He lifted from Africa, Carribean, Latin America - there were hardly any listeners of these types of music in India, so his blatant lifts flew under the radar. Plus he lifted from unknown / obscure albums. Smart fellow LOL.
Well said ! Chori wo hoti hai jo pakdi jaye is time to ksiis ne socha bhi nahi hoga kaha se copy kiya hai still log Acha content nahi deserve karte india me ,look at current state of cinema and art . Its even more medicore.
We in Guyana knew about this for a long time . The radio stations played both western and hindi songs and it was an open secret that practically all hindi songs were plagiarized.
This is why modern music directors prefer RD Burman as he was the expert of converting non indian to bollywood. Laxmikant Pyarelal did copy but RD is a joke 😂
I take umbrage to the ignorance of the audience, dismissing plagiarism as inspiration. That argument would loose sorely in court. Give credit where credit is due.
We should see our music composers as remixers, curators, reinterpreters and so on. They are funneling an unfathomable amount of local and international sources into the musical requirements of the films they are handling. I am really curious about their "workflow", especially the older composers. How were they accessing all this foreign music before the internet and at a time when international travel was rare and expensive?
If it is possible to become RDB by copying western music everyone would have become successful music director.. The foolish people who are here criticizing blindly RDB are all allowed to become a RDB by copying.. And of course all music directors of India have been doing the same thing.. So why black listing RD only??
I can understand why he copied, writing and composing takes time and a lot of talent, when there is pressure of composing like 6-7 songs for one movie like Bollywood demands, and working for 2 to 3 movies at the same time is quite impossible. But later accepting awards for such copied composition is just heights of arrogance and a low blow for the original creators
Yes!!! We called out Annu Mallik for copying!!! RDB escaped without being caught!!!! During those days the Internet was not there so we were not aware!!
Yes!!! We called out Annu Mallik for copying!!! RDB escaped without being caught!!!! During those days the Internet was not there so we were not aware!!
True,he never blatantly took anything ,he mixed his own thinking, creativity and innovation which resulting a different song from the original. But others just lifted tune, rhythms, sounds, 😂
Murkh , kishore kumar jaisa to iss sadi me koi hua hi nahi, aur rahi baat gano ki nakal ki to kishore da gana gaate the banate nahi the na hi likhte the....aya bada Naushad wala
Naushad Ji also copied a song from Dr. Bhupen Hazarika's one of Assamese song....Naushad Ji used in the movie Mother India..song was "Dukh bhare din beete re bhayya"...and Assamese one "Ghan Baraxun Pisal Mati".
The people who search for this work very hard. RD Burman is no legend. I knew some of his songs were copied but this is too much and not sure whether others will be found out. How did they find so many in the past? International Radio?
@@Cosmuse-pg I am talking about the music directors who copied. Those days how they got access to international music that public did not know not even the elites of Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata?
Obviously, these MDs were rich enough to travel to other nations, and there they learned about western music. I once heard from someone that Bappi Lahiri used to visit usa a lot, where he bought many cassettes of pop American songs, and then he lifted their tunes in Bollywood songs.
They had access of all over the globe with no internet. Thats how they took those music . They were no normal people. Other than Queen, Abba ,bettles , micheal jackson very few foreign bands were popular in india back then
R. D. Burman is no legend? Did you listen to the FULL songs? Portions were taken as inspiration! That's normal in the music industry. It wasn't only Panchamda, but Laxmi- Pyare, Shankar- Jaikishan, Kalyanji- Anandji. Why are you only singling out Panchamda??? Have you heard ALL of his groundbreaking work? You should be ashamed of yourself that you fail to credit an Indian musical genuis despite living in the same country as him! Thuuuuu....
One thing people are missing here, majority of R D Burmans songs hardly had some 8-16 bars similarity with original songs. Which could be counted as first 2 lines of the mukhra. But, the catch is the remaining song parts were original and it is believed that his Antaras were much better than his mukhras. Also, R D used to compose for over 15-20 movies in 70s, so with that it averages 100 songs per year. It's not possible for a human being to create 1 tune every 3 days and record it in studios. You produce, you record and you sale. It's a long process. Also, RDs legacy will never die because he composed over 2000 songs in lifetime and around 100-120 songs were inspired (again 2 lines of mukhras only, not a blatant lift). So that accounts only 5-6% of his total discography. Each music composers have done it, some with own intention and some were forcefully asked to do by the producers, actors, and directors. People can blame easily, but they will never know what were the background stories. RD and the other music directors of 70s,80s and 90s will remain legends. Actually 100 times better than todays crap people listen. 😊
@mohan2304 Those days the credit concept was an alien thing, but yes RD often said on interviews that he used to take inspiration from English songs, which itself is a big thing for a music composer to admit. He was an open book to all. Watch this video of Asha and RD in late 80s- ruclips.net/video/8nax5AQczrk/видео.htmlsi=JHw6fBfludwJ74vp
Most of the songs were inspired from other songs. If you hear 'original 'full song you can realise the matter. You can't say indian songs copied from other.
