Ive seen all kinds of answers that does not really answer this question, I honestly am the only one that have answered this question in my content section
@@legal_solutions_india well you're a fool for criticizing someone for their works, when you know that Salvation does not come from any man's works or yours. You're too Ignorant about scripture to say you have the right Gospel, you actually Worship a man, have you even thought about Christianity actually worshiping the Antichrist, that man isnt even Jesus, its Cesare Borgia. So watch your mouth about your Judgements, and give it a sincere thought. I was already a Christian, and i know a lot about Christianity, including the foolishness of speaking in tongues. Its all the work of a devil, the Antichrist. Revelation 13:14 (NLT) 14 And with all the miracles he was allowed to perform on behalf of the first beast, *he DECEIVED all the people* who belong to this world. He ordered the people to make a *GREAT STATUE of the first BEAST, WHO WAS FATALLY WOUNDED AND THEN CAME BACK TO LIFE* WAKE UP. COME BACK TO GOD
@@legal_solutions_india youre not Christian but you dont know the Bible enough to slander, judge without eye witness, the 9th commandment is not to bear false witness, you only read about this man. Do you understand what a false prophet is in Matthew 24:24? it is someone who performs miracles to deceive the elect into converting to the false religion. Do you know what repent means, the very act of repenting is to cease your evil actions and convert to God's religion. You think you are safe from the fire's of Hell? With all the slander you have said about a Prophet of God? I know both sides of this war, and I know everything Biblical about Islam, the Bible doesn't say the world is ignorant and hates God's people for no reason. If you think your safe, then find out, if you wish to receive Mercy then do yourself a favor, not me, not people, do yourself a favor and ask for Mercy from the One that can burn your Soul for Eternity. If you dont believe in God, go watch some of these Christians being possessed in Churches speaking in tongues rolling on the floor laughing. All God's work to show you what's right or wrong. Stop slandering a prophet, better yet, stop slandering people that you only read about, there is a real tyrant in the world and he has sex slaves too, he is in N. Korea but I dont see you doing anything about that oppression. Mark my words, This is your warning. If you had an ounce of intelligence you would be sincere in your search, if you want help watch my content anonymously.
One advise to you @Sapience Institute, please illustrate your upcoming video explanations with diagrams, pictures, animation if possible for us to relate to what is explained, it would be much easier to follow this way. Keep up the good work and all the best.
The irony is that every testicles literally originate from between backbone and ribs.. but not every testicles descend inside the scrotum / pelvic. As a doctor i don't have a problem with that. Rather, for me personally, this verse is truly miraculous. It truly has a multi layered and very deep meanings
and also the baby emerges from between the backbone and the ribs during delivery we all know of Shelving and the relief the mother feels a few days before delivery.
@@kanizfatima1377 I;m a let you in on somewhat of an uncommon piece of information. the Uterus moves through the peritoneum in a unique manner when gravid. it adjusts the other organs around
@@kautharlukman5218 I am not an expert on sperm production, but I don't think the van deference goes up all the way to the ribs ruclips.net/video/zzRydwGWeho/видео.html. And the Quran says ejected in sura 86verse 6. Even if it is true that testicles originate from the backbone and the ribs the Quran is still appears to be wrong because we know that sperm production happens at puberty not birth. quran.com/86
Thank you, this actually makes sense. I've read some wishy-washy explanations before which didn't convince me. I didn't doubt the Quran, just thought that there was some part of the creation of a human which science didn't know about. But it's not really hard, especially the third explanation. Jazakallahu khairan
The originate and formation of testis or ovaries in womb isfrom the space which is present in between the backbone and ribs It later on descends in the scrotum No doubt that quran from Allah swt❤❤
Third one is new to me and it makes sense. I used understand this verse in a different way. There is a thing called "descent of testis".Formation of Testis initially stars between t10 and t12 spine and that place is exactly "between backbone and ribs". When a boy becomes 9 months old the testis descents into scrotum. So testis was formed between backbone and ribs and from from testis sperms come. Allah knows best.
When someone talks about ejected fluid, they might be talking about adult testes because talking about fetal testes at that time would be redundant, imo third option might be the way, in any case Allah knows best
@@goldsaint7 Yeah it could be but whatever it is it's not an invalid verse as there are correct interpretations for it. Allah knows best what it actually means.
@@_faiyaz_moni_7010 i think that the length of ductus defferens vas defferent is 35-40 cm which is the exact length of the distance from loins to ribs. Maybe
@@JamieMoore-el7ub "He is the One Who has revealed to you ˹O Prophet˺ the Book, of which some verses are precise-they are the foundation of the Book-while others are elusive.1 Those with deviant hearts follow the elusive verses seeking ˹to spread˺ doubt through their ˹false˺ interpretations-but none grasps their ˹full˺ meaning except Allah. As for those well-grounded in knowledge, they say, “We believe in this ˹Quran˺-it is all from our Lord.” But none will be mindful ˹of this˺ except people of reason."[3:7]
Sulb means hard,strong,rigid, stiff,tough,robust,sturdy or hardy. Sulb : hardest of the stones Sulb (singular) : sacrum bone (holy bone) because sacrum bone is hardest of the bones Sacrum is wedge-shaped triangular bone at the base of the vertebral column. It is largest and the densest bone of the vertebral column, and slowest to decay after death. Taraaib (plural) : Pairs of organs Al-taraaib is derived from turab meaning dust grains. In the sense that dust grains are equal. In the dictionary , Al-taraaib is used to refer to the body parts which are in pairs. Pairs of eyes, hands and legs together referred as a “taraaib” Ribs come in pair. Right and left sides of each pair are exactly the same so pairs of ribs is referred as a “taraaib”. There are two hip bones, one on the left side of the body and other on the right. Each hip bone is made of three bones, the illium,pubis and ischium. So here pairs of illium,pubis and ischium bones can be referred to as “taraaib” Area between the sacrum bone and Pairs of hip bones together is known as pelvis The prostate and the seminal vesicles produce fluid that nourishes the sperm. This fluid provides most of the volume of semen, the fluid in which the sperm is expelled during ejaculation. Other fluid that makes up a very small amount of the semen comes from the vas deferens and from Cowper glands in the urethra. All this organs are located in the pelvis cavity. He was created from a fluid comes out from between the sacrum bone and Pairs of hip bones. 86:6-7
@@saidali5676 but brother one may argue that man is not created from The semen,rather he is created from the sperm the sperm takes a vital role in Human reproduction(formation of zygote)....But not the semen…the other fluids allow the sperm to reach its journey,but they do not play a vital role in the formation of zygote
@@raditz4583that’s the whole point. Sureh imran verse 7 “Some of its verses are absolutely clear and lucid, and these are the core of the Book. Others are ambiguous. Those in whose hearts there is perversity, always go about the part which is ambiguous, seeking mischief and seeking to arrive at its meaning arbitrarily, although none knows their true meaning except Allah.”
@redfordkobayashi6936 i think u need remove communism from ur eyes.. And btw.. The word Qur'an itself means - to read, to recite. So u might wanna do..what it says
If you read surah tariq no were in that whole surah sperm is mentioned, it says ما which means water. The anti islam had to put their own words to try to proof their mistaken point. That just shows the highest degree of inconsistency and insecurity. Islam is superior and nothing can surpass.!!!!!!
So human beings are made by water from between the backbone and ribs? Also you do realize that nearly every translation of that verse is made by muslims?
@@ciismanakh9707 humans aren't created from the water, they are created from sperm, water in the semen helps make the sperm enter the female but the sperm is the only part that creates life
@@ciismanakh9707 we are made of water but not created from water itself, water itself can't creat life. sperm is what creates life when it is fertalized
I would also like to input that from a medical perspective the hormones a man produces to undertake spermatogenesis originate from the adrenal cortex, which is directly between the ribs and the spine, just under the last rib and above the kidney. I've always understood that this is what Allah is referring to in the origination of the fluid being created is from the adrenal glands which produce most of the sex hormones. Furthermore the testes and the ovaries originate embryologically from just beneath the kidneys and then migrate down (due to the gubernaculum) to their positions in male and females. And so again the origination of the sperms and ovaries is from directly between the last rib and the spine in the location specified by Allah.
It's actually more than that. A man who has no backbone is not regarded by woman. You will see such effeminate men having no backbone getting to an age where they even stick out their backbone. You take the percentage of backbone in a woman, compared to the rest of her body. We don't need rapist doctors ripping out women's bits to find out about this. It was clear and obvious. No one calls the backbone of a man his coccyx. No one sees the coccyx, that's hidden.
Isn't it kind of strange that the way things like this are written in the Quran sound exactly as how one would expect humans would understand these things 1400 years ago plus depends hugely on how you interpret the verses? If this is truly written by an all mighty god and a miracle why isn't this explained spot on in detail without any interpretation needed so one could not even disagree? How can it be that we today can explain these things much better than an all knowing god? Doesn't it make more sense that this simply is another human made book like ALL books are?
@@bustinjieber2673 I think the whole point is that it is actually explained clearly and in sublime detail that even we cannot understand without years of research. The way I see it is if you have proved an empirical fact in science and it contradicts the Quran, it is because you have misunderstood what you thought you had read. And then when we go back to read the quran with the new information we have learned we can reinterpret it and realise that the quran was right all along and we were the ones who didn't realise. In this example specifically, scientists discover and understand the embryology of the gonads and the sexual hormones origin - and then go back to the quran with new knowledge and reinterpret this verse and realise how it is correct on a deeper level. Allah doesn't need to go into any further detail because the people at the time would then disagree with the statement because they don't know yet the science behind things. Then when civilisation catches up and reinterpret the quran they are then amazing at the accuracy. For example Allah explains how He is expanding the universe - they never understood it before and then people would say "that is clearly wrong" and then disbelieve until now science tells us that the universe is expanding and we realise the quran is correct all along. That is what I make of it anyway :)
There is this one guy,a spammer named mike who needs to see this. He is a christian missionary working to make the islamic youth divert away from Islam. Even had a freaking Zoom call with me. Doesnt accept the truth.
maybe show him the contradictions in the bible, also its impossible to translation something from one language to another perfectly maning the divine bible doesnèt exist and the current bible was simply inspired from the original
@@amazingamx1255 I showed him. I literally showed him how the old testament *supported* child marriage and girl se x slaves,killing,looting,plundering. I showed him how the new testament clearly affirms the old testament. He just went,"No it doesnt,no it doesnt" and he didnt let the argument happen.
@@TheMuslimPerspective www.atheists.org/activism/resources/biblical-contradictions/ some people r just brainwashed and ignorant ask him why jesus would need to be sacrificed for god to forgive everyoneÉ is god not alpowerfulÉ if he is interested in being open minded and willing to learn then yea debate him if ur sure there's no hope just destroy him.(he worships a god who cant even preserve the language of his book, his god is regarded and has terrible memory for not remembering his own commandments etc)and use laughing emoji etc Remember that slavery and telling Christians to rape etc is subjective and he may see nothing wrong with it just like how we see nothing wrong with men having more rights over women and this makes feminists mad
@@amazingamx1255 We have more rights than women,because of course we work for it. Men need to work a hella lot more than women. Women go to heaven much easier.
