@@canaris32 They actually smelted down the bulk of them for their metal... And many others were shipped to private collections around the world. What you see is just a fraction of what once was.
@@spacewhale8279 He knew, he was just being intimidated by what they represent ... Just like the narrator said these pieces do to many people like him.
Just looking at the beautiful motifs on the garment worn by many West Africans is reason enough to believe these guys have a thriving culture and endowed with tremendous artistic sense.
@@iberedemobot857 The jackass is jealous of Africans. You can see by his trolling African videos and attempt at manipulating history with thought up lies to discredit facts. There was no history of Arabs in Africa before Jesus ran to EGYPT. Egyptians were smithing iron and gold before Jesus was born No Islamic religion in existence. Nothing like Arabs then.
@@Obs23456 "The peoples of ancient Egypt, in the aforementioned tropical and semi-tropical/arid tropic zones, show clear limb proportion characteristics of tropically adapted people, and more closely resemble other tropically adapted Africans on the continent, than Europeans or Middle Easterners. (Raxter and Ruff 2008, Zakrewski 2003, 2007; Holliday et al, 2003, Kemp, 2005)" Source: www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=scholarcommons.usf.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi%3Farticle%3D4500%26%26context%3Detd&ved=2ahUKEwiA8YHip7jiAhWCr3EKHY_FBjwQFjAAegQIBBAB&usg=AOvVaw2ewGqY_wOQJlrxGq1iK0x2
@@Obs23456 King Tut dna by Zahi Hawass Strongest Affinity with people of the Great Lakes countries like Rwanda, Kenya etc. Source: www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.dnatribes.com/digest_articles.php&ved=2ahUKEwi7gaSC2LTiAhUDGewKHYxqA3MQFjAFegQIARAB&usg=AOvVaw2AvY-BWU5HWpvqxmzdFB9q Ramses 3 showed up with the same results. "These results indicate that both Ramesses III and Unknown Man E (possibly his son Pentawer) shared an ancestral component with present day populations of Sub-Saharan Africa.... A previous issue of DNA Tribes Digest identified African related ancestry for King Tut and other royal mummies from the Amarna Period. In this issue, results indicate that the later pharaoh Ramesses III also inherited alleles that are most frequent in present day populations of Sub-Saharan Africa. This provides additional, independent evidence of Sub-Saharan African ancestry (possibly among several ancestral components) for pharaonic families of ancient Egypt.....In addition, these DNA match results in present day world regions might in part express population changes in Africa after the time of Ramesses III. In particular, DNA matches in present day populations of Southern Africa and the African Great Lakes might to some degree reflect genetic links with ancient populations (formerly living closer to New Kingdom Egypt) that have expanded southwards in the Nilotic and Bantu migrations of the past 3,000 years (see Figure 1)" Source: www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.dnatribes.com/digest_articles.php&ved=2ahUKEwirzqq82LTiAhVSsaQKHc5QBFEQFjAFegQIAxAB&usg=AOvVaw2AvY-BWU5HWpvqxmzdFB9q
Not all. The Ife statues are in Nigeria (although these were loaned out to the British museum before being returned, whereas the Bronzes should simply be returned not 'loaned' back to Nigeria)
@Loki &Loki The narcissism and blatant racism in your comment is disgusting to say the least. I'm African, we wouldn't have languages with scripts and alphabets just for the joy of it. Of course you've never heard of the meroetic script, tifinagh, geez, hieroglyphics, nsibidi, adrinkra and many others.
@Loki &Loki The thing is, why does the lack of full/complete/formal writing systems get pinned solely on Africa when many other cultures didn't have their own indigenous form of writing and communication? Oral tradition was present elsewhere.
@Loki &Loki There is no contradiction. Comments like yours tend to have a particular focus on Africa, making it out to be some backwards outlier for lacking a writing system when as mentioned, there were other cultures that were in a similar situation, also relying on Oral tradition. It also is rather lazy of you (and reveals your mindset) to throw about the term 'lazy' in your description of a people because they did things differently to others.
@Loki &Loki Now you've resulted to insults ("carer"??? ) thus revealing your lack of self control and ability to debate sensibly. Oh well. Moving on...
“Africa had no history or civilization for thousands of years” Timbuktu: y’all heard something? Nubia: Axum: Great Zimbabwe: Benin city: nah, let’s continue on with our day
Factz Again , nobody “FORGOT “ it 🤦🏿♂️. The point is that he literally just choose a select few from each region to prove a point, his comment wasn’t about listing all the powerful African states... Also, The Arjuran weren’t the only to beat an European in Naval battle, the Mali Empire did so as well in the 1400’s, just saying
Factz Incorrect, Portuguese and Mali did have a naval war, the reason was to stop the Portuguese raids but the manner of battle was naval. That’s basic african history not “ a lie”
You do realise one of the main motivating factors for the invasion of Benin is because your state refused to stop the practice of human sacrificial crucifixion, and selling slaves to Arab traders who had replaced the Portuguese after 1836. Maybe deal with your own historic crimes before you start pointing fingers.
Most of history is stained by one crime or another; in every country so thats not an argument. I don't believe that is the sole reason for the invasion if it is one at all. I'm not pointing fingers but I said what I said; it should be returned
godscop999 what gives you the impression that there are no Nigerian museums? Check again; besides I don't know why you think you have a say over property that is not yours.
Abigail Eshigbemeh Nigeria, with a Sunni north and Christian south. Sharia law applied in some states, more to come. Boko Haram at large, unstable nations surrounding. Ethnocentrism, tribalism, secessionist movements, recent civil war. Not to mention the hugely growing population. C’mon, really?!
These skills and art works are till today carried out in Benin by only one Ancestral lianage which stays in Igun Street in Benin metropolis. No other families are allowed to make cast with bronze except that very families in Igun. They are the most creative with bronze artifacts
They aren't masks you doughnut, they are bronze cast plaques with very advanced intricate detailing. They adorned the palace walls before the country was betrayed by trade partners, invaded, and stolen as they burned the palace to the ground.
The denial of African history is a pillar of white supremacy. The fact that the British aren't returning the art to Benin is part of that white supremacy too --- it displays a perception that Benin/African people are under control of Britain --- to British citizens and tourist visiting the museum. All these efforts were originally formed when it became fully aware that Pythagoras, Archimedes, Euclid learned math/science/philosophy from the Kemetians. All this hatred/jealousy/distortion because of pride and not wanting to admit that the African people were the source of the enlightenment and the economic saviors of Europe / the "new world" as a whole --- LoL. White supremacy is basically hating how everything unfolded in history and hoping to lie about it to make yourself feel better. ;P Pride comes before a great fall.
BLACK HISTORY DID NOT START YESTER YEAR. WE HAD RISEN AND ARE RESPOSIBLE FOR THE UPLIFTING OF THE ANCIENT WORLD.LONG BEFORE THE INDUS AND YELLOW RIVER SOCIETY. THE EUROPEANS ARRIVED YESTERDAY . IN THE LAST DAYS ALL WILL BE REVEALED.WHEN WE LIE WE ARE TELLING LIES TO OURSELVES.MOST HUMAN BEINGS CAN REASON AND KNOW THE TRUTH. THE BENIN BRONZE IS THE TIP OF THE ICEBERG.ALL THIS NOT VERY CLEVER AFTER ALL. RETURN THE BRONZE AND ALL THAT WAS TAKEN. FREE YOUR MINDS.
They're not returning the Elgin. Marble's either. Suppose that's white supremacy too. You jump on every little thing because of your inferiority complex. Would these bronze's have been curated and preserved in Benin do you think or would they have made it to the black market.? Nobody hid this. Why would Europeans teach " your" history anyway? It was Europe that taught you everything you know. Be real and stop being childish ffs!
Its there cause they don't want to return it & are using many poor excuses for keeping all artifacts they've stolen or destroyed over the past 600 years
Legally they are allowed to be returned to the place of origin. But due to political instability and turmoil it's usually agreed that the artefacts are safer kept and maintained at the British museum for the time being.
@@elleyonaspg9580kun nope and Benin City was mostly in western Nigeria. They can definitely handle their own artefacts (as they did centuries ago). Regardless, the fate of the artefacts should be decided by those who it belongs to, not the ones who stole and lied about it.
The thieves have refused to release them peacefully because they are still profiting from Them . It’s always hard for people to get rid of privileges . The income is too good to let go
You know the Republic of Benin and Nigeria (Benin Kingdom) are different, right? The country of Benin has no connection to Benin City in modern Nigeria, nor to the Benin Bronzes. Benin kingdom may have included parts of the present-day Republic of Benin at some point, but the main area of the Benin Kingdom was in south-west Nigeria e.g. Benin city. That's where these were stolen from and that's where the Oba (King) resided. Many present-day countries took inspiration from the past kingdoms or empires. Before the present day Ghana was called Ghana, they took inspiration from The Ghana Empire ( c. 700 until c. 1240), properly known as Wagadou and present-day southeastern Mauritania and western Mali.
@robert howard the country benin where once called dahomey..cos of the influenced of Benin city(Edo) in dahomey(west Africa) they took right from the then oba of benin to change the from dahomey to republic of benin
@@supergay6479 Damn right. The cave beasts knew they couldn't defeat Tyrone on physical power alone, so they crawled to the Asians who taught them how to make guns.
@@brucedobson5285 ACTUALLY WE HAVE A SUPERIORITY COMPLEX if anything. By the way...If you can't spell African...then we already know we are talking to a racist devil with hate in his heart AND NO HIGH INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY. WE ARE NOT EQUALLY YOKED. You are waaaaay beneath me. THEREFORE I will leave you to enjoy your hatred by yourself and Trumpanzees who may think the same as you.
Why conquer or steal something that has no value? Control Africa, and you control the world. I. AM. A descendant of the founders of civilization, master builders, and geniuses...
@Julio Ernesto Moreta Castillo Y’alls limited world view and lack of knowledge of human history is imbecilic and entertaining. Don’t be ashamed, or jealous you guys are part of this legacy too.
david nichols Europeans 'still' extract the abundant life that's 'still' present in Africa. (FACTS)If this extraction of the land stops what would really become a shit hole? The East or the West? The West heavily relies on the East for the way of 'Living' ignorant racist people don't know this but some do and perpetuate negativity. david nichols, you probably fit in that bracket for that dum comment. Very stupid!
@@ElusiveCube Proud of copulating with donkeys or worshipping a pedophile/child rapist? www.thesun.co.uk/news/4247444/fifteen-teens-treated-for-rabies-after-gang-rape-of-donkey-as-cops-urge-anybody-else-who-admired-the-beast-to-turn-themselves-in-to-avoid-disease-spreading/ Sure, Jan. Such a WONDERFUL culture to be proud of! LMBO!!!
I saw these in may at the British Museum. Felt happy to see them but sad they were not in their rightful place. Am from Edo state, Nigeria and grew up hearing stories of this magnificent sculptures we had.
