Final Oscar Thoughts 2024 with Brian & Cody!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 148

  • @alpe1987
    @alpe1987 8 месяцев назад +69

    Yorgos Lanthimos has directed Olivia Colman and Emma Stone and they won Oscars. Rachel Weisz needs to team up again with Lanthimos and get that second Oscar for best actress then THE FAVOURITE trifecta will be complete

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

      ه 👀I was think same thing
      He amazing diroctor
      And he make british story amazing way
      He now get two oscar by his actross
      Olivia and emma
      His diroction for performance amazing
      Emma stone amaze me how she act in her body languge.

  • @trinaq
    @trinaq 8 месяцев назад +75

    Even Emma Stone seemed to be surprised that she won over Lily Gladstone. While I was hoping that Gladstone would win, Stone delivered an unforgettable, powerful performance, and hopefully Gladstone will eventually win later in her career.

    • @eamonndeane587
      @eamonndeane587 8 месяцев назад +2

      Hopefully....
      That being said, I keep having this nasty feeling that Gladstone's Next Nomination will be a posthumous one, and she'll lose that as well....
      Maybe just me being cynical, but I can't shake that feeling 😔.

  • @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv
    @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv 8 месяцев назад +26

    Why do many people keep saying the Boy and the Heron win was a surprise?
    ・If an animated feature wins BAFTA, Golden Globe and loses Annie, it never loses Oscar.
    ・It got higher Metascore than Spiderman
    ・The Academy has invited so many Asian members recently.
    ・Hayao Miyazaki is highly recpected and influential who had 1 last chance to win (he is Akira Kurosawa in Anime industry)
    ・Spiderman prequel has already won and Spiderman has the next year to win
    It was a shoe in

    • @JeekayTenn
      @JeekayTenn 8 месяцев назад +2

      Agreed. I think people weren't thinking about it properly, were just looking at the Annie awards (which doesn't have much academy representation to begin with) and assumed Spider-verse would win. But hindsight is also a thing.

    • @laurajones1773
      @laurajones1773 8 месяцев назад

      Also, people, including myself thinking of Spiderverse doing better at the guilds than Boy and the Heron including Spiderverse’s PGA win.

    • @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv
      @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv 8 месяцев назад +4

      @@laurajones1773 PGA had never even nominated non-English animation film, Parasite did not win either.
      It is so biased in the first place.
      The Boy and Heron's PGA nomination is equal to its Oscar win

    • @laurajones1773
      @laurajones1773 8 месяцев назад

      Then why didn’t The Boy and the Heron get an ACE Eddie nomination? That film is the first Best Animated Feature Oscar winner without an ACE nomination. Even Big Hero 6 got nominated at ACE even if it lost to The LEGO Movie.

    • @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv
      @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@laurajones1773 When "Spirited Away" won, that award did not exist. No one actually knew whether this rule is applied to a Japanese anime. How many voters do you think are film editors?

  • @raymondmedel1879
    @raymondmedel1879 8 месяцев назад +28

    Poor Things costumes also reflect the evolution of Bella Baxter and her journey to enlightenment

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад +2

      ه 👀 Emma stone her role win costumes
      Amazing bella baxter win best role and best fashion
      The role win best actross and fashion and make up
      Wining from outside and inside 👏👏👏

    • @laurajones1773
      @laurajones1773 8 месяцев назад

      The costumes are gaudy imo. Barbie should have won the costume award. Although, Poor Things deserves the production design award though.

    • @myytchanneldinakoha8498
      @myytchanneldinakoha8498 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@laurajones1773gaudy is exactly why Poor Things won. It’s costumes, not a fashion show.

    • @laurajones1773
      @laurajones1773 8 месяцев назад

      If how gaudy the costumes looks is the reason it wins is stupid.

  • @mentonerodominicano
    @mentonerodominicano 8 месяцев назад +24

    Emma winning is almost like Olivia winning 4 years ago. Because of the narrative, a lot of voters probably thought Gladstone and Close were a safe win, so many of them just voted for their favorite performance overall, which helped Olivia and Emma win.

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад +3

      ه 👀Olivia and emma win for sama diroctor
      He is genius intelgant diroctor
      Let his actross get oscar
      Becase he make them make amazing acting
      Olivia wining was surpriseing more emma
      Emma was the big front runner even if lilly was in comption

  • @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv
    @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv 8 месяцев назад +24

    I am Japanese Director and VFX director Takashi Yamazaki reveled us many intersting things.
    ・As he said in his speech, he was inspired by Spielberg, and they met. Spielberg said he watched Gadzilla 3 times in theater, and he gave Spielberg a Godzilla doll he had which Spielberg seemed to want.
    ・All the extras in the film were enthsiastic Godzilla fans. He didn't have to give any acting advice because all of them were so good at being scared by Godzilla.