Copy Sub Ne Kiya tha Naushad bhi , abhi bhi dhundna Chalu hai itne purane gaane hai to😂 & The RD (Rahul Dev) Burman is the greatest ever composer of india. Jo Chahe ukhadle😂 Kuch nhi Kar Payega. He is from bengal & a true bengali. Woh lungi Chod nhi tha😂. Sub bade composers & also a few lungi Composers maan liya hai ke yeh God of the Composers the hain aur rhenge😂.
Yaar waise ek baat bolu if you watch western youtubers naa you would realise that ki jo gaane hum log copy kar rhe hai wo bhi kahi se churaya hai it means that wo gaana already 1-2 baar copy ho chuka hai to bas art ko enjoy karo aur ye sab to facts hai haa ye hai ki jo gaane copy kiye hai wo sunne layak sirf 10-12% hi hai hindi mai baaki to sunne layak bhi nhi
dont comment nonsense if u r not working in that field western music and film productins all were original yes they d steaing from turish music and fims but that is 1-2% ret they were advanced in their techniques enough to create and prduce their own music and films they were deveped not develping their techniques their technology they create they dont aopt like india idnain fim and msui industry is a big zero in front of them as they steal a lot
There is difference between plagiarism and inspiration. And to note, folk songs do not have any copyright. The talent is in the beautiful Indianisation. There lies his ingenuity.
इसमे चोरी की कोई बात ही नही है आप किस तरह से उसको अपनी भावनाओं और हित के लिए प्रयोग करते हैं। जैसे उदाहरण के लिए आप लोग रोज सुनते होंगे कि भारत ने अचूक मिसाइल का परीक्षण किया तो मिसाइल तो औरो के पास भी है और भारत ने भी बनाई तो काम तो सभी एक तरह से कर रही किसी की अपने तरीके से तो हमारी अपने तरीके से लेकिन टारगेट एक है लक्ष्य को भेदना यही संगीत कर रहा सुर को कहाँ कैसे लगाना है ये सबके बस की बात नही ना उसपे बोल बैठना जो आत्मा को छू ले। लोग चोरी किसने की बताने वाले बहुत मिल जाएंगे देखा किसी ने नही।
Did they ever create any original tune? Now I think even these tunes were probably suggested by the Goan musicians who worked as arrangers for our music directors. Sebastian D’Souza-SD Burman, Frank Fernand-Shankar Jaikishan, Anthony Gonzalvis-Lakshmikanth Pyarelal, Kersi Lord - RD and SDB, etc.
So, number 1- R.D.Burman, who is for sure the pirate king, and number 2- Laxmikant-Pyarelal. But I wonder, did singers know about it? I mean see the names, greats like Kishore Kumar....🤔
RDBurman has less than 30-40 songs which he copied, even there his arrangements were original, he has over 1000 compositions, listen to his classical indian music based songs
@@REVELATIONSTV-y3q R.D Burman Copied 3 or 4 songs Same to Same. He only copied the interlude or 1st line of the Song, he didn't copy & paste. His compositions are better than the original videshi 😂. Plz listen those.
It can be. But most the time Producers & Directors demands this. Sometimes, when there is a situation where no song is demanded, than Music Director suggest to have it there. For example: Mehbooba Mehbooba Song of Sholay movie was suggested by R D Burman to put weightage on the Film story by showing that the Gabbar after having arms deal, is doing party with dealer. Same in Deewar movie too. After Hero gets huge booty to Villain. There it is suggested to have Celebration song.
For about 20/30 years people thought of RDB as some kind of genius but he was the biggest CHOR - a lot of his songs are straight up lifts - RDB is the king of plagiarism.
I strongly disagree. Bappi Lahiri ws the biggest pilferer. R d Burman had improved on many original songs. Yes he has copied I agree but his contribution to Indian music is irreplaceable
R D Burman was a copy paste music director. Kishore should also be tagged because he was his pet singer. We know this fact after Internet came in India. Others are in the list but less.
Phone pe charcha in 70's by RD, Lakshmikanth & Bappi would sound something like this: " Mein RD bathkarraha hoon, char fresh mal aya hai africa, US or afghan se, ek tu lakshmi rak le, ek bappi tu rak le, mein do rakloonga" 😝
There was a Holly Movie of 1930s - Dick Powell and Ann Sheridan - about the 'Music Plagiarism'... and in the end, (a court room), it is hinted that the tunes which it is supposed to have been plagiarised from, itself is adapetd from an older (and out of copyright) tune. eg Oneway ticket (not Boney M, but actually Neil Sadaka's) itself, if sufficiently searched, one could find the 'Influence'.
