad’s funeral 2 days before my 18th birthday and he was my hero and the wisest man I’ve ever met. So the dad/daughter dynamic (even though I’m a son) and the “my dad promised me” really has always hit me hard, and the fact that interstellar could be representative of possible futures for our reality some day. The earth dying and what not.. the organ and soundtrack is just insane. But inception is its own master piece too. And equally as good. People can relate to that guilt Leo feels about what he did and I feel close to that as someone who shares deep guilt too knowing that I could have seen my dad the night he died but chose to go to a dumb high school party. And it’s not like I knew he’d suddenly pass but. Us humans are hard on ourselves. Regardless they’re just both master pieces in acting, soundtrack, plot. Everything.
Also disagree, Hans has done many better scores. Lion King, Gladiator, Pirates of the Caribbean, this just gets more noticed as it is more "recent" than those.
@@samirSch I don’t think Inception is intended to move you with emotions. IMO the film was designed to take you on a crazy ride, to blow your mind by the expertise of Nolan’s vision. Interstellar is a beautiful blend of science, visuals and emotions.
If you had stayed awake the first time you tried to see this movie, we would never have been able to enjoy your reaction. It was not a crime to fall asleep. It was a blessing.
I saw this in theaters with a girlfriend when it was released. I'm hoping to see it with her again this year when it re-releases, now that we're married with kids. I hope to see it with my daughter when she is older.
A good father daughter movie, I did that with my daughter and she see's me in a new light, What wouldn't dad do for me? We have been closer than ever before. I would say watch it with her and let her cuddle when she needs too. (Dad will always be there for her)
I never got the chance to watch this back then. Hell, my first time watching this movie was 3 years ago on a plane lol. I've been waiting for it to come back later this year so i can have the official theatrical experience lol
I love Hanz Zimmers score for this it's brilliant. The scene on the water planet, the clicking you hear in the background the whole scene is counting 1 day per click back on earth. When you listen to it go by so fast like that it's crazy to think about. Also, Arrival is the movie that made me obsessed with the idea of how the language we speak decides how we see the word and learning new languages and the possibilities and outlooks that can come with that. So fascinating.
are you saying that we heard ~8400 clicks in that sequence? :D Its 1 second / click (its a sound of a clock), simply to keep us reminded of passing time and to induce a feel of urgency.
@@zatharigo7815 Honestly, I can't tell you the math on it lol I'm just a music nerd who took Hanz' Masterclass and he talks about how he plays with time within his movie scores. And he just mentioned that based on the time slippage, 1 click is supposed to represent 1 day on earth. And yes for the reason you stated to keep us reminded of what is at stake :) The sound fades into the score as it gets bigger so its hard to say how many there are total, but I don't think it's supposed to add up the the 20+ years they were actually there. He does it quite a bit in Inception too where parts of his score or sounds are slowed down by x3 when they are 3 levels deep in the dream. Just fun music things :)
The clicking tempo changes, from 48 bpm (once every 1.25 seconds) to 60 bpm (once every second). With the 7yr/h 48 bpm equates to ~21.3 hours, for 24 hours it would've had to be ~42.6 bpm. Maybe they just rounded the 7.89 yr/h down.
@@marwinhochfelsner I kind of just figured with them spending twenty-three years, four months, and eight days there in Earth time, equalling three hours and seventeen minutes in their own time... we don't see 3 hours of on screen footage for that scene so i just thought we are to assume some time has passed that we don't see. Filling the gaps of how many clicks we would hear. I didn't even realize the clicks change bpm!
I love how at 1:13:57, after being told the station is named after his daughter and not him, that he has this big, proud smile on his face. Absurdly wholesome.
The black hole illustration for this movie looked almost exactly like the first picture taken of an actual black hole, years before the actual picture was taken. They nailed it. William Shatner had a deep spiritual experience when he went up to space at age 90. The video of him and the other people in the capsule shows them laughing and talking, and he stands to one side, looking so irritated with the others. He said he felt terrified by the utter black of space and when he tried to talk about it the others were drinking champagne like it was a a carnival ride. A lot to process at his age.
That’s because they actually did the real calculations and modeled it based on gravitational physics. Kip Thorne consulted on this movie and the VFX team actually got a scientific paper published on black holes because of it
I totally understand being annoyed with people not understanding and appreciating the meaning of the thing that's happening right in front of them. I'd be indignant too. Especially since you only have about 10 min before having to come back down.
@@bassmunk people have different ways of reacting to that. That's why there are lots of different religions out there, and atheists as well. I myself am a Deist.
Shatner's experience is one that will always stand out in my mind as epic. He broke down and you could see it in his eyes he wasn't acting. He had a new look upon life on the planet.
What a blast, Interstellar is one of my favorite Sci-fi movies! Nolan is a genius! I also like Contact with Jodie Foster AND ALSO Matthew McConaughey 🙂 "Eureka" is an exclamation used to celebrate a discovery or invention, originating from a cry attributed to the Ancient Greek mathematician and inventor Archimedes. After a discovery, he supposedly ran naked around a public market place and yelled "Eureka", meaning "I have found it!"
LOL, I love how at the very start you're like "this is a Nolan movie so I need to FOCUS" and then as soon as the opening title image appears you're like "oh right, that reminds me, I need to dust and clean my apartment..." 😂 Lovely reaction and discussion, as always!
Overwhelmed??? The second time I watched the movie was 5 minutes after I finished watching it the first time... The silence, the physics, how the camera is attached to the vehicles... everything so realistic... this movie has the best transitions ever made in cinema (Cooper going away with the countdown, the message from Murph to change to earth and the message from Dr. Brand to return to the ship) an so many others... This is the best movie forever
The experience of astronauts you are talking about is called The Overview Effect and it is induced by seeing our small, insignificant planet without its boarders and boundaries, against the full, endless blackness of space. To see the planet without all the pointless fighting, pointless separation, pointless "othering" of each other - it is awe-inspiring. And that is the word you are looking for, not cool, but awe. Awesome, in the full original meaning of the word. Also Miranda you should know that all of the shots from inside the Ranger where the actors can see stuff outside, through the windows, that's all in camera. Nolan did everything that would normally be done in post production, ie VFX stuff and did it all FIRST. He then projected all those elements onto screens outside the Ranger model so the actors are actually reacting to things in front of them, rather than a green screen. Anne Hathaway said she was moved to tears when she saw the black hole/wormhole for the first time on set. And you're not alone. The Pulitzer Prize winning author Ernest Becker wrote a book about this very thing, which was expanded upon by the work of a man named Sheldon Solomon and his colleagues. Basically, if human beings only thought about the existential nature of their existence - the fact that we are defecating meat puppets on a tiny insignificant rock in a literal sea of trillions and trillions of insignificant rocks, the fact that our awareness that we are here inadvertently creates an awareness that we will someday not be here and that time itself will continue eternally even though we won't be here to experience it - if that is all we thought about as humans, we would become so catatonic that we would probably die of thirst never leaving our beds. So to counteract what Ernest termed "death anxiety" human beings created Culture, all the cultures that exist today and have ever existed - and what a magnificent sight culture is to behold.
Well yeah, if you stopped eating and drinking and just sat around thinking about stuff then we would die of thirst. Humans can think about incomprehensible ideas just fine and our brains don't crash when we think about how the universe is so massive. Humans do not fall into a catatonic state because of it. It's only a thing in fictional stories to create a dramatic effect and to emphasize how significant and impactful what they saw is.
@@Fragenzeichenplatte It doesnt have anything to do with thinking about the "incomprehensible." It has to do with the weight and implications of what it means to exist and be a person, what it means consciousness and to be aware of the eventual death of that consciousness, the notion that the world continues without us indefinitely while we aren't here to experience it, the notion that other conscious beings exist, meaning and purpose etc. I wasn't referring to it with regards to the content of the movie specifically, ie space. What I was saying has nothing to do with thinking about space, let alone the vastness of the universe itself. The reason we don't go catatonic thinking about it, is because we developed a buffer that helps our minds compartmentalize all that, which as I said, is human culture.
@@BadassRaiden The "weight and implications" don't affect the brain at all. It's not human culture, it's just how the brain works. If it was different you wouldn't even be able to have these thoughts in the first place. The brain can deal with difficult, complex questions, the same way it can handle a math problem or a move in chess or even a tricky shot with a rifle during the Olympics. No one talks about "catatonic states" then.
