@@jaipalsingh8931 bhai she's a woken, Don stop them from iskon too, jab woh log, periods, women's place compared to men etc, woh log khud hi samajh lenge
You are intelligent 😂😂😂😂Do you know that the one who says that he is very intelligent is the biggest fool in whole universe and you are the very big fool...😂
I am glad Hindus are realising it. I myself am atheist. In nacheyyo ko kya pta bhartiy darshan shastr ke bare me. Ek ne toh sidha swami Vivekananda pr hi durbhashy kr diya. Himmat toh dekho. In vaishnvo ne Bharat ka sar sharm se jhuka diya hai, desh videsh me. Nacheyye kahi ke.
Oh my dear brother what would I say to bibble and Quran is also important to prove that God is one who is the supreme personality of godhead Krishna In Muslim religion lord Krishna or Ram is called as Allah and in Christianity they called as christ
😂😂😂😂😂 🤣 krishna is a demigod 😂😂lol 😆 pakdandi pisconite. Adi Shakti, narayan and shiv are the supreme god😂😂. Not krishna lol . Average pisconiite 😂@@yatishsharma3699
गोरखपुर ऒर इस्कॉन दोनों दो दोनों best हें लेकिन सामने vala isckon से ही कृष्णा की बातो को समझ पायेगा ये मेरा दावा हें क्यू की गीताप्रेस के शब्द बहुत हार्ड हें सबको समझ नहीं आता बहोत ज्यादातर पढ़े लिखो को भी नहीं. ❤
@@RaamAudio Asaan chez zaruri nahi acchi ho. Aap kisi granth ki transition nahi badal sakte. Ye to ek tarah se crime Homa chahiye. I know not everyone knows Sanskrit but Geeta press have Hindi translation too
@@nish8756 ट्रांसलेशन नहीं बदला हें लेकिन कर्म का महत्व कृष्णभावनायुक्त कर्म बताया हें ताकि जो कृष्णा चाहे वही हों, गीता में अर्जुन ने जमीन के लिये युद्ध नहीं किया था कृष्णा के लिये किया था तो गीता का सही ट्रांसलेशन यही होना चाहिए क्यू की उस समय ज्यादातर लोग भक्ति भाव में ही मग्न थे लेकिन सब की भक्ति करते थे कृष्णा ने कहा मुजमे ही सब हें ऒर मेरे लिये कर्म करो या मेरे लिये भक्ति करो दोनों सेम हें इसलिए गीता ज्ञान दिया लेकिन समय के हिसाब से लोगो का भक्ति से ही ध्यान भटक गया तब जाकर प्रभुपाद ने ट्रांसलेशन में कृष्णा जो कहना चाहते थे वो कलयुग के लोगो को नये युग के हिसाब से समझाया ऒर इसीलिए isckon की गीता पढ़ने kको बोला ताकि ये मैसेज घर घर पहुँच सके, प्रभुपाद यहाँ से प्रचार के लिये कुछ लेकर नहीं गएथे सब खुद कमा कर कृष्णा के लिये प्रचार करना पड रहा था लेकिन भारत में आज ऐसा एक भी संप्रदाय बताओ जो दान के पैसे के बगैर खुद के दम पर आगे बधा hहों... इसलिए isckon best हें प्रभुपाद का हिस्ट्री देख लो वहा क्या क्या हुआ... खुद ही isckon से प्यार हों जायेगा.. लेकिन aap नहीं समझोगे, कोई विरोधी नहीं समझ पायेगा कृष्णा के इस संघ को.... ऒर isckon के भी पहले से यहां रह रहे गुरुके चेले जो चैतन्यमहाप्रभुजी के जितने अनुयायी हें यहाँ के उनको पूछो की क्या isckon गलतहें??? कोई नहीं कहेगा की गलत he...
@@nish8756 iskcon gita ka prabhav dekhna hai to vrindavan jaao. jo jeevan badal de wo powerful hai. Baki shloka same hain. tippadi alag hai. isme comparision nahi hona chahiye, ye moorkhta hai.
@@dogbite-7 Kisi religious scriptures ki misleading translation is conspiracy. Tumhara logic ajeeb hai, agar koi nakli samaan manufacture karke jyada sale kar raha ho to use original maan lo. Vrindavan ho ya Vancouver, matter nahi karta. US mei bhi inhone networking karke bhakt banaye hain. Agar Krishna se itna pyar hai to uski translation kyu badal rahe ho. Maine khud ek inke followers ko challenge kiya tha, jo kehta tha hamari geeta sahi hai. Naa sirf maine use galat prove kiya, sath mei ye bhi kaha agar agge se kisi ki ye books mere area me sale ki to police complaint karunga.
7:09 Abe gadhe tum jo translation dikha rahe vo galat hei. Budhiyog ka matlab nahin pata. Yog matlab kya? Yog matlab ishwar se yog. So budhiyog in practical sense means hari ki budhi se prakashit hone wali buddhi. Apne satwa rajas tamas wali budhi nahin. Warna to allah wale bhi budhiyog kar rahe kafiron kon maarke. Krishna bhakti(samarpan) hui budhi matlab budhiyog. So iskcon ki translation sahi hei in practical sense. Tum log gadhe ho...koi practical knowledge to hei nahin. Aur kisi anpadh ka translation dikha rahe. Murkh pehle yog matlab samjho.
@@musicalmedicoanu8132sun bhai srimad Bhagavad Geeta Ramayan,ved or puran hindu dharm ka basic hai or isko koi bhi organisation badal Raha hai apne according to wo galat kar raha hai kyu ki aisa kane se aaj ka insan bhagwan or Rishi muniyo ke diye huye message ko nahi samjh payega ye iskon ka Geeta dekhne ke baad lag raha hai ki ye log Krishna ka MSG ni samjhna chahte hai balki sirf ye apna MSG samjhana chahte hai taki inki fayeda ho.
@@ShivamKumar-so5fuBhai sab Iskcon ke proponent Srila Prabhupada ji ka koi alagh duniya ka MSG nhi hai Woh Krishna ki aur logo ka marg darshan kar rhe hai Unke Gita me kisiko bhi harm karne ki baat nhi likhi hai Gita press walo ko problem hai ki har jagah bhakti bhakti kyu likha hi But bhakti me burayi kya hai Hamare sabhi ved upanishad puranas ka ak hi conclusion hai BHAGWAD PREMA SO whi likha hai Iskcon Gita me Aur bad and good exist everywhere...koi ak galat bolta hai toh Puri organisation toh buru nhi ho sakti na Aur is admi ne agr itna Gita para hai hi toh apne suna guru ko lekr inke words😢😢😢😢itna Gita ke bad he is using abusive words Jo sanatan ke virodh hai
no knowledge will relieve you from suffering 😊 , everything is here in the human subconsciousness.A person who knows no language will know what is right n wrong for him or her.We just tend to rely too much on books and schools of thoughts and get clouded by so many ways of thinking.
It is heart breaking to see some organisations are misleading people to gain followers. they are dividing our gods, someone is saying lord krishna is superior someone is saying lord shiva is superior. normal people like me will totally get confused. please be united and keep our religion and culture above any organisation.
Bro, even i had a nasty experience in Iskcon ,where they invited me for Bhagavad Gita class on sunday. Actually i am not well versed in sanskrit, so i am reading english version of geeta press Srimadbhagvad Gita and i raised many questions to them, so they asked me which Gita ,are you reading and i said Gita press one, as soon as i named Gita press, the main head who was giving lecture, got enraged and started saying that that press is useless and bla bla bla, than i simply told that main head that you know what is the difference between you( Iskcon) and gita press is that gita press never discourage Isckon and never do advertisement like you people and you just teach one aspect of Gita that is bhaktiyoga but gita press Srimadbhagvad gita comprises of jnanayoga, karmayoga and bhaktiyoga ,which you people will never understand, then next time onward they stopped inviting me in their sunday classes.
@@sadhnasharma573 you know, infact I told them what you are teaching is bhaktiyoga but Gitapress Gita comprises of all 3 forms and also told them I have hugh respect for prabhupada ji (founder of iskcon) but not for so - called parbhuji working in Iskcon today, who straightforward criticised Gita press Gita by calling it crap and for whom devotion is business now. That guy who was taking Sunday class was very arrogant, aggressive and egoistic but our Srimad Bhagvad Gita teaches us to refrain from such things.
@@sadhnasharma573 kindly first ask so- called prabhuji in Iskcon not to defame our Gitapress Srimadbhagvad Gita which is our holy book. Ask them to be equanimous which our holy book main highlight is. Ask them not to fix the rate of their membership and other related rituals like gau seva etc because there are many who are not capable of providing such rate in our country, ask them instead of making it business focus on the devotion.
@@sadhnasharma573 इस्कॉन एक संस्था है संप्रदाय नहीं। संप्रदाय केवल 4 हैं। इस्कॉन जिस संप्रदाय के होने का दावा करता है उसी के सिद्धांतो के खिलाफ चलता है।
@@sadhnasharma573 Sorry the intention is not to defame. We have correct them. I am worried these days because ISCON is becoming islam of hinduism. Because they dont recognise other gods even Sri Maha Vishnu as god which will pave a pathfor dividersof our Dharma.
I was also thinking like you when I read ISKCON gita for the first time "There are so many mistranslations". Then I read 2 other Gitas of anciant gaudiya vaishnava acharyas and understood the conclusion of gita as surrendering to Supreme lord Krishna by always thinking of Krishna, rendering loving service to Him as given in 18.65 & 66. Then I understood the greatness of ISKCON's gita. Prabhupad has taken the conclusion of gita and presented it everywhere possible, so that any common man can understand the secret. All glories to Srila Prabhupad & ISKCON
Sir iskon Bhagwat Gita is best it has done lot of life transformation brought big change in others life I have seen it practically it’s matter of our trust
I respect your perspective. However, Geeta is VERY EXPLICIT in its Advaita. While recognising Dwaita as legitimate. Geeta 18 20-21-22 "Advaita is Satvic, Dwaita is Rajasic, rest is Tamasic and based in inferring entireties from partialities and based in illogic". Chapter 11, Vishwaswaroop, his Comic Form contains ALL. All things moving, non moving. His FORM itself is limitless. Prabhupad and others from Madhavacharya School COULD have maintained Dwaita and that would have been legitimate. BUT - they go out of their way. They falsely translate Geeta, because it's prima facie can ONLY mean Vishisth Adwaita. From there on, they don't stop - they vilify and slander Adwaita. Calling them "demonic preachers". As they get exposed, they are getting more vicious. Amogh Lila is trying to bring down Adwaita icons too. With his "Would a Saint do this?". Well, would a Saint deliberately misinterpret and lie about Geeta? They need not have attacked Adwaita school if they were sincere about it. Entire "Here is our meaning of Geeta for lay person" would have been carried out without needing to demonize others and fabricate Geeta. This makes their "intent" VERY suspicious if not entirely malicious. Also, the point that the common person cannot understand Geeta is demonstrably false. Vivekananda and Acharya Prashant both extol it without any pollution of text. Neither they give false analogies - the properties and characteristic if the meaning and the comparison is always accurate. But Iskon, for its legacy of relentless demonization of other schools (which are ACTUALLY based in Geeta) will be exposed. That is simply Iskon's Karma. Iskon should revise its stance and reconcile its core tenets with the actual text. That would be the graceful option. | Om |
I am totally agree because Prabhupada is Pure realised soul coming in line of Guru Parampara .But now a days everyone wants to prove their translation,They should understand that BG as it is by Prabhupada has transformed masses ,Reality is checked by appreciation and transformation.
I read many version but actual meaning more or less same, iskcon gita, swami mukunanada gita, vivek vani, gita press, and some more. This guy wrongly interpreting.
First of all i am not iskon devotee , so they are not brainwashing actually they focused on way of Bhaktiyog , and ultimately they are making you Krishna devotee not terrorist 😅 brainwashed is not a suitable word here.
Wahi tou... Har koi apne deity ko priority deta hai... Koi organisation perfect nhi.... Lekin kuch log sirf larte rehte hai... Bhaad mei jaaye sab kuch bas apni bhakti pei dhyan do bhagwan apne app rasta dikhayenge
Iskcon geeta is just a opinion of a person who read geeta. Not geeta itself. The original is Sanskrit we just need good translation not a opinion. Geetapress is the best one we got.
@@nish8756 I mean Same Translation of Original. I read it, In first Few Pages they Mention it's Translation is same as Krishnaji Original Words, that's why it's called Yatharoop, I know They are Making us fool at some Level.
@@itsajaypatel Yes they are selling these books in outside India & I confronted one of their disciple in US. She just ran away when I mentioned how their Gita is not the correct translation & they are actually offending Hindus.
ISKCON अच्छा है या बुरा ये तो नई पता पर जीवन में अच्छा इंसान बन ने के लिए आपको भक्ति मार्ग का सहारा लेना ही पड़ेगा बिना भक्ति के आप अच्छे इंसान नई बन सकते , ISKCON कहता है कृष्ण को जानो , मंदिर जाव या ना जाव बस कृष्ण को जानो , सनातनी सो रहे थे इतना दिन कोन आके उनको जगाया आपके वीडियो से तो कोई नई जागा अपने जगाया भी नई कोसिस भी नई की , ये बात 100% सही है की ISKCON ने हिन्दुओं को जगाया है और कृष्ण भावना अमृत प्रदान किया , हरे कृष्ण,🙏❤️ हरी बोल
acha insan hone k liye bhakti hi jaruri nahi, ye khud krishna ne gita me alag alag yog k bare me samjhaya hai... apane man se kuch bhi mat boliye jake gita padhiye
में भी तो वो ही बोल रहा हूं जाके गीता पड़ो , कलयुग है मनुष्य अपने कर्म तो करता ही है पर भक्ति में ध्यान नई देता , में तो बोल रहा हूं कर्म तो हम करते ही है थोड़ा ध्यान भक्ति में भी लगा लो मेरे भाई , By the way am a software engineer 🙏❤️ हरे कृष्ण
iskcon ne HariHar bhedi bana rakhe hai , deviyo ki kuch mante nahi hai , yaha tak ki Ram aur Krishn me bhi bhed kar rahe hai aur yahi chij videshiyo ko aur apno ko sikha rahe hai. aur ab to apne hi santo ka apman kar rahe hai . Agar aisa Hindu jagana ho jo sirf ek sanstha tak hi simit reh jaye aur dusre devi devta aur santo ka apman kare to isse achha hai Hindu sota Rahe. Har Har Mahadev , Jay shree krishna
@@harvy345 aap samjhe nai bhai , aap khud shiv or shakti , radha or krishna me vhed kar rahe hoo , dono me koi ved nahi hai radha ke bina krishna hamesa adhure hai , Radha ko pujoge to krishna bhi chale ayenge , haan ISKCON wale amog lila prabhu ji kaa bhasan mujhe v bura laga jab Radha radha nam karne walo shanto ke upar bola or swami Vivekananda ji ke bare me bola bhot hi buri tarike se represent kiya unko , aap acchi chijo ko pakdo bhai buri chijo ko nai, aap bhakti ko pakdo ISKCON ko nai , bhakti aap ghar pe v kar sakte ho ISKCON jane ki jarurat nai hai , कीर्तनिया सदा हरि हरे कृष्ण ❤🙏 हरी बोल
There's a saying in spirituality, if a scholar want to understand bhakti and krsna, he will never able to know the actual reality but if a person having compassionate heart will understand and develop the love for God even without knowledge, bhakti me hriday chahiye, dimaag lagaoge to kuch samjh nhi aayega
Baat sahi or galat ki he baat bhakti ki nhi koi aapko bhakti kese karni he ye nhi bta skta bhakti ek seva bhaav or nirantar karma karte rehne ka naam he karma ko jano agar ye shrishti ghumna rok de to koi nhi bachega ye is shrishti ka karma he, tumhara karma kya he sirf bhakti krna karma nhi he karma krte rehne ko he bhakti kehte he ye krishna samjha smjha kr thak gye pr log smjh nhi paay , tum laakho bar naam lelo krishna ka pr krishna sirf uski he sunega jo karma karega har karma se pehle parabhu ko yaad kro or krte jaao karma ko
@@prakshit1909 aap toh ulta he bol gaye bhaiya Krishna ji ne 'Karma' shabd ke saath 'Yog' shabd bhi lagaya hai jiska arth hai aatma ka parmatma se milan vo kehte hai karma karo par fal ki chinta na karo aur karma karo par iss bhaav se ki yaha kuch mera nahi hai jo kuch hai Bhagwaan ka hai aur mai jo bhi kuch karma kar raha hu vo unki he seva mein kar raha hu isko kehte hai Karmyog ki karma karne ke pehle, karma karte samaye, AUR karma karne ke baad bhi SIRF bhagwaan ka smaran karein naaki sirf karma karne se pehle formality kardi unka naam leke baaki karma karte SAMAYE unko BHOOL gaye YE baat Krishna ji samjhaate samjhaate thak gaye aur dursri baat Krishna ji unki he sunte hai jo har vakt unka dhyaan karta rehta hai naaki apne ko 'karta' (doer) maanke sansaar ko paane ke laalach mein bhaagta rehta hai aur apne aap ko shareer samajh baitha hai aur apni aatma ka lakshya jaanta he nahi jo ki hai God-realisation (bhagwad praapti) bhagwaan ke prati samarpan, bhagwaan se nishkaam prem (selfless love) Samjhe aap?