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

      Godzila have many fans
      Rooting for

    • @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv
      @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv 8 месяцев назад +2

      The fact that no one knows about Godzilla Minus One:
      At the age of 25, Tatsuji Nojima became the youngest winner of the category. Probably he still doesn't know.
      Suzanne M. Benson (born in 1958) for "Aliens"(1986) was probably the youngest winner

  • @dj71162
    @dj71162 8 месяцев назад +27

    It looks like the Academy is finally moving towards international representation, and being less American-centric. BAFTA has as far back as the 40s recognised foreign-language films and performances. The Academy definitely should have done this, but always seemed to look down on them.

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад +1

      Academy prove in emma stone wining
      It can give british role the best actress against amrican role if british role was the best
      And prove if the role was the best
      They will give the actross secend oscar

    • @thegodsofgalaxy2109
      @thegodsofgalaxy2109 8 месяцев назад +1

      BAFTA was totally off last year

    • @dj71162
      @dj71162 8 месяцев назад

      @@thegodsofgalaxy2109 Or was it that the Academy was totally off last year?

    • @thegodsofgalaxy2109
      @thegodsofgalaxy2109 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@dj71162 Bafta was.

  • @claranism
    @claranism 8 месяцев назад +15

    Congrats for sticking w Emma!! 🎉✌️ I reckon only you and Luke Hearfield stick w her while the vast majority (99.5%) of Oscars experts/pundits follow the herd n switch camp to Lily in the last few days leading up to the Oscars, even thot many were super unsure of their final choice. All of them are totally blindsided by SAG!! 😂
    I luv that the SAG stats are broken!! so that no expert/pundit can be 100% sure or just default to SAG's winners next year!! 🤗

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

      After sag lilly gladstone was still fron-runner
      And she still fron runner in oscar even if she lose the oscar.
      She was real threat.
      She lose that mean she top two in the end.
      Becase one of emma or lilly was will lose and anthor will win..
      And audiance rooting not for same
      Some fans to lilly and some of them to emma
      Some with pafta and some with sag.
      And some thing the voters vote for emma after bafta
      And some thing voters give lilly voting after sag.

  • @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv
    @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv 8 месяцев назад +9

    The fact that no one knows about Godzilla Minus One:
    At the age of 25, Tatsuji Nojima became the youngest winner of the category. Probably he still doesn't know.
    Suzanne M. Benson (born in 1958) for "Aliens"(1986) was probably the youngest winner

  • @edhance9753
    @edhance9753 8 месяцев назад +3

    Cody and you play off each other very well! I used to follow movies and the oscars at the first half of the 2010s, but then my professional career took almost all of my energy. Since Everything Everywhere All At Once ive fallen back into it. This was the first Oscars I have seen all BP nominees and im glad i did, Looking forward to seeing more from you guys.

  • @CocogoatMain0501
    @CocogoatMain0501 8 месяцев назад +15

    IMO, Emma's oscar win is one of the most deserved of all time.

  • @lregwoc2
    @lregwoc2 8 месяцев назад +5

    I love the pairing of both Brian and Cody. Can't wait for next year or earlier.

  • @Sylv1ception71
    @Sylv1ception71 8 месяцев назад +11

    Yes, the work on costumes for Barbie was fantastic, but by no meaning close to the incredible job they did on Poor Things - just like the production design!!

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

      ه 👀Poor thing and naplion was the best
      But poor thing creative something not exist
      Naplion they based on real history so no creative

  • @MrMgkman13
    @MrMgkman13 8 месяцев назад +15

    The nomination is what’s important. All this “we have all this work to do over again.” Is bullshit.
    We literally just had the first ever Asian winners last year all that doesn’t get undone because Emma Stone won this year. Tired of hearing this kind of talk.

    • @jomamamac
      @jomamamac 8 месяцев назад +1

      yah right?! -- a bit of a "reset" -- come one...!

  • @emillion4470
    @emillion4470 8 месяцев назад +2

    Conflicted is the right word.
    Not to take anything away from Emma's triumph, just as many people felt sad about Lily's loss. They were both deserving but the sting is deep and resonates. Gladstone holding an Oscar would have been a perfect ending - worthy of a Hollywood movie.

    • @wheretheyhaveribs55
      @wheretheyhaveribs55 8 месяцев назад +2

      Diversity sucks. Best actress category is for best acting. Not best tribe, best race, best feel good. Woke enough?

  • @minavamp2811
    @minavamp2811 8 месяцев назад +3

    after emma won bafta, 4 days later final oscar voting began. so she has the momentum going in. then after 3 days of oscar voting, lily won sag. so lily has the momentum for the last 3 days of oscar voting. where as in the case of last year, after michelle yeoh won sag, 4 days later final oscar voting began. so michelle has the momentum going in for the entire 6 days of oscar voting, and i think that makes a difference between michelle winning and lily losing the oscar. the timeline for last year final oscar voting is so important that it also helps brendan fraser to win over austin butler, and jamie lee curtis to win over angela basset and kerry condon.

