At 17:06 he says that stopping visa for Pakistanis will help in boosting the economy. He also gives a says that Indian economy did well because they stopped giving Visa to Indian engineers. Pakistan are not getting visas anywhere so why isn’t that helping economy? The fact is that Indians have capabilities which the US cannot do without. Just have a look at the CEOs of all the major IT companies in the US.
Manufacturing in Pakistan is very uneconomical due to its high cost. Mr. Shabbar Zaidi is right that Pakistan should try to promote export of services. Export of services account for more than 40% of India's total exports.
Every Pakistani says that till the 90,s Pakistan was ahead of India. Nobody talks about the IMF loans, aid, grants and the free money and arms and ammunitions received from USA and NATO during the Afghan wars which was not required to be paid back. Obviously under such circumstances Pakistan was bound to be ahead. Pakistan has been in about 24 IMF programs in 66 years averaging a loan every 3 years (starting from 1958) to date while India has been in an IMF loan program only once in 1991. Now all that free money, aid and grants have dried up, so Pakistan is where it should actually be. Honestly I will not be surprised if all the Pakistani policy makers are praying for another war in the neighbourhood and American intervention is there for all that free aid and grants to start flowing in again. Unfortunately for Pakistan the so called Iron brother China does not give give aid or grants and will take back every penny it lends either in cash or kind so the western intervention in the neighbourhood is the only hope for Pakistan as things stand today.
@ Merchandise exports: $437.06 billion, a 3% decrease from the previous year Services exports: $341.1 billion, a 4.8% increase from the previous year Here are some other highlights from India's 2023-24 exports: Trade deficit: Improved from $121.6 billion in 2022-23 to $75.6 billion in 2023-24 Imports: Decreased by 5.66% to $675.44 billion Export destinations: The Netherlands became India's third largest export destination. Other major destinations included the U.K., U.S., China, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, Bangladesh, Germany, and Italy. Top merchandise exports: Gems and jewelry, organic and inorganic chemicals, and drugs and pharmaceuticals were among the top exports from Indian states. Sector performance: Electronic goods and drugs and pharmaceuticals were resilient despite the global trade slowdown. Agricultural exports, however, contracted by 8%. Future plans: The government is working to diversify exports into electronics, pharmaceuticals, engineering products, and food items.
Washmallay! Rs 280/Rs 86 Against dollar. Dollar grows in our desert dryland soils. Palm tree fruits in coastal vast belt region but palm development authority leaderships never intrested to develop supply chain industry.
Shabr Zaidi zaidi sahib analysis is 100% Right analysis about our country ecnomical status & future of Pakistan economy and other matters. Politicians/ rulers with their machinary/ powerful institutions are in nexus.they ( nexus ) only protect their own interests. Rulers knoweach & every thing but they want to keep systen as such ( STATUSCO ).
بہترین پروگرام -امیر ملک کی معیشت 1964تک بہترین-وطن عزیز جرمنی اور دوسرے غریب ممالک کو کو عطیات دیتا رہا ۔کمبزخت کو ایسی نظر لگ گئی کہ سازش کی بھر مار شروع -عظیم قوم کو قومیت ،غربت اور غیر اخلاقی سرگرمیوں میں پھنسا یا گیا۔آج امیر ملک میں دو وقت کی روٹی بھی مشکل۔--جبکہ 1947 کی تقسیم ہند کے وقت چندو پر چلنے والا کمزور ہمسایہ ملک - بھارت- آج ورلڈ اکنامک فورم کا اہم رکن ۔
AGar Pakistan kooo bachana hain toooo yeee 4 kaam foran karnee hongeee 1- Change NFc award and give the authority of collection of taxation to province to run it by themselves. 2- Make new provinces on basis of population/ Ethnicity/ Administration 3- Give power to local govts where mayor is directly elected by public and right to collect following taxes property tax, service tax , local council tax 4- Jis tarah seee natural resources jese, petrol, diesel, gas, seee ane wale revenue ki royalty province kooo millte hain aesee heee districts kooo bhee milnee chahyee
Yaar yeh bandana Pakistan ka naqaam tareen insaan hii... He was the most unsuccessful Chairman of FBR and even couldn't do any notable work in govt.. He can only speak, complain, mourn, because he do not have any vision for solution. Pakistan problem started when such people were promoted to big posts...
