I pray Russia never makes the mistakes of the west. They need people who will respect their culture and assimilate, not bring their old life. Learn the language and educate their children, if not leave. Thank you for another informative video
the central asian migrant crisis there is pretty bad tbh. some groups are lobbying the government to do it. i can only imagine it being much worse in EU countries.
@@zombieseezombiedo It is terrible is this bananarepublic of turdeauland. Along with crime, lack of housing and high food and taxes it is unsustainable.
Immigrants in the past learned the native language primarily through television programs presented in the native language. Today immigrants get cable programs with programming in all sorts of foreign languages which provides no incentive for an individual to learn the native language in the Country they are residing.
So here’s the thing, to live in Russia you have to jump through hoops, like learning the language, and being tested on it, being financially independent, if you don’t work, you don’t get to be paid. Values, the state, the family, and if you commit crime you get punished. So we know if Canadian family moved and are building a home, a farm, and going through the hoops, just like some Australian families. If you fail at the tests etc, you are not allowed to stay, etc. where as in UK we are getting 700 people a day land on the beach, getting housed, money, etc. the vast majority are fighting aged men. We have cities that are more than 50% ethnic, and there is no integration, or respecting the host countries laws, values. Yet as you say in Russia you have 152 different ethnic groups, but all respect Russian laws,the state. I hope that Russia remains stable, and that communities stay strong and prosperous.
Because those different groups are there naturally, been living for millenia in those boundaries and in such formations, having no other land to live in
I am pretty sure not all respect Russia. There are definitely criminals in Russia. Crime is in any given society so it doesn’t make sense to assume Russia is completely different.
Лента Креста Святого Георгия не в честь победы. Это в честь героизма, отваги, мужества, воли к победе и в честь боя не на жизнь, а на смерть. А также знак Гвардии. Знак беззаветной преданности.
смешал в кучу гвардейскую ленту и георгиевскую . подмену совершили лет 10 назад. все захавали. а теперь вот даже поправляют шарящих иностранцев. все верно сказано. георгиевская лента в честь святого георгия. гвардейская за подвиги. в царской россии давали георгиевскую, в сссровской гвардейскую. в современной все смешалось в кучу
Игорь вообще не знает что такое русская культура. Не понимает разницы между культурой российской, включающей в себя культуры всех народов России и культурой этнической русской в триединстве русского народа. Странный выбор эксперта агностиком. Видимо главным критерием выбора является знание английского языка.
Exactly.🤣We are just 2 westerners talking about a hot topic. Again the show is in English to show westerners what is going on here. For them this will be interesting. For a Russian I don’t know but I’m grateful for Russians that want to watch.
Joe, are we allowed to share your videos on other social media sites? I like your videos, and you always present a fair , (to both sides) unbiased view from a personal account. You have done some awesome videos. I dont like to share unless I ask permission first. Thanks from Michigan
Фин очень неправ. Русская культура - это Русская Православная Славянская культура и именно она сейчас под угрозой беспредельной миграции Средней Азии. Приезжие даже если они не агрессивны намерены русских и культуру сделая из России ту же жопу как та из которой они приехали. Есть другие народы России но они не являются угрозой русскому миру так как те которые в своё время убивали русских и гнали их со своей землёй ю, это бывшие Республики Средней Азии, а теперь намерена выселить русских из России тоже.
This is the same issue that Texas has with California. California has gone to shit so people are fleeing from there to other states. But when they stay in Texas some of them want to keep thinking and doing the same way that broke California. And Texas aint having it. They want Californians to learn the Texan ways that made Texas prosperous.
Hi! There is a resident of Moscow here. I would like to clarify a few points. Now in our country there is something like a similar migration crisis like in Europe and the United States, which everyone knows about, but it proceeds very implicitly and therefore people gradually began to get used to it. The authorities are trying to do something about it, but they missed the moment somewhat and now the crime rate, including for serious criminal offenses, has increased significantly. Nevertheless, residents began to organize themselves into various volunteer communities to restore order, organize raids on illegal migrant sites, and help fight corruption as much as possible. At the moment, the situation remains difficult and it is not clear what will happen next, since there are strong pro-migrant corrupt lobbies in the government and no one seems to be fighting them much, which may end badly.
@@user-xfb3ni9pq He will leave only in 2030, it is very difficult to say what will happen by that time. I think there will be a warming of relations with the West on the foreign policy scene by this time, but I cannot imagine what will happen inside Russia. I think everything will be about the same and significant changes will begin to occur only after 2030, it depends on who Putin chooses as his successor and a huge number of factors.
You talking nonsense, don't mistaken parliament , (DUMA), and government, authorities taking all under control, thousands of emigrants was deported from Russia.
Я живу в Санкт-Петербурге. Не центр, юго- запад города, 50 лет домам спального района. И у меня вопрос. А может быть иначе? Не представляю даже, что может быть мусор на улицах. У нас нет мешков с мусором рядом с домами и зданиями. Это правда, я иду по улице и даже одной бумажки не вижу. Чисто
@@user-lk3nk1oq5g sadly, in America, we have people who throw their personal trash out the window of their car while driving, people will change a baby diaper in the car and then toss it out the window while driving. There is no respect at all. Walking down the street, they will throw cups, empty bags, food containers etc they eat while walking and dump trash while walking. We, my siblings and I were not raised that way, and if we ever did that , our pops would physically spank us and then make us go clean it up. We raised our kids the same.
Small correction. In percentage terms, Muslims are much smaller than Christians. There are a small number of territories where the indigenous faith is Islam. And Russians are against importing people with a different culture. After all, Muslims are also very different. There are aggressive fanatics. And wild peoples.
Why would you put one group of people into one category? Do you know all Muslims around the world? There are many Muslim fanatics but there are also many Christian fanatics.
@@Boznaniac >>> Why would you put one group of people into one category? LOL just because it's one group of people. another group of people will fall to another category.
Check the new laws on immigration, police have the right to deport without a court hearing, second reading already in Duma. Legal immigration is needed and encouraged.
I think if you go to abandoned Russian space station with two shuttles like baldandbankrupt you are guaranteed to get deported haha. I didn't even know we had an abandoned shuttle space station until I saw a video of him going inside there. I think it qualifies as a military secret area.
Путин подписал закон только о репатриации.Никаких законов о поощрении миграции не существует,наоборот в Госдуме неоднократно ставился и ставится вопрос о запрете вообще любой эмиграции в Россию Пока это предложение отложено,но рано или поздно к нему вернуться.Путин ставил вопрос только о приглашении из-за рубежа специалистов,которых можно будет потом поменять на своих при увеличении числа выпускников российских ВУЗов,что бы потом вообще можно было отказаться от приглашения любых специалистов из-за рубежа.ниокакомпоощрении миграции ,речь не шла и не идёт.Наоборот,чтобы уменьшить число желающих переехать в Россию,Госдумой и принят закон об обязательной постановке на воинский учёт,как тех граждан,кто получил гражданство и до сих пор не стоит на воинском учёте,так и тех, из иностранных граждан,кто в будущем хочет стать гражданином РФ Паспорт гражданина РФ будет выдаваться вместе с автоматической постановкой на воинский учёт и,те кто не стал на воинский учёт также автоматически лишается гражданства РФ.Закон подписан Путиным несколько дней назад.
Два "экспата" рассуждают о БОМЖ'ах и алкашах... один в пластиковых тапках на босу ногу (уверен он так же и в ресторан ходит) другой в обшарпаной кожанке. Если б я выискивал по Москве алкашей, обратил бы внимание на этих двух типчиков в первую очередь! 🤣🤣
@@expatamerican3234 like the majority of russian housewives, i think it's great for a person to have a homeland, to stay within its borders and to love it independent of its prosperity. But if some righteous (even though consumerism oriented) foreigners come round, we don't mind
@@arinaf4515 it's odd that you would be picking on Joseph calling him a wasp. Joseph,, she's calling you a white Anglo-Saxon Protestant. Very odd, considering she might be Russian
Is Russia culture being dilutes or changed owing to immigration etc. I have never been even near Russia. I was raised on the Western side of that "Iron Curtain" - propagandised from birth by the USA and UK. But I view Russian / Ukrainian movies online, and follow content on RUclips. Based on that, it seems to me that since 1990, the ex-Soviets have grown to afford the Western culture and USA in particular with way more respect and envy that they should. So I see so much of the West adopted by the Russian population. I really enjoy seeing Russians celebrating what they are, who they are, and their ancestors who protected their intermittence. But maybe well intention Western EXPATS also influence Russia. Be careful, because I expect that in Russia rests the future of CIVILISATION. I am really old, and the western system has winners and losers - I am have lost all in the Western family court, so can not move, nor could I be an asset to Russia - else, I would emigrate in a flash.
