Willow Hemmings Ok so usually the club is me and my friends at school but we could start our own youtube 5sosclub We could talk through the comments and maybe we could make a new video about 5sos once a week and the video could be on the same topic as others in the club
MichaelWantsAnotherSlice it was Ash and Calum if you watch the music video it’ll cut to Ash at that part, and most live videos do too, but I get where you’re coming from cuz Ash does sound a lot like Luke
Q&A questions: 1. have you been to a 5sos concert? If yes, how was it? 2. Feelings on Luke and Michaels long hair? 3. What is your favorite album (by any band/artist)? (p.s. I love your vids💕)
1. i think is Luke (correction : Mickael) 2. i think is Calum (correction : Luke) 2i'm sure is Ashton (good) 2 pt 3. Calum 2 pt! 4. Luke. 2pt! 5.Ashton. 2pt ! 6.for sure sure sure is Ashton! 2pt! (i'm so strong , my gosh) 7. Calum? 2pt! 8. Luke or Mick? i think is Mickael. 2 pt! 12 points! /16 points. it's good
Got all of them right haha. Still don't understand how people are getting 3 and 6 mixed up, like it's definitely Ashton, Luke has a very different voice in my opinion :)
i got all of them im surprised i mean i listen to them every day but ashton and calum sound so much alike its crazy im so happy that they are back on tour thought it makes me so happy i was screaming
whitewolfvideos Don't worry, I'm pretty sure a lot of people were surprised at what they got 😂 and I'm really glad as well since hopefully it means 5SOS 3 is on its way!
I got all of these right not just because i’m familiar with the way their voices sound but also because of heard these songs so many times that i’ve memorised whose parts are whose... I need a life lmao
-Casually waits for the singing to start- I know their voices pretty well =) I CAN MEMORIZE THEIR VOICES LIKE JIORENF I LISTEN TO THEM TOO MUCH EKJVBVJHGF
How to (sort of) tell Luke and Ashton apart: - Ashton's voice is slightly brigther, not as bright as Calums but still brighter - I've never heard Ashton sing low notes but we've heard Luke sing them so if it's a lower notes it's almost guaranteed to be Luke - Ashton has a very specific diction when it comes to certain words, it reminds of an American accent eg. Just Saying when he said, "I got my own place."
OMG I actually got them all right :P totally checking your channel for more videos. 5 I went for Michael but then I changed my mind in the count down and went for Luke instead :P
I got them all right, this was super easy for me because I can very easily recognise people’s voices, so in bands I can very easily tell who’s singing which part lmao
If you wan a get really technical here 3 is Ashton and Calum at on point, 4 is Calum and Alex Gaskarth and 6 is Ashton with Luke AMD Michael in the back maybe even Calum too
3 is ash you can tell the difference between the luke and ash's voices and then with 6 that is ash because when he sings live it is him who sings that whether it looks like luke sings it in the music video or not
i got 8/8 right , how do people mix up ashton for luke in Just Saying ? if you listen to it a couple times , you’d know it’s ashton. nd i think ashton’s voice has a lil more pitch than lukes , it’s so easy to tell them apart
Okay so number 6 for a split second I thought it was Luke, until I remembered that usually Ashton sings the last parts to a lot of there songs. I had to listen a little closer to 6 but I got all of them right though 😊💜I love all of their voices lol
Mone B Aw thank you. There was no need for me to be rude, it was a simple little thing she got wrong, everyone has those days even me 😂 but thank you! 💖
only ever heard maybe a couple songs (probably singles) but watched a few acoustic performances out of curiosity... got them all right except i thought the first ashton was calum (idk why) but i think i mostly just guessed the order right haha
Jaye Fenton if you got them all right can you tell me what song is at 6:15 I really want to know cuz I think that's the only song that I haven't heard by them
12/16 I feel like both of Ashtons were trick questions. on the Good Girls one, he was the high part but not the low part (I thought it was talking about the low part so I said Calum) and I’ve never even heard that first one...