Yahi to isckon bhi sikhata hai bhai 😂😂...tumlogo isckon pach nahi raha hai ki hamse zyada gyani kaun aa gaya hai idhar😂😂...wo bhakti ka matlab is video ko daalne waale ko khud nhi pata hoga...aadha Jan ko lagata hai bhakti ka matlab sanyasi banna😂😂to aise dimag walon ke lie isckon hai bhi nahi.. bhagwan ke lie Prem badhana hai to bhakti zaruri hai...sirf karma karke bhagwan ke prati Prem nahi aayega...aur Prem badhane ke lie bhagwan ka naam...aur puja ki jaati hai...material world Mai aaye ho to karm to janm se lekar maran tak karna hai...sirf karm karne ke lie manushya sharir nahi milta hai...bhagwan ko prassanna karne ke lie milta hai...unke karib jaane ke lie milta hai...
I follow Bhagwat Geeta courses by Ramakrishna Mission. Whenever they take any course on Bhagwat Geeta, they take the real Bhagwat Geeta original sanskrit version and then teaches from it. Those are actually one of the most accurate interpretations of the slokas.
@@AviatorBro Here is the channel. Go to playlists section, you will find Bhagwad Geeta both hindi and bengali version ruclips.net/video/eWKlcuvg45U/видео.html
I also follow the Ramakrishna Mission books. They sell books on their store (it is also available online for those looking to buy their books). Even Gita Press is very reliable in terms of translations. I always compare different translations whenever I find myself in doubt.
Ha ye baat toh balki inki Geeta hath me lene ka tareeka aur page platne ka tareeka bhi theek nhi hai Geeta bhagwan ki Vani he aur jab bhi Geeta haath me lo toh pyar se päge paltne chahiye aise nhi matlab Geeta ji aur hamari school ki notebook me koi anter nhi
We can get inspired by anything but once inspired we have to go to the core books . Like we got inspired by Adipurush, went and bought ValmikiRamayanam( Geeta Press ) and started reading. We gotta remember this as now-a-days inspiration can come from anywhere 🙏
It's not only about ISKCON, other organisations may be doing this to favour their organisation. The problem is we are not learning Sanskrit and depending on others to explain these for us. I think this is the real problem.
We take the meaning of the sankrit word what previous acarya says not by our material scholarship. Meaning of Sanskrit reveal by the mercy of lord but not by our own efforts.
@@shyambalaramshyambalaram3989 sab acharyas ki same translation hsi hai bhai😊 Madhvacharya ki ramanuja charya ki Baldev bhushan ji ki geetapress ki sbki translation same hsi hai Bhashya sbka alag alag hota h acharya ke time pe hindi nhi thi sanskrit he thi sanskrit ke shloka unke liye already he translation thi vo sirf bhashya krte the sanskrit me Isiliye sb geeta ki translation same h kyuki baaki sampradaya walo ko business nhi karna iskcon ke jaise
@@BalajiCreation108Achha Matlab iskcon itna successful ho gya baki organization se jada aur unki geeta logo ka jeewan Badal rhi h to usko ab bol do ki business kr rhe h ye log waah.😅😅 Are bhai kabhi bahar niklo kaliyuga ke log jo bhagwan ko bhul ke dukh ke Sagar me hai unke pas bhagwan ka Sandesh phuchao unko harinam lena sikaho. Idhar youtube pe baith ke criticize krna bhot assan hai thik hai. Tmhe pta bhi ni hai iskcon ke bhakt bina kisi swarth apna jeewan de dete hai jan Kalyan ke liye tmhe kya pta. Aur Jha tk baat rhi galat translation ki to aajana kbhi face to face tmhre saare jo doubt ko minute me dur kr denge . Iskcon wale hai hm sb kuch leke chalte hai . Ye movement ek sudh bhakt ke realization pe based hai aise ni youtube pe baith ke kuch bak diya. Aur business waigrah bina jaane smjhe mat bako. Tmko pta bhi ek temple ko chalne ke liye kitna paisa lgta hai . Hm bas kitab ka print cost lete h na ki dhandha kyuki agar koi paise dega to uski value krega padh ke. Aur agar donation maange ayenge to bologe ke bhik maang rhe kya kre bhai btao😅. Kbhi kisi ek insan ko bhagwan ka naam japna btao pta chalega kitna khun paseena lgta ek bhakt bnanae me . Niklo bhai ghar se logo ka prachar kro
The problem with us is we justify what we believe, not what is correct. With all due respect, acharyas and gurus may not be correct always. Bhagawan Krishna explained different types of maarg(path), it was not only the Bhakti maarg. We should not argue, shall introspect and analyse what is correct. Not blindly follow anyone - be this video or your guru or acharya. We shall strive for what is correct by intuitive thinking.
I am not an ISKCON member, but can say for sure that they are responsible for a large share of awareness and spread of Sanaatana Dharma across the world. No other organisation has been as successful, and of course while it does have its share of internal problems and politics, with such success come the detractors and naysayers.
One should respect the success of ISKCON but that doesn't mean they are correct. Falsity often travels the whole world while the truth is preparing itself for its first exposure.
Success !!.. Even Hitler had success But he killed so many Prabhupad was an agent of Ford ka baccha And Created and MNC Using Krishna as Brand ambassador Beatles also
Is video me kaha ki iskcon hat jagah bhakti bhakti kr raha hai but ye to sahi ki iskcon bhakti se inshano ko maya se alag kr raha iskcon ne meri bhi bhaut madad ki thi even kr raha hai
@@Arandomguyat1 There is no wrong translation. The video maker is misleading people. For example, in relation to the words 'buddhau saranam', in Bhagavad Gita 2.49, Srila Sridhara Swami says " बुद्धौ शरणं त्रातारमीश्वरमाश्रयेत्यर्थः". This is exactly how Srila Prabhupada translates it. Don't believe in this fake video created out of envy for acaryas.
The main issue is which school of thought is giving the purport/Bhasya: 2 main schools - dvet (duality) and advet (non-duality) which itself has further sub schools - around 7/8. However, direct translation of Sanskrit shouldn’t be different. Shankaracharya translation is non-duality related, same from Bhaktivedanta - Swami Sarvariyananda has good non-duality podcasts of Bhagvadgita. Iskon is pure duality and hence pure bhakti. Pakhand nahin hain balki different school of thought.
Madhvacharya ji ki bhi translation same h bhai geeta ko koi translation change nhi hoti bhashya ho skte h Video dekha nhi lgta h aapne dhang se. Translation or bhashya ka toh farak samjho
@@srinivasacaryadasa4915 You're missing the entire point. The target language to which the sanskrit shlokas are being translated is irrelevant. They're changing the substance of the shloka itself to suit their needs. The differences in schools of thought are considered too, however, you can't mistranslate important spiritual texts to support your point.
@@floe61 I am not missing anything here. Srila Prabhupada's translations are inline with the spirit of the Gita and follows in the foot steps of previous acaryas who have accepted Krsna's instructions without personal motivation. Sanskrit words have multiple meanings and the meaning that fits into the flow and the spirit of the Gita will be chosen by the acaryas. Sometimes there may be multiple interpretations. But as long as they fit into the flow and bigger essence of the text the interpretation is valid. There is no such thing as original translation. Original is in Sanskrit and when translated to local languages the acaryas explain in a way it makes sense in the local language. The fruit of a tree is judged by the fruit it produces, phalena pariciyate. The impact that Srila Prabhupada's Gita had in the lives of people across the globe is phenomenal, life changing and unparalleled. There are envious people who could do something better in their lives than go after a pure devotee of Lord Krsna and bring misfortune upon themselves. Bhakti will be destroyed in our hearts if we blaspheme pure devotees.
Iskcon has contributed a lot to spread Hinduism across the world. Because of Iskcon, Hinduism Sanatan Dharma is spreading like a wild fire. In fact Gita Press is above of all. Many many tributes to Gita Press the superior Publication of all times for Hindu scriptures ❤❤
@@ipratiksachan फ़ायदा ही सही। तुम फ़ायदा ले कर ही हिन्दू धर्म का प्रसार कर के दिखा दो। कितने लोगों को भगवद्गीता पहुंचाई है? इतने सुंदर विशाल मन्दिरों का निर्माण, गोशालाएं, मन्दिर का रखरखाव, कोविड से अभी तक 7.5 करोड़ लोगों को भोजन कराना, भगवद्गीता का प्रचार प्रसार, गुरुकुल शिक्षा, सब पैसे से ही होगा, फोकट में नहीं होता। तुम्हारे कथावाचक जया किशोरी टाइप लोग 1 करोड़ रु तक कथा करने और पंडाल में नाचने के लिए लेती है । पैसे के बिना कुछ नहीं होता। समझे भाईसाहब।
Sanatan Dharm is not spreading among foreigner countries , especially in European countries, people of Europe they actually don't say a single good thing about hindusium & our culture instead of they hate ,mock & make fun of us , our culture ,our relegion & the way we dressed each & every thing only the iskcon &iskonics are showing a small portion to you the rest all behind the curtains
@@ankitrawal3240 Hinduism in England is the third largest religion in the country, with over 1,020,533 followers as of the 2021 Census. This represents over 1.5% of the English population, up from 1.1% the previous decade. Hindus are predominantly in the cities of London and Leicester, where they make up greater proportions of the population (Hindu Enclaves, also known as Hindu Hotspots). England has a number of Hindu temples, including the Hindu temple at Neasden which is the largest Hindu temple in Europe.Recently the largest Hindu Mandir in the North of England, the Bradford Lakshmi Narayan Hindu Temple opened in Bradford,West Yorkshire.
I agree, I myself have seen so many faults in their geeta. Especially insulting our shiva. I hate it I hate when they turn us against us. They’ve insulted Shiva in their bhagavadgeeta. Saying he himself got trapped by maya. I don’t accept that.
Dont follow iskon culture. They will destroy your family by brain washing and your family will be spoiled. You can go for any bhagwat gita except iskon.
Read the Shiv Puran Shiva was indeed trapped by Maya that was the reason he cut off his son's head (Shri Ganesh ji) That means Shiva is not omniscient which Krishna is in the Geeta
After watching this I am happy to buy ISKON geeta and I will also distribute it also because ISKON Geeta writer Swami Prabhupāda is not only a best translater but also legend bhakt. My question Why people only love to read ISKON geeta? Even i myself love to read ISKON geeta. After reading ISKON geeta I am trying to become bhakt I am become vegetarian Try to follow brahmacharya And many more I don't think if I was read another geeta I will do any of these things
iskcon hates mahadev. counts shiv as a dev not a god. now let me get started. prabhupaad counts krishna/vishnu as the only deity in the world and said in our temples only radha rani or jagganath must be worshipped. iskcon are vaishnavs who hates shiv and shaivs. There is a shlok in iskcon's geeta chapter 13 saying about krishna having another diety inside him which is maheshwar. maheshwar means shiv. in the translation they cut off shiv and say maheshwar is maha ishwar who is non other then shiv. I can go on with their pakhad. but i guess this is enough
Becoming devotee according to ISKCON will only make you Andhabakth, and it's like christianity where prabhupada is their messenger like jesus, where in reality he's just a translator(which we've seen in this video how good he is). ISKCON people value prabhupada so much, what about VedaVyasa maharshi who actually written those puranas. Sanatan dharmam concept of god is different than any other religion. As far as I understood, Universe can be broken down(viewed as) as thrimurthis, where shiva is the one who holds, Vishnu is the one who runs the process, and Brahma can be related to Brahman(intelligence/ chaitanyam in us). I'm still trying to understand the significance of each god. God doesn't mean we've to look up and imagine someone situated somewhere like abrahamic religions. Religion is part of Sanatana dharmam but sanatana dharmam itself is not religion.
@@chagantiraviteja9483 well do not use term ‘Andhbhakt’. It has no relevance whatsoever & no one ever has been explained this term & looks like an idiot
@@raghavdikshit5314who said maheshwar means shiv ? Maheshwar means mahan + ishwar. Jo ishwar supreme hai. It's an adjective. You can be a devote of shiva. That's great. But according to brahma samhita shiva is a form of Krishna only. He has the purpose to rule taamsik goon. He has 50 qualities where Krishna in his full form has 64 qualities. Its all there already in brahma samhita. If you love shiva and hate krishna there is no bigger fool than you. You don't even understand the true hindu sanatan dharma's essence. I don't like prabhupada or iskon. I eat and relish meat. I don't like his views on gandhi, vivekananda and ramakrishna. But i still read that gita book because he is the only translator who loves krishna above everything else. Nothing wrong in that.
Every scripture leads you to bhakti, you can go in circles and find it after spending good part of your life but end result is bhakti, Karm yog becomes bhakti when you start giving all credit to supreme lord, same applies to gyan yog or dhyan yog. In Bhagwat Geeta, last advice to Arjun from Lord was to full surrender to Krishna and forget about all other aspect "guhiyatam gyan"
I don't care because I only read Shlokas and meaning because commentry is often manipulated but I still Love Iskcon for their Devotion to our Lord Krishna.
Yes i also noticed. But if you think in broad way, if we do bhakti then budhhi automatically purified and will become buddhi yuktam. So no need to fight internally with our sanatan people.
Bhagavad Geeta is the essence of Upanishads(Vedanta). Which remembers the ultimate purpose of human life and the ways to achieve the moksha( liberation). The goal is one but the paths to reach it are many. Those paths to gain moksha are explained in Geeta in 18 chapters names end with Yoga( the bond which connects ātma with Paramāthma). Plz do read Geeta press ghorakpur's Shankara bashya Geeta only.
But amogh lila made fun of this too in that swami Vivekananda video..he said how can different paths take u to one goal.. If u want to go to Australia and you landed to Antarctica, arctic.. Australia ko jaane ka marg ek hi hai.. Abb kya hi bolne ka inko, Australia ka example spiritual enlightenment ke sath jod raha hai
@@creativeaarts4023 Few people don't even have common sense and they call themself as Sanyasi. If you want to go to Australia you can go by a ship or by an aeroplane. You can go by constructing a massive long bridge and can go by walk on that. But ultimately your goal is to reach your destination i.e Australia. Same as there are many ways to attain moksha. The choice is ours. You know bhakti gives us purification ( chitta shuddhi). By simply chanting hare krishna one can't get moksha even in his entire life. Self realisation ( I'm soul not the body) is must and should to attain moksha. The self realisation is attained in Nirvikalpa samadhi( the ultimate state of meditation).