The assumption that African civilizations weren't capable of producing or appreciating fine art is exactly the mentality that led colonial Britain into justifications for enslaving Africans like beasts. It makes one appreciate the British Museum scene from the Black Panther movie a lot more!
It's no assumption, during the time benin kingdom existed the notre dame had already been built the mona lisa was painted so were michelangelo's fresques in the italian churches. By comparison with the art that was being made in europe during that time (1180 - 1897) and the benin kingdom, the art from the benin kingdom was considerably less impressive so I would think they had every right to think so. And did you also now about the horrific treatment of millions of white slaves under islamic arab rule during the same period? No they only teach you about the struggles of black people in history as if they were the only people ever systematically mistreated.
@@willlee5853 Nice "whataboutism!" The video your commenting on said it was an assumption. However If one thinks about the pyramids, or the rock hewn Cristian churches in Lilabela Ethopia your statements are seen as purely ignorant. Let's not forget Cathage was in North Africa either. Also Benin as of 2013 is not only a quarter Muslim, it's a quarter Roman Catholic. How do you think they became Catholic? Lastly I am of Irish descent and know the story of the Barbary Pirates well (NOT from Benin though) Also the hidden history of Irish indentured slaves that were my first American ancestors. The one fact has nothing to do with the other my Bulgarian friend!
@Bro9650 The Aztecs etc. atleast had a calendar, written language and rather advanced agriculture which in the end didn´t matter as they were conquered by a superior civilization. The Sahara desert can and have always been traversed and if the Europeans could come to Africa then the Africans should also have come to Europe but i guess that´s rather difficult if you haven´t even invented the boat. Africa was only an important trading hub for Africans, and then to Europeans when they arrived but still India and China was a much more valuable trade hub. And you say yourself that you´ve never even had a written language after thousands of years that´s rather pathetic. And don´t ever compare Japanese with an average IQ of 110 to Africans with an average IQ of around 70, that´s insulting to the Japanese.
@Bro9650 The thing is that humans are supposed to have originated from Africa so Africans should have been first with everything not the other way around as it is. Ofcourse Japan got most of it´s language from China as humans settled in Japan moving eastwards from China, same thing with Greeks from Phoenicians, and also these peoples are genetically similar which Africans and Arabs aren´t. Latin is a European language and the Latin letters are the ones were using now.
@Jo Sm you're very foolish, Europeans can't tell me about my narratives, if you want authentic one read the books from professor Egharevba not those ones written by the same westerners that conquered us, if you're not stupid of course they'll write something that benefits them, so everyone can think the white supremacists are the most perfect being, sorry I'm not like you, I'm proud of my cultural heritage 😉
@Anthony. Yes, that's why the British tried to erase benin language then introduced the Yoruba and Igbo language in Edo state but God is more than them.
As an Indonesian, I'm actually quite disappointed we don't have *more* Asian-African art in Europe. It's interesting that the countries with smallest representation in UK museums are those least popular with British tourists.
I am from Europe, and it breaks my heart every day to see what was done to the Ashanti kingdom and Benin kingdom! I cannot imagine how painful this would be for Nigerians, Ghanaians or other Western Africans. How inspirational, beautiful and magical it would be, that I as a European could visit the old town of Kumasi or Benin city and see the wonder of those old cultures, just as I can indulge in the beauty of Isfahan, Marrakech, Paris, Krakow, Lijiang or Jodhpur, instead I can only see looted objects in a museum in London and a few old pictures and drawings of Kumasi and Benin city. Incredible, I am speechless
Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha!!! You haven’t missed much. Enjoy the culture that sold other africans to the rest of the world in mass quantities. Everything I see so far is rather hideous to see. Give an afro a rope and he wanna be a cowboy! Hahahahahahaha!!
WE ARE WHO WE ARE (1) The Edo Monarchy is not any ordinary monarchy, it is a spiritual institution and the Oba is a deity. He is referred to as the personification of ”ErhimwinIdu” or ”The Spirit of Edo.” There are layers and layers of palace societies around him. They check and balance each other. (2) When the entire empire is threatened, these societies become one major force together with the people. This existed before the British came and continued after. It is beyond politics or local governance. It is a belief system and way of life. (3) The Oba doesn't get power, he is power. He was born as ”ErhimwinIdu” and no Oba has ever passed away before they get on the throne. The shortest reign was of an Oba who was killed by accident during his coronation ceremony by a stay arrow to his forehead. He was already crowned. (4) The line of succession has remained unbroken for generations. It is not something we joke with. Each family also has a family shrine or Ukhure where we also trace our lineage. The Ukhure of Benin is the monarchy and there is a priest who keeps the records. (5) I explained once that the stolen artifacts by the British are not decorations but records. We kept our records in 3D. Christianity came and saw it as ”idolatory” but the same Christian Missionaries came from places with monarchies and records. Charlemagne saved those records. (6) He used Catholic Monks to keep a record of all local practices. Most of the history of Europe would have been lost without the Catholic Church and Charlemagne. The Portuguese came to Edo long before the British and respected our culture. They even gained from it. (7) The battle of 1897 was really to erase something the British feared and I think it was Portuguese influence. Oba Esigie spoke Portuguese and the Edo Monarchy had a long history with Portugal. This is why even the crown prince commands great respect by our Federal Governments. (8) The British couldn't replace Oba Ovoramwen after the war and they couldn't kill him. They deported him and there was no peace until his son who became Eweka II took over. He rebuilt the monarchy and was great grandfather to Oba Ewuare II.The British couldn't replace Oba Ovoramwen after the war and they couldn't kill him. They deported him and there was no peace until his son who became Eweka II took over. He rebuilt the monarchy and was great grandfather to Oba Ewuare II. Ọba gha tó Ọ kpére....isẹ
The British government should return all plundered and stolen objects. Give it all back. Thanks for sharing. Yet everybody but Us benefit from what is ours.
And if it gets finally returned and few decades down the line they get lost, stolen, ruined and even destroyed, you'll probably regret you ever made that suggestion, the same way Obama regrets assassinating Gaddafi. Be careful what you wish for because you might just get it, but never in the form you expected.
Mali take many idea from Arabs and Berbers from North. they dont have stone city wall, old city gates, stone wall, stone building, great sophisticate architecture mosque, palace, fort, citadel,castle any many others.
@@safuwanfauzi5014 Why would they stone when they were not living in areas with large amount of stone? In that case, is the Sumerian civilization not valid as many of its buildings were of clay/mud/reeds? They didn't have an abundance of stone in their architecture either.
When the Brits colonised Zimbabwe 🇿🇼 (Southern Africa) & saw the Great Zimbabwe city built in the 11th century they also refused to believe that my ancestors built it coz there was evidence of trade with the Chinese etc. Early historians claimed it was built by Alexander the Great & for a 100 years natives were not allowed to visit these historical sites. Fortunately we have managed to reclaim most of the stolen art from Europe.
@OMEGA LOLActually Mansa Musa made his wealth off the gold mines in his territory, and the taxes of all trade goods imported/exported and travelling through his realm. The Arabs at this time were soley dependant mainly on acquiring their black slaves from their East African City States. i.e Kilwa, Malindi, Zanzibar, Madagascar, Mombasa etc... They had quicker access to captives from the interior and trade routes crossing the Indian ocean with slaves during the monsoon season than having to travel or aquire captives from all the way over on the other side across the continent. Some slaves however from Mali did make their way north to the Berber territories, however it was GOLD, TAXES n TRIBUTE not slaves that made Mansa Musa the Wealthiest man who ever lived. If he had sold all his neighbours, he could he have "continually" make money from them?? He subjugated, then squeezed profits out of em lol.
@OMEGA LOL I'm not here to convince you with my FACTS on the one who was dubbed the title "LORD OF THE MINES" for his wealth by Europeans and Arabs alike. If he was this monster as you claim then so were his neighbours and everyone else in that age. My point is and will always be that he made his wealth from being the worlds most notable provider of gold and the monies he accumulated coming in out of his Realm. Did he have slaves YES. Did he gain his wealth specifically as you claim by selling off all his neighbours n his own people NO. I supported my claim with facts on specific peoples, time frame, methods and geographic locations. All I'm hearing from you is emotion with nothing to back up the your claims. I'll leave you to your world. Btw You stated Mansa Musa got rich by selling all his neighbours to "The Muslims" Uhmm.... Mansa Musa was a Muslim.
Actually the pourtguese came to Benin because they saw that it was similar to settlements in Europe. Benin was a rich kingdom, the people wore white garments and travelled on wide roads and had feats. It was rich and divine and they wanted evreything.
CoronaVirus is already being sent to ravage them in their millions...but they dont know of Soponna or why he is now set to gradually destroy them. Those artworks are coming back home soon....that much, I know. When exactly, I cant say, but very soon.
I've never seen these! I'm 43 years old! I can't believe I've never seen these!🤯(edit: there are several documentaries on the subject here on RUclips. Fascinating!)
I, a Bini (from Benin Kingdom, Nigeria), like most Binis living today, have never set my eyes on these artworks made by my ancestors. All who consent to these artworks being where they are today, consent to the injustice, theft & evil. And recompense from the most High.
They were given back. Your government gifted them to your old Oba, great family history the guy, whose private property they are now. So you’ll never see them which is a shame. Should’ve booked a flight to Germany 5 years ago, there they were well taken care of and open to the public.
How about repatriations instead? Repatriations, reparations - what's the difference!? Blacks gets a complimentary spear and a Coca-Cola, and are sent back to Africa..
This doesn't show the vast artistry of benin artistry. They did terrecota too. Benin empire is the mother empire to Egypt. The origin of egypt starts in benin . It's no other empire in Africa that has the history that can compete with egypt/nubia ,when it comes to artifacts. On the Benin bronzes you can see their hair style was similar to Egyptians.
@@gingerbreadmangangafarmer2251 Ashanti artifacts were skilled in metallurgy but the Akan kingdom were mainly trading gold or selling gold . There's no kingdom in Africa that can compare to Benin and the Yoruba ,when it comes to artifacts . There are more artifacts underground in Nigeria.
@Alba Celani the half white people coming at you hard lol. guys you still have castles and cathedrals allot of you are more western "white" then i am lol
@Alba Celaniits great you have your own landmarks to cherish still but perhaps they would like to store their stolen are in an African landmarks such as Manhyia palace, Gondar Castle, Grand Mosque of Bamako , BCEAO Tower , Great Mosque of Djenné , Royal Palace of the Oba, Kwame Nkrumah Mausoleum , Krishna Balaram Palace
We will never forget the havoc the British wrecked on our Kingdom and ancestors repatriation or no repatriations we will definitely come for our stolen valuables and mandate some day. Obghatokpere Ise...(long live our Oba 🙏)
Festus Agbongiasede then y don’t we demand for it now sir. It belongs to us so many of our people where killed we still let this people come to our country while they hold our property captive in their home.isee🙏🏿
But after missionaries came and preached Christianity to you guys, you also gave up some of you're ancient artifact to destroy as mark of cleansing from idols god and you obliged. You gave out your civilization because of Western god;those artifact are Africans history but people gave them up to embraced foreign gods.
