@@Rak9-j8h But that is the fun part, most of the time. Look at shows like "Stump the Schwab". Was always fun to watch general sports fans go up against someone that knowledgeable. Or, at least, it was fun to me. I'd love to see their best go up against Lucas and see if they can beat him as a team.
They mentioned offhand in a video once that Lucas is really good at knowing lists of stuff and numbers, but really bad at like...everything else. So Scattergories, unbeatable. General trivia, apparently pretty average.
Before watching: Dalton, Lucas, and Max is a level of cracked that I thought I would never see on the same panel at the same time. I hope Penik can keep up!
ah, babe ruth, famous star starting pitcher for the world-series winning boston red sox in 1916 and 1918, in which he scattered three runs across 31 IP in those two world series runs. unfortunately for Penik, he did go on to play for a different franchise in the later years of his career.
I actually have a BJ Surhoff moment. Orioles played my Tigers and I was in the right field bleachers. He tossed me a 3rd out ball. I was probably like 10-12
Me playing along Bartolo Colon, Rickey Henderson, Jesse Chavez, Joakim Soria, Nelson Cruz 47 points Jon Gray, Jose Ureña, Robinson Chirinos, Rougned Odor, Sandy Leon 53 points Joe Mauer, Jeff Bagwell, Craig Biggio, Charlie Blackmon, Felix Hernandez 69 points 169 total points
Nine. I was wondering about him. I knew he bounced around a lot but thought his value might be slightly diminished because he had 4 stints with the A's and 2 with the Padres.
I will never forgot BJ Surhoff crying when the O's traded him, in no small part because his kid was being treated at Hopkins. Plus, he used to show up at Terps games when they hosted the Heels.
first round is right off my Immaculate Grid cheat sheet... Ron Villone, Bruce Chen, Paul Bako, Matt Stairs, Edwin Jackson, Royce Clayton, Latroy Hawkins, Octavio Dotel all 10+ franchise players
Great categories. This was an awesome video. Also I had a pretty strong no all star list: Jesse Chavez, Cervelli, Rich Hill, Sal Fasano, and Joaquin Benoit.
I played along and got 149 points, best round was round 2: yuniesky betancourt: 9 nori aoki: 6 jeff mathis: 17 bengie molina: 13 dick mountain: 20 total: 65
I would love if they could tell us what the top 5 possible answers are at the end of the round (granted there might not be only 5 answers sometimes, but maybe top ones sorted by war or something)
Just want to put my names for the first category out there: Bartolo, Bobo Newsom (should be HOFer), Dan Miceli, Oliver Drake, Edwin (so he would have gotten wiped) Mike Cameron and Jesse Chavez would have been names I scribbled at the bottom of my board
Playing along at home I won with 192. I canceled out Latroy Hawkins, David Robertson, and Stan Musial. I did what Lucas did not do and used as many pre-All-Star game names I could think of. Round 1. Latroy Hawkins Bartolo Colon. David Robertson. Johnny Damon. Reggie Jackson. Round 2. Honus Wagner. Walter Johnson, Ty Cobb, Cy Young. Dizzy Dean. Round 3. Stan Musial. Cal Ripken Junior. Lou Gehrig. Ty Cobb. Walter Johnson.
For never made an all-star team I had Nick Punto, Sidney Ponson, Lyle Overbay, Doug Mirabelli, and Vicente Padilla. Padilla was a 1 time AS so my round was 51 points.
BJ Surhoff was the random player I always hurt in the one of MLB video games by diving into the wall, I don’t know why I did it. It wasn’t like I had a weird grudge. Now Marcus Giles, he was the guy that I always traded first, I had a weird grudge towards him. I’d almost always traded Marcus Giles, Wes Helms, and Brian Jordan. Those were my most hated players for some reason.
I like to play along, this is my score card. Nelson Cruz 8 Andrew Miller 7 Tucker Barnhart 4 Aroldis Chapman 6 Carlos Santana 7 32 Gerald Laird 13 Ricky Weeks Jose Urena 10 Mike Pelfrey 12 Adam Everette 11 46+32=78 Chipper Jones 19 Al Kaline(Matched) 22 Ryan Howard 13 Ryne Sandberg Alan Trammell(Matched) 20 78+22= Final Score. 100 Lucas Killed me that final round.
Playing along my favorite pull was Oliver Perez for player that was never an all-star, good for 20 yrs - was hoping Dalton or Jolly might have shouted out the mets/snakes legend (also shoutout to Pedro Feliciano for 9 yrs each for rounds 2 and 3 lol)
Dotel - 13, Tom Gordon - 8, Hawkins - 11, Lee Smith - 8, Gary Sheffield - 8 (48) Turk Wendell - 11, Mark Lemke - 11, Lee Stevens - 10, Candy Maldonado - 15, Alejandro Pena - 15 (62) Trammell - 20, Whitaker - 19, Frank White - 18, George Brett - 21, Yount - 20 (98) total 208
Growing up in dc the orioles were the team to watch..bj surhoff was definitely a dude…i remember he hit a couple hrs in a playoff game in 96..the series before the jeffrey maier interference debacle
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
4 headsets before GTA 6
Such an awesome comment 😂😂
Finally got enough mics for everyone. You love to see it
And an actual whiteboard eraser. No sleeves needed.
