Yeah, I mean, AEG is okay for what it is, the concept of trains running around in a cartoonish manner inspires something entirely new of that caliber. But as a Thomas series, it's just... okay at best, and at worst, it leaves an ass loud to be desired.
so if only AEG was its own original show without using our thomas characters and brand it will be decent? I still dont like AEG tho and never watched it (why should i?) but i do agree with u abt that
All Engines Go may be keeping the franchise afloat (barely), but not relevant. I may keep your kids entertained for half an hour, but it won’t stick with them the rest of their lives like what we grew up with. The proof is in the pudding; you’re lucky to find any merch in stores, and when you do it only occupies half a shelf. What’s even more depressing is that I’ve already seen parents selling used AEG toys on eBay, some of which are barely a year old. I grew up mainly with classic Trackmaster. I was introduced to the range on my third birthday and continued to collect and play with them until I was 11. I still love Thomas to this day as a 20 year old but I cannot see AEG sticking with kids past the age of 6.
I agree plus 1 I want all characters in the big book of engines plus Paxton den and dart 2 movies will have thetriatrical releases and 3 Hasbrouck will produce it and its dvd releases plus blu rays for movies
The best thing to do once AEG is officially cancelled is to just let the show die for little while. Leaving it alone for a bit gives Mattel time to actually use their brains for once and think about how to make a Thomas great show again that isn't produced for the sole purpose of selling toys. Toys should be the by-product of a kids show, not the other way around. The most logical thing to do is look back on the show's history and it's most successful period and take plenty of notes of everything that made it so successful, consulting the fans for our advise would be a really good move as we'd actual steer Mattel in the right direction to bring back OG Thomas. But in all honesty though, if Mattel really wants Thomas to be a household name again, then all they have to do is HIRE THE FANS make the show for them. With people who actually know and care what Thomas The Tank Engine truly is and it's core appeal, there is no way the show would ever fall from grace again. Heck... i'm willing to bet we'd even fix Mattel's dreadful state of merchandise ranges and bring back quality toys again as well.
My idea for a new Thomas & Friends series would be to take all the elements of every version of the franchise and combine them into an entirely new series in a storytelling format that's reminiscent of the Railway Series and the first five seasons of the Classic TV series, one that's rooted in realism. And with all the bad things in each version, I'd repurpose them into something that would work better than how they were originally depicted. Edit: Oh, and it would all be in CGI, the best quality CGI animation affordable. Edit Number 2: Also, Mattel should really take a long break from producing anything Thomas-related and put the focus on studying everything good and bad about the franchise, consult and collaborate with fans and railway enthusiasts, connoisseurs and experts on what works, what doesn't work, hire professional writers who know the lore inside and out and how to execute the stories properly, and figure out how to reintroduce TV series exclusive characters to this whole new setting and flesh them out in ways that make them feel less out of place than they were as perviously portrayed. You do 75 to 80 percent that, and we've got a new high quality series that fans old and new can enjoy wholeheartedly.
2:42 I had this personal "Percy, don't do that" joke idea that if he jumpscares someone, they would mention how AEG would receive its 5th season (and then it would cut to its official announcement).
Honestly, the TV side of the franchise has been going on near-constantly for 40 years. They've been milking it dry for the past 20. At this point, they might as well just let the show rest for a bit...
I personally prefer the steam team as it's accurate to real life as engines were assigned to certain sheds like Flying Scotsman being assigned to a shed at Kings Cross
opinion, but i rather watch the portions of sodor in TATMR than ANYTHING mattel put out. sodor in tatmr is done right. like i said, you either like the other elements of the movie or you don't. i do like them for the stand alone movie it is so yes it's not on the list. mattel is all about silly lazy ideas. in TATMR the engines are worried about diesel 10 destroying all of them. in SLOTLT, they're worried about buried treasure and a pirate ship... that ain't TTTE to me and never will be. again an opinion, but i will always prefer TATMR and 1-7. mattel made movies basically to sell merchandise as they were slowly killing the brand and the core identity of sodor/the engines
For the show it would be cool for it to be 20 style animation but more realistic, all characters from seasons 1-7 appear and they have stories based on classic tvs stories. Also if they just kept Michael white on and have Britt and Andrew Brenner to help with stories it would be perfect
I agree with most of this comment except for getting Britt back. I’ve nothing against her but I have a bad feeling she and Andrew would probably have conflicting ideas about what Thomas should be.
