A mind-blowing explanation of symmetry | Frank Wilczek for Big Think
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 июн 2024
- This interview is an episode from The Well, our new publication about ideas that inspire a life well-lived, created with the John Templeton Foundation.
Subscribe to Big Think on RUclips ► / bigthink
Up Next ► What science can’t answer, according to physicist Jim Al-Khalili • What science can’t ans...
Dr. Frank Wilczek is the newly announced recipient of the 2022 Templeton Prize, which, valued at over $1.4 million, is one of the world's largest annual individual awards.
Dr. Wilczek is celebrated for his investigations into the fundamental laws of nature that have transformed our understanding of the forces that govern our universe. In this video, Dr. Wilczek explores the question, ‘does the world embody beautiful ideas?’ through science and humankind’s relationship to (and love for) symmetry.
"We can look at the record of what people have found beautiful, what they were hoping for in their understanding of the world with what the remarkable understanding of the world we've achieved in recent years looks like. And we can therefore frame a meaningful discussion and a meaningful question, a meaningful meditation, on the issue.”
The Templeton Prize was established by the late global investor and philanthropist Sir John Templeton. It is given to honor those who harness the power of the sciences to explore the deepest questions of the universe and humankind’s place and purpose within it.
► Read more details of Dr. Wilczek’s achievement here: www.templetonprize.org/laurea...
► And here: www.templetonprize.org/laurea...
► Continue learning about Dr. Wilczek: www.templetonprize.org/laurea...
► Learn more about the Templeton Prize: www.templetonprize.org/
► Read the full video transcript: bigthink.com/the-well/law-of-...
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About Frank Wilczek:
Frank Wilczek is an American theoretical physicist, mathematician and a Nobel laureate. He is currently the Herman Feshbach Professor of Physics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). Wilczek, along with David Gross and H. David Politzer, was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics in 2004 for their discovery of asymptotic freedom in the theory of the strong interaction. He is on the Scientific Advisory Board for the Future of Life Institute. His new book is titled A Beautiful Question: Finding Nature's Deep Design.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read more from The Well:
I put a camera on a monkey. Here’s how it shook my understanding of humanity
► bigthink.com/the-well/awe-ani...
Atheism is not as rare or as rational as you think
► bigthink.com/the-well/atheism...
System 1 vs. System 2 thinking: Why it isn’t strategic to always be rational
► bigthink.com/the-well/system-...
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About The Well
Do we inhabit a multiverse? Do we have free will? What is love? Is evolution directional? There are no simple answers to life’s biggest questions, and that’s why they’re the questions occupying the world’s brightest minds.
So what do they think?
How is the power of science advancing understanding? How are philosophers and theologians tackling these fascinating questions?
Let’s dive into The Well.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join The Well on your favorite platforms:
► Facebook: bit.ly/thewellFB
► Instagram: bit.ly/thewellIG 
Наука
Do you think the world embodies beautiful ideas?
Yes
Understanding of nature, the desire to create, experience and flow through pure inner workings of knowledge
I think the world IS an embodiment of a beautiful idea. One that we all had together a long time ago
"If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?" Same difference. The thing of beauty is the observing agent.
Nature is filled with beautifully crafted items ranging from simple to complex.
While symmetry has a certain beauty, it is also mixed with asymmetry and that adds depth to the infinite array of beautiful creations that surround us.
All we have to do is take a bit of time and observe.
If You believe that Entropy, Extinction and Heat Death is "Beauty" .... Then, You will tend to believe that The World "embodies" "Beauty" ....
This guy seems like the nicest man you can ever meet in your life.
He is intelligent too. What a wonderful human being
The only thing you could possibly know about somebody after 7 minutes with them is what the CHOOSE to show you.
~In other words, a murderer could have you thinking "what a wonderful human being" ( not that he is anything remotely similar)
Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
I’d like to imagine he’s the most clumsy man when not sitting down talking about nature and life lol
@@BigDG80 it is difficult to synthesize great ideas from a wicked personality.
Criminals can fake it, but the content of what they share are either common or non-groundbreaking thoughts.
You cannot compose superlatove ideas from a crooked person.
I only wonder why you were not able to appreciate his points.
