Wow..... I guess i saw this coming but probably not to this extent. Calling us Racists seems like a big stretch, but ok. 🤷🏻♂️ Something that I think is being misunderstood is the term "Flat". I think that some people think that we're describing his voice as flat, which is wrong. We are saying Flat as in the musical term for being slightly under the pitch. He is singing a little bit out of tune. This is something that EVERY SINGLE SINGER has done before. Most singers struggle with this, including ourselves, and thats why we use it as a tool to learn from Marcelito. We know Marcelito is capable of singing in tune, he is a PROFESSIONAL SINGER! At the start of the video we say "Good singers sing Flat sometimes", this is because we get a lot of backlash from people thinking we're taking someone down when we're trying to normalize wrong notes. The best singers in the world have off days. I know that this will not change peoples minds about us. We just want to be correctly understood if we are going to receive this much hate.
That compressed falsetto.. No other country except Filipinos can do exceptional things when it comes to music.. We don't have to go to school just to learn how to sing..
Filipinos are self taught when it comes to singing.they will never understand that.i just want to ask these two who is the singer they taught singing? Do they have a famous student in singing?🤣 I don't think they have....
Yes, it's pure gift..I like the way Marcelito sing this song..Maybe you have perfect version of this, but I prefer his version because it's not even easy to sing a duet song (all by himself).. Amazing gifted man..#MarcelitoPomoy ..Proud of you..😘👍👍😘🥰
i've been viewing to many reactions from vocal coaches & singers about marcelito... they are super amazed & impressed...u are the only ones who say he's flat! what are you...SUPER PERFECT hard to please vocalists? Mark my word, this is gonna be the first and last time i would ever view this channel!
Interesting discussion on the flatness. I think he's also holding back a bit of his energy for those booming Bocelli parts, like a runner warming up for a sprint. He sounds gorgeous in both voices, I'm just gobsmacked by his ability to do both of these parts at the same time. Phenomenal.
use of the thang technique, use of vibrato impressive, marcelito sings with a voice head mix, always remains in resonance head mix, always stays between the third and fourth octave, then when he needs power he alternates the male and female head mix for go beyond the fourth octave of a note,I'm impressed because I'm Italian, I've been singing as a tenor for over 38 years.
ive been listening to music for over 40 years and never heard one person doing a duet (males and females) part and make it sound like two different persons singing and doing it that good. every time i hear him sing im in shock and ah because its not normal. its actual unheard of.
That was quite the analysis! I'm trying to sing in the same way Marcelito does. If you didn't know - he hadn't had any voice lessons. I could (and have) listened to him sing all day. I am intrigued by his abilities.
Doing duets by himself alone is what made him famous. 🙃 That’s what sets him apart from all other great singers. You guys saying that you prefer him to sing one part of the song only is like telling him to lose his trademark.
Doing a two character to sing as duet is a masterpiece. Its a hard part. I dont blame some other people are make critiques, id like to here from you as what marcelito did sing, the good way in two character so we can here from you the true or how to sing it right.
He is self taught, never had a lesson in his life . Lived on the streets from an early age as he was abandoned. He sang as its something he loved. He has quite a story if you read up about it.
Please do a cover of this song guys, it might be PERFECT.... and we Pilipinos do the reactin, esp. you melia, This video is all about Marcelito,, dont compare him to any singer. Next time do not do reaction to any Pilipino singer.....
It is my understanding that he learned to sing by hearing others music and mimicking their voice. He grew up on the streets and he used to sing so he wouldn’t feel so alone.
For me, the tone, timbre, ranges, sounds, pitch, and anymore musical terms for the song " The Prayer" - Marcelito Pomoy has done it perfectly, excellently and amazingly beautiful. Period..
Meliafrom where are you ?you probably grew up in America right?So don’t compare yourselves to Marcelito who grew up in the street and did’nt have proper Education like you guys. Can you guys, sing like him?with two voice?
Indeed, those who cannot practice, teach...and those who cannot perform, criticize...and those who cannot act, react. That's true in every field, in every profession, in every career, in every industry, in every art. That's made more manifest & real in this reaction video.
The word you were looking for is “head voice”. And about your comment and preferring that he should sing with someone else, what he is currently doing is actually a traditional singing in the Philippines called “Doble-Kara”. But minus the half-half costume that doble-kara singers wear in the Philippines. So no, he shouldn’t do a duet with someone else just because you’re missing the harmony. He is keeping a style of Filipino singing alive. A cultural thing that isn’t seen often anymore as it was back in the day. Also too much ego attached. Relax a little bit. While staying educational and strict while staying neutral. You’re letting a lot of personal preferences take over a video instead of focusing on the technical and artistic side of things more. Who cares what voice you prefer from Dimash. It’s not a choice, it’s their brand of singing and their art. Not a standard that should or shouldn’t be for you or your students. They are artists. If you want to make this more educational, lose a bit of the ego and yourselves, and more on technical and artistic parts while still letting them be what they are instead of trying to mold artists into your own style or preferences. There’s just too much things about yourselves not enough on the art of singing itself. Just my 2 cents. I’m a nobody. 😊
drfdwf, I agree with you regarding the girl Melia about her EGO. Just because she's a Vocal Coach, she has the audacity to give an unsolicited and degrading comments. And I guess she's also jealous/envy with the Philippines that is full of Singers Locally and Internationally known compared to her compatriots. That's why she's trying tp demean Pilipino Singers. I heard their Duet of Drivers License and in my opinion nothing but mediocre and not even Live, compared to Marcelito on the Wishbus, wherein all singers are doing it Live. Maybe they don't know that the Singer of Drivers License, Olivia Rodrigo, is Half-Filipino.
I have seen a ton of reaction videos on this piece by Marcelito from more experienced senior vocal coaches, and not once did I hear them say about him being flat and all your other critiques.
This is a honest critic people. Hell, I'm a Filipino. That's it. These people are vocal coaches.tThey know their stuff. Respect the critique. That is the purpose of React videos. Mga kababayan... it's not all the time we get praise. These coaches know what they're talking. Thanks for the honest critic. Sana lahat ng mga youtubers ganyan mag critic, di yung puro pauwi! (To all youtubers, like you both, All am wishing is an all unbiased,, honest critic. Not all praise!) Mano po.
This channel is like watching a nurse telling a qualified surgeon how to do his job.😀😀😀😀especially after watching her singing, I will crown her the KARAOKE QUEEN.🙏🏾🙏🏾
I've listened to at least twenty reactions to this cover and a lot of them have been by voice teachers. Amazing how all the others didn't pick up on the things you did. Just amazing......... You do know that english and Italian are not his native tongue, right? And he is trying to sound like Celine Dion. The fact that he can pronounce the vowels just like she does is pretty amazing. He's doing it on purpose. And just so you know, at the end, he's not yawning. The guys behind the scenes were teasing him about his female voice, and at the end, he's "spitting" the female out.
