10 Controversial Referee Decisions That May Have Cost A Team An Important Match (NRL)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 июн 2020
- Forward pass or backwards out of the hands? Knock on or knock back? Try or no try? Rugby league is no stranger to controversy with big moments in big games sometimes being decided by a 50/50 call by the referees. We will be ranking this list based on moments that occurred in a finals series, state of origin match, or grand final. Some of these calls are correct, some of these calls are wrong but we will let you be the judge!
Facebook: / greatestgameall
Instagram: / greatgameofall
DISCLAIMER: We do not own any of the images and videos used in this video. We have referenced each source where we found images and videos in the bottom left of the screen accordingly. All images were retrieved from google images and are owned by the respective website producers. All videos are owned by the NRL and/or the Nine Network and are for the purpose of helping us explain our top 10 list and are in no way intending to breach any copyright infringements these organisation may have if any.
#nrl 
Спорт
This shows that Sterling is the most unbiased commentator. He always calls it spot on even when it is against his team.
Probably has a strong sense of justice after having to put up with Hartley making biased calls against Parramatta during his playing career.
@M you came to a NRL channel. ROFLMFAO
@M okay ?
Gee you parra supporters won't let it go will you. OK. Fact time. When Hartley stuffed the tackle count up manly put a bomb up near half way, got the ball back with 6 again and scored. How could he have engineered that. We also forget in that game manly was trailing 11-2 (remember only 3 points for a try then) and he sent manlys John Gray off. How's that for biased. Parramatta whinged the whole way through the 70's and they still whing to this day. The 75 semi against manly was a classic whinge fest ( Hartley wasn't a ref then). Every manly try was unfair according to Parramatta. They are the only team to have demanded to be awarded the title after the storms salary cap blow out.
@M real fans call it football and it isn't the biggest sport in Australia as of a very long time ago to this day😂
Sterling the only one not addicted to betting on the games and calling them based on personal monetary bias, and I’m not even sure that he’s clean
As a cowboys fan, experiencing those decisions prior to the 2015 GF win, that made the win so much sweeter as we should have been in there with a chance years prior
As a Dragons supporter, let me just say, the Cowboys win in the 2015 GF was probably the most excited and the happiest I've ever been watching Rugby League in my whole life. No one, not even my Dragons, deserved a premiership more than Thurston's Cowboys after all the robbery you guys had been subjected to in the previous 3 seasons. The fact that Thurston, possibly the greatest player of all time, got to score the game winning field goal in golden point time was just the icing on the cake.
Can I say as a storm supporter we and most of Australia had your backs during that grand final to end like that is a moment I’ll never forget incredible stuff and one of them many reasons why rugby league is the greatest sport on earth
As a parra supporter, I'm so glad you guys won it in 2015. It's just such a shame cause I reckon you guys would of had won more prior to the 2015 GF
@M that's because more blokes are born with vaginas these days, Very sad! Definitely something in the water.
You can thank Ben Hunt
That raiders 6 again call is probably the worst thing to happen in a final in history. No matter what the NRL say that repeat set could have won them the game either by scoring or taking time off the clock. They screwed the Raiders out of the grand final there's no other way to put it.
rubbish - it was he right call as it wasn't again get over it
The ref made a mistake and changed it to the right call stop crying the roosters were still stuck inside their end not like the try was handed to and if the ref stuck with the wrong call and they didn’t score I bet you’d be crying about that the better team won get over it
@@dukewellington3174 It doesn't matter, he made a call he can't just go back on it. If a ref awards a try he can't just decide later that it's not a try.
@@lockey4262 it does matter because the correct call was made for once. Get over it the shit cunts had all the ball and couldn't score.
That’s rugby league. Roosters defended there line for 15minutes straight and raiders couldn’t score so you cant say they were gonna score. Also raiders couldn’t score when roosters were one man down for 10 minutes. Roosters had one opportunity and scored
Thurston one of the most professional players out there. Even when he's being robbed, man still stands on the field with dignity. Glad they won it in '15.