@yen cabañas You're wrong on multiple fronts. But it's not something worth getting into in a comment section.
~And if you're talking about appreciating Emil's points, it's called idol worship and it's unhealthy and corrosive to society.
Beauty is the recognition of patterns and symmetries in the chaos of life.
However the chaos is not adverse to beauty, it is the necessary background from which we can perceive patterns to begin with. Without the chaos there wouldn't be any patterns and without the patterns there wouldn't be any chaos. Both create each other.
What we consider beautiful is therefore a result of our capacity to recognize the patterns within the chaos of our own perception. This is why we perceive beauty as both subjective and yet somehow universal. Because those who have the clarity of mind to see the patterns in every chaos and the chaos in every pattern, those see the beauty in everything. Because everything that appears to be ugly contains and frames beauty and is therefore beautiful in its own right. When we have recognize it's place in the world, and symmetrically our place in the world, we no longer fear what we consider ugly, which simply is something that we do not yet understand.
True objectivity is capable of seeing the ugly and at the same time seeing only beauty. There is no need to resolve the paradox as there is none, for the chaos creates order just as order creates the chaos and both are one and the same.
👏
This was beautiful. 🦋
👏👏
brilliantly put and did the idea total justice. love it.
Facts
An old German scientist friend of mine, Dr. Bruno Manz, wrote "Without resonance of the human soul beauty does not exist."
I love his music.
I am Bruno
@@osimoes5113 We don't talk about Bruno
That's nice to say, but is it true? Is it a testable statement? And what would you say to a bee swimming in the cup of a flower? Does the flower look beautiful to the bee? Does the peacock look beautiful to the peahen? And would a conscious and intelligent space creature have a concept of beauty? And would it be the same as ours? Would a spacefaring visitor to our planet find the flower and the peacock beautiful?
Thsnk you for sharing, this is beautiful.
I love the framing around symmetry and the idea of a circle retaining its basic nature even while all of the points on the circle are changing. This connected to me within a non-dualistic philosophical context.
The idea of a unified, unchanging, a-temporal, non-spatial truth from which the physical universe of matter and energy manifests is the center piece of so many philosophical and spiritual traditions. Compellingly, this truth is demonstrable and attainable to anyone who seeks it and practices; after which the "nature" of the universe that physics and science are describing becomes quite clear. The physical universe of stuff is like the points on the circle always in motion and change. While the "underlying quantum field" remains unchanged like the nature of the circle itself. (Rather than saying quantum field, I think the Tao or God is probably a better descriptor.)
Thank you so much for sharing this video of Mr. Wilczek. It is inspiring to see and hear people like this talking about subjects like this.
I am always in awe as to how articulate and thought-through are Frank Wilczek’s answers! Amazing. - One thing that really caught me in both of Einstein’s theories of Relativity was the importance he gave to the notion of invariance, and how he expressed it through the language of tensors: they allow a description that does not depend on a “point of view” (coordinate system). Galileo had already had the idea, but Einstein and others elevated it to a fundamental goal, to which Emmy Noether gave the final crown. I find this idea of invariance or symmetry so powerful, with such far-reaching implications, that my mind reels. And wouldn’t it be wonderful if we could also apply it to psychology and education? The average human is still a very primitive creature when incapable of seeing that what s/he’s seeing is highly affected and constrained by his or her “point of view”. Around a sphere there are an infinite number of points of view, even if all are seeing the same sphere.
I don’t know how quantum mechanics enters the picture here, in terms of invariance and symmetry, but Frank tells us it works on the same principle. However, it doesn’t seem we can then understand QM symmetries as “points of view”, but I may be totally wrong here. Maybe not visual p.o.v. but mathematical ones? I suppose E8 is one such?
Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
One of my near relatives who passed away in 2008 [Mary Golda ross] was the first Native American Aerospace engineer. Not to toot our own horn, but I've realized the potential we have as a incredibly intelligent species of humans, with my family on my dads' side going to show that these people formed the nation.
What to deduct from this is that to use symmetry, you need to understand symmetry yourself, not in a physical manor but rather a more mental or cognitive way.
