Keyword French 😂😂Who will ever listen to s frenchy when it comes to war?? They will be the 1st to surrender. They think we forget how weak they are. Hilarious
Read French history. They were the greatest military power in Europe for a millennium. Ever heard of Charles Martel, Charlemagne. French had many victories against England in Plantagenet times. Napoleon did quite well until invading Russia and even then won Borodino battle.
@@hemanshuambani9572 Napoleon won Austerlitz and Borodino. He conquered and burned Moscow. He lost the war because everybody ganged up against him. He won most of the main battles but overstretched in his megalomania.
How did they manage to get so many grotesque people together in the same programme? And how did Marie get appointed when she doesn't appear to able to separate bile and bigotry from political analysis? Truly mystifying
Mario the prof must stop living in eutopia......... This theatre is not a lecture room....... It is not academia......... The hit on Dnipro using the experimental ballistic, is a shocker to the west...........!!🤔 Let's face it, the air defense could not see it come , nor hit..... We are talking of, French , American, British , Germany defence systems combined ...... were unable to stop this ICBM....... So stop being academic here....... The USA , the most powerful Nation today, shut it's embassy in anticipation......... What is the frech professor dreaming about....... Russias threat of using tactical nuclear......... Is not a bluff...!! 🤔 She must stop lying to Ukrainians....... It is impossible as we speak for Ukraine to beat Russia in this war....... Its a pipe dream.
Is this a media house or a propaganda medium.? How come out of 4 commentators none is from the Russian side? Won't this stain the paint of your integrity?
Just a reminder, "all of humanity" includes America too, they still live on this planet, where "continents" are connected, by land, water and human values.
Let’s hope Trump can put an end to this madness. Your guests are terrible. Invite Russians and find out from the source what Russians really think instead of all this speculative diatribe.
jumbled talk, incoherent analysis, what is happening to western intelligentsia, or inviting the wrong experts to the studio, very disappointed, france 24 can do a better job!
Of course it is... What do you expect from the French??? Even that gas debacle in Germany.... France cancelled the construction of a gas pipeline from the Iberian peninsula to Germany!!! Nowwww they're selling energy to Germany!!! They're PLAYING THE GAME bro! The woman professor talking about Propaganda and Aggression is like a psychopath talking about compassion... They have NONE! France acts like they all innocent and pure... THEY AREN'T. They too have colonies and took a dump in many of them
Could you imagine living through the bombings and displacement and having to listen to all the other people making decisions about what you can do to protect yourself?
The USA retorric is very bad. You just forget how everything started. From Maidan to nowdays. I think you still have response from Russia, since you think they are weak.
U have to convince people that Putin is the aggressor …I mean man😂😂😂now what nato has done to other countries no one think they are the aggressor NATO is
French professor symbolizes is what exactly happens in French society which is total clueless what’s going on in the world and take macron in that account
Hoping the EU is strong ! Please, allow me to laugh at this joke. If not for the USA, Europe's leaders would crawl back into their caves. to hide from reality.
It will be very simple the Russian Church and the Russian Language and the Russian ethnicity to be protected in the Ukranian constitution and all 5 regions will be recognized by Ukraine as Russian also Ukraine will become neutral and will be able to join the EU but never NATO. 😇
Nice! Can we also have the US return or give to Mexico - California, New Mexico, Texas, Colorado, Nevada? And also have Spanish as the main official language of the US. And have mexicans ethnicity protected, including open borders permanent policy. And also have some Russian and Chinese troops invited in Mexico. And have Mexico tell the US which treaties or organizations should be part of. This sounds so nice!
French Brilliance : The ICBMmmmm was a perepegaaaadaaa and we need to ignooor it. I think even if they hit the Refill Tower, they'll say it's a Prepegaaaaadaaa.
Russia advance is is started in sumi and harkov regions to create buffer zone as created in south and east ukraine. Definately Russian forces advance will continue to zaparoze city and east side of denpr river.
She is saying Putin cannot risk a nuclear strike, at the same time saying Putin is not predictable. What a clueless, contradicting and confused analyst.