![Finish the Lyrics [5 Seconds of Summer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/okD8OelGwlg/mqdefault.jpg)
OMG A COOL RUclipsR PINNED MY COMMENT
IM SO HAPPY
ALSO IF THIS GETS PINNED TOO I WANT THE WORLD TO KNOW
I LOVE LUKE HEMMINGS
I'm not cool 😂 but thank you. I also love Luke Hemmings 💙
australian unicorn I love him tooo, I named my penguin after him🐧🐧🐧🐧🐧🐧I love penguins
Willow Hemmings
Same umm
Since you like 5sos so much would you like to join my 5sos fanclub
OMg yas yas yas yas yas
Willow Hemmings
Ok so usually the club is me and my friends at school but we could start our own youtube 5sosclub
We could talk through the comments and maybe we could make a new video about 5sos once a week and the video could be on the same topic as others in the club
Calum and Michael’s voices are so easy to determine 😂♥️
Annalicia Urtiaga Luke's too tbh
lol yea
True Luke and ashtons are simalr
Ikr
yeah 😂😂
When the drummer sings everyone just shuts up.... I LOVE ASHTON *Giggles like the fangirl that I am*
Elena Salinas my best friend’s a Ashton girl! 💖
IDK if I'm an Ash girl of a Calum girl.... THEYRE JUST SO FREAKIN CUTE
Elena Salinas Gla. (Giggle like Ashton)
I'm definitely an ashton fangirl, i just love him
same tho 😭
Ashton and Luke have the sameeee voice lol
I AGREE
Ashton has a wider vocal range
Ikr?? Every time their part comes I’m like “this is either luke or ashton”😂
right?
Yeet _ bro sometimes yes
10/16
THEY ALL SOUND THE SAME ESPECIALLY LUKE AND ASHTON OMG
Katie THEY SOUND NOTHING ALIKE
Raven misses dan and phil ! AGREED I GOT 16/16
Katie they Sound nothing alike
Ravenous very much agree
Ikr omggg
Why don't do "Guess who tweeted that" challenge
YES
I need 5sos 3 so bad
5 Seconds Of Violet ME! 😂 I'm freaking praying for this shit! 🙏🏻 😂
5 Seconds Of Violet same 😭
same
5 Seconds Of Violet same.
5 Seconds Of Violet sammmeee. But for real if you wanna trip me up play San Francisco like I can't distinguish any of them
8 right... how can people not know Ashton's voice??? 3 and 6 are clearly Ash
sophie landers OMG SOMEONE FINALLY SAID IT! PREACH! 🙏🏻
sophie landers that's what I though bahaha, Ash has a very distinct voice :))
I actually didn't know Ashton's voice... each time I thought it was Luke... so I got only the Ashton ones wrong
sophie landers I know right
i missed 6 bc i was like "that's either micheal or ash.... I'm going with michael" and i was wrong
I have listened to each of their songs hundreds of times and I know the words to ALL of them help me I got all of these right
Looks like you have a case of fan girlitis...ok that didn't work the way I wanted it to...😂 💙
Different Account Fangirlitis is contagious. I have it too. Lol.
Same!
same ill be in class and ill start humming their songs
i'll ;-;
i got them all except Just Saying... I THOUGHT IT WAS LUKE
me too, I could have sworn it was luke, and I'm still not convinced that it is ash
It's definitely ash xD Ashton has a very distinctive voice and it's very different to Lukes 😊
Yeah, that is definitely Ashton's voice
Lol
Same.
They literally all have such distinct voices 😂
A lot of people are saying that number 3 and 6 are both Luke when they are clearly Ashton 😂
Different Account HOW DO THEY NOT KNOW ITS ASHTON?!?!?!
Different Account if you can't tell that you aren't a 5soser😂❤️❤️❤️
5SOSFam no one is a 5soser
Ok I swear 6 is Luke and the back voice was ash
MichaelWantsAnotherSlice it was Ash and Calum if you watch the music video it’ll cut to Ash at that part, and most live videos do too, but I get where you’re coming from cuz Ash does sound a lot like Luke
#1 THATS MICHAEL???? ALL THIS YEAR'S I THOUGHT IT WAS LUKE ?!!!!