Naushad sab C Ramachandra SD Burman Madan Mohan never heard these names in plagiarism. Don't if any 1or 2 instances were these . But they were true legends who composed their own down south Saluri , ms viswanatham k V mahadevan illlayaraja , dakshina.urthy all were legends who had great base in classical music . Few were Inspired from classical but mostly their originals
Asha Bhonsle said in an interview that RDB had every possible song as needed by the producer and he rarely left a Producer without giving a song to his satisfaction. Now we know that he had all the copied tunes ready. . Anu Malik also claimed in an interview that later in his career, he had to follow RDB way of dealing with the producers who discarded his original tunes. . Bhappi Lahari is one unique personality who had recorded songs ready and producers just had to pick what they wanted as it already had been completely recorded. So he stole left and right from anything he heard of. 😂😂😂
Well that skill of improving a stolen copy isn't special to Burman saab. Pritam, Anu Malik both have done this too. But the netziens like to call out Malik saab while defend Burman ji.
I knew about RDB long before YT found out. Even entered into bad arguments with some music friends who refused to believe my opinion of RDB but now it's all clear - everyone knows it.
@@dilippathak7498 someone in family who played mandolin in mumbai film industry shared this (and some other) information. So, the fact is those who played instruments in films knew it already.
ARR has copied many tunes, especially the tunes, that propelled him to the top, are mostly copied. But unlike all musicians, he has created many genuine tunes as well
@@viveksingh5648 debate is long. Jai ho is actually not ARR composition but by Sukhwinder and that too lifted from a song. Even the base line of Taal se Taal is picked from a flute piece from HERO composed by Laxmikant Pyarelal
@@Muzikseviyorumstealing is a talent. This was shown by every king who was born, every politician, every bureaucrat, every industrialist born ever. Everyone is the same, even hypocrite common man included. 😂😂😂
@@neilbhatt7096 Even they were copied. Bollywood is a big copy cat. They copy movie plots, scenes, songs.....then where is the creativity. Although Sholay was well made, I was disappointed when I came to know even that movie was copied scene to scene...
@@neilbhatt7096 50s songs also were copied it seems!!! I have seen a video of 50s songs that were copied from West!! SD Barman also copied several pieces of music!!!
@tpt9028 you have heard all songs? I have listened to most (nobody can claim all) and I'm pretty sure the chori was much less (very small) in 50s and 60s. Tell me which song AAP ki nazaron ne samja or lag ja gale were copied from? I can lust a thousand songs and nobody can show me they were lifted. The trend started in late 60s by RDB in a Mass scale. Most of his songs are copied. Earlier SJ, Salil Chowdhry and one or two MD"s lifted small # of tunes - but nothing like RDB or Bappi.
Sickening, shameless. What matters is for how many generations they cheated the public who were not aware that these songs were lifted from western tunes. Only a few who listened to pop western tunes were aware of these lifts. However there are still some who will defend these copycats who have minted money on other artists talent thinking they sre obviously performing an act of patriotism. An acquaintance of mine who used to play the bongos for hindi songs at Film studios at Tardeo in mumbai told me for background music they just played an instrumental LP & recorded it on to the soundtrack! Need i say anything more?
All, except the last song, “Tum ho mere dil ki Dhadkan”. Procol Harum’s “Whiter shade of pale” is not same. I listened to it a few times, changed playback speed. May be it’s still a copy but not of this.
Few tunes here and there doesn't reduce the genius of R D Burman....if u listen to full songs of both songs, u will realise original version 1.0 and R D Burman 9.0 of the same tune....no match...for mobile phone companies release various series, upgraded series ...latest release is of higher quality than it's original version
Now we know why so many Bollywood movies and songs were produced at such a high rate! All they had to do is to listen to the original and lift it!
He lifted from Africa, Carribean, Latin America - there were hardly any listeners of these types of music in India, so his blatant lifts flew under the radar. Plus he lifted from unknown / obscure albums. Smart fellow LOL.
Well said ! Chori wo hoti hai jo pakdi jaye is time to ksiis ne socha bhi nahi hoga kaha se copy kiya hai still log Acha content nahi deserve karte india me ,look at current state of cinema and art . Its even more medicore.
We in Guyana knew about this for a long time . The radio stations played both western and hindi songs and it was an open secret that practically all hindi songs were plagiarized.