@@TheMuslimPerspective Actually there’s a Sahih Hadith that states the majority of hell are ungrateful women. Sahih al-Bukhari 29 Narrated Ibn 'Abbas: The Prophet (ﷺ) said: "I was shown the Hell-fire and that the majority of its dwellers were women who were ungrateful." It was asked, "Do they disbelieve in Allah?" (or are they ungrateful to Allah?) He replied, "They are ungrateful to their husbands and are ungrateful for the favors and the good (charitable deeds) done to them. If you have always been good (benevolent) to one of them and then she sees something in you (not of her liking), she will say, 'I have never received any good from you." حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ اللَّهِ بْنُ مَسْلَمَةَ، عَنْ مَالِكٍ، عَنْ زَيْدِ بْنِ أَسْلَمَ، عَنْ عَطَاءِ بْنِ يَسَارٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ، قَالَ قَالَ النَّبِيُّ صلى الله عليه وسلم " أُرِيتُ النَّارَ فَإِذَا أَكْثَرُ أَهْلِهَا النِّسَاءُ يَكْفُرْنَ ". قِيلَ أَيَكْفُرْنَ بِاللَّهِ قَالَ " يَكْفُرْنَ الْعَشِيرَ، وَيَكْفُرْنَ الإِحْسَانَ، لَوْ أَحْسَنْتَ إِلَى إِحْدَاهُنَّ الدَّهْرَ ثُمَّ رَأَتْ مِنْكَ شَيْئًا قَالَتْ مَا رَأَيْتُ مِنْكَ خَيْرًا قَطُّ ". Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 29 In-book reference : Book 2, Hadith 22 USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 1, Book 2, Hadith Sunnah.com
The problem with the 1st interpretation is that the seminal vesicle is below the ribs and not "in between the ribs and the backbone" so it's out of the window. You literally have to draw a diagonal line from the bottom of the ribs to the bottom of the tailbone to get to the seminal vesicle. Even so, it's not the actual fluid that gives rise to a new human. That's the sperm and it is produced in the testes of a male after puberty, not in the embryonic stage so where the gonads originally were during pregnancy is irrelevant
the Arabic word “Yakhruju” means to emerge, to come out, to leave,to exit the arabic word “sulb” also mean loins… The loins is the area where one puts on their underwear….According to classical arabic dictionaries,the word “sulb” in the Arabic language includes the tailbone or coccyx. So you got a higher region when we included the tailbon or coccyx…And seminal vesicles are actually in the space between the tailbone or coccyx and the ribs..or between ribs and loins 70% of the ejaculatory fluid that contains sperm comes from the seminal vesicles..
this could still be correct as "between" the backbone and rib makes sense. same way as your head is between your shoulders. this might be a stretch tho but let me know what you think 🤔
Dr. Imran's explanation from EfDawah is actually really good. Read the Mohammad Asad translation of the Quran 86:5-7 LET MAN, then, observe out of what he has been created: (6) he has been created out of a seminal fluid (7) issuing from between the loins [of man] and the pelvic arch [of woman]. So the man is created from a gushing fluid coming from between the loins of man, and the pelvic arch of a woman, and together these fluids create a man.
"The Quran | Embryology and Semen Production From between the Backbone and the Ribs | Part 1" is the title of the video, watch in foundational thoughts channel.
Correct me if I am wrong sulb can also mean the loin. I am not making this up. In Surah 4 Ayah 23, in the long Ayah, the word aslabikum is used which is similar to sulb. All the mufassirun translated it as loin. Now according to the googled oxford dictionary loin means the part of the body on both sides of the spine between the lowest (false) ribs and the hipbones. So the Ayah makes complete sense in this regard. Hope this helps.
One thing that so many Christians get wrong about this verse is that they base it on their misunderstanding of definition of the English translation. When Allah refers to a MAN being created from a "GUSHING FLUID" proceeding from between the backbone and the ribs. Many Christians who deny Islam try to say this is a false statement. And the author of The Qur'an has no idea what they r referring to. Because scientifically, the male reproductive cell, spermatazoa, is produced n the testes. Not between the backbone and the ribs. But, due to their misunderstanding those same Christians, make an error by thinking the GUSHING FLUID is spermatazoa instead of SEMEN. SEMEN is the white fluid produced n the prostate, which is positioned n males BETWEEN OUR BACKBONE AND OUR RIBS. And when ejaculations happen SEMEN mixes with spermatazoa and other nutrients and comes out of the male sex gland. U also noticed the verse said where MAN being created from. MANKIND before we r born, r n the WOMBS of our mothers for approximately 9 months. The WOMBS of our mothers' r ALSO BETWEEN THEIR BACKBONE AND RIBS. So it goes to show u God Allah, The Unique Author of The Qur'an knew exactly what He was talking about. Even back n the 7th century, before microscopes, sonograms were invented
The miracle is that you listen to MH dribble a whole big pile of camel poo and think he is explaining it. When in reality he is speaking a lot of words with 0% truth. Really sad.
@@legal_solutions_india 1- the word in the Hadith is different than the word in the Quran one is talking about the vena cava the other is Aorta and it’s not even literal 2- there is no evidence of any slave being forced to be slept with and even if it was the case she is a war captive 3- you provided no reference please provide one 4 she’s a mother by breastfeeding that’s all she isn’t actually his mother 5- it was about they’re death the Quran makes it clear no one knows the hour
@@legal_solutions_india 1 please don’t teach me Arabic The word in the Quran is وتين the word in Hadith is ابهر and it’s not even literal lol Her father and brother actually forced her into marriage and when she objected they slapped her and they waged war on top of it there is no reason to believe she loved her family and she could of left the prophet pbuh if she wanted Provide me with the ayah The kid still doesn’t get inheritance from the mother so she’s just the mother in breastfeeding not the actual mother As for the Hadith it is known according to literally everybody that it’s meant for them in another Hadith different to this one the prophet Pbuh used the same analogy and it specifically says your hour
@@legal_solutions_india إِنْ يَعِشْ هَذَا لَمْ يُدْرِكْهُ الْهَرَمُ قَامَتْ عَلَيْكُمْ (سَاعَتُكُمْ ") Here is the Hadith of Aisha in Muslim the last word in brackets clearly says your hour specifically taking about the people of his time
I believe this verse reffers to Bone Marrow which is primarily located in the ribs, vertebrae, sternum, and bones of the pelvis and is responsible for creation of new red cells in the boody and therefore sustains life.
Are you good enough for The Almighty to let you into heaven? How many lies have you told, and what do you call someone who lies? Have you ever stolen something, and what do you call someone who steals? Have you ever taken God’s name in vain (very serious; in Old Testament times, the Jews wouldn’t even say the name of God for fear of blasphemy) - even ‘OMG’? One more: Jesus said whoever looks at a woman to lust after her has already committed adultery in his heart; have you ever looked with lust? Well I’m not judging you - but if you’ve done these things then you’re a liar, thief, blasphemer and adulterer-at-heart; that’s how seriously God takes sin. He is Holy (perfectly good/righteous and separate from sin) which means that He is perfect in justice - and if He were to judge you by the moral law (we’ve already looked at 4 commandments) would you be innocent or guilty? Heaven or Hell? The answer is hell - the wrath of God upon you for your sin. Is that concerning? But fortunately, God’s will is not that you perish. He wants all men everywhere to be saved. So do you know what He did for us guilty sinners? In self-giving mercy, He sent His Son Jesus Christ. He lived the perfect life that we should have lived - tempted at all points and yet He NEVER sinned. Through His life, being in very nature God, He revealed God to men; but we in our hatred condemned Him to death. On that cross as Jesus suffered, He took on the sin of the world and was judged in our place; receiving God’s wrath. You and I broke God’s law, but Jesus paid the fine. God can justly forgive us. On that cross He died, then He was buried, but 3 days later He was raised from the dead - conquering death and Hell and ushering in The Kingdom of God. He then ascended to the right hand of God the Father (where He came from) now Lord of the living and the dead. God has fixed a date when He will judge the world in righteousness - Jesus us coming back. What you need to do is repent (In humility, acknowledge your sin before God and turn to a relationship with Him) and trust ALONE in Jesus Christ and His work on the cross; and God will grant you the gift of the Holy Spirit. Then be baptised. When you place your trust in Jesus - the Lord and Saviour - these things will happen: 1) God will forgive the sins that you have committed; they were paid for by Jesus at the cross. 2) The perfect life that Jesus lived will be credited to you. He will find you holy and blameless on judgement day (and now), as Christ’s righteousness covers you. 3) You receive a place in Christ’s kingdom as an adopted child of God. God becomes your Father. Eternal life isn’t just about living forever, but a personal relationship with God Himself. That life can start now; The Father will reveal Himself to you if you seek Him. 4) God doesn’t just save you from the penalty of your sin (Hell). He can save you from the power of sin itself. Whoever practices sin is a slave of sin; but when you repent and believe the gospel [WHICH HAS BEEN DESCRIBED] the Holy Spirit comes to dwell in you and sanctify you (working in you to further abandon sin and turn to the will of God). When the end of the age comes, and eternity begins, this work will be brought to completion as you are finally freed from the presence of sin. Jesus offers to take away your sin and to give you His righteousness; you must receive it by faith. Choose this day if you will align with the world, or with Jesus and His kingdom - only His is eternal. ROMANS 10:9 - If you confess with your mouth Jesus as Lord and believe in your heart that God raised Him from the dead, you will be saved.
@Ca So Are you good enough for The Almighty to let you into heaven? How many lies have you told, and what do you call someone who lies? Have you ever stolen something, and what do you call someone who steals? Have you ever taken God’s name in vain (very serious; in Old Testament times, the Jews wouldn’t even say the name of God for fear of blasphemy) - even ‘OMG’? One more: Jesus said whoever looks at a woman to lust after her has already committed adultery in his heart; have you ever looked with lust? Well I’m not judging you - but if you’ve done these things then you’re a liar, thief, blasphemer and adulterer-at-heart; that’s how seriously God takes sin. He is Holy (perfectly good/righteous and separate from sin) which means that He is perfect in justice - and if He were to judge you by the moral law (we’ve already looked at 4 commandments) would you be innocent or guilty? Heaven or Hell? The answer is hell - the wrath of God upon you for your sin. Is that concerning? But fortunately, God’s will is not that you perish. He wants all men everywhere to be saved. So do you know what He did for us guilty sinners? In self-giving mercy, He sent His Son Jesus Christ. He lived the perfect life that we should have lived - tempted at all points and yet He NEVER sinned. Through His life, being in very nature God, He revealed God to men; but we in our hatred condemned Him to death. On that cross as Jesus suffered, He took on the sin of the world and was judged in our place; receiving God’s wrath. You and I broke God’s law, but Jesus paid the fine. God can justly forgive us. On that cross He died, then He was buried, but 3 days later He was raised from the dead - conquering death and Hell and ushering in The Kingdom of God. He then ascended to the right hand of God the Father (where He came from) now Lord of the living and the dead. God has fixed a date when He will judge the world in righteousness - Jesus us coming back. What you need to do is repent (In humility, acknowledge your sin before God and turn to a relationship with Him) and trust ALONE in Jesus Christ and His work on the cross; and God will grant you the gift of the Holy Spirit. Then be baptised. When you place your trust in Jesus - the Lord and Saviour - these things will happen: 1) God will forgive the sins that you have committed; they were paid for by Jesus at the cross. 2) The perfect life that Jesus lived will be credited to you. He will find you holy and blameless on judgement day (and now), as Christ’s righteousness covers you. 3) You receive a place in Christ’s kingdom as an adopted child of God. God becomes your Father. Eternal life isn’t just about living forever, but a personal relationship with God Himself. That life can start now; The Father will reveal Himself to you if you seek Him. 4) God doesn’t just save you from the penalty of your sin (Hell). He can save you from the power of sin itself. Whoever practices sin is a slave of sin; but when you repent and believe the gospel [WHICH HAS BEEN DESCRIBED] the Holy Spirit comes to dwell in you and sanctify you (working in you to further abandon sin and turn to the will of God). When the end of the age comes, and eternity begins, this work will be brought to completion as you are finally freed from the presence of sin. Jesus offers to take away your sin and to give you His righteousness; you must receive it by faith. Choose this day if you will align with the world, or with Jesus and His kingdom - only His is eternal. ROMANS 10:9 - If you confess with your mouth Jesus as Lord and believe in your heart that God raised Him from the dead, you will be saved.
You can search for every thing that he says and see what the scholars of islam said about these topics. We believe that our religion is the right religion for a reason rather than just accepting this life of eat play sleep repeat. May Allah guid you to Islam
Its talking about babies emerging from women's bellies. It's not rocket science. Translations were based on assumptions that it was talking about sperm but the context proves that it was referring to a human being born. If I say: "Paul was walking with his baby. He was so cute with his pacifier." It's only the context that tells you that the second phrase refers to the baby. We should use this principle to translate this verse.
This is actually the best answer you Muslims could possibly give. For me it’s a clear error. But to cover this blatant error this answer is the best you can give and survive yet again.
I see that this is the logical answer, because I know Arabic and I see, according to the verse, that it means the Human who emerges from his mother’s womb
@@JamieMoore-el7ubno one’s covering this Classical scholar Qurtubi and Ibn Attiya had this view who came way before the development of modern science …Are you gonna say that They made up an excuse too??
