ARE THEY THE SAME FRAGRANCE? Cotton Candy Clouds vs. Whipped Berry Meringue vs. Pinkberry Clouds
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 июл 2022
- It's clear that Cotton Candy Clouds, Whipped Berry Meringue, and Pinkberry Clouds share many similarities but are they the same fragrance? Keep watching to find out! ☁️
🧼 More Bath & Body Works related videos 🧼
How to shop Semi Annual Sale: • 🔴🟡 SEMI ANNUAL SALE Q&...
Q&A with a BBW Manager (Part 1): • Q&A WITH A BATH & BODY...
Q&A with a BBW Manager (Part 2): • Q&A WITH A BATH & BODY...
Q&A with a BBW Manager (Part 3): • Q&A WITH A BATH & BODY...
Battle of the Body Scrubs: • WHICH IS THE BEST BRAN...
Pink 🍍 Sunrise vs. Fiji 🍍 Palm: • Pink Pineapple Sunrise...
Summer Vibes Candle Ranking: • WHICH OF THE NEW SUMME...
Summer Body Care + Butterfly Box: • NEW Bath & Body Works ...
SUBSCRIBE to my channel 👉 tinyurl.com/y3bcs954
FOLLOW me on Instagram 📷 / melissacavileer
🎥 Equipment I use to make my videos 🎥
🔵 USB Hub so I don't break my back bending over to plug stuff in: amzn.to/3Etfl3E
🔵 SD Card that can handle my HD masterpieces: amzn.to/3blSkDp
🔵 Audio Interface connects my microphone and looks sleek: amzn.to/3pL2uWD
🔵 Mouse with extra buttons to make editing videos a breeze: amzn.to/3vVkhey
🔵 Microphone that makes my voice sound more aesthetic than it actually is: amzn.to/3vRXQqQ
🔵 Portable Hard Drive that stores my bajillions of videos when my computer gets full: amzn.to/2ZxSnKc
🔵 Camera that is bae: amzn.to/3jKNdRC
🔵 Headphones that make bad music sound good and good music sound great: amzn.to/3jMzutO
🔵 Audio Editing Software that brings my music and voice-overs to life: amzn.to/3BtFwp0
🔵 Video Editing Software I use to turn footage into the cinematic gem you just watched: amzn.to/3GBe7We
My favorite is Pinkberry Clouds!!!! I loved it some much last year and will be getting more this year. To me it’s a more mature version of Cotton Candy Clouds/Boardwalk Taffy with the fresh air note that I like and it’s long lasting!! Next is Whipped Berry Meringue which has more of the sugared berry than the others with a sugary vanilla cream scent and LAST would be Cotton Candy Clouds because it a complete repackage of Boardwalk Taffy scent notes and all!! Even though I think the Boardwalk taffy is stronger. But they are all nice…Since I have all of them and some back ups 😂
Yes so true! Pinkberry Clouds is like a mature and sophisticated version! I agree with you. I have been hearing that the Boardwalk Taffy is just a stronger smelling version of CCC. Haha that's like me, I could end the whole thing by saying, 'but I like them all anyway!" 😂 Thanks for watching!
Hi Melissa!
I have all 4 & my very favorite is Boardwalk Taffy. It's the OG of them all! 🫐🍓🍬🍦
I also love Pink Berry Clouds. I love the fresh air note & wear it in August & September. ☁️🌦🫐🍓
Tfs Melissa!
Whipped Berry Meingue has more of that berry note and Cotten Candy Clouds is more of a sugar candy. They are both very similar though that I can hardly tell a difference. This will have to be my favorite bathandbodyworks bodymist
Agreed, on first sniff I easily could have mistaken them for identical. It wasn't until it was on my skin I noticed some variation. Agreed, Whipped Berry Meringue to me was a little fruitier while Cotton Candy Clouds was more sugary. Thanks for watching! 😊
Absolutely LOVE your channel and enjoy all your videos, especially the organization and declutter ones! I have to say Pink Berry Clouds is my favorite, it’s such a nice sophisticated scent while keeping it fruity and yummy! It somewhat reminds me of Velvet Sugar in the slightest, even though that one doesn’t have the marshmallow woodsy note! Spot-on description, loved the video🎉
Hi Morgan! Thank you so much, I appreciate it! 😊 I definitely want to make some more organizing/decluttering videos in the future still! And I agree, Pinkberry Clouds is the perfect combo of sweet and fun, but still sophisticated! Thanks again!
