The BEST Text to Speech Software | This is WILD

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 сен 2024
  • Guys, I think I finally found my favorite text to speech software! Descript Overdub turns your own voice in AI generated text to speech! In this video, you'll see how Descript Overdub works, and why I think it's the best text to speech software I've found.
    If you want to try Descript Overdub for yourself, click here: get.descript.c...
    If you want to see my Synthesia Custom Avatar, you can see it here! • I got DEEPFAKED! | Syn...
    Visit www.jennjager.com to learn more.
    Shop My Gear!
    Camera: amzn.to/330jcFP
    Lights: amzn.to/2G5Ztvm
    Microphone: amzn.to/30kyeFc
    Headphones: amzn.to/2RQhOPF
    Music Library: bit.ly/3raqXTU
    For event bookings, sponsorships or collaborations email fan@myvideo101.com
    For professional video production services, visit www.plumproduct...
    Follow me on Instagram @jennjagervideo
    Follow me on Facebook: / myvideo101
    When you purchase products through links on my page, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you.

Комментарии • 363

  • @JennJager
    @JennJager  Год назад +19

    If you want to see my Synthesia Custom Avatar, you can see it here! ruclips.net/video/9YrYF0wpisg/видео.html

    • @rogueFactor
      @rogueFactor Год назад

      it seems like that initial exclamation point made your entire overdub sound like you were frustrated at the listener. haha. but it's still pretty automagical

    • @MySperrytop
      @MySperrytop Год назад

      Hi Jenn, thanks for sharing. I immediately heard the difference between your real voice and the A.I. from the first clip. It was a bit too fast the way it read the sentences and maybe if there was a way to control the speed of the voice would make it much more accurate. What do you think? As we know naturally when we speak, speed, pitch and tone make a huge difference how your speech is perceived.

    • @charlesneely
      @charlesneely Год назад

      What are you worried about this is how it is in the world deal with it

    • @weareunstoppable935
      @weareunstoppable935 Год назад

      Do I have to use my own voice or can I use AI(not copy of my voice) and still get monetized?

  • @jefflordan
    @jefflordan Год назад +55

    I can hear a big difference in the timbre of the voice as if they were recorded in different environments. As far as telling whether it was you or not is another story. That is quite amazing.

  • @TheGeneticHouse
    @TheGeneticHouse Год назад +9

    I am legally blind and cannot use the text editor in descript at all. The overdub is so amazing I will spend an extra hour going to a text editor copying pasting into descript until it gets to be correct lol

  • @Odaddysnow
    @Odaddysnow Год назад +4

    Descript is fantastic! My wife thought I was talking live through a whole script! She thought it was pretty scary!

  • @mccleish
    @mccleish Год назад +12

    We are certainly living in the future! If you didn't tell me this was being overdubbed by Descript I would have totally believed everything was you. This is the thing about technology, it keeps getting incrementally better and as time progresses it seems like magic. I await to see the full AI version of you in the next video!

  • @thedvguy
    @thedvguy Год назад +5

    This is very cool! I'm a filmmaker. We do a thing called ADR, where we bring the actor in to overdub their voice when there's too much background noise on location, or for some other reason the audio recorded on set doesn't work. This could save a lot of time and $$$. Thanks for sharing!

    • @MrOscar5690
      @MrOscar5690 Год назад +3

      be careful using this for that service, last thing you'd want is for them to own at least in part, the voices in your film... Seek a commercial license instead

  • @aslynnmoore8601
    @aslynnmoore8601 Год назад +1

    I can definitely tell when it is you speaking and when it was the program. It sounds like the same person speaking either way, but you speaking sounds enthusiastic and the program sounds stern. It wouldn't matter for a short overdub of a segment, but you wouldn't want to use it for the whole presentation. At least until they add some emotional markup to it.

  • @coloradodayhiker
    @coloradodayhiker Год назад +14

    A couple of things that I have noticed with several of the Ai text to speech programs is that they speak to fast so trying to get them to slow down can be a bit of a problem, and also trying to convey emotions can be impossible to do. But given time these text to speech programs will only get way much better.