  • @maxfieldfulton
    @maxfieldfulton 8 месяцев назад +6

    One note about costumes. The reason I switched from Barbie to Poor Things is that the latter had two elements that Oscar voters love: period style (Little Women, Ma Rainey) and imagination (Black Panther). True, as Cody pointed out, the Academy does like to reward fashion-focused movies, but Phantom Thread was a period piece, and Cruella had imaginative costumes. The fact that Wakanda Forever beat Mrs. Harris last year makes me think that period style and imagination count more than fashion-focus.

  • @patrarus6097
    @patrarus6097 8 месяцев назад +4

    Thanks for another excellent video, Brian. I'm glad that you and Cody are collaborating. Keep up the great work!

  • @criss8836
    @criss8836 8 месяцев назад +5

    I am loving Brian and Cody friendship. Keep videos coming!
    Taking the occasion to thank you both for this amazing Awards season.
    How fun was to watch you guessing and reviewing movies.
    And now...on to the next!
    Congratulations to all the winners and good luck for the new season ❤

  • @countfosco1
    @countfosco1 8 месяцев назад +3

    I don't get it. I always believed (though one can't be one hundred per cent for certain) that Emma stone would win it, and that the SAG award was compensation for the fact that Gladstone wasn't going to win. Stone was actually very good and she's loved. Remember when Julie Christie won the SAG but lost the Oscar.

  • @jamielee7943
    @jamielee7943 8 месяцев назад +4

    While I was really hoping for Lily Gladstone to win I’m not unsurprised it was Emma Stone who won. I didn’t really like Poor Things but she was great in it. A very technically impressive performance. I much prefer this win over La La Land.
    I think the thing that is bothering me & this is nothing against Emma… is that she is always in the conversation. She’s very popular. Adored by her peers. Her films are always on the radar. She’s been nominated regularly over the past few years & now she has won 2 Oscars in 7 years. We all know she’ll be back in next few years possibly to be considered again. I mean she has another Yorgos film coming out soon. I feel like she’s becoming the Leonardo DiCaprio of the awards circuit… she’s always there. Lol. Which is awesome for her. She should be if she’s giving amazing performances…
    It’s not her I have the problem with. I think it’s just sad we got so close to Lily making history that really would have meant something to so many people.
    I’m with Cody… it does feel like we’ve gone back to the beginning of the progress that Lily paved the way for. It is like a reset after almost getting there. How long will it be now until a Native American man/woman does win an Oscar? They certainly don’t get nominated like Emma Stone does.
    I just hope we get more Lily Gladstone in our future. She has a fantastic career ahead of her. And maybe one day soon she’ll get that elusive Oscar.

  • @jomamamac
    @jomamamac 8 месяцев назад +7

    I saw both "killers of the flower Moon" and "poor things" . To say that Gladstone would beat over Stone is a joke, unless of course you take all the demographic points and social expectations Emma Stone carried "poor things", and hands down. Every scene was a controlled burn, with both gas and matches in her hands. She owns that victory without looking back.

    • @VikingMatt879
      @VikingMatt879 8 месяцев назад +4

      Agreed 100%. All the things I heard about Lily Gladstone possibly winning was "Gladstone has the narrative, a win would make a historical moment, it's the only win that Killers Of The Flower Moon will get, Emma Stone already has an Oscar, etc etc...." Not once did I hear anyone say that Gladstone would win the Oscar because she gave a better performance than Emma Stone. You know why? Because she didn't. I can't even fathom Gladstone taking that Oscar over what Stone did in Poor Things.

  • @pepperminttree
    @pepperminttree 8 месяцев назад +4

    i may the only one who thought that the sound in oppenheimer was just ok. i could barely hear any of the dialogue

    • @jomamamac
      @jomamamac 8 месяцев назад +2

      that is par for the Nolan course.

  • @samuelbarber6177
    @samuelbarber6177 8 месяцев назад +13

    I’m just a bit annoyed that Killers of the Flower Moon didn’t win anything, especially given that several of the Indigenous nominees were passed over for people who’d already won. I’d have at least given Best Actress and Best Original Song. Maybe best Score just to honour the late Robbie Robertson, but it’s hard to be mad with Ludwig Goransson winning for his incredible work on Oppenheimer.
    But overall it was a mostly agreeable ceremony. Oppenheimer cleaned up in all the categories I wanted it to (particularly the cinematography award made me happy), Wes Anderson finally won something (even if he wasn’t there, which is funny), John Mulaney’s bit as well as Schwarzenegger/DeVito/Keaton, most of the acceptance speeches and I can’t be the only one who kind of loves Al Pacino’s best Picture announcement? Right?

    • @mohitrawat5225
      @mohitrawat5225 8 месяцев назад +1

      This thing has happened with 4th time this century that his film was nominated in a lot of categories but failed to win in a single. Others were Gangs of New York, The Wolf of Wall Street, The Irishman

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

      Martin scorssisy problem he is always make his film funny and light sooo he in the end looose
      And if he focus in lilly gladston role more leanardoo maybe she win
      He foucus about criminal not about victim
      Academy invite native amrican to play music and invinte themin red carpet

    • @frankcarlosanaliza
      @frankcarlosanaliza 8 месяцев назад +7

      "People who had already won". It is not about spreading the love, but giving it to the most outstanding choice on its category.