@@Fragenzeichenplatte You simply fail to understand what I'm talking about about. The brain only successfully thinks about these problems, if it stops every once in a while, utilizing the buffer that is culture. It ALL we ever thought about was the fact that we are defecating meat puppets, conscious of the fact that we are here and that someday we will not be here, and the weight of what it means to be a moral agent, we would never get out of bed. It's called Death Anxiety and it's been proven as a concept through literal decades of psychological research. If you think the weight and implications simply don't affect the brain at all, then you have no idea what you are talking about. There has been a considerable number of studies, again, over decades, that proves beyond a reasonable doubt, that when you remind the average person of their mortality, and by remind I mean subconsciously - by flashing the word death in front of their eyes so fast they don't even consciously read it - they are more likely to not be generous to strangers, Christians are more likely to be less compassionate towards Jews, they are more likely to be accepting of the killing of animals other then for protection or food, religious individuals are more likely to consider being a suicide bomber - doesn't matter if they are Muslim - and in general they are more likely to be okay with the bombing of another country that doesn't pose a serious, current existential threat to their safety. Human beings do not like being reminded that they are animals that will someday die. Period. It's called Death Anxiety, it is a real, proven phenomena.
Watching this in IMAX was an almost spiritual experience... Every aspect was a masterpiece of film making. Thank you for your insight and real and emotional reaction. You should also watch the film 'Contact' if you haven't seen it yet, very much in the same vein as this and Arrival.
@@davidfox5383 Too bad IMAX requires movie-goers to travel to an IMAX theater in order to fully experience the movie. That being said, I love that the IMAX format ensures that the movie is captured at really high resolution, unlike those first digitally shot movies like Star Wars Episodes 1 and 2.
Imagine watching this in theaters... ❤ You feel every single thing. The docking scene was the most intense experience I've had watching a movie in a theater. The seats were shaking, the soundtrack was blaring, I felt like I was literally there with them. If it ever comes back on IMAX, I've got to do it again. This movie is a masterpiece ❤
Fun fact, Kip Thorne was the science advisor for the movie (he's THE living reference for general relativity, and gets a nobel prize for gravitationnal waves in 2017... so he's a big deal). That was the first time that they use general relativity equations to generate images with that much details and resolution, to create image of the black hole. Black hole simulation were already done for more than 30 years, but not at this scale, they actually discover things doing it. They had to tweek it a little to not confuse viewers (moslty on colors and luminosity), but the movie is incredibly accurate for the rendering of the black hole.
My favorite movie of all time. Like you, I felt profoundly changed by this movie. Have watched it at least 10 times, and dozens of YT reactions. Really enjoyed yours. You’re not alone, this film touches on deep, deep aspects of what makes us human. It just happens to take place partly in space, but it’s not just a “space movie”.
Brand never knew that Murphy solved the gravity problem, so she's completing the "Plan B" mission without realizing life on Earth has improved. Thus, Cooper is going to find her to help her, bring her back, or otherwise not leave her alone for the rest of her life.
Life in earth didn’t improve. Murph solved the gravity issue and built the huge space stations. Cooper was going to help Brand start a new civilization on a new habitable planet not rescue her.
It wasn't Einstein running nude through the streets of Syracuse - according to legend Archimedes ran naked through the streets of Syracuse shouting "Eureka" [I have found it] when he had come up with the idea of Archimedes' Principle, the idea that the volume of water displaced by an object equals the volume of the object. This makes it easy to calculate the volume of oddly shaped objects and thus the objects density if you weigh it.
From wikipedia: The upward buoyant force that is exerted on a body immersed in a fluid, whether fully or partially, is equal to the weight of the fluid that the body displaces.
"I think I'm too emotional for this movie today." No, no you're not. As a grown ass man, I'm not ashamed to say I bawled my eyes out. This movie is just emotional. This is the only movie to ever make me ugly cry.
Wonderful Miranda. It's amazing to see how emotionally invested you get. Same with your video games, I've only watched a couple of those as I prefer films, but it's great to see someone like you doing these because you feel things so intensely.
As a physicist, this movie has always been intriguing to me. Some people have asked about the validity of the science in the movie. It actually is about as accurate as possible. The main advisor was Kip Thorne, a Nobel prize winner, and one of the greatest living astrophysicists. He won the Nobel for detecting gravitational waves. I went thru the equations myself because I was curious if the time dilation of a planet orbiting a huge black hole would be greater due to the relativistic velocity required to maintain orbit (relativity) or due to the huge gravitational well of the black hole itself. I could only calculate it for a non-rotating black hole. The proper equations take into account a spinning black hole, which drags the gravity field around with it, making space-time even more distorted. However, even my simpler equations got numbers that were in line with those in the movie. It turns out that the gravity effect dominates for a black hole the size of the one in the movie.
Ive watched this several times, but i just realized that they said there are 6 billion people on earth. So 2+ billion people have already died (presumably) due to the atmospheric changes on earth.
Maybe so but also this is some unknown time in the future, at least several decades. Some of it might have been attrition as old people died off and birth rates plummeted. Probably a mix of that and starvation.
There's a line where I believe Mathew's character says to Michael's (paraphrasing) "they realized 'ending' people wasn't a long term solution", so that likely means there was a period of global war/extermination going on at some point.
Also in reality there would be no possible way to transfer 6 billion people logistically off the planet to a space station....let alone another planet through a worm hole. Maybe a few hundred thousand tops. The rest would die on earth.
5 месяцев назад+2
The craziest thing about the whole scene with Cooper docking to the Endurance, wasn't just that Cooper had to match the rotation of the ship, but that he had to do it through absolutely MASSIVE G forces. I'd guess he was probably pulling like 15-16 G's by the end of the spin, since Brand passed out like halfway into the rotation, which I'd expect was probably around 8-9 G's.
This is my favorite Nolan! Seeing it in IMAX 70mm was a life changing experience, haha can't wait to do that again later this year. And yes, "because my dad promised me" kills every damn time.
Film student here: at 48:18 the "dubbing" over of the lines is called ADR which stands for Automated Dialogue Replacement. How it's done is the actor is brought into a recording studio during post-production, they stand in a booth with a monitor and microphone and they watch the scene on screen and then recite the lines that need to be replaced. This is done when the audio recrded on set isn't good enough or there was some other issue with the audio in the shot. It is extremely challenging for both the actor who has to give the same energy, cadence, tone, etc (this is usually done a long time after shooting), and also the sound engineer who has to recreate the same sound environment and effects, matching things like echo, reverb and room tone (audio recorded on set with multiple microphones will sound way different then a single microphone right in front of the subject in a sound proof booth). The ironic thing about ADR is though the first letter stands for automated, there isn't a single automated thing about it xD! Also fun fact about movies: While dialogue is mostly captured on set and used in the final cut, practically every single other sound you hear in a movie is created in post-production. Everything from a gunshot and door slams to clothes rustling and footsteps. Sound is the main reason why films take so long to make.
It's more of a realization by scientists than a contribution of raw data to science. All they did for this VFX was plug in some numbers from a physicist about relativity. Don't get me wrong: it's awesome to have an accurate depiction of a black hole!
@@kratosGOW Saying it like that undermines the achievement, I think, of course it was a little more than plugging in some numbers. If I'm not mistaken the shots of the black hole took months to render. There's even peer-reviewed papers that discuss this movie.
@@VColossalV It did take a lot of data to process and render the black hole, yeah. The end product could have inspired some ideas about the workings of a black hole within the scientific community, I agree. I'm willing to accept that.
Nolan brought Kip Thorne early on the project (still in the writing phase) because he wanted the science to be as realistic as possible. He was very clear on that and it is all checks out until the point Cooper enters the Black Hole at the end.. The fact that Kip was an executive producer on the movie shows his dedication to this really well. He is a theoretical physicist working on gravitational physics. They developed a computer model that based on his equations was able to simulate how a black hole would look like. They used that model as a basis for the CGI in the movie. The fact that science proved them right later just shows what a brilliant scientist he really is. He was awarded the Nobel prize in 2017 for his work on gravitational waves. I have always been a fan of Hans Zimmer, most of his work is just amazing. Pirates of the Caribbean, Black Hawk Down, Gladiator, The Dark Knight, Inception, The Da Vinci Code, Blade Runner, etc... All exceptional work but in my opinion this is his Magnum Opus. There is just something about the way he uses organs here its almost distracting. It brings up so much emotions in me I can barely focus on the movie. Seen it about 15 times and it never fails to completely overwhelm me its not even funny at this point the whole thing is just surreal. I am a huge fan of original movie soundtracks and I adore a lot of them so much I have them on my phone and listen to them on a daily basis. But this one is really special to me, in my opinion its one of the best piece of music of the modern era. And thats a really high praise I am aware of that. Here is a short 5 mins long vid where Nolan and Zimmer talks about the creation of the soundtrack. Really interesting stuff. ruclips.net/video/L_8t2VlwK4w/видео.html It's perfect casting, outstanding writing and performances across the board. But damn that little girl who played Murph...usually child actors performances go from bad t mediocre but very rarely you get one that kills it so hard than this young lady did. Mackenzie Foy deserves all the credits for her performance here, the relationship with her dad was so believable and natural doesn't matter how many times I watch it, I cant find anything that stand out as not genuine. I agree on the masterpiece part. This was the movie that made me a fan of Nolan. I loved his previous stuff and knew he was stupidly talented but this movie....not that many people could make a movie that makes me feel so gutted after watching it for the 10+th time. Even tough I am a huge fan of Star Wars, this is by far my favourite scifi movie lol And please don't be embarrassed for crying, its the natural state of things watching this movie. I think it was quite sweet. I had a lot of fun watching it.