    • @edstar83
      @edstar83 Год назад

      How much better?
      ruclips.net/video/MT_u9Rurrqg/видео.html

  • @tallboarder
    @tallboarder Год назад +1

    @jennjager Descript Overdub does a correct American speech pattern with a flat or downward inflection at the end of the sentence indicating it's a statement. The upward inflection is reserved for a question. The reason you hear it differently is because your speech patterns fall into the uptalk/upspeak with the upward inflection at the end of a definitive statement sentence. If you pay attention and by eliminating the uptalk/upspeak and record it again then the Overdub will make a better match. You can search the topic of uptalk/upspeak in RUclips you'll find many videos explaining why it should be corrected. All the best.

  • @danielmonge2318
    @danielmonge2318 Год назад +2

    Your inflection is sweeter and somewhat not too confident (sometimes it sounds like you're asking a question when you are actually making an affirmation) while the AI is more authoritative and assertive. It almost sounds as if you are angry. lol It's the 5% that breaks the magic, but it's almost there. Very fun stuff.

  • @joahanmarks8560
    @joahanmarks8560 Год назад +2

    Awesome! That is absolutely your voice. I was at another window just hearing your video and at first I didn't even noticed it was the TTS that said "Let's hear what this voice sounds like".
    I'm hoping they include this feature in Brazilian Portuguese, they are already transcribing to my language, would be awesome to have my own voice in my native language!

  • @attilazimler1614
    @attilazimler1614 Год назад +1

    the replacement over the corrected audio sounds angrier than the context.

  • @dfxdfx5368
    @dfxdfx5368 Год назад +11

    The A I. voice sounds more aggressive than yours. You are right about the app not being very simple to navigate in. I tried it a week ago, I wanted to generate a voice (not mine) but I didn't manage to do that. I wrote my piece and no sound came out of it.

  • @murukeshj
    @murukeshj Год назад +115

    I just imagine how dangerous this is. What would happen if someone trains the model with the voice of a politician/leader or any other popular personality. Then create some content that would trigger political unrest among public /communities

    • @fkxfkx
      @fkxfkx Год назад

      We don’t give a fuck anymore what they say due to the excessive lying and misinformation they spew.
      What does matter what ai is made to say as fake speech?
      It won’t be any worse than what the say already

    • @studio85amsterdam
      @studio85amsterdam Год назад +7

      Its also possible to immitate video with deep fake.

    • @slavsh
      @slavsh Год назад +16

      I am pretty sure it is happening now anyway with similar software!

    • @goodgame3374
      @goodgame3374 Год назад +1

      It is a real issue that we are likely to see soon. There will also then be people denying they said things.
      It will have a negative impact because people already fall for easily debunked misinformation on things like vaccines, so it's only a matter of time before fringe groups pick it up.

    • @murukeshj
      @murukeshj Год назад +1

      @@goodgame3374 very true

  • @ProAdvicez
    @ProAdvicez 6 месяцев назад

    Great video, it was really insightful, keep them coming.....

  • @cut--
    @cut-- Год назад

    wow! I've recently been diagnosed with a carcinoma tumor on my vocal cords. I'm going to radiation treatment but I'd love to have my voice recorded/sampled so that in case I lose my voice completely I can use future tech to talk to people! thank you!

  • @xtomvideo
    @xtomvideo Год назад +3

    Still sounds robotic but who knows how this will sound in the future with further ai developments.

  • @therelaxation_channel
    @therelaxation_channel Год назад

    I agree. Just from the time i've listened to you, the generated version is just a little flat..almost slightly mechanical compared to your actual voice. But i think that me watching this video beforehand probably accenuated it more in my mind. You could likely do any video you have, not let the person ever have seen your content, and they wouldn't notice anything.

  • @KING-pl3jg
    @KING-pl3jg Год назад +1

    Pretty wild stuff, I ran into your video when I found out that the voice of Darth Vader in Obi-Wan Kenobi was not James Earl Jones, it was all AI. Great video explaining this process.

  • @StefanFuhrmann
    @StefanFuhrmann Год назад

    I really love the way the human Jenn speaks and explains. For me there is no real personality, no enthusiasm in the generated voice.

    • @claudioagmfilho
      @claudioagmfilho Год назад +1

      🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷👏🏻, Such a nice option isn't it!

  • @kathybirkett7986
    @kathybirkett7986 Год назад

    Maybe it's because I was an audio engineer, but I could tell right away. That inflection is part of your personality coming through when you talk, and the software doesn't match it at all. However, for short mistake replacements, it would likely be fine. I wouldn't use it for a long project, though.
    Interesting software and testing! Thanks for sharing.

