1:05 sometimes I forget that Joy is the lead rapper because she's given so many singing lines, but then she hits us with bars like this and I'm reminded of her role lmao
Just to help People to understand why was Yeri added up to the Group (that late, that young and someone who is not the best singer ) : 1. There are now different laws in Korea for underage working People in the Entertaiment industry. At the Age of 15 she would have couldn´t done as mutch of Promotion as she could with 16. So the planned to add her after her 16 birthday. [ It wasn´t even sure until short before the debut if joy would ad up later to the Group or if she would debut with the other 3 members because of her short Training time ] 2. Sm Entertaiment always release either Groups with uneven number of Members (or giant Groups like SJ or EXO). Sm don´t care if they have 4,6 or 8 talents they either cut one of them or add some unready so that all Groups have 5,7 or 9 members that they can have there symetrie formations with one in the front singing and no one is covered. by an other member. 3. Sm wanted to have a third good dancer (2nd lead dancer) in the Group so they added the best dancing Trainee to the Group. (not the oldest, or the best singing or the one with the most overall Talent). So don´t overcriticize that kid pls :)
Here are the reasons why you should stan Red Velvet 1. All of them have an amazing voice 2. They're all beautiful 3. All of them is good when it comes to dancing (especially seulgi) IN SHORT THEY ARE TALENTED😍 SM PICKS THE RIGHT GIRLS😍💖
@베로니카우유로 만들어진 두유 예리 노래 잘하는데 목소리가 얇고 랩 파트를 누군가는 맡아야하니까 적은거고요 예리가 노래 잘하니까 첫번째로 솔로앨범 냈겠죠,,,,ㅎㅎ 스물에게 라이브 보면 음원보다 더 잘해요 예리는 그 어렵다는 글로벌오디션보고 들어온 케이슨데 못하는게 더 이상해죠 ㅎㅎㄹ 그리고 라이브 삑사리 한번 낸다고 조이가 저렇게 쳐다보지 않아요 ㅋㅋㅋ 피카부 라이브한번 보고 오세요
@베로니카우유로 만들어진 두유 그리고 웬디 목 상태 안좋은게 저때가 아니였나봐요 그부분에 대해선 제가 잘못 알고 있나보네요 근데 저때가 최상인지는 웬디본인이 아닌데 어떻게 아세요?? 아무리 덤덤때 목상태 좋았다해도 많은 스케쥴에 고음에 하다보면 목 충분히 지쳐서 한번쯤 실수할수도 있는거죠
I can't hear Yeri going out of tune! Okay, maybe a little, but She hasn't been a trainee long time. She Will learn it! She's still my bias along eith Irene and Joy❤️
![레드벨벳 Red Velvet "행복 Happiness " 라이브 LIVE / 140822[이소라의가요광장]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/c9JNLXzJBzM/mqdefault.jpg)
![레드벨벳 Red Velvet "행복 Happiness " 라이브 LIVE / 140822[이소라의가요광장]](/img/tr.png)
![[슈퍼주니어의 키스더라디오] Red Velvet (레드벨벳) 'Dumb Dumb'](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/R1a-QG-S89I/mqdefault.jpg)
![State of Play | September 24, 2024 [ENGLISH]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fVs0suPHAX8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Velvet - Dumb Dumb, 레드벨벳 - Dumb Dumb [정오의 희망곡 김신영입니다] 20160324](/img/1.gif)
RV = Red Velvet
Real Visuals
Real Voice
😍😍😍
Very true!
Real Vocal
Real dance
G. Seulgi yup trueeee
1:03 she felt so happy when she finished her line.
😂😂😂
pinkvelvet ahahahahahhahahaha
pinkvelvet 😂😂
blackvelvet i
Ikr
Irene's looking at Yeri the same way she used to look at Wendy when Wendy sang her 'shine on me' part during Happiness promotions
Lianna Magsino saw this and noticed how good of a leader Irene is
The leader being a leader
Lianna aaa yeirene
1:20 awwww
솔직히 말해서 슬기 음색 대박좋다..저런음색 취저
진짜 이런게 라이브지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ썡라이브 .... 잘한다잘해 완전 풋풋한 시절이였는데도 잘한다 저렇게 다 썡으로 할줄은 몰랐는뎈ㅋㅋ역시
Someone went out of tune and Joy is not that happy. HAHAHA.
@Linnen Kim When??
@@salinashrestha5177 2:55-2:58 When Wendy went about of the tune, hehe 😅😂
@Flo Uribe Thank you 😊😊
@@salinashrestha5177 You're welcome 😄
Yeri did
2:56 - Our little cutie joy reaction 😭😍🧸😘
새삼 이때도 노래 너무 잘했네
joy definitely knows sth about singing, the look she is giving is like one of those recorder looks when sth goes wrong. You are really cute JOY.
다들 풋풋하다...