I'd be excited to learn more about my distant family or relatives more, and feel like it's in my best interest to continue the legacy of mathematics and cosmology better for our world
Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
You are staying calm even when things are difficult. This is a super power🔋✅
Indeed. Thanks for this reminder. 🙏
Right!
This was amazing! Thank You!
Yes. The world embodies beauty.
My current photography of old telephone lines and electrical poles.
The fancy crisscross of wires.
Also, there's glorious music.
Thank you.
Peace💕🇺🇲
Eloquently spoken description of brain processes 😊 it's graspable once heard with that visual perspective 👍 do you have other videos?
Thanks so much for this. A symmetrical hug
What week explanation on the point on a sphere. Every point on a sphere is its center. That means no matter who you are or where you are you're ALWAYS at the center of the earth from your own perspective.
Your saying the same thing. Also what day of the WEEK is it?
Yes, the people who strife to see the magnificence of the world tend to look for beautiful ideas, all scientists, writers, artists, musicians, fisherman, teachers, builders, pilots, and so many other fulfilling careers.
Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
Great video! Subscribed!
This must’ve been why God repeatedly commands man to contemplate on nature and His creations. We fail on this so miserably.
Beautiful! 👏👏👏👏
Nothing exists without a conscious mind to observe it
False
Yes!!! Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
We see in 2D whilst living in a 3D world, what if I’m not equipped to see the third dimension? Does consciousness interpret and help?
Just as symmetry has a large scope to be relevant axiomaticly across many different systems, I find it extremely interesting that so many sub systems of things have the same properties of seemingly unrelated systems. What an amazing world we live in
Thank you!
Excellent!!
Most Excellent!
great video tx
Great thinker, Frank Wilczek is.
Thank you
"Does the world embody beautiful ideas?"
Why don't we consider the reintegration of nomadic rituals? We've been experimenting with sedentary lifeways since the agricultural revolution. I'm not suggesting it's unnatural to settle and establish a system of operations, I just think we need to address the lag between our design and our understanding.
Immediately after high school, in two attempts, I completed the Appalachian Trail (now 2,192 miles.) Three years later and I am still obsessed with anything and everything related to long-distance hiking (and similar experiences.) After having a hike canceled by covid in 2020, I'll be attempting a southbound thru-hike of the Continental Divide Trail this summer ^.^
Benton MacKaye's proposition for the trail was published in 1921. This is a paragraph from the journal:
"We civilized ones also, whether urban or rural, are potentially helpless as canaries in a cage. The ability to cope with nature directly-unshielded by the weakening wall of civilization-is one of the admitted needs of modern times. It is the goal of the “scouting” movement. *Not that we want to return to the plights of our Paleolithic ancestors. We want the strength of progress without its puniness.* We want its conveniences without its fopperies. The ability to sleep and cook in the open is a good step forward. But “scouting” should not stop there. This is but a faint step from our canary bird existence. It should strike far deeper than this. We should seek the ability not only to cook food but to raise food with less aid-and less hindrance-from the complexities of commerce. And this is becoming daily of increasing practical importance. Scouting, then, has its vital connection with the problem of living."
From what I understand, he suggested we establish communities along the trail, or a trail network perhaps. That's already a lot to take in, so I'll just emphasize that we should think outside the 🏠
Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
Incredible!
There is one process that could form this geometry forming three-dimensional space with one variable in the form of time.
And that is a process of spherical symmetry forming and breaking. At high temperatures this process would be relative to plasma with charge being able to cover a whole star or even a large area of interstellar space.
At lower temperatures, we have a phase change in matter and the process is relative to the atoms of the periodic table.
Forming the potential for cell life and the Fibonacci Spiral with nothing ever being totally perfect because it arises out of broken spherical symmetry
Snowflake diversity is a good example of this process in action!