  • @mrdonsmith
    @mrdonsmith Год назад +12

    It occurs to me that people who face a change in their voice, such as those who have throat cancer or famous actors who want to continue doing voiceovers after age changes their voice, would benefit by establishing their voice in this app early in life. If it's acceptable, think of creating podcasts with only a script. There's one possible catch, though; for years, we've been able to type text and have the computer read it back in its own voice, but there are words the computer will not pronounce correctly. Usually, there's a technique to add marks and commands to force the correct pronunciation of difficult words and my question here is to ask if there's a way to change the pronunciation of a word. Thanks, Jenn. A great review as always. I want it!

  • @rickard.eriksson
    @rickard.eriksson Год назад +16

    I compressed the descript audio, and EQ a bit. So the amplitude is bigger, and its sounds more organic.

    • @sumdomguoy548
      @sumdomguoy548 Год назад +1

      How do you do that?

    • @stratinolampino
      @stratinolampino Год назад

      @@sumdomguoy548 I tried it using GarageBand. It’s mainly used for music but you can use it to compress audio and mess with the Eq

  • @the1andonly
    @the1andonly Год назад +2

    It sounds like your voice, but the inflection is no better than any of those apps. I would definitely not pay $ 24 / month for something like that. Maybe a one time purchase of the app would be reasonable, but this seems like a rip-off to me.

  • @diptiman2008
    @diptiman2008 Год назад

    Jenn..I saw your video first time. I must say that I enjoyed that bubbly voice of yours and the so relatable expressions... its so refreshing. You will do outstandingly well. . You are underrated Dear. I am seeing 140k subs today. Hope the next time I see you will be crossing a million. Rock !!

  • @americatruecrime
    @americatruecrime Год назад +3

    I can immediately tell it's not you speaking (robotic) but it's a so-so stand in as your natural diction is more precise and clear than most. I can see it working best for voices that are a certain quality but may not be close for other voices.

  • @sipandsynoptics
    @sipandsynoptics Год назад

    This is wild! I downloaded descript by mistake and stumbled across this video. But now I'm super excited to use it!! Lol

  • @johnbrewer1430
    @johnbrewer1430 Год назад

    I could hear the slight difference, but that is crazy how good it was.

  • @speakyourmindinEnglish
    @speakyourmindinEnglish Год назад

    I can DEFINITELY hear the difference. The text to speech part sounds a little like you have a cold. But it is pretty close.

  • @CLTGeek
    @CLTGeek Год назад +1

    I can tell the difference. Needs some pacing and inflection tweaks. Not the best TTS I've heard. Not the worst TTS I've heard. Definite progress from 2 years ago.

  • @magu619
    @magu619 3 месяца назад

    Very clever Jenn, indeed! Thank you so much! 🙏🔝🔝🔝

  • @Alianger
    @Alianger Год назад +3

    It sounds like older text to speech I've heard but with (pretty much) your voice, which is cool I guess. Just not a replacement as it still sounds quite robotic, unless manual tweaking is powerful enough without being time consuming.

  • @justicedugbazah3705
    @justicedugbazah3705 Год назад

    Wow superb. I never knew the descript voice was playing. I thought the whole voice was your voice only.

  • @iphris_in_words
    @iphris_in_words Год назад

    This was so cute! I really need to resume going out by myself soon and feel that main character energy.💜

  • @martingrey2231
    @martingrey2231 Год назад

    Experts in what is AI and what is the real person's voice will make millions as trial experts.

  • @5Gburn
    @5Gburn 11 месяцев назад +1

    I heard a *huge* difference between your voice and the Descript program. Firstly, the inflection is...staccato and hard on the first syllable. It also sounds perpetually angry, and I just don't get that vibe from you 😂. If you use the training sentences they provide to train the program on your voice, it might give a much different result.

  • @LegacyCrusaders
    @LegacyCrusaders Год назад

    If you just record a bunch of actual spoken word audio in descript using the in programs recorder or by uploading a file, if you apply your overdub speaker label to the audio, you can then select a few words in a sentence and right click and goto the overdub drop down menu and create a new voice style, then your over dubs using that style should fit in with the audio in that sentence you apply it to better. You also get to keep the style, and if you think your overdubs just sound better with that style just use it instead of the default. I find one of the styles I've made just sounds more natural then the one they sent back to me.