@@zackjohnson9204 bet u support NSW
@@zackjohnson9204 well then you’d know damn well u ain’t right
@@deadwillytv6528 You must have a pretty short memory. He was famous in the early days for getting in the face of the refs.
na he didn’t want a 30 grand fine was happening that year hahaha kept saying na na i’ll say something stupid, he had a go at robinson when the roosters won, and no one else has the balls to say anything
Didn’t they build him a monument at Coffs?
Yeah true the cowboys got robbed a lot
I knew it had happened a lot but seeing it like this is ridiculous, but they can't take their premiership away from them
02 and 03 yes but 04 his hand facing opposition line deems a knock on
Drifter Thrifters they weren’t robbed idiot
I think this comment was supposed to be a reply to the top comment
Drifter Thrifters Broncos weren’t robbed you clown
craig smiths try shouldnt have been controversial, it was a penalty try as soon as the defender tackled him as Craig was scoring the try
It's controversial in so much as it was a game-deciding try. Penalty tries are rare, penalty tries that decide a GF, I can't think of another instance outside of this. I still remember the commentary word-for-word. It's the LAST thing a ref wants to do in being the deciding factor in a game but Chris Ward and Bill Harrigan had no choice.
As a Dragons fan as much as I wish it wasn’t a penalty try it definitely was haha the ball was in Smiths hands inches away from being put down, could only ever be a penalty try
@@Dickey1996 Thank you, it's one of those instances where yes it's controversial, but it is the only right decision.
Agreed completely
It was absolutely a try
That 6 again call still makes me filtthy and I'm a warriors fan
they couldn't even score against 12 mighty roosters😂😂
@@mistagrove4349 you don’t have to score you just have to mount pressure
I cried when the six again call was made and I’m a Raiders fan
Should've been 6 again for sure, Ben Cummins stuffed up big time he was right the first time!
Well didn’t the roosters score off the ball hitting a leaguesafe person
Thurston: TWICE we been robbed man!!
Ref: yeah thats fine* 😂🤦🏽♂️
Brooo I was like wow 😮 at the ref for saying that’s fine.. 🤣🤦🏽♂️👀.... refs ruined a lot of bets and multis 😂
That made me laugh it was so fucked up lol poor cunts
As a young fella growing up & glued to every game not just the cows.. I can literally remember the tears I shared with my mates as we were robbed again and again. 2015 was my first and only year living outside of TSV.. I must have been one of the happiest blokes in Victoria when we finally won it
New video:
NRL vs North Qld Cowboys
nrl commentators vs storm lol
id love to see that
NRL wi
@Jonathan Georgis n
you'll get a longer one against the bunnies. lol. some are just not meant to win, and the cowboys were one of them. the year they won, you couldn't fault their finals run. how do you penalise a perfect team? best finals year and by alot, the greatest grand final in a long time! and i've seen plenty.
Poor Cowboys. Great video mate
Too bad the refs couldn't have called Ben Hunts dropped ball in Golden Point as going back...
Delai Lama tg but cowboys are coated
Delai Lama it was clearly lost ball man what are you talking about? It bounced off him and everything
@@mangoburster5156 I'll explain it to you.
1 - The Cowboys have a history of bad calls against them in big games.
2 - I'm a Broncos fan.
3 - I am not arguing that it wasn't a knock on.
4 - As a Broncos fan, it would have been nice if it was called knocked back because we might have had a chance to win the Grand Final.
5 - It's a joke.
Delai Lama ok that’s all good then
That 6 again call still makes me feel sick 🤦♀️😡
Being a cowboys fan I feel your pain
They clearly made the wrong call and corrected it... that call didn't lose the raiders the game not being able to score against 12 men and bombing two certain tries did.
@james sakky that was unfortunate. If we are going to go back and say all the buts about the game what about when keary was clearly taken out after his kick mid air and the Roosters got no penalty for that. It was a great game ruined by poor refereeing.
@James Sakky That should have been a penalty to Sydney as the fullback was tackled in the air but the referee missed it. Watch the replay.
James Sakky what about when they changed the decision of knock on when the raiders dropped the ball, giving them field position leading to a questionable cronk sin binning? raiders have literally no leg to stand on they were given ample opportunity to win and couldn’t.