@@mohammadrazzaqgulabkhan9639 😅 ji bhai zaroor in Shaa Allah , asal mei abhi Hamare College ke Unit tests etc shuru hain aur mujhe Kuch books bhi padhna complete karna hai , isliye Instagram se break le liya , Instagram bahot Time zaaye kar deta hai , aapki hawsla afzahi ke liye shukriya bhai , jazaak Allahu khairan
The MOST IMPORTANT thing is not which interpretation is correct. The most important thing that every muslim and critic must know is THIS It is He who sent down upon thee the Book, wherein are verses clear that are the Essence of the Book, and others ambiguous. As for those in whose hearts is swerving, they follow the ambiguous part, desiring dissension, and desiring its interpretation; and none knows its interpretation, save only God. And those firmly rooted in knowledge say, 'We believe in it; all is from our Lord'; yet none remembers, but men possessed of minds. Quran 3: 7
Sulb - Can it be translated as "Solids" i.e rocks under the ground or the ground itself? Tara'ib - Can it be understood as a collection of "Turab" - Sand/dirt? I.e, mankind created from water that comes out from between the earth, and not the ribs?
Assalam U Alaikum brothers and sisters, in my view Allah SWT has talked of the reflection of man upon himself so that he could know what is his true status. In the context of the following verse, Allah then tells man of what is he created from. Allah says he is created from a gushing fluid. Now here, no mention of word semen nor egg is used rather a combined word is used for the fluid from which man comes Finally the last verse isn’t the explanation of the preceding verse rather it is talking of man as to where he was and from where he came i.e from between the backbone and the ribs. And that refers to pregnancy and consequent events
@@snahmda yeah I remember reading that a while back I will have a look I will probs add it in the description of my RUclips video. I have one coming out today if your interested. ruclips.net/channel/UCKtCxYXlBYBmEwYBFDKXwPw It will be on Muhammad pbuh prophethood 25 mins. InshAllah it will be out in the next 45 mins
I think Allah was referring to what scientists call "spinal ejaculation", as quoted by the National Institute of Health: "Ejaculation is a reflex mediated by a spinal control center, referred to as a spinal ejaculation generator. During intercourse, the spinal ejaculation generator integrates the sensory inputs that are necessary to trigger ejaculation." Knowing that the vertebral column (backbone) is a protective layer for the spinal cord, we can deduce that Allah was referring to the spinal cord which is therefore located between the ribs and the backbone. When Allah mentions that the fluid is emitted between the backbone and the ribs, he is talking about the spinal cord which triggers ejaculation during the intercourse
While the third opinion makes sense Dr Zakir Naiks view is also perfectly legitimate. It can be talking about gon...adal ridge which is the origin of male tract During the third week of gestation, primordial germ cells arise in the yolk sac and migrate from along the dorsal mesentery to populate the gon# adal ridges located in the lower thoracic and upper lumbar levels. (Source : Embryology of the Genitourinary Tract Alan W. Partin MD, PhD, in Campbell-Walsh-Wein Urology, 2021) Please don't get confused between spe# rmatogenesis (which involves only the test# is) and eja# culation which involves other male organs as well. If God said the fluid came from t...estis it would only be partially correct as it is only one organ involved. Instead of making it a science class God covers all parts responsible for the fluid (eja# culation) with two simple words.
I agree, also the Arabic says "yakhruj" which means exit not originate so the rational understanding of this verse is childbirth not the formation of sperm or zygote.
The ambiguity and everyone’s confusion makes me remember a verse in the Quran.. Surah 3:7. He it is Who has sent down to thee the Book: In it are verses basic or fundamental (of established meaning); they are the foundation of the Book: others are allegorical. But those in whose hearts is perversity follow the part thereof that is allegorical, seeking discord, and searching for its hidden meanings, but no one knows its hidden meanings except Allah. And those who are firmly grounded in knowledge say: "We believe in the Book; the whole of it is from our Lord:" and none will grasp the Message except men of understanding.
So why send a book that only Allah knows the meaning? It defeats the purpose for which it was revealed in the first place isn’t it? If you think about it, you will see I am right. You are blinded by lies and deceit and that is why you are refusing to admit what was stated plainly and confidently has to be reinterpreted to fit the science.
@@steamerSama The point is to test future readers through imprecise verses as Surah 3:7 implies. Anyway the confusion only happened because of some classical Muslim commentators saying that the verse is talking about semen. But as medieval Arabic scholar ibn-Atyyia (not an apologist and not aware of any criticism) made a commentary on the verse in al-Muharar al-Wajiz he said that the verse could be talking about either the man or the fluid. And if you check the verses after it continues talking about the man so it makes more sense to say that the verse is referring to man coming out of the body not the fluid and god will bring him back (ie. resurrection of man not bringing the semen back it doesn't make sense).
I think it’s read akin to, “So let humankind reflect on how they were created. Humans were created from a fluid that is forcefully released, emerging from between the man’s backbone and the woman’s nurturing place, the womb.” interpreting “الصُّلْبِ (as-sulb)” as “steel” or “backbone”, symbolizing rigidity, and “التَّرَائِبِ (al-tara'ib)” as “soil” or soft tissue. Al-Juhani links التَّرَائِبِ to the female reproductive system based on classical Arabic roots, which can mean dust or soil, tying to fertility and reproduction.
Good job brother. I'm inclined to agree with the 3rd opinion because Allah swt is chastising the human being for thinking he is so grand and great, he was created from a gushing liquid and he came from between the backbone and ribs (womb) of another person.
1) The verse refers to fluid and not sperm, and the fluid comes from between the backbone or loins and the ribs. Even if the Qur’ān were referring to sperm, the sperm is created in the testes which are located between the loins and the ribs. 2) The verse refers to the baby emerging from the mother’s womb, which is located between the backbone or loins and the ribs. 3) The verse refers to the man and woman engaged in sexual intercourse, by which the ejaculatory fluid is issued between them during intercourse.
In embryology, the testicles are generated from tissue that lies in the abdomen, and then descend during puberty. So it’s another view that can be taken.
I am not a scholar. But I can see a much simpler explanation for these verses. It is much simpler than all three explanations. When Quran say that humans are created from X, it can mean three different things. 1. Originally Adam (AS) was created from X when humans were first created. This is my understanding of "salsalin kalfakhar" (صَلْصَالٍ كَالْفَخَّارِ) in Quran 55:14. 2. When a person is born, he is made from X or made up of X. This is clear interpretation of maain maheen (مَّاءٍ مَّهِينٍ) in Quran 32:8 3. At present human beings are made up of X. I think of maain daafiq (مَّاءٍ دَافِقٍ) in Quran 86:6 in this term. This verse is referring to blood. It is pumped from heart. Heart is located right between "salb" and "taraib" for both men and women. If there is any mistake in my analysis, I would humbly request you to correct me.
But the translation says created from. Right? 🤔if it's blood then it should be created of. Right? I felt like the explanation in the vedio is more satisfactory😅
If god is so powerful why should we humans needs to argue about this stuff, everything should be flawless. Why do I need to know different meanings of words etc. make no sense
Because God gives us enough information when it's important and enough ambiguous stood for those who want to hate, to hate. You must learn this verse: It is He who sent down upon thee the Book, wherein are verses clear that are the Essence of the Book, and others ambiguous. As for those in whose hearts is swerving, they follow the ambiguous part, desiring dissension, and desiring its interpretation; and none knows its interpretation, save only God. And those firmly rooted in knowledge say, 'We believe in it; all is from our Lord'; yet none remembers, but men possessed of minds. Quran 3: 7
@@moiez0192 what convinced you is your issue God judgment of you is something you should think about, if you are wise. But it sounds like you are stuck in hate /anger mode. That disables your rational mind. Lose the emotion, and learn about things openly, bravely and with sincerity. It's for your own benefit.
@@think-islam-channel mate learn how when you know so much than a average person and have high iq than a average person. I don’t understand how are you not critical. Maybe you don’t know enough like me
fluid emitted refers to the semen, and it comes out from in between the sulb and the tara’ib. However, the truth of the matter is that the word ‘tarai’b’-according to the Arabic-is actually referring to a female body part. Much like the English word ‘penis’ can only be ascribed to a male, the word ‘tara’ib’ can only be applied to a female. This is not apologetic modernism or revisionism; the classical works of Quranic commentary throughout the last 1400 years confirm this view categorically. In other words, the sulb belongs to the male, and the tara’ib belongs to the female. This is the view of the Muslims since the last fourteen hundred years, and there is consensus (ijma) on this matter, since the time of the Sahabah (the Prophet’s disciples) until today. Shaykh `Abd al-Wahhâb al-Turayrî of IslamToday.com writes: The phrase “mâ’ dâfiq” (emitted fluid) is not restricted in meaning to sperm but is used in Arabic for both the sperm and the egg. Ibn Kathîr, in his commentary on this verse, writes: “It emanates from the man and the woman, and with Allah’s permission, the child comes forth as a product of both.” …The words translated as “backbone” (sulb) and “ribs” (tarâ’ib) are not understood in Arabic to belong to the same person. Arabs understand the “sulb” to refer to a part of the male body and the “tarâ’ib” to a part of the female. Ibn Kathîr states: “It refers to the ‘sulb’ of the man and the ‘tarâ’ib’ of the woman…” He then quotes this interpretation on the authority of the Prophet’s companion Ibn `Abbâs. This same understanding is given in all the major classical works of Qur’anic commentary. Many non-Arabs misinterpret this verse because they think that sulb and tara’ib refer to different body parts of the male. In reality, tara’ib is feminine, and refers to the female’s body part. For fourteen hundred years, all of the scholars have held this belief, and not a single classical scholar has ever differed on this point. The reason is that the Arabic makes it clear that tara’ib refers to a feminine body part, and not a male one.
so some magical invisible liquid is secreted when they copulate? I don't understand what you're clarifying? or maybe you are casting aspersions on the Quran?🤔
You forgot to mention the next verse which confirms that it can only refer to the first noun which is man 86:8 "Verily, (Allâh) is Able to bring ""him"" back (to life)! 86:10 "Then ""he"" will have no power, nor any helper." So the "He" in the next verse could only refer back to the first noun which is the Man likewise that verse talks about the man and where he comes from not the fluid itself..
If you draw an imaginary line between the end of the back bone (coccyx) and the bottom of of the ribs in 3D you’d most likely intersect midway from front and back of the body around adrenal glands (just above the kidneys). The hormonal role of the adrenals is well known and who is to say that the adrenals are not also involved in fertility in both male and female? This is yet a 4th plausible explanation in addition to 3rd explanation mentioned by another medic above as it’s precisely describing the area from where the testes originate & descend from.
It’s like the critics don’t know people or even creatures had testicles back then. 16 year old I heard of who fell on a fence and tore his testicles, and guess what spewed. Clearly no one has ever torn testicles throughout the history of mankind until this kid. Not even those of animals which many considered edible.
@@Akhi_Umar 🙄🙄akhi in Egyptian Arabic the word insan means human if we remove the n then it means to forget so In Arabic insan is written انسان and means person. I believe it has the same root as Hebrew anashim אנשים which means people. This makes it an ancient Semitic word.
@@Akhi_Umar so the Arabic word for human is insan which is derived from word uns which means love and also branch from the word nasiya which means to forget so use your brain we human die this world forget him within weak they get busy with their work so see don't waste your time do worship of Allahswt and make yourself obedient to Allahswt
These are pretty wild excuses. Basically all three options require the same massive stretch: that "between the backbone in the ribs" refers not to the chest area (you know, the part that has the backbone in the back and ribs in the front and sides), but to the area below the ribs, down to the tailbone. How anyone can say this with a straight face I don't know but here we are.
Quran describes the gushing water in the point of view from up down-looking from top head to bottom feet.Just look how the first verse of Surah At Tarik begins with a star then verse 4 says "There is no human being but has a protector over him" so its says "over him" then again it returns back to sky and in verse 11 says: By the sky which sends back. So, Quranic point of view about gushing water is from top to bottom, looking in vertical line, same as other verses i wrote above.And, when you look to male skeleton system from up to down you see that the ejaculating organs is exatly in between the backbone and the ribs.
That doesn't make sense . The backbone and ribs don't have seperate beginnings. Ribs end at a point in between . So what comes in between the ribs and backbone would be the the lungs the diaphragm etc . Even seminal vesicles or ovaries are further down . Also the origin of man is not from seminal vesicles . The cells responsible for life is the spermatozoa which comes from the testes .
