To be honest, I'm think Melanie was taken by Icebreaker, because she would have told The People If Icebreaker about her findings and they wouldn't have believed her so she is imprisoned on the Icebreaker
The next episode will be getting much more better along with the train scenes and I will never forget about the train battle scenes in Episode 3, those were the best scenes I've ever watched expect this episode to be honest. But I hope Icebreaker will be appeared for the finale episode.
I agree on your point of view. When i first watched it I felt that sense of filler and nonsense in the ambience. Especially with the letter liana gave to layton. Though, i wanna say that i really liked the episode but in a stand alone kind of way. I think this episode's narrative is kind of meta or self-aware. First, it is an episode that kind of satarizes itself, making fun about the concept of the whole series. And second, it is the fact of "Ouroboros". A cycle that never ends, 'cause those are their revolutions; 1024 cars long.
Also, a bit of a side note, i wish that the third train that has been peeked in the promos isn't releated to wilford industries; i wish it is a train build by survivors and it is being powered by whatever fuel they can find.
@@seandanilromero2488 no it’s icebreaker. There’s no other train that they’ve teased or we’ve seen so far because the only one way Melanie would survive is in that little track scaler. Too small for icebreaker
My opinions: 1: I think the whole dream/coma thing should not have existed in the walls of the show. However, it was pretty goofy to see all the characters with different roles and jobs, like it kinda feels like something a fan fiction would do or just a random dream that someone had of snowpiercer, and it technically is a dream due to Layton. 2: I think the whole bunker thing was not supposed to show Layton causing blood, I think it’s they way his mind conveys and reasonable explanation. Also about the raiders, I believe this is him fabricating the idea of random survivors such as Asher that still have exist, something that would happen at the start of the freeze. 3: the letter, I think Layton knew about it and perhaps Zara had shown him some time after his kid was born. 4: I don’t think icebreaker is arriving, or at the very least not in this season, in the teaser you can see a speeder like convoy which most likely Melanie is in. My theory for where she got it: the people at the research station might of been working on it in some sort of garage before they went Mad, and Melanie finished it. You can see Melanie is asleep of knocked out, so maybe the machine is in auto pilot or a ‘rouge machine’ as in the teaser when I paused you can see it has 2 pointy bits sticking out meaning snowpiercer needs to avoid it whilst saving Melanie, not sure about the fog yet but perhaps it’s some sort of chemical reaction to do with CW7, and in my opinion it sort of looks like spice from Star Wars but it obviously not. Well those are my thoughts thanks for reading until the end :):)
yes, but we must not forget the fact that wilford realizes that a train passed through the tracks, and believes that he is following the trail of the snowpiercer, (that happens in the first episode of the third season) and asks alex if the snowpiercer went through those roads, and alex replies that they didn't go through those tracks.
Well i think that Icebreaker is arriving neither not, i was thinking that, how did the frozen bodies did not appear when they connected in chicago w/big alice? strange..
I said what I said... "Ouroboros" SUCKED. It was out-of-place, weird plot, random, and the writing was just so bad. Isn't Snowpiercer supposed to be a story based in realism? Where is the realism in Season 3? The showwriters buy themselves out with the "bUT iTS a DrEaM, eVerYThIng Can HapPend, No LoGiC, buT bE suRe tO GEt thE DeePer ANd MeaNiNgFul mEsSage, riGht?". They skipped the intro, skipped to even explain what an ouroboros was, which you would have thought, because that was the episode's title. I don't want to see Layton's dreams, Layton should NOT be the main character. He just cries and complains all the time. And everything he's done this season is some form of coping mechanism or what? Wilford is at least honest and understandable, regardless if you agree with his opinions or not. Melanie seems to be clearly alive, which is fun, but now the season 2 ending has lost it's meaning. People change personalities and alliances without a clear explanation. It's time to bring in some new showwriters and stop this train soon. Season 3 has been a disappointment, the quality drop from previous seasons is HUGE. And this was the worst episode of the whole series. I sense derailment, and I don't like it.
I think you are being way, way to harsh. Season 3 has been the best season so far (in my opinion). I will admit, this episode was bad, but can you please just say 1 thing good about this season please thank you
Please, please. You misread me. Season three IS a good season. I enjoy it very much, much more than season 2. I just absolutely hate this episode. I am unsure if you have seen my other six reviews but I have said time and time again that I enjoy this season and enjoy being proved wrong after my "season three bad" video.
My bad my bad. I haven’t watched all of your streams and have only really seen the pre season review, the 1st review, and this one. I completely misunderstood you.
i didnt mind the episode. like how the transformed the train
To be honest, I'm think Melanie was taken by Icebreaker, because she would have told The People If Icebreaker about her findings and they wouldn't have believed her so she is imprisoned on the Icebreaker
The next episode will be getting much more better along with the train scenes and I will never forget about the train battle scenes in Episode 3, those were the best scenes I've ever watched expect this episode to be honest. But I hope Icebreaker will be appeared for the finale episode.