One of the reasons I enjoy watching reacts is because it reminds you of your first watch of your favorite movies. The best part is finding somone online with the same like-mindedness and see their first reaction. But, sometimes you stumble upon people who will catch certain things about your favorite movies and add that additional magic to the things that you love. Thank you! That moment when Mann wakes up, you mentioned everyone's being a little selfish and I didn't think about that. Love it!
Also, the crazy thing about the water planet from Romilly’s perspective is that the ranger would seem to slow down faster and faster as it moved away from the Endurance until it basically stopped. You wouldn’t notice it had moved until years later
This is probably my favorite sci fi movie of all time. Most movies in this genre have big space battles or cool aliens and stuff but this movie keeps the relationships between the characters and the emotional moments at it's core and that's what makes it such a masterpiece
I got to see this movie twice in theaters and what an experience it was both times. The second time I took this girl, I was dating at that time, and she was crying at the scene when Coop was seeing the messages from his family, hard down sobbing
I think I 100 percent agree you. 100 percent. To see there are still people like this, and are willing to speak it, makes me feel like there is still hope in this world.
“It has been said that astronomy is a humbling and character-building experience. There is perhaps no better demonstration of the folly of human conceits than this distant image of our tiny world. To me, it underscores our responsibility to deal more kindly with one another and to preserve and cherish the pale blue dot, the only home we've ever known.” Carl Sagan ~ Pale Blue Dot
I have watched probably most of the reactions to this masterpiece but I was hoping that I'd watch yours and not only I was so excited when I saw the notification but I knew it'd be the best reaction to it. I love your reactions, I've said it before n will keep saying that, the combination of witty remarks, emotional, comedy, silliness, nerdy moments, all make your reactions something to look forward to. There's so much I could say about this movie and about your reaction but will just say in the water planet, there was a clicking noise, not sure if you noticed it, that represented every 1.25 seconds there would be a day on earth. The amount of research Nolan did for that movie is insane but def worth it as he showed, before it was actually proven by scientists, how a black hole would look like. All those space shots were amazing too. I'm so glad to have watched your reaction.
This movie was and still is the greatest movie theater experience I've ever had. And it did give me that same feeling of a "spiritual awakening" that you described, I'm glad you loved it! 😊
I saw this movie in an IMAX like theatre in North Carolina a few weeks ago and let me tell you. The black hole scene was such a loud low frequency it vibrated inside your chest
I thought I maximized the entertainment value by watching and rewatching interstellar. But rewatching it with you Miranda has truly taken it to another level. I honestly related to ever single emotional tug at your heart and surprisingly relived it all over again like watching it for the first time. I feel like Christopher Nolan is a soul friend from another dimension. He has taken the concept of time in Memento, Inception, Interstellar...and not only enlightened me in its abstractness, but also immersed me in the experience. Epic...truly epic! masterpiece
One of the best, if not the best, reactions to this movie I've ever seen. And I've seen quite a few! Natural, spontaneous, genuine, funny, and at times profound. I sincerely congratulate you.
Ursula K. Le Guin's "The Lathe of Heaven", a novel published in 1971, explores the idea that we are living a reality shaped by the dreams of others. It's been made into a TV movie for PBS in 1980 and re-made years later. Not available on streaming services but I managed to snag the DVD (and the book) from Amazon.
Ouch. Cooper denies Brand's request to follow her love probably because he's pissed off at the extremely costly mistake she had made on the first planet. And maybe he wanted to throw some cold, hard science in her face after she apparently decided to abandon it. That might seem petty, but I can't blame him. It cost him 23 years on Earth, and cost another guy his life. 😣
Hans Zimmer created the themes for this film without seeing it. He didn't even know it was a sci-fi epic. Nolan told him it was about a man who had to leave his family, and he developed the musical motifs on that basis.
I love how your brain works, it's just like my own! Fun Fact: Lazarus is also the one who brought back King Leoric as an undead King in the first game "Diablo" of the Diablo franchise back in 1997. Lazarus is also a biblical figure dating back to the time of Jesus Christ and was the brother of Saint Mary of Nazareth, aka- Jesus's Mother. I don't think anyone can understand the level of psychological impact and toll that kind of loneliness Dr. Mann had to endure would cause on someone's psyche. Just imagine being galaxies from any nearest human being with no way of communicating or interacting with someone else. No matter how introverted we are that level of loneliness is too much for even the most introverted person on the planet. It is one thing to have the ability to "Choose" "When" we go into solitude, but a whole other thing entirely not having an option whatsoever. Many believe that "Love" is humanity's strongest emotion, but that is incorrect, "Fear" is. The way i think of the Universe is like this this: Ok, so as someone who does not believe in "God", a pantheon of "Gods" or anything that resemble a "Divinity", i have a hard time understanding how the lack of definitive proof of it's existence trumps what we do know from science. Like how can people be so ignorant of the fact that everything around us, the root of every single convenience we have, come from the intrinsic human need to seek "Truth". Science was born out of that necessity and science have the theories and the concept of "God" and the "Divine" to thank for it's existence. Because without their flawed explanations for how things operate, which does not add up to our reality, science would never exist. However, I personally believe that we don't have enough proof to say that "God" and the "Divine" does not exist either. Because we simply do not have enough information about the universe to make that conclusion. So i am open to the possibility of it, but lean towards the fact that the scientific evidence so far suggests that it is highly unlikely. But I also believe that we need not only both to come to the real "Truth", but also something else that is yet to come to our understanding in order to get to the bottom of the fundamental "Truth".
All in all i think believing in something higher than ourselves ultimately serve as good for the prosperity of our species, up until the point that belief becomes weaponized and used against those who do not believe / have a religious faith, or faith different from yours, or used explicitly to gain power. The moment it is used for selfish reasons, or is used to impose your belief / faith upon others by force / submission / fearmongering or any other non voluntary method, it loses the very essence of what it's supposed to represent. The human need to seek "Truth" is also directly responsible for the birth and creation of the concept of "God". Our human need for "Truth" used these concepts to make sense of things that was yet to be understood on a deeper level. Now, the life of a human being is "Finite" and the psychology of our mind as a species has evolved over time to look at the world from the perspective of "Beginnings" and "Ends" in order to make sense of things and to survive. Most human beings lack the ability to comprehend perspectives on massive scales, like the scale of the universe and it's perceived "Origin". That "Origin" is an assumption most humans make when thinking about the universe. But if they had really stopped to think about it for real, the most logical answer to the age old question about the "Origin of the Universe" is that: "There is no Origin". The Universe have always been here. That is something most people cant come to grips with, because we tend to view the existence of anything in "Beginnings and Ends". Which is very true to an extent, but is also dependent on our perspective. The example i tend to use in order to explain where i come from with this is: 1. Let's look at a human life because that is very relatable and easy to understand from a conceptual perspective. 2. We are conceived, we grow in the utero, we are born, we live, and we die. 3. That is the entire span of a human life, it has a "Beginning" and an "End". 4. Now, let's break that mindset to be able to look at things from a larger perspective. 5. So, Before we were conceived, the atoms, quarks and everything else that made us into a human being still existed in the universe, they were part of something else right? As a configuration in something with a different purpose. 6. We all now understand that everything that converge upon conception to form the Beginning of Life converged from a prior existence and purpose? 7. Now then, when we die, what then happens to everything that was part of our particular configuration of atoms, quarks etc? Well, naturally the same thing happens as when we were born but in reverse. The Atoms, Quarks etc, everything that made us who we were in life, is transformed again into something else with a new purpose in the universe. So far we can all agree right? 8. So now i ask you to look at, or choose Anything from the Universe and ask yourself does the same process happen to that? 9. And the answer to that is unequivocally: Yes! So, this brings me to the final conclusion for my reasoning and the question for both me and for you all that took the time to read this: "Why would the Universe itself be any different from anything within it?" And the answer to that becomes crystal clear doesn't it? It is not. It has always been here. But just as my example above of a human life and everything else that change over time, so does the shape of the universe. What science is able to trace "back" is simply one point out of an infinite amount of changes that has occurred. The universe has always existed, there is no beginning or end to it, it is just under constant change / morphology. If you took the time to read my thoughts on the "Universe, God and Existence" Thank You for your patience! I would love to hear if you agree or disagree and if so what is a good counter argument that is based on logic and reasoning, not superstition!