Thanks for sharing the video. How about other meaning of اخراج I think it has meaning of direction or production as well. For example in Arabic movies they say اخراج for production or director. And role of sympathetic nervous system which are emerging from thoracic and lumber region and causes ejaculation. والله اعلم😊
Sura At Tariq 86:5,6,7 Let the human being reflect that from what he has been created. He is created from a drop which is emitted from a space between the backbone and the ribs
Interesting interpretations, but why rely on the opinion of 'classical' tafseer? The Arabic language has beeb preserved for all eternity. The word 'sulb' refers to the male sexual parts. Are we seriously saying arabs didn't have a word for male genitalia ? The word 'taraai'b' refers to the FEMALE pelvic arch area, a rare expression. So in Surah 86 verse 7 '.yakhrojo min baynis salbi wataraaib..' is the Qur'aanic way of putting in the most polite terms that life has to start with the union of the sexual area of a man and the sexual area of a woman. Note the grammatical construction 'min bayna' is used in the Qur'aan several times. When it comes to human reproduction in the Qur'aan, all the different verses have to be read together to get a clear picture. I still think Dr Maurice Bucaille did the best job in explaning this.
We need an interpration because of the richness of the Arabic language. the meanings of the Arabic words changes with the speech, harakah, and position. 1 word has more than 100 meanings.
@@ayada8884that not the definition of a rich language A rich language is a language where 1 word doesnt have many meaning But 1 concept can be described by many words For example sand, there are many words to descube it in arabic English is a poor language because 1 word can have many meaning It is poor because it do not have many words . So compared to english, Arabic can not really be interpreted differently unless you force it to be so, unless you want to push a narrative
Testicles only produce sperm, the sperm itself needs a fluid to swim in, the seminal vesicle which is near the prostate creates the actual fluid that makes up semen, and it is located in between the rib and the vertabrate direct under.
In between backbone and ribs also make senses. In our biology book it is written that sperm is originated from a gland in the pelvis which is in kidney and kidney is located in between backbone and ribs. So alhamduillah there's no wrong.
Lolllllllllllllllll Then if you take then testcles are between head and feet Heart and knees Eyes and feet Quran tells it is frem backbone Not bw backbone and ribs Stop being a stupid
This guy is clutching to straws 😂 what the hell is he on about? In the 7th century they didn’t know certain things and that’s why it’s wrong in the Quran
@@TheQuranExplainsItself if Allah is going through the trouble to talk about biology (how man is created), at least it can be correct. It is necessary for god all knowing to be right
I’d rather go with the explanation of the “backbone and ribs” of the women, for a simple reason. The words that are used by Allah to address those places that are shameful for us to express literally wouldn’t be more respectfully said rather than this way.
فَلْيَنظُرِ ٱلْإِنسَـٰنُ مِمَّ خُلِقَ Let people then consider what they were created from خُلِقَ مِن مَّآءٍۢ دَافِقٍۢ They (i.e. Human beings) were created from a spurting fluid (i.e. Sperms) يَخْرُجُ مِنۢ بَيْنِ ٱلصُّلْبِ وَٱلتَّرَآئِبِ *stemming* from between the backbone and the ribcage Simply, Here Muhammed Hijab is explaining that stemming from between the backbone and the ribcage is not referring to the Spurting fluid but the human being. You can read the interpretation that way.
In 86:5-7 Al-insan refers to both men and women. The two body parts also refer to either of them. Sulb and tara'ib, of the male and of the female origins of ma'in, or fluid.
You don’t appear convinced. Couldn’t Allah be clear in his message so you don’t have to do these mental acrobatics to find an explanation for the text?
He could but he deliberately v wasn't as with many verses in the Qur'an. This is to give haters (perhaps like you?) the full freedom to reject Islam if it does their biases . The most important verse for any critic who wants to study the Qur'an with honesty should read and ponder very deeply on is this: It is He who sent down upon thee the Book, wherein are verses clear that are the Essence of the Book, and others ambiguous. As for those in whose hearts is swerving, they follow the ambiguous part, desiring dissension, and desiring its interpretation; and none knows its interpretation, save only God. And those firmly rooted in knowledge say, 'We believe in it; all is from our Lord'; yet none remembers, but men possessed of minds. Quran 3: 7
@@sipkestorm4050 You focused on the least impetus part of the post? You're bias is blinding. Which proves you are a hater. In that case the warnings in the Quran for those like you is something you should investigate. Getting angry and full of indignation is not going to avert God's judgment on you
THANK YOU SIR! OMFG they are stretching something out so much that it starts to sound insane. Funny thing is that classical interpretations of this verse by early muslims like Ibn Kathir say none of this hogwash. Ibn Kathir says: gushing fluid from the backbone of man and ribs of women. These early muslims did not have the agenda or the need to twist a verse to fit science
My question is this : Let us assume Quran was written by some man, then why would such a statement exist in the quran since everyone even then could see from where the semen is ejected.
However you try to spin it the quran is wrong. You talk about the coccyx but the ribs are much higher, the quran description is scientifically wrong, thats just a fact or truth
You could explain this by specific diagrams. I think better reupload with pictures and diagrams. It would be understandable. Also please talk slowly . It would be good.
Oh , boy, it is sooooo clear that he is trying so hard to make it look like it is not what is so clearly stated in the Qur'an that is super cringy , He basically said : the qur'an says it comes from the backbone , and we are talking about sperm , and he keeps saying sperm comes from inside the women ?? Is he demented ???
The real miraculous nature of these verses comes from the fact that they are multilayered and timeless. Meaning at any point in time it would match the current understanding of this portion of biology. But go ahead and keep telling yourself an illiterate man in the 6 century made it up. The rejection of Islam is so blatantly built on nonsensical hatred and intentional ignorance.
I was wondering why so many anti MH comments and comments attacking Hijab's desperate attempt to cover up an obvious mistake in the Qur'an were being posted and just realised it's not his channel. The coward Hijab can't remove all the comments calling out his lies like he normally does on his own channel.
@@mahadism7455 Oh the irony. You are accusing me of something that your boy Hijab has beem guilty of for years. He's the one deleting any counter arguments to his videos on his channel. I have had so many posts removed/not posted due to his over zealous moderating and so have many others. As an experiment I then posted posts agreeing with his videos and bang, they miraculously appear. In light of that, the fact that you accused me of not putting up an argument is truly laughable.
@@alanwright3716 its not Ironic, hijab can do whatever he likes with his comment section, if you want to respond to him you’re always free to make your own videos or find him in person and stick a camera in his face like he does every sunday with random people. You know what the Odd thing is, this channel dosen’t belong to hijab so the comments aren’t being moderated and I haven’t seen not a single substance’d response to hijab... only insults. So maybe he was correct in banishing you all from his comment section. You commented twice and you still haven’t responded to what he said btw
@@mahadism7455 You are missing the point. I don't have any interest in engaging with Muslims about this teaching. I have pretty much stopped discussing theology with Muslims as I feel it's pointless. These arguments just go around in circles and end up going nowhere. My post was to simply highlight my amazement that I have been seeing Hijab's views being attacked. I never once saw this on his channel and we know why that was. I just wanted to highlight his cowardly stance on blocking opposing viewpoints.
@@alanwright3716 lol I knew you didn’t have anything to offer😂 And how cowardly of him! He actually debates EDUCATED people in-front of audiences and allows anyone to literally stick a camera in his face and question his views. YES thats very cowardly 😂 This comment section is just confirmation that hijab was right, you lot have nothing to offer you just want to insult him on his channel.
![Gucci Mane & Sexyy Red - You Don't Love Me [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/j7IBqyFKT4c/mqdefault.jpg)
When we are saying "this is a classic interpretation" it is very important because those scholars were not influenced by these new ideas.
May Allah guide u towards the light.. I wish u would had studied well so that u wouldn't be in that much darkness..
Ive seen all kinds of answers that does not really answer this question, I honestly am the only one that have answered this question in my content section
@@legal_solutions_india you think Jesus wasnt a troublemaker? LoL then you don't know the Gospel 🤣🤣
@@legal_solutions_india well you're a fool for criticizing someone for their works, when you know that Salvation does not come from any man's works or yours. You're too Ignorant about scripture to say you have the right Gospel, you actually Worship a man, have you even thought about Christianity actually worshiping the Antichrist, that man isnt even Jesus, its Cesare Borgia. So watch your mouth about your Judgements, and give it a sincere thought. I was already a Christian, and i know a lot about Christianity, including the foolishness of speaking in tongues. Its all the work of a devil, the Antichrist.
Revelation 13:14 (NLT)
14 And with all the miracles he was allowed to perform on behalf of the first beast, *he DECEIVED all the people* who belong to this world. He ordered the people to make a *GREAT STATUE of the first BEAST, WHO WAS FATALLY WOUNDED AND THEN CAME BACK TO LIFE*
WAKE UP. COME BACK TO GOD
@@legal_solutions_india youre not Christian but you dont know the Bible enough to slander, judge without eye witness, the 9th commandment is not to bear false witness, you only read about this man. Do you understand what a false prophet is in Matthew 24:24? it is someone who performs miracles to deceive the elect into converting to the false religion.
Do you know what repent means, the very act of repenting is to cease your evil actions and convert to God's religion.
You think you are safe from the fire's of Hell? With all the slander you have said about a Prophet of God? I know both sides of this war, and I know everything Biblical about Islam, the Bible doesn't say the world is ignorant and hates God's people for no reason. If you think your safe, then find out, if you wish to receive Mercy then do yourself a favor, not me, not people, do yourself a favor and ask for Mercy from the One that can burn your Soul for Eternity. If you dont believe in God, go watch some of these Christians being possessed in Churches speaking in tongues rolling on the floor laughing. All God's work to show you what's right or wrong. Stop slandering a prophet, better yet, stop slandering people that you only read about, there is a real tyrant in the world and he has sex slaves too, he is in N. Korea but I dont see you doing anything about that oppression. Mark my words, This is your warning. If you had an ounce of intelligence you would be sincere in your search, if you want help watch my content anonymously.
One advise to you @Sapience Institute, please illustrate your upcoming video explanations with diagrams, pictures, animation if possible for us to relate to what is explained, it would be much easier to follow this way. Keep up the good work and all the best.
I totally agree
We have now the audio maybe someone can make afterwards in Shaa Allah
@@anoniem012 Free Quran Education does great animation. They even have a science RUclips channel
but then the mental contortions will be very obvious
The irony is that every testicles literally originate from between backbone and ribs.. but not every testicles descend inside the scrotum / pelvic.
As a doctor i don't have a problem with that. Rather, for me personally, this verse is truly miraculous. It truly has a multi layered and very deep meanings
and also the baby emerges from between the backbone and the ribs during delivery we all know of Shelving and the relief the mother feels a few days before delivery.
That's very true
@@kanizfatima1377 I;m a let you in on somewhat of an uncommon piece of information.
the Uterus moves through the peritoneum in a unique manner when gravid.
it adjusts the other organs around
Honestly i have no clue why this verse was an issue, since well bones in the past never had names i guess
@@kautharlukman5218 I am not an expert on sperm production, but I don't think the van deference goes up all the way to the ribs ruclips.net/video/zzRydwGWeho/видео.html. And the Quran says ejected in sura 86verse 6. Even if it is true that testicles originate from the backbone and the ribs the Quran is still appears to be wrong because we know that sperm production happens at puberty not birth. quran.com/86
Thank you, this actually makes sense. I've read some wishy-washy explanations before which didn't convince me. I didn't doubt the Quran, just thought that there was some part of the creation of a human which science didn't know about.
But it's not really hard, especially the third explanation.
Jazakallahu khairan
Add kheyran
How
The originate and formation of testis or ovaries in womb isfrom the space which is present in between the backbone and ribs
It later on descends in the scrotum
No doubt that quran from Allah swt❤❤
😂
The verse literally don't mention any sperm @@prasannakumar5140
Third one is new to me and it makes sense. I used understand this verse in a different way. There is a thing called "descent of testis".Formation of Testis initially stars between t10 and t12 spine and that place is exactly "between backbone and ribs". When a boy becomes 9 months old the testis descents into scrotum.
So testis was formed between backbone and ribs and from from testis sperms come.
Allah knows best.
When someone talks about ejected fluid, they might be talking about adult testes because talking about fetal testes at that time would be redundant, imo third option might be the way, in any case Allah knows best
@@goldsaint7 Yeah it could be but whatever it is it's not an invalid verse as there are correct interpretations for it.
Allah knows best what it actually means.