@@creativeaarts4023uki unlogoka iskcon tika huwa hai Australia America Europe k foreigners k paiso k upar islea unlogoko hamesha videsh hi nazar ata hai😂😂😂😂
नाहं प्रकाश: सर्वस्य योगमायासमावृत: | text like Gita is so flexible...that its knowledge can be applied for any path of devotion....and in this Gita... Prabhupad has given the easiest and topmost path especially for the people of kalyuga which is Krishna Consciousness to attain God.... Hare Krishna🙏
Bro your so called GURU is not greater than the God/Speaker himself. Why are you so foolish to think that prubhupada is smarter than god himself. To change gods speech according to his will/ profit
this is true the translation what exactly are should not matter, what matters is the intention, the translation are so flexible that they can be altered in any way possible and i dont think iskcon translation is teaching anything wrong , no one in kalayuga is so good to achieve liberation just by theri "karma" so bhakti is what which can overcome the karma
@@Admin-tk6ri the intention you are talking about ....bhagwan krishna has told each single word ...even each single matra with certain intention ....u can not distort a single word which came from bhagawan' s vaani ....it is criminal ....you are applying your human like intentions and thus human translations to justify and modify bhagawan' s vaani .....are u serious?😂😂😂😂
prabhupad has given topmost path ?..... 😂😂😂😂what can i say?....yes ..bhakti siddhanta was given by prabhupad ..right?😂😂 the only thing that prabhupad has given ...is distorted meaning and distorted translation of bhagwaan' s vaani ....the ultimate audacity anyone can perform .
I even noticed it and started only reading the Sanskrit part and understand what it is rather than reading their tatparya!!! Thanks for noticing and highlight
There is no other Gita, it's either authentic translation or manipulated version the one ISKCON presents. My heart bleeds when I see these manipulated versions being named original and creating divide. I / we are not against ISKCON but it takes a lot to accept the wrongfulness of self. They call Shiv ji a demigod ? A term which had never existed in Satya Sanatan Dharm, it was introduced by ISKCON itself. Unfortunately no text presented by them Is authentic and real it is just the will of one man and now the belief of thousands 🙏.
@@yogeshchaurasia5611 even a pandit of iskon said without pita, pati,putra a stri is weak and even when we are in our periods we are " auchut? 🥺 Is that really krishna thinks about us like that 😭
The reason this actually makes sense is because during war, why would lord krishna preach about bhakti when it was necessary for Arjuna to do his Karma
The karma in bhakti is called akarma and by doing bhakti one is able to do akarma . Read bhagwad gita my friend you'll get to know more about types of karma.
@@mukundboyat word akarma has nothing to do with bhakti , when you translate akarma it means "inactivity" , the thing you said , tell it to Sanskrit scholars, I have asked it to my Sanskrit prof. before in University, the translation simply mean inactivity or where no action is going on
Many Iskcon translations of sacred texts like Bhagavad Gita, Chaitanya Charitamrita, and Srimad Bhagavatam contain errors, misinterpretations, or biases, leading to misunderstandings.
Thanks to Iskon I know about Krishna and the Gita...... 😊they have changed the world to be positive......Steve jobs and George Harrison were a part of it........😊
Undoubtedly credit has to be given to ISKON for popularizing Geeta among masses. But the problem is when they translate Karma Yog, Gyan Yog and everything from Devotion point of view, because for a devotee, nothing but devotion is paramount.
Steve jobs was not influenced by Iskon Gita. He did not tell Mark Zuckerberg to travel India to visit ISKON. Anyone who knows a bit of Sanskrit wouldn’t fall in their trap.
Isckon is a fraud organisation. They dont even call themselves Hindus. They abuse Shiv ji and Ganpati Bappa. Their founder said good things about Christianity
i am little bent towards vedanta and while reading the bhagwat geeta from iskcon i also felt the same they have emphasized soo much upon bhaktiyog. i mean geeta isn't a text of sanyas it is the way of doing karma and iskcon also have the supreme god thing , the beauty of sanatan is in multiple gods but they also contradict with this
Exactly. Bhakti yog is easiest. Look at rural life's or brahmins they used to lead a bhakti yog. Krishna never says in one life he will free. He only says humans never says all other lokas even pandavas went to swarg. Krishna also says play the game and still stay away from maya like a lotus.
@@akshatbhandari4779okay so according to you bhakti means being a sanyasi 😂😂😂wow...hats off to your knowledge...manushya sharir 84 lakh yoniyon ke baad milta hai...aur karma se bhagwan prassana zarur honge magar agar wo sab karma ke alawa aap bhagwan ke prati Prema ya unko surrender nahi karoge to aapke aur jaanwar Mai koi antar nahi hai...wo bhi Karma kar rahe hai tum bhi kar rahe ho... manushya sharir milne par bhakti zyada karni hoti hai taaki bhagwan se Prema badhe..bhakti Mai karma ko nahi side kia jaata hai...agar wo aapke dimag mai chal raha hai to aap saaf galat ho aur isckon ko bhi galat hi bol rahe ho...
स्वार्थी दुनिया में लोग आपको तब तक याद करते हैं जब उनको आपकी जरूरत होती है अगर आप एक बार मदद मांगते हैं तो वो पीछे हट जाते हैं ये मेरे खुद का अनुभव है अगर किसी को भरोसा करना ही है तो कृष्ण को करो वो कभी आपका साथ नहीं छोड़ेंगे, कर्म योग तो है ही जरूरी भक्ति योग भी बहुत ज्यादा जरूरी है कलयुग में अगर कोई बचा सकता है तो आपकी भक्ति जो कृष्ण के प्रति है Hare Krishna 🙏
This kind of debate and discussion only elevates our spirituality that is the beauty of our religion Edit: also another reason why every hindu must learn Sanskrit
Saare geetha ko inhone bhakti yog kar diya?? Ye galat hai. Bhagawaan ko paane ke liye geetha me karmyog bhi hai, jnanyog bhi hai, sanyasa yog bhi hai, bhakti yog bhi hai.
Or 4.12 ki commentary me likha shiv ji or Narayan ek nhi hai or 10.65 ki commentary me likha ki bhakt ko Krishna roop me he man lagana chahiye ram ji or Narayan me nhi lagana chahiye
@@BalajiCreation108 lagta hai ye log abrahamic faiths prabhavit hai. 🤣Saara moolabhooth waad aur brainwashing Abramic religions me hai. Geetha me Moolbhoothwaad kahi bhi nahi hai. Me Narayan ,KRISHNA, ram, SHIVA sabko ek maanta hun. Ek hi shakthi ko hum alag alag naam se pukarte hai.
@@govindappa6143 ye toh hai he jabhi toh hum exposed bna rhe hai iskcon ka maksad he yhi tha ki baaki religion jaise sanatan dharm bhi abhramic banjae koi bhakt nhi h ye natak krte h maximum ye
@@govindappa6143 Prabhupada jo the unhone shaf kehdia ki hum durga ji demigodess ki puja nhi krte kyuki durga ji Krishna ji ki daasi haii. Or tulsidas ji ke liye bhi kaha ki vo pure vaishanav nhi haii
In the past I had started reading the Autobiography of a Yogi, it was basically salepitch "Kriya Yoga meditation". And in order to know it you basically have to join them.
When Its not your time don’t try reading Autobiography of Yogi. Rajinikanth kept 25 years , you might pick up in next life. Kriya yog is real essence of Bagavat Gita.
@@codelikepro198 Some are degraded to this level nowadays....But not all... You can see preachers from ISKCON Bangalore... They never talks anything apart from Krishna.
I had studied the geeta press publication and I had been thinking about reading Iskon publication Bhagvad Gita as well. But I'd suspicion about their way of devotion.
I personally request to those people who are willing to start Gita to begin with the Holy Geeta by Swamy Chinmayananda. And next you can go for Shankaracharya bhashya on gita (Which is somewhat high level to understand for the beginners) Also for the beginners Gita commentary by Swami Sarvapriyananda from RK math order were truly a bliss.
make this video reach 10 lac views, many people need to be aware on how ISKCON's Gita is misleading. When Amogh Lila comes back he and others will think many many times before even thinking of defaming some saints of India.
Being a bhakta, he should never have translated gita Wrongfully!!!! Hare Krishna, all glories to Sri Krishna!! Krishna is my everything.❤❤❤❤❤ But not Prabhupada. No obalation or respect to Prabhupada! His mind was filled with Christianity and Christian belief!!! Not authentic!
मित्र.. आपका अध्ययन और कार्य सराहनिय है. लेकीन आपकी भाषा बहुत असभ्य है वो भी सन्यासी गुरू के लिये.. सनातन धर्म मे अलग अलग संप्रदाय होते है ओर सभी संप्रदाय अपने अपने तत्त्वज्ञान का प्रचार प्रसार सदियो से करते आये है. जैसे की वैष्णव विष्णू को भगवान मानते है और शैव शिव को, कोई अद्वैती है कोई द्वैती... तो आप सिर्फ सही राह दिखाये, जागरूक करे... नाकी द्वेष से किसिको अपमानित करे. क्योकी इस्कॉन के लोग कोई बुरा या निंदनीय कार्य नही कर रहे है, बल्की वो पुरे दुनिया मे श्रीकृष्ण की भक्ती फैला रहे हैं. और गीता ग्रंथ का आदर करे, जीस तरीके से आप ग्रंथ के पन्ने पलट रहे है, उससे ग्रंथ को हानी होगी.🙏🏻
I agree, like i am not against ISKON but even i compared and i was shocked when their was a lot of difference in ISKON bhagvad gita and the real one that i had.
Great service in exposing invalid translations. I am reading "The Bhagavad Gita Comes Alive" by Jeffrey Armstrong; based on this video, Jeffrey's translation seems to be very authentic based on the specific verses mentioned here.
That's the Bhagavad Gita I have and I find it beautifully written. Everything is so well explained that for the first time I truly enjoyed and understood the Bhagavad Gita.
@@rosanilebron1566 agree that irrespective of some translation issues, this version has most appeal currently and on the whole has the desired impact of propagating the divine message to a wider public.
आपका video देखा, बहत अच्छा लगा, मगर आपको एक बात बोलूंगा... में isckon का अनुयाई नही हूं... मगर आज का समाज जिस राह में चल रहा हे, उन्हें पहले भक्ति के मार्ग में लाकर कर्म, कर्तव्य राह में चला सकते हैं । आज समाज को पहले भक्ति के नसा देना चाहिए, उसके बाद बो कर्म की राह में चल पाएंगे । Isckon समाज में बहत कुछ बदलाव ला रहा हे, कृपया उसे स्वागत करे । आज यदि श्रीमद भगवद्गीता दुनियाभर में फेल राहा हे, तो उसमे isckon की सहयोग बहत हे।
Bro 😅 jiska tu abhi video dekh rha hai na o tere ko mind wash kr rha hai jake 18.66 padh usme kya likha bhaktya mamabhujanati eska matlab bhakti hin Aisa marg jisse mujhe Jana ja skta hai to bhai yaha pe bhagwan bol to rhe hai bakti kro aur mujhe jano @annonymoussi9sjs
Hats off to you .People don't know sanskrit still they are translating. Some of youtubers also are misleading interpreting different meanings of purana upnishad etc.
Amazing video….I hope more and more people see this. I have read Geeta of Geeta press Gorakhpur version and on the contrary I think more emphasis has been put on how to live this worldly life properly rather than leaving everything behind for the sake of ‘Bhakti’. Shree Krishna always emphasised on Karma in different manner and said that it’s also the path of Yoga and equally fruitful.
Dont follow iskon culture. They will destroy your family by brain washing and your family will be spoiled. You can go for any bhagwat gita except iskon.
, yes u are right, yet Shri Krishna also mentions further that for Kaliyuga people , most easiest and most practical way to attain the Supreme Him is to practice and perform Bhakti Yoga , all other ways(Yoga--be it gyan or dhyan or ashtang or karma) also help u reach the same destination but its more difficult to follow those in the age of Kali.
It's from Madhavacharya's lineage. He "developed" his school of thought in 11th century during his "experience" with Islam. He also declared that Advaita Wadis are "demonic preachers". Iskon's Geeta vilifies Advaita preachers too.
Namaste! 🙏🏼 Wish this video had English subtitles for people like myself who don't speak any Indian language. I can suggest the Bhagavad Gita by Jeffrey Armstrong (Kavindra Rishi). I have it and it is in Sanskrit and English. It is a well researched translation, no commentaries or explanations. Just the Gita as it is.
The gita in true form never talk about praying to any deity. So it isn't really specific to hinduism at all. It just teaches the ultimate truth mainly cessation of craving. It is much similar to buddhist ideologies. ISKON in its translation stresses upon praying to Krishna which isn't real translation
Dont follow iskon culture. They will destroy your family by brain washing and your family will be spoiled. You can go for any bhagwat gita except iskon.
I'd suggest Bhagwad Gita From Gita Press Gorakhpur if you can get it near your place. It's the most unbiased nd the most authentic one. I don't know which Bhagwad Gita you're reading right now. But if it's unbiased, then by reading it, you'll be more devoted towards your Dharm(Work, Sense of Right nd Wrong and you'll be more generous towards others). In original bhagwad Gita, devotion towards the god is very very less. It's not a book that will ask you to leave everything nd just worship God. It's a book that will teach you how to be a good, productive and a sensible human being. So any Bhagwad Gita which shows everything related to devotion towards the god only is wrongly translated. Gita is the way of life. It'll teach how how to live a better life. It's not just about God. Devotion towards God is very limited in this book. I hope this information will help you to know whether you're reading the correctly translated Bhagwad Gita or not. 🙏
@@mehulbhatt3541 don't spread misinformation It is related to Vedic/hindu religion Just like Bible is related to christianity But yeah anyone can read Geeta just like anyone can read Bible or tripitak
There goes a story like this: In a village there were no one who knew elephants. And 4 blind men were choosen to experience an elephant. They came back and described to the villagers about elephant. It was seen that after some days the villagers were divided into four groups. 1. The elephant is like a pillar. (Leg) 2. The elephant is like a rope.(tail) 3. The elephant is like a tank.(belly) 4. The elephant is like a flat plate. (ear). Now these four groups are regulaly quarelling with each other on elephant matter. But when one wise man with the help of one blind reached the elephant and saw the truth. The problem is that most people don't have that patience and preserverance to strive to reach the end. They fall in quarellism and get distracted from truth pursuance. 🕉️
गीता प्रैस गोरखपुर से मेरा सादर व सविनय निवेदन है कि गीता के अनुवाद की समीक्षा की जाए। कई स्थानों पर सुधार की आवश्यकता है। मैं पहले उन्हें एक पत्र भी लिख चुका हूँ।
Dont follow iskon culture. They will destroy your family by brain washing and your family will be spoiled. You can go for any bhagwat gita except iskon.
Dont follow iskon culture. They will destroy your family by brain washing and your family will be spoiled. You can go for any bhagwat gita except iskon.
You're never reading the wrong scripture. Just read one Gita with full divine. Don't listen to these RUclipsrs whose motive is just to create some money and seeking attention of people like you. So i request you to read Gita which you have rn and believe that Gita fully. Hare Krishna 💗✨
guys im not in isckon but trust me all this translation what is writtenor not wriiten which god is supreme or not dont induldge yooourslef in these type of things just go in iskcon for once at the time of keertan just for once go in nay iskcon temple exp cant be explained in words just trust me your life will chang e
I'm very happy to see that somebody has exposed the ISKON guys' Geeta translation & interpretation. But these guys are thick skinned. Four years ago, I confronted one their bald headed guys who had come to our society to deliver a lecture. He was, as you are describing, trying to give a wrong interpretation of Geeta. We had a few WhatsApp chat exchanges. I asked him, "have you read Lokmanya Tilak's Geeta Rahasya, in which Tilak argues very forcefully and convincingly that it is the Karmyog, which is the real meaning of Geeta?" He had not. Then I asked him to justify the translation and interpretation he was giving. He went on in a very round about way and refused to answer my questions. I offered him my own copy of Geeta Rahasya (English translation). He was not inclined to change his views. Finally, I gave up. How long can one bang his head on a stone wall? So, thank you; you are doing a good job. Keep it up.