I was born in Angola 🇦🇴, because war went to Portugal when i was 3 years old,in school what i learn about Africa just about slavery but now with internet I'm so happy to learn Africa have a very rich history.
I've not seen the full documentary, but from this clip it looks to be outstanding and I will seek it out. In a couple of months I hope to produce my own RUclips series on the Benin bronzes but having watched this the bar has just been raised! I agree with David Olusoga as to the tragedy of the bronzes; this is one of the motivations for making my series.
So sad to think how much effort was put into making sure - history of Africa and African Americans has been purposely twisted and destroyed for so long !
You must be African-American youself.. You people always think you are the only black people outside of Africa, so pathetic.. The world does not evolve around you you know.. The Caribbean is also full of black people and so is south-America and Europe. All black people who have tons more knowledge of their true-self than any African-American who still claps for jesus or wait, it’s jahweh now isn’t it…yawnn.. get over yourself.
We are the Children of Great Benin Empire. We are the Owner of the Red Soil. We are the Children of the Cradle of Black Civilization Oba of Benin Kingdom is Our Father and God's Representative to Mankind on Earth to Us all. We are the Children of UMOGUN Oza. We are the Real Children Of Ogiso. Ogidigan is Our Father and the Link between the Benins and Ancestors of Our Land. Everything You see in Benin Kingdom was either won by Love or By Blood but never MONEY, because anything that can be bought has no real values. The Ekpen No'Owa. The OGidigan. The Uku Akpolokpolo. The UMOGUN Oza The Head and Leader of all Edo Race which is His Royal Majesty, Omo N'Oba N'Edo Uku Akpolokpolo, Ewuare II, Oba of Benin is priceless to Us. We will and shall continue to Love Our Dear and Respected Oba. Ovbi' Ekpen N' Owa Ovbi' Adimila Agbaghe, N'Ovbi Olokun Abieyuwa N'Ovbi Odua N'uhe Ovbi' Ada, Ovbi' Eben Ovbi'Ekenekene ma deyo Ovbi'Ekuaho N'Olo, Ovbi'Ekuabo N'Olo Ovbie Ikpinhianbo kpuru no Gb'oduma Nohien utete no gh'ughe s'omwan Ovbi'Oghonwan nei bun aro Ovbi'ode, ode n'ohan ren mu' ete Oba of Benin is the Eminiminimini hope they know the meaning of that word, the UMOGUN is a living Deity, Ọba gha tó Ọ kpére....isẹẹ
For the racists who claim black Africans didn't have a real Civilization, read up on Nubia, Axum and Zimbabwe kingdoms. Also Queen Nizinga, a one eyed warrior fought and be the Portuguese.
Lili Bee I agree. They hold treasures from other countries as well. Then again, there they are for the world to see. Had they remained in Africa i am afraid virtually nobody would know they exist. And those plates are nothing compared to some chest figures of nok cultures nobility.
north those plates are recorded history for the people who created them , it worth alot to them, you reason very low. Why did you think they were kept at the palace?
letloveguard wells They were kept in the palace for the same reason as European monarchs. For the pleasure of themselves and nobility and to make their palace look as pompous as possible. Of course they are important to nigerians. But that doesn't take away from the fact that they are way easier to steal there than in Britain. They should be returned of course but personally I would keep contacts ready to buy them from underworld if and when some get stolen.
@@PrincezzJin why couldn't we just continue to trade our minerals and resources in free open commerce like the rest of the world was doing centuries prior
@@PrincezzJin Most likely prosperous or at least stable, are you so ignorant of history to think Europe colonization of Africa benefitted anyone but Europe.
And yet people ask “can any good thing come out from Africa.?” I’ve said this and will say this again. Ones intelligence is not based on their skin colour. Our efforts have been over look and as the presenter said we are and we’ve seen as savages.
Well, Im. From india, and many of our artwork are still there in the british museum. Fortunately fir us, they couldn't destroy it, but some pieces of it were stolen from us, and we have no "right"to claim it back(!). Unfortunately for you, they destroyed it, nearly wiped it out, and then they tell you that you're savages.
These relics are the genuine historical property of African countries from where these are taken, the point is those who have them realize it now or still don't have the capacity to see that.
Like my mom used to tell me you can't expect for them to teach you right if they don't treat you right. I myself had to get out there and learn about African history.
I was so Impressed and relieved, and proud, and disappointed when first sad the artwork. Why did I not see this work when I was a child? These works are in Museums all over the world. This is a tragedy. They belong to people of Benin origins. I
Why? Have you made these artwork? What kind of "connection" do you, a person of 21st century have with people from the 16th or 19th century? What connection do you have, that an American, European or Asian doesn´t that is reason enough for your claim? You only have nationalistic interest in these arty, the personal interest is not of your concern. And that is just nationalistic propaganda!
Please, the video is about Benin kingdom in Nigeria not Benin republic and please to clear the air, Africa is not a country or a tribe, it's a continent and yes we have access to you tube because not all of us look like the people on UN ads. Please before you have a take on Africa as a continent, live there. Please stop with the assumptions.
Soon (and it's already started) it will be China who will plunder the resources of Africa. If you spend all your time railing against the past you just might miss the dangers that lie ahead. Wealth is power and I know many wish that whites (as if we all share the same culture and beliefs) are going to dissapear but even if we did does that automatically make African or American blacks situation any better? Do you believe that the south Asians, middle eastern and Chinese will share that wealth? They are the ones gaining it faster than anyone after all and will your lot in life improve automatically or will you have a new adversary that feels no guilt or remorse? I'm not British by the way and my people (because once again whites aren't a singular group) have been on the losing end dealing with them but we've moved on, hopefully you can do the same but it takes hard work,ingenuity,a boatload of cash, and leaders who won't bleed you dry as has been the case in so many African countries. When you say "if we displayed them", who's we? People are very tribal whether black, white,yellow, brown,Christian,Muslim, Buddhist,Jewish Zoroastrian, Irish,Bantu, Somalian, Spanish or Cherokee. Believing that any race automatically sides with similarly colored people from a different country is wishful thinking at best and downright dangerous any other time.
@A A Then why are you watching a documentary on our history and culture? Guess we do have one since there are documentaries acknowledging our ancient kingdoms A A.
It was stolen and should be returned. The Vatican vaults need to be opened, publically viewed and returned to every country from which they were taken. This must include the Smithsonian Institution as well.
@@Komeshokakunanwene A thief tries to get what he wants, without the owner noticing. Quietly, in the night, avoiding confrontation. Overtly confronting your opponent, besting him, and walking away with his stuff is not thieving. Want to call it robbery, fine. I'd call it conquest - since the bronzes were not the primary motivation. And let's not pretend the people of Benin themselves, were strangers to conquering others, looting them, enslaving them.
@@teaCupkk we can go on and play around with English, also throw in whataboutisms, but what was done when these Bronzes were taken from rightfull owners was not short of thieving. Robbers take by force, which was done here. They can also chose to kill and leave a trail of destruction, which was done here. They (robbers) refuse to return what they stole, again it is thieving. These people here, who did this to Benin are the human rights champions of today while accusing others of being dictators and ensuring that ICC goes for them.
I am author of the books: The Great Wall of Africa: The Empire of Benin’s 10,000 Mile Long Wall, The Real Wakandas of Africa and The Real Vibranium of Africa (by Maurice Miles Martinez). Most people are unaware that African people built a wall before transatlantic slavery in the Benin empire that is one of the most massive structures in the world. At 10,000 miles long, the Great Wall of Africa contains more material than all of the buildings in New York City’s Manhattan. If cut into 1 meter high blocks, it would wrap around the equator more than 65 times! It is arguably the planet’s greatest man-made structure. Yet, it has been ignored by historians. In my book The Great Wall of Africa: The Empire of Benin’s 10,000 Mile Long Wall, I explore the dimensions of the wall, the history of the Benin Empire’s Kings (Obas) and the stolen Benin Bronzes. These treasures that sit in the world’s museums amount to more than $14 Billion. Most people who read this book are left wondering why they never heard about the Great Wall of Africa in their history classes. The world needs more videos on this topic. Maurice Miles Martinez
These works of Art and Culture are among the items that the colonizers are willing to acknowledge and display. It could be nigh unimaginable what stolen treasures remain hidden!!!
@Carlo Canti I would be proud to be a "dirt poor" farmer because I would know how to make a dollar. I would know how to grow food, process food, and preserve food. You were most likely raised on welfare, food stamps, and a housing subsidy. You are probably raising your children on welfare, food stamps, and a housing subsidy. You don't know how to make a dollar, legally. If you are in "the land of the free" you are still too stupid to farm, to plant anything. You are too stupid to know how to build anything. You are too stupid to make a dollar. I know you are not a "royal" nor a descendant of a "royal". You will always be low class, illegal, and on welfare. Dependent on the government. When you learn how to spell, read, and write at at least a 3rd grade level, then I will talk. In the meantime, I don't talk to trash.
I have a story about a man who makes bread in his community, very good bread best in the area. One day members of the neighboring community raids his bakery, steals his freshly baked bread, kills his wife, kids and parents and forced him in servitude to bake bread for them. They become rich and expand their business, while he suffers in silence. His own nieces and nephews now have a pay a high price for bread their own uncle baked. Just a story you say, and you might be correct, except Europe still has Africa’s ‘freshly baked bread’ and we are still in servitude.
They didn't steal anything dummy, the fought them, beat them, burned the palace to the ground, then took the bronzes as souvenirs. Maybe they should give them back though, make some nice replicas to keep for the museum, and send the originals back.
I know that they belong in Greece not a museum in England. For future interest if you really have an interest in educating someone maybe you shouldn't use words like ignorant. God help your children.
Whoever controls the past controls the future. The more you know, the more you realize you don't know. Truth unites. Control corrupts. Don't let race blind you. Those that seek power want the races fighting with each other.
Why is is do hard to believe Africa has history? Europe and Asia could be as easily dismissed if society had a high audience of prejudice against them, yet we just accept their cultures and history without questioning its authenticity. All of this research put into Africa dismissed by public for a variety of reasons, much is from prejudice. How long would it be before the world accepts Africa for its once glorious past?
This is a demonstration of human capabilities which manifest in many and different forms. African history is human history. Indian, Chinese, European, Maya, Incas, etc is all human history
This brought tears to my eyes looking at the art work of the anicent and to know what has been stolen away from the people Benin. The art needs to be return back to rightful country.
you know that that art in their original sense was never handed to "the people" but stood in the palace of a king!? Yet the idea and reality of museums are to show art etc to the public!
isn't it amazing that the ones that got the thumbs down still don't want to believe and accept that a black man was capable of doing these things that the Most High God created us to do great things in great exploits we not one 3/5 of a person we are whole beings just like anyone else and those thumbs down the Most High will judge you and he is going to judge you because you hate and it's in your heart and if you don't get the hate out of your heart you will be going to a burning Lake of Fire
Now I really really overstand what kilmunger in black panther felt when he was looking at this same art in a museums in the movie. One day in the not so distant future these Europeans will ultimately pay a hefty price for their deeds here on earth... Their children will pay as well.
mazimadu - I'm not from Benin, but according to my DNA test I'm 39% Benin/Togo, which is the highest percentage of my African DNA. This makes me very proud of my ancestry and history!