@@jordandewitt9454dan Rourke would still use his pant leg. I am surprised he hasn't wiped it on his head.
Now they should take Dalton's away.
my favorite BJ Surhoff moment is him going 0-2 in the 1999 all-star game
Also penik on here is like having a normal person compete in the Olympics
He’s their JM Football guy
@@SSL20.linn28we know brotha
tbf like 5 of his answers were 1 season away from correct for like 100 points worth of super close ones. but yeah....
Best comment ever
@@SSL20.linn28 And he's not even particularly good at that lol
Penik doing Yogi Berra and Babe Ruth is hilarious.
I read this during the first question and was in ‘surely not’ mode
How is Lucas not the person playing in The Chase? Baseball encyclopedia, that man is
I think that's why. it just wouldn't be fair. He's the Ken Jennings of JM Baseball so he hosts the games.
@@Rak9-j8h But that is the fun part, most of the time. Look at shows like "Stump the Schwab". Was always fun to watch general sports fans go up against someone that knowledgeable. Or, at least, it was fun to me. I'd love to see their best go up against Lucas and see if they can beat him as a team.
@@Rak9-j8h That argument is the same as saying that Michael Jordan shouldn't have been allowed to play in the NBA, b/c he was too good.
Lucas vs Ryan in a baseball trivia game would be sick. Or them on the same team vs the rest of the office.
They mentioned offhand in a video once that Lucas is really good at knowing lists of stuff and numbers, but really bad at like...everything else.
So Scattergories, unbeatable. General trivia, apparently pretty average.
Everybody has mics, except Jolly who sounds like he's talking from the bottom of a well.
underrated comment
4 headsets and an eraser? Someone is trying to use up the budget before year end
Lucas really let it swing hard that last round. Damn that was food :3
For one of these trivia games, I'd love to see Lucas versus Chris Rose. Battle of the Baseball Behemoths!
Before watching: Dalton, Lucas, and Max is a level of cracked that I thought I would never see on the same panel at the same time. I hope Penik can keep up!
They should have given a 2X multiplier for his points to make it fair.
After watching: he couldn't 😂
those babe ruth and yogi berra picks were brutal
@@harrisonbaylor1432 like sort of a golf handicap?
This ended up being my favorite scattergories of all time. Honestly if they do the same lineup but replace Penik with Ryan it would be *peak*.
"look at all these guys.....writin'" love it from Lucas
The game was over the moment Lucas gave the two thumbs up and smiled to Max saying "I went recent" he had it in the bag and he knew it.
There was still the suspense of maybe him and Dalton having the same guys
ah, babe ruth, famous star starting pitcher for the world-series winning boston red sox in 1916 and 1918, in which he scattered three runs across 31 IP in those two world series runs.
unfortunately for Penik, he did go on to play for a different franchise in the later years of his career.
I actually have a BJ Surhoff moment. Orioles played my Tigers and I was in the right field bleachers. He tossed me a 3rd out ball. I was probably like 10-12
I figured Rich Hill would get picked for the "0 ASGs" round
I actually was thinking of him for first round of “playing for different teams”
@@Calbrakkenyeah was surprised nobody said him or Bartolo Colon
@@Calbrakken I'd have had him. Or Rickey Henderson is also a sneaky 9.
Martin Maldonado was the first name that came to mind lol (13)
jeff mathis is a good one for that
Love this style of content! And the fact that Jolly sounds like a drive-thru operator just adds that special touch.
BJ Surhoff is a great guy. Went to school with his kids and he would drive us some days in a carpool
Penik singing George Strait wasn’t on my bingo card.
Really good categories, great video.
damn you got a fourth headset??? must've hit the big time! congrats!
Me playing along
Bartolo Colon, Rickey Henderson, Jesse Chavez, Joakim Soria, Nelson Cruz
47 points
Jon Gray, Jose Ureña, Robinson Chirinos, Rougned Odor, Sandy Leon
53 points
Joe Mauer, Jeff Bagwell, Craig Biggio, Charlie Blackmon, Felix Hernandez
69 points
169 total points
Could have said jesse chavez for both the teams and not making the all star team (17 points that one)
Yeah Idk why I didn’t
Run this back next week. Love this group
Possibly my favorite scattergories video so far! Lucas is a freak with the knowledge of baseball stats!