@saumyashah4831 Shree Ganesh is not a son of Shiva... it's just one of the Avtaar of Lord Ganesha.. like Shree Ram is avtaar of Bhagwaan Vishnu. If Ganesha is son of Shiva, then why Lord Shiva did Ganesha's upasana before tripurasur vadh? How can any father worship their own son?? Even Parvati did Ganesh upasana before Ganesha become her son... she did ganesh upasana to have Ganesha as her son! And the Avtaar is Umangamalaj Avtaar... Not Ganesh
Spreading iskcon business not sanatan dharm.. They are actually dividing sanatani into Jain Buddhism vaishnavism shaktism shaivism.. Sanatan dharm is collective of all philosophies which includes Jainism Buddhism Sikhism and different branches of Hinduism.. So plz don't bring up this excuse that they are helping poor people.. You might be a naive person to fall for their tricks.
@@somparashar6349 bruhhhh just to show krishna above they say shiv and bhrma are demi gods and should not be considered supreme, also they say shiv and bhrma bhakt as murkh(stupid)
Ultimate goal of any gita version is to make you devotee of krishna.Iskcon gita is powerfull becoz it transformed many western people and made them devotees.
No ultimate goal of Gita is not to make you a devotee of Krishna.. The goal of Gita is to tell u paths that will lead to self realization and where u will attain God. Now if u consider God as Krishna after reading Iskcon then it's ur problem.. Because it's the ishwar who said Geeta.. It's bhagwan Uvach, not Krishna Uvach.. Which clearly it's the Ultimate Ishwar who spoke via Krishna.. That's why if u worship any God u will reach to main God only... That's the problem with Iskcon and hence the name Krishna consciousness Iskcon..
@@creativeaarts4023Thats the prblm now a days people want gita without krsna. krsna is bhagwan.Self realization is achived through krsna bhakti.Krsna clearly mentions just surrender to me.
so true , i always stopped reading bhagwat gita from iskcon so many times because all this bhakti made me confused. i am sanathani i want knowledge to improve my life not bhakti.
@@GloryToAryaVrat iskcon Lord krishna ka nam spread kartey hai via bhagwat geeta. Isckon is only organization who spread Hinduism🕉️. Because Lord krishna is the only door 🚪 to get moksha.
I was also surprised by the translations as I know little bit of Sanskrit, but its not such a big thing. It will be problematic only for those who read English version only
tumko kya pta ki iski btayi translation hi sahi h kal ko koi aur kuchh bhi translation le ke aa gya to fir problem yahi h ki ham sanskrit nhi pd rhe h aur iskon ko bhi galat bolna band kro becoz iskon ne jo kiya h vo tum jaise youtubers uska 1 percent bhi nhi kr skte h atleast they are changing people from a hippie to a devotee of lord krishna
@@alexsten4665bar bar ek percent bhi nhi kr pa rhe ek percent bhi ni kr pare bolne se kuch nahi hoga, jo sach hai wo sach hai, Glt translation hai to hai tum use kisi bhi Sanskrit dictionary se check krlo ya koi Anya texts se ki unka meaning kya h.
It's true brother. Even I bought the gita published by ISCKON. I have an old gita of gitapress. You won't believe There are lots of differences between these two books. But now it's time to stop this
Kindly don't do this, even i have read so many Gita books but finally a got clarity after reading Iskcon BG.. This person is really really misleading all
Srimad bhagavatam mein likha hai ki Bhakti ke hi 2 sons hai. Gyan aur vairagya. To bhakti karke bhi gyan praapt hota hai. Iskcon ka translation bhale hi thoda alag ho lekin unhone ye soch kar use translate kiya hoga. Jai shree Krishna.
No respect for Prabhupada!!!!😢 All other Acharyas are far better cause they never changed the word of the lord!!! Wrong translation is wrong no matter who does it!😢 Jai Shree Krishna!❤
Oh brother. I want to meet Krishna. But without a guru, it's difficult to. Please direct me towards an actual sampradaya and parampara, where I can get initiated from a real guru. Thank you 🙏
i have read about 100 pages of GEETA BY ISKCON, its like written in devotion of krishna ji, not the real one, every 5th 10th line like says, krishna krishna jaap karo, like tbhi moksh milega, somewhere meanings are manupulated but only 10 20%
Bhai ye isiliye hei kyu ki sari book prabhu pad ke conversations pe bani hei or sare conversations jo hue hei wo prabhu pad or British logo ke bich hue hei isiliye jesus ka naam liya gya hei taki log samajh sake ki krishna hi supreme lord hei❤
@@adityadas4302jo Krishna bhagwan ke time pr nhi the unse relate krne ka koi fayda Nhi ISKCON baaki bhagwan ko nicha dikhate h joki galat h Sab bhagwan ek hi h
In relation to the words 'buddhau saranam', in Bhagavad Gita 2.49, Srila Sridhara Swami says " बुद्धौ शरणं त्रातारमीश्वरमाश्रयेत्यर्थः". This is exactly how Srila Prabhupada translates it. Don't believe in this fake video created out of envy for acaryas.
I'm attending iskcon free gita classes right now and can't deny that something feels off. Like so much focus on bhakti yoga. At one point they said that we should just chant that mantra and not do anything. Chanting hare Krishna mantra is a better way to salvation than doing good deeds according to them 🫤
Yes ....same feeling Suppose I love practicing juggling, they consider it wordly , material and degrade it.. Each person has his own way and interest... I want to choose the path of the warrior not of a priest or saint.
@@sathyanayaksk1330 same dude... i aspire to be a doctor and save people but according to iskcon missionaries, chanting all day is the best way to reach krishna.. i mean bhakti is essential but spending entire life in it instead of serving humanity is a lil too much. i bet their translation is wrong. imagine if arjuna had stopped fighting against kauravas and sat down chanting... evil would have succeeded...
@@gac379 precisely Swami Vivekananda is the real deal. He says " if a person is hungry " give him food first before preaching him anything.. Prabhupada condemns sport activities as waste of time.. Swamiji says strengthen ur body first before understanding gita. See , people like Abdul Kalam, Ambedkar, Bhagat singh ....they worked for the betterment of the country. So they possibly couldnt have transfixed on God. Does this mean they go to tell ? 😌
@@sathyanayaksk1330 I'm glad i found someone with the same opinion as me. I understand why they are emphasising so much on bhakti yoga. This is probably one of their business tactics. In the name of bhakti yoga, they get a lot of people visiting the iskcon mandirs to chant mantras, thereby increasing business. Prabhupada is a shrewd man and probably had a clear idea about all the plans, therefore he started preaching in America as they have no idea about our puranas and can easily be brainwashed. You know what enraged me so much? I arise from a family of Shaiva Brahmins and they once called shiva a 'demigod'. A FRICKING DEMIGOD. like the term demigod itself isn't mentioned in our puranas. And according to them shri krishna is the almighty and Vishnu is one of Krishna's avatars. There are many instances like this that made me leave their free online class and honestly I am proud of this decision. I know that because of iskcon, our hindu dharma is getting an international reach, but what's the point when they are preaching wrong things? i hope people wake up soon. And this isn't just about iskcon. Every other organisation, for an instance, esha foundation, is also quite shady. I hate the fact that they are minting out money in the name of dharma :/ (and really sorry if this is too long. I just have no one to talk to about this) Also, follow your dream as you wish, brother. Don't let anybody block your path.
No wonder When I read Geeta for the first time published by ISKON " it shocked me with bhakti, I am the one, I am the only one, and was like Is God that desperate. But on the quest came across Asta Bakra Geeta then moved to other Upanishads. The most awakened moment of life and since then My quest is to comprehend my own brahma. Thank you I was like this is what I was waiting for?
Han aisa mujhe v lga h...jha2 bhgwan krishna bolte h iskcon wale book m ki sirf mai hi bhgwan hun demigod ki puja krna byarth hai mujhe lga bhgwan krsihna aise to nhi ho skte..
To apkay jivan may kya parivartan hua hai kya ap bat sakte hsi mere hua hai may ek bhakt ban gaye pap punaya ka lekha jokha rakne lagi Gatti karne say phele hi Krishna ki awaj sunne lagi ......dusro ko dosh Dene say jyada logo kay Jeevan may jisay pad kar parivartan hot hai vo sahi mano
Ashtavakra Gita is different but it emphasizes on Atma. It also tells to liberate ourselves from this worldly life. But in Bhagwad Gita The Lord is himself telling everything. There are different topics covered for liberation. There is a big difference. If anyone gets enlightenment or even gets peace of mind then he or she has succeeded.
@@pratishayadav8992mata kyuki bhakti ki mana koi ni krra without bhakti,gyaan,karma kaam ni chlega all three are important for only one thing that is moksha but iskcon gyaan or karma ko dur fek deta h bas y problem hai. Samarpan to sabse shreshth karma hai parantu bina gyan or karma k samarpan kese hoga?
Because of iskcon atleast i started reading bhagawat gita ...but iam intelligent enough not to get brainwashed also
Use it as tool but never think theyr the authority
No you are not
@@jaipalsingh8931 bhai she's a woken, Don stop them from iskon too, jab woh log, periods, women's place compared to men etc, woh log khud hi samajh lenge
You are intelligent 😂😂😂😂Do you know that the one who says that he is very intelligent is the biggest fool in whole universe and you are the very big fool...😂
Geeta padh rahe ho aur apne aap Ko bahut Bada Gyaani samjh rahe ho are murkh Geeta tum Jaiso Ke liye nahi hai Tumhe padhne ka koi Profit Nahi hai
I am glad Hindus are realising it. I myself am atheist. In nacheyyo ko kya pta bhartiy darshan shastr ke bare me. Ek ne toh sidha swami Vivekananda pr hi durbhashy kr diya. Himmat toh dekho. In vaishnvo ne Bharat ka sar sharm se jhuka diya hai, desh videsh me. Nacheyye kahi ke.
Respect for gita press📈📈📈📈
Respect for gita press as well as iskcon atleast they are making us read bhagwad gita not Bible or Quran.
Oh my dear brother what would I say to bibble and Quran is also important to prove that God is one who is the supreme personality of godhead Krishna
In Muslim religion lord Krishna or Ram is called as Allah and in Christianity they called as christ
😂😂😂😂😂 🤣 krishna is a demigod 😂😂lol 😆 pakdandi pisconite. Adi Shakti, narayan and shiv are the supreme god😂😂. Not krishna lol . Average pisconiite 😂@@yatishsharma3699
Shutup 😂@@yatishsharma3699
😂😂😂😂😂@@yatishsharma3699
गीता प्रेस को कोटि कोटि धन्यवाद, जो हमें सही गीता अनुवाद से लाभान्वित करा रहे हैं।
हम किसी को उपहार दें तो गीता प्रेस की पुस्तकें दें।
गोरखपुर ऒर इस्कॉन दोनों दो दोनों best हें लेकिन सामने vala isckon से ही कृष्णा की बातो को समझ पायेगा ये मेरा दावा हें क्यू की गीताप्रेस के शब्द बहुत हार्ड हें सबको समझ नहीं आता बहोत ज्यादातर पढ़े लिखो को भी नहीं. ❤
@@RaamAudio Asaan chez zaruri nahi acchi ho. Aap kisi granth ki transition nahi badal sakte. Ye to ek tarah se crime Homa chahiye. I know not everyone knows Sanskrit but Geeta press have Hindi translation too
@@nish8756 ट्रांसलेशन नहीं बदला हें लेकिन कर्म का महत्व कृष्णभावनायुक्त कर्म बताया हें ताकि जो कृष्णा चाहे वही हों, गीता में अर्जुन ने जमीन के लिये युद्ध नहीं किया था कृष्णा के लिये किया था तो गीता का सही ट्रांसलेशन यही होना चाहिए क्यू की उस समय ज्यादातर लोग भक्ति भाव में ही मग्न थे लेकिन सब की भक्ति करते थे कृष्णा ने कहा मुजमे ही सब हें ऒर मेरे लिये कर्म करो या मेरे लिये भक्ति करो दोनों सेम हें इसलिए गीता ज्ञान दिया लेकिन समय के हिसाब से लोगो का भक्ति से ही ध्यान भटक गया तब जाकर प्रभुपाद ने ट्रांसलेशन में कृष्णा जो कहना चाहते थे वो कलयुग के लोगो को नये युग के हिसाब से समझाया ऒर इसीलिए isckon की गीता पढ़ने kको बोला ताकि ये मैसेज घर घर पहुँच सके, प्रभुपाद यहाँ से प्रचार के लिये कुछ लेकर नहीं गएथे सब खुद कमा कर कृष्णा के लिये प्रचार करना पड रहा था लेकिन भारत में आज ऐसा एक भी संप्रदाय बताओ जो दान के पैसे के बगैर खुद के दम पर आगे बधा hहों... इसलिए isckon best हें प्रभुपाद का हिस्ट्री देख लो वहा क्या क्या हुआ... खुद ही isckon से प्यार हों जायेगा.. लेकिन aap नहीं समझोगे, कोई विरोधी नहीं समझ पायेगा कृष्णा के इस संघ को.... ऒर isckon के भी पहले से यहां रह रहे गुरुके चेले जो चैतन्यमहाप्रभुजी के जितने अनुयायी हें यहाँ के उनको पूछो की क्या isckon गलतहें??? कोई नहीं कहेगा की गलत he...
@@nish8756 iskcon gita ka prabhav dekhna hai to vrindavan jaao. jo jeevan badal de wo powerful hai. Baki shloka same hain. tippadi alag hai. isme comparision nahi hona chahiye, ye moorkhta hai.
@@dogbite-7 Kisi religious scriptures ki misleading translation is conspiracy. Tumhara logic ajeeb hai, agar koi nakli samaan manufacture karke jyada sale kar raha ho to use original maan lo. Vrindavan ho ya Vancouver, matter nahi karta. US mei bhi inhone networking karke bhakt banaye hain. Agar Krishna se itna pyar hai to uski translation kyu badal rahe ho. Maine khud ek inke followers ko challenge kiya tha, jo kehta tha hamari geeta sahi hai. Naa sirf maine use galat prove kiya, sath mei ye bhi kaha agar agge se kisi ki ye books mere area me sale ki to police complaint karunga.
If we don't learn Sanskrit, we are doomed to suffer like Muslims. This video is an eye opener.
7:09 Abe gadhe tum jo translation dikha rahe vo galat hei. Budhiyog ka matlab nahin pata.
Yog matlab kya? Yog matlab ishwar se yog. So budhiyog in practical sense means hari ki budhi se prakashit hone wali buddhi. Apne satwa rajas tamas wali budhi nahin. Warna to allah wale bhi budhiyog kar rahe kafiron kon maarke. Krishna bhakti(samarpan) hui budhi matlab budhiyog. So iskcon ki translation sahi hei in practical sense.
Tum log gadhe ho...koi practical knowledge to hei nahin. Aur kisi anpadh ka translation dikha rahe. Murkh pehle yog matlab samjho.
Koi ni duba rha sir aapko… Ek hi bat likhi h …bas iss tarike se likhi h ki log implement kr sake ….baki books to log bhot padhte h
@@musicalmedicoanu8132sun bhai srimad Bhagavad Geeta Ramayan,ved or puran hindu dharm ka basic hai or isko koi bhi organisation badal Raha hai apne according to wo galat kar raha hai kyu ki aisa kane se aaj ka insan bhagwan or Rishi muniyo ke diye huye message ko nahi samjh payega ye iskon ka Geeta dekhne ke baad lag raha hai ki ye log Krishna ka MSG ni samjhna chahte hai balki sirf ye apna MSG samjhana chahte hai taki inki fayeda ho.