Thank you for answering my question, Melissa!
No problem, Michelle! Hope you're having a great day so far! 😊
I’m loving the background. Now, what’s funny is that when Whipped Berry Meringue came out I smelled it and opted out of getting it. When I smelled Cotton Candy Clouds I immediately wanted it lol. This seems odd if they are so similar but I let my nose decide. Pink Berry Clouds sounds great and I can’t wait to try it. The other one I keep hearing is very similar to these is Boardwalk Taffy but I’ve never smelled it either. Thanks for the video and have a great day. 😀
Thank you, Cheryl! Even though they are similar, those subtle differences really make an impact! Like I mentioned in the video, I really noticed the difference once they dried on my skin as opposed to just smelling them in the cap! Yes, I remember Boardwalk Taffy but I don't have that one in my collection so I couldn't really get a good comparison in. Everyone I've heard says that it's the same as Cotton Candy Clouds and Whipped Berry Meringue, but now that I smell a small difference in CCC and WBM, now I'm not so sure! Thanks, I hope you have a great day as well! ☀️
I did the same thing with those two! I’m newer to BBW so I’m a bit clueless still but smelled the berry meringue and didnt like it. Then smelled cotton candy and loved it! Then went back and got the berry meringue and then today grabbed pinkberry totally unaware that they smelled so similar till I went to pick it up. Still love all three
This was good. From the beginning I was in total agreement! And I love love comparison reviews!
Thank you, I'm glad we agree! ☺️
Good morning, I absolutely love the background that view is amazing! 😍🌞 Thanks for sharing!
Hi there! Thanks so much...it's so pretty this time of year with the green hills! Thank you!
OMG your backyard is gorgeous!!! I did get Cotton candy clouds and I have the Whipped Berry Meringue and to me they are different, but similar.
Thank you, Laura! Idaho is beautiful this time of year! ☀️ I completely agree, similar but varying slightly! Thanks for watching! 😊
I love love love pink berry clouds! I actually layer this with cotton candy clouds.. it smells super sweet, but I really like it.
Oh yes, I'm sure when used together they would make a really nice combo! I agree, I thought it was one of the more long lasting scents out there! Thanks for stopping by! 😊
The rolling hills behind you are stunning! I picked up Cotton Candy during the sale after smelling whipped berry and not liking it. Then I heard they were similar so went back and loved whipped berry so grabbed it. Picked up pinkberry today totally unaware till I smelled it but still loved it and grabbed it too. Ha! They are all very very similar like you said with some small nuances. Totally agree with what you said.
Thank you! I love them this time of year! 🌾
Haha sometimes you gotta warm up to a smell and give it a couple of tries. I know i've started with a fragrance not enjoying it only for it to grow on me!
Yes, agreed! 😊
Background is gorgeous
Thanks so much! 🌾
thanks for this honest opinion really aprecciate. :)
Glad it helped! Thanks for watching! 🤗☁
WoW! I literally just commented on someone else's channel about how the Cotton Candy Clouds totally reminds me of that Juice Bar Cotton Candy mist! HOW AMAZING is that!!!!???? I immediately got that vibe too, and I have a dupe to Cotton Candy Clouds!!!
That Juice Bar stuff was my childhood in a bottle!! I wish they'd sell them again! 😁
Whipped berry meringue and boardwalk taffy are the same to me. They’re my favorites. Cotton candy clouds is similar but to me not the same. Still good but I was excited because a lot were saying they’re dupes. They’re definitely close but really not the same to me.
Yes, I think that the closer I smell all of them, the more I can sense the difference even though they are very close!
I’m my opinion you nailed these!! As someone who loves All 3 of these scents along with Boardwalk TFfy I agree 100%!!
I don’t know if it’s because Boardwalk Taffy is no longer available but that one is my all time fave 💕💕💕 it’s soooo strong!!! I think CCC and BT are the same but I love BT a little more if that makes sense 😂
I’m thrilled Pinkberry Clouds is back!!