    • @jomamamac
      @jomamamac 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@frankcarlosanaliza right!!! ON!!!

  • @brettdarling1178
    @brettdarling1178 8 месяцев назад +8

    These are two best friends, I love this! Brian imitated Cody perfectly. 😂 “No… Spider-Man.” 🤣

  • @MrJoker3571
    @MrJoker3571 8 месяцев назад +8

    The Hurt Locker is still the last BP winner to have won in the Sound category.

  • @bilaalbadurdeen2733
    @bilaalbadurdeen2733 8 месяцев назад +6

    Stone vs stone 🔥

  • @muriela.4673
    @muriela.4673 8 месяцев назад +1

    You and Cody are such a great team, love their dialogues and happy there will be more collab in the future

  • @BigNoseDog
    @BigNoseDog 8 месяцев назад +2

    I think of lot of folks making predictions were guilty of overthinking. The fact that Lily Gladstone wasn’t even nominated at BAFTA should’ve been the clearest sign she wasn’t going to win the Oscar. It’s one thing to be nominated but lose. But when you’re not even nominated? This is why I couldn’t understand why so many people were attaching so much weight to SAG. Does a win at one show completely negate not being nominated at the previous show?

  • @maxfieldfulton
    @maxfieldfulton 8 месяцев назад +4

    I felt the way about best actress the way Cody felt about best animated feature. In contrast to Brian, my favorite wins of the night are usually the ones I predict wrong. This year it was Emma Stone, last year it was Ruth Carter.
    Love, love, love this series. Please bring Cody back next year!

  • @thomashavard-morgan8181
    @thomashavard-morgan8181 8 месяцев назад +5

    Narrative undoubtedly always plays a part, but the question is how much should it? Gladstone winning would almost have felt her winning based on her ethnicity and the moment as opposed to her performance and how right is that? What we need less of is narratives like, insert ''first ever'' winner and more stories and roles that allows those from minority backgrounds the same careers and opportunities of their white counterparts. Lily's loss stings not because she was robbed, but rather because, will she get another shot, whereas Emma will likely continue to be given prestigious roles that fit her talent and thus allow further chances to be nominated and win. The system needs to change.

    • @benhaynes4409
      @benhaynes4409 8 месяцев назад

      Absolutely correct ! Well said.

  • @esciteach7997
    @esciteach7997 8 месяцев назад

    17:00 agree 100% have watched many, many Acad. Awards Ceremonies. This one made me smile; a feel good show/event. Last time I felt this good during one of these ceremonies was when Parasite and Bong Joon Ho won for director, and the wins for EEAAO. Great video by you guys, btw !!!

  • @singstreetcar5881
    @singstreetcar5881 8 месяцев назад +4

    Bring back ryan.
    He is a cutie❤

  • @JTigre99
    @JTigre99 8 месяцев назад +3

    I really enjoy the commentary with you and Cody.

  • @poett8875
    @poett8875 8 месяцев назад +12

    I’m happy for all the winners. However I hope next year there’s some sort of suspense going into Oscar night. This season became extremely predictable very fast.

    • @samuelbarber6177
      @samuelbarber6177 8 месяцев назад +2

      To be fair, I think that was mostly more down to the films rather than the ceremony. I feel like as soon as Oppenheimer dropped and became such a hit there was no way it missing out on the major awards it did win, unless something else truly phenomenal and that could eclipse it had come out. Killers of the Flower Moon could’ve been that film but it just didn’t have that kind of momentum. Similarly, something like Poor Things was maybe just a bit too weird for general audiences.

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

      That why emma stone wining make her cry
      Becase she still same audiance to in the end she dont know if she will win or lilly will be the winer
      But i love the rusult
      Not suspence but right ✔✔✔

  • @tashkenty
    @tashkenty 8 месяцев назад +4

    Congrats to Emma, but all I can say is the Academy is not ready to recognize the wrongdoings against a Nation committed a century ago, nor willing to celebrate and embrace its rich cultural history and heritage. The story will always remain the same. Only chance for Native Americans and Latinas to get rewarded is to form their own guilds and separate themselves from AMPAS, which is basically a satellite organization of BAFTA.

    • @Ray03595
      @Ray03595 8 месяцев назад +4

      The award should be about the best actress not best narrative. There’s a strong argument that Lily is more of a supporting actress than lead actress in the film too. Emma deserved the win this year.
      You’re going about solving the problem the wrong way. You should be asking for Hollywood to make more films that center around natives. It’s asking too much for one film to carry all the recognition for Native Americans. Simple truth is that Lily wasn’t the best lead actress this year, and if her representatives had campaigned her for supporting actress there’s a highly probability she would’ve swept award season because her own real competition was Da’Vine

    • @tashkenty
      @tashkenty 8 месяцев назад

      @@Ray03595 you’re entitled to your opinion as I am entitled to mine. Lily Gladstone is leading for me, and to a lot of actors, especially the SAG voters. And yes, 96 years of academy awards history and Hollywood film history are more than enough to make a fair assessment on how Hollywood has treated, underestimated and grossly overlooked Native American and Latino performers, and shall continue to do so. So congratulations to Emma Stone for winning the White Oscars, or shall I say the BAFTA American Awards. At this point I really don’t give a damn if she and Billie Eilish get 100 Oscar’s, it’s the awards destined and expected for THEIR ethnicity anyway, they should award their own tribe. Chris Rock got it right all along.

