Do you like BE:FIRST X ATEEZ collab ? Song : Hush Hush Artist : BE:FIRST X ATEEZ (에이티즈) Album : [-] Outro : Hush Hush #ATEEZ #BEFIRST #hush_hush #linedistribution
This is very fair for a collab between 15 people, imo! Ofc they can’t all get completely the same amount of lines, the choice was most likely made considering who’s tone of voice fit this one particular song more, but both ATEEZ and BE:FIRST are well represented. When I listen to the song and watch the MV I feel like everybody is seen and appreciated, not one of the 15 members got lost to me. Bravo to both teams
@@passionyoungfever_ever YH can be the perfect example he still can shine even he don't get enough lines and screen times. And what I really respect about YH, JH, MG stans. They never show their toxicity, they never whining and complaint if their bias don't get enough lines and screen times, especially YH.
To the ATINY who are complaing about line distribuition.. I mean, also Ryoki had least line between BE:FIRST members, he is my favorite member but it's okay, I mean they are 15 of them and it's not so easy to make them sing the same lines but Hidaka never made differences between BE:FIRST, he is only based on their voices and which of them suit the song better but everyone has their own song where they shine. I would never be mad at Manato who had more lines of everyone because I know how talented and how amazing his voice is. They're all talented! Just enjoy the song!
Just be grateful for that. because in every Ateez songs, there will stans that winning and complaint their bias always don't get enough lines and screen times
@@howareyou610 , why don't you next time make your own songs for YS and give all the parts to him. People like you is clearly ruined and embrassing the fandom. Whining and complaint over line distribution, when other stans never say anything when their bias don't get enough lines and screen times. As expected and as always WY, YS and SN stans is the most toxic stans
I invite anyone who's complaining to write and produce a very good 3-4 minutes song, with 3 different languages, and distribute the lines in 15 perfectly equal singing time.
I don't complain about the line distribution also when San is my favorite man tho. The mv shoots of him are so damn beautiful! And this song is a fck banger!! My favorite song this year so far and i am totally sure that won't change. The beat is sick! SLAAAAAY!!
All of them doing really well and shine even some members don't get enough lines and screen times. And to see solo stans that can't stop whining and complaint over line distribution is getting annoying and really ruined every comment section when other people want to praise both groups
Thank you for not being annoying about it ! Some people can't help themselves I swear. Let's be positive about this collab,it's a first ! They all get their time to shine!
@@haki_47 Totally! The voices are fitting perfectly all in all. I'm not into the names with BE:FIRST members but it was the best idea with giving Woo and Yuyu that lines because it's a 100000% match and no one can tell me otherwise. People should listen to sth else if they don't want to hear that in the way they did👺
Never would I have imagined that a line distribution between 15 people can be so fair. As someone who didn't know be:first I was almost sure someone would be forgotten between all 15 but DAMN xD Also love that Yeosang and Wooyoung are not that far behind, like they definitly are in a lot of ateez songs but here everyone got to shine as brightly as they deserved. ^^ I also thought Seonghwa was less in it but I could probably not tell his voice apart as easy as usal due to 7 new people I don't know LOL But yeah. Ty for this video! Such Line Distributions videos are always so fun to watch!!! :D
For people who are complaining this song is made by Sky high the ceo of Befirst he isn't biased just because befirst is his group he doesn't gave them more lines or screentime if it was a collab made by korean company they would be biased considering how koreans always down play jpop idols. Also even manato,leo and most members of befirst get less screen times than ateez idk why these fans are so ungrateful
Thank you so much for saying this because I noticed there a More solo stans that never stop whining and complaint over line distribution and screen times, whether is Ateez songs and Ateez collaboration with other group. Is funny when is Ateez songs ,they accused Eden and Eden production team biased, they say bad things to KQ and Eden members that get more lines because KQ and Eden biased them and now they want to blame japanese producer and songwriter for not give their bias more lines and screen times. Is so sad when Ateez fandom have so many toxic and rude stans. But I really respect to some kind people in Ateez fandom that praise both groups.