How many possible grand finals have North Queensland been robbed of... fair dinkum
almost every theyve been apart of
@@petersinclair338 the only year they didnt get robbed, they won a premiership... shouldve maybe been more than just 2015
@@weepjng yeah that was a brilliant game too dunno if you watched it back then but i did :D
the atmosphere was insane
Peter Sinclair yeah mate, I’ll never forget it 🔥
not many. Against sharks nobody wants to talk about wrong calls in cowboys favour that resulted in them being in a position to score a try rather than defending with sharks attacking their line becasue they wee not as big mistakes. However they were still wrong calls and cowboys would not have been in the game if they had been correct. Other than that if they were going to win the GF then they had over half the game to overcome it. If they couldn't then they just weren't good enough.
Interestingly enough; the first call should have been a penalty to the Cowboys. Minichiello knocks on and it’s picked up by a Rooster in an offside position.
accidental offside scrum.
Nope, accidental offside is always a penalty. Poor refereeing. The only justice is that Paul Simpsons did not get to officiate the grand final
marcus86tiger accidental offside is a scrum, if he deliberately played at the ball then it would be a penalty
@@marcus86tiger well there are a lot of refs getting it wrong then judging from the number of scrums for accidental offside!
Part Time Gamer He did play at the ball. Minichiello knocked the ball forward and the Rooster in front of him picked the ball up; offside penalty. If it had bounced off the Rooster in front it would have been a scrum, but he played at it by picking it up. It should have been a penalty; giving the Cowboys one last crack.
Imagine how many premierships Thurston probably could of had if cowboys weren’t robbed
1
@@lidawano he has 2 though
@@jackboxsell6771 2*
lol they wouldn’t beat storm in 2012
Agreed
That Tonga one always makes me so sad. I love the Tongan team so much, they clearly have an immense passion for the sport.
not sure if it's tonga or png, but don't venture out on state of origin night. they're so passionate, the highest murder rate is on those 3 nights.
Makes me sick how many times we got robbed but we stuck it to the NRL in 2015
This video makes me feel sick as a Cowboys fan! Plus that 2019 game left me fuming for days afterward!
Imagine if they hadnt won that theyd have 3 wins since 05.
I’m glad the cowboys were finally able to come back to win the 2015 premiership after all the dud calls in previous years
The Robert Lui call against the Roosters was correct. Don't know what the commentators were smoking. A definite knock on. But Cowboys were definitely robbed in the previous years
8:18 i actually agree with that call 100%
same
especially in today’s game
was 100000% forward
@@cooperfleming7494 you don't understand the forward pass rule
Everybody did, this guy is a salty Queenslander trying to stir up controversy
Disclaimer, I am not a Canberra or Roosters fan but I was at the 2019 grand final. For those still arguing whether the 6 again decision and reversal was correct or not, it actually doesn't matter as the referee is not allowed in this situation to change his decision. Refer to the following from the NRL rule book:
Section 16. Duties of Referee and Touch Judges
Changing decision 9. The Referee judges on matters of fact and shall not
subsequently alter those judgments. He may cancel
any decision made if prior foul play of which he had
no knowledge is reported to him by a Touch Judge.
John Beaver except that rule doesn’t apply to mid play decisions. As long as a tackle hadn’t occurred from the time he called six again and then changed it back to 5th tackle which it didn’t. Then the ref is within their right to correct their decision. Once a tackle is complete or a penalty given or something else happens that calls that play dead then that rule comes into effect
@@Ryan-ys3yd You will have to show in the rule book where your statement is interpreted, there is nothing in the rule I posted that states when and where the rule is limited by your interpretation. The referee made a decision and called and signaled that decision, I don't see in the rules where this is negated by the fact that the play was not completed.
John Beaver it’s called spending my whole life living with a rugby league referee. That’s how I know that the rule applies what I said
@@Ryan-ys3yd but there's nothing written in the rule book you can point me too that explains this?
@@johnbeaver206 prob is but I have a life I don't have a few hours to read a rule book word for word. When I've already explained why it doesn't apply to open play and why the nrl said Cummins was within his rights to change his decision.