Yay, I'm glad we agree on this! I like all 3 as well! I wish I had grabbed Boardwalk Taffy at least in a hand cream or something so it could have been a part of this video! I've heard that a lot of people like that one the best! 😊 I know I'm heavily influenced by packaging as well so when picking a favorite I know that makes me like a scent more if I like the bottle over others. 😂 I'm so excited for the new Fall scents to come, as well! 🍂
@@MelissaC yes Boardwalk Taffy was amazing and it was the first one out of these scents that I wore so that could be an influence as well.
I’m super excited about the Fall scents to come too!! Fall scents are my all time favorite!!
I agree with you. I don’t think the are the same. I love cotton candy clouds. I smelled pink berry clouds in the store yesterday. Definitely will give it a try this fall.
Same! I like the smell of all of them, but I think Cotton Candy Clouds probably smelled the best on me, although, I feel like I need a second opinion. I will have someone else smell them on me and let me know! 😂 I'm definitely excited for the Fall fragrances coming in already!
I agree with everything you said so I do believe there's a difference between CCC & WBM I think you were right about everything 👍
Thank you! I'm glad we agree! 😁
I had the two, pink berry clouds and whipped berry maringu . I love pink berry cloud i felt it is more long lasting and has a strange beautiful note which can't be discribed than WBM it's so light . So i gifted it and bought a back up of Pinkberry 💜 .thank you
I agree with what you said about Pinkberry Clouds! It has a unique not that the others don't have and it makes it so much more rich and sophisticated. 😊
@@MelissaC it's weird that so many girls i know in my country ( except my close friend) ,don't like it at all , they told me it smells like row eggs 😂😂 , i think they are talking about that strange note 😅 so i tried to search in the smell for any "eggs" me and my friend couldn't find anything except a significant smell ☺️ it's funny how our tastes can be sooo different ..
I love love Cotton Candy Clouds, to the point that I’ve had to resort to buying more on eBay. 😭 That was also after I tried in desperation as a substitute: WBM and BT! Neither is the same as CCC but similar. WBM has more berry and BT has more of the sweet vanilla to an almost over whelming point. I just want CCC back so I can buy back up!
Great video!! I love the view!! I have Cotton Candy Clouds and Whipped Berry Meringue. I think they’re a tad different, my Cotton Candy Clouds is much stronger than Whipped Berry Meringue. I’m interested in smelling the Pinkberry Clouds when it comes out, I love woodsy notes.
Thank you! Yes I've been enjoying the view too, it's so pretty in the summertime! ☀️
Agreed, I think they are super similar but are just slightly different, and the difference is most noticeable when you smell it on your skin with body chemistry and all. You'll have to give Pinkberry Clouds a try, it's just now starting to hit stores! It's like Cotton Candy, but more rich with a tiny bit of earthiness!
One of my old favorites was raspberry sweet mint. It came in the line with the lavender apricot. I also agree on how annoying it is when they change the names too much
Yes!! That one was also super good! I had a trio of it in minis that I actually just finished up this spring. I would definitely buy that one again if they ever brought it back! 😊
Blackberry and basil is a repackage of raspberry sweet mint.
I personally think they are all different and pink berry clouds is my favorite of the 3 😁. I agree with your assessment also. I didnt care for the cotton candy clouds, but hands down pink berry clouds with stay in my B&BW club as long as they make it.
Good choice! I'm glad that Pinkberry Clouds will be back this Fall. 🍓☁️ Thanks for watching, Jessica! 😊
There are fragrances which I refer to as "gourmand ideations" - meaning that it has a gourmand vibe to it but not like an * actual * foody item. So Pinkberry Clouds seems something like that.
That's the word I needed to describe Pinkberry Clouds! Good one! 😁
Thanks for beatiful sharing
Thanks for stopping by! 😊
Hello;) I’m new to your channel (subscribed😊) and really enjoyed your video. Great content and info. Plus you have a great personality. I actually have pinkberry clouds on its way to me. I did have whipped berry meringue but exchanged it after smelling it. I thought that it was too close to strawberry pound cake. Fingers crossed that I like pinkberry clouds.