  • @buckycore
    @buckycore Год назад +1

    This tool seems so amazing and fun to use!!!

  • @tangotribu
    @tangotribu Год назад

    Thanks, Jenn for making this video, thank you RUclips for showing it to me! ❤

  • @skyheart125
    @skyheart125 Год назад

    Totally awesome... probably, some future software can even "learn" with more samples given to even analyze inflection , pauses.. etc.

  • @ElvisTranscriber2
    @ElvisTranscriber2 Год назад

    I think it would have gotten much better results if you read that training speech if you aimed to read it with a more perky "let-me-entertain-you" kind of voice rather than a let-me-pronounce-each-word-with crystal-clear enunciation type of voice

  • @asociacioncolibri
    @asociacioncolibri Год назад +2

    Sounds great, can it also be used with languages ​​other than English?😀

  • @AmazingPhilippines1
    @AmazingPhilippines1 Год назад

    Cool! Watching from the Philippines and just came across your channel. After searching through your video topics, I subscribed, as I appreciate the options and learning experience.

  • @instructionaldesign2023
    @instructionaldesign2023 Год назад +2

    Great review yet again! I agree. Descript is certainly a game changer. I use it quite a lot and it is hard to tell the difference when using the overdub feature. I am looking forward to when the development team overhaul the UI to make it less clunky and more userfriendly. Keep up the good work!

    • @j.goebbels2134
      @j.goebbels2134 Год назад +2

      Not saying simp things like "game changer" would be a game changer at this point.

  • @Big-GVideo
    @Big-GVideo Год назад

    Great idea and video. Ii I were watching a video where this technique has been used I wouldn't be able to tell the difference

  • @orikatz936
    @orikatz936 Год назад +1

    I prefer to use Colbass

  • @zachmartin2957
    @zachmartin2957 Год назад

    great video! Really like the way you interact with the viewer, and was very helpful!

  • @MichelBarbaro
    @MichelBarbaro Год назад

    Wow! That sounds scaring accurate! 😅

  • @MrS-pe6sd
    @MrS-pe6sd Год назад +1

    We’ll look back on this time as the breakthrough for the singularity. Where we really picked up momentum for the end of humanity. It’s been fun, goodbye

  • @AdatheTraveler
    @AdatheTraveler Год назад +1

    Thx for including this amazing product. I wonder if I put a transcript of another language, do I have to record my own voice again in other language?

  • @Chrisgpop
    @Chrisgpop Год назад

    The staccato annunciation is a little much. Would be cool if you could somehow soften the consonants. The AI sounds like you're almost spitting out the consonants.

  • @garryentropy
    @garryentropy Год назад

    sounds real, no uncanny valley effect, how did it match up with the original video clip being a bit shorter

  • @RickPena777
    @RickPena777 Год назад

    ok I'm convinced! Thank you! Great video, I'm scurrrred LOL.

  • @MrS-pe6sd
    @MrS-pe6sd Год назад +1

    We should never believe anything we see or hear again. Unless it’s in person

  • @merlizaserna
    @merlizaserna 6 месяцев назад

    Great work, thanks!

  • @medialex78
    @medialex78 Год назад

    Fascinating technology! Although I was quite disappointed when I read on the company´s website that this service is only availabe in English for now.

  • @tzeffsmainchannel
    @tzeffsmainchannel 9 месяцев назад

    LOL! your thumbnail!! 😂 Poor girl!!🤣

  • @CyberFlask
    @CyberFlask Год назад

    Your voice is amazing! I don't think the AI voice does it justice... Just my opinion

  • @PhetteHollins
    @PhetteHollins Год назад

    Wow. Super impressive & definitely a game changer.

  • @mynaturalperfume828
    @mynaturalperfume828 Год назад

    I think the difference is only noticeable when the original is present for compairison

  • @dt9233
    @dt9233 Год назад +1

    I think this is amazing and have been purchased the pro to work out this program... My problem is how do you make the voice change for the styles for the voice we made ? I'm lost..... Yes the GUI is a bit confusing..