The RWC Tonga vs England on field decision made me never want to watch rugby league again. It was one of those last minute tries that needed video referees.
lol imagine not wanting to watch NRL again because the right call was made
it was a loose carry buddy
@@benoh8321same ref allowed inglis review knock on try. Same thing happened 1 on 1 play on but no review for fifita
@@raypiste1972same ref allowed to review inglis knock on try. You call loose carry still?
that new zealand pass from the wing clearly is forward. he throws it near the 20 and it lands near the 10
Its a forward through but not a forward pass, if the aussie player didnt touch it, it would have been a forward pass or knock on
I didnt see an aussie touch it and 10 metres forward means there is no possible way it was backwards motion, wasnt even a pass, it was a lobbed throw.
@@mohommadhabibi4616 how did you not see an aussie touch it hahahah
I'm a kiwi and I think that was the biggest forward pass in history hahaha. There's no argument for backwards out of the hands, it was blatantly forward.
@@andymehrts6071 but it doesn’t matter. if it had gone to one of our players without being touched it would have been forward. but it was touched
I can't believe that ref made that decision at the 2019 grand final Canberra got so robbed worst decision I've ever seen
The referees seem to look after the Chooks a lot
they're worse with melbourne. even well after slutter and his cronies retired.
Blake Ferguson’s pass is the most desperate attempt to create controversy. It went miles backwards out of the hands
A pass so backwards tedesco had to stop and reach out backwards.
Ferguson pass the ball from behind the line and tedesco caught the ball in front of the line
S Wright you should probably read up on the laws of the game if you think that’s forward
I'm a Queensland fan and I've never argued with that try because there's nothing wrong with it
The person who made the video is obviously a Queenslander trying to make excuses on how they lost hahaha
Listening to Gus crying on the Inglis try. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Mate. Awesome video. I never really picked up on the cowboys dilemmas in finals before. Makes so much more sense with Thurston’s emotions when he actually got the win!
It just goes to show how shocking Australia’s rugby league referees really are
how the fuck do you find this shocking. Everyone makes mistakes mate.
Yep
@@xtract_crews2327 mistakes are one thing, a fucking joke is another, and the league has been a fucking joke for over 15 years now. how the fuck do you NOT find this shocking that women fucked it, and we have fairies screwing calls so much and penalising teams to the point they should just have a dance off in tutu's instead..... must be a queenslander.
Would rather 1 person making a mistake can handle that, but when the bunker gets it wrong it's a disgrace proves it's useless.
@xtract_crews2327 Because these are paid professional refs with consistent "mistakes"?
The 1999 Grand final penalty try is the right call. You can dress it up however you want but it doesn't change the fact that if you foul a player in the act of scoring a try and they do not ground the ball it is a penalty try. If Ainscough let's him ground the ball the conversion would have been from further out. Also don't forget Mundine being a glory hog and dropping the ball over the line with an unmarked Darren Tracey in support.
Basically, if I'm the ref, I'm only going TMO to determine whether it's a penalty try or an eight-pointer.
Before I do, the tackler sees RED. That's a sending-off offense.
@@michaelfalkner1186 Dragons supporter here. I completely agree. Penalty try was absolutely the right call. And I say that as someone who was a broken-hearted 9 year old boy watching live at the time that try was actually awarded. Still hurts to watch, but that was the right call.
@@jamesedward3619 All I'm saying is I'd go up to check the grounding, and send off the tackler.
@@michaelfalkner1186 Yeah bro, I agree. There's no way it wasn't at least a penalty try, possibly an 8 point try like you said.
That's Treacy to u
Omg you’ve grown so much in subs you had 300 then 3k now 8k keep going man
To be fair the right call was 5 and last but it sucks that the reff didnt rule that first
Would have been handy if the nrl allowed captains challenges that year. That way Roosters could have challenged the 6 again call instead of the ref changing his mind on the spot.
It sucks more that the ref didn’t allow Canberra to really set their defensive line before they allowed the Chooks to play on.
So glad the cowboys got that premiership, they were robbed so much before that 😅
Man, I’m a raiders fan, my dad is a roosters fan, I’m still fuming about that call nearly two years later
Enjoyed the video, but you were really clutching at straws when you added the NSW 2019 try.