Hey, I know there’s disagreements in the comments considering the lines Yeosang and San got, but for 15 voices this distribution is relatively fair. Yes, SN and YS did not shine as much with lines or screen time with this one, but there are other comebacks where other members of both teams have suffered the same. Lets just show support to all 15 boys in this song and appreciate how much of a banger this is 💕
Tbh i’m glad that at least wooyoung got a lot of screen time and lines this time since him and yeosang usually end up having the least lines :,) I’m sad for yeosang tho, i need him to have more lines next comeback because its just kinda sad that he never gets any lines
@@niki7149 , they did SAN and YEOSANG super dirty not the first time though. Which stupid that's doesn't understand what your complaint and whining. If you're so stupid, you think everyone is stupid like you. If you want to praise just praise, why need to whinning and complaint?? Here we go again with someone that always ungrateful and unsatisfied with everything
Here we go again. Ungrateful people that never stop whining and complaint. Say that people didn't understand what they read. If you're stupid, you think everyone as stupid like you. They did SAN and YEOSANG super dirty...... not the first time though. If you want to praise just praise, why need to keep whinning and complaint. 😒🙄.
OMG here we go again. Someone really annoying and ungrateful over lines distribution.They did SAN and YEOSANG super dirty..... not the first time though. You think everyone is stupid just like you. If you want to praise them just praise them but need to whinning and complaint say they did SAN and YEOSANG super dirty😒🙄
Can't you just shut up. What else do you want?? KQ should give WY all the lines and screen times?? Why WY and YS stans never stop winning and complaint about WY and YS always get least lines but When YH, SH get least lines no one say anything
@@airinavasquez4164Why are you so toxic? I see your negative comments a lot whenever someone asks for a fair like distribution. It’s obvious you don’t care about all 8 members
I’m sick and tired of so-called “atiny” standing up for the unfair treatment yeosang and wooyoung get when it comes to their lines. Just shut up and stop making it obvious that you don’t like those two amazing members
@@starry_atz , yeah right that's what you called Toxic..why when other members like YH, SH, MG, get least lines no one cares but when YS and WY get least lines everyone make fussed about it?? Want to talk about toxic thing. So what about people mobbed and follow ATEEZ to their hotel and film SAN without his permission when he just want to enjoy his free time?? That's not toxic?? But you dared to say my comment is toxic. See my comment a lot. So, what you do to protect them?? Nothing just hiding and laugh because you only think my comment is toxic. Such a hypocrite
@@airinavasquez4164 why are you so pissed for?? wooyoung DID have more screen time in this song and DID have more lines in this song. In the work mv he only had about 7 seconds screentime and 9 seconds for lines. thats less than the amount of seconds he had here? and why are you comparing member stans for .. how is addressing the fact that wooyoung got more lines here than work make you a wooyoung stan ? it sounds like YOUR the solo stan.
@@sarahbarenstark9953, is not the first time. Atiny especially WY and YS stans complaint and whining about that members get least lines. And even dare to say bad things to eden, KQ and Edenary team
@@airinavasquez4164 I kinda understand them because they have in fact mostly the least lines, but why I watched the behind the scenes of recording Golden Hour 1 I felt that Wooyoung picked the lines he wanted to sing himself and if I noticed it right (I'm a new Atiny) he doesn't get dance breaks to get some air often, so it might be harder to do both... I noticed Yeosangs voice in the back vocals more often then I expected it and he might be still a little bit shy when he is in the centre... The most important thing is, I trust their friendship enough to be sure that they won't leave anyone behind... And I can't remember hearing Yeosang say himself that he wants more lines...
@@sarahbarenstark9953, WY picked the lines he want to sing himself and WY and YS get good lines when other members like YH and SH don't get that lines. WY get to be In center of Halazia dance break and YS have a chance to use his deep voice and he get praise for that. Is getting annoying when fans can't stop whining and complaint. YS, WY and SN don't get enough lines whether is Ateez songs or Ateez collaboration with other group. And they even dared to say KQ biased the members that get more lines and they want to exploded KQ, they mad at Eden and his production team.. what is that?? Is that really necessary to keep blame, complaint and whining over line distribution?? If they don't get enough lines, people should praise them about something else. Their dance skills, their deep voice, they become center. There still many fans can praise and focus but why they never stop whining and complaint. Ateez have great vocalist and rappers also can sing, is not easy to give fair lines to all of them
I thought the same thing. Seems like Leo from BE:FIRST sings up to 02:52 "just between you and me", then Jongho from ATEEZ sings "I know we can change the world" Being very new to ATEEZ, I was amazed by Jongho's powerful high tone and very thankful for this line distribution😃
Can you just shut up and enjoy this song. You think is so easy for all of them to get fair lines. Just support all of them, is not easy for Ateez to get collaboration with great group.. if you think your bias don't get enough lines and they did them dirty, make your own song for them
@@airinavasquez4164 I do not underestimate the difficulty of distributing the lines to 15 people, but Yeosang did not appear in any of ATEEZ's songs and only had two sentences!! If I'm not yeosang fan I won't glimpse him in the mv
sometimes i wonder why wooyoung always gets more lines in songs that are not on an ateez korean album. i mean, if they can actually give him more lines, why not in his own groups album??? 😂
My advice is to know the positions of the members instead of complaining, it’s not you who distributes the lines and I’m talking about fans in general.