A masterpiece indeed ❤ if you haven't seen The Martian you should consider it for your next watch. They're very different, yet they go together. Perfect reaction, glad you fell asleep the first time, looking forward to the next
I mean regardless of whether or not the movie claims that, which is also what I think, it’s just a great way to think about life and humanity in general
@@pleutron Why? Why do some humans have a need to be grammar police online? For one, some people struggle with words and sentence structure. Others aren't native English speakers. And the point of communicating is to convey something. Was it understood what was conveyed? Yes. So what's the issue?
@@ProxCyde I’m sure spelling and definitions matter in other languages just as much as English. In this particular instance, there is a huge difference in the definitions of “no” & “know”, except for their *sound* .
@@LochAndLoad95 I struggle with Spelling/Grammer/Reading especially if it’s not important it’s just my brain don’t work like that. If you ask me to draw you it would be like a photo if you asked me to remember numbers or names or anything I can my retaining skills are top tier lol.
I watched this movie & The Martian (Matt Damon) recently, and I was in awe!! I had never watched them. Despite always having a fascination with space growing up, I never watched either movie. And I'm so glad that I finally did
Listen to the audiobook on Audible for The Martian. The movie did not remotely do it justice. Also, listen to the Bobiverse (4 books at this writing). Most fun you'll ever have!
I'm an introvert and I loved COVID. I loved that I didn't have to meet with people and everyone was off the street. COVID was the perfect time to work on oneself and reset. I miss that time.
Inception Dunkirk and Tenet are also Nolan movies. Dunkirk is a historical recreation. Inception and Tenet are Sci-fi and will really mess with your mind
You may want to check out Christopher Nolan's brother Jonathon Nolan's work as well, he wrote the Interstellar script and just recently did the new Fallout TV show. Both brothers are equally genius level filmmakers.
48:20 I have watched this movie over a hundred times, literally, and I have never ever noticed the dubbed audio at that spot. Holy hell that was a good catch
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
Hey everyone! It's been over a week since I have seen this movie, and it has really stuck with me... I have never something like this that was so thought provoking. I keep thinking about how important it is to be grateful & how valuable our time is, especially when spending it with loved ones. I just want to thank you for taking the time to enjoy this masterpiece with me! ❤
❤️
You are so right.
In addition, it reminds me to support people around me, so they get the support and some experiences, their family or situation does not provide.
(small scale, not rich and certainly no saint)
It's been years since I watched this movie. It is still stuck with me. Don't worry its normal ahaha
Watch Tenet that's Nolans greatest movie, it's an R rated written and directed by Nolan masterpiece, once again about the concept of time, and it has a terrifying villain played by Kenneth Brenagh, and it's a mind bender beyond anything ever put on screen before.
I swear I got completely lost in this movie. It was an unforgettable experience.
McConaughey not even being nominated for this film is one of the Oscars biggest misses.
The average Oscar voter makes elderly Murph look young and spritely. They are increasingly irrelevant.
the oscars has and always will be just bunch of industry goons patting each other on the back.if you're not part of the wide scale circle jerk in hollywierd , then chances are you won't get an oscar or even a nomination.
So true. Watching his movie has been when I realized how good an actor Mr. M is.
I agree
@@Mathemagical55 Such as the far leftie Robert Deniro! lol
Everyone misses the point of the ending. Brandt takes off her helmet showing that the atmosphere is breathable and that all along her love for the guy was guiding them to the right place.
Yeah dude... Everyone noticed that
And his love for his daughter was what saved the humans back on earth and sent them to colonize space.
A few may have missed it - otherwise, no: because it's the entire point of the movie.
That is literally the whole point of the movie, I dont think I know anyone who missed the ending after a second watch...
Nobody with a double digit IQ missed that lmao
“Because my dad promised me” hits like a truck.
heh. that was fast.
|or Not.|
Or like a faceblast of dust
@@kimnielsen3430 or a orbiting fleck of paint on the windshield of a space station
every fucking time. upon rewatches i may not cry in whole movie but this line breaks me always.
Like a ton of bricks
this movie saved my life twice in 2014 and 2019 from depression and attempts, i am now happy fully employed looking to start a family this year
Why are u lying
May god bless you, stay strong
Why are you so soft..wtf.. remember all humans suffered all kinda of different things...Be tough
@@gamebredo8880 ????????
I’m happy for you, and glad you got through it. Keep going strong. 👍
"Because my dad promised me" Broke me every time 😭
so it doesn't anymore? what changed?
@@pleutronTime is relative, and can be navigated with gravity. It broke me two days from now, and it will break me again last week…
@@inhonoroftrip6320 😂 love(d) that answer. Except Terrance Howard says gravity doesn’t exist
I’ve seen this a million times and that lines still kills me.
@@Etticos. which ones?
The fact that this movie makes a "talking vending machine" a super lovable character you end up caring for is so amazing imo
"I've heard this movie is very emotional" **looks at thumbnail again** Yeah...
😂😂
Oh you poor child
"I have my tissues here ready"
Buy more.
Look up a movie called passengers
@@johncashman1119fantastic movie.
Hans Zimmer never disappoints, and this movie has my favorite compositions of his. When they land on the water planet there's a faint sound of a clock ticking in the background. It happens once every 1.25 seconds, which was intentional and is mathematically accurate. Each time the clock ticks an entire day passes back on earth.
That would be equivalent to 7.89 years per hour. It could be a rounding error, but then you'd think they would've said 8 years per hour. The correct rate for seven years per hour is one day every 1.41 seconds:
(1 hr.P / 7 yr.E) * 60 min/hr * 60 sec/min * 1 yr/365 days = 1.41 sec.P/day.E
This is perhaps the movie that has moved me the most in so many years as a cinema enthusiast, and it's been 47 now.
Of all the reactions I’ve seen about this movie, yours is the one most similar to mine the first time I watched it in the theater. A whirlwind of emotions, questions about time, space, and the meaning of life.
Most people reacting to it ask silly and embarrassing questions about marginal issues, supposed plot holes, or inconsistencies that make no sense. You immediately empathized and embraced the film for what it is: a great love story with a solid scientific foundation. Thank you, Miranda, you never disappoint.
Christopher Nolan actually made a real black hole for this movie. A black hole in our hearts for how sad it truly is.
That’s nothing. Christopher Nolan actually helped humanity evolve into four dimensional beings to hire some as set builders for the tesseract scene.
He actually made a real black hole. None of that CGI crap
@@peterwinters8587 I knew it!
he actually made the real black hole. Not so long time ago we got first actual pictures of black hole and it is very similiar to what shown in the movie
Even as a 4th dimensional being I still don't understand Tenet
I love how this movie plays with emotions. When you realize he’s the “ghost”, you get a sudden sense of hope, but then you realize that he was sending messages to tell himself not to leave… and you’re crushed.
The old people talking about the dust are not actors but people who lived through the dust bowl.
They really are a documentary. They are clips from the Ken Burns documentary on the great American dust bowl. Great documentary by the way
@@DaleKingProfile shame most people have no idea what that is
Although in hindsight you can tell one of those old people is better-looking and more presentable than the others, and that’s Helen Burstyn
@@Big_Tex It's Ellen, by the way not Helen.
@@DaleKingProfile haha I initially typed Helen Mirren because I get them confused
"Because my dad promised me"
What father wouldn't go through hell and back for his kids.
Good reminder of what good parents are like. Weather solo or couple.
Yeah, sadly there are fathers out there who just don’t care. But I guess they wouldn’t be called fathers at that point. More so “organic material”
You speak the truth. I'd easily trade my life for theirs, if it came to it.
Right at the beginning, he says to Murph "I'm here because of you". What an understated call forward to the ending.
Fun fact: Christopher Nolan bought a field and planted all the corn the truck drives through. After the movie was made, they harvested the corn and actually managed to turn a small profit....
not harvested, but sold the farm to a local farmer :)
@@andyjensen2497the corn used was harvested. Look up the article. That’s all this comment meant to convey…Jesus Christ.
Lesser directors would have just added a CGI cornfield in post.
I want this film to leave everyone feeling uplifted, not feeling small. It's a love letter to humanity, celebrating our brilliance, courage, and unwavering will to push beyond the limits of what we think is possible-despite the vastness of the universe and our seemingly insignificant place within it.
Christopher Nolan brought in real-life physicist Kip Thorne as a consultant on this film in order to get as much of the physics of gravity, relativity, and black holes as correct as he could. As no one had ever seen a real black hole before production began, Gargantua's appearance was based on renderings of actual scientific calculations to approximate what a black hole would really look like. It turned out to be remarkably accurate when the first-ever composite photo of a real black hole was taken in 2019, as it appeared very similar to Interstellar's Gargantua.
Also, the decommissioned robot was called KIP in honour!
Unfortunately this is very unrealistic, physics-wise. The scales are completely off unfortunately. But the concepts are at least true.
If you look into the lore of this movie, that wormhole that appeared near saturn was discovered in 2019.