Mattel should just stop with All engines go, maybe take a break for a while, and then bring the show back with a reboot in the season 20 style, plus a bring back more of the older characters, including Boco, and then the franchise can finally get back to normal!
My Little Pony has a high school human spin off. And the fans have put T&F scenes as humans. So a humanised high school or railway teaching school could be an option.
I very much left the Thomas community since All Engines Go came out. I feel like the series might continue for 2 more seasons because of how well the merchandise sells to the fans (mostly Bruno for some reason), again that's my opinion. I don't know how long AEG will keep going, but there's going to be a certain point once again, Mattel has to start from scratch. They either finally end the Thomas and Friends series, or go for another reboot.
They need to sell Thomas lock stock and barrel to someone who cares! Maybe a new Thomas show could be animated by Blue Zoo in a style similar to The Adventures of Paddington!
if series 25 did happen thomas was gonna go to japan, in 2015 sam wilkinson wanted to bring the culdee fell railway, bear, and possibly d199 to cgi but it didn't happen
I really hope the original Thomas and Friends show will come back and get a season 25. Because that's what I like better. I also hope the show will have some more Railway Series adaptations and add some more Railway Series characters like Wilbert, Bear/D7101, Jock, Frank, D199/Spamcan, Big City Engine, Sixteen, Culdee and and the other mountain railway engines, Ivo Hugh, 40125/Old Stuck Up, Albert, Victoria and Helena.
I hope they go back to models mainly because that's surprisingly cheaper than CGI not to mention I'm sure Draton manner would not mind handing over the models they have and the community can just make more replicas
Oi the reason they switch to CGI is because the models! In 2009, HIT Entertainment forced them to switch to CGI (Season 13) is because how costly it costs to make Model production (Season 12) 🙄
Mattel should take a leaf out of Thunderbirds are go and combine models with cgi for their next Thomas series. For this new series I would keep Nia and Rebecca but place them at Vicarstown sheds rather than at Tidmouth sheds. Thomas, Percy and Toby I would place them at the Ffarquhar sheds (Tidmouth) rather than at Tidmouth sheds/Toby's shed. Edward, I would keep at Wellsworth and Henry at Tidmouth sheds.
I haven't seen or watched any AEG because the terrible reception but also because I didn't like the fake non realistic track hopping and stuff etc and I just don't like it. Loved the last few videos, thanks for GOATED content
no more reboot but season 25 of thomas and friends with the cgi series and kana, bruno, sandy, Farona and Frederico, Riff and Jiff, Tess and some more characters that were exclusive in the books like Zoom and Eugene (E10) for ex. will make it to the new season.
I have an idea. How about they make a reboot. But no ordinary reboot, A reboot for the rws series. Each season will focus on the lore. For example, no percy in season 1 because thats the season the island of sodor would be building a new railway.
Hopefully it won't be another crappy reboot I do hope there will be a proper Revival that takes place after the 24th season going back to CGI with no bouncing and nothing that's extremely unrealistic
I really want the original Thomas & Friends series to go back and season 25 of original classic Thomas era should be Big World Big Adventures or the series 19-21 era style
What we need is the season 21 animation style, which is flashy and beautiful without looking overly cartoonish, bring back Brenner, original steam team, but more episodes led by female characters for gender diversity, like a 50/50 split. No bouncing, no fantasy sequences and no musicals...
If All Engines go gets cancelled, I think the next show should be a continuation from the CGI series. My idea would be expand Tidmouth Sheds and bring back Edward, Henry and Toby. If I had to write the first episode, I would write it from another point of view like Doctor Who did in Rose, but I would write it from the point of view from Sir Topham Hatt.
i already said why, but the engines of sodor do not care about pirate ships and buried treasure. it's another gimmick mattel put in there because all the movies they made had to have a gimmick. it's just lazy in my opinion. it's NOT TTTE. not to mention SLOTLT reuses the idea that thomas does something wrong and then another engine is brought in who pulls annie and clarabel. thomas messing up and being a baby is a big part of the movie too. not interesting to me. i prefer TATMR and 1-7. not really a fan of CGI thomas and friends, mattel stopped letting sodor be sodor and the characters be steam engines. while doing all the things fans defend TO THE DEATH, they drove the brand into the ground 😹 so i guess the dinosaurs and buried treasure wasn't good enough to keep people and kids interested. and of course not, it's not TTTE.