Great list well done on your research.
Thank you.
pretty much every final series cowboys got ripped off somehow
good video though brother , well explained
Us cowies have been robbed enough.
amen brother
Amen
no cowboys just suck
@@sk8foryellow168 they're been robbed numerous of times in the past.
Before you guys entered the comp the broncos copped it alot and still do
As a warriors supporter I cried for you guys for every time. I cried even more when you won. I don’t watch NRL anymore because of those decisions.
As a Cowboys fan, man the players had to earn that first premiership. So many dud calls in close games. The Foran one was the worst. They all hurt, but it made that first premiership even sweeter.
Just get better referees.. poor cowboys 3 years in a row
Had the ref not corrected its call in the Roosters v Canberra, the argument would have been that he made a wrong call because Tedesco never knocked that ball on.
As for a more controversial result than that, the 2010 Saints v Roosters GF when the video ref award a try to BMoz to win the Grand Final only for the replay to show that BMoz had put his foot on the sideline as he was scoring a try which gave them the game and the trophy.
Great video mate :) Subbed your channel
Other great gems you left out.
Dragons v Bulldogs 98 semi final at kogarah (Steven Clark needed a security escort out of the ground)
Tigers v Roosters 2010 semi final (In the lead up to the Anasta field goal the entire roosters pack pushed early in the scrum and ref called play on)
and here i was thinking i was the only one to think the tiges got robbed that game
I'd forgotten how angry those decisions against the cowboys made me at the time. The one against Tonga brings back memories of all the shit decisions ruled against the island teams. Painful.
It was a knock on from Donga
@@universeobserver378that same ref allowed to review inglis knock try. Didn't review fifitas strip same calls
Number 7 and number 1 the most outrageous. Roosters the beneficiary on both occasions. Outstanding video mate.
I remember sitting behind the posts in that penalty try GF, Dragons v Melbourne, i felt so sorry for Jamie Ainscough, not going for either side as I'm an Eels fan. I remember being at that state of origin game too when Gordie was sent off.
Geez poor cowboys, they’re in almost all of these.
Give them a break.
Canberra was robbed with that incident against roosters. Refs need to stick by their initial decision otherwise its just confusing for players 🙄
Incredible video, great research. You got a new sub!
Time to add that 6 meter forward pass that got the Broncos the sealer try earlier tonight
Fergos pass to Teddy was clearly backwards
Wonder how many grand finals the Cowboy may have won between 2004 and 2015. Also interesting how many Sydney side came on top of these poor decisions.
Hey Glen, how you going mate
Love these vids
Top video. You’ve got a good narration voice and the background sounds match well.
Raiders should have won 2019 grand final. The ref clearly signaled 6 again.
I was falking about it yesterday and a roosters fan was in the room, who refused to agree. They just dont get it 🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️
Lukania13 The raiders couldn’t score against 12 men. You don’t lose a game because of 1 call. There was a pretty clear penalty against the raiders that the ref didn’t call 2 tackles before the 6 again call but you don’t talk about that. The games 80 minutes, you gotta play for 80
There’s no guarantee that the raiders score in that set, how do they deserve anything at 8-8. Lol
Very true they would of at least kicked a field goal
@Tim I don’t agree with 4 tries in six minutes but they would of kicked the field goal and won
I wonder how many of these "bad calls" are related to gambling.
Interesting you say that, because with all the Sportsbet and tab ect commercials advertising gambling on NRL games, makes you wonder with all the dodgy calls teams that shouldn’t win do ect.....last few years I’ve hardly watched any NRL because you can generally tell who’s gonna win by looking at “their odds” 🤷♂️
about as many as there are flat earthers that are right :P
@@jonski223 Yes, that's quite literally what having lower odds means...
I doubt it was enough to cost them a game, but I still vividly remember Jarryd Hayne's disallowed try in Game I of Origin 2009 where his foot would have been out by less than a blade of grass, only for Valentine Holmes to score an almost identical try in Game II of 2017 and be awarded a try.