  • @fastheartmartvideos
    @fastheartmartvideos Год назад

    Thanks for this helpful video! "Descript Overdub" does sound really good!

  • @ToddMusgrove79
    @ToddMusgrove79 Год назад

    I heard the difference between your real voice and the AI generated voice but only because I was focused on the sound of your voice, not paying attention to what you were actually saying (if that makes sense). But if you had inserted a clip where else in the video with tell us, I don't think I would have noticed.

  • @BILLTHOMPSON-pp9qk
    @BILLTHOMPSON-pp9qk Год назад +1

    Hi Jenn, you are my favorite for learning. Thanks to you, I have Descript Pro. I have a video that's been published on RUclips. Now I want to use my AI voice to dub over my regular voice on the video, (I keep getting errors). do you have a vid for that? Or reference me to one? Many Thanks. Bill T

  • @consumationist
    @consumationist Год назад

    Excellent video. First time I hear of such a technology.

  • @Alianger
    @Alianger Год назад

    3:20 what's stopping someone from training an AI on your videos and then signing such a form with a recorded message?

  • @XxDarkRaverxX
    @XxDarkRaverxX 8 месяцев назад

    Is there a way to edit the inflection or emphasis of words with this software?

  • @rickdeckardbladerunner2049
    @rickdeckardbladerunner2049 Год назад +1

    Could you create character voices and select them for audiobooks? I can do many voices, so wonder how that would work with this.

  • @Mohamed-430
    @Mohamed-430 Год назад

    You've done an outstanding review of this software. Thank you for sharing

  • @housetopranch
    @housetopranch Год назад +1

    Well, I could certainly tell the difference between your natural speaking cadence and the overdub. As the producer of a sci-fi themed rock-oriented music radio show, I work with AI-generated speech a LOT! My entire cast of the Starfighter Centaur on my program "Zombies of the Stratosphere" is computer generated. The biggest hurdle I have encountered is trying to get the nuance and cadence correct for my crew members. This involves lots of punctuation edits like adding -or eliminating-dashes, commas, quotes, and periods in ways that differ from "normal" script writing meant to be read aloud. Adding prosody cues helps to generate some speech nuances like raised excitement levels, or stupefaction (think-when a cast member's body is inhabited by an alien life force), or even sickness. Most often, in order to rectify the problematic section of the script, I end up rewriting the sentence over and over, or abandoning it entirely to take a different approach. If you watch many RUclips videos critically you can plainly hear that the voice on so many of them, while pleasant, simply says a lot of things in a wonky manner. In addition to proper cadence, appropriate emphasis at key points in the script is EVERYTHING! Even when, like your example, it is in the producer's own AI voice. However, given the rapid progress of AI "art forms" in general I am sure that it will not be too long before your natural looking and sounding avatar can continue making video presentations well into your 60s while still looking young, vibrant and attractive as you are now! To hear my humble efforts using AI-generated speech you can hear my radio program here. My cast comes in at the beginning, about 20 minutes after, 40 after, and at the end: kpov-od.streamguys.us/Zombies%20of%20the%20Stratosphere_stream.mp3

  • @anxietyexpertwahida
    @anxietyexpertwahida Год назад +1

    Thanks for showing this I’m a hypnotherapist and I’ve lost my voice with laryngitis multiple times so it’s now mostly croaky so I’ve delayed creating hypnosis audios. I’m hoping this has natural sounding tones and not robot if i try to use it for recordings or videos 😊

  • @oguzhankarahan1737
    @oguzhankarahan1737 Год назад

    Why the ending is so wild?! If it's the best text to speech software, then where are the SSML tags?

  • @surfrider71
    @surfrider71 Год назад

    that's insane! let's hear what this voice sounds like!

  • @fuzzy-02
    @fuzzy-02 Год назад

    I m looking for a way to build my own using libraries instead of submitting my voice for others to train the model on and send me back the result

  • @real45x63
    @real45x63 Год назад +1

    Thanks for this great video, and you are right about the awful and unintuitive UI 😖 It took me a while even after reading documentation that in order to access the stock voices, I needed to go into writing mode, and from there I could then click on a "Speaker Label" to access the voices. It just wasn't self-explanatory enough.
    But the stock voices are amazing.

  • @ScottSalvi
    @ScottSalvi Год назад

    I don't have a great Overdub voice yet...I want to try to use one of their default voices for my next video just to test... :) Thanks Jenn!