Jeffrey Sachs, John Mearsheimer, Douglas Macgregor, Scott Ritter, Aaron Mate, Gilbert Doctorow, Phil Giraldi, Tony Shaffer, Chas Freeman, Max Blumenthal - that's the people you should listen to but that's the people you will never see on this channel..
Aha... So, Putins propaganda crew outside of Ruzzia is what we should be listening to?.. Why not make RT the only legit news source while you're at it?..🤔 Have the Kremlin rule all?..🧐😘
It's a bit confusing for me, I'm viewing from Toronto Canada. But I do follow geopolitics quite closely. My question is for the producers of your segments. Surely, they've done the resume legitimacy of all the important guests this show brings on for its expert panels... But twice now, I've recently seen representatives from the "Heritage Foundation" . You do know who they are ~ yes? They are part of the architecture behind project 2025. They are very determined MAGA loyalists... They don't represent a legitimate think tank organization... They are hard ideologues and propagandists... How can you showcase them? Is it just to "beef-up", the contrasting voices on the show? Make it seem more intellectually entertaining for your audience?? That's a harmful bit of "ratings at any cost" methodology . They shouldn't be showcased on a programme of your credible standards.
Putin said, "Secretary Baker promised that NATO would not expand even an inch eastward." However, Gorbachev himself, who met with Secretary Baker on February 9, 1990, stated in Russia Beyond the Headlines (Russian English-language media) on October 16, 2014, "The issue of NATO expansion itself was not raised at that meeting. Putin's story is a fabrication. I can state this with confidence." At that time, Gorbachev's Soviet Union, which promoted democratization, was no longer the enemy of the Western countries, but was expected to adopt democracy and become their ally or partner. There was no need to make such a promise in such a political situation.
Only because Russia only have 19 jet tanker and 1 aircraft carrier, Russia has no chance in a conventional war. These two things are really important, nato have 20 aircraft and 700 tanker. Without that, they cannot go too far
and yet nobody seems to draw the parallel between the behavior of the USA regarding Palestine and their behavior regarding the Ukraine conflict.... How can you possibly believe that a nation that has been in conflict for more than 95% of its existence is the harbinger of peace? How can you believe that the only nation on Earth to drop not one, but two atomic bombs on civilian cities is somehow interested in peace?
Wow, the united states has become so irresponsible. What if something bad happens. What do we do to the people responsible for ignoring the signals? Coptas is the biggest idiot of all.
In 2000, Russia held its first presidential election, and Putin, who pledged to "democratize Russia and double the national economy," was elected. In 2002, Putin enthusiastically attended the NATO conference in Rome and requested that Russia join NATO. However, since Russia's progress in democratization had not yet met NATO's standards, it was treated as an associate member for the time being. It was only natural that Ukraine, seeing this, would aim to join NATO. However, Putin then halted Russia's democratization and steered it toward authoritarianism. He then began to distance himself from NATO and became hostile. In other words, Ukraine is not to blame for anything. Putin's selfish behavior is solely to blame.
But both Prof. John Mearsheimer and Jeffrey Sachs blame the West for not keeping up with its promise of NATO not expanding one inch eastward. In fact, after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, NATO has gained 13 more members. Russia had repeatedly warned against this. The last straw was Ukraine applying for NATO membership which even Merkel opposed.
You don't have any margin to blame U.S. for anything? Not even that tiny tini just very very little chance that the U.S who attacked Iraq on complete false pretext and the whole N.A.T.O nation leaders lied knowingly? 😮
Maybe he wanted to join because he felt safer that way. Why did he change his mind? Zucchini is not a democratically elected president and it would have made sense to make peace with his neighbor. The stuff that was happening in that country should not have been allowed to happen.
@@allegrap1054 Why did Putin change his mind? Perhaps he gave up on democratizing Russia halfway through. He realized that Russians prefer dictatorial structures of power, and turned his political course toward dictatorship. This led him to turn away from NATO, which was calling for democratization, and to hate NATO even more. As the years passed, Putin himself became more and more like Hitler, as his personal dictatorship deepened.