@@cramkisson9709 hindi songs 🎵 are far better than any songs 🎵 anywhere in the world 🌎....no comparison can be done
@@cramkisson9709 bollywood music best 👌 in the world especially before 1990s
@@jaydeepdhar7203 fox and grape story.
😉😉😉
Now I can say that YoYo Honey singh is Super Talented in terms of Music Production..
This is why modern music directors prefer RD Burman as he was the expert of converting non indian to bollywood. Laxmikant Pyarelal did copy but RD is a joke 😂
Great research and knowledge base .
Glad you liked it
@@Cosmuse-pg koi jadu hota to ek dum se tere subscriber 3million kar deta
@@xetayetatysm❤
Awesome compilation. The fact is because of Indian music director we got to know so many great western songs and bands!
Thanks, im trying my best:)
@Cosmuse-q4g keep it up ! 👍
@@tapankumarmukherjee8848hey, actually I found it on some archived forum, I don't exactly remember from where but it is on the internet definitely.
Well done!!! You have done a great job in exposing these theives!!!! 👍
I love the hardwork you have Done Brother....
Wow! What a collection of finds
I take umbrage to the ignorance of the audience, dismissing plagiarism as inspiration. That argument would loose sorely in court. Give credit where credit is due.
We should see our music composers as remixers, curators, reinterpreters and so on. They are funneling an unfathomable amount of local and international sources into the musical requirements of the films they are handling. I am really curious about their "workflow", especially the older composers. How were they accessing all this foreign music before the internet and at a time when international travel was rare and expensive?
R D Burman always made much version, superior version of the originals ....no match to RD Burman music
R D Burman is a genius...no question on that
If it is possible to become RDB by copying western music everyone would have become successful music director.. The foolish people who are here criticizing blindly RDB are all allowed to become a RDB by copying.. And of course all music directors of India have been doing the same thing.. So why black listing RD only??
Well, it's internet now so ppl r caught easily before becoming rd burman😂
Well Burman is being blacklisted because apparently, he has copied maximum number of songs. Just accept the fact, don’t try to justify it
@@sriv1556 Justification is coming because of his nativity bias
Yar lagta mera har favourite gana copy hai...😂
I can understand why he copied, writing and composing takes time and a lot of talent, when there is pressure of composing like 6-7 songs for one movie like Bollywood demands, and working for 2 to 3 movies at the same time is quite impossible. But later accepting awards for such copied composition is just heights of arrogance and a low blow for the original creators
Cant't believe this .....hats off to you for this research !!! Great
@@udaybatwal3719 why can't you believe???
Nation demands an answer.
☺☺☺
RD Burman - Jebkatra
😂😂
Songkatra😂😂
Kuch bacha hai jo nahi copy kiya😂😂
😂😅
RD burman ne tho kamal kardiya
@@kanasangat haan woh Kamal 2 tarah ka thha.
1) Kamal Hassan, the actor
2) Hassan Kamal, the lyricist
☺☺☺
Sad to see legend like Naushad saab in this list. RD Burman did dominate this list but almost all MD are there. big hits of Sholay are in this list 🙂
RD Burman was a big copycat Shameless
Yes!!! We called out Annu Mallik for copying!!! RDB escaped without being caught!!!! During those days the Internet was not there so we were not aware!!
Yes!!! We called out Annu Mallik for copying!!! RDB escaped without being caught!!!! During those days the Internet was not there so we were not aware!!
Rajesh roshan always lifted VANGELIS music..
I hope everyone sues or has sued those copycats.
Omg! So many tunes were stolen from western sources by Bolly, with no permission? Should have been charged with plaigiarism.
Don't know about Pancham da legacy now...but kishore kumar is and will forever be my legend...
some folks like me knew this 20 years ago (i'm old lol).
RD BURMAN AND BAPPI LAHIRI are the TOP copycat.
They are not composures. They are all copycats....
Shameful..
Oh!This is ultimate.So many classic songs are copied.Very sad.
That is chor bengalee for you
@@kaushikmukherjee671 why sad??? Is rdb your chacha. 🤔🤔🤔
Now we understand why bollywood present music directors are copying,pasting songs
Actually there r following their RD Burman footsteps😂
Pl remember folks that rdb use to take essence of tunes ,add his own creativity and give new lease of life to songs
No,he copied as it is
Plz don't justify stealing
True,he never blatantly took anything ,he mixed his own thinking, creativity and innovation which resulting a different song from the original. But others just lifted tune, rhythms, sounds, 😂
@@bodhisatwajana6868 You mean every song..what a shame for No1. Chor RDB
Bro he shamelessly copied it straight forward.its simple
Naushad was only true great, thats y he never considered Kishore a singer 🤣
Murkh , kishore kumar jaisa to iss sadi me koi hua hi nahi, aur rahi baat gano ki nakal ki to kishore da gana gaate the banate nahi the na hi likhte the....aya bada Naushad wala
Wo besura aunty? Mujhe nooran sisters ka awaj jaisa lagta hai. 😂😂😂
Naushad bhi bada Chor tha😂uska abhi tak. Jyada Nhi mile 😂 jaldi nikalenge😂. Kishore Ki baat alag hai😂. Unka bhikhari (Rafi)Jaisa awaz nhi tha😂.