Russia is multicultural country since it's existence 1200 years ago, the problem is in Russia they are tolerant against each other's, there racism of course, but not segregated like USA
how come 85% population Russians makes country multicultural, but 85% of one ethnicity in any other country (e.g. Hungary) makes country mono-national? hint: bolsheviks and Lenin specifically made this narrative to destroy Russian Empire, split it into many independent countries. then communists continue pushing this narrative to destroy USSR, split it into more countries. now this narrative still repeated again and again for RF. Guess what going to be the result?
@@user-dz9vt4dg9y please watch the full Tucker Carlson / Vladimir Putin interview. The Russian president clearly outlines the beginnings of Russia, as being influenced by Swedish Vikings., did you not know that Swedish Vikings, mostly, came down the rivers capturing slaves, AKA Slavs, and sold their Quarry in Constantinople. Please learn history before attempting to teach me, thank you very much.
Бомж (bomzh) stands for "без определенного места жительства", or "without fixed place of living". It's a coincidence that the abbreviation sounds like a natural word for a rugged unwashed homeless person.
Here in Melbourne theres a place called Dandenong with lots of muslims and immigrants and theres a shopping centre there which is very similar to the Russian shopping centre and the song reminded me of an Australian shopping centre.
Igor speaks perfect Russian and simplified English, like the majority of Russians living abroad, but likes to think about himself that he is something else.
@@expatamerican3234Of course we do. It's just that some people that think that "freedom of speech" makes it obligatory to air one's opinion about everything without being asked to.😊
I guess thats a personal matter who thibks of himself what. Im pretty satisfied with what i think of myself thank u. Dunno how u got dishonesty into this 😂
@Igorinrussia Igor, I have nothing against you. I watch your videos sometimes. But your native language is Russian, not English. There is no need to pretend it's not so.
Great video! Expat American do you speak Russian and if so what level? What is your means of income, unless you’re a full time youtuber? As for illegal immigration, I think the situation in Russia is a lot less severe than western countries. In Russia there doesn’t seem to be a lot of identity politics and political correctness.
Верно, но мы убираем всю нелегальную, сейчас очень серьёзные возмущения в обществе, примитивные азиаты себя показали плохо со своим исламом, поэтому их убирают уже сейчас, но работы в этом еще много. Ну а в Англии с этим ужас, там ужасная трагедия и политики похоже ничего с этим не делают.
One does not move to Russia to change their culture. It smacks of what the US Army and military forces did in Afghanistan for 20 years. I should mention that in regard to Legal immigration
They needs to be wise on that: they needs to bring people from all around the world for workforce BUT only if they shared Russian values and if they do something illegal or committ any crime they have to be bring up as an example like they did with the terrorists arrested for the atrocity committed some months ago. They have to preserve their nation, their history and their values and not commit the same mistakes that western societies did.
11:23 БОМЖ = человек Без Определенного Места Жительства, буквальная аббревиатура советских времен когда необходима было иметь запись об официальной прописке по месту жительства в паспорте. Человек, ночующий на земле или на лавочке на улице/вокзале где-нибудь в Москве в те времена практически неизбежно привлекал внимание патрулирующих эти места милиционеров которые прежде всего проверяли документы и запись о прописке. Сильно пьяных и вызывающего поведения, не предъявивших документы - забирали в милицейское отделение или сдавали в медвытрезвитель, но не оставляли замерзать на улице.
Ещё 120 лет назад Россия была христианской, а только с недавнего времени в России приезжают потоком мусульмане, для России это не традиционная религия, была малая совсем часть мусульман всегда в России, это только с недавнего времени в России увеличивается число мусульман, это вообще не традиционно для России, поэтому ставить христианство и мусульманство в России на один уровень и говорить что это как то было ещё в прошлом традиционно,это не правильно
how many people are in moscow? 20 million? Google says 11-13 million 5k density per square km. Or its registed to live and the rest 9-7 million are in transit, visitors, and gastrobiters workers from abroad?
Both. Plus there's the "administrative boundaries" and reality on the ground, when you cross the road and are already in administrative limits of Moscow, while you might be registered and permanently residing on the opposit side of the road, i.e. in some regional town or village, which get engulfed as Moscow grows, and those administrative borders change or often lag behind the actual reality on the ground
Yes and in russia you must register to be counted as a person living in the city. Many dont change that so there are possibly millions people not registered to moscow. Saint pete for example is propably 7mil instead of 5
I think illegal immigration needs to be controlled. However, there is no way to get to 0 because people who are desperate enough will always find a way. I don’t think loss of culture is a problem because that isn’t really happening it’s not like culture vanishes it changes. The real problem with illegal immigration are in my opinion drug and weapon smuggling, gang crime, human trafficking.
You know, for russian even that words 'illegal immigration should be controlled' spoken as an opinion sounds absurd. Like, is so obvious - if it's illegal it is crime, and crime should be controlled 😅 I mean it is so crazy someone even consider that it shouldn't
Hello from the Eastern Siberia - Republic of Buryatia, few remarks: 1. You're a foreigner in our country and you have no right to discuss this illegal immigration topic. 2. The foreigners you showed in the beginning of your video (for instance) a lady with a scarf on her head looks like a typical Dagestani lady she doesn't look like a migrant and she has more rights in our country than you definitely. She has a right to discuss why are your here since her ancestors have been Russian citizens for many centuries and defended this country. 3. Calling yourself "an expat" doesn't give you a right to discuss the rights of ex-ussr people to be here. It is not your level. 4. Before you film a lady with black hairs and put her in your video about illegal immigration at least you could ve asked her origins (might be she is from Yakutia republic) 5. I can perfectly understand if your release videos where you discuss your country. All in all my advise is just forget it do more subway videos.
You are making a lot of assumptions about what I think and what my ancestry is, for randomly filming in public and then editing just to show that Russia is multicultural and then asking questions about this topic.🧐
Я тоже из Бурятии и не вижу проблем в том, что эмигранты обсуждают проблемы нелегальной миграции. В российском обществе эта проблема стоит остро и, так как они желают стать частью нашей страны, их она так же напрямую касается
Thumbs down on your comment sir . Many Americans will be heading that way, and we won't be trying to change the culture. If she was Udmurt, should we just assume that she has red hair?
Russia isn't different from escandinavian countries if you're migrants arrive there without find work, the government isn't going to giving you anything, I knew it by my own... I.m European citizen who use to emigrate to Sweden and Denmark back 2010, looking for better life after 2008 , financial crisis, in Sweden they don't even look at you, and advised you to back to your country, in Denmark even you not going to find home to rent, even if you bank account is fat ,
I would be moving to Russia, to live in THAT culture. Russia is EVERYTHING the USA is NOT now. I would feel safer in Moscow, than in Earlington, Kentucky.
У нас ценятся все кто умеет делать хорошо свою работу. Всегда нужны строители и плотники- мы любим жить в красивых домах. Нужны повара- очень много ресторанов. Русские всю жизнь учат английский язык и никак не выучат- так что всегда нужны носители языка, нужны талантливые руководители, технологи, инженеры, химики, биологи, айтишники.. Россия огромная, нам всегда нужны хорошие люди.
What do you mean? There is legal path, and some people brake the rules so their stay are illegal, they are illegal immigrants. Those who abide the rules and do paperwork needed, are, on the other hand, legal immigrants...