😹 tf he's not the TTTE bible, he's just another human with an opinion. i could care less, stop copying 'this big RUclipsr's opinion'. it's pathetic, think for yourself. so many thomas fans on YT act like that^^^
I would say bring back the cgi era of Thomas & Friends, because the og models are either shipped to different parts of the world or damage. If I were to bring the show back, then first I would bring Edward and Henry back to sheds. Then, I bring back the other cast back (ex Neville, Molly, Dennis, Murdoch, Hank, Freddie, Duke, Smudger, Proteus & the others). Make stories focus on other characters besides Thomas. Make Henry not a scaredy engine and Percy not a child. And make Sam, Logan and Dustin appeared and make them stars of their own episodes.
I think it’s time to let our friend Thomas rest for a while. All the magic that made Seasons 1-5 and 17-21 special is all gone. The brand needs to be dead for a while before they can try again. If they reboot the brand and bring in people who care than that would be a miracle but it’s far too soon now. I’m 23 years old and I grew up with the classic series and saw the Brenner era as it was coming out. We had a good thing but it’s over now and we need to move on. I do want the real Thomas to return at some point in the future but it’s far too soon now. If All Engines Go does end next year then I don’t wanna see another Thomas reboot for at least six years. Our friend Thomas needs to rest.
With the state of Drayton Manor. I wouldn’t go back to the models. I would go back to the CGI, bring back Andrew Brenner, have Adam Sandler narrate the US dub, and John Cleese to narrate the UK dub.
@ at the Thomas land exhibit, lots of the models have been damaged or stolen, some of the faces have fallen off or they don’t even work anymore. it’s really sad especially to us Hardcore Thomas fans.
Even if they somehow did go back to models (which I don’t see happening), I don’t even think they would use the original models from seasons 1-12. They’d likely make new models for the characters. Also, this is just my opinion but I don’t think Adam Sandler would fit Thomas. I think he sounds too goofy.
I would love to go back to the classic era but there is a problem with money and props Mattel will have to get the money and make new props since the old ones need a rest which will take time and maybe do some new mechanics since exact parts c ctould or could not be found bring back the brenner era and when ready switch to the classic era Or just call up the fandom to help. Great video
I dont see any issues with nia and rebecca, and henry delivering goods to the mainland often would make sense for him to stay at vicarstown and edward living at wellsworth since its the start of his branchline makes sense too. Toby didnt live at tidmouth but he never left the main cast of the show, they just need to learn how to keep edward and henry in the main cast, which to be honest, they dont have much going on with them lets be honest, henry is just a scared loser and edward is a wise engine who the others usually come to for advice. Maybe work in how Henry is the one usually away and not thomas, he comes back and tells stories of the mainland, and the tv series could really work in more elements how edward is a father figure towards bill and ben and other branchlines stories
Seasons 1 and 2 had a narrator doubling up as the voice for all the characters, that's the way Thomas the Tank Engine & Friends should be kept. The music should be the same as it was in Seasons 1 and two, no disappearances of any of the theme tunes. Come along MATTEL, get with the show. Get rid of that sleazy new childish image of Thomas and go back to 1984 and 1986. Not hard to do. However, I'm tired of only giving my thoughts on MATTEL ruining Thomas' classic image. Can't we change the subject? Christmas isn't very far away. What's on your Christmas wishlist?
In 2021 mattel should have just sold the toys only and cancel the TV show and go on hiatus and sold the toys and should’ve made money off of that then during the 80th anniversary come out with a movie and just had a movie series about Thomas the Tank Engine and then make a little TV show out of the movies and put it on TV and they should’ve just sold the minis motorized and push alongs because Mattel decided to make motorized a standard toy train line and then that’s how the toys would go from that on they should have never released all engines go
I would like CGI to return in my casting for the US dub David menkin as Thomas Rino Romano as Edward Kevin frank as Henry Kerry shale as Gordon David menkin as James Christopher Ragland as percy Emily same actor Uk Eddie Glenn as Thomas John Sparkes as Edward John Sparkes as Henry John Sparkes as Gordon Mark Moraghan as james Joanna Ruiz as Percy Colm Feore as toby Joanna Ruiz as Emily Etc etc etc
It’s only been out for 3 years, there’s no way you’re young enough to have grown up with it and simultaneously be mature enough to have a RUclips account at this time.