@@TimeFadesMemoryLasts Yeah while I love this movie everything about Millers planet and the time dilation of being on the surface is incredibly unrealistic. If the gravitational forces of Gargantua are so strong to cause such a time dilation, how could the crew operate like it was normal earth gravity while on the surface? Not to mention the dilation effect should be similar whether you were in orbit or on the surface since it wasn’t from the planet itself.
The only plausible explanation was they the landed on the side of the planet nearest Gargantua where the planetary gravity and the gravity from Gargantua somehow equaled out to around 9.8m/s squared. But that doesn’t explain why someone in orbit would experience time at earth speeds. But whatever, it makes for a great scene
@@TimeFadesMemoryLasts Of course they are, for artistic license. Otherwise the movie would be boring, or simply impossible.
The most heartbreaking thing about him watching the tapes is that he went through all those emotions and had to process decades of events in just one sitting, he felt joy for a second only to be broken a minute later...that's just too tragic
Nolans best movie. Zimmers best score. An absolute masterpiece.
Nolans second best movie and second best score of Hans Zimmer. Inception and Time is a bit better
@@Jigsaw_2101 I disagree but very much respect your opinion, Inception was also awesome
They’re pretty neck and neck I think for the majority of the population or the majority of Nolan and zimmer fans so I’ve never been upset with someone thinking one is better than the other, I often think I know which one I like more, but then it changes just like that. I attended my dad’s funeral 2 days before my 18th birthday and he was my hero and the wisest man I’ve ever met. So the dad/daughter dynamic (even though I’m a son) and the “my dad promised me” really has always hit me hard, and the fact that interstellar could be representative of possible futures for our reality some day. The earth dying and what not.. the organ and soundtrack is just insane. But inception is its own master piece too. And equally as good. People can relate to that guilt Leo feels about what he did and I feel close to that as someone who shares deep guilt too knowing that I could have seen my dad the night he died but chose to go to a dumb high school party. And it’s not like I knew he’d suddenly pass but. Us humans are hard on ourselves. Regardless they’re just both master
pieces in acting, soundtrack, plot. Everything.
Also disagree, Hans has done many better scores. Lion King, Gladiator, Pirates of the Caribbean, this just gets more noticed as it is more "recent" than those.
very much disagree on this being nolan's best movie. It's at best 4th for me behind dark knight, dunkirk, inception.
this movie has a 100% success rate of making me cry multiple times.
Every reactor's reaction to realizing he's the ghost is *chef's kiss*. The reveal, the buildup, the drama of it, and then instant tears and crying.
I'm 30 years old. No children. But each time it wrecks me so badly. So no, you are not alone. Noone who shares the same feeling is alone.
Inception definitely needs to be your next Nolan movie...
My personal favorite Nolan film. The acting, the story telling, the twists and turns… and the ending! Simply a masterpiece of film!
For sure worth watching, and it's a great and fun movie, but nowhere as moving as Interstellar...IMHO.
@@samirSch I don’t think Inception is intended to move you with emotions. IMO the film was designed to take you on a crazy ride, to blow your mind by the expertise of Nolan’s vision. Interstellar is a beautiful blend of science, visuals and emotions.
Absolutely!
You're waiting for a train…
@@samirSch Inception is better and deeper than Interstellar.
If you had stayed awake the first time you tried to see this movie, we would never have been able to enjoy your reaction.
It was not a crime to fall asleep. It was a blessing.
I saw this in theaters with a girlfriend when it was released. I'm hoping to see it with her again this year when it re-releases, now that we're married with kids. I hope to see it with my daughter when she is older.
A good father daughter movie, I did that with my daughter and she see's me in a new light, What wouldn't dad do for me? We have been closer than ever before.
I would say watch it with her and let her cuddle when she needs too. (Dad will always be there for her)
I never got the chance to watch this back then. Hell, my first time watching this movie was 3 years ago on a plane lol. I've been waiting for it to come back later this year so i can have the official theatrical experience lol
Now, imagine seeing this on a giant IMAX screen on opening day. Just amazing.
I love Hanz Zimmers score for this it's brilliant. The scene on the water planet, the clicking you hear in the background the whole scene is counting 1 day per click back on earth. When you listen to it go by so fast like that it's crazy to think about.
Also, Arrival is the movie that made me obsessed with the idea of how the language we speak decides how we see the word and learning new languages and the possibilities and outlooks that can come with that. So fascinating.
Correct. Learning a new language means learning a new way to think.
are you saying that we heard ~8400 clicks in that sequence? :D
Its 1 second / click (its a sound of a clock), simply to keep us reminded of passing time and to induce a feel of urgency.
@@zatharigo7815 Honestly, I can't tell you the math on it lol I'm just a music nerd who took Hanz' Masterclass and he talks about how he plays with time within his movie scores. And he just mentioned that based on the time slippage, 1 click is supposed to represent 1 day on earth. And yes for the reason you stated to keep us reminded of what is at stake :) The sound fades into the score as it gets bigger so its hard to say how many there are total, but I don't think it's supposed to add up the the 20+ years they were actually there.
He does it quite a bit in Inception too where parts of his score or sounds are slowed down by x3 when they are 3 levels deep in the dream. Just fun music things :)
The clicking tempo changes, from 48 bpm (once every 1.25 seconds) to 60 bpm (once every second). With the 7yr/h 48 bpm equates to ~21.3 hours, for 24 hours it would've had to be ~42.6 bpm. Maybe they just rounded the 7.89 yr/h down.
@@marwinhochfelsner I kind of just figured with them spending twenty-three years, four months, and eight days there in Earth time, equalling three hours and seventeen minutes in their own time... we don't see 3 hours of on screen footage for that scene so i just thought we are to assume some time has passed that we don't see. Filling the gaps of how many clicks we would hear. I didn't even realize the clicks change bpm!
I love how at 1:13:57, after being told the station is named after his daughter and not him, that he has this big, proud smile on his face.
Absurdly wholesome.
The black hole illustration for this movie looked almost exactly like the first picture taken of an actual black hole, years before the actual picture was taken. They nailed it. William Shatner had a deep spiritual experience when he went up to space at age 90. The video of him and the other people in the capsule shows them laughing and talking, and he stands to one side, looking so irritated with the others. He said he felt terrified by the utter black of space and when he tried to talk about it the others were drinking champagne like it was a a carnival ride. A lot to process at his age.
That’s because they actually did the real calculations and modeled it based on gravitational physics. Kip Thorne consulted on this movie and the VFX team actually got a scientific paper published on black holes because of it
You didn't see the first photo, did you? It's just a glowing blobb xD
I totally understand being annoyed with people not understanding and appreciating the meaning of the thing that's happening right in front of them. I'd be indignant too. Especially since you only have about 10 min before having to come back down.
@@bassmunk people have different ways of reacting to that. That's why there are lots of different religions out there, and atheists as well. I myself am a Deist.
Shatner's experience is one that will always stand out in my mind as epic. He broke down and you could see it in his eyes he wasn't acting. He had a new look upon life on the planet.
Love this 100%. I love how much you appreciate this movie
When cooper tosses the coin it curves in the air unnaturally and falls back towards the center of gravity (where the dust settled).
I LOVE that you said "Coward." and Hans named that track during his scene that.
What a blast, Interstellar is one of my favorite Sci-fi movies! Nolan is a genius!
I also like Contact with Jodie Foster AND ALSO Matthew McConaughey 🙂
"Eureka" is an exclamation used to celebrate a discovery or invention, originating from a cry attributed to the Ancient Greek mathematician and inventor Archimedes. After a discovery, he supposedly ran naked around a public market place and yelled "Eureka", meaning "I have found it!"
Imagine Cooper just showing up where Brand is and just saying "You won't believe what happened."
then Brand replies:
"I accidentally crash laned my ship RIGHT on top of Edmunds the second I got here 😭"
LOL, I love how at the very start you're like "this is a Nolan movie so I need to FOCUS" and then as soon as the opening title image appears you're like "oh right, that reminds me, I need to dust and clean my apartment..." 😂
Lovely reaction and discussion, as always!
Overwhelmed??? The second time I watched the movie was 5 minutes after I finished watching it the first time... The silence, the physics, how the camera is attached to the vehicles... everything so realistic... this movie has the best transitions ever made in cinema (Cooper going away with the countdown, the message from Murph to change to earth and the message from Dr. Brand to return to the ship) an so many others... This is the best movie forever
The experience of astronauts you are talking about is called The Overview Effect and it is induced by seeing our small, insignificant planet without its boarders and boundaries, against the full, endless blackness of space. To see the planet without all the pointless fighting, pointless separation, pointless "othering" of each other - it is awe-inspiring. And that is the word you are looking for, not cool, but awe. Awesome, in the full original meaning of the word.