Fibonacci is only one type of geometry. Like inertia there is also centrafugal working together. Fibonacci has a companion that is seen in cathedrals. 📐🕐🔥
youre so right!!! jesus and the big man upstairs wants to tell you YOU BELONG HERE!!!! PRAISE THE UPSTAIRS GUY!!!!! the symmetry of broken shoes is really blowing my mind rn. 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
I'm going to shower me with attention and my awareness. I'm going to give me a lot of my time. I'm going to be in physical proximity to me. I'm going to touch me, hold me, cuddle me. I'm going to try to connect with me physically, emotionally, intellectually, spiritually. I'm going to take good care of me. I'm going to care about my needs. I'm going to help me to meet my needs. I'm going to help me to survive. I'm going to shelter me from excessive suffering, fear and trauma. I'm going to have my back. I'm going to defend me and be loyal to me. I'm going to take on my agenda as my own. I'm going to make me an extension of you. I'm going to treat me as well as i would treat myself. I'm going to be happy for me when I succeed. I'm going to want for me what me most want for myself. I'm going to sacrifice for me and work on my behalf. I'm going to support me nurture me and encourage me. I'm going to cheerlead me. I'm going to encourage my self-exploration, self-expression and self-actualization. I'm going to respect my sovereignty as a consciousness. I'm not going to try to manipulate me, control me, dominate me or exploit me. I'm going to totally accept me and never judge me. I'm going to value me for my sake and appreciate me and see my intrinsic beauty. I'm not going to need anything from me and I'm not going to make me a tool to satisfy my own needs. I'm going to respect my point of view, wanting to understand my point of view, wanting to understand me, my uniqueness, taking the time to deeply get to know me. I'm not going to force your agenda or point of view on me. I'm going to listen to me and care about my interests and share similar interests with me. I'm going to develop togetherness with me and collaborate with me. I'm going to be there for me when i'm down and hopeless. I'm going to be there for me when I'm lonely. I'm going to validate my feelings, sharing my emotions with me, empathizing with me. My pain is going to be my pain. I'm going to meet me where I'm at, at my developmental level. I'm going to forgive me for my mistakes.
I'm going to be patient with me. I'm going to see the good in me even when I don't see the good in myself. I'm going to be generous and kind. I'm going to give myself verbal approval and praise. I'm going to compliment me on my uniqueness. I'm going to keep my promises to me. I'm going to keep my peace with me, avoid conflict with me. I'm going to tell the truth to me. I'm going to be able to fully trust me and I'm never going to cash in on that trust. I'm going to see my realness, warts and shadow and all as I truly are. I'm going to deeply appreciate the finite portion of consciousness that me are and I'm going to accept my selfishness whenever me have the urge to be selfish. Now ask myself on a scale of 0 to 10 how loved do me feel? Open Your Eyes. 😂🦘🦘🧨
we are lucky to be here
So is symmetry the property that allows changing one aspect without affecting another. Sort of decoupler?
Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
Beautiful logic
Emmy Noether's brilliant theorem connects symmetries to conservation laws. Quote from Einstein: The old guard at Göttingen should take some lessons from Miss Noether! She seems to know her stuff.
Brunelleschi discovered the formula for perspective in painting in 1420, which allowed for an effective rendering of perspective, foreshortening and realistic depictions of still life. Some other cultures deemed the perspective the realm of god and not to be used by humans
Yes! Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
amazing
beautifulvideo
Love. That. Tie.
just powerful! what is the point of all this ? to does it embody beautiful ideas ?, very neat!
Wondered why I always noticed symmetries & patterns 🤔
I love looking deeper and see those things.
Some people just walk by and don't take the time to observe.
They miss so much beauty.
Do they really care about beauty?
Maybe after its gone.
That's what our brains do. Pattern recognition.
I will refer to the book "Chaos" a similar argument on symmetry is discussed
Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
ok so it seems the binding energy or strong force gives the matter mass
I did not understand a word this man was saying, but I kept watching because he's quite charming :)
Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
Beautiful man, beautiful mind.
He seems a nice person
Well deserved Templeton Prize
Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
i found beauty instantly u said.
Yes.
its vibrations like the water on a speaker and play frecquancies you see the patters cool gonner try this soon
Answer me this..... How does a fish know to look like a rock. How does a moth have shapes on it's wings that resemble eyes. And on and on it goes. Maybe it's not three dimensional space. There is something not understood. It is a law. Does the fish know? Does the bug that looks like a leaf know? Does stick bug know? Where lies the adjustment? If it's tried and true, who is trying it? And the big one, why?