@@moosaseethi6227 Shut your mouth! And be proud of what? I am Nigerian but not Bini. I started this thread so I can learn about the bronzes FROM THE MOUTHS OF BINI/EDO. They know the language, the culture and history.
Am African don't call Africa a dark continent africa is the richst continent in the world that why the Europeans don't want to let africa alone but now is the time Africa is united free tread only in African continent then you will say the bright africa! !
While many are upset about these works not remaining in their home countries if they had not been stolen/looted they may have been lost forever or melted down by many that did not care about their significance. Sad to admit that with so many wars and upheavals over the centuries many treasures would have been lost if Europeans had not taken them.
What's really sad is that all the wars were started by Europeans so they could plunder. What is most sad is the no matter what. The European is always regarded as the savior to the simple minded.
Let me get it... You start a war to endanger stuff, then you pretend like you're trying to keep the stuff you endangered safe. Make it make sense. Those artworks had been perfectly safe and preserved for centuries. Nothing was going to happen to them if the British hadn't happened.
Every time they search for the truth they find us they dig up earth they find us but still deny African excellence..... Damian Marley
Never in the history of Africa has there been a civilization that can compare to anywhere else in the world. Show me one ruin that can compare?
@@humptysgames9665 dont let me embarrass you
@@damianfung3309 as you literally embarrass your self.
@@humptysgames9665 and your mother too
@@humptysgames9665 You sure?
Best way to convince an entire region they have no history is by destroying everything that defined their history.
Except that they didn't destroy the Benin bronzes, if they had you wouldn't be watching a RUclips video on them.
canaris32 He meant it metaphorically you dumbass.
@@canaris32 They actually smelted down the bulk of them for their metal... And many others were shipped to private collections around the world. What you see is just a fraction of what once was.
@@spacewhale8279I like that. So if I say something patently untrue and someone exposes it as such, I can just claim I was speaking "metaphorically".
@@spacewhale8279 He knew, he was just being intimidated by what they represent ... Just like the narrator said these pieces do to many people like him.
Just looking at the beautiful motifs on the garment worn by many West Africans is reason enough to believe these guys have a thriving culture and endowed with tremendous artistic sense.
lagosian we are still waiting for you to school him oh
@@iberedemobot857 the idiot didn't reply back. I hate talking to dead person.
@@iberedemobot857 The jackass is jealous of Africans. You can see by his trolling African videos and attempt at manipulating history with thought up lies to discredit facts. There was no history of Arabs in Africa before Jesus ran to EGYPT. Egyptians were smithing iron and gold before Jesus was born No Islamic religion in existence. Nothing like Arabs then.
@@Obs23456 "The peoples of ancient Egypt, in the
aforementioned tropical and
semi-tropical/arid tropic zones, show
clear limb proportion characteristics of
tropically adapted people, and more
closely resemble other tropically adapted
Africans on the continent, than
Europeans or Middle Easterners.
(Raxter and Ruff 2008, Zakrewski 2003,
2007; Holliday et al, 2003, Kemp, 2005)"
Source:
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=scholarcommons.usf.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi%3Farticle%3D4500%26%26context%3Detd&ved=2ahUKEwiA8YHip7jiAhWCr3EKHY_FBjwQFjAAegQIBBAB&usg=AOvVaw2ewGqY_wOQJlrxGq1iK0x2
@@Obs23456 King Tut dna by Zahi Hawass
Strongest Affinity with people of the Great Lakes countries like Rwanda, Kenya etc.
Source:
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.dnatribes.com/digest_articles.php&ved=2ahUKEwi7gaSC2LTiAhUDGewKHYxqA3MQFjAFegQIARAB&usg=AOvVaw2AvY-BWU5HWpvqxmzdFB9q
Ramses 3 showed up with the same results.
"These results indicate that both Ramesses III and Unknown Man E (possibly his son Pentawer) shared an ancestral component with present day populations of Sub-Saharan Africa.... A previous issue of DNA Tribes Digest identified African related ancestry for King Tut and other royal mummies from the Amarna Period. In this issue, results indicate that the later pharaoh Ramesses III also inherited alleles that are most frequent in present day populations of Sub-Saharan Africa. This provides additional, independent evidence of Sub-Saharan African ancestry (possibly among several ancestral components) for pharaonic families of ancient Egypt.....In addition, these DNA match results in present day world regions might in part express population changes in Africa after the time of Ramesses III. In particular, DNA matches in present day populations of Southern Africa and the African Great Lakes might to some degree reflect genetic links with ancient populations (formerly living closer to New Kingdom Egypt) that have expanded southwards in the Nilotic and Bantu migrations of the past 3,000 years (see Figure 1)"
Source:
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.dnatribes.com/digest_articles.php&ved=2ahUKEwirzqq82LTiAhVSsaQKHc5QBFEQFjAFegQIAxAB&usg=AOvVaw2AvY-BWU5HWpvqxmzdFB9q
Someome call Kilmonger
Don't need em', TMH said they already in the winepress. . .
daustin8888 😂😂😂😂
daustin8888 lol
👍
🤣🤣🤣
If the Africans had no history, why is their Artistry in the Museum's of Europe.
Not all. The Ife statues are in Nigeria (although these were loaned out to the British museum before being returned, whereas the Bronzes should simply be returned not 'loaned' back to Nigeria)
@Loki &Loki The narcissism and blatant racism in your comment is disgusting to say the least. I'm African, we wouldn't have languages with scripts and alphabets just for the joy of it. Of course you've never heard of the meroetic script, tifinagh, geez, hieroglyphics, nsibidi, adrinkra and many others.
@Loki &Loki The thing is, why does the lack of full/complete/formal writing systems get pinned solely on Africa when many other cultures didn't have their own indigenous form of writing and communication? Oral tradition was present elsewhere.
@Loki &Loki There is no contradiction. Comments like yours tend to have a particular focus on Africa, making it out to be some backwards outlier for lacking a writing system when as mentioned, there were other cultures that were in a similar situation, also relying on Oral tradition.
It also is rather lazy of you (and reveals your mindset) to throw about the term 'lazy' in your description of a people because they did things differently to others.
@Loki &Loki Now you've resulted to insults ("carer"??? ) thus revealing your lack of self control and ability to debate sensibly. Oh well. Moving on...
“Africa had no history or civilization for thousands of years”
Timbuktu: y’all heard something?
Nubia:
Axum:
Great Zimbabwe:
Benin city: nah, let’s continue on with our day
Best comment
No Name nice hahaha 💯
Factz he could add 100 more tbh, this was just to get 1 Major Kingdom from each region
Factz Again , nobody “FORGOT “ it 🤦🏿♂️. The point is that he literally just choose a select few from each region to prove a point, his comment wasn’t about listing all the powerful African states...
Also, The Arjuran weren’t the only to beat an European in Naval battle, the Mali Empire did so as well in the 1400’s, just saying
Factz Incorrect, Portuguese and Mali did have a naval war, the reason was to stop the Portuguese raids but the manner of battle was naval.
That’s basic african history not “ a lie”
Proudly Benin! It should all be returned
You do realise one of the main motivating factors for the invasion of Benin is because your state refused to stop the practice of human sacrificial crucifixion, and selling slaves to Arab traders who had replaced the Portuguese after 1836.
Maybe deal with your own historic crimes before you start pointing fingers.
Most of history is stained by one crime or another; in every country so thats not an argument. I don't believe that is the sole reason for the invasion if it is one at all. I'm not pointing fingers but I said what I said; it should be returned
What, so they can be left unprotected, unseen by many, sold off or destroyed?
Balls to that.
godscop999 what gives you the impression that there are no Nigerian museums? Check again; besides I don't know why you think you have a say over property that is not yours.
Abigail Eshigbemeh
Nigeria, with a Sunni north and Christian south. Sharia law applied in some states, more to come. Boko Haram at large, unstable nations surrounding. Ethnocentrism, tribalism, secessionist movements, recent civil war. Not to mention the hugely growing population.
C’mon, really?!
Everybody has genius in their culture why is this so hard to believe
These skills and art works are till today carried out in Benin by only one Ancestral lianage which stays in Igun Street in Benin metropolis. No other families are allowed to make cast with bronze except that very families in Igun. They are the most creative with bronze artifacts
Easy cause of the rich British ( Europeans) false belief of the white man's burden.
@@BlackDollNerd73 What burden? Please explain.
They aren't masks you doughnut, they are bronze cast plaques with very advanced intricate detailing. They adorned the palace walls before the country was betrayed by trade partners, invaded, and stolen as they burned the palace to the ground.
@J. Coleman Are you implying that Egyptians don´t exist? Egyptians are Arabs just so you know.
The denial of African history is a pillar of white supremacy. The fact that the British aren't returning the art to Benin is part of that white supremacy too --- it displays a perception that Benin/African people are under control of Britain --- to British citizens and tourist visiting the museum. All these efforts were originally formed when it became fully aware that Pythagoras, Archimedes, Euclid learned math/science/philosophy from the Kemetians. All this hatred/jealousy/distortion because of pride and not wanting to admit that the African people were the source of the enlightenment and the economic saviors of Europe / the "new world" as a whole --- LoL. White supremacy is basically hating how everything unfolded in history and hoping to lie about it to make yourself feel better. ;P Pride comes before a great fall.
The truth is coming to light gradually
BLACK HISTORY DID NOT START YESTER YEAR. WE HAD RISEN AND ARE RESPOSIBLE FOR THE UPLIFTING OF THE ANCIENT WORLD.LONG BEFORE THE INDUS AND YELLOW RIVER SOCIETY. THE EUROPEANS ARRIVED YESTERDAY . IN THE LAST DAYS ALL WILL BE REVEALED.WHEN WE LIE WE ARE TELLING LIES TO OURSELVES.MOST HUMAN BEINGS CAN REASON AND KNOW THE TRUTH. THE BENIN BRONZE IS THE TIP OF THE ICEBERG.ALL THIS NOT VERY CLEVER AFTER ALL. RETURN THE BRONZE AND ALL THAT WAS TAKEN. FREE YOUR MINDS.
Oh the irony hahahahhahahaha omg you guys are funny
They're not returning the Elgin. Marble's either. Suppose that's white supremacy too. You jump on every little thing because of your inferiority complex. Would these bronze's have been curated and preserved in Benin do you think or would they have made it to the black market.? Nobody hid this. Why would Europeans teach
" your" history anyway? It was Europe that taught you everything you know. Be real and stop being childish ffs!