@@ShivamKumar-so5fuBhai sab
Iskcon ke proponent Srila Prabhupada ji ka koi alagh duniya ka MSG nhi hai
Woh Krishna ki aur logo ka marg darshan kar rhe hai
Unke Gita me kisiko bhi harm karne ki baat nhi likhi hai
Gita press walo ko problem hai ki har jagah bhakti bhakti kyu likha hi
But bhakti me burayi kya hai
Hamare sabhi ved upanishad puranas ka ak hi conclusion hai
BHAGWAD PREMA
SO whi likha hai Iskcon Gita me
Aur bad and good exist everywhere...koi ak galat bolta hai toh Puri organisation toh buru nhi ho sakti na
Aur is admi ne agr itna Gita para hai hi toh apne suna guru ko lekr inke words😢😢😢😢itna Gita ke bad he is using abusive words Jo sanatan ke virodh hai
no knowledge will relieve you from suffering 😊 , everything is here in the human subconsciousness.A person who knows no language will know what is right n wrong for him or her.We just tend to rely too much on books and schools of thoughts and get clouded by so many ways of thinking.
It is heart breaking to see some organisations are misleading people to gain followers. they are dividing our gods, someone is saying lord krishna is superior someone is saying lord shiva is superior. normal people like me will totally get confused. please be united and keep our religion and culture above any organisation.
you have no brain to understand gita . that is why you confused.
Shivaya Vishnu roopaya shiv roopaya vishnave ❤️
Seriously 😑
You are all greater knowledgeable person than Bhagban ved vyas.
Bro, even i had a nasty experience in Iskcon ,where they invited me for Bhagavad Gita class on sunday. Actually i am not well versed in sanskrit, so i am reading english version of geeta press Srimadbhagvad Gita and i raised many questions to them, so they asked me which Gita ,are you reading and i said Gita press one, as soon as i named Gita press, the main head who was giving lecture, got enraged and started saying that that press is useless and bla bla bla, than i simply told that main head that you know what is the difference between you( Iskcon) and gita press is that gita press never discourage Isckon and never do advertisement like you people and you just teach one aspect of Gita that is bhaktiyoga but gita press Srimadbhagvad gita comprises of jnanayoga, karmayoga and bhaktiyoga ,which you people will never understand, then next time onward they stopped inviting me in their sunday classes.
your thought is as prescribed in kaliyuga.
@@sadhnasharma573 you know, infact I told them what you are teaching is bhaktiyoga but Gitapress Gita comprises of all 3 forms and also told them I have hugh respect for prabhupada ji (founder of iskcon) but not for so - called parbhuji working in Iskcon today, who straightforward criticised Gita press Gita by calling it crap and for whom devotion is business now. That guy who was taking Sunday class was very arrogant, aggressive and egoistic but our Srimad Bhagvad Gita teaches us to refrain from such things.
@@sadhnasharma573 kindly first ask so- called prabhuji in Iskcon not to defame our Gitapress Srimadbhagvad Gita which is our holy book. Ask them to be equanimous which our holy book main highlight is. Ask them not to fix the rate of their membership and other related rituals like gau seva etc because there are many who are not capable of providing such rate in our country, ask them instead of making it business focus on the devotion.
@@sadhnasharma573 इस्कॉन एक संस्था है संप्रदाय नहीं। संप्रदाय केवल 4 हैं। इस्कॉन जिस संप्रदाय के होने का दावा करता है उसी के सिद्धांतो के खिलाफ चलता है।
@@sadhnasharma573 Sorry the intention is not to defame. We have correct them. I am worried these days because ISCON is becoming islam of hinduism. Because they dont recognise other gods even Sri Maha Vishnu as god which will pave a pathfor dividersof our Dharma.
I was also thinking like you when I read ISKCON gita for the first time "There are so many mistranslations". Then I read 2 other Gitas of anciant gaudiya vaishnava acharyas and understood the conclusion of gita as surrendering to Supreme lord Krishna by always thinking of Krishna, rendering loving service to Him as given in 18.65 & 66. Then I understood the greatness of ISKCON's gita. Prabhupad has taken the conclusion of gita and presented it everywhere possible, so that any common man can understand the secret. All glories to Srila Prabhupad & ISKCON
Absolutely Right
Sir iskon Bhagwat Gita is best it has done lot of life transformation brought big change in others life I have seen it practically it’s matter of our trust
I respect your perspective.
However, Geeta is VERY EXPLICIT in its Advaita. While recognising Dwaita as legitimate. Geeta 18 20-21-22 "Advaita is Satvic, Dwaita is Rajasic, rest is Tamasic and based in inferring entireties from partialities and based in illogic". Chapter 11, Vishwaswaroop, his Comic Form contains ALL. All things moving, non moving. His FORM itself is limitless.
Prabhupad and others from Madhavacharya School COULD have maintained Dwaita and that would have been legitimate.
BUT - they go out of their way. They falsely translate Geeta, because it's prima facie can ONLY mean Vishisth Adwaita. From there on, they don't stop - they vilify and slander Adwaita. Calling them "demonic preachers".
As they get exposed, they are getting more vicious. Amogh Lila is trying to bring down Adwaita icons too. With his "Would a Saint do this?". Well, would a Saint deliberately misinterpret and lie about Geeta?
They need not have attacked Adwaita school if they were sincere about it. Entire "Here is our meaning of Geeta for lay person" would have been carried out without needing to demonize others and fabricate Geeta. This makes their "intent" VERY suspicious if not entirely malicious.
Also, the point that the common person cannot understand Geeta is demonstrably false. Vivekananda and Acharya Prashant both extol it without any pollution of text. Neither they give false analogies - the properties and characteristic if the meaning and the comparison is always accurate.
But Iskon, for its legacy of relentless demonization of other schools (which are ACTUALLY based in Geeta) will be exposed. That is simply Iskon's Karma. Iskon should revise its stance and reconcile its core tenets with the actual text. That would be the graceful option.
| Om |
I am totally agree because Prabhupada is Pure realised soul coming in line of Guru Parampara .But now a days everyone wants to prove their translation,They should understand that BG as it is by Prabhupada has transformed masses ,Reality is checked by appreciation and transformation.
I read many version but actual meaning more or less same, iskcon gita, swami mukunanada gita, vivek vani, gita press, and some more.
This guy wrongly interpreting.
First of all i am not iskon devotee , so they are not brainwashing actually they focused on way of Bhaktiyog , and ultimately they are making you Krishna devotee not terrorist 😅 brainwashed is not a suitable word here.
Correct
Wahi tou... Har koi apne deity ko priority deta hai... Koi organisation perfect nhi.... Lekin kuch log sirf larte rehte hai... Bhaad mei jaaye sab kuch bas apni bhakti pei dhyan do bhagwan apne app rasta dikhayenge
Absolutely...They are doing good thing..But translations are little problematic
@@dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569 You don't call that 'little' problematic 😂
@@dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569 You don't call that 'little' problematic 😂
Iskcon geeta is just a opinion of a person who read geeta. Not geeta itself.
The original is Sanskrit we just need good translation not a opinion.
Geetapress is the best one we got.
It's Not a Opinion , it's Yatharoop means same it is as Original.
@@itsajaypatelNo it’s not it’s not translated as it is in Sanskrit. Iskon did not invent Sanskrit.
@@nish8756 I mean Same Translation of Original. I read it, In first Few Pages they Mention it's Translation is same as Krishnaji Original Words, that's why it's called Yatharoop, I know They are Making us fool at some Level.
@@itsajaypatel Yes they are selling these books in outside India & I confronted one of their disciple in US. She just ran away when I mentioned how their Gita is not the correct translation & they are actually offending Hindus.
@@nish8756 Business Buddy Business,
ISKCON अच्छा है या बुरा ये तो नई पता पर जीवन में अच्छा इंसान बन ने के लिए आपको भक्ति मार्ग का सहारा लेना ही पड़ेगा बिना भक्ति के आप अच्छे इंसान नई बन सकते , ISKCON कहता है कृष्ण को जानो , मंदिर जाव या ना जाव बस कृष्ण को जानो , सनातनी सो रहे थे इतना दिन कोन आके उनको जगाया आपके वीडियो से तो कोई नई जागा अपने जगाया भी नई कोसिस भी नई की , ये बात 100% सही है की ISKCON ने हिन्दुओं को जगाया है और कृष्ण भावना अमृत प्रदान किया ,
हरे कृष्ण,🙏❤️
हरी बोल
acha insan hone k liye bhakti hi jaruri nahi, ye khud krishna ne gita me alag alag yog k bare me samjhaya hai... apane man se kuch bhi mat boliye jake gita padhiye
में भी तो वो ही बोल रहा हूं जाके गीता पड़ो , कलयुग है मनुष्य अपने कर्म तो करता ही है पर भक्ति में ध्यान नई देता , में तो बोल रहा हूं कर्म तो हम करते ही है थोड़ा ध्यान भक्ति में भी लगा लो मेरे भाई , By the way am a software engineer 🙏❤️ हरे कृष्ण
@@LearnWithJK03 sahi kaha bhakti se koi hani nhi hoti har condition me labh hi hai ...
iskcon ne HariHar bhedi bana rakhe hai , deviyo ki kuch mante nahi hai , yaha tak ki Ram aur Krishn me bhi bhed kar rahe hai aur yahi chij videshiyo ko aur apno ko sikha rahe hai. aur ab to apne hi santo ka apman kar rahe hai . Agar aisa Hindu jagana ho jo sirf ek sanstha tak hi simit reh jaye aur dusre devi devta aur santo ka apman kare to isse achha hai Hindu sota Rahe.
Har Har Mahadev , Jay shree krishna
@@harvy345 aap samjhe nai bhai , aap khud shiv or shakti , radha or krishna me vhed kar rahe hoo , dono me koi ved nahi hai radha ke bina krishna hamesa adhure hai , Radha ko pujoge to krishna bhi chale ayenge , haan ISKCON wale amog lila prabhu ji kaa bhasan mujhe v bura laga jab Radha radha nam karne walo shanto ke upar bola or swami Vivekananda ji ke bare me bola bhot hi buri tarike se represent kiya unko , aap acchi chijo ko pakdo bhai buri chijo ko nai, aap bhakti ko pakdo ISKCON ko nai , bhakti aap ghar pe v kar sakte ho ISKCON jane ki jarurat nai hai ,
कीर्तनिया सदा हरि
हरे कृष्ण ❤🙏
हरी बोल
भगवत गीता का simple translation चाहिये तो ज्ञानेश्वरी पढीए simple language मे🙏🌅
There's a saying in spirituality, if a scholar want to understand bhakti and krsna, he will never able to know the actual reality but if a person having compassionate heart will understand and develop the love for God even without knowledge, bhakti me hriday chahiye, dimaag lagaoge to kuch samjh nhi aayega
Baat sahi or galat ki he baat bhakti ki nhi koi aapko bhakti kese karni he ye nhi bta skta bhakti ek seva bhaav or nirantar karma karte rehne ka naam he karma ko jano agar ye shrishti ghumna rok de to koi nhi bachega ye is shrishti ka karma he, tumhara karma kya he sirf bhakti krna karma nhi he karma krte rehne ko he bhakti kehte he ye krishna samjha smjha kr thak gye pr log smjh nhi paay , tum laakho bar naam lelo krishna ka pr krishna sirf uski he sunega jo karma karega har karma se pehle parabhu ko yaad kro or krte jaao karma ko
Bruh.
@@prakshit1909 aap toh ulta he bol gaye bhaiya Krishna ji ne 'Karma' shabd ke saath 'Yog' shabd bhi lagaya hai jiska arth hai aatma ka parmatma se milan vo kehte hai karma karo par fal ki chinta na karo aur karma karo par iss bhaav se ki yaha kuch mera nahi hai jo kuch hai Bhagwaan ka hai aur mai jo bhi kuch karma kar raha hu vo unki he seva mein kar raha hu isko kehte hai Karmyog ki karma karne ke pehle, karma karte samaye, AUR karma karne ke baad bhi SIRF bhagwaan ka smaran karein naaki sirf karma karne se pehle formality kardi unka naam leke baaki karma karte SAMAYE unko BHOOL gaye YE baat Krishna ji samjhaate samjhaate thak gaye aur dursri baat Krishna ji unki he sunte hai jo har vakt unka dhyaan karta rehta hai naaki apne ko 'karta' (doer) maanke sansaar ko paane ke laalach mein bhaagta rehta hai aur apne aap ko shareer samajh baitha hai aur apni aatma ka lakshya jaanta he nahi jo ki hai God-realisation (bhagwad praapti) bhagwaan ke prati samarpan, bhagwaan se nishkaam prem (selfless love)
Samjhe aap?
Yahi to isckon bhi sikhata hai bhai 😂😂...tumlogo isckon pach nahi raha hai ki hamse zyada gyani kaun aa gaya hai idhar😂😂...wo bhakti ka matlab is video ko daalne waale ko khud nhi pata hoga...aadha Jan ko lagata hai bhakti ka matlab sanyasi banna😂😂to aise dimag walon ke lie isckon hai bhi nahi.. bhagwan ke lie Prem badhana hai to bhakti zaruri hai...sirf karma karke bhagwan ke prati Prem nahi aayega...aur Prem badhane ke lie bhagwan ka naam...aur puja ki jaati hai...material world Mai aaye ho to karm to janm se lekar maran tak karna hai...sirf karm karne ke lie manushya sharir nahi milta hai...bhagwan ko prassanna karne ke lie milta hai...unke karib jaane ke lie milta hai...
correct brother
I follow Bhagwat Geeta courses by Ramakrishna Mission. Whenever they take any course on Bhagwat Geeta, they take the real Bhagwat Geeta original sanskrit version and then teaches from it. Those are actually one of the most accurate interpretations of the slokas.
Are the courses online or in-person?
@@chriswoodson6643 The courses happen offline. But the video lectures are available online.
@@skittles6486 From where I can learn them online?
@@AviatorBro Here is the channel. Go to playlists section, you will find Bhagwad Geeta both hindi and bengali version
ruclips.net/video/eWKlcuvg45U/видео.html
I also follow the Ramakrishna Mission books. They sell books on their store (it is also available online for those looking to buy their books). Even Gita Press is very reliable in terms of translations. I always compare different translations whenever I find myself in doubt.
आपने उन्हें expose किया, बहुत सुंदर
परन्तु यदि आप अपनी भाषा और मर्यादित रखते, आपकी बात सभी के लिए और प्रभावशाली होती...🙏
Ha ye baat toh balki inki Geeta hath me lene ka tareeka aur page platne ka tareeka bhi theek nhi hai Geeta bhagwan ki Vani he aur jab bhi Geeta haath me lo toh pyar se päge paltne chahiye aise nhi matlab Geeta ji aur hamari school ki notebook me koi anter nhi
He did.
गीता जैसा महान ग्रंथ को अपवित्र करने वालो से कैसे बात करे, सच्चे भक्त को गुस्सा जरूर आना चाहिए
He did absolutely right. That is how fraudsters shd be handled.
We can get inspired by anything but once inspired we have to go to the core books . Like we got inspired by Adipurush, went and bought ValmikiRamayanam( Geeta Press ) and started reading.
We gotta remember this as now-a-days inspiration can come from anywhere 🙏
My inspiration was also iskcon gita
But later I got in core things
Not the iscon one
It's not only about ISKCON, other organisations may be doing this to favour their organisation. The problem is we are not learning Sanskrit and depending on others to explain these for us. I think this is the real problem.
Yess
We take the meaning of the sankrit word what previous acarya says not by our material scholarship.
Meaning of Sanskrit reveal by the mercy of lord but not by our own efforts.