In the first place, nobody taught him how to "sing correctly". He learned it by listening. The mere fact that he did it on his own makes him stand out. You two turn us off. Not finishing this video.
He doesn’t sound flat to me. There are a few times when he seems just a little bit off, especially as he runs out of breath or just before a transition to the other voice. I suspect it’s partly that he’s getting a breath and quickly rearranging his vocal structures. After all, achieving the impossible isn’t easy. I don’t see how it could be done better. This is an extraordinary performance and his voice is gorgeous. I think you agree. I don’t know if you realize it, but there is a Philippine tradition of men singing in two voices, so it’s not strange there. He is singing in two foreign languages, which must add even more difficulty. He is not classically trained, he is self-taught. His little gesture at the end isn’t a yawn, he explained that he was spitting out Celine Dion.
find me a person in this whole universe who can sing that kind of song sitting down better than him in a duet, you win but if you cannot find anyone (CASE CLOSED) MARCELITO WINS
@@coriange123 indeed very well said 😆cant wait them to show us what they got on voice capability and ability😁....honestly,just ashamed though how they reacted on Filipino singers not just Marcelito only they seem too talented on their reactions the fact that they are not known for themselves on the big stage I dont know them in anyways but let just see what they got infront of Simon on AGT 😆
Delia judging in the beginning like a pro, it's 'superflat'🤣🤣 to singing like an amateur because she finally heard he is so perfect and she sounds so ordinary🤣🤣
Melia sang driver's license and there's nothing special about it. They then criticized morrissette's cover of the same song to feel better about their cover
My take to this two is...go and applied in BGT....AGT.. or X-factor ...and let see if any of them be recognized...lets just see how they will be at parbwith others......you two ..try it....we will wait n watch.....give yourself a chance....
explanations and critique are fine and ok, but when that drags on and on for a longer time than the song itself, and when it criticizes song choices (like using celine's style) and even suggesting that he would be better of when not switching voices but doing one voice correctly (at least that is the feeling i got from those comments) it becomes annoying. and even when afterwards saying that it wasn't meant in a bad way and he didn't sing completely bad, that doesn't change much about what i perceived for half an hour in a reaction to a much shorter song. ps: maybe you could technically sing it better, but i don't think that even with two people you could give us the feeling to hear Andrea and Celine.
Your vocal coaching analysis is not what I was hoping for, but rather your amazement and astonishment by his vocal abilities considering he never even had a single vocal lesson.
the "superflat" which you downgraded later on to "minutely audible flats" are due to the style he chose (like the slides and celine-like vowels); and pop singing is different from classical also. Technically you may be right, but the styles he chose for me made him sound better. If he sang it the way you wanted him to sing it, it may turn out "lame" and "ordinary". I hope you get what i mean....sometimes it is about sounding "better" as opposed to sounding "correct". As you said- it is a matter of preference. Peace!
And we can no confuse things: you are singing theacher - you are not si gera. You know how to sing, how to teach and help people to sing. You don't need to perform better than your pupils to teach them and to help them to improve. Well done! Good work!
@@mariecel4096 i dont watch any of their reaction anymore.. hahaha, just came in since i got some notification but, these guys didnt get the kind of stuff Marcelito does, and come to think of it, these guys cant even sing two voices in one.. the way she said her comments is just she is full of herself.
I have seen a couple of them say that he was getting flat towards the end or that he was losing the female tone toward the end which is true. But overall he’s doing something much harder than most other singers doing and he’s fabulous and should be commended for it.
sounds good to the rest of the world, its the talent, skill ability, show me anyone else that can do this, its not the "perfection" thats needed, who cares, he has a good range of voices
Omg...you guys talk more about comparing yourselves to someone who is just self taught .. . while you guys obviously went to school to learn to learn how to sing....HE IS GIFTED. You should just be grateful listening to someone like him...sheesh.
I don't sing. I'm tone deaf. However, as a Pinoy, I expect any singer to start singing a song by emulating the recording, syllable by syllable, tone for tone, pitch for pitch, including the idiosyncracies. Finally, you (@Chase and Melia) understood this version of The Prayer at the 14:40 mark. It's a wonderful feeling when you finally understand where it's coming from. Personally, I haven't heard Marcelito sing his heart out in his own voice. I agree with Melia that Marcelito should sing his heart out in his natural baritone. Again, I don't know music theory, but I agree with Melia about the "super flat" thing. On a side note, one of the most popular female Pinoy concert singers, Pops Fernandez, goes flat on a lot of her live concert songs. Her singing is very emotional. Chase's comment at 23:10 didn't mention it, but in my opinion, Marcelito sings this version at half-voice almost throughout. I agree that he does not push it enough. Also, supposedly, this "party trick" started in the 1920's in the Philippines, and is called "doble cara." It was revived in the 1970s and 1980s lounge acts by gay entertainers, because they can. I learned a lot from your video. More power, guys!
Lol none of you guys know what singing is like then. Singing is super technical and if it’s profession we’re talking about, delivery will always be about AIMING for the perfect pitch. That doesn’t mean you can’t be an amazing singer if you fall flat or over the top sharp. Singers always have off key moments. You might want to check the purpose of this channel again, which is literally for teaching people how to sing.
His story is that he was orphaned at the age of 7ys old, he was living on the street alone. when he was 14 he realized he can sing and by imitating what he hears and saw on tv.
I've watched 50+ Marcelito Pomoy's "the prayer" reaction videos. With vocal coach observation, but you two have the best fare and equal judgement about it, especially with Melia, I'm looking it in positive way. But in the end, Marceleto is the best so far. By the way, I'm from the Philippines. 🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭 Keep it up! and more power to your channel.😊
based on your reaction, analysis and criticism, we challenge you both to sing LIVE "The Prayer". then your viewers will judge if it's as good as Marcelito's version... you're too technically perfectionist that you don't know how to listen and enjoy the talent that he has...
ABSOLUTELY!! Also, they can't sing together, they each have to do the male/female voices, sing in 2 languages, sitting down AND Live. I would love to see that, then we can all compare. Marcelito's talent is God given!
@TIMOTHY CHANDLER people nowadays feels like if they love or keen on something, they are an expert. The fanatics with lots of bias and cannot take criticism. This guys are vocal teachers. They know all the technicality through experience, training and school. I dont know why most people here butthurt when hear criticism. It is a good reflection. I think this trend when people suggest video to make sure others will have the same view as them. At least what we can say that this yoituber is sincere and honest. And not really here to gain sympathy and views, but to educate. I love Marcelito Pomoy rendition of the Prayer but I am just a newb in music. Just an avid good music listener and impressed of people's talent
What do you expect?? They are critics.. if you don't like it you don't have to watch.. and you don't have a good singer to have your opinion on a singer..
@@daisuke910 As you have said theyre the expert why dont they give as sample of singers songs they critisized and show us how the song should have been sung. If theyre really that perfect. Actually theyre doing samples of what they think is not right and they sounded awful than with the singers theyre critisizing. They sounded terrible and more disgusting.