@Diecastcreations well I did, but that’s not the point. I just find it hard to believe that you’re old enough to be commenting on RUclips if you grew up watching AEG since it’s not even that old.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Mattel can bring back classic Barney but
THEY CAN'T EVEN BRING BACK CLASSIC THOMAS???!!
NOT EVEN THE CGI SERIES?!!
Let me say this AEG BY IT SELF is a fine show for its target audiences
But looking at the whole brand of Thomas is another story
Yeah, I mean, AEG is okay for what it is, the concept of trains running around in a cartoonish manner inspires something entirely new of that caliber. But as a Thomas series, it's just... okay at best, and at worst, it leaves an ass loud to be desired.
so if only AEG was its own original show without using our thomas characters and brand it will be decent? I still dont like AEG tho and never watched it (why should i?) but i do agree with u abt that
@ that’s one way to but it
All Engines Go may be keeping the franchise afloat (barely), but not relevant. I may keep your kids entertained for half an hour, but it won’t stick with them the rest of their lives like what we grew up with. The proof is in the pudding; you’re lucky to find any merch in stores, and when you do it only occupies half a shelf. What’s even more depressing is that I’ve already seen parents selling used AEG toys on eBay, some of which are barely a year old. I grew up mainly with classic Trackmaster. I was introduced to the range on my third birthday and continued to collect and play with them until I was 11. I still love Thomas to this day as a 20 year old but I cannot see AEG sticking with kids past the age of 6.
well said man. AEG leaves your brain as fast as it enters. there's no merch anywhere in stores!
go back to cgi no bouncing no stupid crap.
😹
@@SodorProductions
How do you record your audio? And what software do you use? Capcut?😊
i have a shuremv6 mic. no software except the app for the mic. i just plug it into my macbook air and into imovie and thats it
It’s like they’re evolving but backwards, ewwwww
I love the model series and the Cgi but I despise the reboot of Thomas.
I’d love to see a reboot that follows up on the CGI series.
Me too
God hear you, man.
Same
I agree plus 1 I want all characters in the big book of engines plus Paxton den and dart 2 movies will have thetriatrical releases and 3 Hasbrouck will produce it and its dvd releases plus blu rays for movies
I ment Hasbro
To be honest a continuation from the original run would still be feasible - remember, the gap between Seasons 2 and 3 was over 5 years long
Plot twist: Thomas wakes up in a season 20 style thinking AEG was a dream
In the new Thomas and Friends, One-off characters would have a good chance that they will have more appearances.
I would really love to see a 2d animated show in the style of the CGI storyboards
Go back to the original show and continue it from Season 24, simple enough.
There’s already a season 25, 26, and 27, 28 is coming up!
@alexwinandy4792 Some sources count AEG as these seasons; dunno what stance Mattel would take if the original series were to return
@alexwinandy4792 That's the reboot, not the original.
@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967 TVS is model, cgi, and aeg.
@alexwinandy4792 AEG is a very different show. It ISN’T season 25-onwards. Season 25 got cancelled because of it.
The best thing to do once AEG is officially cancelled is to just let the show die for little while. Leaving it alone for a bit gives Mattel time to actually use their brains for once and think about how to make a Thomas great show again that isn't produced for the sole purpose of selling toys. Toys should be the by-product of a kids show, not the other way around.
The most logical thing to do is look back on the show's history and it's most successful period and take plenty of notes of everything that made it so successful, consulting the fans for our advise would be a really good move as we'd actual steer Mattel in the right direction to bring back OG Thomas. But in all honesty though, if Mattel really wants Thomas to be a household name again, then all they have to do is HIRE THE FANS make the show for them. With people who actually know and care what Thomas The Tank Engine truly is and it's core appeal, there is no way the show would ever fall from grace again. Heck... i'm willing to bet we'd even fix Mattel's dreadful state of merchandise ranges and bring back quality toys again as well.