Jolly just became the first person to host a game show underwater
There was another video where he sounded like he was deep in the building's vents. It was hilarious.
22:50 jolly olive forgetting how to spell yastrzemski, silence ensues
I like Dalton's silliness at the beginning.
Rickey for the multiple teams
Nine. I was wondering about him. I knew he bounced around a lot but thought his value might be slightly diminished because he had 4 stints with the A's and 2 with the Padres.
BIG shoutout to our goated blitz ball broadcaster PETER MOYLAN for being worth 14 in round two
yall putting max manis in these videos is crazy work
I will never forgot BJ Surhoff crying when the O's traded him, in no small part because his kid was being treated at Hopkins. Plus, he used to show up at Terps games when they hosted the Heels.
Greatest BJ Surhoff moment was the Kenny Lofton wall climb home run robbery!
I got 57 in the never All-Star round with Nick Punto (14), Bengie Molina (13), Skip Schumaker (11), Max Kepler (10) and Antonio Bastardo (9).
first round is right off my Immaculate Grid cheat sheet...
Ron Villone, Bruce Chen, Paul Bako, Matt Stairs, Edwin Jackson, Royce Clayton, Latroy Hawkins, Octavio Dotel all 10+ franchise players
i wouldve put jamie moyer for never an all star and i wouldve been wrong since apparently he made one lol
For no all-stars, I IMMEDIATELY started saying Honus Wagner, Cy Young, etc. I'm glad that Lucas pointed out that loophole.
Lucas pointed it out because he would have smoked everyone if it was allowed.
Great categories. This was an awesome video. Also I had a pretty strong no all star list: Jesse Chavez, Cervelli, Rich Hill, Sal Fasano, and Joaquin Benoit.
Max looked so incredibly salty that he lost at the buzzer
I would be too if I thought that I had actually the baseball encyclopedia man
Wish someone would've said Robin Yount for the single team answer, but Lucas had some awesome pulls. Another good one would've been Biggio.
Ernie Banks
I played along and got 149 points, best round was round 2:
yuniesky betancourt: 9
nori aoki: 6
jeff mathis: 17
bengie molina: 13
dick mountain: 20
total: 65
The episodes where Plouffe is the silent partner are always the best.
Absolute masterclass by Lucas in the last round my goodness
I so look forward to the JM Baseball / Football videos. They are so entertaining!
for no all stars, I thought someone would say Jeff Mathis, Willie Bloomquist, Jeff Francour, or David Ross.
Jesse Chaves 17, BJ Upton 12, Jordan Lyles 14 were among my answers
LaTroy Hawkins - 21 years no stars. oliver perez - 20 yrs
Jeff Mathis was my first thought too. He's the first idea of a guy who hangs around due to non-stat reasons. Now it's Austin Hedges
Surprised no one said Mr. Dick Mountain, aka, Rich Hill
Henry Blanco 16 years. So many career backup catchers are a gold mine.
Jose Molina and Coco Crisp going absolutely bonkers
MLB Scattegories is one of my favorites!
You guys are responsible for Matt Stairs never being more than 2 percent on immaculate grid
I always think using Matt Stairs will have more of a percentage every time I use him. But it doesn't.
penik semi professional baseball knower, pretty good for a football guy
I would love if they could tell us what the top 5 possible answers are at the end of the round (granted there might not be only 5 answers sometimes, but maybe top ones sorted by war or something)
Kind of surprised that Robin Yount or Cal Ripken Jr did not get mentioned. Great players on teams that didn't contend that often.
My non-all stars:
Joe Smith (the reliever): 15
Jeff Mathis: 17
Daniel Hudson: 15
Rick Porcello: 11
Bryan Shaw: 14
Total: 72
Bro you cannot be on a baseball channel and say Babe Ruth only played for one team lmfaooo
Just want to put my names for the first category out there:
Bartolo, Bobo Newsom (should be HOFer), Dan Miceli, Oliver Drake, Edwin (so he would have gotten wiped)
Mike Cameron and Jesse Chavez would have been names I scribbled at the bottom of my board
This episode rocked
im so sick rn and this video just made my day better. W video.
lucas and max were just dripped out for this video
As a Brewers fan, I would have selected Jim Gantner twice. 17 year career, all with Milwaukee, and never selected to an All-Star team.
The fact that Rich Hill wasn't used for most teams or zero AS round is crazy.
Lucas and Max are cracked
I hope Penik takes the jabs in good humor. I think he’s hilarious. 😂
Playing along at home I won with 192. I canceled out Latroy Hawkins, David Robertson, and Stan Musial. I did what Lucas did not do and used as many pre-All-Star game names I could think of.
Round 1. Latroy Hawkins Bartolo Colon. David Robertson. Johnny Damon. Reggie Jackson.
