I don't know who Luke is but he does have quite impressive vocals But it's no mystery that Liam definitely is better (sorry to anyone I offended) BTW can someone please tell me the song name at 2:19 and 9:45?
I'm gonna disagree with almost everyone and go with Luke. Liam has a wider range and better technique of course, but somehow his voice got to nasal over the years idk maybe to fit pop songs. I liked him better at first to be honest. I don't know if people throwing Luke away have really heard him a bunch of times. His vocals in Sounds Good Feels Good are great, huge improve from the first album. I never thought he was such a good singer when I first heard him, I guess he was too young and his voice wasn't defined yet. He has a really beatiful tone and I love his runs and his raspyness. Also he fits his band pop-punk style too well. I'm gonna go with Luke in this
taniaPerroni then what you are saying you like more his Tone of voice yeah he sings good but overall I'm with Liam because has better tone for me like he is so versatil he sings so different and not eveytime the same, better control , technique and range , he an fasettos ns high notes so yeah.
Veru Torres yeah I like Luke's tone better that's why I went with him. Also technique wise Luke has a way better belting imo. Liam is great for real an really trained but I don't think 1D let him shine in the way he could; not sure he's gonna do either according to the style he's apparently gonna go solo with
Zeeyum Xia yeah like the tone of a voice doesn't matter much because that is preference unlike the technique, what he can do with his voice and range , that all of this is for Liam also the versatily of his voice that he can sing so many genders and sounds good , tbh idk why people said that Liam voice is "boring " or "regular " compared to others because I don't think I like his tone but well everybody has an opinion and ppl can like the voice of Luke more but when it's comes to facts Liam is overall better .
Well tone does matter of course it is subjective but if two vocalists are close then u might choose by tone. Luke is better than Liam in belting and tone which matters more to me than low notes (not used in the genre Liam sings), or falsetto which everyone can do. So I prefer Luke it is a personal choice.
liam won hands down :)
liam is best😍😍😍😍
liam won
Liam Payne
Liam all the way hes my fave of 1D
😙❤❤
Definitely Liam Payne 😍 😍
Liam payne is the king 😍😍😍❤❤❤
Sorry but this isn't a question. Didn't need to watch the video to know Liam won
me toi😍
me too😍
Range wise : Luke Technique : Liam overall sings better imo, especially in falsetto
Liam has wider vocal range
liam won no doubt
Liam Payne 😍😍😍
OK OK Luck surprised me but still my lima is better
Liam Payne won, DUH
Luke Hemmings won definitely ❤️
Luke hemmings hands down ❤
liam
Liam is the BEST!!!
Liam James Payne
Zayn Malik, Michael Clifford, Luke Hemmings Vocal Battle ruclips.net/video/01XSuO3EYdI/видео.html
Zayn Malik vs Luke Hemmings Vocal Battle ruclips.net/video/_-QS_c2INMs/видео.html
Pual McCartney vs John Lennon Vocal Battle ruclips.net/video/7RPMczsG1vY/видео.html
Tyler Joseph Vocal Range ruclips.net/video/2ODkeuJNqQw/видео.html
Harry Styles vs Calum Hood Vocal Battle ruclips.net/video/JAMWfdMZyUE/видео.html
Brendon Urie Vocal Range ruclips.net/video/QWZeJuyFqTI/видео.html
Light Lyric Tenor ruclips.net/video/c9Uts-1VIY4/видео.html
I don't know who Luke is but he does have quite impressive vocals
But it's no mystery that Liam definitely is better
(sorry to anyone I offended)
BTW can someone please tell me the song name at 2:19 and 9:45?
Winter Soul 9:45 is called ‘she looks so perfect’ by 5sos
BTW Luke is the lead vocalist for the band 5 seconds of summer(5sos)
Sabiha Ahmad thanks for that
have a great year
Winter Soul your welcome and I hope u have a great year too xx
Sabiha Ahmad thanks😊😊😊
Liam ofc..... Are you kidding??? They have absolute no competition....
Liam Payne, Luke Hemmings, Harry Styles Vocal Battle ruclips.net/video/0vY-gftLzl8/видео.html
Luke hemmings won... hands down (don't mean to offend anyone just my opinion)
Obviously my PAYNO is the best🤧
Liam is a high bass. Feodor Chaliapin had the same type of voice. Liam just singing in pop style.
Dear 5sos fans, what's the song at 13:50? It sounds lit
Brianda Flores Girls Talk Boys
taniaPerroni thank you!💖
I'm gonna disagree with almost everyone and go with Luke.
Liam has a wider range and better technique of course, but somehow his voice got to nasal over the years idk maybe to fit pop songs. I liked him better at first to be honest.
I don't know if people throwing Luke away have really heard him a bunch of times. His vocals in Sounds Good Feels Good are great, huge improve from the first album. I never thought he was such a good singer when I first heard him, I guess he was too young and his voice wasn't defined yet.
He has a really beatiful tone and I love his runs and his raspyness.
Also he fits his band pop-punk style too well.
I'm gonna go with Luke in this
taniaPerroni then what you are saying you like more his Tone of voice yeah he sings good but overall I'm with Liam because has better tone for me like he is so versatil he sings so different and not eveytime the same, better control , technique and range , he an fasettos ns high notes so yeah.
Veru Torres yeah I like Luke's tone better that's why I went with him. Also technique wise Luke has a way better belting imo.
Liam is great for real an really trained but I don't think 1D let him shine in the way he could; not sure he's gonna do either according to the style he's apparently gonna go solo with
Liam's still greater than Luke. No matter who you prefer.
Zeeyum Xia yeah like the tone of a voice doesn't matter much because that is preference unlike the technique, what he can do with his voice and range , that all of this is for Liam also the versatily of his voice that he can sing so many genders and sounds good , tbh idk why people said that Liam voice is "boring " or "regular " compared to others because I don't think I like his tone but well everybody has an opinion and ppl can like the voice of Luke more but when it's comes to facts Liam is overall better .
Well tone does matter of course it is subjective but if two vocalists are close then u might choose by tone.
Luke is better than Liam in belting and tone which matters more to me than low notes (not used in the genre Liam sings), or falsetto which everyone can do.
So I prefer Luke it is a personal choice.
8:40 isn’t Luke it’s Michael
13:25 is Calum hood not Luke
Did you know what falsetto is?
lmao u just cant compare an a-list (liam) to an average singer (luke)
this A4 is actually Harry, not Liam
actually the A4 is louis not harry or liam :)
@@jennyblack451 backing vocals
Zayn Malik vs Michael Clifford Vocal Battle ruclips.net/video/SYR8QHEOcn8/видео.html