Naushad Ji also copied a song from Dr. Bhupen Hazarika's one of Assamese song....Naushad Ji used in the movie Mother India..song was "Dukh bhare din beete re bhayya"...and Assamese one "Ghan Baraxun Pisal Mati".
Naushad had Muslim bias, he only worked with his Muslim camp
The people who search for this work very hard. RD Burman is no legend. I knew some of his songs were copied but this is too much and not sure whether others will be found out. How did they find so many in the past? International Radio?
Idk how, but they did a commendable job.
@@Cosmuse-pg I am talking about the music directors who copied. Those days how they got access to international music that public did not know not even the elites of Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata?
Obviously, these MDs were rich enough to travel to other nations, and there they learned about western music. I once heard from someone that Bappi Lahiri used to visit usa a lot, where he bought many cassettes of pop American songs, and then he lifted their tunes in Bollywood songs.
They had access of all over the globe with no internet. Thats how they took those music . They were no normal people. Other than Queen, Abba ,bettles , micheal jackson very few foreign bands were popular in india back then
R. D. Burman is no legend? Did you listen to the FULL songs? Portions were taken as inspiration! That's normal in the music industry. It wasn't only Panchamda, but Laxmi- Pyare, Shankar- Jaikishan, Kalyanji- Anandji. Why are you only singling out Panchamda??? Have you heard ALL of his groundbreaking work? You should be ashamed of yourself that you fail to credit an Indian musical genuis despite living in the same country as him! Thuuuuu....
One thing people are missing here, majority of R D Burmans songs hardly had some 8-16 bars similarity with original songs. Which could be counted as first 2 lines of the mukhra. But, the catch is the remaining song parts were original and it is believed that his Antaras were much better than his mukhras. Also, R D used to compose for over 15-20 movies in 70s, so with that it averages 100 songs per year. It's not possible for a human being to create 1 tune every 3 days and record it in studios. You produce, you record and you sale. It's a long process. Also, RDs legacy will never die because he composed over 2000 songs in lifetime and around 100-120 songs were inspired (again 2 lines of mukhras only, not a blatant lift). So that accounts only 5-6% of his total discography. Each music composers have done it, some with own intention and some were forcefully asked to do by the producers, actors, and directors. People can blame easily, but they will never know what were the background stories. RD and the other music directors of 70s,80s and 90s will remain legends. Actually 100 times better than todays crap people listen. 😊
But he never credited the original composers, which should be a bigger concern for his fans
@@mohan2304Agreed.Its was never the practice of Hindi film industry.
@SmallWandere.Very well articulated,with facts.
@mohan2304 Those days the credit concept was an alien thing, but yes RD often said on interviews that he used to take inspiration from English songs, which itself is a big thing for a music composer to admit. He was an open book to all.
Watch this video of Asha and RD in late 80s-
ruclips.net/video/8nax5AQczrk/видео.htmlsi=JHw6fBfludwJ74vp
@@SmallWanderer He has elaborated more in this interview
ruclips.net/video/plmGvWxpx-M/видео.htmlsi=bgMsm6_31TEUpyos
And the sad part is sab ne khoob kamaya tha ye sab gaane banake especially RD BURMAN ne
Most of the songs were inspired from other songs. If you hear 'original 'full song you can realise the matter. You can't say indian songs copied from other.
And people get mad at Anu Malik for copying songs. Rd burman is far worse at ripping off songs. That is why he was no.1 most of the 70s 😅
because he hides his mohmeddan identity by using Hindu name like dilip kumar😂
Copy Sub Ne Kiya tha Naushad bhi , abhi bhi dhundna Chalu hai itne purane gaane hai to😂 & The RD (Rahul Dev) Burman is the greatest ever composer of india. Jo Chahe ukhadle😂 Kuch nhi Kar Payega. He is from bengal & a true bengali. Woh lungi Chod nhi tha😂. Sub bade composers & also a few lungi Composers maan liya hai ke yeh God of the Composers the hain aur rhenge😂.
God of copy, fraud composer
@@tariqsiddiqi7964 Allah of copy & fraud of composers is A.R. Rehman 😂. worst ever 😂. Copy Cat 😂 then Naushad & others.
