grrm is great at depicting complex, multi-layered, and quite broken characters, but he really outdid himself with sandor because, yes, we never see things through his eyes, yet he shapes so much of the narrative. sansa and arya both give us pricelesss insight into him as a person, and these insights are like night and day, but both hold some truth.
Since I never read the books, my judgement is based on what I've seen in the show: Sandor "The Hound" Clegane, I really like this character and the vital role he plays. Without him Sansa would be raped and murdered long before she returns to her home, Arya never would have seen her sister again, would never have survived until she can punish Little Finger for betraying her father and never would have killed the Night King. What made him my favourite character instantly was his act of bravery when he saved Ser Loras when the Mountain tried to kill him. My sympathy for this troubled, broken man who is more of a true knight than all so called knights is unbroken to this very day.
Yes, a great scene 👍🏻 He also very elegantly ends the fight when King Robert shouts out, while the mountain acts like a nasty child that is too strong and brutal to be controlled
Lovely :-) I'm a (personality) psychologist, too, and binged lore videos recently. I missed a psychological perspective, because I think it's the characters more than the plot (not necessarily much, but usually a bit more) that make a lasting impression when you read or watched a great piece of fiction. He's an impressive character on the show for having to stand completely on his own, his nihilistic attitude does not make him friends, but also masks his vulnerability - constant anger is something distressing and depleting, nothing that makes you stronger - and his bitter disappointment about being deprived of being accepted as a normal human being. Judgemental and narrow-minded people are toxic for an individual who was traumatised, the stigma can cause more pain than the immediate symptoms. Say, are you also interested in analysing Lord of the Rings characters?
Thank you! It's great to get some feedback from a fellow psychologist! :) I'd say it's the interplay between the characters and the plot that must work, as in the end it's thanks to the circumstances that the characters find themselves in that the character's individual traits are played out and shaped in return. The Hound is very interesting also because of him being so close to the actual non-fictional human being without any exaggerations or fantastical elements, but with all that's harsh and naturalistic combined with the noble that struggles to survive despite the tragedy. Great suggestion, I love Lord of the Rings! It's certainly a literary masterpiece with many characters worth analysing!
wonderful analysis! sandor clegane is one of my favorite characters, he is fascinating in my opinion. Please do not ever stop making these videos, Im learning so much from you, your channel is amazing and I'm sure that it's going to grow more and more
He is digging graves on the Quiet Isle and I can't wait to see what George does with this character. His story isn't over yet and I can't wait to see how he handles the violence and devastation that is inevitably coming to the Isle. Will he pick up the sword again? Will Elder Brother be his support in forging a more healthy path forward? I think he will use the sword again but will he still enjoy the act of killing or will he fight for something greater than just himself and become a warrior for the dawn at the Wall? I kinda want to see him meet back up with the Brotherhood and Thoros like in the show but he will see how far they've fallen since they last met in the books.
I love the show only text of “the world is built by killers” I think although it’s show only it shows his mindset and criticisms of knighthood. As an inherently violent institution.
If only half of what a you are suggesting here is true then GRRM is even more genius than I thought. E.G. the Cerberus comparison. I am currently re-reading ASOIF and the sheer amount of characters, how they are intertwined and the build up for later events is so complex and thought out that I am in awe over and over again, how one person can come up with such dexterous and in depth world building. I really wish the series will be finished in his lifetime. May I ask, can someone recommend a similar work like ASOIF? Preferably in a medieval fantasy world with magic or a science fiction scenario. However, as long as it is comparable to GRRM work I dig everything :) Thank you for the effort with the video.
Enjoying your videos. For a suggestion, have you seen the movie Ladyhawke ? from the 80s? I love a lot of the 80s fantasy movies, like Neverending Story and Labyrinth. I'd love to hear your analysis on the symbolism in those. You do a superb job in breaking down Game of Thrones.
Thanks for watching everyone! I appreciate your feedback! I'm already working on a second video, which should be published soon. Leave suggestions for any interesting characters/themes in fiction in the comments!
Too much emphasis on Sansa.... who in reality is just a fleeting desire to him, he learned far more about himself from Arya who he saw was quite like him ... this caused him to think long and hard about what his life had become.... he saw that Arya was vulnerable and didn't want to see her come to harm. The hound redeems himself through Arya and while she might not admit it she was the safest she ever was from the time she left kings landing while she was with him. He developed a sense of purpose with Arya, he became a teacher and protector and as time went on you could see developed an affection of sorts for her and even confided in her about what happened to him. She also softened towards him in spite of herself. She saw another side of him that she really didn't fully understand until he implored her to turn back from trying to kill Cersei. It was then that they found peace with each other.... had the hound not died I imagine both of them coming together as some kind of duo... not a romantic one but one of trust and partnership.