I gotta admit, Igor, with all due respect, confused "russian" as a nation and "russian" as citizenship. It's really not fair to say that Muslim religion is part of the russian culture, as peoples who live in Russia and practice it are not russian by nationality. Tatar people for example, they have their own language, their own culture, they are HUUUUGE population wise. And if you call a tatar person "russian" , they would correct you with no hesitation. Its like calling "taking your shoes off when you enter the house" american culture, even though only certain ethnic and cultural groups practice this custom
It depends how you wanna think pf it, i do know that there are many minorkty groups, that what you can call russian community, or even russians.. not meaning that they are not actually tatars. I dont think ive said anything hurtful to these people
This is itself a big self-replicating myth that Russia needs more people: economy growth is not the most important thing in life. I don't care if the quantitive numbers of GDP they show to you go up if the country changed completely in terms of quality in pursuit of it, and is no longer my (ours) country anymore, which it used to be. Yes, sure, it's important to have a sufficient amount of young working force in a country, but the real problem is why we come to a point why we need foreigners to work instead of us. And it is low birth-rates of local people. If there is less Russians than used to be, then obviously economy won't be able to grow any further -- you see this undisputable fact, but then we get to decide what is more important: the people or the economy. With the first answer, you prioritize your own people and think how to change the situation with decline of autochthonous population. With the second answer, in pursuit of empty numbers you as a country consume foreign people component (without producing any more goods to the world or your people -- this process is simply redistribution of people masses between countries, together with power and ownage of lands and cultural course) and call it a growth. The only OK migration policy is when the immigrants don't get a citizenship and pay for all the expanses they bring with them to the country (such as healthcare and law), but judging by the video you were talking about naturalized immigrants as well. And we do have lots of problems on behalf of this here in Russia, just as do people in the West with the exploitation of their national welfare by the immigrants who at the end also will replace them. Check the situation in Britain. Besides, you know, there were times in the past when less people lived in Russia and it was fine -- though not optimal, I am the first to admit it; there should be more Russians, and we can't settle with the course modern times have set to all the peoples who went through the demographical turnaround. Though I am totally okay with the westerners of european descend who come to Russia in search of home: for y'all it is not that hard to assimilate and to accumulate Russian values, we have close enough cultures and there won't be any noticeble ethnic conflicts and shifts in the future generations.
exactly, it's a ridiculous globalist myths, though Russia unlike many other places has no overpopulation (territory-wise, resources-wise, things-to-do-wise - i.e. educationally, industirally, etc.) and won't suffer, can allow, etc. if right people come, and can benefit from that (as some additional unnecessary benefit, sort of luxury or something like that, some extra- stuff to gain and/or to ensure the global balance and order of things properly, to help others at least but not the last, as Russia has always been the most generous fabulous and benevolent saviour of the world, folks and entire civilisations, the moral leader, a unique case in world's history after all)
@@expatamerican3234 States always need more people - more people means more power, taxes, etc. No doubt. The problem is that a state and a country are somewhat different entities with to some extant different interests (even though ideally they should overlap), and that in the past states could 1) accumulate more power through inside growth of their own population (most important point), and 2) through imperialistic inclusion of neighbouring countries, giving them status of poddanstvo (not sure how to translate this accurately, basically "allegiance" towards state figure of King/Tsar; a form of light colonialism, or even a true rough colonialism). The latter could establish transparent relationships between every nationality/ethnos and the state, and the former point was making sure that the state remains majorily driven by the interests and in the name of its original people, having strong support of state power in native people. In case of Russia they are the Russians, the east slavic people, and in times of the Russian Empire it was also largely tied to being Orthodox Christian. But getting back to modern times, nowadays: 1) almost all first world states are struggling with the first point: birth-rates are as low as 1.4 per woman as for Russia, with minimally acceptable in order to have sustainability being 2.1; which leads to problems with ability to have natural growth in power from natives, and which leads to governors seeking alternative ways for the state to grow more potent. And 2) empires as a concept are no more, with the mobility of people has been being increased and the common accent of thought has been being shifted from ethnical thinking to nationalistic or even to liberal, leading to it being easier to absorb new people by citizenship when by including them as ruled states with preserved and to some extant separated culture and society. Multiculturalism and free-border policy are forms of new colonialism, but with the only people who get bonuses being the ruling class and the migrants, and not the ruling class and the natives whom they rule, like it was in the past centuries. Thank God that the Russian government is not fully corrupted be self-interests of "motherlandless" money bags and by ideological bullshit of bad faith actors... not yet, at least. Hoping for changes for the best.
Generally-speaking, do You-Joe think 'free speech' in Russia. is limited, when talking about 'illegal immigrants'? In the UsA there is the *1st Ammendment* of the US Constitution, found in the auxillary *Bill of Rights*. So, what is the difference, between Russia & UsA? Can You truely speak your mind or, self-censor?
It is a good question I have been turning in my head because the USA has on paper the right to Free Speech but I feel less restricted in my speech here. And on the channel of I ever feel I need to watch my words it is because of the algorithm and not Russia.
Immigration both legal and illegal has caused a loss of culture in the United States. There are fewer accents today and they are all becoming one with no central point or cultural background in which to build. It is very sad when a country's culture is diminished or no longer exists.
@@expatamerican3234 And a very real fear! illegal immigration is occurring all over the World today. It is out of control in the United States. The United States may be big but not big enough to take on the whole World. Russia is in a better situation as they seem to have illegal immigration under control and partly because people fear entering the Country. They have no fear of entering the United States, as they will be provided a free room in a Hotel or Motel with meals provided and all free. It is hard to believe the United States is using the tax payer's money to provide free living spaces and food for illegals entering the Country while homeless camps abound all over the Country in every major City and even small towns all the while Citizen's are living in cardboard boxes and tents.
7:30 - Все что нужно знать о бомжах финах которые приезжают бухать в Карелию. | All you need to know about finish people, only come to Karelia and drink vodka, drink wiskey drink everything whats burn.
@@OnlyThis-1 It was not meant to put down Russian people! But non of video I see any! I was there in 80s and it has Flourished. If I was not in my 60s with infermities I would go back in a Flash!
Начнём с того, что то, что происходит внутри России не ваше дело. Молчать и не вякать. Приехал в чужую страну, восхищайся, без обсуждения. У вас есть своя страна, её проблемы обсуждайте. А русские сами разберутся. Без вас.
Where are you from? And since I am married to a Russian raising Russian children will I ever be allowed to have an opinion or should I be resigned to being a second class citizen for the rest of my life?
@@expatamerican3234 The longer you keep narcissistically emphasizing that you are an American, the longer you will remain second-class in Russia...🤦🏼♂️ Isn't it so obvious?🤷🏼♂️
This gentleman is not really well informed about immigrant situation in Russia. Russia is close to having the same shitty situation as some western countries
@@Droomerz-nl8dp oh really, please do tell. How well some of the western countries doing when it comes to immigration, both “legal” and illegal. No issues at all? Want me to name a few?
@@fraochflanagan-km1ou there should be some policies and ways to integrate migrants. Every (almost every) car share driver from Central Asia in Moscow, was quite well educated and able to maintain interesting discussion. I also see lots of intermarriages in Moscow and their kids-they look great. Mixed people are awesome.
Если ваша культура бедная то любой иммигрант её обогатит. Наша культура в таком опылении не нуждается. У нас 200 народов и народностей. Мы сами кого Хочешь опылим по полной
@@user-jo4hq8ks8n это не так. Я жил много лет в мультикультурных обществах. Они гораздо интереснее монокультурных, в которых я тоже жил помногу лет, где кроме хуторского обихода ничего другого нет. Например Великобритания. Там интересные кулинарные традиции. Но без восточных или южных европейских культур великобритания вряд ли привлекала национальной кухней. Ведь там даже рост биф приготовят без соли и перца, не говоря уж о пряностях. А итальянцы, готовя ростед биф, обязательно добавят пряности.
@@user-oh7sx8qr4t И, между прочим, это так и есть. Так как все это организовано по очень схожим сценариям и под копирку с некоторыми локальными нюансами.
I watch another Russian channel on here and outside of cities there is extreme poverty, no jobs and poor care for the elderly left in abandoned towns. Towns that used to be 'Farming' towns where they grew their food communialy and then sold the surplus to Russia at large. These people including the disabled, elderly and veterans etc are forgotten. So while Russian cities may be great the REST of the country struggle. They don't have even basics like doctors or grocery stores etc. They have food stores that are vans delivering basic goods to the elderly. There should be an effort to get back to basics where your countries food is grown in Russia where EVERY place has the basic needs of citizens met. Basic human needs should be provided to ALL Russians not just City Dwellers. I'm just saying. Russian cities maybe beautiful and lovely but there's the REST of the Country virtually abandoned.