Thanks, chickadee🍃🌸
Aw thank you so much, I really appreciate it! 🥰 Oh yeah, it's definitely worth a try! I found it the most unique of those berry/vanilla kinds of scents that they've recently been making! I hope it goes well! 😊
I loved the mini for this year’s Pinkberry Clouds but I blind bought Enchanted Candy Potion which also sounds like it fits this profile 🤔 I still might want the large Pibkberry Clouds though.
I'd like to try the Enchanted Candy Potion as well...it sounds and looks so cute and makes me excited for Fall and Halloween! I hope it's a different scent than one of these fragrances! So far I've heard one say it's the same (I think as Cotton Candy Clouds) and one person say it's a bit different!
I love your videos.
Aw thank you so much! I appreciate it! 😊
I don't see marshmallow as the same as vanilla though... but I get why people wouldn't see a huge distinction though.... I love marshmallow almost more than vanilla!
Agreed, although I wouldnt put it past BBW to pass it off as the same, or interchange them for the sake of packaging! 😂
I got Cotton Candy Clouds today in both the shower gel and spray mist. I am wearing it right now, and I really love it. I wanted a new scent that can be my favorite since my old favorites, Pink Coconut Calypso and Coconut Candy Apple are not returning to Bath and Body Works, sadly.
I'm glad you've found another favorite! I remember Pink Coconut Calypso and aw mannnn I love Coconut Candy Apple! That one HAS to make a comeback someday! 🤞
@@MelissaC Thanks! I hope so. :)
Whipped Berry Meringue smells much more different to me then Cotton Candy Clouds. I love Cotton Candy Clouds it has a sweet but pleasant fragrance to me and leaves a nice dry down. The Whipped Berry Meringue smell is a very artificial berry smell to me and very nauseating. It has a sickening sweet smell that just increases the longer its on my skin. The body cream is stronger I find. I actually want to get rid of mine because I just can't tolerate it. I haven't tried Pinkberry Clouds but from your description I think I may like that one, although I can't imagine the fresh note in it with the sweet note. I definitely want to smell it in store before I blind buy it online. Thanks for this very helpful video!
Oh, that's interesting! I have smelled that type of artificial berry scent in some of BBW's scents, such as Vampire Blood and some of their random hand creams that are "berry sweet" or whatever and that note doesn't sit with me well either, but thankfully my nose didn't perceive Whipped Berry Meringue that way at all! It's funny how different noses notice different things! 😮
It's funny because to me, even though the note in Pinkberry Clouds is "fresh air" because of the sweet/woodsy vibe I don't really see it as being fresh (not like Sea Island Cotton, Saltwater Breeze, etc). I think it was there way of trying to describe it as being outdoorsy, but I find it more woodsy than fresh airy. I hope that helps, it's definitely one I would smell before buying blind like you mentioned! 😊
I love cotton candy clouds. I returned whipped berry meringue lol. And I’m iffy about pink berry clouds 🤔
🤦🏻♀️😆
I think it’s the packaging that gets me.
Haha I totally understand that. Packaging makes decisions for me way too often! 🤣
Cotton Candy clouds and whipped berry meringue are definitely cousins IMO
For sure, I always say "siblings, but not twins!" 😁🍨
I ordered both CCC and WBM during SAS, and while they are super similar, there is something about CCC I just don't like. I can't put my finger on what, exactly - maybe it's my body chemistry. I'm tempted to order PBC but I went pretty hard during SAS and need to give it a rest 😆
Oh, that's interesting! But you don't notice that so much with the Whipped Berry Meringue? Body chemistry makes such a big difference, so online shopping can be tough sometimes. I know I want to buy all sorts of new Fall goodies but I feel very stocked up from SAS too! 😅 Thanks for watching! 😊
I think they are all different. There’s a def variation in formula. I have all of them, and in my opinion Boardwalk Taffy is most similar to whipped berry meringue. Cotton candy clouds smells a tad more “cheap” and strange on the dry down. Kind of stale on my skin. I don’t like it. Out of all of them, (whipped berry meringue, cotton candy clouds 2021 version and 2022, boardwalk taffy) in the spray boardwalk taffy wins. But in the cream, whipped berry meringue is way better.