You have finally understood that he is not flat, because he is self-taught, he lived on the street from the age of 7 to 28, abandoned by his family whom he found later thanks to his celebrity... and he learned to sing on his own to eat every day its like that he sings both voices so well which is rare to do, he first sang Céline Dion then Andréa and then he did both with the cool swich ... and this is how a woman spot her in the street and marry her and he has a girl and does america's got talent ect... and is in demand all over the world these days because he has this unique ability to do all the voices he just has to listen to a person sing and then he does the same lol... with his head voice and his chest voice, and sitting down, it's not his embarrassment because necessarily in the street he was singing like that.. . another seated will have a harder time singing lol... here's the info and he comes from the Philippines....
Wow! Do you really know what you’re talking about? I’ve read hundreds of reactions from very good voice teachers and a lot of very very good reactors who are very technical when it comes to music and singing and none have said he is “very, very flat”. Wow! I can’t believe you said that.
Some people seriously is narrow-minded their reaction is much better than evry reactor I've seen. I'm a Filipino and I can't even be mad at their reaction.
Really of all the things to say about MARCELITO POMOY you say a lot of negative comments. Of all the decades of listening to great singers, he is a truly unique singer. Thousands of professional vocal coaches, teachers, and so on have never pointed that he sings flat. They do point out how difficult it is to go from female voice to male voice and it is simply astounding. I could go on and on, but I will say this there are millions of people who appreciate his talent. People admire him, for a man who grew up on the streets of the Philippines, homeless, and penniless. He also taught himself how to sing, with no technical training. My question is who are you? Have you had that much difficulty in your life?
Why do you feel so personally insulted by their comments, which by the way are totally correct. He is in fact flat on some notes, yet that doesn’t make him a bad singer. They are totally amazed by him, yet just point out minor mistakes. Marcelito is a one of a kind talent, yet was a little flat sometimes in this performance (who cares it happens to every great singer). Very childish to question their lives just because they point out some notes, because they never disrespect or not admire him in this particular reaction do they now? As u yourself said: he is a self-taught singer with almost no technical training, so doesn’t it makes sense that he might have some minor ‘mistakes’ here and there?
:@@FrisoJacobs First of all, if one resorts to name-calling who is being 'CHILDISH " . In this open format/arena expect a challenge if you don't agree with a certain commentary. If you think we (the readers) have to sit back and say nothing if one disagrees, you are wrong. Secondly," minor mistakes" as you put it why even bother commenting on it? The things Marcelito has done are amazing. There is one person who did a reaction to Marcelito's video, and she has all the credentials and rights to criticize and all she had to say was positive comments. Everything Macelito has done far outweighs his short commings and that is how I remember Marcelito Pomoy.
Something to keep in mind is Marcelito speaks very little English or Italian. So he will not pronounce things like a native speaker. I wouldn’t interpret him as flat, he is just singing words he doesn’t actually know…. And I think intentionally singing soft at times. Personally, I think he is incredibile and I was extremely impressed.
He is from the Philippines and he is doing English and Italian perfectly. I have to say if you guys can sing in both languages please show us. I would love to see it.
I wouldn’t say he’s doing Italian “perfectly” (I am Italian) but yeah he’s pretty good. And they are not judging his accent, they’re judging his type of singing. I really don’t understand why you guys are getting so touchy over some critique 🤦🏽♀️
here in the philippines is have a lot of singer man or talent like that marcelito pomoy one man have a two voice girl and boy because here in the philippines the hobbies of all people is singing everywhere wherever u want sing
Somehow I knew I was going to hate these peoples reaction after watching them do Morissite. These two who are unknown and with no discernible talent are harsh on those who are relatively well known. At least way more well known than those the react to.
Dont know where you guys get the AUDACITY to react to Marcelito `s cover , after hearing and seeing you singing in your video , his male" and "female" voice is 100 times better than yours.
marcelito pomoy did an excellent job. Almost no one can sing the two different styles at the same time. Bringing up where he is from, the philippines, it definately is a hard life but the Filipinos are some of the most loving people on earth so I can see where he comes by his music as they have it playing night and day there to lift their souls..great job marcelito and God bless you and your people..
Yeah but this video was taken years after he’s already won PGT and has sang many many times on ASAP, showtime tv shows etc…and most artists have a vocal coach already. What you’re saying is just an excuse now. He has the experience, the lessons to better himself. But obviously not all artists are perfect. So what we can say is that Marcilito is a growing artist and learning to master his craft
Like me none of you know Marcelito or what training he has had or hasn’t after PGT. But knowing how much money and time he gives to charitable endeavors I highly doubt he would want to spend excessive amounts to vocal coaches. Why can’t people just enjoy his talent and story without being critical.
I am confused,how these two are finding so called many flaws in his singing,I have watched many reaction videos from real professional vocal coaches,and none of them were this critical and condescending.I will not make the mistake of clicking on this channel again.
Different people will see different things, sometimes some people will see something but not see it as a big enough deal to comment on. Some people try to be overly nice to please viewers. And other people objectively see different things.
I am also confused. I just watched their reactions to Dimash's SOS and Olimpico. They said that he struggled with a note (mid-range for him), his note was flat and almost out of tune, and he ran out of breath. So I decided to check out this one. I feel a little bad that they received a lot of angry comments from both Dimash and MP's fans, but also feel that they might not be knowledgeable enough to evaluate those artists.
I really don't understand how a lot of people in the comment section are hating on this reaction - these two are trained vocal coaches and part of vocal lessons is technique and intonation. Just because other reactors are sometimes too scared to touch on anything "negative" doesn't mean there are not things that can be improved. Being "critical" - which is actually trying to help a person in sounding healthier and more free in order to have endless vocal possibilities - is literally part of their job. And that does not mean that Marcellito is not amazing at what he does. He is an amazing singer who has a beautiful voice. And I didn't get the vibe that any of them thought differently. So thank you for your reaction. I really liked your points of view and your opinions.
When you start by criticizing from the start of the song to the end and you are viewing something you don't see much on earth, you probably think of yourselves so high up there on a pedestal.
How about you two sing the same song and lets compare which one is better. His version (alone) who have no proper training? Or your version, who have a proper training and experience?
It maybe Flat but sounds Amazing to an ordinary guy like me.. 💛He's the Champion of Pilipinas Got Talent before..and he joined America's Got Talent in 2020.
Another comment for Chase, very good observation about his intonation. We're always singing the songs just based on what we're hearing, in this case, Marcelito is just singing his interpretation of how he is hearing how Celine sings the song, and this is actually how he sings the Celine part. He didn't know anything about "flat" or whatnot, he just sings it the way he listens to it sang by Celine...
I'm a music teacher (30 years) and have very good relative pitch. Marcelito is not in tune all of the time, but it is not to the detriment of his performance. Some performers are painful to listen to, as they are sooo out of tune. Marcelito is fine. Listen to his entire performance (and other songs) before trying to 'fix' his intonation.