@@airinavasquez4164 idk why you're being rude to me. i was genuinely curious because i believe wooyoung has a great voice. it would be great if the producers could make better use of all the members' voices in their songs isnt?
@@haihello2656 , dude. I see so many WY, SN and YS stans whinning and complaint over line distribution and screen times. Whether is collaboration or Ateez songs. Why we can't just support and praise both groups?? Is that so hard. You want me to respect you but did you respect all of those people that work so hard to give their best to their fans. Just stop whinning and complaint is like we can do better job than them
@@GoodMorningDhiawhy would i cry? the member i stan is the most well-known and popular anyway. he’ll have his solo ✌️ more than me, you should be more scared once he stops being this humble, he’ll make you guys cry even more lol
Can you just stop whining and complaint..why people like you even exist in Ateez fandom?? For what?? I never say anything when YH as main dancer don't get enough lines, don't get to be in center, people don't give him enough praise and attention..but people like you especially SN, WY and YS stans getting annoying
@@sansppudding870, is getting annoying when most toxic stans never stop whining and complaint over line distribution when other members stans that doesn't get enough lines and screen times never say anything. Both groups doing really well and each one of them really shine even there members don't get enough lines and screen times but why need to whinning and complaint just because of that. And I don't think he will stop being humble because that's not his personality
15 people and the distribution is so fair. Congratulations 👏🏻
And if there solo stans still want to whinning and complaint because their bias don't get many lines or screen times, it was so stupid
This is very fair for a collab between 15 people, imo! Ofc they can’t all get completely the same amount of lines, the choice was most likely made considering who’s tone of voice fit this one particular song more, but both ATEEZ and BE:FIRST are well represented. When I listen to the song and watch the MV I feel like everybody is seen and appreciated, not one of the 15 members got lost to me. Bravo to both teams
This is so much, much better than any other songs by single groups out there
I feel like Wooyoung and Yunho shined brighter 🥴❤️💕
Me too!!! I was so happy
@@passionyoungfever_ever YH can be the perfect example he still can shine even he don't get enough lines and screen times. And what I really respect about YH, JH, MG stans. They never show their toxicity, they never whining and complaint if their bias don't get enough lines and screen times, especially YH.
i love this collaboration so much 🙏🙏
Did there a chance for them to win something because this collaboration is really cool
To the ATINY who are complaing about line distribuition.. I mean, also Ryoki had least line between BE:FIRST members, he is my favorite member but it's okay, I mean they are 15 of them and it's not so easy to make them sing the same lines but Hidaka never made differences between BE:FIRST, he is only based on their voices and which of them suit the song better but everyone has their own song where they shine.
I would never be mad at Manato who had more lines of everyone because I know how talented and how amazing his voice is. They're all talented! Just enjoy the song!
yeosang has more lines than i thought because his screen time is so little 😭
Just be grateful for that. because in every Ateez songs, there will stans that winning and complaint their bias always don't get enough lines and screen times
Justice for yeosang
@@airinavasquez4164the thing is yeosang almost always used to be bottom of thr list
@@howareyou610 , why don't you next time make your own songs for YS and give all the parts to him. People like you is clearly ruined and embrassing the fandom. Whining and complaint over line distribution, when other stans never say anything when their bias don't get enough lines and screen times. As expected and as always WY, YS and SN stans is the most toxic stans
@@airinavasquez4164 chill why so angry i just said that yeosang gets less lines same to wooyoung i am an ot 8even an yeosang. Who is your bias tho.