@@JohnSmith-qq8tx STFU LYING DEVIL
So why are these pieces of artwork still in the British museum?
Its there cause they don't want to return it & are using many poor excuses for keeping all artifacts they've stolen or destroyed over the past 600 years
Legally they are allowed to be returned to the place of origin. But due to political instability and turmoil it's usually agreed that the artefacts are safer kept and maintained at the British museum for the time being.
is there political instability and turmoil in Benin?
@@elleyonaspg9580kun nope and Benin City was mostly in western Nigeria. They can definitely handle their own artefacts (as they did centuries ago). Regardless, the fate of the artefacts should be decided by those who it belongs to, not the ones who stole and lied about it.
Ashe'
Bring them back to where they belong! There they have true value. The kind of value no one can buy!
A museum is white man's trophy case.
W
@@tnbn55 for Killing stealing and destroying. He has No own History. Only ourstory
The thieves have refused to release them peacefully because they are still profiting from
Them . It’s always hard for people to get rid of privileges . The income is too good to let go
They use them for witchcraft. Thats how they oppress. The demons are crafty
These were the first record before the oba was the ogiso....
Ogiso Igodo (40 BCE - 16 CE).
Ogiso Ere (16 - 66 CE).
Ogiso Orire (66 - 100 CE).
Ogiso Odia (385 - 400 CE),
Ogiso Ighido (400 CE - 414 CE),
Ogiso Evbuobo (414 -432 CE),
Ogiso Ogbeide (432 - 447 CE),
Ogiso Emehe (447 - 466 CE),
Ogiso Ekpigho (466 - 482 CE),
Ogiso Akhuankhuan (482 - 494 CE),
Ogiso Efeseke (494- 508 CE),
Ogiso Irudia (508- 522 CE).
Ogiso Orria (522- 537 CE),
Ogiso Imarhan (537- 548 CE)
Ogiso Etebowe (548- 567 CE),
Ogiso Odion (567- 584 CE),
Ogiso Emose (584- 600 CE),
Ogiso Ororo (600- 618 CE), .
Ogiso Erebo (618- 632 CE),
Ogiso Ogbomo (632 -647 CE),
Ogiso Agbonzeke (647-665 CE),
Ogiso Ediae (665- 685 CE),
Ogiso Orriagba (685- 712 CE)
Ogiso Odoligie (712- 767 CE),
Ogiso Uwa (767- 821 CE)
Ogiso Eheneden (821-871 CE),
Ogiso Ohuede (871- 917 CE),
Ogiso Oduwa (917- 967 CE),
Ogiso Obioye (967- 1012 CE),
Ogiso Arigho (1012- 1059 CE),
Ogiso Owodo (1059-1100 CE),
Pre-Imperial Obas of Benin (pre-1280 - 1440)[1]Edit
Eweka I
Uwuakhuahen
Henmihen
Ewedo
Oguola
Edoni
Udagbedo
Ohen
Egbeka
Orobiru
Uwaifiokun
Obas of the Benin Empire (1440-1897)Edit
There is some uncertainty in the dates of the reigns of some of the earlier warrior kings[2]
Ewuare I (1440-1473)
Ezoti (1473-1474)
Olua (1475-1480)
Ozolua (1480-1504)
Esigie (1504-1547)
Orhogbua (1547-1580)
Ehengbuda (1580-1602)
Ohuan (1602-1656)
Ohenzae5)
Akenkpaye (1675-1684)
Akengbedo (1684-1689)
Ore-Oghene (1689-1701)
Ewuakpe (1701-1712)
Ozuere (1712-1713)
Akenzua I (1713-1740)
Eresoyen (1740-1750)
Akengbuda (1750-1804)
Obanosa (1804-1816)
Ogbebo (1816)
Osemwende (1816-1848)
Adolo (1848-1888)
Ovonramwen Nogbaisi (1888-1914) (exiled to Calabar by the British in 1897)
Post-Imperial Obas of Benin (1914-Present)Edit
Eweka II (1914-1933)
Akenzua II (1933-1978)
Erediauwa (1979-2016)
Ewuare II (2016-)
i've always been obsessed with these bronzes and was very happy when i checked my dna and found i'm mostly benin and then secondly from ghana.
Mjosiah, very interesting dont know if you noticed but they are wearing fringes on their garments?. They are indeed a very special people.
You know the Republic of Benin and Nigeria (Benin Kingdom) are different, right? The country of Benin has no connection to Benin City in modern Nigeria, nor to the Benin Bronzes. Benin kingdom may have included parts of the present-day Republic of Benin at some point, but the main area of the Benin Kingdom was in south-west Nigeria e.g. Benin city. That's where these were stolen from and that's where the Oba (King) resided. Many present-day countries took inspiration from the past kingdoms or empires. Before the present day Ghana was called Ghana, they took inspiration from The Ghana Empire ( c. 700 until c. 1240), properly known as Wagadou and present-day southeastern Mauritania and western Mali.
@robert howard the country benin where once called dahomey..cos of the influenced of Benin city(Edo) in dahomey(west Africa) they took right from the then oba of benin to change the from dahomey to republic of benin
@robert howard one love💚👌
Because you can through through the Atlantic slavery trade before that you were in Israel. Don’t let them lie to you.
WHY ARE MY ANCESTORS BRONZE ART IN BERLIN AND BRITAIN AND ALL WE GOT IS A FEW IN NIGERIA? I'm not even Nigerian. Shouldn't they be in BENIN.
Because MY ANCESTORS couldn't defend themselves from the BRITISH BVLLS .
@@supergay6479 Damn right. The cave beasts knew they couldn't defeat Tyrone on physical power alone, so they crawled to the Asians who taught them how to make guns.
Bruce Dobson whitcuok
@@supergay6479 funny and real comeback
@@brucedobson5285 ACTUALLY WE HAVE A SUPERIORITY COMPLEX if anything.
By the way...If you can't spell African...then we already know we are talking to a racist devil with hate in his heart AND NO HIGH INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY. WE ARE NOT EQUALLY YOKED. You are waaaaay beneath me. THEREFORE I will leave you to enjoy your hatred by yourself and Trumpanzees who may think the same as you.
Say it again, we are descendants of the founders of civilization, master builders, and geniuses!
Lmao Keep up the group think, and I don't think history agrees with you.
Why conquer or steal something that has no value? Control Africa, and you control the world. I. AM. A descendant of the founders of civilization, master builders, and geniuses...
@@4RunnnerKing lol,yes,and today,2019 you are still living in mud huts....
@Julio Ernesto Moreta Castillo Y’alls limited world view and lack of knowledge of human history is imbecilic and entertaining. Don’t be ashamed, or jealous you guys are part of this legacy too.
@Carlo Canti you barbarian stole everything
The devil comes rob kill steal,destroy
@david nichols a land that's not yours not our fault you were born on shot hole mineraless continent
david nichols Africa has the richest history on earth. Get out of Africa and stop raping the land.
KUSHITIC WONDERING that is why Europeans are dying off. Judgement is upon y’all. Now go tremble somewhere else.
david nichols Europeans 'still' extract the abundant life that's 'still' present in Africa. (FACTS)If this extraction of the land stops what would really become a shit hole? The East or the West? The West heavily relies on the East for the way of 'Living' ignorant racist people don't know this but some do and perpetuate negativity. david nichols, you probably fit in that bracket for that dum comment. Very stupid!
Striker is Nazbol lol!!!!!! You sound very dumb!
So proud to be Benin and Yoruba
A I Edo people and Yoruba people are brother and sister not the same
ElusiveCube ‘unfortunately no negro art’ did you even watch the video?
All Arab Muslims are proud,
@@ElusiveCube
Proud of copulating with donkeys or worshipping a pedophile/child rapist?
www.thesun.co.uk/news/4247444/fifteen-teens-treated-for-rabies-after-gang-rape-of-donkey-as-cops-urge-anybody-else-who-admired-the-beast-to-turn-themselves-in-to-avoid-disease-spreading/
Sure, Jan. Such a WONDERFUL culture to be proud of!
LMBO!!!
I’m Benin and Yoruba as well
I saw these in may at the British Museum. Felt happy to see them but sad they were not in their rightful place. Am from Edo state, Nigeria and grew up hearing stories of this magnificent sculptures we had.
Repatriation now return stolen artifacts
I'd rather see them in pictures and have them held by the people they belong to then see them in person and stolen from the land they were made in.
The assumption that African civilizations weren't capable of producing or appreciating fine art is exactly the mentality that led colonial Britain into justifications for enslaving Africans like beasts. It makes one appreciate the British Museum scene from the Black Panther movie a lot more!
Where is Killmonger when you need him?
It's no assumption, during the time benin kingdom existed the notre dame had already been built the mona lisa was painted so were michelangelo's fresques in the italian churches. By comparison with the art that was being made in europe during that time (1180 - 1897) and the benin kingdom, the art from the benin kingdom was considerably less impressive so I would think they had every right to think so. And did you also now about the horrific treatment of millions of white slaves under islamic arab rule during the same period? No they only teach you about the struggles of black people in history as if they were the only people ever systematically mistreated.
@@willlee5853 Nice "whataboutism!" The video your commenting on said it was an assumption. However If one thinks about the pyramids, or the rock hewn Cristian churches in Lilabela Ethopia your statements are seen as purely ignorant. Let's not forget Cathage was in North Africa either. Also Benin as of 2013 is not only a quarter Muslim, it's a quarter Roman Catholic. How do you think they became Catholic? Lastly I am of Irish descent and know the story of the Barbary Pirates well (NOT from Benin though) Also the hidden history of Irish indentured slaves that were my first American ancestors. The one fact has nothing to do with the other my Bulgarian friend!
Don't forget all African slaves were sold by Clan chiefs or African kings. Who are you going to complain to? No seller, no market!
@1 2 And just like you kid. You're a sheep like everybody else is. Get a reality check.
Look at Africa.... My People...
bonginkosi emanuel If only you saw their true greatness before.
It´s shit, the most worthless civilization on the planet.
@Bro9650 It´s contribution to mankind in terms of technology, art, science etc, of which Africans have given none.
@Bro9650 The Aztecs etc. atleast had a calendar, written language and rather advanced agriculture which in the end didn´t matter as they were conquered by a superior civilization. The Sahara desert can and have always been traversed and if the Europeans could come to Africa then the Africans should also have come to Europe but i guess that´s rather difficult if you haven´t even invented the boat. Africa was only an important trading hub for Africans, and then to Europeans when they arrived but still India and China was a much more valuable trade hub. And you say yourself that you´ve never even had a written language after thousands of years that´s rather pathetic. And don´t ever compare Japanese with an average IQ of 110 to Africans with an average IQ of around 70, that´s insulting to the Japanese.