@@_faiyaz_moni_7010 i think that the length of ductus defferens vas defferent is 35-40 cm which is the exact length of the distance from loins to ribs. Maybe
My opinion is that no book from god could possibly be so demonstrably unclear. Hundreds of vague, nonsense verses.
@@JamieMoore-el7ub "He is the One Who has revealed to you ˹O Prophet˺ the Book, of which some verses are precise-they are the foundation of the Book-while others are elusive.1 Those with deviant hearts follow the elusive verses seeking ˹to spread˺ doubt through their ˹false˺ interpretations-but none grasps their ˹full˺ meaning except Allah. As for those well-grounded in knowledge, they say, “We believe in this ˹Quran˺-it is all from our Lord.” But none will be mindful ˹of this˺ except people of reason."[3:7]
Still people who don't know anything about arabic grammar deny this. Subhan Allah
That.s why islam is only for arabic speaking people...right?
Sulb means hard,strong,rigid, stiff,tough,robust,sturdy or hardy.
Sulb : hardest of the stones
Sulb (singular) : sacrum bone (holy bone) because sacrum bone is hardest of the bones
Sacrum is wedge-shaped triangular bone at the base of the vertebral column. It is largest and the densest bone
of the vertebral column, and slowest to decay after death.
Taraaib (plural) : Pairs of organs
Al-taraaib is derived from turab meaning dust grains. In the sense that dust grains are equal.
In the dictionary , Al-taraaib is used to refer to the body parts which are in pairs.
Pairs of eyes, hands and legs together referred as a “taraaib”
Ribs come in pair. Right and left sides of each pair are exactly the same so pairs of ribs is referred as a “taraaib”.
There are two hip bones, one on the left side of the body and other on the right. Each hip bone is made of three bones, the illium,pubis and ischium.
So here pairs of illium,pubis and ischium bones can be referred to as “taraaib”
Area between the sacrum bone and Pairs of hip bones together is known as pelvis
The prostate and the seminal vesicles produce fluid that nourishes the sperm. This fluid provides most of the volume of semen, the fluid in which the sperm is expelled during ejaculation. Other fluid that makes up a very small amount of the semen comes from the vas deferens and from Cowper glands in the urethra. All this organs are located in the pelvis cavity.
He was created from a fluid comes out from between the sacrum bone and Pairs of hip bones. 86:6-7
honestly the best interpretation ive heard but dont the pelvic bones fuse later in development making taraib not applicable?
@@arrivederciheheeeeee5809 fused bones of hip are still identified individually as the ilium, ischium, and pubis.
@@saidali5676 ok 👀
@@saidali5676 but brother one may argue that man is not created from The semen,rather he is created from the sperm
the sperm takes a vital role in Human reproduction(formation of zygote)....But not the semen…the other fluids allow the sperm to reach its journey,but they do not play a vital role in the formation of zygote
These verses are deeply layered with deep meanings...
Vague statements
@chagzyahya😂😂😂
No...they're just incorrect and these ridiculous Muslims have to make up nonsense interpretation to correct them. Very sad
@@raditz4583that’s the whole point. Sureh imran verse 7
“Some of its verses are absolutely clear and lucid, and these are the core of the Book. Others are ambiguous. Those in whose hearts there is perversity, always go about the part which is ambiguous, seeking mischief and seeking to arrive at its meaning arbitrarily, although none knows their true meaning except Allah.”
This is a miraculous verse
Yes it teaches embryology, anatomy and physiology...3 things at the same time..
SubhanAllah...this is the creation of ALLAH
Teaches them wrong
@@amaarmustafa2309 there is zero scientific miracles in the Quran god all muslims make the same boring npc arguments
@redfordkobayashi6936 i think u need remove communism from ur eyes..
And btw..
The word Qur'an itself means - to read, to recite.
So u might wanna do..what it says
You fanatic fools
If you read surah tariq no were in that whole surah sperm is mentioned, it says ما which means water. The anti islam had to put their own words to try to proof their mistaken point. That just shows the highest degree of inconsistency and insecurity.
Islam is superior and nothing can surpass.!!!!!!
So human beings are made by water from between the backbone and ribs?
Also you do realize that nearly every translation of that verse is made by muslims?
@@hasanal-hussein7079 human beings are created from water yes. And before the sperm produces, it is water coming from your back down to your testicles
@@ciismanakh9707 humans aren't created from the water, they are created from sperm, water in the semen helps make the sperm enter the female but the sperm is the only part that creates life
@@ok-sw3st lool hide yourself, human are created from water,you idiot
@@ciismanakh9707 we are made of water but not created from water itself, water itself can't creat life. sperm is what creates life when it is fertalized
I would also like to input that from a medical perspective the hormones a man produces to undertake spermatogenesis originate from the adrenal cortex, which is directly between the ribs and the spine, just under the last rib and above the kidney. I've always understood that this is what Allah is referring to in the origination of the fluid being created is from the adrenal glands which produce most of the sex hormones.
Furthermore the testes and the ovaries originate embryologically from just beneath the kidneys and then migrate down (due to the gubernaculum) to their positions in male and females. And so again the origination of the sperms and ovaries is from directly between the last rib and the spine in the location specified by Allah.
It's actually more than that. A man who has no backbone is not regarded by woman. You will see such effeminate men having no backbone getting to an age where they even stick out their backbone. You take the percentage of backbone in a woman, compared to the rest of her body. We don't need rapist doctors ripping out women's bits to find out about this. It was clear and obvious. No one calls the backbone of a man his coccyx. No one sees the coccyx, that's hidden.
@Mo Khattak the information above is in the public domain
Isn't it kind of strange that the way things like this are written in the Quran sound exactly as how one would expect humans would understand these things 1400 years ago plus depends hugely on how you interpret the verses? If this is truly written by an all mighty god and a miracle why isn't this explained spot on in detail without any interpretation needed so one could not even disagree? How can it be that we today can explain these things much better than an all knowing god? Doesn't it make more sense that this simply is another human made book like ALL books are?
@Mo Khattak med student, inshallah soon to be doctor so please do dua for me to pass my exams inshallah
@@bustinjieber2673 I think the whole point is that it is actually explained clearly and in sublime detail that even we cannot understand without years of research.
The way I see it is if you have proved an empirical fact in science and it contradicts the Quran, it is because you have misunderstood what you thought you had read. And then when we go back to read the quran with the new information we have learned we can reinterpret it and realise that the quran was right all along and we were the ones who didn't realise.
In this example specifically, scientists discover and understand the embryology of the gonads and the sexual hormones origin - and then go back to the quran with new knowledge and reinterpret this verse and realise how it is correct on a deeper level.
Allah doesn't need to go into any further detail because the people at the time would then disagree with the statement because they don't know yet the science behind things. Then when civilisation catches up and reinterpret the quran they are then amazing at the accuracy.
For example Allah explains how He is expanding the universe - they never understood it before and then people would say "that is clearly wrong" and then disbelieve until now science tells us that the universe is expanding and we realise the quran is correct all along.
That is what I make of it anyway :)
mashallah brother this was a top tier explanation, you completely eliminated any doubt I would've had in this verse. jazakallah
There is this one guy,a spammer named mike who needs to see this. He is a christian missionary working to make the islamic youth divert away from Islam. Even had a freaking Zoom call with me. Doesnt accept the truth.
maybe show him the contradictions in the bible, also its impossible to translation something from one language to another perfectly maning the divine bible doesnèt exist and the current bible was simply inspired from the original
@@amazingamx1255 I showed him. I literally showed him how the old testament *supported* child marriage and girl se x slaves,killing,looting,plundering. I showed him how the new testament clearly affirms the old testament. He just went,"No it doesnt,no it doesnt" and he didnt let the argument happen.
@@TheMuslimPerspective www.atheists.org/activism/resources/biblical-contradictions/
some people r just brainwashed and ignorant
ask him why jesus would need to be sacrificed for god to forgive everyoneÉ is god not alpowerfulÉ
if he is interested in being open minded and willing to learn then yea debate him if ur sure there's no hope just destroy him.(he worships a god who cant even preserve the language of his book, his god is regarded and has terrible memory for not remembering his own commandments etc)and use laughing emoji etc
Remember that slavery and telling Christians to rape etc is subjective and he may see nothing wrong with it just like how we see nothing wrong with men having more rights over women and this makes feminists mad
@@amazingamx1255 We have more rights than women,because of course we work for it. Men need to work a hella lot more than women. Women go to heaven much easier.
@@TheMuslimPerspective Actually there’s a Sahih Hadith that states the majority of hell are ungrateful women.
Sahih al-Bukhari 29
Narrated Ibn 'Abbas:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said: "I was shown the Hell-fire and that the majority of its dwellers were women who were ungrateful." It was asked, "Do they disbelieve in Allah?" (or are they ungrateful to Allah?) He replied, "They are ungrateful to their husbands and are ungrateful for the favors and the good (charitable deeds) done to them. If you have always been good (benevolent) to one of them and then she sees something in you (not of her liking), she will say, 'I have never received any good from you."
حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ اللَّهِ بْنُ مَسْلَمَةَ، عَنْ مَالِكٍ، عَنْ زَيْدِ بْنِ أَسْلَمَ، عَنْ عَطَاءِ بْنِ يَسَارٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ، قَالَ قَالَ النَّبِيُّ صلى الله عليه وسلم " أُرِيتُ النَّارَ فَإِذَا أَكْثَرُ أَهْلِهَا النِّسَاءُ يَكْفُرْنَ ". قِيلَ أَيَكْفُرْنَ بِاللَّهِ قَالَ " يَكْفُرْنَ الْعَشِيرَ، وَيَكْفُرْنَ الإِحْسَانَ، لَوْ أَحْسَنْتَ إِلَى إِحْدَاهُنَّ الدَّهْرَ ثُمَّ رَأَتْ مِنْكَ شَيْئًا قَالَتْ مَا رَأَيْتُ مِنْكَ خَيْرًا قَطُّ ".
Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 29
In-book reference : Book 2, Hadith 22
USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 1, Book 2, Hadith
Sunnah.com
The problem with the 1st interpretation is that the seminal vesicle is below the ribs and not "in between the ribs and the backbone" so it's out of the window. You literally have to draw a diagonal line from the bottom of the ribs to the bottom of the tailbone to get to the seminal vesicle. Even so, it's not the actual fluid that gives rise to a new human. That's the sperm and it is produced in the testes of a male after puberty, not in the embryonic stage so where the gonads originally were during pregnancy is irrelevant
Very good point that humans are actually created from the sperm and not the seminal fluid
the Arabic word “Yakhruju”
means to emerge, to come out, to leave,to exit
the arabic word “sulb” also mean loins… The loins is the area where one puts on their underwear….According to classical arabic dictionaries,the word “sulb” in the Arabic language includes the tailbone or coccyx.
So you got a higher region when we included the tailbon or coccyx…And seminal vesicles are actually in the space between the tailbone or coccyx and the ribs..or between ribs and loins
70% of the ejaculatory fluid that contains sperm comes from the seminal vesicles..
this could still be correct as "between" the backbone and rib makes sense. same way as your head is between your shoulders. this might be a stretch tho but let me know what you think 🤔
As i know, Said ibn Jubair(tabiin) said, that in this ayah means floating ribs
@@непридумалникБостанов ??? explain
@@profanotherletter4346 what to explain?
@@непридумалникБостанов what u said
@@profanotherletter4346 i did my best
Dr. Imran's explanation from EfDawah is actually really good. Read the Mohammad Asad translation of the Quran
86:5-7 LET MAN, then, observe out of what he has been created: (6) he has been created out of a
seminal fluid (7) issuing from between the loins [of man] and the pelvic arch [of woman].
So the man is created from a gushing fluid coming from between the loins of man, and the pelvic arch of a woman, and together these fluids create a man.
"The Quran | Embryology and Semen Production From between the Backbone and the Ribs | Part 1" is the title of the video, watch in foundational thoughts channel.
@Joker watch the video, or get a life
This is based on thafsir ibn Kaseer
@@irf71 yes
quran doesn’t say that you added more words, the quran is wrong lol sorry man
The noor from the T-shirt.