Shabbar Zaidi is saying what I had said decades ago (in mid/late 1980s) before coming to America: It was not worth for the Urdu Speakers to make the 'Quota System' such a violent issue that the very peace of the city would be destroyed. I had actually said that to an MQM student wing worker, who got upset with me. And almost FOUR DECADES later Shabbar is saying the same thing: Karachi is self sufficient in many ways while the unfair beneficiaries of the quota system have their home cities/communities still far behind.
Doesnt mean the people who were protesting for their rights were in the wrong in the first place. Not all can have the foresightedness of a blessed few!
@@syedasaadahmed9717 Protesting peacefully is fine but it was not worth it to ruin the communal harmony and the peace of a city like Karachi. Well, history proved me correct as is what Shabbar is also saying in this video! And no need for the 'blessed few' sarcasm. I was right then and I am right now. The city of Karachi paid a huge price for the violence starting mid 80s.
@@meengla Not being sarcastic at all, you thinking as such makes it amusing To your point, this city’s ethos was deliberately messed up by the establishment since the 1960s, regardless what people would or wouldn’t have done at the time does not matter My point is I don’t know you if visited Khi recently or had a chance to visit any local govt setup, civic centre etc, its really demeaning and frustrating to work with those unfair beneficiaries of quota system out of which only few have any competence or integrity, they have been ruling for the past 16 years and have made this wonderful city a shithole like their own rural lands
@@syedasaadahmed9717 Thank you for clarifying. I was myself a victim of the 'Quota System' otherwise probably would have made it to Sindh Medical College in 1984. But I knew the math about maybe 10,000 govt job vs the peace of the city. The peace of the city was destroyed using the unfair Quota System as the clarion call, with disastrous results. And here is Shabbar, four decades later, very astutely mentioning Karachi potentially self sufficient and that it is the private sector which is the real engine for growth.
pakistani dramas are better is a myth . You only create good love story soap operas. In india you can't even imagine the genres and amount of work produced in each day. The size is so big that people only name mainstream saas bahu dramas which isn't the reality.
@09:18, a proper & clearcut answer was not given to the gentleman who asked about three economic indicators to be brought back on track..... That was a sensible & direct query What's the use of other nonsensical, irrelevant talk by Mr. Zaidi. Very low quality talk show
Ek hi hal hy sary masail ka,mulk ko aaeen k mutabiq chalaya jaey,free n fair election kra k true democracy qaim ki jaey. 3 sal mein bhut change a jaey gi.
Wah wah kya zabardast Suchyee baat express kee hey; banow qaabil banow qawbil, where is Flahhee Open IqraaNagar and volunteer retired professee resources for the development of potential skillful human force; lipservices all around longitudes and latitudes.