1994 State of origin Game 1
I always thought that the pass from Willie Carne to Steve Renouf went forward. I wonder how that may not of been assessed if need be in the modern era
Couldn't agree more.
You could just watch every Warriors match and find a team robbed every week by terrible decisions.
Breaks my heart seeing my raiders on the top spot, but I 10000% agree, we got our revenge anyways
Got me with that "Another one" XD
What about the 2009 grand final when parra got robbed by storm when fui fui moi moi got penalised for holding on to slater when he was just tackling him and slater just lost it cold
makes that 2015 GF win so much sweeter for the cowboys. robbed so many times holy shit.
They robbed brisbane in the last minute aswell lol
Take Sportsbet and other linked gambling out of the picture; I wonder how different things would be.
Awesome 😎 mate 👍🏾
As a Cowboys fan, I was surprised there wasn't a referral to the bunker when Kyle Feldt scored on the buzzer in the 2015 gf. As a Cowboys fan you just become conditioned to getting fucked over from the refs.
How much do I need to pay referees to win like Cockhea-- I mean Roosters?
lol this video should be called, "how many premierships should the Cowboys have won if not for wrong referee decisions
The NSW bias is overwhelming
#10 (Easts vs North QLD) ... looked to me as though one of the Easts players (ahead of Mighty Mouse) touched the ball (but made sure #1 recovered the ball) ... offside, penalty Cowboys.
c'mon, the chooks ...
It’s amazing that the beneficiary of these are mostly roosters haha
True!! 😡
BRO RAIDERS SHOULD HAVE WON THAT btw i was at the game i swear
Cowboys got done on the manly and sharks calls (and i'm a sharks fan - love that seven tackle set!) but it went forward off lui in 2014. Also imagine anyone but Thurston getting away with calling the entire NRL rigged against QLD, in the middle of the QLD state of origin dynasty. He should've been massively fined for that no matter how many times the cowboys got hard calls.
Oh man, that 2012 Origin howler stings in my memory. Paul Gallen saying: “This is ridiculous, where this is getting!”, after six years of close games, desperation and repeated heartbreak - and yes, absolutely terrible refereeing decisions (on both sides) - everyone in Australia, regardless of where they’re from could agree with Gal there. It was ridiculous where it was getting, and it was only going to get worse.
You could quite easily make a top 20 video, just on Origin howlers that were detrimental to NSW.
The roosters, could a team be any more protected
Penalty broncos
Cameron Smith would like a word with you.
Not Roosters but ‘Rorters’.
@@pantherz9103 evidence - back it up
The dragons weren’t robbed, it was a fair call, it’s definitely a penalty try, and the 2019 the pass was miles back, so I would say those two were robbed, but great video, love your content
Love your videos and my name is daisy and my brothers are really into footy🤘🏈
in the old days of League any drop was a knock on regardless of if it went a metre forward or ten metres back
I’m a Raiders fan through and through but if they went on with the 6 again and they got a try there would still be controversy
Albeit controversy, getting back to back premierships off the back of it isn’t really a good thing.
Nearly every bunker decision this year
great videos man please upload more often.
🐮🧒4lyf! Watched every game mentioned. Screamed my heart out!
The Roosters did not deserve to win the 2019 Grand Final.
I wouldn't say they didn't deserve to win. Roosters 100% deserved to win just as much as the raiders. The 6 again call was actually correct, it was just poorly executed and should have been done differently. the trainer call was also bad, but there were other calls in favour of the raiders and they didn't take advantage of the opportunities they had throughout the game
The ref made a mistake and changed it to the right call stop crying the roosters were still stuck inside their end not like the try was handed to and if the ref stuck with the wrong call and they didn’t score I bet you’d be crying about that the better team won get over it
Storm vs Eels Qualifying Final, 2006. The Eels were denied a try that would have been sent into golden point and the eels had the chance to win it
When? They didn’t lose by just a converted try
@@sliat1981 It was in 2006. The eels did lose by 6 points.