@@shyambalaramshyambalaram3989 sab acharyas ki same translation hsi hai bhai😊
Madhvacharya ki ramanuja charya ki Baldev bhushan ji ki geetapress ki sbki translation same hsi hai
Bhashya sbka alag alag hota h acharya ke time pe hindi nhi thi sanskrit he thi sanskrit ke shloka unke liye already he translation thi vo sirf bhashya krte the sanskrit me
Isiliye sb geeta ki translation same h kyuki baaki sampradaya walo ko business nhi karna iskcon ke jaise
@@BalajiCreation108Achha Matlab iskcon itna successful ho gya baki organization se jada aur unki geeta logo ka jeewan Badal rhi h to usko ab bol do ki business kr rhe h ye log waah.😅😅
Are bhai kabhi bahar niklo kaliyuga ke log jo bhagwan ko bhul ke dukh ke Sagar me hai unke pas bhagwan ka Sandesh phuchao unko harinam lena sikaho.
Idhar youtube pe baith ke criticize krna bhot assan hai thik hai. Tmhe pta bhi ni hai iskcon ke bhakt bina kisi swarth apna jeewan de dete hai jan Kalyan ke liye tmhe kya pta.
Aur Jha tk baat rhi galat translation ki to aajana kbhi face to face tmhre saare jo doubt ko minute me dur kr denge .
Iskcon wale hai hm sb kuch leke chalte hai .
Ye movement ek sudh bhakt ke realization pe based hai aise ni youtube pe baith ke kuch bak diya.
Aur business waigrah bina jaane smjhe mat bako.
Tmko pta bhi ek temple ko chalne ke liye kitna paisa lgta hai .
Hm bas kitab ka print cost lete h na ki dhandha kyuki agar koi paise dega to uski value krega padh ke.
Aur agar donation maange ayenge to bologe ke bhik maang rhe kya kre bhai btao😅.
Kbhi kisi ek insan ko bhagwan ka naam japna btao pta chalega kitna khun paseena lgta ek bhakt bnanae me .
Niklo bhai ghar se logo ka prachar kro
The problem with us is we justify what we believe, not what is correct. With all due respect, acharyas and gurus may not be correct always. Bhagawan Krishna explained different types of maarg(path), it was not only the Bhakti maarg. We should not argue, shall introspect and analyse what is correct. Not blindly follow anyone - be this video or your guru or acharya. We shall strive for what is correct by intuitive thinking.
I am not an ISKCON member, but can say for sure that they are responsible for a large share of awareness and spread of Sanaatana Dharma across the world. No other organisation has been as successful, and of course while it does have its share of internal problems and politics, with such success come the detractors and naysayers.
Iskcon is a cult
One should respect the success of ISKCON but that doesn't mean they are correct.
Falsity often travels the whole world while the truth is preparing itself for its first exposure.
Success !!..
Even Hitler had success
But he killed so many
Prabhupad was an agent of Ford ka baccha
And
Created and MNC
Using Krishna as Brand ambassador
Beatles also
Yes, but Lord Krishna will make them correct.😊
But spreading wrong information, wrong in formation is a big zero
The whole gita is to surrender to supreme personality the path may be other but the result is same. Hare Krishna ❤
correct brother
Is video me kaha ki iskcon hat jagah bhakti bhakti kr raha hai but ye to sahi ki iskcon bhakti se inshano ko maya se alag kr raha iskcon ne meri bhi bhaut madad ki thi even kr raha hai
@@NikunjGoyal1008 exactly✅... ISKCON is about Krishn consciousness not only pooja pat.
But u should not do wrong translation
@@Arandomguyat1 There is no wrong translation. The video maker is misleading people. For example, in relation to the words 'buddhau saranam', in Bhagavad Gita 2.49, Srila Sridhara Swami says " बुद्धौ शरणं त्रातारमीश्वरमाश्रयेत्यर्थः". This is exactly how Srila Prabhupada translates it. Don't believe in this fake video created out of envy for acaryas.
The main issue is which school of thought is giving the purport/Bhasya: 2 main schools - dvet (duality) and advet (non-duality) which itself has further sub schools - around 7/8. However, direct translation of Sanskrit shouldn’t be different.
Shankaracharya translation is non-duality related, same from Bhaktivedanta - Swami Sarvariyananda has good non-duality podcasts of Bhagvadgita.
Iskon is pure duality and hence pure bhakti.
Pakhand nahin hain balki different school of thought.
Madhvacharya ji ki bhi translation same h bhai geeta ko koi translation change nhi hoti bhashya ho skte h
Video dekha nhi lgta h aapne dhang se.
Translation or bhashya ka toh farak samjho
@@BalajiCreation108 agreed, edited.
@@BalajiCreation108 Madhvacarya didn't translate to English.
@@srinivasacaryadasa4915 You're missing the entire point. The target language to which the sanskrit shlokas are being translated is irrelevant. They're changing the substance of the shloka itself to suit their needs. The differences in schools of thought are considered too, however, you can't mistranslate important spiritual texts to support your point.
@@floe61 I am not missing anything here. Srila Prabhupada's translations are inline with the spirit of the Gita and follows in the foot steps of previous acaryas who have accepted Krsna's instructions without personal motivation. Sanskrit words have multiple meanings and the meaning that fits into the flow and the spirit of the Gita will be chosen by the acaryas. Sometimes there may be multiple interpretations. But as long as they fit into the flow and bigger essence of the text the interpretation is valid. There is no such thing as original translation. Original is in Sanskrit and when translated to local languages the acaryas explain in a way it makes sense in the local language. The fruit of a tree is judged by the fruit it produces, phalena pariciyate. The impact that Srila Prabhupada's Gita had in the lives of people across the globe is phenomenal, life changing and unparalleled. There are envious people who could do something better in their lives than go after a pure devotee of Lord Krsna and bring misfortune upon themselves. Bhakti will be destroyed in our hearts if we blaspheme pure devotees.
Iskcon has contributed a lot to spread Hinduism across the world. Because of Iskcon, Hinduism Sanatan Dharma is spreading like a wild fire. In fact Gita Press is above of all. Many many tributes to Gita Press the superior Publication of all times for Hindu scriptures ❤❤
Hinduism nhi keval iskcon fail raha hai
Paisa ke liye fayde ke liye kuch bhi ho sakta hai
@@ipratiksachan फ़ायदा ही सही। तुम फ़ायदा ले कर ही हिन्दू धर्म का प्रसार कर के दिखा दो। कितने लोगों को भगवद्गीता पहुंचाई है? इतने सुंदर विशाल मन्दिरों का निर्माण, गोशालाएं, मन्दिर का रखरखाव, कोविड से अभी तक 7.5 करोड़ लोगों को भोजन कराना, भगवद्गीता का प्रचार प्रसार, गुरुकुल शिक्षा, सब पैसे से ही होगा, फोकट में नहीं होता। तुम्हारे कथावाचक जया किशोरी टाइप लोग 1 करोड़ रु तक कथा करने और पंडाल में नाचने के लिए लेती है । पैसे के बिना कुछ नहीं होता। समझे भाईसाहब।
Sanatan Dharm is not spreading among foreigner countries , especially in European countries, people of Europe they actually don't say a single good thing about hindusium & our culture instead of they hate ,mock & make fun of us , our culture ,our relegion & the way we dressed each & every thing only the iskcon &iskonics are showing a small portion to you the rest all behind the curtains
@@ankitrawal3240 Hinduism in England is the third largest religion in the country, with over 1,020,533 followers as of the 2021 Census. This represents over 1.5% of the English population, up from 1.1% the previous decade. Hindus are predominantly in the cities of London and Leicester, where they make up greater proportions of the population (Hindu Enclaves, also known as Hindu Hotspots). England has a number of Hindu temples, including the Hindu temple at Neasden which is the largest Hindu temple in Europe.Recently the largest Hindu Mandir in the North of England, the Bradford Lakshmi Narayan Hindu Temple opened in Bradford,West Yorkshire.
I agree, I myself have seen so many faults in their geeta. Especially insulting our shiva. I hate it I hate when they turn us against us. They’ve insulted Shiva in their bhagavadgeeta. Saying he himself got trapped by maya. I don’t accept that.
Dont follow iskon culture. They will destroy your family by brain washing and your family will be spoiled. You can go for any bhagwat gita except iskon.
Right
shiva and narayana are both satchitanada.
Don't spread hatred
Read the Shiv Puran
Shiva was indeed trapped by Maya that was the reason he cut off his son's head (Shri Ganesh ji)
That means Shiva is not omniscient which Krishna is in the Geeta
Problem is we fight internally so much that we fail to see what is happening around us .
Yes
After watching this I am happy to buy ISKON geeta and I will also distribute it also because ISKON Geeta writer Swami Prabhupāda is not only a best translater but also legend bhakt.
My question
Why people only love to read ISKON geeta? Even i myself love to read ISKON geeta.
After reading ISKON geeta I am trying to become bhakt
I am become vegetarian
Try to follow brahmacharya
And many more
I don't think if I was read another geeta I will do any of these things
You can do but anyone who knows Sanskrit would not fall in their trap of fake translation
iskcon hates mahadev. counts shiv as a dev not a god. now let me get started. prabhupaad counts krishna/vishnu as the only deity in the world and said in our temples only radha rani or jagganath must be worshipped. iskcon are vaishnavs who hates shiv and shaivs. There is a shlok in iskcon's geeta chapter 13 saying about krishna having another diety inside him which is maheshwar. maheshwar means shiv. in the translation they cut off shiv and say maheshwar is maha ishwar who is non other then shiv. I can go on with their pakhad. but i guess this is enough
Becoming devotee according to ISKCON will only make you Andhabakth, and it's like christianity where prabhupada is their messenger like jesus, where in reality he's just a translator(which we've seen in this video how good he is). ISKCON people value prabhupada so much, what about VedaVyasa maharshi who actually written those puranas. Sanatan dharmam concept of god is different than any other religion. As far as I understood, Universe can be broken down(viewed as) as thrimurthis, where shiva is the one who holds, Vishnu is the one who runs the process, and Brahma can be related to Brahman(intelligence/ chaitanyam in us). I'm still trying to understand the significance of each god. God doesn't mean we've to look up and imagine someone situated somewhere like abrahamic religions. Religion is part of Sanatana dharmam but sanatana dharmam itself is not religion.
@@chagantiraviteja9483 well do not use term ‘Andhbhakt’. It has no relevance whatsoever & no one ever has been explained this term & looks like an idiot
@@raghavdikshit5314who said maheshwar means shiv ? Maheshwar means mahan + ishwar. Jo ishwar supreme hai. It's an adjective.
You can be a devote of shiva. That's great. But according to brahma samhita shiva is a form of Krishna only. He has the purpose to rule taamsik goon. He has 50 qualities where Krishna in his full form has 64 qualities. Its all there already in brahma samhita.
If you love shiva and hate krishna there is no bigger fool than you. You don't even understand the true hindu sanatan dharma's essence.
I don't like prabhupada or iskon. I eat and relish meat. I don't like his views on gandhi, vivekananda and ramakrishna. But i still read that gita book because he is the only translator who loves krishna above everything else. Nothing wrong in that.
The sad part is many many people follow the mistranslated gita
thank u so much for confirming my doubts. you are doin god's own work, may krishna bless you
Every scripture leads you to bhakti, you can go in circles and find it after spending good part of your life but end result is bhakti, Karm yog becomes bhakti when you start giving all credit to supreme lord, same applies to gyan yog or dhyan yog. In Bhagwat Geeta, last advice to Arjun from Lord was to full surrender to Krishna and forget about all other aspect "guhiyatam gyan"
I don't care because I only read Shlokas and meaning because commentry is often manipulated but I still Love Iskcon for their Devotion to our Lord Krishna.
But then why their devotee spread false information like bhagwan shiva is a demigod and only krishna is Supreme
Because you are an iskconist 😂🫵🏻🫵🏻
Wow then you're brainwashed 😂😂 dharma always allows to question not like abrahamic
Yes i also noticed. But if you think in broad way, if we do bhakti then budhhi automatically purified and will become buddhi yuktam. So no need to fight internally with our sanatan people.
Nah they don't even teach karma yog they are making zombies not real sanatanis who can't even defend himself in danger
Bhagavad Geeta is the essence of Upanishads(Vedanta). Which remembers the ultimate purpose of human life and the ways to achieve the moksha( liberation). The goal is one but the paths to reach it are many. Those paths to gain moksha are explained in Geeta in 18 chapters names end with Yoga( the bond which connects ātma with Paramāthma).
Plz do read Geeta press ghorakpur's Shankara bashya Geeta only.
But amogh lila made fun of this too in that swami Vivekananda video..he said how can different paths take u to one goal.. If u want to go to Australia and you landed to Antarctica, arctic.. Australia ko jaane ka marg ek hi hai.. Abb kya hi bolne ka inko, Australia ka example spiritual enlightenment ke sath jod raha hai
@@creativeaarts4023 Few people don't even have common sense and they call themself as Sanyasi. If you want to go to Australia you can go by a ship or by an aeroplane. You can go by constructing a massive long bridge and can go by walk on that. But ultimately your goal is to reach your destination i.e Australia. Same as there are many ways to attain moksha. The choice is ours. You know bhakti gives us purification ( chitta shuddhi). By simply chanting hare krishna one can't get moksha even in his entire life. Self realisation ( I'm soul not the body) is must and should to attain moksha. The self realisation is attained in Nirvikalpa samadhi( the ultimate state of meditation).
@@creativeaarts4023uki unlogoka iskcon tika huwa hai Australia America Europe k foreigners k paiso k upar islea unlogoko hamesha videsh hi nazar ata hai😂😂😂😂
The only way to salvation is Lord Jesus Christ.
Amen
@@Itsfmt your jesus died long ago now stop these bullshit 🤣😂🤣🤣 paganism is reviving and increasing in England 😂😂😂
नाहं प्रकाश: सर्वस्य योगमायासमावृत: | text like Gita is so flexible...that its knowledge can be applied for any path of devotion....and in this Gita... Prabhupad has given the easiest and topmost path especially for the people of kalyuga which is Krishna Consciousness to attain God.... Hare Krishna🙏
Bro your so called GURU is not greater than the God/Speaker himself. Why are you so foolish to think that prubhupada is smarter than god himself. To change gods speech according to his will/ profit
this is true the translation what exactly are should not matter, what matters is the intention, the translation are so flexible that they can be altered in any way possible and i dont think iskcon translation is teaching anything wrong , no one in kalayuga is so good to achieve liberation just by theri "karma" so bhakti is what which can overcome the karma
@@Admin-tk6ri the intention you are talking about ....bhagwan krishna has told each single word ...even each single matra with certain intention ....u can not distort a single word which came from bhagawan' s vaani ....it is criminal ....you are applying your human like intentions and thus human translations to justify and modify bhagawan' s vaani .....are u serious?😂😂😂😂
prabhupad has given topmost path ?..... 😂😂😂😂what can i say?....yes ..bhakti siddhanta was given by prabhupad ..right?😂😂
the only thing that prabhupad has given ...is distorted meaning and distorted translation of bhagwaan' s vaani ....the ultimate audacity anyone can perform .
@@drpg3250search "Srila Prabhupada did wrong translation? part 1" its a YT short. hope you'll get your answer.shree radhe.
I even noticed it and started only reading the Sanskrit part and understand what it is rather than reading their tatparya!!!
Thanks for noticing and highlight
There is no other Gita, it's either authentic translation or manipulated version the one ISKCON presents. My heart bleeds when I see these manipulated versions being named original and creating divide.
I / we are not against ISKCON but it takes a lot to accept the wrongfulness of self.
They call Shiv ji a demigod ? A term which had never existed in Satya Sanatan Dharm, it was introduced by ISKCON itself. Unfortunately no text presented by them Is authentic and real it is just the will of one man and now the belief of thousands 🙏.