@Bro9650 The thing is that humans are supposed to have originated from Africa so Africans should have been first with everything not the other way around as it is. Ofcourse Japan got most of it´s language from China as humans settled in Japan moving eastwards from China, same thing with Greeks from Phoenicians, and also these peoples are genetically similar which Africans and Arabs aren´t. Latin is a European language and the Latin letters are the ones were using now.
My kingdom my love 💙. Benin empire Alive forever
Benin empire currently Benin kingdom in southern Nigeria not Benin republic 🇧🇯
@Jo Sm only your family have slave history, useless bigot
@Jo Sm bought? Human sacrifice? 🤣🤣🤣 What a dimwit, if you're a black person that means u r totally brainwashed, smh
@Jo Sm you're very foolish, Europeans can't tell me about my narratives, if you want authentic one read the books from professor Egharevba not those ones written by the same westerners that conquered us, if you're not stupid of course they'll write something that benefits them, so everyone can think the white supremacists are the most perfect being, sorry I'm not like you, I'm proud of my cultural heritage 😉
@Jo Sm you just admitted you're just a bitter foolish fool, but it's okay I've met a lot of stupid people online
Benin was a treat to the world
Timbuktu .mansa Musa . West africans are still woke
@1 2 there's a different Benin in Africa the one they are talking about is a state in Nigeria while the one you're talking about is another country
@1 2 You're a special kind of stupid aren't you? Benin Empire was located in Nigeria smdh.
@Anthony. Yes, that's why the British tried to erase benin language then introduced the Yoruba and Igbo language in Edo state but God is more than them.
If they were left alone for another 1000 years .. imagine!! What they would have done
Saint Scanderbeg No
Would still be the way it is
Saint Scanderbeg like what???
That was and always will be a problem leaving blacks alone suggested messages from pastor stephen Darby(who are we) and the Manboys
@Saint Scanderbeg -- They were killed by European diseases. Many indigenous were.
As an Indonesian, I'm actually quite disappointed we don't have *more* Asian-African art in Europe. It's interesting that the countries with smallest representation in UK museums are those least popular with British tourists.
There is tonnes of Asian art in British museums
I am from Europe, and it breaks my heart every day to see what was done to the Ashanti kingdom and Benin kingdom! I cannot imagine how painful this would be for Nigerians, Ghanaians or other Western Africans. How inspirational, beautiful and magical it would be, that I as a European could visit the old town of Kumasi or Benin city and see the wonder of those old cultures, just as I can indulge in the beauty of Isfahan, Marrakech, Paris, Krakow, Lijiang or Jodhpur, instead I can only see looted objects in a museum in London and a few old pictures and drawings of Kumasi and Benin city. Incredible, I am speechless
Liar. Nobody says that they are from Europe. They would say they are a Frenchman or Greek or whatever else.
@@joebloggs5318 He might be Croatian, just a guess from the name, either way you should not assume he's lying.
@@ennui9745 There's sadly lots of people on the internet who lie. I want to believe everyone but a lot of what people say turns out to be false.
@@joebloggs5318 Not everyone has the same outdated mindset like you
Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha!!! You haven’t missed much. Enjoy the culture that sold other africans to the rest of the world in mass quantities. Everything I see so far is rather hideous to see. Give an afro a rope and he wanna be a cowboy! Hahahahahahaha!!
WE ARE WHO WE ARE
(1) The Edo Monarchy is not any ordinary monarchy, it is a spiritual institution and the Oba is a deity. He is referred to as the personification of ”ErhimwinIdu” or ”The Spirit of Edo.” There are layers and layers of palace societies around him. They check and balance each other.
(2) When the entire empire is threatened, these societies become one major force together with the people. This existed before the British came and continued after. It is beyond politics or local governance. It is a belief system and way of life.
(3) The Oba doesn't get power, he is power. He was born as ”ErhimwinIdu” and no Oba has ever passed away before they get on the throne. The shortest reign was of an Oba who was killed by accident during his coronation ceremony by a stay arrow to his forehead. He was already crowned.
(4) The line of succession has remained unbroken for generations. It is not something we joke with. Each family also has a family shrine or Ukhure where we also trace our lineage. The Ukhure of Benin is the monarchy and there is a priest who keeps the records.
(5) I explained once that the stolen artifacts by the British are not decorations but records. We kept our records in 3D. Christianity came and saw it as ”idolatory” but the same Christian Missionaries came from places with monarchies and records. Charlemagne saved those records.
(6) He used Catholic Monks to keep a record of all local practices. Most of the history of Europe would have been lost without the Catholic Church and Charlemagne. The Portuguese came to Edo long before the British and respected our culture. They even gained from it.
(7) The battle of 1897 was really to erase something the British feared and I think it was Portuguese influence. Oba Esigie spoke Portuguese and the Edo Monarchy had a long history with Portugal. This is why even the crown prince commands great respect by our Federal Governments.
(8) The British couldn't replace Oba Ovoramwen after the war and they couldn't kill him. They deported him and there was no peace until his son who became Eweka II took over. He rebuilt the monarchy and was great grandfather to Oba Ewuare II.The British couldn't replace Oba Ovoramwen after the war and they couldn't kill him. They deported him and there was no peace until his son who became Eweka II took over. He rebuilt the monarchy and was great grandfather to Oba Ewuare II.
Ọba gha tó Ọ kpére....isẹ
The British government should return all plundered and stolen objects. Give it all back. Thanks for sharing. Yet everybody but Us benefit from what is ours.
they would be left with nothing,even the queen would not have a crown to wear
And if it gets finally returned and few decades down the line they get lost, stolen, ruined and even destroyed, you'll probably regret you ever made that suggestion, the same way Obama regrets assassinating Gaddafi. Be careful what you wish for because you might just get it, but never in the form you expected.
@1 2 Thanks for sharing...never been there.,.I have seen beautiful Egyptian statues in print/tv media and on line...
Talk of musa Mensa and the great Malian empire 😎😎..Africa had its history and culture
Mali take many idea from Arabs and Berbers from North. they dont have stone city wall, old city gates, stone wall, stone building, great sophisticate architecture mosque, palace, fort, citadel,castle any many others.
@@safuwanfauzi5014 Learn English then we take you serious.
@@safuwanfauzi5014 Come back when you learn proper English Mr. Troll.
@@safuwanfauzi5014 Take your meds.
@@safuwanfauzi5014 Why would they stone when they were not living in areas with large amount of stone? In that case, is the Sumerian civilization not valid as many of its buildings were of clay/mud/reeds? They didn't have an abundance of stone in their architecture either.
When the Brits colonised Zimbabwe 🇿🇼 (Southern Africa) & saw the Great Zimbabwe city built in the 11th century they also refused to believe that my ancestors built it coz there was evidence of trade with the Chinese etc. Early historians claimed it was built by Alexander the Great & for a 100 years natives were not allowed to visit these historical sites. Fortunately we have managed to reclaim most of the stolen art from Europe.
You're not in the least bit concerned about the fact that a historical revisionist is the presenter?
The richest man who ever lived was Monsa Musa, a west African king before the time of slavery.
They've had slavery since the cavemen.
@@Astyanaz No shit!!!! I'm speaking on the transatlantic slave trade genius.
@OMEGA LOLActually Mansa Musa made his wealth off the gold mines in his territory, and the taxes of all trade goods imported/exported and travelling through his realm.
The Arabs at this time were soley dependant mainly on acquiring their black slaves from their East African City States. i.e Kilwa, Malindi, Zanzibar, Madagascar, Mombasa etc...
They had quicker access to captives from the interior and trade routes crossing the Indian ocean with slaves during the monsoon season than having to travel or aquire captives from all the way over on the other side across the continent.
Some slaves however from Mali did make their way north to the Berber territories, however it was GOLD, TAXES n TRIBUTE not slaves that made Mansa Musa the Wealthiest man who ever lived.
If he had sold all his neighbours, he could he have "continually" make money from them??
He subjugated, then squeezed profits out of em lol.
@OMEGA LOL No I am not.
You are.
@OMEGA LOL I'm not here to convince you with my FACTS on the one who was dubbed the title "LORD OF THE MINES" for his wealth by Europeans and Arabs alike. If he was this monster as you claim then so were his neighbours and everyone else in that age.
My point is and will always be that he made his wealth from being the worlds most notable provider of gold and the monies he accumulated coming in
out of his Realm. Did he have slaves YES. Did he gain his wealth specifically as you claim by selling off all his neighbours n his own people NO.
I supported my claim with facts on specific peoples, time frame, methods and geographic locations.
All I'm hearing from you is emotion with nothing to back up the your claims.
I'll leave you to your world.
Btw
You stated Mansa Musa got rich by selling all his neighbours to "The Muslims"
Uhmm....
Mansa Musa was a Muslim.
Actually the pourtguese came to Benin because they saw that it was similar to settlements in Europe. Benin was a rich kingdom, the people wore white garments and travelled on wide roads and had feats. It was rich and divine and they wanted evreything.
RETURN THIS BEAUTIFUL ART WORK BACK TO AFRICA!
@John Wheaton not like ours is any different.
This is why Yahoo Boys should drain their pockets!
Brother that is to bring curses on us... But... Isee! 😁
CoronaVirus is already being sent to ravage them in their millions...but they dont know of Soponna or why he is now set to gradually destroy them. Those artworks are coming back home soon....that much, I know. When exactly, I cant say, but very soon.
Repaying evil for evil?
@@goldenchild1368 Taking what is yours is not evil. Exodus 3:22 says different.
Africas greatest art work. In london.
I've never seen these! I'm 43 years old! I can't believe I've never seen these!🤯(edit: there are several documentaries on the subject here on RUclips. Fascinating!)
Please go to edo state in Nigeria and see more by your self... Benin city
I'm seen them & touch them many times. Get your arse down to The British Museum before they are returned or visit Benin to view the remaining figures.
The World we have no peace if they fail to return our Ancestors back Home, it's seems like play but that's the real issues on ground
Idk even know what any of you guys are talking about.
HappyandAtheist LoL you can deny all you want. The facts still remains and the facts don’t care for your feelings... pig
I, a Bini (from Benin Kingdom, Nigeria), like most Binis living today, have never set my eyes on these artworks made by my ancestors. All who consent to these artworks being where they are today, consent to the injustice, theft & evil. And recompense from the most High.
They were given back. Your government gifted them to your old Oba, great family history the guy, whose private property they are now. So you’ll never see them which is a shame. Should’ve booked a flight to Germany 5 years ago, there they were well taken care of and open to the public.
@@glockenreinsomeone has already cursed you for your lies, I will only add that you will reap what you sow incubus.
@@glockenreinsomeone has already cursed you for your lies, I will only add that you will reap what you sow incubus.
@@glockenreinyour lies will be your end, incubus.
Reparations is so due to Africans and return of their artifacts
How about repatriations instead? Repatriations, reparations - what's the difference!? Blacks gets a complimentary spear and a Coca-Cola, and are sent back to Africa..