اتنے بھی برے حالات نہیں ہیں پاکستان کے۔ غربت کی شرح کم ہے۔ لوگ خوشحال ہیں۔ خیرات کرتے ہیں زکوٰۃ دیتے ہیں۔صدقہ کرتے ہیں۔ حج کے دوران سب اسلامی ممالک میں زیادہ تعداد پاکستانیوں کی ہوتی ہے۔ صرف ٹیکس نہیں دیتے جس کی وجہ سے حکومت پہ قرضہ ہے۔ غربت دیکھنی ہے تو انڈیا میں دیکھیں آپ شکر کریں گے کہ ہم پاکستان میں رہتے ہیں
AAP NAY SACH FARMAYA YAH LOG SAB AIK HAION YAH LOG KHUD KO TEEK NAHION HOTHAY DOSRUION KO KAHTHAY HAION TEEK HO JAWO KAMIYAB ADME WOH HAY JO IS KAY KAY SAY MAION BAYTAION HAION OUR IS THARA YAH MULK TEEK NAHION HO GA
Es kothe se puchain jab aap minister thy pti ke doure hokomat main es per implement kion nahi kia oos waqat tho Murad Saeed bi 200 million dollars la Raha tha 100 million dollars imf ke moon per maarna tha aur 100 million dollars Pakistan main doodh ki nadian bahaani thee Khan Sahab ke eik ishaare per dunya se dollars ki barish honee thee sub baatain qoum ko topi oehnaani thee Jo aaj talk youthion ne pehnee hai yeh sub do no economist hai mulak se paise kamaane ke dong hai dramy baaz hai pti sameyth es thara ke logoon ko musalat Karke mulak ka Bera gharaq kia gaya
Islam pr mat dalien,islam mein haram ka kamaya huwa zakat kherat qubool nahi,jo shakhas mazdoor ko ujrat poori to kya zra si late b dy to us ky liye sakht sza hy, aesy logo ko islam sy mt joro.
اگر کسی بچے کا باپ فوت ہو جاتا ہے تو وہ پھر بھی جیتا ہے وقت کے ساتھ ساتھ اسکو کسی کی مدد کے بغیر جینا آجاتا ہے ۔ یہی سمجھو کے پاکستانی حکومت مر چکی ہے اب جو کچھ بھی کرنا ہے خود ہی کرنا ہے ۔
I can bet a million bucks that nothing can happen without human development in knowledge and social science and pakistan will take 20 to.30 years
200 years atkeast
You cannot change the Pakistani System because it was built like that. Only Army and their government can get benefits.
Zaidi guy is not telling these students that Pakistanis are not getting visas to enter Dubai let alone getting a job!
At 17:06 he says that stopping visa for Pakistanis will help in boosting the economy. He also gives a says that Indian economy did well because they stopped giving Visa to Indian engineers. Pakistan are not getting visas anywhere so why isn’t that helping economy? The fact is that Indians have capabilities which the US cannot do without. Just have a look at the CEOs of all the major IT companies in the US.
It doesn't happen overnight. He means that when the going gets tough, tough gets going.
Aby lauday usmain 10-15 sal lugty hain
Manufacturing in Pakistan is very uneconomical due to its high cost. Mr. Shabbar Zaidi is right that Pakistan should try to promote export of services. Export of services account for more than 40% of India's total exports.
Every Pakistani says that till the 90,s Pakistan was ahead of India. Nobody talks about the IMF loans, aid, grants and the free money and arms and ammunitions received from USA and NATO during the Afghan wars which was not required to be paid back. Obviously under such circumstances Pakistan was bound to be ahead. Pakistan has been in about 24 IMF programs in 66 years averaging a loan every 3 years (starting from 1958) to date while India has been in an IMF loan program only once in 1991. Now all that free money, aid and grants have dried up, so Pakistan is where it should actually be. Honestly I will not be surprised if all the Pakistani policy makers are praying for another war in the neighbourhood and American intervention is there for all that free aid and grants to start flowing in again. Unfortunately for Pakistan the so called Iron brother China does not give give aid or grants and will take back every penny it lends either in cash or kind so the western intervention in the neighbourhood is the only hope for Pakistan as things stand today.
As a economist I agreed with his ❤ but unfortunately there is jungle Law nothing to happens system can created like this 😔
India's exports in 2023-24 were estimated to be around $778.2 billion, which is a slight increase from the previous year's $776.4 billion.
These 778 exports also include Russian oil reexports... Actual number is between 280 to 330 billion for goods Exports...
@ Merchandise exports: $437.06 billion, a 3% decrease from the previous year
Services exports: $341.1 billion, a 4.8% increase from the previous year
Here are some other highlights from India's 2023-24 exports:
Trade deficit: Improved from $121.6 billion in 2022-23 to $75.6 billion in 2023-24
Imports: Decreased by 5.66% to $675.44 billion
Export destinations: The Netherlands became India's third largest export destination. Other major destinations included the U.K., U.S., China, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, Bangladesh, Germany, and Italy.