So True Ms.Norths. Russia has one of the greatest potential to be the top economy in the world. And hopelfully when it works on it, the economic benefits shall get distributed across the populace.
Not true. It is improving at at a slower pace than large cities, but improving everywhere. Life is also easier in the country where by law, citizens have a 30% discount on energy costs. Country podcast checkup
@@Ms.Norths.Musings small towns near big cities are actually okay, but those in the middle of nowhere actually something like that. Though it is considered economically unviable to develop it somehow, big agricultural farms cultivate land and there is no more need in this amount of people with their private small farms. More than that, sometimes small towns were built around factories, most of which closed after USSR dissolution. USSR economy donated hugely in autarchy and so many local manufacturers were actually subsidised, now there is free market and most of production much cheaper to import from elsewhere, from china for example. Developing national manufacturing requires a lot of protection measures and subsidising, which would lead to high prices and low quality for many years, and also all this is against free market.
There are plenty of vagrants and homeless in Moscow. The scale I can compare to, is late 90's early 00's Toronto level homeless and beggars. BOMZ Bez = Without Opredeljionovo = Defined Mjesto = Place Dzjidelstva = Living
@@expatamerican3234 Know Broadview park? Was there ever a homeless encampment there? I mean there was always a homeless village under the Danforth-Blur bridge... but now it spilled over.... Another place in Etobicoke, off the higway, there was a turn to a hotel, and a bunch of trees and bushes planted. Usually you'd have one or two tents there camping. This summer there was a dozen. It must have got so bad for the neighbourhood, that they had to clear cut all the brush to displace them... and the nature of the homeless has changed. in the 00's a lot of the homeless were vagrant alternative culture kids... now its different. i'll just leave it at that.
Really interesting, different points of view enriches knowledges!!
Glad you enjoyed it
I pray Russia never makes the mistakes of the west. They need people who will respect their culture and assimilate, not bring their old life. Learn the language and educate their children, if not leave. Thank you for another informative video
Thank you
the central asian migrant crisis there is pretty bad tbh. some groups are lobbying the government to do it. i can only imagine it being much worse in EU countries.
@@zombieseezombiedo It is terrible is this bananarepublic of turdeauland. Along with crime, lack of housing and high food and taxes it is unsustainable.
@@fraochflanagan-km1ou sorry to hear it
Immigrants in the past learned the native language primarily through television programs presented in the native language.
Today immigrants get cable programs with programming in all sorts of foreign languages which provides no incentive for an individual to learn the native language in the Country they are residing.
So here’s the thing, to live in Russia you have to jump through hoops, like learning the language, and being tested on it, being financially independent, if you don’t work, you don’t get to be paid. Values, the state, the family, and if you commit crime you get punished.
So we know if Canadian family moved and are building a home, a farm, and going through the hoops, just like some Australian families. If you fail at the tests etc, you are not allowed to stay, etc.
where as in UK we are getting 700 people a day land on the beach, getting housed, money, etc. the vast majority are fighting aged men.
We have cities that are more than 50% ethnic, and there is no integration, or respecting the host countries laws, values.
Yet as you say in Russia you have 152 different ethnic groups, but all respect Russian laws,the state.
I hope that Russia remains stable, and that communities stay strong and prosperous.
Почему это сделали в Англии. Это же против народа. Почему это продолжают . какие уроды у вам во власти . нужна революция в Англии.
Because those different groups are there naturally, been living for millenia in those boundaries and in such formations, having no other land to live in
I am pretty sure not all respect Russia. There are definitely criminals in Russia. Crime is in any given society so it doesn’t make sense to assume Russia is completely different.
@@svensulzmann4282 there's such a thing as proportions, shares, etc. and that thing matters
😢
President Putin is doing a very hard job to save cultures and peace for all various Ethnics - they are all Russian and love their motherland🇷🇺🙏
Лента Креста Святого Георгия не в честь победы. Это в честь героизма, отваги, мужества, воли к победе и в честь боя не на жизнь, а на смерть. А также знак Гвардии. Знак беззаветной преданности.
Thanks for sharing this.
смешал в кучу гвардейскую ленту и георгиевскую . подмену совершили лет 10 назад. все захавали. а теперь вот даже поправляют шарящих иностранцев. все верно сказано. георгиевская лента в честь святого георгия. гвардейская за подвиги. в царской россии давали георгиевскую, в сссровской гвардейскую. в современной все смешалось в кучу
And it stands for fire and smoke
@@Igorinrussia да, именно так и написано в статуте этой награды российской империи.
Игорь вообще не знает что такое русская культура. Не понимает разницы между культурой российской, включающей в себя культуры всех народов России и культурой этнической русской в триединстве русского народа. Странный выбор эксперта агностиком. Видимо главным критерием выбора является знание английского языка.
Джо не политолог, он пригласил в видео просто чела, которого он знает лично.
Exactly.🤣We are just 2 westerners talking about a hot topic. Again the show is in English to show westerners what is going on here. For them this will be interesting. For a Russian I don’t know but I’m grateful for Russians that want to watch.
@@expatamerican3234
If you don't get the point, you better go back asap...
@@Sergey_Bezhentsev I’m grateful for you too.🤣
Российская культура? Что-то новенькое. Типа "советский народ"?
Wow. It's beautiful there.
It really is!
Joe, are we allowed to share your videos on other social media sites? I like your videos, and you always present a fair , (to both sides) unbiased view from a personal account. You have done some awesome videos. I dont like to share unless I ask permission first.
Thanks from
Michigan
Please do! Just click the share button and copy link and post it everywhere of course. 😉
Фин очень неправ. Русская культура - это Русская Православная Славянская культура и именно она сейчас под угрозой беспредельной миграции Средней Азии. Приезжие даже если они не агрессивны намерены русских и культуру сделая из России ту же жопу как та из которой они приехали. Есть другие народы России но они не являются угрозой русскому миру так как те которые в своё время убивали русских и гнали их со своей землёй ю, это бывшие Республики Средней Азии, а теперь намерена выселить русских из России тоже.
This is the same issue that Texas has with California. California has gone to shit so people are fleeing from there to other states. But when they stay in Texas some of them want to keep thinking and doing the same way that broke California. And Texas aint having it. They want Californians to learn the Texan ways that made Texas prosperous.
Hi! There is a resident of Moscow here. I would like to clarify a few points. Now in our country there is something like a similar migration crisis like in Europe and the United States, which everyone knows about, but it proceeds very implicitly and therefore people gradually began to get used to it. The authorities are trying to do something about it, but they missed the moment somewhat and now the crime rate, including for serious criminal offenses, has increased significantly. Nevertheless, residents began to organize themselves into various volunteer communities to restore order, organize raids on illegal migrant sites, and help fight corruption as much as possible. At the moment, the situation remains difficult and it is not clear what will happen next, since there are strong pro-migrant corrupt lobbies in the government and no one seems to be fighting them much, which may end badly.
"strong pro-migrant corrupt lobbies in the government" - this is scary.
What do you think will happen after Putin is gone?
@@user-xfb3ni9pq He will leave only in 2030, it is very difficult to say what will happen by that time. I think there will be a warming of relations with the West on the foreign policy scene by this time, but I cannot imagine what will happen inside Russia. I think everything will be about the same and significant changes will begin to occur only after 2030, it depends on who Putin chooses as his successor and a huge number of factors.
Thanks for all these details.
You talking nonsense, don't mistaken parliament , (DUMA), and government, authorities taking all under control, thousands of emigrants was deported from Russia.
hi does Russia accept like skilled migrants like software engineers
7:12 The St. George ribbon was not invented for Victory Day, but back in 1769 by Catherine the Great when she established the corresponding order.
S nami Bog!
Yes. I didn’t mean to say it was created for Victory Day. It has been adopted I would say.