@George Kush built with Stolen stuff, Stolen oil thieves
This doesn't show the vast artistry of benin artistry. They did terrecota too. Benin empire is the mother empire to Egypt. The origin of egypt starts in benin . It's no other empire in Africa that has the history that can compete with egypt/nubia ,when it comes to artifacts. On the Benin bronzes you can see their hair style was similar to Egyptians.
What about Ashanti kingdom?
@@gingerbreadmangangafarmer2251 Ashanti artifacts were skilled in metallurgy but the Akan kingdom were mainly trading gold or selling gold . There's no kingdom in Africa that can compare to Benin and the Yoruba ,when it comes to artifacts . There are more artifacts underground in Nigeria.
@@gingerbreadmangangafarmer2251 let me put it like this . Benin artifacts are better than Greece artifacts by a Longshot
@@TheTrill334 Who told you?Have you been to Ghana? There are a lot of gold artifacts in Ghana
@@gingerbreadmangangafarmer2251 I believe it is but these are my opinions
Bring back our stolen arts!!
Alba Celani we could have kept our own castles, palaces and monuments if they were not destroyed by your people.
@Alba Celani the half white people coming at you hard lol. guys you still have castles and cathedrals allot of you are more western "white" then i am lol
@Alba Celani you sound stupid there is Castles in Africa that predates any castle in Europe
@Alba Celaniits great you have your own landmarks to cherish still but perhaps they would like to store their stolen are in an African landmarks such as Manhyia palace, Gondar Castle, Grand Mosque of Bamako
, BCEAO Tower
, Great Mosque of Djenné
, Royal Palace of the Oba, Kwame Nkrumah Mausoleum
, Krishna Balaram Palace
Alba Celani which cities u talk about clown?
We will never forget the havoc the British wrecked on our Kingdom and ancestors repatriation or no repatriations we will definitely come for our stolen valuables and mandate some day. Obghatokpere Ise...(long live our Oba 🙏)
Festus Agbongiasede then y don’t we demand for it now sir. It belongs to us so many of our people where killed we still let this people come to our country while they hold our property captive in their home.isee🙏🏿
Black Africa owes black people with Caribbean heritage reparations.
But after missionaries came and preached Christianity to you guys, you also gave up some of you're ancient artifact to destroy as mark of cleansing from idols god and you obliged.
You gave out your civilization because of Western god;those artifact are Africans history but people gave them up to embraced foreign gods.
@@watchingthehawks355 Source for that?
robert howard The ancient city of Bini Kingdom, the first kingdom in the world 🌍 located in Southern Nigeria 🇳🇬
I was born in Angola 🇦🇴, because war went to Portugal when i was 3 years old,in school what i learn about Africa just about slavery but now with internet I'm so happy to learn Africa have a very rich history.
Give them back!
The measures that the colonizers went through to erase the legacy of one group of people. Just goes to show their true greatness!
I've not seen the full documentary, but from this clip it looks to be outstanding and I will seek it out. In a couple of months I hope to produce my own RUclips series on the Benin bronzes but having watched this the bar has just been raised! I agree with David Olusoga as to the tragedy of the bronzes; this is one of the motivations for making my series.
Bear in mind that David Olusoga is a historical revisionist.
So sad to think how much effort was put into making sure - history of Africa and African Americans has been purposely twisted and destroyed for so long !
You must be African-American youself.. You people always think you are the only black people outside of Africa, so pathetic.. The world does not evolve around you you know.. The Caribbean is also full of black people and so is south-America and Europe. All black people who have tons more knowledge of their true-self than any African-American who still claps for jesus or wait, it’s jahweh now isn’t it…yawnn.. get over yourself.
@@darrenblake5011 we wouldn't be here if y'all hadn't sold us off to the Europeans.
We are the Children of Great Benin Empire.
We are the Owner of the Red Soil.
We are the Children of the Cradle of Black Civilization
Oba of Benin Kingdom is Our Father and God's Representative to Mankind on Earth to Us all.
We are the Children of UMOGUN Oza.
We are the Real Children Of Ogiso.
Ogidigan is Our Father and the Link between the Benins and Ancestors of Our Land.
Everything You see in Benin Kingdom was either won by Love or By Blood but never MONEY, because anything that can be bought has no real values.
The Ekpen No'Owa.
The OGidigan.
The Uku Akpolokpolo.
The UMOGUN Oza
The Head and Leader of all Edo Race which is His Royal Majesty, Omo N'Oba N'Edo Uku Akpolokpolo, Ewuare II, Oba of Benin is priceless to Us. We will and shall continue to Love Our Dear and Respected Oba.
Ovbi' Ekpen N' Owa
Ovbi' Adimila
Agbaghe, N'Ovbi Olokun
Abieyuwa N'Ovbi Odua N'uhe
Ovbi' Ada, Ovbi' Eben
Ovbi'Ekenekene ma deyo
Ovbi'Ekuaho N'Olo, Ovbi'Ekuabo N'Olo
Ovbie Ikpinhianbo kpuru no Gb'oduma
Nohien utete no gh'ughe s'omwan
Ovbi'Oghonwan nei bun aro
Ovbi'ode, ode n'ohan ren mu' ete
Oba of Benin is the Eminiminimini hope they know the meaning of that word, the UMOGUN is a living Deity,
Ọba gha tó Ọ kpére....isẹẹ
E riowa no. Ẹdo ma ghi. Ọba gha tokpere.
I am from the Benin Kingdom and I can say Benin lost its glory and splendour after the punitive war and colonisation.
For the racists who claim black Africans didn't have a real Civilization, read up on Nubia, Axum and Zimbabwe
kingdoms. Also Queen Nizinga, a one eyed warrior fought and be the Portuguese.
Beautiful art...they should be allowed to go home to their people
Lili Bee so that they would be stolen. I frankly doubt that Nigeria could guard them accordingly.
Man of the north That’s not the point. They belong to them. If the people who have them now cared, they could help them find a safe place for them.
Lili Bee I agree. They hold treasures from other countries as well. Then again, there they are for the world to see. Had they remained in Africa i am afraid virtually nobody would know they exist. And those plates are nothing compared to some chest figures of nok cultures nobility.
north those plates are recorded history for the people who created them , it worth alot to them, you reason very low. Why did you think they were kept at the palace?
letloveguard wells They were kept in the palace for the same reason as European monarchs. For the pleasure of themselves and nobility and to make their palace look as pompous as possible.
Of course they are important to nigerians. But that doesn't take away from the fact that they are way easier to steal there than in Britain. They should be returned of course but personally I would keep contacts ready to buy them from underworld if and when some get stolen.
Y'all should have just left us the hell alone. I'm just sad.
true. but where would europe be without africa?
@@PrincezzJin why couldn't we just continue to trade our minerals and resources in free open commerce like the rest of the world was doing centuries prior
@@PrincezzJin Most likely prosperous or at least stable, are you so ignorant of history to think Europe colonization of Africa benefitted anyone but Europe.
The Portuguese taught the Benis how to make bronze..look it up
@@theinternetsavedmylife That is a lie. Africans have been practicing metallurgy long before Europeans were taught by us.
And yet people ask “can any good thing come out from Africa.?” I’ve said this and will say this again. Ones intelligence is not based on their skin colour. Our efforts have been over look and as the presenter said we are and we’ve seen as savages.
They called us "Savages" as justification to treat us like savages.
Well, Im. From india, and many of our artwork are still there in the british museum. Fortunately fir us, they couldn't destroy it, but some pieces of it were stolen from us, and we have no "right"to claim it back(!).
Unfortunately for you, they destroyed it, nearly wiped it out, and then they tell you that you're savages.
These relics are the genuine historical property of African countries from where these are taken, the point is those who have them realize it now or still don't have the capacity to see that.
Like my mom used to tell me you can't expect for them to teach you right if they don't treat you right. I myself had to get out there and learn about African history.
How are you going to think they were incapable, when you had Egypt/Kemit, Olmecs and over 100 of other civilizations?
Olmecs are native American, stop stealing their history
@@KateeAngel Mayans learn from the black Olmecs. Two different people idiot.
ruclips.net/video/G5r8w1yibp4/видео.html
@@KateeAngel the only ones stealing history are you shameless armed robbers
As an African born in the Caribbean ,these Beautiful Arts have significant spiritual meaning to us ,these Arts including us was stolen
Late, but are you sure you weren't sold as slaves by African slavers?
I was so Impressed and relieved, and proud, and disappointed when first sad the artwork. Why did I not see this work when I was a child? These works are in Museums all over the world. This is a tragedy. They belong to people of Benin origins. I
Why? Have you made these artwork? What kind of "connection" do you, a person of 21st century have with people from the 16th or 19th century? What connection do you have, that an American, European or Asian doesn´t that is reason enough for your claim?
You only have nationalistic interest in these arty, the personal interest is not of your concern.
And that is just nationalistic propaganda!
@@georgederuiter1412 Are you daft return those artifacts to where they were stolen from you evil scumbags
Please, the video is about Benin kingdom in Nigeria not Benin republic and please to clear the air, Africa is not a country or a tribe, it's a continent and yes we have access to you tube because not all of us look like the people on UN ads. Please before you have a take on Africa as a continent, live there. Please stop with the assumptions.
Why have I never even heard of the Benin Bronzes ? … Another history suppressed ?
Theres alot they dont tell you..
The colonizers rewrote our history too to suite their narrative.....
Because they're irrelevant
Irrelevant yet generating a ton of money in your musuems.
Sunifred you are a big fool
Sunifred if that’s so than they wouldn’t be making billions of this.
The sad part is, today, beautiful artworks like these are seen as strange and fetish to some Nigerians. They are disconnected from their roots.
And Britain continues to profit by us. If we displayed these ourselves they would never come to see it nor acknowledge its existence.
In my opinion they never deserved to lay eyes upon them in the first place.
Soon (and it's already started) it will be China who will plunder the resources of Africa. If you spend all your time railing against the past you just might miss the dangers that lie ahead. Wealth is power and I know many wish that whites (as if we all share the same culture and beliefs) are going to dissapear but even if we did does that automatically make African or American blacks situation any better? Do you believe that the south Asians, middle eastern and Chinese will share that wealth? They are the ones gaining it faster than anyone after all and will your lot in life improve automatically or will you have a new adversary that feels no guilt or remorse? I'm not British by the way and my people (because once again whites aren't a singular group) have been on the losing end dealing with them but we've moved on, hopefully you can do the same but it takes hard work,ingenuity,a boatload of cash, and leaders who won't bleed you dry as has been the case in so many African countries. When you say "if we displayed them", who's we? People are very tribal whether black, white,yellow, brown,Christian,Muslim, Buddhist,Jewish Zoroastrian, Irish,Bantu, Somalian, Spanish or Cherokee. Believing that any race automatically sides with similarly colored people from a different country is wishful thinking at best and downright dangerous any other time.
@@buckodonnghaile4309 🗣️ JUDGEMENT DAY is set✊🏽✊🏽
@1 2 unfortunately for you, your Crown government doesn't think so!