Also Miranda you should know that all of the shots from inside the Ranger where the actors can see stuff outside, through the windows, that's all in camera. Nolan did everything that would normally be done in post production, ie VFX stuff and did it all FIRST. He then projected all those elements onto screens outside the Ranger model so the actors are actually reacting to things in front of them, rather than a green screen. Anne Hathaway said she was moved to tears when she saw the black hole/wormhole for the first time on set.
And you're not alone. The Pulitzer Prize winning author Ernest Becker wrote a book about this very thing, which was expanded upon by the work of a man named Sheldon Solomon and his colleagues. Basically, if human beings only thought about the existential nature of their existence - the fact that we are defecating meat puppets on a tiny insignificant rock in a literal sea of trillions and trillions of insignificant rocks, the fact that our awareness that we are here inadvertently creates an awareness that we will someday not be here and that time itself will continue eternally even though we won't be here to experience it - if that is all we thought about as humans, we would become so catatonic that we would probably die of thirst never leaving our beds. So to counteract what Ernest termed "death anxiety" human beings created Culture, all the cultures that exist today and have ever existed - and what a magnificent sight culture is to behold.
Well yeah, if you stopped eating and drinking and just sat around thinking about stuff then we would die of thirst.
Humans can think about incomprehensible ideas just fine and our brains don't crash when we think about how the universe is so massive. Humans do not fall into a catatonic state because of it. It's only a thing in fictional stories to create a dramatic effect and to emphasize how significant and impactful what they saw is.
@@Fragenzeichenplatte It doesnt have anything to do with thinking about the "incomprehensible." It has to do with the weight and implications of what it means to exist and be a person, what it means consciousness and to be aware of the eventual death of that consciousness, the notion that the world continues without us indefinitely while we aren't here to experience it, the notion that other conscious beings exist, meaning and purpose etc. I wasn't referring to it with regards to the content of the movie specifically, ie space. What I was saying has nothing to do with thinking about space, let alone the vastness of the universe itself. The reason we don't go catatonic thinking about it, is because we developed a buffer that helps our minds compartmentalize all that, which as I said, is human culture.
@@BadassRaiden The "weight and implications" don't affect the brain at all. It's not human culture, it's just how the brain works.
If it was different you wouldn't even be able to have these thoughts in the first place.
The brain can deal with difficult, complex questions, the same way it can handle a math problem or a move in chess or even a tricky shot with a rifle during the Olympics. No one talks about "catatonic states" then.
@@Fragenzeichenplatte You simply fail to understand what I'm talking about about. The brain only successfully thinks about these problems, if it stops every once in a while, utilizing the buffer that is culture. It ALL we ever thought about was the fact that we are defecating meat puppets, conscious of the fact that we are here and that someday we will not be here, and the weight of what it means to be a moral agent, we would never get out of bed. It's called Death Anxiety and it's been proven as a concept through literal decades of psychological research. If you think the weight and implications simply don't affect the brain at all, then you have no idea what you are talking about.
There has been a considerable number of studies, again, over decades, that proves beyond a reasonable doubt, that when you remind the average person of their mortality, and by remind I mean subconsciously - by flashing the word death in front of their eyes so fast they don't even consciously read it - they are more likely to not be generous to strangers, Christians are more likely to be less compassionate towards Jews, they are more likely to be accepting of the killing of animals other then for protection or food, religious individuals are more likely to consider being a suicide bomber - doesn't matter if they are Muslim - and in general they are more likely to be okay with the bombing of another country that doesn't pose a serious, current existential threat to their safety. Human beings do not like being reminded that they are animals that will someday die. Period. It's called Death Anxiety, it is a real, proven phenomena.
Yes, you absolutely hit the nail on the head, Interstellar is a MASTERPIECE!!! This is by far my favorite movie of all time!
Watching this in IMAX was an almost spiritual experience... Every aspect was a masterpiece of film making. Thank you for your insight and real and emotional reaction.
You should also watch the film 'Contact' if you haven't seen it yet, very much in the same vein as this and Arrival.
Agreed.
@@davidfox5383 Too bad IMAX requires movie-goers to travel to an IMAX theater in order to fully experience the movie. That being said, I love that the IMAX format ensures that the movie is captured at really high resolution, unlike those first digitally shot movies like Star Wars Episodes 1 and 2.
Agreed, but whilst its good, its not quite as good as either this or arrival for me. just my personal opinion ofc.
Y E S ! Please watch "Contact". You will LOVE it. Based on the book by Carl Sagan.
Imagine watching this in theaters... ❤ You feel every single thing. The docking scene was the most intense experience I've had watching a movie in a theater. The seats were shaking, the soundtrack was blaring, I felt like I was literally there with them. If it ever comes back on IMAX, I've got to do it again. This movie is a masterpiece ❤
Best sci fi film I’ve ever seen, which is why I enjoy re-living first time watches with other people. Well done.
21:47 "I was not expecting these kind of emotions"
oh Miranda, saddle up, you're in for some serious tears
Fun fact, Kip Thorne was the science advisor for the movie (he's THE living reference for general relativity, and gets a nobel prize for gravitationnal waves in 2017... so he's a big deal). That was the first time that they use general relativity equations to generate images with that much details and resolution, to create image of the black hole. Black hole simulation were already done for more than 30 years, but not at this scale, they actually discover things doing it. They had to tweek it a little to not confuse viewers (moslty on colors and luminosity), but the movie is incredibly accurate for the rendering of the black hole.
"Eureka" means "I have found it!" and goes all the way back to ancient Greece.
My favorite movie of all time. Like you, I felt profoundly changed by this movie. Have watched it at least 10 times, and dozens of YT reactions. Really enjoyed yours. You’re not alone, this film touches on deep, deep aspects of what makes us human. It just happens to take place partly in space, but it’s not just a “space movie”.
Brand never knew that Murphy solved the gravity problem, so she's completing the "Plan B" mission without realizing life on Earth has improved. Thus, Cooper is going to find her to help her, bring her back, or otherwise not leave her alone for the rest of her life.
Life in earth didn’t improve. Murph solved the gravity issue and built the huge space stations. Cooper was going to help Brand start a new civilization on a new habitable planet not rescue her.
It wasn't Einstein running nude through the streets of Syracuse - according to legend Archimedes ran naked through the streets of Syracuse shouting "Eureka" [I have found it] when he had come up with the idea of Archimedes' Principle, the idea that the volume of water displaced by an object equals the volume of the object. This makes it easy to calculate the volume of oddly shaped objects and thus the objects density if you weigh it.
Wasn’t it to prove if gold given to a king was real?
From wikipedia: The upward buoyant force that is exerted on a body immersed in a fluid, whether fully or partially, is equal to the weight of the fluid that the body displaces.
It might be likely Einstein never went to Syracuse indeed.
@@MikeB12800 Yes. By showing how dense it was he proved it wasn't real gold.
"I think I'm too emotional for this movie today."
No, no you're not. As a grown ass man, I'm not ashamed to say I bawled my eyes out. This movie is just emotional. This is the only movie to ever make me ugly cry.
Wonderful Miranda. It's amazing to see how emotionally invested you get. Same with your video games, I've only watched a couple of those as I prefer films, but it's great to see someone like you doing these because you feel things so intensely.
As a physicist, this movie has always been intriguing to me. Some people have asked about the validity of the science in the movie. It actually is about as accurate as possible. The main advisor was Kip Thorne, a Nobel prize winner, and one of the greatest living astrophysicists. He won the Nobel for detecting gravitational waves. I went thru the equations myself because I was curious if the time dilation of a planet orbiting a huge black hole would be greater due to the relativistic velocity required to maintain orbit (relativity) or due to the huge gravitational well of the black hole itself. I could only calculate it for a non-rotating black hole. The proper equations take into account a spinning black hole, which drags the gravity field around with it, making space-time even more distorted. However, even my simpler equations got numbers that were in line with those in the movie. It turns out that the gravity effect dominates for a black hole the size of the one in the movie.
Ive watched this several times, but i just realized that they said there are 6 billion people on earth. So 2+ billion people have already died (presumably) due to the atmospheric changes on earth.
And starvation.
Maybe so but also this is some unknown time in the future, at least several decades. Some of it might have been attrition as old people died off and birth rates plummeted. Probably a mix of that and starvation.
Last time I read WE'RE at over 8 BILLION POPULATION now this year of 2024! That's a lot of "MATING GOING ON"!! WE gotta' SLOW THAT DOWN.
There's a line where I believe Mathew's character says to Michael's (paraphrasing) "they realized 'ending' people wasn't a long term solution", so that likely means there was a period of global war/extermination going on at some point.
Also in reality there would be no possible way to transfer 6 billion people logistically off the planet to a space station....let alone another planet through a worm hole. Maybe a few hundred thousand tops. The rest would die on earth.
The craziest thing about the whole scene with Cooper docking to the Endurance, wasn't just that Cooper had to match the rotation of the ship, but that he had to do it through absolutely MASSIVE G forces. I'd guess he was probably pulling like 15-16 G's by the end of the spin, since Brand passed out like halfway into the rotation, which I'd expect was probably around 8-9 G's.