ATEEZさんの事を知らなかったので、誰が歌っているのかわかり易くて嬉しいです！ありがとう♡
i'm so obsessed with this song....OH dear noww...i'm GOTTA WORK GONNA MAKE THAT MONEY MAKE IT PURSE
ほんとにこのコラボはもっともっと評価されていいと思う👏👏二組のメンバーが揃って歌えることはこの先どこかで実現するのかな？DUNKが一番可能性高い？想像するだけで鳥肌モノ〜❤❤
I invite anyone who's complaining to write and produce a very good 3-4 minutes song, with 3 different languages, and distribute the lines in 15 perfectly equal singing time.
my glorious kings sota and yunho
YH don't get many lines and screen times but he did really well. All of them did really well
I don't complain about the line distribution also when San is my favorite man tho. The mv shoots of him are so damn beautiful! And this song is a fck banger!! My favorite song this year so far and i am totally sure that won't change. The beat is sick! SLAAAAAY!!
All of them doing really well and shine even some members don't get enough lines and screen times. And to see solo stans that can't stop whining and complaint over line distribution is getting annoying and really ruined every comment section when other people want to praise both groups
Thank you for not being annoying about it ! Some people can't help themselves I swear. Let's be positive about this collab,it's a first ! They all get their time to shine!
@@haki_47 Totally! The voices are fitting perfectly all in all. I'm not into the names with BE:FIRST members but it was the best idea with giving Woo and Yuyu that lines because it's a 100000% match and no one can tell me otherwise. People should listen to sth else if they don't want to hear that in the way they did👺
Thank you so very much!! I am very new to ATEEZ, and have been trying to find out the name of each member.
思った以上に公平だった。
素晴らしいね。
ATEEZさんの気になる声の方が誰かわかりやかったからありがたい。
Never would I have imagined that a line distribution between 15 people can be so fair. As someone who didn't know be:first I was almost sure someone would be forgotten between all 15 but DAMN xD
Also love that Yeosang and Wooyoung are not that far behind, like they definitly are in a lot of ateez songs but here everyone got to shine as brightly as they deserved. ^^
I also thought Seonghwa was less in it but I could probably not tell his voice apart as easy as usal due to 7 new people I don't know LOL
But yeah. Ty for this video! Such Line Distributions videos are always so fun to watch!!! :D
THIS IS A GOOD LINE DISTRIBUTION.
EVERYONE GET TO SHINE BRIGHT LIKE THE STARS ✨
It's pretty fair for a collab tho ❤
Thank you. Why there still people especially Solo stans whinning their bias get least lines?? Is really annoying
From ATEEZ ,Yunho and Wooyoung era of course 🔥
For people who are complaining this song is made by Sky high the ceo of Befirst he isn't biased just because befirst is his group he doesn't gave them more lines or screentime if it was a collab made by korean company they would be biased considering how koreans always down play jpop idols. Also even manato,leo and most members of befirst get less screen times than ateez idk why these fans are so ungrateful
Thank you so much for saying this because I noticed there a More solo stans that never stop whining and complaint over line distribution and screen times, whether is Ateez songs and Ateez collaboration with other group. Is funny when is Ateez songs ,they accused Eden and Eden production team biased, they say bad things to KQ and Eden members that get more lines because KQ and Eden biased them and now they want to blame japanese producer and songwriter for not give their bias more lines and screen times. Is so sad when Ateez fandom have so many toxic and rude stans. But I really respect to some kind people in Ateez fandom that praise both groups.
Hey, I know there’s disagreements in the comments considering the lines Yeosang and San got, but for 15 voices this distribution is relatively fair. Yes, SN and YS did not shine as much with lines or screen time with this one, but there are other comebacks where other members of both teams have suffered the same. Lets just show support to all 15 boys in this song and appreciate how much of a banger this is 💕
Tbh i’m glad that at least wooyoung got a lot of screen time and lines this time since him and yeosang usually end up having the least lines :,) I’m sad for yeosang tho, i need him to have more lines next comeback because its just kinda sad that he never gets any lines
First I've seen Ryoki is on High And Low, I didn't know he can sing so high
Hello🎉 thank you🎉 Japan
COMO SIEMPRE YEOSANG SIN LÍNEAS 😤
Increíble trabajo! 💪🏻💗
𝑇ℎ𝑎𝑛𝑘 𝑦𝑜𝑢❤
Wooyoung shines here wow best mv 🎉
曲を聞いててそんなに感じなかったけど、マナトが1番多かったんですね。
でも楽曲制作に参加してるから納得ではありますね。
now, imagine if nct did the same thing with 20 people XD
Как остановить бабочки в животе 🦋
Fair distribution between Ateez & Be:First BUT they did San & Yeosang super dirty..... not the first time though
OMG, here we go again. So yo want SAN and YEOSANG to get all the lines when all of them is have good vocalist??