The funny thing is that. Listen to old folk who about to die in 5 to 10 years time. Wanna disappear all of us because most of them already fail in their lives. Sad world
12:11 unfortunately this professor hasn’t been in the military and doesn’t understand the real issues with the war and how Ukraine is really being screwed on both ends
We the people of Loy Afghanistan/Pashtoonkhwa want to help the needy people of Ukraine. They have been suffering a lot, That’s enough. Russia must go back.
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
So much nonsense in this discussion.
This lady, the French professor, is absolutely clueless.
She is beyond stupid
Keyword French 😂😂Who will ever listen to s frenchy when it comes to war?? They will be the 1st to surrender. They think we forget how weak they are. Hilarious
she's not clueless, she's paid to say exactly that..
Nonsense!
she is ignorant she should go in the cuisine and cook some hamburgers and shout her mouth professor in what
Why can’t all of you go to the frontline and help Ukraine to fight instead of making big mouth in a comfortable seats?
Go help russians to front, they need koreans like you 😂😂😂.
So true, Life is not important then their ideology in their eyes‼️
Yes south koreans like himfor Ukraine, yeah.@@Howiex-is8gq
Choice is upto Ukrainians. They are supporting them. Not everybody have to fight.
@@Howiex-is8gq no need its self sufficient unlike beggar nation
Zelensky asked for long range missiles and Russia delivered 😂
🤣
It delivered them on time 😂😂
😂😂😂
😂😊😅
imagine your country being bombed constantly and lost your family and you make jokes about it.
How do commentators like this help the end of the war and the arrival of peace? What I see is their desire to escalate the war❤❤❤
Leaks coming out about Trump working together with shareholders involved with Quarden Token
Scam alert 😂
french lady is saying the most but saying nothing. all gibberish
The french talking about winning wars 😂😂😂
Read French history. They were the greatest military power in Europe for a millennium. Ever heard of Charles Martel, Charlemagne. French had many victories against England in Plantagenet times. Napoleon did quite well until invading Russia and even then won Borodino battle.
Lol😂
@@DaniRaj666they have no idea about history ignore them
@@hemanshuambani9572 Napoleon won Austerlitz and Borodino. He conquered and burned Moscow. He lost the war because everybody ganged up against him. He won most of the main battles but overstretched in his megalomania.
Spoken like a true ignoramus. France has one of the greatest military histories .
And the French has contributed embarrasingly little compared to other European countries. She is a perfect example of their weakness.
Try inviting someone that knows about war and geopolitics like Colonel Douglas MacGregor. A realist perspective.
Don't listen to that woman she is so lie
yes she its pro ukrine hole EU its same
This woman in the Studio is mad... She thinks that Putin is blufing...
Nuclear blackmail cannot succeed. We take the risk on for our beautiful Europe.
She is talking garbage
Totally misconceptions about China. They never have invaded other countries, the only concerns are Taiwan and their domestic affairs.
🤔The Islands that are Philippine territories, independent Tibet ?
@@JamesC785Tibet has always been China
If china never invaded any country in the past, it doesn’t follow that it will never invade any country in the future
They invaded Tibet
@@JamesC785 should the 4 philippine colonizers remind you of what invasion means?
She is right about inique heritage of Odessa. Beatiful russian city.
All four guests are pro-Ukraine, so where is the debate? or just propaganda?!
exactly!!!
Don’t poke Russia any more.
Russia will make Ukraine small again
Is this the standard of French debate. Shockingly poor.
listening to this discussion is a waste of time
One of the biggest problems is our empty thinktanks. They make a lot of noise.
This interview panel is a joke🤣😅
It's just sn echo chamber 😆 🤣
Hanna you should see Gaza. You should thank God your enemy is not Israel.
How did they manage to get so many grotesque people together in the same programme? And how did Marie get appointed when she doesn't appear to able to separate bile and bigotry from political analysis? Truly mystifying
Funny how these embassies start closing fast 💨 . Then reopen when safe to do so . To start intimidating again . And they got advance notice .