God of copy undisputed winner is Shankar Jaikishan
RD Burman was the Anu Malik of 70s
Each every song in bollywood jo popular hai vo copy hai
aisa nahi hai - Aaap Ki Nazaron Ne Samja , Lag Ja Gale - they are so many songs that are famous but original. It depends on ones taste.
@@neilbhatt7096 lag ja gale is also copied
@sayanroy5560 from which song
RD Burman deserves salute he revolutionized music industry by copying western tunes the inspiration of Annu Malik, Pritam and Bappi Lahiri
This is main reason hindi cinema slowly slowly going down.
Great❤
Same of Jatin Lalit & Nadeem Shravan but will say we are inspired by not copying 😅
Every song, every movie in hindi film industry is COPIED! dont @ me
😭😭😭
Not all.. Duniya ke rakhwale copy nahi
R D Burman was copy master 😂
And we called rd a legend
Le JHAND tha 😂
My music life was all sham all these years 😢
Yaar waise ek baat bolu if you watch western youtubers naa you would realise that ki jo gaane hum log copy kar rhe hai wo bhi kahi se churaya hai it means that wo gaana already 1-2 baar copy ho chuka hai to bas art ko enjoy karo aur ye sab to facts hai haa ye hai ki jo gaane copy kiye hai wo sunne layak sirf 10-12% hi hai hindi mai baaki to sunne layak bhi nhi
dont comment nonsense if u r not working in that field western music and film productins all were original yes they d steaing from turish music and fims but that is 1-2% ret they were advanced in their techniques enough to create and prduce their own music and films they were deveped not develping their techniques their technology they create they dont aopt like india idnain fim and msui industry is a big zero in front of them as they steal a lot
Original musicians are Legends.
Very good compilation. Lot of research has gone into it. Copied or not good music is for keeps.
If copy gives us so pleasure, pls make us happy with your originals.
There is difference between plagiarism and inspiration. And to note, folk songs do not have any copyright. The talent is in the beautiful Indianisation. There lies his ingenuity.
इसमे चोरी की कोई बात ही नही है आप किस तरह से उसको अपनी भावनाओं और हित के लिए प्रयोग करते हैं। जैसे उदाहरण के लिए आप लोग रोज सुनते होंगे कि भारत ने अचूक मिसाइल का परीक्षण किया तो मिसाइल तो औरो के पास भी है और भारत ने भी बनाई तो काम तो सभी एक तरह से कर रही किसी की अपने तरीके से तो हमारी अपने तरीके से लेकिन टारगेट एक है लक्ष्य को भेदना यही संगीत कर रहा सुर को कहाँ कैसे लगाना है ये सबके बस की बात नही ना उसपे बोल बैठना जो आत्मा को छू ले। लोग चोरी किसने की बताने वाले बहुत मिल जाएंगे देखा किसी ने नही।
Did they ever create any original tune? Now I think even these tunes were probably suggested by the Goan musicians who worked as arrangers for our music directors. Sebastian D’Souza-SD Burman, Frank Fernand-Shankar Jaikishan, Anthony Gonzalvis-Lakshmikanth Pyarelal, Kersi Lord - RD and SDB, etc.
pure genius work by your channel… how you managed?
Do you know about rmim newsgroup? Most of the content is available there.
So, number 1- R.D.Burman, who is for sure the pirate king, and number 2- Laxmikant-Pyarelal.
But I wonder, did singers know about it? I mean see the names, greats like Kishore Kumar....🤔
😂😂😂 No.1. Annu Malik then Pritam & new others.
RD Burman copied lesser than L-P .
Yes RD copied too many!!! During those days the internet was not there so he escaped from getting caught!!!😂
RDBurman has less than 30-40 songs which he copied, even there his arrangements were original, he has over 1000 compositions, listen to his classical indian music based songs
@@REVELATIONSTV-y3q R.D Burman Copied 3 or 4 songs Same to Same. He only copied the interlude or 1st line of the Song, he didn't copy & paste. His compositions are better than the original videshi 😂. Plz listen those.
@@user-wl3dh5nq7c Not 40 or 50, RD Barman copied hundreds of songs!!!
Vinyl records are the source.
Majority of RD Burman Songs were copy
RDB का अलग से एक 10 घंटे का वीडियो बन सकता है
It may be a coincidence that the tune in which the songs were composed had a similarity with european songs.
It can be. But most the time Producers & Directors demands this. Sometimes, when there is a situation where no song is demanded, than Music Director suggest to have it there.
For example: Mehbooba Mehbooba Song of Sholay movie was suggested by R D Burman to put weightage on the Film story by showing that the Gabbar after having arms deal, is doing party with dealer.
Same in Deewar movie too. After Hero gets huge booty to Villain. There it is suggested to have Celebration song.
This thought crossed my mind too..