Well now I want to try the Boardwalk Taffy out for myself! I'll have to see if they bring it back someday! 🍬 I agree that there are differences in all of the scents, and especially noticed it once it was on my skin. Thanks for the insight! 😊
Juice Bar’s Cotton candy was AMAZING
I used to have that! 🩷🩷🩷
And now we have Among The Clouds (Wild Berry Skies Whipped Vanilla Clouds) 🤔 haha
Hahaha and I think Cloud 9 is coming back too! So many clouds! ☁😂
I think Bath & Body Works had you in mind when they created the mythical "Kate" Lovely long blonde hair living in the rolling hills of middle America! Rubbing your wrists together can bruise the molecules. I just learned this recently! Pinkberry Clouds is my favorite of the 3, and longest lasting on my skin. I call similar scents, a "family." Within this family ( CCC, WBM, PC) they share common notes, but in each fragrance a different note is amplified or muted. If that makes sense.
Aww I love that! I really feel like I am Kate sometimes. 🤣 Thank you! 🥰
Yeah, I learned that while working at BBW and I smelled on someone's wrist the same fragrance, one wrist air dried and the other rubbed in. It was weird how different they were, and how much stronger/longer lasting the air dried one was! It's a Cotton Candy family! ☁️
@@MelissaC You're very welcome. BBW lost a great employee. You have so much knowledge about fragrance! Yes, cotton candy family!
I didn’t like any of them but love watching the review💕
What fragrances do you currently enjoy? I hope Fall brings some good newness! Thanks so much for watching! 😊
Whipped Berry Meringue is a repackage for Boardwalk Taffy. Pinkberry Clouds is sweet and airy.
That's what I've been hearing the most about Boardwalk Taffy! 🍬 Thanks for your insight! 🤗
I want to ask you also about be enchanted and midnight pomegranate !! Are they similar ? Couse i have already BE and i absolutely love it , and i'm thinking to get MP , what do you think melisa ? They both have pomegranate and berry notes .
It's funny, because I've smelled both before but don't recall in depth what each one smells like since it was a long time ago. From what I understand from reading the notes and what I do recall in my memory is that they do share similarities but Be Enchanted is a little more feminine and florally sweet while Midnight Pomegranate has more of an emphasis on the base notes that are a little bit muskier. I hope this helps!
💗💗💗💗
😊🥰🤗
I own Boardwalk Taffy mist and bought Cotton Candy Clouds this year, they smell the same except Boardwalk Taffy is much more concentrated and pungent, I do not like this scent, everyone thinks it’s sugary and sweet but I smell an odd musk that takes away from the cotton candy that I was expecting.
Thanks for the insight on Boardwalk Taffy! I don't have that one in my collection so I wasn't able to include it in this video. I did smell it in stores when it first came out but I don't remember what it was like very well. That does sound odd, I know musks and florals don't do too well with my body chemistry so maybe I'm okay with not having that one then! LOL! Thanks for stopping by! 🤗
Can you review Poppy?
Yes, I'm on it! 🌸
I don't know how I missed pink berry cloud last year, I looove the packaging and the woody airy sweet fragrance is totally my type of sent the sad thing is they changed the packaging this year and I don't think the store in my country is going to bring it back.. I hope I can find it with a re seller🤞🏻
At my store rn they have it out in the mini's
@@ShopandMorewithKimberlyNSantos I'm going to call my store to see if the have at least the minis 😃 thanks
Yes it originally came out early last Fall of 2021! Like they said below, stores are starting to get them in stock, and I'm assuming that it will smell exactly the same as last year's edition! ☁️🍓 I hope you're able to find some! 😊
@@angelaggarrido7816 ur welcome! The full size bottle dropped online and in store yesterday😊
I’ve had this question with myself since last year when I bought boardwalk taffy and later ccc. I’ve gone back and forth with it. I do think pinkberry clouds is different, and I only bought a lotion and body cream to whipped berry meringue, but I swear it’s more berry than boardwalk taffy. Now with Halloween coming out, is the new enchanted candy spell (Is that the name?) going to be another spin on ccc 🤔
I know what you mean! I will be curious to get a good sniff of the Enchanted Candy as well...I was hoping it was going to be a different fragrance! I would find it unusual of them to make it the same fragrance, or even similar. I hope it's not the same...🤔 Thanks so much for watching! 🤗
This was my exact thoughts. Haha
Where does Boardwalk Taffy fall in comparison?