Sir can I ask you something??
@@babluchakroborty1054 please go ahead sir, I'll try my best if it's something in my knowledge.
@@yogeshchaurasia5611 in Gita lord krishna consider " stri", " vaiyas(merchant)" and " sudra" as " sinful and low birth" can you tell me why ? 🥺
@@yogeshchaurasia5611 even a pandit of iskon said without pita, pati,putra a stri is weak and even when we are in our periods we are " auchut? 🥺 Is that really krishna thinks about us like that 😭
The reason this actually makes sense is because during war, why would lord krishna preach about bhakti when it was necessary for Arjuna to do his Karma
The karma in bhakti is called akarma and by doing bhakti one is able to do akarma . Read bhagwad gita my friend you'll get to know more about types of karma.
@@mukundboyatwth it was not what he asked for😂
@@mukundboyat word akarma has nothing to do with bhakti , when you translate akarma it means "inactivity" , the thing you said , tell it to Sanskrit scholars, I have asked it to my Sanskrit prof. before in University, the translation simply mean inactivity or where no action is going on
Bhakti yoga has only 20 shlokas in whole bhagavtheeta while there are many shlokas and yogas on karma
Fake Krishna . Never existed
Many Iskcon translations of sacred texts like Bhagavad Gita, Chaitanya Charitamrita, and Srimad Bhagavatam contain errors, misinterpretations, or biases, leading to misunderstandings.
Thanks to Iskon I know about Krishna and the Gita......
😊they have changed the world to be positive......Steve jobs and George Harrison were a part of it........😊
Undoubtedly credit has to be given to ISKON for popularizing Geeta among masses.
But the problem is when they translate Karma Yog, Gyan Yog and everything from Devotion point of view, because for a devotee, nothing but devotion is paramount.
Steve jobs was not influenced by Iskon Gita. He did not tell Mark Zuckerberg to travel India to visit ISKON. Anyone who knows a bit of Sanskrit wouldn’t fall in their trap.
Steve Jobs asked Mark Zuckerberg to visit Neem Karoli Baba. That's when both of them got new lives when they got back to start their brands.
You should say thanks to Swami prahbupada because he is the one who translated it and started iskcon.
@@gamerguypratik8316 Really this is joke of the century 😂😂
Jo gita apne Gorakhpur press wala dikhaya hai kya yeh Amazon pe hai? Mujhe same wala chahiye. Koi link de sakta hai kya?
Everyone is doing their side of work in spreading Hinduism. The worst thing about us is that we are against them who work for us
right.
right.
That's a very primitive thinking about religion.
If some one translate Quran wrong then it’s wrong but Bagavat Gita manipulation is good because it’s spreading my religion?
Mera galthi galati nai hai
Isckon is a fraud organisation. They dont even call themselves Hindus. They abuse Shiv ji and Ganpati Bappa. Their founder said good things about Christianity
i am little bent towards vedanta and while reading the bhagwat geeta from iskcon i also felt the same they have emphasized soo much upon bhaktiyog. i mean geeta isn't a text of sanyas it is the way of doing karma and iskcon also have the supreme god thing , the beauty of sanatan is in multiple gods but they also contradict with this
Exactly. Bhakti yog is easiest. Look at rural life's or brahmins they used to lead a bhakti yog. Krishna never says in one life he will free. He only says humans never says all other lokas even pandavas went to swarg. Krishna also says play the game and still stay away from maya like a lotus.
@@akshatbhandari4779okay so according to you bhakti means being a sanyasi 😂😂😂wow...hats off to your knowledge...manushya sharir 84 lakh yoniyon ke baad milta hai...aur karma se bhagwan prassana zarur honge magar agar wo sab karma ke alawa aap bhagwan ke prati Prema ya unko surrender nahi karoge to aapke aur jaanwar Mai koi antar nahi hai...wo bhi Karma kar rahe hai tum bhi kar rahe ho... manushya sharir milne par bhakti zyada karni hoti hai taaki bhagwan se Prema badhe..bhakti Mai karma ko nahi side kia jaata hai...agar wo aapke dimag mai chal raha hai to aap saaf galat ho aur isckon ko bhi galat hi bol rahe ho...
स्वार्थी दुनिया में लोग आपको तब तक याद करते हैं जब उनको आपकी जरूरत होती है अगर आप एक बार मदद मांगते हैं तो वो पीछे हट जाते हैं ये मेरे खुद का अनुभव है अगर किसी को भरोसा करना ही है तो कृष्ण को करो वो कभी आपका साथ नहीं छोड़ेंगे, कर्म योग तो है ही जरूरी भक्ति योग भी बहुत ज्यादा जरूरी है कलयुग में अगर कोई बचा सकता है तो आपकी भक्ति जो कृष्ण के प्रति है
Hare Krishna 🙏
This kind of debate and discussion only elevates our spirituality that is the beauty of our religion
Edit: also another reason why every hindu must learn Sanskrit
Saare geetha ko inhone bhakti yog kar diya?? Ye galat hai. Bhagawaan ko paane ke liye geetha me karmyog bhi hai, jnanyog bhi hai, sanyasa yog bhi hai, bhakti yog bhi hai.
Or bhi bahut translation change ki haii or jo shloka Parabhakti ko darshate the vo bhi change krdiee or 2.62 ki commentary me shiv ji ki ninda bhi ki
Or 4.12 ki commentary me likha shiv ji or Narayan ek nhi hai or 10.65 ki commentary me likha ki bhakt ko Krishna roop me he man lagana chahiye ram ji or Narayan me nhi lagana chahiye
@@BalajiCreation108 lagta hai ye log abrahamic faiths prabhavit hai. 🤣Saara moolabhooth waad aur brainwashing Abramic religions me hai. Geetha me Moolbhoothwaad kahi bhi nahi hai.
Me Narayan ,KRISHNA, ram, SHIVA sabko ek maanta hun. Ek hi shakthi ko hum alag alag naam se pukarte hai.
@@govindappa6143 ye toh hai he jabhi toh hum exposed bna rhe hai iskcon ka maksad he yhi tha ki baaki religion jaise sanatan dharm bhi abhramic banjae koi bhakt nhi h ye natak krte h maximum ye
@@govindappa6143 Prabhupada jo the unhone shaf kehdia ki hum durga ji demigodess ki puja nhi krte kyuki durga ji Krishna ji ki daasi haii. Or tulsidas ji ke liye bhi kaha ki vo pure vaishanav nhi haii
It's like a slow poison to our society😢
In the past I had started reading the Autobiography of a Yogi, it was basically salepitch "Kriya Yoga meditation". And in order to know it you basically have to join them.
When Its not your time don’t try reading Autobiography of Yogi. Rajinikanth kept 25 years , you might pick up in next life. Kriya yog is real essence of Bagavat Gita.
This video is an eye opener . I always felt that the translation of the verses are deliberatly altered .
Iskcon gurus behave like a motivational speaker or a stand up comedian.
@@codelikepro198white male is a mleccha who will NEVER EVER LET A BROWN MAN lord over him and this is yet another proof.
@@codelikepro198 Some are degraded to this level nowadays....But not all... You can see preachers from ISKCON Bangalore... They never talks anything apart from Krishna.
I had studied the geeta press publication and I had been thinking about reading Iskon publication Bhagvad Gita as well. But I'd suspicion about their way of devotion.
iskcon used to call me for donation and many other things, after few weeks of regular call from iskcon I was frustrated then I blocked them
❤❤❤
I personally request to those people who are willing to start Gita to begin with the Holy Geeta by Swamy Chinmayananda. And next you can go for Shankaracharya bhashya on gita (Which is somewhat high level to understand for the beginners) Also for the beginners Gita commentary by Swami Sarvapriyananda from RK math order were truly a bliss.
Gita press is the best for beginners.
@@Mahakaalkideewani111 yes agree.
Have you read Sadhak Sanjeevani?
Go check it out. IMO it is the best Hindi translation and commentary on BG.
@@dutybound5079 is it avaialble in English?
Thank you bruh. Tired of life. Was searching for some real advice.
Every one is like Gita yeh hai Gita woh hai. 🎉
make this video reach 10 lac views, many people need to be aware on how ISKCON's Gita is misleading. When Amogh Lila comes back he and others will think many many times before even thinking of defaming some saints of India.
All glories to shrila Prabhupad❤❤krisnas tu bhagwan swayam
Being a bhakta, he should never have translated gita Wrongfully!!!! Hare Krishna, all glories to Sri Krishna!! Krishna is my everything.❤❤❤❤❤
But not Prabhupada. No obalation or respect to Prabhupada! His mind was filled with Christianity and Christian belief!!! Not authentic!
मित्र.. आपका अध्ययन और कार्य सराहनिय है. लेकीन आपकी भाषा बहुत असभ्य है वो भी सन्यासी गुरू के लिये..
सनातन धर्म मे अलग अलग संप्रदाय होते है ओर सभी संप्रदाय अपने अपने तत्त्वज्ञान का प्रचार प्रसार सदियो से करते आये है. जैसे की वैष्णव विष्णू को भगवान मानते है और शैव शिव को, कोई अद्वैती है कोई द्वैती...
तो आप सिर्फ सही राह दिखाये, जागरूक करे... नाकी द्वेष से किसिको अपमानित करे. क्योकी इस्कॉन के लोग कोई बुरा या निंदनीय कार्य नही कर रहे है, बल्की वो पुरे दुनिया मे श्रीकृष्ण की भक्ती फैला रहे हैं.
और गीता ग्रंथ का आदर करे, जीस तरीके से आप ग्रंथ के पन्ने पलट रहे है, उससे ग्रंथ को हानी होगी.🙏🏻
Main agree hu aapki bat se.....👍🏻
I agree, like i am not against ISKON but even i compared and i was shocked when their was a lot of difference in ISKON bhagvad gita and the real one that i had.
Great service in exposing invalid translations. I am reading "The Bhagavad Gita Comes Alive" by Jeffrey Armstrong; based on this video, Jeffrey's translation seems to be very authentic based on the specific verses mentioned here.
That's the Bhagavad Gita I have and I find it beautifully written. Everything is so well explained that for the first time I truly enjoyed and understood the Bhagavad Gita.
@@rosanilebron1566 agree that irrespective of some translation issues, this version has most appeal currently and on the whole has the desired impact of propagating the divine message to a wider public.
आपका video देखा, बहत अच्छा लगा, मगर आपको एक बात बोलूंगा...
में isckon का अनुयाई नही हूं...
मगर आज का समाज जिस राह में चल रहा हे, उन्हें पहले भक्ति के मार्ग में लाकर कर्म, कर्तव्य राह में चला सकते हैं ।
आज समाज को पहले भक्ति के नसा देना चाहिए, उसके बाद बो कर्म की राह में चल पाएंगे ।
Isckon समाज में बहत कुछ बदलाव ला रहा हे, कृपया उसे स्वागत करे ।
आज यदि श्रीमद भगवद्गीता दुनियाभर में फेल राहा हे, तो उसमे isckon की सहयोग बहत हे।
Yes 🎉
Bahut uttam vichar....
Yes
@annonymoussi9sjsbhai Mera bhi sawal yahi hai, baki sare sant, parampara zhut hai Aisa kiase ho sakta hai
Bro 😅 jiska tu abhi video dekh rha hai na o tere ko mind wash kr rha hai jake 18.66 padh usme kya likha bhaktya mamabhujanati eska matlab bhakti hin Aisa marg jisse mujhe Jana ja skta hai to bhai yaha pe bhagwan bol to rhe hai bakti kro aur mujhe jano @annonymoussi9sjs
Hats off to you .People don't know sanskrit still they are translating. Some of youtubers also are misleading interpreting different meanings of purana upnishad etc.
Amazing video….I hope more and more people see this. I have read Geeta of Geeta press Gorakhpur version and on the contrary I think more emphasis has been put on how to live this worldly life properly rather than leaving everything behind for the sake of ‘Bhakti’. Shree Krishna always emphasised on Karma in different manner and said that it’s also the path of Yoga and equally fruitful.
Dont follow iskon culture. They will destroy your family by brain washing and your family will be spoiled. You can go for any bhagwat gita except iskon.
, yes u are right, yet Shri Krishna also mentions further that for Kaliyuga people , most easiest and most practical way to attain the Supreme Him is to practice and perform Bhakti Yoga , all other ways(Yoga--be it gyan or dhyan or ashtang or karma) also help u reach the same destination but its more difficult to follow those in the age of Kali.
to get clear understanding of Gita , read Shrimad Bhagavatam.
Iskcon's Gita seems like Madrasa's distant cousin
It's from Madhavacharya's lineage. He "developed" his school of thought in 11th century during his "experience" with Islam. He also declared that Advaita Wadis are "demonic preachers". Iskon's Geeta vilifies Advaita preachers too.
are you chipsbuzz by any chance?
A religion that tolerates everything, stands for nothing
Namaste! 🙏🏼 Wish this video had English subtitles for people like myself who don't speak any Indian language.
I can suggest the Bhagavad Gita by Jeffrey Armstrong (Kavindra Rishi). I have it and it is in Sanskrit and English. It is a well researched translation, no commentaries or explanations. Just the Gita as it is.
The gita in true form never talk about praying to any deity. So it isn't really specific to hinduism at all. It just teaches the ultimate truth mainly cessation of craving. It is much similar to buddhist ideologies. ISKON in its translation stresses upon praying to Krishna which isn't real translation
Dont follow iskon culture. They will destroy your family by brain washing and your family will be spoiled. You can go for any bhagwat gita except iskon.
Exactly as non dual vedanta would read the Gita
I'd suggest Bhagwad Gita From Gita Press Gorakhpur if you can get it near your place. It's the most unbiased nd the most authentic one. I don't know which Bhagwad Gita you're reading right now. But if it's unbiased, then by reading it, you'll be more devoted towards your Dharm(Work, Sense of Right nd Wrong and you'll be more generous towards others). In original bhagwad Gita, devotion towards the god is very very less. It's not a book that will ask you to leave everything nd just worship God. It's a book that will teach you how to be a good, productive and a sensible human being.
So any Bhagwad Gita which shows everything related to devotion towards the god only is wrongly translated. Gita is the way of life. It'll teach how how to live a better life. It's not just about God. Devotion towards God is very limited in this book.
I hope this information will help you to know whether you're reading the correctly translated Bhagwad Gita or not. 🙏
@@mehulbhatt3541 don't spread misinformation
It is related to Vedic/hindu religion Just like Bible is related to christianity
But yeah anyone can read Geeta just like anyone can read Bible or tripitak
There goes a story like this:
In a village there were no one who knew elephants. And 4 blind men were choosen to experience an elephant. They came back and described to the villagers about elephant. It was seen that after some days the villagers were divided into four groups. 1. The elephant is like a pillar. (Leg) 2. The elephant is like a rope.(tail) 3. The elephant is like a tank.(belly) 4. The elephant is like a flat plate. (ear).
Now these four groups are regulaly quarelling with each other on elephant matter.
But when one wise man with the help of one blind reached the elephant and saw the truth.
The problem is that most people don't have that patience and preserverance to strive to reach the end. They fall in quarellism and get distracted from truth pursuance. 🕉️
And ISKON is that Fanatic blind man
@@DivinityGlobal-jz6rpperfect
Wow I loved this
All glories to srila Prabhupada 🙏
🤣
😂
Tumhare jaise andhe aur brain washed vakyti ... Aise hii bologe tum pe mujhe bahot gussa aata hai 🤦🏻
Gita press wale ❤️
Iskcon wale 🤎
Jaldi comment karo 😅
🧡🧡🧡
❤❤
thank you bro i needed this video indeed 😁
🚩 जय श्री राम 🚩
🙏 जय श्री कृष्ण 🙏
🙌 हर हर महादेव 🙌
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
गोरखपुर गीता प्रेस के जो भी जितने भी ग्रंथ है उसके श्लोक और अर्थ और सुंदर शब्दों वाले सबसे सटीक होते हैं।
हरे कृष्णा 🚩
गीता प्रैस गोरखपुर से मेरा सादर व सविनय निवेदन है कि गीता के अनुवाद की समीक्षा की जाए। कई स्थानों पर सुधार की आवश्यकता है। मैं पहले उन्हें एक पत्र भी लिख चुका हूँ।
Iskon bhagwat is best it is best to understand spiritual knowledge
Dont follow iskon culture. They will destroy your family by brain washing and your family will be spoiled. You can go for any bhagwat gita except iskon.