12:28. You 'believe' he's still alive, while showing an image of him indeed still being alive, and posting this video *well* after the series had already ended? How does that work?
Interesting take on the hound. For some of your analyses, you have no basis for though, and it also seems like you're trying to fit a square peg into a round hole, it's not going to fit no matter how hard you try. For instance, you say that Arya and the Hound are basically the same person. How? 🤔 Because they both want revenge for something done to them. This seems like an obvious generalization to fit your own story and dialog. You could also say the same thing for Sansa.
grrm is great at depicting complex, multi-layered, and quite broken characters, but he really outdid himself with sandor because, yes, we never see things through his eyes, yet he shapes so much of the narrative. sansa and arya both give us pricelesss insight into him as a person, and these insights are like night and day, but both hold some truth.
Golden. Admittedly I’ve only watched the show but there is something very genuine in the portrayal of the Hound and Theon
The hound is my favourite character both in books and in show
My darling, angry, scary man.
This is beautiful. Thank you for making it. Your voice is very soothing.
She sounds like Sansa
Since I never read the books, my judgement is based on what I've seen in the show: Sandor "The Hound" Clegane, I really like this character and the vital role he plays. Without him Sansa would be raped and murdered long before she returns to her home, Arya never would have seen her sister again, would never have survived until she can punish Little Finger for betraying her father and never would have killed the Night King. What made him my favourite character instantly was his act of bravery when he saved Ser Loras when the Mountain tried to kill him. My sympathy for this troubled, broken man who is more of a true knight than all so called knights is unbroken to this very day.
Yes, a great scene 👍🏻 He also very elegantly ends the fight when King Robert shouts out, while the mountain acts like a nasty child that is too strong and brutal to be controlled
one of my fav characters as well, he is fascinating
Well said
He was always the threshold of impending death. Brutality.. vengeance..but a sense of loyalty and reason
My boi Gregor always tried to keep Sandor warm :)
Too warm.
You sound like sansa
Oh wow and even your accent you say the words “ser dontos” “circumstances” exactly like her
Lovely :-) I'm a (personality) psychologist, too, and binged lore videos recently. I missed a psychological perspective, because I think it's the characters more than the plot (not necessarily much, but usually a bit more) that make a lasting impression when you read or watched a great piece of fiction. He's an impressive character on the show for having to stand completely on his own, his nihilistic attitude does not make him friends, but also masks his vulnerability - constant anger is something distressing and depleting, nothing that makes you stronger - and his bitter disappointment about being deprived of being accepted as a normal human being. Judgemental and narrow-minded people are toxic for an individual who was traumatised, the stigma can cause more pain than the immediate symptoms. Say, are you also interested in analysing Lord of the Rings characters?
Thank you! It's great to get some feedback from a fellow psychologist! :) I'd say it's the interplay between the characters and the plot that must work, as in the end it's thanks to the circumstances that the characters find themselves in that the character's individual traits are played out and shaped in return. The Hound is very interesting also because of him being so close to the actual non-fictional human being without any exaggerations or fantastical elements, but with all that's harsh and naturalistic combined with the noble that struggles to survive despite the tragedy.
Great suggestion, I love Lord of the Rings! It's certainly a literary masterpiece with many characters worth analysing!
wonderful analysis! sandor clegane is one of my favorite characters, he is fascinating in my opinion. Please do not ever stop making these videos, Im learning so much from you, your channel is amazing and I'm sure that it's going to grow more and more
He is digging graves on the Quiet Isle and I can't wait to see what George does with this character. His story isn't over yet and I can't wait to see how he handles the violence and devastation that is inevitably coming to the Isle. Will he pick up the sword again? Will Elder Brother be his support in forging a more healthy path forward? I think he will use the sword again but will he still enjoy the act of killing or will he fight for something greater than just himself and become a warrior for the dawn at the Wall? I kinda want to see him meet back up with the Brotherhood and Thoros like in the show but he will see how far they've fallen since they last met in the books.
Wonderful video the hound is one of my favorite characters
The Man was a true Knight. And perhaps one of the est developed characters. It will be interesting to see him and Arya meet again in the books
My absolute favorite character
Wow! Some really interesting thoughts here on my fav GoT character :)
I love the show only text of “the world is built by killers”
I think although it’s show only it shows his mindset and criticisms of knighthood. As an inherently violent institution.
I honestly thought the narrator was Sansa Stark.
If only half of what a you are suggesting here is true then GRRM is even more genius than I thought. E.G. the Cerberus comparison.