Same I feel bad
In like 3 seconds of the music clip I got it. I need a life 😂
Kiana Richards Why is this me? 😂 I'm the freaking same! 💖
Same
i can't tell if it's bad and i have an obsession because i knew all these or if it's a good obsession 😂
I'd say good obsession 😂
Within 1 second of Dont stop I was like "MICHAELLLLLL"
got all right should I be worried
Ashwin Clifford nope, girl we're all like that 😂👌🏻💖
Ashwin Clifford nah
Ashwin Clifford Haha, same.
No, also I love your profile
ARMYY
Q&A questions:
1. have you been to a 5sos concert? If yes, how was it?
2. Feelings on Luke and Michaels long hair?
3. What is your favorite album (by any band/artist)?
(p.s. I love your vids💕)
1. i think is Luke (correction : Mickael)
2. i think is Calum (correction : Luke)
2i'm sure is Ashton (good) 2 pt
3. Calum 2 pt!
4. Luke. 2pt!
5.Ashton. 2pt !
6.for sure sure sure is Ashton! 2pt!
(i'm so strong , my gosh)
7. Calum? 2pt!
8. Luke or Mick? i think is Mickael. 2 pt!
12 points! /16 points. it's good
At 2:53 there’s no way that’s not luke lmao ever since this son came out I thought it was luke now I feel like a fake fan
IM TRASH I MESSED UP TWICE
You're not trash 😂
Different Account THANK YOU😂❤️
Same I messed up twice cuz I thought Ashton was Luke I'm such an idiot
Katy 5sos SAME LMFAO
Katy 5sos do did I, I never knew what Ashton sounded like
I think your yt name should be...........michaelwantsanotherslice
Lily Stinson that’s really good! I actually might do this!
16/ 16. Total fangirl, I guess. All I listen to.
I always thought that part of Just Saying was Calum whoops 😂
Dani Snot On Fire omg love the username 😂💖👌🏻
Different Account Haha thanks 😂
Got all of them right haha. Still don't understand how people are getting 3 and 6 mixed up, like it's definitely Ashton, Luke has a very different voice in my opinion :)
I could even tell it was Calum saying "you know he lies to you" in Just Sayin
i got all of them im surprised i mean i listen to them every day but ashton and calum sound so much alike its crazy im so happy that they are back on tour thought it makes me so happy i was screaming
whitewolfvideos Don't worry, I'm pretty sure a lot of people were surprised at what they got 😂 and I'm really glad as well since hopefully it means 5SOS 3 is on its way!
i cant wait for 5sos 3 i kinda want to scream 'hurry the hell up guys i have been wait to damn long' at them lol
Me too! 😂 like SGFG came out in 2015! we need 5SOS 3! It's long overdue
You practically have to just know the parts that Ashton sings to be able to tell him and Luke's voices apart😂
I THOUGHT THAT WAS CALUM 😂😂 (Just Saying)
Ducky Dem Gamez OK 😂😂
Same and I thought 6 was luke
Alaska Jay Same!!!!!
Ahh! Are you just saying that or was it on the song just saying
SAME
just found this video and stumbled upon your FAQ. Happy birthday 💕
Hope Out The Window thank you! I really appreciate it! 💞
I don't get how people keep getting Ash and Luke mixed up? Hahaha, they have very different voices in my opinion😂
I got them all right though haha
I got all of these right not just because i’m familiar with the way their voices sound but also because of heard these songs so many times that i’ve memorised whose parts are whose... I need a life lmao
-Casually waits for the singing to start- I know their voices pretty well =) I CAN MEMORIZE THEIR VOICES LIKE JIORENF I LISTEN TO THEM TOO MUCH EKJVBVJHGF
8/8 it’s so easy when you’ve been a fan for about 5 years now
I love your channel and that you put Selena's new song as the background😏
Addisyn Rod thank you girly! 💖 and of course! Only good music on this channel 😏
Well, I got all right and I skipped the 10 seconds to think😂😂
I only messed up at 6 while good girls is one of my favourite songs. KILL MEH
3 and 6 are ASHTON come on peeps. I listen to my 5sos babies on repeat I stg 😂 I know their voices and the lyrics 😂❤️🥰
I got every single one right😂😂
At least we know I’m not a don’t stop😂
If you have been listening to them for as long as me you know who’s voice is who’s when they sing
I read your FAQ and omg, we're litterally like the same person, I love Miniminter, 5SOS and Rihanna too!