For about 20/30 years people thought of RDB as some kind of genius but he was the biggest CHOR - a lot of his songs are straight up lifts - RDB is the king of plagiarism.
I strongly disagree. Bappi Lahiri ws the biggest pilferer. R d Burman had improved on many original songs. Yes he has copied I agree but his contribution to Indian music is irreplaceable
@@namratbhaijust being compared with BL is a massive shame. RDB was very good at 'Indianizing' the things he lifted.
Hum to Mahesh Bhatt ko he sabse bada copy master samjhte the per pura bollywood he copy master hai..
Make them pay all copy rights for stealing melody's that's very bad vibes
R D Burman was a copy paste music director. Kishore should also be tagged because he was his pet singer. We know this fact after Internet came in India. Others are in the list but less.
Shall we call them legend after listening these ?
Yes , a copying legend 😅
@abhishekawasthi7306 🤣🤣🤣
@@abhishekawasthi7306 👍
Bongs will be unhappy. 🤣🤣
Bongs were/are the biggest chor ... lol...yet they are SNOBS.
RD Burman made Kishore kumar thru Plagirised songs and music
AllRD songs are plagirised
Na Izzat ki chinta, Na fikar koi apmaan ki
Jai bolo Beimaan ki, Jai Bolo, Bolo Jai bolo beimaan ki Jai Bolo.....😂😂😂
Phone pe charcha in 70's by RD, Lakshmikanth & Bappi would sound something like this: " Mein RD bathkarraha hoon, char fresh mal aya hai africa, US or afghan se, ek tu lakshmi rak le, ek bappi tu rak le, mein do rakloonga" 😝
PLAGIARISM (STEALING)✅
NEPOTISM ✅
NUDITY ✅
SENSE ❌
BOLLYWOOD IN A NUTSHELL 😂
RD BURMAN ab kya hi bolu
😂😂😂 Old Is Rolled Gold
There was a Holly Movie of 1930s - Dick Powell and Ann Sheridan - about the 'Music Plagiarism'... and in the end, (a court room), it is hinted that the tunes which it is supposed to have been plagiarised from, itself is adapetd from an older (and out of copyright) tune. eg Oneway ticket (not Boney M, but actually Neil Sadaka's) itself, if sufficiently searched, one could find the 'Influence'.
In film music no one composes from scratch zero. Movies are themselves borrowed from other movies. Same applies for the songs. 😊😊😊
Rd burman akele me saare foreign songs sunte honge fir hindi me copy maar lete..saara game mukhde ka hi hota he ..great thief..
Not only rd burman they all were thief and started stealing from 1949 😢
Exactly. Mukhda and Melody are the main things. The rhythm and tempo is decided by the melody itself. So what else is needed after that? Not much.
Naushad sab C Ramachandra SD Burman Madan Mohan never heard these names in plagiarism. Don't if any 1or 2 instances were these . But they were true legends who composed their own down south Saluri , ms viswanatham k V mahadevan illlayaraja , dakshina.urthy all were legends who had great base in classical music . Few were Inspired from classical but mostly their originals
Great work
Everything was copied. Nothing was authentic or original.
Very sad.
Asha Bhonsle said in an interview that RDB had every possible song as needed by the producer and he rarely left a Producer without giving a song to his satisfaction. Now we know that he had all the copied tunes ready.
.
Anu Malik also claimed in an interview that later in his career, he had to follow RDB way of dealing with the producers who discarded his original tunes.
.
Bhappi Lahari is one unique personality who had recorded songs ready and producers just had to pick what they wanted as it already had been completely recorded. So he stole left and right from anything he heard of. 😂😂😂
It's nothing but making a burger in Indian way !!!
@mustaqahmed9812 yes..... Like
Masala Burger
Aloo Chitpole burger
Idaly Dosha Burger Sambar dip
Vangi Baat burger
Masala Dosa burger
Chai Coffee waala Burger
Berger painted Burger
😆😆😆
Sab ki poll khol di 🤣Khaas R. D. Burman ki
Does not matter. People will still like R. D. Burman. Reason. He turned the original on its head and made better versions.
Well that skill of improving a stolen copy isn't special to Burman saab. Pritam, Anu Malik both have done this too. But the netziens like to call out Malik saab while defend Burman ji.
Sahi kaha kaheka pancham da 😂🤣
So true@@kaushikbho2129
I knew about RDB long before YT found out. Even entered into bad arguments with some music friends who refused to believe my opinion of RDB but now it's all clear - everyone knows it.
How did you come to know??? Please tell
@@dilippathak7498 someone in family who played mandolin in mumbai film industry shared this (and some other) information. So, the fact is those who played instruments in films knew it already.
