5 Most Common Reasons A Movie Idea Is Rejected - Scott Kirkpatrick

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 окт 2024

Комментарии • 45

  • @filmcourage
    @filmcourage  Год назад +6

    We understand that rejection of any kind is never easy. We hope this video helps!

  • @cryptohalloffame
    @cryptohalloffame Год назад +23

    be a good human being, be likeable, come across as intelligent, and people will (eventually) want to work with you, that's all you can do, apart from working hard and working smart

  • @beebuzz959
    @beebuzz959 Год назад +8

    A producer once told me we have to go through X amount of rejections before we get a yes, so we should embrace them all because they get us that much closer.

  • @jimmyl9140
    @jimmyl9140 Год назад +3

    Good info. Keep it coming Film Courage.

  • @jubilantvision2212
    @jubilantvision2212 Год назад +8

    If they reject bad films, why do bad movies still get made?

    • @beebuzz959
      @beebuzz959 Год назад +1

      Because not just anyone can turn a good script into a good movie. But not just that, things happen on set that change the outcome, and investors and producers and actors all want their fingerprints in it, but don't always understand how to do that while maintaining a good story like a good writer can.

  • @Hypatude
    @Hypatude Год назад +2

    Good interview as always

  • @Stoltzfilmstudio
    @Stoltzfilmstudio Год назад

    Kirkpatrick's book Writing for the Green Light was very helpful for me. Explaining the "gold mine" genres was the kind of practical information someone like me (far away from CA) could use. One of those "ah ha" moments like when I read Save the Cat and learned what a beat sheet was. Anyway, I recently bought and read Mastering the Pitch. It's the third screenwriting book by Kirkpatrick. The three biggest takeaways I had personally from reading the book were: in the pitch deck to include a verifiable audience for your topic. The second was that this book was just published in 2023 and it was nice to see a refresher of the "gold mine genres," as these were also discussed in Writing for the Green Light when that was published in 2015. The third was the discussion about what genres were hard to pitch.

    • @filmcourage
      @filmcourage  Год назад +1

      Nice to see your familiarity with Scott's work. We appreciate you taking the time to share some of your insights here. Thank you for your post!

  • @nerdock4747
    @nerdock4747 Год назад +1

    That first 20 seconds felt like it could also describe dating.
    2:19 This comment aged well, quickly.

  • @83shadow3
    @83shadow3 Год назад +1

    What he said makes sense but at the same time it makes no sense. Because I learned from listening to audio commentaries an watching bonus features. That on occasion movie studio executive will read a script or screenplay then approve it. Then step in an go they hated the movies story so they alter it. After the movie is finished so that brings in a key question. If they hated it from the beginning then why did they approve it an fund it in the first place. Only to spend more money shooting new scenes to alter the movie. If they didn't like it from the start why approve it in the first place.

  • @subramanianramamoorthy3413
    @subramanianramamoorthy3413 Год назад +1

    We cannot skip listening to Mr. Scott

  • @Thenoobestgirl
    @Thenoobestgirl Год назад +4

    Every time I have to fill out a form to upload a script to like coverfly or something and I get asked what the budget for the movie would be and I'm like how tf do I know??? Do I look like an accountant? 😩

    • @beebuzz959
      @beebuzz959 Год назад

      Can you compare it to a few others that are similar enough that might cost in the same ballpark? Is basically asked because producers want an idea, and it doesn't have to be exact.

  • @NotMolly-jf2rh
    @NotMolly-jf2rh Год назад +3

    WHY is your Greenlight book in hardcover $192-$200 on Amazon?!?

    • @faa9261
      @faa9261 Год назад +1

      That’s a lot

    • @BigDaddyJinx
      @BigDaddyJinx Год назад

      Because capitalism. LOL
      Why else?

    • @Thenoobestgirl
      @Thenoobestgirl Год назад +1

      Wtf? Really? That's a *bit* much...

    • @beebuzz959
      @beebuzz959 Год назад

      Is it out of print or a specialty copy?