I've heard it's most identical to Cotton Candy Clouds, but is stronger. This is just what I've seen others say though. I need to get my hands on a bottle so I can sniff for myself though!
when you said lakeside breeze it hurt 🤧🤧😂
Hahaha sorry, I meant Lakeside Citrus. At least I didn't call it "Lakeside whatever" like I sometimes do when I can't remember the exact name of a fragrance I'm thinking of! 🤣
I heard somone say boardwalk taffy smells like whipped berry merange but idk bc some ppl said it smells like cotton candy clouds and idk I have both but I don’t have boardwalk taffy so idk what one smells more like it
I think that they are all slightly different, but so close to being the same that they almost aren't worth having all in your collection if you're going for a well-rounded collection, if that makes sense! ☁ But yes, I've heard that too! 🤗
I don't like Whipped Berry Meringue & never smelled the other 2
And Coconut Pie
I really like Coconut Cream Pie! 🥥
They discontinued it in my store plus whipped berry. I wish the girls had told me what was similar to it. I'll try the 2 you said
@melissac do you wear your mists alone or with perfume ???
I usually just use fine fragrance mist. I only have 2-3 concentrated perfumes, but I don't use them much if at all!
@@MelissaC can you help me understand why perfume mist was created ? Was it for college students or for school purposes as for living in the uk some schools don’t allow to wear perfume ?!
So, is enchanted candy potion going to be the same as others? 🤷♀️
I will have to find out for myself, but from what I have seen so far from others who have smelled it, is that it is slightly different from all of these versions but very similar. Kinda weird that they'd even make a scent that similar so soon after...I was hoping for a caramel apple body care for Halloween sometime! 🍎
should have added boardwalk taffy as well
I would have but I don't have that fragrance in my collection. I've heard that both Boardwalk Taffy and Enchanted Candy Potion are similar enough to be considered as one of these fragrances. If not exactly the same, at least close enough! 😅
@@MelissaC yeah I've heard boardwalk taffy is difficult to find now unless you want to overpay to get it from a reseller. I haven't gotten to try any of them other than whipped berry meringue which I love so I imagine the others a great
Pinkberry clouds went a little ' baby vomit' on me, sold it right away. So now I'm scared to try these other 2 🤣
Eww haha I wonder if that's a body chemistry thing. Some scents just don't smell good on certain people. I love the scent of strawberry but about 75% of strawberry scents on me smells like that bright pink Chinese sweet and sour sauce on my skin! 🤣 Not my favorite way to smell!
@@MelissaC yeah probably because fake Strawberry always turns me off. But maybe not on others, not sure.
@@tessab9374try whipped berry meringue. Its similar to strawberry pound cake but while SPC is super sweet on the strawberry almost syrupy n candyish, WBM is smooth n airy with bluberry which is not as much in ur face than strawberries.
Ready to see if bath and body is gaslighting us
Bath & Body Works: Gaslighting since 1990 Hahaha! Yet we can't stay away... 👁️👄👁️
@@MelissaC it all started with “Kate” also that was a lovely background! So calm, so summer.
I have never understood why they market the same fragrance as different with a different product name and packaging, as if it was a completely different product. It seems deceitful to me, and I don’t understand how it benefits them? Boardwalk Taffy was extremely popular, in my opinion, then they market it as cotton candy clouds. Weird
Do you have horses??
I don't have horses, but I am doing live-in pet/house sitting for someone who lives in the country so my next few videos are going to have some pretty backgrounds of the Idaho countryside! 👩🏽🌾🍓🌻🐤
Such a pretty back drop!
I just finished your video, I enjoyed hearing it actually compared and not just saying "oh yeah they're basically the same". Im always like thanks for that, how nondescript 😑
I think my favorite of the 3 is whipped berry meringue!
I think the Whipped Berry Meringue definitely has more of a Berry note. It is very light though. I’m gonna try the Pinkberry Clouds this year.
They aren't the same!!
Pink Berry clouds stinks in my opinion
😂 That's fair! I can see some people not enjoying it!