I have perfect pitch and I agree. Some notes are a little under pitch, but they’re not completely flat or off. IMO his “flatness” (I’d call it more just a bit under pitch at times) is not as flat as Melia makes it seem to be, but that’s my opinion. I am glad though they are sharing their critiques and opinions since many voice teacher reactions to this have no critical substance and they’re just blown, as they should be lol, but still.
He has an accent and barely knows english lol he mimi what he heard and yall teachers create yall own tones. Like Celine Dion has always been flat and sung from her nose.
@@UteNawratil there's 1 billion other videos of reactors/vocal coaches kissing up to their viewers and gloating over this guy's performance. go to those videos instead of whining bc you can't handle hearing criticism.
@@stargrrl__ I think I heard pretty much all of them. And the good ones name the weak points precisely as well as recognize the techniques that are used. And I'm not a fan of Mr. Pomoy, by the way. That's not why I find those two annoying. And looking to the other comments, it seems that I'm not alone.
This was very educational. There are plenty of places to go to watch reactors falling over themselves and gawping. I came here to learn something from trained professionals. And I did. Thank you for this even though you caught so much hate from people shopping for something you weren't ever advertising in the first place :)
Lol! “Most singers having off days..” this performance is far from off. He was outstanding & his voice is out of this world & just beautiful to listen to. Not forgetting that he’s a male!! I’m interested in seeing you doing a cover of this song & then we’ll see🤔
Check their channel, there is a duet on it. 😂😂 From there, i can say that the voice of marcelito doing female voice if far good that this girl saying superflat, 😂😂😂😂
So many people offended in the comments. 😓 I'm a Filipino too, but they're right. _I'm not saying Marcelito is not a good singer. That's also not what Chase and Melia meant._ I personally enjoyed the objective analysis. Hope you guys continue reacting to Filipino artists. 😊
Wow..... I guess i saw this coming but probably not to this extent. Calling us Racists seems like a big stretch, but ok. 🤷🏻♂️
Something that I think is being misunderstood is the term "Flat". I think that some people think that we're describing his voice as flat, which is wrong. We are saying Flat as in the musical term for being slightly under the pitch. He is singing a little bit out of tune. This is something that EVERY SINGLE SINGER has done before. Most singers struggle with this, including ourselves, and thats why we use it as a tool to learn from Marcelito.
We know Marcelito is capable of singing in tune, he is a PROFESSIONAL SINGER! At the start of the video we say "Good singers sing Flat sometimes", this is because we get a lot of backlash from people thinking we're taking someone down when we're trying to normalize wrong notes. The best singers in the world have off days.
I know that this will not change peoples minds about us. We just want to be correctly understood if we are going to receive this much hate.
🤮🤮🤮
That compressed falsetto.. No other country except Filipinos can do exceptional things when it comes to music.. We don't have to go to school just to learn how to sing..
@@ryanisedino9381 Nobody has to go to school to learn how to sing.... 🤦🏻♂️ Who says you do?
LOL..
The only channel that reacts "SUPER FLAT"😊😊😊
Melia WAS SO PERFECT 👏👏👏
Show us what you got
I just wanna say, Marcelito didn't take any vocal lessons. No formal trainings. Pure gift.🇵🇭
Filipinos are self taught when it comes to singing.they will never understand that.i just want to ask these two who is the singer they taught singing? Do they have a famous student in singing?🤣 I don't think they have....
Exactly 💯 %
Yes, it's pure gift..I like the way Marcelito sing this song..Maybe you have perfect version of this, but I prefer his version because it's not even easy to sing a duet song (all by himself).. Amazing gifted man..#MarcelitoPomoy ..Proud of you..😘👍👍😘🥰
@eliewandas5427 just like as the saying goes.. "Unlike singers and poet, teachers are made except the Lord Jesus".
First time hearing a reaction looking for perfection instead of being amaze that a person can sing two voices
Totally agree.
Totally agree!
Plus their own singing is FAR from perfect.
@@erictheman5992 I agree
They talked rubbish they cannot do what marcelito can do
i've been viewing to many reactions from vocal coaches & singers about marcelito... they are super amazed & impressed...u are the only ones who say he's flat! what are you...SUPER PERFECT hard to please vocalists? Mark my word, this is gonna be the first and last time i would ever view this channel!
Interesting discussion on the flatness. I think he's also holding back a bit of his energy for those booming Bocelli parts, like a runner warming up for a sprint. He sounds gorgeous in both voices, I'm just gobsmacked by his ability to do both of these parts at the same time. Phenomenal.
This.
he did the little "yawn" at the end because his producer was kidding him about his "Celine" voice, so he essentially was "spitting her out" lol
Oh my! I've watched many reaction videos to this and by far you two are the most critical! Wont be watching you again.
use of the thang technique, use of vibrato impressive, marcelito sings with a voice head mix, always remains in resonance head mix, always stays between the third and fourth octave, then when he needs power he alternates the male and female head mix for go beyond the fourth octave of a note,I'm impressed because I'm Italian, I've been singing as a tenor for over 38 years.
ive been listening to music for over 40 years and never heard one person doing a duet (males and females) part and make it sound like two different persons singing and doing it that good. every time i hear him sing im in shock and ah because its not normal. its actual unheard of.
That was quite the analysis! I'm trying to sing in the same way Marcelito does. If you didn't know - he hadn't had any voice lessons. I could (and have) listened to him sing all day. I am intrigued by his abilities.
Doing duets by himself alone is what made him famous. 🙃 That’s what sets him apart from all other great singers. You guys saying that you prefer him to sing one part of the song only is like telling him to lose his trademark.
Z
Before u say something let him sing first....
Exactly.
There is ...they can watch all PM videos
Doing a two character to sing as duet is a masterpiece. Its a hard part. I dont blame some other people are make critiques, id like to here from you as what marcelito did sing, the good way in two character so we can here from you the true or how to sing it right.
"Those who can, do. Those who can't, teach."
Waiting you two cover this song...we will see how good you are.
perfect, love the comment . hahaha
He is self taught, never had a lesson in his life . Lived on the streets from an early age as he was abandoned. He sang as its something he loved. He has quite a story if you read up about it.
Please do a cover of this song guys, it might be PERFECT.... and we Pilipinos do the reactin, esp. you melia, This video is all about Marcelito,, dont compare him to any singer. Next time do not do reaction to any Pilipino singer.....
Mabuhay
It is my understanding that he learned to sing by hearing others music and mimicking their voice. He grew up on the streets and he used to sing so he wouldn’t feel so alone.
come on let us here you sing this piece
For me, the tone, timbre, ranges, sounds, pitch, and anymore musical terms for the song " The Prayer" - Marcelito Pomoy has done it perfectly, excellently and amazingly beautiful. Period..
Marcelito wouldn't have known any of the terms they are using to criticise him. He sings what he hears and he does it very, very well.
"Listening to someone singing and looking just for the mistakes then you're not listening at all"
It took 32 minutes to tear apart a guy from P.I. that doesn't speak English and is singing in English and Italian. Good Job!