Whats interesting is that wilford seems happy that Melanie is alive
They found the baby under a pool table.They didn’t know if his name was Our Rob or Ross. Who is he?
love the FNAF ambiance , also Mafia Boss Wilofrd , btw there is a new train thingy only an engine
I agree on your point of view. When i first watched it I felt that sense of filler and nonsense in the ambience. Especially with the letter liana gave to layton.
Though, i wanna say that i really liked the episode but in a stand alone kind of way. I think this episode's narrative is kind of meta or self-aware. First, it is an episode that kind of satarizes itself, making fun about the concept of the whole series. And second, it is the fact of "Ouroboros". A cycle that never ends, 'cause those are their revolutions; 1024 cars long.
Also, a bit of a side note, i wish that the third train that has been peeked in the promos isn't releated to wilford industries; i wish it is a train build by survivors and it is being powered by whatever fuel they can find.
How would Melanie have gotten to France from the Rockies? Just saying.
She had to have been saved.
@@HallimarRathlornStudios ooh. By whom though?
@@JG-oc9gc Icebreaker, Maybe.
@@seandanilromero2488 no it’s icebreaker. There’s no other train that they’ve teased or we’ve seen so far because the only one way Melanie would survive is in that little track scaler.
Too small for icebreaker
My opinions:
1: I think the whole dream/coma thing should not have existed in the walls of the show. However, it was pretty goofy to see all the characters with different roles and jobs, like it kinda feels like something a fan fiction would do or just a random dream that someone had of snowpiercer, and it technically is a dream due to Layton.
2: I think the whole bunker thing was not supposed to show Layton causing blood, I think it’s they way his mind conveys and reasonable explanation. Also about the raiders, I believe this is him fabricating the idea of random survivors such as Asher that still have exist, something that would happen at the start of the freeze.
3: the letter, I think Layton knew about it and perhaps Zara had shown him some time after his kid was born.
4: I don’t think icebreaker is arriving, or at the very least not in this season, in the teaser you can see a speeder like convoy which most likely Melanie is in. My theory for where she got it: the people at the research station might of been working on it in some sort of garage before they went Mad, and Melanie finished it. You can see Melanie is asleep of knocked out, so maybe the machine is in auto pilot or a ‘rouge machine’ as in the teaser when I paused you can see it has 2 pointy bits sticking out meaning snowpiercer needs to avoid it whilst saving Melanie, not sure about the fog yet but perhaps it’s some sort of chemical reaction to do with CW7, and in my opinion it sort of looks like spice from Star Wars but it obviously not.
Well those are my thoughts thanks for reading until the end :):)
yes, but we must not forget the fact that wilford realizes that a train passed through the tracks, and believes that he is following the trail of the snowpiercer, (that happens in the first episode of the third season) and asks alex if the snowpiercer went through those roads, and alex replies that they didn't go through those tracks.
Well i think that Icebreaker is arriving neither not, i was thinking that, how did the frozen bodies did not appear when they connected in chicago w/big alice? strange..
@@seandanilromero2488 spoiler, Is just a Little snowplow.
Great video
To be honest, I felt like this was a breakout episode for Layton, but they kind of broke the rule of Sean Bean not dying
Since it was a hallucination and not the main story, i guess we (and he probably) can let this pass.
Hallimar how did you get the clips early before the episodes came out
What clips?
@@HallimarRathlornStudios on ep 3x04
I disagree. I think there's a lot of foreshadowing. You just have to look for it.
I said what I said...
"Ouroboros" SUCKED. It was out-of-place, weird plot, random, and the writing was just so bad. Isn't Snowpiercer supposed to be a story based in realism? Where is the realism in Season 3? The showwriters buy themselves out with the "bUT iTS a DrEaM, eVerYThIng Can HapPend, No LoGiC, buT bE suRe tO GEt thE DeePer ANd MeaNiNgFul mEsSage, riGht?". They skipped the intro, skipped to even explain what an ouroboros was, which you would have thought, because that was the episode's title. I don't want to see Layton's dreams, Layton should NOT be the main character. He just cries and complains all the time. And everything he's done this season is some form of coping mechanism or what? Wilford is at least honest and understandable, regardless if you agree with his opinions or not. Melanie seems to be clearly alive, which is fun, but now the season 2 ending has lost it's meaning. People change personalities and alliances without a clear explanation. It's time to bring in some new showwriters and stop this train soon. Season 3 has been a disappointment, the quality drop from previous seasons is HUGE. And this was the worst episode of the whole series.
I sense derailment, and I don't like it.
I think you are being way, way to harsh. Season 3 has been the best season so far (in my opinion). I will admit, this episode was bad, but can you please just say 1 thing good about this season please thank you
Please, please. You misread me. Season three IS a good season. I enjoy it very much, much more than season 2. I just absolutely hate this episode. I am unsure if you have seen my other six reviews but I have said time and time again that I enjoy this season and enjoy being proved wrong after my "season three bad" video.
My bad my bad. I haven’t watched all of your streams and have only really seen the pre season review, the 1st review, and this one. I completely misunderstood you.
The only good part of this episode was the last 45 seconds, what a waste of my time
There’s 10 precious episodes to work with and they wasted it on this?