00:30 The big mistake is expecting meaning. Just because your brain wants it, doesn't mean it has to exist. That things exist we have ourselves as proof. That things have meaning is something created by us.
GREAT PHYSICIST --
That was deep.
A deep answer to a question so deeper we don't even know what it is. Yeah; impressive.
Understand
Is not the body symmetric
intelligent design, the more obvious and prominent something is, the more blind we get to it unfortunately, the same thing applies to everything hidden in plain sight including the things you should be grateful for in life
The more we learn, the less we know.
_One of the basic rules of the universe is that nothing is perfect. Perfection simply doesn’t exist…Without imperfection, neither you nor I would exist._ -Stephen Hawking
*_Without love life is meaningless._* 💕 ☮ 🌎 🌌
Best voice in science.
Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
@@quantumfineartsandfossils2152 I was talking about only the sound of his voice. Not endorsing him as a "voice" of science. But I do really like the sound of this guys voice lol
@@jonathanseagraves8140 lol I got you :) I too like sounds separate from personality good point.
Wow
I'm 59 years old and I have spent quite a lot of time on the meaning of existence and similar topics. First, there can never be a conclusion as the Universe is ever changing. Second, why do we need answers at all? Answers are for the mind. The answer, if there can ever be one is to watch, better yet "see" in awe.
I am in my late 20s and agree. I found the concept of Shiva’s cosmic dance of creation helpful in illustrating this. Also psychedelics and some life hardships
It is such huge freedom once you stop trying to over intellectualise any meaning and just marvel at the fact that you are here to witness it. I definitely see more beauty in the world now than perhaps 10 years ago despite life becoming increasingly difficult
There must be no chemicals for the experience of the ultimate. Not possible...
@@skpince interesting that you write an entire post about accepting that you do not know everything.. and then going on the say something is “impossible” perhaps you are not as wise as you think?
Remember old man, that your perspective is no better than anyone else’s.
Psychedelics are natural and grow purely in nature. They have been used by my ancestors for millennia to assist in accessing other levels of consciousness. I have been in deep meditation without plant medicine also and they produce similar effects.
I do not believe in many things, but even I am sensible enough to know that I cannot with any conviction say that something somebody else experiences is “impossible”
ok. it seems three quarks make up the matter of a proton or neutron, why do three quarks have so much less mass than a proton or neutron
What does it all mean ?
What do you all mean ?
Set laws
that is all
And yet it is the asymmetry of matter that allows us to exist. And the beauty of that dysmorphia is undeniable...blowing to smithereens prosaic ideas of beauty itself.
Nice comment... Chaos reveals a false order. Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
As Spock would say, "fascinating "
Synergy is evenness.
🙏🙏🙏
Coil with battery air founded
we don't know whether the laws of physics change over time.. or distance for that matter..
they do. get ready...
@@youtubecanthandlethetruth3949 no.. we don't know.. and neither do you.. ;9)
@@paulflute Hmm...Clearly YOU don't know. And you also don't know what *I* Know, obviously. So you can't speak for me.. ;)
@@youtubecanthandlethetruth3949 i suspect if you have convincing evidence of alternate laws of physics over space and time we might have heard by now.. care to prove me wrong..? ;9)
we are never taught to think about symmetry with respect to time at all in school/college? its always symmetry about a drawable coordinate..
Time is a compact dimension one Planck second in size.
Through Kuramoto synchrony this creates a hyperplane of the present. We are all on this surface called NOW and always are. But things like photons can move along the surface at a rate of one Planck length each Planck second.
The other side of this plane is the anti matter universe which is a perfect inversion of ours in charge and spin. When you make a mountain gold one one side you create a valley fold on the other. An inflow here is an outflow from there. Clockwise here is counterclockwise there. This is also because we exist on minimal single sided closed surface (Klein) “Shirley’s Surface” Surface (cos(u/2)cos(v/2),cos(u/2)sin(v/2),sin(u)) 0>u>4pi 0>v>2pi
Notice that 2 full rotations are needed to complete surface. Electron half spin.
Neutron decay cosmology is the physical process solution to black hole paradox and fine tuning.
So beautiful! Intellectually orgasmic. :) Thank you.
4:06 but that would suggest we've no will of our own.