"There is so much injustice in this world." Some RL fan in 2020 :)
Greg Inglis’s origin try in 2012 may of been a knock on but it makes up for the obvious Brett Hodgson and Eric Grothe knock on try in 2006
It's all swings n roundabouts hey mate
Bryce M yeh ayee
And Fletcher in 2000 at Stadium Australia 😂😂😂😂😂
dunno what you're bitching about, considering inglis should have been playing nsw, and not queensland. he was born nsw, started playing nsw, represented in nsw, but somehow qualified for queensland... bit like robbie o'davis way back, where he represented both states, nsw first, then when queensland bawled like bitches, went to the maroons. there's always controversy in state of origin, but you couldn't get a clearer knock on than in the case of greg inglis' try. great player, deserved the records, but that was a bullshit call no matter what. nothing justifies all that.
haha how biased is the commentator on the match at 13:20
You mean Wally Lewis talking about how there's nothing dangerous about it?
@Daece haha lol
Storm vs Sharks. Christian Welch pushes on a players back once he’s grounded and gives away a penalty right in front of goals. Could have gone either way, but they scored a try on the next set and won the game. Not a controversial or wrong call, but could have gone either way. Definitely decided the match
2014 Cowboys one was fine. There was only really controversy there because of the years before it.
You could tell Tedesco knew the raiders were robbed by his celebration, he had just won his team a gf and he didn’t even really celebrate. He knew the opposition had been robbed.
that's idiotic
You mean he was respectful of the opposition and situation and continued on with his professional approach.
Queensland 2019? Oh please it wasn’t forward the maroons are really salty now
I reckon why was that even in the countdown. That’s backwards any day of the week
Yeah they just salty
hahaha what’s ur excuse for last nights loss?
This comment was made a month ago
Throws it 20m out, get caught 17m out....... wtf is wrong with you?!
You could make a video on the way the Warriors get shafted, it will be long though.
These people don't care when the warriors get bad calls, did you not get the memo?
It continues till today in 2020 (even after lockdown) - somebody is going to get fed up ..... and a team will walk from the field (in the middle of the game) and won't come back.
Inglis knocked on everyday of the week cause it comes off his arm still after its hit Robbie's foot
that changed the whole series, 2012 was NSW year tbh
Deadset knock on, can't believe it was awarded a try worst decision I have ever seen!
10) If there was ever a place for a "professional error" (a full penalty would probably extend play), there it is.
9) I don't know which is worse: The call, or getting sent off in an Origin match for straight-up referee abuse. He was not suspended but should've been banned at least 3-6 months, given the gravity of the situation and the fact that, IIRC, it was the first sending-off in years and it was straight-up referee abuse. Tallis actually captained the squad the next year, something which, under NO CIRCUMSTANCES, should've been allowed.
8) I'm actually surprised the referee didn't finish off what I would actually believe a fixed match by sending off the captain for that last bit, even though the captain was right!
7) Nope. That one's right. Did go forward on the ground, forward pass/knock on. No try. Probably on the list because that's three years in a row the Cowboys were done by the refs.
6) Sending off, and you go upstairs. It's either a single penalty try or an 8-pointer. That's the ONLY controversy here. Blatant high shot to the head foul play to prevent the winning try. Since he did not ground the ball, there's no controversy here, just how long the other player gets banned for for that highly dangerous high-shot professional foul. Again, probably MONTHS on that suspension, especially given the nature of the foul and it's deliberate professional intent, but he walks -- no tribunal discipline.
5) You have multiple problems here. The passer gets taken out late, but the ball is clearly two meters AT LEAST forward. But the camera shot makes it impossible to see whether the ball was tipped or what -- so the best call you probably get as stands is probably "Benefit of the Doubt" and the winning try stands.
4) Unless one can see that hand in the back of the carry, it looks "poor carry". But if it's a strip, you have to have MAJOR QUESTIONS for the official, up to and including fixing the match. You DON'T let that situation go unexamined in a World Cup semifinal, even if the call is eventually right! So you're either right or you want England vs. Australia and some major questions have to be asked.
3) That pass was at least four meters forward, but the problem was, it was touched -- what were the rules at the time in that situation? When does the violation occur for forward pass? It would appear the violation has already occurred, even though the ball is in the air when it is touched by the opposition.