Yes was prt of russian imperial army traditions
Кстати в 1769 году США ещё не было
Geez look how clean those sidewalks and subway are!!! 😮
Indeed its night and day compare to us here in Montreal,Québec lolll
Russia is one of the cleanest countries in the world!Japan and Russia I would say
Thanks for all the comments
Я живу в Санкт-Петербурге. Не центр, юго- запад города, 50 лет домам спального района. И у меня вопрос. А может быть иначе? Не представляю даже, что может быть мусор на улицах. У нас нет мешков с мусором рядом с домами и зданиями. Это правда, я иду по улице и даже одной бумажки не вижу. Чисто
@@user-lk3nk1oq5g sadly, in America, we have people who throw their personal trash out the window of their car while driving, people will change a baby diaper in the car and then toss it out the window while driving. There is no respect at all. Walking down the street, they will throw cups, empty bags, food containers etc they eat while walking and dump trash while walking. We, my siblings and I were not raised that way, and if we ever did that , our pops would physically spank us and then make us go clean it up. We raised our kids the same.
Brawo ,beautiful ROSJA
Thanks!
@@mariatkaczyk4531 ROSSIJA 👌
Small correction. In percentage terms, Muslims are much smaller than Christians. There are a small number of territories where the indigenous faith is Islam. And Russians are against importing people with a different culture. After all, Muslims are also very different. There are aggressive fanatics. And wild peoples.
Why would you put one group of people into one category? Do you know all Muslims around the world? There are many Muslim fanatics but there are also many Christian fanatics.
@@Boznaniacwhy don’t you go have a cup of coffee in a beautiful morning in gaza? Try that😂
@@ervinreyes6302 Why would I? Im not from Gaza nor am I a Muslim...
@@Boznaniac
>>> Why would you put one group of people into one category?
LOL
just because it's one group of people.
another group of people will fall to another category.
Check the new laws on immigration, police have the right to deport without a court hearing, second reading already in Duma. Legal immigration is needed and encouraged.
@@derrickmoriarty7600 I'll move there.
I think if you go to abandoned Russian space station with two shuttles like baldandbankrupt you are guaranteed to get deported haha. I didn't even know we had an abandoned shuttle space station until I saw a video of him going inside there. I think it qualifies as a military secret area.
Путин подписал закон только о репатриации.Никаких законов о поощрении миграции не существует,наоборот в Госдуме неоднократно ставился и ставится вопрос о запрете вообще любой эмиграции в Россию Пока это предложение отложено,но рано или поздно к нему вернуться.Путин ставил вопрос только о приглашении из-за рубежа специалистов,которых можно будет потом поменять на своих при увеличении числа выпускников российских ВУЗов,что бы потом вообще можно было отказаться от приглашения любых специалистов из-за рубежа.ниокакомпоощрении миграции ,речь не шла и не идёт.Наоборот,чтобы уменьшить число желающих переехать в Россию,Госдумой и принят закон об обязательной постановке на воинский учёт,как тех граждан,кто получил гражданство и до сих пор не стоит на воинском учёте,так и тех, из иностранных граждан,кто в будущем хочет стать гражданином РФ Паспорт гражданина РФ будет выдаваться вместе с автоматической постановкой на воинский учёт и,те кто не стал на воинский учёт также автоматически лишается гражданства РФ.Закон подписан Путиным несколько дней назад.
Interesting
@@ColKorn1965 do so, gladly welcome! Proceed calmly and patiently, and everything will be alright! Russian are quiet people.
That's me in the corner
That's me in the spotlight
Losing my culture...
😎Exactly!
Два "экспата" рассуждают о БОМЖ'ах и алкашах... один в пластиковых тапках на босу ногу (уверен он так же и в ресторан ходит) другой в обшарпаной кожанке. Если б я выискивал по Москве алкашей, обратил бы внимание на этих двух типчиков в первую очередь! 🤣🤣
Примерно так))
Вы из ЦИПСО? Или просто желчегонного лучше курс пройдите, если се же не оттуда.. Сколько в вас негатива.
@@HomeMade_Polysynth а у вас слишком много желания целовать каждую англосаксонскую задницу. Впрочем не только у вас. Вас тут таких много
My footwear is leather.😎
@@expatamerican3234God bless you Joseph and Igor. Ignore people like this
Gonna have an interesting talk once again!
Yes! Absolutely.
I think a discussion would be more interesting with the boorish birther moderator of this channel (sFilin) involved...
@@Sergey_Bezhentsev I’m intrigued but I do not exactly understand what you mean.
I'm In Igor! Sweden here...
@@Christopher-cf6wm heja Sverige!
I enjoyed this video. 😊❤
Thanks
Hello!
Nice
Thanks
Imagine being a citizen of a country (USA) that was founded and built by immigrants.... complaining about immigrants 😂
Поэтому там полный бардак
@@user-jo4hq8ks8nit actually isn’t a complete mess just come and check for yourself. Yosemite area is beautiful.
I do not think I’m complaining.
@@expatamerican3234 not at all. I was referring to my other fellow Americans who do complain about immigrants
@@miguelohara-mo5xw 💪🏻😎Got it.
Nice city, nice people ❤
Thanks!
EXCELLENT VIDEO.
Thank you very much!
When I am there Russia's culture suffers🤣 because I'm uncultured
Har bloody har.
Very funny
No for Central Asians and Yes for Europeans.
А кто такие "европейцы"? Наполеон, Гитлер, Бербок это европейцы?
Based
@@user-jo4hq8ks8n Уер, they were outstanding Europeans.
@@Svyatayarus actual stance of most russians on immigration issue
@@Svyatayarus actual stance of most russians on immigration issue
Joseph, you are so wasp American, refined and picky... The outgoing rulers of the globe
Maybe. Where are you from and what is your position in life?
@@expatamerican3234 like the majority of russian housewives, i think it's great for a person to have a homeland, to stay within its borders and to love it independent of its prosperity. But if some righteous (even though consumerism oriented) foreigners come round, we don't mind
@@arinaf4515 thank you.🙏 The outgoing rulers need to retire somewhere.🤷🏼♂️😁
@@arinaf4515 it's odd that you would be picking on Joseph calling him a wasp. Joseph,, she's calling you a white Anglo-Saxon Protestant. Very odd, considering she might be Russian
Is Russia culture being dilutes or changed owing to immigration etc. I have never been even near Russia. I was raised on the Western side of that "Iron Curtain" - propagandised from birth by the USA and UK. But I view Russian / Ukrainian movies online, and follow content on RUclips. Based on that, it seems to me that since 1990, the ex-Soviets have grown to afford the Western culture and USA in particular with way more respect and envy that they should. So I see so much of the West adopted by the Russian population. I really enjoy seeing Russians celebrating what they are, who they are, and their ancestors who protected their intermittence. But maybe well intention Western EXPATS also influence Russia. Be careful, because I expect that in Russia rests the future of CIVILISATION. I am really old, and the western system has winners and losers - I am have lost all in the Western family court, so can not move, nor could I be an asset to Russia - else, I would emigrate in a flash.
Thanks for a detailed comment
If you lose the ethnic Slavic Russian as dominant, you lose the Russian culture. Period. This sort of thing is very obviously true.
В Конституцию РФ недавно внесли поправку о том что этнические русские являются народом, формирующим государство.
@@user-jo4hq8ks8n государствообразующим, с "особой ролью Православия"
You lose Russia as a civilizational phenomenon.
@@Droomerz-nl8dp я намеренно изменил формулировку для того чтобы робот перевёл корректно на английский язык
@@Droomerz-nl8dp но смысл сохранил
❤❤❤. With love 💘 and respect from Mozambique 🇲🇿.
💪🏻😎
Russia is multicultural country since it's existence 1200 years ago, the problem is in Russia they are tolerant against each other's, there racism of course, but not segregated like USA
Interesting
how come 85% population Russians makes country multicultural,
but 85% of one ethnicity in any other country (e.g. Hungary) makes country mono-national?
hint: bolsheviks and Lenin specifically made this narrative to destroy Russian Empire, split it into many independent countries.
then communists continue pushing this narrative to destroy USSR, split it into more countries.
now this narrative still repeated again and again for RF.
Guess what going to be the result?
btw Igor, Sweden is here ;) :)
Thanks for saying Hello! Join us in the live chat.
Sweden has been in Russia, aka the Rus, since the Viking age
@@edwardsisk3253 Нет. Швеция никогда не была в составе Руси. Финляндия была в составе Российской Империи и Польша.