How such an uninformed person be a professor. Is she teaching at a French university? If so, what a shame.
This guy on the left made my day love it
Yeah, he seems to understand things the others do not.
@@IB4UUB4ME like what B's from the main stream media,,, hypocrites
Mario the prof must stop living in eutopia.........
This theatre is not a lecture room.......
It is not academia.........
The hit on Dnipro using the experimental ballistic, is a shocker to the west...........!!🤔
Let's face it, the air defense could not see it come , nor hit.....
We are talking of, French , American, British , Germany defence systems combined ...... were unable to stop this ICBM.......
So stop being academic here.......
The USA , the most powerful Nation today, shut it's embassy in anticipation......... What is the frech professor dreaming about.......
Russias threat of using tactical nuclear......... Is not a bluff...!! 🤔
She must stop lying to Ukrainians.......
It is impossible as we speak for Ukraine to beat Russia in this war....... Its a pipe dream.
Don’t mix Africa with Europe issues, we have many issues to solve in Africa.
Echo chamber.😅😅Russia deranged syndrome.
Marie Mendras is as silly as she looks, should have just kept quiet. Are they giving professorships for free now?
😂😂😂 talk about liberal echo chamber....lol you clows are in for a very rude wakeup call, clearly the old lady has no idea what she is talking about...
This woman who many children do you have.l
Let you and your children go first
What did Putin say? "There will always be a response."
Is this a media house or a propaganda medium.? How come out of 4 commentators none is from the Russian side? Won't this stain the paint of your integrity?
We showed weakness all along. If you understand Putin you would know that.
I am sick of Americans drumming up war and talking out of place while threatening all of humanity from a different continent.
Just a reminder, "all of humanity" includes America too, they still live on this planet, where "continents" are connected, by land, water and human values.
Let’s hope Trump can put an end to this madness. Your guests are terrible. Invite Russians and find out from the source what Russians really think instead of all this speculative diatribe.
jumbled talk, incoherent analysis, what is happening to western intelligentsia, or inviting the wrong experts to the studio, very disappointed, france 24 can do a better job!
Zelensky : "I don't need a ride. I need my last rites". 😁
This discussion is laughable with their so called analysis and knowledge of Putin, now called even a dictator.
Of course it is... What do you expect from the French??? Even that gas debacle in Germany.... France cancelled the construction of a gas pipeline from the Iberian peninsula to Germany!!! Nowwww they're selling energy to Germany!!! They're PLAYING THE GAME bro! The woman professor talking about Propaganda and Aggression is like a psychopath talking about compassion... They have NONE! France acts like they all innocent and pure... THEY AREN'T. They too have colonies and took a dump in many of them
this is not even worth watching
and why do you watch? you mental?
Until you invite somebody reasonable from Russia, you will continue hearing this meaningless chat of incompetent people.
Does such a person exist?
I listen to the professor & the only thing that comes to mind is, “ thick as a brick.”
The whole european countries proved spine less cocktails
What a silly group of panelists. Get some guest who live in reality on.
after seeing oreshnik i immediately thought of the song grease lightning
I always enjoy 'The Debate' when Craig is on the panel.We need more people like him .He always says what needs to be said
Could you imagine living through the bombings and displacement and having to listen to all the other people making decisions about what you can do to protect yourself?
Just as it was in the beggining
The USA retorric is very bad. You just forget how everything started. From Maidan to nowdays. I think you still have response from Russia, since you think they are weak.
The ‘debates’ are always ridiculous on this site but this one tops it up…
This woman get information from criminals
U have to convince people that Putin is the aggressor …I mean man😂😂😂now what nato has done to other countries no one think they are the aggressor NATO is
French professor symbolizes is what exactly happens in French society which is total clueless what’s going on in the world and take macron in that account
How much the Ukraine war is on "Putin's terms" depends on the EU. I hope the EU is strong.
Europe has no say. The US and Russia will negotiate about this. European leaders have castrated themselves.
Hoping the EU is strong ! Please, allow me to laugh at this joke. If not for the USA, Europe's leaders would crawl back into their caves. to hide from reality.