*Smiles
sacred geometry
A detailed scientific/ mathematical, explanation of the echoing signature of God; in nature, and thus mimicked by human creativity.
If you say so.
Oh, please, Ronald, keep dreaming!
@@totalfreedom45 Living in my own world, is preferable to the present one they wish to create. I've already lowered my expectations of humanity; so "keep on dreaming" I will continue; non plussed by being despised, by Neo Marxist utopians.
@@massimookissed1023
And only because he says so.
Please, take me through the steps of how you got from symmetry to God.
amazing! great video
apparently nature has a mind and is good at designing cool stuff. kinda sounds like God
Um , yup :)
so we emerge from spacetime?
seems so
Voice is slow
space is big
Start at start.” The Final Theory: Rethinking Our Scientific Legacy “, Mark McCutcheon. The expanding electron is as simple (Occam) as it gets. SR wrong due to reference frame mixing and bad math. Newton no better on gravity.
The answer is in the question…
Lose the music
God is great and nature is His servant. Nature by itself does not do anything unless directed by God. Nature is created in order to reveal the existence of God.
Symmetries? Approximations.
Beauty begins with ugly.
I like to take the word "laws" and change it to "flaws," because that's what nature does. It handles the derivations that occur when copies are made from copies by finding utility in exceptions.
Nice. I Wish it was longer
4th I know lol
SubhânAllah
While I agree that fascination of nature perceived as the nature and its laws bein beautiful play a role in attracting people to science this is not always helpful. Why that is so?
Sabine Hossenfelder may help to understand that why quest for beauty is not always help in physics or generally in science.
Wilczek flakily is friends with & sympathizes with fellow flakes Lawrence Krauss, Sabine Hossenfelder & Eric R Weinstein (outed in Jennifer Ouellette's 'You've Been Played') all who support: domestic abusers, sexual harassers & child abusers in public- so I would not put much faith in anything he has to say. 2:48+ He is talking about the golden ratio, nothing he is talking about is new or out of this world, it wont change much, he's talking to us in a condescending way, its not quantum supremacy or symmetry protected quantum computing & more he's offering us, he's obviously art illiterate & doesn't care about or see the implications. A xylophone soundtrack is always supposed to imply world changing events or a credit card advertisement but the truth is nobody cares about climate he's not enthused to inspire a 'symmetry movement'..
This doesnt make yall believe someone purposely made it?
Ouh dang , symmetry in the sense of the word only exists in an imaginative realm of thoughts .
Nowhere else
The idea of symmetry is a crude simplification and easily leads to false assumptions..
Galaxies should get flung apart according to terrestrial mathematics
End of announcement °
higgs field
Symmetry doesn't explain that combination of shirt and tie.
Funny thing is that there is no absolute symmetry in the universe. Clearly the universe has to use patterns, if it didn't then it would be just a jumbled up mess. I can't wait for the day when humanity stops questioning the universe and just accepts it for what it is and enjoy existence rather than finding ways to exploit it for our benefit.
Nice. And I'll add. Circles exists like love, or nations, exist. Useful concepts in very particular circumstances.
western vs indigenous approach to the world. We'll see which one self destructs soon and is quickly forgotten..
@@youtubecanthandlethetruth3949 Yes, but to be fair, the "western approach" has brought many amazing things. Both have problems. The issue is not which *extreme* is better but about balance and nothing is ever forgotten(everything is encoded in to the universe's future, even you farting will effect the outcome. This is because the universe is chaotic(and I mean the precise mathematical notion)).
The universe is about balance and as something becomes to extreme there will be a swing in the other direction and that thing will become extreme and so the pendulum will repeat.
For us, the "western approach" has swung too far and at some point, if it isn't already, it will start to swing the other way transforming in to a more balanced(when v is largest which means it won't last long) approach and then move off in to something that won't last very long.
Until humans understand the principle of balance it will continue in the washing machine until it either learns or is destroyed,
Engineering courses should have teachers lile him
How much clearer can God be
I see no evidence for a god... 🤷🏻♂️
this guy seems like a walking w
Symmetry : What doesn't change with time, motion and space.
Philosophy: Change is the only constant.
God does not change being complete. Nature being created does change.
so who owes?