@@user-dz9vt4dg9y please watch the full Tucker Carlson / Vladimir Putin interview. The Russian president clearly outlines the beginnings of Russia, as being influenced by Swedish Vikings., did you not know that Swedish Vikings, mostly, came down the rivers capturing slaves, AKA Slavs, and sold their Quarry in Constantinople. Please learn history before attempting to teach me, thank you very much.
@@user-dz9vt4dg9y you are wrong. Simply watch the Tucker Carlson / Vladimir Putin interview, where Vlad schools Tucker on the history of Russia
Россия это в первую очередь христианская страна белых людей 😊
I watched 👀 this video 📹. Good one. 👍
Glad you enjoyed it
Good man!
@@Igorinrussia thanks - how's weather in Saint Petersburg today? Raining, I guess 😉
@@olegzaytsev5997 always
Бомж (bomzh) stands for "без определенного места жительства", or "without fixed place of living". It's a coincidence that the abbreviation sounds like a natural word for a rugged unwashed homeless person.
🤣Very interesting. Thanks
Yep thats the one!
Can you interview me too. Thanks for another great video. From Ron in the Philippines
I interviewed you already.😁 Your short is popular BUT do you have more to say? Text me.
@@expatamerican3234 we will do another interview soon. I always have more to say
@@DyadyaRona great
Here in Melbourne theres a place called Dandenong with lots of muslims and immigrants and theres a shopping centre there which is very similar to the Russian shopping centre and the song reminded me of an Australian shopping centre.
Interesting
Igor speaks perfect Russian and simplified English, like the majority of Russians living abroad, but likes to think about himself that he is something else.
But do you like him?
@@expatamerican3234Of course we do. It's just that some people that think that "freedom of speech" makes it obligatory to air one's opinion about everything without being asked to.😊
@@expatamerican3234 I have nothing against Igor, but I prefer honest bloggers like you.
I guess thats a personal matter who thibks of himself what. Im pretty satisfied with what i think of myself thank u.
Dunno how u got dishonesty into this 😂
@Igorinrussia Igor, I have nothing against you. I watch your videos sometimes. But your native language is Russian, not English. There is no need to pretend it's not so.
Great video! Expat American do you speak Russian and if so what level? What is your means of income, unless you’re a full time youtuber?
As for illegal immigration, I think the situation in Russia is a lot less severe than western countries. In Russia there doesn’t seem to be a lot of identity politics and political correctness.
Верно, но мы убираем всю нелегальную, сейчас очень серьёзные возмущения в обществе, примитивные азиаты себя показали плохо со своим исламом, поэтому их убирают уже сейчас, но работы в этом еще много. Ну а в Англии с этим ужас, там ужасная трагедия и политики похоже ничего с этим не делают.
I am full time with this. Thanks!
@@expatamerican3234 and do you speak Russian?
@@OnlyThis-1 считайте, что вам повезло! Так как вам не проходится иметь дело с чернокожими и южными соседями америки!
@@hansschwartz1480 sorry. Yes and no. I’m like a 6 year old. I’m taking my lessons. You can hear me speak it in the previous Soviet Cafe video.
Those are sandals, Joseph.
Thanks! I assumed maybe they were a certain type of sandal.
@@expatamerican3234 heh heh, birkenstocks, romans?
One does not move to Russia to change their culture. It smacks of what the US Army and military forces did in Afghanistan for 20 years. I should mention that in regard to Legal immigration
That is me on my telephone account, Joseph, lol.
Got it.💪🏻😎
They needs to be wise on that: they needs to bring people from all around the world for workforce BUT only if they shared Russian values and if they do something illegal or committ any crime they have to be bring up as an example like they did with the terrorists arrested for the atrocity committed some months ago. They have to preserve their nation, their history and their values and not commit the same mistakes that western societies did.
11:23 БОМЖ = человек Без Определенного Места Жительства, буквальная аббревиатура советских времен когда необходима было иметь запись об официальной прописке по месту жительства в паспорте. Человек, ночующий на земле или на лавочке на улице/вокзале где-нибудь в Москве в те времена практически неизбежно привлекал внимание патрулирующих эти места милиционеров которые прежде всего проверяли документы и запись о прописке. Сильно пьяных и вызывающего поведения, не предъявивших документы - забирали в милицейское отделение или сдавали в медвытрезвитель, но не оставляли замерзать на улице.
Thanks for these details.
I like the cleaness in Russia. It shows they are a people of good charachter. If I eas jung I would move to Russia!
It is a very good sign.
I wish I could retire and move to Russia. Hows the catholic church there?
There are 4 in Moscow.
Спасибо за видео😊
Thanks for commenting.
St, George patron saint of Russia
А ещё святой Андрей Первозванный. А ещё Богородица. А ещё сам Бог. Потому что врагом России является сам сатана.
Thanks
S nami Bog!
Ещё 120 лет назад Россия была христианской, а только с недавнего времени в России приезжают потоком мусульмане, для России это не традиционная религия, была малая совсем часть мусульман всегда в России, это только с недавнего времени в России увеличивается число мусульман, это вообще не традиционно для России, поэтому ставить христианство и мусульманство в России на один уровень и говорить что это как то было ещё в прошлом традиционно,это не правильно
Thanks for the details.
BOMZh - A person without permanent living place
Thanks
how many people are in moscow? 20 million? Google says 11-13 million 5k density per square km. Or its registed to live and the rest 9-7 million are in transit, visitors, and gastrobiters workers from abroad?
Both. Plus there's the "administrative boundaries" and reality on the ground, when you cross the road and are already in administrative limits of Moscow, while you might be registered and permanently residing on the opposit side of the road, i.e. in some regional town or village, which get engulfed as Moscow grows, and those administrative borders change or often lag behind the actual reality on the ground
Thanks for the question and answer. Yes. It is a matter of what is inside the technical boundaries and what is in the greater Moscow area.
Yes and in russia you must register to be counted as a person living in the city. Many dont change that so there are possibly millions people not registered to moscow. Saint pete for example is propably 7mil instead of 5
Какова площадь города Москва?
Бизнес млжно открыть за пол часа если будешь обращаться специализированную юридическую контору и это будет стоить не так дорого.
Thanks for the information. What is the connection to the video?
He means your "sliders" - the style of sandals you're wearing.
Thanks.😉
haha yes
I think illegal immigration needs to be controlled. However, there is no way to get to 0 because people who are desperate enough will always find a way. I don’t think loss of culture is a problem because that isn’t really happening it’s not like culture vanishes it changes. The real problem with illegal immigration are in my opinion drug and weapon smuggling, gang crime, human trafficking.
Thanks for sharing this.
You know, for russian even that words 'illegal immigration should be controlled' spoken as an opinion sounds absurd. Like, is so obvious - if it's illegal it is crime, and crime should be controlled 😅 I mean it is so crazy someone even consider that it shouldn't
@svensulzmann4282 Потеря культуры -это лично для Вас не является проблемой. Для нас это не приемлемо!
@@user-dz9vt4dg9ywhy how do you loose culture exactly?
I don't see any obese people in the frame..
❤from🇨🇦
There are much less.
Обожаю твои видео! 👍
Thanks so much!
Привет друг.Видел твою жену на 1 Канале! Она становится известной!Поздравляю!))
Hello from the Eastern Siberia - Republic of Buryatia, few remarks: 1. You're a foreigner in our country and you have no right to discuss this illegal immigration topic. 2. The foreigners you showed in the beginning of your video (for instance) a lady with a scarf on her head looks like a typical Dagestani lady she doesn't look like a migrant and she has more rights in our country than you definitely. She has a right to discuss why are your here since her ancestors have been Russian citizens for many centuries and defended this country. 3. Calling yourself "an expat" doesn't give you a right to discuss the rights of ex-ussr people to be here. It is not your level. 4. Before you film a lady with black hairs and put her in your video about illegal immigration at least you could ve asked her origins (might be she is from Yakutia republic) 5. I can perfectly understand if your release videos where you discuss your country. All in all my advise is just forget it do more subway videos.
You are making a lot of assumptions about what I think and what my ancestry is, for randomly filming in public and then editing just to show that Russia is multicultural and then asking questions about this topic.🧐
Я тоже из Бурятии и не вижу проблем в том, что эмигранты обсуждают проблемы нелегальной миграции. В российском обществе эта проблема стоит остро и, так как они желают стать частью нашей страны, их она так же напрямую касается
Thumbs down on your comment sir . Many Americans will be heading that way, and we won't be trying to change the culture. If she was Udmurt, should we just assume that she has red hair?