Round 2. Honus Wagner. Walter Johnson, Ty Cobb, Cy Young. Dizzy Dean.
Round 3. Stan Musial. Cal Ripken Junior. Lou Gehrig. Ty Cobb. Walter Johnson.
On the first one I had rickey Henderson, roger clemens, Randy Johnson, mark melancon, Kyle Schwarber. Sneaky good choices
Dalton did it for the memes and it worked! 😂
13:30 i legit spit my coffee out. That was funny. Big PEen is funny
I'm surprised no one wrote Edgar Martinez for the single team round. He's probably the most notable life long Mariner.
Was waiting for Matt Stairs in round 1 XD and the combined "Morneau" was awesome
For never made an all-star team I had Nick Punto, Sidney Ponson, Lyle Overbay, Doug Mirabelli, and Vicente Padilla. Padilla was a 1 time AS so my round was 51 points.
Max and Lucas in a video? Awesome!
BJ Surhoff was the random player I always hurt in the one of MLB video games by diving into the wall, I don’t know why I did it. It wasn’t like I had a weird grudge. Now Marcus Giles, he was the guy that I always traded first, I had a weird grudge towards him. I’d almost always traded Marcus Giles, Wes Helms, and Brian Jordan. Those were my most hated players for some reason.
The way Max said “demoralizing” legit made me lol 😂😂😂
Screaming Rich Hill and Jesse Chavez the entire "no all star nods" round
These were some great categories. I'm so disappointed (yet happy for him) that Tim Wakefield made one AS team
This a great squad. Lucas in these videos is awesome
cal ripkin jr getting snubbed in the last round is crazy
I like to play along, this is my score card.
Nelson Cruz 8
Andrew Miller 7
Tucker Barnhart 4
Aroldis Chapman 6
Carlos Santana 7
32
Gerald Laird 13
Ricky Weeks
Jose Urena 10
Mike Pelfrey 12
Adam Everette 11
46+32=78
Chipper Jones 19
Al Kaline(Matched) 22
Ryan Howard 13
Ryne Sandberg
Alan Trammell(Matched) 20
78+22=
Final Score. 100
Lucas Killed me that final round.
I use Bruce Chen for immaculate grid almost every game.
He’s very applicable here.
Playing along my favorite pull was Oliver Perez for player that was never an all-star, good for 20 yrs - was hoping Dalton or Jolly might have shouted out the mets/snakes legend (also shoutout to Pedro Feliciano for 9 yrs each for rounds 2 and 3 lol)
Rich Hill would’ve been legendary round one and two (also my go-to immaculate grid guy when I’m stumped 😂)
Before Lucas pointed out the loophole on all-star games, I was thinking "Ty Cobb, Walter Johnson, Cy Young..."
As an audio engineer....jesus h christ, thank you for finally giving everyone a headset.
Matt Stairs would have gone so hard for the first two rounds, 12 teams across 19 years lol
No way I'm playing an old baseball game and LaTroy Hawkins was pitching to me when Dalton said his name.
Now I see why Lucas is rarely allowed out from behind the camera, that was a domination..
Jolly and Dalt need to smoke one together and figure it out 😂😂😂
Can't believe they left out the legend that is Jesse Chavez, biggest all star snub this year
Penik doing the panthers roar for a baseball player you love to see it
I think this was the best one yet 🎉
Didn't know Dalton was a snakes fan! Lets go!
Dotel - 13, Tom Gordon - 8, Hawkins - 11, Lee Smith - 8, Gary Sheffield - 8 (48)
Turk Wendell - 11, Mark Lemke - 11, Lee Stevens - 10, Candy Maldonado - 15, Alejandro Pena - 15 (62)
Trammell - 20, Whitaker - 19, Frank White - 18, George Brett - 21, Yount - 20 (98)
total 208
PENIK DOESN’T PANIC
Put it on a shirt 😂
Two Olivers = 40 points - Oliver Perez (20 years without Allstar) and Darren Oliver (20 years without Allstar)
This is a true all-star squad
Really like these categories
Mark McClemore was my crazy pick for no all star teams. 19 seasons
Always love the games. Now that the total bases is over, whens the next season of ref guess coming back?
Growing up in dc the orioles were the team to watch..bj surhoff was definitely a dude…i remember he hit a couple hrs in a playoff game in 96..the series before the jeffrey maier interference debacle
Picks for no all star.
Jesse chavez - 17 points
Mike timlin- 18 points
Jamie moyer - 0 points (1 allstar in 25 years)
Charlie hough - 0 points (1 allstar in 25 years)
Russel branyan - 14 points
Kip Wells is my multi-team lock. Immaculate Grid legend
No Rich Hill for the first two rounds is crazy. He alone is worth 33 points for those two rounds.
Rich Hill being one of the better picks for a couple of these rounds and not getting said :(