🤣🤣 Probably washed by tide
Correct me if I am wrong sulb can also mean the loin. I am not making this up. In Surah 4 Ayah 23, in the long Ayah, the word aslabikum is used which is similar to sulb. All the mufassirun translated it as loin. Now according to the googled oxford dictionary loin means the part of the body on both sides of the spine between the lowest (false) ribs and the hipbones. So the Ayah makes complete sense in this regard. Hope this helps.
hijab, are these all the approaches to this verse? might need a part 2 to this
Yeah I think that’s all of them and I think the 3 one is what make most sense, read asadullah ali paper on this he's also explain it in different way
@@abduallahamin2001 but the fetus grows under the ribs
One thing that so many Christians get wrong about this verse is that they base it on their misunderstanding of definition of the English translation.
When Allah refers to a MAN being created from a "GUSHING FLUID" proceeding from between the backbone and the ribs. Many Christians who deny Islam try to say this is a false statement. And the author of The Qur'an has no idea what they r referring to. Because scientifically, the male reproductive cell, spermatazoa, is produced n the testes. Not between the backbone and the ribs.
But, due to their misunderstanding those same Christians, make an error by thinking the GUSHING FLUID is spermatazoa instead of SEMEN.
SEMEN is the white fluid produced n the prostate, which is positioned n males BETWEEN OUR BACKBONE AND OUR RIBS. And when ejaculations happen SEMEN mixes with spermatazoa and other nutrients and comes out of the male sex gland.
U also noticed the verse said where MAN being created from. MANKIND before we r born, r n the WOMBS of our mothers for approximately 9 months. The WOMBS of our mothers' r ALSO BETWEEN THEIR BACKBONE AND RIBS.
So it goes to show u God Allah, The Unique Author of The Qur'an knew exactly what He was talking about. Even back n the 7th century, before microscopes,
sonograms were invented
Anti Islam groups bring this up to try to bring down Islam, little do they know that this verse is a scientific miracle!
The miracle is that you listen to MH dribble a whole big pile of camel poo and think he is explaining it. When in reality he is speaking a lot of words with 0% truth. Really sad.
@@legal_solutions_india 1- the word in the Hadith is different than the word in the Quran one is talking about the vena cava the other is Aorta and it’s not even literal
2- there is no evidence of any slave being forced to be slept with and even if it was the case she is a war captive
3- you provided no reference please provide one
4 she’s a mother by breastfeeding that’s all she isn’t actually his mother
5- it was about they’re death the Quran makes it clear no one knows the hour
@@legal_solutions_india 1 please don’t teach me Arabic
The word in the Quran is وتين the word in Hadith is ابهر and it’s not even literal lol
Her father and brother actually forced her into marriage and when she objected they slapped her and they waged war on top of it there is no reason to believe she loved her family and she could of left the prophet pbuh if she wanted
Provide me with the ayah
The kid still doesn’t get inheritance from the mother so she’s just the mother in breastfeeding not the actual mother
As for the Hadith it is known according to literally everybody that it’s meant for them in another Hadith different to this one the prophet Pbuh used the same analogy and it specifically says your hour
@@legal_solutions_india إِنْ يَعِشْ هَذَا لَمْ يُدْرِكْهُ
الْهَرَمُ قَامَتْ عَلَيْكُمْ (سَاعَتُكُمْ ")
Here is the Hadith of Aisha in Muslim the last word in brackets clearly says your hour specifically taking about the people of his time
@@legal_solutions_india and the word qiyamah is not mentioned in any of the Hadith
Yes brother you're right
الراجح أن الضمير يعود على الإنسان
I believe this verse reffers to Bone Marrow which is primarily located in the ribs, vertebrae, sternum, and bones of the pelvis and is responsible for creation of new red cells in the boody and therefore sustains life.
his hair is at its best when like this mashaAllah
Are you good enough for The Almighty to let you into heaven?
How many lies have you told, and what do you call someone who lies? Have you ever stolen something, and what do you call someone who steals? Have you ever taken God’s name in vain (very serious; in Old Testament times, the Jews wouldn’t even say the name of God for fear of blasphemy) - even ‘OMG’? One more: Jesus said whoever looks at a woman to lust after her has already committed adultery in his heart; have you ever looked with lust?
Well I’m not judging you - but if you’ve done these things then you’re a liar, thief, blasphemer and adulterer-at-heart; that’s how seriously God takes sin. He is Holy (perfectly good/righteous and separate from sin) which means that He is perfect in justice - and if He were to judge you by the moral law (we’ve already looked at 4 commandments) would you be innocent or guilty? Heaven or Hell? The answer is hell - the wrath of God upon you for your sin. Is that concerning?
But fortunately, God’s will is not that you perish. He wants all men everywhere to be saved. So do you know what He did for us guilty sinners? In self-giving mercy, He sent His Son Jesus Christ. He lived the perfect life that we should have lived - tempted at all points and yet He NEVER sinned. Through His life, being in very nature God, He revealed God to men; but we in our hatred condemned Him to death. On that cross as Jesus suffered, He took on the sin of the world and was judged in our place; receiving God’s wrath. You and I broke God’s law, but Jesus paid the fine. God can justly forgive us.
On that cross He died, then He was buried, but 3 days later He was raised from the dead - conquering death and Hell and ushering in The Kingdom of God. He then ascended to the right hand of God the Father (where He came from) now Lord of the living and the dead. God has fixed a date when He will judge the world in righteousness - Jesus us coming back. What you need to do is repent (In humility, acknowledge your sin before God and turn to a relationship with Him) and trust ALONE in Jesus Christ and His work on the cross; and God will grant you the gift of the Holy Spirit. Then be baptised.
When you place your trust in Jesus - the Lord and Saviour - these things will happen:
1) God will forgive the sins that you have committed; they were paid for by Jesus at the cross.
2) The perfect life that Jesus lived will be credited to you. He will find you holy and blameless on judgement day (and now), as Christ’s righteousness covers you.
3) You receive a place in Christ’s kingdom as an adopted child of God. God becomes your Father. Eternal life isn’t just about living forever, but a personal relationship with God Himself. That life can start now; The Father will reveal Himself to you if you seek Him.
4) God doesn’t just save you from the penalty of your sin (Hell). He can save you from the power of sin itself. Whoever practices sin is a slave of sin; but when you repent and believe the gospel [WHICH HAS BEEN DESCRIBED] the Holy Spirit comes to dwell in you and sanctify you (working in you to further abandon sin and turn to the will of God). When the end of the age comes, and eternity begins, this work will be brought to completion as you are finally freed from the presence of sin.
Jesus offers to take away your sin and to give you His righteousness; you must receive it by faith. Choose this day if you will align with the world, or with Jesus and His kingdom - only His is eternal.
ROMANS 10:9 - If you confess with your mouth Jesus as Lord and believe in your heart that God raised Him from the dead, you will be saved.
@Ca So Are you good enough for The Almighty to let you into heaven?
How many lies have you told, and what do you call someone who lies? Have you ever stolen something, and what do you call someone who steals? Have you ever taken God’s name in vain (very serious; in Old Testament times, the Jews wouldn’t even say the name of God for fear of blasphemy) - even ‘OMG’? One more: Jesus said whoever looks at a woman to lust after her has already committed adultery in his heart; have you ever looked with lust?
Well I’m not judging you - but if you’ve done these things then you’re a liar, thief, blasphemer and adulterer-at-heart; that’s how seriously God takes sin. He is Holy (perfectly good/righteous and separate from sin) which means that He is perfect in justice - and if He were to judge you by the moral law (we’ve already looked at 4 commandments) would you be innocent or guilty? Heaven or Hell? The answer is hell - the wrath of God upon you for your sin. Is that concerning?
But fortunately, God’s will is not that you perish. He wants all men everywhere to be saved. So do you know what He did for us guilty sinners? In self-giving mercy, He sent His Son Jesus Christ. He lived the perfect life that we should have lived - tempted at all points and yet He NEVER sinned. Through His life, being in very nature God, He revealed God to men; but we in our hatred condemned Him to death. On that cross as Jesus suffered, He took on the sin of the world and was judged in our place; receiving God’s wrath. You and I broke God’s law, but Jesus paid the fine. God can justly forgive us.
On that cross He died, then He was buried, but 3 days later He was raised from the dead - conquering death and Hell and ushering in The Kingdom of God. He then ascended to the right hand of God the Father (where He came from) now Lord of the living and the dead. God has fixed a date when He will judge the world in righteousness - Jesus us coming back. What you need to do is repent (In humility, acknowledge your sin before God and turn to a relationship with Him) and trust ALONE in Jesus Christ and His work on the cross; and God will grant you the gift of the Holy Spirit. Then be baptised.
When you place your trust in Jesus - the Lord and Saviour - these things will happen:
1) God will forgive the sins that you have committed; they were paid for by Jesus at the cross.
2) The perfect life that Jesus lived will be credited to you. He will find you holy and blameless on judgement day (and now), as Christ’s righteousness covers you.
3) You receive a place in Christ’s kingdom as an adopted child of God. God becomes your Father. Eternal life isn’t just about living forever, but a personal relationship with God Himself. That life can start now; The Father will reveal Himself to you if you seek Him.
4) God doesn’t just save you from the penalty of your sin (Hell). He can save you from the power of sin itself. Whoever practices sin is a slave of sin; but when you repent and believe the gospel [WHICH HAS BEEN DESCRIBED] the Holy Spirit comes to dwell in you and sanctify you (working in you to further abandon sin and turn to the will of God). When the end of the age comes, and eternity begins, this work will be brought to completion as you are finally freed from the presence of sin.
Jesus offers to take away your sin and to give you His righteousness; you must receive it by faith. Choose this day if you will align with the world, or with Jesus and His kingdom - only His is eternal.
ROMANS 10:9 - If you confess with your mouth Jesus as Lord and believe in your heart that God raised Him from the dead, you will be saved.
Jazzak Allah khair Happy to have you back brother :)
You can search for every thing that he says and see what the scholars of islam said about these topics.
We believe that our religion is the right religion for a reason rather than just accepting this life of eat play sleep repeat. May Allah guid you to Islam
Its talking about babies emerging from women's bellies. It's not rocket science. Translations were based on assumptions that it was talking about sperm but the context proves that it was referring to a human being born.
If I say: "Paul was walking with his baby. He was so cute with his pacifier." It's only the context that tells you that the second phrase refers to the baby. We should use this principle to translate this verse.
This is actually the best answer you Muslims could possibly give. For me it’s a clear error. But to cover this blatant error this answer is the best you can give and survive yet again.
I see that this is the logical answer, because I know Arabic and I see, according to the verse, that it means the Human who emerges from his mother’s womb
@@JamieMoore-el7ubno one’s covering this
Classical scholar Qurtubi and Ibn Attiya had this view who came way before the development of modern science …Are you gonna say that They made up an excuse too??
Ooooohhh how come human from between those parts????
Ma Shaa Allah , his T shirt is so Noorani 😄
bhai instagram pr wapis ao
@@mohammadrazzaqgulabkhan9639 😅 ji bhai zaroor in Shaa Allah , asal mei abhi Hamare College ke Unit tests etc shuru hain aur mujhe Kuch books bhi padhna complete karna hai , isliye Instagram se break le liya , Instagram bahot Time zaaye kar deta hai , aapki hawsla afzahi ke liye shukriya bhai ,
jazaak Allahu khairan
Was eagerly waiting for that video
The MOST IMPORTANT thing is not which interpretation is correct.
The most important thing that every muslim and critic must know is THIS
It is He who sent down upon thee the Book, wherein are verses clear that are the Essence of the Book, and others ambiguous. As for those in whose hearts is swerving, they follow the ambiguous part, desiring dissension, and desiring its interpretation; and none knows its interpretation, save only God. And those firmly rooted in knowledge say, 'We believe in it; all is from our Lord'; yet none remembers, but men possessed of minds.
Quran 3: 7
Sulb - Can it be translated as "Solids" i.e rocks under the ground or the ground itself?
Tara'ib - Can it be understood as a collection of "Turab" - Sand/dirt?
I.e, mankind created from water that comes out from between the earth, and not the ribs?
Assalam U Alaikum brothers and sisters, in my view Allah SWT has talked of the reflection of man upon himself so that he could know what is his true status. In the context of the following verse, Allah then tells man of what is he created from. Allah says he is created from a gushing fluid. Now here, no mention of word semen nor egg is used rather a combined word is used for the fluid from which man comes
Finally the last verse isn’t the explanation of the preceding verse rather it is talking of man as to where he was and from where he came i.e from between the backbone and the ribs. And that refers to pregnancy and consequent events
I was gonna upload a video on this on my channel
"Spreading the truth"
I still will InshAllah
There's an Article made by Asadullah Ali it's so good
@@snahmda yeah I remember reading that a while back I will have a look I will probs add it in the description of my RUclips video.
