I am encouraged by the review of Tilly and Ros and am glad to hear you consider the new novel a fun romp. I found "The Secret..." not at all rompish, but dark, mysterious, and quite serious. It was not at all gossipy or light, and it encouraged the reader to question what they actually knew about people, but especially women, and their possible life choices more than a century ago in rural England. That protagonist was like Jane Eyre but without her armor fully formed and her personality in flux.
Excellent discussion! Thank you! I have struggled trying to describe both of Katie's books as simultaneously authentic and modern. I think you both did a better job. Tilly's summary at 3:50 is spot on!
In this new period of thought crime and speech crime, one must be careful. I have NOT seen or read either Bridgerton or Hamilton but have no problem with their authors exploring whatever they care to. I read the reviews, but I surely do not know enough to be informed. The case of the new Persuasion, however (the new movie release of a year or so ago), cuts a little closer to the bone and to the July just passed. Having half the cast black, and Lady Russell being an "easy" black woman taking holidays in France for ash dragging ARE artistic decisions that can be explained and defended, but I'll never say I approve when I don't. Austen (IMO) deserves better than having Lizzie or Anne Elliot a cracked-out girl of the street or with half the cast gay atheists, but if that is one's muse, play on. Sometimes artistic freedom yoked to political/social axe grinding will carry a project completely over the cliff. Audience #'s and reviews will usually tell the authors whether they hit or missed. I don't believe THAT Persuasion persuaded very many that it was true to Jane's worldview.
This just brightened my day so much. Thank you both. I absolutely would like my books to be fun romps - definitely my aim! 😊
@@katiejlumsden I'm very glad. Your books bring me great pleasure.
I am encouraged by the review of Tilly and Ros and am glad to hear you consider the new novel a fun romp. I found "The Secret..." not at all rompish, but dark, mysterious, and quite serious. It was not at all gossipy or light, and it encouraged the reader to question what they actually knew about people, but especially women, and their possible life choices more than a century ago in rural England. That protagonist was like Jane Eyre but without her armor fully formed and her personality in flux.
Such a fun video so start my morning! Thank you for sharing your thoughts. Can't wait to read Katie's new release.
@@janeaustenliteracyfoundation you'll enjoy it and spot the hints of Austen .
Wonderful discussion. Thank you.
@@BookishTexan we both enjoyed it.
I didn't realise we ended up chatting for so long! We both found a lot in this book to dig into.
@@tillysshelf we did!
Lovely discussion! Good to see you both. I can’t wait to read Katie’s book!
@@HannahsBooks we both enjoyed reading and talking about it. The novel is more lighthearted than Hartwood Hall but equally polished.
I really enjoyed your discussion! So thoughtful. Now I must read Katie’s book!
@@BookChatWithPat8668 have fun with the book.
Mine is ordered, can't wait. I loved her last book!!!!
@@LeeKempter I'm sure you will love this one too.
Great discussion! I had a wonderful time reading it too. A fun romp is a perfect description!
@@elizabethaliteraryprincess it made me think I need to read more joyful books.
Looking forward to reading this book. I really enjoyed her first!
@@susan3037 this is equally enjoyable and in some ways more fun.
Excellent discussion! Thank you! I have struggled trying to describe both of Katie's books as simultaneously authentic and modern. I think you both did a better job. Tilly's summary at 3:50 is spot on!
@@timheaney7408 that is their distinctive quality, isn't it?
Great discussion!
@@59cubanita thanks. I love Katie so am probably a little biased but it really is a delightful book.
@@scallydandlingaboutthebook2711 I still need to read her first book that I do have on my shelf
Lovely discussion - I’m so glad you both enjoyed it. I can’t wait to get a physical copy so I can see the map! Hoping to pick one up this weekend 🤞
@@spreadbookjoy I think our reactions were similar to yours. A map is always a bonus.
Lovely chat as always. I agree with all of your thoughts. This made me really want to check out Bridgerton 😁
@@AaronReadABook I have not read the books but have found the series entertaining.
In this new period of thought crime and speech crime, one must be careful. I have NOT seen or read either Bridgerton or Hamilton but have no problem with their authors exploring whatever they care to. I read the reviews, but I surely do not know enough to be informed.
The case of the new Persuasion, however (the new movie release of a year or so ago), cuts a little closer to the bone and to the July just passed. Having half the cast black, and Lady Russell being an "easy" black woman taking holidays in France for ash dragging ARE artistic decisions that can be explained and defended, but I'll never say I approve when I don't. Austen (IMO) deserves better than having Lizzie or Anne Elliot a cracked-out girl of the street or with half the cast gay atheists, but if that is one's muse, play on.
Sometimes artistic freedom yoked to political/social axe grinding will carry a project completely over the cliff. Audience #'s and reviews will usually tell the authors whether they hit or missed. I don't believe THAT Persuasion persuaded very many that it was true to Jane's worldview.