If they can fix Star Wars and Jurassic Park's merchandise ranges, there's no doubt they can do the same for Thomas & Friends.
My idea for a new Thomas & Friends series would be to take all the elements of every version of the franchise and combine them into an entirely new series in a storytelling format that's reminiscent of the Railway Series and the first five seasons of the Classic TV series, one that's rooted in realism. And with all the bad things in each version, I'd repurpose them into something that would work better than how they were originally depicted.
Edit: Oh, and it would all be in CGI, the best quality CGI animation affordable.
Edit Number 2: Also, Mattel should really take a long break from producing anything Thomas-related and put the focus on studying everything good and bad about the franchise, consult and collaborate with fans and railway enthusiasts, connoisseurs and experts on what works, what doesn't work, hire professional writers who know the lore inside and out and how to execute the stories properly, and figure out how to reintroduce TV series exclusive characters to this whole new setting and flesh them out in ways that make them feel less out of place than they were as perviously portrayed. You do 75 to 80 percent that, and we've got a new high quality series that fans old and new can enjoy wholeheartedly.
2:42 I had this personal "Percy, don't do that" joke idea that if he jumpscares someone, they would mention how AEG would receive its 5th season (and then it would cut to its official announcement).
You mean like-- "GUYS!!!!"
@AndrewHager02 *D'OH D'OH D'OH D'OH D'OH; PERCY, DON'T DO THAT!!!*
*YOU'LL MAKE ALL ENGINES GO GREENLIT SEASON 5!!!*
Guys, for once, we might have hope, its slim but never zero.
Honestly, the TV side of the franchise has been going on near-constantly for 40 years. They've been milking it dry for the past 20. At this point, they might as well just let the show rest for a bit...
Agreed, let it rest for a few years before going back to work on it, with someone more competent as the showrunner.
dry for the past 20... couldn't agree more ✊
I personally prefer the steam team as it's accurate to real life as engines were assigned to certain sheds like Flying Scotsman being assigned to a shed at Kings Cross
A new series with hybrid design. Rws and TTTE. Great story and old character return.
1:55 Thomas and the magic railroad: okay but I have a magical engine in my movie and I'm somewhat not in the list?
opinion, but i rather watch the portions of sodor in TATMR than ANYTHING mattel put out. sodor in tatmr is done right. like i said, you either like the other elements of the movie or you don't. i do like them for the stand alone movie it is so yes it's not on the list. mattel is all about silly lazy ideas. in TATMR the engines are worried about diesel 10 destroying all of them. in SLOTLT, they're worried about buried treasure and a pirate ship... that ain't TTTE to me and never will be. again an opinion, but i will always prefer TATMR and 1-7. mattel made movies basically to sell merchandise as they were slowly killing the brand and the core identity of sodor/the engines
For the show it would be cool for it to be 20 style animation but more realistic, all characters from seasons 1-7 appear and they have stories based on classic tvs stories. Also if they just kept Michael white on and have Britt and Andrew Brenner to help with stories it would be perfect
I agree with most of this comment except for getting Britt back. I’ve nothing against her but I have a bad feeling she and Andrew would probably have conflicting ideas about what Thomas should be.
@joshuaW5621 in my opinion they would be there to give advice Andrew Brenner might write stories tho
Mattel should just stop with All engines go, maybe take a break for a while, and then bring the show back with a reboot in the season 20 style, plus a bring back more of the older characters, including Boco, and then the franchise can finally get back to normal!
My Little Pony has a high school human spin off.
And the fans have put T&F scenes as humans.
So a humanised high school or railway teaching school could be an option.
I wouldn’t really be a fan of a humanised Thomas series tbh.
I very much left the Thomas community since All Engines Go came out. I feel like the series might continue for 2 more seasons because of how well the merchandise sells to the fans (mostly Bruno for some reason), again that's my opinion. I don't know how long AEG will keep going, but there's going to be a certain point once again, Mattel has to start from scratch. They either finally end the Thomas and Friends series, or go for another reboot.