  • @delia88209
    @delia88209 8 месяцев назад +4

    Poor things was awesome to look at the sets and the costumes. Emma stone was great but I struggled with the plot.

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

      ه 👀Struggle with plot becase was fantsy story
      I was hope the story was realistic
      Will be realy amazing
      Espialy how bella bahviar in victorian community and how she make sixial thing in that era becase she was sopntenus as a child in adult body

  • @johnnolan5579
    @johnnolan5579 8 месяцев назад +2

    So tired about the duel between Stone and Gladstone, especially considering that Sandra Huller was so outstanding.

    • @laurajones1773
      @laurajones1773 8 месяцев назад +2

      I agree. Sandra Huller from Anatomy of a Fall was the best performance from last year.

  • @MarcioDAstrain
    @MarcioDAstrain 8 месяцев назад +5

    I hope that next year they will bring this group of 5 actors again to present the categories - but I would like to see more legendary actors who are still with us (as was the case with Jessica Lange, Rita Moreno and Sally Field). Bring Meryl Streep, Julie Andrews, Cher, Whoopi Goldberg, Susan Sarandon, Kathy Bates, Judi Dench, etc.

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

      I hope sooo
      Amazing grup of 5😍😍😍👍👍👍👍👍👍👏👏👏👏
      Same cate winslet wining
      But i hope with clip

  • @Joe-bd4xc
    @Joe-bd4xc 8 месяцев назад

    Brian - U R FANTASTIC😅 I love your critiques and sense of humor.

  • @singstreetcar5881
    @singstreetcar5881 8 месяцев назад +4

    Poor things won 3 technical awards in a row (makeup, costumes, set design) and immediately i knew emma stone was gonna win best actress

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

      Amazing❤i was upset emma stone was in backstage that time😄

  • @aagold76
    @aagold76 8 месяцев назад +2

    Clips over Eulogies any day!!!!!!!

  • @jennywhite5531
    @jennywhite5531 8 месяцев назад +3

    I've said it before I will say it again will be Gladstone was an example of category fraud. She was not a leading performer in killers of the flower Moon and 100% that is why she didn't get nominated at bafta and that is why she did not win the oscar. She should have been nominated, however then I sincerely doubt she would have beaten Divine Joy Randolph

  • @deborahdemanno471
    @deborahdemanno471 8 месяцев назад

    Hey Brian - any thoughts on your favorite “Past Lives” not winning anything? It is a jewel of a film but so quiet, were the nominations the best they could hope for?

  • @SKMunt
    @SKMunt 8 месяцев назад +1

    OmG did you guys watch Piers Morgan's take on the Oscars? He's saying it's like the worst line up of movies and ceremony ever. I couldn't believe it. He even acted like Oppenheimer was blah

  • @kurobeach13
    @kurobeach13 8 месяцев назад +1

    Was happy for Boy and the Heron’s win! and Zone of Interest. I didn’t get a chance to watch KotFM or Poor Things. But from clips, I’d say I liked Gladstone’s performance more…

    • @eugenemarshall1594
      @eugenemarshall1594 8 месяцев назад +3

      You are in for such a treat when you watch Poor Things.

    • @charles-edouardmorel3173
      @charles-edouardmorel3173 8 месяцев назад +3

      Seeing just clips of Poor Things doesn't do Emma Stone's performance justice

  • @lauriedaviesrodrigues297
    @lauriedaviesrodrigues297 8 месяцев назад +3

    Love you!

  • @branagain
    @branagain 8 месяцев назад +1

    I liked Oppenheimer but I wanted Holdovers to win all of its categories.

  • @zakuraiyadesu
    @zakuraiyadesu 8 месяцев назад

    Love the videos, man. Keep it up!!!

  • @vins1979
    @vins1979 8 месяцев назад

    How could you find the best sound award to the Zone of Interest as "surprising"? For me, it was OBVIOUS that the Zone of Interest was going to win that. I mean, the sound of the Zone of Interest is literally the main character of the movie!