@@airinavasquez4164 omg here we go again with someone who doesn't understand what they read 🥲
@@niki7149 , they did SAN and YEOSANG super dirty not the first time though. Which stupid that's doesn't understand what your complaint and whining. If you're so stupid, you think everyone is stupid like you. If you want to praise just praise, why need to whinning and complaint?? Here we go again with someone that always ungrateful and unsatisfied with everything
Here we go again. Ungrateful people that never stop whining and complaint. Say that people didn't understand what they read. If you're stupid, you think everyone as stupid like you. They did SAN and YEOSANG super dirty...... not the first time though. If you want to praise just praise, why need to keep whinning and complaint. 😒🙄.
OMG here we go again. Someone really annoying and ungrateful over lines distribution.They did SAN and YEOSANG super dirty..... not the first time though. You think everyone is stupid just like you. If you want to praise them just praise them but need to whinning and complaint say they did SAN and YEOSANG super dirty😒🙄
Wooyoung has more liens and screen time than Work cb
Can't you just shut up. What else do you want?? KQ should give WY all the lines and screen times?? Why WY and YS stans never stop winning and complaint about WY and YS always get least lines but When YH, SH get least lines no one say anything
@@airinavasquez4164Why are you so toxic? I see your negative comments a lot whenever someone asks for a fair like distribution. It’s obvious you don’t care about all 8 members
I’m sick and tired of so-called “atiny” standing up for the unfair treatment yeosang and wooyoung get when it comes to their lines. Just shut up and stop making it obvious that you don’t like those two amazing members
@@starry_atz , yeah right that's what you called Toxic..why when other members like YH, SH, MG, get least lines no one cares but when YS and WY get least lines everyone make fussed about it?? Want to talk about toxic thing. So what about people mobbed and follow ATEEZ to their hotel and film SAN without his permission when he just want to enjoy his free time?? That's not toxic?? But you dared to say my comment is toxic. See my comment a lot. So, what you do to protect them?? Nothing just hiding and laugh because you only think my comment is toxic. Such a hypocrite
@@airinavasquez4164 why are you so pissed for?? wooyoung DID have more screen time in this song and DID have more lines in this song. In the work mv he only had about 7 seconds screentime and 9 seconds for lines. thats less than the amount of seconds he had here? and why are you comparing member stans for .. how is addressing the fact that wooyoung got more lines here than work make you a wooyoung stan ? it sounds like YOUR the solo stan.
❤❤
Omg we have same name lmao
Now I know why I don't even hear San sing
gladly i still can heard his voice clearly❤
I'm so disappointed that they have the least lines and the rest have so much more
They also gave them less screen time
the lead vocalist. what a joke
Sad for san, but it the same case for wooyung and yeosang in most of ateez comeback they always get least lines
Wooyoung always takes more lines if producers other than eden produce a song for them 🙃
But Eden is the producer 😅
Why don't you produce your own song, and asked only WY sing the song that you produce
@@sarahbarenstark9953, is not the first time. Atiny especially WY and YS stans complaint and whining about that members get least lines. And even dare to say bad things to eden, KQ and Edenary team
@@airinavasquez4164 I kinda understand them because they have in fact mostly the least lines, but why I watched the behind the scenes of recording Golden Hour 1 I felt that Wooyoung picked the lines he wanted to sing himself and if I noticed it right (I'm a new Atiny) he doesn't get dance breaks to get some air often, so it might be harder to do both...
I noticed Yeosangs voice in the back vocals more often then I expected it and he might be still a little bit shy when he is in the centre...
The most important thing is, I trust their friendship enough to be sure that they won't leave anyone behind...
And I can't remember hearing Yeosang say himself that he wants more lines...