  • @Temas_TAD
    @Temas_TAD Год назад

    How do we know the audio n this video is not the generated voice?

  • @prescriptionlaughter
    @prescriptionlaughter Год назад

    very useful and well explained, thank you!

  • @DavidGS66
    @DavidGS66 6 месяцев назад

    Where I want to delete someone's voice & replace it with text to speech, I'd rather enter length of time of original segment to be deleted rather than use trial & error with a speed slider like Text 2 Speech android app, etc, etc. This is particularly necessary to get a victim voice off of a long crime video.

  • @takis76
    @takis76 Год назад

    At 3:35 when you sent your voice to the AI to be trained, then suddenly your clothes were changed. This is a super AI not only change your voice but and your clothes too. Wow....

  • @tharii314
    @tharii314 Год назад

    7:44 I wAnted to work with, there I noticed some autotuning-like mishap.

  • @hanvour
    @hanvour Год назад

    It did sound like you! Wow!

  • @steves672
    @steves672 Год назад

    Fantastic presenting! Brilliant! 👋

  • @ericsuzuki8966
    @ericsuzuki8966 Год назад

    It's probably less robotic sounding if you use their training scripts. The inflection is way off but that's probably because 10 minutes is the recommended minimum, and that's from the script that was designed to catch all the nuances. 10 minutes from a video recording probably isn't enough time.

  • @Sophocles13
    @Sophocles13 Год назад

    I don't know if I'm more impressed or scared by this...

  • @BodyWellnessHub
    @BodyWellnessHub Год назад +1

    If you want your videos monitized then do not use text to speech. RUclips is demonitizing videos with it.

  • @MrOscar5690
    @MrOscar5690 Год назад +1

    I really dislike billing structure of these services. "its $12/month but we charge for the year." they should advertise what they're going to bill not an irrelevant breakdown. that's like goin to Starbucks and paying $12 for a 12 oz coffee and they "justify" it by breaking it down as its only $1oz. but you'll have to buy a minimum 12 oz, whether you want 12 or not. smh.

  • @chrisbenn
    @chrisbenn 6 месяцев назад +1

    What if you are dyslexic and just want to read text online? Can this program read for you?

    • @michaelmerrifield5914
      @michaelmerrifield5914 Месяц назад +1

      Try speechify

    • @chrisbenn
      @chrisbenn Месяц назад +1

      @@michaelmerrifield5914 Thank you for replying ! :) I already tried that one!

  • @MrVuTrades
    @MrVuTrades 8 месяцев назад

    Great content! Thanks for sharing.

  • @TheGeneticHouse
    @TheGeneticHouse Год назад

    This descript overdub voice TTS is the best thing out there! Truly amazing! But it would have caution Don't like I did try uploading 9 hours of your video for it to train on your voice lol this is still too new and it will just break everything lol Little bits at a time :-)

  • @RealUnveilingShadows
    @RealUnveilingShadows Год назад

    the longer you train your voice on descript the better it is.

  • @halmathikmat
    @halmathikmat Год назад +1

    would you check out this tts REVOICER please?

  • @MovieWorld-id7qd
    @MovieWorld-id7qd Год назад

    How can I solve this? Each time I extract an audio voice in a video and translate it to another audio voice and when I try to put it back to the video it does not match the video any more. Is either the voice is moving faster than the video or the video is moving faster than the voice please how can i make it match to look more real?

  • @ProPetPhotog
    @ProPetPhotog Год назад

    Mind. Blown.wowza. can't wait for next weeks vid.

  • @EBERUFUN44
    @EBERUFUN44 Год назад

    yeah yeah this is a very sophisticated program or application🤠🤠🤠🤠🤠

  • @justjuanamany
    @justjuanamany Год назад

    sorry, but you sound WAAAYYY better than the computer generated version

  • @ferdous_khalifa
    @ferdous_khalifa Год назад

    This is scary and amazing at the same time!

  • @SheetSmarts
    @SheetSmarts Год назад

    Is there a way to add voice inflection?

  • @NichelsWorth
    @NichelsWorth Год назад

    I think I prefer the overdub voice. It seems sexier! 😍

  • @swrandom12
    @swrandom12 Год назад

    can i make it into conversation between 2 people?