Top merchandise exports: Gems and jewelry, organic and inorganic chemicals, and drugs and pharmaceuticals were among the top exports from Indian states.
Sector performance: Electronic goods and drugs and pharmaceuticals were resilient despite the global trade slowdown. Agricultural exports, however, contracted by 8%.
Future plans: The government is working to diversify exports into electronics, pharmaceuticals, engineering products, and food items.
Washmallay! Rs 280/Rs 86 Against dollar. Dollar grows in our desert dryland soils. Palm tree fruits in coastal vast belt region but palm development authority leaderships never intrested to develop supply chain industry.
26:02 to 26:07
ye hi hoga kyu k awam to yahi kehti hain. jab sab apne zime hai to kia fark parta hai jhanda or note kiska hoga
A insan bohot accha..i am indian but very intalegent man enone❤❤
I have never seen or know someone who ever have watch Pakistani drama? But once Turkish dramas were famous in INDIA 🇮🇳 when the relations were good.
Shabr Zaidi zaidi sahib analysis is 100% Right analysis about our country ecnomical status & future of Pakistan economy and other matters. Politicians/ rulers with their machinary/ powerful institutions are in nexus.they ( nexus ) only protect their own interests. Rulers knoweach & every thing but they want to keep systen as such ( STATUSCO ).
True sir, during the year1986, there were so many students of different countries in Peshawar university
Freelancing dead kr di, Government jo bnda khud $kma raha tha usko ab aisa kam kr rahi thi k woh Government pa dependent ho gain,,
right. if they change the system the government in pakistan will change.
yes AbbuAmrican will ALWAYS be there to do regime change in momineen countries......PK, BD, Iraq, Syria......sooooo easily.......why???
Pakistans economic problem are actually because of social issues Mr Shabbar is absolutely right
National government is excellent suggestion
بہترین پروگرام -امیر ملک کی معیشت 1964تک بہترین-وطن عزیز جرمنی اور دوسرے غریب ممالک کو کو عطیات دیتا رہا ۔کمبزخت کو ایسی نظر لگ گئی کہ سازش کی بھر مار شروع -عظیم قوم کو قومیت ،غربت اور غیر اخلاقی سرگرمیوں میں پھنسا یا گیا۔آج امیر ملک میں دو وقت کی روٹی بھی مشکل۔--جبکہ 1947 کی تقسیم ہند کے وقت چندو پر چلنے والا کمزور ہمسایہ ملک - بھارت- آج ورلڈ اکنامک فورم کا اہم رکن ۔
کراچی کے مسئلے کا ایک ہی حل ہے، کراچی صوبہ ضروری ہے، کراچی کو سندھ سے الگ کرو۔
اسلام و علیکم بھائی صاحب شبر زیدی صاحب سارا دن حرام کمائی کے بعد شام کو خیرات کرنے سے کبھی حرام کمائی کا گناہ ختم نہیں ہوتا
AGar Pakistan kooo bachana hain toooo yeee 4 kaam foran karnee hongeee
1- Change NFc award and give the authority of collection of taxation to province to run it by themselves.
2- Make new provinces on basis of population/ Ethnicity/ Administration
3- Give power to local govts where mayor is directly elected by public and right to collect following taxes
property tax, service tax , local council tax
4- Jis tarah seee natural resources jese, petrol, diesel, gas, seee ane wale revenue ki royalty province kooo millte hain aesee heee districts kooo bhee milnee chahyee
Good thoughts but does not address the root cause.
@@tonyb680
So what are the roots cause
Lack of honesty
@@oldbull1659
These are just social evils in every society
@@masroorkhalil9655 create the same environment that existed in pre-Zia days.
Yaar yeh bandana Pakistan ka naqaam tareen insaan hii... He was the most unsuccessful Chairman of FBR and even couldn't do any notable work in govt..
He can only speak, complain, mourn, because he do not have any vision for solution. Pakistan problem started when such people were promoted to big posts...