"The people of the dark continent had no history no culture and no civilization."
Egypt: Hello!
Fuck Egypt
Brandon Robinson clearly smh sad
Although Egypt was in Africa, its inhabitants weren't dark. Just saying.
@@TheEridiacta That has nothing to do with the phrase, the dark continent, and some Egyptians are dark
Timbuktu says Hi too
Stolen Artwork from the motherland.
@A A Then why are you watching a documentary on our history and culture?
Guess we do have one since there are documentaries acknowledging our ancient kingdoms A A.
It was stolen and should be returned. The Vatican vaults need to be opened, publically viewed and returned to every country from which they were taken. This must include the Smithsonian Institution as well.
@A A you do ur DNA I can tell u that 50% will be Africa, then u known Africa is the mother land, mother earth, long live mama Africa
And yet they say Africa is corrupt. I wonder...what do you call a thief?" A THIEF!!!
They didn't steal those bronzes numbnuts. They fought the owners, beat them, took their stuff. Call it looting or whatever, but that's not stealing.
teaCupkk that’s still stealing you dumbass
@@teaCupkklt is robbery.. Arms robbery. Which is still a form of thieving. What is the difference between that and robbery?
@@Komeshokakunanwene A thief tries to get what he wants, without the owner noticing. Quietly, in the night, avoiding confrontation.
Overtly confronting your opponent, besting him, and walking away with his stuff is not thieving. Want to call it robbery, fine. I'd call it conquest - since the bronzes were not the primary motivation.
And let's not pretend the people of Benin themselves, were strangers to conquering others, looting them, enslaving them.
@@teaCupkk we can go on and play around with English, also throw in whataboutisms, but what was done when these Bronzes were taken from rightfull owners was not short of thieving. Robbers take by force, which was done here. They can also chose to kill and leave a trail of destruction, which was done here. They (robbers) refuse to return what they stole, again it is thieving. These people here, who did this to Benin are the human rights champions of today while accusing others of being dictators and ensuring that ICC goes for them.
WE WANT OUR ARTIFACTS BACK 😏
I am author of the books: The Great Wall of Africa: The Empire of Benin’s 10,000 Mile Long Wall, The Real Wakandas of Africa and The Real Vibranium of Africa (by Maurice Miles Martinez). Most people are unaware that African people built a wall before transatlantic slavery in the Benin empire that is one of the most massive structures in the world. At 10,000 miles long, the Great Wall of Africa contains more material than all of the buildings in New York City’s Manhattan. If cut into 1 meter high blocks, it would wrap around the equator more than 65 times! It is arguably the planet’s greatest man-made structure. Yet, it has been ignored by historians. In my book The Great Wall of Africa: The Empire of Benin’s 10,000 Mile Long Wall, I explore the dimensions of the wall, the history of the Benin Empire’s Kings (Obas) and the stolen Benin Bronzes. These treasures that sit in the world’s museums amount to more than $14 Billion. Most people who read this book are left wondering why they never heard about the Great Wall of Africa in their history classes. The world needs more videos on this topic.
Maurice Miles Martinez
Congratulations!
These works of Art and Culture are among the items that the colonizers are willing to acknowledge and display. It could be nigh unimaginable what stolen treasures remain hidden!!!
It just amazes me how these Brits have art that has nothing to do with their history no need to ask how they got it.
Explain to me how do England always come to be in possession of all rare African artifacts
when we were kings
And we are still Kings and Queens
@Carlo Canti I would be proud to be a "dirt poor" farmer because I would know how to make
a dollar. I would know how to grow food, process food, and preserve food. You were
most likely raised on welfare, food stamps, and a housing subsidy. You are probably raising
your children on welfare, food stamps, and a housing subsidy. You don't know how to make
a dollar, legally. If you are in "the land of the free" you are still too stupid to farm, to plant
anything. You are too stupid to know how to build anything. You are too stupid to make a dollar.
I know you are not a "royal" nor a descendant of a "royal". You will always be low class, illegal,
and on welfare. Dependent on the government. When you learn how to spell, read, and write at
at least a 3rd grade level, then I will talk. In the meantime, I don't talk to trash.
@@jattojohn7704 true
The Bronzes are very artistically planned, placed, practiced, drawn, crafted, sculpted, thought out
This artwork needs to be returned to the continent
The people it belonged to are gone and dead, its not owned by a continent.
@@chinogambino9375 you are ignorant...
@@chinogambino9375 you are very dumb, us edo people are still here and want our stuff back.
We were one of the first civilization. 👑👑💪🏽💪🏾💪🏿
I have a story about a man who makes bread in his community, very good bread best in the area. One day members of the neighboring community raids his bakery, steals his freshly baked bread, kills his wife, kids and parents and forced him in servitude to bake bread for them. They become rich and expand their business, while he suffers in silence. His own nieces and nephews now have a pay a high price for bread their own uncle baked. Just a story you say, and you might be correct, except Europe still has Africa’s ‘freshly baked bread’ and we are still in servitude.
That's what they did to every black prospering town in 🇺🇸 American not just talsa
I knew my people had history..
EVERYTHING!!
Everyone knows that anyone has some kind of history. Noone ever said something different.
Yet I doubt, you had any proper education
No group of human beings are savages
Have you seen people at Walmart during Black Friday sale? It will change your mind.
And why did they steal those artifacts and put them in their demonic museums? Give it back to who it belongs to!!!!
This is a key for reparations
They didn't steal anything dummy, the fought them, beat them, burned the palace to the ground, then took the bronzes as souvenirs. Maybe they should give them back though, make some nice replicas to keep for the museum, and send the originals back.
For witchcraft. Thats how they oppress
@1 2 there are museums here, what you said is extremely offensive.
why do yall still think we're in the stone age?
1 2 doesn’t answer the question,you were being very ignorant,just because you don’t hear about them doesn’t mean they don’t exist
Ironically the BBC does a lot of interesting work...good job.
They were stolen from their country of origin like the artifacts of Egypt and the Elgin Marbles of Greece.
Do you think those artifacts were happily given to Britain?@portlandstone3mw
I know that they belong in Greece not a museum in England. For future interest if you really have an interest in educating someone maybe you shouldn't use words like ignorant. God help your children.
2:00 disappointing to hear these aren't in Africa where they belong
Whoever controls the past controls the future. The more you know, the more you realize you don't know. Truth unites. Control corrupts. Don't let race blind you. Those that seek power want the races fighting with each other.
GIVE IT BACK!!! .... Before those nice people decide to up there take it back themselves. Figure it out.
Why is is do hard to believe Africa has history? Europe and Asia could be as easily dismissed if society had a high audience of prejudice against them, yet we just accept their cultures and history without questioning its authenticity. All of this research put into Africa dismissed by public for a variety of reasons, much is from prejudice. How long would it be before the world accepts Africa for its once glorious past?
This is a demonstration of human capabilities which manifest in many and different forms. African history is human history. Indian, Chinese, European, Maya, Incas, etc is all human history
Woow so proud to have a little bit of benin ancestry in me im ecuadorian🙏🏼 crazy i have some ancestry from this beautiful civilization
Wow good to known u are also my sister...
God, what a kind of fool are you? So everyone, who has a tiny splash of Italian ancestry is capable of building a David like Michelangelo?! Laughable.
@@georgederuiter1412 who even said anything like that ? 🤡 I got ancestors from there that simple ain't any deeper than that
2:51..wow those statues look like they will move any sec. looks so lifelike. Let me guess the Christian missionaries created them lol.
I was born in Benin City but from Delta...
The devil came to steal, kill, and destroy
The whole truth!
Damn...this hit hard. It makes me want to read the Bible again but with a different perspective
Shame on Brits for looting these artifacts.
Jjkhjgkjhkjb hgjhghnjn ikr wtf are they even there?
This brought tears to my eyes looking at the art work of the anicent and to know what has been stolen away from the people Benin. The art needs to be return back to rightful country.
you know that that art in their original sense was never handed to "the people" but stood in the palace of a king!? Yet the idea and reality of museums are to show art etc to the public!
And they say we don't have history????😂😂😂😂😂
I am not surprised people always under estimate us Africans by the way bring them back to Benin and nija
isn't it amazing that the ones that got the thumbs down still don't want to believe and accept that a black man was capable of doing these things that the Most High God created us to do great things in great exploits we not one 3/5 of a person we are whole beings just like anyone else and those thumbs down the Most High will judge you and he is going to judge you because you hate and it's in your heart and if you don't get the hate out of your heart you will be going to a burning Lake of Fire
I am emotional seeing great works from Africa!
These bronze are the perfect depiction of Jesus' skin color in Revelation 1:15 his feet is like fine bronze burned into a furnace.
Now I really really overstand what kilmunger in black panther felt when he was looking at this same art in a museums in the movie. One day in the not so distant future these Europeans will ultimately pay a hefty price for their deeds here on earth... Their children will pay as well.
Where are all the Nigerians on this thread?
Thumbs up if you are Nigerian.
2 thumbs if you are Bini.
mazimadu - I'm not from Benin, but according to my DNA test I'm 39% Benin/Togo, which is the highest percentage of my African DNA. This makes me very proud of my ancestry and history!
Come on now, all Africans around the world should be proud not just nigerians on benin
@@moosaseethi6227 Shut your mouth! And be proud of what?
I am Nigerian but not Bini. I started this thread so I can learn about the bronzes FROM THE MOUTHS OF BINI/EDO. They know the language, the culture and history.
My apologies I did not mean to insult or offend you "yes I will shut my mouth now even though I used my fingers, sorry dear
@@moosaseethi6227 no I apologize, I'm starting to realize that Nigerians aren't really interested in discussing their culture on the internet
Make those thieves at the British Museum, Smithsonian return the stolen ancient artifacts because I had ancestors from Benin 🇧🇯
AlligatorShuz they're referring to the Benin kingdom in southern Nigeria, not Benin Republic the country in West Africa
AlligatorShuz hey are u mad why u referring to Benin republic when they talking about Benin kingdom in south south of Nigeria 🇳🇬
Am African don't call Africa a dark continent africa is the richst continent in the world that why the Europeans don't want to let africa alone but now is the time Africa is united free tread only in African continent then you will say the bright africa! !
While many are upset about these works not remaining in their home countries if they had not been stolen/looted they may have been lost forever or melted down by many that did not care about their significance. Sad to admit that with so many wars and upheavals over the centuries many treasures would have been lost if Europeans had not taken them.
This is a sad truth. Unfortunate but the truth non the less.
What's really sad is that all the wars were started by Europeans so they could plunder. What is most sad is the no matter what. The European is always regarded as the savior to the simple minded.
So the hundreds of years some of this artefacts were in Africa they were looted and melted down, interesting
Let me get it... You start a war to endanger stuff, then you pretend like you're trying to keep the stuff you endangered safe. Make it make sense. Those artworks had been perfectly safe and preserved for centuries. Nothing was going to happen to them if the British hadn't happened.