@neilbhatt7096 thanks 👍
RD Burman was considered Best ever ...but not anymore after the rise of internet...Only AR Rahman is...Original now
Shiv-Hari also.
Even A R Rehman has lifted tunes
AR rahman is genuine but hugely inspired by greek composer Vangelis style
ARR has copied many tunes, especially the tunes, that propelled him to the top, are mostly copied. But unlike all musicians, he has created many genuine tunes as well
@@viveksingh5648 debate is long. Jai ho is actually not ARR composition but by Sukhwinder and that too lifted from a song.
Even the base line of Taal se Taal is picked from a flute piece from HERO composed by Laxmikant Pyarelal
बप्पी लहरी ने 1977 में ऐसा म्यूजिक दिया
लगता नहीं है
If you're going to steal, steal from the best.
y steal create ur own by producing ur own software stealing is not a talent
@@Muzikseviyorumstealing is a talent. This was shown by every king who was born, every politician, every bureaucrat, every industrialist born ever. Everyone is the same, even hypocrite common man included. 😂😂😂
I think copy king was the burman , filmfare awards should drop his paid awards .
Earlier I thought about 20-30% bollywood songs are copied. But now it seems 100%....They have shamelessly copied even lyrics...
Yes!! We thought these guys were legends!!!! Now we know they were legends in copying!!!😂
not the songs of 50s and 60s. 90% of songs of Golden Era (era before likes of RDB came on scene) were pure, original and might I add - better too.
@@neilbhatt7096 Even they were copied. Bollywood is a big copy cat. They copy movie plots, scenes, songs.....then where is the creativity. Although Sholay was well made, I was disappointed when I came to know even that movie was copied scene to scene...
@@neilbhatt7096 50s songs also were copied it seems!!! I have seen a video of 50s songs that were copied from West!! SD Barman also copied several pieces of music!!!
@tpt9028 you have heard all songs? I have listened to most (nobody can claim all) and I'm pretty sure the chori was much less (very small) in 50s and 60s. Tell me which song AAP ki nazaron ne samja or lag ja gale were copied from? I can lust a thousand songs and nobody can show me they were lifted. The trend started in late 60s by RDB in a Mass scale. Most of his songs are copied. Earlier SJ, Salil Chowdhry and one or two MD"s lifted small # of tunes - but nothing like RDB or Bappi.
Meanwhile Rahul Gandhi.... Bhai Mazza aaya. Aur main yeh jo mazza hai, hindustan ke har ek vyakti ko dena chahta hoon. 😊😊😊
Good work 👏
Sickening, shameless. What matters is for how many generations they cheated the public who were not aware that these songs were lifted from western tunes. Only a few who listened to pop western tunes were aware of these lifts. However there are still some who will defend these copycats who have minted money on other artists talent thinking they sre obviously performing an act of patriotism. An acquaintance of mine who used to play the bongos for hindi songs at Film studios at Tardeo in mumbai told me for background music they just played an instrumental LP & recorded it on to the soundtrack! Need i say anything more?
Damn that's pathetic!
all do copies.. but the thumbnails got permanent picture of rd burman.. how funny..
pioneer of lifting - he deserves to have a photo on this one. He started the MASS copy business.
RD burman decieved Indians emotions , now nation is ashamed
All, except the last song, “Tum ho mere dil ki Dhadkan”.
Procol Harum’s “Whiter shade of pale” is not same. I listened to it a few times, changed playback speed. May be it’s still a copy but not of this.
संगीत के सात सूर है इसलिए धूने तो थोडा बहोत मिलता-जुलता रहेगा
R D Burman the criminal.
Choriwood 😂
😂
Cheaters still cheating. Copy cat.
Every thief says i am not a thief
Everybody copied rd Burman..they just made it before him😂😂😂
nopes rd burman copied everything nt copied stole the original work of foreign music
😂😅
So what ?? RD Burman has composed hundred of other excellent songs . He is a legend .
وہ بھی چوری کے ہی ہونگے 😂
Few tunes here and there doesn't reduce the genius of R D Burman....if u listen to full songs of both songs, u will realise original version 1.0 and R D Burman 9.0 of the same tune....no match...for mobile phone companies release various series, upgraded series ...latest release is of higher quality than it's original version
Also Anu Malik , Bapi Lahiri and Usha Utthup did that
Inhone bachoon ki rhymes bhi chori kar li 😂😅😂
I am surprised why you have tagged all the songs sung by Kishore Kumar as R.D Burman!!
Why would I tag Kishore Kumar when RDB was the md of those songs, he was the one who stole those tunes.
Kishore Da To sirf Singer hai.. main Composition To RD Burman ne kia hai ..wo jaise Tune me bataye waisa gaana padhta h😊