Lol. I agree! Pathetic.
Meliafrom where are you ?you probably grew up in America right?So don’t compare yourselves to Marcelito who grew up in the street and did’nt have proper Education like you guys. Can you guys, sing like him?with two voice?
Wow you are the first reaction I encountered to tell Marcelino got a flat note on his vowels
Indeed, those who cannot practice, teach...and those who cannot perform, criticize...and those who cannot act, react.
That's true in every field, in every profession, in every career, in every industry, in every art.
That's made more manifest & real in this reaction video.
The word you were looking for is “head voice”.
And about your comment and preferring that he should sing with someone else, what he is currently doing is actually a traditional singing in the Philippines called “Doble-Kara”. But minus the half-half costume that doble-kara singers wear in the Philippines. So no, he shouldn’t do a duet with someone else just because you’re missing the harmony. He is keeping a style of Filipino singing alive. A cultural thing that isn’t seen often anymore as it was back in the day.
Also too much ego attached. Relax a little bit. While staying educational and strict while staying neutral. You’re letting a lot of personal preferences take over a video instead of focusing on the technical and artistic side of things more. Who cares what voice you prefer from Dimash. It’s not a choice, it’s their brand of singing and their art. Not a standard that should or shouldn’t be for you or your students. They are artists. If you want to make this more educational, lose a bit of the ego and yourselves, and more on technical and artistic parts while still letting them be what they are instead of trying to mold artists into your own style or preferences. There’s just too much things about yourselves not enough on the art of singing itself.
Just my 2 cents. I’m a nobody. 😊
Ha! Thanks! We're hope you got something from it! 😊
drfdwf, I agree with you regarding the girl Melia about her EGO. Just because she's a Vocal Coach, she has the audacity to give an unsolicited and degrading comments. And I guess she's also jealous/envy with the Philippines that is full of Singers Locally and Internationally known compared to her compatriots. That's why she's trying tp demean Pilipino Singers. I heard their Duet of Drivers License and in my opinion nothing but mediocre and not even Live, compared to Marcelito on the Wishbus, wherein all singers are doing it Live. Maybe they don't know that the Singer of Drivers License, Olivia Rodrigo, is Half-Filipino.
Well said I definitely agree.
Correct
Preach😂🤣😍
I have seen a ton of reaction videos on this piece by Marcelito from more experienced senior vocal coaches, and not once did I hear them say about him being flat and all your other critiques.
Bobo
For me he is the best singer in world I ever heard...
This is a honest critic people. Hell, I'm a Filipino. That's it. These people are vocal coaches.tThey know their stuff. Respect the critique. That is the purpose of React videos. Mga kababayan... it's not all the time we get praise. These coaches know what they're talking.
Thanks for the honest critic. Sana lahat ng mga youtubers ganyan mag critic, di yung puro pauwi!
(To all youtubers, like you both, All am wishing is an all unbiased,, honest critic. Not all praise!)
Mano po.
This channel is like watching a nurse telling a qualified surgeon how to do his job.😀😀😀😀especially after watching her singing, I will crown her the KARAOKE QUEEN.🙏🏾🙏🏾
🤣🤣🤣
Hahaha!!!! Right!!
Lol chill out man. This is for entertainment. Do you see Simon Cowell being able to sing to judge someone else's singing? Hahaha.
aaaaaAa
🤣🤣🤣
Can you two do a cover of this song? let me see how amazing your techniques based on your critic.
Agree
This girl doesnt' know anything about Pomoy,that he has no formal education,he's self taught.
Oh, i love to hear them sing this.. then we'll compare... 2 against 1 🤪
i saw their video. Some only has 5views..
Agree
Why don't you both sing like the songs Pomoy sings
I've listened to at least twenty reactions to this cover and a lot of them have been by voice teachers. Amazing how all the others didn't pick up on the things you did. Just amazing......... You do know that english and Italian are not his native tongue, right? And he is trying to sound like Celine Dion. The fact that he can pronounce the vowels just like she does is pretty amazing. He's doing it on purpose. And just so you know, at the end, he's not yawning. The guys behind the scenes were teasing him about his female voice, and at the end, he's "spitting" the female out.
You guys could talk under water. You made it all about YOU.
In the first place, nobody taught him how to "sing correctly". He learned it by listening. The mere fact that he did it on his own makes him stand out. You two turn us off. Not finishing this video.
So amazing, heavenly, Brilliant talent...He had no formal training, learned by mimicking sound. Just amazing.
He doesn’t sound flat to me. There are a few times when he seems just a little bit off, especially as he runs out of breath or just before a transition to the other voice. I suspect it’s partly that he’s getting a breath and quickly rearranging his vocal structures. After all, achieving the impossible isn’t easy. I don’t see how it could be done better. This is an extraordinary performance and his voice is gorgeous. I think you agree.
I don’t know if you realize it, but there is a Philippine tradition of men singing in two voices, so it’s not strange there. He is singing in two foreign languages, which must add even more difficulty. He is not classically trained, he is self-taught.
His little gesture at the end isn’t a yawn, he explained that he was spitting out Celine Dion.
Wauwwwww what a comment, please just listen how talented this guy is.......Gods gift....and non vocal lessons, did you?
find me a person in this whole universe who can sing that kind of song sitting down better than him in a duet, you win but if you cannot find anyone (CASE CLOSED)
MARCELITO WINS
Marcelino wins because he has no professional training,...just pure gift,...hope you understand what pure gift is!
If our Marcelito is SUPER FLAT, you guys are SUPER PERFECT! So we want you guys to show us what you've got.✌️
That woman is very ignorant ,shame on you,you are a big joke in music,judo artist.your voice is super SHARP. ha ha ha.😝😝😝😝😝😝😝😝
@@elmerreyes5553 lmao that's a big fact 😭😭
Agree po😁...grabe cla😂
Hope both of you will "stage your next concert" here in the Philippines! Can't wait to hear your angelic voices! 😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡
@@coriange123 indeed very well said 😆cant wait them to show us what they got on voice capability and ability😁....honestly,just ashamed though how they reacted on Filipino singers not just Marcelito only they seem too talented on their reactions the fact that they are not known for themselves on the big stage I dont know them in anyways but let just see what they got infront of Simon on AGT 😆
"he spent alot of time working on it"
Lmao
Delia judging in the beginning like a pro, it's 'superflat'🤣🤣 to singing like an amateur because she finally heard he is so perfect and she sounds so ordinary🤣🤣
He is self taught. His mother abandoned him when he was 7 yrs. old. He had to live on the streets. Lesson to his story. So sad.
People that criticize others are ways to validate their own insecurities and to reaffirm the negative perception they have of themselves.