I have one coming out today if your interested.
ruclips.net/channel/UCKtCxYXlBYBmEwYBFDKXwPw
It will be on Muhammad pbuh prophethood 25 mins.
InshAllah it will be out in the next 45 mins
Cry harder
I think Allah was referring to what scientists call "spinal ejaculation", as quoted by the National Institute of Health: "Ejaculation is a reflex mediated by a spinal control center, referred to as a spinal ejaculation generator. During intercourse, the spinal ejaculation generator integrates the sensory inputs that are necessary to trigger ejaculation." Knowing that the vertebral column (backbone) is a protective layer for the spinal cord, we can deduce that Allah was referring to the spinal cord which is therefore located between the ribs and the backbone. When Allah mentions that the fluid is emitted between the backbone and the ribs, he is talking about the spinal cord which triggers ejaculation during the intercourse
Which of spinal cord section? The reflex is realized through lumbar-sacral segments, don’t talk nonsense here
Why is his shirt glowing 😂😂
His eman overtook his shirt
Noor of emaan 😀❤️
Hahahahaha
Light will always win........so much nur....even the freaking shirt glew up
Could be the camera or the material of the shirt makes light bounce off efficiently... Idk :/
mashallah you explained it very well thanks
While the third opinion makes sense
Dr Zakir Naiks view is also perfectly legitimate.
It can be talking about gon...adal ridge which is the origin of male tract
During the third week of gestation, primordial germ cells arise in the yolk sac and migrate from along the dorsal mesentery to populate the gon# adal ridges located in the lower thoracic and upper lumbar levels. (Source : Embryology of the Genitourinary Tract
Alan W. Partin MD, PhD, in Campbell-Walsh-Wein Urology, 2021)
Please don't get confused between spe# rmatogenesis (which involves only the test# is) and eja# culation which involves other male organs as well.
If God said the fluid came from t...estis it would only be partially correct as it is only one organ involved. Instead of making it a science class God covers all parts responsible for the fluid (eja# culation) with two simple words.
I agree, also the Arabic says "yakhruj" which means exit not originate so the rational understanding of this verse is childbirth not the formation of sperm or zygote.
The ambiguity and everyone’s confusion makes me remember a verse in the Quran.. Surah 3:7.
He it is Who has sent down to thee the Book: In it are verses basic or fundamental (of established meaning); they are the foundation of the Book: others are allegorical. But those in whose hearts is perversity follow the part thereof that is allegorical, seeking discord, and searching for its hidden meanings, but no one knows its hidden meanings except Allah. And those who are firmly grounded in knowledge say: "We believe in the Book; the whole of it is from our Lord:" and none will grasp the Message except men of understanding.
So why send a book that only Allah knows the meaning? It defeats the purpose for which it was revealed in the first place isn’t it? If you think about it, you will see I am right. You are blinded by lies and deceit and that is why you are refusing to admit what was stated plainly and confidently has to be reinterpreted to fit the science.
then please please please tell me what was the point of this verse? or at least what does it allegorises?
@@pauloviero4452 exactly
@@steamerSama The point is to test future readers through imprecise verses as Surah 3:7 implies.
Anyway the confusion only happened because of some classical Muslim commentators saying that the verse is talking about semen.
But as medieval Arabic scholar ibn-Atyyia (not an apologist and not aware of any criticism) made a commentary on the verse in al-Muharar al-Wajiz he said that the verse could be talking about either the man or the fluid.
And if you check the verses after it continues talking about the man so it makes more sense to say that the verse is referring to man coming out of the body not the fluid and god will bring him back (ie. resurrection of man not bringing the semen back it doesn't make sense).
I think it’s read akin to, “So let humankind reflect on how they were created. Humans were created from a fluid that is forcefully released, emerging from between the man’s backbone and the woman’s nurturing place, the womb.”
interpreting “الصُّلْبِ (as-sulb)” as “steel” or “backbone”, symbolizing rigidity, and “التَّرَائِبِ (al-tara'ib)” as “soil” or soft tissue. Al-Juhani links التَّرَائِبِ to the female reproductive system based on classical Arabic roots, which can mean dust or soil, tying to fertility and reproduction.
Over red at dit (take the at out) “religionai” sub I dive into it.
Brother Hijjab please make a video about Surah Muminun that some say speaks of “bones before flesh”. Jazakallah
Thumma doesn't mean then , it means and in this ayat
Allah give you more knowledge more strength mashallah brother
Mashallah brothers
If only you can explain the verses by introducing a "textual visual explanation" on the screen.
Wafa9akoum allah.
Good job brother. I'm inclined to agree with the 3rd opinion because Allah swt is chastising the human being for thinking he is so grand and great, he was created from a gushing liquid and he came from between the backbone and ribs (womb) of another person.
1)
The verse refers to fluid and not sperm, and the fluid comes from between the backbone or loins and the ribs. Even if the Qur’ān were referring to sperm, the sperm is created in the testes which are located between the loins and the ribs.
2)
The verse refers to the baby emerging from the mother’s womb, which is located between the backbone or loins and the ribs.
3)
The verse refers to the man and woman engaged in sexual intercourse, by which the ejaculatory fluid is issued between them during intercourse.
So,in this verse
They are not talking about
The sperm but the egg
Or zygote
Nice attractive thumbnails with this sapience series.
A suggestion I have is to use anatomy charts on the screen to help aid the explanation.
In embryology, the testicles are generated from tissue that lies in the abdomen, and then descend during puberty. So it’s another view that can be taken.
Lol gushing fluid is when things develop. This verse is too vague , I think it's an error
@@raditz4583 read comment above of Chris 123
@@niazikhan7478 not good enough. It's a very vague statement. You tell me why it's important
@@raditz4583 why
@@raditz4583 Quranic verses are multilayered for 7th century as well for 21st century
I would recommend inserting the verses/hadiths which you mention in the video so thats easier to follow
Great explanation, and I see third opinion is more satisfactory than others and more logical ❤ JazakAllah
Jazaaka Allaaho Khayr Mr. Hijab
I am not a scholar. But I can see a much simpler explanation for these verses. It is much simpler than all three explanations.
When Quran say that humans are created from X, it can mean three different things.
1. Originally Adam (AS) was created from X when humans were first created. This is my understanding of "salsalin kalfakhar" (صَلْصَالٍ كَالْفَخَّارِ) in Quran 55:14.
2. When a person is born, he is made from X or made up of X. This is clear interpretation of maain maheen (مَّاءٍ مَّهِينٍ) in Quran 32:8
3. At present human beings are made up of X. I think of maain daafiq (مَّاءٍ دَافِقٍ) in Quran 86:6 in this term. This verse is referring to blood. It is pumped from heart. Heart is located right between "salb" and "taraib" for both men and women.
If there is any mistake in my analysis, I would humbly request you to correct me.
But the translation says created from. Right? 🤔if it's blood then it should be created of. Right?
I felt like the explanation in the vedio is more satisfactory😅
@@captianhydra1712 but the blood provides the nutrients for the baby, so really this explanation makes sense
@@MuaazAwan I'm not sure thats true
The last opinion is what make most sense to me and what I understand from the language of the verse in arabic
If god is so powerful why should we humans needs to argue about this stuff, everything should be flawless. Why do I need to know different meanings of words etc. make no sense
that's why God give human beings the ability to think brother.
Because God gives us enough information when it's important and enough ambiguous stood for those who want to hate, to hate.
You must learn this verse:
It is He who sent down upon thee the Book, wherein are verses clear that are the Essence of the Book, and others ambiguous. As for those in whose hearts is swerving, they follow the ambiguous part, desiring dissension, and desiring its interpretation; and none knows its interpretation, save only God. And those firmly rooted in knowledge say, 'We believe in it; all is from our Lord'; yet none remembers, but men possessed of minds.
Quran 3: 7
@@think-islam-channel always some sh*t argument which is not convincing humans????
@@moiez0192 what convinced you is your issue
God judgment of you is something you should think about, if you are wise.
But it sounds like you are stuck in hate /anger mode.
That disables your rational mind.
Lose the emotion, and learn about things openly, bravely and with sincerity.
It's for your own benefit.
@@think-islam-channel mate learn how when you know so much than a average person and have high iq than a average person. I don’t understand how are you not critical. Maybe you don’t know enough like me
In ibn kathir, it says - from between the backbone of man and ribs of woman. You missed it brother hijab.
fluid emitted refers to the semen, and it comes out from in between the sulb and the tara’ib. However, the truth of the matter is that the word ‘tarai’b’-according to the Arabic-is actually referring to a female body part. Much like the English word ‘penis’ can only be ascribed to a male, the word ‘tara’ib’ can only be applied to a female.
This is not apologetic modernism or revisionism; the classical works of Quranic commentary throughout the last 1400 years confirm this view categorically. In other words, the sulb belongs to the male, and the tara’ib belongs to the female. This is the view of the Muslims since the last fourteen hundred years, and there is consensus (ijma) on this matter, since the time of the Sahabah (the Prophet’s disciples) until today.
Shaykh `Abd al-Wahhâb al-Turayrî of IslamToday.com writes:
The phrase “mâ’ dâfiq” (emitted fluid) is not restricted in meaning to sperm but is used in Arabic for both the sperm and the egg. Ibn Kathîr, in his commentary on this verse, writes: “It emanates from the man and the woman, and with Allah’s permission, the child comes forth as a product of both.”
…The words translated as “backbone” (sulb) and “ribs” (tarâ’ib) are not understood in Arabic to belong to the same person. Arabs understand the “sulb” to refer to a part of the male body and the “tarâ’ib” to a part of the female. Ibn Kathîr states: “It refers to the ‘sulb’ of the man and the ‘tarâ’ib’ of the woman…” He then quotes this interpretation on the authority of the Prophet’s companion Ibn `Abbâs. This same understanding is given in all the major classical works of Qur’anic commentary.
Many non-Arabs misinterpret this verse because they think that sulb and tara’ib refer to different body parts of the male. In reality, tara’ib is feminine, and refers to the female’s body part. For fourteen hundred years, all of the scholars have held this belief, and not a single classical scholar has ever differed on this point. The reason is that the Arabic makes it clear that tara’ib refers to a feminine body part, and not a male one.
Ok bro but if it is talking about female egg then why is it mentioning male backbone?
so some magical invisible liquid is secreted when they copulate? I don't understand what you're clarifying? or maybe you are casting aspersions on the Quran?🤔
Most awaited video
You forgot to mention the next verse which confirms that it can only refer to the first noun which is man
86:8 "Verily, (Allâh) is Able to bring ""him"" back (to life)!
86:10 "Then ""he"" will have no power, nor any helper."
So the "He" in the next verse could only refer back to the first noun which is the Man likewise that verse talks about the man and where he comes from not the fluid itself..
The Qur'an should not be taken literally. Exactly. Thank you.
If you draw an imaginary line between the end of the back bone (coccyx) and the bottom of of the ribs in 3D you’d most likely intersect midway from front and back of the body around adrenal glands (just above the kidneys). The hormonal role of the adrenals is well known and who is to say that the adrenals are not also involved in fertility in both male and female? This is yet a 4th plausible explanation in addition to 3rd explanation mentioned by another medic above as it’s precisely describing the area from where the testes originate & descend from.
It’s like the critics don’t know people or even creatures had testicles back then.
16 year old I heard of who fell on a fence and tore his testicles, and guess what spewed. Clearly no one has ever torn testicles throughout the history of mankind until this kid. Not even those of animals which many considered edible.
he is true I agree with him as a medical student 😍
Right a medical student born in 2009 who can’t spell?
You must be Mulah not student😅
@@Akhi_Umar 🙄🙄akhi in Egyptian Arabic the word insan means human if we remove the n then it means to forget so In Arabic insan is written انسان and means person. I believe it has the same root as Hebrew anashim אנשים which means people. This makes it an ancient Semitic word.
@@Me-gc3pu 👹👹joker
@@Akhi_Umar so the Arabic word for human is insan which is derived from word uns which means love and also branch from the word nasiya which means to forget so use your brain we human die this world forget him within weak they get busy with their work so see don't waste your time do worship of Allahswt and make yourself obedient to Allahswt
Peace, mercy and blessings of God be upon you. I am a woman from Palestine. I am a lady from Palestine. I am a woman from Palestine.