  • @Doggieworld3Show
    @Doggieworld3Show Год назад +1

    Arent we are own worst enemy? if voices and money goes to hero movies, vampires/zombies, pro-female, remakes, etc., the genres will propagate.
    and thats also something A.I will pick up too.

  • @grantgreyguda
    @grantgreyguda Год назад

    👍 👍

  • @buggobricks
    @buggobricks Год назад

    So what you’re telling me is that my story won’t sell? Lol, great video though.

  • @donjindra
    @donjindra Год назад +1

    If your project is too similar to other things in the market? Is this guy serious? Rarely is a film released that's not similar to other material out there. Almost everything is trite today. Not many producers have gotten his message.

    • @beebuzz959
      @beebuzz959 Год назад

      And sometimes they want similar.

  • @jeffmcmahon3278
    @jeffmcmahon3278 Год назад +1

    Bill Goldman was right!

  • @justayoutuber1906
    @justayoutuber1906 10 месяцев назад

    "Tax efficient state" He sounds like a politician. Just say it : Tax breaks for big corporations.

  • @omegaswiper
    @omegaswiper Год назад

    Zack Snyder goes big he should see this.

  • @jesperburns
    @jesperburns Год назад

    #6: you know nobody in the industry. Though I guess you wouldn't even get invited then.

  • @Robertsmith-un5cu
    @Robertsmith-un5cu Год назад

    has this guy ever produced one great film?

  • @ToyFiend
    @ToyFiend Год назад +1

    Just make your own film. Or waste your time.

  • @nikonboy07
    @nikonboy07 Год назад

    Makes you wonder how junk like Monster Hunter got green lit☹️

  • @ai4cmvnmt62
    @ai4cmvnmt62 Год назад +13

    It sounds like politics lol idk .

    • @SecurityAgentService1
      @SecurityAgentService1 Год назад +1

      We need to step on the independent side to shine a light on New Writers and Directors.
      I think the projects that we choose to make will determine how successful you will be if you're a writer/director

  • @thereccher8746
    @thereccher8746 Год назад +3

    Sell your soul to capitalism in other words.

    • @beebuzz959
      @beebuzz959 Год назад

      Think of it more as get creative in ways that will get your stuff made.

  • @BigDaddyJinx
    @BigDaddyJinx Год назад +2

    "...general trends...general buckets of content..."
    Ah, so woke nonsense then. That's the trend and that's the general bucket of content these days. A bucket of woke noise. The woker the better. These studios can't possibly fail fast enough which has to explain why they are so intent on producing the most unwatchable, woke content imaginable.
    Gotcha. Understood. So make it woke and you make it work. Thanks for the heads up.

    • @trentmiller976
      @trentmiller976 Год назад +5

      You ok?

    • @andrewhughes7642
      @andrewhughes7642 Год назад +2

      Are studios not allowed to have their values? I suppose there are non-"woke" studios as well if being inclusive, tolerant and respectful to others is really not your thing. Failing that, you can always go and produce your film on your own or set up your own studio. Maybe you could get John Birch Society, KKK or NRA funding for it. There are limitless options for you. You keep on insisting it is the land of the free, after all.

    • @donjindra
      @donjindra Год назад +1

      @@andrewhughes7642 As long as everyone knows the shingle on their door is "Preacher" not "Movie Producer" sure, they can have values.

    • @andrewhughes7642
      @andrewhughes7642 Год назад +1

      @@donjindra Art without values as a concept does exist but it is very, very rare, and rather perverse. The problem you have is that you don't share the values that predominate in Hollywood. So, do your own thing.

    • @donjindra
      @donjindra Год назад +2

      @@andrewhughes7642 More than likely we are talking about the difference between pushing one set of values exclusively versus creating a rich story. If a producer always pushes only one set of values, he's a preacher. Great movies normally have dramatic conflict which means fictional characters have values that conflict with each internally and/or externally.