  • @richardkastlemusic
    @richardkastlemusic 8 месяцев назад +2

    My final thought was that Maestro won all the Oscars it deserved. (Zero) It was doomed because it was about Bernstein, who took a wrecking ball to classical music. I posted a video on my RUclips channel titled THE BERNSTEIN EFFECT that explains how Bernstein's teachings were deigned to make pianists, composers and conductors stupid. He used the Young Peoples Concerts to dumb down the arts, ruining the way symphonies and concertos are performed. The press made him their sacred cow and slanted the coverage. I made another video about how he vandalized Beethoven's symphonies. Bad movie about a bad conductor = zero Oscars

  • @emmo5858
    @emmo5858 8 месяцев назад

    You are amazing Brian...a few things by an addicted cinephile and award junky (myself). It's been 23/23 for me, some of what my gut was saying (thank god I was not following the latest trends) and some because of my instict prediction and not rational thought. We should finally admit that academy has changed... in a good way
    Best Picture: Maestro was my number 10 (was not expecting any win....Bradley should stop trying so so hard). KOTFM was my 9, I have red the book during quarantine and in my opinion they butchered it with the adaptation ( no shock it was not nominated) in comparison for example to Poor Things that McNamara followed Lanthimos vision and took it to another level, though respecting the main theme (one of my favourite books for the last 10 years)
    Best Sound: For me TZOI, as soon as got the best movie nomination, I was sure will get this cause for me sound is the actual leading performance. It does not just elevate it, it makes the movie.
    Makeup, Production, Costume: Well deserved for Poor Things. All three are crucial for the movie and made brilliantly from scratch in order to complete Bella's character and journey. Barbie's was undeniably fabulous work and definitely number 2 but for me was just recreation of the toys.
    Leading actress: Lilly was great, introvert subtle performance but the movie was not. It was not the screen time as her part was never the lead in book. To remind Hopkins in Silence of the Lamps. If you ask somebody how long he was screened, nobody will believe it was just 20 mins. His essence is there all the time. Emma was simply brilliant. She did something so difficult and genuine without precedent. Her performance will be remembered as a classic. I know she wanted Lilly to win but she was the performance of the decade.
    And finally about the whole narrative factor. I believe it has the least weight in the "new" academy and thank god for it. Maybe will be a tiebreaker between 2 equal performances, which makes me believe that Lily was not close to Emma.
    Excuse my very long comment...😊

  • @eugeneimbangyorteza
    @eugeneimbangyorteza 8 месяцев назад

    I think if Gladstone just had 5 minute more screentime she would have won. I personally prefer Emma Stone though.

  • @fabiencoze9829
    @fabiencoze9829 8 месяцев назад +8

    Lily lost because she wasn't the LEADING part of KOTFM .
    PERIOD .

    • @JeekayTenn
      @JeekayTenn 8 месяцев назад

      Antony Hopkins won Best Actor and he had a total screentime of 12 minutes in Silence of the Lambs.

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

      Not the end
      Many actross lose many time
      And in the end win the oscar
      Julian more and cate winslet for example
      Lilly gladston white native amrican so she can play new role

    • @singstreetcar5881
      @singstreetcar5881 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@JeekayTenn Anthony Hopkins is a veteran who has been acting for years. Lily Gladstone is a new comer.
      Silence of the lambs was all the rave back then, killers of the flower moon wasn't the rave this award season

    • @xoxo20000
      @xoxo20000 8 месяцев назад

      Exactly. People should blame Scorsese and Leo more for why she didn't win.

  • @Martin-gx7yu
    @Martin-gx7yu 8 месяцев назад +4

    I don't buy this narrative thing. If the narrative is so important for the Academy why did they wait 96 years to award an indigene actress? Or why did they wait till 2010 to award a female director? Or why did they wait till 2002 to award a black actress? Or till 2023 to award an asian actress?they didn't do this before because the narrative is not a thing for the Academy.

    • @countfosco1
      @countfosco1 8 месяцев назад

      @Martin-gx7yu Actors and actresses don't exist in a vacuum, and no one more so than non-white actors and actresses or minorities. Hattie McDaniel is always written up in white/Anglo discourses as having won her Academy award over the very white Olivia de Havilland, as if it were an anomaly of sorts rather than as an achievement in its own right.
      The point is that white actors are never regarded in this fashion next to non-white or non-Anglo performers, nor are people amazed they have scored a nomination for being white (it's assumed their whiteness never plays a part although it plays a great part if you think about it; when Emma Stone won, though, those who lamented that Gladstone didn't are always told by way of rationalisation, that only the performance should matter, but that's never said about Hattie McDaniel and her win). It's just taken for granted. No one even says Emma Stone is an Anglo actress the way they say Lily Gladstone is "an indigene actress".
      It wasn't until the 'Oscars so white' hashtag that the narrative around the Academy awards began to change. Well, it also took Jada Pinkett's boycott in 2016 to sir things up. Then people began to see how white and male the Academy was. It still is, folks (it's shifted a bit, but not much).

    • @Ray03595
      @Ray03595 8 месяцев назад

      This is more evidence of a narrative. For ages the narrative was that only white actors deserved recognition.