They need to sell Thomas lock stock and barrel to someone who cares! Maybe a new Thomas show could be animated by Blue Zoo in a style similar to The Adventures of Paddington!
if series 25 did happen thomas was gonna go to japan, in 2015 sam wilkinson wanted to bring the culdee fell railway, bear, and possibly d199 to cgi but it didn't happen
I think they should bring back the famous 8 I miss duck being part of the main cast
I really hope the original Thomas and Friends show will come back and get a season 25. Because that's what I like better. I also hope the show will have some more Railway Series adaptations and add some more Railway Series characters like Wilbert, Bear/D7101, Jock, Frank, D199/Spamcan, Big City Engine, Sixteen, Culdee and and the other mountain railway engines, Ivo Hugh, 40125/Old Stuck Up, Albert, Victoria and Helena.
Hope that new TV show is a followup to the original
And hopefully they start airing the remaining episodes of the original on TV including The Royal Engine
Id like to say, maybe a model series/CGI type of series, what I’m saying is they make cgi models of the models and make a series with that
2D, and a rewrite railway series that after the adaptation of book 42, it expands the lore of the railway series
I hope they go back to models mainly because that's surprisingly cheaper than CGI not to mention I'm sure Draton manner would not mind handing over the models they have and the community can just make more replicas
Oi the reason they switch to CGI is because the models! In 2009, HIT Entertainment forced them to switch to CGI (Season 13) is because how costly it costs to make Model production (Season 12) 🙄
The og Thomas and friends
Mattel should take a leaf out of Thunderbirds are go and combine models with cgi for their next Thomas series. For this new series I would keep Nia and Rebecca but place them at Vicarstown sheds rather than at Tidmouth sheds. Thomas, Percy and Toby I would place them at the Ffarquhar sheds (Tidmouth) rather than at Tidmouth sheds/Toby's shed. Edward, I would keep at Wellsworth and Henry at Tidmouth sheds.
I haven't seen or watched any AEG because the terrible reception but also because I didn't like the fake non realistic track hopping and stuff etc and I just don't like it. Loved the last few videos, thanks for GOATED content
🙌
It's probably gonna be a live action reboot from 3 folks behind Wonka
A new Thomas series with a new timeline and better characterization would be amazing!
We need boco and the other forgotten characters in the cgi series again
no more reboot but season 25 of thomas and friends with the cgi series and kana, bruno, sandy, Farona and Frederico, Riff and Jiff, Tess and some more characters that were exclusive in the books like Zoom and Eugene (E10) for ex. will make it to the new season.
it couldbe cgi and aeg coexisting, i think that should be the best choice
I have an idea.
How about they make a reboot. But no ordinary reboot,
A reboot for the rws series.
Each season will focus on the lore. For example, no percy in season 1 because thats the season the island of sodor would be building a new railway.
Hopefully it won't be another crappy reboot I do hope there will be a proper Revival that takes place after the 24th season going back to CGI with no bouncing and nothing that's extremely unrealistic
What if Salty was introduce in Thomas and The Magic Railroad?
it means we would have seen the docks and that would have been awesome
What would be cool if that's characters appear in the first time in TATMR?
A) Murdoch
B) Emily
C) Fergus
If they would go back to the model series, they might need some voice actors for their roles like in “Thomas And The Magic Railroad”.
I can't quite see where else the show would go (other than content farms perhaps) besides returning to its original form
If all engines go have a season 5 please return Oliver and possibly Rebecca or shane
I really want the original Thomas & Friends series to go back and season 25 of original classic Thomas era should be Big World Big Adventures or the series 19-21 era style
Bro bring back the model era please I don’t wanna see another Thomas jumping in the air
What we need is the season 21 animation style, which is flashy and beautiful without looking overly cartoonish, bring back Brenner, original steam team, but more episodes led by female characters for gender diversity, like a 50/50 split. No bouncing, no fantasy sequences and no musicals...
Nia and Rebecca look like Thomas and Friends fandom characters stolen from DeviantArt and put into the show.
If All Engines go gets cancelled, I think the next show should be a continuation from the CGI series. My idea would be expand Tidmouth Sheds and bring back Edward, Henry and Toby. If I had to write the first episode, I would write it from another point of view like Doctor Who did in Rose, but I would write it from the point of view from Sir Topham Hatt.
Hmm do you know what I guess they could make a Thomas the Tank Engine anime adaptation?