Shabbar Zaidi is saying what I had said decades ago (in mid/late 1980s) before coming to America: It was not worth for the Urdu Speakers to make the 'Quota System' such a violent issue that the very peace of the city would be destroyed. I had actually said that to an MQM student wing worker, who got upset with me. And almost FOUR DECADES later Shabbar is saying the same thing: Karachi is self sufficient in many ways while the unfair beneficiaries of the quota system have their home cities/communities still far behind.
Doesnt mean the people who were protesting for their rights were in the wrong in the first place.
Not all can have the foresightedness of a blessed few!
@@syedasaadahmed9717 Protesting peacefully is fine but it was not worth it to ruin the communal harmony and the peace of a city like Karachi. Well, history proved me correct as is what Shabbar is also saying in this video! And no need for the 'blessed few' sarcasm. I was right then and I am right now. The city of Karachi paid a huge price for the violence starting mid 80s.
@@meengla Not being sarcastic at all, you thinking as such makes it amusing
To your point, this city’s ethos was deliberately messed up by the establishment since the 1960s, regardless what people would or wouldn’t have done at the time does not matter
My point is I don’t know you if visited Khi recently or had a chance to visit any local govt setup, civic centre etc, its really demeaning and frustrating to work with those unfair beneficiaries of quota system out of which only few have any competence or integrity, they have been ruling for the past 16 years and have made this wonderful city a shithole like their own rural lands
@@syedasaadahmed9717 Thank you for clarifying. I was myself a victim of the 'Quota System' otherwise probably would have made it to Sindh Medical College in 1984. But I knew the math about maybe 10,000 govt job vs the peace of the city. The peace of the city was destroyed using the unfair Quota System as the clarion call, with disastrous results. And here is Shabbar, four decades later, very astutely mentioning Karachi potentially self sufficient and that it is the private sector which is the real engine for growth.
@@meengla Interesting story sir, may the Almighty bless you!
زندہ آباد زیدی صاحب
SHABBAR ZAIDI CAN CHANGE & IMPROVE THE SYSTEM FOR THE BETTERMENT OF PAKISTAN.
Good debate.
Wow great
عوام کھو چکے اعتماد حکومت کا سو فیصد شیخوپورہ والے ۔
Karachi people's are more intelligent than other without government support karachi survive
pakistani dramas are better is a myth . You only create good love story soap operas. In india you can't even imagine the genres and amount of work produced in each day. The size is so big that people only name mainstream saas bahu dramas which isn't the reality.
Jab tak aarmi pawer me rahega hukumat kamjor rahega tab tak Pakistan hal aesa hi rahega
Karachi mein Sab Kuch ho ga to wardi walon ko jagga kaon de ga, cola next😢😢😢
balance sheet e braber karty han.. agreed
Don’t put the bad people,s intentions on Islam,they are responsible for their own deeds nothing to do with Islam.
اور الطاف حسین صاحب 120 گز کہ ایک چھوٹے سے گھر میں یہاں رہتے تھے
Shabbat zaidi is a full time IMF agent.never talk about against IMF Destabilization program
پاکستان میں آدھا وقت نیشنل گورنمنٹس نے ہی چلایا ، ایوب، ضیاء مشرف کی حکومتیں قومی حکومتیں ہی تو تھیں ،
@09:18, a proper & clearcut answer was not given to the gentleman who asked about three economic indicators to be brought back on track.....
That was a sensible & direct query
What's the use of other nonsensical, irrelevant talk by Mr. Zaidi.
Very low quality talk show
Ek hi hal hy sary masail ka,mulk ko aaeen k mutabiq chalaya jaey,free n fair election kra k true democracy qaim ki jaey.
3 sal mein bhut change a jaey gi.
Need to be baldiati facilities grassroots level for better environment and economy crises and power transfer to the UCS members directly immediately
Jitana qarza IMF se lia gaya us qarze se ese 10 pakistan aur banjate..