2) Was this ever decided whether it was a try on the touchdown or actually (for the foot and dangerous play) determined a penalty try? At least as of 2015, that's a penalty try under Law 9. You cannot legally kick the ball out of a player's hands under Law 9 -- the only question there being when that law was put in effect. If that was in effect here, it's a stone-cold penalty try.
1) At least the second fixed match on this list, if not the third. For those who know American sports, especially of the era, this was like the offensive foul Michael Jordan committed for his sixth rigged championship in the NBA. They wanted to send this player off with another title, come how they can do it.
Number 7 isn’t a knock on mate, just about every pass is thrown in that direction and it’s play on
@@ronb233 Not when it rolls forward like that. That's why most everything that's dropped is called a knock on.
Michael Falkner you’ve just proven you know nothing by thinking that the ball has to bounce backwards. As long as the pass is backwards out of the hands originally it’s play on
@@michaelfalkner1186 theother j
guy is right
If you think that "push" was an offensive foul, you're delusional. Watch it in slow Mo. Russell just got beaten hands down.
The 1999 Dragons one is a textbook penalty try. I was there btw happened right in front of me. But no controversy it was clear.
6:16 Commentators are blind if they think that went anywhere than upfield off of his arm.
Moral of the story is: Don't make half baked late grabs at the ball, and you won't knock it on.
Only time the Cowboys truly got robbed was the 6 tackle debacle. Video ref even got the Foran call correct - no clear proof = call stands. Yeah he probably touched it, but there's no shot showing emperical proof his hand making contact, for all the clip shows he hit the back of JT's hand.
The Tonga no-try was a clear knock on. Tackler clearly grabbed Fifita's arm, never touched the ball & ya can't strip the ball without laying a finger on it - loose carry & pick up your socks mate, you done goofed up your teams star moment.
Aussies got absolutely robbed by the forward pass in the 4 Nations final - but listen - if you let your opponent literally carve you up so bad that none of the refs are anywhere near the play - you'll just have to accept their opinion that it looked back from the hand - which was all based on the gammy loop Jase hooked his arm in to pass it. Rules should be allowing forward pass reviews, but its so tricky with the camera angles, they'd literally need a spider cam and those cost more for each game than both teams wages - there simply isn't a budget for that technology.
The Inglis try is such a non event - only an oblivious retard thinks Farrah didn't intentionally play at the ball with his foot - that's a clear cut infringement and has been ever since Ridgey I think it was got cleaned out by some idiot heading in feet first at the ball.
6 Again was just a debacle. 1 game - 1 referee thanks.
Raiders robbed. How the Cowboys were repeatedly shafted is a black mark on the game. Criminals.
Ball came of raiders hand. Not robbed at all They had numerous chances to score that game but couldnt score. Roosters 1 chance and scored
Raiders robbed when! Haha grow up and watch it mate. Coward
Of course, the Raiders were robbed. They were the best team on the field that night.
The chooks couldn’t score without their 14th player, Ben Cummins the clown.
The Rosters were handed two tries by the Santa Cummins Clause. First, the falcon of the trainer’s head. What was he doing on the field after two minutes from start of the game? Then the all-time joke of the 6-again rubbish call by the Cummins the clown.
Then chooks cry for sending Cronk off for tackling without the ball to prevent 100% try by big Papa which was wrongfully not awarded!
Anyway, no need to hide guys, the sun is up there and we all know the reality.
Rowan , Raiders hand :) That’s new! Are you sure you watched the game? Or perhaps someone told you about it?
khalidep first of all the ball hitting the trainer was accidental and theres nothing anyone can do about that. Second of all how can u garrentee that papli wouldve score, he was metres away from the try line. Cronk legit tackled papli a millersecond before the ball and he was sin binned wrongfully . The raiders had all the ball even when roosters had 12 players on and couldnt score. The 6 again call came of raiders hand hence why the changed the call. And Roosters showed there championship qualities and scored of 1 chance they had. Raiders where not good enough and you wont talk about how the roosters defended really well that game but u will make exuses saying raiders where robbed. You can cry about it all you want but the Roosters are the reigning champs buddy