I would like it to go back to CGI
i want a break from the franchise being ruined
We all do
If they produce a new show I want to see where this goes I like AEG
It will be more like the railway series books and have characters from the books and seasons 1-12
sounds good!
I’d like to see the books continued or return to maybe S19
STOP SHAMING LOST TREASURE, IT WAS THE BEST THOMAS MOVIE WE EVER GOT
opinion* and no
@@SodorProductions Tell me why it's not the best then
i already said why, but the engines of sodor do not care about pirate ships and buried treasure. it's another gimmick mattel put in there because all the movies they made had to have a gimmick. it's just lazy in my opinion. it's NOT TTTE. not to mention SLOTLT reuses the idea that thomas does something wrong and then another engine is brought in who pulls annie and clarabel. thomas messing up and being a baby is a big part of the movie too. not interesting to me. i prefer TATMR and 1-7. not really a fan of CGI thomas and friends, mattel stopped letting sodor be sodor and the characters be steam engines. while doing all the things fans defend TO THE DEATH, they drove the brand into the ground 😹 so i guess the dinosaurs and buried treasure wasn't good enough to keep people and kids interested. and of course not, it's not TTTE.
@@SodorProductions Go tell that to The Unlucky Tug and see what he says
😹 tf he's not the TTTE bible, he's just another human with an opinion. i could care less, stop copying 'this big RUclipsr's opinion'. it's pathetic, think for yourself. so many thomas fans on YT act like that^^^
I would love to see a more rws style aproach in cgi
I think I'm retiring myself from being a Thomas fan, and being part of the Thomas community, For good cuz this is just too far.....
Fr I actually left the community a while ago due to how toxic it is
I hope that the original thomas and friends series returns after all the cgi is really amazing and i love it
I would say bring back the cgi era of Thomas & Friends, because the og models are either shipped to different parts of the world or damage. If I were to bring the show back, then first I would bring Edward and Henry back to sheds. Then, I bring back the other cast back (ex Neville, Molly, Dennis, Murdoch, Hank, Freddie, Duke, Smudger, Proteus & the others). Make stories focus on other characters besides Thomas. Make Henry not a scaredy engine and Percy not a child. And make Sam, Logan and Dustin appeared and make them stars of their own episodes.
I'm fucking scared! I'm guessing it's gonna be back to that 2D Bullshit!
hahaha it probably will be man
Can we have Thomas the tank engine & Friends being a British railway again? That's all I'm asking for
classic series >>>
@SodorProductions Yes sir
If this is the case, they should announce a new television series sometime in late 2025 possibly.
I think it’s time to let our friend Thomas rest for a while. All the magic that made Seasons 1-5 and 17-21 special is all gone. The brand needs to be dead for a while before they can try again. If they reboot the brand and bring in people who care than that would be a miracle but it’s far too soon now. I’m 23 years old and I grew up with the classic series and saw the Brenner era as it was coming out. We had a good thing but it’s over now and we need to move on. I do want the real Thomas to return at some point in the future but it’s far too soon now. If All Engines Go does end next year then I don’t wanna see another Thomas reboot for at least six years. Our friend Thomas needs to rest.
No more AEG! Back to CGI and or Model!
Yes
Mattel,If you’re Reading this
Please go back to the Classic and CGI Series,Bring Back Edward and Henry(including Toby)back to the Steam Team
With the state of Drayton Manor. I wouldn’t go back to the models. I would go back to the CGI, bring back Andrew Brenner, have Adam Sandler narrate the US dub, and John Cleese to narrate the UK dub.
how bad has drayton manor become? idk myself im just curious
@ at the Thomas land exhibit, lots of the models have been damaged or stolen, some of the faces have fallen off or they don’t even work anymore. it’s really sad especially to us Hardcore Thomas fans.
Even if they somehow did go back to models (which I don’t see happening), I don’t even think they would use the original models from seasons 1-12. They’d likely make new models for the characters.
Also, this is just my opinion but I don’t think Adam Sandler would fit Thomas. I think he sounds too goofy.
I WANT CGI and ORIGINAL CHARACTERS BACK AS WELL!!
Maybe a 2D Animated Thomas And Friends show not like AEG, like CGI but 2D
I want the new tv series to be a best of all worlds from the entire franchise, ESPECIALLY the railway series, personally I love the railway series!