  • @singstreetcar5881
    @singstreetcar5881 8 месяцев назад +5

    Martin scoresere needs to go back to the basics. These long epic giant budget movies aint it. The Irishman and killers of the flower moon, 11 and 10 nominations, zero wins.
    He need to work with fresh faces also. No more deniro or leo, or pesci

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

      He need be more searies in film
      He make comedy in tragidy story
      And he make wrong screenplay
      And oppnhimer was here

  • @big-fish1199
    @big-fish1199 8 месяцев назад +3

    Spiderverse and The Creator losing Animated Feature and VFX were my only negatives. Besides that I think I'd agree with basically every award that was won

    • @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv
      @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv 8 месяцев назад +4

      I don't understand why you guys ignored the fact that the Academy has invited so many Asian members recently.
      "Godzilla" and "The Boy and Heron" were shoe in

    • @big-fish1199
      @big-fish1199 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv I understand why they won, I just don't believe they deserved it. The Boy in the Heron has a case, but there's no way Godzilla deserved to win

    • @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv
      @お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@big-fish1199 Because it only costs 8 monthes, $15,000,000, 35 people. This year, nothing was visually new in any films. Instead, they evaluated the creativity. The director Takashi Yamazaki started his career as a VFX guy. He can controll everything by himself. No one else in the world can do what he does.

    • @big-fish1199
      @big-fish1199 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv Gareth Edwards is a former VFX worker too. Also it's a category judging who had the best visual effects, not who had the lowest budget. The Creator also had a small budget compared to most blockbusters, but that's not what the category is supposed to be judged upon. Also The Creator literally invented new technology to make the movie, so there were visually new things

    • @big-fish1199
      @big-fish1199 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@お笑いヌーヴェルヴァーグLaghterneuv I liked Godzilla, but it should not have won. It didn't deserve the Oscar

  • @tbrown5836
    @tbrown5836 2 месяца назад

    To me Oppenheimer is this decades Amadeus

  • @jennywhite5531
    @jennywhite5531 8 месяцев назад

    The zone of Interest was my I really really want it to win but don't think it's going to win moment for sound I thought their use of sound was so brilliant and powerful and Innovative in a way that Oppenheimer wasn't plus I just really didn't like Oppenheimer so I was so so so so so so so so so so excited when they won

  • @Miguel-ws9zm
    @Miguel-ws9zm 8 месяцев назад

    I accepted most of the wins, but was bummed about Spider-Man ATSV not winning the Best Animated category. Even though I am a fan of Miyazaki films, I think The Boy and the Heron wasn’t his best and did not deserve the award

  • @Renegade-kf8fp
    @Renegade-kf8fp 8 месяцев назад +2

    Christopher Nolan is a top 5 director of all time

  • @johncra8982
    @johncra8982 8 месяцев назад +10

    The Boy and The Heron winning is maybe my favorite Oscars decision of all time, never imagined the Academy could get a category so right, especially when there was such a garbage Hollywood slop alternative with the most mindless tasteless fanbase imaginable also in contention.

    • @ratedwrong
      @ratedwrong 8 месяцев назад +2

      You can criticize Hollywood for being too reliant on established IP, but Across the Spiderverse was a masterpiece of animation. The techniques and creativity utilized in its storytelling are revolutionary.

    • @johncra8982
      @johncra8982 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@ratedwrong that flick was literal pisswater. people who glaze it are on par with the clowns that wanted to see Endgame nominated for Best Picture.

    • @abermen
      @abermen 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@johncra8982you’re entitled to your opinion, of course, but don’t expect any points for being a contrarian grouch (with poor taste). And I say this as someone who enjoyed Boy and the Heron.

    • @johncra8982
      @johncra8982 8 месяцев назад

      @@abermen keep seething ig? 😂

    • @praxton
      @praxton 8 месяцев назад

      @@johncra8982child

  • @pepperminttree
    @pepperminttree 8 месяцев назад +1

    12:27 well elvis didnt win last year...

  • @kencockrell3977
    @kencockrell3977 8 месяцев назад +2

    Emma Stone wasvthe BEST by far. People shouldnt win because of their ethnicity.

  • @xoxo20000
    @xoxo20000 8 месяцев назад +1

    Emma Stone was always winning and Lilly never was. Lilly's whole narrative was that she is Native. Thats not enough for voters to vote for you.
    1. Poor Things was much more loved than KOTFM
    2. Emma gave the better performance