اینکر بھائی مہمان کو بات کرنے دیا کرو۔ ہم زیدی صاحب کو سننا مانگتا تمہیں نہیں ۔ امید ہے آئندہ دھیان دینے کا ۔
سیالکوٹ کے بارے میں کیا خیال ھے ۔
Pakistan ka mojuda political system nakaam ho chuka hai,pakistan mey (president form of govt)ka itlaaq✍kia jae.
Shabir bhi thk kh rehy ha F 16 ky pabandi ky bd hm ny J F 17 bania tha
Wah wah kya zabardast Suchyee baat express kee hey; banow qaabil banow qawbil, where is Flahhee Open IqraaNagar and volunteer retired professee resources for the development of potential skillful human force; lipservices all around longitudes and latitudes.
Shabbar sb .IMF se lia gaya qarza aap bata sakte hy ye qarza kon kon khata hy..
APNI education ka standred dekha ha.
اتنے بھی برے حالات نہیں ہیں پاکستان کے۔ غربت کی شرح کم ہے۔ لوگ خوشحال ہیں۔ خیرات کرتے ہیں زکوٰۃ دیتے ہیں۔صدقہ کرتے ہیں۔ حج کے دوران سب اسلامی ممالک میں زیادہ تعداد پاکستانیوں کی ہوتی ہے۔ صرف ٹیکس نہیں دیتے جس کی وجہ سے حکومت پہ قرضہ ہے۔ غربت دیکھنی ہے تو انڈیا میں دیکھیں آپ شکر کریں گے کہ ہم پاکستان میں رہتے ہیں
اپنی آنکھیں کھولو
AAP NAY SACH FARMAYA YAH LOG SAB AIK HAION YAH LOG KHUD KO TEEK NAHION HOTHAY DOSRUION KO KAHTHAY HAION TEEK HO JAWO KAMIYAB ADME WOH HAY JO IS KAY KAY SAY MAION BAYTAION HAION OUR IS THARA YAH MULK TEEK NAHION HO GA
Pakistani government hospital pandan,ughaldan.
Still your message is not clear, confusing...
Why he is provided media coverage??? Failed totally. Try to bring entrepreneurs with fresh mind ideas and who have struggled for Pakistan.
Es kothe se puchain jab aap minister thy pti ke doure hokomat main es per implement kion nahi kia oos waqat tho Murad Saeed bi 200 million dollars la Raha tha 100 million dollars imf ke moon per maarna tha aur 100 million dollars Pakistan main doodh ki nadian bahaani thee Khan Sahab ke eik ishaare per dunya se dollars ki barish honee thee sub baatain qoum ko topi oehnaani thee Jo aaj talk youthion ne pehnee hai yeh sub do no economist hai mulak se paise kamaane ke dong hai dramy baaz hai pti sameyth es thara
ke logoon ko musalat Karke mulak ka Bera gharaq kia gaya
Theoretically perfect but practically useless solution.
Will the patients from other countries come to Pakistan for treatment .... IMPOSSIBLE?
تم خود بھی چار سال حکومت میں تھے۔ اس وقت یہ مہارت کہاں تھی۔
Shabbar bhai u just talk talk and talk. U ran away when u got a chance to do something .
Islam pr mat dalien,islam mein haram ka kamaya huwa zakat kherat qubool nahi,jo shakhas mazdoor ko ujrat poori to kya zra si late b dy to us ky liye sakht sza hy, aesy logo ko islam sy mt joro.
Nonsense
اگر کسی بچے کا باپ فوت ہو جاتا ہے تو وہ پھر بھی جیتا ہے وقت کے ساتھ ساتھ اسکو کسی کی مدد کے بغیر جینا آجاتا ہے ۔ یہی سمجھو کے پاکستانی حکومت مر چکی ہے اب جو کچھ بھی کرنا ہے خود ہی کرنا ہے ۔
کراچی ہانگ کانگ طرز کا ماڈل شہر بنتا لگ رہا😅
Hamara doctor's or engineers bahir ja raha hai