БОМЖ - homeless
Thanks
Russia isn't different from escandinavian countries if you're migrants arrive there without find work, the government isn't going to giving you anything, I knew it by my own... I.m European citizen who use to emigrate to Sweden and Denmark back 2010, looking for better life after 2008 , financial crisis, in Sweden they don't even look at you, and advised you to back to your country, in Denmark even you not going to find home to rent, even if you bank account is fat ,
Very interesting
Are you Greek by any chance?
I would be moving to Russia, to live in THAT culture. Russia is EVERYTHING the USA is NOT now. I would feel safer in Moscow, than in Earlington, Kentucky.
Thanks for sharing.
@@expatamerican3234 It's the honest truth, Joseph.
I'm more likely to die here, than I would be there. We've got more Nazis here in the USA than in Ukraine.
Well it wasn't really about illegal immigrants was it?
We are asking the question and answering for westerners that want to know how Russia compares to the west.
Awesome video! I wish I could move to Russia and be able to make a living. Idk what I’d do there lol
English speakers teach English or work in media.
У нас ценятся все кто умеет делать хорошо свою работу. Всегда нужны строители и плотники- мы любим жить в красивых домах. Нужны повара- очень много ресторанов. Русские всю жизнь учат английский язык и никак не выучат- так что всегда нужны носители языка, нужны талантливые руководители, технологи, инженеры, химики, биологи, айтишники.. Россия огромная, нам всегда нужны хорошие люди.
Прости, Джозеф. 9 минут просмотра... льём воду, болтовня ни о чём... не могу смотреть такую фигню.
У агностиков всегда избыток смысла
Remember these videos are to show Russia to the west but I’m glad that you enjoy some.
@@user-jo4hq8ks8nчто то у тебя какая-то зацикленность на агностиках странная в каждом комментарии
If it's illgal, how are you there?
And why are you still not there? If you are this cute lady in the pic, and hopefully a humourous one with that flat earth nickname
@@Droomerz-nl8dp I'm not a criminal. I'm also a 82 year old great grandfather.
What do you mean? There is legal path, and some people brake the rules so their stay are illegal, they are illegal immigrants. Those who abide the rules and do paperwork needed, are, on the other hand, legal immigrants...
@@msgn1132 What?
@@Flat_Earth_Addy you asked how Joseph is there if it's illegal, no?
Как же он похожа на немецкого актера по имени Тиль Швайгер.
Igor?
@@expatamerican3234 да))
I gotta admit, Igor, with all due respect, confused "russian" as a nation and "russian" as citizenship.
It's really not fair to say that Muslim religion is part of the russian culture, as peoples who live in Russia and practice it are not russian by nationality. Tatar people for example, they have their own language, their own culture, they are HUUUUGE population wise. And if you call a tatar person "russian" , they would correct you with no hesitation.
Its like calling "taking your shoes off when you enter the house" american culture, even though only certain ethnic and cultural groups practice this custom
It depends how you wanna think pf it, i do know that there are many minorkty groups, that what you can call russian community, or even russians.. not meaning that they are not actually tatars. I dont think ive said anything hurtful to these people
@@Igorinrussia no, of course not, it's just confusing to people in comments as well, and I think it gives Joe the wrong idea too.
This is itself a big self-replicating myth that Russia needs more people: economy growth is not the most important thing in life. I don't care if the quantitive numbers of GDP they show to you go up if the country changed completely in terms of quality in pursuit of it, and is no longer my (ours) country anymore, which it used to be.
Yes, sure, it's important to have a sufficient amount of young working force in a country, but the real problem is why we come to a point why we need foreigners to work instead of us. And it is low birth-rates of local people. If there is less Russians than used to be, then obviously economy won't be able to grow any further -- you see this undisputable fact, but then we get to decide what is more important: the people or the economy. With the first answer, you prioritize your own people and think how to change the situation with decline of autochthonous population. With the second answer, in pursuit of empty numbers you as a country consume foreign people component (without producing any more goods to the world or your people -- this process is simply redistribution of people masses between countries, together with power and ownage of lands and cultural course) and call it a growth. The only OK migration policy is when the immigrants don't get a citizenship and pay for all the expanses they bring with them to the country (such as healthcare and law), but judging by the video you were talking about naturalized immigrants as well. And we do have lots of problems on behalf of this here in Russia, just as do people in the West with the exploitation of their national welfare by the immigrants who at the end also will replace them. Check the situation in Britain. Besides, you know, there were times in the past when less people lived in Russia and it was fine -- though not optimal, I am the first to admit it; there should be more Russians, and we can't settle with the course modern times have set to all the peoples who went through the demographical turnaround.
Though I am totally okay with the westerners of european descend who come to Russia in search of home: for y'all it is not that hard to assimilate and to accumulate Russian values, we have close enough cultures and there won't be any noticeble ethnic conflicts and shifts in the future generations.
exactly, it's a ridiculous globalist myths, though Russia unlike many other places has no overpopulation (territory-wise, resources-wise, things-to-do-wise - i.e. educationally, industirally, etc.) and won't suffer, can allow, etc. if right people come, and can benefit from that (as some additional unnecessary benefit, sort of luxury or something like that, some extra- stuff to gain and/or to ensure the global balance and order of things properly, to help others at least but not the last, as Russia has always been the most generous fabulous and benevolent saviour of the world, folks and entire civilisations, the moral leader, a unique case in world's history after all)
It is something to think about. Does a country not really need more people?🧐 Thanks for your detailed opinion.
@@expatamerican3234 States always need more people - more people means more power, taxes, etc. No doubt. The problem is that a state and a country are somewhat different entities with to some extant different interests (even though ideally they should overlap), and that in the past states could 1) accumulate more power through inside growth of their own population (most important point), and 2) through imperialistic inclusion of neighbouring countries, giving them status of poddanstvo (not sure how to translate this accurately, basically "allegiance" towards state figure of King/Tsar; a form of light colonialism, or even a true rough colonialism). The latter could establish transparent relationships between every nationality/ethnos and the state, and the former point was making sure that the state remains majorily driven by the interests and in the name of its original people, having strong support of state power in native people. In case of Russia they are the Russians, the east slavic people, and in times of the Russian Empire it was also largely tied to being Orthodox Christian.
But getting back to modern times, nowadays: 1) almost all first world states are struggling with the first point: birth-rates are as low as 1.4 per woman as for Russia, with minimally acceptable in order to have sustainability being 2.1; which leads to problems with ability to have natural growth in power from natives, and which leads to governors seeking alternative ways for the state to grow more potent. And 2) empires as a concept are no more, with the mobility of people has been being increased and the common accent of thought has been being shifted from ethnical thinking to nationalistic or even to liberal, leading to it being easier to absorb new people by citizenship when by including them as ruled states with preserved and to some extant separated culture and society.
Multiculturalism and free-border policy are forms of new colonialism, but with the only people who get bonuses being the ruling class and the migrants, and not the ruling class and the natives whom they rule, like it was in the past centuries. Thank God that the Russian government is not fully corrupted be self-interests of "motherlandless" money bags and by ideological bullshit of bad faith actors... not yet, at least. Hoping for changes for the best.
Why does it sound, like You are saying eager instead of Igor? 😂
Hahah i noticed too 😂
@@Igorinrussia I would have been correcting him repeatedly 😁
🤣I thought I had to say it this way in Russian.🤷🏼♂️
Here we go again. It's how it's pronounced, in Russian. Just like Ivan it's not pronounced like it is in the West
@@expatamerican3234 oh! Now i get it
Generally-speaking, do You-Joe think 'free speech' in Russia. is limited, when talking about 'illegal immigrants'? In the UsA there is the *1st Ammendment* of the US Constitution, found in the auxillary *Bill of Rights*. So, what is the difference, between Russia & UsA? Can You truely speak your mind or, self-censor?
It is a good question I have been turning in my head because the USA has on paper the right to Free Speech but I feel less restricted in my speech here. And on the channel of I ever feel I need to watch my words it is because of the algorithm and not Russia.
Free speech in US is gone long time ago.Try speaking against LGBT
In Russia, you may speak of all kinds of things, except trying to change the political power forcibly by ideological, religious or social violence.