  • @marrmart7690
    @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

    ه 👀 Emma stone oscar wining🏆😍🏆😍
    Amazing and right wining✔😍🏆
    Bella baxter
    Iconic charachter 🏆🏆🏆
    I love how meachel yuo when she open unvilope and close it and say the name...
    Amazing announcement 😍
    I love how she call emma stone name from the golden globe.
    She dont just win oscar for her acting as best actress of the year...
    Her role also win best custume and make up and hairstyle.
    Emma stone as if she win
    Three oscar in same year for her role.
    ( best role..best fashion and make up and hairstyle for bella baxter) 👏👏👏🏆
    But she was out theatre when this two wining.
    Her performance must teach it in acting school.👏🏆👏
    All seance sucide and final table talking..and fantastic dance with marck rafilo and how she be child and how she
    Emma was genuras when she ( share her oscar )
    With lilly gladston.
    But one thing if i can change it in the show
    Is ( emma stone ) dress.
    Her dress elegent but so tall she can not walk in in.
    And uncomfortable...and break her dress in the end.
    I was hope she wear princess dress.
    Becase this amazing performance film and secend wining of oscar...desearve diffrent dress.
    - paul jiamatii
    Losing
    Broke my heat💔💔💔
    I was want to watch prenden fraser give paul jiamatti the trophy.
    The audiance and the critics and the voters
    Love cillian marphy for oppnhimer becase the role more important historically and big famous film of the year and piopic.
    But i still think paul jiamatii
    Was the best.
    All category of acting
    Waaas right 👍
    Lilly desearve to win but emma stone she desearve it same.
    Robert downy j and davine joy randolph 👍👍👍
    The only category iam not with
    Cillian marphy wining but i axpect it.
    I love the soooong😍😍😍
    Sad song and dancing song same i just kain💖💖💖😄😄😄😄
    But i dont how the show be soooo funy all the time
    I watch emma stone face when jimmy all the time make all category funny.
    I love sandra huller and carry mouligan dress ♥😍♥
    I love past winers 😍😍😍
    I wish all time watch this thing happend.
    But i want to watch
    Clip not just pic... in acting category.
    Clip make it sooo exiting.
    I dont like they announce best supporting acting
    Earlly in the show.
    And bad happy music when they call names.
    I feel music for broadway not for oscar winers.
    I like beatfull wommen wear red 💖💖💖 she give trophy
    What a beatfull wommen.
    I like
    Emma stone and her hausppend ♥❤
    And how lovly
    colmin domingo was with his ( gay ) partner.
    This first time i watch gay cuple support partner as nomnise in oscar.
    Thank you brian 😍💛😍
    You the first one and in early time
    You beleave on
    Emma stone and davine joy randolf and robert downy j
    As the best
    And they get oscar 👏👏👏
    You know earlly they will get oscar before awards seasion
    You was right 👏👏👏😍💛😄

  • @DrR0BERT
    @DrR0BERT 8 месяцев назад

    So I finally watched Poor Things based on your enthusiasm towards Emma Stone. I hate to say it, but Emma Stone is about the only thing in that movie I liked. I disliked everything else.

  • @tennman
    @tennman 8 месяцев назад +1

    U are acting like Gladstone has the better performance or in a better movie when the only thing going for her is that she is the first nominee of native American decent. The award should be for performance not race

  • @kadenprows8079
    @kadenprows8079 8 месяцев назад

    I really don't get the hype around The Boy and the Heron. It, alongside Animated Short, is the most disappointing win for me. Spider-Verse did things with animation that even the first movie didn't do, and it's just overall the better movie. Boy and the Heron was nothing special in my opinion.

  • @55555gino
    @55555gino 8 месяцев назад +2

    Kimmel has to go , terrible host.

  • @sa34w
    @sa34w 8 месяцев назад

    Emma stone imo was the worst pick for best actress in her category and did the same kind of acting she got last time.

  • @jennywhite5531
    @jennywhite5531 8 месяцев назад

    You Def didn't have to bring Cody back lolol plz stop

  • @DontStartWithMe.
    @DontStartWithMe. 8 месяцев назад

    You seem nice but why do you care so much. They are all millionaires and they don’t need all this fawning over them. They are just people

  • @kristineh1601
    @kristineh1601 8 месяцев назад

    I should ALWAYS be about who was the best, NEVER about narrative/race/past performances. We have got to stop with “this feels like a step backward” nonsense.

  • @myytchanneldinakoha8498
    @myytchanneldinakoha8498 8 месяцев назад

    Brian, Luke Hearfield is a better guest, with better insight.

  • @wheretheyhaveribs55
    @wheretheyhaveribs55 8 месяцев назад

    Stop talking about diversity. So annoying. It's about best performance. That is why it's best actress. Not best diversity, best race, best narrative.... Cody is insufferable

  • @jalex3645
    @jalex3645 8 месяцев назад

    BS

  • @mohitrawat5225
    @mohitrawat5225 8 месяцев назад +2

    Merit won over diversity quota uh uh Lily Gladstone
    RIP Wokeism 😂😂😂😂

    • @marrmart7690
      @marrmart7690 8 месяцев назад

      That answer peaple was need to know
      Academy give merit

    • @countfosco1
      @countfosco1 8 месяцев назад

      @mohitrawat5225 Translation: only a white person wins fair and square, but when a non-white or non-Anglo wins, it's not merited but based on diversity. There are better ways to argue for Emma stone's win. Your sad racist drivel isn't one of them, and Stone would be the first to agree.

  • @pophector
    @pophector 8 месяцев назад +1

    Yay at Cody being part of the retrospective videos. Rowe-Derricks 2024 cinematic ticket 🎟 Fun awards season to follow and ready to go back on past time machines now. Great coverage on the whole ❤