Ok are you a lady or woman from Palestine?
These are pretty wild excuses.
Basically all three options require the same massive stretch: that "between the backbone in the ribs" refers not to the chest area (you know, the part that has the backbone in the back and ribs in the front and sides), but to the area below the ribs, down to the tailbone. How anyone can say this with a straight face I don't know but here we are.
Quran describes the gushing water in the point of view from up down-looking from top head to bottom feet.Just look how the first verse of Surah At Tarik begins with a star then verse 4 says "There is no human being but has a protector over him" so its says "over him" then again it returns back to sky and in verse 11 says: By the sky which sends back. So, Quranic point of view about gushing water is from top to bottom, looking in vertical line, same as other verses i wrote above.And, when you look to male skeleton system from up to down you see that the ejaculating organs is exatly in between the backbone and the ribs.
That doesn't make sense . The backbone and ribs don't have seperate beginnings. Ribs end at a point in between . So what comes in between the ribs and backbone would be the the lungs the diaphragm etc . Even seminal vesicles or ovaries are further down . Also the origin of man is not from seminal vesicles . The cells responsible for life is the spermatozoa which comes from the testes .
Thanks for sharing the video.
How about other meaning of اخراج I think it has meaning of direction or production as well. For example in Arabic movies they say اخراج for production or director. And role of sympathetic nervous system which are emerging from thoracic and lumber region and causes ejaculation.
والله اعلم😊
Sura At Tariq
86:5,6,7
Let the human being reflect that from what he has been created.
He is created from a drop
which is emitted from a space between the backbone and the ribs
Interesting interpretations, but why rely on the opinion of 'classical' tafseer? The Arabic language has beeb preserved for all eternity. The word 'sulb' refers to the male sexual parts. Are we seriously saying arabs didn't have a word for male genitalia ?
The word 'taraai'b' refers to the FEMALE pelvic arch area, a rare expression. So in Surah 86 verse 7 '.yakhrojo min baynis salbi wataraaib..' is the Qur'aanic way of putting in the most polite terms that life has to start with the union of the sexual area of a man and the sexual area of a woman.
Note the grammatical construction 'min bayna' is used in the Qur'aan several times. When it comes to human reproduction in the Qur'aan, all the different verses have to be read together to get a clear picture. I still think Dr Maurice Bucaille did the best job in explaning this.
Allah is such a good communicator we have to have different experts try to interpret what he could have said in a less ambiguous way.
What a smart God
We need an interpration because of the richness of the Arabic language. the meanings of the Arabic words changes with the speech, harakah, and position. 1 word has more than 100 meanings.
@@ayada8884that not the definition of a rich language
A rich language is a language where 1 word doesnt have many meaning
But 1 concept can be described by many words
For example sand, there are many words to descube it in arabic
English is a poor language because 1 word can have many meaning
It is poor because it do not have many words .
So compared to english, Arabic can not really be interpreted differently unless you force it to be so, unless you want to push a narrative
The mental gymnastics that Islam needs to do to make sense is the true miracle.
I know, it's truly astonishing the rubbish and spin they have to do to elevate a man written to something it's not, truth has no relevance.
It's doesn't actually the prophet knew that that the testies produce semen but thr verse from the context refering to the man emerging not the fluid
Testicles only produce sperm, the sperm itself needs a fluid to swim in, the seminal vesicle which is near the prostate creates the actual fluid that makes up semen, and it is located in between the rib and the vertabrate direct under.
I stick with the 3rd opinion. Thats an iron man's blow to the doubt. MashaAllah.
JazakAllah brother
In between backbone and ribs also make senses. In our biology book it is written that sperm is originated from a gland in the pelvis which is in kidney and kidney is located in between backbone and ribs. So alhamduillah there's no wrong.
Are you mad😂
@@skanderberg8701 Shiptar Mohammad Anis said it right sperm is not only fluid in testicles
Lolllllllllllllllll
Then if you take then testcles are between head and feet
Heart and knees
Eyes and feet
Quran tells it is frem backbone
Not bw backbone and ribs
Stop being a stupid
Which biology book are reading mate? I’m medical student this stuff don’t make sense
moiez0192qquran😂
Allah hu akhbar✨
NONE of the three apologies fit.
The third is very valid and classical understanding
Why not interpretate fluid here as a follicular fluid of female ?
قال تعالى (ماء دافق) ولم يقل منى دافق
It didn't take but one minute 10 seconds for the first excuses to show up. Just saying it comes to Natural for you friend. Character trait
Now you are looking more handsome 👌
I was eagerly waiting for this topic
This guy is clutching to straws 😂 what the hell is he on about? In the 7th century they didn’t know certain things and that’s why it’s wrong in the Quran
Quran is not wrong brother. This is revelation from the creator of everything. May Allah guide you.Ameen
they didn't know but Allah know everything 😱
Interesting point of view 🧐
3 stages.
1. Sperm.
2. Baby’s position in the womb which he exists from.
3. The human enters the world and now wants to challenge his creator 🤦🏿♂️
Sperm itself does not create a life. You need the egg from the female.
forgets the most important piece: the female egg. Brilliant
@@sistaex7624 it’s not a biology lesson nor is it necessary.
@@TheQuranExplainsItself if Allah is going through the trouble to talk about biology (how man is created), at least it can be correct. It is necessary for god all knowing to be right
@@sistaex7624 where’s the error? Omitting unnecessary information is not an error.
I’d rather go with the explanation of the “backbone and ribs” of the women, for a simple reason. The words that are used by Allah to address those places that are shameful for us to express literally wouldn’t be more respectfully said rather than this way.
As-salamou aleikum
Baraka Allah fikum
Can you give the reference of the Tafsir of Al qurtubi ?where Can I but a good traduction ?
No sorry I don't buy it. I'm still confused. It's says it COMES from the backbone AND ribs. What is this?..... Make it make sense.
فَلْيَنظُرِ ٱلْإِنسَـٰنُ مِمَّ خُلِقَ
Let people then consider what they were created from
خُلِقَ مِن مَّآءٍۢ دَافِقٍۢ
They (i.e. Human beings) were created from a spurting fluid (i.e. Sperms)
يَخْرُجُ مِنۢ بَيْنِ ٱلصُّلْبِ وَٱلتَّرَآئِبِ
*stemming* from between the backbone and the ribcage
Simply, Here Muhammed Hijab is explaining that stemming from between the backbone and the ribcage is not referring to the Spurting fluid but the human being. You can read the interpretation that way.
does old english make sense to you?
@@rest747 ?
Back then they didn’t know it’s purely from the balls😂
When you form in your mother your family jewels start in the ribs and spine and descend into the private parts in essence it’s basic embryology
In 86:5-7 Al-insan refers to both men and women. The two body parts also refer to either of them. Sulb and tara'ib, of the male and of the female origins of ma'in, or fluid.
You don’t appear convinced.
Couldn’t Allah be clear in his message so you don’t have to do these mental acrobatics to find an explanation for the text?
He could but he deliberately v wasn't as with many verses in the Qur'an.
This is to give haters (perhaps like you?) the full freedom to reject Islam if it does their biases
.
The most important verse for any critic who wants to study the Qur'an with honesty should read and ponder very deeply on is this:
It is He who sent down upon thee the Book, wherein are verses clear that are the Essence of the Book, and others ambiguous. As for those in whose hearts is swerving, they follow the ambiguous part, desiring dissension, and desiring its interpretation; and none knows its interpretation, save only God. And those firmly rooted in knowledge say, 'We believe in it; all is from our Lord'; yet none remembers, but men possessed of minds.
Quran 3: 7
@@think-islam-channel Excellent deflection method, every time someone has an honest critique just call them a hater.
@@sipkestorm4050
You focused on the least impetus part of the post?
You're bias is blinding.
Which proves you are a hater.
In that case the warnings in the Quran for those like you is something you should investigate.
Getting angry and full of indignation is not going to avert God's judgment on you
This is a good topic to focus on since the character of Allah is indefensible.
??
It says the sperm come from, not where the testis developed in embryo. Twist and turn to fit it into science. Lol.
Also it doesn't say sperm it says semen. But we can ignore quran and hadith that say semen stays in the womb 40 days.
THANK YOU SIR! OMFG they are stretching something out so much that it starts to sound insane. Funny thing is that classical interpretations of this verse by early muslims like Ibn Kathir say none of this hogwash. Ibn Kathir says: gushing fluid from the backbone of man and ribs of women. These early muslims did not have the agenda or the need to twist a verse to fit science
@@sistaex7624 meanwhile Qurtubi and ibn attiya Laughing at u people
@@sistaex7624ibn attyah actually says it's the man that emerges and not the fluid
Subhanallah thanks for explaining
The worst scientific explanation I've ever heard. 🤣🤣🤣🤣.. Sorry dude but I'm a Doctor. Prophet has really fooled you.
My question is this : Let us assume Quran was written by some man, then why would such a statement exist in the quran since everyone even then could see from where the semen is ejected.
However you try to spin it the quran is wrong. You talk about the coccyx but the ribs are much higher, the quran description is scientifically wrong, thats just a fact or truth
False the third explanation make perfect sense
you need a better mike, maybe use an iPhone 12 to record and increase base of the audio
I miss your hair 😢
You could explain this by specific diagrams. I think better reupload with pictures and diagrams. It would be understandable. Also please talk slowly . It would be good.
Oh , boy, it is sooooo clear that he is trying so hard to make it look like it is not what is so clearly stated in the Qur'an that is super cringy , He basically said : the qur'an says it comes from the backbone , and we are talking about sperm , and he keeps saying sperm comes from inside the women ??
Is he demented ???
He just wanted to say oh let me alone with my delusional Prophet 😂
@@stopworrying8850the third explanation is crystal clear
Despite knowing the Scientific Miracles in Quran.
I don't need Science to believe in Allah SWT.
The real miraculous nature of these verses comes from the fact that they are multilayered and timeless. Meaning at any point in time it would match the current understanding of this portion of biology. But go ahead and keep telling yourself an illiterate man in the 6 century made it up. The rejection of Islam is so blatantly built on nonsensical hatred and intentional ignorance.
Vague verses are not miracles. You are easily impressed
The illiterate man said it plainly but the academics have to reinterpret it to fit modern science.
So what you’re saying is that the miracle is people’s ability to perform mental gymnastics?
thank you for making these videos hijab!
I was wondering why so many anti MH comments and comments attacking Hijab's desperate attempt to cover up an obvious mistake in the Qur'an were being posted and just realised it's not his channel. The coward Hijab can't remove all the comments calling out his lies like he normally does on his own channel.
Its hilarious that instead of putting up a thoughtful counter argument you focus solely on insults. Shows you really have nothing to say!
@@mahadism7455 Oh the irony. You are accusing me of something that your boy Hijab has beem guilty of for years. He's the one deleting any counter arguments to his videos on his channel. I have had so many posts removed/not posted due to his over zealous moderating and so have many others. As an experiment I then posted posts agreeing with his videos and bang, they miraculously appear. In light of that, the fact that you accused me of not putting up an argument is truly laughable.
@@alanwright3716 its not Ironic, hijab can do whatever he likes with his comment section, if you want to respond to him you’re always free to make your own videos or find him in person and stick a camera in his face like he does every sunday with random people.
You know what the Odd thing is, this channel dosen’t belong to hijab so the comments aren’t being moderated and I haven’t seen not a single substance’d response to hijab... only insults. So maybe he was correct in banishing you all from his comment section. You commented twice and you still haven’t responded to what he said btw
@@mahadism7455 You are missing the point. I don't have any interest in engaging with Muslims about this teaching. I have pretty much stopped discussing theology with Muslims as I feel it's pointless. These arguments just go around in circles and end up going nowhere.
My post was to simply highlight my amazement that I have been seeing Hijab's views being attacked. I never once saw this on his channel and we know why that was. I just wanted to highlight his cowardly stance on blocking opposing viewpoints.
@@alanwright3716 lol I knew you didn’t have anything to offer😂
And how cowardly of him! He actually debates EDUCATED people in-front of audiences and allows anyone to literally stick a camera in his face and question his views. YES thats very cowardly 😂
This comment section is just confirmation that hijab was right, you lot have nothing to offer you just want to insult him on his channel.