@@watchdog3301 You can change political power by voting but why would they replace Putin The Great?I would vote for him everyday
What's the sense in changing a good reliable leader by someone unknown?
For sure is loosing
Immigration both legal and illegal has caused a loss of culture in the United States.
There are fewer accents today and they are all becoming one with no central point or cultural background in which to build.
It is very sad when a country's culture is diminished or no longer exists.
This is my fear
@@expatamerican3234 And a very real fear! illegal immigration is occurring all over the World today. It is out of control in the United States. The United States may be big but not big enough to take on the whole World. Russia is in a better situation as they seem to have illegal immigration under control and partly because people fear entering the Country. They have no fear of entering the United States, as they will be provided a free room in a Hotel or Motel with meals provided and all free.
It is hard to believe the United States is using the tax payer's money to provide free living spaces and food for illegals entering the Country while homeless camps abound all over the Country in every major City and even small towns all the while Citizen's are living in cardboard boxes and tents.
Эксперт вообще не понравился,неприятная личность.
Just pretend I am the expert in this one.😉
7:30 - Все что нужно знать о бомжах финах которые приезжают бухать в Карелию. | All you need to know about finish people, only come to Karelia and drink vodka, drink wiskey drink everything whats burn.
I will let Igor comment on this.😎
One thing I do not see in Russia is Laughter!
Смеха или резиновых одноразовых улыбок на лицах прохожих?
В цирке много смеха, в кинотеатре, в детских парках много смеха.
Да много людей улыбаются, у каждого свой повод.
"Laughter without a reason is a sign of a fool", there's such a proverb
@@OnlyThis-1 It was not meant to put down Russian people!
But non of video I see any!
I was there in 80s and it has Flourished.
If I was not in my 60s with infermities I would go back in a Flash!
8:40 стоп кадр.
Why?
@expatamerican3234 8:40 There are two funny guys in the frame on the left.
Yes - Mosquebad is capital of Northern Uzbekiston.
Москва это столица СССР
you haven't had, or simply missed math at school altogether, right?
@@Droomerz-nl8dpor go see a doctor😂
Клизма 7вëдерная тебе уже не поможет.
Игорь русский?
Not on paper.
@@expatamerican3234yep
Начнём с того, что то, что происходит внутри России не ваше дело. Молчать и не вякать. Приехал в чужую страну, восхищайся, без обсуждения. У вас есть своя страна, её проблемы обсуждайте. А русские сами разберутся. Без вас.
Where are you from? And since I am married to a Russian raising Russian children will I ever be allowed to have an opinion or should I be resigned to being a second class citizen for the rest of my life?
@@expatamerican3234
The longer you keep narcissistically emphasizing that you are an American, the longer you will remain second-class in Russia...🤦🏼♂️ Isn't it so obvious?🤷🏼♂️
Хм! Простите, но я например так и не понял, о чём видио! Это очередной обзор метро и вокзалов в Москве!?
🤣No. Maybe if you live in Russia it is not so interesting. 🙏We are in English to show the west what Russia is.
hahah😂 who want go there
Top-3 (or actually 2) by the number of both migrants and refugees
This gentleman is not really well informed about immigrant situation in Russia. Russia is close to having the same shitty situation as some western countries
Which gentleman?😁
You are not well informed about "situation in some (all) western counries" to compare them even "close"
@@Droomerz-nl8dp oh really, please do tell. How well some of the western countries doing when it comes to immigration, both “legal” and illegal. No issues at all? Want me to name a few?
@@expatamerican3234 not you, Joseph 🙂
@@THEele7en you have no idea how much worse that is in the West on absolutely all levels from top to bottom, to compare those even remotely
Immigration benefits a lot. It enriches culture.
Thanks for commenting
Unfortunately it has backfired in this bananarepublic of turdeauland
@@fraochflanagan-km1ou there should be some policies and ways to integrate migrants. Every (almost every) car share driver from Central Asia in Moscow, was quite well educated and able to maintain interesting discussion. I also see lots of intermarriages in Moscow and their kids-they look great. Mixed people are awesome.
Если ваша культура бедная то любой иммигрант её обогатит. Наша культура в таком опылении не нуждается. У нас 200 народов и народностей. Мы сами кого Хочешь опылим по полной
@@user-jo4hq8ks8n это не так. Я жил много лет в мультикультурных обществах. Они гораздо интереснее монокультурных, в которых я тоже жил помногу лет, где кроме хуторского обихода ничего другого нет. Например Великобритания. Там интересные кулинарные традиции. Но без восточных или южных европейских культур великобритания вряд ли привлекала национальной кухней. Ведь там даже рост биф приготовят без соли и перца, не говоря уж о пряностях. А итальянцы, готовя ростед биф, обязательно добавят пряности.
Смешно , Игорь форинер с русским акцентом!
🤣Yes
@@expatamerican3234well i dont have russian accent tho,,, i do have some forwigner accent in my russian
Не существует таких мировых заговоров, которых подросток не мог бы разоблачить в интернете даже не вставая с дивана. 😆
@@user-oh7sx8qr4t И, между прочим, это так и есть. Так как все это организовано по очень схожим сценариям и под копирку с некоторыми локальными нюансами.
I watch another Russian channel on here and outside of cities there is extreme poverty, no jobs and poor care for the elderly left in abandoned towns. Towns that used to be 'Farming' towns where they grew their food communialy and then sold the surplus to Russia at large. These people including the disabled, elderly and veterans etc are forgotten. So while Russian cities may be great the REST of the country struggle. They don't have even basics like doctors or grocery stores etc. They have food stores that are vans delivering basic goods to the elderly. There should be an effort to get back to basics where your countries food is grown in Russia where EVERY place has the basic needs of citizens met. Basic human needs should be provided to ALL Russians not just City Dwellers. I'm just saying. Russian cities maybe beautiful and lovely but there's the REST of the Country virtually abandoned.
Total bs and you know it.
Oh yeah, watch and listen to as much western propaganda as u can. Make things turn upside down in your head.
So True Ms.Norths. Russia has one of the greatest potential to be the top economy in the world. And hopelfully when it works on it, the economic benefits shall get distributed across the populace.
Not true. It is improving at at a slower pace than large cities, but improving everywhere. Life is also easier in the country where by law, citizens have a 30% discount on energy costs. Country podcast checkup
@@Ms.Norths.Musings small towns near big cities are actually okay, but those in the middle of nowhere actually something like that. Though it is considered economically unviable to develop it somehow, big agricultural farms cultivate land and there is no more need in this amount of people with their private small farms. More than that, sometimes small towns were built around factories, most of which closed after USSR dissolution. USSR economy donated hugely in autarchy and so many local manufacturers were actually subsidised, now there is free market and most of production much cheaper to import from elsewhere, from china for example. Developing national manufacturing requires a lot of protection measures and subsidising, which would lead to high prices and low quality for many years, and also all this is against free market.
There are plenty of vagrants and homeless in Moscow. The scale I can compare to, is late 90's early 00's Toronto level homeless and beggars.
BOMZ
Bez = Without
Opredeljionovo = Defined
Mjesto = Place
Dzjidelstva = Living
Is this good or bad? I was not in Toronto then.
@@expatamerican3234 Know Broadview park? Was there ever a homeless encampment there? I mean there was always a homeless village under the Danforth-Blur bridge... but now it spilled over.... Another place in Etobicoke, off the higway, there was a turn to a hotel, and a bunch of trees and bushes planted. Usually you'd have one or two tents there camping. This summer there was a dozen. It must have got so bad for the neighbourhood, that they had to clear cut all the brush to displace them... and the nature of the homeless has changed. in the 00's a lot of the homeless were vagrant alternative culture kids... now its different. i'll just leave it at that.
@@zombieseezombiedo sad
More important to support Ukraine in its endeavors than worry about social issues within the Russian dictatorship
you truly support the fail because you are the fail you smell it and feel it like it's yours! haha
Are you actually doing parody right now?
@@Droomerz-nl8dp another parody maker.
Lose its culture? What are you talking about? Russia is a multi ethnic state. There are different cultures within Russia.
It can be multiethnic and still lose its culture.
❤❤❤. With love 💘 and respect from Mozambique 🇲🇿.
Thanks