Melia sang driver's license and there's nothing special about it. They then criticized morrissette's cover of the same song to feel better about their cover
My take to this two is...go and applied in BGT....AGT.. or X-factor ...and let see if any of them be recognized...lets just see how they will be at parbwith others......you two ..try it....we will wait n watch.....give yourself a chance....
explanations and critique are fine and ok, but when that drags on and on for a longer time than the song itself, and when it criticizes song choices (like using celine's style) and even suggesting that he would be better of when not switching voices but doing one voice correctly (at least that is the feeling i got from those comments) it becomes annoying. and even when afterwards saying that it wasn't meant in a bad way and he didn't sing completely bad, that doesn't change much about what i perceived for half an hour in a reaction to a much shorter song. ps: maybe you could technically sing it better, but i don't think that even with two people you could give us the feeling to hear Andrea and Celine.
I agree.
@@Anson_AKB totally agree dude! In short, it's plain and stupid. 🤡🤡
You really have to listen to this with a really good pair of headsets. You can hear some but not all.
Your vocal coaching analysis is not what I was hoping for, but rather your amazement and astonishment by his vocal abilities considering he never even had a single vocal lesson.
this woman is so perfect to the point that she never finished first the song b4 giving her "comments"
Very assuming perfectionish
Indeed. ☺️
Correct!!!
Read my comment because you understand what I’m saying! Listening is a gift! Evidently she doesn’t have that gift!
OH that's why this woman is very well known all over the world.... who is she again?
the "superflat" which you downgraded later on to "minutely audible flats" are due to the style he chose (like the slides and celine-like vowels); and pop singing is different from classical also. Technically you may be right, but the styles he chose for me made him sound better. If he sang it the way you wanted him to sing it, it may turn out "lame" and "ordinary". I hope you get what i mean....sometimes it is about sounding "better" as opposed to sounding "correct". As you said- it is a matter of preference. Peace!
You are absolutely correct. This lady is talking about her style if singing. Period.
Cos shes An idiot🤣😆 she spoke too much before she listen
She's annoying, she's too boastful!
@@chitregis3262 very true
@@Shyragirl80 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
His Exprsssion of this song reaches deep...the soul expression of how he sings this song is better than anyone I have heard before.
And we can no confuse things: you are singing theacher - you are not si gera. You know how to sing, how to teach and help people to sing. You don't need to perform better than your pupils to teach them and to help them to improve. Well done! Good work!
just like as the saying goes.. "Unlike singers and poet, teachers are made except the Lord Jesus".
A lot of reactors and voice teachers reacted to this, and you're the only one who said he is superflat. Lol
She said it was superflat then after a couple of minutes she said it was minutely flat hahaha. 🤣
thats why i stop viewing their channel, i was just curious about their reaction thats why i click it but got disappointed hayyy
I don’t think these people know what they are talking about. Can’t trust what they say. It’s just their questionable opinions.
@@mariecel4096 i dont watch any of their reaction anymore.. hahaha, just came in since i got some notification but, these guys didnt get the kind of stuff Marcelito does, and come to think of it, these guys cant even sing two voices in one.. the way she said her comments is just she is full of herself.
I have seen a couple of them say that he was getting flat towards the end or that he was losing the female tone toward the end which is true. But overall he’s doing something much harder than most other singers doing and he’s fabulous and should be commended for it.
My head is spinning listening to your reaction on Marcelitos performance. That is me reacting to you both Lol
Get a life both of you!!!! He is brilliant!! The best I heard all my life!!
sounds good to the rest of the world, its the talent, skill ability, show me anyone else that can do this, its not the "perfection" thats needed, who cares, he has a good range of voices
We're waiting for your version miss.
I also like when he sang the 'con te partiro' @ America's Got Talent .. Marcelito nailed it.
How often do you send food back to the kitchen at restaurants? That's the vibe I'm getting.
You two are so professional can we hear you two make a cover of this song. I can see that it will be soo good
I love your sarcasm. Yeah, I want to hear them too.
Omg...you guys talk more about comparing yourselves to someone who is just self taught ..
. while you guys obviously went to school to learn to learn how to sing....HE IS GIFTED. You should just be grateful listening to someone like him...sheesh.
TOTALY AGREEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Exactly..they think that every artist singer gone to studied music ,skills n tecnique..
I can switch pretty well to lower than expected as an alto- but yeah, definitely difficult, and I’m nowhere as good as Marcelito.
Don't worry, neither are they.
You two seems like a perfect singers … would you mind singing the same song.. and let's see how good you could be😊
no one said they are perfect yet acted like they were they are just doing what voice teachers do and call out mistakes u bozo
Hahaha boom is that challenge hmmmm...
I don't sing. I'm tone deaf. However, as a Pinoy, I expect any singer to start singing a song by emulating the recording, syllable by syllable, tone for tone, pitch for pitch, including the idiosyncracies. Finally, you (@Chase and Melia) understood this version of The Prayer at the 14:40 mark. It's a wonderful feeling when you finally understand where it's coming from.
Personally, I haven't heard Marcelito sing his heart out in his own voice. I agree with Melia that Marcelito should sing his heart out in his natural baritone. Again, I don't know music theory, but I agree with Melia about the "super flat" thing.
On a side note, one of the most popular female Pinoy concert singers, Pops Fernandez, goes flat on a lot of her live concert songs. Her singing is very emotional.
Chase's comment at 23:10 didn't mention it, but in my opinion, Marcelito sings this version at half-voice almost throughout. I agree that he does not push it enough.
Also, supposedly, this "party trick" started in the 1920's in the Philippines, and is called "doble cara." It was revived in the 1970s and 1980s lounge acts by gay entertainers, because they can.
I learned a lot from your video. More power, guys!
This two is being too perfectionist why dont you just sing and be a famous if you really know how to sing ..
I think this two hate filipino singers. Maybe they listen to sixties song so much that they don't appreciate today's singer.
True those morons like those two is useless for sure
yup FLAT (^-^)....
Lol none of you guys know what singing is like then. Singing is super technical and if it’s profession we’re talking about, delivery will always be about AIMING for the perfect pitch. That doesn’t mean you can’t be an amazing singer if you fall flat or over the top sharp. Singers always have off key moments. You might want to check the purpose of this channel again, which is literally for teaching people how to sing.
True🤣🤣
His story is that he was orphaned at the age of 7ys old, he was living on the street alone. when he was 14 he realized he can sing and by imitating what he hears and saw on tv.
happy here we go again.. history lesson and everybody is not interested.very pinoy attitude lol
I've watched 50+ Marcelito Pomoy's "the prayer" reaction videos. With vocal coach observation, but you two have the best fare and equal judgement about it, especially with Melia, I'm looking it in positive way. But in the end, Marceleto is the best so far. By the way, I'm from the Philippines.
🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭 Keep it up! and more power to your channel.😊
Super flat talent you have guys & Marcelito Pomoy has a Super Brilliant talent that keep blowing up our mind thanks for your opinion
You’re just good in critising him being flat can you do two voices youreself too?
Correct!
based on your reaction, analysis and criticism, we challenge you both to sing LIVE "The Prayer". then your viewers will judge if it's as good as Marcelito's version... you're too technically perfectionist that you don't know how to listen and enjoy the talent that he has...