It will be very simple the Russian Church and the Russian Language and the Russian ethnicity to be protected in the Ukranian constitution and all 5 regions will be recognized by Ukraine as Russian also Ukraine will become neutral and will be able to join the EU but never NATO. 😇
Nice! Can we also have the US return or give to Mexico - California, New Mexico, Texas, Colorado, Nevada? And also have Spanish as the main official language of the US. And have mexicans ethnicity protected, including open borders permanent policy. And also have some Russian and Chinese troops invited in Mexico. And have Mexico tell the US which treaties or organizations should be part of. This sounds so nice!
@@jorgemachado669 if Mexico is able to achieve all that I don't see the problem
And you will gain nothing from it. Your elites will just buy themselves more yachts and property in the west.
French Brilliance : The ICBMmmmm was a perepegaaaadaaa and we need to ignooor it. I think even if they hit the Refill Tower, they'll say it's a Prepegaaaaadaaa.
Can't understand the discussion! Lot of conflicting statements.
It's always going to be a problem for the United States because we care about human rights.
Oh brother the yelling dude is back 😪
Empty vessels makes the most noise
Russia advance is is started in sumi and harkov regions to create buffer zone as created in south and east ukraine. Definately Russian forces advance will continue to zaparoze city and east side of denpr river.
She is saying Putin cannot risk a nuclear strike, at the same time saying Putin is not predictable. What a clueless, contradicting and confused analyst.
"Bear Hunting with the Politburo" by Craig Copetas - I'd like to read this book.
What are you all complaining about. The lady is right and tells the truth about Putin and the war as of now.
This Craig guy is too emotional and lost perspective
Slava russia
Jeffrey Sachs, John Mearsheimer, Douglas Macgregor, Scott Ritter, Aaron Mate, Gilbert Doctorow, Phil Giraldi, Tony Shaffer, Chas Freeman, Max Blumenthal - that's the people you should listen to but that's the people you will never see on this channel..
You forgot “The Duran”, and “The New Atlas”. Those channels are a geopolitical treasure trove
Aha... So, Putins propaganda crew outside of Ruzzia is what we should be listening to?.. Why not make RT the only legit news source while you're at it?..🤔 Have the Kremlin rule all?..🧐😘
Since the West was almost neutral, blind, and deaf with assistance to Ukraine, now is the time to pay the price for indifference...
Thanks France 24 .. we must in Europe speak more about what's happening in Ukraine ..
Ukraine is exclusively European problem not worlds problem
It's a bit confusing for me, I'm viewing from Toronto Canada. But I do follow geopolitics quite closely. My question is for the producers of your segments. Surely, they've done the resume legitimacy of all the important guests this show brings on for its expert panels... But twice now, I've recently seen representatives from the "Heritage Foundation" . You do know who they are ~ yes? They are part of the architecture behind project 2025. They are very determined MAGA loyalists... They don't represent a legitimate think tank organization... They are hard ideologues and propagandists... How can you showcase them? Is it just to "beef-up", the contrasting voices on the show? Make it seem more intellectually entertaining for your audience?? That's a harmful bit of "ratings at any cost" methodology . They shouldn't be showcased on a programme of your credible standards.
Putin said, "Secretary Baker promised that NATO would not expand even an inch eastward." However, Gorbachev himself, who met with Secretary Baker on February 9, 1990, stated in Russia Beyond the Headlines (Russian English-language media) on October 16, 2014, "The issue of NATO expansion itself was not raised at that meeting. Putin's story is a fabrication. I can state this with confidence." At that time, Gorbachev's Soviet Union, which promoted democratization, was no longer the enemy of the Western countries, but was expected to adopt democracy and become their ally or partner. There was no need to make such a promise in such a political situation.
Ukraine is a sovereign nation and therefore free to join or not to join NATO. This is none of Russia's business.
Lies
Please petition your politicians to express your outrage about this NATO actions!
This lady is unbelievable. She says don't pay attention to Putin. And say it's propaganda. She is propaganda herself. Unbelievable. Irresponsible
Europe start supplying the weapons all you want because America will not be there to back you up I suggest you think twice before you do this.