I would love to go back to the classic era but there is a problem with money and props Mattel will have to get the money and make new props since the old ones need a rest which will take time and maybe do some new mechanics since exact parts c ctould or could not be found bring back the brenner era and when ready switch to the classic era Or just call up the fandom to help. Great video
You mean like the 2004 to the Present Reboot Series Thomas & Friends Adventure Series.
call me crazy but what if thomas and friends go the same way as mlp eg. Where the trains could be human Just like in mlp eg where ponys are human
I hope the season 25 will realest
scrap nina and the others bring back edward and henry
1:15 Man of the people speaking😤
hahaha
They need to bring the CHI and the original actors back
This no go way don’t have season 5! All Engines Go
I dont see any issues with nia and rebecca, and henry delivering goods to the mainland often would make sense for him to stay at vicarstown and edward living at wellsworth since its the start of his branchline makes sense too. Toby didnt live at tidmouth but he never left the main cast of the show, they just need to learn how to keep edward and henry in the main cast, which to be honest, they dont have much going on with them lets be honest, henry is just a scared loser and edward is a wise engine who the others usually come to for advice. Maybe work in how Henry is the one usually away and not thomas, he comes back and tells stories of the mainland, and the tv series could really work in more elements how edward is a father figure towards bill and ben and other branchlines stories
What about Treehouse? 😢
I don't want the brenner era back I want the models back, like how it used to be
2:30 ABC Kids 😔
honestly i think theyll probably make another all engines goish show (if it even gets canned)
I hope they keep the 2D Thomas but make it look like the railway series it won't be perfect as always but it will be better than that
Look just make Rebecca and nia better personalitys and yeah m relocate them
Seasons 1 and 2 had a narrator doubling up as the voice for all the characters, that's the way Thomas the Tank Engine & Friends should be kept. The music should be the same as it was in Seasons 1 and two, no disappearances of any of the theme tunes. Come along MATTEL, get with the show. Get rid of that sleazy new childish image of Thomas and go back to 1984 and 1986. Not hard to do. However, I'm tired of only giving my thoughts on MATTEL ruining Thomas' classic image. Can't we change the subject? Christmas isn't very far away. What's on your Christmas wishlist?
Wait what Thomas and friends all engines go is cancelled or something?
We don’t know yet.
Nah Mattel should just sell the franchise to a more competent company
We want the chi series back
If they do, I want Eddie and hengy
Go back to the regular show and just continue where they left off
Go back to the 1984 stop motion models.
They were not stop motion. only for like a few episodes
In 2021 mattel should have just sold the toys only and cancel the TV show and go on hiatus and sold the toys and should’ve made money off of that then during the 80th anniversary come out with a movie and just had a movie series about Thomas the Tank Engine and then make a little TV show out of the movies and put it on TV and they should’ve just sold the minis motorized and push alongs because Mattel decided to make motorized a standard toy train line and then that’s how the toys would go from that on they should have never released all engines go
I like Sodor's legend of the lost treasure
Bring back CGI
just make 5 minute run of episode and make thomas great again oh i forgor bring back the old voice actors
I would like CGI to return in my casting for the US dub
David menkin as Thomas
Rino Romano as Edward
Kevin frank as Henry
Kerry shale as Gordon
David menkin as James
Christopher Ragland as percy
Emily same actor
Uk Eddie Glenn as Thomas
John Sparkes as Edward
John Sparkes as Henry
John Sparkes as Gordon
Mark Moraghan as james
Joanna Ruiz as Percy
Colm Feore as toby
Joanna Ruiz as Emily
Etc etc etc
Mf All Engines Go was literally my childhood I’m not gonna let you diss it like this here 😤😤😤
It’s only been out for 3 years, there’s no way you’re young enough to have grown up with it and simultaneously be mature enough to have a RUclips account at this time.
@ Holy hell gramps 😂😂😂 Next thing I know you’re gonna tell me you were alive for the model series
@Diecastcreations well I did, but that’s not the point. I just find it hard to believe that you’re old enough to be commenting on RUclips if you grew up watching AEG since it’s not even that old.
Average bwba/aeg hater opinion:
Bring back Edward and Henry