OMG! Literally the same 😂 Are you Australian too? 💙
Different Account unfortunately not, I'm British
My grandad is from England if that helps 😂
Different Account its actually crazy, we have things in common you know 😂 but my cousin is married to a kiwi so, so close 😂❤️
That's really true! Sad that im not kiwi 😂
Happy birthday, i stumbled upon this video and i read the information bar
5sosfam thank you! I really appreciate that! 💞
Different account I love you soooo much!!!! PLEASE DO MORE!!!
I love you too girl! Hopefully in the next couple weeks!
Different Account I Also subscribed to your channel. U R so amazing, girl!!
Aw thank you so much, and your amazing for watching and supporting my videos 😊 💖
Great Quiz! Maybe you could do a 5sos crack compilation...
can u do guess who's singing with 5sos duets?
love your videos! x
How to (sort of) tell Luke and Ashton apart:
- Ashton's voice is slightly brigther, not as bright as Calums but still brighter
- I've never heard Ashton sing low notes but we've heard Luke sing them so if it's a lower notes it's almost guaranteed to be Luke
- Ashton has a very specific diction when it comes to certain words, it reminds of an American accent
eg. Just Saying when he said, "I got my own place."
OMG I actually got them all right :P totally checking your channel for more videos.
5 I went for Michael but then I changed my mind in the count down and went for Luke instead :P
My ears aren't trained to Ashton's voice
I got them all right....
I listen to their music too much--- other than 18, and I was very confused when that came on. XDD
Me too 😂 I honestly quite like 18 though ☺️
Aww, tanks fo da like~
So cliche for thanks, I know... But I'd feel bad if I didn't... so I'm sayin' it! :3
Oh, holy moly, who wrote that? *Cringes*
I should have read it over before posting that 'thank you comment'.
I know I’m obsessed when all they have to do is sing one word and I know which one is singing
I got all of them right should I be concerned..?
Anyone else said their names like this
Luke!!Lucas❤️🥰❤️
Cal🥰
Ash😘
Mikey😊
This was so fun I love these tips of videos.❤❤😊
i can literally guess their voices like that but i can barely remember my childhood
I'm into this fandom way too much
16/16 and all guessed before the counter even started
Can you do some guess the 5sos song challenges? I've done all the ones I've found 🥺
Sometimes when I’m on the bus to school I test myself to know if I know there voice
got all of them 😂 ashton and luke sound a lot alike in some songs
No way we have the same birthday!!! 😁 But mine was in 1999😅. HAPPY EARLY BIRTHDAY😆
Christina Lusk Omg that’s awesome! HAPPY EARLY BIRTHDAY TO YOU! 💞
When you’ve been listening to 5sos for so long that you can just tell their voices apart from the first word 16/16
You're so sweet 🥺 i love this account so much ❤️
having been a fan for about a month now, i got one wrong and I'm actually pretty proud of myself
14/16 I missed #3. I thought it was Calum but it was Ashton.
If I didn’t know my babies vocals then I wouldn’t be a true fan
is that i cant even from the neighbourhood?