그리고 아이스크림케이크 듣기는 진짜 좋지만 부르기는 진짜 어려운 곡인데 다들 가수는 가수네...
1:05 sometimes I forget that Joy is the lead rapper because she's given so many singing lines, but then she hits us with bars like this and I'm reminded of her role lmao
Just to help People to understand why was Yeri added up to the Group (that late, that young and someone who is not the best singer ) :
1. There are now different laws in Korea for underage working People in the Entertaiment industry. At the Age of 15 she would have couldn´t done as mutch of Promotion as she could with 16. So the planned to add her after her 16 birthday.
[ It wasn´t even sure until short before the debut if joy would ad up later to the Group or if she would debut with the other 3 members because of her short Training time ]
2. Sm Entertaiment always release either Groups with uneven number of Members (or giant Groups like SJ or EXO). Sm don´t care if they have 4,6 or 8 talents they either cut one of them or add some unready so that all Groups have 5,7 or 9 members that they can have there symetrie formations with one in the front singing and no one is covered. by an other member.
3. Sm wanted to have a third good dancer (2nd lead dancer) in the Group so they added the best dancing Trainee to the Group. (not the oldest, or the best singing or the one with the most overall Talent).
So don´t overcriticize that kid pls :)
With all due respect, Yeri can sing. It's just that they don't give her enough lines .
@@graceadams5443 True
Also, Jisung of NCT is smaller when he joined NCT and debut. He is only 14 at that time :"
Yeri is in their debut mv tho, in "Happiness" on the first clip, so she was really meant for Red Velvet 💜
Yeri was always meant to be in red velvet, SM just debuted them early so decided to add Yeri later
For some reason, i find it so cute when Joy raps. her lips and cheeks are all that i can see when she raps.
I wish Wendy's and Joy's shirt switch. #HappinesEra
lmao for joy's reaction. wahehehe so cutie even if ur kinda annoyed park sooyoung. 😘😘😘
라이브 진짜 완벽
라라라까지 하네 저게 라이브지ㅠㅠㅠㅠ역시 보통걸그룹이랑은 다르넹 레드벨벳 너무죠타ㅏ♥♥♥
Look at their positions! Irene is the center, the left side of her is 94-line and the right side is maknae line ~ ^v^
I love Joy's judging face to Yeri.
예리ㅠㅠ 저머리색에 양갈래 ㅠㅠ 제일 조아ㅠㅠ 양갈래 세계최고 잘어울려
Here are the reasons why you should stan Red Velvet
1. All of them have an amazing voice
2. They're all beautiful
3. All of them is good when it comes to dancing (especially seulgi)
IN SHORT THEY ARE TALENTED😍
SM PICKS THE RIGHT GIRLS😍💖
This is the first video I watched of RedVelvet. I just love joy's reaction. I'm now a fan of them 😍
Comparing 4th gen rookies to rookie Redvelvet they ate them vocally. Rookie Redvelvet is top tier.
김예림 데뷔 열흘째.... 아가다 증말
They're soooo good,as always^^ Red Velvet fighting! Joy
Suelgi miming Irene's rap is the cutest thing I have ever seen.
야레야레....꼭 소리도 못내는것들이 댓글로 못부른다고 지적하나니깐...★
공감ㅋㅋ실제론 못부르는것들이
꼭 가수 평가질ㅋㅋㅋ
진짜 애기들... 특히 예리는 갓난애기같애 너무 귀요워
이때 예림이 양갈래 너무귀여워ㅠㅠ
와.. 진짜 라이브다 ㄷㄷ 역시 레드벨벳
Joy just was not having it
This just proves that they are dedicated to sing their song into almost perfect live. They are singers with passion so I don't think it's a big deal.