I am currently re-reading ASOIF and the sheer amount of characters, how they are intertwined and the build up for later events is so complex and thought out that I am in awe over and over again, how one person can come up with such dexterous and in depth world building. I really wish the series will be finished in his lifetime.
May I ask, can someone recommend a similar work like ASOIF? Preferably in a medieval fantasy world with magic or a science fiction scenario. However, as long as it is comparable to GRRM work I dig everything :)
Thank you for the effort with the video.
This was an amazing video you really dove deep
Sandor is by far my favorite character in the series. Books or show he is #1 for me.
This was so interesting! I'm so glad I found your channel & can't wait to see more of your stuff!
This is such an insightful well presented video, it has everything I was looking for, you should honestly be very proud. Just excellent.
great vid! love that u added pictures
Jung applied properly. This is amazing.
holy crap, i thought the first line was a lineread from sophie turner. i didnt realize that was your actual voice!
Great analysis 👌🏽💯
Spot on.
It is amazing, thank you :)
Very insightful.
Great video. Such interesting insights.
Is it sansa's voice...???
Ah, busted! Indeed, it's me, Sophie Turner! ... Kidding! Do I sound like her? Because I don't think I do. :D
@@FictionPsychology I actually thought so.
@@FictionPsychology similar, voice, but different accent.
Interesting! I never would've thought so myself. (:
@@FictionPsychology You do sound like her. But a bit different, very smooth.
One doesn't need to believe in a God('s) to have morals.
Enjoying your videos.
For a suggestion, have you seen the movie Ladyhawke ? from the 80s? I love a lot of the 80s fantasy movies, like Neverending Story and Labyrinth. I'd love to hear your analysis on the symbolism in those. You do a superb job in breaking down Game of Thrones.
This is extremely brilliant and insightful! Can you do Theon Greyjoy and House of the Dragon (Fire and Blood) characters?
It's a show and a fictional character my opinion the actor who played him did a good job
Thanks for watching everyone! I appreciate your feedback! I'm already working on a second video, which should be published soon. Leave suggestions for any interesting characters/themes in fiction in the comments!
Thank you
Please do a video on Tywin Lannister
Certainly! Tywin Lannister is on the list. I've been working on videos on some socio-political issues recently, but I'm going back to fiction soon!
Your wish has been granted. :) ruclips.net/video/jDrSXpbe8II/видео.html
thank you
Is Sansa's voice?
Favorite character alongside Tormund Giantsbane
"You've Changed LittleBird..."
Brilliant analysis
He got dat dawg in him
Great video I loved it!!!!!!!
Great video!
You sound like Sansa but with a different accent.. I wonder what accent :D
Too much emphasis on Sansa.... who in reality is just a fleeting desire to him, he learned far more about himself from Arya who he saw was quite like him ... this caused him to think long and hard about what his life had become.... he saw that Arya was vulnerable and didn't want to see her come to harm. The hound redeems himself through Arya and while she might not admit it she was the safest she ever was from the time she left kings landing while she was with him. He developed a sense of purpose with Arya, he became a teacher and protector and as time went on you could see developed an affection of sorts for her and even confided in her about what happened to him. She also softened towards him in spite of herself. She saw another side of him that she really didn't fully understand until he implored her to turn back from trying to kill Cersei. It was then that they found peace with each other.... had the hound not died I imagine both of them coming together as some kind of duo... not a romantic one but one of trust and partnership.
U have a beautiful voice.
Omg when u started to talk I thought it was Sansa talking😳 u sound a lot like her😳
trully a tragic hero who tried in the end to turn his own suffering into vaccine to prevent others from suffering.
I like him
12:28. You 'believe' he's still alive, while showing an image of him indeed still being alive, and posting this video *well* after the series had already ended?
How does that work?
Hast du nicht gehört, dass sie gesagt hat, sie bezieht sich auf die Bücher?! In den Romanen ist unklar, ob er noch am Leben ist. Es gibt Andeutungen.
Interesting take on the hound. For some of your analyses, you have no basis for though, and it also seems like you're trying to fit a square peg into a round hole, it's not going to fit no matter how hard you try. For instance, you say that Arya and the Hound are basically the same person. How? 🤔 Because they both want revenge for something done to them. This seems like an obvious generalization to fit your own story and dialog. You could also say the same thing for Sansa.
Eh ...
I liked the art work ...
As to psychology ... I'm pretty much in agreement with Erica Wing's Father.
.
.......
You sound kinda like Sansa lol
Please keep making videos, they are absolutely fascinating and thought provoking
For a moment, i thought Sansa Stark was narrating
good channel! keep it up!