Valentina Emmert in the background? Nope, it’s Selena Gomez - Fetish 💖
Calum just has a distinct voice I’d know it from anywhere sksksk and for number 3 I genuinely thought it was Luke for the longest time
I sometimes can't determine luke and Ashton
I got them all right, this was super easy for me because I can very easily recognise people’s voices, so in bands I can very easily tell who’s singing which part lmao
If you wan a get really technical here 3 is Ashton and Calum at on point, 4 is Calum and Alex Gaskarth and 6 is Ashton with Luke AMD Michael in the back maybe even Calum too
I got them all right!! NOTHING CAN GO PAST THE 5SOSFAM
12/16 not bad! I get their voices mixed up, it’s hard to define since not listened to most of these songs in a hot minute! 🙈🙈
3 is ash you can tell the difference between the luke and ash's voices and then with 6 that is ash because when he sings live it is him who sings that whether it looks like luke sings it in the music video or not
there are so many on which the voices overlap and they got me hella confused
Everything right... I'll go down with this fandom
Calum’s voice is so soft in #7 omg 🥺
I need 5sos 3 to hear them again
16/16 i love the boys so much Luke and Calum are my favorite by far
i got 8/8 right , how do people mix up ashton for luke in Just Saying ? if you listen to it a couple times , you’d know it’s ashton. nd i think ashton’s voice has a lil more pitch than lukes , it’s so easy to tell them apart
Okay so number 6 for a split second I thought it was Luke, until I remembered that usually Ashton sings the last parts to a lot of there songs. I had to listen a little closer to 6 but I got all of them right though 😊💜I love all of their voices lol
Got them all right and guessed them right at the time of the clip. I've been in the fam for just 2 months.
What is life ?
HOW HHOW HAVE I LIVED MY WHOLE LIFE THINKING THAT MICHAEL WAS #5 BUT IT WAS LUKE!?
number 6 was wrong. It was luke who sang that part. You see it in the music video for Good Girls
No..in the music video it clearly shows ashton singing this part? 😊 Ill link you! ruclips.net/video/0FfG_5JBVBQ/видео.html it's at 2:43
sorry, I was mistaken
That's alright 😊 people get confused and it kinda does sound like Luke just a little bit 💖
Different Account I love ur kindness
Mone B Aw thank you. There was no need for me to be rude, it was a simple little thing she got wrong, everyone has those days even me 😂 but thank you! 💖
I can already Identify it before the timer has started, lol.
16/16 Been a fan since June 2014
Taya T July 2013 here ❤❤ so crazy how much they've grown
only ever heard maybe a couple songs (probably singles) but watched a few acoustic performances out of curiosity... got them all right except i thought the first ashton was calum (idk why) but i think i mostly just guessed the order right haha
is it bad that i knew it just based on the song? like i didn’t really need to hear it ..😗
Don't worry it was the same with me
I got it all right! I'm so proud
Jaye Fenton I'm proud of you too! 💖
Awh thank you! 😝
No worries 😊
Jaye Fenton if you got them all right can you tell me what song is at 6:15 I really want to know cuz I think that's the only song that I haven't heard by them
Reilley Smith Its called everything i didnt say, its such a beautiful song lmaooo
I've been in the fam for 2 month and I knew them all. I. Literally. Have. No. Life
welcome to the fam! i've been a fan for 4 years sooo...lol!
@@sue5208 yay thanks 🎉 lucky you
You should do Muke Cashton ! And just find a totally random 5sos pfp
I kept getting Calum and Ash Confused 🤷♀️ but I got Michael and Luke for the most part except for the last one ☝️!!!
7/8 I thought 5 was Micheal
12/16 I feel like both of Ashtons were trick questions. on the Good Girls one, he was the high part but not the low part (I thought it was talking about the low part so I said Calum) and I’ve never even heard that first one...
YOU KNOW YOU’RE IN TO DEEP WHEN YOU GET 16/16
if you could only eat one food for the rest of your life, what would it be?
I GOT ALL OF THEM
but i’m reading all these comments saying ashtons singing was luke but literally they sound different how can u think that i’m-
12 points. Ashtons voice is hard to determine cuz its so different between songs
I got all of them within a second of hearing their voice I am so pathetic.
I got 16/16. Just Saying almost had me but then I remembered it was Ashton from a lyric video I watched when I first joined the fandom.
I just love the boys so much🤗❤️