ABSOLUTELY!! Also, they can't sing together, they each have to do the male/female voices, sing in 2 languages, sitting down AND Live. I would love to see that, then we can all compare. Marcelito's talent is God given!
Big Purrrrr
@TIMOTHY CHANDLER people nowadays feels like if they love or keen on something, they are an expert. The fanatics with lots of bias and cannot take criticism. This guys are vocal teachers. They know all the technicality through experience, training and school. I dont know why most people here butthurt when hear criticism. It is a good reflection.
I think this trend when people suggest video to make sure others will have the same view as them. At least what we can say that this yoituber is sincere and honest. And not really here to gain sympathy and views, but to educate.
I love Marcelito Pomoy rendition of the Prayer but I am just a newb in music. Just an avid good music listener and impressed of people's talent
What do you expect?? They are critics.. if you don't like it you don't have to watch.. and you don't have a good singer to have your opinion on a singer..
@@daisuke910 As you have said theyre the expert why dont they give as sample of singers songs they critisized and show us how the song should have been sung. If theyre really that perfect. Actually theyre doing samples of what they think is not right and they sounded awful than with the singers theyre critisizing. They sounded terrible and more disgusting.
Chase thank you so much for your honest opinion😊
You have finally understood that he is not flat, because he is self-taught, he lived on the street from the age of 7 to 28, abandoned by his family whom he found later thanks to his celebrity... and he learned to sing on his own to eat every day its like that he sings both voices so well which is rare to do, he first sang Céline Dion then Andréa and then he did both with the cool swich ... and this is how a woman spot her in the street and marry her and he has a girl and does america's got talent ect... and is in demand all over the world these days because he has this unique ability to do all the voices he just has to listen to a person sing and then he does the same lol... with his head voice and his chest voice, and sitting down, it's not his embarrassment because necessarily in the street he was singing like that.. . another seated will have a harder time singing lol... here's the info and he comes from the Philippines....
Wow! Do you really know what you’re talking about? I’ve read hundreds of reactions from very good voice teachers and a lot of very very good reactors who are very technical when it comes to music and singing and none have said he is “very, very flat”. Wow! I can’t believe you said that.
They only spoke the truth. And that might hurt.
@@ErgoDog And how did you know its true are you also a perfect teacher/vocal coach like them ogag?
@@gamulolauro9648 you guys are so triggered it is hilarious. If u can't hear some of the stuff they pointed out u might be delusional.
@@ErgoDog truth! ur not even a coach! lol ur nobody!
@@mephistomorningstar9049 ass
I think its more nasally than flat, but for being self taught he does an excellent job
He sings better than most so-called professional singers! Regardless if he's self-taught or not.
Some people seriously is narrow-minded their reaction is much better than evry reactor I've seen. I'm a Filipino and I can't even be mad at their reaction.
it's really amazing how pomoy sings dual, it shows how versatile he was by doing that, doesn't matter if there's error at least he made it his style.
Ive watched literally 10s of reactions of this video, youre the first one to say hes singing flat 😅.
Really of all the things to say about MARCELITO POMOY you say a lot of negative comments. Of all the decades of listening to great singers, he is a truly unique singer. Thousands of professional vocal coaches, teachers, and so on have never pointed that he sings flat.
They do point out how difficult it is to go from female voice to male voice and it is simply astounding. I could go on and on, but I will say this there are millions of people who appreciate his talent. People admire him, for a man who grew up on the streets of the Philippines, homeless, and penniless. He also taught himself how to sing, with no technical training.
My question is who are you? Have you had that much difficulty in your life?
I dont like their reactions too. No wonder they dont have many subscribers. So sad. I also unsubscribe to their channel
Why do you feel so personally insulted by their comments, which by the way are totally correct. He is in fact flat on some notes, yet that doesn’t make him a bad singer. They are totally amazed by him, yet just point out minor mistakes. Marcelito is a one of a kind talent, yet was a little flat sometimes in this performance (who cares it happens to every great singer).
Very childish to question their lives just because they point out some notes, because they never disrespect or not admire him in this particular reaction do they now? As u yourself said: he is a self-taught singer with almost no technical training, so doesn’t it makes sense that he might have some minor ‘mistakes’ here and there?
Ha ha hahhh..l9ve your comment😍
@@FrisoJacobs Let's say he was flat sometimes.but saying "SUPER FLAT"?? Lol That was degrading.
:@@FrisoJacobs
First of all, if one resorts to name-calling who is being 'CHILDISH " . In this open format/arena expect a challenge if you don't agree with a certain commentary. If you think we (the readers) have to sit back and say nothing if one disagrees, you are wrong.
Secondly," minor mistakes" as you put it why even bother commenting on it?
The things Marcelito has done are amazing. There is one person who did a reaction to Marcelito's video, and she has all the credentials and rights to criticize and all she had to say was positive comments. Everything Macelito has done far outweighs his short commings and that is how I remember Marcelito Pomoy.
Something to keep in mind is Marcelito speaks very little English or Italian. So he will not pronounce things like a native speaker. I wouldn’t interpret him as flat, he is just singing words he doesn’t actually know…. And I think intentionally singing soft at times. Personally, I think he is incredibile and I was extremely impressed.
I'm watching! Again this show.
Wow2x!! Very impressive voice
Amazing.💕👏💕..
TALENTED and GIFTED! Period!
Yes!!!!
CORRECT ✔️✔️✔️
He is from the Philippines and he is doing English and Italian perfectly. I have to say if you guys can sing in both languages please show us. I would love to see it.
And on key, and with two totally different beautiful voices, male and female, and switching from a pop sound to a classical sound.
Agree' Majes"🎤🎶👍
and he did not even have a proper education because his an orphane.
Ang pangit ng boses nyung dalawa kung makacritesize kau akala nyu kaya nyu tularan c marce!!
I wouldn’t say he’s doing Italian “perfectly” (I am Italian) but yeah he’s pretty good. And they are not judging his accent, they’re judging his type of singing. I really don’t understand why you guys are getting so touchy over some critique 🤦🏽♀️
here in the philippines is have a lot of singer man or talent like that marcelito pomoy
one man have a two voice girl and boy
because here in the philippines
the hobbies of all people is singing everywhere
wherever u want sing
Somehow I knew I was going to hate these peoples reaction after watching them do Morissite. These two who are unknown and with no discernible talent are harsh on those who are relatively well known. At least way more well known than those the react to.
Dont know where you guys get the AUDACITY to react to Marcelito `s cover , after hearing and seeing you singing in your video , his male" and "female" voice is 100 times better than yours.
Thank you.
Absolutely!!!
perfectly correct
AHAHHAHAAHA
Saw some of their videos.. i cant believe i just wasted my time 😂🤣😂🤣 didnt evn get till 10secs 🤣😂🤣😂...