Is propergander continue,
You'll cry for Ukraine
Nobody knows who the elites in the west Putin is talking about 😂😂 like nobody knows in the entire studio
Half way into the video, i am still waiting for a debate to begin.
The debate of the sames. Better than Putin is?😮😮😮 It is very clear at the beginning the nonsense on the table.
Who vetted Marie Mendras for this debate. It is a shame a whole professor subjective and ignorant to the facts
Only because Russia only have 19 jet tanker and 1 aircraft carrier, Russia has no chance in a conventional war. These two things are really important, nato have 20 aircraft and 700 tanker. Without that, they cannot go too far
and yet nobody seems to draw the parallel between the behavior of the USA regarding Palestine and their behavior regarding the Ukraine conflict.... How can you possibly believe that a nation that has been in conflict for more than 95% of its existence is the harbinger of peace? How can you believe that the only nation on Earth to drop not one, but two atomic bombs on civilian cities is somehow interested in peace?
I like that guy Craig Copetas! We - people of the free world need to wake up
Wow, the united states has become so irresponsible. What if something bad happens. What do we do to the people responsible for ignoring the signals? Coptas is the biggest idiot of all.
WHAT A MESS THIS WORLD IS ‘ EH?
I agree with the Daily Beast gentlemen.
This woman you don't know what Putin is.
If you try Russia you will see and understand
Old woman is clueless about what cause the war
I have realize that also. She thinks we are mad.
In 2000, Russia held its first presidential election, and Putin, who pledged to "democratize Russia and double the national economy," was elected. In 2002, Putin enthusiastically attended the NATO conference in Rome and requested that Russia join NATO. However, since Russia's progress in democratization had not yet met NATO's standards, it was treated as an associate member for the time being. It was only natural that Ukraine, seeing this, would aim to join NATO. However, Putin then halted Russia's democratization and steered it toward authoritarianism. He then began to distance himself from NATO and became hostile. In other words, Ukraine is not to blame for anything. Putin's selfish behavior is solely to blame.
But both Prof. John Mearsheimer and Jeffrey Sachs blame the West for not keeping up with its promise of NATO not expanding one inch eastward.
In fact, after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, NATO has gained 13 more members. Russia had repeatedly warned against this. The last straw was Ukraine applying for NATO membership which even Merkel opposed.
You don't have any margin to blame U.S. for anything? Not even that tiny tini just very very little chance that the U.S who attacked Iraq on complete false pretext and the whole N.A.T.O nation leaders lied knowingly? 😮
Maybe he wanted to join because he felt safer that way. Why did he change his mind? Zucchini is not a democratically elected president and it would have made sense to make peace with his neighbor. The stuff that was happening in that country should not have been allowed to happen.
@@allegrap1054 Why did Putin change his mind? Perhaps he gave up on democratizing Russia halfway through. He realized that Russians prefer dictatorial structures of power, and turned his political course toward dictatorship. This led him to turn away from NATO, which was calling for democratization, and to hate NATO even more. As the years passed, Putin himself became more and more like Hitler, as his personal dictatorship deepened.
Lol
Forgiving the $4.7 billion which were sent to Ukraine, then given to various high ranking visitors in the form of coffers full of cash?
The funny thing is that. Listen to old folk who about to die in 5 to 10 years time. Wanna disappear all of us because most of them already fail in their lives. Sad world
Send nato army in!
Sure, so long as the United States is not part of that NATO army.
Send the weak Europeans
12:11 unfortunately this professor hasn’t been in the military and doesn’t understand the real issues with the war and how Ukraine is really being screwed on both ends
All these quest are crazy especially the lady
The French professor is deluded
Ladies are still living in their minds, not in reality
We the people of Loy Afghanistan/Pashtoonkhwa want to help the needy people of Ukraine. They have been suffering a lot, That’s enough. Russia must go back.
good discussion, unfortunately the audio is very bad
If EU no independent policy ,only following USA policy of entering war , will gain big losses at end.
where did u find this woman