@@sarahbarenstark9953, WY picked the lines he want to sing himself and WY and YS get good lines when other members like YH and SH don't get that lines. WY get to be In center of Halazia dance break and YS have a chance to use his deep voice and he get praise for that. Is getting annoying when fans can't stop whining and complaint. YS, WY and SN don't get enough lines whether is Ateez songs or Ateez collaboration with other group. And they even dared to say KQ biased the members that get more lines and they want to exploded KQ, they mad at Eden and his production team.. what is that?? Is that really necessary to keep blame, complaint and whining over line distribution?? If they don't get enough lines, people should praise them about something else. Their dance skills, their deep voice, they become center. There still many fans can praise and focus but why they never stop whining and complaint. Ateez have great vocalist and rappers also can sing, is not easy to give fair lines to all of them
1:28 isnt this Yeosang? I clearly hear the lisp
unfortunately not, bcs that line is japanese while ateez was singing in korean
@@oohwawann ohh youre right, i didnt even notice that! I guess that means Leo has a cute lisp as well xD
O San conseguiu cantar menos que o Yeosang mds kkkk
Why are Yeosang’s lines disappearing?🤨
Why don't you make your own songs for YS
They're probably talking abt the bar thing bc it disappeared@@airinavasquez4164
That doesn't sound like Jongho. 2:49
I thought the same thing. Seems like Leo from BE:FIRST sings up to 02:52 "just between you and me", then Jongho from ATEEZ sings "I know we can change the world" Being very new to ATEEZ, I was amazed by Jongho's powerful high tone and very thankful for this line distribution😃
It counts background vocals too, which Jongho was during that part
@@arisaeleanorhara4342, thanks you for being so sweet and don't being toxic like some Ateez members stans
They did yeosang and San so dirty 💀
Frfr
sadly i stan them both but it is what it is, still a banger
Can you just shut up and enjoy this song. You think is so easy for all of them to get fair lines. Just support all of them, is not easy for Ateez to get collaboration with great group.. if you think your bias don't get enough lines and they did them dirty, make your own song for them
@@airinavasquez4164 no one said they ddint enjoy then damn song lol
@@airinavasquez4164 I do not underestimate the difficulty of distributing the lines to 15 people, but Yeosang did not appear in any of ATEEZ's songs and only had two sentences!!
If I'm not yeosang fan I won't glimpse him in the mv
sometimes i wonder why wooyoung always gets more lines in songs that are not on an ateez korean album. i mean, if they can actually give him more lines, why not in his own groups album??? 😂
Make your own song for WY, then he can get more lines. People like you shouldn't exist in Ateez fandom
Can't you just be grateful. What else did you want. WY get all the lines and screen times when other members just being his backup dancer
My advice is to know the positions of the members instead of complaining, it’s not you who distributes the lines and I’m talking about fans in general.
@@airinavasquez4164 idk why you're being rude to me. i was genuinely curious because i believe wooyoung has a great voice. it would be great if the producers could make better use of all the members' voices in their songs isnt?
@@haihello2656 , dude. I see so many WY, SN and YS stans whinning and complaint over line distribution and screen times. Whether is collaboration or Ateez songs. Why we can't just support and praise both groups?? Is that so hard. You want me to respect you but did you respect all of those people that work so hard to give their best to their fans. Just stop whinning and complaint is like we can do better job than them
For me, San never got his due in this song and that his voice deserves to be in first place 😡😠and San is first in any case.
Go make your own songs for him and only SAN sing all the line, get all the screen times. You're so annoying, Ateez is not all about WY, SN and YS.
look at the lead vocalist. what a joke
Go cry, baby
@@GoodMorningDhiawhy would i cry? the member i stan is the most well-known and popular anyway. he’ll have his solo ✌️ more than me, you should be more scared once he stops being this humble, he’ll make you guys cry even more lol
what?
Can you just stop whining and complaint..why people like you even exist in Ateez fandom?? For what?? I never say anything when YH as main dancer don't get enough lines, don't get to be in center, people don't give him enough praise and attention..but people like you especially SN, WY and YS stans getting annoying
@@sansppudding870, is getting annoying when most toxic stans never stop whining and complaint over line distribution when other members stans that doesn't get enough lines and screen times never say anything. Both groups doing really well and each one of them really shine even there members don't get enough lines and screen times but why need to whinning and complaint just because of that. And I don't think he will stop being humble because that's not his personality