CRAZY!
follow him with your tuned keyboard
marcelito pomoy did an excellent job. Almost no one can sing the two different styles at the same time. Bringing up where he is from, the philippines, it definately is a hard life but the Filipinos are some of the most loving people on earth so I can see where he comes by his music as they have it playing night and day there to lift their souls..great job marcelito and God bless you and your people..
In defense of Marcelito , he grew up very poor and didn’t have voice lesson. Self thought like most Pilipino singers.
Yeah but this video was taken years after he’s already won PGT and has sang many many times on ASAP, showtime tv shows etc…and most artists have a vocal coach already.
What you’re saying is just an excuse now. He has the experience, the lessons to better himself. But obviously not all artists are perfect. So what we can say is that Marcilito is a growing artist and learning to master his craft
@@roilargo3215 TOTALLY AGREE
They’re not commenting about Marcelito’s life but voice. Please set aside that fact
Like me none of you know Marcelito or what training he has had or hasn’t after PGT. But knowing how much money and time he gives to charitable endeavors I highly doubt he would want to spend excessive amounts to vocal coaches. Why can’t people just enjoy his talent and story without being critical.
@@andreasavanna5666 the price on pgt invloved singing a contract to a music label and to abs cbn and that’s a fact
I learn so much from you videos. Thank you for sharing your knowledge!
No worries still appreciating your reactions. Don't mind others. Just do what do still I'm enjoying your reaction. Love from the philippines.
Attention! He is sitting down and in a live bus studio. Try to sing like this while you are sitting.
I am confused,how these two are finding so called many flaws in his singing,I have watched many reaction videos from real professional vocal coaches,and none of them were this critical and condescending.I will not make the mistake of clicking on this channel again.
Agree
Different people will see different things, sometimes some people will see something but not see it as a big enough deal to comment on. Some people try to be overly nice to please viewers. And other people objectively see different things.
Or maybe this two are very courageous to do the honor of critical response level3😁😁😁😁👏👏👏
Wla na duguan na di na mkatayo
I am also confused. I just watched their reactions to Dimash's SOS and Olimpico. They said that he struggled with a note (mid-range for him), his note was flat and almost out of tune, and he ran out of breath. So I decided to check out this one. I feel a little bad that they received a lot of angry comments from both Dimash and MP's fans, but also feel that they might not be knowledgeable enough to evaluate those artists.
I really don't understand how a lot of people in the comment section are hating on this reaction - these two are trained vocal coaches and part of vocal lessons is technique and intonation. Just because other reactors are sometimes too scared to touch on anything "negative" doesn't mean there are not things that can be improved. Being "critical" - which is actually trying to help a person in sounding healthier and more free in order to have endless vocal possibilities - is literally part of their job. And that does not mean that Marcellito is not amazing at what he does. He is an amazing singer who has a beautiful voice. And I didn't get the vibe that any of them thought differently.
So thank you for your reaction. I really liked your points of view and your opinions.
I think a fanatic of those so called vocal coach or maybe one of their family member.
When you start by criticizing from the start of the song to the end and you are viewing something you don't see much on earth, you probably think of yourselves so high up there on a pedestal.
How about you two sing the same song and lets compare which one is better. His version (alone) who have no proper training? Or your version, who have a proper training and experience?
You two always talk so much.You are interrupting marcelito's performance.
You two are insane...not valid for being as a reactor...a lot of interupting for nothing...
It maybe Flat but sounds Amazing to an ordinary guy like me.. 💛He's the Champion of Pilipinas Got Talent before..and he joined America's Got Talent in 2020.
Another comment for Chase, very good observation about his intonation. We're always singing the songs just based on what we're hearing, in this case, Marcelito is just singing his interpretation of how he is hearing how Celine sings the song, and this is actually how he sings the Celine part. He didn't know anything about "flat" or whatnot, he just sings it the way he listens to it sang by Celine...
You two are the ones Simon Cowell would say, "Fire your music teacher!!!" Like trump would say..."YOU'RE FIRED!!!"
I'm a music teacher (30 years) and have very good relative pitch. Marcelito is not in tune all of the time, but it is not to the detriment of his performance. Some performers are painful to listen to, as they are sooo out of tune. Marcelito is fine. Listen to his entire performance (and other songs) before trying to 'fix' his intonation.
I have perfect pitch and I agree. Some notes are a little under pitch, but they’re not completely flat or off. IMO his “flatness” (I’d call it more just a bit under pitch at times) is not as flat as Melia makes it seem to be, but that’s my opinion. I am glad though they are sharing their critiques and opinions since many voice teacher reactions to this have no critical substance and they’re just blown, as they should be lol, but still.
He has an accent and barely knows english lol he mimi what he heard and yall teachers create yall own tones. Like Celine Dion has always been flat and sung from her nose.
@@tkrc1888 Agreed, the flatness that she says was not really flat by definition, its not just dead center like what Melia wanted to be.
Clearly you are so much in love with your own voices that you can't be bothered to listen properly.
They must sing this also😊
they're vocal coaches. their job is to give constructive criticism. lmao
@@stargrrl__ And yet they succeed to miss almost all the crucial points. If they are really coaches they are the worst I ever saw on YT.
@@UteNawratil there's 1 billion other videos of reactors/vocal coaches kissing up to their viewers and gloating over this guy's performance. go to those videos instead of whining bc you can't handle hearing criticism.
@@stargrrl__ I think I heard pretty much all of them. And the good ones name the weak points precisely as well as recognize the techniques that are used. And I'm not a fan of Mr. Pomoy, by the way. That's not why I find those two annoying. And looking to the other comments, it seems that I'm not alone.
This was very educational. There are plenty of places to go to watch reactors falling over themselves and gawping. I came here to learn something from trained professionals. And I did. Thank you for this even though you caught so much hate from people shopping for something you weren't ever advertising in the first place :)
Lol! “Most singers having off days..” this performance is far from off. He was outstanding & his voice is out of this world & just beautiful to listen to. Not forgetting that he’s a male!!
I’m interested in seeing you doing a cover of this song & then we’ll see🤔
I wanna hear you guys sing duet and we’ll check reactions from viewers..
Yes! Let's see how perfect they are. 😆
Yaaaaaaah come on sing it you guys duet and we'll check reaction from us!
Check their channel, there is a duet on it. 😂😂 From there, i can say that the voice of marcelito doing female voice if far good that this girl saying superflat, 😂😂😂😂
Yes, i want to hear them sing. Show us how good you are.
ruclips.net/video/_ocVHtaOROo/видео.html
he is creating the female voice that's why you hear flatness.
Because shes too JUDGEMENTAL. Pomoy had just starting singing and she spoke already too much. Hahahahah🤣
@@Shyragirl80 yeah hahaha
I was chomping at the bit waiting for you guys to get to the male side! 😉
So many people offended in the comments. 😓 I'm a Filipino too, but they're right. _I'm not saying Marcelito is not a good singer. That's also not what Chase and Melia meant._
I personally enjoyed the objective analysis. Hope you guys continue reacting to Filipino artists. 😊