와 .. 이때 예림이 진짜 애기였네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅠㅠ개귀여워ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
open.kakao.com/o/gBdrsBib 레드벨벳을 좋아하신다면? 이 옵챗방에서 신나게 덕질 해주시면 감사해요~
Red velvet's voice and harmony is no joke
Lol Joy is kind of annoyed hahaha don't worry Joy, Yeri will get it some other time maknaes :3
People saying RV someone is out of tune lol. They sing 1000x better than other groups live
웬디는 언제나 웃고있어
고마워요
yeri with pony tail is the cutest thing in the world, what a little sister 😊
Seulgi, my bae
레베럽들 모여라~~~♡♡
cute yeri😂😂 she looks nervous
seulgi looks most enjoyable than other members
How possible is it that they have the visuals, the vocals, the personalities all in one group? Only RED VELVET ❤💛💙💚💜
they all look so soft and cute omg and when joy got annoyed
IRENE is always supporting the others i love my babyface leader
레드벨벳 노래잘부르구 이쁘세요ㅠㅠ
Wendy is so cute ♥
Van VS I love wendy so much
I think Wendy is always enjoys singing on live show like this 💞love my cute bias Wendy ✨✨✨✨
웬디가 아니라 예리가 화음을 못맞추는것 같은데, sm메인보컬들은 전부 꽤 잘하는걸로 알고있는데 여기서 화음으로 한소리 듣고 있을줄 몰랐네;;
예리는 딱 튀는 그런 이쁜 음색인데 저때 화음은 예리 목소리가 아닌것 같아요!! 그렇다고 웬디가 잘못했다는건 아니고 웬디도 사람이니까 한번쯤 실수할수도 있고 화음에서도 웬디는 워낙 높은음을 맡으니까 힘들었을수도 있죠
@베로니카우유로 만들어진 두유 엥 저때 웬디 성대결절로 고생한걸로 알고있어요 아무리 메보라고 해도 한번쯤은 실수할 수 있는거에요,,,ㅎㅎ 그리고 예리도 목소리 자체가 높아서 음 삑사리 잘 안나고 사람들이 잘몰라서 욕하는거지 예리 노래 잘해요
@베로니카우유로 만들어진 두유 한번 틀렸다고 그게 웃긴건 아니죠 ㅎㅎ 그리고 예리를 보는게 아니라 그냥 한줄로 서있으니까 옆에 쳐다본것 같아요
@베로니카우유로 만들어진 두유 예리 노래 잘하는데 목소리가 얇고 랩 파트를 누군가는 맡아야하니까 적은거고요 예리가 노래 잘하니까 첫번째로 솔로앨범 냈겠죠,,,,ㅎㅎ 스물에게 라이브 보면 음원보다 더 잘해요 예리는 그 어렵다는 글로벌오디션보고 들어온 케이슨데 못하는게 더 이상해죠 ㅎㅎㄹ 그리고 라이브 삑사리 한번 낸다고 조이가 저렇게 쳐다보지 않아요 ㅋㅋㅋ 피카부 라이브한번 보고 오세요
@베로니카우유로 만들어진 두유 그리고 웬디 목 상태 안좋은게 저때가 아니였나봐요 그부분에 대해선 제가 잘못 알고 있나보네요 근데 저때가 최상인지는 웬디본인이 아닌데 어떻게 아세요?? 아무리 덤덤때 목상태 좋았다해도 많은 스케쥴에 고음에 하다보면 목 충분히 지쳐서 한번쯤 실수할수도 있는거죠
who is the female dj? shes so pretty @__@
I only noticed today that joy has the habit of bouncing whenever they do dome live recording😂😂 its so adorableeee
Back here in 2019.. They grew up so well 😭😭😭😭😭
Joy is so cute when she knows that someone is out of tune =)))
Joy heard someone out of tune at the end.
Yeri is so cute I can't 🥺😩
Wendy is such a happy 🐶 here while joy is exactly this emoji 😤
Who’s here in 2021???
i want to see irene smile like this again 🥺❤️❤️ and active on instagram :)❤️
Joy's face before the video fades. 😂 Haha
いつも一生懸命に歌うRedVelvet
が好きスルギの声が特に好き
みんな好きだけど！！！！！
Watching Red Velvet performing so perfectly is really a delight😍😍
they all look so young, and smol. they're so cute 😮😮
how many times the chord progression changing but they do it well, wow
역시 레드벨벳♡
joy looks so cute💚
헐....맨투맨 겁나이쁘다.... 웬디 완정 잘어울려ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
I kept coming back here to see Joy’s sassy eyebrows HAHAHAHA
I stan the right group
Yeri looks so cute with her hair
Wendy and Joy are so cute
Wendy on the corner vibing
JOY'S FACE TOWARDS THE END LOOOOL
That blonde hair is so suitable to seulgi. She look so beautiful
I can't hear Yeri going out of tune! Okay, maybe a little, but She hasn't been a trainee long time. She Will learn it! She's still my bias along eith Irene and Joy❤️
joy at 2:57 and 3:00: who the fuc
she could kill somebody with that look lol
OH my joy😂😂😂😂 she looks so so so so so so so sleepy 😂😂😂
Joy slayed it 💜
조이 졸귀다ㅠㅠ
2021 and still love this live
Yeri still looks like a baby heree so cute!😍💜
Red Velvet ~ so good
Yeri is so cute with her cute twin ponytail♥
Joooooy ❤❤❤
RED VELVET queen live performance
I remember when this came out, time flies so fast
who's watching this 2018?
They are so fricking cute i can't freaking do this.
in love with joy's hair color
I really love Seulgi's voice
다여신이야^^
streaming happiness mv and listening to this in the meantime
꺄악!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
and another video where i want joy to switch sweater but now with wendy
Red Velvet for life.. breakfast lunch and dinner
Love yeri😙😙
yeri's voice😂😂😂😂😂
Diwa Fransiska -_-
1:55 cameraman thought that Seulgi was singing xD
Yeri is so beautiful ! ♥ I love her!
Joy ate the CD =)))
Joy sings so well without dancing