This is my favorite Nolan! Seeing it in IMAX 70mm was a life changing experience, haha can't wait to do that again later this year. And yes, "because my dad promised me" kills every damn time.
Yeah, there’s no way I’m watching this on my favorite media device. True IMAX is the only way to experience it.
I hope they re-release it in my country too, I will spend the entire day in the theater lmao
When's the re-release? I missed it the first time it came to theaters
I KNOW! I have it marked on my calendar in late October so I don't miss buying tickets. To quote Romilly, "I've waited years."
I feel this is the magnum opus for both Christopher Nolan and Hans Zimmer.
Film student here: at 48:18 the "dubbing" over of the lines is called ADR which stands for Automated Dialogue Replacement. How it's done is the actor is brought into a recording studio during post-production, they stand in a booth with a monitor and microphone and they watch the scene on screen and then recite the lines that need to be replaced. This is done when the audio recrded on set isn't good enough or there was some other issue with the audio in the shot. It is extremely challenging for both the actor who has to give the same energy, cadence, tone, etc (this is usually done a long time after shooting), and also the sound engineer who has to recreate the same sound environment and effects, matching things like echo, reverb and room tone (audio recorded on set with multiple microphones will sound way different then a single microphone right in front of the subject in a sound proof booth). The ironic thing about ADR is though the first letter stands for automated, there isn't a single automated thing about it xD!
Also fun fact about movies: While dialogue is mostly captured on set and used in the final cut, practically every single other sound you hear in a movie is created in post-production. Everything from a gunshot and door slams to clothes rustling and footsteps. Sound is the main reason why films take so long to make.
This is such a wonderful reaction! I’m hooked on your channel and your personality is amazing!
Imagine trying to break into an abandoned military base only to discover, it's not abandoned.
Creating the VFX for that black hole actually contributed to science, discovering new things about how black holes work.
It's more of a realization by scientists than a contribution of raw data to science. All they did for this VFX was plug in some numbers from a physicist about relativity.
Don't get me wrong: it's awesome to have an accurate depiction of a black hole!
@@kratosGOW Saying it like that undermines the achievement, I think, of course it was a little more than plugging in some numbers. If I'm not mistaken the shots of the black hole took months to render. There's even peer-reviewed papers that discuss this movie.
@@VColossalV
It did take a lot of data to process and render the black hole, yeah.
The end product could have inspired some ideas about the workings of a black hole within the scientific community, I agree. I'm willing to accept that.
Nolan brought Kip Thorne early on the project (still in the writing phase) because he wanted the science to be as realistic as possible. He was very clear on that and it is all checks out until the point Cooper enters the Black Hole at the end.. The fact that Kip was an executive producer on the movie shows his dedication to this really well. He is a theoretical physicist working on gravitational physics. They developed a computer model that based on his equations was able to simulate how a black hole would look like. They used that model as a basis for the CGI in the movie. The fact that science proved them right later just shows what a brilliant scientist he really is. He was awarded the Nobel prize in 2017 for his work on gravitational waves.
I have always been a fan of Hans Zimmer, most of his work is just amazing. Pirates of the Caribbean, Black Hawk Down, Gladiator, The Dark Knight, Inception, The Da Vinci Code, Blade Runner, etc... All exceptional work but in my opinion this is his Magnum Opus. There is just something about the way he uses organs here its almost distracting. It brings up so much emotions in me I can barely focus on the movie. Seen it about 15 times and it never fails to completely overwhelm me its not even funny at this point the whole thing is just surreal. I am a huge fan of original movie soundtracks and I adore a lot of them so much I have them on my phone and listen to them on a daily basis. But this one is really special to me, in my opinion its one of the best piece of music of the modern era. And thats a really high praise I am aware of that.
Here is a short 5 mins long vid where Nolan and Zimmer talks about the creation of the soundtrack. Really interesting stuff.
ruclips.net/video/L_8t2VlwK4w/видео.html
It's perfect casting, outstanding writing and performances across the board. But damn that little girl who played Murph...usually child actors performances go from bad t mediocre but very rarely you get one that kills it so hard than this young lady did. Mackenzie Foy deserves all the credits for her performance here, the relationship with her dad was so believable and natural doesn't matter how many times I watch it, I cant find anything that stand out as not genuine.
I agree on the masterpiece part. This was the movie that made me a fan of Nolan. I loved his previous stuff and knew he was stupidly talented but this movie....not that many people could make a movie that makes me feel so gutted after watching it for the 10+th time. Even tough I am a huge fan of Star Wars, this is by far my favourite scifi movie lol
And please don't be embarrassed for crying, its the natural state of things watching this movie. I think it was quite sweet. I had a lot of fun watching it.
I love all of Nolan's work, but Interstellar just hits different.
One of the reasons I enjoy watching reacts is because it reminds you of your first watch of your favorite movies. The best part is finding somone online with the same like-mindedness and see their first reaction. But, sometimes you stumble upon people who will catch certain things about your favorite movies and add that additional magic to the things that you love. Thank you!
That moment when Mann wakes up, you mentioned everyone's being a little selfish and I didn't think about that.
Love it!
Also, the crazy thing about the water planet from Romilly’s perspective is that the ranger would seem to slow down faster and faster as it moved away from the Endurance until it basically stopped. You wouldn’t notice it had moved until years later
This is probably my favorite sci fi movie of all time. Most movies in this genre have big space battles or cool aliens and stuff but this movie keeps the relationships between the characters and the emotional moments at it's core and that's what makes it such a masterpiece
I got to see this movie twice in theaters and what an experience it was both times. The second time I took this girl, I was dating at that time, and she was crying at the scene when Coop was seeing the messages from his family, hard down sobbing
I was crying too. Such a heartbreaking scene
I think I 100 percent agree you. 100 percent. To see there are still people like this, and are willing to speak it, makes me feel like there is still hope in this world.
“It has been said that astronomy is a humbling and character-building experience. There is perhaps no better demonstration of the folly of human conceits than this distant image of our tiny world. To me, it underscores our responsibility to deal more kindly with one another and to preserve and cherish the pale blue dot, the only home we've ever known.” Carl Sagan ~ Pale Blue Dot
When Nolan wants to make a movie, give him as much money as he wants. He is a unique talent.
I have watched probably most of the reactions to this masterpiece but I was hoping that I'd watch yours and not only I was so excited when I saw the notification but I knew it'd be the best reaction to it. I love your reactions, I've said it before n will keep saying that, the combination of witty remarks, emotional, comedy, silliness, nerdy moments, all make your reactions something to look forward to.
There's so much I could say about this movie and about your reaction but will just say in the water planet, there was a clicking noise, not sure if you noticed it, that represented every 1.25 seconds there would be a day on earth.
The amount of research Nolan did for that movie is insane but def worth it as he showed, before it was actually proven by scientists, how a black hole would look like. All those space shots were amazing too.
I'm so glad to have watched your reaction.
I don't usually get emotional during movies but watching you get emotional makes me get emotional. I love you!
I saw this in theaters and I still haven't fully recovered. Glad you've experienced this now!
This movie was and still is the greatest movie theater experience I've ever had. And it did give me that same feeling of a "spiritual awakening" that you described, I'm glad you loved it! 😊
I saw this movie in an IMAX like theatre in North Carolina a few weeks ago and let me tell you. The black hole scene was such a loud low frequency it vibrated inside your chest
Yeah seeing this in IMAX was beyond epic.
1:06:41 Love the switch from, "we've gone plaaad! 😂😂😂" to "wait those are books 😶"
There's a plane you can book that climbs and then dives, when it dives, you experience zero gravity.
VOMIT BOMBER 🙂
Yep, and it’s called the Vomit Comet 🤣
Comet Comber
I thought I maximized the entertainment value by watching and rewatching interstellar. But rewatching it with you Miranda has truly taken it to another level. I honestly related to ever single emotional tug at your heart and surprisingly relived it all over again like watching it for the first time. I feel like Christopher Nolan is a soul friend from another dimension. He has taken the concept of time in Memento, Inception, Interstellar...and not only enlightened me in its abstractness, but also immersed me in the experience. Epic...truly epic! masterpiece
This movie is coming back to IMAX again this year in September. I saw it when it came out in the huge IMAX in NYC. Can’t wait to see it again
One of the best, if not the best, reactions to this movie I've ever seen. And I've seen quite a few! Natural, spontaneous, genuine, funny, and at times profound. I sincerely congratulate you.
Ursula K. Le Guin's "The Lathe of Heaven", a novel published in 1971, explores the idea that we are living a reality shaped by the dreams of others. It's been made into a TV movie for PBS in 1980 and re-made years later. Not available on streaming services but I managed to snag the DVD (and the book) from Amazon.