Iskon gita is rhe worst. 'Bhagwat Gita As it is not'.
Once I met a scholar teaching in a school of ISKCON. He told me " Prabhupada's 'Bhagavad-Gita As It Is' is actually Bhagavad-Gita as not it is " !
😅😅
hahhahahhahahahahhahahaa true
Hare krishna ❤
Jai Prabhupada 🚩 🚩 🚩
Kitna pad ta Hain tumlogoka prabhu pad😅🎉
@@Jayanta10025 padhane se jyada jaruri h unke adesho ka palan karna …Aur unka Adesh h Krishna bhaktikarne ka….
Very enlightening! Thank you so much for this. I get to know today that I have been reading the wrong versions. Thank you for rectifying 🙏
Dont follow iskon culture. They will destroy your family by brain washing and your family will be spoiled. You can go for any bhagwat gita except iskon.
You're never reading the wrong scripture. Just read one Gita with full divine. Don't listen to these RUclipsrs whose motive is just to create some money and seeking attention of people like you. So i request you to read Gita which you have rn and believe that Gita fully. Hare Krishna 💗✨
guys im not in isckon but trust me all this translation what is writtenor not wriiten which god is supreme or not dont induldge yooourslef in these type of things just go in iskcon for once at the time of keertan just for once go in nay iskcon temple exp cant be explained in words just trust me your life will chang e
I'm very happy to see that somebody has exposed the ISKON guys' Geeta translation & interpretation. But these guys are thick skinned. Four years ago, I confronted one their bald headed guys who had come to our society to deliver a lecture. He was, as you are describing, trying to give a wrong interpretation of Geeta. We had a few WhatsApp chat exchanges. I asked him, "have you read Lokmanya Tilak's Geeta Rahasya, in which Tilak argues very forcefully and convincingly that it is the Karmyog, which is the real meaning of Geeta?" He had not. Then I asked him to justify the translation and interpretation he was giving. He went on in a very round about way and refused to answer my questions. I offered him my own copy of Geeta Rahasya (English translation). He was not inclined to change his views. Finally, I gave up. How long can one bang his head on a stone wall?
So, thank you; you are doing a good job. Keep it up.
According to Iskon krishan = Jesus = Allaha but The Sada shiv, Adhi Shatki, Shri Ganesh is demigod.... और इनकी पूजा नहीं करनी चाहिए
They aren't wrong
Shri Ganesh is not the creator of the universe
He is literally the son of Shivji and Parvati Mata
Thats what a demigod is
@saumyashah4831 Shree Ganesh is not a son of Shiva... it's just one of the Avtaar of Lord Ganesha.. like Shree Ram is avtaar of Bhagwaan Vishnu.
If Ganesha is son of Shiva, then why Lord Shiva did Ganesha's upasana before tripurasur vadh? How can any father worship their own son??
Even Parvati did Ganesh upasana before Ganesha become her son... she did ganesh upasana to have Ganesha as her son! And the Avtaar is Umangamalaj Avtaar... Not Ganesh
yes and after reading this version of geeta they are doing too much of social work, free prasadam every day , spreading sanatan like anything.
Spreading iskcon business not sanatan dharm.. They are actually dividing sanatani into Jain Buddhism vaishnavism shaktism shaivism..
Sanatan dharm is collective of all philosophies which includes Jainism Buddhism Sikhism and different branches of Hinduism..
So plz don't bring up this excuse that they are helping poor people.. You might be a naive person to fall for their tricks.
And same strategy used by Christianity.. By helping poor people they convert them ,and then they say we are good people we help so many poor people..
I read Geeta in English and didn’t feel much amazement. Now I understand why . Dhanyawad
No but they are dividing hindus on basis of their own god, this way no harmony will exist between hindus
@@somparashar6349 bruhhhh just to show krishna above they say shiv and bhrma are demi gods and should not be considered supreme, also they say shiv and bhrma bhakt as murkh(stupid)
ISKON is the real reason why so many foreigners are accepting sanatan and because of ISKON we are seeing Rath Yatra in New York.....
So what?
They are spreading lies
@@Spideykaka you don't know anything!
@@GardeningwithShishir akh kholke Dekho
Apne dharma KO bat rahe hea ye log
Ultimate goal of any gita version is to make you devotee of krishna.Iskcon gita is powerfull becoz it transformed many western people and made them devotees.
Andhvishwas faila kr devotee loll...voh toh sb krte h india mein so what's new wth tht iskcon
No ultimate goal of Gita is not to make you a devotee of Krishna.. The goal of Gita is to tell u paths that will lead to self realization and where u will attain God. Now if u consider God as Krishna after reading Iskcon then it's ur problem..
Because it's the ishwar who said Geeta.. It's bhagwan Uvach, not Krishna Uvach.. Which clearly it's the Ultimate Ishwar who spoke via Krishna.. That's why if u worship any God u will reach to main God only...
That's the problem with Iskcon and hence the name Krishna consciousness Iskcon..
@@creativeaarts4023Thats the prblm now a days people want gita without krsna. krsna is bhagwan.Self realization is achived through krsna bhakti.Krsna clearly mentions just surrender to me.
@@AditiVerma-uk3ri what andhwishwas pls explain in detail
so true , i always stopped reading bhagwat gita from iskcon so many times because all this bhakti made me confused.
i am sanathani i want knowledge to improve my life not bhakti.
Same like me....would u mind chatting with me ?
Premanand baba ko sunkar asli cheeze samajh aati hai❤
Bro, गीताप्रेस का जो बुक आपने यहां दिखाया है, उसका buy link दीजिए प्लीज ।
ISCON ko ek bangali log abhay charan de ne banaya hai.. Iscon Hinduism jistara spread karta hai aur koi nehi karta.
Iskcon Wale apne aap ko hare Krishna bolte he foreign me
Hinduism nahi spread ker rahe woh log
Iskcon spreading it's own business not sanatan dharm
@@GloryToAryaVrat iskcon Lord krishna ka nam spread kartey hai via bhagwat geeta. Isckon is only organization who spread Hinduism🕉️. Because Lord krishna is the only door 🚪 to get moksha.
@@creativeaarts4023 isckon is not business model it's a hindu organization who spread Hinduism via bhagwat geeta and Lord krishna name 🤗
Iskcon Sanatan Dharma ka prachar karti hai, Hare Krishna Mahamantra aur Bhagavad Gita evam Bhagavatam ka prachar karti hai.
I always doubted that iskon is similar to Christian evangelism. You opened my eyes.
Do they force to covert in other religion?
Ha bhgwan agy murkh
@@tiwariji1212 I guess iskcon doesn't force to covert in to religion but they definitely have their own propaganda.
han ye bhai sahab sahi bo rahe mtlb ki kuchh bhi 🤣😂😅
@@kathakmadhav 😂
The name itself reveals the aim of this congressional ( international society for Krishna consciousness)- ISKCON.
जय श्री कृष्ण।
हर हर महादेव।
नमो भगवते वासुदेवाय नारायणय नमः।
I was also surprised by the translations as I know little bit of Sanskrit, but its not such a big thing. It will be problematic only for those who read English version only
White male wont ever let a brown one above him and this is yet another proof
tumko kya pta ki iski btayi translation hi sahi h kal ko koi aur kuchh bhi translation le ke aa gya to fir problem yahi h ki ham sanskrit nhi pd rhe h aur iskon ko bhi galat bolna band kro becoz iskon ne jo kiya h vo tum jaise youtubers uska 1 percent bhi nhi kr skte h atleast they are changing people from a hippie to a devotee of lord krishna
@@alexsten4665bar bar ek percent bhi nhi kr pa rhe ek percent bhi ni kr pare bolne se kuch nahi hoga, jo sach hai wo sach hai,
Glt translation hai to hai tum use kisi bhi Sanskrit dictionary se check krlo ya koi Anya texts se ki unka meaning kya h.
हरे कृष्ण हरे कृष्ण कृष्ण कृष्ण हरे हरे हरे राम हरे राम राम राम हरे हरे ।
श्रील प्रभुपाद की जय
It's true brother. Even I bought the gita published by ISCKON. I have an old gita of gitapress. You won't believe There are lots of differences between these two books. But now it's time to stop this
Kindly don't do this, even i have read so many Gita books but finally a got clarity after reading Iskcon BG.. This person is really really misleading all
Erwin Schrodinger prominent quantum physicists, he loved Upanishads
Srimad bhagavatam mein likha hai ki Bhakti ke hi 2 sons hai. Gyan aur vairagya. To bhakti karke bhi gyan praapt hota hai. Iskcon ka translation bhale hi thoda alag ho lekin unhone ye soch kar use translate kiya hoga. Jai shree Krishna.
Bhale hi iskon kuch bhi kre but hame ye nhi bhoolna chahiye ki wo hai to Britishers hi ☺️
All Glory to Shrila Prabhupad ♥
A Blind follower.... Sad to see
Wow fake
Why??
No respect for Prabhupada!!!!😢 All other Acharyas are far better cause they never changed the word of the lord!!! Wrong translation is wrong no matter who does it!😢 Jai Shree Krishna!❤
Spot on... Lagta he "Kalki ji" iscon aur Iscon jaise adharm ko saaf karke Dharm staapana karne aayenge 🕉️
HAR HAR MAHADEV 🚩🚩🚩🚩
Right Brother ये बताना काफी हिम्मत का काम हे Keep It Up....
ismai konsi himmet hai? koi ser tan se juda ker dega? Kuch bhi ha
The most accurate translation of Bhagvat Geeta is given by Sant Dnyaneshwar in 13th century.
It is called Dnyaneshwari
@@ElonMusk-tb2yi vo commentry h translation nhi
I believe in parambrambh ....
I respect iskon
I respect ur thought also ...coz not one is perfect ...
Only God is perfect .
:)
🙂
Oh brother. I want to meet Krishna. But without a guru, it's difficult to. Please direct me towards an actual sampradaya and parampara, where I can get initiated from a real guru. Thank you 🙏
Read the story of meera, Thyagaraj ji, they had no guru they tried hard connecting directly…
i have read about 100 pages of GEETA BY ISKCON, its like written in devotion of krishna ji, not the real one, every 5th 10th line like says, krishna krishna jaap karo, like tbhi moksh milega, somewhere meanings are manupulated but only 10 20%
Maine iskcon se kayi books padhi h jisme har cheez ko wo Jesus se relate krke btate h.... At the end they all are Britishers 😅
Bhai ye isiliye hei kyu ki sari book prabhu pad ke conversations pe bani hei or sare conversations jo hue hei wo prabhu pad or British logo ke bich hue hei isiliye jesus ka naam liya gya hei taki log samajh sake ki krishna hi supreme lord hei❤
@@adityadas4302jo Krishna bhagwan ke time pr nhi the unse relate krne ka koi fayda
Nhi
ISKCON baaki bhagwan ko nicha dikhate h joki galat h
Sab bhagwan ek hi h
ISKCON's Gita conveys the meaning in the correct way.
In relation to the words 'buddhau saranam', in Bhagavad Gita 2.49, Srila Sridhara Swami says " बुद्धौ शरणं त्रातारमीश्वरमाश्रयेत्यर्थः". This is exactly how Srila Prabhupada translates it. Don't believe in this fake video created out of envy for acaryas.
Bhai Rampal jo gyan ganga Geeta likha h , ushka bhi exposed karo❤
I'm attending iskcon free gita classes right now and can't deny that something feels off. Like so much focus on bhakti yoga. At one point they said that we should just chant that mantra and not do anything. Chanting hare Krishna mantra is a better way to salvation than doing good deeds according to them 🫤
Yes ....same feeling
Suppose I love practicing juggling, they consider it wordly , material and degrade it..
Each person has his own way and interest...
I want to choose the path of the warrior not of a priest or saint.
@@sathyanayaksk1330 same dude... i aspire to be a doctor and save people but according to iskcon missionaries, chanting all day is the best way to reach krishna.. i mean bhakti is essential but spending entire life in it instead of serving humanity is a lil too much.
i bet their translation is wrong.
imagine if arjuna had stopped fighting against kauravas and sat down chanting... evil would have succeeded...
@@gac379 precisely
Swami Vivekananda is the real deal. He says " if a person is hungry " give him food first before preaching him anything..
Prabhupada condemns sport activities as waste of time..
Swamiji says strengthen ur body first before understanding gita.
See , people like Abdul Kalam, Ambedkar, Bhagat singh ....they worked for the betterment of the country.
So they possibly couldnt have transfixed on God. Does this mean they go to tell ? 😌
@@sathyanayaksk1330 I'm glad i found someone with the same opinion as me.
I understand why they are emphasising so much on bhakti yoga. This is probably one of their business tactics. In the name of bhakti yoga, they get a lot of people visiting the iskcon mandirs to chant mantras, thereby increasing business. Prabhupada is a shrewd man and probably had a clear idea about all the plans, therefore he started preaching in America as they have no idea about our puranas and can easily be brainwashed.
You know what enraged me so much?
I arise from a family of Shaiva Brahmins and they once called shiva a 'demigod'. A FRICKING DEMIGOD.
like the term demigod itself isn't mentioned in our puranas.
And according to them shri krishna is the almighty and Vishnu is one of Krishna's avatars.
There are many instances like this that made me leave their free online class and honestly I am proud of this decision.
I know that because of iskcon, our hindu dharma is getting an international reach, but what's the point when they are preaching wrong things? i hope people wake up soon.
And this isn't just about iskcon. Every other organisation, for an instance, esha foundation, is also quite shady. I hate the fact that they are minting out money in the name of dharma :/
(and really sorry if this is too long. I just have no one to talk to about this)
Also, follow your dream as you wish, brother. Don't let anybody block your path.
No wonder When I read Geeta for the first time published by ISKON " it shocked me with bhakti, I am the one, I am the only one, and was like Is God that desperate. But on the quest came across Asta Bakra Geeta then moved to other Upanishads. The most awakened moment of life and since then My quest is to comprehend my own brahma. Thank you I was like this is what I was waiting for?
Han aisa mujhe v lga h...jha2 bhgwan krishna bolte h iskcon wale book m ki sirf mai hi bhgwan hun demigod ki puja krna byarth hai mujhe lga bhgwan krsihna aise to nhi ho skte..
@tapb8731 ha pdhta hun...puri nhi pdhi h avi ....teesre chapter m hun
To apkay jivan may kya parivartan hua hai kya ap bat sakte hsi mere hua hai may ek bhakt ban gaye pap punaya ka lekha jokha rakne lagi Gatti karne say phele hi Krishna ki awaj sunne lagi ......dusro ko dosh Dene say jyada logo kay Jeevan may jisay pad kar parivartan hot hai vo sahi mano
Ashtavakra Gita is different but it emphasizes on Atma. It also tells to liberate ourselves from this worldly life. But in Bhagwad Gita The Lord is himself telling everything. There are different topics covered for liberation. There is a big difference. If anyone gets enlightenment or even gets peace of mind then he or she has succeeded.
@@pratishayadav8992mata kyuki bhakti ki mana koi ni krra without bhakti,gyaan,karma kaam ni chlega all three are important for only one thing that is moksha but iskcon gyaan or karma ko dur fek deta h bas y problem hai.
Samarpan to sabse shreshth karma hai parantu bina gyan or karma k samarpan kese hoga?