They re-made the movie not long ago, but the original PBS movie is still my favorite. It's definitely a 70's sci-fi, but in the good ways.
The original is excellent, if you don’t mind the low budget aspects of the production. Very thought provoking.
That is a really good book
I read that a long time ago if I recall.... Was there something about giant flying turtles in it? Meh, can't remember.
There’s a Vorlon at the end selling hot dogs
Ouch. Cooper denies Brand's request to follow her love probably because he's pissed off at the extremely costly mistake she had made on the first planet. And maybe he wanted to throw some cold, hard science in her face after she apparently decided to abandon it. That might seem petty, but I can't blame him. It cost him 23 years on Earth, and cost another guy his life. 😣
Hans Zimmer created the themes for this film without seeing it. He didn't even know it was a sci-fi epic. Nolan told him it was about a man who had to leave his family, and he developed the musical motifs on that basis.
Leave his daughter* more specifically
I love how your brain works, it's just like my own!
Fun Fact: Lazarus is also the one who brought back King Leoric as an undead King in the first game "Diablo" of the Diablo franchise back in 1997.
Lazarus is also a biblical figure dating back to the time of Jesus Christ and was the brother of Saint Mary of Nazareth, aka- Jesus's Mother.
I don't think anyone can understand the level of psychological impact and toll that kind of loneliness Dr. Mann had to endure would cause on someone's psyche.
Just imagine being galaxies from any nearest human being with no way of communicating or interacting with someone else.
No matter how introverted we are that level of loneliness is too much for even the most introverted person on the planet.
It is one thing to have the ability to "Choose" "When" we go into solitude, but a whole other thing entirely not having an option whatsoever.
Many believe that "Love" is humanity's strongest emotion, but that is incorrect, "Fear" is.
The way i think of the Universe is like this this:
Ok, so as someone who does not believe in "God", a pantheon of "Gods" or anything that resemble a "Divinity", i have a hard time understanding how the lack of definitive proof of it's existence trumps what we do know from science.
Like how can people be so ignorant of the fact that everything around us, the root of every single convenience we have, come from the intrinsic human need to seek "Truth".
Science was born out of that necessity and science have the theories and the concept of "God" and the "Divine" to thank for it's existence.
Because without their flawed explanations for how things operate, which does not add up to our reality, science would never exist.
However, I personally believe that we don't have enough proof to say that "God" and the "Divine" does not exist either.
Because we simply do not have enough information about the universe to make that conclusion.
So i am open to the possibility of it, but lean towards the fact that the scientific evidence so far suggests that it is highly unlikely.
But I also believe that we need not only both to come to the real "Truth", but also something else that is yet to come to our understanding in order to get to the bottom of the fundamental "Truth".
All in all i think believing in something higher than ourselves ultimately serve as good for the prosperity of our species, up until the point that belief becomes weaponized and used against those who do not believe / have a religious faith, or faith different from yours, or used explicitly to gain power.
The moment it is used for selfish reasons, or is used to impose your belief / faith upon others by force / submission / fearmongering or any other non voluntary method, it loses the very essence of what it's supposed to represent.
The human need to seek "Truth" is also directly responsible for the birth and creation of the concept of "God".
Our human need for "Truth" used these concepts to make sense of things that was yet to be understood on a deeper level.
Now, the life of a human being is "Finite" and the psychology of our mind as a species has evolved over time to look at the world from the perspective of "Beginnings" and "Ends" in order to make sense of things and to survive.
Most human beings lack the ability to comprehend perspectives on massive scales, like the scale of the universe and it's perceived "Origin".
That "Origin" is an assumption most humans make when thinking about the universe.
But if they had really stopped to think about it for real, the most logical answer to the age old question about the "Origin of the Universe" is that: "There is no Origin".
The Universe have always been here.
That is something most people cant come to grips with, because we tend to view the existence of anything in "Beginnings and Ends".
Which is very true to an extent, but is also dependent on our perspective.
The example i tend to use in order to explain where i come from with this is:
1. Let's look at a human life because that is very relatable and easy to understand from a conceptual perspective.
2. We are conceived, we grow in the utero, we are born, we live, and we die.
3. That is the entire span of a human life, it has a "Beginning" and an "End".
4. Now, let's break that mindset to be able to look at things from a larger perspective.
5. So, Before we were conceived, the atoms, quarks and everything else that made us into a human being still existed in the universe, they were part of something else right?
As a configuration in something with a different purpose.
6. We all now understand that everything that converge upon conception to form the Beginning of Life converged from a prior existence and purpose?
7. Now then, when we die, what then happens to everything that was part of our particular configuration of atoms, quarks etc?
Well, naturally the same thing happens as when we were born but in reverse.
The Atoms, Quarks etc, everything that made us who we were in life, is transformed again into something else with a new purpose in the universe.
So far we can all agree right?
8. So now i ask you to look at, or choose Anything from the Universe and ask yourself does the same process happen to that?
9. And the answer to that is unequivocally: Yes!
So, this brings me to the final conclusion for my reasoning and the question for both me and for you all that took the time to read this:
"Why would the Universe itself be any different from anything within it?"
And the answer to that becomes crystal clear doesn't it? It is not.
It has always been here.
But just as my example above of a human life and everything else that change over time, so does the shape of the universe.
What science is able to trace "back" is simply one point out of an infinite amount of changes that has occurred.
The universe has always existed, there is no beginning or end to it, it is just under constant change / morphology.
If you took the time to read my thoughts on the "Universe, God and Existence" Thank You for your patience!
I would love to hear if you agree or disagree and if so what is a good counter argument that is based on logic and reasoning, not superstition!
The music score is beautiful
It is.
It's the best part of the film.
Hans Zimmer really is a musical genius
The fact that Nolan made McConnaughey actually sit through and listen to 23 years of messages to nail that scene. Unreal.
A masterpiece indeed ❤ if you haven't seen The Martian you should consider it for your next watch. They're very different, yet they go together.
Perfect reaction, glad you fell asleep the first time, looking forward to the next
you know its a good movie when it makes someone contemplate life...
Murphy’s Law means ‘whatever can go wrong will go wrong,’ but I believe this film is saying if that is true then so is the opposite.
I mean regardless of whether or not the movie claims that, which is also what I think, it’s just a great way to think about life and humanity in general
This film won't be repeated.
It is off the scale
Love your reaction
Watching it now...
Fun Fact. No Actor used GreenScreen in this film. I no this as Anne Hathaway and Matthew Mcconaughey said so in a interview with Graham Norton
you no? or you know?
@@pleutron Why? Why do some humans have a need to be grammar police online? For one, some people struggle with words and sentence structure. Others aren't native English speakers. And the point of communicating is to convey something. Was it understood what was conveyed? Yes. So what's the issue?
@@ProxCyde I’m sure spelling and definitions matter in other languages just as much as English. In this particular instance, there is a huge difference in the definitions of “no” & “know”, except for their *sound* .
@ProxCyde nothing wrong with pointing out spelling/grammar mistakes so the OP can learn from it. Don't take it so personally 😂
@@LochAndLoad95 I struggle with Spelling/Grammer/Reading especially if it’s not important it’s just my brain don’t work like that. If you ask me to draw you it would be like a photo if you asked me to remember numbers or names or anything I can my retaining skills are top tier lol.
2:57 lmao 😂 I wasn’t looking at the screen for a moment there until you said my name haha
No problem Miranda! Dust busta! 👊
Forbidden Planet...50's first honest sci-fi movie will knock your socks off
"You're gonna love that vending machine"
I watched this movie & The Martian (Matt Damon) recently, and I was in awe!! I had never watched them. Despite always having a fascination with space growing up, I never watched either movie. And I'm so glad that I finally did
Listen to the audiobook on Audible for The Martian. The movie did not remotely do it justice.
Also, listen to the Bobiverse (4 books at this writing). Most fun you'll ever have!
I'm an introvert and I loved COVID. I loved that I didn't have to meet with people and everyone was off the street. COVID was the perfect time to work on oneself and reset. I miss that time.
Great work Miranda! Can you PLEASE do Terminator 1 and 2??? So good.
"because my dad promised me" completely broke me. That whole scene with dying murph is so damn impactful
Inception Dunkirk and Tenet are also Nolan movies. Dunkirk is a historical recreation. Inception and Tenet are Sci-fi and will really mess with your mind
My FRIEND, you are so BEAUTIFUL and you are a great file critic...
You may want to check out Christopher Nolan's brother Jonathon Nolan's work as well, he wrote the Interstellar script and just recently did the new Fallout TV show. Both brothers are equally genius level filmmakers.
"He's the ghost and he didn't even believe in ghost" kudos! Great pick up!!
48:20 I have watched this movie over a hundred times, literally, and I have never ever noticed the dubbed audio at that spot. Holy hell that was a good catch
I just said the same thing tonight 😂
@@CJFromGroveSt09 looks like he says "wake up" instead of "waking date"